Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO
WESTERN DIVISION
IN RE: DEPUY ORTHOPAEDICS, INC. ASR HIP IMPLANT PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION --------------------------------------------------------- This Document Relates to: Cases Listed on Attached Exhibit A
) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )
MDL Docket No. 1:10-md-2197
HONORABLE JEFFREY J. HELMICK
ORDER
This matter comes before the Court on Defendant’s unopposed motion for entry of
dismissal with prejudice. As the parties represent their consent to dismissal of the cases listed in
the attached Exhibit A, the Court grants that motion. Accordingly, an order of dismissal with
prejudice shall be entered in each case-specific docket.
Counsel has certified that the requisite assessment is being withheld and deposited into
the Common Benefit Fund.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
Dated: _October 11, 2016 __ s/ Jeffrey J. Helmick United States District Judge
Case: 1:10-md-02197-JJH Doc #: 1086 Filed: 10/11/16 1 of 24. PageID #: 11679
Appendix A
DEPUY ASRTM HIP SYSTEM CASES
MDL No. 2197
No. Plaintiff Name Plaintiff's Firm MDL Case No.
1 Moore, Rose Acosta Law Firm 11dp20774
2 Stevenson, Ryan Allan Berger & Associates, PLC 11dp23107
3 Garner, Loveda Anapol Schwartz 14dp20618
4 Eyster, Janet Anapol, Schwartz, Weiss 13dp21500
5 Gladfelter, Michael Anapol, Schwartz, Weiss 13dp21499
6 Hayes, Nanette Anapol, Schwartz, Weiss 12dp21203
7 Kessler, William Anapol, Schwartz, Weiss 15dp20041
8 Maguire, Lori Anapol, Schwartz, Weiss 13dp20544
9 Scoles, Elaine Anapol, Schwartz, Weiss 15dp20057
10 Swengel, Donna J. Anapol, Schwartz, Weiss 12dp21440
11 Baxter, Linda Andrews & Thornton 12dp23052
12 Schaff, Michael Anesi, Ozmon, Rodin 11dp22612
13 Owen, Carole Armbruster, Dripps, Winterscheidt & Blotevogel, LLC 14dp20541
14 Crandell, Teresa L. Atkinson, Haskins, Nellis 11dp21881
15 Bedford, Lynn Aylstock, Witkin, Kreis 12dp22267
16 Egbert, Peggy Aylstock, Witkin, Kreis 12dp20793
17 Filoramo, Richard Aylstock, Witkin, Kreis 14dp20381
18 Gamber, Richard Aylstock, Witkin, Kreis 12dp22779
19 Hadley, Elizabeth Aylstock, Witkin, Kreis 13dp20877
20 Hayes, Teresa Aylstock, Witkin, Kreis 13dp21115
21 Hirsch, Robb Aylstock, Witkin, Kreis 12dp22297
Case: 1:10-md-02197-JJH Doc #: 1086 Filed: 10/11/16 2 of 24. PageID #: 11680
Appendix A
DEPUY ASRTM HIP SYSTEM CASES MDL No. 2197
3
No. Plaintiff Name Plaintiff's Firm MDL Case No.
22 Labandeira, Toni Kay Aylstock, Witkin, Kreis 12dp22300
23 Parnham, Thomas S. Aylstock, Witkin, Kreis 12dp22355
24 Porter, Sandra Sue Aylstock, Witkin, Kreis 13dp20220
25 Wilson, Hayden Eugene Aylstock, Witkin, Kreis 12dp23295
26 Foster, Millicent Bailey Perrin & Bailey 11dp22051
27 Gonzalez, Frances Bailey Perrin & Bailey 12dp22099
28 Graves, John W. Jr. Bailey Perrin & Bailey 12dp21708
29 Johnson, Henry C. Bailey Perrin & Bailey 12dp22054
30 Jones, Shirley M. Bailey Perrin & Bailey 12dp22086
31 Cox, Claudia Bartimus, Frickleton, Robertson & Goza 12dp20961
32 Raymond, William K. for Raymond, Patricia (dec'd)
Bartimus, Frickleton, Robertson & Goza 13dp21263
33 Stace, Theresa June Bartimus, Frickleton, Robertson & Goza 11dp22255
34 Thornton, Robert Bartimus, Frickleton, Robertson & Goza 11dp22136
35 Blouse, Miriam Darlene Beasley, Allen, Crow, Methvin 12dp21140
36 Collins, Robert E. Jr. Beasley, Allen, Crow, Methvin 13dp21332
37 Miller, Kevin W. Beasley, Allen, Crow, Methvin 13dp29010
38 Pangburn, Gary Beasley, Allen, Crow, Methvin 12dp23154
39 Reed, Steven Beasley, Allen, Crow, Methvin 12dp23156
40 Spradlin, Bobby W. Beasley, Allen, Crow, Methvin 12dp20361
41 Steinruck, Michael Beasley, Allen, Crow, Methvin 12dp23226
42 Wilson, Stephen K. (dec'd) Beasley, Allen, Crow, Methvin 13dp20784
Case: 1:10-md-02197-JJH Doc #: 1086 Filed: 10/11/16 3 of 24. PageID #: 11681
Appendix A
DEPUY ASRTM HIP SYSTEM CASES MDL No. 2197
4
No. Plaintiff Name Plaintiff's Firm MDL Case No.
