Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Specialized Technical Assistance for Reviewing of Environmental Studies
Mining Sector, Perú
Environmental Impact Assessment is a complex process, sometimes, a confictive one.
ApprovalReview of EISEnvironmental Impact Statement Monitoring
Typical problems Frequent issuesTechnical Training asymmetry between private sector and public sector
Asymmetric compensation, limited access to institutional training, rotation, instability and lack of incentives
Limited time for review of studies, due to legal constraints
Increased risk of pressures, omissions, inconsistencies, likelihood of errors
Undefined METHODOLOGIES to implement review procedures
General standards do not solve the demand for analysis to obtain consistent and homogeneous revisions
Limited quality control in the review process Thinking beyond the “King can do no wrong” maxim, as part of the Rule of Law.
Limited access to technology Paper based proceeding usually determines sequential proceedings, not traceable, limited accessibility, limited transparency
Limited consideration of Project Context Social, environmental and economic issues are frequently underestimated
Towards strengthening the review process
Envir. Impact St. (EIS) Review of EIS Approval Monitoring
ATEREA PROJECT´S MAIN COMPONENTS:
-STANDARDIZED PROCEDURE, as a microregulation-COMPUTERIZED, WEB BASED management module
-MULTIDISCIPLINARY TEAM ready to work at several projects at a time
-TECHNICAL COMMITEE for purposes of quality assurance and ethics control
-TRAINING PROGRAM, comprehending on the job training, awarness workshops, etc.
Standardized procedure (I)
Standardize Procedure (II)
ATEREA’ s Software Solution
Collateral Benefits
Environmental Impact Assessment as a tool for improving good governance
Assures proper informationRequires apropriate participationPromotes transparencyBuilds on more efficient process of decision
makingAllows to quantify environmental managment
Environmental Impact Assessment is a complex process, sometimes, a confictive one. Well developed, becomes a powerful tool for improving environmental governance.
ApprovalReview of EISEnvironmental Impact Statement Monitoring
MINEM EQUIPO TÉCNICO MULTIDISCIPLINAR
IO
COMITÉTÉCNICO
EIA
¿cumple? S
N
Info
Proceso
No Obj.
S
N Rec.A
A
Lev. Obs.
No Obj.
S
N Rec.
C
Propuesta Rec. B
Propuesta Rec.A B
EAsProceso
Proceso
Contextua-lizador
Contextualization
Caracte-rizador
Characterization
Caracte-rizador
Characterization
Caracte-rizador
Characterization
Caracte-rizador
Characterization
C-ETM Jefe deRevisión
Human resources
C-ETM Jefe deRevisión
Selecting specialists
C-ETM Jefe deRevisión
Human Resources
ETMRecommendations
Jefe deRevisión
Consistency Evaluation
Technical Commitee
• Fullfillment of macro and micro regulations• Consistency analysis• Issues findings and recommendations• Issues no objection to Report proposal
