Upload
henry-turner
View
95
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
European Journal of Political Research33: 125–164, 1998. 125c 1998Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
Party government in 20 Democracies: an update (1990–1995)
JAAP WOLDENDORP1, HANS KEMAN1 & IAN BUDGE21Department of Political Science and Public Administration, Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam,The Netherlands;2Department of Government, University of Essex, UK
Abstract. The country tables of the data collection ‘Political Data 1945–1990. Party Gov-ernment in 20 Democracies’ (European Journal of Political Research, Vol. 24, No. 1 (July1993), pp. 1–119) are updated and corrected to the end of 1995. Errors and omissions on thelevel of separate Ministers and/or Ministries have been corrected as well. These are listed as‘changes/corrections’ in the corresponding tables in the original data collection.
Introduction
In 1993 we published for the first time a full set of data concerning partygovernments in 20 democracies, covering the period 1945–1990 (see:Euro-pean Journal of Political Research, Volume 24, no. 1, pp. 1–119). To our oursatisfaction we have noticed that this data-collection has been used by manycomparativists as well as by country specialists. On the one hand, it appears tobe a useful instrument for research in coalition politics and related theory; onthe other hand, it is widely used as a source for developing variables to analysepublic policy-formation, government behaviour and comparative research onparties in and out government. At the same time, however, some colleagueshave pointed to errors in the original publication, and it is the correction ofthese data, together with what we hope will be a useful update of the figuresto the end of 1995, that has prompted this new supplementary report. In thisarticle we have chosen to (re)print thecountry tableswhich open the presen-tation of the data of each country. The tables have been completely correctedand now run until 1996 (as far as data were available). Partly these data arederived from the Political Data Yearbooks as published in this Journal� andpartly we checked – as we did originally –Keesing’s Contemporary Archives.This has led to a number of corrections, particularly in the figures for theduration of governments (DUR), the number of ministers (NOM), and, toa lesser extent, the participation of parties in government and their seats in
�See EJPR Vol. 22, no. 4 (1992), Vol. 24, no. 4 (1993), Vol. 26, no. 3/4 (1994), and Vol.28,no. 3/4 (1995).
126 J. WOLDENDORP, H. KEMAN & I. BUDGE
parliament (PY). The new data have been added, of course, in the same formatas applied in the original tables (see also below).
Below each of the country-tables we have added explanatory notes wherenecessary, followed bychanges/correctionsin the other tables. These tables,which can be found in the original data-book, contain information on thelevel of separate ministries(i.e. party affiliation; competences and portfolios;individual features like name and sex: seeEJPR, Vol. 24, no. 1: 7). Thesechanges/corrections are presented as follows:
� pagenumber(which refers to the original special issue and the hardbackedition by Kluwer, 1993)
� number of government (#)� office and/or competence(s)� name of minister and party affiliation
For example: under the updated country Table forFinlandone will find:
page 40
# 38 Health: * Eskelinen, K.-H. (KESK)
This correction shows that – in comparison with the original issue – the partyaffiliation is now available.
In order to make the tables understandable for those who wish to use thisupdate independentlyfrom the original publication we reprint here the formatof the data set.
Glossary of format of data set and stucture of presentation
The information is presented by country and by government. The basic formatis as follows: cases represent governments (= rows) and variables representdata on and within each government (= columns). Party names follow theMackie/Rose coding, names of individuals are spelled according to the origi-nal language and sex will be indicated (by means of an asterisk = * for femaleMinisters). The structure of the tables for each country is as follows:
Gov = Number of governmentBegin = Date of investiture of governmentEnd = Date of termination of governmentDur = Duration of government in daysRfT = Reason for termination of governmentToG = Type of governmentPy = Government party, seats in parliamentCPG = Political complexion of parliament and government
POLITICAL DATA: AN UPDATE (1990–1995) 127
NoM = Number of ministers in government (only fullcabinet members, no Ministers of State,Junior Ministers etc. unless stated otherwise)
Prime Minister (py) = self explanatory (party)NONA = non-alignedIND = Independent
Reason for Terminationis a classification for modes of termination:
1. Elections.These include any election stipulated by law or constitution as well asanticipated elections, which are not required by law;
2. Voluntary resignation of the Prime Minister.3. Resignation of the Prime Minister due to health reasons.
Both these last two reasons should be considered as non-political ones,but mode 2 may well be a cover-up for factional dispute within a party orgovernment (as for instance in Japan). Yet, since we cannot distinguish‘real’ from ‘fake’ reasons, we have accepted them entirely on face value.
4. Dissension within government.This covers those instances when either a coalition breaks up withoutexternal pressure or when there are publicized quarrels and/or movementof personnel. Often these incidents are not discussed in the literature sincein many cases they have no visible consequence for a government definedin a more relaxed way than we have defined it here.
5. Lack of parliamentary support.This reason for termination, of course, lies at the heart of any parliamen-tary democracy. We have counted here every instance when parties eitherwithdrew support from government, or there occurred a (successful) voteof no confidence (or similar parliamentary action).
6. Intervention by the Head of State.Apart from semi-presidential regimes (such as Finland and France) therole of the Head of State is much less essential for government terminationthan with respect to government formation.
Types of Governmentis based on the number of parties participating and theirparliamentary status. The following six types of government make up ourclassification:
1. Single Party Government: one party takes all government seats.2. Minimal Winning Coalition: all participating parties are necessary to form
the government.3. Surplus Coalition: this comprises those coalition governments which
exceed the minimal-winning criterion.
128 J. WOLDENDORP, H. KEMAN & I. BUDGE
4. Single Party Minority Government: the party in government does notpossess a majority in Parliament.
5. Multi Party Minority Government: the parties in government do not pos-sess a majority in Parliament.
6. Caretaker Government: the government formed is not intended to under-take any kind of serious policy-making, but is only temporarily mindingthe shop.
Political complexion of parliament and governmentis an indicator whichintroduces a more qualitative aspect to government composition. It attemptsto account for the relative strength of parties in government with referenceto the Left-Right dimension, through a five-point scale in which the propor-tional shares of the Left, Centre and Right are transformed into scores (1 to5) representing the degree of dominance of either party both in parliamentand government. It is mostly used to relate the degree of party-control of agovernment to its policy guided actions. It is operationalised as follows:
1. right-wing dominance (share of seats in Government and their supportingparties in Parliament larger than 66.6 per cent)
2. Right-Centre complexion (share of seats of Right and Centre parties inGovernment and their supporting parties between 33.3 and 66.6 per centeach)
3. balanced situation (share of Centre larger than 50 per cent in Governmentand in Parliament; or if Left and Right form a government together notdominated by one side or the other)
4. Left-Centre complexion (share of seats of Left and Centre parties inGovernment and supporting parties between 33.3 and 66.6 per cent each)
5. Left-wing dominance (share of seats of Government and supporting par-ties in Parliament larger than 66.6 per cent)
We hope that this publication of the update of governments and the correctionsregarding the additional tables will be helpful to all our colleagues workingin this field of comparative research. Finally, we would be grateful to receiveany comments and corrections regarding the data set to enable us to improveit yet further. You can send this information to:
Hans Keman/Jaap WoldendorpDepartment of Political Science and Public AdministrationVrije UniversiteitDe Boelelaan 1081c1081 HV AmsterdamThe Netherlandsor by E-mail: [email protected]
POLITICAL DATA: AN UPDATE (1990–1995) 129
Acknowledgements
We are grateful to Rose Hogenbirk, Roos Siwalette and Arend Lijphart whohave assisted us in correcting the existing data-set as well as in collectingthe new data. This article was accepted for publication under the journaleditorship of Michael Laver and Peter Mair.
130 J. WOLDENDORP, H. KEMAN & I. BUDGEA
US
TR
AL
IA
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
113
.07.
4530
.10.
4647
51
1A
LP
495
19C
hifle
y,J.
B.(
AL
P)
231
.10.
4618
.12.
4911
451
1A
LP
435
19C
hifle
y,J.
B.(
AL
P)
319
.12.
4910
.05.
5150
81
2L
IB55
CN
T19
119
Men
zies
,R.G
.(L
IB)
411
.05.
5108
.07.
5411
551
2L
IB52
CN
T17
120
Men
zies
,R.G
.(L
IB)
509
.07.
5410
.01.
5655
11
2L
IB47
CN
T17
120
Men
zies
,R.G
.(L
IB)
611
.01.
5608
.12.
5810
631
2L
IB57
CN
T18
112
Men
zies
,R.G
.(L
IB)
709
.12.
5822
.12.
6111
101
2L
IB58
CN
T19
112
Men
zies
,R.G
.(L
IB)
823
.12.
6116
.12.
6372
41
2L
IB45
CN
T17
112
Men
zies
,R.G
.(L
IB)
917
.12.
6325
.01.
6677
12
2L
IB52
CN
T20
112
Men
zies
,R.G
.(L
IB)
1026
.01.
6613
.12.
6632
21
2L
IB52
CN
T20
112
Hol
t,H
.E.(
LIB
)
1114
.12.
6617
.12.
6736
93
2L
IB61
CN
T21
112
Hol
t,H
.E.(
LIB
)
1218
.12.
6709
.01.
6823
22
LIB
61C
NT
211
11M
cEw
en,J
.(C
NT
)
1310
.01.
6827
.02.
6849
x2
LIB
61C
NT
211
12G
orto
n,J.
G.(
LIB
)
1428
.02.
6810
.11.
6962
21
2L
IB61
CN
T21
112
Gor
ton,
J.G
.(L
IB)
1511
.11.
6920
.03.
7149
52
2L
IB46
CN
T20
113
Gor
ton,
J.G
.(L
IB)
1621
.03.
7118
.12.
7263
91
2L
IB46
CN
T20
213
McM
ahon
,W.(
LIB
)
1719
.12.
7211
.06.
7454
01
1A
LP
675
27W
hitla
m,E
.G.(
AL
P)
1812
.06.
7411
.11.
7551
86
1A
LP
665
27W
hitla
m,E
.G.(
AL
P)
1912
.11.
7517
.12.
7536
12
LIB
40C
NT
222
15F
rase
r,J.
M.(
LIB
)
2018
.12.
7519
.12.
7773
21
2L
IB68
CN
T23
112
Fra
ser,
J.M
.(L
IB)
2120
.12.
7701
.11.
8010
481
2L
IB67
CN
T19
114
Fra
ser,
J.M
.(L
IB)
2202
.11.
8010
.03.
8385
91
2L
IB54
CN
T20
114
Fra
ser,
J.M
.(L
IB)
2311
.03.
8312
.12.
8464
31
1A
LP
755
13H
awke
,R.(
AL
P)
2413
.12.
8421
.07.
8795
11
1A
LP
825
17H
awke
,R.(
AL
P)
2522
.07.
8702
.04.
9098
61
1A
LP
865
16H
awke
,R.(
AL
P)
2603
.04.
9026
.12.
9163
32
1A
LP
785
17H
awke
,R.(
AL
P)
2727
.12.
9123
.03.
9345
31
1A
LP
775
18K
eatin
g,P
.(A
LP
)
2824
.03.
931
AL
P80
520
Kea
ting,
P.(
AL
P)
Gov
13:F
ollo
win
ghi
sel
ectio
nto
the
Fed
eral
Hou
seof
Rep
rese
ntat
ives
inth
eby
-ele
ctio
nat
Hig
gins
,the
PM
,Gor
ton,
anno
unce
dth
athe
wou
ldfo
rma
new
gove
rnm
ent.
Change
s/co
rrect
ions
pp.1
6–19
:p.
18,#
26,E
nviro
nmen
t:*
Kel
ly,R
.(=
fem
ale)
.
POLITICAL DATA: AN UPDATE (1990–1995) 131
AU
ST
RIA
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
118
.12.
4506
.11.
4914
201
3O
VP
85S
PO76
KPO
43
13F
igl,
L.(
OV
P)
207
.11.
4901
.04.
5312
424
2O
VP
77S
PO67
311
Fig
l,L
.(OV
P)
302
.04.
5322
.06.
5611
781
2O
VP
74S
PO73
311
Raa
b,J.
(OV
P)
423
.06.
5614
.07.
5911
171
2O
VP
82S
PO74
312
Raa
b,J.
(OV
P)
515
.07.
5903
.11.
6047
64
2O
VP
79S
PO78
312
Raa
b,J.
(OV
P)
604
.11.
6011
.04.
6115
93
2O
VP
79S
PO78
312
Raa
b,J.
(OV
P)
712
.04.
6123
.03.
6371
11
2O
VP
79S
PO78
312
Gor
bach
,A.(O
VP
)8
24.0
3.63
02.0
4.64
376
22
OV
P81
SPO
763
12G
orba
ch,A
.(OV
P)
903
.04.
6422
.10.
6556
84
2O
VP
81S
PO76
312
Kla
us,J
.(OV
P)
1023
.10.
6518
.04.
6617
81
2O
VP
81S
PO76
212
Kla
us,J
.(OV
P)
1119
.04.
6621
.04.
7014
641
2O
VP
851
13K
laus
,J.(O
VP
)12
22.0
4.70
21.1
0.71
548
14
SP
O81
413
Kre
isky
,B.(
SPO
)13
22.1
0.71
28.1
0.75
1468
11
SP
O93
514
Kre
isky
,B.(
SPO
)14
29.1
0.75
09.0
5.79
1289
11
SP
O93
514
Kre
isky
,B.(
SPO
)15
10.0
5.79
23.0
5.83
1475
11
SP
O95
515
Kre
isky
,B.(
SPO
)16
24.0
5.83
15.0
6.86
1119
22
SP
O90
FPO
114
15S
inow
atz,
F.(S
PO)
1716
.06.
8620
.01.
8721
91
2S
PO
90F
PO12
416
Vra
nitz
ky,F
.(S
PO)
1821
.01.
8716
.12.
9014
251
2S
PO
80O
VP
773
15V
rani
tzky
,F.(
SPO
)19
17.1
2.90
29.1
1.94
1444
12
SP
O80
OV
P60
315
Vra
nitz
ky,F
.(S
PO)
2030
.11.
9411
.03.
9646
84
2S
PO
65O
VP
523
16V
rani
tzky
,F.(
SPO
)21
12.0
3.96
2S
PO71
OV
P40
314
Vra
nitz
ky,F
.(S
PO)
Gov
1:K
PO-m
inis
ter
K.A
ltman
step
ped
dow
nfr
omgo
vern
men
ton
19N
ovem
ber
1947
.
132 J. WOLDENDORP, H. KEMAN & I. BUDGE
BE
LGIU
M
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3P
y4P
y5C
PG
NoM
Pri
me
Min
iste
r(p
y)
111
.02.
4531
.07.
4517
14
3C
VP
73B
SP
64L
P33
KP
B9
318
Ack
er,A
.van
(BS
P)
201
.08.
4510
.03.
4622
21
2B
SP
64L
P33
KP
B10
DU
13IC
AT
63
18A
cker
,Ava
n(B
SP
)3
11.0
3.46
31.0
3.46
215
5B
SP
69L
P17
317
Spa
ak,P
.H.(
BS
P)
401
.04.
4601
.08.
4612
35
2B
SP
69L
P17
KP
B23
319
Ack
er,A
.van
(BS
P)
502
.08.
4626
.03.
4723
74
2B
SP
69L
P17
KP
B23
319
Huy
sman
s,C
.(B
SP
)6
27.0
3.47
25.1
1.48
610
52
BS
P69
CV
P92
319
Spa
ak,P
.H.(
BS
P)
726
.11.
4816
.08.
4926
41
2B
SP
69C
VP
923
17S
paak
,P.H
.(B
SP
)8
17.0
8.49
29.0
6.50
317
42
CV
P10
5L
P29
217
Eys
kens
,G.(
CV
P)
930
.06.
5017
.08.
5049
51
CV
P10
81
15D
uvie
usar
t,J.
(CV
P)
1018
.08.
5014
.01.
5251
54
1C
VP
108
116
Pho
lien,
J.(C
VP
)11
15.0
1.52
21.0
4.54
828
11
CV
P10
81
16H
outt
e,J.
van
(CV
P)
1222
.04.
5425
.06.
5815
261
2B
SP
86L
P25
316
Ack
er,A
.van
(BS
P)
1326
.06.
5806
.11.
5813
45
4C
VP
104
216
Eys
kens
,G.(
CV
P)
1407
.11.
5801
.09.