43 Bernard, Mary F. Bernstein Liebhard 11dp21947
44 Chasing Hawk, Eugene V. Bernstein Liebhard 11dp22770
45 Loyd, Rebecca A. Bernstein Liebhard 12dp21018
46 Macleish, Sandra Bernstein Liebhard 12dp23662
47 McEnaney, Terrence J. Bernstein Liebhard 12dp20417
48 Smith, William D. Bernstein Liebhard 12dp23877
49 Wilhoit, Ronald M. Bernstein Liebhard 12dp20704
50 Dodson, DeMarr Bohrer Law Firm 12dp23647
51 Jackson, Maria Delfina Bohrer Law Firm 13dp21272
52 Goral, Christine Bottar Leone, PLLC 11dp20123
53 Scarlett, Barbara Westbrook Bottar Leone, PLLC 11dp21726
54 Pennington, Wesley Bowersox Law Firm 13dp20595
55 Gustafson, Noreen J. Branch Law Firm 14dp20513
56 Massad, Pat Branch Law Firm 11dp22827
57 Maxwell, Doris Branch Law Firm 13dp21213
58 Maxwell, Doris M. Branch Law Firm 11dp20053
59 Donatelli, Kathleen M. Brannon & Associates 11dp20536
60 McVan, Michele Brian P. McVan 12dp23687
61 Cooke, Beth Brown Chiari 14dp20449
62 McConnell, Shannon Buckman & Buckman 11dp22200
63 Mason, Ashley Isabella Burg Simpson 14dp20133
64 Miller, James C. Burg Simpson 14dp20132
Case: 1:10-md-02197-JJH Doc #: 1086 Filed: 10/11/16 4 of 24. PageID #: 11682
Appendix A
DEPUY ASRTM HIP SYSTEM CASES MDL No. 2197
5
No. Plaintiff Name Plaintiff's Firm MDL Case No.
65 Powell, Linda Lee Burg Simpson 12dp20202
66 Friedland, Audrey Burke Wise Morrissey 11dp20239
67 Klingbiel, Randy L. Cannon & Dunphy 13dp20431
68 Nelson, Richard C. Cannon & Dunphy 14dp20060
69 Dixon, Turnie Carey Danis & Lowe 12-dp-23502
70 Nuxhall, Stephen Carey Danis & Lowe 15dp20073
71 Barber, Darrell D. Cellino & Barnes 11dp22698
72 Bauer, Carol C. Cellino & Barnes 11dp22477
73 Cappel, Jack Cellino & Barnes 11dp22451
74 Cavaluzzi, Pamela J. Cellino & Barnes 11dp22530
75 Freed, Denise M. Cellino & Barnes 11dp22679
76 Glowniak, Robert Stanley Jr. Cellino & Barnes 11dp22700
77 Hawley, Thomas E. Cellino & Barnes 12dp20161
78 Larkin, Jr., Nathaniel Cellino & Barnes 11dp22423
79 McLean, Gloria L. Cellino & Barnes 11dp22521
80 Recor, David Cellino & Barnes 14dp20176
81 Rommes (McLean), Cheryl A. Cellino & Barnes 12dp21988
82 Saunderson, Gene II Cellino & Barnes 14dp20356
83 Scarlata, Frances R. Cellino & Barnes 11dp22593
84 Swartz, Timothy Scott Cellino & Barnes 14dp20026
85 Marston, Robert Scott Chester H. Boyd 13dp20688
86 Beal, Gerald Wayne Childers, Schlueter & Smith 12dp23269
Case: 1:10-md-02197-JJH Doc #: 1086 Filed: 10/11/16 5 of 24. PageID #: 11683
Appendix A
DEPUY ASRTM HIP SYSTEM CASES MDL No. 2197
6
No. Plaintiff Name Plaintiff's Firm MDL Case No.
