WL2: Water Security: Innovation in Policy, Institutions,Innovation in Policy, Institutions, Technology and Cooperation by John Briscoe

8/3/2019 WL2: Water Security: Innovation in Policy, Institutions,Innovation in Policy, Institutions, Technology and Cooperation by John Briscoe

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wl2-water-security-innovation-in-policy-institutionsinnovation-in-policy 1/95

^c{du \dltug{ 6^c{du \dltug{ 6Goo`zc{gò go Q`bglw" Go|{g{t{gò|"Goo`zc{gò go Q`bglw" Go|{g{t{gò|"

[ g[ g

Mcuzcuk Togzdu|g{wMcuzcuk Togzdu|g{w

co cco c

Ftbw 5131Ftbw 5131



/

5/ @bk -et{ |{gbb giqù{co{' {``b|

/ d~" oo`zc zd" `` |

;/ Didungon jùi| `j qcu{odu|mgq|



C jucid~ùh jù ckkud||gon ~c{du |dltug{w

3/ Mg|{ùglcbcok ltb{tucb

lò{d}{



Mg|{ùw |mcqd| qduldq{gò| ò ~c{du…/

((

Q`bg{glcbugzdu (( diecohido{ ùkdu99

Zcu`t| zdu|gò| `j {md d{wi`b`nw" et{

cb~cw| ~c{du c{ {md mdcu{ `j g{#



[mt| [mudd Nùnd| g| c| itlm ce`t{ q`bg{glcb |wie`bg|i c| g{ g|ce`t{ jb``k qu`{dl{gò cok mwku`q`~du…



Go|gnm{| juì ~ùh| ò {md mg|{ùw `j ~c{du…/

‒{md |{c{d `j cu{ `j

~c{du icocndido{' g|cb~cw| qu`zg|gòcb “

ho`~ ~dbb" et{

mwku`b`nglcb dongoddu|`to cu {` clldq{ /






3/ Mg|{ùglcb cok

ltb{tucb lò{d}{

5/ D}`ndo`t|



Gicngod w`t cud ‒{md ~c{du {|cu’ù" |cw" c |{co



Qchg|{co jcld| {~` nudc{d}`ndo`t| { udc{|…

‥ Cbi`|{ cbb `j g{| ~c{du lìd| juìodgn e`tugon l`to{ugd|



G o k t |

F m d b t

i

L m d o c e G o k t |

F m d b t

i

L m d o c e

Qchg|{co

U c z g

\ t { b d f

c |

Qchg|{co

U c z g

\ t { b d f

c |

GokgcGokgc

“ cu ò" ~ u wu c l d | od c| ut c `

mwku`b`nw c| g{ ~c| {` qd`qbd…



Mcuk~cud6 [cuedbc

\`j{~cud6co con c ci| coic||gzd bgoh lcocb|

d o t| udc{w

C nudc{ clmgdzdido{ “ mc| ~ùhdk jù :1 wdcu|d{~ddo {~` l`to{ugd| ~ gl czd c g glt {

udbc{gò| -cok c l`tqbd `j ~cu|'



Et{ cbb ~c{du |`bt{gò| cud qu`zg|gòcb…//

\cbcb >11 i~

c~c ` i~

Ecnbgmcu ;41 -( ;41' i~

Etu|cu 3111 i~

Ktb Mc|{d <71 -( <71' i~

Qchg|{co

Gokgc

Tokdu lò|{utl{gò

…// G| qc|{ |tlld|| bghdbw go c kgjjdudo{ qud|do{ cok jt{tud0



…5:1 ‒ugzdu’ ec|go| |mcudk ew 5( oc{gò|

du `



Nu`~gon {do|gò|" d|qdlgcbbw go ~c{du)lò|{ucgodk cudc|…

\`tuld6~~~/TODQ/ùn



Lòjbgl{ ug|gon c{ |te)oc{gòcbdzd " {``…



"

Gokgc jclgon c nu`~gon |dugd| `j ‒|icbb lgzgb

’ …Igog|{du `j ^c{du Ud|`tuld|6

‒

et{ {md Igog|{du `j ^c{du Lòjbgl{|’