6066
54
2C
VP
104
LP
211
21E
yske
ns,G
.(C
VP
)15
02.0
9.60
24.0
4.61
235
12
CV
P10
4L
P21
220
Eys
kens
,G.(
CV
P)
1625
.04.
6127
.07.
6515
551
2C
VP
96B
SP
843
20L
efev
re,T
.(C
VP
)17
28.0
7.65
19.0
3.66
235
42
CV
P77
BS
P64
220
Har
mel
,P.(
CV
P)
1820
.03.
6617
.06.
6882
16
2C
VP
77L
P48
219
Van
denb
oeyn
ants
,P
.(C
VP
)19
18.0
6.68
20.0
1.72
1312
42
CV
P69
BS
P59
327
Eys
kens
,G.(
CV
P)
POLITICAL DATA: AN UPDATE (1990–1995) 133
BE
LG
IUM
(con
tinue
d)
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3P
y4P
y5C
PG
NoM
Pri
me
Min
iste
r(p
y)
2021
.01.
7225
.01.
7337
14
2C
VP
47P
SC
20B
SP
613
19E
yske
ns,G
.(C
VP
)21
26.0
1.73
24.0
4.74
454
53
BS
P61
CV
P47
PS
C20
PV
V20
322
Leb
urto
n,E
.(B
SP
)22
25.0
4.74
11.0
6.74
48x
5C
BP
50P
SC
22P
VV
21P
LP
222
19T
inde
man
s,L
.(C
VP
)23
12.0
6.74
08.1
2.76
911
42
CV
P50
PS
C22
PV
V21
PL
P12
RW
131
21T
inde
man
s,L
.(C
VP
)24
09.1
2.76
02.0
6.77
176
52
CV
P50
PS
C22
PV
V21
PR
LW12
RW
132
25T
inde
man
s,L
.(C
VP
)25
03.0
6.77
19.1
0.78
504
43
CV
P56
PS
C24
BS
P62
FD
F10
VU
203
23T
inde
man
s,L
.(C
VP
)26
20.1
0.78
02.0
4.79
165
16
CV
P56
PS
C24
BS
P62
FD
F10
VU
203
22V
ande
nboe
ynan
ts,
P.(
PS
C)
2703
.04.
7922
.01.
8029
54
3C
VP
57P
SC
25B
SP
26P
SB
32F
DF
113
25M
arte
ns,W
.(C
VP
)28
23.0
1.80
17.0
5.80
116
52
CV
P57
PS
C25
BS
P26
PS
B32
325
Mar
tens
,W.(
CV
P)
2918
.05.
8021
.10.
8015
74
3C
VP
57P
SC
25B
SP
26P
SB
32P
VV
223
27M
arte
ns,W
.(C
VP
)30
22.1
0.80
05.0
4.81
166
42
CV
P57
PS
C25
BS
P26
PS
B32
325
Eys
kens
,G.(
CV
P)
3106
.04.
8116
.12.
8125
54
2C
VP
57P
SC
25B
SP
26P
SB
323
25E
yske
ns,G
.(C
VP
)32
17.1
2.81
27.1
1.85
1442
42
CV
P43
PS
C18
PV
V21
PR
L22
115
Mar
tens
,W.(
CV
P)
3328
.11.
8519
.10.
8769
14
2C
VP
49P
SC
20P
VV
22P
RL
221
15M
arte
ns,W
.(C
VP
)34
20.1
0.87
09.0
6.88
234
16
CV
P49
PS
C20
PV
V22
PR
L22
216
Mar
tens
,W.(
CV
P)
3509
.06.
8807
.03.
9213
731
2C
VP
43P
SC
19P
SB
40B
SP
32V
U16
318
Mar
tens
,W.(
CV
P)
3613
.03.
9222
.06.
9511
941
2C
VP
39P
SC
18P
SB
35B
SP
273
15D
ehae
ne,J
.-L
.(C
VP
)37
23.0
6.95
2C
VP
29P
SC
12P
SB
21B
SP
203
15D
ehae
ne,J
.-L
.(C
VP
)
134 J. WOLDENDORP, H. KEMAN & I. BUDGE
BE
LG
IUM
(con
tinue
d)
Gov
22:R
easo
nfo
rTe
rmin
atio
nw
asth
atR
Ww
asas
ked
tojo
into
form
am
ajor
itygo
vern
men
t.G
ov29
:PR
L(1
4se
ats
inpa
rliam
ent)
also
part
icip
ated
ingo
vern
men
t.C
hange
s/co
rrect
ions
pp.2
4–28
:pa
ge24
#15
Inte
rior:
Lefe
bvre
,R.(
LP)
#25
Dep
uty
PM
:Hur
ez,L
.(B
SP
)#
26D
eput
yP
M:H
urez
,L.(
BS
P);
For
eign
Aff:
Sim
onet
,H.(
BS
P)
#27
/28
Dep
uty
PM
:Spi
tael
s,G
.(B
SP
);F
orei
gnA
ff:S
imon
et,H
.(B
SP
)#
29D
eput
yP
M:S
pita
els,
G.(
BS
P)
#30
Dep
uty
PM
:Spi
tael
s,G
.(B
SP
);In
terio
r:M
atho
t,G
.(B
SP
)#
31D
eput
yP
M:M
atho
t,G
.(B
SP
);In
terio
r:M
atho
t,G
.(B
SP
)pa
ge25
#1/
2/4/
5H
ealth
:Mar
teau
x,A
.(K
PB
)#
15E
cono
mic
Aff:
Deq
uae,
A.(
CV
P)
#19
Fin
ance
:Coo
ls,A
.(B
SP
)pa
ge26
#27
/28
Fin
ance
:Spi
tael
s,G
.(B
SP
);E
cono
mic
Aff:
Cla
es,W
.(B
SP
)#
30F
inan
ce:M
atho
t,G
.(B
SP
)#
31F
inan
ce:M
atho
t,G
.(B
SP
);E
duca
tion:
Bus
quin
,F.(
PS
B)
page
27#
12O
ther
:Bui
sser
et,A
.(LP
)#
18S
ocia
lAff:
*Rie
mae
cker
-L.,
M.L
.de
(CV
P)
page
28#
27P
ublic
Wor
ks:M
atho
t,G
.(B
SP
);O
ther
:Deh
ouss
e,J.
-M.(
BS
P)
#28
Oth
er:D
ehou
sse,
J.-M
.(B
SP
)#
29P
ublic
Wor
ks:D
ecro
o,H
.(P
VV
)#
30P
ublic
Wor
ks:S
pita
els,
G.(
BS
P)
#35
Pub
licW
orks
:Gee
ns,A
.(C
VP
)
POLITICAL DATA: AN UPDATE (1990–1995) 135
CA
NA
DA
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
130
.08.
4515
.11.
4811
742
1L
IB12
51
20M
acke
nzie
,W.L
.(L
IB)
216
.11.
4825
.06.
4922
21
1L
IB12
51
20S
t.L
aure
nt,L
.(L
IB)
326
.06.
4909
.08.
5315
061
1L
IB19
31
22S
t.L
aure
nt,L
.(L
IB)
410
.08.
5329
.06.
5714
201
1L
IB17
11
21S
t.L
aure
nt,L
.(L
IB)
521
.06.
5730
.03.
5828
31
4C
ON
112
120
Die
fenb
aker
,J.G
.(C
ON
)6
31.0
3.58
08.0
8.62
1592
11
CO
N20
81
20D
iefe
nbak
er,J
.G.(
CO
N)
709
.08.
6221
.04.
6325
65
4C
ON
116
120
Die
fenb
aker
,J.G
.(C
ON
)8
22.0
4.63
17.1
2.65
971
14
LIB
129
124
Pea
rson
,L.B
.(L
IB)
918
.12.
6520
.04.
6885
52
4L
IB13
11
23P
ears
on,L
.B.(
LIB
)10
21.0
4.68
05.0
7.68
761
4L
IB13
11
25T
rude
au,P
.E.(
LIB
)11
07.0
7.68
26.1
1.72
1604
11
LIB
155
120
Tru
deau
,P.E
.(L
IB)
1227
.11.
7207
.08.
7461
95
4L
IB10
91
20T
rude
au,P
.E.(
LIB
)13
08.0
8.74
03.0
6.79
1761
11
LIB
141
129
Tru
deau
,P.E
.(L
IB)
1404
.06.
7902
.03.
8027
35
4C
ON
136
111
Cla
rk,J
.(C
ON
)15
03.0
3.80
29.0
6.83
1214
21
LIB
147
127
Tru
deau
,P.E
.(L
IB)
1630
.06.
8316
.09.
8444
51
1L
IB14
71
25T
urne
r,J.
N.(
LIB
)17
17.0
9.84
06.1
2.88
1541
11
CO
N21
11
29M
ulro
ney,
B.(
CO
N)
1807
.12.
8824
.06.
9316
722
1C
ON
170
122
Mul
rone
y,B
.(C
ON
)19
25.0
6.93
03.1
1.93
132
11
CO
N15
61
25*C
ampb
ell,
K.(
CO
N)
2004
.11.
931
LIB
177
123
Chret
ien,
J.-C
.(LI
B)
Change
s/co
rrect
ions
pp.2
9–32
:pa
ge29
#15
Dep
uty
PM
:M
acE
ache
n,A
.J.
(LIB
);F
orei
gnA
ff:M
acG
uiga
n,M
.(L
IB);
Def
ence
:La
mon
tagn
e,G
.(L
IB);
Inte
rior:
Pin
ard,
Y.(L
IB);
Just
ice:
Chre
tien,
J-C
.(LI
B),
Kap
lan
R.(
LIB
).
136 J. WOLDENDORP, H. KEMAN & I. BUDGE
DE
NM
AR
K
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3P
y4C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
108
.11.
4512
.11.
4773
55
4L
IB38
[RA
D11
]1
14K
riste
nsen
,K.(
LIB
)2
13.1
1.47
14.0
9.50
1037
54
SD
57[R
AD
10]
516
Hed
toft,
H.(
SD
)3
15.0
9.50
26.1
0.50
425
4S
D59
414
Hed
toft,
H.(
SD
)4
27.1
0.50
04.0
5.53
921
15
CO
N27
LIB
321
13E
rikse
n,E
.(L
IB)
505
.05.
5329
.09.
5314
81
5C
ON
26L
IB33
113
Erik
sen,
E.(
LIB
)6
30.0
9.53
31.0
1.55
489
34
SD
745
14H
edto
ft,H
.(S
D)
701
.02.
5527
.05.
5784
71
4S
D74
[RA
D14
]5
13H
anse
n,H
.C.(
SD
)8
28.0
5.57
19.0
2.60
998
32
SD
70R
AD
14JP
93
16H
anse
n,H
.C.(
SD
)9
21.0
2.60
17.1
1.60
271
12
SD
70R
AD
14JP
93
15K
ampm
ann,
V.(S
D)
1018
.11.
6003
.09.
6265
53
5S
D76
RA
D11
417
Kam
pman
n,V.
(SD
)11
04.0
9.62
25.0
9.64
753
15
SD
76R
AD
114
17K
rag,
J.O
.(S
D)
1226
.09.
6427
.11.
6679
31
4S
D76
[RA
D10
][S
PP
10]
517
Kra
g,J.
O.(
SD
)13
28.1
1.66
31.0
1.68
430
54
SD
69[S
PP
20]
519
Kra
g,J.
O.(
SD
)14
01.0
2.68
10.1
0.71
l348
12
RA
D27
LIB
34C
ON
371
17B
auns
gaar
d,H
.T.I
.(R
AD
)15
11.1
0.71
04.1
0.72
360
24
SD
705
19K
rag,
J.O
.(S
D)
1605
.10.
7218
.12.
7344
01
4S
D70
519
Jørg
ense
n,A
.(S
D)
1719
.12.
7312
.02.
7542
11
4L
IB22
112
Har
tling
,P.(
LIB
)18
13.0
2.75
24.0
2.77
743
54
SD
53[R
AD
13]
[SP
P9]
[CO
M7]
516
Jor
gens
en,A
.(S
D)
1925
.02.
7729
.08.
7855
1*
4S
D65
518
Jørg
ense
n,A
.(S
D)
2030
.08.
7825
.10.
7942
24
5S
D65
LIB
214
20Jø
rgen
sen,
A.(
SD
)21
26.1
0.79
30.1
2.81
797
54
SD
685
18Jø
rgen
sen,
A.(
SD
)22
31.1
2.81
09.0
9.82
253
44
SD
595
20Jø
rgen
sen,
A.(
SD
)23
10.0
9.82
20.0
1.84
498
55
CO
N26
LIB
21C
DM
15[C
PP
4]1
21S
chl
uter
,P.(
CO
N)
2421
.01.
8409
.09.
8713
281
5C
ON
42L
IB23
CD
M8
[CP
P5]
121
Sch
lut
er,P
.(C
ON
)
POLITICAL DATA: AN UPDATE (1990–1995) 137
DE
NM
AR
K(c
ontin
ued)
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3P
y4C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
2510
.09.
8702
.06.
8826
75
5C
ON
38L
IB19
CD
M9
[CP
P4]
123
Sch
lut
er,P
.(C
ON
)26
03.0
6.88
17.1
2.90
927
15
CO
N35
LIB
22R
AD
101
21S
chl
uter
,P.(
CO
N)
2718
.12.
9024
.01.
9377
02
5C
ON
30L
IB29
119
Sch
lut
er,P
.(C
ON
)28
25.0
1.93
25.0
9.94
609
12
SD
71R
AD
7C
DM
8C
PP
43
24R
asm
usse
n,N
.(S
D)
2926
.09.
945
SD
62R
AD
8C
DM
53
20R
asm
usse
n,N
.(S
D)
[]D
enot
espa
rtie
ssu
ppor
ting
gove
rnm
entw
ithou
tpar
ticip
atin
gin
it.G
ov18
:Als
osu
ppor
ted
byL
SP
(4se
ats
inpa
rliam
ent)
.G
ov19
:Rea
son
for
Term
inat
ion
isbr
oade
ning
ofco
aliti
on.
Change
s/co
rrect
ions
pp.3
4–37
:pa
ge34
#25
Inte
rior:
Ped
erse
n,T.
(LIB
)#
26In
terio
r:P
eder
sen,
T.(L
IB)
#27
Inte
rior:
Ped
erse
n,T.
(LIB
)pa
ge35
#25
Eco
nom
icA
ff:Ja
cobs
en,E
.(C
ON
)#
26E
cono
mic
Aff:
dele
teW
ilhje
lm,N
.(C
ON
)#
27F
inan
ce:d
elet
eR
asm
usse
n,A
.F.(
LIB
);E
cono
mic
Aff:
dele
te*L
undh
olt,
A.B
.(C
ON
),in
clud
eR
asm
usse
n,A
.F.(
LIB
)pa
ge36
#25
Env
ironm
ent:
Chr
iste
nsen
,C.(
CD
M)
#26
Env
ironm
ent:
Chr
iste
nsen
,C.(
CD
M)
#26
Indu
stry
/Tra
de:d
elet
eP
eder
sen,
T.(L
IB),
incl
ude
Wilh
jelm
,N.(
CO
N)
#27
Indu
stry
/Tra
de:d
elet
eP
eder
sen,
T.(L
IB),
incl
ude
*Lun
dhol
t,A
.B.(
CO
N);
Hou
sing
:Hou
man
d,S
.E.(
LIB
)pa
ge37
#25
Soc
ialA
ff:*S
tillin
g-Ja
cobs
en,M
.(C
DM
);P
ublic
Wor
ks:C
hris
tens
en,F
.N.(
CD
M),
dele
te*L
auts
ten,
A.(
CO
N);
Oth
er:d
elet
eC
hist
ense
n,C
.(C
PP
)#
26S
ocia
lAff:
Ols
en,A
.(R
AD
);P
ublic
Wor
ks:d
elet
e*K
ock-
Pet
erse
n,T.
(LIB
);O
ther
:del
ete
Chr
iste
nsen
,C.(
CP
P)
#27
Pub
licW
orks
:del
ete
*Lar
sen,
E.(
LIB
)
138 J. WOLDENDORP, H. KEMAN & I. BUDGEF
INLA
ND
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3P
y4P
y5C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
117
.04.
4524
.03.
4634
22
3K
ES
K49
SD
P50
RK
P15
LK
P9
SK
DL
493
12P
aasi
kivi
,(N
ON
A)
225
.03.
4628
.07.