87 Brown, Ricky D. Childers, Schlueter & Smith 11dp23080
88 Davis, Sandra AKA Nail, Sandra Davis Childers, Schlueter & Smith 11dp21837
89 Duffie, Olivia Childers, Schlueter & Smith 14dp20620
90 Hagan, Laurlinda Childers, Schlueter & Smith 15dp20015
91 Hickey, Barbara Childers, Schlueter & Smith 12dp23905
92 Jackson, Carl Minton Childers, Schlueter & Smith 11dp21835
93 Long, Vernie Childers, Schlueter & Smith 13dp20193
94 Mobasser, Shapour Childers, Schlueter & Smith 12dp24046
95 Nelson, Edwin D. Childers, Schlueter & Smith 11dp21254
96 Noland, Anthony P. Childers, Schlueter & Smith 12dp21061
97 Orr, Billy Foster Jr. Childers, Schlueter & Smith 11dp23065
98 Pinkerton, Jill Childers, Schlueter & Smith 11dp21258
99 Richardson, Timothy Childers, Schlueter & Smith 14dp20267
100 Taylor, Gloria Patricia Childers, Schlueter & Smith 12dp23800
101 Thomas, Emmanuel Childers, Schlueter & Smith 12dp20632
102 Williams, Michelle R. Childers, Schlueter & Smith 13dp20992
103 Dahl, Stephen A. Ciano & Goldwasser 12dp22203
104 Fresco, Robert A. Ciano & Goldwasser 11dp21620
105 Clausen, Chris Clark, Love & Hutson 12dp22723
106 Jordan, Walter Clark, Love & Hutson 12dp22604
107 Neumann, George Clark, Love & Hutson 12dp22394
108 Roberson, Macey Clark, Love & Hutson 12dp21840
Case: 1:10-md-02197-JJH Doc #: 1086 Filed: 10/11/16 6 of 24. PageID #: 11684
Appendix A
DEPUY ASRTM HIP SYSTEM CASES MDL No. 2197
7
No. Plaintiff Name Plaintiff's Firm MDL Case No.
109 Stagg, Jeff Clark, Love & Hutson 12dp22350
110 Stefinsky, John Clark, Love & Hutson 12dp22568
111 Threats, Andrew Clark, Love & Hutson 12dp22049
112 White, Bobby Clark, Love & Hutson 12dp22331
113 Wilmot-Sandell, Donna L. Clark, Love & Hutson 12dp21611
114 Wolfe, Beverly Clark, Love & Hutson 12dp22583
115 Slayton, Jackie Lee Cochran Firm 11dp21094
116 Terrell, Jewell Ellen Cochran Firm 12dp20597
117 Williams, Jerry Cochran Firm 12dp20934
118 Alberto, John M. Jr. Cohen & Feeley 14dp20274
119 Bartashunas, Anthony R. Cohen & Feeley 12dp22230
120 Chorones, Anthony Cohen & Feeley 12dp22224
121 Jones, Garland R. Cohen & Feeley 12dp22381
122 Kluck, Brian W. Cohen & Feeley 13dp21566
123 McGee, Dennis Cohen & Feeley 12dp22387
124 Tighe, Philip J. Dr. Cohen & Feeley 12dp22558
125 Wernett, Barbara A. Cohen & Feeley 12dp22734
126 Matti, Patricia A. Cohen, Feeley, Altemose & Rambo, P.C. 13dp21563
127 McCullor, Judy Colley & Colley 11dp20457
128 Bjerke, Kay M. Cory, Watson, Crowder 15dp20123
129 Bowman, Anthony Todd Sr. Cory, Watson, Crowder 11dp22550
Case: 1:10-md-02197-JJH Doc #: 1086 Filed: 10/11/16 7 of 24. PageID #: 11685
Appendix A
DEPUY ASRTM HIP SYSTEM CASES MDL No. 2197
8
No. Plaintiff Name Plaintiff's Firm MDL Case No.
