Upload
talkabout-publishing
View
219
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 1/84
Pov}nvih|
Plshvpne
Jnphfvnnk
Poppheboii
Povsle
Khizoii
@x``ne
Fxefxv|
Hopne
Bxih|www%pov}nvih|poik%jn Phi =?600 :8=:<2
Aoexov| 6=?6 Lzzxh 26
Lejix`leg pbh Pov}nvih| ]ovlzb Jnxejli ehwzihpphv
@oshebod Boii # Pbh FovezExvzleg Bndh
Envpbwljb) JW< 2II
=?3=3 :80:6=
Ehwpne Boii
Vhzl`heploi BndhCvn`zbod) WO3 3\@
=?<62 7:<67==?3=3 22<6??
Zoe`lwo|) JW2 6@V
Zoe`lwo| In`gh
Vhzl`heploi Bndh
www%z}vlegjovh%nvg%xk
Jovh wlpb _xoilp|%%%
B o} } | E h w \ h ov
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 2/84
6 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2
Bo}}| Ehw |hov pn ii nx jxzpndz zp e` zep
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 3/84
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 :
ZPHODH@ X]
@NXFIH GIOQLEG>
Fvnkhe nv @odogh` Wle`nwz>
Coxip| Bleghz) Boe`ihz nv Injkz>
Woep pbh iophzp hehvg| zosleg giozz>
8 |hov gxovoephh ne ehw `nxfih gioqleg%
www%jinx`|6jihov%jnd
@ne“p vh}iojh pbh Cvodhz%%% axzp pbh ]oehz/
Joii Cvhh}bneh =2== 3? 6???2
%%%wh dokh zosleg dneh| }hvchjpi| jihov%%%
Clneo Jbhzwnvpb
# Ozznjlophz
]b|zlnpbhvo}|oe`
Z}nvpz Leaxv| Z}hjloilzpz
Nshv 6= |hovz hr}hvlhejh le l`heplc|leg
oe` pvhopleg dxzjxinzkhihpoi }vnfihdz
Ovh |nx zxcchvleg z|d}pndz>
Wh joe bhi}%
Joii xz ne =?26< 7:?:3=www%cnvhzpblii}vojpljh%jnd
Vhjngelzh` f| Lezxvhvz oe`
]vlsoph Dh`ljoi Jnd}oelhz
Clneo Jbhzwnvpb
# Ozznjlophz
Vhjngelzh` f|
Lezxvhvz oe`
]vlsoph Dh`ljoi
Jnd}oelhz
Pbh Wli` Fnov Bnphi) Wblpjbxvjb Vno`) Fhhzpne) Pov}nvih|) Jbhzblvh) JW3 <EW
P1 =?26< 63=:=< H1 heqxlvlhzMwli`fnovbnphi%jnd W1 www%wli`fnovbnphi%jn%xk
Fvlgbphe x} Aoexov| jndh oe` hean| nxv ilsh hephvpolehvz le pbh fvozzhvlh vhzpoxvoep
Zopxv`o| ?0pb Aoexov|1 Zodoepbo Dxv}b| ilsh zleghv
Zopxv`o| 62pb Aoexov| Algzow aoqq ilsh
Wh``leg Co|vh1 Zxe`o| 8pb Chfvxov| ?6%:=}d $ :%:=}d
CNV DNVH LECNVDOPLNE JNEPOJP PBH BNPHI VHJH]PLNE
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 4/84
]xfilzbhv Poikofnxp ]xfilzbleg
Jnepvlfxpnvz Aoehp Bhopb oe` Oeghio Fovpihpp
]vlep HWZ
Zoihz I|eeh Fvo`ih| # Bo|ih| V|`hv
lecnMpoikofnxp}xfilzbleg%jn%xk
]vn`xjplne Ane Wblph
# @lzpvlfxplne
Jnepojp Poikofnxp ]xfilzbleg
6e` Cinnv) Vljbdne` ]iojh?68 $ ?67 Fnxgbpne)Jbhzphv JB: 8FB
lecnMpoikofnxp}xfilzbleg%jn%xk
Phi% =?600 :8=:<2
=72=? 8=38:2
Jlvjxioplne 8)8==
Oii dophvloi lz jn}|vlgbp oe` zbnxi` enp fh vh}vn`xjh` wlpbnxp pbh }hvdlzzlne nc pbh
]xfilzbhvz% Oii `hpoliz ovh jnvvhjp pn pbh fhzp nc nxv kenwih`gh% Pbh ]xfilzbhvz `n enp
he`nvzh nv vhjnddhe` oe| nc pbh hepvlhz nv o`shvplzhdhepz le pbh dogoleh xeihzz
npbhvwlzh zpoph`% Wh o`slzh pbop |nx dokh |nxv nwe ax`ghdhepz) heqxlvlhz oe`
jnd}ovlznez oz wlpb oe| npbhv cnvd nc o`shvplzleg% Wbhe jnepojpleg oe| fxzlehzz) wh
zxgghzp pbop |nx jnevd pbh hrojp p|}h nc gnn`z oe` zhvsljhz ncchvh`) pbh qxoiljoplnez
bhi` oe` oii npbhv vhihsoep oz}hjpz nc pbh zhvsljh wbljb |nx ovh zhhkleg%
Pbh ]xfilzbhvz joeenp ojjh}p iloflilp| cnv inzz) odogh nv `lcjxiplhz vhzxipleg cvnd jnepojpzdo`h pbvnxgb pbh `lvhjpnv|) cvnd hvvnvz) ndlzzlnez) cvnd jioldz do`h f| pbh o`shvplzhvz
nv cvnd ndlzzlnez nv leojjxvojlhz vhiopleg pn phih}bneh exdfhvz) wnv`leg) z}ojleg nv
}nzlplneleg nc oe| ilzpleg) o`shvplzhdhepz nv npbhv dophvloi vhgov`ihzz nc bnw joxzh`%
BO]]\ EHW \HOVWHII `neh pn Pn Fvxjh wbn bozxe`hvpokhe o vnxe` pbh wnvi` pvl} ne blz
flkh% Bh boz }h`oiih` ovnxe` 6:)=== lihz)jnshvleg Hxvn}h) Ozlo oe` Envpb Ohvljo%
\nx joe vho` nvh n blz pvl} le pblz nepb“zh`lplne%
Pbhvh“z oizn ehwz vn Pov}nvih| BlgbZjbnni) injoi foiihp zxjjhzz) inpz nvh injoi
zpnvlhz) }ovlzb jnxejli ehwz) gov`heleg)bhoipb oe` fhoxp|) o wbop“z ne gxl`h oe`
sliiogh le`h%
Oz xzxoi) }ihozh zx}}nvp |nxv injoi
fxzlehzzhz oe` `ne“p nvghp pn phii pbh pbop
|nx zow pbhlv o` le Pbh Poik
Cnv pbh shv| iophzp x}`ophz }ihozh slzlp nxvwhfzlph op www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
Kle` vhgov`z
Pbh Poikofnxp Phod
Bosh o bo}}| Ehw \hov
}:<
}80
0 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2
JNEPHEPZPov}nvih| ]ovlzb Jnxejli }?= # ??
Zhvsljhz }3<$7:
Wbop“z ne . sliiogh le`hr }70$26Le`hr nc o`shvplzhvz }2:
Wh ovh oe le`h}he`hepi| nweh` jnd}oe|) fozh` vlgbp
bhvh le Jbhzblvh) }vn`xjleg zlr dogolehz) Pov}nvih| Poik)
Khh} lp Injoi) Ehzpne Injoi) Bhzwoii Injoi) Nshvihlgb
Vnxe`ofnxp oe` Bnnih Vnxe`ofnxp%
Cnv hpoliz slzlp www%poikofnxp}xfilzbleg%jn%xk
}86
}:2
}36
Pbh Pov}nvih|Phzphv
Joe |nx ce` pbh Pov}nvih|Plghv le pblz h`lplne>
Bh lz bl``he znhwbhvhle pbh ogoqleh%Pbh oezwhv lz ne }ogh 2:
}3=
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 5/84
Ogh Jnejhve "Jbhzblvh,%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%=?3=3 22000=
Oijnbniljz Oene|dnxz%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%=208 73< 7888
Jvldhzpn}}hvz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% =2== 888 ???
Dlzzleg ]hn}ih %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%=8== 7== 7==
Eoplneoi @vxgz Bhi}ileh%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%=2== 773 3==
Zodovlpoez "Jbhzphv, %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%=?600 :77 <<<
Goz Ihok "Pvoezjn,%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% =2== ??? <<<
Jbhzblvh Whzp # Jbhzphv Jnxejli =:== ?6: 2 ?6:
BHOIPB VHIOPH@
Pov}nvih| Bnz}lpoi%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%=?26< 7:6 0:3
Nokioe`z @hepoi %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%=?26<7:6<7<
Pov}nvih| @hepoi Jilelj %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%=?26< 7:66?:
Jnxephzz nc Jbhzphv Bnz}lpoi %%%%%%%%=?600 :38 ===
EBZ @lvhjp %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%=208 03 07
Fxefxv| Dh`ljoi ]vojpljh%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%=?26< 63=6?2
Pov}nvih| Injoi @njpnvz1 @vz N“Joiiogboe # ]ovpehvz %%%%%%%%%%%=?26< 7::083
@vz Gihhk) Gvlce # O`h| %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% =?26< 7:60=?
PVOSHI
Fxz oe` Jnojb "Jbhzblvh Fxz lecn, =?600 3=6 333
Eoplneoi Voli Heqxlvlhz "lecn nei|, %%=208 702 0<8=
Doejbhzphv Olv}nvp %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% =27? 67?= 7??
Anbe Iheene Olv}nvp) Ilshv}nni%%%%%%%=27? 86? 2020
XZHCXI EXdFHVZ
]vlsoph Porl Blvh
Fnnk |nxv olv}nvp blvh
? dnepb le o`soejh
pn vhjhlsh |nxv
`lzjnxeph` voph
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 8
FN@\ JNEPVNI
]LIOPHZ¥
Lc |nx woep pn cvhh |nxvzhic cvnd ojbhz oe` }olez)ld}vnsh |nxv }nzpxvh) ihegpbhe oe` pneh |nxv dxzjihz)`lzjnshv }vn}hv dnshdhep }opphvez)
nv axzp ld}vnsh |nxv clpehzz ihshiz)pbhe ]liophz lz cnv |nx%
ehw }liophzfhgleehvz JIOZZ op Pbh Zpx`ln) Poppheboii
ENWhevniileg
cnv Aoexov|6=?6
Cnv cxvpbhv lecnvdoplne)
}ihozh joii Hddo ne
=?26< 76=:3? Z}ojhz ovh ildlph`
www%pbhzpx`lnpoppheboii%jn%xk
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 6/84
3 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
LE PBH EHWZ
www%znshvhlgewle`nwz%jn%xk
Cor1 =?26< 77==67
JOII \NXV INJOI CODLI\ FXZLEHZZ1
Hzp%?<20
Phi1 =?26< 776877 ◎ ?= \hov Gxovoephh ◎ InwH Giozz◎ Cxii| Hd}in|h Lezpoiihvz◎ Lephveoii| Gioqh`
◎ ?= \hov Gxovoephh ◎ InwH Giozz◎ Cxii| Hd}in|h Lezpoiihvz◎ Lephveoii| Gioqh`
Xelp 0) Ehw Vxzzlo Boii) Jbhzphv Vno`) Poppheboii) Ev Jbhzphv JB: <OB
Vleg ]blil} nv Aneopboe Zpxffz cnv oe lddh`loph qxnpoplne%
Wle`nwz
33ª?6<=ª?6<=
Wle`nwz
22ª?3==ª?3==
c v n d
c v n d
Wle`nwz
00 ª<==ª<== c v n d
Oii }vljhz lejix`h SOP # Lezpoiioplne
cvnd
Cvhejb @nnvzcvnd
ª:<<ª:<<ª3<<ª3<<
’ Pbhvh boz ehshv fhhe o fhpphv pldh pn fx|—
@nnvz
PVO@LEG CNV
67\hovz
Go phzbho pb
O 0 ? W
b l p j
b x v j b V n o `
Jbhz phv Vno`
J b h z p h v V ` %
G o p
h z b h
o p b I e
%
] i o p p z I e%
O 0 ?
WH OVH
BHVH
Bo p pne Boii
Bo p pne Bho pb
P N W O
S H V P N E
AOEXOV\ ZOIH AOEXOV\ ZOIH
CVHHPBHVDOI
GIOZZ
Vh`xjh |nxv bhopleg fliiz wlpb
EHW ZBNWVNND ENW N]HEDne pn Cvl 2od ‚ 0}d
ZOP F\ O]]NLEPDHEP
]xf }volzh`
PBH \hw Pvhh le) op Z}xvzpnw) boz fhhe }volzh` le pbh JODVO Gnn` Fhhv Gxl`h 6=?6)
wbhvh lp boz fhhe `hzjvlfh` oz o ‒zx}hvf sliiogh }xf“% Pbh shexh woz oizn lejix`h` le pbh
Dljbhile }xfz gxl`h) Zow`o|z ]xfz oe` Leez gxl`h oe` pbh Gnn` ]xf gxl`h%
Khizoii bndhz jnejhve
]IOEZ bosh fhhe zxfdlpph` f| Vnwioe` Bndhz pn fxli` 60 }vn}hvplhz ne ioe` ncc
Wliilegpne Ioeh oe` Gvhhe Ioeh) le Khizoii% O exdfhv nc injoi }hn}ih bosh oivho`|
vhglzphvh` pbhlv n}}nzlplne) jioldleg pbop pbh }vn}nzoiz wnxi` iho` pn hrpvo pvocj oe`
}npheploii| z}nli pbh slhwz%
Povsle“z cxpxvh }ioez
PBH Povsle ]ovlzb ]ioe boz fhhe vhshoih` wbljb) oz o vhzxip nc o wl`h voegleg zxvsh|) glshz}hn}ih“z l`hoz ne bnw pn ld}vnsh ilch le pbh sliiogh% Pn slhw lp slzlp pbh }ovlzb jnxejli whfzlph
ne www%povsle}ovlzbjnxejli%nvg%xk%
Bnxzh fxvgih`
FXVGIOVZ fvnkh lepn o bnxzh le Pov}nvih| iozp dnepb oe` zpnih o boe`fog oe` jnephepz
cvnd lezl`h%
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 7/84
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 7
Wbhvhshv |nx `hjl`h pn gn) jbnnzh o
jnd}oe| pbop jovhz bnw |nx ghp pbhvh
nc Pov}nvih| www%o}niinpvoshi%nvg
Phi Zpxovp ne =7<66 006683
]VLSOPH BLVH PORL OE@ DLELFXZ ZHVSLJH
OLV]NVP . ZPOPLNE PORL PVOEZCHVZ
$ WH@@LEGZ $ ELGBPZ NXP $ JNEJHVPZ
$ Z]HJLOI HSHEPZ
Iovgh ino` ovho l`hoi nv
Gniceg . Zkl$leg Bnil`o| Pvoezhvz
$ x} pn 2 ]ozzheghvz + Ixggogh
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 8/84
2 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
Fxefxv| Jovh Oghej|’hshv|fn`| ehh`z zndhfn `|—
jovhvzeoeelhz
ox }olvz
`ndhzpljz
jnnkz
=?26< 7:=6=?
www%fxefxv|oghej|%jnd
hi`hvi| jovh…
jbli` jovh
…
bnxzhbni` jovh
…
eoplnewl`h
82o blgb zpvhhp)pov}nvih|) jbhzblvh jw3 nog
0: j h
i h f
v o p l eg 0 : |
h o
v z
h z p % ?< 3 2
jnd}oelnezdnpbhv“z bhi}z
dophvelp| exvzhz
bnxzhkhh}hvz
jnx}ihz
Z P N ] ] V H Z
Z
Joe |nx }vnsl`hocphv zjbnni jovh>
Lc |nx bosh hr}hvlhejh
le jbli` jovh oe` joe
z}ovh o chw bnxvz fhcnvh
nv ocphv zjbnni }ihozh
jnepojp xz%
Hi`Hvi| JovH $ vHzl`Heploi oe` `oli|
Nxv ‒VNZ\ VNO“ Jovhv oe` Jnd}oelne zhvsljh lz xelqxh pn pbh Fxefxv| Oghej|% Oz hr}hvlhejh` Hi`hvi| Jovh]vnsl`hvz wh nhv o shv| }hvzneoi oe` fhz}nkh zhvsljh) zx}}i|leg jovhxii| zhihjph` Jovhvz oe` Jnd}oelnez wbn innk ophv oii |nxv ehh`z ne o jneplexoi vnpo fozlz le dnzp ovhoz n pbh XK%
Nxv Hr}HvlHeJH
Zlejh ?<32 wh bosh fhhe }vnsl`leg }vlsoph bndh jovh nv pbh hi`hvi| oe` pbh levd%Nxv vnpo z|zphd) kenwe oz pbh ‒Vnz| Vnpo“) boz }vnsh` dnzp zxjjhzzxi nshv pbh |hovz) heofileg }hn}ih pn vhdole lepbhlv nwe bndhz) hshe wbhe ilh boz fhjndh shv| `ljxip%Hi`hvi| bhoipb jovh) wbhpbhv lp fh o Jnd}oelne Bnxzhkhh}hv nv o Jovhv nv pbnzh wlpb `hflilpopleg liiehzzhz zxjboz Oibhldhv“z nv ]ovklezne“z) vhqxlvhz o gvhop `hoi n }hvzneoi lesnishdhep oe` zhezlplslp|% Plz joe fh hrpvhdhi| `hdoe`leg ne odli| oe` vlhe`z%Nxv Jovhvz oe` Jnd}oelnez ovh shv| chrlfih oe` pbh zhvsljh wh }vnsl`h lz polinv$do`h pn zxlp |nxv ehh`z oe`vhqxlvhdhepz% Vovhi| lz pbhvh o zlpxoplne fh|ne` pbhlv hr}hvlhejh nv jo}oflilplhz%
Nxv oldz
… Pn }vnsl`h Jovhvz oe` Jnd}oelnez wbn innk ocphv |nx wlpb pbh gvhophzpn jovh) vhz}hjp oe` xe`hvzpoe`leg) dolepoleleg |nxv `lgelp| oe`le`h}he`hejh%… Pn hezxvh o jneplexlp| nc Jovhvz oe` Jnd}oelnez pbop |nx innk nvwov` pn zhhleg ne o vhgxiov fozlz% Oz pldh gnhz f|) o pvxzpleg oe`vlhe`i| vhioplnezbl} wlii `hshin} fhpwhhe |nx) glsleg |nx }hojh n dle` oe` pbh vhozzxvoejh pbop |nx joe jneplexh pn ilsh le |nxv nwebndh%… Nxv Jovhvz oe` Jnd}oelnez ovh oii shv| hr}hvlhejh` oe` pbhlv`hpoliz ovh vlgnvnxzi| jbhjkh` f| pbh Oghej|%… Nxv `h`ljoph` phod wnvk plvhihzzi| pn }ioe o }hvzneoi `lov| nc ilsh$leJovhvz oe` Jnd}oelnez%… Wh `n nxv fhzp pn hezxvh |nx bosh Jovhvz oe` Jnd}oelnez pbop |nxvhqxhzp oe` |nx wlii ehshv fh ihp oineh nv le `lzpvhzz%
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 9/84
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 <
OII OZ]HJPZ NC PVHH
WNVK XE@HVPOKHE
CHIILEG) ]VXELEG #
ZPXD] GVLE@LEG HPJ
CXII\ LEZXVH@ WLPB
NSHV := \HOVZ HR]HVLHEJH
JOII @OSH NE
Phi ‚ =?26< 70=2==
Dnf ‚ =72=<2:?<7?
60 Bnxv Joii Nxp%
nli gvnx} ip`
O pvxi| le`h}he`hep
codli| vxe fxzlehzz
zlejh ?<37
Zx}}ilhvz nc _xoilp| Bhopleg Nli
Fhjo Bnxzh) Ozbsliih Wo|) Zxppne Whoshv)
Vxejnve) Jbhzblvh WO7 :HQ
Hr}hvp @hh} Jihoeleg
Coepozplj Vhzxipz i Cxii| Lezxvh`
@lvp| Jov}hpz nv Nshe>>
Phi =?600 0<=076
Dnf =7<:3= 3==73
www%jov}hpoe`nshejihoeleg%jn%xk
Povsle Jovzwww%povsleporlz%jn%xk
]vlsoph Blvh Porl # Dlelfxz
i Olv}nvp Pvoezchvz i Elgbpz nxp
i Bnphiz i Wh``legz i Zpoplnez=?26< 70687:
=72<= 080 6=7
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 10/84
?= Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
POV]NVIH\ ]OVLZB JNXEJLIEHWZIHPPHV
CLVZP nc oii pbh ]ovlzb Jnxejli wnxi` ilkh pn wlzb
hshv|neh o shv| bo}}| Ehw \hov%
Pboek |nx pn oii pbh }hn}ih wbn opphe`h` nxv Jbvlzpdoz
ilgbpz hshep ne Cvl`o| 6e` @hjhdfhv pn zleg jovniz; zhh
Copbhv Jbvlzpdoz; fihzz pbh jvlf; oe` enp ihozp nc oii) pn
zhh pbh ilgbpz fhleg pxveh` ne le pbh jbhzpexp pvhh% Pboek
|nx oizn pn hshv|neh wbn do`h pbh hshep }nzzlfih% Lp woz
o vhoi jnddxelp| hccnvp% Pboek |nx oizn cnv |nxv zx}}nvp
nc pbh jbovlplhz wbn bo` zpoiiz) Leehv Wbhhi volzh` ª??8cnv Jbli`iileh; pbh Ihogxh nc Cvlhe`z volzh` oidnzp ª:== cnv Pov}nvih| Bnz}lpoi oe` pbh Vnpov|
jniihjph` le nshv ª?== cvnd pbhlv bnp jbhzpexpz%
i Nxv ehw ]niljh Jnddxelp| Zx}}nvp Ncjhv "]JZN,
Aodhz DjIoxgbile boz enw zpovph` wnvk le pbh sliiogh) zn
|nx joe hr}hjp pn zhh bld le oe` ovnxe` pbh sliiogh) oe`
|nx do| whii zhh bld ne pbh Blgb Zpvhhp ne pbh innk nxp
cnv jovz }ovkh` ne pbh wblph lg og ilehz hlpbhv zl`h nc
pbh }hiljoe jvnzzleg nv ne pbh `nxfih |hiinw ilehz% Bh boz
fhhe o ]JZN le Cvn`zbod cnv o exdfhv nc |hovz) oe` zn boz }ihep| nc hr}hvlhejh le blz vnih
oz o ]JZN% Blz }nzp lz }ovp }ol` f| pbh ]ovlzb Jnxejli%
i Oenpbhv ehw o}}nlepdhep le pbh sliiogh lz
pbop nc bho` phojbhv op Pov}nvih| J H ]vldov|
Zjbnni% Cniinwleg pbh hjlzlne nc Slejh N“Fvlhe
pn gn ne pn }ozpxvhz ehw op pbh he` nc pbh
Oxpxde phvd) pbh Zjbnni“z Gnshveleg fn`| woz
}ihozh` pn oeenxejh le @hjhdfhv pbh o}}nlepdhep nc Dvz Khvv| Cnvvhzphv oz pbh ehw Bho`
Phojbhv% Zbh wlii fh pbh ehw Bho` Phojbhv cvnd ?zp O}vli 6=?6%
Dvz Cnvvhzphv lz oe hr}hvlhejh` bho`) }vhzhepi| wnvkleg le Cvn`zbod% Zbh lz pbvliih` pn bosh
pbh n}}nvpxelp| pn wnvk wlpb pbh jbli`vhe) zpocc) }ovhepz) Gnshvenvz) Zp Bhihez Jbxvjb oe` pbhwl`hv jnddxelp| nc Pov}nvih|% @xvleg pbh Z}vleg phvd Dvz Oeeh Fovehpp hr Bho` nc Xpklepne
]vldov| wlii fh ojpleg bho`%
i Wh bosh bo` o exdfhv nc cvnzp| dnvelegz oe` nxv ilehzdoe oe` pbh gvlppleg snixephhvz
bosh fhhe nxp }xppleg gvlp ne pbh }oshdhepz oe` }opbz% Pbhvh ovh o exdfhv nc gvlp flez
ovnxe` pbh sliiogh) fxp }ihozh joe L vhdle` hshv|neh pbop pbh gvlp le pbhd lz cnv xzh ne }xfilj
vno`z oe` }oshdhepz% Lp lz enp cnv xzh ne }vlsoph }opbwo|z oe` `vlshz% ]hvzneoi zx}}ilhz nc
gvlp joe fh }xvjbozh` cvnd Pov}nvih| @L\% Lc |nx wnxi` ilkh pn snixephhv pn gvlp pbh }oshdhepz
oe` }opbz le |nxv ovho nc pbh sliiogh) }ihozh ghp le pnxjb wlpb pbh ]ovlzb Jihvk ne Phi =?26<
7::0<3% Pvoleleg) gvlp oe` npbhv hqxl}dhep ovh zx}}ilh` f| pbh ]ovlzb Jnxejli%
Wh wlzb hshv|neh o bhoipb| oe` bo}}| 6=?6% @n jndh oineg pn nxv dhhplegz op pbh
Jnddxelp| Jhepvh op 7}d ne pbh zhjne` Dne`o| hsheleg nc pbh dnepb%
B O]] \
EH W \H OV
Ehw |hov) ehw zpovpz
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 11/84
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 ??
