MESA Finnie Mueller

8/12/2019 MESA Finnie Mueller

1/43


2/43

!"# A%>< 45*B#'(

)@7 !71;6+2,? -@7 "AA7>-2B7,7;; *A #-6(

47,- $24 C+*=7>-. *+ -@7 !"#$ C+*=7>-. 2; 1

A*6+ D71+ +7;71+>@ 7AA*+- E72,? >*,46>-74 ED

-@7 31,1421, "46>1-2*, C+*=7>- 1,4 -@7#>@**F A*+ C*F2>D #-6427; 1- G677,H; I,2B7+(

;2-D *, E7@1FA *A -@7 31,141 !2FF7,,26:

#>@*F1+;@2< J*6,41-2*,9 K- @1; E77, 47;2?,74

-* 1,;87+ -@7 A*FF*82,? A*6+ L67;-2*,;M

$A-7+ ?+1461-2,? A+*: @2?@ ;>@**F. -77,(

1?7+; >*:2,? A+*: F*8(2,>*:7 E1>N(

?+*6,4; A1>7 1 >@*2>7 1; -* 1--7,4 >*FF7?7

*+ 6,2B7+;2-D. *+ ,*-9 J*+ -@*;7 8@* 4241--7,4. @*8 4* -@7D >*:- :*+7 F*8(2,>*:7 ;-647,-; -*

*,41+D 746>1-2*,O

P*7; 1-2*,

:1N7 2- :*+7 F2N7FD A*+ F*8(2,>*:7 ;-6(47,-; -* ;-1D 2, 1,4 ?+1461-7O

$+7 F*8(2,>*:7 ;-647,-; 42AA7+7,- 1>+*;;

31,141O

)@2; @7+; 87+7

1;N74 -* 8+2-7 1E*6- 2;;67; *A 1>>7;; 1,4

7 2, *,41+D 746>1-2*, 2,31,1419 )@7 +7L62+7:7,-; A*+ -@7 6++7,-FD(7S2;-2,? #-1-2;-2>; 31,141 41-1E1;7;

*+ 1,*-@7+ ;*6+>7 *A 31,1421, 41-19 "1>@ *A

-@7 - *+ 2-; *(*+42,1-2*,. 41-1 D

T >F71,2,?. 1,4 2,-7?+1-2*, *A -@7 A2,1F +7(

; 6 F - ; 1 - - @ 7 7 , 4 * A - @ 7 < + * = 7 > - 9

8889746>1-2*,1FD9*+?

)@7 ?,2,6.,2 %67',(.*2 45*B#'(@ 1,4 7B1F61-2*, 7S*,41+D 1,4

*,41+D 746>1-2*,1F 2,;-2-6-2*,;. 7F7(

:7,-1+D 1,4 ;7>*,41+D ;>@**F E*1+4;. ;-6(

47,- ?+*6@ *A *6+ 8*+N -* 41-7 471F; 82-@ ;-647,-;

1,4 D*6-@ 1- -@7 *,41+D F7B7F. 87 1+7

2,>+71;2,?FD 7,?1?2,? 2, +7;71+>@ 1- -@7 7F7(

:7,-1+D 1,4 ;7>*,41+D F7B7F; 1; 87FF 1; F**N(

2,? 1- ;-647,- :*E2F2-D -@+*6?@ F2A7F*,? F71+,(

2,? 1,4 -+1,;2-2*,; E7-877, Y(Z% 1,4 *,41+D 746>1-2*,9 8889>1,74-9>1

"AA7>-; *A I,2B7+;2-D 3@1+1>-7+2;-2>; 1,4 $>147:2> [7?6F1-2*,; *, #-647,- C7+;2;-7,>7. P7?+77 3*:


3/43

)@7 >'"**/ *& 4*/.'0 >(76.#) ,( D7##2N)

F2.G#5).(0 U!!!"#$%%&'$"()*'+'V 2; 1 F7142,?

>7,-+7 A*+ 14B1,>74 746>1-2*,. +7;71+>@. 47(

E1-7 1,4 2,-7+1>-2*, 82-@ -@7 ,*,(1>147:2>

8*+F4 2, -@7 A27F4; *A 14:2,2;-+1-2*,1,4 2,46;-+21F +7F1-2*,;9 3*,-2,62,? -@7 F*,?(

;-1,42,? >*::2-:7,- *A G677,H; I,2B7+;2-D

-* 7S>7FF7,>7 2, -@7;7 1+71;. -@7D 1+7 -+12,2,?

-@7 ,7S- ?7,7+1-2*, *A F7147+; A*+ F2A7 2, 1

?F*E1F 1?79 )@72+ :1;-7+H; 7 -* *,*:2>.

1F. ;*>21F 1,4 -7>@,*F*?2>1F >@1,?7;

-@1- 1+7 -+1,;A*+:2,? -@7 81D 87 F2B7 1,4 -@781D 87 8*+N9 #-647,-; 7,@1,>7 -@72+ >*:(

:6,2>1-2*, 1,4 +7;71+>@ ;N2FF;. 1,4 ?12, ,78

;N2FF; 2, :1,1?7:7,-. D 1,1FD;2;. 7>*(

,*:2>; 1,4 L61,-2-1-2B7 :7-@*4;9 )@72+

?+1461-7; 1+7 87FF 7 :1,1?7:7,-

1,4 2,46;-+21F +7F1-2*,; 2, 1 B1+27-D *A .

D #-6427; :1,1?7; -@7 [7(;71+>@ [7B278 3*::2--77 A*+ -@7 !"#$ C+*(

=7>-. 8@2>@ 2; +7;*,(

-+2E6-*+D +7;71+>@ -; -@1- @2?@F2?@- 2:(

'"*/,5)".H

+*726,(.*2 2; 1 - *A C1+F21:7,- 2,

Z\\'9 K- 7,>*6+1?7; 31,1421, ;-647,-; -*;-+2B7 A*+ 7S>7FF7,>7 1,4 @*F1+;@2@ D71+ -@+*6?@*6- 31,1419

K-; *E=7>-2B7; 1+7 -* 2:>7;; -* *,41+D 746>1-2*, A*+ 1FF 31,1421,;. 7;21FFD -@*;7 A1>2,? 7>*,*:2> *+ ;*>21F E1++2(

7+;R -* 7,>*6+1?7 1 @2?@ F7B7F *A ;-647,-

1>@27B7:7,- 1,4 7,?1?7:7,- 2, 31,1421,

;*>27-DR 1,4 -* E62F4 1 ,1-2*,1F 1FF21,>7 *A

*+?1,2W1-2*,; 1,4 2,42B2461F; 1+*6,4 1

;@1+74 *,41+D 1?7,419 )@7 J*6,41(

-2*, 2; A6,42,? -@7 !"#$ C+*=7>- *B7+1FF. 1,4

@1; ,7?*-21-74 1>>7;; -* 2-; ;-647,- 14:2,2;(-+1-2B7 F2;-; 82-@ 71>@ *A -@7 7; *, -@7

-H; E7@1FA9

!!!",-..%&&-$,'(/0.)1'/-+'"()

22 "AA7>-; *A I,2B7+;2-D 3@1+1>-7+2;-2>; 1,4 $>147:2> [7?6F1-2*,; *, #-647,- C7+;2;-7,>7. P7?+77 3*:


4/43


5/43

!,O/# *& ?*2(#2()

9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999K,-+*46>-2*, Z

99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999)@7 g2-7+1-6+7 ^

99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999!7-@*4*F*?D h

9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999)@7 P1-1 i

9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999[7;6F-; '

99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999)@7 j1;7F2,7 !*47F; '

999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999$442,? d2?@ #>@**F k+147; -* -@7 !*47F \

999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999$442,? -@7 #>1F7 l1+21EF7; ZZ

999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999990B7+B278 *A -@7 J2,42,?; Zh

999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999993*,>F6;2*,; 1,4 C*F2>D K:1-2*,; Z_

9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999[7A7+7,>7; Z'

99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999)1EF7; 1,4 J2?6+7; %&

CF71;7 >2-7 1;M

J2,,27. [*;;. 1,4 !67FF7+. [2>@1+4 "9 U%&&'V9 2/% 455%(6' 05 7),8

-.9 :&(0,%; 6/%1 ?)(@A10$&= 7)(601'

0& B((%'' 60


6/43

12(5*67'(.*2

)@7+7 ,*8 7S2;-; 1 ;6E;-1,-21F E*4D *A

+7;71+>@ *, -@7 2:7 *A A1:2FD E1>N(

?+*6,4 2,AF67,>7;. -62-2*, F7B7F;. 1,4 *-@7+

+7F1-74 B1+21EF7; *, 1>>7;; -* *,41+D746>1-2*, UC#"V e 2, 31,141 1; A*+ *-@7+

>*6,-+27;9 J*+ 7>*,*:2;-;. -@2; 7:21F A1>-*+; :1N7; - ;7,;79 )@7

7 :7>@1,2;: 2; >*,;247+74 -* E7 2:2;2*, e 8@2>@ 2;

@*8 -@7 >@*2>7 *A ;>@**F2,? F7B7F 2; -D1FFD

B278749 $,4 -@7 1B12F1E2F2-D *A -@7 A6,4; +7(

L62+74 -* :1N7 -@7 2,B7;-:7,- e 2, -@2; >*,(

-7S- *A-7, *:7 F7B7F e 2; 1, 7L61FFD >+2-2>1F A1>(

-*+. 7;21FFD 2, 1 >*,-7S- 8@7+7 >1>7;; -* A2,1,>2,? E7>16;7

*FF1-7+1F -* E1>N -@72+ E*+(

+*82,? U;77 A*+ 7S1:@*F1+FD +7;71+>@ 2, -@7 1+71 *A1>>7;; -* C#" U79?9. 36,@1. 7- 1F9. %&&i.

d7>N:1,. %&&nV @1;. @*87B7+. ;@2A-74 -@7

7:21F A1>-*+; 1; 1 ,787+

?7,7+1-2*, *A 7:1F 8*+N @1; 2,42>1-74

-@1- A2,1,>21F +7;*6+>7; 1+7 E6- *,7 *A :1,D

2:7 :1,D *A -@7;7

A1>-*+; 1+7 >*++7F1-74 82-@ A1:2FD 2,>*:7 2,

-@7 ;@*+-(-7+: +71;7 C#" 27; 1+7 ,*- 2:*++7F1-74 82-@ *-@7+ B1+21EF7; 8@2>@

1+7 1F;* ;2?,2A2>1,- 47-7+:2,1,-; *A C#" 27 *A

-@7;7 A2,1,>21F B1+21EF7;9 J*+ D 7;; F7B7+ U79?9.