4885
71
3K
ES
K49
SD
P50
RK
P15
SK
DL
494
12P
ekka
la,M
.(S
KD
L)
329
.07.
4816
.03.
5059
62
4S
DP
545
13F
ager
holm
,K.(
SD
P)
417
.03.
5016
.01.
5130
6x
5K
ES
K56
RK
P14
LK
P5
[KO
K32
]1
10K
ekko
nen,
U.(
KE
SK
)
517
.01.
5120
.03.
5163
43
KE
SK
56S
DP
54R
KP
14L
KP
53
11K
ekko
nen,
U.(
KE
SK
)
621
.03.
5119
.09.
5118
31
6K
ES
K56
RK
P14
LK
P5
17
Kek
kone
n,U
.(K
ES
K)
720
.09.
5108
.07.
5365
82
3K
ES
K51
SD
P53
RK
P15
FP
P10
311
Kek
kone
n,U
.(K
ES
K)
809
.07.
5315
.11.
5313
05
5K
ES
K51
RK
P15
211
Kek
kone
n,U
.(K
ES
K)
916
.11.
5304
.05.
5417
06
6K
OK
28R
KP
15F
PP
102
11T
uom
ioja
,S.(
FP
P)
1005
.05.
5420
.10.
5416
94
3K
ES
K53
SD
P54
RK
P13
311
Tor
ngre
n,R
.(R
KP
)
1120
.10.
5402
.03.
5650
02
2K
ES
K53
SD
P54
310
Kek
kone
n,U
.(K
ES
K)
1203
.03.
5626
.05.
5745
04
3K
ES
K53
SD
P54
RK
P13
FP
P13
311
Fag
erho
lm,K
.(S
DP
)
1327
.05.
5701
.07.
5736
45
KE
SK
53R
KP
13F
PP
132
11S
ukse
lain
en,
V.J.
(KE
SK
)
1402
.07.
5701
.09.
5762
x5
KE
SK
53F
PP
132
11S
ukse
lain
en,
V.J.
(KE
SK
)
1502
.09.
5728
.11.
5788
55
KE
SK
53S
KO
G6
FP
P13
211
Suk
sela
inen
,V.J
.(K
ES
K)
1629
.11.
5725
.04.
5814
85
x2
11F
iean
dt,R
.von
(NO
NA
)
1726
.04.
5828
.08.
5812
51
x[K
ES
K53
][S
KO
G6]
[FP
P13
]2
12K
uusk
oski
,R.(
KE
SK
)
1829
.08.
5812
.01.
5913
74
3K
ES
K48
KO
K29
SD
P48
RK
P14
FP
P8
211
Fag
erho
lm,K
.(S
DP
)
1913
.01.
5913
.07.
6191
32
4K
ES
K48
[RK
P14
][S
DP
48]
[KO
K29
)1
11S
ukse
lain
en,
V.J.
(KE
SK
)
2014
.07.
6112
.04.
6227
36
4K
ES
K48
211
Mie
ttune
n,M
.(K
ES
K)
2113
.04.
6221
.10.
6355
74
2K
ES
K53
KO
K32
RK
P14
FP
P13
211
Kar
jala
inen
,A
.(K
ES
K)
2222
.10.
6317
.12.
6357
42
KE
SK
53K
OK
32R
KP
14F
PP
132
10K
arja
lain
en,
A.(
KE
SK
)
2318
.12.
6311
.09.
6426
9x
61
12L
ehto
,R.R
.(N
ON
A)
2412
.09.
6426
.05.
6662
21
2K
ES
K53
KO
K32
RK
P14
FP
P13
111
Viro
lain
en,
J.(K
ES
K)
2527
.05.
6621
.03.
6866
52
3K
ES
K49
SD
P55
SK
DL
41T
PS
L7
311
Paa
sio,
R.(
SD
P)
2622
.03.
6813
.05.
7078
31
3K
ES
K49
SD
P55
RK
P12
SK
DL
41T
PS
L7
312
Koi
vist
o,M
.(S
DP
)
2714
.05.
7014
.07.
7062
6x
[KE
SK
37]
[SD
P51
][K
OK
37]
[RK
P12
][F
PP
8]3
12A
ura,
T.(F
PP
)
2815
.07.
7025
.03.
7125
44
3K
ES
K37
SD
P51
RK
P12
FP
P8
SK
DL
363
13K
arja
lain
en,
A.(
KE
SK
)
2926
.03.
7128
.10.
7121
74
3K
ES
K37
SD
P51
RK
P12
FP
P8
314
Kar
jala
inen
,A
.(K
ES
K)
3029
.10.
7122
.02.
7211
71
6K
ES
K37
KO
K37
SD
P51
FP
P8
313
Aur
a,T.
(FP
P)
POLITICAL DATA: AN UPDATE (1990–1995) 139F
INL
AN
D(c
ontin
ued)
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3P
y4P
y5C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
3123
.02.
7203
.09.
7219
42
4S
DP
554
14P
aasi
o,R
.(S
DP
)
3204
.09.
7212
.06.
7510
124
2[K
ES
K35
][S
DP
55]
[RK
P10
][F
PP
7]3
16S
orsa
,K.(
SD
P)
3313
.06.
7529
.11.
7517
01
xK
ES
K35
KO
K34
SD
P55
RK
P10
FP
P7
317
Liin
amaa
,K.(
SD
P)
3430
.11.
7528
.09.
7630
44
3K
ES
K39
SD
P54
RK
P10
FP
P9
SK
DL
403
18M
iettu
nen,
M.(
KE
SK
)
3529
.09.
7614
.05.
7722
86
5K
ES
K39
RK
P10
FP
P9
216
Mie
ttune
n,M
.(K
ES
K)
3615
.05.
7701
.03.
7829
14
3K
ES
K39
SD
P54
RK
P10
FP
P9
SK
DL
403
15S
orsa
,K.(
SD
P)
3702
.03.
7824
.05.
7944
91
3K
ES
K39
SD
P54
FP
P9
SK
DL
403
14S
orsa
,K.(
SD
P)
3825
.05.
7924
.02.
8210
072
3K
ES
K36
SD
P52
RK
P10
SK
DL
353
17K
oivi
sto,
M.(
SD
P)
3925
.02.
8229
.12.
8230
84
3K
ES
K36
SD
P52
RK
P10
SK
DL
353
17S
orsa
,K.(
SD
P)
4030
.12.
8206
.05.
8312
81
5K
ES
K36
SD
P52
RK
P10
317
Sor
sa,K
.(S
DP
)
4107
.05.
8329
.04.
8714
541
3K
ES
K38
SD
P57
RK
P11
FR
P17
317
Sor
sa,K
.(S
DP
)
4230
.04.
8727
.08.
9012
164
3S
DP
56K
OK
53R
KP
13F
RP
93
18H
olke
ri,H
.(K
OK
)
4328
.08.
9025
.04.
9121
41
3S
DP
56K
OK
53R
KP
133
17H
olke
ri,H
.(K
OK
)
4426
.04.
9119
.06.
9411
154
3K
ES
K55
KO
K40
RK
P12
SK
L8
317
Aho
,E.(
KE
SK
)
4520
.06.
9412
.04.
9529
61
2K
ES
K55
KO
K40
RK
P12
316
Aho
,E.(
KE
SK
)
4613
.04.
953
SD
P63
KO
K39
VIH
R9
VAS
223
18L
ippo
nen,
P.(
SD
P)
[]P
arty
supp
ortin
gth
ego
vern
men
tw
ithou
tpar
ticip
atin
gin
it.G
ov4:
Rea
son
for
Term
inat
ion,
the
PM
invi
ted
allp
artie
sto
form
aN
atio
nalC
oalit
ion.
The
SD
Pjo
ined
tofo
rmgo
vern
men
ts.
Gov
14:R
easo
nfo
rTe
rmin
atio
n,th
ele
ft-w
ing
‘Sko
g-gr
oup’
ofth
eS
DP
(6se
ats
inP
arlia
men
t)jo
ined
the
coal
ition
tofo
rmgo
vern
men
tnu
mbe
r15
.G
ov15
,17:
SK
OG
isle
ft-w
ing
‘SK
OG
-gro
up’w
ithin
SD
P.
Gov
16:‘
Bus
ines
sC
abin
et’.
Gov
17:N
on-p
arty
gove
rnm
ent,
min
iste
rsdi
dno
toffi
cial
lyre
pres
entt
heir
resp
ectiv
epa
rtie
sK
ES
K(5
);S
KO
G(2
);L
KP
(1);
NO
NA
(1).
Gov
23:R
easo
nfo
rTe
rmin
atio
n,M
r.V
irola
inen
,Par
liam
enta
ryle
ader
ofK
ES
K,s
ucce
eded
11.0
9.64
tore
plac
eth
eN
on-p
arty
gove
rnm
ent
bya
gove
rnm
ents
uppo
rted
bya
Par
liam
enta
rym
ajor
ity.
Gov
27:G
over
nmen
tof‘
expe
rts’
.Min
iste
rs‘a
ssoc
iate
dw
ith’:
SD
P(3
);K
ES
K(3
);K
OK
(1);
RK
P(1
);N
ON
A(3
).G
ov33
:Non
-pol
itica
ltem
pora
rygo
vern
men
twhi
chin
clud
edm
embe
rsof
the
prev
ious
coal
ition
,plu
sa
cons
erva
tive
and
5no
n-pa
rty
min
iste
rs.
Change
s/co
rrect
ions
pp.3
9–42
:pa
ge40
#38
Hea
lth:*
Esk
elin
en,K
.-H
.(K
ES
K)
140 J. WOLDENDORP, H. KEMAN & I. BUDGE
FR
AN
CE
4
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3P
y4P
y5C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
123
.11.
4528
.01.
4667
23
MR
P14
1P
SF
134
PC
F14
8R
SP
353
22D
eG
aulle
,C.(
NO
NA
)
229
.01.
4618
.06.
4614
01
3M
RP
141
PS
F13
4P
CF
148
320
Gou
in,F
.(P
SF
)
319
.06.
4611
.12.
4614
6’1
3M
RP
160
PS
F11
5P
CF
146
322
Bid
ault,
G.(
MR
P)
412
.12.
4616
.01.
4736
16
PS
F11
53
17B
lum
,L.(
PS
F)
517
.01.
4707
.05.
4743
43
PS
F90
MR
P15
8R
SP
55P
CF
166
326
Ram
adie
r,P
.(P
SF
)
608
.05.
4723
.10.
4716
7x
2P
SF
90M
RP
158
RS
P55
325
Ram
adie
r,P
.(P
SF
)
723
.10.
4721
.11.
4730
43
PS
F90
MR
P15
8R
SP
55IN
D70
313
Ram
adie
r,P
.(P
SF
)
822
.11.
4723
.07.
4824
84
3P
SF
90M
RP
158
RS
P55
UD
SR
53
12S
chum
an,R
.(M
RP
)
924
.07.
4804
.09.
4843
43
PS
F90
MR
P15
8R
SP
55IN
D70
319
Mar
ie,A
.(R
SP
)
1005
.09.
4812
.09.
488
43
PS
F90
MR
P15
8R
SP
55IN
D70
315
Sch
uman
,R.(
MR
P)
1113
.09.
4827
.10.
4941
04
3P
SF
90M
RP
158
RS
P55
IND
70U
DS
R5
211
Que
uille
,H
.(R
SP
)
1228
.10.
4906
.02.
5010
24
3P
SF
90M
RP
158
RS
P55
IND
70U
DS
R5
218
Bid
ault,
G.(
MR
P)
1307
.02.
5001
.07.
5014
55
3M
RP
158
RS
P55
IND
70U
DS
R5
217
Bid
ault,
G.(
MR
P)
1402
.07.
5011
.07.
5010
53
MR
P15
8R
SP
55IN
D70
UD
SR
52
21Q
ueui
lle,
H.(
RS
P)
1512
.07.
5009
.03.
5124
15
3R
SP
55M
RP
158
PS
F90
IND
70U
DS
R5
222
Ple
ven,
R.(
UD
SR
)
1610
.03.
5110
.08.
5115
41
3R
SP
77P
SF
94M
RP
82IN
D87
UD
SR
107
222
Que
uille
,H
.(R
SP
)
1711
.08.
5119
.01.
5216
25
3R
SP
77M
RP
82IN
D87
UD
SR
107
224
Ple
ven,
R.(
UD
SR
)
1820
.01.
5207
.03.
5248
43
RS
P77
MR
P82
IND
87U
DS
R10
71
26F
aure
,E.(
RS
P)
1908
.03.
5206
.01.
5330
54
3R
SP
77M
RP
82IN
D87
UD
SR
107
117
Pin
ay,A
.(IN
D)
2007
.01.
5325
.06.
5317
05
3R
SP
77M
RP
82IN
D87
UD
SR
107
123
May
er,R
.(R
SP
)
2126
.06.
5318
.06.
5435
65
3R
SP
77M
RP
82IN
D87
UD
SR
107
122
Lan
iel,
J.(I
ND
)
2219
.06.
5422
.02.
5524
95
3R
SP
77M
RP
82IN
D87
UD
SR
107
116
Men
des
-Fra
nce,
P.(
RS
P)
2323
.02.
5530
.01.
5634
01
3R
SP
77M
RP
82IN
D87
UD
SR
107
119
Fau
re,E
.(R
SP
)
POLITICAL DATA: AN UPDATE (1990–1995) 141
FR
AN
CE
4(c
ontin
ued)
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3P
y4P
y5C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
2431
.01.
5610
.06.
5749
74
5P
SF
88R
SP
73U
DS
R16
313
Mol
let,
G.(
PS
F)
2511
.06.
5705
.11.
5714
84
5P
SF
88R
SP
73U
DS
R16
314
Bou
rges
-Mau
nory
,M
.(R
SP
)
2606
.11.
5713
.05.
5818
9,1
3R
SP
73P
SF
88U
DS
R16
MR
P71
IND
952
17G
ailla
rd,
F.(R
SP
)
2714
.05.
5831
.05.
5823
43
MR
P57
RS
P23
IND
133
UD
SR
198
218
Pfli
mlin
,P.(
MR
P)
2801
.06.
5807
.01.
5922
11
3G
AU
L19
8M
RP
57P
SF
44R
SP
23IN
D13
32
24D
eG
aulle
,C.(
GA
UL
)
Gov
1:U
DS
Rin
clud
esR
SP
.G
ov6:
Rea
son
for
Term
inat
ion
was
volu
ntar
yre
sign
atio
nto
exte
ndth
eco
aliti
on.
Gov
20:U
DS
Rin
clud
esA
RS
.G
ov21
:UD
SR
incl
udes
AR
San
dU
RA
S.
Gov
26:U
DS
Rin
clud
esG
AU
Lan
dR
DA
.G
ov27
:UD
SR
incl
udes
RD
A.
Gov
28:G
AU
Lin
clud
esR
DA
.C
hange
s/co
rrect
ions
pp.4
4–45
:pa
ge45
#5
Hea
lth:M
arra
ne,A
.(P
CF
).
142 J. WOLDENDORP, H. KEMAN & I. BUDGEF
RA
NC
E5
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3P
y4C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
2908
.01.
5914
.04.
6211
931
3G
AU
L19
8R
SP
23M
RP
57IN
D13
31
21D
ebr
e,M
.(U
NR
)30
15.0
4.62
15.0
5.62
315
3U
NR
198
MR
P57
IND
133
122
Pom
pido
u,G
.(N
ON
A)
3116
.05.
6205
.12.
6220
4x
3U
NR
198
IND
133
120
Pom
pido
u,G
.(N
ON
A)
3206
.12.
6208
.01.
66l1
301
3U
NR
230
IND
181
22P
ompi
dou,
G.(
NO
NA
)33
09.0
1.66
07.0
4.67
454
23
UN
R23
0IN
D18
118
Pom
pido
u,G
.(N
ON
A)
3408
.04.
6730
.05.
6841
96
2U
NR
191
VR
EP
411
22P
ompi
dou,
G.(
VR
EP
)35
31.0
5.68
11.0
7.68
421
5V
RE
P41
122
Pom
pido
u,G
.(V
RE
P)
3612
.07.
6821
.06.
6934
52
3U
DR
282
IND
641
19C
ouve
deM
urvi
lle,M
.(U
DR
)37
22.0
6.69
06.0
7.72
1111
63
UD
R28
2P
DM
26IN
D64
119
Cha
ban-
Del
mas
,M.(
UD
R)
3807
.07.