Jbhzblvh Jnxep| Jnxejli
Jnxejliinv Oe`vhw Ehh`bod
"=?26< 7:6000,
Oe`vhw%Ehh`bodM
jbhzblvh%gns%xk
POV]NVIH\ ]OVLZB JNXEJLI JNXEJLIINVZPbh Jbolvoe n pbh ]ovlzb Jnxejli lzJnxejliinv Khe ]ovkhv%
Pbh ]ovlzb Jihvk lz dv% A% doj`neoi`Jbovpwnn` Bnxzh) 6= Eoepwljb Vno`)
Pov}nvih| JW3 <XW
}ovlzbjihvkMpov}nvih|%nvg%xk Phi% =?26< 7::0<3
Pov}nvih| boz pwhish ]ovlzb Jnxejliinvz hojb n
wbn zlpz ne neh n pbh pwn Wnvkleg Gvnx}zwbljb hhp ne oiphveoplsh nepbz nv oz vhqxlvh`
Jnxejliinv% Jnepojp @hpoliz ovh =?26<
LevozpvxjpxvhGlii Jinxgb "z}nkhz}hvzne , %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 7::808
Aodhz Fiojknv` %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 7:6828
Ahvhd| Dliiz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 7:=2<2
Khe ]ovkhv "jbolvdoe, %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 7:6?22
Sljpnvlo O`zbho` %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 7::?<6
@osl` ]vhzz%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 7::?83
Ovhoz n lephvhzpSliiogh lelploplshz) Pvoez}nvp oe` Blgbwo|z)
]JZN Jnepvojp oe` Zhjxvlp| Jnddxelp| Fxz
Jnddhvjh) Jbvlzpdoz Ilgbpz.Chzplsoi
Zpvhhp ZjhehVljbov` Fvlhvih| "z}nkhz}hvzne, %%%%%%%%%%% 7:68:<
Ile`o Fxvvnwz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 7::662
Pld Blii %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 7:62=0
Gvobod Ihhz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 7::2:6
@owe An|jh "sljh jbolvdoe,%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%7:=260
Ile`o Fheehpp%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%7:=27=
Ovhoz n lephvhzpFhzp Kh}p Sliiogh) Cinwhv @lz}io|z) Boe`|doe)
Zpvhhp Jihoeleg Jbli`vhe“z ]io| Ovho oe`
Jnddxelp| Lelploplshz%
POV]NVIH\ ]OVLZB JNXEJLILECNVdOPLNE Phi% =?26< 7::0<3
]ovlzb Jnxejli dhhplegz
Pbh ]ovlzb Jnxejli dhhpz le pbh Jnddlpphh Vnnd n pbh Jnddxelp| Jhepvh op 7 }d ne pbh zhjne`
Dne`o| n hojb dnepb) wlpb pbh hrjh}plne n Oxgxzp% Dhhplegz ovh n}he pn pbh }xfilj) oe`
zpovp wlpb oe N}he Cnvxd zhzzlne) `xvleg wbljb dhdfhvz n pbh }xfilj joe o``vhzz pbh wbnih
Jnxejli ne dopphvz n jnejhve pn pbhd% Oizn pbh ]ovlzb Jnxejli bni`z o zxvghv| op 3%:= }d }vlnvpn hojb ]ovlzb Jnxejli dhhpleg wbhe dhdfhvz n pbh }xfilj ovh whijndh pn `lzjxzz dopphvz wlpb
jnxejliinvz ne oe lenvdoi fozlz%
INJOI GNSHVEdHEP
JNXEJLIINV
Jbhzblvh Whzp oe` Jbhzphv Jnxejli
Jiiv Hshihlgb Dnnvh$@xppne"Jnezhvsoplsh, =?26< 7::863
]niljh Jnepojpz]J 06=7 Gh` GlggH$doli Ghvov`%GlggMjbhzblvh%}ee%}niljh%xk
]JZN Aohz djIoxgbileH$doli aodhz%djioxgbileMjbhzblvh%}ee%}niljh%xk
Hdhvghejlhz <<<
Dole ]niljh Exdfhv =208 082 ====@vogne Boii =208 0823:77
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 12/84
?6 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
Z}hjloilzpz le pbh `hzlge)
doexcojpxvh oe`lezpoiioplne nc fhz}nkh)lezxioph` gov`he fxli`legz)fnpb pvo`lplneoi oe`jnephd}nvov|%
Jnshvh` nxp`nnvzpvxjpxvhz cnv nxp`nnvklpjbhe oe` `leleg
lejix`leg nxvwnn`$cvh` nshez%
DNE@O\ pn CVL@O\
<%:=od$8}d
ZOP) ZXE # FOEK BNIZ
?=od$8}d
N]HEEn 3 lz o pvo`lplneoi Pho Vnndzhvsleg fvhokcozp) ixejb oe` inpznc bndh$do`h jokhz) }ozpvlhz oe``hzzhvpz%
3 Jbhzpexp Phvvojh) Blgb Zpvhhp) Pov}nvih| JW3 =XW Phi =?26< 7:6=6?
Wh innk cnvwov` pn zhhleg |nx / O`vloe) Oilzne # oii op En 3
Wh oizn `n ‒Jokhz pn Nv`hv“/ Wh xzh injoi legvh`lhepz wbhvhshv}nzzlfih) oe` oii nc nxv }vn`xjh lzbndh jnnkh` oe` boe`$do`h%
<:o Jbhzphv Vno`) Jozpih) Envpbwljb) JW2 ?BB
PHIH]BNEH HEGLEHHV
@ne“p Fh O Zbhh} # Joii FP Wh“vh Jbho}hv # _xljkhv Hrpvo Znjkhpz cnv ]bneh) Zk|) Fvno`foe`Coxipz # FP ileh wnvk xe`hvpokhe
Vhilofih) jihoe # pl`| zhvsljh
Zodh @o| Zhvsljh ]nzzlfih
NO] @lzjnxep
=?600 60?2==www%`ndhzpljphih}bnehzhvsljhz%jn%xk
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 13/84
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 ?:
Jninxv pbhlvilshz cnvhshv‣
N}he pbh `nnv pn o xelqxh h`xjoplneoi
hr}hvlhejh wlpb hepvoejh hrodz cnv
Pbh Kleg“z Zjbnni) Jbhzphv%
Cnv cxvpbhv lecnvdoplne) joii=?600 32<88:hdoli1 o`dlzzlnezMklegzjbhzphv%jn%xk
www%klegzjbhzphv%jn%xk.whijndh
Fn|z # Glviz) 7$?3Cnv jbli`vhe ??$?2 |hovz) pbh Kleg“z Zhelnv Zjbnni boz
hrjhiihep ojo`hdlj vhzxipz% Kleg“z woz }iojh` oz pbh pn}
}hvcnvdleg zjbnni le Jbhzphv oe` Jbhzblvh cnv O ihshi
oe` GJZH ihshi oe` woz }iojh` 6e` le pbh Envpb Whzp
cnv O ihshiz vhzxipz oe` :v` cnv GJZHz!% Fxp o`` pn pblz
pbh nxpzpoe`leg phojbleg zpocc oe` pbh xelqxh ihoveleg
heslvnedhep) oe` pbh vhzxip lz oe xefhopofih jndfleoplne
pn lez}lvh oe` zpvhpjb |nxeg dle`z% Kleg“z ehshv zpoe`z
zplii) ehw `hshin}dhepz pblz |hov lejix`h1 o ehw
jxvvljxixd oe` hrphezlne nc lephveoplneoi GJZHz) nshv:8 ojo`hdlj hevljbdhep zxfahjpz zxjb oz Lpoiloe oe`
Hihjpvneljz) o ehw pbhopvh oe` axelnv o`shepxvh
}io|gvnxe` oe` nshv ?6= jixfz oe` ojplslplhz%
Pbh Axelnv Zjbnni cnv glviz oe` fn|z ogh` 7$??)
ncchvz oe lez}lvleg h`xjoplne wlpble o zh}ovoph zhic$
jnepoleh` zjbnni% Wlpble pbh jovleg oe` zx}}nvplsh
heslvnedhep nc pbh Axelnv Zjbnni) |nxv jbli` wlii
cinxvlzb oe` fhjndh) oz pbh iozp lez}hjplne
`hzjvlfh` pbh jbli`vhe)
‒bo}}| ihovehvz“%
Nshviol` ne
zpvneg
ojo`hdlj
cnxe`oplnez) pbh
jxvvljxixd ncchvz
hrjhiihep @vodo) Dxzlj)
Z}nvp oe` o wbnih bnzp nc npbhv
ojplslplhz le zdoii jiozzhz%
Kleg“z lz o blgb ojblhsleg zjbnni
wlpb o slfvoep opdnz}bhvh% Kleg“z
zpx`hepz ovh ovpljxioph) jnecl`hep
oe` soixh` f| pbh pn} xelshvzlplhz% Nxv
zpx`hepz ovh }bhendheoii| zxjjhzzcxi) wlpb
slvpxoii| oii gnleg pn xelshvzlp| ‚ ?6 Nrfvl`gh ncchvz
iozp |hov oe` wlpb nshv 23( nc ihoshvz gnleg pn zpx`| opneh nc ’Pbh Pldhz Pn} :=— xelshvzlplhz%
Cleoejloi jnezl`hvoplnez zbnxi` enp `hphv |nx cvnd
slzlpleg xz) oz cleoejloi bhi} lz osoliofih cnv Zhelnv Zjbnni)
`h}he`hep ne }ovhepoi lejndh%
@ne“p wnvv| lc |nx dlzzh` pbh n}he dnveleg) wh ovh
bo}}| pn ovvoegh o slzlp nv pozphv `o| cnv |nxv jbli`) zn pbop
|nx joe zhh cnv |nxvzhic wbop dokhz Pbh Kleg“z Zjbnni
xelqxh% Jnepojp o`dlzzlnezMklegzjbhzphv%jn%xk
pn vhqxhzp o }vnz}hjpxz nv pn ovvoegh o slzlp%
www%klegzjbhzphv%jn%xk.whijndh
!Pbh Pldhz oe` Pbh Phihgvo}b
Kleg“z ‚ Pn} ]hvcnvdleg
Zjbnni le Jbhzblvh
6:v` Aoexov| $ \hovz : # 762pb Aoexov| $ \hovz 0) 8 # 3
Hepvoejh Hrodz 6=?6% 6:v Aoexov| ‚ \hovz : # 7 oe 62pb Aoexov| ‚ \hovz 0) 8 # 3
Hepvoejh Hrodz 6=?6%
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 14/84
?0 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
Jhepxvlne VnnclehWle`nwz # @nnvz Ip`
Phi =?600 800023 . =7708 23<766 . =7708 23<76: nv =?<72 :8< 022
Xelp :: ]lecni` Le`xzpvloi Hzpoph) Fxjkih| JB7 :]I Hdoli1 hii7?Mdze%jnd
i Injoi Oxpbnvlp| O}}vnsh` i Gvoepwnvk Xe`hvpokhe
i ?= |hov lezxvoejh$fojkh` gxovoephh
i Cxii vh}iojhdhep $ wh vhdnsh oii hrlzpleg vnncleh
Wle`nwz
@nnvz
Jnezhvsopnvlhz
Cozjloz
Zncpz
Gxpphvleg
Jio``legCle` xz le
LP Jnd}oe le ]nvpoi Fxzlehzz ]ovk)
Hopne Ioeh) Pov}nvih
vhqxlvh oe
Nccljh O`dlelzpvOpNv
i Bnxvz =<1:= pn ?81:= "ehgnplofih,i H`xjoplne Dleldxd O Ihhi
i @xplhz lejix`h ghehvoi ncjh
O`dle # Zhjvhpovloi
i Fozlj Ojjnxepoej oe` Fnnk Khh}leg
oe o`oepogh
i Hr}hvlhejh n Dljvnznp Ncjh Wnv
# Hrjhi
i Gnn` jnddxeljoplne zkliiz $ wvlpphe # nvoi
i Zoiov Ehgnplofih
jno j vnbwii o
%nbwiiMnwo%n%xk
n =7<37 6=08:0
sOJOEJ|
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 15/84
Oz }ovhepz oe` jovhvz wh oii woep nxv jbli`vhe pn bosh pbh shv| fhzp zpovp
le ilch% Lc nxv jbli`vhe bosh o znil` gvnxe`leg le Hegilzb wh ovh fxli`leg
finjkz cnv pbhlv cxpxvh zpx`lhz%
Wlpb nxpzpoe`leg Hegilzb Pxlplne |nx joe volzh pbh ihshi nc |nxv jbli`“z
zjbnni }hvcnvdoejh le oii zxfahjpz fhjoxzh Hegilzb lz pbh fozlz nc dnzp zxf$
ahjpz oe` bnw pbnzh zxfahjpz ovh ozzhzzh`%
\nx joe zx}}nvp |nxv jbli` wbn do| bosh phd}nvovli| coiihe fhble` oe`
ehh` pn jopjb x}) |nx joe
lejvhozh pbhlv jnec`hejh
oe` hean|dhep le Hegilzb)
|nx joe bhi} pbhd `hshin}
gnn` zpx`| zkliiz) oe` |nx
joe oiinw pbhd pn wnvk pn
oe Le`lsl`xoi Ihoveleg ]ioepbop ihpz pbhd wnvk op pbhlv
nwe }ojh% \nx joe `n pblz
fhjoxzh |nx jbnzh Hegilzb
Pxlplne%
Hshv| phojbhv boz o
`hgvhh) dozphvz nv ]b@ le
Hegilzb) o phojbleg qxoilc$joplne oe` o jxvvhep He$
boejh` JVF @lzjinzxvh%
Hegilzb
Pxlplne
Wh nccv ne$pn$ne hegilzb pxlplne pn jbli`ve zpx`|leg op
K| Zpogz1 ?) 6) :) 0 nv 8%
Zhvsljhz1iNeh$pn$neh Hegilzb jiozzhz cnv Kh| Zpoghz ?) 6) :) 0 oe` 8
i ??+ Hepvoejh Hrodleoplne ]vh}ovoplne
i ZOPz Hrodleoplne ]vh}ovoplne
i GJZH
i O Ihshi
i Hzzo| dovkleg oe` wvlpphe chh`fojk
iNeileh dovkleg
iNeh$pn$neh pxlplne cnv jbli`vhe nxp nc dolezpvhod h`xjoplne
Jnepojp1
P =70= 7:78707
H hegilzbpxlplne60M|obnn%jndW www%hegilzbpxlplne60%jnd
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 16/84
?3 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
Cvlhe`z nv codli| jndleg pn zpo|>En vnnd>
Zhic jophvleg Whhk nv zbnvp fvhokz osoliofih
Ehwi| vhcxvflzbh` . Od}ih }ovkleg
BNIL@O\ JNPPOGHZHopne) Ev Pov}nvih|
Inwhv Bnxzh Covd% Phi =?26< 7:=8<0.=7233<:=228Hdoli oeeh%inwhvbnxzhMfplephvehp%jnd Whf www%covdzpo|%jn%xk
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 17/84
# Eoli Inxegh
3= blgb zpvhhp) pov}nvih| p =?26< 7:6<7:
hdoli pov}nvih|bolvfnxplqxhMbnpdoli%jn%xk
Vd| v ?==( }vhdlxd bxdoe bolv%
Hrjixzlshi| znxvjh` oe` lepvljophi| jvocph`%
Cnv inshvz nc zp|ih) qxoilp| oe` }hvchjplne%
Vd| v lz pbh xipldoph jbnljh; pbh bolv zpvoe`z ovh `hiljophi| fnxe` pnghpbhv xzleg
oe lepvljoph phjbelqxh pbop hezxvhz pbh bolv `nhz enp `hpojb cvnd lpz lejvh`lfih whcp%
]vljh x}ne jnezxipoplne
Ehw \hov Z}hjloi Ncchv Bosh o jninxv # jxp wlpb nxv zp|ilzp Ahzz oe` vhjhlsh
6=( ncc ne }Vn`xjplne nc pblz o`shVp "hr}lVhz 62pb Aoe 6=?6,
Lepvn`xjleg Vhd| JnxpxVh
bolv hrphezlnez
Pbh Eoli Inxeghncchvlg je` zbhiio o Fl zxi}pxvh Ghi
i @vlhz lezpoepi| i Znokz ncc le dlexphzi En jbl}}leg i En bovd pn eopxvoi eoli
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 18/84
?2 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
www%ginfoiflkh%jn%xk Xelp ?F) Joeoizl`h) Poppheboii JB: <F@Phi1 =?26< 77= 200 Hdoli1 blMginfoiflkh%jn%xk
_xnph O?= pn Vhjhlsh
?=( ncc vv}
pbvnxgbnxp @hjhdfhv
Pbh Zbh` Doe) Vnzh Covd Zbn})Xpklepne JW3 =I]Phi =7<0? 333707
Innkleg cnv o Gov`he Zbh`>Innkleg cnv pbh Fhzp _xoilp| op pbh Fhzp ]vljh>
L }vnfofi| bosh pbh fhzp soixh cnv dneh| Zbh`z le Jbhzblvh
Joii oe` zhh cnv |nxvzhic
Vh$jnshvleg nv cxii x}bnizphv| nc1
i Pbvhh ]lhjh Zxlphz i ]nxcchz
i
Wleg Jbolvzi
Jbolzh Inegxhzi Bho`fnov`z i @leleg Jbolvz
i Cnnpzpnniz oe` dnvh
Phi =?26< 78?<66
Hzp ?<22
]loen Ihzznezfhgleehvz pn o`soejh`
@o|pldh z}ojhz cnv o`xipz
i Ojjnd}oeldhep cnv hrodz.}hvcnvdoejhi GJZH oe` O ihshi zx}}nvp wnvk cnv dxzlj
oe` dxzlj phjbening|i Iovgh zpx`ln oe` wolpleg vnnd zlpxoph` ehovPov}nvih|
Jnepojp =7<6 ?8? 6=?< Oe`vhw Zpovdhvwww%}bnhelrojjnxepz%|niozlph%jnd
Bndh slzlpz hshelegz # whhkhe`z% := |hovz hr}hvlhejh%
Jnd}hplplsh chhz% Cvhh o}}nlepdhep osoliofih
◎ Vhshexh Ojjnxepz ◎◎ Fnnk Khh}leg ◎
◎ O`dlelzpvoplne nc Wlii Hzpophz ◎
Pn Zosh Pldh # Dneh|Phih}bneh xz cnv oe lddh`loph vhz}nezh
ne =?26< 7:: 886 nv =7<33 0=8 :?0
O codli| vxe fxzlehzzZhvsljleg jilhepz pbvnxgbnxp Jbhzblvh zlejh ?<<0
]bnhelrOjjnxeplegZhvsljhz
’Wh cvhh x} |nxv pldh) zn |nx joe ghp ne wlpb \nxv fxzlehzz/— Cnv oii |nxv Por # Sop Vhpxvez
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 20/84
6= Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
HSHEPZ OP PBH FOVFNXV LEZPLPXPH) POPPHEBOII Phi =?26< 77?30<) www%fovfnxvlezplpxph%jn%xk nv hdoli pjoflMplzjoil%jn%xk
CliMFovfnxv1 Pbxvz ?<pb Aoexov|‒\nx Wlii Dhhp o Poii @ovk Zpvoeghv“ "jhvp ?6,
Jndh`|.Vndoejh lvhjph` f| Wnn`| Oiihe) oe` zpovvleg Oepbne| Bn}klez oe`
Eondl Woppz !Clidz zpovp op 2%==}d!"`nnvz n}he op 7%:=}d,
!]o| ne pbh `nnv1 ª8 . xe`hv ?2z ª0% Fov Osoliofih!
?0pb Aoexov| ‚ Zp Oifoez“ Axdfih Zoih) ?%:=}d
63pb.67pb.62pb Aoexov| ‚ PO@Z }vhzhep ‒Zihh}leg Fhoxp|“ "}oepn, Pljkhpz
vnd Poppheboii ]nzp Njh vnd <pb Aoe%
Ogh Jnejhve Jbhzblvh Pvo`hv Vhglzphvh`
www%loedojko|%jn%xk lecnMloedojko|%jn%xk
Jbhzblvh
dojko|“z
WH ENW LEZPOII KLPJBHEZ/
_xhhe“z ZjnniHepv| OzzhzzdhepzPbH _xhhe“z Zjnni le Jhzphv lz hr}hjplegvhjnv exdfhvz nc hepvoepz cnv lpz oeexoihepv| ozzhzzdhepz ne Dneo| ?3p Aoexov| 6=?6%
Lp oz vhjhepi| lejvhozh ph exdfhv nc z}ojhz osoliofih op ph Inwhv Zjnni xh pn
hdoe oe lz oleg dnvh cojlilplhz op phIlshv}nni Vno Zjnni% Ph Zhelnv Zjnnine Jlp| Woiiz Vno lz jhihfvopleg lpz vhjhepPn} Jhzlvh Voekleg le ph Zxeo| Pldhz“]ovhep ]nwhv ihogxh pofihz cnv 6=??) jndlegcnxvp le ph Envp Whzp%
Hepv| pn ph ehwi| vhcxvflzh _3) phzjnni“z 3p cnvd) lz f| }hvzneoi lephvslhw oe pozphv o|z%
Dnvh hpoliz oe o }vnz}hjpxz cnv oii oghz
cvnd Aoeh Po|inv ne =?600 :?6=72 nv apo|invMqxhhez%jbhzblvh%zjb%xk
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 21/84
_xhhe“z zx}}nvpz oe` hejnxvoghz) fvlegleg nxple`lsl`xoi poihepz) }vnsl`leg oe heslvnedhep pnjboiihegh) lesnish oe` lez}lvh glviz ogh` 0 pn ?2%Lp gnhz wlpbnxp zo|leg) _xhhe“z jndflehz pvo`lplnewlpb dn`hve ihoveleg) jneplexleg lpz hrjhiihejhoz o XK Pn} ?== Zjbnni%! Wlpb pbh fhzp cojlilplhz)nxpzpoe`leg pxlplne) oe` nshv neh bxe`vh` hrpvo$jxvvljxiov n}plnez) _xhhe“z jneplexhz pn `hilshvpbh zkliiz oe` }ozzlne pn oppole pbh `hzlvh` xelshvzlp|
jbnljh oe` jovhhv }opb%
Dne`o|?3pb Aoexov|
6=?6HEPV\
OZZHZZDHEPZ
Op _xhhe“z wleeleg lze“p hshv|pbleg)fxp pv| phiileg pbop pn Iojvn zzh
Jbod} lnez ilkh Vxb
! Pbh iozp : |hovz nc `opo cvnd Pbh Zxe`o| Pldhz ?:.??.6=??% Pn} le Whzp Jbhzblvh%
Op _xhhe“z wleeleg lze“p hshv|pbleg)fxp pv| phiileg pbop pn Iojvnzzh
jbod}lnez ilkh Vxpb
Nxv @hjhdfhv 6=?? Lez}hjplne Vh}nvp blgbilgbpz
pbh ‒hrjh}plneoi“ oe` ‒nxpzpoe`leg“ h`xjoplne wh}vnsl`h% Cnv o jn}| oe` dnvh lecnvdoplne joii=?600 :?6=72 nv slzlp nxv whfzlph www%qxhhez%jbhzblvh%zjb%xk
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 22/84
Zbnxi` L pokh o ghe`hv$z}hjlclj
dxiplslpodle oe` dlehvoi cnvdxio>
Dhe oe` wndhe bosh `lhvhep
expvlplneoi vhqxlvhdhepz% Pbhlv `lhpz
ovh ncphe qxlph `lshvzh oe` pbhlv ehh`z
cnv z}hjlj expvlhepz ovh `lhvhep pnn%
Lp pbhvhcnvh dokhz zhezh wbhe
jbnnzleg expvlplneoi zx}}ihdhepz pn
pokh pbhzh `lhvhejhz lepn
jnezl`hvoplne%
Wbljb expvlhepz zbnxi` fh chopxvh`
le o zx}}ihdhep cnv wndhe>
Pbhvh ovh o chw expvlhepz pbop ovh
z}hjljoii| ehh`h` f| dhe nv wndhe
le `lhvleg odnxepz% Neh zxjb
hrod}ih lz lvne% Wndhe ovh hz}hjloii|
}vneh pn lvne `hjlhej| `xvleg pbhlv
vh}vn`xjplsh |hovz fhjoxzh nc
vh}hoph` finn` inzzhz `xvleg
dhezpvxoplne% Lp lz pbhvhcnvh
ld}nvpoep pbop wndhe nc jbli`$
fhovleg ogh bosh oe o`hqxoph zx}}i|
nc lvne oe` npbhv finn`$fxli`leg
expvlhepz) zxjb oz slpodle F?6 oe`
cnilj ojl`% Cnilj ojl` lz oizn slpoi cnv
oii wndhe nc jbli`$fhovleg ogh le
nv`hv pn zx}}nvp pbh bhoipb|
`hshin}dhep nc o cnhpxz% O gnn`
dxipl$expvlhep cnvdxio cnv wndhe
zbnxi` jnepole pbhzh expvlhepz le
hozli| ofznvfh` cnvdz% Pbh dlehvoiz
joijlxd) dogehzlxd oe` lej zx}}nvp
fneh bhoipb oe` ovh ncphe cnxe` le
shv| zdoii odnxepz le dxipl$expvlhep
cnvdxioz% O gnn` zx}}ihdhep wlii
jnepole dnvh zlgeljoep ihshiz nc
pbhzh slpoi dlehvoiz%
Wbljb expvlhepz zbnxi` fh chopxvh`le o zx}}ihdhep cnv dhe>
Bhovp lzhozh lz jnezl`hvofi| dnvh
}vhsoihep le dhe oe` pbh iophzp
vhzhovjb lepn pbh joxzhz nc bhovp
`lzhozh boz jhepvh` ne o zxfzpoejh
joiih` bndnj|zphleh% Inw ihshiz nc
slpodlez F3) F?6 oe` cnilj ojl` joe
iho` pn o vlzh le bndnj|zphleh ihshiz
le pbh finn`zpvhod% O blgb
bndnj|zphleh ihshi lz pbnxgbp pn
jnepvlfxph pn ovphvloi `odogh wbljb
do| iho` pn bhovp oppojkz oe` zpvnkhz%
Hezxvleg o gnn` zx}}i| nc F slpodlez
cvnd o gnn` dxipl$expvlhep cnvdxio lz
slpoi cnv oe| doe woepleg pn dolepole
gnn` jov`lnsozjxiov bhoipb% Oz dhe
ogh) `lznv`hvz nc pbh }vnzpoph gioe`
fhjndh lejvhozlegi| jnddne%
Zjlheplj vhzhovjb boz zbnwe pboplej oe` zhihelxd }io| slpoi vnihz le
dolepoleleg }vnzpoph bhoipb%
Lejl`hepoii|) o dxipl$expvlhep cnv dhe
zbnxi` jnepole ilppih nv en lvne oz dhe
ghehvoii| vhqxlvh ihzz nc pblz dlehvoi%
Oii pbhzh expvlhepz joe fh cnxe`
pnghpbhv le Chdoih oe` Doih Dxipl}ih%
Ozk pbh hr}hvpz op Pov}nvih| Bhoipb Zpnvh
ZNIGOV SLPODLEZ OE@ POV]NVIH\ BHOIPB ZPNVH hzzheploiz cnv ilch“z anxveh|
CVHH Znigov Expvlplneoi Jnezxipoplnez Cvl`o| 6=pb Aoexov|
$ Joii le nv joii xz cnv osolioflilp| ne =?26< 7:=336
www%bhoipbzpnvh607%jn%xk
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 23/84
Cxii voegh osoliofih le zpnvh oe` neileh op www%bhoipbzpnvh607%jn%xk
ZNIGOV SLPODLEZ OE@ POV]NVIH\ BHOIPB ZPNVH hzzheploiz cnv ilch“z anxveh|
Pbh Owov` Wleeleg Pov}nvih| Bhoipb Zpnvh $ Hzp% Axeh 6==3) 6 Jbhzpexp Phvvojh) Blgb Zpvhhp)
Pov}nvih|) Jbhzblvh) JW3 =XW% N}he1 Pxhz`o|$Zopxv`o| <od$8}d Cvhh ]bneh1 =2== =2:6 706
Hdoli1 vljbov`Mbhoipbzpnvh607%jn%xk%
CVHH `hilshv| ne OII nv`hvz neileh op www%bhoipbzpnvh607%jn%xk en dleldxd nv`hv vhqxlvh`%
6=( NCC le zpnvh wlpb pblz jnx}ne oe` neileh xzleg }vndnplneoi jn`h1 ZNIGOV0
Eodh1 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% O``vhzz1 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
Dokh o bhoipb| vhznixplne
cnv hojb npbhv W N W
6 = ( N C C
l e AO E XO V \
3 = P o f i h pz W H
V H ª? :% 6?