F*1,;. ?+1,-;. *+ F*;7+ -62-2*,V :71,; F7;;

;+71;74 -62-2*, 1+7 ,*- @1B2,? -@747;2+74 7AA7>- *, 1>>7;; 1,4 +7-7,-2*,. -@1,

-@7;7 +7;*6+>7; :1D ;2:>6:6F1-2,? -* -@*;7 8@*;7 C#" 47>2;2*,;

1+7 ,*- ;7,;2-2B7 -* -@7;7 A2,1,>21F B1+21EF7;

1,4 8*6F4 @1B7 E77, 1--7,42,? 1,D81D9

k*B7+,:7,-; 8*6F4 >2,>-FD

;6::1+2W7 -@7 1+?6:7,-. ,*-2,? -@1- >@2F(

4+7, 8@*;7 *:7 @1B7

E7--7+ 1>>7;; -* L61F2-D ;>@**F;. 1,4 -@7;7

;1:7


7/43

-2*,; *A -@72+ >@2F4+7,9 )@7D 1+7 1F;* 1EF7 -*

E7--7+ ,6+-6+7 -@7 2,-7FF7>- *A -@72+ >@2F4+7,

ED 1;;2;-2,? 1,4 42+7>-2,? -@72+ ;-6427;9 )@7D

1F;* ,*-7 -@1- >*?,2-2B7 1E2F2-D e 1- F71;- 1;

:71;6+74 ED KG *, ;-1,41+42W74 -7;-; e 2;A*+:74 ED -@7 1?7 *A Zh 1,4 -@1- -@7 2,AF6(

7,>7; *A A1:2FD A1>-*+; 1>>6:6F1-7 A+*: E2+-@

;* -@1- ;>@*F1;-2> 1E2F2-D 2; 47-7+:2,74 ED -@7

7,4 *A @2?@ ;>@**F9 $?12,. -@7 2:1-2*, *A

-@7;7 1+?6:7,-; 2; -@1- 27; 12:74 1- 2,(

AF67,>2,? D*6,? N:1,.

Z\\'R "+:2;>@ 1,4 J+1,>7;>*,2. %&&ZR Y71,71,4 X*FN(

:1,. %&&nV. +7F1-2B7FD F2--F7 41-1 @1; E77,

E+*6?@- -* E71+ *, -@2; -*. 1,4 87 E7F27B7

*6+ 41-1 -* @1B7 >7+-12, ;-+7,?-@; -@1- >1, E7

A*6,4 2, ,* @ ;7- *A E1>N?+*6,4 B1+21EF7;

-@1- >1, E7 14474 -* -@7 :*47F;9 )@2; 2; 7;(

21FFD -+67 2, -@7 31,1421, >*,-7S-. 1,4 -*

-@7 E7;- *A *6+ N,*8F74?7. *6+; 2; -@7 A2+;-;-64D 6;2,? 31,1421, 41-1 8@2>@ 1--7:N?+*6,4 2,AF67,>7; *,

1>>7;; -* C#" 2, -@2; A1;@2*,9PK, 6F1+. 87

A*>6; *, -@7 E1>N?+*6,4 *A D*6,? 146F-; 1-

-@7 -2:7 8@7, -@7D 1+7 Z_(D71+; *F4 -* 1;(

;7;; -@7 2:7 *A -@7;7 A1>-*+; *, 7,(

-7+2,? 72-@7+ >*FF7?7 *+ 6,2B7+;2-D9

)@7 >*,-+2E6-2*, *A -@2; @ +2>@7+ ;7+27; *A E1>N(

?+*6,4 B1+21EF7; 2,-* -@7 1,1FD;2;. -@6; 1FF*8(2,? 6; -* 1,1FD;7 -@7 7AA7>-; *A E*-@ -@7 :*+7

-+142-2*,1FFD :71;6+74 47-7+:2,1,-; *A 1>(

>7;; -* C#" U79?9. A1:2FD 2,>*:7V 1; 87FF 1;

-@7 B1+2*6; ;7-; *A *-@7+ E1>N?+*6,4 B1+2(

1EF7; -@1- 1F;* :1D E7 *A 2:79 K- 2;

-@2; F1--7+ ?+*6< *A A1>-*+; -@1- :1DE7 >*++7(

F1-74 82-@ A2,1,>21F B1+21EF7;. 1,4 D7- :1D

-@7:;7FB7; E7 2:*++7F1-7; *A C#"

21F7c B1+21EF7; 8@2>@

>1147:2> 1,4 ;*>21F 7,?1?7:7,- 1,4

+7F1-74 @*F*?2>1F(;*>2*F*?2>1F 1--+2E6-7;.

1,4 1 ;-1,41+42W74 2,-7+,1-2*,1F +7142,? -7;-

;>*+79 X7 7S- -@1- -@7 2,>F6;2*, *A -@7;7

B1+21EF7; 82FF 1--7,61-7 -@7 7AA7>-; *A -+142(

-2*,1F B1+21EF7; U;6>@ 1; 1-2*,

1,4 2,>*:7V9 X7 1,-2>2@ 1; @2?@ ;>@**F ?+147; 1,4 ;-1,(

41+42W74 +7142,? -7;- +7;6F-; 82FF @1B7 1 -; *A-@7;7 B1+21EF7; 1,4 :71;6+2,? -@7 >@1,?7; 2,

-@7 7;-2:1-74 7AA7>-; *A -@7 :*+7 -D1F

E1>N?+*6,4 B1+21EF7; 8@7, -@7 E+*147+ ;7-;

1+7 2,-+*46>74. 1+7 -@7 :12, A*>6; *A -@7


8/43

I-2F2W2,? :6F-2,*:21F F*?2- :*47F; -* >1@ ?7,(

7+1-7; 1 -. E6- 1F;* :*+7 F2N7FD

-@1- 6,2B7+;2-D 82FF E7 -@7 F7B7F *A >@*2>7.8@2>@ @1; 1 ,7?1-2B7 2,AF67,>79 )@7 ;-+7,?-@

*A -@7 2,>*:7 7AA7>- 2;. @*87B7+. ?+71-FD 42(

:2,2;@74 *,>7 1-2*, 2; 2,>F6474

2, -@7 7;-2:1-2*,. ;6??7;-2,? -@1- 8@7, 2,(

>*:7 2; 2,>F6474 82-@*6- 746>1-2*, 2- 2;

F1+?7FD >1- *A -@7 F1--7+.

8@2>@ 2; -@7 4*:2,1,- 7AA7>-9 K, F2N7 A1;@2*,.

-@7 2:7 *A 1-2*, U7;21FFD *, 6,2B7+;2-D 1--7,41,>7V 2; 42:2,2;@74-* ;*:7 47?+77 e 1F-@*6?@ 2- +7:12,; ;-+*,?

e *,>7 >7+-12, :71;6+7; *A @2?@ ;>@**F

?+147;. 1>147:2> b7,?1?7:7,-.c 1,4 ;-1,(

41+42W74 +7142,? -7;- ;>*+7; U2979. CK#$ +7(

;6F-;V 1+7 2,>F64749 K,-7+7;-2,?FD. -@7;7 1442(

-2*,1F B1+21EF7; 4* ,*- A6+-@7+ +746>7 -@7 7;(

-2:1-74 2:7 *A A1:2FD 2,>*:7. ;6?(

?7;-2,? -@1- 1, 2,47*:7 7AA7>-

+7:12,; 1A-7+ 1FF -@7;7 A1>-*+; 1+7 -1N7, 2,-*1>>*6,- e 7B7, 2A 2- 2; ,*- ,71+FD 1; ?+71- 1;

:2?@- E7 -@*6?@- A+*: 7;-2:1-7; ?7,7+1-74

8@7, 1 F7;; >*:7; +1-@7+ -@1,

>6++7,- 2,>*:7 2, 7AA7>-2,? >@1,?7 2, -@7

+1-7; 1,4 >7;; -* C#" 1:*,?;- D*6,?

-74V9

31+,72+* 1,4 d7>N:1, U%&&%V +7B278 -@7

I# F2-7+1-6+7 1,4 144 ,78 7B247,>7 ;6N?+*6,4. *B7+;@*+-(-7+: A1>-*+;. ;6>@ 1; >+742- >*,;-+12,-;9

#2,>7 :1,D *A -@7;7 E1>N?+*6,4 A1>-*+; 1+7

>*++7F1-74 82-@ A1:2FD 2,>*:7 2, -@7 ;@*+-(

-7+: N:1, UZ\\'.

%&&ZV. Y71,7 1,4 X*F>7;;A6F U2, -7+:; *A 2,>*:7V

>7;;A6F >@2F4+7,9 )@7

2:1-2*, *A -@2; +7;71+>@ 2; -@1- C#" 2-61F 1(

^ "AA7>-; *A I,2B7+;2-D 3@1+1>-7+2;-2>; 1,4 $>147:2> [7?6F1-2*,; *, #-647,- C7+;2;-7,>7. P7?+77 3*:


9/43

-2*, 1,4 -@1- +7F1S2,? ;@*+-(-7+: >+742- >*,(

;-+12,-; @1B7 *,FD @1B7 1 :2,2:1F 7AA7>- *,

2*:7 42B247 2, >*FF7?7

1--7,41,>7 2, -@7 I# ,*-7; -@1- -@2; 2,7L61F(2-D b16:6F1-2*, *FF7?7(

?*2,? 1?79c )@7 D 2:1-2*, *A -@7;7

;-6427; 2; -@1- -+D2,? -* +7F1S ;@*+-(-7+: A2(

,1,>21F >*,;-+12,-; 2, 1--7,42,? C#" 82FF E7

F1+?7FD 2,7AA7>-2B79

)@2; E*4D *A 8*+N +77;; -* C#" 2, 31,1419 #2A2>1FFD. 87 144 -*

-@7 7S2;-2,? F2-7+1-6+7 ED 2,>F642,? 1 :*+7

>*:N?+*6,4 B1+21EF7;

8@2>@ 1+7 47-7+:2,74 E7A*+7 7,-+D 2,-* C#"

-* 1;;7;; -@7 2:- *A -@7;7 B1+21EF7; *,

1>>7;; -* >*FF7?7 1,4 6,2B7+;2-D 1,4 @*8 2,(

-+*46>2,? -@7;7 1442-2*,1F B1+21EF7; 1AA7>-;7;-2:1-7; *A -@7 :*+7 >*,B7,-2*,1F :71;(

6+7;. ;6>@ 1; A1:2FD 2,>*:7. 1; 87FF 1; 1-2*,9

)@2; 8*+N 1F;* A2-; 2,-* 1 ;2A2>1FFD 31(

,1421, F2-7+1-6+79 )@7 1>>6:6F1-74 7B247,>7

;6??7;-; -@1- -@7 47:1,4 A*+ C#" 2, 31,141

2; 7 2,7F1;-2> U56,*+ 1,4 I;@7+. %&&hV. 1F(

-@*6?@ -62-2*, 2,>+71;7; :1D @1B7 1 F1+?7+2:- *, 2,42B2461F; A+*: F*8(2,>*:7 A1:2(

F27; U3*7FF2. %&&_V9 j*-@ 3@+2;-*F647 *:7 2, -@72+ :*47F; *A C#" 2*FF7?7. 8@2F7 -62-2*,

?7,7+1FFD @14 F2--F7 ?7,7+1F 7AA7>-. E6- :1D

@1B7 :*+7 2:- *, 2,42B2461F; A+*: F*8

2,>*:7 A1:2F27;9 J+7,7--7 U%&&_V 1,4 P+*F7-

U%&&_V ;2:2F1+FD A2,4 -@1- C#" 1--7,41,>7 ?1*:7 A1:2F27; 2;

,1++*874 8@7, >*FF7?7; 1,4 6,2B7+;2-27; 1+7

E*-@ >*,;247+74. E6- -@1- ;-647,-; A+*: F*8(

2,>*:7 A1:2FD 1+7 F7;; F2N7FD -* 1--7,4 72-@7+.7;21FFD 6,2B7+;2-D9

)8* +7>7,- ;-6427; UJ+7,7--7. %&&_.

