19
Large shield volcanoes on the Moon Paul D. Spudis, 1 Patrick J. McGovern, 1 and Walter S. Kiefer 1 Received 29 August 2012; revised 5 December 2012; accepted 4 February 2013. [1] The volcanic style of the Moon has long been understood to consist almost exclusively of ood basalts erupted from ssures along with minor pyroclastic activity; large central vent shield volcanoes that characterize basaltic volcanism on the other terrestrial planets appeared to be absent. Small (few kilometers diameter) central vent constructs have long been recognized in the lunar maria and often are found clustered in elds throughout the lunar maria. New global topographic data from the LOLA and LROC instruments on LRO reveal that almost all of these volcanic complexes on the Moon occur on large, regional topographic rises in the lunar maria, tens to hundreds of kilometers in extent and between several hundred to several thousand meters high. We propose that these topographic swells are shield volcanoes and are the lunar equivalents of the large basaltic shields found on the Earth, Venus, and Mars. The newly recognized lunar shields are found peripheral to the large, deeply ooded impact basins Imbrium and Serenitatis, suggesting a genetic relation to those features. Loading of the lithosphere by these basalt-lled basins may be responsible for inducing a combination of exural and membrane stress, inducing a pressure distribution on vertically oriented dikes favorable to magma ascent. This condition would occur in a zone annular to the large circular loads produced by the basins, where the shield volcanoes occur. Citation: P. D., Spudis, P. J. McGovern and W. S. Kiefer (2013), Large shield volcanoes on the Moon, J. Geophys. Res. Planets., 118 doi:10.1002/jgre.20059. 1. Introduction [2] Although basaltic volcanism is a common process on the terrestrial planets, it manifests itself with differing styles and intensities on different planetary bodies. Volcanism on the Moon is manifested largely by the presence of extensive plains of basaltic lava. The dark smooth lunar maria are composed of basaltic lava ows that were largely emplaced through ssure-fed, ood-style eruptions. This style of volcanism is also common on the other terrestrial planets; both Venus and Mars show vast plains made of basaltic lava in addition to their massive, central-vent shields. On Earth, continental ood basalt eruptions are considered the best analog for mare volcanism, with high-effusion rate ows of uid lava creating vast plateaus of basalt [e.g., Swanson and Wright, 1978]. [3] Central vent, shield-building volcanism is common on Earth, Venus, Mars, and Io and may also have occurred on Mercury. Small shield and dome volcanoes have been observed and mapped on the Moon for many years, but typically are very small (210 km diameter) and occur in groups or clusters within selected areas of the maria [McCauley, 1964; Greeley, 1971; Guest, 1971; Whitford-Stark and Head, 1977]. The vast bulk of lunar volcanic deposits is ood lavas, in which large volumes of magma are erupted rapidly from ssures and spread out as sheets on the surface [e.g., Head, 1976]. The Moon seems to lack the very large shield volcanoes [BVSP, 1981; Head and Wilson, 1991] that typify some of the mountains of Earth, Mars, and Venus [Pike, 1978; BVSP, 1981; Plescia, 2004; Herrick et al., 2005]. Or does it? [4] Shield volcanoes are positive-relief, central vent structures that are broader than they are high, so they have relatively low, average positive slopes [Whitford-Stark, 1975]. The term was rst coined to characterize the shape of certain lava constructs on Earth made up principally of low viscosity, basaltic lava that builds up a broad, shield-shaped construct. The bulk of the volcano is made of lava ows, although pyroclastic activity may occur in minor amounts, particularly during late stage eruptions. Many shield volcanoes display a summit crater (caldera) resulting from collapse of the surface over a drained or depleted magma chamber, but some shields do not have a summit crater [Whitford-Stark, 1975; Herrick et al., 2005] and such is not required for the edice to be classied as a shield volcano. Shield volcanoes typically have both radial and circumferential ssure zones, which serve as pathways for magma to get to the surface and erupt a continuing supply of lava. Parasitical cone and dome building often occurs near the summit and on the anks of such features during the latter stages of shield growth [e.g., McDonald and Abbott, 1970]. [5] Until recently, regional topographic information for the Moon was sparse and non-contiguous. Nonetheless, substantial regional slopes were evident in the Clementine 1 Lunar and Planetary Institute, Houston, Texas, USA. Corresponding author: P. D. Spudis, Lunar and Planetary Institute, 3600 Bay Area Blvd., Houston, TX 77058, USA. ([email protected]) ©2013. American Geophysical Union. All Rights Reserved. 2169-9097/13/10.1002/jgre.20059 1 JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH: PLANETS, VOL. 118, 119, doi:10.1002/jgre.20059, 2013

Large shield volcanoes on the Moon - Spudis Lunar Resources · 2018. 1. 23. · Large shield volcanoes on the Moon Paul D. Spudis, 1 Patrick J. McGovern, 1 and Walter S. Kiefer 1

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Large shield volcanoes on the Moon - Spudis Lunar Resources · 2018. 1. 23. · Large shield volcanoes on the Moon Paul D. Spudis, 1 Patrick J. McGovern, 1 and Walter S. Kiefer 1

Large shield volcanoes on the Moon

Paul D. Spudis,1 Patrick J. McGovern,1 and Walter S. Kiefer1

Received 29 August 2012; revised 5 December 2012; accepted 4 February 2013.

[1] The volcanic style of the Moon has long been understood to consist almost exclusivelyof !ood basalts erupted from "ssures along with minor pyroclastic activity; large centralvent shield volcanoes that characterize basaltic volcanism on the other terrestrial planetsappeared to be absent. Small (few kilometers diameter) central vent constructs have longbeen recognized in the lunar maria and often are found clustered in "elds throughout thelunar maria. New global topographic data from the LOLA and LROC instruments on LROreveal that almost all of these volcanic complexes on the Moon occur on large, regionaltopographic rises in the lunar maria, tens to hundreds of kilometers in extent and betweenseveral hundred to several thousand meters high. We propose that these topographic swellsare shield volcanoes and are the lunar equivalents of the large basaltic shields found on theEarth, Venus, and Mars. The newly recognized lunar shields are found peripheral to thelarge, deeply !ooded impact basins Imbrium and Serenitatis, suggesting a genetic relationto those features. Loading of the lithosphere by these basalt-"lled basins may beresponsible for inducing a combination of !exural and membrane stress, inducing apressure distribution on vertically oriented dikes favorable to magma ascent. This conditionwould occur in a zone annular to the large circular loads produced by the basins, where theshield volcanoes occur.

Citation: P. D., Spudis, P. J. McGovern and W. S. Kiefer (2013), Large shield volcanoes on the Moon, J. Geophys. Res.Planets., 118 doi:10.1002/jgre.20059.

1. Introduction

[2] Although basaltic volcanism is a common process onthe terrestrial planets, it manifests itself with differing stylesand intensities on different planetary bodies. Volcanism onthe Moon is manifested largely by the presence of extensiveplains of basaltic lava. The dark smooth lunar maria arecomposed of basaltic lava !ows that were largely emplacedthrough "ssure-fed, !ood-style eruptions. This style ofvolcanism is also common on the other terrestrial planets;both Venus and Mars show vast plains made of basaltic lavain addition to their massive, central-vent shields. On Earth,continental !ood basalt eruptions are considered the bestanalog for mare volcanism, with high-effusion rate !owsof !uid lava creating vast plateaus of basalt [e.g., Swansonand Wright, 1978].[3] Central vent, shield-building volcanism is common on

Earth, Venus, Mars, and Io and may also have occurred onMercury. Small shield and dome volcanoes have beenobserved and mapped on the Moon for many years, buttypically are very small (2–10 km diameter) and occur ingroups or clusters within selected areas of the maria[McCauley, 1964; Greeley, 1971; Guest, 1971; Whitford-Starkand Head, 1977]. The vast bulk of lunar volcanic deposits is

!ood lavas, in which large volumes of magma are eruptedrapidly from "ssures and spread out as sheets on the surface[e.g., Head, 1976]. The Moon seems to lack the very largeshield volcanoes [BVSP, 1981; Head and Wilson, 1991] thattypify some of the mountains of Earth, Mars, and Venus [Pike,1978; BVSP, 1981; Plescia, 2004; Herrick et al., 2005].Or does it?[4] Shield volcanoes are positive-relief, central vent

structures that are broader than they are high, so they haverelatively low, average positive slopes [Whitford-Stark,1975]. The term was "rst coined to characterize the shapeof certain lava constructs on Earth made up principallyof low viscosity, basaltic lava that builds up a broad,shield-shaped construct. The bulk of the volcano is madeof lava !ows, although pyroclastic activity may occur inminor amounts, particularly during late stage eruptions.Many shield volcanoes display a summit crater (caldera)resulting from collapse of the surface over a drained ordepleted magma chamber, but some shields do not have asummit crater [Whitford-Stark, 1975; Herrick et al., 2005]and such is not required for the edi"ce to be classi"ed as ashield volcano. Shield volcanoes typically have both radialand circumferential "ssure zones, which serve as pathwaysfor magma to get to the surface and erupt a continuingsupply of lava. Parasitical cone and dome building oftenoccurs near the summit and on the !anks of such featuresduring the latter stages of shield growth [e.g., McDonaldand Abbott, 1970].[5] Until recently, regional topographic information for

the Moon was sparse and non-contiguous. Nonetheless,substantial regional slopes were evident in the Clementine

1Lunar and Planetary Institute, Houston, Texas, USA.