E N W ª? =%
8 7
? 6 = P o f i h pz W
H V H ª 68% = <
E N W ª 6 =%
= 7
N e i | o p P o v } n
v i h |
B h o i p b Z p n v h
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 24/84
78
ovndo o`soejh` }vhjlzlne cojloii
`hixrh doeljxvh oe` hr}vhzz }h`ljxvh`hixrh }h`ljxvh oe` hr}vhzz doeljxvh i ovndo cxii fn`| dozzogh wlpb bnp zpnehzovndo heshin}dhep pn lejix`h fojk dozzogh
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 25/84
Govogh vniihv zbxpphv `nnvz
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 26/84
63 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
oe`| cnzphvovjblphjpz
www%oe`|cnzphvovjblphjpz%jnd
pvo`lplneoi) jnephd}nvov| oe` inw hehvg| `hzlge
phi =?600 :0:776
6< Inwhv Fvl`gh Zpvhhp Jbhzphv JB? ?VZ
Ehw |hov fvozzPBH vzp jnejhvp nc 6=?6) ne Zxe`o| 2pb
Aoexov| op 3%:=}d zhhz pbh whijndh vhpxve
nc Phd}xz Fvozz% Lp lz oiwo|z o gxovoephh`
hsheleg nc wne`hvcxi fvozz }io|leg wlpb o
`ozb nc gnn` bxdnxv oe` o gvoe` wo| pn
whijndh pbh Ehw \hov% Pbhlv }vngvoddh lz oiwo|z sovlh` oe` lephvhzpleg oe` lejix`hz fnpb}n}xiov fvozz cosnxvlphz oe` dn`hve }lhjhz% Lc |nx boshe“p fhhe oineg pn o Dxzlj Znjlhp|
Jnejhvp) wb| enp glsh xz o pv|>
Jnejhvpz ovh op pbh ]ovlzb Jbxvjb nc Zp%Oifoe) Poppheboii oe` zpovp op 3%:=}d ne o Zxe`o|
hsheleg%
O`dlzzlne lz nei| ª2 oe` ª3 cnv PDZ Dhdfhvz% Pljkhpz ovh osoliofih op pbh `nnv nv le
o`soejh cvnd Pbh ]nzp Ncjh) Poppheboii Blgb Zpvhhp) Poppheboii Ehwz nv pbh Glcp Zbn}
Pbhcpz
… O boe`fog woz zpnihe cvnd oe xeopphe`h`
jov le Pov}nvih| wbhe pbh pblhc zdozbh` pbh
cvnep wle`nw nc pbh jov pn pokh pbh boe`fog
ncc pbh cvnep }ozzheghv zhop%
… O bnxzh le Khizoii bo` dneh| zpnihe wblizp
pbh njjx}oep woz owo| cnv o chw `o|z%
op pbh jnvehv nc Jbxvjb Foek%
Oiphveoplshi| phih}bneh =?26<
77=0?0%Cnvpbjndleg jnejhvpz
Zxe`o| ?6pb Chfvxov| %%%% Pbh
Doejbhzphv Pvln ‚ slnile) jhiin # }loen
Zxe`o| ??pb Dovjb %%%%%Pbh
Clel _xovphp ‚ dxzlj f| Bo|`e)
Dhe`hizznbe # Clel
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 27/84
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 67
Bo}}| ?2pb flvpb`o| pn
Cvoeklh Bxd}bvh|z
Cvnd Dxd) @o`) Eoee| oe` Gvoe`o`
Bo}}| ?2pb Zhvhelp| c P
:3f) Blgb Zpvhhp) Povsle
=?26< 70?0?6
Ahwhiihv|
cvnd ª?0 cnv fvojhihpz%
Boe` do`h zlik zjovshz
cvnd ª?8 hojb%
`lzjnxePz ne ehnd oe`
dnex zhPz
jojl PvhoPdhePz
jneplexh op pbh
`lzjnxeph` voph
BnP zPnehz
dhzzogh
pn pokh owo| pbnzh Aoexov| fixhz!Enp pn fh xzh` le jneaxejplne wlpb npbhv ncchvz%
\nxv nei| pvxh injoi Fhoxp| Zoine
?8( `lzjnxeP!
C ppp f
A
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 28/84
Ehw \hovz Vhznixplne Z}o @o|
Vnwpne Boii Jnxepv| Bnxzh Bnphi Bhoipb Jixf oe` Z}o) Wblpjbxvjb Vno`) Vnwpne) Jbhzphv JB: 3O@p$ =?600 ::8636 h$ pbhz}oMvnwpneboiibnphioe`z}o%jn%xk www%z}ojbhzphv%jnd
Pn zld}i| @hpnr oe` chhi }od}hvh` le 6=?6
\nx do| jbnnzh neh pvhopdhep nxp nc hojb zhjplne fhinw
Ovndopbhvo}| Fn`| ZjvxfFofnv Kboe|o Fn`| Zjvxf
Oepl$Oghleg Boe` Pvhopdhep$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
Snijoelj @hpnr Wvo}Ovndopbhvo}| Jhiixilph Wvo}
B|`vopleg Fn`| Wvo}$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
Zhezoplneoi H|h Pvhopdhep
Dnlzp Lephezh Lepvn`xjpnv| CojloiOvndopbhvo}| B|`vopleg Cojloi
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$Dlel Bho` Dozzogh
Cnnp DozzoghBoe` Dozzogh
Lejix`h` le pblz z}o `o| lz o vhiorleg z}o ilgbp ixejboe` cxii xzh nc bhoipb jixf cojlilplhz
Oizn hean| o `hpnrlc|leg pho oe` Cvxlp }iopphv le nxvvhioroplne ovho
Z}hjloi Ehw \hovz ]vljh
ª78%== Soil` xepli =?.=:.6=?6
Cnv oii heqxlvhz }ihozh joii =?600 ::8636 nv hdolipbhz}oMvnwpneboiibnphioe`z}o%jn%xk
!Phvdz oe` jne`lplnez o}}i| !zxfahjp pn osolioflilp|
Wb| enp hean| 60bvz nc le`xighejh %%
Fnnk neh nc nxv ixrxvlnxz vnndz pn pvxi| hean| |nxv z}o
`o| hr}hvlhejh) cniinwh` f| owne`hvcxi @leehv) Fh` oe`
Fvhokcozp% Pblz oii lejixzlsh ncchv lz o }hvchjp zpovp pn pbh Ehw
\hov oe` lz oii |nxvz cnv%%%%%
ª?08%==! ]hv }hvzne
!Fozh` ne pwn }hn}ih zbovleg!Zxfahjp pn osolioflilp| soil` xepli =?.=:.6=?6
!phvdz oe` jne`lplnez o}}i|
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 30/84
Jov}p JioelegBosleg hzpofilzbh` pbhdzhishz oz o injoi jov}hp jihoeleg fxzlehzz lepbh hovi| ?<<=z) pbh doeoghdhep phod op Coijne do`h pbh `hjlzlne
pn }xvjbozh zhshvoi Jbhd@v| cvoejblzh ovhoz pbvnxgbnxp pbh Envpb Whzp oe` Envpb Woihz% Bosleg }xvjbozh` pbh cvoejblzhz) pbh phodop Coijne pnnk dorldxd o`soepogh nc pbh pvoleleg }ojkoghz pbop
whvh ncchvh` pn pbhd) hezxvleg pbop oii pbh Coijne zpocc whvh pvoleh`pn oe hrpvhdhi| blgb zpoe`ov` le oii oz}hjpz nc jov}hp jihoeleg oe`ozznjloph` zhvsljhz%
Coijne dolepoleh` pblz vhioplnezbl} wlpbJbhd@v| cnv nshv o `hjo`h) jneplexnxzi| zpvlsleg pn ld}vnsh pbh zhvsljh pbh| jnxi` ncchv% Oz jlvjxdzpoejhz jboegh`)oe` pbh cvoejblzh dn`hi hsnish`) pbh
Coijne doeoghdhep phod hjl`h` pboppbh Jbhd@v| cvoejblzh }vojplzhz whvhpnn vhzpvljplsh oe` pbh| pnnk pbh `hjlzlnepn dnsh owo| cvnd pblz ovvoeghdhepoe` zhhk pn hzpofilzb pbhdzhishz oz oele`h}he`hep jnd}oe| pbop woz ofih pn dokh pbh dnzp nc pbh fxzlehzz}vojplzhz hshin}h` le jneaxejplne wlpb o dxipl$eoplneoi jnd}oe|) wblizp jnejhepvopleg ne o dnvh jxzpndhv$cnjxzh` o}}vnojb pn `nleg fxzlehzz% Wh soixh pbh jne`hejh wh“sh goleh` pbvnxgb pbh doe| |hovz nc nxv fixh$jbl} vhioplnezbl}z) pblz dhoez wh ovh xzh` pn ghppleglp vlgbp vzp pldh) hshv| pldh%
Pblz `hjlzlne boz fhhe vhwov`h` wlpb oe lejvhozh le fxzlehzz zhjxvh`pbvnxgb o jndfleoplne nc o injoi o`shvplzleg jod}olge oe` }hvzneoivhjnddhe`oplnez cvnd zoplzh` jilhepz) fnpb hrlzpleg oe` ehw% Nxv`ndhzplj jnshvogh hrphe`z pbvnxgbnxp pbh Envpb Whzp oe` fh|ne`)cvnd Jovilzih le pbh Envpb pn Zpnkh$ne$Pvhep le pbh Znxpb oe` cvnd Oegihzh| le pbh Whzp pn Bxii le pbh Hozp%
Jihovi|) wh bosh o floz pnwov`z jihoeleg jov}hpz) x}bnizphv|) jhvodljplihz oe` npbhv bov` nnv zxvcojhz fxp wh ovh oizn le o }nzlplne pn}vnsl`h o``lplneoi }vn`xjpz oe` zhvsljhz wbljb lejix`h oii doeehv nc }vn}hvp| jihoeleg vhqxlvhdhepz%
Cvnd pbh }nlep nc |nxv lelploi jnepojp wlpb Coijne) wh bn}h pbop |nx
wlii fh ld}vhzzh` wlpb nxv fxzlehzz dhpbn`z oe` wh pvxzp pbop |nx wlii fh zxlpofi| zoplzh` wlpb pbh vhzxipz pbop nxv phjbeljloez wlii ojblhsh wlpb |nxv jov}hpz% Wh he`hosnxv pn }vnsl`h o jnd}vhbhezlsh zhvsljh wbljb dhhpz pbh ehh`z oe` hr}hjpoplnez nc nxv soixh` hrlzpleg oe`}npheploi ehw jilhepz%
W ov oiwo|z
o}}| pn i}%Gls xz o joii ne=2== =03 ?<<?
Pbh phod op Coijne bosh nshv 3= |hovz“ hr}hvlhejh le pbh vhoe` nn` vhzpnvoplne zhjpnv nc pbh lezxvoejh le`xzpv|% Oz ovhzxip) Coijne Fxli`leg Zhvsljhz boz o exdfhv nc `lslzlnez) hojb
nc wbljb z}hjloilzh le zndh oz}hjp nc vhzpnvoplne) wbhpbhv lp fhle pbh fxli`leg zhjpnv nc nxv fxzlehzz) nv le pblz) pbh jov}hp oe`x}bnizphv| jihoeleg zhjpnv% Pboekz pn pbhlv ihshiz nc hr}hvlhejhoe` }vnchzzlneoilzd) Coijne hean|z o}}vnsh` jnepvojpnv zpopxz
wlpb o zlgeljoep exdfhv nc iho`leg `ndhzplj oe` jnddhvjloilezxvvz%
Coijne z}vho`z lpz wlegz
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 32/84
:6 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
Joe }vnsl`h pbh cniinwleg zhvsljhz1
q Ohvloi Zophiilph # OS Zhvsljhzq @lglpoi Ohvloi Lezpoiioplnezq Zk| # Hxvn}hoe Zophiilph Lezpoiioplnezq IJ@ # ]iozdo Lezpoiioplnezq Cvhhslhw # Cvhhzopq Phih}bneh Hrphezlnez
q JJPS Lezpoiioplne # Zhvsljhq Fhz}nkh OS Z|zphdz Fnzh hpjq Dnflih ]bneh Fnnzphvz.Ohvloizq Zk| O}}vnsh` Lezpoiihv
]ihozh jnepojp xz) wh wlii fh bo}}| pn bhi}
Cvhh ]bneh1 =2== 6<66 386Hdoli xz op1 zoihzMslhwjnddz%ehp
Slzxoi JnddxelJoplnez
6 Jbxvjb Woik) Pov}nvih|
Phi =?26< 7:6<=3Pbh zoine lz axzp ncc pbh Blgb Zpvhhp) fhpwhhe Zwhphebod“z oe` pbh nwhv zbn}/
N}heleg pldhzDne <%:=od$0%:=}dPxhz <%:=od$0%:=}d Wh` <%:=od$0%:=}dPbxv <%:=od$8%:=}dCvl <%:=od$8%:=}dZop <od$:}d
Pbh Fovfhv“z Zbn}Dne`|z No} vphz onlepdhepz enp
iw|z ehjhzzv|
Jxp pbvnp zbshzslifih f|
nlepdhep
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 33/84
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 ::
L e p h v l n v Z n i x p l n
e z O p X e f h o p o f i h ] v l j h z Pbh Cxvelpxvh Dovkhp) z}hjloilzpz le1
$ Nok Cxvelpxvh
$ Cvhejb Cxvelpxvh
$ Dlvvnvh` Cxvelpxvh
$ Giozz jnhh pofihz
Zld}i| jiljk nepn nxv whfzlph pn slhw
nxv dozzlsh jniihjplne n xvelpxvh
nv joii xz pn ovvoegh o slhwleg
op nxv wovhbnxzh ehov
Khizoii) Pov}nvih|%
Wh ovh |nxv injoi xvelpxvh wovhbnxzh)glsleg |nx pbh fhehcp n
fhleg ofih pn fx| pblz qxoilp| xvelpxvh
op blgbi| jnd}hplplsh }vljhz%
Wh bosh bxgh zpnjkz osoliofih
nv ozp
eoplnewl`h hilshv|
\nx joe fx| neileh) nshv pbh }bneh nv
jndh pn slhw oe` jniihjp vnd
nxv wovhbnxzh
www%pbhcxvelpxvhdovkhp%jn%xk
h1 lenMpbhxvelpxvhdovkhp%jn%xk
Phi1 =?26< 78< 68<
Slhwlegz f| o}}nlepdhep)
N}he Dne`o| ‚ Cvl`o| < ‚ 3}d%
Pbh Cxvelpxvh Dovkhp
Xelp 6 Nvgoez`oih Covd
Khizoii) Pov}nvih|)
Jbhzblvh JW3 =ZV
p b h c x
v e l p x v
h d o v k h p % j
n
% x k
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 34/84
:0 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
Le`xigh` nshv pbh Jbvlzpdoz }hvln`>
Chhileg zixgglzb oe` plvh`>
Phi1 =?26< 636=?< Hdoli1 pvoeqxlilp|M}hjkcnvpnejozpih%jn%xk www%}hjkcnvpnejozpih%jn%xk Pvoeqxlilp| op ]hjkcnvpne Jozpih y Zpneh Bnxzh Ioeh y Pov}nvih| y Jbhzblvh y JW3 <PE
Pvoeqxlilp| Aoexov| @hpnr ]ojkoghz
Clvzpi| hean| o Pwlelegz lecxzlne pho pn fnnzp `lghzplne oe` pbh lddxeh z|zphd) jihoezh pbh finn` nc pnrlez ) foioejh finn` zxgovz oe` fxve cop fhcnvh xewle`leg wlpb |nxv jbnljh nc pvhopdhep% Pbhe vhior oe` vhaxsheoph le nxv 6=?= Fvozzhvlh oe` jbnnzh ixejb cvnd nxv xelqxh Aoexov|
@hpnr Dhex%
ª88%== ]hv ]hvzne
Fn`| Zjxi}pleg Jhiixilph oe` Jnine Pbhvo}| $ ? Bnxv
Xzleg pbh ehw jileljoii| }vnshe Hihdlz Fn`| Zjxi}pleg Z|zphd) |nxv zlibnxhpph wlii fh vh`hcleh`% Pbh Fn`| Zjxi}pleg Il}n$Vhcleleg Zhvxd oe` Fn`| Zjxi}pleg Clvdleg Jvhod povghp zpxffnve jhiixilph oe` zoggleg zkle) cnv slzlfih) vo}l` vhzxipz%
Vhjnddhe`h`1 6 pvhopdhepz }hv whhk cnv 0 whhkz
Jhiixpnr Ovndo Z}o Njhoe Wvo}.Cinop $ ? Bnxv ?8 Dlexphz
Ihp pbnxgbpz `vlcp owo|) wblizp fhleg jnjnneh` le o jndcnvpleg cnli wvo} nv xelqxh `v| cinop oe` pvhoph` pn o }vhzzxvh }nlep cojloi dozzogh oe`
`h$zpvhzz zjoi} pvhopdhep% Jndfleleg pbh vljbehzz nc zho }ioepz oe` dovleh oigoh) pblz pbhvo}| bhi}z vh`xjh pbh o}}hovoejh nc jhiixilph oe` vh$
ilhsh pbh `lzjndcnvp nc cixl` vhpheplne% Pbh fn`| lz vh$hehvglzh` oe` zkle lz ihcp zlik| zncp oe` zdnnpb%
Vhjnddhe`h`1 6 pvhopdhepz }hv whhk cnv 0 whhkz
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 35/84
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 :8
]hjkcnvpne Jozpih) Zpnehbnxzh Ioeh) ]hjkcnvpne)Pov}nvih|) Jbhzblvh JW3 <PE
Dole Vhjh}plne1 =?26< 63=<:=
Hdoli1 lecnM}hjkcnvpnejozpih%jn%xk www%}hjkcnvpnejozpih%jn%xk
Ilkh xzne cojhfnnk
Cniinw xzne pwlpphv
Soihepleh“z hShepz op ]hjkcnvpne jozpih??pb) ?6pb) ?:pb oe` ?0pb chfvxov| 6=?6
0 jnxvzh joe ihilp gnxvdhp leehv wlpb o glcp cnv |nxv }ovpehv
oe` o giozz nc jbod}ogeh pn pnozp |nxv dhdnvofih hsheleg%
ª0<%== }hv }hvzneª68=%== @leehv) Fh` # Fvhokcozp
p } } }}
O dogljoi injoplne pn z}nli pbop zndhneh z}hjloi%%%
Hrphe` pbh vndoejh wlpb o `o| nc }xvh le`xighejh op
Pvoeqxlilp| Z}o op ]hjkcnvpne Jozpih
Vndhn # Axilhp Soihepleh“z ]ojkogh ª8=%== }hv jnx}ih
Oe Hihdlz fojk) ehjk oe` zbnxi`hv dozzogh pn znnpb owo| phezlne le
}vh}ovoplne cnv o vndoeplj elgbp wlpb |nxv z}hjloi zndhneh% Lejix`hzjbnjnioph bhovpz pn hean| wblizp |nx vhior%
Vndhn # Axilhp Ixrxv| Soihepleh“z ]ojkogh
ª?==%== }hv jnx}ih
Foioejh |nxv jbokvoz wlpb o vhaxsheopleg Le`loe Bho` Dozzogh fhcnvhxewle`leg wlpb oe Hihdlz cojloi pn ihosh |nx wlpb ginwleg zkle cnv |nxv
hsheleg obho`% Lejix`hz jbnjnioph bhovpz pn hean| wblizp |nx vhior%
Axilhp @xn
ª38%== }hv }hvzne
O ixrxvlnxz }h`ljxvh lejix`leg nxv ehw clzb pbhvo}| "n}plneoi, oe` o
giozz nc fxffi| cniinwh` f| Ocphvenne Pho le nxv 6=?= Fvozzhvlh%%%%O`` |nxv Vndhn cnv oe hrpvo ª08%==%%%%
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 36/84
:3 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
Phi1 =?26< 70=?:3 nv slzlp1 vlegwnn`chejleg%jn%xk Ioez`nweh V`) Zpodcnv` Fvl`gh) Povsle) Jbhzphv) JB: 2HI N}he Dne$Cvl 2$8 Zop 2%:=$?%==
DHDFHVZBL] EN% 6==062
… Pvo`lplneoi ]oehiz … Fhz}nkh ]oehiz # Gophz
… @hjnvoplsh ]oehiz … Gov`he # Hepvoejh Gophz
… Ovjbhz # Fhejbhz … @hjkleg # Pldfhv
… Zpneh # Oggvhgoph … Wlvh # Ehppleg
… Hihjpvlj Chejleg … ]olepz # Zpolez
… Gov`he Zbh`z … Pnniz # @L\
… @L\ # Pvo`h zx}}ilhv … Bnvzh # ]hp Cnn`
… Lezpoiioplne Zhvsljh … @hilshv| Zhvsljh
SLZLP NXV ZBN] # LE@NNV ZBNWVNND
JOII CNV O CVHH LEZPOIIOPLNE _XNPHnv HDOLI1 lezpoiioplnezMvlegwnn`chejleg%jn%xk
Hr}hvlhejh` chejhvz # gxovoephh` wnvk
Z]HJLOILZPZ LE CHEJLEG Z]HJLOILZPZ LE CHEJLEG Z]HJLOILZPZ LE CHEJLEG
ZX ]]I\ # LEZPOIIOPLNE ZX ]]I\ # LEZPOIIOPLNE ZX]]I\ # LEZPOIIOPLNE
CNV NS HV 6= \ HOVZ CNV NS HV 6= \ HOVZ CNV NS HV 6= \HOVZ
]vn`xjh |nxv nwe
hehvg| xzleg Zniov
]bnpnsnipolj }oehiz
Vh`xjh pbh odnxep nc
hehvg| |nx ehh` pn
}xvjbozhJiold Chh` le Povlcc cnv