%&&nV. @1B7 1F;* >1;- 4*6E- *, -@7 >+742-

>*,;-+12,- @D*,;-+12,-;9 [1-@7+ 2- 2; 42AA7+7,>7; 2, ;-1,(

41+42W74 -7;- ;>*+7; 1,4 @2?@ ;>@**F :1+N;-@1- 7S7; 12:74 1-

+7F1S2,? >+742- >*,;-+12,-; U79?9. F*1,; 1,4

7B7, ?+1,-;V :1D E7 :2;42+7>-74 1,4 :2?@-

E7 E7--7+ 6-2F2W74 1- 2:@**F F7B7F

*+ *;-; 1,4 E7,7(A2-; *A 746>1-2*,9

A#("*6*/*;0

)@2; +7;71+>@ 6;7; 1 +7F1-2B7FD ;-1,41+4

7:1F :*47F A*+ 7;-2:1-2,? 1>>7;; -* C#".

8@7+7 1>>7;; 2; -1N7, -* E7 1 A6,>-2*, *A 42A(

A7+7,- ;7-; *A 2,AF67,>7;. 8*+N2,? A+*: 1

;:1FF7+ ;7- *A +7?+7;;*+;. 2,>F642,? -@7 -2B7,7;; *A #-647,- $24 h


10/43

>2N?+*6,4 B1+21EF7; >*,B7,(

-2*,1FFD 2,>F6474 2, ;6>@ :*47F;. 1,4 E62F42,?

-* 1 :*+7 >*:-*+; *A >*B1+21-7; -@1- 2,AF67,>7 . -@7

q2 1+7 -@7 >*7AA2>27,-; 1;;*>21-74 82-@ 71>@

;7- *A p. 1,4 s 2; -@7 >F1;;2>1F ;-*>@1;-2> 7++*+

-7+:9

pZ >*:*,B7,-2*,1F A1:(

2FD E1>N?+*6,4 B1+21EF7; ;6>@ 1; A1:2FD 2,(

>*:7. 1-2*,. A1:2FD -D9

8@2>@ 1+7 -D1FFD -1N7, 2, -@7 F2-7+1-6+7 -*E7 -@7 2:1-*+; *A -@7 14B1,(

-1?7; *A A1:2FD E1>N?+*6,4 2, -7+:; *A ?*2,?

*, -* C#"9 )@1- 2;. 2,42B2461F; A+*: @2?@7+ 2,(

>*:7 A1:2F27; *+ U7;21FFDV -@*;7 82-@ :*+7

@2?@FD 746>1-74 1-*+;9

$ ,7S- ;7- *A +7?+7;;*+;. p^. 2,>F647 *-@7+

N2,4; *A 2,AF67,>7; -@1- @1B7 E77, ?12,2,?2,>+71;2,? 1--7,-2*, 1; 7;; -* C#"9 )@7;7 2,>F647 :71;6+7; *A

b7,?1?7:7,-c 1,4 b2,>F6;2*,.c ;6>@ 1; @*8

>*,,7>-74 -@7 ;-647,- A7F- -* @2; *+ @7+ @2?@

;>@**F. 1 ;-647,-Q; ;7FA(17 1,4 >*:7. 2@2F4+7,. 7->9

K- ;@*6F4 E7 +7>*?,2;74 -@1- -@7;7 1442(

-2*,1F 2,AF67,>7; 4* ,*- ,7>7;;1+2FD @1B7 1

,1-6+1F. b7>*,*:7-+2>1FFD(>*++7>-c *+47+2,?

2, -7+:; *A -@72+ 2,>F6;2*,. 16;7 87

4* ,*- D7- 6,47+;-1,4 -@7;7 7;;7; B7+D

87FF9 J6+-@7+ 8*+N 82FF 6,4*6E-74FD >*,-2,67

*6+ 14B1,>7; 2, -@2; +7;-9 X@1- 2; :*;-

2:6++7,- 1,1FD;2;. @*87B7+. 2;-@1-MU2V -@7D 1+7 1FF 47-7+:2,74 E7A*+7 -@7

7,-+D 2,-* C#" U8@2>@ 2; 8@7, -@7D @1B7 E77,

:71;6+74 e 2979. 46+2,? -@7 71+F27+ N?+*6,49 d7,>7. 2,>F642,?

-@7: 82FF >*:2;7 2, :*B2,? -*(

81+4; U2V 247,-2AD2,? 1 A6FF7+ ;7- *A 2,AF67,>7;

*A 1>>7;; -* C#". 1,4 U22V ;772,? @*8 1442,?

_ "AA7>-; *A I,2B7+;2-D 3@1+1>-7+2;-2>; 1,4 $>147:2> [7?6F1-2*,; *, #-647,- C7+;2;-7,>7. P7?+77 3*:


11/43

;6>@ 1442-2*,1F :71;6+7; 1AA7>-; *6+ 6,47+(

;-1,42,? *A -@7 42+7>- 1,4 2,42+7>- 7AA7>-; *A

A1:2FD E1>N?+*6,4 *, 1>>7;; -* C#"9

l1+2*6; 6F1+ ;2A2>1-2*,; *A -@2;:*47F 1+7 7;-2:1-74. 1FF *A 8@2>@ 6;7 1 :6F(

-2,*:21F F*?2- ;7-(6< -* 42AA7+7,-21-7 E7-877,

1>>7;; -* >*FF7?7 1,4 6,2B7+;2-D9R K- 2; 2:*:7 U1F-@*6?@ ,*- ,7>7;;1+2FD 7F2:2(

,1-7V -@2; 7,4*?7,72-D *,;2;-7,- 82-@ *6+ ?*1F *A

7;-2:1-2,? -@7 7:1F +7F1-2*,;@2@1,?7 U*+

,*-V 1; -@7 :*47F 2,>F647; +2>@7+ ;7-; *A +7(

?+7;;*+;9 $442,? -@7 :*+7 >*:-2B7,7;; *A #-647,- $24 i

RX7 1+7 181+7 -@1- -@7 6;7 *A 1 :6F-2,*:21F F*?2- :*47F +7L62+7; -@7 1;;6:*FF7?7 *+ 6,2B7+;2-D 1+7 ,*- F 2N7FD 2,471-2*,; *6-F2,74 E7F*8 6;2,? 1 :6F-2,*:21F @ 4*7; ,*- +7L62+7 -@2; ;-+*,? 1;;6:1;7; 424 -@7

+7;6F-; >@1,?7 :1+N74FD A+*: -@*;7


12/43

)@7 472474 -* 7,-7+ C#" 1- -@2; F642,? -@*;7 8@*@1B7 47>2474 ,*- -* 1--7,4 1; 87FF 1; -@*;7

8@* :1D ?* F1-7+9 X@2F7 2- 8*6F4 1F;* E7 2,(

-7+7;-2,? e 1,4 2, ;*:7 81D; :*+7 2,-7+7;-(

2,? e -* F**N 1- 1>>7;; 8@7, 2,42B2461F; 1+7

*F47+ 1,4 8*6F4 -@7+7A*+7 @1B7 @14 :*+7

-2:7 -* +7-6+, -* -@72+ ;-6427; 1A-7+ ,*- 7,(

-7+2,? C#" 42+7>-FD A+*: @2?@ ;>@**F. *-@7+

8*+N @1; A*6,4 -@1- -@7 +7F1-2*,;@2< E7(

-877, 2


13/43

*6;FD 4* ,*- *E;7+B7 1,D @ 1,4

J+1,>7;>*,2. %&&ZV 2; -@1- -@7 7AA7>- *A *:7 e 7;21FFD 2, -@7 F1-7(-77, D71+;

8@7, C#" 47>2;2*,; 1+7 :147 e 2; 42:2,2;@74

?+71-FD *,>7 87 >*,-+*F A*+ 1-2*,9T

J*+ 7S1:*,-+*F; A*+

:1F7; -@1- 4* ,*- 2,>F647 1-2*,;@*8 -@1- 1 *:7 F7B7F *A

]Z&&.&&& 1,4 *B7+ 2; 1;;*>21-74 82-@ 1 Z\9Z

7,-1?7 +71;7 2, -@7 *:*,(

-+*F ?+*6< *A ]_&.&&& -* ]n_.&&&9 X@7, 1-2*, F7B7F 2; 2,>F6474. @*87B7+.

-@2; A2?6+7 4+*- *A 8*+N2,? 46+2,? ;>@**F 1,4 -@7 7AA7>- *A 7:9 *, -@7 *,41+D 746>1-2*, >@*2>79 K- 2; *6+ *


14/43

*:7; *;- *A

\9% 7,- F*87+ +1-7; *A >*FF7?7 1--7,(

41,>79 )@2; :1N7; ;7,;7M 1-2*,

>@1,?7; ,*- *,FD @*8 :1,D 2,42B2461F; ?* *,-* C#" U-@7 ,7- 2,>+71;7 *A ^_9\ 7,- +7-; -1N7, -*?7-@7+ 2,

-@7 7S1:@**F2,? -@7D 7,?1?7 2,

U2,>+71;2,? 6,2B7+;2-D F7B7F ;>@**F2,? 1,4 47(

>+71;2,? >*FF7?7 F7B7F 21-; 2, -@7 7>*,*:7-+2>1FFD 1*:7 U1; >61-2*, 1+7 2:7 -* C#"9 d7 >*:(

@2F4+7, +1,4*:FD 1;;2?,74 -* 14*@2F4+7, 8@* F2B7 82-@ -@72+E2+-@ *,-+*F ?+*6*:7. E6- 746>1-2*, 2; 1, 2:72B74 2, @2?@ ;>@**F 1- -@7 -2:7 *A -@7 A2+;-

81B7 *A -@7 ;6+B7D 2, %&&& 8@7, -@7;7

D*6,? 2F2-1-7 -@7 +7F7B1,- >*:(

@**F 1B7+1?7 ?+147

U,6:7+2>1F ;>*+7V @1; 1 ,7?1-2B7 7AA7>- *,>*FF7?7 2


15/43

)@7;7 +7;6F-; 1+7 1F:*;- 247,-2>1F A*+ E*-@

A7:1F7; 1,4 :1F7;9U

d2?@ ;>@**F ?+147; 2, 71>@ *A :1-@. F1,(

?61?7. 1,4 ;>27,>7 U1F;* ,6:7+2>1F ;>*+7;V.1F;* D27F4 >*7AA2>27,-; *A -@7 ;1:7 ;2?,. 1F(

-@*6?@ *A ;:1FF7+ :1?,2-647;. ;6??7;-2,?

-@1- 2- 2; *B7+1FF ?+147;. +1-@7+ -@1, 1,D 2,42(

B2461F ?+147. -@1- 2; 2:F6474 U>*F6:, _V. 2- 2; -@7 *B7+1FF ?+147

-@1- 2; *A 79

$, 2,-7+7;-2,? 6F1+ +7;6F- 2; -@1- -@7

:1-@ ?+147 2; ,6:7+2>1FFD -@7 F71;- 2:7.