7204
.04.
7327
21
3U
DR
282
PD
M26
IND
641
20M
essm
er,P
.(U
DR
)39
05.0
4.73
28.0
2.74
330
x2
UD
R17
8C
DP
21IN
D54
122
Mes
smer
,P.(
UD
R)
4001
.03.
7427
.05.
7488
12
UD
R17
8C
DP
21IN
D54
116
Mes
smer
,P.(
UD
R)
4128
.05.
7416
.08.
7681
26
3U
DR
178
CD
P21
IND
54R
EF
301
16C
hira
c,J.
(UD
R)
4217
.08.
7629
.03.
7722
54
3U
DR
178
CD
S21
IND
54M
RG
111
18B
arre
,R.(
CD
S)
4330
.03.
7703
.04.
7837
01
3R
PR
178
CD
S21
IND
54M
RG
111
15B
arre
,R.(
CD
S)
4404
.04.
7821
.05.
8111
441
3U
DF
124
RP
R14
21
20B
arre
,R.(
UD
F)
4522
.05.
8122
.06.
8132
16
PS
F26
83
31M
auro
y,P
.(P
SF
)46
23.0
6.81
21.0
3.83
637
63
PS
F26
8P
CF
435
36M
auro
y,P
.(P
SF
)47
22.0
3.83
22.0
7.84
487
63
PS
F26
8P
CF
435
23M
auro
y,P
.(P
SF
)48
23.0
7.84
19.0
3.86
604
14
PS
F26
85
23F
abiu
s,L
.(P
SF
)49
20.0
3.86
11.0
3.88
721
15
RP
R14
6U
DF
128
225
Chi
rac,
J.(R
PR
)50
12.0
3.88
27.0
6.88
108
65
PS
F21
0U
DF
533
19R
ocar
d,M
.(P
SF
)51
28.0
6.88
14.0
5.91
1052
64
PS
F26
95
22R
ocar
d,M
.(P
SF
)52
15.0
5.91
01.0
4.92
322
64
PS
F26
95
20*C
ress
on,E
.(P
SF
)53
02.0
4.92
29.0
3.93
362
14
PS
F26
95
20B
ereg
ovoy
,P.(P
SF
)54
30.0
3.93
17.0
5.95
779
22
RP
R24
7U
DF
205
124
Bal
ladu
r,E
.(R
PR
)55
18.0
5.95
07.1
1.95
182
22
RP
R25
7U
DF
213
127
Jupp
e,A
.(R
PR
)56
08.1
1.95
2R
PR
257
UD
F21
31
28Ju
ppe,A
.(R
PR
)
POLITICAL DATA: AN UPDATE (1990–1995) 143
FR
AN
CE
5(c
ontin
ued)
Gov
29:G
AU
Lin
clud
esR
DA
and
UN
R.
Gov
31:R
easo
nfo
rTe
rmin
atio
nis
volu
ntar
yre
sign
atio
nto
exte
ndor
resh
uffle
the
coal
ition
;UN
Rin
clud
esU
DT.
Gov
32,3
3,34
:UN
Rin
clud
esU
DT.
Gov
34,3
5:V
RE
Pin
clud
esIN
D.
Gov
39:R
easo
nfo
rTe
rmin
atio
nis
volu
ntar
yre
sign
atio
nto
exte
ndor
resh
uffle
the
coal
ition
.G
ov41
:gov
part
ies
incl
ude
RA
D(1
1se
ats
inpa
rliam
ent)
.G
ov44
:UD
F=
AP
P–U
DF
+U
DF
–CD
S+
UD
F–P
R.
Gov
45,4
6,47
,50,
51:P
SF
incl
udes
MR
G.
Gov
48:P
SF
incl
udes
PS
Uan
dM
RG
.G
ov49
:UD
Fin
clud
esU
DF
–RP
and
UD
F–C
DS
.G
ov50
:UD
F=
UD
F–P
R.
Gov
51:U
DF
=U
DF
–RP
and
UD
F–C
DS
;Ind
ivid
uals
from
UD
F–P
R,U
DF
–CD
S,a
ndU
DF
–RA
Dpa
rtic
ipat
edin
the
gove
rnm
ent.
Gov
52:I
ndiv
idua
lsfr
omF
ranc
eU
nie
and
Eco
logy
Gen
erat
ion
part
icip
ated
inth
ego
vern
men
t.G
ov54
–56:
UD
F=
UD
F–R
Pan
dU
DF
–CD
S.
Change
s/co
rrect
ions
pp.4
9–52
:pa
ge49
#38
Just
ice:
Ple
ven,
R.(
PD
M)
#41
Just
ice:
Leca
nuet
,J.(
CD
P)
#42
/43/
44F
orei
gnA
ff:G
uirin
gaud
,L.d
e(N
ON
A)
page
50#
31E
cono
mic
Aff:
Pal
ewsk
i,G
.(U
NR
)#
42/4
3F
inan
ce/E
cono
mic
Aff:
Bar
re,R
.(C
DS
);L
abou
r:B
eulla
c,C
.(N
ON
A);
Edu
catio
n:H
aby,
R.(
NO
NA
);H
ealth
:*V
eil,
S.(
NO
NA
)#
44H
ealth
:*V
eil,
S.(
NO
NA
)pa
ge51
#45
/46
Indu
stry
/Tra
de:J
ober
t,M
.(P
SF
)pa
ge52
#38
Oth
er:D
uham
el,J
.(P
DM
)#
41O
ther
:Abe
lin,P
.(C
DP
)#
43S
ocia
lAff:
*Vei
l,S
.(N
ON
A)
#44
Soc
ialA
ff:*V
eil,
S.(
NO
NA
);P
ublic
Wor
ks:L
ecat
,J.-
P.(
RP
R)
144 J. WOLDENDORP, H. KEMAN & I. BUDGE
GE
RM
AN
Y
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3P
y4C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
115
.09.
4908
.10.
5314
851
2C
DU
139
FD
P52
DP
171
14A
dena
uer,
K.(
CD
U)
209
.10.
5322
.07.
5565
24
3C
DU
243
FD
P48
DP
15G
BH
E27
116
Ade
naue
r,K
.(C
DU
)
323
.07.
5520
.03.
5624
24
3C
DU
243
FD
P48
DP
151
16A
dena
uer,
K.(
CD
U)
421
.03.
5621
.10.
5758
01
3C
DU
243
FD
P48
DP
151
18A
dena
uer,
K.(
CD
U)
522
.10.
5730
.06.
6098
34
3C
DU
270
DP
171
17A
dena
uer,
K.(
CD
U)
601
.07.
6013
.11.
6150
11
4C
DU
270
118
Ade
naue
r,K
.(C
DU
)
714
.11.
6118
.11.
6237
04
2C
DU
242
FD
P67
121
Ade
naue
r,K
.(C
DU
)
819
.11.
6213
.12.
6225
46
CD
U24
21
16A
dena
uer,
K.(
CD
U)
914
.12.
6215
.10.
6330
62
2C
DU
242
FD
P67
121
Ade
naue
r,K
.(C
DU
)
1016
.10.
6325
.10.
6574
11
2C
DU
242
FD
P67
120
Erh
ard,
L.(
CD
U)
1126
.10.
6527
.10.
6636
74
2C
DU
245
FD
P49
121
Erh
ard,
L.(
CD
U)
1228
.10.
6630
.11.
6634
26
CD
U24
52
18E
rhar
d,L
.(C
DU
)
1301
.12.
6621
.10.
6910
561
3C
DU
245
SP
D20
23
20K
iesi
nger
,K
.(C
DU
)
1422
.10.
6916
.05.
7293
85
2S
PD
224
FD
P30
416
Bra
ndt,
W.(
SP
D)
1517
.05.
7214
.12.
7221
21
2S
PD
223
FD
P26
416
Bra
ndt,
W.(
SP
D)
1615
.12.
7215
.05.
7451
72
2S
PD
230
FD
P41
418
Bra
ndt,
W.(
SP
D)
1716
.05.
7414
.12.
7694
41
2S
PD
230
FD
P41
416
Sch
mid
t,H
.(S
PD
)
1815
.12.
7603
.11.
8014
201
2S
PD
214
FD
P39
416
Sch
mid
t,H
.(S
PD
)
1904
.11.
8016
.09.
8268
24
2S
PD
218
FD
P53
418
Sch
mid
t,H
.(S
PD
)
2017
.09.
8203
.10.
8217
56
SP
D21
83
13S
chm
idt,
H.(
SP
D)
2104
.10.
8229
.03.
8317
71
6C
DU
226
FD
P53
117
Koh
l,H
.(C
DU
)
2230
.03.
8310
.03.
87l4
421
2C
DU
244
FD
P34
117
Koh
l,H
.(C
DU
)
2311
.03.
8703
.10.
9013
032
CD
U22
3F
DP
461
19K
ohl,
H.(
CD
U)
2404
.10.
9016
.01.
9110
51
2C
DU
305
FD
P59
119
Koh
l,H
.(C
DU
)
2517
.01.
9116
.11.
9414
001
2C
DU
319
FD
P79
125
Koh
l,H
.(C
DU
)
2617
.11.
942
CD
U29
4F
DP
471
19K
ohl,
H.(
CD
U)
CD
Uin
clud
esC
DU
prop
erpl
usC
SU
.G
ov4:
split
inF
DP
;FV
P(s
eats
inpa
rliam
entu
nkno
wn)
cont
inue
sto
part
icip
ate
ingo
vern
men
t.G
ov6:
split
inD
P;9
ofth
e15
MP
’sjo
inth
eC
DU
.G
ov23
:inc
lusi
onof
5m
inis
ters
from
the
new
east
ern
Lan
der
inth
eF
eder
algo
vern
men
t.G
ov24
:afte
run
ifica
tion
the
Bun
dest
agw
asen
larg
edfr
om51
9to
663
seat
s.C
hange
s/co
rrect
ions
pp.5
4–57
:pa
ge57
#2
Oth
er:O
berla
nder
,T.(
CD
U)
#4
Oth
er:B
luche
r,F.
(FD
P)
POLITICAL DATA: AN UPDATE (1990–1995) 145IC
ELA
ND
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3P
y4C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
121
.10.
4403
.02.
4786
64
2IP
20U
SP
/PA
10S
DP
93
5T
hors
,O.(
IP)
204
.02.
4706
.12.
4910
361
2IP
19S
DP
7P
P13
26
Ste
fans
son,
S.J
.(S
DP
)3
07.1
2.49
12.0
3.50
965
2IP
19P
P17
SD
P7
26
Ste
inth
orss
on,S
.(P
P)
413
.03.
5012
.09.
5312
791
2P
P17
IP19
16
Ste
inth
orss
on,S
.(P
P)
513
.09.
5324
.07.
5610
474
2P
P16
IP21
16
Tho
rs,O
.(IP
)6
25.0
7.56
22.1
2.58
882
42
PP
17S
DP
8U
SP
/PA
83
6Jo
nass
on,H
.(P
P)
723
.12.
5819
.11.
5933
24
4S
DP
84
4Jo
nsso
n,E
.(S
DP
)8
20.1
1.59
13.1
1.63
1455
32
IP24
SD
P8
36
Tho
rs,O
.(IP
)9
14.1
1.63
11.0
6.67
1306
12
IP24
SD
P8
37
Ben
edik
tsso
n,B
.(IP
)10
12.0
6.67
09.0
7.70
1125
32
IP23
SD
P9
37
Ben
edik
tsso
n,B
.(IP
)11
10.0
7.70
13.0
6.71
339
12
IP23
SD
P9
37
Haf
stei
n,J.
(IP
)12
14.0
6.71
28.0
8.74
117
42
PP
17U
SP
/PA
10U
LL
53
7Jo
hann
esso
n,O
.(P
P)
1329
.08.
7430
.08.
7814
631
2IP
25P
P17
18
Hal
lgrim
sson
,G.(
IP)
1431
.08.
7814
.10.
7941
04
2P
P12
SD
P14
US
P/P
A14
29
Joha
nnes
son,
O.(
PP
)15
15.1
0.79
07.0
2.80
116
14
SD
P14
46
Gr
onda
l,B
.(S
DP
)16
08.0
2.80
25.0
5.83
1202
53
PP
17IP
21U
SP
/PA
112
10T
horo
ddse
n,G
.(IP
)17
26.0
5.83
07.0
7.87
1504
12
PP
14IP
231
10H
erm
anns
son,
S.(
PP
)18
08.0
7.87
27.0
9.88
448
52
PP
13IP
18S
DP
103
11P
alss
on,T
.(IP
)19
28.0
9.88
27.0
9.89
366
x2
PP
.13
SD
P10
US
P/P
A8
[RE
P1]
39
Her
man
nsso
n,S
.(P
P)
2028
.09.
8929
.04.
9157
91
2P
P13
SD
P10
CP
7U
SP
/PA
83
11H
erm
anns
son,
S.(
PP
)21
30.0
4.91
22.0
4.95
1454
12
IP26
SD
P10
310
Odd
sson
,D.(
IP)
2223
.04.
952
IP25
SD
P15
310
Odd
sson
,D.(
IP)
Gov
19:R
easo
nfo
rTe
rmin
atio
nis
broa
deni
ngof
coal
ition
.G
ov20
:RE
P(1
seat
inpa
rliam
ent)
supp
orte
dth
ego
vern
men
t.C
hange
s/co
rrect
ions
pp.5
8–61:
page
58#
11Ju
stic
e:*A
udun
s,A
.(S
DP
)pa
ge59
#6
Hea
lth:V
ladi
mar
sson
,H.(
US
P)
page
60#
6A
gric
ultu
re:J
osef
sson
,L.(
US
P)
=(C
OM
);In
dust
ry/T
rade
:Jos
efss
on,L
.(U
SP
)=
(CO
M)
#12
Agr
icul
ture
:Jos
efss
on,L
.(U
SP
)=
(CO
M)
146 J. WOLDENDORP, H. KEMAN & I. BUDGE
IRE
LAN
D
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3P
y4C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
118
.02.
4812
.06.
5112
115
5F
G31
LA
B14
CN
T7
CN
P10
214
Cos
tello
,J.A
.(F
G)
213
.06.
5101
.06.
5410
855
4F
F69
112
Val
era,
E.d
e(F
F)
302
.06.
5419
.03.
5710
225
2F
G50
LA
B19
CN
T5
214
Cos
tello
,J.A
.(F
G)
420
.03.
5722
.06.
5982
52
1F
F78
112
Val
era,
E.d
e(F
F)
523
.06.
5910
.10.
6184
12
1F
F78
114
Lem
ass,
S.(
FF
)6
11.1
0.61
31.0
3.65
1268
14
FF
701
15L
emas
s,S
.(F
F)
701
.04.
6509
.11.
6658
83
1F
F72
115
Lem
ass,
S.(
FF
)8
10.1
1.66
01.0
7.69
965
11
FF
721
15Ly
nch,
J.A
.(F
F)
902
.07.
6913
.03.
7313
511
1F
F75
114
Lync
h,J.
A.(
FF
)10
14.0
3.73
04.0
7.77
1574
12
FG
54L
AB
192
15C
osgr
ave,
L.(
FG
)11
05.0
7.77
10.1
2.79
889
21
FF
841
16Ly
nch,
J.A
.(F
F)
1211
.12.
7929
.06.
8156
71
1F
F84
115
Hau
ghey
,C.J
.(F
F)
1330
.06.
8108
.03.
8225
25
5F
G65
LA
B15
215
Fitz
gera
ld,G
.M.D
.(F
G)
1409
.03.
8213
.12.
8228
05
4F
F81
116
Hau
ghey
,C.J
.(F
F)
1514
.12.
8209
.03.
8715
474
2F
G70
LA
B16
217
Fitz
gera
ld,G
.M.D
.(F
G)
1610
.03.
8711
.07.
8985
51
4F
F81
115
Hau
ghey
,C.J
.(F
F)
1712
.07.
8910
.02.
9294
42
5F
F77
PD
61
17H
augh
ey,C
.J.(
FF
)18
11.0
2.92
11.0
1.93
327
45
FF
77P
D6
115
Rey
nold
s,A
(FF
)19
12.0
1.93
14.1
2.94
702
42
FF
68L
AB
333
15R
eyno
lds,
A.(
FF
)20
15.1
2.94
2F
G45
LA
B33
SD
L4
315
Bru
ton,
J.(F
G)
Change
s/co
rrect
ions
pp.6
2–64
:pa
ge62
#2
Just
ice
dele
te:M
acG
illig
an,P
.(F
G)
POLITICAL DATA: AN UPDATE (1990–1995) 147
ISR
AE
L
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3P
y4P
y5C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
014
.05.
