EXHIBIT t

Checklist Item No. 20

( 2950 MINA MAHI'AI-KA'ANAPALI COFFEE COTTt PROPOSED BED & BREAKFAST DWELLING PHOTOS

1. Main Entrance to the Lot (2 Views)

2. Main Driveway

4. Parking Area for Guests Parking Area for Owners

EXHIBIT 3

4, East Side of House 4. North Side of House

3. South Side of House 4, West Side of House

4. East View from House S. North View from House

5. South View from House 5. West View from House

6. Living Room

6. Bedroom 1 6. Bedroom 2

(

6. Lanai 8. Fire Extinguisher

, 7. Bedroom 1 Smoke Detector 7. Bedroom 2 Smoke Detector 9. Water Shut Off

Checklist Item No. 21

2950 AINA MAHI'AI- KA'ANAPALI COFFEE COTIA PROPOSED BED & BREAKFAST NOTICE SIGN PHOTOS

1. Across the Street

2. Main Driveway

4. Parking Area for Guests

0 r ~ ; Ill t iO

.t> F m

~ > I

, ~ Second F11nn Dwelling for Kathy & Chris Davey

K.o'an~p£1i CoiTft F11111• • Mo~kl ~oin1 Lot'~ 'Aina Mahi'ai rlacc, K.o'ana,Wi, MauL H•waii

Thlh. 2 ·1-4..020 0~:!

Hn,lW..•-" ratr.L&t.na\·•• ta l ').lUio" lol'J'D\mtlt C'l~t,...ll(

na.ctw~~~ena\u. r. l1-UJI•rr nmunt11r.:

\ \ \

EXHIBIT 1

EXH!B~T ~

z :::=::'= =~~=

c; I I ,r c :::o=-I I

c

c

c

c

c

c

t. r

t!

SC4le ,~, - ~~

::. =~c ., ..- ::;:: =. ~ :_._.!. -E:) A-:...cc~~-o: ,: =--

Q,..:_! ,: .. _..:. ~C"~ C ::_,T •1 • • .:.

8af3 oW

5=-:;::<!oo-= t · -~-;=-..:: '"'j

- --·· ~~~J- :-_ ...

IEXHIBIT U;

-)

f~p7~ 7 _,._ COUNTY OF MAUl DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING 260 SOUTH HIGH STREET WAILUKU, HAWAII M783 Telephone: (808) 270.773& Facelmlle: (808) 270-7834 E-mail: planninqCRmtulqountv.gov

APPLICATION FORM Please orint lealblv or tvoe the followina.

APPUCANT INFORMATION Applicant'• Name(•): Morgan Gerdel Addreu: 2145 Wells Street Suite 301 Wailuku, HI 96793

Phone Number(•): , ~~ 808-270.5051 n (hm)

Signature( a): / Vl/l_ ~ M-- J.L.l [/ I

CONTACT INFORMATION

Contact Nama(a): Morgan Gerdel Addren: 2145 Wells Street Suite 301 Wailuku, HI 96793

Phone Numbar(a): (bual 808-27Q-5054 fl (hm)

Signature(•): ~. ~ •A_ £l.IJ • " y '

OWNER INFORMAnON

PROPERTY/PRbJECTINFORMATION I Tax Map Key No: (2) 4-4-Q20:052 AddreutLocatlon: 'Alna Mahl'al Place, Kaanapali, Maui, Hawaii

State Land Use Dlatrlct Boundary Dnlgnatlon: Agricultural

Community Plan Designation:

FARM PLAN APPLICATION

' Email: morgan@adcmaul.com

(eel) 808-214-2119 (flDC) 808-27Q-5054 Date: 1 0131/13

Email: morgan®adcmaul.com

(eel) 808-214-2119 (tax) 808-27Q-5054 Data: 1 0/31/13

Total Lot Area: 6.355 acres

County Zoning: Agricultural

Building Pennlt Application No. & o.tcrlptlon:

BT2013/1329, BT2013/1330, BT2013/1331 for a Main Farm Dwelling, ltarm ::;nea ana t"OOI

Bed & Brukfast Pannlt Application No. & Description:

FOR COUNTY USE ONLY

Fann Plan Pannlt No: f1?IT1l d-1_!5/ PlJfJ

'· S:\ALL\FORMS\ZAED\FarmPian\OidForma\FarmPianApp_Rev02.13.doc (Rev .. 2/13)

Date:

Date: ./ I

Page4

EXH~B~T 1

LOT1ZA

/

LOT13

I LOT14

DEPT. OF PLJl.Ni' JING COUNTY 0~ r'I /.C.

NO 2013 RECEIVED

22'X50' ABSORPTON F ELD

I LOT1S

Farm Dwelling for Kathy & Chris Davey Archilectur(11 Design & Construction, Inc. 'Ama Mahi'ai Place • Ka'anapali, Maui. Hlllfail 96761 TMK: (1) 4-4-0JO:OJ1

1US IV11l1 St., SlUt I JOJ • JV.,;lu.b4 MauL Hawcnt 967SIJ Td•phDtw: (8011) H6-8JOO • Faz: (1108) 986-8JOJ • ~/: "*@4dcmauz.oan~

~fl ci'-DJ.3/()J'f/ t ~ =- :j

CJ LOT53A

FARM 5P ACE- alfft!El!U6 102051' o4~3-4!>5F

•~SF lflo4,~

lrOTAl..~·~:al

Farm Plan Sal11: 1:1~0

N

~

11108//J

EXH!BIT g

-.. ..... __ _

D

/ I

.,.--/ __ ,.

\

570 1140

•• ao:DJ:lill:ll) I

~ - . l """"'IIIDI --

··~ --------1710 2260 ft

EXH IB~T q

EXH~B~T to

Tara Furukawa - RE: Request for Comment

From: To: Date: Subject:

Aloha Tara:

DBEDT LUC <dbedt.luc.web@hawaii.gov> Tara Furukawa <Tara.Furukawa@co.maui.hi.us> 6/5/2017 11:33 AM RE: Request for Comment

Page 1 of2

Is this the entire documentation for a Special Permit for the B&B? The discussion of how this permit application meets the requirements of a Special Permit are lacking. Farm plan documentation is limited also. 1 see some documentation for the initial building permitted as a "farm dwelling" but where is any additional documentation which allows for the additional dwelling as "farm worker housing"? That additional dwelling should have been subject to agricultural use and need for farm workers; there's nothing by right about being able to build a second dwelling unit on an ag property. The date ofthe buildings seems to suggest that the intent to create short-term rentals was contemplated all along. The contention by the applicants that the portion of the property that is currently occupied by the dwellings is not suitable for agriculture is not logical. Absent the dwellings this land is quite suitable for agriculture; the portion used for housing is indistinguishable from the land currently planted in coffee and other crops.

I hope you can forgive my bluntness. The level of detail in the application is sorely lacking and we would hope that the Planning Department would request that the applicant fully discuss, supported with evidence, specifically how they meet the Special Permit criteria that is spelled out in Chapter 205, HRS and within the County of Maui's ordinances. Aloha, Scott

Scott A .K. Derrickson, AICP Staff Planner State of Hawai' i, Land Use Commission (808) 587-3921 <scott.a.derrickson@hawaii.gov>

Confidentiality Notice: This e-mail message, including any attachments, is for the sole use of the intended recipient(s) and may contain confidential and/or privileged information. Any review, use, disclosure. or distribution by unintended recipients is prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient. please contact the sender by reply e-mail and destroy all copies of the original message.

From: Tara Furukawa (Tara.Furukawa@co.maui.hi.us] Sent: Sunday, June 04, 20171:18 PM

EXHIBIT \\

tile:///C:!Users/County%20Employee/ AppData/Local/Temp/XPgrpwise/5935416Egw55do... 617/2017

Page 2 of2

To: &LUC <luc@dbedt.hawaii.gov>; Bernardino, Briana L <briana.l.bernardino@hawaii.gov>; Nakano, Mei-Lynn E <mei-lynn.e.nakano@hawaii.gov>; Funakoshi, Rodney Y <rodney.y.funakoshi@hawaii.gov> Subject: Request for Comment

Hi, attached please find the agency transmittal form with attachments for the proposed Kaanapali Coffee Cottage Bed and Breakfast. We're so sorry it's last minute! We would appreciate any comments you might have by Friday, June 16, 2017.

Tara Furukawa, Staff Planner County of Maui Department of Planning 2200 Main St., Suite 619 Wailuku, HI 96793 (808) 270-7520 Email: tara.furukawa@co.maui.hi.us

file :1//C:/U sers/County%2 0 Employee/ AppData/Localff emp/XPgrpwise/593 5416Egw5 5do... 6/7/2017

( {

November 17.2016

RE: 2952 Aina Mahi•ai Place. Lahaina. HI 96761

Dear Sir or Madam:

I am currently a licensed architect in the State of Hawaii and was licensed to practice architecture in Hawaii at the time I designed and completed construction documentation for the single-family residence ("secondary farm dwelling") located at 2952 Aina Mahi'ai Place, Lahaina. HI. I certify that the residence at the time of its construction and completion was fully compliant with applicable Maui County building plwnbing and electrical codes.

As used herein. the word certify shall mean an expression of the Architect's professional opinion to the best of his information. knowledge and belief. and does not constitute a warranty or guarantee by the Architect.

Clayton H. Nishikawa. AlA

2145 Wells Street. Suite 301 • Wailuku, Maui, Hawaii 96793 • (808) 986-8300 • Fax (808) 986-8301 Email: adc@adcmaui.com

License# BC-22502

EXHIBIT Jz.