8@7-@7+ -@7 B1+21EF7 7,-7+; -@7 :*47F 2,42(

B2461FFD *+ =*2,-FD 82-@ -@7 *-@7+ ?+147 B1+2(

1EF7;9 )@7 F1>N *A ,6:7+1>D ;N2FF; U1- F71;- 1;

+7AF7>-74 ED -@7 :1-@ ?+147V 4*7; ,*- 1*6F4 >@1,?7 2A 87 87+7 -*

F**N 1- ;2A2> 1+71 *A ;-64D. 82-@ :1-@

?+147; F2N7FD -* E7 +7F1-74 -* 7,-+D 2,-* -@7

;>27,>7;. 7,?2,77+2,?. 1,4 *-@7+ 42;>2@ 47-; *A *:7 +7:12, +7F1-2B7FD6,>@1,?74 8@7, @2?@ ;>@**F ?+147; 1+7 2,(

>F6474. 8@7+71; -@7 7AA7>- *A 1(

-2*, 2; 1--7,61-74. 2, ;*:7 >1;7; ;2?,2A2>1,-FD

;*. 2, E*-@ -@7 >1;7; *A :1F7; 1,4 A7:1F7;9

J*+ 7S1:- *A @1B2,? 7 47>F2,7; A+*: h_9Z 7,-1?7 F6474 U>*F6:,_V9 J*+ 8*:7,. -@7 >@1,?7 2; A+*: ^n9% 7,- -* Z\9\ 7,-9 )@7;7 +7;6F-; ;6??7;-

-@1- -@7 2,AF67,>7 *A 1-2*,

8*+N;. 1- F71;- 2, @**F

?+147;. 8@7+71; 2,>*:7 2; >1@ 2;

;-+7,?-@7,74 ED -@7 +7;6F-; 8@2>@ A*FF*8V9

)@2; A2,42,? 2; 2,-7+7;-2,? -* >*:N:1, 1,4

B1+2*6; >*(16-@*+;V9 )@7D A2,4 -@1- -@7 ;2?(

,2A2>1,- 7AA7>-; *A A1:2FD 2,>*:7 *, I9#9 >*F(

F7?7 1--7,41,>7 Ub6,2B7+;2-Dc A*+ 6;V 1+7

F1+?7FD 7F2:2,1-74 *,>7 1, KG -7;- ;>*+7 *E(

-12,74 8@7, -@7 F6474 2, -@7 :*47F9 )@72+ 2,-7+(*,-7S- 8@7+7 -@7D 4* ,*-

2,>F647 1-2*, 2, -@72+ :*47F; e

2; -@1- A1:2FD 2,>*:7 2;. 2, -@7 1E;7,>7 *A -@7

-7;- ;>*+7. @**F2,? 1,4 *-@7+ ;6>@ 2,AF67,>7;9

06+ A2,42,? *A 1 +746>74 1-2*,

7AA7>- 1; @2?@ ;>@**F ?+147; 1+7 14474 @2F4Q; @2?@ ;>@**F *6->*:7;

8@2>@ 2; E72,? >1-; *A A1:2FD 2,>*:7 *, -@7;79 !71,8@2F7.

*6+ A2,42,? *A 1, 7,46+2,? 2,>*:7 7AA7>- ;6?(

!"#$ ( !71;6+2,? -@7 "AA7>-2B7,7;; *A #-647,- $24 Z&

U31-7?*+2>1F ?+147; 87+7 1F;* -+274 2, 7 *A -@7 >*,-2,6*6; ,6:7+2>1F ?+147; 2, -@7;7 -8* -1EF7; U79?9. _&(i&t. i&(n&t. 7->9V9 )@7 +7(

;6F-; 87+7 7;;7,-21F -@7 ;1:7 1; -@*;7 1-7?*+2>1F B1+21EF7; U79?9. i&(n& 7,- 7L61F;

i_ 7,-. 7->9V9 $ 2, -@7 :*47F9

$?12,. -@7+7 87+7 ,* 2:7; 82-@ -@7 +7;6F-;


16/43

?7;-; :*,7D :2?@- E7 :1--7+2,? 1- -@7 @ *A -@7 -@+77 @2?@ ;>@**F 7,?1?7(

:7,- B1+21EF7; U1; 87FF 1; -@7 -8* ;6E>1-7?*(

+27; -@1- >*:147:2> 7,?1?7:7,-B1+21EF7 e 1>147:2> 247,-2A2>1-2*, 1,4 1>1(

47:2> 27

*, >*FF7?7 1--7,41,>79

)@7 :*;- 2:147:2>

2@**F.

4*2,? @*:78*+N. 7->9V 8@2>@ 2; 2:*:147:2> 7,?1?7:7,- B1+21EF7. 8@2>@ 2;1 ;2:147:2> 2147:2> 247,-2A2>1-2*,. -@7 F1--7+ E72,?

E1;2>1FFD 1 :71;6+7 *A B1F62,? 1,4 E7F*,?2,?

1- ;>@**F9 J*+ A7:1F7;. E72,? *,7 ;-1,41+4

47B21-2*, 1E*B7 -@7 :71, *, -@2; 1>147:2>

21F7 2,>+71;7; 6,2B7+;2-D 1--7,(

41,>7 ED 1E*6- Z^9\ 7,-1?7 *:147:2> 247,-2A2(

>1-2*, 7AA7>-; 1+7 ;2?,2A2>1,-. E6- 1 F2--F7

871N7+. 2, -@7 i(n 7,- 7AA7>- +1,?79

K, 1442-2*,. -@7 2,AF67,>7 *A 1-2*, 47>F2,7; 2, 2:7 *,>7 1>1(47:2> 2F6474. ;6??7;-2,?

-@1- -@7 -8* B1+21EF7; 1+7 *++7(

F1-74. 16;7 1-2*, -7,4 -* -71>@ -@72+ >@2F4+7,

-* @1B7 ?**4 8*+N @1E2-; 1,4 ;* *, e *+ E7(

>16;7 -@7D *-@7+82;7 @1;7 -@7 2,6++2>6F1+ 1>-2B2-27;. >F6E;. 7->9V -@1-

E62F4 -@7;7 E7@1B2*6+;. *+ E7>16;7 -@7D *-@(

7+82;7 -+1,;A7+ *+ ?7,7+1-7 -@7 1--+2E6-7;-@1- E62F4 1>147:2> 221F 7,?1?7:7,- +7AF7>-; -@7 47?+77 -*

8@2>@ 1, 2,42B2461F A77F; 1>>7


17/43

1,4 2,>F6474 2, -@7 @2?@ ;>@**F 7,B2+*,:7,-.

1,4 1F-@*6?@ 2- 2; *FF7?7 1--7,41,>79

#7FA(7- ;@*8 -@1- 1FF -@+77 1+7

1,-FD >*++7F1-74 82-@6,2B7+;2-D e E6- ,*- >*FF7?7 e 1--7,41,>7. 1-

F71;- 8@7, 7,-7+74 2,42B2461FFD9 #7FA(7AA2>1>D.

@*87B7+. @1; -@7 F1+?7;- 7AA7>- A*+ E*-@

:1F7; 1,4 A7:1F7;. 1E*6- -82>7 -@7 2:- *A

-@7 *-@7+ -8* :71;6+7;9

#*>21F ;627,- 7;-2:1-7; 1+7 +7F1(

-2B7FD ;:1FF. 1,4 -@7 B1+21EF7 2; ,*- ;2?,2A2>1,-A*+ A7:1F7;9 )@7;7 +7;6F-; -@6; ;6??7;- -@1-

-@*;7 8@* F**N -* 2:+*;;(,1-2*,1F C+*?+1::7 A*+ K,-7+,1-2*,1F#-647,- $;;7;;:7,- UCK#$V +7142,? -7;- +7(

;6F-;9 )@7 *++7;


18/43

8@2F7 -@7 2,>F6;2*, *A -@7 +7142,? ;>*+7 47(

>+71;7; -@7 B1F67 *A 1-2*, 1-

-@7 E1>@7F*+Q; 1,4 ?+1461-7 F7B7F; UA*+ 7S1:(

*:N:1, U%&&%V 8@* 1F;* 6;7

;-1,41+42W74 -7;- ;>*+7; -* 7S7; 2, >*FF7?7 1--7,41,>7 2, -@7 I,2-74

#-1-7;9

K- 2; 2:*+7; 1+7 E1;74 *, 1>-61F -7;-;. 8@7+71; -@7

@2?@ ;>@**F ?+147; U;6>@ 1; -@*;7 ;@*8, 2,

)1EF7; %1 1,4 %EV 1+7 ;7FA(+7D

*, 7:*:21-74 47>+71;7 2, -@7

:1?,2-647 *A -@7 1-2*, B1+21EF7

U:12,FD 1- -@7 j$ 1,4 ?+1461-7 ;>@**F F7B7F;V

8@7, -@7 ;-1,41+42W74 -7;- ;>*+7 2; 2,>F6474U)1EF7; ^V B7+;6; 8@7, -@7 ;7FA(1;;7;;74

:71;6+7 *A 1E2F2-D 1+7 2,>F6474 2, -@7 :*47F;

U)1EF7; %V9X

X@7, 1FF -@7;7 ;>1F7 B1+21EF7; 1+7 >*,(

;247+74 -*?7-@7+ U>*F6:, Z_ 2, -@7 -1EF7;V.

-@7 +7;6F-; >*,-2,67 -* ;6??7;- +7F1-2B7FD F2--F7

2,AF67,>7 *, >*FF7?7 27. @*87B7+. 1,4

47;F6474. ;*:7 *A 8@2>@ 8*6F4 E7 7S-74 -*

E7 >*++7F1-74 1,4 @1B7 ;*:78@1- ;2:2F1+ 7A(

A7>-;. >7+-12, ;-+*,? 2,AF67,>7; >*,-2,67 -* E7

;77,9 K, 6F1+. 1>147:2> 21>D 1,4 +7142,? 1E2F2-D 1FF +7:12,2:*,-2,67 -* 42AA7+9 $ *,7(

;-1,41+4 47B21-2*, 2,>+71;7 A+*: -@7 :71,

*A 1>147:2> 2


19/43

2; 1 ;N2FF 47+2B74 *B7+ 1 *,;2;-7,- 82-@ -@7 71+F27+ 8*+N

*, -@2; ;6E=7>- ED 31:7+*, 1,4 d7>N:1,

UZ\\'. %&&ZV 1,4 31+,72+* 1,4 d7>N:1,

U%&&%V. 1FF *A 8@2>@ -*+; 2, 47-7+:2,2,?

;6>>7;; 2, C#" -@+*6?@ -@7 2,B7;-:7,-; A1:2(

F27; :1N7 2, -@72+ >@2F4+7,Q; 71+FD >*?,2-2B7

1,4 E7@1B2*6+1F 47B7F**,-2,67 -* ;@*8

;*:7 ;2?,2A2>1,>7. 1F-@*6?@ 2, 1 :*+7 :2S74

A1;@2*, U:7, B7+;6; 8*:7,V 1,4 2,42>1-2,?

?7,7+1FFD ;:1FF7+ 7AA7>-;. 2,>F647 ;*>21F ;6*,-2,67; -* @1B7 -@7 >6+2*6;

7AA7>- *A ;F2?@-FD 47>+71;2,? 6,2B7+;2-D 2+71;2,?

