What is the Rule of Law BY LEON LOUW ما هو حكم القانون؟ ليون لاو

7/30/2019 What is the Rule of Law BY LEON LOUW

1/77


2/77

www.minbaralhurriyya.org

All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by

any means without the prior permission of Minbaralhurriyya Team.


3/77

www.arab-csr.org

All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by

any means without the prior permission of Arab Center for Scientific Research

and Humane Studies Team.


4/77

1/74

What is the Rule of Law

Leon Louw

26-282007

:


5/77

2/74

)(

.

.

.

" ."

1.1.

:

.

.

"

."


6/77

3/74

)(

. )(

.

) (

"" ) (

"" ""

.1

)18-252005(

" :

."2

)(

1 )1.(

) (

]).[1(2

.


7/77

4/74

)(3

.

)(

""

.

" "

""""""""""

"" )(

.

"" )(

"" "" ""

"""."

") " (

" "

)

( .4

3 2005].[4 )..

: 2.( ) ..

: 3.(


8/77

5/74

""

" " """"

. ) (

.

)( :

:

.

.

""

)( )(.

:

.


9/77

6/74

.5

)(

)(

((

. :

)( ).(

1.2. )" :("

" "

""

""

" "

" "

.

5 )(

.


10/77

7/74

) (

.

" "

.

"" ""

" "

6

)(

. )(

.

7 8 .

6

.7: :)4.(

.8 " "

.


11/77

8/74

"""."

)(

)(

.

.

. " "

.

)

""""(

) ( )

( .

:


12/77

9/74

""

.

.

.

:

:)(

.

: :

.

.

)(


13/77

10/74

.

) (

)(

.

)(

)

.( )( )(

.

.

)(

.


14/77

11/74

)() (9

.

.

" "

.

") " (10

.

9:) .( :

.. : )5.(

: )6.(

: )7.(

: )8.(10 :..

)9.(


15/77

12/74

)(

)(

.

.

3.1.

"" .

)(

)(

""""

"

"11 ""

)( .

"" )(

"").(

)( :

* .

* .

: 11 .

)1767-1832].([


16/77

13/74

* .

""

)(

""

"" .

""

( (

)(

)

( "" .

" "

( ( ).(12

"

"13

) )

12 )

( " "

"."13

" : " : )10.(


17/77

14/74

.: 14

:)(

(.(

.

.

):

14

:)11(33-38.


18/77

15/74

(

" :

."15

" :

."16

.

" "

" "

:

15 .3716

.


19/77

16/74

1. .17

2. .3. .

4. .

5. .

6. .7. .

8. .

"" )()(

.

.2.3

""

.18

17

.18

:

: )12.(

: )13.(


20/77

17/74

.

"" .19 )

(20

.

) (21

.

) (

:)14.(

.. :)15(.

:)16.(

: )17.(

:)18.(

( (

) ( .19 .1977)413(20 .21

)103(1991.


21/77

18/74

""

.

)Alec Irwin(

.

.

.

"" .

)(


22/77

19/74

.

22

. :

.

.

.

" "

.

.

22

)1993.(


23/77

20/74

" "

)(

.

.

)(

) (

).( :

)( :

) *( .

* .

* .

.


24/77

21/74

.

4.1. )

.(23

)(

:

. .

)

(

.

) (

:

1..

2..

3..

23: 51999

)19.(


25/77

22/74

)(

)()(:

"" :

)(

)(

.

""

.

)(

) () () .()(

. ) (

) (

.


26/77

23/74

.24""

) (25

.

)(

. )(

)RICO(26

)POCA(27

)(

""

"" . )(

) .(28 29

24 :

)20.(25 )1996" :(

."

).(26 ).)21 27 )22.(28 )4.4.(.29 )( ( (

.


27/77

24/74

" "

)in rem(:) .(

""

"

"

.

)( )( )(

)( )()(

.30

)(

30

)( .

) (

" "

.


28/77

25/74

)(

.

) 1885(

)( " :

."31

4.2.

.32

)

( " 33"

][)(

][ ) ( ]) [(

][ ][) (

]) [ ( ][

][) (

31: 198 )23.(32 :

.33 " "

).(


29/77

26/74

]) [( ]) [] ([

)(. )

(

:

:

.

.

.

.

) (

.

: ") " .(

" " )(


30/77

27/74

)().(

)

() ( )

(34 :

)) "

"

.)

( 1997"

" ) ... .(

((.

