Zaid Hamid: BrassTacks Policy Paper: Missing Persons of Baluchistan – looking beyond the Obvious

7/31/2019 Zaid Hamid: BrassTacks Policy Paper: Missing Persons of Baluchistan looking beyond the Obvious

1/10


2/10

Gexxenf Zd|xanx ai Lbothm

Ztloexmd`; =pm Ktou/


3/10

4

L|bxxPbhcxZaoehuZbzd|x rtdxpean |dgbenx pmbp vmu vato` Zbcexpbnx avn b|gu/ IH a| bnu bfdnhu/ce`nbz pmd zdbhdito bn` zbp|eapeh

Lbothm zdazod1 Na fayd|ngdnp enxpeptbpean/ enhotènf Xtz|dgd Hat|p cnavx pmd d}bhp ntgld| ai gexxenfzd|xanx/vmehm odb`x pa bnapmd| lbxeh rtdxpean pmbp mav pmd Xtz|dgd Hat|p ai Zbcexpbn dxpbloexmd` pmd d}'bhp ntgld| ai gexxenf zd|xanx1 Bn` b |dobpd` bn` drtboou h|epehbo rtdxpean b|exdx an pmd h|epd|eb ai Xtz|dgdHat|p/ bx vdoo/ pa dhob|d b zb|pehtob| enèye`tbo bx gexxenf.Pmd rtdxp pa bnxvd| pmdxd rtd|edx odb`x tx pa bnbou{d/ boanf vepm apmd| `dydoazgdnpx/ pmd zd|ia|gdnhd/ di'hednhu bn` hagzdpbnhu ai z|ayenhebo bn` id`d|bo fayd|ngdnpx ai ZZZ.

Pmd exxtd ai gexxenf zd|xanx vato` ndyd| fdp |dxaoyd` lu iahtxenf an pmd bzzb|dnp `dydoazgdnpx boand.

Xtz|dgd Hat|p veoo mbyd pa oaac lduan` pmd alyeatx. Pmd|d b|d gtopezod enpd|nbo bn` d}pd|nbo unbgehx pmbpmbyd xmbzd`'tz ht||dnp xp|eid'|e``dn dnye|angdnp en Lbothmexpbn bn` tn`d|xpbnènf pmdxd bxzdhpx vato` mdoztx pa bnbou{d pmd zaxxelod egzoehbpeanx ai pmd enpd|eg a|`d| ai pmd Xtz|dgd Hat|p en ayd|boo nbpeanbo xdht|epuzd|xzdhpeyd.

Pmd Dnye|angdnp

2. Enxt|fdnhedx;Pmd z|ayenhd ex en pmd f|ez ai oav odydo han'ehpx/ oenftexpeh yeaodnhd bn` xblapbfd `td pa ia|defn itn`d`pd||a|exp bn` xdzb|bpexp gaydgdnpx oecd LOB bn` L\B. Pmdxdpd||a|expx atppx mbyd p|benenf bn` oafexpehbo lbxdx en Bifmbne'xpbn xtzza|pd` lu Enèbn \BV bn` HEBx `|tf ndpva|c. EFIHLbothmexpbn mbx boxa mefmoefmpd` pmd |aod ai ia|defn bfdnhedxen Lbothmexpbn tn|dxp bn` pmex vbx dnà|xd` lu pmd ktèhebo

haggexxean. Bhha|ènf pa EFIH Lbothmexpbn/ ga|d pmbn 2::p|benenf hbgzx vd|d bhpeydou p|benenf pmd Lbothm geoepbnpx atpai vmehm bogaxp 8: hbgzx vd|d oahbpd` enxe`d Bifmbnexpbn.0Lbothm xdzb|bpexpx b|d nav bhpeyd en Cb|bhme bx vdoo3 xtzzouenfvdbzanx bn` bggtnepean pa pmd h|egenbo fbnfx ai Obub|e. EnGbu


4/10

6

L|bxxPbhcxZaoehuZbzd|x oahbo Lbothm odb`d|x. Hd|pbenou/ pmd zaoepehbo xeptbpean e n pmd z|ayenhd ex napmenf xma|p ai b hagehbo he|htx

vmd|d boo pmd bhpa|x |dgben hagzodpdou aloeyeatx pa pmd f|byepu ai pmd dnxtenf hmbax en pmd z|ayenhd.

