33
Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE

Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    10

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE

Page 2: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

Outline

DIP History and Applications

Corrosion Issues

Internal Cleaning Technologies

Rehabilitation Options

Page 3: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

DIP History and Applications

Corrosion Issues

Internal Cleaning Technologies

Rehabilitation Options

Page 4: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

DIP history dates back to the early 1800s

1st CIP Horizontal,

Molded

1st CIP Vertical,

Centrifugal

Hot Dip Bituminous

Lining/ Coating

1st Cement-Mortar Lining

1st DIP

Ceramic Epoxy Lining

1816 1850 1860 1922 1955 1990

DI replaced CI

in 50’s and 60’s

Page 5: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

Typical applications of DIP in sewer

• Gravity and pressurized systems

• Collection systems, lift stations, and treatment plants

• High groundwater table

• Deep excavations

• Unique applications

– Above water lines

– Replacing VCP

– Inverted siphons

– River and bridge crossings

Page 6: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

DIP provides unique benefits for gravity sewer applications

• Long service life, durable

• High strength

– Traffic, deep bury, surge pressures

• Behaves as flexible conduit

• Resistant to differential settlement and seismic events

• Allows less inflow/infiltration

• Cost competitive

Page 7: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

DIP History and Applications

Corrosion Issues

Internal Cleaning Technologies

Rehabilitation Options

Page 8: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

(typically

1 mm thick)

Air

Wastewater

Acid

ic

Condensate

H2S Entering Air

Oxygen Entering Water

Water Level

Pipe

Wall

Slime

Layer

Pipe Wall Oxidation

How corrosion occurs in pipes

Dissolution of Sulfide

Page 9: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

Microbiologically-induced corrosion (MIC) cycle

1. Sulfate (SO4)

2. Dissolved Sulfide (H2S)

3. Hydrogen Sulfide Gas

(H2S)

4. Sulfuric Acid (H2SO4)

Page 10: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

Rate of corrosion is affected by wastewater in the collection system

• Low DO promotes anaerobic bacteria and sulfide generation

• High temperature increases microbial growth rate

• Low pH favors hydrogen sulfide gas (H2S)

• Low velocity increases solids deposition

• Turbulence promotes hydrogen sulfide release

Page 11: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

Interior pipe linings offer abrasion resistance

• Design for velocities greater than 2 fps

• Apply ceramic epoxy interior pipe linings

– Tnemec Series 431 Perma-Shield

– Protecto 401

Page 12: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

Tuberculation buildup in DIP reduces pipe diameter

Page 13: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

Tuberculation in DI sewer pipe increases friction and reduces capacity

Page 14: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

DIP History and Applications

Corrosion Issues

Internal Cleaning Technologies

Rehabilitation Options

Page 15: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

Typical cleaning technologies may not remove tuberculation

• High-pressure water jetting (4,000 and 10,000 psi)

– equally distributed

– point-focus

– rotating

– flushing

Page 16: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

Robust mechanical cleaning methods remove tuberculation but can damage pipe

• Cutters, milling machines, and chain knockers/ spinners

– Water pressure driven

– Designed to align within pipe

– Debris suction downstream

Page 17: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

High pressure water cleaning

Page 18: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

Spinner/chain knocker cleaning

Before After

Page 19: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

DIP History and Applications

Corrosion Issues

Internal Cleaning Technologies

Rehabilitation Options

Page 20: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

Pipe rehabilitation provides many benefits

1. Structural restoration

2. Reduction of Inflow and Infiltration (I/I)

3. Reduced O&M

4. Maximize benefit of existing asset

Page 21: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

Pipe Replacement Pipe Rehabilitation Point Repair

Microtunneling Cured-in-Place Pipe

(CIPP) Structural Sleeves

Pipe Jacking Sliplining Joint Seals

Horizontal Directional

Drilling (HDD)

Chemical Grouting/Flood

Grouting CIPP

Pipe Ramming Fold & Formed/ Formed

Reformed Joint Grouting

Impact Moling Spiral Wound Carbon Fiber

Auger Boring Grout-in-Place

Liners/Panel Liners

Pipe Bursting Sprayed

Pipe Reaming Carbon Fiber

Pipe Rehab/Replacement Methods

Page 22: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

Cured-in-Place Pipe (CIPP) for DI pipe

Applications

• 6” to 120” gravity sewer

• Thermosetting resins

• Hot water, steam, UV curing

• I/I elimination

• Structural restoration

Benefits

• Manhole installation*

• Navigates minor bends

• Minimal capacity reduction

• Can include carbon fiber

Challenges

• Pre-cleaning required

• Bypass pumping required

• Access every 1000 ft

*Depends on size to remove cone of manhole

Page 23: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

CIPP Animation

Page 24: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

Ultraviolet light CIPP (UV-CIPP) for DI pipe

Applications • 6” to 48” gravity sewers

• I/I elimination

• Structural restoration

Benefits • No water/steam for curing

• Fast curing time (10 ft/min)

• Stronger than traditional CIPP

• Pre-cure CCTV inspection

Challenges • Bypass pumping required

• Access every 1,000 ft

Page 25: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

UV-CIPP Animation

Page 26: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

Pipe Bursting/Splitting for DI pipe

Applications

• 4” to 54” diameter

• Gravity and pressure applications

• Uses roller blade cutters for non-fracturable pipe

Benefits

• Upsize diameter

• Added capacity

• I/I elimination

• Long design life

Challenges

• Access every 1,500 ft

• Bypass pumping required

Page 27: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

Pipe splitting specifically designed for DI pipe

• Blade cutting wheel/roller configuration

• Split host pipe instead of ripping or tearing

• Requires less power than other static systems

• Clean process that protects damage of product pipe

Page 28: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

Pipe Bursting Animation

Page 29: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

Sliplining for DI pipe

Applications

• 8” to 60” diameter

• Gravity and pressure applications

Benefits

• Structural stability

• I/I elimination

• Long design life

Challenges

• Reduces pipe diameter

• Access every 1,500 ft

• Bypass pumping required

Page 30: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

Sliplining for DI pipe

Page 31: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

Aged DIP causes collection system deficiencies

• Rehabilitation techniques

– CIPP and UV-CIPP

– Pipe Splitting

– Sliplining

• Replacement with new pipe

Page 32: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

Summary

Page 33: Letty Arvide-Gomar, PEsections.weat.org/Presentations/2015CMOM9_LGomar.pdf · Letty Arvide-Gomar, PE . Outline DIP History and Applications Corrosion Issues Internal Cleaning Technologies

Questions?

Letty Arvide-Gomar [email protected]