>*FF7?7 21;7 *A 8*:7,R

@ @1; 1 ;:1FF - *, 6,2B7+;2-D 1--7,41,>7 A*+ A7(

:1F7;R 1,4 2,>*,;2;-7,- 2@ @1; 1 ;:1FF ,7?1-2B7 7AA7>- *, 6,2B7+(

;2-D 2N?+*6,4 A1>-*+; 2, :*47F; *A 1>>7;; -*

C#"9 K, 6F1+. J2,,27. g1;>7FF7; 1,4

#877-:1, U%&&_V 1F;* A2,4 -@1- 2,>F642,? 1

B1+27-D *A @2?@ ;>@**F ?+147; 1,4 *-@7+ E1>N(

?+*6,4 B1+21EF7; +746>7; -@7 2,AF67,>7 *A 1-2*, *, 1>>7;; U-@7D 4* ,*- @1B7

1 A1:2FD 2,>*:7 B1+21EF7V9 )@7D 1F;* A2,4 -@1-

1-2*, 2; ;-2FF 1, 2:7 1A-7+ -@7;7 ?+147; 1,4 E1>N?+*6,4 B1+2(

1EF7; 1+7 -1N7, 2,-* >*,;247+1-2*,. 7;21FFD

1- -@7 6,2B7+;2-D F7B7F9 06+ +7;6F-; 1+7 ;2:2F1+9

>F%1F-%! 05 6/% 7-&=-&A'

X@1- >1, 87 :1N7 *A -@7;7 +7;6F-; -1N7,

-*?7-@7+O )@7 A1>- -@1- 1>147:2> 2@**F F7B7F 1,4 @2?@7+ CK#$

+7142,? 1E2F2-D +7;6F-; 1+7 2:1-2*, ;77:; *EB2*6;9

)@7 F7;;*, @7+7 2; -@1- -1F7,-. 8*+N2,? @1+4

1,4 E72,? +7;F71+FD +7(

F1-74 -* 1-2*, U7;21FFD *7AA2>27,-;

*, -@7;7 B1+21EF7; 2,42>1-7 -@1- -@7D 1+7 F7;;

2:-V 47-7+:2,1,-; *A 6,2B7+;2-D

2N?+*6,4B1+21EF7; 1+7 14474 -* -@7 :*47F9

)@7 -+1,;:2;;2*, :7>@1,2;: A+*: @2F4. @*87B7+. >1,,*- E7 1;>7+-12,74

A+*: *6+ 7;-2:1-7;9 P* @2?@FD 746>1-74 *:@. 6;2,? -@7 `K)# 41-1

*+ *-@7+ N2,4; *A 1,1FD;2;9

)@7 ?7,7+1FFD ;:1FF 1,4 *A-7, 2,;2?,2A2(

>1,- >*7AA2>27,-; *, -@7


20/43

,72+* 1,4 d7>N:1, U%&&%V. -* ,1:7 E6-

-@+77 *A -@7 +7F7B1,- +7>7,- ;-6427;9

J2,1FFD. -@7 :*47F; 1FF -a2,47- *A A1:(2FD 2,>*:7 *, 1>>7;; -* C#". +7?1+4F7;; *A

8@1- *-@7+ 7S7

47>F2,7 ;@1+*:7 2;

,*-. 2- ;77:;. =6;- >1@ *6+ A6FF7+ :*47F; 1+7 1EF7 -*

>*,-+*F A*+9 $?12,. -@7 2;7 :1,,7+ 2,8@2>@ A1:2FD 2,>*:7 42+7>-FD 1AA7>-; 1>>7;; -*

C#" +7:12,; E7D*,4 -@7 ;>*


21/43

*A >*:7 1,4 >*,A247,>7 1- ;>@**FV 2;

1F;* ;2?,2A2>1,-9

J*6+-@. 8@7, @2?@ ;>@**F ?+147;. 1>1(

47:2> 2*+7 *,-@7 CK#$ 1+7 14474 -* -@7 E1;2> :*47F. -@7

42+7>- 7AA7>- *A 1-2*, 2; 42:2,(

2;@74. E6- 2; A1+ A+*: 7F2:2,1-74. 1,4 +7:12,;

1, 2:7;; -* C#". 7;21FFD 6,2B7+;2-D9 )@7 F1+?(

7;- 4+*< 2, -@7 1-2*, 7AA7>-

>*:7; A+*: -@7 2,>F6;2*, *A -@7 CK#$ +7142,?

1E2F2-D ;>*+7. 1-*+ *A 1E2F2-D 1:*,? -@7 E1>N?+*6,4 B1+2(1EF7; 2,>F6474 2, -@7 :*47F U:1,D *A 8@2>@

1+7 ;7FA(+77 1>>7;; -*

C#"9 X7 >1,,*-. @*87B7+. 247,-2AD A+*: -@7;7

7;-2:1-7; -@7 2;7 7-1N7;9 K- >*6F4 E7 -@7 +7;6F- *A @2?@FD 746(

>1-74 @2F(

4+7,. -71>@2,? -@72+ >@2F4+7, E7--7+ 8*+N

@1E2-;. @1,?7 -@7 7S2?7,- F7B7F *A 1-2*,. 1F-@*6?@ D >*6F4 2,AF67,>7 2-;

F7B7F A*+ -*41DQ; D*6,? @ 1-2*, 2; +7F1-74. 1; 87FF

1; -@7 *-@7+ 42+7>- 2,AF67,>7; *, 1>>7;; -*

C#" 247,-2A274 2, *6+ :*47F;. ;6>@ 1; +7142,?

1E2F2-D. 1>147:2> 2@**F ?+147;9

#-2FF. -@2; :1D ,*- E7 1; ;2:@ 2, -@2; 1+71 U36,@1.

7- 1F9. %&&iR 36,@1 1,4 d7>N:1,. %&&nV +7(

=7>-; -@7 2471 -@1- 7>*,*:2> *6->*:7; ;6>@

1; 1>>7;; -* @2?@7+ 746>1-2*, >1, E7 147(

L61-7FD 7S@*-*:D9 [1-@7+ -@7 1>L62;2-2*, *A;N2FF; 2; >*:-2*,

E7-877, >*?,2-2B7. ,*,(>*?,2-2B7 1,4 7,B2(

+*,:7,-1F 2,AF67,>7;9 J6+-@7+:*+7. 2,B7;-(

:7,- 2, ;N2FF A*+:1-2*, A774; *, @ @1B7 -@7 @2?@7;-

+1-7 *A +7-6+,. -@7 F1>N *A -@7;7 2,B7;-:7,-;

>1, U1- F71;- 2, *:7 ED 2,B7;-(

:7,-; F1-7+ 2, F2A79Y

$>>*+42,? -* d7>N:1, U%&&&V >*?,2-2B7

1E2F2-27; U1; :71;6+74 ED KGV :1D @ 1; :*-2B1-2*,. ;7FA(

!"#$ ( !71;6+2,? -@7 "AA7>-2B7,7;; *A #-647,- $24 Zi

Yd7>N:1, 1,4 !1;-7+*B U%&&nM iV ,*-7Mc k1*FF7?7 1--7,41,>7 1>+*;; ;*>2*7>*,*:2> ?+*6*:7 F7B7F; 1+7 1;;*>21-74 82-@


22/43

42;>221F ;N2FF; >1, E7 7,@1,>74

1- F1-7+ 1?7;9 )@7;7 1+7 A1>-*+; 8@2>@ :*+7 *+

F7;; >*++7;F6474 2,

-@7 @ 8@2>@ 1+7 >7;;9 )@2; 2:2;2*,

2; :147. -@1- 8*6F4 @ 2, -@7 :7426:(-7+:. 1;

D :1N7+; -; *A I,2B7+;2-D 3@1+1>-7+2;-2>; 1,4 $>147:2> [7?6F1-2*,; *, #-647,- C7+;2;-7,>7. P7?+77 3*:


23/43

@##2'#)

j1++. m2>@*F1;9 Z\\^9 b$F-7+,1-2B7 J6,42,? [7;*6+>7; A*+ d2?@7+ "46>1-2*,.c Z\\^9 )@7 ">*,*:2> 5*6+,1F

Z&^UhZ'V. nZ'(n%'9

31:7+*,. #-7N:1,9 Z\\'9 bg2A7 3D>F7 #>@**F2,? 1,4 PD,1:2> #7F7>-2*, j21;M

!*47F; 1,4 "B247,>7 A*+ J2B7 3*@*+-; *A $:7+2>1, !1F7;.c 5*6+,1F *A C*F2-2>1F ">*,*:D Z&iU%V.%i%(^^^9

31:7+*,. #-7N:1,9 %&&Z9 b)@7 PD,1:2>; *A "46>1-2*,1F $--12,:7,- A*+ jF1>N.

d2;. 1,4 X@2-7 !1F7;. 5*6+,1F *A C*F2-2>1F ">*,*:D Z&\U^V. h__(\\9

31+,72+*. C1EF*. 1,4 51:7; 59 d7>N:1,9 %&&%9 b)@7 "B247,>7 *, 3+742- 3*,;-+12,-; 2, C*;-(#7>*,41+D

#>@**F2,?.c )@7 ">*,*:2> 5*6+,1F ZZ%Uh'%V. n&_(^h9

3@179 Z\\n9 b3*,>71-2*,.c )@7 ">*,*:2> 5*6+,1F Z&nUhh%V. n^'(_Z9

3@+2;-*@17F d*D9 %&&Z9 bJ1:2FD K,>*:7 1,4 C*;-(#7>*,41+D "46>1(-2*, 2, 31,141.c 31,1421, 5*6+,1F *A d2?@7+ "46>1-2*,. ZUZV. Znn(%&'9

3*7FF2. !2>@17F9 %&&_9 b)62-2*,. [1-2*,2,? 1,4 K,7L61F2-D 2, C*;-(#7>*,41+D "46>1-2*, $--7,41,>7.c I,2(

B7+;2-D *A j+2-2;@ 3*F6:E21 X*+N2,? C17

*A g2A7 3D>F7 #N2FF J*+:1-2*,.c 2, d1,4E**N *A -@7 ">*,*:2>; *A "46>1-2*,. l*F9 Z9 "49 "+2> $9 d1(

,6;@7N 1,4 J2,2; X7F>@9 m78 `*+NM "F;7B27+. i\n('Z%9

36,@1. JF1B2*. 1,4 51:7; 59 d7>N:1,9 %&&n9 b)@7 )7>@,*F*?D *A #N2FF J*+:1-2*,.c $:7+2>1, ">*,*:2>

[7B278. C17742,?; \nU%V. ^Z(hn9

P+*F7-. !1+279 %&&_9 bC1+-2>2*,41+D "46>1-2*, 2, 31,141M d1; -@7 [*F7 *A C1+7,-1F K,(

>*:7 1,4 "46>1-2*, 3@1,?74 *B7+ -@7 Z\\&;Oc #-1-2;-2>; 31,141. $,1FD-2>1F #-6427; j+1,>@ [7(

;71+>@ C11(

-2*,1F $--12,:7,-;.c ">*,*:2>1 i'U%n&V. Z^n(_i9

J2,,27. [*;;. "+2> g1;>7FF7;. 1,4 $+-@6+ #877-:1,9 %&&_9 bX@* k*7;O )@7 P2+7>- 1,4 K,42+7>- "AA7>-; *A

J1:2FD j1>N?+*6,4 *, $>>7;; -* C*;-;7>*,41+D "46>1-2*,.c 2, d2?@7+ "46>1-2*, 2, 31,1419 "49

j71>@. 3@1+F7; !9. [*E2, X9 j*1481D. 1,4 [9 !1+B2, !>K,,2;9 !*,-+71F 1,4 Y2,?;-*,M !>k2FF(

G677,Q; I,2B7+;2-D C+7;;. %\_(^^'9

J2,,27. [*;;. 1,4 [*,1F4 !7,?9 %&&_9 bg2-7+1>D 1,4 g1E*6+ !1+N7- 06->*:7;M #7FA(1;;7;;:7,- B7+;6;

