27
7/20/2007 Ver. 1.0 7/21/2007 Ver. 1.1 7/23/2007 Ver 1.2 (Added particle distribution curve) Preliminary report of the July 16, 2007 Niigata prefecture Chuetsu Off shore (Niigata-ken Chuetsu-Oki), Japan, Earthquake Based on the reconnaissance conducted from July 17-19, 2007 (Strong motion records by K-NET are acknowledged.) Tetsuo TOBITA, Assistant Professor Mohammad Reza GHAYAMGHAMIAN, Visiting Researcher (Associate Professor, International Institute for Earthquake Engineering and Seismology, Iran) Gi-Chun KANG, Doctoral candidate Susumu IAI, Professor Disaster Prevention Research Institute Kyoto University, Japan

Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

7/20/2007 Ver. 1.07/21/2007 Ver. 1.17/23/2007 Ver 1.2 (Added particle distribution curve)

Preliminary report of theJuly 16, 2007 Niigata prefecture Chuetsu

Off shore (Niigata-ken Chuetsu-Oki),Japan, Earthquake

Based on the reconnaissance conducted from July 17-19, 2007(Strong motion records by K-NET are acknowledged.)

Tetsuo TOBITA, Assistant ProfessorMohammad Reza GHAYAMGHAMIAN, Visiting Researcher

(Associate Professor, International Institute for Earthquake Engineering and Seismology, Iran)Gi-Chun KANG, Doctoral candidate

Susumu IAI, Professor

Disaster Prevention Research InstituteKyoto University, Japan

Page 2: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

Related Links:

The Headquarters for Earthquake Research Promotionhttp://www.jishin.go.ip:80/main/oshirase/20070716 chuetsu oki.htm

ERI (English):http ://www.eri.u-tokyo:ac.ij /topics/niigata200707l6/index-e.html

DPRIhttp:l/sms.dpri.kyoto-u.ac.ip/chuetsuoki07O716.htm!

http://wwwcatfish.dpri. kyoto-u.ac. ip/-goto/eq/20070716/reportO. htmIhttp://www.eqh.dpri.kyoto-u.ac.-ip/-masumi/eq/niigata.pdf

Japan Geotechnical Society (Japanese)http://www.jiban.or.ip/organi/bu/somubu/1 9niigatachuetsu/niigatachuetsusokuho.html

K-NET (NIED)http://www.k-net.bosai.go.ip/k-net/

Niigata prefecture (Japanese)http:l/bosai.pref.niiqata.iplbosaiportall0716jishin/hiigai/index.html

http://bosai.pref.niigata.ip/bosaiportal/0716jishin/photo/photo.html

Page 3: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

General informationA large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in

Chuetsu region, Niigata, Japan. The epicenter was located off shore of Kariwa village and Kashiwazaki city(Fig. 1). Preliminary results of the source inversions show a reverse fault with the NE-SW (strike: 34, Dip: 51,Rake: 74 degrees) (http://wwweic.eri.u-tokyo.ac.jp/topics/20070716/), and the rupture propagated to Northand South directions.

The instrumental JMA seismic intensity (Fig. 1) was 6+ (IX in MMI) in Kariwa village, Kashiwazakicity, Nagaoka city, in Niigata prefecture, and Ohzuna-machi in Nagano prefecture.

Ten people were killed and more than 1284 were injured and more than 10,000 were evacuated(as of 7/20/07, Niigata Prefecture). The number of totally collapsed houses were 949 in Niigata. Majorlifelines, gas, water, electricity, have been damaged and suspended for more than a day. Electricity wasrecovered after a day in most of the area. Watersupply has not been recovered for four days (as'of July 20,2007). In Kariwa village, one of the world largest nuclear power plants (7 reactor's total 8,200,000 kW), whichreportedly suffered damage due to unexpectedly large strong shaking (recorded 6.8 m/s 2 , designed with 2.7m/s 2)

Figure 1 Location of the epicentral area

Page 4: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

Epicenter7/16/2007 10:13AM 48Mj 6.8 D=15 km 4 W(preliminary)37.557N 138.615E(NIED Hi-Net)

/ Kannon misaki (Cape Kan-non)- Landslide: slide 11____ ____ ___ ____ ___ ____ ___ ____ _ ~3 1 /