130 Chambers, Louise for Chambers, Gwyn Wesley (dec'd)
Cory, Watson, Crowder 11dp20617
131 Claiborne, Benjamin Charles Cory, Watson, Crowder 11dp22440
132 Davis, Joe Ann Cory, Watson, Crowder 11dp22694
133 Falewee, Kathryn Cory, Watson, Crowder 14dp20312
134 Fults, Charles Cory, Watson, Crowder 11dp23169
135 Holland, Marian Fredrika Cory, Watson, Crowder 12dp20064
136 Street, Helen Lucile Cory, Watson, Crowder 11dp21297
137 Johnson, Allen David E. Ross, II 14dp20301
138 Jackson, Grace Maye Davis & Taliaferro 10dp20012
139 Rodham, Anthony Davis Saperstein & Salomon 12dp21022
140 Ball, Barbara Dean Law Firm 12dp22964
141 Carlson, Vincent Eugene Debrincat, Padgett, Kobliska & Zick 14dp20046
142 Brandon, Christopher Douglas & London 12dp22599
143 Griffin, Sara E. Douglas & London 12dp20085
144 Ellerd, Mary D. Drake Law Firm 14dp20600
145 Peil, Pamela Drake Law Firm (MT) 12dp21216
146 Zeller, Ronald Dugan Law Firm 11dp20056
147 Bauer, Edward Edwards Law 12dp21273
148 Broadie, Sarah Egerton & Associates P.A. 14dp20094
149 Carnell, Dale Egerton & Associates P.A. 14dp20097
150 Collins, Boyd Egerton & Associates P.A. 14dp20102
Case: 1:10-md-02197-JJH Doc #: 1086 Filed: 10/11/16 8 of 24. PageID #: 11686
Appendix A
DEPUY ASRTM HIP SYSTEM CASES MDL No. 2197
9
No. Plaintiff Name Plaintiff's Firm MDL Case No.
151 Koontz, Jack Egerton & Associates P.A. 14dp20074
152 Benson, James M. Eglet Wall Christiansen 13dp20863
153 Passer, Joann K. for Tobler, Carol K. (dec'd) Eglet Wall Christiansen 12dp23778
154 Wiedeman, Eileen A. Eglet Wall Christiansen 12dp23779
155 DeSantis, Patricia Elizabeth P. Kagan 14dp20569
156 Behnke, Gary Engelmeyer & Pezzani 11dp22778
157 Geck, Suzanne M. Faraci Lange 14dp20211
158 Oyer, Steven C. Faraci Lange 14dp20181
159 Sinesiou, Gail Mary Faraci Lange 13dp21422
160 VanLoo, Virginia E. Faraci Lange 14dp20203
161 Barkley, Ann J. Fleming, Nolen & Jez 14dp20433
162 Cahn, Edgar B. Fleming, Nolen & Jez 12dp21477
163 Dodson, Rebecca A. Fleming, Nolen & Jez 14dp20434
164 Glover, Robert S. Fleming, Nolen & Jez 14dp20420
165 Goolsby, Tony A. Fleming, Nolen & Jez 14dp20412
166 Kurtz, Sandra S. Fleming, Nolen & Jez 14dp20411
167 Young, Jeffrey E. Fleming, Nolen & Jez 15dp20044
168 Vega, Mercedes Freeman Law Firm 12dp20106
169 Turner, Freddie Michael Freese & Goss 12dp20322
170 Walker, Douglas W. Freese & Goss 12dp20663
171 Romaguera, Edgar Albert Jr. Gainsburgh Benjamin David 13dp20635
172 Hardester, Ronnie G. Gene A. Ludwig 14dp20435
Case: 1:10-md-02197-JJH Doc #: 1086 Filed: 10/11/16 9 of 24. PageID #: 11687
Appendix A
DEPUY ASRTM HIP SYSTEM CASES MDL No. 2197
10
No. Plaintiff Name Plaintiff's Firm MDL Case No.