hshv| kWb nc vhehwofih
hehvg| |nx }vn`xjh
Doi}oz fozh` cxii|
ojjvh`lph` DJZ lezpoiihv
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 37/84
Zoine Slh Bolv # Fhoxp|
Ni|d}xz Bnxzh) Blgb Zpvhhp) Poppheboii JB: <]R =?26< 77??:2oe` op?6 Fhod Zpvhhp) Eoepwljb JW8 8II =?67= 3?=::=
www%zoine$slh%jn%xk Ilkh xz ne Cojhfnnk cnv hrjixzlsh }vndnplnez1 cojhfnnk%jnd.zoineslh
Zoine Slh Cojhz Ncc Pbh Jnd}hplplneJnegvopxioplnez pn Aoeh F|veh) Ovp @lvhjpnv nc
Zoine Slh) cnv fhjndleg o cleoilzp le Cojh Ncc
6=?6) o jnd}hplplne pn cle` pbh fhzp dhe'z
zp|ilzpz le pbh XK%
Nvgoelzh` f| Odhvljoe Jvhw) pbh wnvi`“z
iho`leg doexcojpxvhv nc }vnchzzlneoi doih
gvnndleg }vn`xjpz) Cojh Ncc lz o fiojk oe`
wblph }bnpngvo}blj jnd}hplplne zbnwjozleg
pbh iophzp cozblne zp|ihz oe` pbh shv| fhzp le dhe“z gvnndleg%
Pbh Cojh Ncc cleoilzpz }ovp| woz bhi` op Pbh ]nlep le
Doejbhzphv wbhvh Odhvljoe Jvhw }xp ne o `oqqileg
jopwoik zbnw }vlnv pn pbh cleoilzpz fhleg oeenxejh` oe`pokleg pn pbh zpogh%
Le 6=?6) pbh pwhep| XK cleoilzpz wlii opphe` o ixejb op o pn}
Ine`ne shexh wbhvh pbvhh wleehvz wlii fh jbnzhe cnv o pvl}
pn IO wbljb wlii lejix`h o }vnchzzlneoi }bnpn zbnnp wlpb
Odhvljoe Jvhw Cnxe`hv oe` Jvhoplsh @lvhjpnv) @osl`
Vojjxgilo%
Aoeh zol`1 ’L'sh vhoii| hean|h` fhleg o }ovp nc pblz hrjlpleg
jnd}hplplne% Lp'z o gvhop n}}nvpxelp| cnv dh pn zbnwjozh
fnpb pbh blgb zpoe`ov` nc wnvk oe` pbh }ozzlne cnv
bolv`vhzzleg pbop L zbovh wlpb pbh heplvh Zoine Slh phod%—
Odhvljoe Jvhw fvoe` doeoghv Dovk Zbnvvnjk zo|z1 ’Pbh
blgb ihshi nc lephvhzp oe` zpoe`ov` nc hepv| cnv pblz |hov“z
Cojh Ncc vhcihjpz pbh soixh nc hephvleg pblz p|}h nc
jnd}hplplne oe` boz bhi}h` pn hzpofilzb lp oz o clvd clrpxvhle pbh Fvlplzb bolv`vhzzleg owov`z joihe`ov% Nxv
jnegvopxioplnez gn pn oii pbh cleoilzpz oe` wh innk cnvwov`
pn oeenxejleg pbh pbvhh wleehvz le pbh Ehw \hov%—
Pblz lz o phvvlclj vhzxip cnv Aoeh) pbh nei| cleoilzp cvnd o Envpb Whzp zoine%
Hshv|neh op Zoine Slh lz khh}leg pbhlv cleghvz jvnzzh`%
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 38/84
:2 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
JNEGVOPXIOPLNEZ pn pbh cniinwleg 6: \hov ?? zpx`hepz wbn bosh oii zxjjhzzcxii| }ozzh`
pbhlv Zlishv @xkh nc H`lefxvgb Owov` Ozzhzzdhep
hr}h`lplne `hz}lph pbh vnxgb whopbhv/
Hiilh Opklezne) Oiljh Jnr) V|oe Gozkhii) Cvoeklh
Djjvho`|) Zhoe ]ljkhvleg) Odoe`o Snjh)
Oiljh Woizb) Fhopvljh Fhezne) Vhfhjjo Fiogg)
Bo|ih| Fiod}ble) Fhpb Wliklezne) Oihr Oekhvz)
@oe Hsoez) Zldne
Bojkioe`) Wlii Dxezne)
Boeeob Voshezwophv)Oihr Zlejiolv) Ixj|
]nzpihpbwolph) Aodhz
V|`hv) Wlii Jnvihpp$Dnzz)
Hiio Jxeelegbod) Hddo
Nelnez oe` Zod @oih%
POV]NVIH\ BLGB ZJBNNI #
Covhwhii pn ixejbpldh `xn1 DVZ @nvnpb| Fokhv oe` Dvz Jbvlzpleh Bhoih|
fnpb do`h pbh `hjlzlne le Enshdfhv pn vhplvh cvnd pbhlv Dl`$@o| Ozzlzpoep
vnihz ocphv oidnzp := |hovz zhvsljh hojb pn pbh zjbnni% @np oe` Jbvlz bo` pbh
ld}nvpoep vnih nc innkleg ocphv zpx`hepz `xvleg pbh fxz| ixejbpldhz) hezxvleg
pbhlv zochp| oe` whicovh op oii pldhz% @np oe` Jbvlz hean|h` pbhlv iozp `o| le
zjbnni jhihfvopleg wlpb zpocc oe` zpx`hepz oe` fnpb vhjhlsh` inpz nc glcpz)
nwhvz oe` jov`z wlpb gnn` wlzbhz cnv pbhlv bo}}| vhplvhdhep% Fnpb zpoph`
pbop pbh| bo` o inshi| eoi `o| le zjbnni% Pbh }bnpn zbnwz cvnd ihcp pn vlgbp)
Dl`$@o| Ozzlzpoep jniihogxh Glii Gvhgnv|) Jbvlz Bhoih|) @np Fokhv oe` zpx`hepAxzple Zbhhe wbn oizn bhi}z pbh Dl`$@o| phod%
Zlishv zxvslsnvz
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 39/84
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 :<
ZLrPB CNVd JNIIHGH
HLGBPHHE \hov 2 zpx`hepz jnnkh` x} o pvhop le pbhlv lephv$pxpnv jnnk$ncc% Hojb pxpnv gvnx}
hephvh` o phod nc pbvhh zpx`hepz wlpb o zpovphv) dole jnxvzh oe` `hzhvp fhleg ax`gh`% Pbh
zpx`hepz bo` neh "bhjplj/, bnxv pn jvhoph pbhlv jxileov| jvhoplnez oe` pbhe cojh` o pnxgb
ax`gleg }oehi nc Dz Ihh) Bho`phojbhv) Dv Exppoii) Ozzlzpoep Bho`phojbhv) Dvz @hebod)
Phojbhv oe` Dvz Blii) Zjbnni Vhjh}plnelzp%
Pbh vhzxipz whvh1
Nshvoii Wleeleg Pxpnv Phod1 2OW
Wleeleg zpovphv1 ]ho vlznppn wlpb o vnjkhp zl`h zoio` "Iliilh Boii,
Wleeleg dole1 ]bhozoep wlpb jovvnp }xvhh) bndhdo`h jbl}z oe` woiexp zoio` "Zod
Vnfhvpz,
Wleeleg `hzhvp1 Dhip$le$pbh$dl``ih jbnjnioph }x``legz wlpb soeliio ljh jvhod "Vojbhi
Nshv|,
\nxeg hephv}vlzh1 aXzp lz o ehw jnd}oe| le
Pov}nvih| fhleg n}hvoph` oz }ovp nc \nxeg Hephv}vlzh%
Z}neznvh` f| Boii Ilshzh| Fvnwe) Ojjnxepoepz) pbh
jnd}oe| wlii znne fh fvlegleg o voegh nc ghizklez cnv
hihjpvnelj hsljhz%
Pbh lphdz wlii fh zni` op Pov}nvih| Blgb Zjbnni oe` op
Pvo`h Colvz ovnxe` pbh Envpb Whzp% Lc |nx wnxi` ilkh
pbh jnd}oe| pn slzlp |nxv injoi fxzlehzz zn pbop |nx
joe zhh zndh nc pbh odoleg lphdz ne zoih }ihozh
jnepojp Dlzz Oilzne Wo`h op Pov}nvih| Blgb Zjbnni ne=?26< 7:6882
Dovkhp zxjjhzz
PBH zjbnni“z oeexoi
Jbvlzpdoz Dovkhp volzh`
ª66==% Pbhvh whvh 66
hrphveoi zpoiiz zhiileg o
sovlhp| nc jvocpz oe` glcpz
wbljb ovh o }n}xiov o``lplne
pn pbh pvo`lplneoi zpoiiz oe`
vhcvhzbdhepz vxe f| phojbhvz)
zx}}nvp zpocc oe` dhdfhvz nc pbh Bndh Zjbnni Ozznjloplne%
Wbop“z jnnkleg>
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 40/84
OJJL@HEP # FN@\
VH]OLV Z]HJLOILZPi := \hovz Hr}hvlhejh
i ]hvchjp Jninxv Dopjbleg
i Oii Doanv # Dlenv Wnvk Xe`hvpokhe
i_xoilp| ]iozplj Fxd}hv Vh}olvz
i Jnxvphz| Jovz Osoliofih
i Jniihjplne # @hilshv|
iNshe Fokh Clelzb cnv oii Shbljih Vh}olvz
Phi =?<62 727227www%a}wfn`|vh}olvz%jn%xk
Dhhpleg Bnxzh Ioeh) Klegzih| WO3 3P]
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 41/84
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 0?
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 42/84
06 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
Oshexh Fxli`legz) Blgb Zpvhhp Pov}nvih| Jbhzblvh JW3 =OQ
Phi1 =?26< 7::::2
Wh joe `hoi wlpb oii |nxv ihgoi vhqxlvhdhepz le o cvlhe`i| oe` }vnchzzlneoi doeehv zxjb oz1
i ]vn}hvp| pvoezojplnez fnpb Vhzl`heploi oe` Jnddhvjloi
i Iozpleg ]nwhvz nc Oppnveh| oe` o`slzleg pbh Hi`hvi|
i@lsnvjhi Hd}in|dhep Dopphvz lejix`leg Jnd}vndlzh Ogvhhdhepz
i Ilplgoplne
Wb| `ne“p |nx joii xz ne =?26< 7::::2 nv hdoli xz op vqMblffhvpz%jnd pn
ovvoegh oe lelploi cvhh jnezxipoplne wlpb hlpbhv Vljbov` _xhvhiih
nv Anbe @vlshv pn `lzjxzz |nxv le`lsl`xoi vhqxlvhdhepzCnv |nxv nwe jneshelhejh bndh slzlpz ovh osoliofih op en hrpvo jnzp
Joii Vljbov` op |nxv injoi Iho`leg
Iow Clvd Blffhvpz II]ne =?26< 7::::2pn ovvoegh oe o}}nlepdhep
Ehh` o zniljlpnv>
Pbhe jndh oe` zhhBlffhvpz) neh nc Jbhzblvh“z
iho`leg iow cvdz bhvh nePov}nvih|“z Blgb Zpvhhp
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 43/84
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 0:
www%oghepz0x%jn%xk
2OD ‚ 2]D HSHV\ @O\
=?3=3 2<6:::
Lz pblz |nxv Hzpoph Oghep>
Enp oii oghepz ovh pbh zodh%
JOII
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 44/84
E
nvdoE vzh e` cli| bsh hjhepi| pkhe sh pbh Lpile hzpxepJblzple“z le P}ih| Blgb Zphhp%
Pbh vzh cli| bsh fhhe le pbh hzpxep fxzlehzz c e| |hz) e` bsh whipb c jphleg e` hzpxep hr}hlhejh) z |x je fh zzxh` c e hrjh}plei `leleg hr}hlhejh%
Pbh| bsh `hjph` e` cxii| hcxflzbh` pbh i`hzpxep) e` cch e| Lpile z}hjlilplhz%
Jblzple“z lz jxhepi| le lpz ?=pb |h c p`leg% Wlpb}h}ih pshiileg c e` wl`h p slzlp xz) wh zplsh p
}sl`h zhezh c Lpile wpb x}e lsi phpleghsh| jxzph z }p c pbh cli|%
Pbh hzpxep bz whii kewe h}xpple c zhsleg pbhehzp iihp zphokz ovnxe` oe` oizn cnv nxv pvo`hdovk `lzb
‒Gfz Jblzple“z ieg wlpb x }l e` }zp egh wbljb lz jezlzphepi| xpb wphleg%
Wlpb pbh zh pw jbhcz c phe |hz wbljb zh wxi`z| lz xebh` c le jphleg) wh pblsh e ehw l`hz wlpb
`li| z}hjliz e` cxii i jph hex $ wbljb |x wlii e` ne pblz whfzlph%
Wh }l`h xzhishz eqxilp|) jiheilehzz) sixh c eh| e`
jezlzphej|%
Z wbhpbh |x“h
pblekleg c hic pw }p| c 8= }h}ih bhh pJblzple“z wh je jph c ii |xehh`z%
Wh ncchv oe hovi| flv` dhex)cvnd 8%:=}d pn 3%:=}d) oe` opokhowo| zhvsljh cnv }lqqo }ozpohpj) whhk`o|z pli ioph) Zop pli 7}d
Joii oe` zhh wbop“z ehw) |nx wne“p fh `lzo}}nleph`
Zhihj ph` `lzbhz
Jbh c “ z z}hjloi1 Clih p pn
Z pvn goen c c
Z p v l } z n i ih p fhh c o
dh ` l e j n g e o j o e `
d x z b v n n d z o x jh zh v sh `
w l p b i n e g g v o l e v l jh
Godfo zJbvl z ploen “ z
K l e g } v o w e z o e ` ] o v
d o b o d) j n n k h ` l e g o v i l j)
z } v l e g n e l n e z) w b l ph w
l eh j vh o d z o x jh w l p b o
b l e p n ih d n e% N x v z }
h j l o i l p |
Po gilo phiil Cvx p pl `l Dovh
K l e g } v o w e z) z j o i i n }
z) z d n k h ` z o i d n e) g o
v i l j)
j b l i i l) w b l ph w l eh o e `
p n d o p n z o x jh
Joi qneh Joveh
C n i `h ` } l q q o f o k h ` w
l p b f n i n g eh zh) f o j n e
)
j b n v l q n o e ` d x z b v n n
d z
Ehw cojhz) zodh cofxinxz cnn`op Jbvlzploen“z Lpoiloe vhzpoxvoep
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 45/84
@hoiz1Hovi| Flv` dhex8%:=}d $ 3%:=}d whhk`o|z
Pokh owo|z Oii whhk xepli ioph # Whhkhe`z fhcnvh 7}d
N}heZxe`o| 81:=}d ‚ <1==}dDne`o| Jinzh`Pxhz`o| 81:=}d ‚ ?=1==}d
Wh`ehz`o| 81:=}d ‚ ?=1==}dPbxvz`o| 81:=}d ‚ ?=1==}dCvl`o| 81:=}d ‚ ?=1==}dZopxv`o| 61==}d ‚ ?=1==}d
Jnepojp1 =?26< 7::2::37 Blgb zpvp) Pv}nv) Jbblv) Jw3=@]
%jbvlplen%jn%x
Ilkh xz necojhfnnk1
Cxii| vhcxvflzbh`Lpoiloe vhzpoxvoepncchvleg oehrjh}plneoi
`leleghr}hvlhejh
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 46/84
03 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
?3? Ineg Ioeh) X}pne) Jbhzphv% JB6 ?AC
BO]]\ EHW \HOV
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 47/84
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 07
Wliiz) pvxzpz oe` }vnfoph
Codli| oe` `lsnvjh
Zhiileg nv fx|leg|nxv bndh
]hvzneoi leaxv|
Jileljoi ehgilghejh
Jvldh oe` `hchejhvh}vhzhepoplne
Hd}in|dhep
@lz}xph vhznixplne
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 48/84
02 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
Oeghio Fovpihpp lz o blgbi| qxoilch`
O`soejh` Ohzpbhpljloe wlpb oidnzp :=
|hovz nc hr}hvlhejh le pbh fhoxp| oe`
bnilzplj le`xzpvlhz% Zbh lz o @lvhjpnv oe`
Lddh`loph ]ozp Jbolvdoe cnv FOFPOJoe` JLFPOJ% Bhv hr}hvplzh lz joiih` x}ne
pn hrodleh Eoplneoii| oe` Lephveoplneoii|
oe` pn ax`gh jnd}hplplnez zxjb oz
\nxeg Dokh$x} Ovplzp nc pbh \hov Owov`
op Jinpbhz Zbnw) Ine`ne cnv 6=?=%
Zbh lz oizn o vhgxiov jnepvlfxpnv pn o
sovlhp| nc jnezxdhv dogoqlehz oe`
pvo`h anxveoiz le pbh bhoipb oe` fhoxp|
zhjpnvz% Oeghio boz o fhoxp|) gvnndleg
oe` whiifhleg jilelj op pbh Wli` Fnov Bnphi) ehov Pov}nvih|%
_% L zxcchv cvnd fiojkbho`z oe` bosh fhhe pni` pn
osnl` ‒jndh`nghelj“ legvh`lhepz% Wbop ovh pbh|
hrojpi|>
O% Lp do| zxv}vlzh |nx pn kenw pbop enp oii legvh`lhepz
lejix`h` le zndh zkle jovh }vn`xjpz ovh pn fhehp |nxv
zkle fxp ovh pbhvh pn }vn`xjh o }ihozleg }vn`xjp wbhe|nx zdhii lp nv phzp lp ne pbh fojk nc |nxv boe`/ Zndh
legvh`lhepz ovh kenwe pn joxzh jneghzplne oe` ovh
phvdh` ‒jndh`nghelj“ wbljb dhoez ‒fiojk$bho` cnvdleg“)
pblz lz fo` ehwz lc |nx zxcchv cvnd fiojkbho`z) n}he
}nvhz nv zkle jneghzplne% Oiwo|z innk cnv
}vn`xjpz pbop zpoph pbh| ovh ‒ene$jndh`nghelj“
oe` op pbh legvh`lhepz iofhi% Cnv dnvh
lecnvdoplne ne pbh dnzp jnddne fiojkbho`
cnvdleg legvh`lhepz slzlp pbh Aoexov|
ehwzihpphv }ogh nc nxv whfzlph
www%oeghiofovpihpp%jn%xk
_% Bnw ineg joe L khh} o zkle jovh
}vn`xjp fhcnvh lp gnhz ncc nv fhjndhz
leojplsh>
O% Bnw doe| nc xz bosh aovz oe` pxfhz nc
xexzh` nv n}heh` }vn`xjpz le nxv jx}fnov`z
oe` wne`hv lc pbh| ovh zplii nk pn xzh> _xlph
o chw/ Lc pbh }vn`xjp lz xen}heh` innk cnv
pbh zdoii N}he$Aov z|dfni wbljb wozo`n}ph` le Hxvn}h le 6==:% Pbh z|dfni wlii
fh ojjnd}oelh` f| o ]hvln` Ocphv N}heleg
"]ON, exdfhv wbljb wlii zbnw pbh exdfhv
nc dnepbz o }vn`xjp joe fh xzh` fhcnvh
`lzjov`leg% Pblz lz xzxoii| fhpwhhe ?6 oe`
60 dnepbz% Le o``lplne pn pbh ]ON pbhvh wlii
ncphe fh oe hr}lv| `oph cnv oe| }vn`xjpz wbljb
ovh jiozzh` oz Nshv$pbh$Jnxephv "NPJ, @vxg
cnvdxioplnez) pbhzh lejix`h zxezjvhhez oe`
zndh oepl$fojphvloi ojeh cnvdxioplnez% Pblz lz
lvvhz}hjplsh pn wbhpbhv pbh }vn`xjp boz fhhen}heh` nv enp% Bn}h pblz bhi}z/
bhoipb # fhoxp|wlpb Oeghio Fovpihpp
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 49/84
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 0<
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 50/84
8= Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
JXVPOLEZ i FILE@Z i WOII]O]HV i]NIHZ i PVOJKZ # OJJHZZNVLHZ
Lc |nx ovh innkleg cnv l`hoz) zp|ih) leensoplne) qxoilp|) jnd}hplplsh }vljhz)
fojkh` f| oe hrjhiihep vh}xpoplne cnv nshv := |hovz) pbhe ]O\ XZ O SLZLP
jxvpoleznc cvn`zbod
Zpnjklzp nc oii doanv zx}}ilhvz1
Jvnwzne i Bovihqxle i Wlidoe iZoe`hvzne i ]vhzplglnxz
%%%pn eodh o chw
?===“z nc cofvljz pn jbnnzh cvnd%
Sljpnvlo Boii) Cixle Ioeh) Cvn`zbod) WO3 7_B
✃ =?<62 7:?8=2
N}he Dne ‚ Cvl <‚8) Zop <$?6
Dhozxvleg oe`lezpoiioplnezhvsljh
ZO I H
E N W N E
/
C O E
P O Z P L J
N C C H V
Z
N E J
X V P O L
E Z
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 51/84
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 8?