)7;- #>*+7 !71;6+7;.c $7 A+*: 1 g1+?7(;>1F7

C+2>7 P7+7?6F1-2*, 2, C+*A7;;2*,1F C+*?+1:;.c #-1-2;-2>; 31,141. $,1FD-2>1F #-6427; [7;71+>@ C1-2B7,7;; *A #-647,- $24 Z'


24/43

J+7,7--7. !1+>9 %&&n9 bX@D 1+7 `*6-@ A+*: g*87+(2,>*:7 J1:2F27; g7;; g2N7FD -* $--7,4 I,2B7+;2-DO

"B247,>7 A+*: $>147:2> $E2F2-27;. C1+7,-1F K,AF67,>7;. 1,4 J2,1,>21F 3*,;-+12,-;c #-1-2;-2>; 31,(

141. $,1FD-2>1F #-6427; [7;71+>@ C1N:1,. 51:7; 59 %&&&9 bC*F2>27; -* J*;-7+ d6:1, 31@ 2, ">*,*:2>; _hUZV. ^(_i9

d7>N:1,. 51:7; 59 %&&n9 b)@7 ">*,*:2>;. )7>@,*F*?D 1,4 m76+*;>27,>7 *A d6:1, 31>7;; 1,4 #-647,- J2,1,>7 2, 31,(

1419 !*,-+71FM )@7 31,1421, !2FF7,,26: #>@*F1+;@2< J*6,41-2*,9

Y71,7. !2>@17F C9 %&&%9 bJ2,1,>21F $24. j*++*82,? 3*,;-+12,-;. 1,4 3*FF7?7 $--7,41,>7M "B247,>7 A+*:

#-+6>-6+1F ";-2:1-7;.c $:7+2>1, ">*,*:2> [7B278. C17742,?; \%U%V. %\^(n9

Y71,7. !2>@17F C9. 1,4 Y7,,7-@ K9 X*F1-2*, $--12,:7,-.c K,-7+,1-2*,1F ">*,*:2> [7B278 h%UhV. Z&_Z(ZZ&^9

!6++1D. 3@1+F7;9 %&&%9 bKG 1,4 K,>*:7 K,7L61F2-D 2, 1 #1:N?+*6,4;.c $:7+2>1, ">*,*:2> [7B278. C17742,?; \%U%V. ^^\(h^9

CF6?. "+2N. 1,4 X2: l2=B7+E7+?9 %&&^9 b#>@**F2,?. J1:2FD j1>N?+*6,4. 1,4 $4*1F ">*,*:D ZZZU^V. iZZ(hZ9

[7;-6>>21. P27?*. 1,4 31+F*; I++6-219 %&&h9 bK,-7+?7,7+1-2*,1F C7+;2;-7,>7 2, "1+,2,?;M )@7 [*F7 *A "1+FD

1,4 3*FF7?7 "46>1-2*,.c $:7+2>1, ">*,*:2> [7B278 \hU_V. Z^_h(n'9

#1>7+4*-7. j+6>79 %&&%9 b)@7 m1-6+7 1,4 m6+-6+7 *A ">*,*:2> 06->*:7;.c $:7+2>1, ">*,*:2> [7B278.

C17742,?; \%U%V. hh(h'9

Z\ "AA7>-; *A I,2B7+;2-D 3@1+1>-7+2;-2>; 1,4 $>147:2> [7?6F1-2*,; *, #-647,- C7+;2;-7,>7. P7?+77 3*:


25/43

!,O/#) ,26 +.;75#)

!,O/# PZ !6F-2,*:21F g*?2- ";-2:1-7; *A $>>7;; -* 3*FF7?7 1,4 I,2B7+;2-D

A,/#) +#-,/#)

P R P R

?*//#;# F2.G#5).(0 ?*//#;# F2.G#5).(0 ?*//#;# F2.G#5).(0 ?*//#;# F2.G#5).(0

I> /*',(.*2 = F5O,2U[6+1FV (&9&h'i

&9Z&%

(&9&hh_

&9&n__

(&9&\hh

&9&i'i

(&9&'%_

&9&^_Zv

w&9&Zix w&9&Z\x w&9&Zix w&9&Z'x w&9&Zix w&9&Z\x w&9&Zix w&9&Z'x

I> 45*G.2'#U0mV

m78A*6,4F1,4 1,4 g1E+14*+ (&9ZZZ &9Z%n (&9ZZ% &9Z&\ (&9Z^& &9Zh% (&9Z%h &9Z^nw&9&%^x w&9&%'x w&9&%^x w&9&%ix w&9&%%x w&9&%ix w&9&%%x w&9&%_x

C+2,>7 "481+4 K;F1,4 (&9Z__ &9%^' (&9Z_& &9%&& (&9Zn^ &9%Zi (&9Zi^ &9Z''w&9&%Zx w&9&%\x w&9&%%x w&9&%nx w&9&Z\x w&9&%_x w&9&Z\x w&9&%hx

m*B1 #>*-21 (&9Zh_ &9%h% (&9Z^n &9Z\^ (&9Zi\ &9%Z\ (&9Z_' &9Z\_w&9&%&x w&9&%ix w&9&%Zx w&9&%_x w&9&Z'x w&9&%^x w&9&Z\x w&9&%^x

m78 j+6,;82>N (&9Zi_ &9Zn% (&9Zi_ &9Z_n (&9Zi^ &9Zn' (&9Z_n &9Zi&w&9&%&x w&9&%nx w&9&Z\x w&9&%_x w&9&Z\x w&9&%^x w&9&Z\x w&9&%^x

!1,2-*E1 (&9%Z_ &9&'\' (&9%ZZ &9&ni' (&9Zh' &9&n'h (&9Zhn &9&n'&w&9&Zix w&9&%\x w&9&Zix w&9&%nx w&9&%&x w&9&%ix w&9&%&x w&9&%_x

#1;N1->@781, (&9Zn& &9&'%_ (&9Znh &9&in^ (&9Z^\ &9&h^nv (&9Zh& &9&^n'

w&9&Z'x w&9&%_x w&9&Z'x w&9&%^x w&9&Z\x w&9&%_x w&9&Z\x w&9&%^x$FE7+-1 (&9ZhZ (&9&%hh (&9Zh^ (&9&%i\ (&9&\&\ (&9&\&h (&9&\_n (&9&'%&

w&9&Z'x w&9&%Zx w&9&Z'x w&9&%&x w&9&%&x w&9&%^x w&9&Z\x w&9&%Zx

j+2-2;@ 3*F6:E21 (&9&'i' &9&&\h\ (&9&''% (&9&&i_' (&9&_\% (&9&_i\! (&9&iZi (&9&_\iw&9&%&x w&9&%%x w&9&%&x w&9&%&x w&9&%&x w&9&%%x w&9&%&x w&9&%Zx

+5#2'" -.2*5.(0 *7().6# D? U$FF

0-@7+;V

&9&_nhv (&9&Z^_ &9&_i_v (&9&ZZ' &9&hih &9&Z&Z &9&_%&v &9&Z%_

w&9&^Zx w&9&îx w&9&^&x w&9&^%x w&9&%\x w&9&^%x w&9&%\x w&9&^Zx

+,-./0 !0H#U)8* C1+7,-;V

!*-@7+ *,FD (&9&^&' &9&Z&n (&9&%'\ (&9&&_'\ &9&Z_^ &9&%Zi &9&Z'^ &9&Z%h

w&9&%hx w&9&^^x w&9&%_x w&9&^&x w&9&%hx w&9&%\x w&9&%hx w&9&%'x

J1-@7+ *,FD &9&&hiZ (&9&_hi &9&%Z\ (&9&nZ\ (&9&ZZi (&9&hi (&9&Z%Z (&9&hZ%

w&9&_^x w&9&iZx w&9&_ix w&9&__x w&9&_^x w&9&iix w&9&_%x w&9&i&x

0-@7+ (&9&^\h (&9&'h^ (&9&%\\ (&9&î_ (&9&^&_ (&9Z'i (&9&î' (&9ZiZ!

w&9&_'x w&9&'hx w&9&ihx w&9Z&x w&9&_^x w&9&i'x w&9&_^x w&9&i^xL.).O/# -.2*5.(0U$FF *-@7+;V (&9&Z&^ &9Z'n (&9&&_%\ &9Znh (&9&&&'n &9Zh% &9&ZZZ &9ZZh

w&9&%nx w&9&^%x w&9&%nx w&9&^&x w&9&%nx w&9&^Zx w&9&%nx w&9&^Zx

?,2,6.,2 O0 .--.;5,(.*2UED

E2+-@V

(&9&%_\ &9Z_& (&9&&%i &9&_Zi (&9&_n &9Z'% (&9&%\n &9ZZZ

w&9&^'x w&9&hix w&9&h&x w&9&hhx w&9&^_x w&9&hZx w&9&^nx w&9&hZxL.).O/# A.2*5.(0 [ ?,2,6.,2 O0

.--.;5,(.*2U*-@7+;V

(&9&Z%% (&9ZZ%! (&9&Z'' (&9&i'% &9&&&\i_ (&9&'\' (&9&&i_Z (&9&hi'

w&9&__x w&9&hix w&9&_hx w&9&_^x w&9&i^x w&9&i%x w&9&i%x w&9&i%x4,5#2(,/\;7,56.,2N) %67',(.*2

Ud# >*:


26/43

)1EF7 Z >*,-2,674

A,/#) +#-,/#)

P R P R

3*FF7?7 I,2B7+;2-D 3*FF7?7 I,2B7+;2-D 3*FF7?7 I,2B7+;2-D 3*FF7?7 I,2B7+;2-D

4,5#2(,/ 12'*-# Q#G#/

U]_&&&& -* ]n_&&&V"S-+7:7FD F*8 U]&(]_&&&V &9&Z_ (&9&%&\ &9&Z_\ &9&&%i' (&9Z&Z! (&9&nn^ (&9&\_Z! (&9&'n

w&9&nZx w&9&'&x w&9&nZx w&9&i\x w&9&hix w&9&\nx w&9&hnx w&9&\_x

]_&&& -* ]%_&&& &9&Zi (&9Z&' &9&^ (&9&h'Z (&9&%%i (&9Z\Z (&9&%'' (&9Z&%

w&9&^^x w&9&^hx w&9&^_x w&9&^nx w&9&%\x w&9&^ix w&9&%\x w&9&^'x

]%_&&& -* ]_&&&& &9&Z\' (&9&_in &9&%%' (&9&Z^h (&9&&&nh (&9Z%h (&9&&'Zi (&9&'Z_

w&9&%&x w&9&%%x w&9&%&x w&9&%Zx w&9&Z\x w&9&%^x w&9&%&x w&9&%^x

]n_&&& -* ]Z&&&&& &9&&Zh_ &9ZZ& &9&Zin &9&h&Zv (&9&Z%Z &9&i_\ &9&&^^i &9&%&_

w&9&Z\x w&9&%_x w&9&%&x w&9&%^x w&9&%&x w&9&%hx w&9&%&x w&9&%^x

]Z&&&&& 1,4 6< (&9&Z&_ &9Z\Z &9&Z\Z &9&i&Z! (&9&_%i! &9Z\' (&9&Zh^ &9Z&^

w&9&%%x w&9&%'x w&9&%^x w&9&%ix w&9&%%x w&9&%_x w&9&%^x w&9&%ix

8O)#5G,(.*2) n'_% n'_% '^ZZ '^ZZP06%'E BF%1)A% ,)1A-&). %55%(6' )1% '/0!&" >,-66%= ()6%A01-%' )1% -& +)1%&6/%'-'" C6)&=)1= %1101' )1% -& O1)(@%6'" +QR"RS; !+QR"RT; U