173 Daniels, Rhonda Gennusa, Piacun & Ruli 12dp23941
174 Hulbert, Phyllis Goddard, Scuteri & Delaney 13dp21496
175 Jensen, Loretta Mae Goldenberglaw 12dp23926
176 Harsha, Edna Lynn Goldenberglaw 12dp22531
177 Rabenberg, Lisa Goldenberglaw 14dp20040
178 Silhasek, David L. Goldenberglaw 12dp20009
179 Best, Larry Grant & Eisenhofer 14dp20368
180 Amundson, Ruth A. Habush Habush & Rottier 14dp20423
181 Lamm, Joann Hardison & Cochran 14dp20004
182 Hatayama, Tina Hare, Wynn, Newell & Newton 14dp20499
183 Johnston, Timothy Matthew Harris Sarratt & Hodges 13dp2166
184 Bailey, Carol L. Harrison Davis Steakley 12dp22463
185 Bryson, Katherine F. Harrison Davis Steakley 12dp22480
186 Carson, Ethel M. Harrison Davis Steakley 15dp20102
187 Economidis, Peter Harrison Davis Steakley 12dp21548
188 Flournoy, JoAnn Harrison Davis Steakley 11dp22359
189 Fowler, Jay Edward Harrison Davis Steakley 11dp22358
190 Hoerster, Robert J. Harrison Davis Steakley 13dp20677
191 Kline, Sandra K. Harrison Davis Steakley 14dp20493
192 Pace, Clarice Anne Harrison Davis Steakley 12dp22614
193 Scott, Larry Harrison Davis Steakley 11dp22603
194 Wilson, Elizabeth Harrison Davis Steakley 12dp22515
Case: 1:10-md-02197-JJH Doc #: 1086 Filed: 10/11/16 10 of 24. PageID #: 11688
Appendix A
DEPUY ASRTM HIP SYSTEM CASES MDL No. 2197
11
No. Plaintiff Name Plaintiff's Firm MDL Case No.
195 Nicholson, Donna Rene Hawkins Gibson, PLLC 11dp21280
196 Stone, Sanford Samuel Hilborn & Hilborn 15dp20002
197 Stutler, Robert L. Hill, Peterson, Carper 11dp21892
198 Wilson, Timothy Hollis, Wright & Couch 11dp20576
199 Fea, Al Houssiere Durant Houssiere 12-dp-23273
200 Felton, Thomas Houssiere Durant Houssiere 13dp20659
201 Baumler, Jesse R. Huber, Slack, Houghtaling 11dp21273
202 Puett, Clifford Sr. Hughes & Coleman 14dp20578
203 Lippincott, Walter Hurley McKenna & Mertz 14dp20609
204 Wolven, Joy Jackson & Campbellf 11dp21433
205 Dahle, Craig Jackson & Foster 15dp20099
206 Wiseman, Ottie V. James F. Humphreys & Associates 11dp22293
207 Price, Erica for Nichols, Penny Lynn (dec'd) James, Carter & Coulter 11dp21486
208 Brown, John Jensen & Associates 12-dp-23458
209 Cook, Rose L. Joel Nash 15dp20013
210 Evans, Ella L. John A. Zick 14dp20134
211 Rukat, William R. John Gehlhausen, PC 13dp21183
212 Brock, Robert R. Johnson Becker PLLC 13dp20352
213 Casaletto, Mark Johnson Law Firm 13dp20868
214 Davis, Allan Johnson Law Firm 13dp20151
215 Holven, Thomas Johnson Law Firm 13dp21514
216 Koehler, Lynn Johnson Law Firm 13dp21442
Case: 1:10-md-02197-JJH Doc #: 1086 Filed: 10/11/16 11 of 24. PageID #: 11689
Appendix A
DEPUY ASRTM HIP SYSTEM CASES MDL No. 2197
12
No. Plaintiff Name Plaintiff's Firm MDL Case No.