Corresponding author: P. D. Spudis, Lunar and Planetary Institute, 3600Bay Area Blvd., Houston, TX 77058, USA. ([email protected])

©2013. American Geophysical Union. All Rights Reserved.2169-9097/13/10.1002/jgre.20059

1

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH: PLANETS, VOL. 118, 1–19, doi:10.1002/jgre.20059, 2013

Page 2: Large shield volcanoes on the Moon - Spudis Lunar Resources · 2018. 1. 23. · Large shield volcanoes on the Moon Paul D. Spudis, 1 Patrick J. McGovern, 1 and Walter S. Kiefer 1

global altimetry [Zuber et al., 1994] for the relatively “!at”maria of the Moon. Such slopes tend to conform to thecon"guration of the containing impact basins, but it wasnoted that some igneous centers in the maria occur ontopographic rises. Speci"cally, the lunar Marius Hillscomplex was found to occur on the summit of a broad,gentle topographic swell, leading to the supposition that thiscomplex might be the lunar manifestation of a basaltic shieldvolcano, a couple of hundred kilometers across and severalhundred meters high [Spudis, 1996]. The Clementinetopography was of low resolution and could not resolvefeatures within the lunar maria with high precision.However, new global data from the LRO laser altimeter[Smith et al., 2010] give us a high-resolution view of lunartopography. Moreover, global stereo images from the LROcamera have been processed into a global topographic map[Scholten et al., 2012]. Thus, it is an appropriate time tore-visit the topographic character of volcanic complexesin the lunar maria and address the question: Do shieldvolcanoes exist on the Moon?

2. Data Sources and Approach

[6] The new global topographic map of the Moonobtained by the Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter (LRO) isthe principal source of topographic information used in thisstudy. The GLD100 global map [Scholten et al., 2012] is astereo-model based on LRO Camera Wide Angle stereoimage data. It has a resolution of 100m/pixel, covers theMoon between !79" latitude, and has been determined tohave vertical accuracy of about 18m compared to the LROlaser altimeter data set. The laser altimeter data [Smithet al., 2010] complete the global topographic maps forlatitudes greater than 79" [Scholten et al., 2012]. Thefeatures studied in this paper all fall within the boundariesof the GLD100 map and have dimensions of hundreds ofkilometers and heights greater than 1000m, much largerthan the scale of this high-resolution topographic data.[7] Small volcanic features in the maria have been mapped

for many years [e.g., McCauley, 1964; Guest, 1971;Wilhelms and McCauley, 1971] and we have used thisprevious mapping to locate clusters of such small featuresin relation to our larger landforms. Speci"cally, we haveused the landform classi"cation and map of Guest andMurray [1976] to show the correspondence of smallvolcanic features with our larger shields. Guest and Murray[1976] recognized several distinct landforms, includingrilles, domes, pits, and cones. Low domes (small shields)are smooth, convex-shaped positive relief landforms withside slopes of 2–3" and sizes of a few kilometers diameter[Guest and Murray, 1976]; some of these features havesummit craters while others do not. Steep domes have moreprominent topography and are comparable in size to shields,but have steeper sides with slopes of 7–20" [Guest andMurray, 1976]. Cones are small features (2-3 km across),often occur on top of a broader shield (over 40 of these arefound in the Marius Hills) or aligned along a linear ventsystem, and tend to have steep sides (>20"). Collapse craters(or pits) are common throughout the maria and many arefound in association with the other landforms; they tend tobe small (a few kilometers across or less) and shallow (tensto hundreds meters). Many collapse pits are associated with

sinuous rilles, a common feature of these eruptive centersand are interpreted as vent systems and their associated lavachannels and tube systems.[8] We have used the basic classi"cation and mapping of

Guest and Murray [1976], including their distinctionbetween shields (or “low domes”) with and without summitpit craters. In the feature maps presented in this paper, werecognize low domes (shields), with and without summitpits, cones, collapse pits, sinuous rilles, and chains of cindercones (interpreted as "ssure vents) [Guest and Murray,1976]. Additionally, we mapped eruptive vent centers whererecognized (indicated by an irregular crater or landformassociated with dark mantling materials). We have plottedthe locations of the most prominent features in these areason a shaded relief base (created from the GLD100topographic map) [Scholten et al., 2012] for each proposedshield volcano. Associated topographic pro"les of eachshield volcano were extracted from the GLD100 databaseusing the pro"ling tool of the Quickmap LROC globalbasemap (http://target.lroc.asu.edu/da/qmap.html).

3. Topography of Volcanic Complexes in theLunar Maria

[9] The new global topographic map of the Moon revealsmany new relationships on the lunar surface. Although thesedata validate the conventional wisdom that mare depositsoccupy low-lying areas of the Moon, several broadtopographic highs are found in both the eastern and westernnear-side maria (Figure 1). These topographic bulges aretens to hundreds of kilometers across and from 600 to over2200m high. We have identi"ed six major and two minortopographic swells (Table 1) that occur within the near-sidelunar maria. Interestingly, all of these rises correspond tohigh concentrations of small (kilometer-scale) volcanicfeatures as mapped over the entire near-side by Guest andMurray [1976], although it appears that the styles oferuption and nature of the dominant landform varies bylocation. The correspondence of volcanic landforms withtopography not only encompasses such long-familiar marevolcanic “complexes” as Mons Rümker, the Marius Hills,and the Aristarchus plateau, but also includes some lesserknown eruptive centers, such as Hortensius and Cauchy.Because our new interpretation of these areas is so radical,we here describe the geology of each volcanic center andits regional geological and topographic setting.

3.1. Marius Hills[10] This complex has long been known as a center of

intense volcanic activity (Figure 2), displaying over 300small cones and domes and numerous sinuous rilles andcollapse pits [McCauley, 1967, 1968; Greeley, 1971; Guest,1971; Weitz and Head, 1999; Heather et al. 2003]. TheMarius Hills volcanic complex (Figures 3 and 4) occurswithin Oceanus Procellarum, the most extensive maria onthe Moon and the site of some of the youngest lunar lava!ows [Schultz and Spudis, 1983; Hiesinger et al., 2003].The cones and domes range in plan from a few kilometersto almost 20 km across and from 200 to over 600m inheight. Numerous sinuous rilles are found in the area,emanating from irregular or elongate source vents [McCauley,1967, 1968; Greeley, 1971; Guest, 1971]. Pit craters and

SPUDIS ET AL.: LUNAR SHIELD VOLCANOES

2

Page 3: Large shield volcanoes on the Moon - Spudis Lunar Resources · 2018. 1. 23. · Large shield volcanoes on the Moon Paul D. Spudis, 1 Patrick J. McGovern, 1 and Walter S. Kiefer 1

Figure 1. Hemisphere view of topographic data from GLD100 [Scholten et al., 2012] for the near-side ofthe Moon, centered on 0", 20"W showing location of proposed large lunar shield volcanoes. Color maphas contour interval of ~250m. Outlines of shield boundaries are approximate.

Table 1. Large Shield Volcanoes on the Moona

Shield SummitAge(Ga)

Diameter(km)

Height(km)

Averageslope (")

Volume(km3) Comments

Rümker 41"N, 59"W >3.4 66 1.2 2.4 1,400 Built on highland blockGardner 16.1"N,

34.1"E>3.8 70 1.6 2.6 2,100 Similar to Rümker; on northern

!ank of Cauchy shieldPrinz 26"N, 43"W 3.4–3.6 166 0.8* 0.5 5,800 Built on highland blockAristarchus 25.4"N, 50"W ~3.8 240 2.0* 0.9 30,100 Partly developed; built on highland

blockKepler 8"N, 38"W 2.1–3.6 270 0.6* 0.3 12,300 Very low slopes; few volcanic featuresHortensius 13"N, 29"W 3.1–3.5 300 1.2 0.4 28,300 Asymmetric; built on Montes CarpatusMariusHills

14"N, 52"W 1.1–3.3 330 2.2 0.8 62,700 Fully developed shield

Cauchy 8"N, 35"E 3.6–3.7 560 1.8 0.1 148,000 Largest shield

aAge estimates taken from the literature (see text). Asterisk indicates that non-shield impact topography was deleted from estimate of edi"ce height.Measurements of diameter and height were made on the LROC-LOLA Digital Terrain Model GLD 100 [Scholten et al., 2012]. Volumes are computed usingan approximation of a simple conical segment of radius (1/2D) and height shown.

Figure 2. The Marius Hills shield. At left, topographic image shows abrupt boundary at northern edge ofshield (arrows). This boundary is clearly seen in the Kaguya high-de"nition television view (right, top andbottom) of the edge of the Marius Hills shield. Kaguya view is looking south while !ying over about18"N, 52"W. Field of view is about 200 km.