+QR"S"

%Z "AA7>-; *A I,2B7+;2-D 3@1+1>-7+2;-2>; 1,4 $>147:2> [7?6F1-2*,; *, #-647,- C7+;2;-7,>7. P7?+77 3*:


27/43

!,O/# R,Z "AA7>-; *A d2?@ #>@**F k+147; *, $>>7;; -* 3*FF7?7 1,4 I,2B7+;2-D. !1F7;

9,)#/.2# P R S T U

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(04,5#2(,/\;7,56.,2N)

%67',(.*2Ud# >*:(

,-66%= ()6%A01-%' )1% -& +)1%&6/%'-'" D0&610.' -&(.$=% ).. 6/0'% -& 2)O.% S" C6)&=)1= %1101'

)1% -& O1)(@%6'" +QR"RS; !+QR"RT; U +QR"S" 7$.. 1%'$.6' )1% )F)-.)O.% $+0& 1%#$%'6"

!"#$ ( !71;6+2,? -@7 "AA7>-2B7,7;; *A #-647,- $24 %%


28/43

!,O/# ROZ "AA7>-; *A d2?@ #>@**F k+147; *, $>>7;; -* 3*FF7?7 1,4 I,2B7+;2-D. J7:1F7;

9,)#/.2# P R S T U

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0 ?*//#;#

F2.G#5=

).(0 ?*//#;#

F2.G#5=

).(0 ?*//#;#

F2.G#5=

).(0 ?*//#;#

F2.G#5=

).(0 ?*//#;#

F2.G#5=

).(04,5#2(,/\;7,56.,2N)

%67',(.*2

Ud# >*:U,6:7+2>1FV

(&9&&^h

&9&%Z\ (&9&&Z\v&9&Z^h

w&9&&&'x w&9&&&nx w&9&&ZZx w&9&&Z%x

A,(" ;5,6# *& /,)(

0#,5 I>U,6:7+2>1FV

(&9&&Z&v&9&&'& &9&&& &9&&&

w&9&&&_x w&9&&&nx w&9&&&ix w&9&&&nx

A,.2 /,2;7,;# ;5,6#

*& /,)( 0#,5 I>

U,6:7+2>1FV

(&9&&Z^v&9&Zh\ &9&&& &9&&^'w&9&&&nx w&9&&&nx w&9&&&'x w&9&&&\x

>'.#2'# ;5,6# *& I>U,6:7+2>1FV (&9&&^& &9&Z^^

(&9&&%h

&9&&n_

w&9&&&hx w&9&&&ix w&9&&&_x w&9&&&nx

8O)#5G,(.*2) '^ZZ '%&h 'Z^i 'Zi& n'i\ nih%

P06%'E BF%1)A% ,)1A-&). %55%(6' )1% '/0!&" >,-66%= ()6%A01-%' )1% -& +)1%&6/%'-'" D0&610.' -&(.$=% ).. 6/0'% -& 2)O.% S" C6)&=)1= %1101'

)1% -& O1)(@%6'" +QR"RS; !+QR"RT; U +QR"S" 7$.. 1%'$.6' )1% )F)-.)O.% $+0& 1%#$%'6"

%^ "AA7>-; *A I,2B7+;2-D 3@1+1>-7+2;-2>; 1,4 $>147:2> [7?6F1-2*,; *, #-647,- C7+;2;-7,>7. P7?+77 3*:


29/43

!,O/# S,Z "AA7>-; *A #-647,- j1>N?+*6,4 *, $>>7;; -* 3*FF7?7 1,4 I,2B7+;2-D. !1F7;

9,)#/.2# P R S T U V W

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(04,5#2(,/\;7,56.,2N) %67',(.*2Ud# >*:(


30/43

)1EF7 ^1 >*,-2,674

9,)#/.2# P R S T U V W

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0I> %2;,;#-#2()

#/&=H#5'#H(.*2c

>#/&=#)(##- &9&&nZ&9&ihn

w&9&&n&x

w&9&&nnx

>#/&=#&&.','0 (&9&&n &9Z&'Zw&9&&i

'x

w&9&&i\x

>#/&=-,)(#50

>*'.,/ >7HH*5(c

4,5#2()N 9#",G=

.*75)cA*2.(*5.2;

O#",G.*75

J75(75,2'#

O#",G.*75

12'*2).)(#2(

6.)'.H/.2#

U[7=7>-2*,(

*+27,-74

E7@1B2*6+V@#,6 2;


31/43

)1EF7 ^1 >*,-2,674

X Y Pb PP PR PS PT PU

?*//#;# F2 G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2 G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2 G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2 G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2 G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2 G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2 G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2 G#5=

).(04,5#2(,/ ;7,56 ,2N) %67',( *2

Ud# >*:


32/43

)1EF7 ^1 >*,-2,674

X Y Pb PP PR PS PT PU

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0I> %2;,;#-#2()

7

E7@1B2*6+

(&9&&Z &9&%%^ (&9&&nh &9&&Z_

w&9&&nZx w&9&&n\x w&9&&nix w&9&&nix

K,>*,;2;-7,-

42;>2-2*,(

*+27,-74

E7@1B2*6+V

(&9&&in (&9&^_n (&9&&n_ (&9&Z%'v

w&9&&nZx w&9&&n_x w&9&&n_x w&9&&nhx

@#,6 2;


33/43

!,O/# SOc "AA7>-; *A #-647,- j1>N?+*6,4 *, $>>7;; -* 3*FF7?7 1,4 I,2B7+;2-D. J7:1F7;

9,)#/.2# P R S T U V W

?*//#;# F2 G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2 G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2 G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2 G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2 G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2 G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2 G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2 G#5=

).(04,5#2(,/ ;7,56 ,2N) %67',( *2Ud# >*:(

-2B7,7;; *A #-647,- $24 %'


34/43

)1EF7 ^E >*,-2,674

9,)#/.2# P R S T U V W

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2.G#5=

).(0I> %2;,;#-#2()

-2*,(

*+27,-74

E7@1B2*6+V

@#,6.2;


35/43

)1EF7 ^E >*,-2,674

9,)#/.2# X Y Pb PP PR PS PT

?*//#;#F2 G#5=

).(0 ?*//#;#

F2 G#5=

).(0 ?*//#;#

F2 G#5=

).(0 ?*//#;#

F2 G#5=

).(0 ?*//#;#

F2 G#5=

).(0 ?*//#;#

F2 G#5=

).(0 ?*//#;#

F2 G#5=

).(0 ?*//#;#

F2 G#5=

).(04,5#2(,/ ;7,56 ,2N) %67',( *2

Ud# >*:-2B7,7;; *A #-647,- $24 ^&


36/43

)1EF7 ^E >*,-2,674

9,)#/.2# X Y Pb PP PR PS PT

?*//#;# F2 G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2 G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2 G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2 G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2 G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2 G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2 G#5=

).(0

?*//#;# F2 G#5=

).(0

I> %2;,;#-#2()

#/&=#)(##-(&9&&Zh &9&Z_n

w&9&&\'x w&9&Z&hx>#/&=#&&.','0

(&9&Z&Z &9&hii

w&9&&'hx w&9&&'nx>#/&=-,)(#50 (&9&&^' &9&_h'

(&9&Z&% &9&&%_w&9&&n x w&9&&' x

w&9&&\_x w&9&Z&%x>*'.,/ >7HH*5(c &9&Zn&! &9&Z%i

&9&Z'\!(&9&%\iw&9&&n&x w&9&&'_x

w&9&&'%x w&9&&\Zx4,5#2()N 9#",G=

.*75)c

A*2.(*5.2;

O#",G.*75

(&9&&^% &9&^'^(&9&&^' &9&%^_

w&9&&'&x w&9&&\ixw&9&&n\x w&9&&''x

J75(75,2'#

O#",G.*75

(&9&&h^ &9&&hn(&9&&_h (&9&&\i

w&9&&n x w&9&&' xw&9&&nix w&9&&'%x

12'*2).)(#2(6.)'.H/.2#

U[7=7>-2*,(

*+27,-74

E7@1B2*6+V

(&9&&hh (&9&^__ (&9&&hn (&9&ZiZ!w&9&&i'x w&9&&nix

w&9&&i\x w&9&&n%x@#,6.2;


37/43

!,O/#


38/43

!,O/# @**F k+147;. !1F7; 1,4 J7:1F7;

Categorical Grades (%)

Mean of Nu-merical Grades

90% to100% 80% to89% 70% to79% 60% to69% 55% to59% 50% to54% Lessthan50%

Total

Males

HS Overall Grade 5.9 26.2 41.8 21.4 3.3 0.9 0.6 100.0 75.58

HS Math Grade 9.6 22.2 30.3 25.9 7.3 4.1 0.6 100.0 73.99

HS Main Language Grade 5.8 27.7 36.2 23.1 4.4 2.5 0.2 100.0 75.14

HS Science Grade 11.4 25.7 26.9 19.2 8.0 5.2 3.5 100.0 73.54

Females

HS Overall Grade 9.0 38.6 37.9 12.1 1.7 0.5 0.3 100.0 78.90

HS Math Grade 10.3 23.7 31.0 22.7 6.0 5.8 0.6 100.0 74.46

HS Main Language Grade 13.3 39.4 31.4 13.2 1.6 1.1 0.1 100.0 79.71

HS Science Grade 13.3 30.5 26.8 16.3 6.2 4.2 2.6 100.0 75.67

J*(#c)* >1F>6F1-7 :71,;. >1-7+?*+2>1F ?+147; 1+7 >*,B7+-74 -* ,6:7+2>1F ?+147; 1; A*FF*8;M \&t -* Z&&t o \_R '&t -* '\t o '_R n&t -*

n\t o n_R i&t -* i\t o i_R __t -* _\t o _nR _&t -* _ht o _%R 1,4 F7;; -@1, _&t o %_9

^^ "AA7>-; *A I,2B7+;2-D 3@1+1>-7+2;-2>; 1,4 $>147:2> [7?6F1-2*,; *, #-647,- C7+;2;-7,>7. P7?+77 3*:


39/43

!,O/# '"**/ %2;,;#-#2( >',/#

>F%1).. '(/00. %&A)A%,%&6

!71;6+7; 1 +7;6;2,? 6-*+;9

[7F1-74 G67;-2*,;M P7+2B74 ED 1 ;2:147:2> 7,?1?7:7,-c 1,4 b;*>21F 7,?1?7:7,-9c

C0(-). %&A)A%,%&6

P7A2,74 1; -@7 247,-2A2>1-2*, 82-@ 1,4 E7@1B2*6+1F 2,B*FB7:7,- 2, -@7 ;*>21F 1;-; *A ;>@**F U-@7 ;>@**F ;*>21F F2A7V9 K- 2,(

B*FB7; E*-@ 1 A77F2,? *A E7F*,?2,? -* -@7 ;>@**FQ; ;*>21F 7,B2+*,:7,- 1,4 1 ;7,;7 *A A2- E7-877, -@7 2,42B2461F 1,4 -@7

;>@**F9 )@2; >*,,7>-2*, +7AF7>-; -@7 7S-7,- -* 8@2>@ ;-647,-; A77F >7F6474 1,4 ;621F 7,B2+*,:7,-9

@#/,(#6 D7#)(.*2)