4809
.03.
4930
01
x13
Ben
-Gur
ion,
D.
110
.03.
4929
.10.
5059
94
3M
PA
I46
UR
F16
PR
OG
5S
EP
H5
312
Ben
-Gur
ion,
D.(
MP
Al)
230
.10.
5004
.03.
5112
65
3M
PA
I46
UR
F16
PR
OG
5S
EP
H5
313
Ben
-Gur
ion,
D.(
MP
AI)
305
.03.
5106
.10.
5121
61
6M
PA
I46
UR
F16
PR
OG
5S
EP
H5
313
Ben
-Gur
ion,
D.(
MP
Al)
407
.10.
5122
.12.
5244
3x
2M
PA
I50
UR
F15
413
Ben
-Gur
ion,
D.(
MP
AI)
523
.12.
5206
.01.
5438
03
3M
PA
I50
GZ
23H
MIZ
8P
RO
G4
MIZ
R2
316
Ben
-Gur
ion,
D.(
MP
AI)
607
.01.
5428
.06.
5553
84
3M
PA
I50
GZ
23H
MIZ
8P
RO
G4
MIZ
R2
415
Sha
rett,
M.(
MP
AI)
729
.06.
5501
.11.
5512
61
6M
PA
I50
HM
IZ8
PR
OG
4M
IZR
24
12S
hare
tt,M
.(M
PA
I)
802
.11.
5505
.01.
5879
62
3M
PA
I45
NR
P11
AA
10M
PA
M9
PR
OG
54
16B
en-G
urio
n,D
.(M
PA
I)
906
.01.
5830
.06.
5817
64
3M
PA
I45
NR
P11
AA
10M
PA
M9
PR
OG
54
16B
en-G
urio
n,D
.(M
PA
I)
1001
.07.
5820
.07.
5938
52
3M
PA
I45
AA
10M
PA
M9
PR
OG
54
13B
en-G
urio
n,D
.(M
PA
I)
1121
.07.
5915
.12.
5914
81
6M
PA
I45
AA
10M
PA
M9
PR
OG
54
13B
en-G
urio
n,D
.(M
PA
I)
1216
.12.
5931
.01.
6141
32
3M
PA
I52
NR
P12
MP
AM
9A
A7
PR
OG
64
16B
en-G
urio
n,D
.(M
PA
I)
1331
.01.
6101
.11.
6127
51
6M
PA
I52
NR
P12
MP
AM
9A
A7
PR
OG
64
16B
en-G
urio
n,D
.(M
PA
I)
1402
.11.
6123
.06.
6359
92
2M
PA
I46
NR
P12
AA
84
16B
en-G
urio
n,D
.(M
PA
l)
1524
.06.
6321
.12.
6454
72
2M
PA
I46
NR
P12
AA
84
15E
shko
l,L
.(M
PA
I)
1622
.12.
6409
.01.
6638
31
2M
PA
I46
NR
P12
AA
84
17E
shko
l,L
.(M
PA
I)
1710
.01.
6631
.05.
6750
7x
3A
LN
M49
NR
P11
MP
AM
8IL
IB5
418
Esh
kol,
L.(
MP
AI)
1801
.06.
6716
.03.
6965
53
3A
LN
M49
HR
UT
26N
RP
11R
AF
I10
MP
AM
84
20E
shko
l,L
.(M
PA
I)
1917
.03.
6914
.12.
6927
31
3A
LN
M49
HR
UT
26N
RP
11R
AF
I10
MP
AM
84
21*M
eir,
G.(
MP
AI)
2015
.12.
6903
.08.
7023
24
3A
LNM
60G
HA
L26
NR
P12
ILIB
44
24*M
eir,
G.(
MP
AI)
2104
.08.
7005
.03.
7413
101
3A
LN
M60
GH
AL
26N
RP
12IL
IB4
418
*Mei
r,G
.(M
PA
I)
148 J. WOLDENDORP, H. KEMAN & I. BUDGE
ISR
AE
L(c
ontin
ued)
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3P
y4P
y5C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
2206
.03.
7402
.06.
7489
23
LA
B54
NR
P10
ILIB
44
22*M
eir,
G.(
MP
AI)
2303
.06.
7428
.10.
7414
84
2L
AB
54IL
IB4
CR
IT3
419
Rab
in,I
.(M
PA
I)
2429
.10.
7420
.12.
7678
44
3L
AB
54N
RP
10IL
IB4
421
Rab
in,I
.(M
PA
I)
2521
.12.
7618
.06.
7718
01
6L
AB
54IL
IB4
418
Rab
in,I
.(M
PA
I)
2619
.06.
7722
.10.
7712
6x
2L
IK45
NR
P12
313
Beg
in,M
.(L
IK)
2724
.10.
7704
.08.
8113
814
3L
IK45
NR
P12
DA
SH
111
17B
egin
,M.(
LIK
)
2805
.08.
8122
.07.
8372
7x
2L
IK48
NR
P6
TAM
I31
18B
egin
,M.(
LIK
)
2923
.07.
8309
.10.
8379
22
LIK
48N
RP
6TA
MI3
118
Beg
in,M
.(L
IK)
3010
.10.
8312
.09.
8433
93
2L
IK48
NR
P6
TAM
I3T
HYA
31
20S
ham
ir,I.
(LIK
)
3113
.09.
8419
.10.
8676
71
3L
AB
44L
IK41
NR
P4
SH
AS
4S
NU
I33
17P
eres
,S.(
LA
B)
3220
.10.
8621
.12.
8879
42
3L
AB
44L
IK41
NR
P4
SH
AS
4S
NU
I33
17S
ham
ir,I.
(LIK
)
3322
.12.
8810
.06.
9053
64
3L
IK40
LA
B39
SH
AS
6N
RP
53
12S
ham
ir,I.
(LIK
)
3411
.06.
9015
.11.
9015
8x
2L
IK40
SH
AS
6N
RP
5T
HYA
3T
ZO
M2
119
Sha
mir,
I.(L
IK)
3516
.11.
9002
.02.
9179
x2
LIK
40S
HA
S6
NR
P5
TH
YA3
TZ
OM
21
19S
ham
ir,I.
(LIK
)
3603
.02.
9129
.12.
9133
04
3L
IK40
SH
AS
6N
RP
5T
HYA
3A
154
120
Sha
mir,
I.(L
IK)
3730
.12.
9121
.01.
9223
42
LIK
40S
HA
S6
NR
P5
TH
YA3
A15
41
19S
ham
ir,I.
(LIK
)
3822
.01.
9212
.07.
9217
51
5L
IK40
SH
AS
6N
RP
51
17S
ham
ir,I.
(LIK
)
3913
.07.
9214
.09.
9342
95
2L
AB
44M
RE
T12
SH
AS
6[H
AD
AS
H3]
[AD
P2]
417
Rab
in,I
.(L
AB
)
4015
.09.
9324
.12.
9446
6x
2L
AB
44M
RE
T12
SH
AS
6[H
AD
AS
H3]
[AD
P2]
416
Rab
in,I
.(L
AB
)
4125
.12.
9421
.11.
9532
7x
2L
AB
44M
RE
T12
HA
DA
SH
3[A
DP
2]4
21R
abin
,I.(
LA
B)
4222
.11.
9517
.05.
9614
61
5L
AB
44M
RE
T12
YI’U
D2
HA
DA
SH
3[A
DP
2]4
20P
eres
,S.(
LA
B)
POLITICAL DATA: AN UPDATE (1990–1995) 149
ISR
AE
L(c
ontin
ued)
Gov
0:pr
ovis
iona
lgov
ernm
ent.
Gov
4:R
easo
nfo
rTe
rmin
atio
nis
broa
deni
ngof
coal
ition
.G
ov8:
NR
Pis
elec
tion
co-o
pera
tion
ofH
MIZ
&M
IZR
.G
ov16
:PA
IS(2
seat
sin
parli
amen
t)su
ppor
ted
the
gove
rnm
ent.
Gov
17:R
easo
nfo
rTe
rmin
atio
nis
broa
deni
ngof
coal
ition
invi
ewof
imm
inen
twar
;Alig
nmen
t=el
ectio
nco
-ope
ratio
nof
MA
PA
Iand
Ahd
utA
voda
(AA
);P
AlS
(2se
ats
inpa
rliam
ent)
supp
orte
dth
ego
vern
men
t.G
ov18
,19
:In
depe
nden
tLi
bera
ls(I
LIB
,5se
ats
inpa
rliam
ent)
wer
epa
rtof
the
gove
rnm
ent
coal
ition
;P
AlS
(2se
ats
inpa
rliam
ent)
supp
orte
dth
ego
vern
men
t.G
ov20
:Alig
nmen
t=el
ectio
nco
-ope
ratio
nof
MA
PA
I,A
hdut
Avo
da(A
A),
MA
PA
Man
dR
AF
I;G
AH
AL
=el
ectio
nco
-ope
ratio
nof
Her
utan
dLi
bera
ls.
Gov
22:L
abou
ris
elec
tion
co-o
pera
tion
ofM
AP
AIa
ndM
AP
AM
.G
ov26
:Rea
son
for
Term
inat
ion
isbr
oade
ning
ofco
aliti
on;L
IKU
Din
clud
esS
hlom
zion
;AIS
(4se
ats)
and
PA
lS(1
seat
)su
ppor
ted
the
gove
rn-
men
t.G
ov27
:D
AS
Hha
s15
seat
sin
Kne
sset
,bu
ta
diss
iden
tfa
ctio
nde
cide
dno
tto
co-o
pera
tein
this
gove
rnm
ent;
AIS
(4se
ats)
and
PA
lS(1
seat
)su
ppor
ted
the
gove
rnm
ent.
Gov
28:R
easo
nfo
rTe
rmin
atio
nis
broa
deni
ngco
aliti
on;A
IS(4
seat
s)an
dT
HYA
(3se
ats)
supp
orte
dth
ego
vern
men
t.G
ov29
:AIS
(4se
ats)
and
TH
YA(3
seat
s)su
ppor
ted
the
gove
rnm
ent.
Gov
30:A
IS(4
seat
s)su
ppor
ted
the
gove
rnm
ent.
Gov
31,3
2:M
SH
A(2
seat
s)an
dO
ME
T(1
seat
)pa
rtic
ipat
edin
gove
rnm
ent;
AIS
(2se
ats)
and
YH
AD
(3se
ats)
supp
orte
dth
ego
vern
men
t.G
ov33
:Lab
our
did
noti
nclu
deM
AP
AM
.G
ov34
:DH
AT
(2se
ats)
,MD
ET
(2se
ats)
and
IND
(3se
ats)
supp
orte
dth
ego
vern
men
t.G
ov35
:rea
son
for
term
inat
ion
isbr
oade
ning
ofco
aliti
on(s
eeal
soG
ov.3
4).
Gov
36:T
ZO
M(2
)pa
rtic
ipat
edin
gove
rnm
ent;
DH
AT
(2)
and
IND
(3)
supp
orte
dth
ego
vern
men
t.G
ov37
:DH
AT
(2)
and
IND
(3)
supp
orte
dth
ego
vern
men
t.G
ov38
:see
Gov
.37.
Gov
39:R
easo
nfo
rTe
rmin
atio
nis
with
draw
alof
SH
AS
from
coal
ition
Gov
40:R
easo
nfo
rTe
rmin
atio
nis
broa
deni
ngof
coal
ition
.G
ov41
:Rea
son
for
Term
inat
ion
isas
sass
inat
ion
ofP
MR
abin
.G
ov42
:YI’U
Dis
brea
kaw
ayfa
ctio
nof
TZ
OM
ET.
150 J. WOLDENDORP, H. KEMAN & I. BUDGE
ITA
LY
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3P
y4P
y5C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
112
.07.
4602
.02.
4720
64
3D
C20
7P
SIU
115
PR
I25
PC
I104
PL
I41
319
Gas
peri,
A.d
e(D
C)
203
.02.
4730
.05.
4711
74
3D
C20
7P
d10
4P
SI1
152
15G
aspe
ri,A
.de
(DC
)
331
.05.
4714
.12.
4719
82
5D
C20
7N
DU
412
17G
aspe
ri,A
.de
(DC
)
415
.12.
4722
.05.
4816
01
3D
C20
7P
RI2
5P
LI4
1P
SD
I115
120
Gas
peri,
A.d
e(D
C)
523
.05.
4826
.01.
5061
44
3D
C30
5P
RI9
PL
I19
PS
DI3
31
20G
aspe
ri,A
.de
(DC
)
627
.01.
5025
.07.
5154
54
3D
C30
5P
SD
I33
PR
I91
19G
aspe
ri,A
.de
(DC
)
726
.07.
5116
.07.
5372
21
3D
C30
5P
RI9
116
Gas
peri,
A.d
e(D
C)
817
.07.
5316
.08.
5331
54
DC
263
117
Gas
peri,
A.d
e(D
C)
917
.08.
5318
.01.
5415
55
6D
C26
31
17P
ella
,G.(
DC
)
1019
.01.
5410
.02.
5423
45
DC
263
119
Fan
fani
,A.(
DC
)
1111
.02.
5405
.07.
5551
04
5D
C26
3P
SD
I19
PL
I13
121
Sce
lba,
M.(
DC
)
1206
.07.
5519
.05.
5768
44
5D
C26
3P
SD
I19
PL
I13
121
Seg
ni,A
.(D
C)
1320
.05.
5709
.07.
5840
71
4D
C26
31
20Z
oli,
A.(
DC
)
1410
.07.
5815
.02.
5922
14
5D
C27
3P
SD
I22
120
Fan
fani
,A.(
DC
)
1516
.02.
5924
.03.
6040
35
4D
C27
31
21S
egni
,A.(
DC
)
1625
.03.
6025
.07.
6012
35
4D
C27
31
22Ta
mbr
oni,
F.(D
C)
1726
.07.
6020
.02.
6257
52
4D
C27
31
24F
anfa
ni,A
.(D
C)
1821
.02.
6220
.06.
6348
51
5D
C27
3P
SD
I22
PR
I61
24F
anfa
ni,A
.(D
C)
1921
.06.
6304
.12.
6316
72
6D
C26
02
23L
eone
,G.(
DC
)
2005
.12.
6321
.07.
6423
05
3D
C26
0P
SI8
7P
SD
I33
PR
I62
26M
oro,
A.(
DC
)
2122
.07.
6422
.02.
6658
15
3D
C26
0P
SI8
7P
SD
I33
PR
I62
26M
oro,
A.(
DC
)
POLITICAL DATA: AN UPDATE (1990–1995) 151
ITA
LY(c
ontin
ued)
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3P
y4P
y5C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
2223
.02.
6624
.06.
6885
31
3D
C26
0P
SI8
7P
SD
I33
PR
I62
26M
oro,
A.(
DC
)
2325
.06.
6811
.12.
6817
02
4D
C26
62
23L
eone
,G.(
DC
)
2412
.12.
6804
.08.
6923
64
3D
C26
6P
SI9
1P
RI9
227
Rum
or,M
.(D
C)
2505
.08.
6926
.03.
7023
42
4D
C26
62
25R
umor
,M.(
DC
)
2627
.03.
7005
.08.
7013
24
3D
C26
6P
SI+
PS
U91
PR
I92
27R
umor
,M.(
DC
)
2706
.08.
7026
.02.
7120
54
3D
C26
6P
SI+
PS
U91
PR
I92
28C
olom
bo,E
.(D
C)
2827
.02.
7117
.02.
7235
64
3D
C26
6P
SI+
PS
U91
227
Col
ombo
,E.(
DC
)
2918
.02.
7225
.06.
7212
91
4D
C26
62
25A
ndre
otti,
G.(
DC
)
3026
.06.
7207
.09.
7343
95
2D
C26
7P
SD
I29
PL
I21
226
And
reot
ti,G
.(D
C)
3108
.09.
7313
.03.
7418
74
3D
C26
7P
SI6
1P
SD
I29
PR
I14
229
Rum
or,M
.(D
C)
3214
.03.
7422
.11.
7425
44
2D
C26
7P
SI6
1P
SD
I29
226
Rum
or,M
.(D
C)
3323
.11.
7412
.02.