SPUDIS ET AL.: LUNAR SHIELD VOLCANOES

3

Page 4: Large shield volcanoes on the Moon - Spudis Lunar Resources · 2018. 1. 23. · Large shield volcanoes on the Moon Paul D. Spudis, 1 Patrick J. McGovern, 1 and Walter S. Kiefer 1

collapse features are common, including a recently discoveredskylight within an apparent lava tube [Haruyama et al., 2009].The cones and domes of the Marius Hills do not appear to becompositionally distinct from either the surrounding mareplains or the inter-volcano plains that make up the surface ofthe Marius Hills construct [Weitz and Head, 1999; Heatheret al., 2003; Besse et al., 2011]. However, the decimeter-scalesurface texture of the domes indicates that at least some of theconstructs are rougher than the average mare surface, possiblyindicating that clinkery aa lava, pasty eruptive spatter, and/orinterbedded pyroclastics make up at least some of these edi"ces[Campbell et al., 2009; Lawrence et al., 2013].[11] The Marius Hills complex occurs on an elongated,

elliptical topographic rise approximately 330 km in extent.It is broadly shaped like a shield, with the summit near14"N, 52"W, about 40 km northwest of the crater Marius,and it rises about 2.2 km above the surrounding mare plain

(Table 1). Images from the orbiting Kaguya HDTV imagerclearly show the shield-like morphology of the structure(Figure 2) and it is also evident in topographic pro"les takenfrom the new global DTM (Figure 5). The cones, domes,and rilles that make up the volcanic complex are allsuperposed on the shield in a manner similar to thenumerous late-stage cones and eruptive vents of the MaunaKea shield on the island of Hawaii [MacDonald and Abbott,1970]. On the basis of the broad, low-relief shape of thistopographic bulge seen in Clementine topography, theMarius Hills were proposed to be the lunar equivalent of abasaltic shield volcano by Spudis [1996].[12] The precise age of the Marius Hills construct is

uncertain, but most workers agree that it is relatively young.It was mapped as Eratosthenian in age by McCauley [1967]and Wilhelms and McCauley [1971]. Whitford-Stark andHead [1980] mapped the lava !ows of Oceanus Procellarum

Figure 3. Volcanic features of the Marius Hills. Left, sinuous rilles and vent craters on western half ofshield. Center, collapse pits (caldera?) near summit of Marius Hills shield. Right, Pit craters, sinuous rillesand low domes near eastern edge of Marius Hills shield.

Figure 4. Volcanic features map of Marius Hills, simpli"ed from McCauley [1968] and Guest andMurray [1976]. Symbols for volcanic landforms used here are the same as on all subsequent maps(landform de"nition and classi"cation from Guest and Murray [1976]; see text for discussion).

SPUDIS ET AL.: LUNAR SHIELD VOLCANOES

4

Page 5: Large shield volcanoes on the Moon - Spudis Lunar Resources · 2018. 1. 23. · Large shield volcanoes on the Moon Paul D. Spudis, 1 Patrick J. McGovern, 1 and Walter S. Kiefer 1

and found that the surface !ows around the Marius Hillsincluded lavas from the uppermost sequence of !ows, theSharp and Hermann Formations; more recent studies havemapped these !ows on the surface of the Marius Hills shieldand have estimated ages of 2.5 and 3.3Ga for the twoprincipal !ow series [Heather and Dunkin, 2002; Heatheret al., 2003]. Most recently, Huang et al. [2011] proposevery young ages for the surface lavas of the Marius Hills,ranging from 0.8 to 1.1 Ga.[13] The free-air gravity anomaly at the Marius Hills is

about 200–250 km across [Konopliv et al., 2001] andrequires the presence of a signi"cant volume of densesubsurface material, which likely takes the form of either alaccolithic intrusion or the in"lling by basalt of the impact-induced pore space in the uppermost crust. Kiefer [2013]models this gravity feature as being produced by two dense,subsurface bodies: a northern one 160–180 km across,corresponding to the Marius Hills bulge (including most ofthe domes and cones within its boundary) and a smaller

one 100–140 km in extent, south of the main part of theMarius Hills shield. The two structures are connected by anarrower line of dense material. The geophysical evidenceof a large, dense subsurface feature centered under thetopographic bulge is consistent with the Marius Hills beingmade up of a single subsurface magmatic system andsupports our interpretation of it as a large basaltic shieldvolcano. If the anomaly is caused by dispersed intrusive inthe crustal pore space rather than being concentrated in aclassical magma chamber, this would inhibit the crustalcollapse needed to form a large, signi"cant summit caldera(although a chain of collapse features (center image,Figure 3) near the summit is evident). Because impact-induced porosity is probably widespread in the uppercrust across the Moon, this may provide an explanationfor the general absence of calderas on the lunar volcaniccomplexes described here.[14] The predominant volcanic landform of the Marius

Hills is the relatively steep-sided cone (Figure 4) [see also

Figure 5. Topographic pro"les of the Marius Hills shield; all topographic information for the featuresdescribed in this paper is taken from the LROC stereo DTM GLD 100 [Scholten et al., 2012]. The typicalbroad shield pro"le is evident, showing a feature about 330 km across and 2.2 km high.

Figure 6. Rümker, a volcanic shield in northern Oceanus Procellarum. This relatively small featureconsists of a broad shield and several overlapping low shields. WAC view of Rümker structure (left);low-sun view of the overlap of shields of the Rümker shield (right).

SPUDIS ET AL.: LUNAR SHIELD VOLCANOES

5

Page 6: Large shield volcanoes on the Moon - Spudis Lunar Resources · 2018. 1. 23. · Large shield volcanoes on the Moon Paul D. Spudis, 1 Patrick J. McGovern, 1 and Walter S. Kiefer 1

McCauley, 1968; Guest and Murray, 1976], most of whichare found at the summits of broad, low shields. Bothcollapse pits and sinuous rilles are also common [e.g.,Greeley, 1971] as are larger collapse pits near the summit(Figure 3). Small shield-like volcanoes without cappingcones are much less common here, although they are abun-dant at some of the other complexes we discuss (see below).The dominance of certain landforms and the paucity ofothers at different complexes probably indicate differingstyles of the predominant eruption and evolutionary pathsof the various complexes [Whitford-Stark and Head,1977]. The near-exclusive presence of cones at Marius Hillssuggests a protracted volcanic evolution, with the eruptionof many, relatively volatile-rich, partly crystallized magmas

(resulting in the production of abundant spatter, degassing,and clinkery aa lava !ows) [Weitz and Head, 1999; Heatheret al., 2003].

3.2. Rümker[15] The Rümker complex (Figure 6) in northern Oceanus

Procellarum (~70 km in extent, centered at 40"N, 58"W) wasrecognized as a volcanic center early in lunar geologicalstudies [McCauley, 1968; Guest, 1971; Scott and Eggleton,1973; Smith, 1973, 1974]. It consists of a broadly elevatedcluster of more than a dozen (up to 30 according to Smith[1974]) blister-like landforms (Figure 7), built on top of akipuka of Imbrium basin ejecta, the Fra Mauro Formation[Guest, 1971; Scott and Eggleton, 1973]. The thin mare

Figure 7. Volcanic features map of Rümker. Low shields, probably of basaltic composition, predominate.

Figure 8. Topographic pro"les of the Rümker shield, showing a construct 66 km across and about1.2 km high.

SPUDIS ET AL.: LUNAR SHIELD VOLCANOES

6

Page 7: Large shield volcanoes on the Moon - Spudis Lunar Resources · 2018. 1. 23. · Large shield volcanoes on the Moon Paul D. Spudis, 1 Patrick J. McGovern, 1 and Walter S. Kiefer 1

!ows of northern Procellarum lap up and partly cover thelower portions of the edi"ce, suggesting that the complexpre-dates the ~3.4Ga old surface mare basalts in this region;very young mare basalts (<1.5Ga old) lap over the complexto the northeast [Hiesinger et al., 2003]. In pro"le, Rümkerdisplays the bulbous shape of an elongate shield (Figure 8),with a typical relief of 1000–1200m above the surroundingmare surface.[16] In some ways, Mons Rümker appears to be a

miniature version of the Marius Hills shield, but muchsmaller and less well developed [Smith, 1974]. However,here at Rümker, the low shield is the dominant landform(Figure 7). Some of the overlapping shield constructs maybe thinly mantled uplands, but the characteristic shield shapeof these features argues instead that they are small, centralvolcanoes, similar to basaltic shields found elsewhere onthe Moon and the other terrestrial planets [e.g., Greeley,

1976, 1982]. A large crater at the north end of the complexmay be a collapse pit (Figure 6). There is no evidence forsinuous rilles or other vent structures, although such featurescould be covered by the younger mare basalts of thesurrounding plain.

3.3. Prinz[17] The Prinz volcanic complex (Figures 9 and 10;

~150 km in extent; 26"N 43"W) is built upon a block ofhighlands material (Montes Harbinger) that is probablyrelated to the Imbrium basin [Strain and El-Baz, 1977].Unlike Rümker (but similar to its neighbor, Aristarchus),the Prinz complex is notable as the source region for severalsinuous rilles (lava channels) that supply the mare depositsnorth and west of the plateau (Figure 10). Some of thedome-like features in the Prinz area could be volcanicconstructs, particularly one that appears to be a breached

Figure 9. Volcanic vents and channels of the Prinz shield (~150 km in extent; 26"N 43"W). Collapsepits and rilles near rim of crater Prinz (left); caldera-like pit and vent area near middle of structure (right).