(ivaNet 9.1.2.1 - Permit Summary http:/lkivanct I Og.co.maui .hi .us/kivanet/2/permitlswnmary/ index.cfin? ...

t of3

~ Home Look Up Print Genealogy Summary RFS

Permit Summary

Permit: B 20140703 ~= NO Temporary: B T20140402

Description: BUILDING PERMIT

Project: DAVEY, CHRISTOPHER DAVEY, CHRISTOPHER

I Status: DONE Entered: 21-Mar-2014 Issued: 21-May-2014 Completed: 24-Nov-2014

Decision: A Expiration: Last Renewal:

f Location Desc.: I

r-----·--1 Parcel Information ~--------------------------------r------------------------~ .Address TMK I I 29S2AIN_A_M_A_H_I_A_l _PL--------------------·~,2-4-40_2_0_0_5_20_0_0_0 _______________ ~

I Scop e of Work

~ect : DAVEY, CHRIS & KATHY

jNow occupied as: N/A To be occupied as: 2ND FARM DWELUNG I LANAI I COVERED LANAI

!Scope: 2 BEDROOMS1 2 BATH, COVERED LANAI, CARPORT

~Dimensions: 1,000 sf- living 3210 sf - cov. lanai/carport

!Walls: 2X6 Partitions: 2X4 Foundation: CONC Floors: WOOD Roof: METAL Ceiling: GYP Basement: NA

special inspection required #4, 7 and 15 Received special inspection report for above items 11-24-14

1 Professionals I Contractors r--ICLAYTON H NISHIKAWA as DESGN 12145 WELLS STREET SUITE 301 WAILUKU, HI 96793 AR - ARCHITECT License: 6710 Expires: 30-Apr-2018

Phone: 244-4440

6/6/2017 11 :09 AM

KivaNet 9.1.2.1 - Permit Summary http:/ /ki vanetl Og.co.maui .hi. us/kivanet/2/pennitlswnmary/index.cfin'? ...

2 of3

ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN & CONSTRUCTION, INC. as PRIME 2145 WELLS STREET, SUITE 301 Phone: 244-4440 WAILUKU, HI 96793 B - GENERAL BUILDING ,License: 0022502 Expires: 30-Sep-2018

rOUANTITIESl

' Structure Classification I

Initial Value: $140,000.00 I Calculated Value: l$162,800.00 Standard Plan: Public Project: NO

# of Structures: 1 # of Res. Units: 1 Total Floor Area: 4210

I Model:

I Occupancy Group Construction Structure Class

Type

l R-3 OWLS/LODGING HSE/CONGREGATE RES V-B (06) TYPE V: 101

SINGLE FAMILY, <=10PERS B DETACHED

I Inspections I CORR ' I Inspection Result Completed Date Completed By Schedule 0 c N . B4 - BLDG FINAL PASS 24-Nov-2014 JRJOHNSON 24-Nov-2014 i N !B3 - BLDG LATHLGYPSUM PASS 21-Jul-2014 COANA 21-Jul-2014 N je2 - BLDG FRAMING PASS 08-Jul-2014 JRJOHNSON 08-Jul-2014 I N je2 - BLDG FRAMING IP1 16-Jun-2014 JRJOHNSON 16-Jun-2014 y

!B2 - BLDG FRAMING F3 12-Jun-2014 JRJOHNSON 12-Jun-2014 N fBi - BLDG FOUNDATION !PASS 02-Jun-2014 JRJOHNSON 02-Jun-2014 N ;..

r Activities

j I Nodes Est. Decision Description ( ssigned laeQIE"d Dur. Completion Target End Decision Date

!INITIAL REVIEW 23-Mar-2014 p 21-Mar-2014 PS I 1j 21 2123-Mar-2014

!comment: CONTRACTOR SIGNATURE

DSA BLDG PLANS [BL 2 3 30 23-Apr-2014 23-Apr-2014 A 07-Apr-2014 REVIEW I Comment: CBO 1-

!ooE 3! 20-Apr-2014 120-Apr-2014 P STATE DEPT. OF I 2 30 28-Mar-2014

I I EDUCATION

I I STATE DEPT. OF DOE 2 3 45 05-May-2014 05-May-2014 READY 07-Apr-2014 EDUCATION-RESUBMIT

Comment: RECEIVED IMPACT FEE PAYMENT STATE DEPT. OF DOE 2 3 30 20-Apr-2014 20-Apr-2014 A 09-Apr-20 14 EDUCATION-RESUBMIT

IDSA ENGINEERING jEL [ •

2 3j 30120-Apr-2014 20-Apr-2014 iA 24-Mar-2014

61612017 II :09 AM

KivaNct 9.1.2.1 - Permit Summary http://kivanet I Og.co.maui.hi. us/ki vanet/2tpcrmi tlswnmary/ index.c fin? .•.

-----FIR~ DEPARTM!;NI jFD I 2 3 30l20-Apr-2014 20-Apr-2014 READY 28-Mar-2014

Comment: 4/3/14· FH inside 500 feet 3/28/14- No fire protection shown,ltr. FIRE FD I 2

31 30 20-Apr-2014 20-Apr-2014 A 15-Apr-2014

DEPT; R!;S!JBMIT I I

HEALTH HD 2 31 30 20-Apr-2014 20-Apr-2014 A 02-May-2014 DEPARTMENT I W/COND

DEPT OF HOUSING HSG 2 3 30 20-Apr-2014 20-Apr-2014 NA 24-Mar-2014 & HUMAN I

I l CONC(;RNS ' ' fCo'~ment: 2nd farm dwelling

=NING jRWAIKIKI I 2 3 30 20-Apr-2014 20-Apr-2014 READY 05-May-2014 RTMENT ,

PLANNING DEPT: IRWAIKIKI RESUBMITTAUADD'L

1 2 3 45 05-May-2014 05-May-2014 A 14-May-20 14

INFO 1FINAL REVIEW !Ps I 31 4 2112-Nov-2016 12-Nov-2016 AN 20-May-2014

iComment: 5/20/14- OWNER'S SIGNATURE OR LTR OF AUTH, CONTRACTOR'S SIGNATURE, $1070.00, START DATE. RENEE .. APPLICATION PS 4 5 90 30-Jul-2019 30-Jul-2019 I 21-May-2014 STATUS

t Permit Flags

Flag Description I Status

I There are no flags on this application

3of3 6/6/2017 II :09 AM

KivaNet 9.1.2.1 - Permit Summary http:flki vanetl Og.co.maui ,hi.us/ki vanet/2/permit/summarylindex.cfin? ...

I of2

Help Home Look Up Print Genealogy Summarv RFS

Permit Summary

l Permit: E 20141901 I .E.lil9s: IN 0

r- Description: ELECTRICAL PERMIT

Project: DAVEY, CHRISTOPHER I DAVEY, CHRISTOPHER

Status: DONE I Entered: jo3-Jun-2014 Issued: 03-Jun-2014 I Completed:I28-Nov-2014

Decision: A

Expiration: I Last Renewal:! Location Desc.:

Parcel Information

•Address ITMK .-----··- ------- -------·-----11--------------l i 2952 AIN~ MAHI;;;:A=:I :::PL=._ ____ .!..,._ ____ ___=:2:::4:::::40:::2:=0::::0:::5:::2:::0:::00::::0:=_ _______ ...LJ

Scope of Work Project: DAVEY, CHRIS & KATHY

Scope: 2ND FARM DWELLING / LANAI/ COVERED LANAI - 2 BEDROOMS, 2 BATH, COVERED LANAI, CARPORT. ELECTRICAL WORK TO INSTALL A NEW lOOA SERVICE EQUIPMENT WITH A NEW FEEDER TO A SUB-PANEL. INSTALL NEW RECEPTACLES, SWITCHES, LUMINAIRES, SMOKE DETECTORS, RANGE/OVEN, DRYER, WATER HEATER, DISPOSAL, RANGE HOOD, EXHAUST FANS, DISHWASHER, CEILING FANS. INSTALL NEW A/C CONTROL WIRING AND jMOTORS FOR AIR CONDffiONING UNIT. I

[Fee Summary: Underground service 1ph, 3w, 120/240V to 100A, 1 feeder not over lOOA, 1682 sq. ft ., 2 a/c control wiring, 1 motor over 1hp to 3hp ... ONE METER ONLY ALLOWED FOR THIS DWELLING

NOTE: Reviewed Residential Plan on Document Manager.

Professionals I Contractors DELTA ELECTRIC INC as PRIME 510 MAALO STREET KAHULUI, HI 96732 C13 - ELECTRICAL

Phone:

6/6/2017 11: 12 AM

Ki vaNet 9.1.2.1 • Permi\ Swnmary http://ki vanet I Og.co.maui .hi .us/ki vanet/2/permitlswnmary/index.c ftn? ...

:! of2

' I

License: 0027681 Expires: 30-Sep-2018 DANA OPUPELE as PROJLEAD

I

EJ - JOURNEY WORKER ELECTRICIAN License: 0008478 Expires: 30-Jun-2017

Structure Classification

Phone:

fOUANTITIESl

i I

1 Calculated Value: l$162,800.00 I Initial Value: l$140,000.00

I Standard Plan:! I Public Project: ! NO

I # of Structures: I # of Res. Units:!

I Total Floor Area: 0

I Model: I

Occupancy Group Construction Ty pe Structure Class

I None at tached. None attached. None attached .

r--- Inspections I r----

I Result CORR I Completed Completed

I Inspection Date By Schedule 0 c N IE4 - ELEC FINAL PASS 28-Nov- 2014 JAM BROSE 28-Nov-2014 N E2 - ELEC ROUGH-IN COMPLETE PASS 31-0ct-2014 JAM BROSE 31-0ct-2014 N DEVICES & LUMIN E3 - ELEC SERVICE PASS 31-0ct-2014 JAM BROSE 31 -0ct -2014 y

IE1WC- ELEC ROUGH-IN PARTLY !PASS 108-Jul-2014 CKELE 08-Jul- 2014 I

y

I !WALLS & CEILINGS I -·

I Activities

Description ~des I

Assigned g-~!Dur. Est. Completion Target End Decision Decision Date There are no activities for this application.