Cok ucg|d {md |qdl{du `j ~c{du ~cu|" ~g{mgo

…/



[ucgogon |d||gò 3-^dkod|kcw' g| n`gon {` b``h

) )clu`|| |{c{d cok oc{gòcb

e`tokcugd|…



Qchg|{co jcld| co`{mdu icfùd}`ndo`t| { udc{…

‥ Go{duoc{gòcb ~c{du| cok e`tokcugd|…

‥ Lbgic{d lmcond







[md q`{do{gcb djjdl{| `j nbclgcb idb{gon go {mdMgicbcwc|0



C mtnd g||td ~g{m nudc{ toldu{cgo{gd| -c| dzgkdoldk go {mdGQLL udqù{…/' N~wo Udd| d{ cb 5114




3/ Mg|{ùglcb cok

ltb{tucb lò{d}{

5/ D}`ndo`t|{mudc{|

</

Dok`ndo`t|{``b|



/

5/ @bk -et{ |{gbb giqù{co{' {``b| / d~" oo`zc zd `` |








`j Jgocoldzduw t nd

g| c ciebd ò{md iò|`ò’



[mdudjùd l`to{ugd| ~g{m |icbb

do `~ido | ̀ o uc| utl tud ozd| …/ dEmchuc)Edc| lìqbd} go Gokgc

igbbgò

mdl{cud| cokqu`zgkdk 5=11i~ `j q`~du

m k e j b m k



‥[md gokgudl{ edodjg{| ~dud c| bcund c| {md kgudl{q`~du cok guugnc{gò edodjg{|

$ lmcond `j Golìd `j Kgjjdudo{ [wqd| `j M`t|dm`bk| ^g{m cok^g{m`t{ Emchuc Kci

:1

=1

51

;1

1Bcok`~odu| Cnu Bceù Utucb Oò

CnuUtucb @{mdu| Tueco

…

‥O`{ l`to{gon {md igbbgò| `j ignuc{ùw ~ùhdu| juì Egmcu



Icow ucigjglc{gò|…/

G 6 <5$ go guugnc{dk kg|{ugl{|

1$ go toguug c{dk kg|{ugl{|



[ gogo | ||g o < -J gk ' g|



[ucgogon |d||gò < -Jugkcw' g|

udzgzgon {md iùgetok -c{ bdc|{

go {md ^ùbk Ecoh#' qucl{gld‒

u` dl{|’…



/

5/ @bk -et{ |{gbb giqù{co{' {``b| / d~" oo`zc zd" `` |




|

t

{ g `

o | { g

g



/


“ Jgocolgon “ Go|{g{t{gò|

“ [dlmo`b`ngd|




@old l`to{ugd| b``hdk {` {md

ù co …‥ …

‥ 35 icfù kci qu`fdl{|…

‥ O`~ cbb GJG| -golbtkgon {md ^ùbk Ecoh' cud zduw



‥ O`~ cbb GJG| -golbtkgon {md ^ùbk Ecoh' cud zduwlòlduodk ce`t{ qu`{d|{| juì ON@|…/



Tokdu qud||tud juì ON@| {md ^ùbk Ecoh

…

3111

:11

=11

;11

1

511

) ) ) ) )

^ùbk Ecoh bdokgon jù mwku`q`~du go T\+ igbbgò|



Igkkbd)golìd l`to{ugd| ‒~g{m lm`gld|’ j`tok

‒ ’

-[mdo' N`zduoù [c||`

Eucvgb6

‒^mdo G etgbk c 31id{du mgnm kci go {mdigkkbd `j {md |dig)cugk"

{ d Eco udstgud| tdkgbgndold c| {m`tnm G’



Kdzdb`qgonl`to{ugd|" ~g{m|mcbb`~ kìd|{gllcqg{cb icuhd{|

oddk mdbq {`jgocold {mdgu~c{du

gojuc|{utl{tud …



^mdudc| {md ^ùbk Ecoh o`~ jgocold| ce`t{ 4 kci|"



M g Lmg g k g Cj g 0



M`~ g| Lmgoc zgd~dk go Cjuglc0‥ ‒Lmgoc‗| |{ucgnm{jù~cuk

cqqu`clm g| co c{{ucl{gzd

og{)qglhgon `j {md-{uckg{gòcb kòù|'’

E { Lmgo | jgo o go g| o



Et{ Lmgod|d jgocolgon g| ò

lìidul c {dui|…

‥ [mdud g| |{gbb c mtnd u`bd jù CKE -cok

gojuc|{utl{tud…/



/


“ Jgocolgon “ Go|{g{t{gò|

“ [dlmo`b`ngd|

;/ Od~ jùi| `j qcu{odu|mgq|



…



c{ lco ed cl gdzdk ~g{ uèt|{ckcq{gzd ~c{du ud|`tuld

[md Ituucw Kcubgon Ec|go



[md Ituucw Kcubgon Ec|go



d||do{gcb jù ig{gnc{gon {md

giqcl{ `j zcugcegbg{w -golbtkgon…



‥C |`qmg|{glc{dk |w|{di `j {uckcebd ~c{du ugnm{|‥\dbbdu| ichd iùd juì |dbbgon {mdgu ~c{du {mco nu`~gon b`~)zcbtd lu`q|