Figure 10. Volcanic features map of Prinz shield. Pit craters and sinuous rilles are the dominant landform.

SPUDIS ET AL.: LUNAR SHIELD VOLCANOES

7

Page 8: Large shield volcanoes on the Moon - Spudis Lunar Resources · 2018. 1. 23. · Large shield volcanoes on the Moon Paul D. Spudis, 1 Patrick J. McGovern, 1 and Walter S. Kiefer 1

cone that might have served as a lava source (arrow inFigure 9) [see also “E” in Figure 1 of Strain and El Baz,1977]. The Prinz complex as a whole displays relief of about600m (Figure 11); this low value, in conjunction with theexposure of many highlands units near and within theconstruct as well as the principal manifestation of rilles asthe main landform here, suggests incomplete developmentas a volcanic complex. Prinz appears to have been asigni"cant eruptive center, but most of its lava products weresupplied to the surrounding mare plains of OceanusProcellarum and Mare Imbrium. Although Prinz is adjacentto the Aristarchus plateau, there is no obvious directconnection between the two complexes; each featuressimilar landforms, but the relative importance of the varioustypes differ. The basalts of the Prinz shield appear to haveages between 3.4 and 3.6Ga [Strain and El-Baz, 1977; Zisket al., 1977], indicating an Imbrian age for the construct.

3.4. Kepler[18] The Kepler volcanic complex (~270 km; 7"N, 38"W)

is newly identi"ed in this work, although its presenceperipheral to the Imbrium basin is predicted by the work ofMcGovern and Litherland [2011]. It consists of a very lowrelief topographic rise near and south of the younger

superposed, unrelated impact crater Kepler. Highlandmaterials in this area are facies of Imbrium basin ejecta,primarily the knobby Alpes Formation [Wilhelms andMcCauley, 1971]. This region is not commonly thoughtof as a mare volcanic complex, but close examinationreveals that sinuous rilles, irregular volcanic craters andassociated dark mantle (pyroclastic) materials occurthroughout the area (Figures 12 and 13). Mare lavas onthe Kepler shield have not been dated directly, but twomare units 3.6 and 2.1 Ga make up part of the westernand southern edges of the shield [Hiesinger et al., 2003].The Kepler feature is similar in developmental state to thePrinz structure described above; it is built on top ofhighlands material, mostly ejecta from the Imbrium basin,which is thinly covered by a veneer of basaltic lava andpyroclastic deposits. Although relatively low in overallrelief (~0.6 km in height; Figure 14), this rise is too talland wide to be attributed exclusively to impact causes,either from the crater Kepler or the regional Imbriumbasin back slope topography and thus we classify it as ashield (Table 1). Rough topography near the summit ofthe Kepler shield (partially obscured by impact ejectafrom the crater Kepler) could be remnants of additionaligneous activity.

Figure 11. Topographic pro"les of the Prinz shield, about 160 km across and slightly less than 1 km high.

Figure 12. Volcanic features of the Kepler shield (~270 km; 7"N, 38"W). Collapse pits and rilles (arrow;left) near Maestlin R; elongate vent and associated dark pyroclastics (arrow) NE of Encke (center);sinuous rille complex (arrow) on eastern shield edge (right).

SPUDIS ET AL.: LUNAR SHIELD VOLCANOES

8

Page 9: Large shield volcanoes on the Moon - Spudis Lunar Resources · 2018. 1. 23. · Large shield volcanoes on the Moon Paul D. Spudis, 1 Patrick J. McGovern, 1 and Walter S. Kiefer 1

3.5. Hortensius[19] The Hortensius-Tobias Mayer area (approximately

150 by 350 km; 12"N, 27"W; Figures 15 and 16) has beenlong known for its high concentration of small volcaniclandforms, including small shields, rilles, and cones[Shoemaker, 1962; Schmitt et al., 1967; Smith, 1973;Schultz, 1976; Phillips, 1989; Wood, 2003; Wöhler et al.,2006]. The northern edge of this structure contains a seriesof vents and pyroclastic deposits that are associated withthe eruption of the famous late Imbrium !ows, the long,striking lobate lava !ows that cover Mare Imbrium[Schaber, 1973; Schaber et al., 1976]. This shield is similar

to both the Prinz and Kepler shields in that altimetry datashow that it is built upon the main ring/rim of the Imbriumbasin, but both volcanic development and the diversity oflandforms at Hortensius are much greater than in either Prinzor Kepler. Imbrium ejecta crop out on the surface as knobbyAlpes Fm. [Wilhelms and McCauley, 1971] along with theoccasional basin massif, but volcanic shields and structuresare abundant and clearly distinguishable from the highlandsunits upon which they are built (Figure 15). The smallshields of Hortensius are well-developed miniaturevolcanoes [Schultz, 1976; Head and Gifford, 1980; Wöhleret al., 2006], similar to basaltic shields that are found in

Figure 13. Volcanic features map of Kepler shield. Pit craters, sinuous rilles, and pyroclastic vents arethe principal features of this shield.

Figure 14. Topographic pro"les of the Kepler shield. Feature is about 270 km across and 500–600m high.

SPUDIS ET AL.: LUNAR SHIELD VOLCANOES

9

Page 10: Large shield volcanoes on the Moon - Spudis Lunar Resources · 2018. 1. 23. · Large shield volcanoes on the Moon Paul D. Spudis, 1 Patrick J. McGovern, 1 and Walter S. Kiefer 1

“plains volcanic terrains” elsewhere on the Moon and onother terrestrial planets [Greeley, 1976; 1982]. Linear vents,lines of spatter cones, and discontinuous pyroclastic deposits(Figures 15 and 16) [see also Gustafson et al., 2012] are alsoabundant, particularly at the northern edge of the shield, theprobable source vents for the spectacular late Imbrium lava!ows [Schaber, 1973; Schaber et al., 1976].[20] The Hortensius shield is one of the largest identi"ed

in this study, extending almost 350 km along its NW/SE axis(Figure 16). Topographic pro"les show that the shield isabout 1200m or less in total height (Figure 17 and Table 1),making it a very low relief structure. Clusters of smallshields are found mostly along the margins of the shield,particularly in the southwest (Figure 16). The eastern marginof the shield is partly masked by ejecta from the craterCopernicus. Mare basalts on the western and southern edgeof the shield have estimated ages of 3.5 and 3.1Ga,respectively [Hiesinger et al., 2003].

3.6. Cauchy[21] The largest of the newly detected volcanic shields is

in eastern Mare Tranquillitatis, centered near the craterCauchy (~560 km; 8"N, 35"E; Figures 18 and 19). This areahas long been known as a locus of small volcanic features,including numerous cones, low shields, and sinuous rilles[e.g., Wilhelms, 1972; Guest and Murray, 1976; Wood,

2003; Wöhler et al., 2006]. Topographic data reveal thatthe eastern half of Mare Tranquillitatis is a broad, low riseabout 560 km across and over 1.8 km high (Figure 20). Thisshield has been the source of multiple !ows and eruptiveevents emplaced between 3.6 and 3.7Ga [Hiesinger et al.,2000; Rajmon and Spudis, 2004]. The existence of thisvolcanic shield may explain the apparent lack of topographicevidence for the putative Tranquillitatis impact basin, forwhich there is clear morphological evidence [Wilhelmsand McCauley, 1971; Wilhelms, 1987]—the Cauchy shieldis built on the !oor of the Tranquillitatis basin, creatinga topographic high in its eastern half, where a low wouldbe expected.[22] The Cauchy shield displays most of the volcanic

landforms seen in other lunar shields. The predominantfeature is a low shield, usually with a summit pit (Figure 18).The unusual Rimae Cauchy I and II appear to becombinations of linear graben and sinuous rilles in differentportions of the features. Rima Cauchy I terminates in acouple of collapse pits (Figure 18), apparently the sourcevents for the basalts that created the sinuous rille parts ofthe feature (Figure 19). The Gardner “megadome” shield(described below) occurs on the northern margin of theCauchy shield, but as with Prinz and Aristarchus, thereappears to be no direct genetic connection between thetwo features.

Figure 15. Volcanic features of the Hortensius shield (approximately 150 by 350 km; 12"N, 27"W).Vent and associated pyroclastic deposits (top left); dark halo crater (vent, yellow arrow) and line of spattercones along "ssure vent (green arrow) (top right); cluster of small shields (bottom left); shields and lowdomes on western edge of Hortensius shield (bottom right).