217 Protasiewicz, Ronald Johnson Law Firm 13dp21470
218 Schwartz, Henry Johnson Law Firm 13dp21474
219 Hatch, Hilary Kaiser Gornick 11dp22783
220 King, Steven B. Jr. Kaiser Gornick 12dp21198
221 Maier, Janet H. Kammholz Messina 12dp23927
222 Ward, John G. Jr. Kammholz Messina 11dp22754
223 Steimle, William L. Kershaw, Cutter & Ratinoff 11dp20146
224 Bonner, Richard E. Lamkin, Van Eman, Trimble 12dp21866
225 Anderson, Victoria McMann Lanier Law Firm 11dp20818
226 Barrymore, John Samuel Jr. Lanier Law Firm 14dp20522
227 Becenti, Ernest Lanier Law Firm 13dp21538
228 Joyce, Marietta Lanier Law Firm 12dp22887
229 Massengill, Jerry DeWayne Lanier Law Firm 11dp22270
230 Peoples, Susan J. Lanier Law Firm 11dp20068
231 Smith, Sky Lanier Law Firm 13dp21539
232 Turner, Brian Lanier Law Firm 14dp20182
233 Wilson, Robert L. Lanier Law Firm 14dp20297
234 Capparelli, Albert Larkin Axelrod 13dp20598
235 Oughton (Metel), Elyse Larkin Axelrod 13dp21521
236 Cole, Gareth H. Larson, King 14dp20231
237 Starry, Lora Ann Law Office of Barry Pasternack 11dp20007
Case: 1:10-md-02197-JJH Doc #: 1086 Filed: 10/11/16 12 of 24. PageID #: 11690
Appendix A
DEPUY ASRTM HIP SYSTEM CASES MDL No. 2197
13
No. Plaintiff Name Plaintiff's Firm MDL Case No.
238 Powers, Judie E. for Mitchell, Edward D. (dec'd)
Law Office of David Randolph Smith 11dp21994
239 Rahn, Alicia, Stanford, Aaron, and Hasler, Erica for Gatlin, Elizabeth (dec'd)
Law Office of John David Hart 11dp20612
240 Carbone, Susan Law Office of Kevin L. Mosley 11dp22312
241 Watts, Michael S. Law Offices of Douglas J. Robinson 13dp21227
242 O'Leary, Patricia Law Offices of Johnston, Sztykiel & Hunt 14dp20149
243 Waymack, Barbara J. Law Offices of Lisa Douglas 15dp20129
244 Urban, Birgit E. and Howard, Eva T. for Thoma, Marlene (dec'd)
Law Offices of Robert J. Fenstersheib 12dp24025
245 Grote, Richard T. Law Offices of Todd N. Hendrickson 14dp20379
246 Cetrullo, Louise H. Levin, Papantonio, Thomas 12dp20278
247 Cosgrove, Tom Levin, Papantonio, Thomas 15dp20078
248 Glantz, Michael Levin, Papantonio, Thomas 11dp22284
249 Holder, Nancy Levin, Papantonio, Thomas 15dp20081
250 Hysock, Cheryl Levin, Papantonio, Thomas 12dp20242
251 King, Robert Jr. Levin, Papantonio, Thomas 13dp21189
252 March, Susan Levin, Papantonio, Thomas 12dp20015
253 McEachern, Angus Levin, Papantonio, Thomas 12dp22008
254 Vander Linde, Alayna M. Levin, Papantonio, Thomas 12dp20444
255 Orvis, Jonathan P. Levy, Baldante, Finney 12dp22112
256 Blank, Gerald Lewis Legal Services 13cv20388
257 Culleton, Jason S. Lewis Saul & Associates 14dp20212
Case: 1:10-md-02197-JJH Doc #: 1086 Filed: 10/11/16 13 of 24. PageID #: 11691
Appendix A
DEPUY ASRTM HIP SYSTEM CASES MDL No. 2197
14
No. Plaintiff Name Plaintiff's Firm MDL Case No.