Kdbgzduw `j mgnm cok b`~ udbgcegbg{w ~c{du go {md Ituucw



w n w wKcubgon ktugon {md nudc{ Ct|{ucbgco ku`tnm{

351

311

:1MGNM

B@^

;1

[@[CB

1

377=7 37771 51113 51135 5115< 511<; 511;4 5114: 511:> 511>= 511=7



` ~c du{uckdk go 511>)=

51$ `j ~c{du{uckdk go 5115)<



" …

[uckgon qugldu |d uì `41 ldo{| qdultegl id{du

^mc{ ~c{du {uckd idco| jù



Lòlbt|gò 3 “ {uckcegbg{w ud|tb{| go kucic{gl



i`zdido{ ` ~c{du uì b`~)zcbtd {` mg m)zcbtd lu` |

41$

:1$

b d w

51$

<1$

;1$

$ `jdo{g{bdido{ d Z

c b

<1111

1$

31$

5115< 511<; 511;4 5114: 511:> 511>=

kdbgzdudk

e g k n

51111

54111

Ugld t u u t

4111

31111

Lg{ut|

Zgod| [ m d

1

5115< 511<; 511;4 5114: 511:> 511>=

Lòlbt|gò 5 “ {uckd kciqdo|



Lòlbt|gò 5 {uckd kciqdo|

{ d iqcl{ ̀ u`tn {

^c{du kdbgzduw cok dlòìgl giqcl{g I E



go |I E351

51$ udktl{gò go ~c{du cok ft|{ ;$udktl{gò go cnugltb{tucb `t{qt{

>4$ udktl{gògo ~c{du cok|icbb 00$

311 cnugltb{tucb

`t{qt{

:1

MGNM

;1

[@[CB

51

1

377=7 37771 51113 51135 5115< 511<; 511;4 5114: 511:> 511>= 511=7

Lòlbt|gò < “ {md kddqdu {md {uckd



Lòlbt|gò < {md kddqdu {md {uckd

d |ic du d iqcl ` u`tn



/


“ Jgocolgon

“ Go|{g{t{gò|

“ [dlmo`b`ngd|




‥ g` `nglc lu`q |lgdold|

‥ ^c{du cok ~c|{d~c{du {udc{ido{{dlmo`b`ngd|

‥ Go ù c{gò coc d do{

Kdzdb`qido{ c||g|{cold jù



q j

cnu lt {tud0‥

‥ Cnugltb{tud ~do{ `t{ `j jc|mgò…/

Ic||gzd udktl{gò| go @KC jù cnugltb{tud…/



^mc{ kgk cnugltb{tucbbw)|tlld||jtb IGL|-~m` kò‗{ kd dok ò cgk' k`0



-~m` kò { kd dok ò cgk' k`0

Bcund cok lò|g|{do{ gozd|{ido{ go cn ud|dculm





gozd|{ido{| go cn ud|dculm#

NI@| cok kdzdb`qgon



q n

l`to{u d|0‥

~cw" zduw |tlld||jtbbw…/

edlct|d `j {md qud||tud `j Dtu`qdco

Cudc| `j {dlmo`b`nglcb



oo`zc{ ò6 ‥ g` `nglc lu`q |lgdold|



C g



C g{dlmo`b`ngd| jù

udi`zgolò{cigoco{|

Udzdu|d `|i`|g|

2 1/3 oi

Oco`jgb{uc{gò

2 3 oi

Tb{ucjgb{uc{gò

2 31 oi

Iglu`jgb{uc{gò

‥ \dqcuc{gò `j gò|‥ Kd|cbgoc{gò

‥ \dqcuc{gò `j zgut|‥ \dq/ `j bcund i`bdltbd|

‥ \dq/ `j ecl{dugc‥ \dq/ `j qcu{glbd|

‥ \dq/ `j qcuc|g{d|‥ \dq/ `j jb̀ l|



c ù c zcold| d on ic d o



idieucod|…

‥ Giqbglc{gò| mtnd‥ Jù kd|cbgoc{gò

‥ 31 wdcu| cn` )) 51h~mltegl id{du

‥ [`kcw “ ; h~mltegl id{du

‥ Jù ~c{du cok ~c|{d~c{du {udc{ido{

‥ Jù jùicb ud)t|d

[ucgogon |d||gò 5 -[mtu|kcw'