4. Ha||tzpean; Pmd Ht||dnp ZZZ |dfegd mbx lddn `dhob|d`bx pmd va|xp en pd|gx ai nbnhebo gbnbfdgdnp bn` ha||tzpeanxenhd en`dzdn`dnhd. At| hatnp|u ex oaxenf \x. 9 pa = leooeanzd| `bu `td pa pmex ha||tzp fayd|ngdnp.5/2: Ltp pmd xeptbpeanen Lbothmexpbn mbx fand lduan` z|dhb|eatx nav ltp pmd ZZZz|ayenhebo genexpd|x nap anou hanxe`d| ep mb|godxx ltp boxa dn'hat|bfd ep3 bx xpbpd` lu pmd Haggtnehbpean Genexpd| ai Lbot'hmexpbn Boe Gb`b` Kbpbc22. Pmex ha||tzpean mbx hbzxe{d` pmddnpe|d b`genexp|bpeyd gbhmend|u en pmd z|ayenhd vmeod b xhbp'pd|d` zaztobpean ex en ndd` ai |bèhbo xpdzx en dydoazgdnp aipmd zayd|pu xp|ehcdn z|ayenhd.

\dhdnpou dyd|u genexpd| en Lbothmexpbn/ -vmd|d dyd|u gdgld|ai Lbothmexpbn bxxdglou ex b genexpd| vepm and a| pva d}hdz'peanx% vbx booahbpd` \x. 8:: geooean ia| `dydoazgdnp va|cx.Pmex p|dn` mbx lddn z|dybeoenf xenhd obxp yd udb|x bn` peoo navLbothmexpbn fayd|ngdnp mbx vbxpd` \x. 02: leooean en dgld{{odgdnp bn` gexgbnbfdgdnp.

9. Xahebo Exxtdx; Xhbppd|d` zaztobpean/ enb`drtbpd eni|bxp|thpt|d bn` oav oepd|bhu |bpd b|d pmd gbka||dbxanx ldmen` pmd xahea'dhanageh zoefmp ai pmd oahbox. Ha||tzpean bn` obhc ai oanf'pd|g zobnnenf boanfvepm zavd| zaoepehx lu pmd oahbo zaoepehebnx mbx zobud` h|epehbo |aod en cddzenf pmd oahbox an pmd oavdxpdhanageh ob``d|. Bx zd| pmd Hanxpeptpean/ |dxat|hd booahbpean bganf pmd z|ayenhdx ex ànd an pmd lbxexai zaztobpean ltp ep ex nap idbxelod ia| Lbothmexpbn ldhbtxd md|d anou 0$ ai pmd papbo zaztobpean ai pmdhatnp|u ex xhbppd|d` ayd| 04$ ai epx papbo b|db. B xeptbpean vepm yd|u oav zd|xanx zd| xrtb|d ceoagdpd| pmbpvato` |drte|d ga|d |dxat|hdx pmbn pmaxd booahbpd` z|dxdnpou tn`d| NIH Bvb|`.

Ke|fb xuxpdg ex pmd leffdxp mt|òd en dnxt|enf xahebo ktxpehd en pmd hagzod} Lbothm p|elbo xahedpu. Pmd z|dx'

dnhd ai pmex xuxpdg egzoedx pmbp pmd|d b|d ybxp b|dbx vmd|d fayd|ngdnp bn` ktèheb|u mbx na v|ep a| kt|ex'èhpean bn` mbx gb`d hagz|agexd ia| zaoepehbo fbenx.

6. Xb|`b|e Xuxpdg;Pmd p|elbo xp|thpt|d ai Lbothm xahedpu ex pmd leffdxp hmboodnfd en z|ayexean ai xahebobn` dhanageh tzoeip ai haggan Lbothmex. Boo pmd gbka| p|eldx mao` hdnpt|edx ao` f|t`fdx bfbenxp dbhmapmd| bn` pmex xahebo unbgeh zobux b hdnp|bo |aod en pmd bltxd ai zavd| bfbenxp apmd| p|eldx dxzdheboou vmdnb zaoepehebn i|ag b hd|pben p|eld kaenx pmd z|ayenhebo a| id`d|bo fayd|ngdnp. Pmex idt`bo Xb|`b|e xuxpdg mbxoepd|boou xpbood` pmd dydoazgdnp en gbnu zb|px ai pmd z|ayenhd zb|pehtob|ou en pmd |dxpeyd exp|ehpx vmeod pmdB|gu ex p|uenf `dxzd|bpdou ia| pmd xahebo tzoeip ai haggan gbn pm|atfm lteoènf xhmaaox bn` maxzepbox.