(( ).( " "

) ()(

""

34

)24.(


31/77

28/74

)( )

" ("

.

"" .

"35".

4.3.)(

:

])) [

[...] .

[...] [...]

:

[...]

[...]

35

.


32/77

29/74

[...]

] ]

.

.

((.

)1899-1992( ):(

))

) (

.))

)(

) .( )1712-1777(

:

)) !

!


33/77

30/74

) (((.

"

."

)36)).(

""

:

:

)) [...]

[...]

)).37 [...]

) (

)( )Reichtsstaat.(38

)(

36 1850 1998)25.(37 .5-438

: 59-76)26.(


34/77

31/74

.

:

. )

(" "" "

.

.

)1689-1755(

.

)1632-1704.(

)(

.

)427-348.(

.

)384-322.( :

)) [...]


35/77

32/74

.

((.

) (

" "

.

)1904" :(

".

.

...:

5.1.

)(

.

:

.1

)(


36/77

33/74

.

2.

) (

:

.

) ( :

.) (

.

" :

"

.

5.2.:

5.2.1.

)

( :

()((

: )(

.


37/77

34/74

""

.

" "

)(

)Sturgess()1928" :( )("

.

.

:

.

.


38/77

35/74

.

.

:

.

.

. )(

.

)(

:

)

.( )Milton Friedman(

""


39/77

36/74

. )

(

.

.

.

:

)(

.

)(


40/77

37/74

.

)Kate ORegan(" : ] ]

."

" ".

.

) (

)(

. ""

)( )(

.

5.2.2.

.39 ""

.

39 . :

)CPI( )27.(


41/77

38/74

""

.

"

."

40

)(

.

" "

" " .

:

. )Yurii

Lutsenko( )

(41 "

40: :)28.(41

)29.(


42/77

39/74

"

)(

.

:

.

.

:

=

.

)David Bruce(

IACC( (

42

" "

42

)30.(


43/77

40/74

"

)Marketization(

."

" " "

)

."( "

)."(

) (

) )

. .

)Encarta(

" "

"

."


44/77

41/74

)Penuel Maduna(

)1999(

"

43".

).(

.

)( .

)(

)Michael Walker(

)( .

.44

43)31.(44

)32.(


45/77

42/74

.45

.)(

6.1.

)( )

(

.

.

) .(

) )

. ):(

1. ) .(

45

.


46/77

43/74

2. .

3. .

46

" ."

) ( .

)(

:

)(

)(.47

.

46: 187 )33.(47

)( .


47/77

44/74

:

.1 )/(

.

2.

.

3. .

6.2.

"

" :

"" " "

.

" "48

" "

.

48 : 2)34.(

: .


48/77

45/74

"

"

.

"

""

49 ".

" ] [

:

.

."50

.)(

: .

) (

.4950

: .


49/77

46/74

.

) ()(

)(51

) (

)88.2(%

)46.1) (% 1.(

)226.7(%

)120(% )2.(52

51 :

.52 2004)35( . 2(A(

..2006)36( .


50/77

47/74

)89/208(

."

" :215/68(()

)51/217() ) ( )66/210(

) ( )62/211() .(53

6.3.

)(

:

6.3.1.

.

6.3.2.

. ) (

:""

"" .

)(

.

53

)1996-2005:( )37.(


51/77

48/74

6.3.3.

)(

.

6.3.4.

:

.

.6.3.5

:

:

.

6.3.6.

.


52/77

49/74

.

.

6.3.7.

.

.

6.3.8. )

(

.

6.3.9.

)(

:

.

""


53/77

50/74

( ()

( "

."54

).(

6.3.10

) (

"

" )

( :

. )

( . )

(

:

1. : )) .

2. .

3. .

54

)38.(


54/77

51/74

4. .

5. .6.

.

7. )

.(

8. .

9. .

10.

.

6.3.11.

.

.

6.3.12.


55/77

52/74

.

.

6.3.13.

.

6.3.14. ( (

.

6.3.15. )

(

.... " : :

."

6.3.16. )Habeas corpus( )

(

)

( .


56/77

53/74

.6.3.17

.

:

1..

2.) ).

3. .

4. .

.5 ). (

).) .6

.

)(

) (.

)

(

.


57/77

54/74

)(

.

.