SPUDIS ET AL.: LUNAR SHIELD VOLCANOES

10

Page 11: Large shield volcanoes on the Moon - Spudis Lunar Resources · 2018. 1. 23. · Large shield volcanoes on the Moon Paul D. Spudis, 1 Patrick J. McGovern, 1 and Walter S. Kiefer 1

3.7. Gardner[23] At the northern end of the Cauchy structure is a

smaller feature, identi"ed as the Gardner “megadome” byWood [2003, 2004]. This small (~70 km; 16"N, 34"E;Figures 21 and 22) topographic blister displays severalsmaller, overlapping shields and sinuous rilles. Its summitdisplays a series of irregular depressions that may constitutea caldera complex. A similar sequence of collapse pits arefound near the summit of the Marius Hills shield [Guest,1971; Figure 3], but in this case, the collapse structure

covers most of the summit of Gardner (Figure 22). Thesurface composition of Gardner seems to be less ma"cthan the surrounding lavas of Mare Tranquillitatis, with~14–16wt.% FeO content, values that while broadly basalticare lower than typical mare material (e.g., the surroundingMare Tranquillitatis basalts have FeO content of ~20wt.%). The low FeO content of the surface of Gardner couldindicate either the eruption of a less ma"c type of volcanicmagma (e.g., high-alumina mare basalts) [BVSP, 1981] orthat the surface materials are at least partly of highlands

Figure 16. Map of volcanic features of Hortensius shield. After Guest and Murray [1976].

Figure 17. Topographic pro"le of Hortensius shield showing feature about 300 km across and over1 km high.

SPUDIS ET AL.: LUNAR SHIELD VOLCANOES

11

Page 12: Large shield volcanoes on the Moon - Spudis Lunar Resources · 2018. 1. 23. · Large shield volcanoes on the Moon Paul D. Spudis, 1 Patrick J. McGovern, 1 and Walter S. Kiefer 1

composition and the Gardner shield is the surface expressionof predominantly intrusive activity, such as a laccolith [e.g.,see Wöhler et al., 2006]. The Gardner shield is relativelysmall, but shows relief of about 1.6 km (Figure 23), thus,as at Rümker, it has higher than typical average slopecompared to other large shield volcanoes. The age of thefeature is undetermined, but both its heavily crateredappearance and the apparent superposition of basinradial texture (Figure 21) suggest that it is old, perhapsolder than 3.8 Ga.[24] Based in part on its alignment with the volcanic area

near the crater Jansen, Wood et al. [2005] proposed thatGardner is the northern terminus of an elongate quasi-linear,volcano-tectonic structure. We suggest instead that Jansen ispart of the Cauchy shield (Figure 19) and that Gardner is apossible parasitic shield of Cauchy, located on its periphery(Figure 1). In terms of size, morphology, and distribution of

features, the Gardner structure strongly resembles theRümker shield, which in turn is a miniature version of theMarius Hills shield. Surface features of the Gardner shieldare mostly smooth, overlapping shield-like domes, some ofwhich have collapse pits (Figure 22). Thus, there appearsto be a continuous sequence of size in lunar shield volcanoesover at least an order of magnitude.

3.8. Aristarchus[25] Among the lunar volcanic structures described here, the

Aristarchus plateau (~250 km; 25"N, 50"W; Figures 24, 25)seems to be a special case. For the plateau, topographic prom-inence is caused principally by the uplifting of a structuralblock associated with the formation of the Imbrium basinand is enhanced only partly by the overplating of erupted lava[Moore, 1967; Zisk et al., 1977; McEwen et al., 1994]. Thehighland block that makes up the bulk of the plateau shows

Figure 18. Selected volcanic features of the Cauchy shield (560 km; 8"N, 35"E). Flooded craters andcollapse pits near Jansen (left); source pit craters and co-mingled sinuous rilles of Rima Cauchy I (center);low shield with summit pit near Cauchy (right).

Figure 19. Map of the volcanic features of the Cauchy shield.Most features are low shields and sinuous rilles.

SPUDIS ET AL.: LUNAR SHIELD VOLCANOES

12

Page 13: Large shield volcanoes on the Moon - Spudis Lunar Resources · 2018. 1. 23. · Large shield volcanoes on the Moon Paul D. Spudis, 1 Patrick J. McGovern, 1 and Walter S. Kiefer 1

clear control by radial structures of the Imbrium basin andejecta from that event is exposed in the rugged terra of the pla-teau (Figure 25). However, massive eruption of lava both ontoand away from the plateau is indicated by the presence ofmany large sinuous rilles, including the enormous VallisSchröteri (165 km long) and numerous other rilles (Figure 26).Some rilles show clear evidence of at least two-phases oferuption (e.g., the highly sinuous rille within the broader,graben-like rille of V. Schröteri; Figure 24), suggesting aprolonged, multi-phased volcanic evolution [e.g., Moore,1967; Schultz, 1976]. The Aristarchus plateau is also thesource of dark red, 49,000 km2 regional pyroclastic deposits,"ve times larger in areal extent than any other on the Moon

[Gaddis et al., 2003]. These eruptions of both lava and ashhave partly covered the pre-existing plateau but seem to haveended before a signi"cant shield-shaped construct could bebuilt. Zisk et al. [1977] estimate the age of plateau materialsto be Orientale-contemporaneous (about 3.8 Ga) but veryyoung lavas are found south of the shield (1–1.5 Ga)[Hiesinger et al., 2003] and at least some of these !owsoriginated from vents on the Aristarchus shield itself(Figure 26).[26] The dominant landform on the Aristarchus shield is

similar to the neighboring Prinz shield, collapse craters,and sinuous rilles (Figure 26), along with the substantialpyroclastic deposits mentioned above. Some of the smallerhills might be volcanic constructs, but the majority appearsto be outcrops of the underlying highlands block upon whichthe plateau lavas have been erupted [Zisk et al., 1977]. Thevery young mare basalts that lap up onto the plateau [e.g.,Hiesinger et al., 2003] partly obscure the relations of therille termini around the eruptive center. These relations sug-gest that the Aristarchus plateau is a proto-shield, currentlyexposed in an arrested state of development whereas theMarius Hills construct (Figure 2) is a fully developed lunarshield volcano. Nevertheless, topographic pro"les of theAristarchus shield (Figure 27) show a broad, shield-likeshape, 240 km across and up to 2 km high (Table 1). Theblister-like morphology of the Aristarchus shield is alsoevident in the low sun angle mosaic (Figure 25).[27] Many of the lunar shields have long been recognized

as volcanic complexes [McCauley, 1967; Guest, 1971;Guest and Murray, 1976] or eruptive centers [Whitford-Stark and Head, 1977], but their topographic nature(Figure 1 and Table 1) has been only mentioned in passingor has not been known. Both Marius Hills and Rümker werelong known to occur on topographic highs and data from theApollo metric camera demonstrated that the Prinz complexis associated with a fragment of the rim massifs of theImbrium basin (Montes Harbinger) [Strain and El-Baz,1977]. Most workers consider the volcanic activity of theseeruptive centers to have been minor adjuncts of the mainphase of mare volcanism, which was largely characterizedby voluminous, "ssure-fed, !at-lying eruptions of !ood

Figure 20. Topographic pro"les of the Cauchy shield.

Figure 21. The Gardner “megadome” shield [Wood, 2003,2004]. Northern edge of shield grades into highlands relatedto Serenitatis basin. Large collapse pit (caldera?) evident,centered on top of shield.

SPUDIS ET AL.: LUNAR SHIELD VOLCANOES

13

Page 14: Large shield volcanoes on the Moon - Spudis Lunar Resources · 2018. 1. 23. · Large shield volcanoes on the Moon Paul D. Spudis, 1 Patrick J. McGovern, 1 and Walter S. Kiefer 1

lavas [e.g., Wilhelms, 1987]. However, Whitford-Stark andHead [1977] suggested that much of the basalt of OceanusProcellarum may have been emplaced as eruptives from afew volcanic centers, including both the Marius Hillsand Aristarchus structures. We concur with this latterinterpretation at least in part, as rilles (lava channels)originating on the lunar shields have clearly supplied lavato the surrounding maria.

4. Distribution and Morphometry of LargeLunar Shields

[28] The distribution of these proposed lunar shieldvolcanoes is decidedly non-random (Figure 1). The largest

grouping (Marius, Prinz, Hortensius, Rümker, Aristarchus,and Kepler) is distributed along the southern and western pe-riphery of the Imbrium basin, within the large Procellarum-KREEP terrane [Haskin et al., 2000], with its anomalouslyhigh-Th content [Lawrence et al., 2007], while the largestshield (Cauchy) sits in the midst of a cluster of mare basins,including Serenitatis, Nectaris, and Crisium. These shieldsall lie within predicted annular zones of enhanced magmaascent produced by stresses from loading of mare units in-side these basins [Litherland and McGovern, 2009; McGo-vern and Litherland, 2011]. The mechanism for enhancingascent of magma stems from a combination of thelithosphere’s !exural and membrane responses to initialbasin-"lling mare loads that creates favorable principal

Figure 22. Volcanic features map of the Gardner shield. The predominant landform expression is aseries of inter"ngered low shields and the collapse pit at its summit.

Figure 23. Topographic pro"les of the Gardner shield.