Permit Flags Flag Description Status

I I

There are no flags on th is applicat ion

616i20 17 II : 12 AM

<.ivaNct 9.1.2.1- Permit Summary http://kivanet iOg.co.maui.hi.uslkivanet/2/permitlsummary/index.efin? ...

I of :!.

&.!2 Home f..!::i.n1 Genealogy Summary RFS

Permit Summary

l Permit: jP 20140806 I .E.J..il!D: jNO

I Description: PLUMBING PERMIT

l Project: DAVEY, CHRISTOPHER DAVEY, CHRISTOPHER

I Status: DONE Entered: 03-Jul-2014 I Issued: 03-Jul-2014 Completed: 26-Nov-2014

f Decision: A ~- - - E~piration: Last Renewal: L __ Location Desc.:

Parcel Information ~ [Address ITMK ] ~2~9~5~2~A~IN_A __ M_A_H_IA_I_P_L------------------~,~2~44~0~2-0-05_2_0_0_00----------------c=l

I Scope of Work

!Project : DAVEY, CHRIS & KATHY I 'To be occu pied as: 2ND FARM DWELLING I LANAI I COVERED LANAI Scope: 2 BEDROOMS, 2 1BATH, COVERED LANAI, CARPORT Dimensions: 1,000 sf- ltvtng 3210 sf- cov. lanai/carport !=====""====== .. ===""=""==; Plumbing Scope of Work: (BP2014/0703)

2 water closet 2 basin 2 shower 1 washing machine 1 kitchen sink 1 dishwasher 1 garbage disposal 1 heater-solar 1 vacuum breaker or backflow prevention device 1 ice maker 1 building sewer to present sewer, septic tank

Professionals I Contractors

MAUl PLUMBING INC as PRIME P 0 BOX 1363

., WAILUKU, HI 96793 C37 - PLUMBING

Phone:

~-e_n~~e~: ~0~0~3~09~7~9~E~x~p~ir~e=s~: ~3~0~-S~e~p~-~2~0~18~-------------------------------------l RAYMOND A MICHAELS as PROJLEAD

Phone:

I

PJ • PLUMBER, JOURNEYMAN

6/6/20 I 7 I 1: 13 AM

( ivaNet 9. 1.2.1 - Permit Surrunary http:/ /ki vanet I Og.co.maui .hi.us/kivanet/2/permit/summary/ index.c fin? ...

!License: 0010009 Expires: 30-Jun-2018

,-----------------------------------------------------------~[Q~U~A:N:TI~T~JE~Sl., Structure Classification 1

Initial Value: $140,000.00 Calculated Value: $162,800.00 Standard Plan: Public Project: NO

# of Structures: # of Res. Units: Total Floor Area: 4210

Model:

Occupancy Group Construction Type Structure Class

None attached. None attached. None attached. ·---- ------------'---------------__._ _____________ ____,

Inspections

Completed Completed CORR Inspection Result Date By Schedule 0 c N

P4 - PLBG FINAL PASS 26-Nov-2014 JTANAKA 26-Nov-2014 N

IP2- PLBG ROUGH-IN PASS 29-Jul-2014 BLAGANOS 29-Jul -2014 N !COMPLETE !P2 • PLBG ROUGH-IN FAIL 08-Jul-2014 BLAGANOS 08-Jul -2014 y I

,fO M ~~~TE ___ lo8-Jul-2014 'Pl - PLBG ROUGH-IN PARTLY I PASS BLAGANOS 08-Jul-2014 I y

. - - -

~- --'

Activities

Nodes I

Decisionloecision Date Description Assigned Beg lEnd Our. Est. Completion Target End

There are no activities for this application.

Permit Flags . ~---~F.~Ia~g~--~--------D~e~sc~r~iLp~ti~o~n _________ ~----s_t_a_t_u_s _______ 1

There are no f lags on this application '--------------------------..-.:.----------------------'

2 of2 6/612017 11:13 AM

1fekaa Poinr

}

/

I

/

EXHIBIT l3

( (

2950 AINA MAHA'IA- KA' ANAPALI COFFEE COTTAGE APPLICATION FOR LAND USE COMMISSION SPECIAL USE PERMIT

DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSED USE

The purpose of this special use permit will be to grant special usage in order to operate a Bed and Breakfast rental home in the two bedroom home located on the southern portion of a 6.355 acre parcel on agriculturally zoned property in Lahaina, HI.

EXHIBIT 11

( (

2950 AINA MAHA'IA- KA'ANAPALI COFFEE COTTAGE APPLICATION FOR LAND USE COMMISSION SPECIAL USE PERMIT

JUSTIFICATION OF REQUEST

Granting of this special use permit will allow the owner to apply for a Bed & Breakfast rental home permit for this parcel.

Operation of a Bed & Breakfast rental home at this location will provide multiple benefits both to local residents and businesses of Maui and will also provide tax revenues to the County of Maui and the State of Hawaii.

At least five acres of this property will continue to be operated as a working coffee farm, thus employing agriculturalists and harvesters.

In regard to the bed and breakfast rental operation, local residents and businesses will be employed as property managers, landscapers, housekeepers, pool service companies and security and utility companies. Tourism based companies such as car rental agencies, restaurants, activities companies, entertainment companies, photographers and event planners, in addition to others, will benefit.

As required by the Bed & Breakfast rental home ordinance, both general excise tax and transient accommodations tax will be paid, in additional to state income tax, thus benefitting the County of Maui and the State of Hawaii.

(

2950 AINA MAHA'IA- KA' ANAPALI COFFEE COTTAGE APPLICATION FOR LAND USE COMMISSION SPECIAL USE PERMIT

REASONABLE AND UNUSUAL USE

If this property is granted a Land Use Commission Special Use Permit, the operation of a Bed and Breakfast rental home permit will not be contrary to the agricultural zoning which the property currently possesses. The property consists of a total of 6.355 acres, of which at least 5 acres are planted with growing coffee plants. There are .587 acres which involve elevated portions and drainage for the agricultural product. The house utilizes 1.0 acre and therefore the satisfies the requirement that agricultural usage comprises more than 50% of the total acreage available for the zoned purposes.

Usage as a bed and breakfast rental home will not adversely affect the surrounding properties. There are 11 other parcels which fall within a 500 foot radius of this property; two of which are roadways. The parcels are at least five acres in size and therefore the number of neighbors is small. Several properties are not occupied on a full time basis and are used by the owners as vacation properties. Additionally, the subject property has significant vegetation growing on its boundaries which act as noise abatement for the surrounding properties. Finally, the owners will occupy another residence on the property and their contact information is identified by permanent sign and notification letter to the surrounding neighbors so that they may contact the owners immediately with any concerns or complaints.

Granting this permit will not unduly burden public roadways and streets, sewers, water drainage and school improvements, and police and fire protection. Occupancy will be less than 100% and is limited to a total of four occupants in a total of two bedrooms. Therefore, all the above named agencies will be impacted far less than if there were permanent residents at the home. Additionally, the bed and breakfast rental home ordinance provides that fire safety equipment in the form of fire extinguishers and smoke detectors be installed and maintained at the residence at all times. Also, the owners' permanent sign with published contact information will provide a method to deal with concerns and complaints without having to involve the local police department.

Unusual conditions, trends and needs have arisen since the district boundaries and rules were established. Although the property was originally zoned as agricultural when it was developed, the usage of single family residences as bed and breakfast rental homes has been permitted pursuant to Maui County Code 19.04.040. Agricultural zoning permits construction of a single family residence and the above identified code provides a permitted method for usage which is not contrary to the current zoning.

The land upon which this proposed usage is sought is unsuited for agricultural purposes. Although the majority of the usable land is currently planted with growing coconut palms and will continue to be utilized as such, the portion of the land which this usage is sought is currently occupied with two residential structures and therefore not suited for agricultural use.

44002B440000

44011203911000

44002lWi01100

4400211400000

....

441lll20il30000

- " / '

1140020470000

440!160860000

f>uukol/1 R'

\.../'

Letters Received

'P r.;. e ~ ~ :.r

440201153D01111

4'l0020180000

-~ ===-£0 .:::::::::a

4400200800m:

44002m121JOOO

0~ t.

• = letter of support received

• = letter of protest received

>< w E

M~p cbra 82017 Google

To: The Department of Planning, 2200 Main Street, Suite 315, Wailuku, Maui, Hawaii 96793

From: Justin Brunold 3251 Aina Mahi'ai Place Lahaina, HI 96 761

Regarding: DAVEY TMK 440200520000 Bed and Breakfast Application

March 19, 2017

Aloha,

DEPi . ..,, r.... . ..

COUNTY OF M/\Uf DEPT. OF PLANNIN G - CURRENT

APR -7 2017

RECElVED

I recently received a "Neighbor Notice" of an application by Kathy Davey to use the ohana next to their home as a licensed Bed and Breakfast. My TMK is 440200130000 and I am within 500 feet of this proposed use. I believe that the Davey's will operate their Bed and Breakfast in a professional manner. There is ample parking and turnaround space for cars on the property. Additionally, there is already a short term rental in this neighborhood and I do not believe that this establishment will cause any disturbances in the neighborhood as the owners are very c.onsiderate of their neighbors.

Mahala for your consideration of this letter of support.

The Department of Planning, 2200 Main, Suite 315, Wailuku, Maui, Hawaii 96793

RE: Bed and Breakfast Application for 440200520000

3/20/17

Aloha,

I am a "Noticed Owner' regarding our neighbor's {Davey) Bed and Breakfast permit. My TMK is 440200110000. I am in support of their application. I have known the owners for several years and I am not worried about their operation of a Bed and Breakfast, especially because they live next door and they would not tolerate any loud or unruly guests as they are very quiet and respect others in the neighborhood.

~h~~ L D T II David Quandt TMK 440200110000

5095 Napilihau Street, Ste 109B Lahaina, HI 96761

03AI3~3~ LIOZ C g ~\1~

• lN3~H:ln:J . 8NINN'tfld :.lO ld3Q ln'liVIJ ::10 AlNno:J

Maui County Department of Planning 2200 Main Street, Suit 315 Wailuku HI 96793.