8.1) .1( )(

)2A(

)2B(

)2C(

)2D(

) (

)2E(

8.77.07.96.68.37.5

8.57.38.18.48.38.3

8.27.57.49.06.98.3

8.28.48.37.810.010.0

8.28.48.28.510.08.3

8.18.47.77.710.010.0

8.18.37.88.510.09.7


58/77

55/74

8.07.66.97.510.010.0

7.98.38.17.010.010.0

7.98.18.37.910.010.0

7.88.47.67.810.010.0

7.78.07.87.610.010.0

7.78.18.18.010.010.0

7.75.35.25.58.36.7

7.76.25.95.58.36.7

7.78.48.28.210.010.0

7.68.88.28.810.08.3

7.68.78.98.210.010.0

7.57.26.47.28.58.3

7.47.75.16.710.08.3

7.97.87.67.79.49.1

6.76.57.46.78.34.2


59/77

56/74

(%)84.883.397.487.088.346.1

)2A-D(88.246.1


60/77

57/74

8.2) .2( )(

)2A(

)2B(

)2C(

)2D(

) (

)2E(

5.42.32.43.05.03.3

5.4-4.9-3.38.3

5.42.13.22.68.36.7

5.42.52.62.93.35.0

5.4-4.7-3.35.0

5.35.54.22.46.75.0

5.33.9-5.03.3

5.21.52.01.64.74.0

5.2-4.1-1.7-

5.0-3.8-1.75.0

4.8-4.0-0.00.0

4.8-3.0-4.74.0


61/77

58/74

4.7-2.9-0.9-

4.63.04.12.42.24.0

4.6-3.32.63.9

4.40.51.12.30.84.2

4.1-2.5-0.01.7

4.1-3.5-0.03.3

3.3-2.7-0.05.0

2.81.82.64.05.02.2

4.71.83.34,02.93.5

6.76.57.46.78.34.2

(%)142.6362.1224.2167.5237.1120.0

-2A(

D(226.7120.0


62/77

59/74

8.3. ):(

)()

(

)( )(

.

)(

1. )(

-)(

)(

2. :

-)(

3.

4.

5. )

(

---


63/77

60/74

.

-)(

. -)(

. -)(

. -)(

.

)(

.

.

.

.

-)(

6. -

)(


64/77

61/74

) (7

8

7.

-)(

8.

36

-)(

9. :

-)(

10.

:

. -)(

.

-)(

.

-)(

.

-)(

11.


65/77

62/74

:

. -)(

. -)(

.

-)(

.

-)(

12. :

13.. --

.

-)(

.

-)(

.

-)(

.

-)(


66/77

63/74

8.4. ) :

(55

.

.

.

)()(

.

1.

2.

.3

4. )(5.

55

.


67/77

64/74

6.

.

.

.

. ):(

.

.

7.

.

.

.


68/77

65/74

.8

.

.)(

.

.)(

.

.)(

.

9.

.

.)(


69/77

66/74

. .)(

.

.)(

.

10.

.11

12. ) (

13.

) (

14.


70/77

67/74

15.

.

.

. ) )

16.

)

)

17.

18.

.19

20.

.


71/77

68/74

.

.5.8

:

.7

7.3.

.

7.4.).(

7.5. ).(

7.6. :

7.6.1. .

7.6.2.) .(

7.6.3.) .(

8. ) (

:

8.3..


72/77

69/74

8.4..

8.5.) .(8.6..

8.7. .

8.8.) .(

8.9.) ).8.10..

. .8.11

.8.12 .

8.13. .

8.14. .

8.15. .

8.16. .

8.17. ) .(

8.18.) ).

8.19..

..8.20

8.21. .


73/77

70/74

8.22..

8.23.) (.8.24..

8.25..

8.26. .

8.27. ). /(8.28..


74/77

71/74

1.www.un.org/webcast/crime2005/statements/23iran_eng.pdf2. Olufemi Taiwo, Legal Naturalism: Marxist Theory of Law, Cornell

University Press, 1995.

3. Robert Fine, Democracy and the Rule of Law, Marxs Critique ofLegal Form, Blackburn Press, 2002.

4. Leon Louw, Habits of Highly Effective Countries, Law Review Project,Johannesburg, 2006.

5. Akbar Ali Kha, Rule of Law and Property Rights: How Do they AffectDevelopment in Bangladesh?

(www.sdnpbd.org/sdi/issues/governance/governance/ruleof_lawan

d_property_rights.pdf).

6. World Bank, Legal Reform, Property Rights and the Rule of Law(http://rru.worldbank.org/PapersLinks/Reducing-Business-Risks/).