SPUDIS ET AL.: LUNAR SHIELD VOLCANOES

14

Page 15: Large shield volcanoes on the Moon - Spudis Lunar Resources · 2018. 1. 23. · Large shield volcanoes on the Moon Paul D. Spudis, 1 Patrick J. McGovern, 1 and Walter S. Kiefer 1

stress orientations [Anderson, 1936] and tectonic stress gra-dients [Rubin, 1995] for vertical transport of magma in dikeswith orientations radial to the basins.[29] The sizes of these lunar shield volcanoes are compa-

rable to other broad, low-relief basaltic shields on the Earth,Mars, and Venus (Figures 28 and 29). For example, the KaliMons volcano on Venus has diameter and !ank slope distri-butions similar to those of the proposed Marius Hills shield(Figure 29). Typical slopes for the !anks of these shields areextremely low, on the order of less than 1" (Table 1). How-ever, the slopes of the two smallest features, Rümker andGardner, are about 2.5"; these features also have uniquepopulations of small overlapping volcanic domes and lowshields. These relations may indicate slightly different pro-cesses at work in the construction of these smaller shields.The estimated volumes of the large lunar shields range fromabout 1012 to 1014m3 (Table 1). These values fall among thelower range of estimates of volumes for shield volcanoes on

Mars, which range from 1012 to more than 1015m3 [Plescia,2004]. It is evident that the size, shape, and volume of theselunar features (Figures 28 and 29 and Table 1) are compara-ble in morphometry to unequivocal basaltic shield volcanoeson other terrestrial planets, including Earth [Pike, 1978],Mars [Plescia, 2004], and Venus [Herrick et al., 2005].[30] With the possible exceptions of Gardner and Marius

Hills, most of the newly described lunar shields do not havesummit pits or calderas. However, some shields on the otherterrestrial planets likewise do not have summit craters andthe absence of such does not negate the classi"cation of ei-ther these or the lunar features as shield volcanoes. Manyshield volcanoes on Venus do not display summit cratersbut the existence of these volcanoes is evident by concentra-tions of eruptive landforms, radiating !ows, and broad, lowrelief topographic swells. The absence of a caldera is consis-tent with the mode of mantle-to-surface magma transportpredicted by the models of McGovern and Litherland[2011]: dikes are aligned with regional (basin-loading)stresses. Evidence for this is particularly strong at theCauchy shield, which is topped by a set of large graben/lava"ssures (Rimae Cauchy I and II) that are radial to the Seren-itatis basin.[31] Scenarios for the development of the proposed

Cauchy shield can be constrained by remote sensing andgeological mapping. Cauchy lacks the strong free-air gravityhigh characteristic of !exurally supported shield volcanoessuch as Marius Hills [Kiefer, 2013], but joint analysis ofgravity and topography indicates a local crustal thicknessmaximum beneath the structure [Neumann et al., 1996],consistent with an isostatically compensated rise of materialwith the density of crustal rocks. Mapping and interpretationof multispectral imaging data indicate that the surface basaltsin eastern Mare Tranquillitatis are on the order of severalhundred meters in thickness [Rajmon and Spudis, 2004].This value is a fraction of the observed 1.8 km relief of theCauchy shield. Perhaps the basalts of the Cauchy shieldcomprise a thin carapace covering a pre-existing crustalblock (similar to the developmental scenario proposed abovefor Aristarchus). Alternatively, the topographic rise couldhave been built up by substantial amounts of intrusion andunderplating of moderate-density magmas, augmented bylate-stage eruptions of denser cumulate-rich magmas aidedby favorable stresses in the lithosphere [McGovern andLitherland, 2011]. The former case would be inconsistent

Figure 25. The LROC WAC mosaic at low sun illumina-tion of the Aristarchus region, showing bulbous, blister-likeshape of the topography of the plateau. Such morphology isconsistent with the interpretation of the Aristarchus plateauas a proto-shield volcano. Mosaic made by Maurice Collins(http://lpod.wikispaces.com/August+20%2C+2012).

Figure 24. Volcanic features of the Aristarchus shield (~250 km; 25"N, 50"W). Pit craters and sinuousrilles of the northern margin of the plateau (left); Cobra Head pit crater source vent and Vallis Schröteri, anested sinuous rille indicating multi-phase eruption history (center); collapse pits and sinuous rilles of theNE section of the plateau (right).

SPUDIS ET AL.: LUNAR SHIELD VOLCANOES

15

Page 16: Large shield volcanoes on the Moon - Spudis Lunar Resources · 2018. 1. 23. · Large shield volcanoes on the Moon Paul D. Spudis, 1 Patrick J. McGovern, 1 and Walter S. Kiefer 1

with the postulated presence of a Tranquillitatis impact basin[e.g., Wilhelms, 1987], while the latter allows it.[32] The recognition of the existence of large shield volca-

noes on the Moon invites a re-examination of scenarios forlunar magma ascent. It has been previously held that theapparent absence of shield volcanoes on the Moon wasconsistent with buoyancy-controlled ascent of magmasthrough the lunar crust [e.g., Head and Wilson, 1991]. In thisview, the presumed negative buoyancy of basaltic magmasin an anorthositic crust precludes the creation of shallowreservoirs at neutral buoyancy horizons, from which rela-tively low- and moderate-volume shield-building eruptionscould emanate. Instead, high-volume eruptions from dikeslong enough to bene"t from positive buoyancy deep in the

mantle were required; these would produce sheets of !oodlavas rather than central-vent edi"ces [Head and Wilson,1991]. Although there is reason to question the negativebuoyancy of mare basalt magmas [e.g., Wieczorek et al.,2001], our observations that large shields do exist suggestthat lunar eruptions probably spanned a range of volumesand mass eruption rates, allowing both shield-building and!ood-type eruptions. The shield-building eruptions couldcome directly from the mantle, driven by basin loading-in-duced stress in dikes [McGovern and Litherland, 2011],from shallow magma bodies created by intrusion-trappingloading stresses [e.g., Solomon and Head, 1980; Galganaet al., 2011] or "lling of pore space in an impact-processedand fractured upper crust [Kiefer, 2013].

Figure 27. Topographic pro"les of the Aristarchus shield.

Figure 26. Map of the volcanic features of the Aristarchus shield (~250 km; 25"N, 50"W). The principallandform is the sinuous rille and pit crater, many of which have emplaced the surrounding mare deposits.Abundant pyroclastic materials discontinuously cover the plateau lavas, making determination of the agesof surface units uncertain.

SPUDIS ET AL.: LUNAR SHIELD VOLCANOES

16

Page 17: Large shield volcanoes on the Moon - Spudis Lunar Resources · 2018. 1. 23. · Large shield volcanoes on the Moon Paul D. Spudis, 1 Patrick J. McGovern, 1 and Walter S. Kiefer 1

[33] Figure 28 shows that the height/diameter ratios for thelunar volcanic shields fall within the general range de"nedby shield volcanoes on Earth, Mars, and Venus. Althoughsome broad trends are evident, there is considerable scatterin the observations for all four objects. One can use a modelof the spreading of an uncon"ned viscous surface sheet !owto gain some insight into the factors that are likely to controlthe large-scale morphology of these volcanoes [Turcotte andSchubert, 2002; Baratoux et al., 2009]. Equations (9-99) and(9-101) of Turcotte and Schubert [2002] can be combined to"nd that:

hd# C

mQkrg

! "3=4

V$ %&1=2

[34] where h/d is the height/diameter ratio of the volcano,m is the magma viscosity, r is the magma density, Q is themagma supply rate, g is the gravitational acceleration, k isthe permeability, V is the volcano volume, and C is a

numerical constant. Based on this simple model, one wouldexpect that planets with smaller g have larger values of h/d.Figure 28 shows that this simple gravity scaling relationdoes not work. For example, based simply on gravityscaling, Earth and Venus should have very similar valuesof h/d, with Mars and the Moon having increasingly largervalues of h/d. In fact, Figure 28 shows that Earth has thelargest values of h/d. Other factors, such as the magmaviscosity and the magma supply rate, must exert strongercontrols on shield morphology than does a simple gravityscaling relationship.[35] In the case of the Moon, the magma composition and

viscosity are different from basaltic magmas on Earth; lunarbasalts are richer in FeO and TiO2 and de"cient in SiO2relative to terrestrial basalts [Neal and Taylor, 1992;Wieczorek et al., 2006]. The lower SiO2 results in signi"cantlylower magma viscosities on the Moon relative to Earth [Weillet al., 1971; Bottinga and Weill, 1972], which more than off-sets the differences in gravitational acceleration. Differences

Figure 29. Cross-sections of topography (solid black line, left y axis) and slope (red boxes, right y axis)for proposed lunar shield volcano Marius Hills (left, from LOLA) [Smith et al., 2010] and for the KaliMons edi"ce on Venus (right, from Magellan) [Ford and Pettengill, 1992]. Azimuths from feature centerare indicated above each pro"le. Slope measurements are calculated using a least squares "t to a planeover an 80 km wide baseline centered on each point.

Figure 28. Height-diameter relations for shield volcanoes on several terrestrial planets; plotted “trends”are informal and diagrammatic. The newly described lunar structures (stars) fall within the ranges of sizesand heights of large, low-relief basaltic shields on Venus and Mars. Data for Earth (green squares) [Pike,1978], Mars (red triangles) [Plescia, 2004], and Venus (blue circles) [Herrick et al., 2005].