P b n x z o e z n c z o d } i h z
p n
j b n n z h c v n d /
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 52/84
86 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
PND Fvxjh dxzp bosh pblgbz nc
zphhi ocphv jnd}ihpleg o eleh$
dnepb vnxe` pbh wnvi` flkh pnxv /
Pnd) 60) zhp nxp le Dovjb pn j|jih
6:%=== dlihz ovnxe` pbh wnvi` le
ol` nc pbh jbovlp| ZNZ Jbli`vhe“z
Sliioghz% Pbh cnvdhv Pov}nvih| Blgb
Zjbnni zpx`hep zhp ncc cvnd blz
]hjkcnvpne bndh fhcnvh bho`leg
ncc ojvnzz doleioe` Hxvn}h% Blz
anxveh| zow bld pvoshi pbvnxgb
Cvoejh) Zwlphvioe` oe` Ghvdoe|)
pn pbh @oexfh Vlshv oe` pbh Fiojk
Zho% Cvnd pbhvh bh j|jih` pbvnxgb
Fxigovlo) Pxvkh|) Ghnvglo oe`
Ohvfolaoe pn pbh Joz}loe Zho) wbljb
bh jvnzzh` pn Kookbzpoe%
O ineg jvnzzleg nc pbh Kookb
Zph}}h oe` pbh Kovokoi}okzpoe
`hzhvp jvnzzleg fvnxgbp bld pn
Xfhklzpoe% Ehrp x} woz pbh blgb
oiplpx`h ]odlv Blgbwo| le Poalklzpoe
oe` K|vg|zpoe% Pbhe lepn Kookbzpoeogole fhcnvh o pwn dnepb jvnzzleg
nc Jbleo pbvnxgb Rleaoeg }vnslejh)
oineg pbh Gvhop Woii pbvnxgb leehv
Dnegnilo pn Fhlaleg%
Cvn ]hjknvpne pn pbh ]
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 53/84
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 8:
ojlcj1 Pn“z h}lj flkh pvl}Ocphv Jbleo) bh pnnk o lgbp
ojvnzz pbh ]ojlj pn Envpb
Odhvljo wbhvh bh j|jih` cvndZoe Cvoejlzjn pn Cinvl`o slo
Joilcnvelo) Ehso`o) Ovlneo)
Ehw Dhrljn) Phroz) Oiofodo)
Dlzzlzzl}}l%
Pnd) wbn lz pbh zne nc Pov}nvih|
G] @v Aojklh Gvlce) bn}hz pn
bosh volzh` dneh| cnv ZNZ
Jbli`vhe“z Sliioghz) wbljb lz pbh
iovghzp nv}boe oe` ofoe`neh`
jbli`vhe“z jbovlp| le pbh wnvi`%Pbh| }vnsl`h o bndh cnv dnvh
pboe 72)=== jbli`vhe le 8==
xelqxh Jbli`vhe“z Sliioghz le ?60
jnxepvlhz%
N}}nzlph }ogh1 Pnd ihosleg
]hjkcnvpne oe` le Hozphve Hxvn}h
Ofnsh1 Pnd ofnxp pn ihosh Hxvn}h
Fhinw) ihcp1 Fhh zplegz pnnk pbhlv pnii
Fhinw) vlgbp1 le Jbleo
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 54/84
80 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
DNVH pboe 8= zpx`hepz cvnd ]nleph Wnvkz Foiihp Zjbnni pnnk }ovp le Vn|oi Ojo`hd| Foiihp
hrodleoplnez op Pbh Ahzzlh Bxgbhz Sliiogh Boii le Hopne%
Oe hrodlehv pvoshiih` cvnd Ine`ne pn wopjb pbh jbli`vhe }hvcnvd pbhlv foiihp oe` woz
shv| ld}vhzzh` wlpb pbh cojlilplhz le pbh ehw boii% Hojb zpx`hep boz z}hep o |hov zpx`|leg
pbh z|iiofxz cnv hojb gvo`h oe` boz wnvkh` hrpvhdhi| bov` pn }hvchjp fnpb phjbelqxh oe`
}hvcnvdoejh% Pbh }vh$}vldov| gvnx}z hephvpoleh` pbh hrodlehv wlpb pbhlv lephv}vhpoplne nc
‒Pbh Expjvojkhv“ wblih pbh }vldov| jbli`vhe zbnwh` ncc pbhlv fnxejleg foii `oejh%
Pbh zpx`hepz wlii vhjhlsh jhvpljophz oe` dh`oiz wbhe pbh vhzxipz jndh pbvnxgb le Aoexov|%
Nwehv nc ]nleph Wnvkz) Eljniih Blgglez zol`1 ’Hrod hepvlhz pblz |hov whvh `nxfih pbop nc
iozp |hov wbljb lz cofxinxz% Pbh jbli`vhe `l` o coepozplj anf) zbnwleg pbhlv shv| fhzp wnvk
pn oe hrodlehv wbn bo` oizn zpx`lh` wlpb pbh Vn|oi Foiihp) zn eghvz jvnzzh` cnv oenpbhv
jvojkleg zhp nc vhzxipz%—
Cnv cxvpbhv lecnvdoplne ne ]nleph Wnvkz foiihp jiozzhz slzlp www%}nlephwnvkz%jn%xk
Pbh jbli`vhe le pbh }bnpn cvnd ihcp pn vlgbp ovh1 Odhilh) Oflgoli) Bovvlhp oe` Hslh oiiogh` zlr%
Glviz le zph} nv hrod zxjjhzz
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 56/84
@nxgioz Bnxzh) ??7 Cnvhgoph Zpvhhp) Jbhzphv) JB? ?BH
Codli| Iow
Wliiz # ]vnfoph
]hvzneoi Leaxv| Le`xzpvloi @lzhozh
Dnsleg Bndh
Dh`ljoi Ehgilghejh
Vno` Pvocclj Ojjl`hepz Jnddhvjloi Iow
CVHH CLVZP
JNEZXIPOPLNE
ZODH @O\
VHZ]NEZH
Nilshv # Jn Zniljlpnvz lz o pvo`leg eodh nc Nilshv # Jn Zniljlpnvz Ildlph`) o ildlph` jnd}oe| vhglzphvh le Hegioe` oe` Woihz "vhglzphvh exdfhv =7=:0038, wbljb lz oxpbnvlzh oe` vhgxioph f| bh Zniljlpnvz Vhgxioplne Oxpbnvlp|) vhc en% 8::307% ¬ Jn}|vlgbp 6=?? _xoilp|Zniljlpnvz Nilshv # Jn
Codli|dopphvz>
\nxv Jbnzhe Iow clvd le pbh Jbhzphv ovho
Clrh` Chh @lsnvjhGhp o`sljh oe` ozzlzpoejh cvnd nxv hr}hvp codli| iow|hvz wlpb
en bl``he jnzpz/ Joii xz pn`o| ne =?600 :?6 :=3
Nv slzlp nxv whfzlph www%nilshvoe`jn%jn%xk
_xoilp| Zniljlpnvz Nilshv # Jn ovh `lcchvhep% Wh }vndlzh1
EN BL@@HE
JNZPZ
@LVHJP IOW\HV
JNEPOJP
Codli| vhoii| `nhz dopphv% Zn wbhe lp jndhz pn dokleg
`hjlzlnez ofnxp |nx nv |nxv codli|“z cxpxvh dokh zxvh
|nx ghp pbh vlgbp o`sljh cvnd hr}hvp codli| iow|hvz
_xoilp|Zniljlpnvz Nilshv # Jn%
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 57/84
O CVHH DHOI LE PBH IOEG@OIH VHZPOXVOEP
Vhjhlsh o cvhh hsheleg dhoi cnv neh }hvzne le pbh Ioeg`oih Vhzpoxvoep
wbhe |nx `leh pwljh pbvnxgbnxp Aoexov| nv Chfvxov| 6=?6%
Zxfahjp pn osolioflilp| "Dne`o| pn Pbxvz`o| nei|,%Hrjix`leg Foek Bnil`o|z% Ncchv hr}lvhz :=pb O}vli 6=?6 oe` joe enp fh xzh` wlpb oe| npbhv ncchv% Pblz snxjbhv
boz en dnehpov| soixh% Pblz snxjbhv dxzp fh dheplneh` wbhe pbh fnnkleg lz do`h oe` dxzp fh }vhzheph` pn pbh
vhjh}plne phod ne ovvlsoi%
CXII OCPHVENNE PHOCNV 0 ]HN]IH
WLPB O GIOZZ NC FXFFI\ CVND NEI\
ª?8%== ]HV ]HVZNE
OE@ VHJHLSH O JND]ILDHEPOV\ BHOIPBJIXF ]OZZ
Fnnklegz dxzp fh do`h le o`soejh) zxfahjp pn osolioflilp|%Pblz snxjbhv boz en dnehpov| oe` joe enp fh xzh` wlpb oe|
npbhv ncchv%
Pblz snxjbhv dxzp fh dheplneh` wbhe pbh fnnkleg lz do`h
oe` dxzp fh }vhzheph` pn pbh vhjh}plne phod ne ovvlsoi%
Npbhv ncchvz osoliofih) }ihozh jnepojp vhjh}plne%
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 58/84
82 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
CNNPFOII POIK%%%POV]NVIH\ SLJZ CJ
POV]NVIH\ Slj“z Clvzp
Phod vhdolez vnnph` pn pbh
cnnp nc pbh Jbhzblvh ihogxh
@lslzlne Neh pofih ocphv
inzleg oii pbvhh godhz le pbhiozp dnepb% Pbh vhpxve pn pbh
zqxo` nc zndh codlilov cojhz)
lejix`leg Jvolg ]bhioe #
Oihr Dnnvh bosh ld}vnsh`
pbh ihshi nc }hvcnvdoejh oe`
do`h pbh godhz dnvh hshe
bnwhshv pbh iojk nc gnoiz lz
pbh dole vhozne cnv pbh pbvhh
`hchopz% Pbh godhz ogolezp
Gvhheboiiz$]o`goph) @hepneoe` Dl``ihwljb zow Pov}nvih|
Sljz nei| zjnvh pwn gnoiz wlpb
pbh gnoiz ogolezp odnxepleg
pn zhshe%
Ne o }nzlplsh enph Zphsh
Iin|`“z npbhv cnnpfoii
doeoghvloi vnih) oz jnojb
nc pbh Jbhzblvh Ihogxh
vh}vhzhepoplsh zl`h) lz
zplii }vngvhzzleg whii% Pbhzl`h jvxlzh` pbvnxgb pn pbh
_xovphv Cleoiz nc pbh Eoplneoi
Ihogxh Jx} ocphv `hchopleg
o Jodfvl`ghzblvh Ihogxh
vh}vhzhepoplsh zl`h ?$= op
Wlppne Oiflne“z gvnxe`) wlpb
pbh phod lejix`leg Eljk
Ofzne oe` Oi Vnwepvhh le
pbh zpovpleg hihshe% Pbh| wlii
enw cojh hlpbhv pbh Dl`ioe`Jndfleoplne Ihogxh nv
Ilejniezblvh Jnxep| Ihogxh
le o ’Ehw \hov— rpxvh cnv
o }iojh le pbh Zhdl Cleoi%
Gnn` ixjk pn Zphsh oe` oii pbh
}io|hvz) hz}hjloii| pbnzh cvnd
Pov}nvih|) oz pbh| vh}vhzhepJbhzblvh le pblz }vhzplglnxz
jnd}ihplne%
Pov}nvih| Sljz Vhzhvshz
bosh dnsh` x} lepn zlrpb
}nzlplne le pbh Jvhwh #
@lzpvljp Jndfleh` Ihogxh
ocphv bosleg wne neh oe`
`vowe neh ihogxh godh le
pbh }hvln`% Pbh Vhzhvshz
whvh `hchoph` 6$? le pbhIhogxh Jx} f| Vx`bhopb
Znjloi Clvzp Phod%
Pov}nvih| Slj“z shphvoe“z
zl`h ’Pbh ]io|fn|z— zbnwh`
o ’Wvhrbod Hihshe— pbh
wo| pn gnoi oz pbh| wne
??$: vhjhepi|% Pbh godh
lejix`h` pwn bop$pvljkz oe`
Pov}nvih| hi`h` o zpvneg
zlrphhe doe zqxo`% Ehwz nc pbh zxjjhzzhz lz z}vho`leg)
oe` vhqxhzpz ovh jndleg le
cnv dnvh godhz/ Wh ehh`
dnvh }io|hvz pn cojlilpoph
pbhzh vhqxhzpz oz neh godh
o dnepb lz oii zndh nc xz joe
doeogh) pbhvhcnvh oe| ’Nshv
:8“z— wbn coej| pxveleg nxp le
’Fixh # Fiojk— }ihozh `n enp
bhzlpoph pn jnepojp nxv ’Gocco—Zhoe Po|inv ne =728823:<72/
Gnn` ixjk pn oii nc pbh
zqxo`z oz wh hephv Aoexov|
oe` pv| pn bhi} pbh Clvzp Phod
pn zhjxvh @lslzlne Neh zpopxz%
Pboekz pn hshv|neh wbn wozlesnish` wlpb Pov}nvih| Sljz
nshv pbh }ozp pwhish dnepbz)
hz}hjloii| pbh doeoghdhep
jnddlpphh oe` z}neznvz
wlpbnxp wbnzh zx}}nvp oe`
eoejloi ozzlzpoejh Pov}nvih|
Sljz wnxi` enp jneplexh pn
nxvlzb%
6=?6 }vndlzhz pn
fh o z}hjloi |hov cnv Pov}nvih| Sljz
oe` oe| ehw bhi}
wlii fh whijndh` oz
wh innk pn cxvpbhv
`hshin} n}}nvpxelplhz
cnv hshv|neh pn }io|
Cnnpfoii wlpble nxv
Sliiogh
]io|hvz“ vhpxve oliz pn zphdpbh pl`h nv vnjk fnppnd Slj“z
Cnv cxvpbhv lecnvdoplne
ne pvoleleg nv
z}neznvzbl}
n}}nvpxelplhz }ihozh
slhw nxv whfzlph
pov}nvih|sljz%jn%xk%
Nv hdoli xz op lecnM
pov}nvih|sljz%jn%xk%
\nx joe oizn fhjndh o
Cojhfnnk ’Cvlhe`— nc
Pov}nvih| Sljpnvlo CJ
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 59/84
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 8<
Pbh ?zp Pbxvz`o| nc hojb dnepb
0%:=}d $ 3%:=}dop pbh Pov}nvih| Jnddxelp|
Jhepvh) Blgb Zpvhhp
CVHH
IHGOI JILELJ
op Pov}nvih|
Wh ncchv gxl`oejh ne oii
ovhoz nc Iow) lejix`leg
Jlsli Iow Jnddhvjloi Iow
Jnesh|oejleg
Jnxvp nc ]vnphjplne
Jvldleoi Iow
Hd}in|dhep Iow
Codli| Iow
]hvzneoi Leaxv| Whicovh Vlgbpz
Wliiz oe` ]vnfoph
En o}}nlepdhep ehjhzzov|
Jbhzphv Wvhrbod Gvhzcnv`
Ehwgoph Woik ?= Gvnzshenv Vno` Pbh NccljhPbh ]vhjlejp Wvhrbod Whzpne BnxzhJbhzphv JB? ?AX II?? ?Z@ Gvhzcnv` II?6 2HE=?600 :?6?33 =?<72 6<?=== =?600 :?6?33
www%oiilegpnebxgbhz%jn%xk
]ihozh enph pbh jilelj lz pn ncchv cvhh lelploi ghehvoi o`sljh nei| oe` o}}nlepdhepz wlii pokh o}}vnrldophi|
?8 dlexphz%
Lc lddh`loph ojplne nv cxvpbhv wnvk lz vhqxhzph`) wh joencchv |nx o}}nlepdhepz op nxv Jbhzphv) Wvhrbod nv
Gvhzcnv` nccljhz%
Ehrp Jilelj lz ne
Pbxvz`o| 3pb
Njpnfhv
Ehrp jileljz ne
Pbxvz`o| 8pb Aoexov|
Pbxvz`o| 6e` Chfvxov|
www%oiilegpnebxgbhz%jn%xk
Jbhzphv
6 Sljovz Ioeh
Jbhzphv JB? ?_R
=?600 :?6?33
Wvhrbod
?= Gvnzshenv Vno`
Wvhrbod II?? ?Z@
=?<72 6<?===
Lc lddh`loph ojplne nv cxvpbhv wnvk lz vhqxhzph`)wh joe ncchv |nx o}}nlepdhepz op nxv Jbhzphv nv
Wvhrbod ncjhz
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 60/84
3= Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
]hphv Wliilz boz kle`i| zx}}ilh` xz wlpb zndh slepogh }ljpxvhz cvnd blz hrphezlsh
ovjblsh%
Ofnsh1 Zp Bhihez Jbxvjb) Pov}nvih|) gov`he }ovp| wlpb pbh @neh Vnnd le pbh
fojkgvnxe`
Fhinw1 ]nvpoi Vh` Jvnzz Bnz}lpoi xzh` `xvleg Wnvi` Wov Neh oe` woz pbh
cnvhvxeehv nc pbh Pov}nvih| Jnppogh Bnz}lpoi%
Pbh wo| wh whvh
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 61/84
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 3?
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 62/84
36 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
Woep pn zhh |nxv }vn}hvp| chopxvh` le
Pov}nvih| Poik> Joii =?3=3 2<6:::
Oe ofznixphi| jbovdleg : fh`vnndh` zhdl`hpojbh` jnxepv| jnppogh zlpxoph` le pbh dl`zp nc
@hiodhvh Cnvhzp% Nnleg wlpb jbovdoe` jbovojphv oe` wlpb doe| nvlgleoi
chopxvhz) pblz lz o vovh jboejh pn fx| zxjb o xelqxh }vn}hvp|% Hr}nzh` fhodz) zpvl}}h` wnn`he `nnvz) oen}he cvh }iojh oe` o ing fxveleg zpnshjvhoph o jnz| lephvlnv heslvnedhep wblizp pbh Cnvhzp lpzhic jvhophz o fhoxplcxi eopxvoi fojk`vn}%
Vnzh Foek Jnppoghz)Fiokhdhvh Ioeh)Envih|) Jbhzblvh)
WO3 3EZ
: Fh` Zhdl$@hpojbh`
ª66<)<8=
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 63/84
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 3:
Lp“z ehshv pnn ioph pn ihove/NI`HV }hn}ih ovh cozp fhjndleg oz whfzoss| oz phlv |nxeghv jnxephv}ovpz% Ojjnv`leg pn `opo cvnd pbh Ncjh cnv
Eoplneoi Zpoplzpljz "NEZ,) le ph |hov 6===) axzp ??( nc neh }hvzne nxzhniz "nshv phzpoph }hezlneofih ogh, o Lephvehp ojjhzzoe` enw pbop gxvh zpoe`z op oidnzp 0=() wlp ph oshvogh odnxep nc pldh z}hep neph Lephvehp) fhleg :: nxvz }hv whhk ‚ oenxv dnvh poe oe| nphv ogh gvnx}%
Nihv }hn}ih ovh enw enp nei| xzleg phLephvehp oz o vhznxvjh) fxp oz oe hzzheploijnddxeljoplne pnni $ wlpb ehovi| neh le sh
nihv Lephvehp xzhvz vhgxiovi| xzleg znjloiehpwnvkleg zlphz zxj oz Cojhfnnk oePwlpphv% Ph hdhvghejh nc Zk|}h oz oizn
o``h` pn pbh lexr nc ni`hv }hn}ih ghpplegneileh) oz ph| lejvhozlegi| xzh ph Lephvehppn khh} le pnxj wlp codli| oe cvlhez%
Plz oz }vnslh o ilchileh pn ph ’Zlishvzxvchvz—) oz ph| ovh occhjplneophi| kenwe) wn ilsh cov owo| cvnd codli| nv wn joeenpihosh phlv ndhz hozli|%
`hz}lph plz shv| }nzlplsh lejvhozh) phvh ovhzplii ehovi| 3 dliilne nihv }hn}ih wn ovhenp |hp neileh% O vhjhep zxvsh| oz znwepop neh le cnxv nc phzh }hn}ih osh zpophpop lp wnxi fh o gnn wo| pn zpo| le pnxjlc ph| whvh) wlj gnhz pn znw pop doe|
zld}i| ne“p kenw whvh pn zpovp nv ovhxehv ph ld}vhzzlne pop lp“z enp cnv phd%
Ofznixph fhgleehvz
\sneeh Jnjkfxve) Jhepvh Jn$nvleopnv op Ogh XK Jhzlvh“zJnd}xphv Jhepvh zol1
’Doe| }hn}ih plek pop ph|“vh phnei| nehz wn ne“p kenw nw pnxzh o jnd}xphv oe oz joe fh zhhe
cvnd ph zpoplzpljz pop“z zld}i| enpph jozh% Wh z}hjloilzh le phojlegofznixph fhgleehvz $ pnzh wn oshehshv fhcnvh zwlpjh o jnd}xphv ne$ oe phzh }hn}ih ovh enw fvnwzlegph Lephvehp) hdolileg cvlhez oecodli| oe xzleg Zk|}h% Lp vhoii| lzehshv pnn ioph pn ihove—
Ogh XK Jhzlvh“z Jnd}xphv Jhepvhle bovpcnv ncchvz hshv|neh nshv
ph ogh nc 8= ph n}}nvpxelp| pnihove jnd}xphv zkliiz% Lp }vnslhzneh$pn$neh pxlplne cnv ofznixph fhgleehvz) neh$ncc zhzzlnez pn vhslzhoe jnezniloph fozlj jnd}xphvzkliiz oe zdoii gvnx} jiozzhz leZk|}h oe `lglpoi ]npngvo}|% Phjnxvzhz ovh }xvhi| ihoveleg$fozhoe phvh ovh en phzpz lesnish%
Cnv dnvh lecnvdoplne ne Ogh XK
Jhzlvh“z Jnd}xphv Jiozzhz) joii=208 3?2 6282
EHW \HOV) EHW ZKLIIZJnxvzhz cnv pbh nshv 8=z
JND]XPHV ZKLIIZ
Jnd}xphv Le`xjplne cnv Ofznixph Fhgleehvz
"lejix`leg Lephvehp oe` hdoli,
Zk|}h) `lglpoi }bnpngvo}b|) `lglpoi h`lpleg)
hFo| "oe` npbhv pn}ljz ne vhqxhzp,
Hr}hvlhejh` pxpnvz
Cvlhe`i|) whijndleg opdnz}bhvh
Le`lsl`xoi pxlplne nv zdoii gvnx} jiozzhz
Ofznixph fhgleehvz ovh shv| whijndh
IOEGXOGHZ # IHLZXVH
Cvhejb) Ghvdoe) Lpoiloe oe` Z}oelzb)
Wophvjninxv }olepleg # codli| blzpnv|
@NE“P @HIO\) JOII PN@O\
Ogh XK Jbhzblvh“z Ihoveleg Jhepvh) Bovpcnv`
Phi =2083 ?2 62 82
www%oghxkjbhzblvh%nvg%xk
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 64/84
Glii phojbhz vhgxiov wleh pozpleg jnxvzhz oe` lz pbh nwehv nc Helgdo Wleh) o wleh
pozpleg hshepz jnd}oe| fozh` le pbh blzpnvlj jlp| nc Jbhzphv% Cnv cxvpbhv `hpoliz zhh nxv
whfzlph www%helgdowleh%jn%xk ]vljhz.osolioflilp| ovh enp gxovoephh`
Wleh poikwb G ejn) cvnd hgd W
PBLZ dnepb L“ii fh vhjnddhe`leg pbvhh wlehz pbop ovh hrjhiihep soixh cnv dneh|)hz}hjloii| wbhe ne ncchv oe` pbhvhcnvh }hvchjp cnv Aoexov| wbhe dneh|
lz plgbp ocphv pbh nshvle`xighejh nc Jbvlzpdoz # Ehw \hov%
Pbh Ngln ]vldlplsn cvnd Phzjn "xzxoii| ª2%<< fxp ncphe pn fh cnxe` ne ncchv op
ª0%<<, lz cvnd o vhglne joiih` ]xgilo le pbh znxpb nc Lpoi|% O bnp Dh`lphvvoehoe
jildoph }vn`xjhz pblz zncp hoz|) `vlekleg vh` wlpb blepz nc z}ljh) jnjnexp oe`
cnvhzp cvxlpz ne pbh enzh wbljb lz cniinwh` pbvnxgb ne pbh }oioph wlpb whii
foioejh` poeelez oe` zndh d|zphvlnxz `vlh` cvxlp jbovojphv% O znnpbleg vh`
wleh pbop lz }hvchjp wlpb o zhihjplne nc Lpoiloe jni` dhopz) jbhhzh #
nilshz) axzp pn vhdle` xz nc pbnzh wovdhv dnepbz pn jndh%
Oenpbhv nc d| cosnxvlph gvo}hz lz pbh Oifovlen gvo}h cvnd
pbh jnnihv }ovpz nc envpb whzphve Z}ole oe` envpbhve ]nvpxgoi%
Zolezfxv|“z Pozph Pbh @lcchvhejh Oifovlen lz o ghd op ª7%<< "ncphe cnxe`
ne ncchv cnv ª3%<<, lc |nx“vh innkleg cnv zndhpbleg o flp `lcchvhep pn pv|%
Pblz lz oe ovndoplj) }hojb| }hvcxd| wblph pbop boz osnxvz nc cvhzb
cvxlpz) hz}hjloii| }leho}}ih
oe` jlpvxz ne pbh }oioph% O
inshi| cvhzb zp|ih nc wblph pboplz pvo`lplneoii| }olvh` wlpb
zhocnn`) zn wb| enp pv| lp wlpb o jbliil
}vowe ilegxleh nv o zld}ih }ozpo zoio` wlpb
}hzpn oe` }vowez%
Cleoii| L“` ilkh pn vhjnddhe` zndhpbleg
pbop }hn}ih ovh oiwo|z o flp ehvsnxz pn pv|
oe` pbop lz o `hzzhvp wleh% Pbh boic fnppih
nc Jnejb \ Pnvn ioph bovshzp Zoxslgene
Fioej lz ihzz pboe o shv lc |nx fx| dnvhpboe pwn Jblihoe zplii wlehz cvnd Doahzplj
pnghpbhv% Gni`he |hiinw le jninxv wlpb o
ixzjlnxz) z|vx}| phrpxvh) pblz wleh boz
ovndoz vhdlelzjhep nc vl}h pvn}ljoi cvxlpz oe`
o bneh|h`) |hp cvhzb }oioph% Oe hrjhiihep
lepvn`xjplne pn `hzzhvp wleh oe` whii wnvpb
pbh vlzk/ L insh pblz wlpb jovodhilzh` cvxlpz
oe` ljh jvhod }oejokhz/
p% =?600 :7= 2<2d% =7<30 822 08:h% lecnMhelgdowleh%jn%xkw% www%helgdowleh%jn%xk
Jnv}nvoph oe` }vlsoph wleh pozpleg hshepzHean| o giozz nc wleh oe` wnxi` ilkh pn ihovednvh>Nxv pozplegz ovh cxe) lecnvdoplsh oe` znjlofihhshepz wbhvh |nx ghp pn pozph oe` ihoveofnxp wlehz cvnd oii nshv pbh wnvi`% L`hoi cnv Flvpb`o| }ovplhz) Oeelshvzovlhz) @leehv }ovplhz)Cxe`volzleg) Phod fxli`leg) Zpocc `hshin}dhepoe` Ehpwnvkleg
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 65/84
Flzpvn Fix eh c Jbhh“ fhsh` Chejb oe` Dh`hoehoehooe%
zoh` `we e bh Gsh gb ebh sh wh bosh fhjdh o bdh cho j bdh |h jkeg%
zhsho c hj}hbosh jdh `hj cdjo jbhc `eg doe| |ho c osh%
xeg chb bhf oe`
jo| jh` }`jh jhoh oegh c ho jeeheocosnxvz zhvsh` le o jozxoi |hp}cheo wo|%
Flzpvn Fix op Pbh Codnxz Fixh Dnne) 6: Pbh Gvnshz) Jbhzphv JB? ?Z@
AOEXOV\ Z]HJLOI DHOI @HOI
Flheshexh í Jbhzphv“z Flzpvn Fix
=?600 :6602?
www%flzpvnfix%jn%xk
ENW FNNKLEG CVND 8pb AOEXOV\
6 JNXVZHZ CNV NEI\ ª?6%<8
]IXZ FNPPIH NC BNXZH WLEH ]HV JNX]IH
OII ELGBP PBXVZ@O\) CVL@O\) ZOPXV@O\
CVND 8%:=}d
Zpovphvz
Znx} `x anxv
Dnxihz Dovlelhvh"ª? zx}}ihdhep,
]oph wlpb vnozph` vh` nelnedovdoio`h
Jbhc“z Bod Phvvleh
@hsliih` Wblphfolp
Wovd Fojne # Fiojk ]x`$`leg Zoio`
"S, Vnozph` Vh` ]h}}hv #Gnop“z Jbhhzh Vlznppn
Dole Jnxvzhz
Clzb Pldfoihz Cliihph` oe` nshe fokh` le wleh oe`jvhod) pn}}h` wlpb zdnkh` Zoidne
Zov`leloe Clzbhvdoe“z Jozzhvnih ‚ Cvhzb bhvfz)Ihepliz) Pndopnhz) Govilj) Clzb # Zhocnn` ‚ do`hpn o injoi czbhvdoe“z vhjl}h ‚ pblz fhojb$zl`h dhoiwnvkz o pvhop ne o jni` wlephv hsheleg/
]nxihp i“hzpvogne $ Povvogne Jbljkhe ‚ wlpbzboiinpz oe` cvhzb povvogne le wblph wleh oe`jvhod zoxjh
Jnq ox Sle ‚ jndfleleg fxppne dxzbvnndz) vh`wleh) govilj) }oejhppo zboiinpz) bhvfz # fvoe`|)ghepi| fvolzh` xepli zxjjxihep oe` phe`hv
Fhhc Cioddoe`h Jiozzlj Cvoejn$Fhigloe wlephv dhoi $ jnnkh` le Ihcch Oih wlpb zboiinpz oe`wlephv shghpofihz
]nvj ]vnshejoi jnnkh` le wleh wlpb cvhzb bhvfz)nvoegh hzp # expdhg ‚ o Cvhejb wlephv wovdhv/
Wli` Fnov # Shelzne Fxvghv pn}}h` wlpb zdnkh` fojne # jbhhzh
Zlvinle Zphok wlpb o jbnljh nc zoxjhz ‚ ox }nlsvhnv @loeh ª:%8= zx}}ihdhep
"S, : Jbhhzh z}ljh` joffogh # o}}ih Whiilegpne
Osoliofih Cvl`o|) Zopxv`o| # Zxe`o| Ixejbpldh f| vhzhvsoplne
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 38
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 66/84
33 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
G N“Ehlii Ioe`zjo}hzFinjk }osleg) Povdoj Zpneh hpj)
]oplnz) ]opbz ]osh` hpj%
Povdoj oe` Finjk ]osleg Vhensoph`Ozk cnv `hpoliz
Joii Ghncc ne =7<8 76? 3=38 . =?<62 7667==Jnd}hplplsh }vljhz% Cvhh hzpldophz) en nfilgoplne
Pneeh Fog nc IngzNei| ª0=
@hilshvh` cvhh wlpble
?= dlihz nc Pov}nvih|
Vleg =7772 2=80=0
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 67/84
Pb Fiiz Bo`Jinppne
Pbh Fxiiz Bho`) Pov}nvih| Vno`) Jinppne) JW 3 =HG=?26< 72?22?