`#$\Y C7*@**F 1+7 2,-7+7;-74 2, 8@1- K @1B7 -* ;1DR`#$\0 K @1B7 A+27,4; 1- ;>@**F 8@*: K >1, -1FN -* 1E*6- @**F 8@* >1, @7F< :7 82-@ ;>@**F 8*+N. 2A ,77474R#)^ZG&Z !D ;>@**F 2; 1 7 8@7+7 K A77F F2N7 1, *6-;247+R#)^ZG&% !D ;>@**F 2; 1 7 8@7+7 K :1N7 A+27,4; 71;2FDR#)^ZG&^ !D ;>@**F 2; 1 7 8@7+7 K A77F F2N7 K E7F*,?R#)^ZG&h !D ;>@**F 2; 1 7 8@7+7 K A77F 18N81+4 1,4 *6- *A 7R

#)^ZG&_ !D ;>@**F 2; 1 7 8@7+7 *-@7+ ;-647,-; ;77: -* F2N7 :7R#)^ZG&i !D ;>@**F 2; 1 7 8@7+7 K A77F F*,7FD9

B()=%,-( %&A)A%,%&6

P7A2,74 1; -@7 247,-2A2>1-2*, 82-@ 1,4 E7@1B2*6+1F 2,B*FB7:7,- U2147:2> 1;-; *A ;>@**F9 $>147:2>

1;-; *A ;>@**F 2,>F647 -@7 ;-647,-;Q 471F2,?; 82-@ -71>@7+;. >6++2>6F1. 1,4 -@7 ;>@**F ?*B7+,1,>79

[7F1-74 G67;-2*,;MP7+2B74 ED 1 ;2:147:2> 2147:2> 247,-2A2>1-2*,c9

B()=%,-( +)16-(-+)6-0&

J*>6;2,? *, -@7 A2+;- -@+77 F7B7F; *A -1S*,*:D -* 1>147:2> 2L627;>7,>7 -* -@7 ,774 -* 1--7,4 ;>@**F.

-* E7 6F1+. 1,4 1-@F7-2> 1;-; *A ;>@**F F2A7 2, 1442-2*, -* *+ 1; 1 ;6E;-2-6-7 A*+ 7S-7,;2B7

2147:2> 8*+N9

[7F1-74 G67;-2*,;M

`#$i @*6+; *, @*:78*+N *6-;247 *A >F1;; 46+2,? A+77 6- *+ ;N2


40/43

I.;" >'"**/ %2;,;#-#2( >',/#cB()=%,-( 4&A)A%,%&6U>*,-2,674V

B()=%,-( +)16-(-+)6-0&

!71;6+7; 1 +7;147:2> 247,-2A2>1-2*, 82-@ @2?@ ;>@**F. -@7 A*>6; *A 1--7,-2*, 2; *, -8* >*:1-2*,. B1F62,? 1,4 E7F*,?2,?9 $ ;-647,- 8@* A12F; -* 247,-2AD 82-@ ;>@**F 2; 7S-74 -* @1B7 1 F1>N *A B1F62,? A*+ -@7

;>@**F 1,4 1 F1>N *A A77F2,?; *A E7F*,?2,? -* -@7 ;>@**F9

[7F1-74 G67;-2*,;M

`#$'K K ?7- 1F*,? 87FF 82-@ -71>@7+;R`#$'5 K 1: 2,-7+7;-74 2, 8@1- K 1: F71+,2,? 2, >F1;;R`#$\" #>@**F 2; *,7 *A -@7 :*;- 2:F1;; 1+7 6;7F7;;R`#$\k !*;- *A :D -71>@7+; 4*,Q- +71FFD >1+7 1E*6- :7`#$\d !*;- *A -@7 -2:7. K 8*6F4 F2N7 -* E7 1,D 7 *-@7+ -@1, 2, ;>@**FR`#$\5 !*;- *A 8@1- K F71+, 2, ;>@**F 82FF E7 6;7A6F 8@7, K ?7- 1 =*ER`#$\g #>@**F 2; *A-7, 1 81;-7 *A -2:7R`#$\! #>@**F 2; :*+7 2:@7+; +71FFD F2;-7, -* 8@1- K @1B7 -* ;1DR#)^&G&h KA K ,774 7S-+1 @7F72B7 2- A+*: :D -71>@7+;R#)^&G&_ !*;- *A :D -71>@7+; -+71- :7 A12+FDR

#)^ZG&n !D ;>@**F 2; 1 7 8@7+7 K 4* ,*- 81,- -* ?*R#)^%G&i K 1: ?2B2,? 2,-7+7;-2,? @*:78*+N9

>#/&=H#5'#H(.*2

C%.58%'6%%,

)@7 ;7FA(7;-77: ;>1F7 -@1- 81; >@*;7, A*+ K)# 2; !*++2; [*;7,E7+?y;%% ;7FA(7;-77: ;>1F7 U[#"V U[*;7,E7+?. Z\i_. @ -* E7 7+-12,FD A77F 6;7F7;; 1- -2:7;R`#KZ5 $- -2:7; K -@2,N K 1: ,* ?**4 1- 1FF9

C%.58%55-()(9

P7A2,7; 1>147:2> ;7FA(7AA2>1>D 1; -@7 ;-647,-Q; >*:7 1,4 >*,A247,>7 2, 7 *A >F1;; 8*+N 1; 72B74 ED

-@7 ;-647,-9 )@2; >*,>71>D *+ :1;-7+D 8@2>@ 2; -@7 E7F27A -@1- *,7 @1; >*,(

-+*F *B7+ *,7Q; *8, 47;-2,D9

@#/,(#6 D7#)(.*2)`#$'Y K 1: >7+-12, K >1, 6,47+;-1,4 -@7 :*;- 42AA2>6F- :1-7+21F *,A247,- K >1, 4* 1, 7S>7FF7,- =*E *, 1;;2?,:7,-; 1,4 -7;-;R`#$'m K 1: >7+-12, K >1, :1;-7+ -@7 ;N2FF; E72,? -16?@-

^_ "AA7>-; *A I,2B7+;2-D 3@1+1>-7+2;-2>; 1,4 $>147:2> [7?6F1-2*,; *, #-647,- C7+;2;-7,>7. P7?+77 3*:


41/43

>#/&=H#5'#H(.*2U>*,-2,674V

C%.58,)'6%19

)@7 1F7 >@*;7, ED `K)# 2; E1;74 6@**F7+ UZ\n'V9 )@2; ;>1F7. +7A7++74 -* 1; -@7

!1;-7+D ;>1F7%_. 1;;7;;7; 1 A77F2,? *A 7 -* >*,>+7-7 F2A7 ;2-61-2*,;9 !1;-7+D >1, E7 47A2,74

1; 1 :71;6+7 -@1- 1;;7;;7; b-@7 7S-7,- -* 8@2>@ *,7 +7?1+4; *,7Q; F2A7>@1,>7; 1; E72,? 6,47+ *,7Q; *8, >*,-+*F 2, >*,-+1;-

-* E72,? A1-1F2;-2>1FFD +6F74c UC71+F2, 1,4 #>@**F7+. Z\n'V9 d7,>7. 2A *,7 ;>*+7; @2?@ *, -@7 :1;-7+D ;>1F7. *,7 4*7; ,*- A77F

F*;7 -*R`#PZJ )@7+7 1+7 *6,- *, 2, -2:7; *A -+*6EF7

4,5#2()E O#",G.*75)

C1+7,-; 8@* 1+7 ;6@**F 1,4 8@* @1B7 1 A2+: E6-

+7;1-2*,1F 1--12,:7,-9 )@7 7; ;>1F7; 1+7 47;2?,74 -* :71;6+7 -@+77 A1>7-; *A 7. 2,>*,;2;-7,- +7=7>-2*,(*+27,-74 42;>2-2*,V 1,4 :*,2-*+2,?9 $, *B7+1FF 1F7 81; ,*- A*+:74 A+*: -@7 -@+77 ;6E;>1F7;9

K0&-601-&A O%/)F-0$1

!71;6+7; -2B2-27;. 8@7+71E*6-; 1,4 A+27,4;9

@#/,(#6 D7#)(.*2)

CjZn$ Y,*8 8@7+7 >@2F4 ?*7; 1- ,2?@-RCjZnP Y,*8 8@1- >@2F4 2; 4*2,? 8@7, @7a;@7 ?*7; *6-RCjZnk Y,*8 8@* >@2F4 ;7,-7+74 7AA7>-2B7 7; ;6>@ 1; ,6+-6+(

1,>7. 2,B*FB7:7,-. 1,4 7:7,-9

@#/,(#6 D7#)(.*2)

CjZn3 C+12;7 >@2F4RCjZnJ g2;-7, -* >@2F4Q; 2471; 1,4 *@2F4 N,*8; -@1- -@7D 1+7 1-2B7,7;; *A #-647,- $24 ^i


42/43

4,5#2()E O#",G.*75)U>*,-2,674V

:&(0&'-'6%&6 =-'(-+.-&%U[7=7>-2*,(*+27,-74 E7@1B2*6+V

@#/,(#6 D7#)(.*2)

CjZnj #**, A*+?7- 1 +6F7 -@1- -@7D @1B7 :147RCjZn" m1? >@2F4 1E*6- F2--F7 -@2,?;RCjZnd Y77< +6F7; *,FD 8@7, 2- ;62-; -@7:;7FB7;R

CjZnK k7- 1,?+D 1,4 D7FF 1- >@2F4RCjZng )@+71-7, *6,-+27; *,FD U7S>7


43/43

!,O/# ;. #>1F7 l1+21EF7;. !1F7; 1,4 J7:1F7;

A,/#) +#-,/#)

Min. Max Mean S.D. Min. Max Mean S.D.

HS Engagement

Academic identification -4.57 4.35 -0.08 0.98 -5.04 3.97 0.12 0.96

Academic participation -4.84 2.83 -0.09 1.00 -4.84 2.85 0.28 0.90

Academic engagement -5.37 3.66 -0.10 0.99 -4.74 3.62 0.24 0.93

Social engagement -3.84 2.74 -0.13 1.03 -3.84 2.74 0.06 1.01

Overall engagement -5.55 3.22 -0.14 0.99 -4.14 3.60 0.17 0.96

Self-perception

Self-esteem -3.52 2.86 0.03 1.00 -3.67 2.04 -0.07 0.96

Self-efficacy -2.55 2.21 0.09 1.03 -2.55 2.31 -0.14 0.98

Self-mastery -3.71 2.92 0.00 0.99 -3.70 2.89 -0.07 0.95

Social Support -3.11 1.77 -0.26 0.99 -2.85 1.77 0.20 0.95

Parents' Behaviour

Monitoring behaviour -7.96 1.26 0.03 0.94 -7.96 1.26 0.11 0.84

Nurturance behaviour -5.08 1.78 -0.04 1.01 -5.47 1.78 0.09 0.98

Inconsistent discipline -3.93 3.54 0.11 0.96 -3.93 4.56 0.00 0.98

Reading Ability 166.01 887.31 519.29 97.04 120.56 909.52 550.01 88.54

!"#$ ( !71;6+2,? -@7 "AA7>-2B7,7;; *A #-647,- $24 ^'

Documents

MESA Finnie Mueller