258 Keough, Lorie Lewis Saul & Associates 15dp20091
259 Peradotto, Erin M. Lipsitz Green Scime 14dp20608
260 Wilson, Pauline Lockridge Grindal Nauen 12dp22318
261 Bailey, Crystal Lynn Loncar & Associates 11dp21132
262 Garcia, Rosa Loncar & Associates 15dp20053
263 Jordan, Constance Loncar & Associates 15dp20058
264 Drago, Carlo M. Lowe Law Group 15dp20093
265 Wuennenberg, Ross T. Magana, Cathcart, McCarthy 11dp21294
266 Fowler, John L., III Maglio Christopher & Toale 13dp20093
267 Stratos, Renee (Stratos, JoAnne Renee) Maglio Christopher & Toale 13dp20199
268 Walker, Veronica Martin & Jones 11dp20798
269 Hilbrandt, Edith Martin, Harding & Mozzotti 14dp20348
270 Guerin, Elliot Martzell & Bickford
271 Barnes, Tracy McGartland Law Firm 14dp20470
272 Wommack, Babette and Robinson, Gregory Gene for Robinson, Marilyn J. (dec'd)
McGartland Law Firm 11dp21424
273 Jansen, Kathleen McSweeney & Langevin 14dp20460
274 Russell, Susan Meagher & Meagher 13dp20146
275 Thurston, James F. Meshbesher & Spence 12dp21391
276 Crossley, James Meyers & Flowers 14dp20516
277 Jenkins, Della Meyers & Flowers 14dp20621
278 Smith, Roger Dale Meyers & Flowers 13dp21331
Case: 1:10-md-02197-JJH Doc #: 1086 Filed: 10/11/16 14 of 24. PageID #: 11692
Appendix A
DEPUY ASRTM HIP SYSTEM CASES MDL No. 2197
15
No. Plaintiff Name Plaintiff's Firm MDL Case No.
279 Wellington, Carl A. Meyers & Flowers 13dp20840
280 Zschernitz, Gary Meyers & Flowers 14dp20622
281 Douglas, Clyde Miller Law Firm 13dp20816
282 MacGregor, Eva Miller Law Firm 12dp23772
283 White, Annetta J. Miller Law Firm 11dp23121
284 Wilson, Louis Miller Law Firm 13dp20274
285 Clancy, Susan Carol Moody Law Firm 11dp21804
286 Dixon, Carolyn L. Moody Law Firm 11dp20321
287 Milligan, Charles W. Jr. Moody Law Firm 11dp22177
288 Yancey, Sherita Moody Law Firm 11dp21113
289 Tanner, Thomas R Moore Landrey 11dp22268
290 Canidate, Debra L. Morgan & Morgan 14dp20112
291 Dodge, Janice for Radszuweit, Gerd (dec'd) Morgan & Morgan 12dp23688
292 Fowler, Mark P. Morgan & Morgan 14dp20432
293 Hooper, Peter C. for Hooper, Ann Marie (dec'd)
Morgan & Morgan 13dp21317
294 Hudson, Harry Roper Morgan & Morgan 13dp21304
295 Johnson, Donald E. Morgan & Morgan 14dp20501
296 Johnson, Theodore E. Jr. Morgan & Morgan 13dp21283
297 Marshall, Thermond Sr. Morgan & Morgan 13dp21250
298 Payne, Haskin Jr. Morgan & Morgan 12dp20772
299 Shuart, Danny D. Morgan & Morgan 12dp21481
Case: 1:10-md-02197-JJH Doc #: 1086 Filed: 10/11/16 15 of 24. PageID #: 11693
Appendix A
DEPUY ASRTM HIP SYSTEM CASES MDL No. 2197
16
No. Plaintiff Name Plaintiff's Firm MDL Case No.
300 Spengler, Betty J. Morgan & Morgan 12dp21482
301 Yarrington, Robert M. Morgan & Morgan 14dp20431
302 Bontrager, John R. Motley Rice 12dp23287
303 Boussaroque, Danielle Motley Rice 12dp23841
304 Glover, James Allen Motley Rice 13dp20159
305 Jones, Anissa Motley Rice 13dp20710
306 Polhamus, Daniel Motley Rice 13dp20471
307 Simmons, Arlene C. Motley Rice 11dp20790
308 Cellucci, Elissa Murphy Law Firm 13dp21251
309 Ramos, Pedro Naquin Law Firm 11dp22140
310 Coffin, Valerie Neblett, Beard & Arsenault 14dp20505
311 Hatch, Jacqueline K. Neblett, Beard & Arsenault 15dp20085
312 McCain, Effie G. Neblett, Beard & Arsenault 12dp20326
313 Messer, Robert D. Neblett, Beard & Arsenault 14dp20502
314 Scheffel, William Neblett, Beard & Arsenault 14dp20503
315 Joyner, Ruby Hinton Nurenberg, Paris 13dp21558
316 Bennett, Donald Ober, Kaler, Grimes & Shriver 13dp21209
317 Wessell, Marilyn Oliver Law Group 11dp20734
318 Howard, John Verdi Onder, Shelton, O'Leary 11dp23141
319 Moss, Lorella R. Onder, Shelton, O'Leary 13dp21342
320 Nider, Christine Onder, Shelton, O'Leary 11dp22755
321 Schneider, Stephanie Onder, Shelton, O'Leary 11dp22873
Case: 1:10-md-02197-JJH Doc #: 1086 Filed: 10/11/16 16 of 24. PageID #: 11694
Appendix A
DEPUY ASRTM HIP SYSTEM CASES MDL No. 2197
17
No. Plaintiff Name Plaintiff's Firm MDL Case No.