SPUDIS ET AL.: LUNAR SHIELD VOLCANOES

17

Page 18: Large shield volcanoes on the Moon - Spudis Lunar Resources · 2018. 1. 23. · Large shield volcanoes on the Moon Paul D. Spudis, 1 Patrick J. McGovern, 1 and Walter S. Kiefer 1

in magma supply rate may also be important. Regional vari-ability in magma supply on the Moon is likely but cannot bewell constrained observationally. Assuming such supply ratevariations do occur, this could contribute to the scatter in h/dobserved for the various lunar shields. Temporal variabilityin magma supply may also be important. For example, volca-nic !ows from the Marius Hills have been mapped as sourcesfor lava !ows in the surrounding regions of Oceanus Procel-larum [Whitford-Stark and Head, 1980] in addition to produc-ing the Marius Hills topographic shield. Periods of relativelyhigh magma !ux would result in thin, widely distributed lava!ows in Oceanus Procellarum, while periods of lower !uxwould result in a thicker lava sequence and a more localizedproduction of lava in the Marius Hills shield.[36] A new appreciation of these lunar volcanic complexes

as shield volcanoes does not alter our general picture of marevolcanism on the Moon as being dominated by the eruptionof high-volume !ood lavas. Sheets of lava erupted fromlinear "ssures are still the best explanation for most of thein"lling of the mare basins to varying degrees. However,the identi"cation of large shield volcanoes indicates thatsome signi"cant fraction of erupted magma on the Moonhas been emplaced via the mechanism of low volume,prolonged shield-building eruptions. The ages of the maresurfaces associated with these features [Hiesinger et al.,2000; 2003] range over several hundred million years duringthe era of mare volcanism (Table 1), from as old as 3.8Gafor the lavas of the Aristarchus shield [Zisk et al., 1977] to!ows possibly as young as ~1Ga on the Marius Hills shield[Huang et al., 2011]. Thus, shield building was a continuousprocess \during the principal epoch of mare volcanism onthe Moon (3.9–3.0Ga) [BVSP, 1981; Wilhelms, 1987] andpossibly extending well beyond it, up to as recently as1Ga ago [Huang et al., 2011].

5. Conclusions

[37] We correlate large topographic prominences in the lu-nar maria with concentrations of small volcanic featuressuch as domes, pit craters, small shields, cones, and rilles.We interpret these large, broad topographic features asshield volcanoes, a previously unrecognized style of lunarvolcanic activity. Shield building occurred during the mainphases of mare volcanism on the Moon, between 3.9 and3.0Ga ago. The lunar shields show a variety of developmen-tal states, ranging from nearly complete shield development(e.g., Marius Hills) to proto-shield, highland block volcanicresurfacing (e.g., Aristarchus). The features studied in thiswork are comparable in size and shape to basaltic shieldvolcanoes on other terrestrial planets, supporting our inter-pretation that they too are volcanic shields. Shields are foundproximate to the large, lava-"lled impact basins Imbriumand Serenitatis and structural features associated with theshields tend to be radial to these basins. The recognitionof shield volcanoes on the Moon af"rms that this style ofvolcanism has been ubiquitous on the terrestrial planets ofour Solar System.

[38] Acknowledgments. This paper is Lunar and Planetary Institutecontribution 1720. This work was supported in part by NASA grantNNX07AF95G. We thank Aileen Yingst, Lisa Gaddis, and two anonymousreviewers for helpful comments on an earlier version of this paper.

ReferencesAnderson, E. M. (1936), The dynamics of the formation of cone-sheets, ring-dykes, and cauldron subsidence, Proc. R. Soc. Edinburgh 56, 128–157.

Baratoux, D., P. Pinet, M. J. Toplis, N. Mangold, R. Greeley, andA. R. Baptista (2009), Shape, rheology, and emplacement times of smallMartian shield volcanoes, J. Volcanol. Geotherm. Res. 185, 47–68.

Basaltic Volcanism Study Project (BVSP) (1981), Basaltic Volcanism onthe Terrestrial Planets, Pergamon Press, New York, 757 pp.

Besse, S., J. M. Sunshine, M. I. Staid, N. E. Petro, J. W. Boardman,R. O. Green, J. W. Head, P. J. Isaacson, J. F. Mustard, and C. M. Pieters(2011), Compositional variability of the Marius Hills volcanic complexfrom the Moon Mineralogy Mapper (M3), J. Geophys. Res. 116,E00G13, doi:10.1029/2010JE003725.

Bottinga, Y., and D. F. Weill (1972), The viscosity of magmatic silicateliquids: A model for calculation, Am. J. Sci. 272, 438–475.

Campbell, B. A., B. R. Hawke and D. B. Campbell (2009), Surface mor-phology of domes in the Marius Hills and Mons Rümker regions of theMoon from Earth-based radar data, J. Geophys. Res. 114, E01001,doi:10.1029/2008JE003253.

Ford, P. G., and G. H. Pettengill (1992), Venus topography and kilometer-scale slopes, J. Geophys. Res. 97, 13, 103–113, 114.

Gaddis, L. R., M. I. Staid, J. A. Tyburczy, B. R. Hawke, and N. E. Petro (2003),Compositional analyses of lunar pyroclastic deposits, Icarus 161, 262–280.

Galgana, G. A., P. J. McGovern and E. B. Gros"ls (2011), Evolution oflarge Venusian volcanoes: Insights from coupled models of lithospheric!exure and magma reservoir pressurization, J. Geophys. Res. 116,doi:10.1029/2010JE003654.

Greeley, R. (1971), Lava tubes and channels in the lunar Marius Hills, TheMoon 3, 289–314.

Greeley, R. (1976),Modes of emplacement of basalt terrains and an analysis ofmare volcanism in the Orientale basin,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 7, 2747–2759.

Greeley, R. (1982), The Snake River Plain, Idaho: Representative of a newcategory of volcanism, Jour. Geophys. Res. 87, B4, 2705–2712.

Guest, J. E. (1971), Centres of igneous activity in the maria, in Geology andPhysics of the Moon, edited by G. Fielder, 41–53, Elsevier, New York.

Guest, J. E. and J. B. Murray (1976), Volcanic features of the nearside equa-torial maria, J. Geol. Soc. (London) 132, 251–258.

Gustafson, J. O., Bell J. F., Gaddis L. R., B. R. Hawke and T. A. Giguere(2012), Characterization of previously unidenti"ed lunar pyroclasticdeposits using Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter Camera data, J. Geophys.Res. 117, E00H25, doi:10.1029/2011JE003893.

Haruyama, J., et al. (2009), Possible lunar lava tube skylight observed bySELENE cameras, Geophys. Res. Lett. 36, L21206, doi:10.1029/2009GL040635.

Haskin, L. A., J. J. Gillis, R. L. Korotev, and B. L. Jolliff (2000), The mate-rials of the lunar Procellarum KREEP Terrane: A synthesis of data fromgeomorphological mapping, remote sensing, and sample analyses, J. Geo-phys. Res. 105, 20403–20415.

Head, J. W. (1976), Lunar volcanism in space and time, Rev. Geophys.Space Phys. 14, 265–300.

Head, J. W. and A. Gifford (1980), Lunar mare domes: Classi"cation andmodes of origin, Moon and Planets 22, 235–258.

Head, J. W. and L. Wilson (1991), Absence of large shield volcanoes andcalderas on the Moon: Consequence of magma transport phenomena?,Geophys. Res. Lett. 18, 11, 2121–2124.

Heather, D. J. and S. K. Dunkin (2002), A stratigraphic study of southernOceanus Procellarum using Clementine multispectral data, Planet. SpaceSci. 50, 1299–1309.

Heather, D. J., S. J. Dunkin, L. Wilson (2003), Volcanism on the MariusHills plateau: Observational analyses using Clementine multispectraldata, J. Geophys. Res. 108, E3, 5017, doi: 10.1029/2002JE001938.

Herrick, R. R., J. Dufek, and P. J. McGovern (2005), Evolution of largeshield volcanoes on Venus, J. Geophys. Res. 110, E1002, doi:10.1029/204JE002283.

Hiesinger, H., R. Jaumann, G. Neukum and J. W. Head (2000), Ages ofmare basalts on the lunar nearside, J. Geophys. Res. 105, 29239–29275.

Hiesinger, H., J. W. Head, U. Wolf, R. Jaumann, and G. Neukum (2003),Ages and stratigraphy of mare basalts in Oceanus Procellarum, MareNubium, Mare Cognitum and Mare Insularum, J. Geophys. Res. 108,5065, doi:10.1029/2002JE001985.

Huang, J., L. Xiao, X. He, L. Qaio, J. Zhao, and H. Li (2011), Geologicalcharacteristics and model ages of Marius Hills on the Moon. Jour. EarthSci. 22, 5, 601–609.

Kiefer, W. S., (2013), Gravity constraints on the subsurface structure of theMarius Hills: The magmatic plumbing of the largest lunar volcanic domecomplex, J. Geophys. Res. Planets, 118, doi:10.1029/2012JE004111.

Konopliv, A. S., S. W. Asmar, E. Carranza, W. L. Sjogren, and D. N. Yuan(2001), Recent gravity models as a result of the Lunar Prospector mission,Icarus 150, 1–18.

SPUDIS ET AL.: LUNAR SHIELD VOLCANOES

18

Page 19: Large shield volcanoes on the Moon - Spudis Lunar Resources · 2018. 1. 23. · Large shield volcanoes on the Moon Paul D. Spudis, 1 Patrick J. McGovern, 1 and Walter S. Kiefer 1

Lawrence, D. J., R. C. Puetter, R. C. Elphic, W. C. Feldman, J. J. Hagerty,T. H. Prettyman, P. D. Spudis (2007), Global spatial deconvolution of Lu-nar Prospector Th abundances, Geophys. Res. Lett. 34, No. 3,L0320110.1029/2006GL028530.