7644
65
5D
C26
7P
RI1
41
25M
oro,
A.(
DC
)
3413
.02.
7628
.07.
7616
71
6D
C26
71
22M
oro,
A.(
DC
)
3529
.07.
7612
.03.
7859
25
4D
C26
31
22A
ndre
otti,
G.(
DC
)
3613
.03.
7820
.03.
7937
35
4D
C26
31
21A
ndre
otti,
G.(
DC
)
3721
.03.
7904
.08.
7913
71
6D
C26
3P
SD
I15
PR
I14
121
And
reot
ti,G
.(D
C)
3805
.08.
7903
.04.
8024
35
5D
C26
1P
SD
I21
PL
I91
25C
ossi
ga,F
.(D
C)
3904
.04.
8018
.10.
8019
85
3D
C26
1P
SI6
2P
RI1
52
28C
ossi
ga,F
.(D
C)
4019
.10.
8027
.06.
8125
25
3D
C26
1P
SI6
2P
SD
I21
PR
I15
227
For
lani
,A.(
DC
)
4128
.06.
8122
.08.
8242
14
3D
C26
1P
SI6
2P
SD
I21
PR
I15
PL
I92
28S
pado
lini,
G.(
PR
I)
4223
.08.
8210
.12.
8211
04
3D
C26
1P
SI6
2P
SD
I21
PR
I15
PL
I92
28S
pado
lini,
G.(
PR
I)
4311
.12.
8203
.08.
8323
61
3D
C26
1P
SI6
2P
SD
I21
PL
I92
28F
anfa
ni,A
.(D
C)
4404
.08.
8301
.08.
8610
945
3D
C22
5P
SI7
3P
SD
I23
PL
I16
PR
I29
230
Cra
xi,B
.(P
SI)
4502
.08.
8617
.04.
8725
91
3D
C22
5P
SI7
3P
SD
I23
PL
I16
PR
I29
230
Cra
xi,B
.(P
SI)
152 J. WOLDENDORP, H. KEMAN & I. BUDGE
ITA
LY(c
ontin
ued)
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3P
y4P
y5C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
4618
.04.
8728
.07.
8710
21
4D
C22
52
25F
anfa
ni,A
.(D
C)
4729
.07.
8712
.04.
8825
94
3D
C23
4P
SI9
4P
RI2
1P
SD
I17
PL
I11
230
Gor
ia,G
.(D
C)
4813
.04.
8822
.07.
8946
65
3D
C23
4P
SI9
4P
RI2
1P
SD
I17
PL
I11
230
De
Mita
,C.(
DC
)
4923
.07.
8914
.04.
9163
14
3D
C23
4P
SI9
4P
RI2
1P
SD
I17
PL
I11
232
And
reot
ti,G
.(D
C)
5015
.04.
9127
.06.
9244
02
3D
C23
4P
SI9
4P
SD
I17
PL
I11
230
And
reot
ti,G
.(D
C)
5128
.06.
9228
.04.
9330
5x
3D
C20
6P
SI9
2P
SD
I16
PL
I17
225
Am
ati,
G.(
PS
I)
5229
.04.
9306
.05.
938
43
DC
206
PS
I92
PD
S10
7LV
ER
DE
163
26C
iam
pi,C
.A.(
NO
NA
)
5307
.05.
9310
.05.
9436
81
3D
C20
6P
SI9
2P
LI1
7P
RI2
72
26C
iam
pi,C
.A.(
NO
NA
)
5411
.05.
9416
.01.
9525
14
2F
reed
omA
llian
ce(3
66)
126
Ber
lusc
oni,
S.(
For
za)
5517
.01.
9530
.12.
9534
76
x21
Din
i,L
.(N
ON
A)
Gov
51:R
easo
nfo
rTe
rmin
atio
nis
disi
nteg
ratio
nof
exis
ting
part
ysy
stem
.G
ov54
:Alli
ance
cons
iste
dof
For
zaIta
lia(3
0),N
atio
nalA
llian
ce(2
3),L
ega
Nor
d(1
1).D
irect
vote
s(3
02).
Gov
55:
Gov
ernm
ent
ofno
n-al
igne
dm
inis
ters
toge
tth
e19
96bu
dget
thro
ugh
parli
amen
t.R
easo
nfo
rTe
rmin
atio
n:go
vern
men
tsu
c-ce
eded
inge
tting
1996
budg
etth
roug
hpa
rliam
ent.
Change
s/co
rrect
ions
pp.7
0–78
:pa
ge73
#28
Lab
our:
Don
at-C
attin
,C.(
DC
);E
duca
tion:
Mis
asi,
R.(
DC
)
POLITICAL DATA: AN UPDATE (1990–1995) 153
JAP
AN
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
122
.05.
4629
.05.
4737
31
2L
P14
1P
P94
114
Yos
hida
,S.(
LP
)
230
.05.
4708
.03.
4828
44
3S
P14
3P
P12
1C
P31
216
Kat
ayam
a,T.
(SP
)
309
.03.
4818
.10.
4822
4x
3S
P14
3P
P12
1C
P31
311
Ash
ida,
H.(
PP
)
419
.10.
4815
.02.
4912
01
4L
P13
11
15Y
oshi
da,S
.(L
P)
516
.02.
4927
.06.
5049
7x
3L
P26
4P
P69
116
Yos
hida
,S.(
LP
)
628
.06.
5028
.10.
5285
45
1L
P26
41
15Y
oshi
da,S
.(L
P)
729
.10.
5220
.05.
5320
45
1L
P24
01
11Y
oshi
da,S
.(L
P)
821
.05.
5308
.12.
5456
75
4Y
L19
91
18Y
oshi
da,S
.(Y
L)
909
.12.
5418
.03.
5510
01
4D
P11
11
17H
atoy
ama,
I.(D
P)
1019
.03.
5521
.11.
5524
8x
4D
P18
51
18H
atoy
ama,
I.(D
P)
1122
.11.
5522
.12.
5639
73
1L
DP
297
118
Hat
oyam
a,I.
(DP
)
1223
.12.
5624
.02.
5764
31
LD
P29
71
17Is
hiba
shi,
T.(L
DP
)
1325
.02.
5711
.06.
5847
21
1L
DP
297
117
Kis
hi,N
.(L
DP
)
1412
.06.
5818
.07.
6076
82
1L
DP
287
118
Kis
hi,N
.(L
DP
)
1519
.07.
6007
.12.
6014
21
1L
DP
287
113
Iked
a,H
.(L
DP
)
1608
.12.
6008
.12.
63l0
961
1L
DP
296
117
Iked
a,H
.(L
DP
)
1709
.12.
6308
.11.
6433
63
1L
DP
283
118
Iked
a,H
.(L
DP
)
1809
.11.
6416
.02.
6783
01
1L
DP
283
118
Sat
o,E
.(L
DP
)
1917
.02.
6713
.01.
7010
621
1L
DP
277
119
Sat
o,E
.(L
DP
)
2014
.01.
7006
.07.
7290
52
1L
DP
288
115
Sat
o,E
.(L
DP
)
2107
.07.
7221
.12.
7216
81
1L
DP
288
118
Tana
ka,K
.(L
DP
)
2222
.12.
7208
.12.
7471
72
1L
DP
271
120
Tana
ka,K
.(L
DP
)
2309
.12.
7423
.12.
7674
62
1L
DP
271
121
Mik
i,T.
(LD
P)
2424
.12.
7607
.12.
7871
42
4L
DP
249
121
Fuk
uda,
T.(L
DP
)
2508
.12.
7807
.11.
7933
51
4L
DP
249
121
Ohi
ra,M
.(L
DP
)
154 J. WOLDENDORP, H. KEMAN & I. BUDGE
JAP
AN
(con
tinue
d)
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
2608
.11.
7916
.07.
8025
25
4L
DP
248
120
Ohi
ra,M
.(L
DP
)
2717
.07.
8025
.11.
8286
22
1L
DP
284
122
Suz
uki,
Z.(
LD
P)
2826
.11.
8225
.12.
8339
51
1L
DP
284
118
Nak
ason
e,Y.
(LD
P)
2926
.12.
8331
.10.
8431
1x
3L
DP
258
NL
C8
122
Nak
ason
e,Y.
(LD
P)
3001
.11.
8421
.07.
8662
81
3L
DP
258
NL
C8
122
Nak
ason
e,Y.
(LD
P)
3122
.07.
8605
.11.
8747
22
1L
DP
310
121
Nak
ason
e,Y.
(LD
P)
3206
.11.
8702
.06.
8957
52
1L
DP
310
120
Take
shita
,N.(
LD
P)
3303
.06.
8908
.08.
8967
21
LD
P31
01
21U
no,S
.(L
DP
)
3409
.08.
8927
.02.
9020
31
1L
DP
310
121
Kai
fu,T
.(L
DP
)
3528
.02.
9004
.11.
9161
53
1L
DP
275
121
Kai
fu,T
.(L
DP
)
3605
.11.
9108
.08.
9364
35
1L
DP
275
121
Miy
azaw
a,K
.(L
DP
)
3709
.08.
9327
.04.
9426
22
5S
DP
7S
HIN
SE
ITO
553
22H
osok
awa,
M.(
JNP
)
3828
.04.
9429
.06.
9463
25
KA
ISH
IN13
0K
OM
EIT
O52
SA
KIG
AK
E13
121
Hra
ta,T
.(K
AIS
HIN
)
3930
.06.
9410
.01.
9656
02
3LD
P20
6S
DP
J74
SA
KIG
AK
E15
321
Mur
ayam
a,T.
(SD
PJ)
4011
.01.
963
LD
P20
6S
DP
J74
SA
KIG
AK
E15
321
Mas
him
oto,
R.(
LDP
)
Gov
3:R
easo
nfo
rTe
rmin
atio
nis
finan
cial
scan
dali
nvol
ving
mem
bers
and
supp
orte
rsof
gove
rnm
ent.
Gov
5:R
easo
nfo
rTe
rmin
atio
nis
reco
nstr
uctio
nof
gove
rnm
entr
epre
sent
ing
the
prop
ortio
nof
seat
sof
the
part
ies
inbo
thH
ouse
s.G
ov9:
supp
ortin
gpa
rtie
sw
ere
Yos
hida
Lib
eral
s(1
99se
ats
inpa
rliam
ent)
and
SP
(138
seat
sin
parli
amen
t).
Gov
10:R
easo
nfo
rTe
rmin
atio
nw
asre
cons
truc
tion
ofgo
vern
men
tfol
low
ing
the
mer
ger
ofD
Ppl
usL
iber
als
into
LD
P.Y
oshi
daL
iber
als
(112
seat
sin
parli
amen
t)su
ppor
ted
the
gove
rnm
ent.
DP
(Dem
ocra
ticP
arty
)di
dno
tye
tex
ist
asa
sepa
rate
part
ydu
ring
gove
rnm
ent
9.It
was
aco
mbi
natio
nof
Pro
gres
sive
Par
tyan
dH
atoy
ama
Lib
eral
s.A
sD
Ppr
oper
they
cont
este
dth
e19
55el
ectio
ns.
Gov
29:R
easo
nfo
rTe
rmin
atio
nw
asre
-ele
ctio
nN
akas
one
asch
airm
anLD
Pan
dhe
nce
PM
.G
ov37
:KO
ME
ITO
(51)
,DS
P(1
5),S
AK
IGA
KE
(13)
,JN
P(3
5),S
HA
MIN
RE
N(4
)al
sopa
rtic
ipat
edin
the
gove
rnm
ent.
POLITICAL DATA: AN UPDATE (1990–1995) 155
JAP
AN
(con
tinue
d)
Cha
nges
/cor
rect
ions
pp.7
9–83
:pa
ge79
#1–
35N
umbe
rof
Min
iste
rs(N
oM):
allc
orre
cted
page
80#
2In
terio
r:K
imur
a,K
.(P
P)
#5
Just
ice:
Ued
a,S
.(N
ON
A)
#9
Inte
rior:
add
Oas
a,T.
(DP
)#
10In
terio
r:ad
dO
asa,
T.(D
P);
Oku
bo,T
.(D
P)
#11
Inte
rior:
add
Oas
a,T.
(DP
);#
14Ju
stic
e:A
ichi
,K.(
LDP
)#
16D
efen
ce:M
ishi
mur
a,N
.(LD
P)
#17
Inte
rior:
add
Yam
amur
a,S
.(LD
P)
#20
Inte
rior:
add
Ara
ki,M
.(L
DP
)#
21In
terio
r:ad
dK
imur
a,T.
(LD
P);
Ham
ano,
S.(
LDP
)#
22D
PM
:Mik
i,T.
(LD
P);
Inte
rior:
add
Fuk
uda,
T.(L
DP
)#
23In
terio
r:ad
dM
atsu
zaw
a,Y.
(LD
P)
#24
Inte
rior:
add
Nis
him
ura,
E.(
LD
P)
#25
Inte
rior:
add
Kan
ai,M
.(LD
P)
#26
Inte
rior:
add
Uno
,S.(
LD
P)
#27
Inte
rior:
add
Nak
ason
e,Y.
(LD
P)
#28
Inte
rior:
add
Sai
to,J
.(LD
P)
#29
Inte
rior:
add
Got
oda,
M.(
LD
P)
#35
Inte
rior:
add
Shi
ozak
i,J.
(LD
P)
page
81#
1H
ealth
:Kaw
ai,Y
.(N
ON
A)
#2
Hea
lth:H
itots
umat
su,S
.(P
P)
#4/
5H
ealth
:Hay
ashi
,J.(
LP)
#6
Hea
lth:K
urok
awa,
T.(L
P)
#7/
8H
ealth
:Yam
agat
a,K
.(LP
)#
9H
ealth
:Tsu
rum
i,Y.
(DP
)#
10H
ealth
:Mat
sum
ura,
K.(
DP
)#
11H
ealth
:Kob
ayas
hi,E
.(LD
P)
#14
Hea
lth:H
ashi
mot
o,R
.(LD
P)
#16
Hea
lth:F
urui
,Y.(
LDP
)#
19E
duca
tion:
Ken
noki
,T.(
LD
P)
#21
Edu
catio
n:ad
dN
akas
one,
Y.(L
DP
)#
22E
duca
tion:
add
Mae
da,K
.(LD
P)
#23
Edu
catio
n:ad
dS
asak
i,Y.
(LD
P)
#24
Edu
catio
n:ad
dU
no,S
.(L
DP
)#
25E
duca
tion:
add
Kan
eko,
I.(L
DP
)#
26E
duca
tion:
add
Osa
da,Y
.(L
DP
)#
27E
duca
tion:
add
Nak
ayaw
a,I.
(LD
P)
#29
Edu
catio
n:ad
dIs
urug
i,M
.(L
DP
)#
30E
duca
tion:
add
Take
nchi
,R.(
LDP
)#
31E
duca
tion:
add
Mits
ubay
ashi
,Y.(
LD
P)
#32
Edu
catio
n:ad
dIto
,S.(
LDP
)#
33E
duca
tion:
add
Nak
amur
a,K
.(LD
P)
#34
Edu
catio
n:ad
dS
aito
<D
E.(
LDP
)#
35E
duca
tion:
add
Osh
ima,
T.(L
DP
)
page
82#
21E
nviro
nmen
t:K
oyam
a,O
.(LD
P)
#22
Env
ironm
ent:
Mik
i,T.
(LD
P)
#23
Env
ironm
ent:
Oza
wa,
T.(L
DP
)#
24E
nviro
nmen
t:Is
hiha
ra,S
.(L
DP
)#
25E
nviro
nmen
t:K
emur
a,S
.(LD
P)
#26
Env
ironm
ent:
Tsu
chiy
a,Y.
(LD
P)
#27
Env
ironm
ent:
Kuj
iraok
a,H
.(LD
P)
#29
Env
ironm
ent:
Ued
a,M
.(LD
P)
#30
Env
ironm
ent:
*Ish
imot
o,S
.(L
DP
)#
31E
nviro
nmen
t:In
anam
ura,
T.(L
DP
)#
32E
nviro
nmen
t:H
oriu
chi,
M.(
LD
P)
#33
Env
ironm
ent:
Yam
azak
i,T.