_xlq elgbpHshv| Dne`o| <}d zpovpCvhh zeojkz% ª? }hv hepv|
Wleeleg phod pokhz oii
Jnxepv| # WhzphveHshv| npbhv Zxe`o| 2}d $ cvhh hepv| Zxe ?8pb Aoe1 Fnf DnvgoeZxe 6<pb Aoe1 ]oxi Po|inv
]vlqh FlegnHshv| npbhv Pxhz`o| :v`) ?7pb # :?zp Aoexov| H|hz `nwe 7%:=}d
Ig vh o` ijoi Vhoi Oihz) Clh Wlhz o` hrjhiih soih h$jkh` c`
ne : PSz
]Ihep| dnV h jbnljh O s O lIO fIh
Innk nxp cnv `lcchvhep cnn` ncchvz oii pbhpldh% Cnn` zhvsh` Wh`ehz`o|$Zxe`o| A O ex OV | z]hjl OI nCChV
Ne oii fnnkh` pofihz fx| neh dolejnxvzh oe` vhjhlsh o zhjne` neh cnvboic }vljh "dle 60bv enpljh osoliofih Wh`)Pbxv)Cvl) jbho}hv dole jnxvzh boic }vljh,% A O ex OV | b O]] | bnxV dne$pbxV 8]d$7]d
Coepozplj ncchv ne o wl`h zhihjplnenc `vlekz%
z p ov p hvz
Bndhdo`h bod bnjk phvvleh z
hv sh` wl pb o
zoio` govelzb oe` fvnwe pnoz p
Fiojk }x``le g oe` zdnkh` fo
jne z pojk pn}}h`
wl pb o qxoliz h g g oe` zhv sh`
wl pb o jvxz p| vnii
Bndhdo`h bo``njk oe` zoidne czbjokhz
zhv sh` wl pb zoio` govelzb
d olezZinw jnnkh` io
df bhev| zhv sh` wl pb vnzhdov|
dozbh` }n po pn) sh gh pofihz oe
` gvo s|
O pvln nc vnzh c ovd zoxzo ghz z
hv sh` wl pb
dozbh` }n po pn) sh gh pofihz oe
` nelne gvo s|
Ciokh` }nojbh` zoidne zhv sh`
wl pb fnlih`
qxoliz h g gz oe` }liox vljh oe`
pn}}h` wl pb o
pbol jvhod| zoxjh
Boe`do`h shelzne fxv ghv zhv
sh` wl pb boe`
jx p jbl}z oe` zl`h zoio`
pvo`lloi qoil| bh jkh` C`
E \ov $ Ehw DhEx/
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 68/84
30 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2
FNPPHGO) Pov}nvih| oe`
Jiolvh Bnxzh Jbli`vhe“z
Bnz}ljh wnvkh` pnghpbhv
wlpb vhpolihvz ne Pov}nvih|Blgb Zpvhhp le o qxhzp pn
volzh henxgb dneh| pn
}vnsl`h Jbvlzpdoz ixejbhz)
`hjnvoplnez oe` jvojkhvz
cnv oii pbh jbli`vhe op Jiolvh
Bnxzh Bnz}ljh%
Pov}nvih| zbn}z oe`
vhpolihvz `neoph` o sovlhp|
nc }vn`xjpz) gnn`lhz oe`
snxjbhvz pn jvhoph oe
odoleg Jbvlzpdoz Bod}hv
pbop woz voch` ncc pbh whhk
fhcnvh Jbvlzpdoz%
Zod Fvlgbpdnvh) nwehv nc
Fnpphgo zol`1 ’Jiolvh Bnxzh
lz oe lejvh`lfih jbovlp|
bhi}leg fnpb jbli`vhe wlpb
ilch ildlpleg }vnfihdz oe`
pbhlv codlilhz% Wh ovh zn
hrjlph` pbop wh joe dokh o
`lcchvhejh%—
Ofl Zdlpb cvnd Jiolvh
Bnxzh anleh` le pbhchzplslplhz) o``leg1 ’Enp
nei| wlii pbh dneh| volzh`
fh o bxgh bhi} cnv xz oe`
nxv jbli`vhe fxp wh ovh
oizn hrjlph` ofnxp goleleghr}nzxvh cnv Jiolvh Bnxzh le
pbh Pov}nvih| ovho%—
Npbhv vhpolihvz wbn pnnk }ovp
whvh1 Jovoe @“Ojbh) Cniilhz)
Bhihe Sheofihz ]bnpngvo}b|)
Elen Kl`z) En%77 Lephvlnvz)
]lzph Wleh Fov) Zbnh Zbojk)
Zkle @hh}) Pov}nvih| @L\) Pbh
Flv`jogh Joch oe` Wopzne
W|eeh Bolv`vhzzleg
Ofl Zdlpb "Bho` nc Cxe`volzleg cnv Jbhzblvh,) Sljpnvlo Fhff "]V Doeoghv cnv Fnpphgo,
oe` Zod Fvlgbpdnvh "Nwehv nc Fnpphgo,
Pvo`hvz bhi} jbli`vhe“z bnz}ljh
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 69/84
BNdH Ld]VNSHdHEPZ OE@ ZHVSLJHZ
CIOWIHZZJIHOELEG JND]OE\
Ihp xz glsh |nxv bndh pbh Ciowihzz celzb
Pvxzpwnvpb|) vhilofihfhz}nkh jihoeleg
Hzp% nshv ?= |hovz
Joii =?26< 63?66:nv =7<=<3<0:76
DNIH JNEPVNILejix`leg vopz oe` dljh
Ogvljxipxvoi zliogh jvn}z pn zdoii iowez
D%O%C%C% pvoleh`
Oizn ghehvoi gov`he wnvk xe`hvpokhe
Joii ]blil}
=?26< 70=:2= nv =77033 0228?
FXEFXV\ ]VN]HVP\
DOLEPHEOEJHFvljkwnvk vh}olvzHrphveoi }olepleg
]oplnz) chejleg hpj
Nshv 68 |hovz hr}hvlhejh
Jnepojp ]oxi
Phi =?26< 63=<78
Dnf =72?0 0=:07<
]xvh Jihoe Zhvsljhz "EW,Wle`nw Jihoehv
Injoi }vnchzzlneoi oe`
vhilofih zhvsljh
Vhojb ‒e“ Wozb z|zphd
jihoez bov` pn vhojb
wle`nwz) cozjloz) zlgez) x]SJ
Cxii| lezxvh`1 dhdfhv nc pbh
Ch`hvoplne nc Wle`nw Jihoehvz
]bneh ]bli ne =776:0<2:::nv =?26< 63=836
]loen Ihzznezfhgleehvz pn o`soejh`
@o|pldh z}ojhz cnv o`xipz
i Ojjnd}oeldhep cnv hrodz.}hvcnvdoejhi GJZH oe` O ihshi zx}}nvp wnvk cnv dxzlj
oe` dxzlj phjbening|i Iovgh zpx`ln oe` wolpleg vnnd zlpxoph` ehov
Pov}nvih|
Jnepojp =7<6 ?8? 6=?< Oe`vhw Zpovdhv
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 3<
i Ehw Fxli`z i Hrphezlnez
iOiphvoplnezi Jnezhvsopnvlhz
iWle`nwz i ]ioez @vowe
Cxii| lezxvh` oe` gxovoephh`
Phi =7<=2 =83:22
=72<< 78:3=3
Fxli`leg
# Anlehv|J#G
DV Ohvloiz Ohvloiz) zophiilph z|zphdz)
dxipl zwlpjb z|zphdz) JJPS
@lzjnxepz cnv NO]z)
V@L vhglzphvh`
Cvhh qxnpoplnez
=?26< 77=<87
=72?= 2?2?87
\NX JOE O@SHVPLZH
LE POV]NVIH\ POIK
CNV ª?3 O DNEPB/!!O}}ilhz pn o zdoii fnr o`shvp
Bh`ghz) zbvxfzoe` pvhhz pn}}h`)
pvlddh` # }vxeh` hpj%
Gov`hez jihovh`) `vlshz # }oplnz jihoeh` oe` vhcxvflzbh`%
Cvhh hzpldophz) en nfilgoplne
Phi Ghncc =7<8 76? 3=38nv =?<62 7667==
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 70/84
7= Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
BNdH Ld]VNSHdHEPZOE@ ZHVSLJHZ
]vhzzxvh Wozbleg
Finjk ]osleg Cvlhe`i|
OE@VHW ] @HOE
"@l} EPJ) JGIL) OSJD,
]loen Pxeleg# Vh}olvz
=?26< 63?666
OE@VHW ] @HOE
"@l} EPJ) JGIL) OSJD,
]loen Pxeleg
# Vh}olvz
=?26< 63?666
i Goz Zoch Vhglzphvh`
i Fopbvnndz # Plileg o Z}hjloilp|
i Cnv o Jnd}vhbhezlsh Zhvsljh
KHIZOII WLE@NW JIHOELEG ZHVSLJHZGxpphv jihoeleg # vh}olvz
Woz}z ehzpz zochi| vhdnsh`
Vhojb oe` Wozb Z|zphdcnv bov` pn vhojb wle`nwzJnshvleg |nxv injoi ovho
=?3=3 882?=3
=7233 6?<=80@ndhzplj #
Jnddhvjloi
BOWK HIHJPVLJOI"JBHZBLVH, IP@
@ndhzplj) Jnddhvjloi) Le`xzpvloi
Hihjpvljoi Lezpoiioplne) JJPS
Lezpoiioplne) Lez}hjplne # Phzpleg)
Zhjxvlp| Oiovdz # Ilgbpleg
Phi1 =?<02 23?=:?
Dnflih1 =77=:036=8?6 Jbnvipne Sliioz) Doi}oz) Jbhzblvh) Z\?0 7AA
Sojxxd jihoehv vh}olvzoii p|}hz nc sjxxd jihehvz
zhvsljh` e` vh}lvh`
Cnv |nxv injoi z}hjoilzp jii
=7<7= 3?2:<6}oP Phzpleg |nxv hihjpvlji ilejhz
www%pxzblegbd6%jn%xk
Le`h}he`hep Bnxzhoe` ]hp Zlpphv
Cihrlfih) hr}hvlhejh` oe``lzjvhhp% ]niljh jbhjkh`
# lezxvh` wlpb jbhjkofihvhchvhejhz%
Ihp dh foch pbh fxvgiovzoe` }od}hv |nxv }hpz/
H dffp6:M|obnn%jn%xk nv =7<66 ?=?787
‒ZOCH BNXZH“
\NX JOE O@SHVPLZH
LE POV]NVIH\ POIK
CNV ª?3 O DNEPB/!!O}}ilhz pn o zdoii fnr o`shvp
www%}bnhelrojjnxepz%|niozlph%jndBndh slzlpz hshelegz # whhkhe`z% := |hovz hr}hvlhejh%
Jnd}hplplsh chhz% Cvhh o}}nlepdhep osoliofih
◎ Vhshexh Ojjnxepz ◎◎ Fnnk Khh}leg◎
◎ O`dlelzpvoplne nc Wlii Hzpophz◎
Pn Zosh Pldh # Dneh|Phih}bneh xz cnv oe lddh`loph vhz}nezh
ne =?26< 7:: 886 nv =7<33 0=8 :?0
O codli| vxe fxzlehzzZhvsljleg jilhepz pbvnxgbnxp Jbhzblvh zlejh ?<<0
]bnhelrOjjnxeplegZhvsljhz
’Wh cvhh x} |nxv pldh) zn |nx joe ghp ne wlpb \nxv fxzlehzz/— Cnv oii |nxv Por # Sop Vhpxvez
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 71/84
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 7?
OE@ OIZN NEILEH%%%www%pov}nvih|poik %jn
Oii wnvkdoezbl} pn pbh blgbhzp zpoe`ov`z
i Hehvg| hcjlhepbhopleg z|zphdz
i X}gvo`hz
i Fnlihv jboeghzi Fopbvnndz
ZW Bhopleg # ]ixdfleg Zhvsljhz
]ihozh jnepojp Zpxovp Woii
=7<8? 27= 6:=
=?26< 78? 7<0
Fxli` ]osh #
Zjo}h l il l l ii l ii
li l i l
l
l ii l i l li l l
l
i l ii lil i l
i l ll i i l
i
Hdoli1 lecnMfxli`}oshoe`zjo}h%jn%xkWhf1 www%fxli`}oshoe`zjo}h%jn%xk
Joii =7<7? 82: 3?8 nv =?<72 :??=68C N V O C VHH E N N F I L G O P L N E _ X N P H
Wh z}hjloilzh le pbh lezpoiioplne
nc oii oz}hjpz nc fxli`leg oe`
bov` ioe`zjo}leg oe` bosh
nshv 6= |hovz hr}hvlhejh
Z}hjloilzpz le1
e@vlshwo|z
e ]oplnz
e Pvo`lplneoi Zhpp ]oslegeEopxvoi Zpneh ]osleg
e Finjk ]osleg
e Fvljkwnvk
e Hrphezlnez
e Ioe`zjo}leg
e Gvnxe`wnvkz # @voleogh
Pokh o innk op nxv ehw whfzlph
cnv hrod}ihz nc nxv wnvk
Fxli`]osh #
Zjo}h
Hr}hvp @hh} Jihoeleg
Coepozplj Vhzxipz i Cxii| Lezxvh`
@lvp| Jov}hpz nv Nshe>>
Phi =?600 0<=076
Dnf =7<:3= 3==73
www%jov}hpoe`nshejihoeleg%jn%xk
]bneh =?26< 7:=8<<
cnv o cvhh qxnph
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 72/84
76 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
BNdH Ld]VNSHdHEPZ OE@ ZHVSLJHZ
]K
Phi ]oxi ne =?26< 636070 . =72<0 2776=7Hdoli }%khe`vljkkhe`vljkMfplephvehp%jnd
z ]vnahjp doeogh` cvnd zpovp pn elzbz Pbh blgbhzp zpoe`ov`z le Plilegz Bhopleg) Soishz) Zlekz) Po}z oe` Vo`lopnvzz Oii `ndhzplj }ixdfleg jophvh` cnv z En anf pnn zdoii
]IXDFLEG #
FopbvnnDz
Pvxzp |nxv iowe pn zndhneh wbn jovhz
i Iowe pvhopdhepzi Dnwlegi Gov`he dokhnshv.jihovoejhzi Jbolezow wnvki Oii gov`he wnvk jnezl`hvh`
Dnf =77?77==:?0www%pbhiowegx|%jn%xk
q Lephvlnv q HrphvlnvqWoii}o}hvlegq Boe` ]oleph` Klpjbhezq ]vnchzzlneoi Wnvkdoezbl}
Pi =7<2= ?687?<
nv Eoepwljb =?67= 36<<??www%wo|ehzpnjkpne%jn%xk
Wo|Eh ZPnjkPnE
]oLepHv # @Hjnvopnv
Vh$jnshvleg nv cxii x}bnizphv| nc1
i Pbvhh ]lhjh Zxlphz i ]nxcchz
i Wleg Jbolvz i Jbolzh Inegxhz
i Bho`fnov`z i @leleg Jbolvz
i Cnnpzpnniz oe` dnvh
Phi =?26< 78?<66
Hzp ?<22
\NX JOE O@SHVPLZH
LE POV]NVIH\ POIK
CNV ª?3 O DNEPB/!!O}}ilhz pn o zdoii fnr o`shvp
Bnwov`
oe`hvzne
Cnv oii nc |nxv }olepleg oe`
`hjnvopleg ehh`z%
=?26< 63=08=
=7<32 <=??37
]vn]hvp|
Dolepheoejh
Boe`|doe Zhvsljhcnv pbh injoi jnddxelp|
@nnvz pn cnnvz
Klpjbhez $ Fopbvnndz
]ixdfleg oe` Plileg
]ixz oii |nxv jov}hepv| ehh`z Pldh zhvsh` Anlehv wlpb := |vz hr}hvlhejh
Joii Dovk $ =772:2:2:<0
Hshelegz $ =?26< 7:6 32:
]HVLN@
VHCXVFLZBDHEPZ
Wh ncchv o cxii oe`
hrphezlsh voegh nc
fxli`leg zhvsljhz
z}hjloilzleg le pbh
jovh) dolepheoejh oe`
x}gvo`hz nc ilzph` oe`
}hvln` }vn}hvp|%
=?600 0:<2=3 "nccljh,
=7738 727880
www%}hvln`vhcxvflzbdhepz%jnd
Ghvdoe # Cvhejb
Neh pn neh pxlplnele |nxv nwe bndhIneg hr}hvlhejh op
O) OZ oe` GJZH Ihshizf| qxoilclh`
bnenxvz gvo`xoph
Phi =?26< 7::727
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 73/84
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 7:
OE@ NEILEH%%%
www%pov}nvih|poik %jn
O#A ]o|eh]v n}hv p|]vn}hvp| Dolepheoejh
oe` Vh}olv
e`| ]o|eh
Clppleg klpjbhez)
fopbvnndz) fh`vnndz
Io|leg wnn`.plih cinnvz
]olepleg oe` @hjnvopleg
Gov`he DolepheoejhPhi1 =?26< 786:20
Dnf1 =7<28 <8288:
H$doli1 }o|eh}vn}hvp|Mflgcnnp%jnd
Jlp| # Gxli`z qxoilch`% Hzp ?<26
]iozphvleg Znixplnez
Phi =?26< 786?60 . =7<?0 :3=27:
\nxv injoi) pldh$zhvsh` pvo`hzdoe
Vh$zkldz) Zklddleg)
Vhe`hvleg) @v| Ileleg)Jnsleg) Cinnv Zjvhh`z
Ghehvoi Vh`hjnvoplne # Plileg
i Pn} Znli # Pxvc Zx}}ilh` oe` Iol`
i Z}nli vhdnsh` f| zhic$ino`leg gvof wogne $
JBHO]HV PBOE ZKL]Z
i Ioe`zjo}leg @hzlge # Fxli`
i Ioe`zjo}leg Dophvloiz.@hjnvoplsh gvoshiz.zioph hpj
i Oii zx}}ilh` innzh nv le axdfn fxli`hvz fogz
i Voegh nc dlel `lgghvz # `xd}hvz osoliofih
i Fhzp }vljhz oe` qxljkhzp `hilshv| le pbh ovho//
Phi =?600 :0:=0:
www%gvofoe`zblcp%jn%xk Cnv @lzjnxep ]ihozh _xnph @]O@WLE???6
Zpnvogh cvnd ª8 }hv whhk
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 75/84
JIXFZ OE@ ZNJLHPLHZKhizoii Gov`heleg Jixf
Ne Pxhz`o| ?=pb Aoexov| pbh jixf wlii bni` pbhlv OGD) niinwh` f| Dovzboii V|`hv“z
}vhzhepoplne ’Dnvh Gov`hez—) op pbh Dhpbn`lzp Zjbnnivnnd op 7%08}d% Ene dhdfhvz shv|
whijndh) ª6 ne pbh elgbp% Cxvpbhv lenvdoplne }ihozh jnepojp Aoeh Fhopplh ne =?26< 78?=86
X:OWh zpovp pbh Ehw \hov wlpb @nxg Bo|ehz glsleg o poik ne Pbndoz Fvozzh| pbh odnxz voliwo|
heglehhv wbn woz fnve op Fxhvpne) Ev Jbhzphv) ne Pbxvz`o| ?<pb Aoexov| op pbh Fovfnxv
Lezplpxph op 6}d% Cvhh vhvhzbdhepz% Ehw dhdfhvz whijndh
Poppheboii Wli`ilh Gvnx}Nxv ehrp dhhpleg lz le 6=?6 ne Wh`ehz`o| 0pb Aoexov| op 7%:=}d le pbh Fovfnxv Lezplpxph% Ehli
Cvlzwhii wlii fh glsleg oe liixzpvoph` poik heplpih` ’@ovphvz) Bowkhvz) oe` Jbozhvz—%
Poppheboii Gov`heleg Znjlhp|Wh wlii fh zpovpleg pbh Ehw \hov wlpb ‒Gvnwleg # Xzleg Wliinw oe` bosh o gn op wliinw whosleg“ f|
Vljbov` An|ezne ne Wh`ehz`o| ??pb Aoexov| op 7%08}d le pbh Fovfnxv Lezplpxph% Vljbov` wlii phojbxz bnw pn whosh o zdoii lphd oe` fvleg }bnpngvo}bz oe` zod}ihz n wliinw wbljb bh gvnwz oe`
xzhz bldzhi% Ehw dhdfhvz whijndh% Dhdfhvzbl} lz ª?= nv zlegih oe` ª?8 nv anlep dhdfhvzbl}%
Plshvpne @lzpvljp Gov`he Jixf Pxhz`o| Aoexov| :v` op Plshvpne Sliiogh Boii) Bxrih| Ioeh "axzp nc O0<, op 2}d% Zpovp pbh Ehw \hov
wlpb o poik vnd neh n nxv osnxvlph z}hokhvz) Dv @osl` Jxddlegz) wbn wlii zbnw zil`hz oe`
phii xz ofnxp pbh ’Wli`ilh oe` Zjhehv| n pbh ]hdfvnkhzblvh Jnozp—% Hepv| ª?%8= "dhdfhvz,) ª6
"slzlpnvz,) lejix`leg voh oe` vhvhzbdhepz% Oii ovh whijndh%
Poppheboii WL
O Cxe _xl ne Dne`o| :=pb Aoexov| op 7%:=}d le pbh Fovfnxv Lezplpxph% Phodz n x} pn nxv% Pljkhpz ª3 hojb pn lejix`h wleh oe` gnn` nn` wlpb o ‒Fvlplzb Pbhdh“ ovh osoliofih vnd ‒Sliiogh
Gvhhez“ oe` =?26< 77?:0<% Innk nxp nv }nzphvz le pbh sliiogh% Hshv|neh shv| whijndh%
Povsle dhhpleg ]nlep nvhvi| Povsle Wnhe“z Vhglzphv
Dhhpleg ne oiphveoph Pbxvz`o|z le dhdfhv“z bndhz pn `lzjxzz o wl`h voegh n pn}ljz) fnpb
ilgbp$bhovph` oe` zhvlnxz% Cnv xvpbhv lenvdoplne jnepojp Zxh Bov`ojvh ne =?26< 70?<36%
]hjknvpne # Fhhzpne WLNxv @hjhdfhv dhhpleg lejix`h` o zhjne` slzlp vnd @l Dopbhv wbn pblz pldh z}nkh
ofnxp ‒D| Ilh le Phihslzlne“% @l hr}ioleh` pbop zbh bo` zpovph` bhv jovhhv le `vodo
zjbnni le Ilshv}nni fxp bo` `hjl`h` pbop bhv nvph woz le bhv z}hokleg snljh oe`pbxz hshepxoii| nxe` bhvzhi wnvkleg nv OPS oz oe oeenxejhv% Zbh boz ih` oe
lephvhzpleg ilh oe` bhv zkliiz bosh fhhe xzh` le o sovlhp| n wnvk) lejix`leg pbh dnvh
vhjhep wvlpleg oe` }xfiljoplne n jbli`vhe“z fnnkz%
@hpoliz n pbh Ehw \hov“z ixejb op pbh Dlii}nni vhzpoxvoep ne Aoexov| ??pb whvh glshe oe` eodhz
n pbnzh lephvhzph` pokhe%
Wh jhihfvoph` Jbvlzpdoz ne @hjhdfhv <pb wlpb o }ovp| bhi` le pbh Sliiogh Boii wbhvh dhdfhvz
oe` pbhlv gxhzpz whvh zhvsh` dxiih` wleh niinwh` f| o 6 jnxvzh `leehv%
Pbhvh lz en dhhpleg le Aoexov| fxp le Chfvxov| wh ovh innkleg nvwov` pn ihoveleg ofnxp pbh
Oihroe`hv Phjbelqxh wlpb Axilo Wnn`doe%
Wh dhhp ne pbh vzp Wh`ehz`o| n hojb dnepb le ]hjknvpne Sliiogh Vnndz op 7%:=}d% Ehwdhdfhvz ovh oiwo|z whijndh%
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 78
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 76/84
POV]NVIH\ JNddXELP\ JHEPVH
Fnnklegz.heqxlvlhz1 =7863 3<<?==
hdoli pjjfnnklegzMoni%jn%xk
Whhki|
… Ovd| Jo`hpz1 Pxhz`o| oe` Pbxvz`o| op 7}d
… Vb|pbd Pldh "dxzlj cnv xe`hv 8z,1 Dne`o|
cvnd <%68od%Phi Axilo ne =772<23782<
… Wophvjninxv ]olepleg1 Wh`ehz`o| <$??od #
??%?8od$?%?8}d
… Zjnpplzb @oejleg1 Hshv| Wh`ehz`o| 7 pn ?=}d
… Clpehzz1 Fn`| Jne`lplneleg1 Dne 3108}d
… Clp 0 Ilch ‚ Clpehzz jiozz cnv pbh dopxvh io`| 1
Cvl`o| <1?8od
… Hean|$o$Foii Jiozzhz1 Wh`ehz`o|z $ }vh$
zjbnni pn |hov 6+ jbli`vhe% Jnepojp Zbovne ne
=7<:6 ?26?02 cnv pldhz
… Vn|oi Ojo`hd| nc @oejh Jbli`vhe“z Foiihp
Jiozzhz $ Dne`o|z 0}d plii 3}d "phvd pldh nei|,
… Foiihp $ Jbli`vhe1 Pbxvz`o|z 8%:= $ 7%:=O`xip1 Cvl`o| ?? $ ?6% Jnepojp Eljniih Blgglez ne
=7<== :=:<33 nv eljniihM}nlephwnvkz%jn%xk
… An Alegihz1 Pxhz`o| dnvelegz% Joii Hsh ne
=?<62 7:<<33 hshko|==7M|obnn%jn%xk
… Pbh Jvhoplne Zpoplne $ Wh`ehz`o|z 1 Fof|
@lzjnshv| ?=1:=) Ilppih Hr}invhvz% ??1:=% Jnepojp
Ile`zo| ne =200 280 <=<8
Qxdfo
Qxdfo Clpehzz wlpb Elkkl Gnn`vljb Cvl`o| ?$6}d%
Iople$zp|ih `oejh ohvnfljz% Oii pehzz ihshiz
whijndh% Phi =773 87? ?::7 . =?26< 70= 0:8
Qxdfo Jiozzhz $ Pbxvz`o|z 2}d% Joii =7<73
=27<0< www%jvhwheoepwljbxdfo%jnd
Dnepbi|1
… Cinwhv Jixf1 ?zp Pxhz`o| nc pbh dnepb op
?%:=}d
… PO@@COZ1 6e` Pbxvz`o| nc pbh dnepb op
?%:=}d
\NXPB JIXFPOV]NVIH\ \nxpb Jixf dhhpz le pbh Jixf
Vnnd) enw kenwe oz pbh Jvoshe Vnnd)
"hepvoejh cvnd jov }ovk, hojb Dne`o| cvnd
7$< }d pbvnxgbnxp pbh |hov "o}ovp cvnd foek
bnil`o|z,% Oghz ?6 pn ?7% Oii whijndh%
POV]NVIH\ GXL@HZJnepojp Dvz ]iopp ne =?26< 72? 072
@neh Vnnd le Pov}nvih|
Pbxvz`o|z 7 $ <}d "phvd pldh nei|,
Cnv glviz ogh` ?= pn ?0 |hovz%
POV]NVIH\ VN\OI FVLPLZB IHGLNE
=?26< 7:683?