Kashiwazaki - Kariwa nuclear power plant

Doh-ai, Yamamoto - Settlement of railway embankment: slide 15-16 /PIA-P ALO

48

Matsunami 2 - Liquefaction in residential area: slide 13-14 -91,

Kashiwazaki City Hall K-NET (NIG018): slide 5-8

Honmachi - Collapse of wooden houses:slide 21-24

Senbon (Route 8).•'• •i•Road damage due to

Ohmigawa1 station - Landslide landslide: slide 12

Kashiwazaki station - derailment

Slide 26

91

Kai port - Damage of quay walls:N,; ••slide 17-19

Page 5: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

Recorded K-NET strong motion (Fig. 2) shows .spiky response in the horizontal records which is typically seenfor dense sands under the state of cyclic mobility caused by a liquefaction. Peak accelerations are observed inthe time period of 25 - 28 seconds when the spiky response is dominant. Their values are 6.67 and 5.13 and3.69 m/s 2, respectively, in the NS, EW and UD directions. Duration of shaking is about 10 seconds. Soil profileat the site also indicates dominancy of dense sands at shallower depth < 5 m (Fig. 3).

NIG0 1820070716101313<

NIG018 2007/07/16 10:13:28 -Seismic Intensity : 6.38

Accelemation [gal] N--S Max.= 655.7865 Min.= -667.0431

6.67e+002 .-

-6.67e+002-

Acceleration [gal] E-W Max.= 492.1,166 Min.= -513.5859

-6.67e+002 -Acceleration [gal] U-D Max.= 369.0388 Min.= -264.7450

6.67+0 -,

-6,67e+002

1:O 20 30 40

Tnie,[s]Figure 2 Acceleration record of NIG018, K-NET, 10:13AM, July 16, 2007

Page 6: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

N-Value . - -

0 10 M0 50

P,S Velocity DensiRy[m/s] " [gcnT]

0 1(Y OM Y 20 3000 I

Soil column

0

I I __

5

_C 10CL.

-8

-2_ Surface soil

"F • Gravel

c) -) c' Gravelly soil

i ' •:•0. Sand

S F: 6V9±; Sandy soil

0 Silt

* *C: Ul'Clay

0: 0MR-±* Organic soil

Volcanic ash day

- Peatj "~ ~ ~ ~ ~~R .... ý9.. .. '.:

Rock

at Kashiwazaki, NIGOI8, K-NET (after N lED).

From P wave velocity, theground water level is-expected to be about G.L.. -4 to -5 m. The ground waterlevel at the event has to beinvestigated. The amount ofprecipitation in July, 2007 inKashiwazaki is 46 mm thatis 21 % less than the -.

average year(220 mm)(JMA AMEDAS).

On plotting STP N-value, K-NET site has no informationregarding the energy ratio.This will be investigatedlater.

15

i p ileSoil profileFigure 3

NIG018 (K-NET)site Behind trees:37.3724N,138.5579E.Elevation: 10.00m

Page 7: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

Near the K-Net site, major cracks on road asphalt may indicate occurrence of lateral spreads towarddown-slope. (Fig. 5).

North A

S Tension

I

K-NET:

/}.':

/

~I~J

#1~ ~

I Sand-

K!ashiwazaki City Hall,

/,}/,

1-1

Page 8: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

The acceleration time histories of 2003 Niigata-ken Chuetsu earthquake recorded at NIG018 show nospikes due to cyclic mobility (Fig. 4).

NIG0180410231756

NIG018 2004/10/23 17:56:06

Acceleration (gal] N-W1.44e+002-

-1 .44e+002 -

Acceleration [gal] E-W1.44e+002-

-1,44e+002Acceleration [gall U-_

1.44e+002 -i

Max.= 97.1312 Min.= -97.8568

4 " if'- [* •iJJ~~ I IK

D

144.3557 Min.= -108.1224

Max.= 75.5641 Min.= -59.7832

MITI

-1A44e+002 -

I•10 20I30 40

050• 60 70

8•80

Time [s]

Figure 4 Acceleration time history of 2003 Niigata-ken Chuetsu earthquake recorded atNIG018, K-NET, 17:56, October 23, 2004

Page 9: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

Photographs

Page 10: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

Two landslides near the Ohmigawa station of JRShin-Etsu line covered rail tracks by the coast line.According to a fisherman who was in the sea forcatching oysters near the site, the landslide startedsimultaneously with strong shaking and, in hisimpression, duration of sliding was in a very shorttime.

Page 11: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

Landslide at Kan-non misaki (Cape Kan-non)

Two landslides were occurred in the North of Kan-non misaki, the nearest land from the epicenter.The landslides covered the Route 352.

Kan-non Misaki: 7/17/07

Page 12: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

Major arterial road, Route 8, which connects Kashiwazaki to Nagaoka was damaged at Senbon dueto landslides. Slide started at about 60 m above the road pavement. Width of broken road was about80 m.