Attn: Tara TMK (2)4-4-020 052 (Kathy Davey)

Subject: Support for B&B Application

Aloha,

Michael J. and MiRa Finnegan 2350 Aina Mahiai Place lahaina, Hawaii 96768

9 April2017

We are writing today in support of the B&B application submitted by Kathy Davey for the property listed above in the Kaanapali Coffee Farm community. We are lot owners in the community and we are currently constructing our home a little over 500' away from the Davey's property. As such, we have a vested interest in the community.

We support the application as it appears to be fully in keeping with the County's intent "to allow for varied accommodations and experiences for visitors while retaining the character of residential neighborhoods.' It is also within the bounds of the community's covenants, which do not restrict the operation of either B&Bs or STVRs.

This property will offer a different experience for visitors, a stay on a coffee farm, that will likely appeal to visitors that " fit" our quiet, agricultural community. As such, we have little concern that the operation of the B&B will be disruptive to the neighborhood. Moreover, as the Davey's, our neighbors, will be living on the property those small concerns are greatly mitigated.

We understand the coffee borer beetle has hit other farms on the Big Island and has been found in Hana, and have heard concerns that the Davey's B&B and the small amount of associated guest traffic will increase the risk for our farm. We understand the concern, and the risk, but quite frankly the idea that keeping out a few tourists will keep the pest away is likely a pipe dream. It seems a greater threat comes from the construction traffic with equipment coming from all over the island. Unless we are prepared to enact a quarantine of the area (which we don't support with the current threat) we risk fooling ourselves by believing that keeping out B&B guests will make a significant difference. Ample education and information material can be offered to registered B&B guests, making them just as likely to adhere to advisories regarding the pest as any other guest or visitor to the farm.

Again, we fully support the Davey's application and their right to use their property as they see fit within the boundaries of the established community covenants.

Mahalo,

~~-~~--· -­Mike Finnegan

April 5, 2017

Department of Planning, 2200 Main Street, Suite 315 Wailuku HI 96793 808-270-8205 Attention: Tera Kalanhara

COUNTY OF MAUl DEPT. OF PLANNING . CURR ENT

APR 1 3 2017

RECEIVED

Re: Kathy Davey's Application for a B&B license at Ka'anapali Coffee Farm TMK(2)4-4-020 052, application number 2017 0022

To Whom It May Concern:

I am writing to express opposition and great concern over the application of a Bed & Breakfast operation at the Davey's home at the Ka'anapali Coffee Farm where we have built our home on

lot 19.

Please note the two reasons for my opposition to this application.

1. As you are aware, the coffee borer beetle is a threat to all coffee farms on Maui including possible farms replacing cane in central Maui which is currently being proposed. As owners, we are striving to limit access to the farm and are worried that daily traffic in and out would increase the risk of this pest being transmitted. We live on a profitable working coffee farm that keeps an agricultural endeavor alive on west Maui. The economic threat this beetle represents to the farm collectively far outweighs the private

benefit to the Davey's.

2. My family and I are uncomfortable with strangers passing through the gates on a daily basis. This is an issue of privacy and security. We chose to build here because of the

sense of privacy and quiet. We do not want these conditions to change.

In summary, a B&B on the farm is a very bad idea. I urge you to deny this permit and any future permits at least until the Coffee Borer Beetle is no longer a threat and the coffee quarantine is

lifted.

Sincerely,

~-.-==7___,___,-\._ \._~r Cell: 778 241 7727 Email: nickbraber@gmail.com

Apnl27. 2017

Dcp;utmcnt of Planmng. 2200 Main Stn:ct, Suite 315 Wa1luku, HI 96793 Attention. Tcra Kalanhara

Re: Kathy Davey's Apphcallotl.' H&H hccn~c-Ku'ana~:~h Coffee !-arm TMK(214-4-020 052 I Application 20 17-002::!

To Whom II May Ct•accrn

I am wntmg to express oppositiOn and great concern o-.cr the application of a Bed & Breakfast operation at the Davey's home at the Kn'anapali Coffee Fnm1 where we have property at Lot 1!!.

Please note the two reasons lor my opposmon to this application .

I) As you arc.: awurc, the coffee borer bccth! lS a :hrcat to all cotlcc 1:1rms on Maui including possible farms rep being cane m ccntrall\laUI which is currently bcmg proposed A!. owners, wc arc stnvmg to lmut access ro the farm and worncd that daily tra!lk m and out would mcreasc rhe risk of this pest o~.:mg transmitted. We livc on a profitabk workmg co flee farm tlmt keeps an agncultural endeavor alive on west Maui. The economic threat tins bccth: represents to the farm collectively far outwc1ghs the pnvate benefit w the Davey's

2) M y funuly :md I !eel uncomfortable with strangers passing through the gates on a da1ly basis. This 1s an ISSUl' of pm acy and security. We chose to settle here bccaust: nf ~he st.msc of privacy ilnd quact m:d do not want these conditions to change.

In summary, a U&U on the furrn as a very bud idea. I ~:rgc you to deny this pcnmt and any future attempts li.lr pcmli!S ut least until the coffee borer be~:tlt' is no longer a threat and lhc coffee quaranune is lifted. Thank you lor your ;ll!cntion t~) th1s matter.

Smccrcly, . ...--

~ .. '\. T-----''.,-- -~.,__,__ _________ ---.. --). < --~~ ....:s----

!'ticl-: Br.1hcr -Cell: 77!!-24 1-7727 ni£khraherltl gmail.com

. ..___

Mr. Nick Braber

nlckbraber@gmall.com

April24, 2017

RE: Davey Bed and Breakfast Application TMI<: (2, 4-4..020 052

Aloha,

I am writing fn response to your letter expressing concern regarding my Bed & Breakfast application for our home In tne Ka'anapali Coffee Farm (KCF) . My husband Chris and illve full time In our home which is next to the ohana whtch Is the subject of this application. Your letter expressed concern regarding the spread of the coffee borer beetle from guests that may stay at our Bed and Breakfast and you also expressed concern regarding strangers entering the coffee farms on a dally basis. Thank you for the opportunity to address these concerns.

Coffee Borer Beetle It Is our understanding also that the coffee borer beetle Is a concern. However, the coffee farms itself has not implemented any restrictions on access. Currently construction vehicles, including earth moving equipment from Hana (where the beetle has been found) construction equipment that is used island wide, construction workers and their vehicles, landscapers doing

maintenance and planting landscape plants, delivery trucks, pool mall"ltenance vehicles, realtors wJtn visitors with rental cars, and everyone who lives here and their friends and guests enter the coffee farm

without any checking of t~res, shoes or equipment for din.

When we begin to advertise, we will emphasize that this Is a working coffee farm and provide information about the borer beetle. We can also screen our guests. Often guests check on rental Information prior to booking their itinerary so If guests are planning on visiting the Big Island prior to visiting Maui we can suggest that Maul be visited first if they wish to book our chana. We can also

provide a voucher for a car wash should our guests travel to Hana. Unfortunately, It Is doubtful that the care we take with our guests wm prevent the Introduction of the beetle considering the dally traffic.

Please be assured that as concerned owners living in the neighborhood, if the KCF Implements restrictions for those who enter the coffee farm we will certainly comply and willlnstNct our guests to do so as well. Also, please note that the quarantine Is for coffee that Is being exported, it is not a quarantine against entry. I have spoken with Jeff Rebuglo of Kaanapali land Management and Cha ~r of the Kaanapali lot Owners Association requesting that he provide owners with a fact sheet regarding the coffee borer beetle. Please contact Jeff for additional coffee borer beetle facts.

Security We live in the home beside the ohana which we hope to use for the bed and breakfast. This Is our full time home. Our guests will be living on our propertv and sharing our driveway. We will use the utmost of care In selecting our guests and we can require a government issued ID prior to booking. A Short Term Rental Home is already permitted and operating within the neighborhood • (Permit #STWM 20150005) Neither the owner nor a manager are required to live on site for a STRH. I do not know of any problems with that STRH. Further, in addition to all those that have access on a dally basis

(construction workers, maintenance workers, deliveries, etc.) bicycle riders and dog walkers from surrounding neighborhoods, electric bike tours and dirt bikes enter the coffee farms almost dally by cutting through the plantings beside the gate, using the construction entrance or riding up through the many farm access roads. Further, there is not a code that will be provided to guests that can be shared with others. Entrance is gained by calling a code from the gate that rings my personal cell phone. As an

owner, we have a couple of extra cards. Guests will be provided these cards and they shall be returned to us for use by the next guests. Should a card get lost or stolen, the number can be deactivated electronically by the KCF office.

1 hope that this information helps alleviate some of your concerns. Please do not hesitate to contact me should you have further questions or concerns.

With aloha, J'., ~~/k>

Kathy and Chris Davey 2950 Aina Mahi'ai Place lahaina, HI 96761

Tara Furukawa - Fwd: Davy B&B

From: To: Date: Subject:

Lyn Muegge <lynmuegge@gmail.com> Tara Furukawa <Tara.Furukawa@co.maui.hi.us> 4/13/2017 9:43AM Fwd: Davy B&B

Page 1 of 1 f/ P2. OU"04 COVv

sorry sent to planning generic address and it bounced so I am forwarding it. It is in relation to Davey B&B app # 2017 0022, Mr Scott is an owner in coffee farm. ----------Forwarded message---------From: Worthy Clay Scott <\\orthvclavscottr(i{aol.com> Date: Thu, Apr 13, 2017 at 7:30AM Subject: Re: Davy B&B To: Lyn Muegge <lvnmucl!ge'ct(gmail.com> Cc: bradley howard <bhoward '£i jackbilt.com>, Barry <bn!000 :aol.com>, Jim K <iimknuppc'ii'gmail .com>, planninll'CI·,mauicountv.gov

Aloha My name is Worthy C. Scott and I am the owner of Lot #7 at the Coffee Farms. I am adamantly opposed to any short term rentals including a B&B, as it will increase the chances of introducing the Borer Beatie with potentially devastating results! Thank you! Worthy Scott

Sent from my iPhone

On Apr 4, 2017, at 11 :16 AM, Lyn Muegge <lvnmuegge@gmail.com> wrote:

Sorry, also intended to tell you that you can submit by email at

planning.a)nauicountv .gov.