(LD
P)
#34
Env
ironm
ent:
*Mor
iyam
a,M
.(L
DP
)#
35E
nviro
nmen
t:Is
him
atsu
,K.(
LD
P)
156 J. WOLDENDORP, H. KEMAN & I. BUDGE
JAP
AN
(con
tinue
d)
page
83#
1O
ther
:add
Hito
tsum
atsu
,S.(
PP
)#
4O
ther
:add
Iwam
otu,
N.(
LP
);In
ouye
,T.(
LP
)#
5O
ther
:del
ete
Kim
ura,
S.(
PP
);ad
dM
asud
a,K
.(LP
)#
8O
ther
:add
Kim
ura,
T(Y
L);
Ono
gi,H
.(Y
L);
Ono
,B.(
YL
);A
ndo,
M.(
YL
);F
ukun
aga,
K.(
YL
)#
9/10
Oth
er:a
ddM
iyos
hi,H
.(D
P)
#11
Oth
er:a
ddS
horik
i,M
.(LD
P);
Nem
oto,
R.(
LDP
)#
12O
ther
:add
Oku
bo,T
.(L
DP
);Is
hida
,H.(
LD
P);
Kaw
amur
a,M
.(L
DP
)#
13O
ther
:add
Aka
ji,M
.(LD
P)
#16
Oth
er:a
ddO
zaw
a,S
.(LD
P);
Iked
a,N
.(LD
P)
#17
Oth
er:a
ddK
urog
ana,
Y.(L
DP
);S
ato,
E.(
LD
P)
#18
Oth
er:a
ddM
asuh
ara,
K.(
LD
P);
Has
him
oto,
T.(L
DP
);K
ono,
I.(L
DP
)#
19O
ther
:add
Mat
suda
ira,I
.(L
DP
);N
ikai
do,S
.(L
DP
);Is
ukah
ara,
T.(L
DP
);F
ukun
aga,
K.(
LD
P)
#20
Oth
er:a
ddH
ori,
S.(
LDP
);N
ishi
da,S
.(LD
P);
Ara
ki,M
.(LD
P)
#21
Oth
er:a
ddF
ukud
a,H
.(L
DP
);M
iki,
T.(L
DP
);N
ikai
do,S
.(L
DP
);H
onna
,T.(
LD
P)
#22
Oth
er:a
ddE
saki
,M.(
LD
P);
Nik
aido
,S.(
LD
P);
Tsu
boka
-wa,
S.(
LD
P)
#23
Oth
er:a
ddF
ukud
a,H
.(L
DP
);Id
e,I.
(LD
P);
Uek
i,M
.(L
DP
);K
anem
aru,
S.(
LD
P)
#24
Oth
er:a
ddO
gana
,H.(
LDP
);S
onod
a,S
.(LD
P);
Fuj
ita,M
.(LD
P);
Taza
wa,
K.(
LDP
)#
25O
ther
:add
Shi
buya
,N.(
LDP
);Ta
naka
,R.(
LDP
);M
ihar
a,A
.(LD
P);
Nak
ano,
S.(
LDP
)#
26O
ther
:add
Ito,M
.(L
DP
);O
buch
i,K
.(L
DP
);S
onod
a,S
.(L
DP
)#
27O
ther
:add
Miy
azaw
a,K
.(LD
P);
Har
a,K
.(LD
P)
#28
Oth
er:a
ddG
otod
a,M
.(LD
P);
Kat
o,K
.(LD
P);
Sai
to,J
.(LD
P)
#29
Oth
er:a
ddF
ujin
ami,
T.(L
DP
);In
amur
a,S
.(L
DP
);N
akan
ishi
,I.(
LD
P);
Mog
ushi
,T.(
LD
P)
#30
Oth
er:a
ddF
ujin
ami,
T.(L
DP
);G
otod
a,M
.(L
DP
);K
awam
oto,
K.(
LD
P);
Kom
oto,
T.(L
DP
);M
ogus
hi,T
.(L
DP
)#
31O
ther
:add
Got
oda,
M.(
LD
P);
Tam
aki,
K.(
LD
P);
Wat
anuk
i,T.
(LD
P)
#32
Oth
er:a
ddO
buch
i,K
.(L
DP
);Ta
kato
ri,O
.(L
DP
);K
asuy
a,S
.(L
DP
);O
kuno
,S.(
LD
P)
#33
Oth
er:a
ddS
hiok
awa,
M.(
LD
P);
Iked
a,Y.
(LD
P);
Inon
e,K
.(L
DP
);N
onak
a,E
.(L
DP
)#
34O
ther
:add
Yam
ashi
ta,T
.(L
DP
);M
izun
o,K
.(L
DP
);A
be,F
.(L
DP
)#
35O
ther
:add
Sak
amot
o,?
(LD
P);
Fun
ada,
S.(
LD
P);
Sat
o,M
.(L
DP
)
POLITICAL DATA: AN UPDATE (1990–1995) 157
LUX
EM
BO
UR
G
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3P
y4C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
120
.11.
4528
.02.
4746
6x
3C
SP
25S
DP
11D
P9
CP
51
8D
upon
g,P
.(C
SP
)2
01.0
3.47
13.0
7.48
501
12
CS
P25
DP
91
7D
upon
g,P
.(C
SP
)3
14.0
7.48
02.0
7.51
1084
12
CS
P22
DP
91
7D
upon
g,P
.(C
SP
)4
03.0
7.51
28.1
2.53
910
32
CS
P21
SD
P18
36
Dup
ong,
P.(
CS
P)
529
.12.
5328
.06.
5418
21
2C
SP
21S
DP
183
6B
ech,
J.(C
SP
)6
29.0
6.54
28.0
3.58
1369
22
CS
P26
SD
P17
38
Bec
h,J.
(CS
P)
729
.03.
5824
.02.
5933
34
2C
SP
26S
DP
173
8F
riede
n,P
.(C
SP
)8
25.0
2.59
17.0
7.64
1970
12
CS
P21
DP
111
7W
erne
r,P
.(C
SP
)9
18.0
7.64
03.0
1.67
900
52
CS
P22
SD
P21
38
Wer
ner,
P.(
CS
P)
1004
.01.
6730
.01.
6975
84
2C
SP
22S
DP
213
8W
erne
r,P
.(C
SP
)11
31.0
1.69
14.0
6.74
1961
12
CS
P21
DP
111
7W
erne
r,P
.(C
SP
)12
15.0
6.74
14.0
7.79
1856
12
DP
14S
DP
173
8T
horn
,G.(
DP
)13
15.0
7.79
19.0
7.84
1832
12
CS
P24
DP
151
9W
erne
r,P
.(C
SP
)14
20.0
7.84
13.0
7.89
1818
12
CS
P25
SD
P21
39
San
ter,
J.(C
SP
)15
14.0
7.89
12.0
7.94
1823
12
CS
P22
SD
P18
310
San
ter,
J.(C
SP
)16
13.0
7.94
25.0
1.95
409
22
CS
P21
SD
P17
310
San
ter,
J.(C
SP
)17
26.0
1.95
2C
SP
21S
DP
173
10Ju
ncke
r,J.
C.(
CS
P)
Gov
1:R
easo
nfo
rTe
rmin
atio
nun
know
n.C
hange
s/co
rrect
ions
pp.8
4–86
:pa
ge85
#9/
10F
inan
ce:W
erne
rP
.(C
SP
),W
ehen
kel,
A.(
SD
P)
158 J. WOLDENDORP, H. KEMAN & I. BUDGE
NE
TH
ER
LAN
DS
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3P
y4P
y5C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
103
.07.
4606
.08.
4876
61
2K
VP
32P
vdA
293
13B
eel,
L.J
.M.(
KV
P)
207
.08.
4814
.03.
5195
05
3K
VP
32P
vdA
27V
VD
8C
HU
93
16D
rees
,W.(
Pvd
A)
315
.03.
5101
.09.
5253
71
3K
VP
32P
vdA
27V
VD
8C
HU
93
15D
rees
,W.(
Pvd
A
402
.0.9
5212
.10.
5615
021
3K
VP
30P
vdA
30A
RP
12C
HU
93
18D
rees
,W.(
Pvd
A)
513
.10.
5621
.12.
5880
05
3K
VP
49P
vdA
50A
RP
15C
HU
133
15D
rees
,W.(
Pvd
A)
622
.12.
5818
.05.
5914
81
6K
VP
49A
RP
15C
HU
131
10B
eel,
L.J
.M.(
KV
P)
719
.05.
5923
.07.
6315
271
3K
VP
49A
RP
14C
HU
12V
VD
191
13Q
uay,
J.E
.de
(KV
P)
824
.07.
6326
.04.
6564
34
3K
VP
50A
RP
13C
HU
13V
VD
161
13M
arijn
en,
V.G
.M.(
KV
P)
927
.04.
6521
.11.
6657
45
3K
VP
50P
vdA
43A
RP
133
14C
als,
J.M
.L.T
h.(K
VP
)
1022
.11.
6602
.04.
6713
21
6K
VP
50A
RP
131
13Z
ijlst
ra,J
.(A
RP
)
1103
.04.
6705
.07.
7115
551
2K
VP
42A
RP
15C
HU
12V
VD
171
14Jo
ng,P
.J.S
.de
(KV
P)
1206
.07.
7116
.08.
7240
84
2K
VP
35A
RP
13C
HU
10V
VD
16D
S70
81
16B
iesh
euve
l,B
.W.(
AR
P)
1317
.08.
7210
.05.
7326
71
6K
VP
35A
RP
13C
HU
10V
VD
161
14B
iesh
euve
l,B
.W.(
AR
P)
1411
.05.
7318
.12.
7716
834
3K
VP
27P
vdA
43A
RP
14D
666
PP
R7
316
Uyl
,J.M
.den
(Pvd
A)
1519
.12.
7710
.09.
8113
621
2C
DA
49V
VD
281
16A
gt,A
.A.M
.van
(CD
A)
1611
.09.
8128
.05.
8226
04
3C
DA
48P
vdA
44D
6617
315
Agt
,A.A
.M.v
an(C
DA
)
1729
.05.
8203
.11.
8215
91
6C
DA
48D
6617
214
Agt
,A.A
.M.v
an(C
DA
)
1804
.11.
8213
.07.
8613
481
2C
DA
45V
VD
361
14L
ubbe
rs,R
.F.M
.(C
DA
)
1914
.07.
8606
.11.
8912
125
2C
DA
54V
VD
271
14L
ubbe
rs,R
.F.M
.(C
DA
)
2007
.11.
8921
.08.
9417
491
2C
DA
54P
vdA
493
14L
ubbe
rs,R
.F.M
.(C
DA
)
2122
.08.
942
PV
DA
37V
VD
31D
6624
314
Kok
,W.(
Pvd
A)
The
1993
Edi
tion
cont
aine
don
ego
vern
men
t(#
17)
whi
chha
sbe
ende
lete
d.A
lthou
ghit
offe
red
itsre
sign
atio
n(0
3.11
.81)
,the
next
gove
rnm
entc
ompo
sitio
nw
asex
actly
the
sam
eas
the
prec
edin
gon
e(#
16).
Hen
ce,r
ow17
inp.
87–8
9sh
ould
bede
lete
d(w
ithou
tlos
sof
info
rmat
ion)
.C
hange
s/co
rrect
ions
pp.8
7–89
:pa
ge87
#1
For
eign
Aff:
Boe
tzel
aar
van
O.,
C.v
an(N
ON
A)
#4
For
eign
Aff:
Bei
jen,
J.W
.(N
ON
A)
#6
Just
ice:
Str
uijk
en,A
.A.M
.(K
VP
)#
9In
terio
r:S
mal
lenb
roek
,J.(
AR
P)
#In
terio
r:V
erda
m,P
.J.(
AR
P);
Just
ice:
Str
uijk
en,A
.A.M
.(K
VP
)pa
ge88
#5
Agr
icul
ture
:Man
shol
t,S
.L.(
Pvd
A)
POLITICAL DATA: AN UPDATE (1990–1995) 159N
EW
ZE
ALA
ND
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
120
.12.
4607
.12.
4910
841
1L
AB
425
13F
rase
r,P
.(L
AB
)2
08.1
2.49
18.0
9.51
650
11
NP
461
13H
olla
nd,S
.G.(
NP
)3
19.0
9.51
25.1
1.54
1164
11
NP
501
13H
olla
nd,S
.G.(
NP
)4
26.1
1.54
25.0
9.57
1035
21
NP
451
16H
olla
nd,S
.G.(
NP
)5
26.0
9.57
11.1
2.57
771
1N
P45
215
Hol
yoak
e,K
.J.(
NP
)6
12.1
2.57
11.1
2.60
1096
11
LA
B41
516
Nas
h,W
.(L
AB
)7
12.1
2.60
19.1
2.63
1103
11
NP
461
16H
olyo
ake,
K.J
.(N
P)
820
.12.
6311
.12.
6610
881
1N
P45
116
Hol
yoak
e,K
.J.(
NP
)9
12.1
2.66
21.1
2.69
1106
11
NP
441
16H
olyo
ake,
K.J
.(N
P)
1022
.12.
6908
.02.
7277
92
1N
P45
117
Hol
yoak
e,K
.J.(
NP
)11
09.0
2.72
07.1
2.72
303
11
NP
452
18M
arsh
all,
J.R
.(N
P)
1208
.12.
7209
.09.
7464
13
1L
AB
555
20K
irk,N
.(L
AB
)13
10.0
9.74
11.1
2.75
458
11
LA
B55
420
Row
ling,
W.E
.(L
AB
)14
12.1
2.75
12.1
2.78
1097
11
NP
551
19M
uldo
on,
R.D
.(N
P)
1513
.12.
7810
.12.
8110
941
1N
P50
117
Mul
doon
,R
.D.(
NP
)16
11.1
2.81
25.0
7.84
958
11
NP
471
19M
uldo
on,
R.D
.(N
P)
1726
.07.
8418
.08.
8711
191
1L
AB
565
20L
ange
,D.(
LA
B)
1819
.08.
8710
.08.
8972
32
1L
AB
585
19L
ange
,D.(
LA
B)
1911
.08.
8913
.07.
8612
115
1L
AB
585
19P
alm
er,G
.(L
AB
)20
14.0
7.86
04.0
9.90
390
21
LA
B58
519
Pal
mer
,G.(
LA
B)
2105
.09.
9001
.11.
9057
11
LA
B58
519
Moo
re,M
.(L
AB
)22
02.1
1.90
27.1
1.93
1102
11
NP
681
20B
olge
r,J.
B.(
NP
)23
28.1
1.93
29.0
6.95
478
11
NP
501
20B
olge
r,J.
B.(
NP
)24
30.0
6.95
27.0
2.96
238
x2
NP
49R
OC
11
23B
olge
r,J.
B.(
NP
)25
28.0
2.96
12.1
0.96
226
12
NP
43[U
P7]
123
Bol
ger,
J.B
.(N
P)
Gov
24:R
OC
isbr
eaka
way
fact
ion
ofN
P;R
easo
nfo
rTe
rmin
atio
nis
broa
deni
ngof
the
coal
ition
Gov
25:U
Pis
afo
rmat
ion
offo
rmer
MP
’sof
Lab
our
and
NP
whi
chsu
ppor
ted
the
gove
rnm
ent.
Change
s/co
rrect
ions
pp.9
0–93
:pa
ge92
#14
Indu
stry
/Tra
de:T
albo
ys,B
.E.(
NP
)
160 J. WOLDENDORP, H. KEMAN & I. BUDGEN
OR
WA
Y
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3P
y4C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
101
.11.
4509
.10.
4914
391
1A
P76
514
Ger
hard
sen,
E.(
AP
)
210
.10.
4915
.11.
5176
63
1A
P85
514
Ger
hard
sen,
E.(
AP
)
316
.11.
5111
.10.
5369
51
1A
P85
513
Torp
,O.(
AP
)
412
.10.
5320
.01.
5546
62
1A
P77
513
Torp
,O.(
AP
)
521
.01.
5506
.10.
5799
01
1A
P77
513
Ger
hard
sen,
E.(
AP
)
607
.10.
5710
.09.
6114
351
1A
P78
515
Ger
hard
sen,
E.(
AP
)
711
.09.
6126
.08.
6371
55
4A
P74
515
Ger
hard
sen,
E.(
AP
)
827
.08.
6323
.09.
6328
55
CP
16C
PP
15C
ON
29L
IB14
115
Lyng
,J.(
CO
N)
924
.09.
6310
.10.
6575
01
4A
P74
515
Ger
hard
sen,
E.(
AP
)
1011
.10.
6506
.09.
6914
261
2C
P18
CP
P13
CO
N31
LIB
181
15B
orte
n,P
.(C
P)
1107
.09.