Dyd|u id`d|bo fayd|ngdnp en pmd mexpa|u ai Zbcexpbn mbx txd` pmex p|elbo xuxpdg ia| epx avn zaoepehbo fbenx.

Ep vbx en pmd 25pm hdnpt|u vmdn pmd L|epexm enp|a`thd` pmex xuxpdg pa eye`d bn` |tod pmd l|byd p|eldx lu zephm'enf pmdg bfbenxp dbhm apmd|. En 256


5/10

5

L|bxxPbhcxZaoehuZbzd|x hmexpbn. Enèbnx mbyd pmde| avn alyeatx bfdn`b bfbenxp Zbcexpbn. Ltp pmd rtdxpean b|exdx bx pa vmu pmd TX

vbnpx pa xdzb|bpd Lbothmexpbn i|ag Zbcexpbn1 Vd gtxp tn`d|xpbn` pmbp pmex ex zb|p ai pmd leffd| F|dbp Fbgdvmehm vbx bn` ex ldenf zobud` en pmd |dfean pa bxxd|p hanp|ao ayd| pmd fdaf|bzmu/ nbpt|bo |dxat|hdx/ p|b d ha||e'à|x bn` en hdgdnpenf pmd zaoepehbo hoatp i|ag Hdnp|bo Bxeb pa pmd Enèbn Ahdbn. Bifmbenxpbn bn` Lbothmexpbnb|d pva gaxp egza|pbnp |dfeanx en pmex xp|bpdfeh fbgd zobn.

Lbothmexpbn bn` pmd Foalbo Fdazaoepehbo F|dbp Fbgd

Lbothmexpbn mbx |dgbend` b f|dbp fdaf|bzmehbo bppdnpean ai pmd foalbo zobud| ia| epx xp|bpdfeh oahbpean an pmd

gbz bn` ybxp tnpbzzd` gend|bo |dxat|hdx vmehm enhot`d fao`/ hazzd|/ nbpt|bo fbx/ aeo/ gb|lod bn` habo. Boogbka| p|b`d bn` dnd|fu |atpdx i|ag Xatpm Dbxp Bxeb pa Ge`òd Dbxp bn` i|ag Hdnp|bo Bxeb pa Enèbn Ahdbnzbxx pm|atfm pmex |dfean. Lbothmexpbn |dgbend` hdnpd| xpbfd ai pmd 25pm hdnpt|ux F|dbp Fbgd ldpvddn \tx'xebn bn` L|epexm Dgze|dx. Bgd|ehbn enpd|dxp en pmd |dfean hbn ld p|bhd` lbhc pa 250


6/10


7/10

28

L|bxxPbhcxZaoehuZbzd|x

@|and lbxdx bn` enpdooefdnhd fbpmd|enf xpbpeanx vd|d dxpbloexmd` en Lbothmexpbn ldmen` pmd ibb`d ai haglbp'enf pd||a|exg. HEB ex txenf xpdbopm |andx bfbenxp E|bn bn` Zbcexpbn. Ltp zaxp'Xbobob Zbcexpbne |dxzanxd ia|hd`pmd TX pa |dgayd pmdxd lbxdx bn` enpdooefdnhd fbpmd|enf xpbpeanx. Vbxmenfpan mbx lddn ztxmenf ia| mbyenfzd|gbndnp enpdooefdnhd lbxdx en pmd z|ayenhd xenhd gbnu udb|x/ ltp |ditxbo lu Exobgblb` ex bganf pmd gben|dbxanx ai èzoagbpeh xp|ben ldpvddn pmd pva hbzepbox. Zbcexpbne xdht|epu dxpbloexmgdnp ldoedydx pmbp pmd |dhdnpTX èzoagbpeh/ zaoepehbo bn` gdèb gbndtyd|enf an Lbothmexpbn Hanf|dxxeanbo mdb|enfx/ |dxaotpeanx lu pmdTX xdnbpa|x ia| en`dzdn`dnp Lbothmexpbn/ hbnhdoobpean ai xdgenb| an pmd Lbothmexpbn h|exex bn` pm|dbpx pa

Zbcexpbn i|ag Zbndppbb|d boo zb|p ai z|dxxt|d pbhpehx pa pbgd Zbcexpbn en booavenf HEB pa dxpbloexm epx hayd|pndpva|c bn` enpdooefdnhd xpbpeanx en pmd z|ayenhd20.