I would suggest doing this and sending a hard copy.

Remember deadline is April 16, but late is never and early is good.

file:/ //C:/Users/County%20Employee/ AppData/Local/Temp/XPgrpwise/58EF4827 gw55do... 4/ 13/2017

Mr. Worthy Clay Scott worthyclayscott@aol.com lot 7

RE: Davey Bed and Breakfast Application TMK: (2) 4-4-020 052

April 24, 2017

Aloha, I am writing In response to your letter expressing concern regarding my Bed & Breakfast application for

our home in the Ka'anapall Coffee Farm (KCF). My husband Chris and I l ive full time In our home which is next to the chana which is the subject of this application. Your letter expressed concern regarding the spread of the coffee borer beetle from guests that may stay at our Bed and Breakfast. Thank you for the opportunity to address these concerns.

It is our understanding that the coffee borer beetle Is a concern. However, the coffee farms Itself has not implemented any restrictions on access. I have spoken w•th Jeff Rebugio of Kaanapali Land Management and Chair of the Kaanapali Lot Owners Association requesting that he provide owners with a fact sheet regarding the coffee borer beetle. Please contact Jeff for additional coffee borer beetle questions.

When we begin to advertise, we will emphasize that this Is a working coffee farm and provide Information about the borer beetle. We can also screen our guests. Often guests check on rental information prior to booking their Itinerary so If guests are planning on visiting the Big Island prior to

visiting Maui we can suggest that Maui be visited first if they wish to book our ohana. We can also provide a voucher for a car wash should our guests travel to Hana. Unfortunately, it Is doubtful that the care we take with our guests will prevent the introduction of the beetle considering the dally construction traffic, Including earthmoving equipment and contractors (some from Hana} and the lack of access restrictions on anv other visitor to the neighborhood.

PI east: bt: assured that as concerned owners Uving in the neighborhood, If the KCF Implements restrictions for those who enter the coffee farm we will certainly comply and will instruct our guests to

do so as well.

With aloha, lA Ka~a:v :£'r 2950 Aina Mahi'ai Place Lahaina, HI 96761

Tara Furukawa - comment on Bed and Breakfast application for TMK(2)4-4-020 052

From: To: Date: Subject:

Barry <bnlOO@aol .com> <planning@mauicounty .gov> 4/4/2017 2:16PM comment on Bed and Breakfast application for TMK(2)4-4-020 052

Department of Planning, 2200 Main Street, Suite 315 Wailuku HI 96793 808-270-8205

Page I of2

Re: Kathy and Jim Davey's Application for a B&B license at Ka'anapali Coffee Farm TMK{2)4-4-020 052

To Whom It May Concern: I am writing to express our great concern and strong opposition to allowing a Bed & Breakfast operation at the Davey's home at the Ka'anapali Coffee Farm, where we are reside on Lot #34. We are the immediate neighbor to the north/west of their property. Our lots are adjacent. My wife and I have three reasons for opposing this application.

1. Development of their three structures is now complete, and apparently is already being rented out. We have seen different cars there over night on several occasions. Due to completely inadequate landscaping, there is insufficient screening between our properties and so we see car lights and can hear noise quite clearly especially during the evenings. Daily rentals will no doubt raise the traffic to and from the property, and increase the chances of us hearing more noise that will disturb the peace and quiet we moved here to enjoy.

2. As you know, the coffee borer beetle is a threat to all coffee farms on Maui. As owners, we are striving to limit access to the farm and are worried that daily traffic in and out would increase the risk of this pest being transmitted. We live on a profitable working coffee farm, the

file:/I/C:/Users/County%20Employee/AppData!Local/Temp/XPgrpwise/58E4B903gw55do... 4/5/2017

Page 2 of2

income from which offsets our homeowner's association fees. The economic threat this beetle represents to the farm collectively far outweighs the private benefit to the Davey's income stream. A daily rental program would no doubt include guests who are coming from the big island where the beetle is presently destroying coffee crops. 3. We built here at the coffee farm- and plan to live here forever. We are highly uncomfortable with strangers passing through the gates on a daily basis. This is an issue of privacy and security. We chose to build here because of the sense of privacy and quiet. We don't want those conditions to change. Had we known that we might be living next door to a B&B we would never have moved here I

In summary, my wife Denise and I think that having a B&B on the farm is a very bad idea. We urge you to deny this permit! Sincerely,

Barry and Denise Nussbaum Project Manager Menehune Ventures, LLC. Lot 34

file:///C:/Users/County%20Employee/AppData/Localffemp/XPgrpwise/58E4B903gw55do... 4/5/2017

Barry and Denise Nussbaum

Project Manager, Menehune Ventures, LLC lot 34 bnlOO@aol.com

RE: Davey Bed and Breakfast Application

TMK: (21 4-4o020 052

April 24, 2017

Aloha,

I am writing In response to your letter expressing concern regarding my Bed & Breakfast (B and B)

application for our home In the Ka'anapall Coffee Farm (KCF). My husband Chris (not Jim) and myself

live full time in our home. He is a physician and I am a retired attorney. Your fetter expressed concern regarding the spread of the coffee borer beetle from guests that may stay at our Bed and Breakfast, the

purpose of our application and our income stream, landscaping, noise and you also expressed concern regarding strangers entering the coffee farms on a dally basis. Thank you for the opportunity to address these concerns.

Coffee Borer Beetle It is our understanding also that the coffee borer beetle is a concern. However, the

coffee farms Itself has not Implemented any restrictions on access. Currently construction vehicles,

Including earth moving equipment from Hana (where the beetle has been found) construction

equipment that is used Island wide, construction workers and their vehlctes, landscapers doing

maintenance and planting landscape plants, delivery trucks, pool maintenance vehicles, realtors with visitors with rental cars, and everyone who lives here and tnelr friends and guests enter the coffee farm

without any checking of tires, shoes or equipment for dirt.

When we begin to advertise, we will emphasize that this Is a working coffee farm and provide

Information about the borer beetle. We can also screen our guests. Often guests check on rental information prior to booking their Itinerary so If guests are planning on visiting the Big Island prior to visiting Maul we can suggest that Maul be visited first If they wish to book our chana. We can also provide a voucher for a car wash should our guests travel to Hana. Unfortunately, it IS doubtful that the care we take with our guests will prevent the Introduction of the beetle considering the dally traffic. All

traffic could be considered a threat to the profits of the coffee farm, not solely the few guests from our B and B. Please be assured that as concerned owners living in the neighborhood, If the KCF Implements

restrictions for those who enter the coffee farm we will certainly comply and will instruct our guests to

dosoas well.

Purpose of aoplicatlon We are applying for a B and 8 permit to comply with the law. We have not begun

short term rentals as your letter to the Planning Commission suggests, nor have we had different cars

here overnight on several occasions. We have relatives In England and an adopted family In Denmark, a son and daughter-In law in Florida and my sister Is In Pennsylvania. When we get visitors, they stay for extended periods. For example, at the end of February, two college friends visited for 10 days and In March my two Danish 'sisters' and their husbands visited for three weeks. When we do not have friends

or family visiting we would like to legally rent the ohana, hence the application. Please be assured that our proposed 8 and 8 is not going to be a hotel-type establishment. Further, the rental is limited by

Maui County for a maximum of four guests. We will not have daily rentals, we will seek a minimum stay

of five days and prefer longer stays. It Is not going to be utilized full time as a Bed and Breakfast, our

family and friends will take preference over any other guests.

Landscaplns. noise and car lights. Both ot our properties have 1m mature landscaping. As you are aware,

we are currently In the process of landscaping our property now that the construction has been completed. We have also planted areca palms, as have you, which should help screen our property from your view. We are perplexed as to your noise complaints "'during the eveningsH as our lanai Is on

the other side of our home and does not face your home. My husband and I live here by ourselves and have only had two small gatherings: the Home Blessing (20 guests) and my 60111 birthday party (7 guests},

both of these events ended around 10· 10:30 p.m .. Further, we do not own any barking dogs that could disrupt the enjoyment of your property In the evenings or during the day.

We do not understand how it Is physically possible to see headlights from cars In our driveway at your

home considering your property is quite a bit higher in elevation than ours and the approximate

distance of one acre from our driveway to your home. Nonetheless, when both of our homes'

landscaping matures we trust It will resolve this issue. Additionally, 1 have spoken with Jeff Rebuglo at

the KCF and it my understanding that additional shrubs or trees may be planted on the berms between

our properties. We hope that this wlll alleviate your concerns regarding headlights from our property.

Finally, the Maul County Code also requires the following to ensure the peace and quiet of the

neighborhood: (Maul Code Sec:.l9.64.030): "Q. The proprietor shall post "house policies'' with•n each guest room and snail be responsible

for enforcing such policies. The house policies shall include the foll.owing provisions: 1. Quiet hours shall be maintained from 9:00p.m. to 8:00 a.m., during which noise In the bed

and breakfast home shall not disturb anyone on a neighboring property.

2. Amplified sound that is audible beyond the property boundaries of the bed and breakfast is

prohibited. 3. Vehicles shall be parked In the designated onslte parking area and shall not be parked on the street overnight."