6912
.03.
7155
24
2C
P20
CP
P14
CO
N29
LIB
131
15B
orte
n,P
.(C
P)
1213
.03.
7117
.10.
7258
52
4A
P74
415
Bra
ttelli
,T.
(AP
)
1318
.10.
7215
.10.
7336
31
5C
P20
CP
P14
LIB
132
15K
orva
ld,L
.(C
PP
)
1416
.10.
7311
.01.
7681
82
4A
P62
515
Bra
ttelli
,T.
(AP
)
1512
.01.
7611
.09.
7760
91
4A
P62
516
Nor
dli,
0.(A
P)
1612
.09.
7703
.02.
8112
413
4A
P76
516
Nor
dli,
0.(A
P)
1704
.02.
8113
.10.
8125
21
4A
P76
417
*Har
lem
Bru
ndtla
ndG
.(A
P)
1814
.10.
8107
.06.
8360
22
4C
ON
541
18W
illoc
h,K
.(C
ON
)
1908
.06.
8325
.11.
8590
21
2C
P11
CP
P15
CO
N54
118
Will
och,
K.(
CO
N)
2026
.11.
8508
.05.
8616
41
5C
P12
CP
P16
CO
N50
118
Will
och,
K.(
CO
N)
2109
.05.
8615
.10.
8912
561
4A
P71
518
*Har
lem
Bru
ndtla
ndG
.(A
P)
2216
.10.
8902
.11.
9038
35
5C
P11
CP
P14
CO
N37
118
Sys
e,J.
(CO
N)
2303
.11.
9014
.09.
9310
371
4A
P63
519
*Har
lem
Bru
ndtla
ndG
.(A
P)
2407
.10.
934
AP
675
18*H
arle
mB
rund
tland
,G
.(A
P)
Change
s/co
rrect
ions
pp.9
4–97
:pa
ge95
#19
/20
Edu
catio
n:B
onde
vik,
K.M
.(C
PP
)pa
ge97
#22
Soc
ialA
ff:*S
olli,
S.(
CP
P)
POLITICAL DATA: AN UPDATE (1990–1995) 161S
WE
DE
N
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3P
y4C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
111
.10.
4627
.10.
4874
81
1S
DA
115
516
Erla
nder
,T.(
SD
A)
228
.10.
4829
.09.
5110
67x
4S
DA
112
519
Erla
nder
,T.(
SD
A)
330
.09.
5120
.09.
5235
71
2S
DA
112
BF
/CP
304
16E
rland
er,T
.(S
DA
)4
21.0
9.52
25.0
9.56
1466
12
SD
A11
0B
F/C
P26
416
Erla
nder
,T.(
SD
A)
526
.09.
5629
.10.
5739
94
2S
DA
106
BF
/CP
194
17E
rland
er,T
.(S
DA
)6
30.1
0.57
01.0
6.58
215
14
SD
A10
65
15E
rland
er,T
.(S
DA
)7
02.0
6.58
30.0
9.60
852
14
SD
A11
15
15E
rland
er,T
.(S
DA
)8
01.1
0.60
03.1
0.64
1464
14
SD
A11
45
14E
rland
er,T
.(S
DA
)9
04.1
0.64
28.0
9.68
1456
14
SD
A11
35
16E
rland
er,T
.(S
DA
)10
29.0
9.68
14.1
0.69
381
21
SD
A12
55
17E
rland
er,T
.(S
DA
)11
15.1
0.69
28.0
9.70
349
11
SD
A12
55
19P
alm
e,O
.(S
DA
)12
29.0
9.70
30.1
0.73
1128
14
SD
A16
35
19P
alm
e,O
.(S
DA
)13
31.1
0.73
06.1
0.76
1072
14
SD
A15
65
18P
alm
e,O
.(S
DA
)14
04.1
0.76
05.1
0.78
732
42
CP
86F
P39
MU
P55
120
Fal
ldin
,T.(
CP
)15
13.1
0.78
11.1
0.79
364
14
FP
391
19U
llste
n,0.
(FP
)16
12.1
0.79
21.0
5.81
588
42
CP
64F
P38
MU
P73
121
Fal
ldin
,T.(
CP
)17
22.0
5.81
07.1
0.82
504
15
FP
38C
P64
118
Fal
ldin
,T.(
CP
)18
08.1
0.82
03.1
0.85
1091
14
SD
A16
65
20P
alm
e,O
.(S
DA
)19
04.1
0.85
28.0
2.86
148
x4
SD
A15
95
21P
alm
e,O
.(S
DA
)20
01.0
3.86
03.1
0.88
947
14
SD
A15
95
20C
arls
son,
I.(S
DA
)21
04.1
0.88
26.0
2.90
511
54
SD
A15
65
21C
arls
son,
I.(S
DA
)22
27.0
2.90
02.1
0.91
583
14
SD
A15
65
22C
arls
son,
I.(S
DA
)23
03.1
0.91
05.1
0.94
1099
15
MU
P80
FP
26K
DS
26C
P31
121
Bild
t,C
.(M
UP
)24
06.1
0.94
4S
DA
161
522
Car
lsso
n,I.
(SD
A)
Gov
2:R
easo
nfo
rTe
rmin
atio
nis
broa
deni
ngof
coal
ition
,Agr
aria
npa
rty
(late
rC
P)
join
edgo
vern
men
t.G
ov19
:Rea
son
for
Term
inat
ion
isas
sass
inat
ion
ofP
MP
alm
e.
162 J. WOLDENDORP, H. KEMAN & I. BUDGE
SW
ITZ
ER
LAN
D
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3P
y4C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
114
.12.
4412
.12.
4536
41
3S
VP
22F
DP
47C
VP
43S
P55
27
Ste
iger
,E.v
on(S
VP
)2
13.1
2.45
11.1
2.46
364
13
SV
P22
FD
P47
CV
P43
SP
552
7K
obel
t,K
.(F
DP
)3
12.1
2.46
10.1
2.47
364
13
SV
P22
FD
P47
CV
P43
SP
552
7E
tter,
P.(
CV
P)
411
.12.
4715
.12.
4837
11
3S
VP
21F
DP
52C
VP
44S
P48
27
Cel
io,E
.(C
VP
)5
16.1
2.48
14.1
2.49
364
13
SV
P21
FD
P52
CV
P44
SP
482
7N
obs,
E.(
SP
)6
15.1
2.49
13.1
2.50
364
13
SV
P21
FD
P52
CV
P44
SP
482
7P
etitp
ierr
e,M
.(F
DP
)7
14.1
2.50
12.1
2.51
364
13
SV
P21
FD
P52
CV
P44
SP
482
7S
teig
er,E
.von
(SV
P)
813
.12.
5110
.12.
5236
41
3S
VP
23F
DP
51C
VP
48S
P49
27
Kob
elt,
K.(
FD
P)
911
.12.
5221
.12.
5337
61
3S
VP
23F
DP
51C
VP
48S
P49
27
Ette
r,P
.(C
VP
)10
22.1
2.53
15.1
2.54
359
12
SV
P23
FD
P51
CV
P48
17
Rub
atte
l,R
.(F
DP
)11
16.1
2.54
14.1
2.55
364
12
SV
P23
FD
P51
CV
P48
17
Pet
itpie
rre,
M.(
FD
P)
1215
.12.
5512
.12.
5636
41
2S
VP
22F
DP
50C
VP
471
7F
eldm
ann,
M.(
SV
P)
1313
.12.
5611
.12.
5736
41
2S
VP
22F
DP
50C
VP
471
7S
treu
li,H
.(F
DP
)14
12.1
2.57
10.1
2.58
364
12
SV
P22
FD
P50
CV
P47
17
Hol
enst
ein,
T.(C
VP
)15
11.1
2.58
16.1
2.59
370
12
SV
P22
FD
P50
CV
P47
17
Cha
udet
,P.(
FD
P)
1617
.12.
5914
.12.
6036
41
3S
VP
23F
DP
51C
VP
47S
P51
27
Pet
itpie
rre,
M.(
FD
P)
1715
.12.
6013
.12.
6136
41
3S
VP
23F
DP
51C
VP
47S
P51
27
Wah
len,
F.(S
VP
)18
14.1
2.61
12.1
2.62
364
13
SV
P23
FD
P51
CV
P47
SP
512
7C
haud
et,P
.(F
DP
)19
13.1
2.62
11.1
2.63
364
13
SV
P23
FD
P51
CV
P47
SP
512
7S
puh
ler,
W.(
SP
)20
12.1
2.63
09.1
2.64
364
13
SV
P22
FD
P51
CV
P48
SP
532
7M
oos,
L.v
on(C
VP
)21
10.1
2.64
07.1
2.65
363
13
SV
P22
FD
P51
CV
P48
SP
532
7T
schu
di,H
.-P
.(S
P)
2208
.12.
6513
.12.
6637
11
3S
VP
22F
DP
51C
VP
48S
P53
27
Sch
affn
er,H
.(F
DP
)23
14.1
2.66
29.1
2.67
381
13
SV
P22
FD
P51
CV
P48
SP
532
7B
onvi
n,R
.(C
VP
)24
30.1
2.67
30.1
2.68
367
13
SV
P21
FD
P49
CV
P45
SP
512
7S
puh
ler,
W.(
SP
)25
31.1
2.68
01.0
2.70
398
13
SV
P21
FD
P49
CV
P45
SP
512
7M
oos,
L.v
on(C
VP
)26
02.0
2.70
08.1
2.70
310
13
SV
P21
FD
P49
CV
P45
SP
512
7T
schu
di,H
.-P
.(S
P)
POLITICAL DATA: AN UPDATE (1990–1995) 163S
WIT
ZE
RLA
ND
(con
tinue
d)
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1P
y2P
y3P
y4C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
2709
.12.
7007
.12.
7136
41
3S
VP
21F
DP
49C
VP
45S
P51
27
Gn
agi,
R.(
SV
P)
2808
.12.
7105
.12.
7236
41
3S
VP
21F
DP
49C
VP
44S
P46
27
Cel
io,N
.(F
DP
)29
06.1
2.72
20.1
2.73
380
13
SV
P21
FD
P49
CV
P44
SP
462
7B
onvi
n,R
.(C
VP
)30
21.1
2.73
03.1
2.74
348
13
SV
P21
FD
P49
CV
P44
SP
462
7B
rugg
er,E
.(F
DP
)31
04.1
2.74
09.1
2.75
371
13
SV
P21
FD
P49
CV
P44
SP
462
7G
rabe
r,P
.(S
P)
3210
.12.
7530
.12.
7638
71
3S
VP
21F
DP
47C
VP
46S
P55
27
Gn
agi,
R.(
SV
P)
3331
.12.
6706
.12.
7734
11
3S
VP
21F
DP
47C
VP
46S
P55
27
Fur
gler
,K.(
CV
P)
3407
.12.
7730
.12.
7838
91
3S
VP
21F
DP
47C
VP
46S
P55
27
Rits
char
d,W
.(S
P)
3531
.12.
7826
.12.
7936
11
3S
VP
23F
DP
51C
VP
44S
P51
27
Hur
liman
n,H
.(C
VP
)36
27.1
2.79
30.1
2.80
370
13
SV
P23
FD
P51
CV
P44
SP
512
7C
heva
llaz,
G.-
A.(
FD
P)
3731
.12.
8030
.12.
8136
51
3S
VP
23F
DP
51C
VP
44S
P51
27
Fur
gler
,K.(
CV
P)
3831
.12.
8120
.12.
8235
51
3S
VP
23F
DP
51C
VP
44S
P51
27
Hon
egge
r,F.
(FD
P)
3921
.12.
8218
.12.
8336
31
3S
VP
23F
DP
51C
VP
44S
P51
27
Aub
ert,
P.(
SP
)40
19.1
2.83
04.1
2.84
352
13
SV
P23
FD
P54
CV
P42
SP
472
7S
chlu
mpf
,L.(
SV
P)
4105
.12.
8410
.12.
8537
11
3S
VP
23F
DP
54C
VP
42S
P47
27
Fur
gler
,K.(
CV
P)
4211
.12.
8509
.12.
8636
41
3S
VP
23F
DP
54C
VP
42S
P47
27
Egl
i,A
.(C
VP
)43
10.1
2.86
08.1
2.87
364
13
SV
P23
FD
P54
CV
P42
SP
472
7A
uber
t,P
.(S
P)
4409
.12.
8706
.12.
8836
41
3S
VP
25F
DP
51C
VP
42S
P41
27
Stic
h,O
.(S
P)
4507
.12.
8805
.12.
8936
41
3S
VP
25F
DP
51C
VP
42S
P41
27
Del
amur
az,J
.-P
.(F
DP
)46
06.1
2.89
30.1
2.90
390
13
SV
P25
FD
P51
CV
P42
SP
412
7K
olle
r,A
.(C
VP
)47
31.1
2.90
03.1
2.91
338
13
SV
P25
FD
P51
CV
P42
SP
412
7C
otti,
F.(C
VP
)48
04.1
2.91
08.1
2.92
370
13
SV
P25
FD
P44
CV
P36
SP
422
7F
elbe
r,R
.(S
P)
4909
.12.
9207
.12.
9336
31
3S
VP
25F
DP
44C
VP
36S
P42
27
Ogi
,A.(
SP
)50
08.1
2.93
06.1
2.94
363
13
SV
P25
FD
P44
CV
P36
SP
422
7S
tich,
O.(
SP
)51
07.1
2.94
12.1
2.95
370
13
SV
P25
FD
P44
CV
P36
SP
422
7V
illig
er,K
.(F
DP
)52
13.1
2.95
3S
VP
29F
DP
45C
VP
34S
P54
27
Del
amur
az,J
.-P
.(F
DP
)
No
min
iste
rs/m
inis
trie
sfo
rL
abou
r,E
duca
tion,
Hea
lth,
Hou
sing
,A
gric
ultu
re,
Indu
stry
/Tra
de,
Env
ironm
ent,
and
Soc
ial
Affa
irs.
164 J. WOLDENDORP, H. KEMAN & I. BUDGE
UN
ITE
DK
ING
DO
M
Gov
Beg
inE
ndD
urR
fTTo
GP
y1C
PG
NoM
Prim
eM
inis
ter
(py)
126
.07.
4527
.02.
5016
781
1L
AB
392
533
Atle
e,C
.R.(
LA
B)
228
.02.
5025
.10.
5160
51
1L
AB
315
518
Atle
e,C
.R.(
LA
B)
326
.10.
5105
.04.
5512
582
1C
ON
321
116
Chu
rchi
ll,W
.(C
ON
)4
06.0
4.55
26.0
5.55
511
1C
ON
345
117
Ede
n,A
.(C
ON
)5
27.0
5.55
09.0
1.57
594
31
CO
N34
51
17E
den,
A.(
CO
N)
610
.01.
5714
.10.
5910
081
1C
ON
365
118
Mac
Mill
an,H
.(C
ON
)7
15.1
0.59
18.1
0.63
1465
31
CO
N36
51
19M
acM
illan
,H.(
CO
N)
819
.10.
6316
.10.
6436
41
1C
ON
365
123
Dou
glas
-Hom
e,A
.(C
ON
)9
17.1
0.64
05.0
4.66
536
11
LA
B31
75
23W
ilson
,H.(
LA
B)
1006
.04.
6619
.06.
7015
361
1L
AB
363
523
Wils
on,H
.(L
AB
)11
20.0
6.70
04.0
3.74
1354
11
CO
N33
01
18H
eath
,E.(
CO
N)
1205
.03.
7417
.10.
7422
71
4L
AB
301
520
Wils
on,H
.(L
AB
)13
18.1
0.74
05.0
4.76
536
21
LA
B31
95
23W
ilson
,H.(
LA
B)
1406
.04.
7604
.05.
7911
241
1L
AB
319
516
Cal
lagh
an,J
.(L
AB
)15
05.0
5.79
11.0
6.83
1499
11
CO
N33
91
22*T
hatc
her,
M.(
CO
N)
1612
.06.
8312
.06.
8714
621
1C
ON
397
121
*Tha
tche
r,M
.(C
ON
)17
13.0
6.87
27.1
1.90
1264
21
CO
N36
71
21*T
hatc
her,
M.(
CO
N)
1828
.11.
9010
.04.
9250
01
1C
ON
376
122
Maj
or,J
.(C
ON
)19
11.0
4.92
1C
ON
336
123
Maj
or,J
.(C
ON
)