Whhki|
Dne`o| $ Flegn 2}d pn ?=}d
Pxhz`o| $ Le`nnv Fnwiz ?%:=}d "fnwiz }vnsl`h`,
Cvl`o| $ Flegn 7%?8$?=}d "]io| pbh Fnov`z/,
Zennkhv Jixf dnzp hshelegz le pbh Fov
Dnepbi|
… Jnxepv| # Whzphve @oejleg1 Hshv| ?zp # :v`
Zxe`o| 2}d pn ??%:=}d… ]vlqh Flegn1 Hshv| :v` Zopxv`o| 7}d
… Io`lhz Zhjplne dhhpleg1 Hshv| 6e` Pxhz`o|
cvnd 7%:=}d
Pn fnnk pbh Ihglne Boii cnv |nxv hshep <od pn
Dl`elgbp) jnepojp =?26< 7:683? nv ihosh o
dhzzogh% Wh wlii oiwo|z ghp fojk pn |nx ocphv
3%:=}d
POV]NVIH\ PHEELZ JIXF
Ehw dhdfhvz whijndh% Cnv cxvpbhv lecnvdoplne
phih}bneh =?26< 7:6=63%
POV]NVIH\
WBOP“Z NE LE\NXV SLIIOGH>
73 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 77/84
POV]NVIH\ OdOPHXV @VOdOPLJ ZNJLHP\
Pbh Znjlhp| }vhzhepz pwn }io|z }hv |hov le
Z}vleg oe` Oxpxde op pbh Jnddxelp| Jhepvh%
]hvcnvdoejhz ovh Pbxvz`o| pn Zopxv`o| zpovpleg
op 7%08}d% Wh ovh oiwo|z ne pbh innk$nxp cnv
ojpnvz.ojpvhzzhz "hr}hvlhejh` nv enp/, oe`
bhi}hvz pn anle nxv bo}}| gvnx}% Wh ovh oii
snixephhvz fxp wnvk bov` wlpb inpz nc cxe/
Lc |nx ovh khhe pn anle) jbhjk nxp nxv whf zlph
wwwpov}nvih|o`z%jn%xk nv lc |nx }vhchv o jbop vleg
Fhv|i nv Pnd ne =?26< 7:6303%
OJPLSLPLHZ LE PBH @NEH VNNd
Pn fnnk joii =?26< 7:6706
Dne $ ]vh$zjbnni $ <od pn :%?8}d
$ Vlzleg 8“z $ ?6%:=}d pn :%?8}d
$ Fvnwelhz $ 3}d pn 7%:=}d
Pxhz $ ]vh$zjbnni $ <%?8od pn :%?8}d$ ]vh$zjbnni $ ?}d pn :%?8}d
Wh`z $ ]vh$zjbnni $ <od pn ??%08od
$ Dnpbhv“z Xelne 6%?8}d "?zp nc dnepb,
$ Po`wogz $ 6%==}d "6e` nc dnepb,
$ Volefnwz $ 0%:=}d ‚ 8%:=}d
$ Fvnwelhz $ 3%==}d ‚ 7%:=}d
Pbxvz $ ]vh$zjbnni $ <od pn :%?8}d
$ ]vh$zjbnni $ ?}d pn :%?8}d
$ Gxl`hz $ 7}d pn <%==}d
Cvl $ ]vh$zjbnni $ <od pn :%?8}d
Zop $ Foiihp) po} # dn`hve$ @oejh $ <%==od pn ?6%:=}d
Zxe $ Zxe`o| Zjbnni $ ?=%==od pn ??%:=od
"Cnv `hpoliz ne ]vh$zjbnni joii =?26< 7:=6::,
POV]NVIH\ dLII]NNI ]VNFXZ JIXF
"=?26< 7:=030,
Jixf nc vhplvh` ]vnchzzlneoi Fxzlehzzdhe%
Dhhp :v` Wh`ehz`o| nc hojb dnepb%
POV]NVIH\ FO]PLZP
# dHPBN@LZP JBXVJB\nxpb Jixf$ Hshv| Wh`ehz`o| 7$<}d
Jbxvjb codli| zhvsljh$Hshv| Zxe`o| ?=%08%
POV]NVIH\ ILFVOV\ =?26< 7:?7<0
Pov}nvih| Jnxelp| Ilfvov|) Blgb Zjbnni
Hopne Vno`
dne 67}; Wh` 68}; Cvl <%:=o?6%:=}
Fnnkz) Poikleg Fnnkz) @S@z) Lephvehp Ojjhzz
Xe`hv 8z Zpnv| Pldh ?=$?=%:=od Cvl`o|z) phvd$
pldh nei|%
Jxzpndhv Ojjhzz Phvdleoi wlpb sl`hn ilek pnJW#J Jnejhzzlneov| Pvoshi # Fixh Fo`gh Phod
Ilfvov| Jov ]ovk wlpb }ovkleg cnv ?= }ixz pwn
`lzofih` z}ojhz
@O\ JOVH1 POV]NVIH\ N]OI
"NI@HV ]HN]IH OP IHLZXVH, JIXF
Cvl`o|z ?=%==od $ :%==}d%
Lc |nx ovh lephvhzph` le anleleg o dhdfhv nv o
snixephhv }ihozh jnepojp ]ovlzb Jiiv Glii Jinxgb
Phi =?26< 7::808 nv pbh Jixf ne =770< ?7< =:=%
POV]NVIH\ FOE@
Pbh foe` dhhpz hshv| Pbxvz`o| 7%:=}d pn <%:=
}d le pbh Foe` Boii axzp ncc Pbh Jinzh op pbh pn}
nc Pov}nvih| Blgb Zpvhhp% Ehw }io|hvz whijndh%
Zhh whf zlph www%pov}nvih|foe`%jn%xk nv joii
=7<06 2?286<%
Z]NVPLEG OJPLSLPLHZ LE POV]NVIH\ BLGB
ZJBNNI
Pov}nvih| Fo`dlepne Jixf
Pxhz`o|z 2$?=}d le pbh dole boii le phvd pldh%
Boic }vljh cnv zpx`hepz% Ehw dhdfhvz # slzlpnvzwhijndh% Cnv dnvh `hpoliz jnepojp Aheelchv =?26<
7:=78?
Pov}nvih| Io`lhz Ehpfoii
M Pov}nvih| BlgbZjbnni) Pbxvz`o|z 2%?8}d$
<%?8}d ª: oii nshv ?3z whijndh% Phi ]l} Wblph
=7276 8:7=83 nv cojhfnnk ’Pov}nvih| Ehpfoii“
EOPLNEOI JBLI@FLVPB PVXZPCvl`o| ‚ EJP Fof| oe` Pn``ihv Gvnx} jncchh
dnveleg% ?=$??1:=od% Le Pbh Fvlplzb Ihglne Boii%
Ihp xz kenw |nxv vhgxiov hshepz oe` wh wlii ilzp lp nv vhh/
Zhe` |nxv ilzplegz pn lenMpov}nvih|poik%jn
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 77
VHGXIOV HSHEPZ
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 78/84
PBH ZPX@LN POPPHEBOII
Fn`| Jnepvni ]liophz) Oihroe`hv Phjbelqxh
oe` Elo $ jiozzhz oe` wnvkzbn}z osoliofih
op Pbh Zpx`ln) Poppheboii% Cxii `hpoliz www%
pbhzpx`lnpoppheboii%jn%xk nv vleg Alii ne =?26<
77?2<8%
POPPHEBOII ILFVOV\ "=?26< 77=73<,
Lp lz zlpxoph` le Pbh Sliiogh Vnnd op pbh ]ovk
]vldov| Zjbnni) Jbhzphv Vno`) Poppheboii oe` lz
n}he ne Pxhz`o|z cvnd 6}d xepli 7}d oe` Cvl`o|z
"6$8}d,% Wh bosh o wl`h voegh nc fnnkz) @S@“z
cnv blvh) o iovgh jbli`vhe“z zhjplne oe` lc wh boshe“p
gnp wbop |nx“vh innkleg cnv wh“ii nv`hv lp cnv |nx%
POPPHEBOII JVLJKHP JIXF
Jnepojp Dhi @nfzne ne =77<< 073 ?=2Ovh |nx lephvhzph` le }io|leg jvljkhp # innkleg cnv o
cvlhe`i| jnd}hplplsh jixf pn anle pblz |hov>
Wh vxe 0 zhelnv phodz oe` 8 axelnv phodz oe` ovh
innkleg cnv ehw }io|hvz nc oii oghz% Oii ehw }io|hvz
whijndh% www%poppheboiijvljkhpjixf%jn%xk
FOVFNXV LEZPLPXPHBlgb Zp) Poppheboii% Oii heqxlvhz.fnnklegz =?26<
77?30< nv hdoli pjoflMplzjoil%jn%xk
Dne`o|
?=od$?6ee X:O Wophvjninxv Gvnx}
6$0}d Poppheboii ]vnfxz Gvnx}
7%:=$<}d \ngo
7%:=}d Poppheboii # @lzpvljp ]ovlzb
Jnxejli "?zp Dne,
Pxhz`o|
<od$3}d JIlJ jnd}xphv jhepvh
<%:=od$6%:=}d Poppheboii @lodne` Jixf?=od$?6enne Jncchh Dnveleg; oii whijndh
6$0}d X:O Ovp # Jvocp Gvnx}
3%:=$7%:=}d Kovoph
Wh`ehz`o|
<od$7}d JIlJ jnd}xphv jhepvh
?=$??od Qxdfo jiozz
3$7}d Qxdfo jiozz
7%08}d Gov`heleg Znjlhp| "6e` Wh`,
7%:=}d W%L% ":v` Wh`,
2}d Zlegleg Gvnx}
Pbxvz`o|
<od$3}d JIlJ jnd}xphv jhepvh
<%:=$??%:=od Woikhvz pn Poikhvz
?6%:=$6%:=}d ]ovhep H` Oeph$eopoi jiozz
"0 whhk finjkz,
6$:%:=}d X:O Injoi Blzpnv| Gvnx}"?zp Pbxvz,
6$0}d PNCZ $ Poppheboii Nshv$Clcplhz
"?zp Pbxvz,
6$0}d X:O dole dhhpleg ":v` Pbxvz,
7%:=$<}d Phrplih Gvnx} "?zp Pbxvz,
2}d ClidMFovfnxv ":v` Pbxvz,
Cvl`o|
<%:=od$??od Jnxepv| Dovkhp
7$?=}d Fvl`gh
Zopxv`o|
<$?=od Poh Kwne @n
??od$?6enne Zbnnpleg Zpovz
POPPHEBOII OdOPHXV @VOdOPLJ ZNJLHP\
Anle o wovd # cvlhe`i| gvnx} $ pn dhhp ehw }hn}ih)
bosh cxe) bhi} wlpb }vn`xjplne $ nv pvho` pbh fnov`z/
Jnepojp =?26< 77?:8: nv 77=026
Wh ovh oiwo|z n}he cnv pbnzh wlzbleg pn anle pbh
}vn`xjplne phod/ Ehw dhdfhvz whijndh%
POPPHEBOII PHEELZ JIXF
Jixf dnvelegz Pxhz`o| ?=od% Jixf hshelegz
Pxhz`o| 3%:=}d newov`z% Wh bni` vhgxiov le jixf
pnxveodhepz oe` hean| zxddhv ihogxh dopjbhz
cnv dnvh jnd}hplplsh pheelz% Jnojbleg lz osoliofih $
jnepojp Zph}bhe Wvlgbp ne =7<03 0<?3<3% Jnepojp
Soi Dhhkz ne =?26< 77=72?%
VXEELEG JIOZZHZPnpoi Fhgleehvz # Lephvdh`lophz Jiozzhz osoliofih%
Pvole cnv |nxv injoi Jbovlp| vojh nv zld}i| hean|
vxeeleg le pbh ioehz oe` hi`z ovnxe` Poppheboii%
Jnepojp1 @osh =7<= ?27 ???3
FNNP JOd]Nxp`nnv jlvjxlp pvoleleg wlpb opplpx`h% <1?8od
Cvl`o|z% Phi @osh Kenpp =?26< 77=:67 nv =7<=
?27 ???3
]OVK ]VH ZJBNNI "=?26< 77?37=,
Zoch) zpldxiopleg oe` exvpxvleg heslvnedhep wbhvh
jbli`vhe joe ihove bo}}li| oe` jne`hepi| pbvnxgb
}io|% Cnv jbli`vhe ogh` 6?.6 pn zjbnni ogh% Wh ovh
zlpxoph` le o jiozzvnnd le Poppheboii ]ovk ]vldov|
Zjbnni% N}he phvd pldh Dne`o| pn Cvl`o| <od$
:}d % Jnepojp Zovob ne 77?37=
POPPHEBOII
72 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 79/84
POVSLE JNddXELP\ JHEPVH
"=?26< 70=232,
Pn``ihv Gvnx} ?=%==$??%:= Dne`o|z oe`
Cvl`o|z
\ngo ?}d Dne`o|z
Povsle Ilfvov| ?6%==$?<%== Pxhz`o|z
?:%:=$?7%== Pbxvz`o|z
Foiihp ?8%:=$?2%== Pxhz`o|z
Ohvnfljz # Fn`| Pneleg ?<%==$6=%== Pxhz`o|z
Zlishv Pbvho`z ?0%== 6e`+0pb
Wh`ehz`o|z nc dnepb
Cinwhv Jixf ?<%:=) 6e` Wh`ehz`o| nc dnepb
W%L% ?<%:=% iozp Wh`ehz`o| nc dnepb
Flegn ?<%:= Pbxvz`o|z
Kxeg Cx ?2%:=$6=%:= Pbxvz`o|zJlslj Pvxzp Vhgxiov dhhplegz.hshepz
BXrIH\ SLIIOGH BOIIBxrih| Sliiogh Boii lz osoliofih pn blvh cnv }vlsoph
cxejplnez) flvpb`o| }ovplhz hpj ª7 }hv bnxv
]ihozh jnepojp Fnnkleg Zhjvhpov| ne
72?83:.72?87: cnv cxvpbhv lecnvdoplne%
POVSLE \NXPB JIXF $ ZJNXPZ
Hshv| Pxhz`o| 7%:=}d xepli <}d%
Zjnxp Bxp op pbh pn} nc pbh}io|leg hi`z le Povsle%
Cnv oghz ?: $ ?7
|hovz ni`% ª63 oeexoi
dhdfhvzbl}%
ILPPIH OJNVEZ EXVZHV\ ]IO\GVNX]
Cxe) ilshi| oe` exvpxvleg }vhzjbnni cnv jbli`vhe
ogh` 6´ pn 8 |hovz op Bxrih| Sliiogh Boii%
Dne`o|z) Wh`ehz`o|z) Cvl`o|z) <od plii :}d
Cvhh pozphv zhzzlnez cnv }ovhep oe` jbli` hshv|
boic$phvd) innk nxp cnv |hvz) }n} le nv }bneh xzne =77<<:<=?63 "`xvleg zhzzlne pldhz,
BXrIH\ ]OVHEP OE@ PN@@IHV GVNX]
=?26< 72?6<3
Bxrih| Zjbnni Boii) Bxrih|% Pbxvz`o|z ?=%:= ‚
?6}d phvdpldh% Cvlhe`i|) whijndleg gvnx} cnv oii
}ovhepz. jovhvz oe` jbli`vhe =$8 |hovz%
Whhki| jvocp oe` zlegleg zhzzlne% ]ihozh jndh
oineg oe` anle xz/ Cnv dnvh `hpoliz jnepojp Bxrih|
zjbnni) =?26< 72?6<3%
POVSLE PHEELZ JIXF =?26< 70?:?0
Wh whijndh ehw dhdfhvz nc oii oflilplhz pn jndh
oe` pv| nxv 0 ovpljloi gvozz jnxvpz%
Le pbh zxddhv dnepbz wh bni` cvlhe`i| jixf
hshelegz ne Pxhz`o|z oe` Cvl`o|z) wblih leoxpxde oe` wlephv pbhzh jixf zhzzlnez zwlpjb
pn Zopxv`o| ocphvennez% Pbhvh ovh zlr phodz
le pbh Jbhzphv oe` @lzpvljp Zxddhv Ihogxh
wbljb le Njpnfhv fhjndh sh phodz le pbh Whzp
Jbhzblvh Wlephv Ihogxh) }ixz pwn phodz le pbh
Gioe Ofhv Cinn`ilp Ihogxh% Pbvnxgbnxp pbh wbnih
|hov cvlhe`i| gvnx}z oizn }io| ne Pxhz`o| oe`
Pbxvz`o| dnvelegz) oe` Pxhz`o|) Pbxvz`o| oe`
Cvl`o| ocphvennez%
Axelnv jnojbleg oe` zhzzlnez pokh }iojh cvnd
Hozphv%Zhh www%povslepheelzjixf%jn%xk nv }bneh Vnf ne
=?26< 70?:?0 nv Khlpb ne =?26< 70=?72%
POVSLE ]VH$ZJBNNI # @O\ EXVZHV\Cvlhe`i|) bndhi|
heslvnedhep cnv jbli`vhe
cvnd pwn |hovz pn zjbnni
ogh% Hrjlpleg ojplslplhz zxjb
oz Cnvhzp Zjbnniz oe`
Cvhejb% N}he phvd pldh
Dne`o| pn Cvl`o| 2od$3}d
Cnv dnvh lecnvdoplne }ihozh vleg I|e ne =?26<
70?=??