Security. We live In the home beside the ohana which we hope to use for the bed and breakfast. This is our full time home. Our guests will be IMng on our property and sharing our driveway. We will use the

utmost of care in selecting our guests and we can require a government Issued 10 prior to booking. Further, unlike a code that Is provided to c::ontractors, t here is not a code that we have that will be provided to guests that can be shared with others. Entrance is gained by calling a code from the gate that rings my personal cell phone. As an owner, we have a couple of extra swipe cards for entry. Guests

w itl be provided these cards and they shall be returned to us for use by the next guests. Should a card

get lost or stolen, the number of the lost card can be deactivated electronically by the KCF office.

The Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Easements for the KCF {the "Declaration"), which was avaUable for review prior to lot purchase, does not prohibit Short Term Rental Homes (STRH) nor Bed

and Breakfasts establishments. Further, prior to submitting our application to the County, we confirmed this with the KCF and there was no objection nor restriction on our application. A Short Term Rental Home Is already permitted and operating within the neighborhood. (Permit #STWM 20150005). Neither the owner nor a manager are required to live on site for a STRH; for a Bed and Breakfast establishment the owner or a full time manager is required to be on·site. I do not know of any problems with that STRH, even though those guests enter unmonltored on a dally basis. Further, in addition to all those that have access on a dally basts (construction workers, maintenance workers, deliveries, etc.) bicycle riders and dog walkers from surrotmding neighborhoods, electric bike tours and dirt bikes enter the coffee farms almost dally by cutting through the plantings beside the gate, using the construction entrance or riding up through the many farm access roads.

We hope that the explanations provided above will help alleviate some of your concerns.

With aloha,

¥~ Kathy and Chris Davey

2950 Aina Mahial Place Lahaina, HI 96761

JACK & LYN MUEGGE

2951 Aina Mahiai PL Lahaina, HI 96761 808-662-0601

March 9, 2017

.Department of P1annmg 2200 ·Main Street

COUNTY OF MAUl DEPT. OF PLANNING • CURRENT

I

Suite 315 Wailuku, Hl96793

Attention: Tera l<alanbara, appllcation # 2017 0022

APR -6 20\7

RECElVED

Re: Ptoposecf Bed & Brearc:fast Ka'anapan Coffee Fa~ rot 5Zfmkfl 440200520000~ 2950 Aina Mahi'ai Place~ Lahaina~ Hl9676-1~ owner Davey.

Our property is 2951 Aina Mahi'ai Place (lot 15) and our entry sits directly across the street from the proposed B & B. Our ohana is within 125 feet of the proposed unit.

We oppose the J;Jpproval cf the ~roposed permit for the following reasons.

The most important is the Coffee Berry Borer Beetle (CBB). The owners are the farmer of the coffee farm and have direct responsibility for costs. The CBB has been identified on Maui near Hana and Kipahulu. This applicant's property sits north into the farm as far in as the road goes and in the middle of the farm east to west. All transient renters will have to drive through the farm area.

Since the CBB has been identified on Maui, farming tours. have been- cancelled, gates closed, signs posted. Coffee-trees afong the roadways where tourists often stop to look have been cut low to prevent infestation on leaves. A substantial monetary investment has been made for additional prevention practices.

Residents have been asked to not go to infested areas on Maui or farms on other i slands .and ·if they .do .go {even close to the ..area) to stop before returning home and have their cars and ·tires washed ·and bag the dothes worn and then wash them immediately. This is a serious threat. Kimo Falconer who leads the coffee operation has been quoted several times in the Maui News about the spread of the CBB. The coffee on Maui is now under quarantine because of the possibte spread. This appticant is very close to many coffee trees (less than 200 feet) both on their lot and lots adjoining and across all corners.

l People who choose to rent in a coffee farm would probably be interested in other coffee operations. Many visitors who come to Maui make the trip t~ Hana and would probably stop by coffee farm there as well. They also may have been to other islands. Therefore approving transient occupancy increases the risk a great deal.

• --

The CBB Is a risk to the entire 4"50 acre operation on the Ka'anapali Coffee. Farm, a major agricultural endeavor that is· highly. successful. Historically the operation has returned a profit distribution to the owners. Not only is this return at risk, if the farm becomes non-profitable the owners will bear that burden. If that burden becomes too high, the coffee will be abandoned.

If the infestation gets to us then it will undoubtedly reach all the farms on Maui. One proposal to replace the islands lost sugar cane is .a major coffee operation. Several articles about tnis have been.pubrished in the Maui News. If the Borer reaches us that would probably cause a rethinking of that proposal.

Additionally, our chana bedrooms are situated on the street side and would be greatly impacted by the additional traffic and noise of a B & B. We are also impacted by the excessive dust generated by roads while construction is being done. Since construction wiH be continuing for several years additional immediate traffic will only exasperate this problem.

We moved here from Ka'anapali Hillside to obtain greater lot sizes and have a quieter life. This investment was meant to be our final home and represents the largest investment in rear estate we have made. When we dia our planning and design B&B's were not allowed so we did not design for that occurrence. Our nei_ghbors have said they always intended to rent their chana .and could ·have designed their driveway and placement of the houses to mitigate the impact on neighbors.

They chose not to do so. And we have no expectation of them being concerned neighbors now. Even asked several times to landscape the chana area they were living in over the past two years during construction of the main home helping to block the~dust and screen their large direct tv antennae they refused. Now that they want a B&B the work is being completed.

Currently our streets are under great stress. Directly above the proposed B&B the street is buckling due to traffic and incorrect water control when it was built. Additional traffic in this area wouJd cause the whore association to incur yet more costs of repair. We are currently studying the reasons but until they are known .additional traffic is no'twante~.

In summary, we feel the application should be denied mainly to aid in the efforts underway to prevent the infestation of the Coffee Berry Borer Beetle and the potential impact on our farm and our financial well-being. We fear one approval WI"'H 1ead to adortional applications.

I' ask the Department of Planning to refuse this. application.

I also ask that the Department of Planning make the Ka'anapali coffee farm an endangered or at least a high risk area for anything increasing transient traffic as long as the quarantine of the coffee is in effect. Thank you for your consideration.

Jack and Lyn Muegge 2951 Alna Mahi'ai Place, Lahaina, HI 96761

RE: Davey Bed and Breakfast Application

TMK: (2) 4-4-020 052

Aprll24,2017

Aloha,

I am writing in response to your letter expressing concern regarding my Bed & Breakfast (8 and B) application for our home in the Ka'anapali Coffee Farm (KCF). As you are aware, my husband Chris and 1

live full time in our home. Your letter expressed concern regarding the spread of the coffee borer beetle

from guests that may stay at our 8 and 8, how our guests will destroy the profitability of the coffee

farm, guest traffic and noise from the B and 8, construction traffic in the neighborhood generating dust, our construction, the state of repair of the roads in the neighborhood, landscaping, the configuration of structures upon our site, the placement of our satellite dish, and you also expressed concern regarding

strangers entering the coffee farms on a dally basis. Thank you for the opportunity to address these concerns.

Coffee Borer Beetle and the economic threat from B and B guests It Is our understanding also that the coffee borer beetle is a concern. However, the coffee farms itself has not Implemented any restrictions on access. Currently construction vehicles, Including earth moving equipment from Hana (where the beetle has been found) construction equipment that Is used island wide, construction workers and their vehic.es, landscapers doing maintenance and planting landscape plants, delivery trucks, pool

maintenance vehicles, realtors with visitors with rental cars, and everyone who lives here and their

friends and guests enter the coffee farm on a daily basis without any checking of tires, shoes or equipment for dirt.

When we begin to advertise, we will emphasize that this Is a working coffee farm and provide information about the borer beetle. We can also screen our guests. Often guests check on rental Information prior to booking their itlnera ry so If guests are planning on v isiting the Big Island prior to

visiting Maui we can suggest that Maul be visited first If they wish to book our ohana. We can also

provide a voucher for a car wash should our guests travel to Hana. Unfortunately, it is doubtful that the

care we take with our guests will prevent the Introduction of the beetle considering the dally traffic. AU

traffic could be considered an economic threat to the profits of the coffee farm, not solely the few guests from our B and B. Please be assured that as concerned owners living In the neighborhood, if the KCF implements restrictions for those who enter the coffee farm we will certainly comply and will Instruct our guests to do so as well. I have spoken with Jeff Rebuglo, whom you know, of Kaanapali land Management and Chair of the KaanapaU Lot Owners Association requesting that he provide all owners

with a fact sheet regarding the coffee borer beetle.

Guest Traffic:. noise from the B and B and the configuration of the structures and satellite dish upon our property, We have relatives in England and an adopted family in Denmark, a son and daughter•in \aw in

Florida and my sister Is In Pennsylvania. When we get visitors, they stay for extended periods. For

example, at the end of February, two friends visited for 10 days and in March my two Danish 'sisters'

and their husbands visited for over three weeks. When we do not have friends or family vlsltlng we would like to legally rent the ohana, hence the application. Please be assured that our B and B

application Is not a hotel-type establishment. We wlfl not have dally rentals, we will seek a minimum stay of five days and prefer longer stays.

The chana has two bedrooms and two baths and pursuant to County Rules there will be a maximum of

four guests. Please be assured that the traffic and noise at the B and 8 will be no more traffic than we

have had with friends and relatives visiting, nor no more traffic nor noise than guests in your ohana have generated In simply living In a residential area.

Maui County Code also requires the following to ensure the Peace and Quiet of the neighborhood: (Maui Code Sec.19.64.030}:

"Q. The proprietor shall post "house policies" within each guest room and shall be responsible for

enforcing such policies. The house policies shall include the following provisions:

1. Quiet hours shall be maintained from 9:00 p.m. to 8:00a.m., during which noise in the bed and breakfast home shall not disturb anyone on a neighboring property.

2. Amplified sound that Is audible beyond the property boundaries of the bed and breakfast Is proh~blted.

3. Vehicles shall be parked in the designated onsite parking area and shall not be parked on the street overnight."

Our carport for the ohana Is on the side of the ohana away from the street so any cars parked there should not be visible from your lot.