Lawrence, S. J., et al. (2013), LRO Observations of Morphology and Sur-face Roughness of Volcanic Cones and Lobate Lava Flows in the MariusHills. J. Geophys. Res., doi:10.1029/jgre.20060, in press.

Litherland, M. M. and P. J. McGovern (2009), Effects of planetary radius onlithospheric stresses and magma ascent on the terrestrial planets, LunarPlanet. Sci. 40, 2201.

MacDonald G. A. and A. T. Abbott (1970), Volcanoes in the Sea: TheGeology of Hawaii, 441 pp., Univ. Hawaii Press, Honolulu, Haw.

McCauley, J. F. (1964), The Marius Hills volcanic complex. Astrogeol.Studies Ann. Prog. Rpt. July 1964–July 1965, U. S. Geol. Survey,Washington DC, 115-122.

McCauley, J. F. (1967), Geologic map of the Hevelius region of the Moon,U. S. Geol. Survey Map I-491.

McCauley, J. F. (1968), Geologic results from lunar precursor probes,Amer. Inst. Aeronaut. Astonaut. Jour. 6, 1991-1996.

McEwen, A. S., M. S. Robinson, E. M. Eliason, P. G. Lucey, T. C. Duxbury,and P. D. Spudis (1994), Clementine observations of the Aristarchus regionof the Moon, Science 266, 1858–1862.

McGovern, P. J. and M. M. Litherland (2011), Lithospheric stress andbasaltic magma ascent on the Moon with implications for large volcanicprovinces and edi"ces, Lunar Planet. Sci. 42, 2587.

Moore, H. J. (1967), Geologic map of the Seleucus quadrangle, U. S. Geol.Survey Map I-527.

Neal, C. R., and L. A. Taylor (1992), Petrogenesis of mare basalts: A recordof lunar volcanism, Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 56, 2177–2211.

Neumann, G. A., M. T. Zuber, D. E. Smith, F. G. Lemoine (1996), Thelunar crust: Global structure and signature of major basins. J. Geophys.Res. 101, E7, 16841–16843.

Phillips, J. (1989), The new lunar dome survey: The Hortensius-Milichius-Tobias Mayer region, Jour. Assoc. Lunar Planet. Observers 33, 61–72.

Pike, R. J. (1978), Volcanoes on the inner planets: Some preliminarycomparisons of gross topography, Proc. Lunar Planet. Sci. Conf. 9,3239–3273.

Plescia, J. B. (2004), Morphometric properties of Martian volcanoes,J. Geophys. Res. 109, E3003, doi:10.1029/2002JE002031.

Rajmon, D. and P. Spudis (2004), Distribution and stratigraphy of basalticunits in Maria Tranquillitatis and Fecunditatis: A Clementine perspective,Meteoritics and Planetary Science 39, 10, 1699–1720.

Rubin, A. M. (1995), Propagation of magma-"lled cracks, Ann. Rev. EarthPlanet. Sci. 23, 287–336.

Schaber, G. G. (1973), Lava !ows in Mare Imbrium: Geologic evaluationfrom Apollo orbital photography, Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 4, 73–92.

Schaber, G. G., J. M. Boyce and H. J. Moore (1976), The scarcity of map-pable !ow lobes on the lunar maria: The unique morphology of theImbrium !ows, Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 7, 2783–2800.

Schmitt H. H., N. J. Trask and E. M. Shoemaker (1967), Geologic map ofthe Copernicus quadrangle of the Moon, U. S. Geol. Survey Map I-515.

Scholten, F., J. Oberst, K.-D. Matz, T. Roatsch, M. Wählisch, E. J. Speyerer,and M. S. Robinson (2012), GLD100: The near-global lunar 100m rasterDTM from LROC WAC stereo image data, Jour. Geophys. Res. 117,E00H17, doi:10.1029/2011JE003926.

Scott, D. H. and R. E. Eggleton (1973), Geologic map of the Rümker quad-rangle of the Moon, U.S. Geol. Survey Map I-805.

Schultz, P. H. (1976),MoonMorphology, Univ. Texas Press, Austin, 626 pp.Schultz, P. H. and P. D. Spudis (1983), The beginning and end of lunarmare volcanism, Nature 302, 233-236.

Shoemaker, E. M. (1962), Interpretation of lunar craters In Physics andAstronomy of the Moon, edited by Z. Kopal, pp. 283–359, AcademicPress, New York and London.

Smith, E. I. (1973), Identi"cation, distribution and signi"cance of lunarvolcanic domes, The Moon 6, 3–31.

Smith, E. I. (1974), Rümker Hills: A lunar volcanic dome complex, TheMoon 10, 175–181.

Smith, D. E., et al. (2010), Initial observations from the Lunar Orbiter LaserAltimeter (LOLA), Geophys. Res. Lett. 37, L18204, doi:10.1029/2010GL043751.

Solomon, S. C. and Head J. W. (1980), Lunar Mascon basins: Lava "lling,tectonics, and evolution of the lithosphere, Rev. Geophys. Space Phys. 18,107–141.

Spudis, P. D. (1996), The Once and Future Moon, pp. 117–118,Smithsonian Inst. Univ. Press, Washington, D.C.

Strain, P. L. and F. El Baz (1977), Topography of sinuous rilles in theHarbinger Mountains region of the Moon, The Moon 16, 221–229.

Swanson, D. A. and T. L. Wright (1978), Bedrock geology of the northernColumbia plateau and adjacent areas, in The Channeled Scabland, editedby V. R. Baker and D. Nummedal, pp. 37–57, NASA Of"ce SpaceScience, Washington, D.C.

Turcotte, D. L. and G. Schubert (2002), Geodynamics, 2nd ed., 456 pp.,Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, U.K. and New York.

Weill, D. F., R. A. Grieve, I. S. McCallum, and Y. Bottinga (1971), Miner-alogy-petrology of lunar samples: Microprobe studies of samples 12021and 12022; viscosity of melts of selected lunar compositions, Proc. LunarSci. Conf. 2, 413–430.

Weitz, C. M. and J. W. Head (1999), Spectral properties of the Marius Hillsvolcanic complex and implications for the formation of lunar domes andcones, J. Geophys. Res. 104, E8, 18933–18956.

Whitford-Stark, J. L. (1975), Shield volcanoes, in Volcanoes of Earth Moonand Mars, edited by G. Fielder and L. Wilson, pp. 66–74, Elek Science,London, U.K.

Whitford-Stark, J. L. and J. W. Head (1977), The Procellarum volcaniccomplexes: Contrasting styles of volcanism, Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 8,2705–2724.

Whitford-Stark, J. L., and J. W. Head (1980), Stratigraphy of Oceanus Pro-cellarum basalts: Sources and styles of emplacement, J. Geophys. Res. 85,6579–6609.

Wieczorek, M. A., M. T. Zuber and R. J. Phillips (2001), The role of magmabuoyancy on the eruption of lunar basalts, Earth Planet. Sci. Letters 185,71–83.

Wieczorek, M. A. (2006), The constitution and structure of the lunar inte-rior, in New Views of the Moon, Reviews of Mineralogy and Geochemistry60, 221–364.

Wilhelms, D. E., et al. (1972), Geologic Map of the Tauruntius Quadrangle,Moon. U.S. Geol. Survey Map I-722.

Wilhelms, D. E. (1987), Geologic History of the Moon, U.S. Geol. SurveyProf. Paper 1348, 302 pp.

Wilhelms, D. E. and J. F. McCauley (1971), Geologic map of the near sideof the Moon, U.S. Geol. Survey Map I-703.

Wöhler, C., R. Lena, P. Lazzarotti, J. Phillips, M. Wirths and Z. Pujic(2006), A combined spectrophotometric and morphologic study of lunarmare dome "elds near Cauchy, Arago, Hortensius and Milichius, Icarus183, 237–264.

Wood, C. A. (2003), The Modern Moon: A Personal View, 209 pp., SkyPublishing Corp., Cambridge Mass.

Wood, C. A. (2004), Astonishing megadome, Lunar Photo of the Day,http://www.lpod.org/archive/LPOD-2004-09-26.htm.

Wood, C. A., W. Higgins, K. C. Pau, and G. Mengoli (2005), The Lamont-Gardner megadome alignment: A lunar volcano-tectonic structure?, LunarPlanet. Sci. XXXVI, 1116, http://www.lpi.usra.edu/meetings/lpsc2005/pdf/1116.pdf.

Zisk, S. H., C. A. Hodges, H. J. Moore, R. W. Shorthill, T. W. Thompson,E. A. Whitaker and D. E. Wilhelms (1977), The Aristarchus-Harbingerregion of the Moon: Surface geology and history from recent remote sens-ing observations, The Moon 17, 59–99.

Zuber, M. T., D. E. Smith, F. G. Lemoine, G. A. Neumann (1994), Theshape and internal structure of the moon from the Clementine mission,Science 266, 5192,1839–43.

SPUDIS ET AL.: LUNAR SHIELD VOLCANOES

19