Pmd TX bn` HEB enyaoydgdnp en Lbothmexpbn mbx lddn z|aydn en hbxd ai Ktn`toobm bn` hayd|p dxzeanbfdazd|bpeanx ai HEB ltp b i|drtdnpou bxcd` rtdxpean ex vmu pmd Enèbn fayd|ngdnp ex fdppenf enyaoyd` en pmdLbothmexpbn exxtd1

I|ag b zt|d xp|bpdfeh bn` xdht|epu zaenp ai yedv pmd bnxvd| ex xp|befmp ia|vb|` and. Pmd geoepb|u agbnu |dfean dzdn`x an pmd hbzbleoepedx pa atp gbndtyd| bn` atp a pmd dndgu en |bzeèpu bn` fbenenai pd||ben. Bipd| xdht|enf pmdxd alkdhpeydx/ pmd dnpe|d exhtxxean blatp pmd bhptbo hanehp ldhagdx itpmdxd db|oed| b`ybnpbfdx b|d gbenpbend` pm|atfm geoepb|u bn` apmd| gdbnx. Ep ex b ibhp pmbp Zbcexpbndnkau bnu xp|bpdfeh `dzpm vmdn ep hagdx pa geoepb|u pm|dbp i|ag Enèb tn`d| md| Hao` Xpb|p @ahp|end}hdzp idv èxp|ehpx ai Lbothmexpbn i|ag vmd|d Zbcexpbn vato` ld blod pa obtnhm b hatnpd|'aiidnxelbhc Enèbn En`dzdn`dnp Lbppod F|atzx -ELFx%. Iobncenf bppbhcx bfbenxp Enèbn ELFx/ i|ag ZtXen`m/ vato`np ld diidhpeyd bx HX@ xddcx pmd hbzbleoepu pa gbcd gtopezod enf|dxxdx en Zbcexpbn bh|apd|nbpeanbo la|`d| xegtopbndatxou. Bn en`dzdn`dnp Lbothmexpbn/ en`dd / vato` pbcd bvbu bnu cen` a`dzpm pmbp Zbcexpbn mbx pa`bu/ i|ag pmd dbxp ai pmd E|bnebn bn` pmd Bifmbn la|`d| pa pmd vdxp ai En`

pmencd|x ldoedyd pmbp bipd| zobnnd` xdhdxxean ai Lbothmexpbn/ pmdu vato` mbyd pmd hbzbleoepu pa htp Zbcpva lu bppbhcenf pmd xaip ldoou ai Zbcexpbn -\bmeg Ub| Cmbn'Xbcct| b}ex%. Pa bhmedyd pmex/ Enèbnx va|cenf an b xegeob| xp|bpdfu xegeob| pa pmd and pmdu dzoaud` en Dbxp Zbcexpbn bfbenxp Vdxp Zbcexpbxenhd pmde| b||eybo en Bifmbnexpbn bipd| 5!22.

Obxpou/ zaxp'Xbobob fdazaoepehbo xhdnb|ea mbx ztp Enèb en b zaxepean pa enpdnxeiu md| bnpe'Zbcexpbn xp|bpden èzoagbhu bn` gdèb vb|ib|d b}ex. Pmd pegenf ai i|dxm Enèbn boodfbpeanx bfbenxp Zbcexpbn ia| zpmd zd|zdp|bpa|x ai


8/10

24

L|bxxPbhcxZaoehuZbzd|x 4. Ei pmd Xtz|dgd Hat|p e` nap mbyd bnu |dxd|ybpean an en'hbgd|b l|ednfx blatp pmd obv bn` a|`d| xept'

bpean en Cb|bhme pmdn vmu b|d EXE bn` GE nap booavd` pa à pmd xbgd en Lbothmexpbn1

9. Mav vato pmd d}bhp ntgld| ai gexxenf zdazod ld bxpd|pbend`1 Fayd|ndgp/ NFAx/ gdèb bn` hag'gexxean tn`d| Ktxpehd Kbyd` Erlbo boo mbyd hagd'tz vepm eiid|dnp ntgld|x.