Page 13: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

Damage on utility poles, asphalt roads, houses due'to liquefaction were found in Matsunami 2, Kashiwazakicity. The site which was originally farm lands and sand dunes was developed as a residential site in 1973-1976. The area is 14 ha and east part of the developed land suffered heavy damage due to liquefaction. Eyewitness accounts of evidence confirms the occurrence of liquefaction after the large shaking with an eruptionof muddy water at 2 m high.

Page 14: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

100

C:

0)Cu

80

60

40

20

0

0.01 0.1 1 10 100

Particle size (mm)

Erupted sand was medium to coarse sand

Utility poles were settled and tilted, but nomanholes were uplifted.

Matsunami 2: 7/18/07

Page 15: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

Settlement of a railway embankment due to the loss of the bearing capacity of its base ground was found inDoh-ai. The railway is crossing a pond with distance of 125 m and that part was settled. Evidence ofliquefaction was NOT? found?? (need confirmation). Cross sectional dimension of the embankment afterdeformation is 6.8 m at the crest, and 16 m at the toe. Its height-after deformation is 1.2 m.

Doh-ai: 7/18/07

Page 16: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

Road pavements near the railway settlement were damaged due to a possible liquefaction of filledmaterial for constructions of swage pipes and manholes. This indicates that a predominant soil in thisarea is cohesive and low permeable material.

Doh-ai: 7/18/07

Page 17: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

Kashiwazaki fishery portMinor to 50 cm of settlement of apron was found.Deformation toward sea < 1 m: Sheet pile type quay wall with tie rods

$11

Kashiwazaki fishery port: 7/17/07

Page 18: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

Kashiwazaki ferry terminal building:Building suffered no damage but evidence of liquefaction was found.Pavement blocks were senarated and settled.

Sand volcanoes at the back of the building

r\db[IIWd4dKI Itz:11Y LU1111111i

Page 19: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

Damage of a sheet pile type quay wall with tie rodsBroken concrete slab indicates that tie rods connected sheet pile walls pulled anchoring piles toward sea.

Kashiwazaki fishery port: 7/17/07

Page 20: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

Large ground fissures due to liquefaction were found in the Sabaishigawa kaishu-kinen park, Makihara,Kashiwazaki. The park was constructed on a sandbar along the Sabaishi river.

Sabaishigawa kaishu-kinen park: 7/17/07

Page 21: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

Near Higashi Honmachi 2 and 3Many wooden houses collapsed ged area in Kashiwazaki.

Typical collapse pattern of wooden houses

Page 22: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

West "

First floor of wooden houses shown above tiltedinto the opposite direction each other. Thisindicates that houses were shaken with theirnatural period.

Old steel frame building were also damaged

N .

NNW

Higashi Honmachi: 7/18/07

Page 23: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

Damage to cultural properties

o

Collapsed entrance roof of the Enma-do, temple

Two story wooden building used as a museum

West

onmacni: tI )7

Page 24: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

Many Japanese-style tomb stones were rotated in the clockwise direction in Honmachi. However,some collapsed to the east and some slid to the west.

Higashi Honmachi: 7/18/07

Page 25: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

Overturning ratio of tomb stones -(Number of overturning)/(Number of standing)

Page 26: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

In Kashiwazaki station, first car of local lines, which consisted of two cars, derailed just before leaving at thestation. Some passengers were on board, but no one was hurt.

7/19/07: Kashiwazaki station

Page 27: Slides for Presentation on 'Preliminary Report of the …General information A large earthquake occurred (preliminary Mj 6.8, D=15 km) at 10:13AM on July 16, 2007 in Chuetsu region,

Preliminary observation

* K-NET record shows high spikes due to cyclic mobility caused by aliquefaction of dense sands. Pavement cracks due to tension andcompression may indicate direction of ground deformation near the K-NETstation.

* Landslides caused major damage on railways and roads.• In Matsunami, Kashiwazaki, liquefaction caused damage to foundation of

residential houses. Utility poles were settled, but no manholes were uplifted.* In Doh-ai, Kashiwazaki, a relatively small embankment for rail tracks of

were settled < (approx) 1 m due, may be, to the loss of bearing capacity ofthe base ground. The embankment was constructed in a natural pond.Uplifted manholes near the site indicate that a predominant soil in this areais cohesive and low permeable material.

* In Kashiwazaki port, Sheet pile type quay walls with tie rods were damaged,but not totally collapsed. Sand boiling was observed.

* In Makihara, lateral spread occurred in a park constructed on a sandbar.* In Higashi Honmachi, many wooden houses collapsed toward west. Tomb

stones were rotated in the clockwise direction.