The configuration of the structures on our property is the mirror Image of the conflguratlon of the

structures on your property. Both of our properties have the chana located on the street side and each

home is set back from the property line. The placement of all structures on our property Is in

compliance w ith the KCF Declaration as is the pla(ement of the satellite dish. We hope that the

vegetation will soon completely screen the dish. This ground placement was preferable to the KCF than a smaller unit placed higher up under the eaves of the ohana.

Construction traffic In the neighborhood generating dust. our construction, the state of repair of the

roads in the neishborhood, landscaping. We also recognize and live with the ongoing construction traffic and construction in the neighborhood which generates dust and is stressing the roads. The two to four guests that will be renting the ohana will be no more traffic than any lot owners' family or friends have generated and Is inslgnlflcant fn terms of traffic and road stress caused by the dally heavy construction traffic. When we were under construction we erected a dust barrier, but given the winds and the nature

of llving on a working coffee farm we unfortunately cannot (ontrof ttle dust on our lot nor the dust and

traffic on the other lots in the neighborhood. Upon tile completion of our construction and the pourlns of our driveway we Immediately began Installing our landscaping. It would have been futile to Install

this prior to the completion of construction. We are installing It as quickly as possible and are also looking forward to a landscaped yard that will be a pleasure to look at for ourselves and our neighbors.

Security. We live In the home beside the ohana which we hope to use for the bed and breakfast. This Is our full-time home. Our guests will be living on our property and sharing our driveway. We will use the utmost of care in selecting our guests and we can require a government issued 10 prior to booking. Further, there Is not a code that will be provided to guests that can be shared with others. Entrance Is

gained by calling a code from the gate that rings my personal cell phone. As an owner, we have a couple

of extra cards. Guests will be provided these cards and they shall be returned to us for use by the next

guests. Should a card get lost or stolen, the number can be deactivated electronically by the KCF office.

Prior to submitting our application to the County, we discussed our application with the KCF and there

was no objection nor restriction on our application. As you are aware, a Short Term Rental Home is already permitted and operating within the neighborhood. (Permit #STWM 20150005). Neither the

owner nor a manager are required to live on site for a STRH; for a Bed and Breakfast establishment the

owner or a full-time manager is required to be on-site. I do not know of any problems with that STRH, even though those guests enter unmonltored dally. Further, In addition to all those that have access dally (construction workers, maintenance workers, deliveries, etc.) bicycle riders and dog walkers from surrounding neighborhoods, electric bike tours and dirt bikes enter the coffee farms almost dally by cutting through the plantings beside the gate, using the construction entrance or riding up through the

many farm access roads.

1 hope the above section addresses your concerns resarding security of the neighborhood and that your