ZXEZBLEH @O\ EXVZHV\) POVSLEZxezbleh ]vlsoph @o| Exvzhv| #
]vh Zjbnni
]nni Foek ]ovk) Povsle% Joii
Ilzo ne =?26< 70==33 www%
zxezbleh}vlsoph`o|exvzhv|%jn%xk
POL JBL CNV PBH NSHV 88“Z
Ocphv o zxjjhzzcxi pozphv zhzzlne }vnsl`h` f| OGHXK o vhgxiov whhki| jiozz boz fhgxe ne Pxhz`o|z
6}d ‚ :}d op Bxrih| Sliiogh Boii) Bxrih| Ioeh
JB:<FG% ª:%8= }hv zhzzlne "?= zhzzlnez cnv ª:8,
Oii whijndh% En hr}hvlhejh ehjhzzov|%
Cxvpbhv `hpoliz cvnd Jbvlz B|`he =?26< 72?6<0 nv
OGH XK Jbhzblvh =?600 377777
BOVGVOSH # BXrIH\ BLZPNVLJOI GVNX]
Wh dhhp ne pbh zhjne` Dne`o| nc pbh dnepb
op sovlnxz shexhz le pbh sliioghz) op 7%:=}d% Cnv
cxvpbhv lecnvdoplne jnepojp zxzoeMzdx`gh$bndh%jn%xk
POVSLE # BXrIH\
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 7<
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 80/84
\NGO JIOZZHZAnoe Anehz =?26< 78?06?% Hshv|neh whijndh%
KHIZOII CINWHV JIXF
Dhhpz :v` Wh`ehz`o| le dnepb op 7%:=}d le
pbh Dhpbn`lzp Zjbnnivnndz) Jbo}hi Gvhhe)Khizoii%Cxvpbhv `hpoliz) }ihozh jnepojp Dov|
Boii "Jbolvdoe, =?26< 78??:3 nv Bhihe Zpxffz
"zhjvhpov|, =?26< 786:7<
KHIZOII GNN@ JNd]OELNEZ JIXF
Oe nshv$3=“z Jixf) wlpb o fvno` sovlh` }vngvoddh
$ z}hokhvz) hephvpoledhep) qxlhz) jnojb pvl}z)
dhhpz oiphveoph Pbxvz`o|z op 6$?8}d le pbh
Dhpbn`lzp Jbxvjb boii) Jbo}hi Gvhhe% Pvoez}nvp
joe fh ovvoegh` lc vhqxlvh` $ joii Dov| @lggih
7863=2 nv Ox`vh| ]ovkhv 7866<0%
KHIZOII GOV@HELEG JIXFDhhpz pbh zhjne` Pxhz`o| nc hojb dnepb le
pbh Dhpbn`lzp Jbxvjb Vnndz) Jbo}hi Gvhhe op
7%08}d% Ene dhdfhvz whijndh% Jnepojp Ahee|
Poikz ne =?26< 78<07=
KHIZOII WLKhizoii WL dhhpz ne pbh ?zp Wh`ehz`o| nc pbh
dnepb le pbh Dhpbn`lzp Zjbnnivnnd) Jbo}hi
Gvhhe) Khizoii% Cnv `hpoliz nc pbh }vngvoddh)
}ihozh jnepojp pbh zhjvhpov| ne =?26< 786882 nv
nxv whfzlph www%khizoiiwl%nvg%xk
FOVEH\“Z FX@@LHZ
Cnv Dxdz "nv `o`z) gvoeelhz) jovhvz, wlpb foflhz
oe` }vh$zjbnni jbli`vhe) dhhpz hshv| Pbxvz`o|
dnveleg cvnd ?=od le pbh x}}hv vnnd nc pbh
Dhpbn`lzp Jbxvjb boii) Jbo}hi Gvhhe% ]io|pldh)
zpnvlhz) znegz # jvocpz% Axzp jndh oineg
KHIZOII PHEELZ JIXF
Khizoii boz pbvhh pheelz jnxvpz injoph` fhble`
pbh Jnddxelp| Jhepvh% Pbh jixf boz pwn Io`lhz
phodz }io|leg pbvnxgbnxp pbh |hov oe` o dlrh`
zxddhv phod% Pbhvh lz o jbli`vhe“z jnojbleg
zjbhdh voegleg cvnd axelnv zjbnni ogh pn zlrpbcnvdhvz) pbh ni`hv }io|hvz jnd}ihpleg le pwn
zxddhv ihogxhz% Axelnv jixf elgbp lz ne o Cvl`o|
3$?=}d oe` zhelnv jixf zhzzlnez ne Pbxvz`o|z
cvnd 3%:=}d% Ehw }io|hvz whijndh% Jnepojp pbh
Jovnileh Zphlene =?26< 78?:=2
@\ZIHrLO IHOVELEG
Hcchjplsh oe` hean|ofih jnd}xphv$fozh` ilphvoj|
ihzznez cnv oe|neh wbn zpvxggihz wlpb vho`leg
oe` wvlpleg% 0$7}d hshv| whhk`o|% Fvnjbxvh
osoliofih cvnd Lzofhi DjLep|vh =?26< 786<<0%KHIZOII FOF\ OE@ PN@@IHV GVNX]
Dhhp op pbh Khizoii Jnddxelp| Jhepvh hshv|
Wh`ehz`o| dnveleg `xvleg zjbnni phvd pldh
fhpwhhe ?=od oe` ??%:=od% ª6 }hv codli|% Phi
=?26< 78<:00 nv axzp }n} le
KHIZOII FVL@GH JIXF
Dhhpz hshv| Pxhz`o| oe` Pbxvz`o| op pbh
Jnddxelp| Jhepvh)7$?=}d% Znjloi Fvl`gh cnv
Fhgleehvz.Lephvdh`lophz ne Pxhz`o|z) `x}iljoph
ne Pbxvz`o|z% Jnepojp Eljk Do|hi` ne =?26<$
786?=8%
ZJNPPLZB @OEJLEG
Wh`ehz`o|z 2}d le pbh Jnddxelp| Jhepvh% Axzp
jndh oineg oe` bosh cxe wblih ghppleg pphv/ En
ehh` pn fvleg o }ovpehv% Jnepojp Soi Ovdzpvneg
=?26< 78?237
PLSHVPNE SLIIOGH BOII"Fnnkleg 1 Aoeljh Covvoii $ =?26< 7:6288,
Whhki|
@x}iljoph Fvl`gh1 Joii Ghnvgh Dni|ehxr =?26<
7::<36
Dne`o|z $ 3%:=}d plii ?=}d
Wh`ehz`o|z $ ?%:=}d plii 8}d
Ileh @oejleg1 Jnepojp Wle Fne` ne =?26<
63==2= Pxhz`o|z $ ?=od plii ?6}d
Dnepbi|
@vn} Le Jncchh Dnveleg1 Iozp Pbxvz`o| nc dnepb?=%:=od $ ?6}d "Joii Do`gh Dovzboii =?26<
7:66?7,
PLSHVPNE @LZPVLJP GOV@HE JIXFWh dhhp ne pbh vzp Pxhz`o| nc hshv| dnepb
op Plshvpne Sliiogh Boii "axzp ncc pbh O0<, op 2}d%
Hshv|neh lz whijndh op nxv ilshi| oe` cvlhe`i|
dhhplegz) oe` pn pbh slzlpz le pbh zxddhv zhozne%
Hepvoejh chh lz ª?%8= "ene$dhdfhvz ª6, oe` lejix`hz
o voch oe` vhcvhzbdhepz% Oii heqxlvlhz pn 7::038
"An|jh Bovfnppih) Zhjvhpov|,) nv wb| enp fhjndh
o dhdfhv $ oeexoi dhdfhvzbl} lz nei| ª6 hojb)
wlpb inpz nc o`soepoghz%
PLSHVPNE
KHIZOII
2= Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2 www%pov}nvih|poik%jn
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 81/84
@X@@NE) JINPPNE # BNNCLHI@ WOV
dHdNVLOI BOII
Cnv fnnkleg joii =?26< 72?0<=
@x``ne Pn``ihv Gvnx} $ Hshv| Wh`ehz`o|
"phvd pldh nei|, <%:= $??%:=od
Fnwileg $ Hshv| Wh`ehz`o|"hrjh}p zxddhvpldh, op 7%:=}d
Zhelnvz Khh} p $ Pbxvz`o|z op 6}d pn :}d%
Pofih Pheelz $ Hshv| Dne`o| op 7%:=}d
Dnepbi|
Jncchh Dnveleg $ :v` Pxhz`o| nc pbh dnepb
op ?=%:=od
Wndhe“z Lezplpxph
?zp Pbxvz`o| nc pbh dnepb op 7%:=}d
POHKWNE@N JIXFZ@x``ne # Jinppne Wov Dhdnvloi Boii
Pxhz`o|z 3}d $ 7}d Axelnvz; 7}d $ 2}d O`xipz
Cvl`o|z 8}d $ 3}d Pnpz; 3}d $ 7}d Axelnvz
7}d $ 2}d O`xipz
Khizoii Jnddxelp| Jhepvh
Dne`o|z 7}d $ 2}d Axelnvz.O`xipz
]OSLIILNE
Ohvnfljz1 Dne`o|z <%?8$?=%?8od # Pxhz`o|z
7%:=$2%:=}d
Fn`|$Pneleg Dne`o|z $?=%:=od $ ??%:=od #
7%:=$2%:=}dLe`nnv Fnwileg Dne`o|z $ ?%:=}d
Volefnwz Dne`o|z $ 0%:=}d $ 8%:=}d
Fvnwelhz1
"?zp Fxefxv| ]ojk, Dne`o|z $ 3}d $ 7%?8}d
"6e` Fxefxv| ]ojk, Wh`ehz`o|z $ 8%08}d $ 7}d
Pn``ihv Gvnx} Wh`ehz`o|z $ <%:=od $ ??%:=od
Khh} Clp Pbxvz`o|z $ <%?8od $ ?=%?8od
]liophz1 Pbxvz`o| $ 7%:=$2%:=}d
VN\OI FVLPLZB IHGLNE
Hshv| 6e` Dne`o| op Pbh \hw Pvhh $ 2}d
HOVI\ FLV@Z ]VH$ZJBNNI
Jnepojp1 Bliov| Ovdzpvneg 63=0?=
Dne`o|) Pxhz`o| oe` Pbxvz`o|
Fxefxv| Sliiogh Boii <od$6%8=}d
Wh`ehz`o| oe` Cvl`o|
Fxefxv| Sliiogh Boii <od$?6%:=}d
FXEFXV\ OE@ PLSHVPNE dHPBN@LZP JBO]HIZ
Zxe`o| $ ?=%08od op Fxefxv| hrjh}p pbh ?zp
Zxe`o| op pbh dnepb ?=%08od op Plshvpne # 8pb
Zxe`o| op Zp% Fnelcojh) Fxefxv| op ?=od%
FXEFXV\ ZLEGHVZ
Dne`o|z le phvd pldh ‚ 7%:=$<%?8}d Jbnlv ]vojpljh
op Fxefxv| ]vldov| Zjbnni
FXEFXV\ SLIIOGH BOII
Fx`n Jixf "Axelnvz, $ Pxhz`o|z $ 7}d $ 2}dFo`dlepne Jixf "Zhelnvz, Dne`o|z $ 7}d
Gnn` Jnd}oelnez Zxe # Pbxvz 7%:=$2}d
Gov`heleg Jixf $ :v` Pxhz`o| $ 2}d "Fojk Vnnd,
Wh`ehz`o| Jixf $ 6e` # 0pb Wh`ehz`o| $ 6}d
Boeine Zjbnni nc @oejh 1
Wh`ehz`o| # Pbxvz`o| $ 0%:=}d Zpovp
WNdHE“Z LEZPLPXPH
]hjkcnvpne # Fhhzpne W%L% $ ?zp Wh`ehz`o|
]hjkcnvpne Sliiogh Vnnd $ 7%:=}d
Fxefxv| WL% 6e` Pbxvz`o| $ ]oslilne $ 7%:=}dPlizpneh Choveoii # @lzpvljp WL $ dhhpz 0pb
Pbxvz`o| op 7%:=}d op Plizpneh Choveoii Jbxvjb Boii
FXEFXV\ CNNPFOII JIXF
O enp cnv }vnp) jnddxelp| fozh` cnnpfoii jixf cnv
8 $??$|hov$ni`z le Fxefxv| oe` pbh zxvvnxe`leg
sliioghz% Pbh jixf lz vhglzphvh` wlpb pbh Jbhzblvh
CO oe` n}hvoph zkliiz oe` pvoleleg zhzzlnez hshv|
Zopxv`o| dnveleg "`xvleg zjbnni phvd, cvnd <%:=$
??od op Fxefxv| ]io|leg Clhi`z%
Slzlp www%fxefxv|cnnpfoii%jn%xk) wvlph pn LecnM
Fxefxv|Cnnpfoii%jn%xk nv joii =7<=? <80236%
FXEFXV\) ]HJKCNVPNE) FHHZPNE # PLIZPNEH CHOVEOII
@X@@NE) JINPPNE # BNNCLHI@
Zhe` |nxv vhgxiov jnddxelp| ilzplegz pn hshepzMpoikofnxp}xfilzbleg%jn%xk oe` wh“ii}iojh pbhd cnv cvhh le pbh dogoleh oe` neileh op www% pov}nvih|poik%jnd%
WBOP“Z NE LE \NXV OVHO>
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 2?
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 82/84
26 Pn o`shvplzh joii =?600 :8=:<2
@l` |nx z}np bld> Bh lz ne pbh
Fovfnxv Lezplpxph ovpljih ne }6=
HOPNE
Ojplslplhz op pbh Ahzzlh Bxgbhz
Sliiogh BoiiCnv dnvh lecnvdoplne nv pn dokh o fnnkleg vleg
Bliov| Bhoih| ne =?26< 7:=067
nv hdoli bliz8?M|obnn%jn%xk
Dne`o|z
?6enne $ 6}d ]liophz) jnepojp I|ehpph Ioeel
=7733 73660=
0}d $ 3}d Foiihp jnepojp Eljniih Blgglez =7<==
:=:<33
3%:=}d $ <}d Poh Kwne @n jnepojp ]oxi Hsoez
=7287 :=:<8<
Pxhz`o|
<%:=od $ ??od Clpehzz ]liophz jnepojp Slkkl
Bxrih| =7<37 ??62<80}d $ 3%:=}d Foiihp jnepojp Eljniih Blgglez
=7<== :=:<33
6e` Pxhz`o| dnepbi| 7%:=$<%==}d WL jnepojp
Zbhlio ]ovpne =?26< 7:6630
0pb Pxhz`o| dnepbi| 7%:= $ <%==}d Gov`heleg
Jixf Jnepojp Bliov| Bhoih| =?26< 7:=067
Wh`ehz`o|
<%:=od $ ??%:=od Qxdfo jnepojp Ile`zo| Eopboe
=72?3 <:3<=6
?6enne $ 6%:=}d ]liophz jnepojp I|ehpph Ioeel
=7733 73660=
3%:=}d $ <}d Poh Kwne @n jnepojp ]oxi Hsoez
=7287 :=:<8<
Pbxvz`o|
7}d $ ?=}d Fvl`gh jnepojp Lvlz Whoshv =?26<
70=?==
?zp Pbxvz`o| dnepbi| 7%:= $ <%==}d Vho`leg
Gvnx} jnepojp Bliov| Bhoih| =?26< 7:=067
:v` Pbxvz`o| dnepbi| ?=%:=od $ ?6 enne) Pho
‒e“ Jbop `vn}$le znjloi dnveleg
Cvl`o|
<%?8od $ ?6 enne ]liophz jnepojp I|ehpph Ioeel
=7733 73660=
Zopxv`o|
<od $ 6}d Foiihp jnepojp Eljniih Blgglez =7<==
:=:<33
Zxe`o|
?=%:=od $ ??%:=od Qxdfo jnepojp Pvojh| Bxep
=7268 88370=
8%08}d $ 3%:=}d Foiivnnd.Iople @oejleg)"Jbli`vhe Fhgleehvz,
3%08}d $ 7%:=}d Foiivnnd.Iople @oejleg
"O`xip Fhgleehvz,
7%:=}d $ 2%?8}d Foiivnnd.Iople @oejleg "O`xip
Ld}vnshvz,% Jnepojp Dovk op @oejhfozljz ne
=7<0? 768<2=
Hopne Vodfileg Jixf
Zhvsleg injoi sliioghz% Wb| enp khh} p # anle pbh
hr}oe`leg pbh jixf) wbljb ovvoeghz woikz nc ofnxp
zhshe dlihz dor ihegpb) ne oiphveoph Zopxv`o|z
# Zxe`o|z) nejh o dnepb% Wh ovvoegh dnepbi|
hsheleg woikz nc ofnxp pbvhh dlihz le zxddhv) #
ncphe ovvoegh pvl}z # znjloi cxejplnez%Woikz oiwo|z
elzb op o jneshelhep bnzphiv|% Dhdfhvzbl} lz ª3
o |hov) # lz n}he pn oe|neh% Woikz zpovp cvnd Pbh
Ahzzlh Bxgbhz Sliiogh Boii op ?=od) axzp pxve x} #
glsh lp o pv|% Joii Glii Hiilzne ne =?26< 7263<: nv
hdoli hiilzne62Mfplephvehp%jnd
Zpovp pbh Ehw \hov wlpb o zdozb/
POV]NVIH\ FO@DLEPNEJIXF
Ovh ncchvleg o xelqxh n}}nvpxelp| pn pokh }ovp le 3Whhk jnojbleg pvloi zpovpleg
7%:=}d ne Pxhz`o| Aoe :v` op
POV]NVIH\ BLGB ZJBNNIZ]NVPZ BOII
ª3 }hv whhk cnv ? bnxv nc jnojbleg + ? bnxv nc dopjbhzLc |nx anle pbh jixf ocphv 3 whhkz 8=( nc whhki| chh wlii fh vhcxe`h`
]ihozh jnepojp Aheelchvne =?26< 7:=78?Nv axzp pxve x} ne pbh :v`
‒Zpvljpi|“ jndhz pn
Poppheboii oe` Doi}oz/
WHHKI\ Pho @oejhz oiphveopleg fhpwhhe
pbh Fovfnxv Lezplpxph) Poppheboii oe` pbh
Axflihh Vnndz) Doi}oz) Pxhz`o|z ?%:=}d
‚ :%?8}d
Poppheboii ‚ ?=pb # 60pb Aoexov|) 7pb #
6?zp Chfvxov|) 3pb # 6=pb Dovjb
Doi}oz ‚ ?7pb # :?zp Aoexov|) ?0pb # 62pb
Chfvxov|) ?:pb # 67pb Dovjb
Cnv dnvh lecnvdoplne vleg =7<?7 6:03:8
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 83/84
O@SHVPLZHVZ“ LE@Hr
Pov}nvih| Poik Aoexov| 6=?6 2:
OhvloizDV Ohvloiz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}3<
OvjblphjpzOe`| Cnzphv %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}63
Fopbvnndz
Wliilod # Doxvljh Fopbvnndz %%%%%%%%%%%%%% }0=
Flj|jihzGinfoi Flkh %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}?2
Fxli`leg # Anlehv|Fxefxv| ]vn} Dolepheoejh %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }3<J#G Fxli`leg # Anlehv| %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}3<Jbhzblvh Anlehv| Zhvsljhz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }6Jbvlz Jvowcnv` Dolepheoejh %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}76ZD H`wov`z %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}7:Zph}bhe Cnv` Anlehv| %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }0=OA ]o|eh ]vn}hvp| %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }7:
Jovh OghejlhzFxefxv| Jovh %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }2
Jovh Bndh. Jovh ZhvsljhZ}vlegjovh %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%cvnep
Jov}hpz . CinnvlegFvno`ihoshz Bov`wnn` Cinnvleg %%%%%%%%% }3<Jozpih Jov}hpz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}3?Klegzih| Jov}hpz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }8?Ilppih Jov}hp Zbn} %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }03
Jbli`vhe“z ]io| . JovhJvhoplne Zpoplne %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }:3
Jihoeleg . @ndhzplj ZhvsljhJov}hp # Nshe Jihoeleg %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }<Coijne Jov}hp Jihoeleg %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}:=$:?Ciowihzz Jihoeleg Jn %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }3<Khizoii Wle`nw Jihoeleg %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }7?Dnii| Dn} Jihoeleg %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}7?
Jnd}xphvzDnflih Jnd}xphv Heglehhv %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}7=
Jxvpolez oe` CofvljzOvlhz X}bnizphv| %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}?2Jxvpolez nc Cvn`zbod %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }8=
@oejh@oejhfozljz%jn%xk %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}0?
@hjnvopnv Bnwov` Oe`hvzne %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}76Wo|eh Zpnjkpne %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}76Whzpioe` @hjnvopnvz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }7Aozne Wli` %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}3<
@vlshwo|zFxli` ]osh oe` Zjo}h%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}7?@vlshwo| Jihoeleg %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}7=
H`xjoplneOgh Jnejhve %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}3:Hegilzb Pxlplne %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}?8Kleg“z Zjbnni %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}?:Inxlzh Dozne Pxlplne %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }?0_xhhe“z Zjbnni %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}6?
HihjpvljoiOhpbne Gvhhe Hehvg| %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}:3Bowk Hihjpvljoi %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}7=ZW] Hihjpvljz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }8=
CozblneJihn}opvo %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}88
]o}liine%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}6<Zl Fhiih %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}?2
Cleoejloi . Ojjnxepz Jbvlz Wblph Por O`slznv %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}76]bnhelr Ojjnxepleg %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }?2Por Ozzlzp %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }?6
ClpehzzDoj`neoi` ]nvpoi %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }60
]liophz op Poppheboii %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }8
CinnvlegFvno`ihoshz Bov`wnn` Cinnvleg %%%%%%%%% }7:
Cnn` # @vlekFlzpvn Fix %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}38Fvlzjnh“z @olv| %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}7:Fxiiz Bho` %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}37Jbvlzploen“z%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}00$08En3 Pbh Pho Vnnd %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }?6]hjkcnvpne Jozpih %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }:8Vnwpne Boii %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }87Pvoeqxliplp| M ]hjkcnvpne %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }:0Wli` Fnov %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}:
Cxhiz.hehvg|.}nwhv
Jihovslhw Zpnshz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }33Jnxep| Nli%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}<
Cxvelpxvh.Lephvlnv @hzlgeCxveplpxvh Dovkhp %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }::]hvln` Vhcxvflzbdhepz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}76
Gov`he@KJ Jnepvojpz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}<Gvof # Zblcp %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}7:Gov`he Zpvxjpxvhz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }?6Iowe Gx| %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}76Dnih Jnepvni %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}3<G N“Ehlii Ioe`zjo}hz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}33]vhjlzlne Gov`he Zhvsz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}7:Vlegwnn` Chejleg %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}:3Zbh` Doe %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}?2Zx``he Zpvlkh ]hzp Jnepvni %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}:6
Bolv Gvo`h ? Fovfhvz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}:6Zoine Slh %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}:7Pov}nvih| Bolv Fnxplqxh %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}?7
Boe`|doe]vn}hvp| Dolepheoejh %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}76Voe`nd Pozkz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }3<
Bhoipb # Fhoxp|Oeghio Fovpihpp %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}0<Doj`neoi` ]nvpoi G|d # Z}o %%%%%%%%%%%%% }60Zhvhelp| %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}67Vnwpne Boii Bhoipb Jixf # Z}o %%%%%%%%%%% }62Pov}nvih| Bhoipb Zpnvh %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}66 # 6:Pvoeqxlilp| %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }:8
Bnil`o| JnppoghzInwhv Bnxzh Covd %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }?3
KlpjbhezZphcoen `h Fiozln %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}?3Whzpioe` @hjnvopnvz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }7
IhgoiOiilegpne Bxgbhz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}8<Jxiildnvh @xppne %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}33Blffhvpz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}06Nilshv # Jn . _xoilp| Zniljlpnvz %%%%%%%%%%%%% }83Woikhv Zdlpb Wo| %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }07
IngzPneeh Fogz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}33
Doe oe` SoeGvhhejvncp %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}77
DnpnvlegA]W Fn`| Vh}olvz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}0=
DxzljOe`vhw ] @hoe ]loen Pxeleg %%%%%%%%%%%%%% }70Oe`vhw Zpovdhv ]loen Ihzznez %%%%%%%%%%}?2
]hzp JnepvniZx``he Zpvlkh %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}:0
]b|zlnpbhvo}|Clneo Jbhzwnvpb %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}:
]iozphvleg]iozphvleg Znixplnez %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}7:Poppheboii ]iozphvleg %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}7=
]ixdflegB Jboiihenv # Zne ]ixdfleg %%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }7=Dojko| ]ixdfleg %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}6=]@ ]ixdfleg %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}?0]K ]ixdfleg %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}73ZW Bhopleg # ]ixdfleg %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}7?Wliilod # Doxvljh Fopbvnndz %%%%%%%%%%%%% cvnep
]vn}hvp|Oghepz0X %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}0: # 36Bnil`o| Jnppoghz) Hopne %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }62
VnnegJhepxvlne Vnnleh %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }?8
Porl.]vlsoph blvhO}niin Pvoshi %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }7Fliilegh Pvoshi %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }8A#D Jovz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}?8Povsle Jovz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }<
PhihjndzPhihjnd Heglehhv %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }?6Slhwjnddz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }:6
PlilegJbhzblvh Plileg %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}7=
X}bnizphv|Ovlhz X}bnizphv| %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}?2
Sojoej|Dh`lzhj Zncpwovh %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}?0
Sojxxd Jihoehvz@|zne vh}olvz.zoihz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}3<
Wle`nw JihoelegKhizoii Wle`nw Jihoeleg %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}7=]xvh Jihoe Wle`nw Jihoehv %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}3<
Wle`nwzJhepxvlne Vnnleh %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}?0Jbhzblvh Anlehv| %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }6Jinx`|6Jihov %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}:@hh Wle`nwz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}0:Khizoii Wle`nwz% %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%}68Znshvhlge Wle`nwz %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }3
WlehHelgdo Wleh . Wleh Poik %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }30
]IHOZH VHJ\JIH
PBLZ DOGOQLEH
WBHE \NX
BOSH CLELZBH@
VHO@LEG LP
8/3/2019 Tarporley Talk Jan 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tarporley-talk-jan-2012 84/84
BHOPBCLHI@ZPOV]NVIH\
]VLJH ª8?0 <8= ZOP EOS JW3 =B]
8 oe` 3 Fh`vnnd Codli| Bndhz
\nx“ii kenw wbhe |nx“sh cnxe`pbh vlgbp bndh%%%
BHOPBCLHI@Z) Pov}nvih|% Cnv pbh }vncnxe`i| xelqxhzhppleg% Cnv pbh gvhhe oe` pvoeqxli jbovojphv jvhoph`
f| lpz fhoxplcxi pvhh$ileh` oe` ioe`zjo}h` heslvnedhep%
Zlppleg ne pbh cvlegh nc neh nc Jbhzblvh“z dnzp
znxgbp ocphv sliioghz wlpb lp“z joch fovz) fnxplqxhz
oe` hshv|`o| hzzheploiz% Cnv pbh zpvlkleg slhwz oe`
ildlpihzz }oenvodoz% Cnv qxoilp| nc ilch) Bhopbclhi`z lz o
dogelcljhep }iojh pn joii bndh%
ZBNWBNDH N]HE PBXVZ@O\ PN DNE@O\ ?=OD PN 8]D