7.

the measurement ofinstitutional quality as attempts to measureproperty rights andgovernance

(http://pgpblog.worldbank.org/archive/2006/11/term/259).

8. Chris Pounds, Property Rights and the Rule of Law,(www.fte.org/capitalism/lessons/02/).


75/77

72/74

9. Richard Epstein, Takings: Private Property and the Power of EminentDomain, Harvard, 1985.

10.Anatomy of the Law (1968) reprinted in Kenneth I Winston ed., ThePrinciples of Social Order, Selected Essays of Lon L Fuller, Duke

University Press, Durham, 1981.

11.Lon L. Fuller Morality of Lawpp. 33-38, revised ed., New Haven, YaleUniversity Press, 1969.

12.Harold Faber, The Book of Laws, Sphere, London, 1979.13.Sheryl Lindsell-Roberts, Funny Laws & Other Zany Stuff, Sterling,

1999.

14.Paul Dickson, The Official Rules, Addison-Wesley, 1990.15.Paul Dickson, New Official Rules: Maxims for Muddling through to

the Twenty-First Century, Portland, 1989.

16.Paul Dickson, The Official Rules for Lawyers, Politicians andEveryone They Torment, Walker & Co, 1996.

17.Kathi Linz, Chickens May Not Cross the Road: and Other Crazy ButTrue Laws, Houghton Mifflin, 2002.

18.Dick Hyman, The Trenton Pickle Ordinance and Other BoneheadLegislation, Penguin, 1984.

19.Nelson Mandela, Annual Open Society Lecture, delivered at theUniversity of the Western Cape, 5 October 1999.


76/77

73/74

20.Shadrack Gutto, The Challenges Facing the South African JusticeSystem vis--vis Some Constitutional Imperatives, Centre for Applied

Legal Studies, Faculty of Law, Wits University, 10 October 2000,

http://www.doj.gov.za/2004dojsite/cfw/colloquium/keynote3.htm.

21.Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act, enacted bysection 901(a) of the Organized Crime Control Act of 1970, Pub. L.

No. 91-452, 84 Stat. 922 (15 October 1970), codified as Chapter 96

of Title 18 of the United States Code, 18 USC. 1961 through 18 USC

1968.22.Prevention of Organised Crime Act, No. 121, 1998.23.A. V. Dicey, The Law of the Constitution(8th ed.), p. 198 et seq.24.World Bank Urges Greater State Role, African Recovery,

www.un.org/ecosocdev/geninfo/afrec/vol11no1/wbank.htm.

25.Friedrich Bastia, The Law, Foundation for Economic Education, NewYork, 1998.

26.Bruno Leoni, Freedom and the Law, William Volker Fund, LosAngeles,1961, IHS 1972 ed, pp59-76, republished in an expanded

3rd edition by Liberty Fund, Indianapolis, 1991.

27.Transparency International, Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI), andGlobal Corruption Reports,

http://www.transparency.org/publications/gcr.

28.Leon Louw, Habits of Highly Effective Countries.29.Yurii Lutsenko, Rule of Law and Fighting Corruption, Carnegie

Endowment for International Peace.

http://www.carnegieendowment.org/events/index.cfm?fa=eventDe

tail&id=852&&prog=zru.

30.http://www.csvr.org.za/articles/artperu.htm


77/77

31.http://www.info.gov.za/speeches/1999/9910221112a1007.htm32.http://unpan1.un.org/intradoc/groups/public/documents/UN/UNP

AN005786.pdf;

http://unpan1.un.org/intradoc/groups/public/documents/UN/UNP

AN010193.pdf.

33.A. V. Dicey, The Law of the Constitution, 10th Ed, 1959, p 187 et seq.34.FA Hayek, The Political Ideal of the Rule of Law, Fiftieth Anniversary

Commemoration Lectures, National Bank of Egypt, p 2, Cairo 1955.

35.Fraser, Economic Freedom of the World, 2004.36.Economic Freedom of the World: 2006 Annual Report. freely

downloadable from the Economic Freedom Network website

(www.freetheworld.com/).

37.D Kaufmann, A Kraay, and M Mastruzzi, Governance Indicators:1996-2005, World Bank, 2006.

38.Helen Yu and Alison Guernsey, What is the Rule of Law?(www.uiowa.edu/ifdebook/faq/Rule_of_Law.shtml).

Documents

What is the Rule of Law BY LEON LOUW ما هو حكم القانون؟ ليون لاو