other concerns have been addressed In this letter as well .

~~~t4 Kathy (and Chris) Davey

2950 Aina Mah1'al Place

Lahaina, HI 96761

Department of Planning, 2200 Main Street, Suit 315 Wailuku HI 96793

808-270-8205

Meredith Halks Miller, MD 799 G)encrag Way

Woodside, CA 94062 29 March 2017

Re: Kathy Davey's Application for a B&B license at Ka'anapali Coffee Farm

TMK(2)4-4-020 052 To Whom It May Concern:

I am writing to express my great concern and opposition to allowing a Bed & Breakfast operation at the Davey's home at the Ka'anapali Coffee Farm, where we are owners of Lot #10.

My husband and I have two reasons for opposing this application.

I. As you know, the coffee borer beetle is a threat to all coffee farms on Maui. As owners, we are striving to limit access to the farm and are worried that daily traffic in and out would increase

the risk of this pest being transmitted. We live on a profitable working coffee farm, the income from which offsets our homeowner's association fees. The economic threat this beetle represents to the farm collectively far outweighs the private benefit to the Davey's income stream.

2. Also, we are building our home at the coffee farm - this is where we plan to live. I am uncomfortable with strangers passing through the gates on a daily basis. This is an issue of privacy and security. We chose to build here because of the sense of privacy and quiet. We don't want those conditions to change.

In summary, my husband Terry and I think that having a B&B on the farm is a very bad idea. We urge you to deny this permit!

Sincerely,

Meredith Halks Miller, MD

Terry P. Miller, MD

Contact Cell Phone: 650-208-6978 Contact email: mhalksm@gmail.com

Meredith Halks Miller, MD Terry P. Miller, MO 799 Glen crag Way Woodside, CA 94062

RE: Davey Bed and Breakfast Application TMI<: (2) 4-4-020 052

April 24, 2017

Aloha,

I am writing In response to your letter expressing concern regarding my Bed & Breakfast (Band B) application for our home in the Ka'anapali Coffee Farm fKCF). My husband Chris and myself live full time in our home which is next to the chana which is the subject of this application. He is a physician and 1 am a retired attorney. Your letter expressed concern regarding the spread of the coffee borer beetle from guests that may stay at our Bed and Breakfast, our Income stream and you also expressed concern regarding strangers entering the coffee farms on a dally basis. Thank you for the opportunity to address these concerns.

Coffee Borer Beetle It Is our understanding also that the coffee borer beetle Is a concern. Because you

are not yet living in the neighborhood you may not be aware that the coffee farms Itself tlas not

implemented any restrictions on access. Currently construction vehicles, including earth moving equipment from Hana {where the beetle has been found) construction equipment that is used Island

wide, construction workers and their vehicles, landscapers doing maintenance and planting landscape plants, delivery trucks, pool maintenance vehicles, realtors with vfsltors with rental cars, and everyone who lives here and their friends and guests enter the coffee farm without any checking of tires, shoes or equipment for dirt.

When we begin to advertise, we will emphasize that this Is a working coffee farm and provide information about the borer beetle. We can also screen our guests. Often guests check on rental

information prior to booking their itinerary so if guests are planning on visiting the Big Island prior to visiting Maui we can suggest that Maul be visited first If they wish to book our chana. We can also provide a voucher for a car wash should cur guests travel to Han a. Unfortunately, It Is doubtful that the

care we take with our guests will prevent the introduction of the beetle considering the daily traffic. All traffic could be considered a threat to the profits of the coffee farm, not solely the few guests from our 8 and B. Please be assured that as concerned owners living in the neighborhood, If the KCF implements restrictions for those who enter the coffee farm we will certainly comply and wflllnstruct our guests to do so as well. I have spoken with Jeff Rebuglo of Kaanapali Land Management and Cha~r of the Kaanapali Lot owners Association requesting that he provide owners with further Information regarding the coffee borer beetle and he has informed me that tie will be sending out a fact sheet. Please address

coffee borer beetle questions to Jeff.

We are applying for a a and B permit to comply with the law. We have relatives In England and an adopted family in Denmark, a son and daughter-in law In Florida and mv sister Is In Pennsylvania. When

we get visitors, they stay for extended periods. For exam pie, at the end of february, two friends visited for 10 days and In March my two Danish 'sisters' and their husbands visited for three weeks. When we do not have friends or family visiting we would like to legally rent the ohana, hence the application. Please be assured that a B and B is not a hotel-type establishment. We will not have dally rentals, we will seek a minimum stay of five days and prefer longer stays. Further, the rental is limited by Maul County for a maximum of four guests. I hope this section addresses your Inquiry as to the coffee borer beetle and our income stream.

Security We live In the home beside the ohana which we hope to use for the bed and breakfast. This Is our full t rme home. Our guests will be living on our property and sharing our driveway. We will use the utmost of care in selecting our guests and we can require a government Issued ID prior to booking. Further, there is not a code that will be provided to guests that can be shared with others. Entrance Is gained by calling a code from the gate that rings my personal cell phone. As an owner, we have a couple of extra cards. Guests will be provided these cards and they shall be returned to us for use by the next guests. Should a card get lost or stolen, the number can be deactivated electronically by the KCF office.

The Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Easements for the KCF does not prohibit Short Term Rental Homes (STRH) nor Bed and Breakfasts establishments. Further, prior to submitting our application to the County, we confirmed this with the I<CF and there was no objection nor restriction on our application. You may not be aware, but a Short Term Rental Home is already permitted and operating within the neighborhood. (Permit #SlWM 20150005}. Neither the owner nor a manager are required to live on site for a STRH; for a Bed and Breakfast establishment the owner or a full time manager is required to be on-site. I do not know of any problems with that STRH, even though those guest5 enter unmonitored on a dally basis. Further, In addition to all those that have access on a dally basis (construction workers. maintenance workers, deliveries, etc.) bicycle riders and dog walkers from surrounding neighborhoods, electric bike tours and dirt bikes enter the coffee farms almost dally by cutting through the plantings beside the gate, using the construction entrance or riding up through the

many farm access roads.

1 hope that this letter helps to alleviate some of your concerns. Please do not hesitate to contact me

should you have further Questions or issues.

~;I~~~ Kathy and Chris Davey 2950 Alna Mahi'al Place Lahaina, Hl96761

COUNTY OF MAUl DEPT OF PLANNING CURRENT

April3, 2017

Planning Director County of Maui Department of Planning 2200 Main St Suite 619 Wailuku, HI 96793

RE: Bed & Breakfast Home Permit Application No. 2017 0022

To: Planning Director County of Maui

From: james Kimo Falconer, President, MauiGrown Coffee, I

APR -6 2017

RECEiVED

I am writing this letter in opposition of this permit applicat n for a Bed & Breakfast operation on the property located at 2950 Aina Mahi'ai Place, Lahaina, HI 96761, TMK # 440200520000.

The homeowners within this agriculture subdivision have been made aware of a very serious pest recently introduced to Hawaii and earlier this year found on the island of Maui. Coffee Berry Borer (CBB) moves most efficiently by way of hitchhiking on ag products, autos, pets and people who have visited farms that have been infested with this insect We do not have this pest yet on West Maui. We are diligent in our operations in trying to delay infection of this farm. There is no chemical means or other means of control that will not result in huge costs due to changes that will be needed to our current cultural practices should this pest arrive. The potential for large crop losses is great

We are concerned that visitor turnover that could arrive after recently visiting an infected area will not be monitored and would put our current work to avoid infection into the hands of people who may not have the farms' best interest in mind.

Thank you for giving me the opportunity to testify in this matter.

275 Lahainaluna Rd. • Lahaina, Maul, HI 96761 • www.mauigrowngreencoffee.com

J

Jam~s Kimo Falconer,

President, Maui Grown Coffee, Inc. 275 lahalnaluna Rd Maui, HI 96761

RE: Davey Bed and Breakfast Application

TMK: (2) 4-4-GZO 052

April 24, 2017

Aloha,

I am writing In response to your letter expressing concern regarding my Bed & Breakfast application for

our home in the Ka'anapali Coffee Farm (KCF}. My husband Chris and myself live full time In our l'lome

which is next to the chana which Is the subject of this application. Your letter e)(pressed concern

regarding the spread of the coffee borer beetle from guests that may stay at our Bed and Breakfast.

Thank you for the opportunity to address these concerns.

When we begin to advertise, we will emphasize that this Is a working coffee farm and provide

information about the borer beetle. We can also screen our guests. Often guests check on rental

information prior to booking their itinerary so If guests are planning on visiting the Big Island prior to

visiting MaUl we can suggest that Maul be visited first if they wish to book our ohana. We can also provide a voucher for a car wash should our guests travel to Hana. Unfortunately, It Is doubtful that the

care we take with our guests will prevent the Introduction of the beetle considering the dally

construction traffic, bringing In of fill dirt, earthmoving equipment and contractors (some from Hana}

and the lack of access restrictions on any other visitor to the neighborhood. for example, a Short Term

Rental Home Is already permitted in the KCF and neither the owner nor the manager live on site to

monitor those guests.

As an owner living In the neighborhood we have not received any written materials regarding

preventative measures. If you have any materials or a fact sheet that I can share with guests that would

be very helpful and most appreciated. I have reached out to Jeff Rebugio and he Indicated that he will be providing owners with some coffee borer beetle rnformation.

With aloha, ~

~·(15 Kathy and Chris Oavey

2950 Ail'\a Mahi'ai Place

Lahaina, HI 96761

Tara Furukawa - Re: Kathy and Jim Davey's Application for a B&B license at Ka 'anapali Coffee Farm TMK(2)4-4-020 052

From: To: Date: Subject:

DeurTura.

Sherry McGann <sherry.mcgann@gmail.com> <Tara.Furukawa@co.maui.hi.us> 4113/201 7 12:03 PM Re: Kathy and Jim Davey's Application for a B&B license at Ka'anapali Coffee Farm TMK (2)4-4-020 052

I am writing to express concern and opposition to allowing a Bed & Breakfast operation at the Davey's home at the Ka'anapali Coffee Farm. where we reside on Lot # 16 (Celestial Properties).

We nrc the neighbor to the south of their property.

I'm not opposed to such operations in the coiTee furm if strict guidelines are established, followed and enforced; however. the development is to new to have resources to create such at this time and we nrc faced with the beetle damage threats.

Please don't hesitate giving me a call if you have any questions or would like to discuss.

Sincerely.

Sherry McGann

file :///C:/Users/County%20Employee/ AppData/Local/Temp/XPgrpwise/58EF690Agw55d... 4/ 13/2017

Sherry McGann

!ill!!fT'I.mcaaonCgmal!.com

Lot 16, "Celestial Propertiesu

April24, 2017

RE: Davey Bed and Breakfast Application TMK: (2) 4-4-020 052

Aloha,

I am writing in response to your email to the County expressing concern regarding my Bed & Breakfast

(Band B) application for our home In the Ka'anapall Coffee Farm (KCF). As you are aware, my husband

Chris (not Jim) and I live full time in our home which Is next to the chana which Is the subject of this

application, our property is several lots (and acres) north of your property. Your Jetter expressed concern regarding the spread of the coffee borer beetle from guests that may stay at our Bed and

Breakfast and guidelines for the Bed and Breakfast. Thank you for the opportunity to address these concerns.

Coffee Borer Beetle It Is our understanding also that the coffee borer beetle is a concern. However, the

coffee farms itself has not implemented any restrictions on access. Currently construction vehicles,

including construction equipment and workers from Hana (where the beetle has been found) and other

equipment that is used lsland w ide, construction workers and their vehicles, landscapers doing

maintenance and planting landscape plants, delivery trucks, pool maintenance vehicles, realtors with

visitors with rental cars, and everyone who lives here and their friends and guests enter the coffee farm

without any checking of tires, shoes or equipment for dirt. I have spoken with Jeff Rebugio of Kaanapali

Land Management and Chair of the Kaanapali Lot owners Association requesting that he provide

owners with further Information regarding the coffee borer beetle and he has Informed me that he will

be sending out a fact sheet. Although one neighbor has called for restricted access to the KCF, Jeff

assures me that construction may continue.

Unfortunately, it Is doubtful that the care we take with our guests will prevent the Introduction ofthe beetle considenng the dally traffic. Please be assured t hat as concerned owners living In the

neighborhood, if the KCF Implements restrictions for those who enter the coffee farm we will certainly

comply and will Instruct our guests to do so as well.

Your second concern related to guidelines for the Bed and Breakfast slnce the neighborhood has not yet

had time to develop any guidelines. Maul County has al ready established minimum guidelines for Bed

and Breakfast establishments. The Maul County Code also requires the following to ensure the peace

and quiet of the neighborhood: (Maul Code Sec.19.64.030):

"Q. The proprietor shall post "house policies" within each guest room and shall be responsible for

enforcing such policies. The house policies shall include the following provisions:

1. Quiet hours shall be maintained from 9:00p.m. to 8:00a.m., during which noise In the bed and

breakfast home shall not disturb anyone on a neighboring property.

2. Amplified sound that Is audible beyond the property boundaries of the bed and breakfast Is prohibited .

3. Vehicles shall be parked in the designated on site parking area and shall not be parked on the street overnight."

Please note also that the rental is limited to 4 persons.

A Short Term Rental Home Is already permitted and operating w ithin the neighborhood. (Permit #STWM 20150005). Neither the owner nor a manager are required 'to live on site for a STRH; for a Bed and Breakfast establishment the owner or a full time manager Is required to be on-site. I do not know of any problems with that STRH, even though the neighborhood had not promulgated any guidelines prlor to

that home obtaining Its permit. It Is operating under Maui County guidelines as well.

1 hope this letter addresses the concerns that you raised In your email to the County. Please do not hesitate to contact me should you have further questions or concerns.

Kathy and Chris a

2950 Alna Mahi'ai Place

Lahaina, HI 96761

CJ3rad{ey (]). Jfoward 819 W. Olive Ave., Burbank, CA 91506 (818) 841-0881 Fax (818) 842-2127

March 09, 2017

Department of Planning 2200 Main Street, Suite 315 Wailuku, III 96793

Re: Bed and Breakfast Permit Parcel Number TMK (2)4-4-020 052

To Whom It May Concern,

Via: planning@mauicounty.gov

Please be advised as an owner of lot 21 on the Kaanapali Coffee farm, I am adamantly opposing the permit for a Bed and Breakfast that Kathy Davis has applied for. The reason I am opposing the B & B is for the sole purpose of protecting the Coffee Farm from the Coffee Borer Beetle.

This particular beetle is easily transferred from one place to the other via tires, clothing and shoes of which all guest visiting a Bed and Breakfast have. The only pre-caution to take to prevent transfer of the beetle would be for guests to wash their car, car tires and bag their clothes and shoes before returning to the farm which guests will not do and there is no way to enforce such, therefore guests of the B & B would undoubtedly bring the beetle to the farm causing irreparable damage and would be far too great of a risk that is not worth taking.

I hope you consider my concerns as I strongly believe that a B&B is not in the best interest of the coffee farm.

;i~;>-o~,.::::.~_-: ___ ~_-_- _C_· ---.......... ~-- ·--1

Mr. Bradley D Howard

819 W. Olive Ave.,

Burbank, CA 91S06

RE: Davey Bed and Breakfast Application

TMK: (2) 4-4-D20 052

April 24, 2017

Aloha,

I am writing In response to your letter expressing concern regarding my Bed & Breakfast application for

our home in the Ka'anapali Coffee Farm (KCF). My husband Chris and I live full time in our home which

Is next to the ohana which Is the subject of this application. Your letter expressed concern regarding the

spread of the coffee borer beetle from guests that may stay at our Bed and Breakfast. Thank you for the opportunity to address these concerns.

It Is our understanding that the coffee borer beetle Is a concern. However, the coffee farms itself has not

implemented any restrictions on access. I have spoken with Jeff Rebugio of Kaanapali Land Management

and Chair of the Kaanapali Lot Owners Association requesting that he provide owners with a fact sheet

regarding the coffee borer beetle. Please contact Jeff for additional coffee borer beetle questions.

When we begin to advert ise, we w ill emphaslz.e that this ls a workin1 coffee farm and provide Information about the borer beetle. We can also screen our guests. Often guests check on rental

information prior to booking their itinerary so If guests are planning on vlsitfng the Big Island prior to

visit jng Maul we can suggest that Maul be visited first If they wish to book our chana. We can also

provide a voucher for a car wash should our guests travel to Hana. Unfortunately, it Is doubtful that the care we take with our guests will prevent the Introduction of the beetle considering the dally

construction traffic, including earthmoving equipment and contractors (some from Hana) and the lack of

access restrictJons on any other visitor to the neighborhood. for example, a Short Term Rental Home is already permitted In the KCF and neither the owner nor the manager live on site to monitor those

guests.

Please be assured that as concerned owners living In the neighborhood, if the KCF implements

restrictions for those who enter the coffee farm we will certainly comply and will instruct our guests to

do so as well.

Witv~ .. ~ Kathy d y ""t

2950 Aina Mahi'al Place

Lahaina, HI 96761