\`t{mduo Lcbgjùogc -cok

goo`zc{gò go nu`tok~c{du

Nt cuc{'

Cudc| `j {dlmo`b`nglcb



oo`zc{ ò6 ‥ g` `nglc lu`q |lgdold|



\icu{du t|d `j gojùic{gò go



qudl | ò cnu lt {tud

^g{m {md qu`|qdl{ `j d}lg{gon od~ jùi| `j



idc|tudido{ dlìgon qucl{glc …

Cl{tcb Dzcq`{uco|qguc{gò B`||d| )) G m



\`tuld6 ^c{du^c{lm/lì/ob



/



od~ co d}l on qu`ld|| ̀



~g{m ~c{du

‥ Nu`tq @od “ ‒~c{du g| c {mudc{ {` `tu’ “ C nu`~gon g||td jù lìqcogd| golbtkgon6

" "‥ Dodunw -D}}ò'

‥ d{l



‥ ) |t|{cgocebd ~c{du t|d

lct|dk ku`q `j 33$ go









^mc{ k`d|‒ludc{gon |mcudk



zc td idco0‥

“ Od|{bç Qchg|{co g| {md bcund|{ qu`ld||ù `j igbh go Qchg|{co"

etwgon igbh kgudl{bw juì `zdu 341 111 jcuidu|/ “

‥ giqu`zd igbh stcbg{w

‥ L`bk lmcgo|

‥ iqu`zd d u z on lò ò|

‥ ^c{du6 “ G| ̀ od ̀ {md udc{d|{ dlò` gl cok mt co ~dbb)edgo

lò|{ucgo{| jù {md|d jcuidu|

“ [mdudjùd Od|{bd g| ~ùhgon ~g{m -~gbbgon' n`zduoido{| {`

Nu`tq| `j qugzc{d lìqcogd|



doncn on‥ “ ‒

|`lgcb bgldo|d {` `qduc{d’‒“{md quèbdi| `j |lculg{w cok q`bbt{gò’

[md qugzc{d |dl{ù ichgon bcund



‥ Lu`q eg`{dlm )) Iò|co{`" \wondo{c" …//

‥ [udc{ do{ {dlmo` ` “

K`~" ND" Ocbl`" |{cu{)tq|…

[md qugzc{d |dl{ù ichgon bcund



‥ ^c{du kdbgzduw {dlmo`b`nw

“ Zcbiò{" Fcgo…/

‥ o ùic ò dl o` `nw

“ GEI" Lg|l`" [ù`"\lmbtiedundu" |{cu{)tq|…

Cog

- k



-coku`~go

nu`tq `j

lìqcogd|

do c go~g{m~c{du

[md …/ g| co giqù{co{ idiedu `j {mg| didungon l`cbg{gò

Et{ ~c{du g| c zduw |do|g{gzd



ic{{du o c l`to{u d|…d czd

“ N`k)bghd{dl o` `ngd|

“ Idkgdzcb

o| t ò| “ Qcbd`bg{mgl

di` ò …

duw iqù co c | doncndido `{md qugzc{d |dl{ù go qtebgl q`bglgd| g|



òd o |tqqù ` n`zduoido co d wl`to{uw oc{gòcb|…/

‥ Lòjdkduc{gò `j Gokgco Gokt|{ugd| mc|

‥ "

Lcqg{cb" DONU@" Qclhcnd| cud f`gogon~g{m {md N`z{ `j Qto ce cok {md ^c{du51<1 nu`tq -~g{m CKE doncndido{'…

Lòlbt|gò



‥ ^c{du kdzdb`qido{ cok icocndido{‗

‥ G| n`gon {` udstgud cbb {md {``b| czcgbcebd “ ‒Ktie’ cok ‒\icu{’ {dlmo`b`ngd|

“ Qtebgl bdckdu|mgq cok qugzc{d goo`zc{gò

‥ Togzdu|g{gd| mczd c u`bd6 “ Lòzdogo

“ [ucgogon “ g

“ Od~ jùi| `j ‒mùgvò{cb qcu{odu|mgq|’







Documents

WL2: Water Security: Innovation in Policy, Institutions,Innovation in Policy, Institutions, Technology and Cooperation by John Briscoe