6. Ei pmd pd||a|expx hbn hagd pa gdèb pa xz|db` pmde| ydnag pmdn vmu pmd EFIH hbnnap z|dxdnp mex zaxe'pean pa pmd nbpean an b xtlpod exxtd en a|`d| pa dn` hanitxeanx1

=. Vmu mbx pmd ktèheb|u ibeod` pa ztnexm b xenfod pd||a|exp pm|atfm ktèhebo z|ahdxx en pmd obxp 2: udb|x1

Hd|pbenou/ na and hbn ld ztnexmd` tnodxx z|aydn fteopu en hat|p ai obv. Pmd Zbcexpbne Hanxpeptpean ftb|bn'pddx pmex |efmp ltp vmbp ep adxnp ftb|bnpdd/ en epx z|dxdnp ia|g/ ex pmd vbu pa zt|xtd pmd z|a}edx bn` ztn'exm pmd pd||a|expx. Pmdxd exxtdx hbnnap ld ayd|hagd lu pmd na|gbo b`genexp|bpeyd obvx `t|enf b vb|. Bx bfoalboou bhhzdpd` z|enhezod/ dgd|fdnhu a| vb|pegd obvx b|d enxpefbpd` en bn dydnptboepu oecd d}expdnpebo vb|.

En bnu hanxpeptpeanbo `dgah|bhu/ pmd ktèheb|uiaooavx pmd hanxpeptpeanbo i|bgdva|c bn` d}exp'enf obvx pa z|axdhtpd pmd h|egenbox. Pmd egzbhpbn` diidhpeydndxx ai pmdxd obvx `dzdn`x xrtb|'boou an pmd dihednhu ai pmd obv gbcenf enxpept'peanx bn` pmd id`d|bo fayd|ngdnp. Xenhd


9/10

26

L|bxxPbhcxZaoehuZbzd|x pva ganpmx bfa en b mefm odydo gddpenf24.

Pmd |dxtgzpean ai NBPA xtzzoedx lu pmex p|dbhmd|atx ZZZ |dfegd mbx azdnd` udp bnapmd| b}ex ia| enpd|nboxdht|epu. Bx zd| at| |dza|px/ b heyeo èxaldèdnhd gaydgdnp ex lteoènf vepm ga|d enpdnxepu bganf pmd p|eldxen Lbothmexpbn/ IBPB bn` Cmuld| vma mbyd yavd` pa loahc bn` lt|n pmd p| thcx hb||uenf pmd xtzzoedx. Pmd|doefeatx zb|pedx b|d boxa zobnnenf loahcb`d ai Zdxmbvb| bn` pmd |ab` pa Cmuld| Zbxx. Hd|pbenou/ pmd |dfegdmbx f|bydou gexhbohtobpd` pmd nbpeanbo bnfd| bn` |bfd ayd| pmex xdoo aii. Dyd|uand vbx d}zdhpenf pmbp NBPAxtzzoedx vato` |dgben hoaxd` dxzdheboou bipd| pm|dbpx lu Zbndppb bn` pmd Zdnpbfanx zobnnd` hayd|p xp|ecdx en'xe`d Zbcexpbn. ZZZ fayd|ngdnp ex ouenf pa pmd nbpean bn` p|uenf pa gexodb` pmd gbxxdx pm|atfm gdèb pmbp anounan'odpmbo xtzzoedx b|d faenf enxe`d Bifmbnexpbn ltp en |dboepu NBPAx gexxenf hanpbend|x vd|d pmd leffdxp

xtzzou xat|hd ai boo odpmbo vdbzanx ldenf txd` bfbenxp Zbcexpbn lapm lu PPZ bn` LOB azd|bpeydx bn` HEB en'hotènf Mdoo|d gexxeodx ia| pmd TX `|andx. Ltp bipd| |dxtgzpean ai xtzzoedx HEB |and bppbhcx mbyd |dxtgd`bx vdoo vepm |dndvd` ydnfdbnhd bn` Zbcexpbn ex anhd bfben xpbnènf vmd|d ep vbx an


10/10

25

L|bxxPbhcxZaoehuZbzd|x Dn` Napdx

2 Bfdnhedx pao` pa z|a`thd Lboahmexpbnx /gexxenf en nd}p mdb|enf/ @beou @bvn/

4 8 boodfd` LOB bhpeyexpx b||dxpd` i|ag Cb|bhme/ @tneub PY/ 6pm Gbu 2:NBL hmedi d}hdd`x P|bnxzb|dnhu hobegx an ha||tzpean ft|dx/ @beou Pmd Ndvx/ Ktou :2/

Matxd ( 9=9/ Bxcb|e \ab`/ Azzaxepd Bxcb|e

Documents

Zaid Hamid: BrassTacks Policy Paper: Missing Persons of Baluchistan – looking beyond the Obvious