322 Smith, Jill Onder, Shelton, O'Leary 11dp22915
323 Stipe, George Jr. Onder, Shelton, O'Leary 11dp21157
324 DeLoach, Thomas Osteen & Osteen 12dp21615
325 Phillips, Mollie Parham Smith & Archenhold 15dp20095
326 Hulbirt, Pamela Parker Waichman 11dp21269
327 Jenkins, Della Parker Waichman 11dp22986
328 Wilson, Clifford Parker Waichman 11dp21596
329 Bedsaul, Sharon R. Patten, Wornom, Hatten 13dp21540
330 Horner, Robert M. Patten, Wornom, Hatten 11dp21709
331 Myatt, Roger V. Patten, Wornom, Hatten 14dp20467
332 Rath, Steven Ocile Pearson, Randall & Schumacher 13dp20708
333 McCulloch, Kenneth L. Sr. Pendley, Baudin & Coffin 11dp21028
334 Williams, James Lee Perdue & Kidd 14dp20355
335 Shimmel, Nicholas Perry, Guthery, Haase & Gessford 14dp20458
336 Maves, Melody Peter F. Ferracuti 13dp20366
337 Cooler, James Everett Peters Murdaugh Parker Elzroth & Detrick 14dp20126
338 Stuntebeck, Richard J. Pitman, Kyle, Sicula & Dentice 11dp22787
339 Abbott, Catherine Pittman, Dutton & Hellums 11dp20159
340 Gray, Joe Ann Pittman, Dutton & Hellums 11dp23111
341 Morris, Patricia Pittman, Dutton & Hellums 11dp21187
342 Sullivan, Daniel E. Pittman, Dutton & Hellums 12dp20144
343 Voigt, Herman A. Pittman, Dutton & Hellums 12dp22822
Case: 1:10-md-02197-JJH Doc #: 1086 Filed: 10/11/16 17 of 24. PageID #: 11695
Appendix A
DEPUY ASRTM HIP SYSTEM CASES MDL No. 2197
18
No. Plaintiff Name Plaintiff's Firm MDL Case No.
344 Harbold, Donna for Hengst, Barry R. (dec'd) Pogust Braslow Millrood 12dp21642
345 White Buffalo, Deborah Pogust Braslow Millrood 12dp22865
346 Godfrey, Mary Popham Law Firm 12dp23132
347 Pettit, Michael Popham Law Firm 12dp22959
348 Diaz, Franklin Powers and Santola 13dp21365
349 McDaniel, Richard James Pritzker, Olsen 14dp20170
350 Pollar, Odette Pritzker, Olsen 14dp20392
351 Wilson, Becky Jo Pritzker, Olsen 12dp21720
352 Dobbs, Dustan Pro Per 12dp23143
353 Riddle, Robert Pro Per 11dp22817
354 Pfeifer, Gayle Reilly Pozner 12dp20645
355 Dodson, Steve Richardson Richardson Boudreaux 12dp20362
356 Kelley, Laurie for Kelley, John (dec'd) Richardson Richardson Boudreaux 12dp20362
357 Handy, Susan J. Richardson, Patrick, Westbrook & Brickman 15dp20109
358 Lundkovsky, Phillip K. Richardson, Patrick, Westbrook & Brickman 15dp20101
359 Burr, Gloria Ann Robins Kaplan Miller & Ciresi 13dp20320
360 Elston, Del Roy W. Robins Kaplan Miller & Ciresi 14dp20603
361 Geyer, Theodore R. Robins Kaplan Miller & Ciresi 12dp21732
362 Grice, Timothy Owen Robins Kaplan Miller & Ciresi 13dp20539
363 McCullough, Geneva L. Robins Kaplan Miller & Ciresi 13dp20252
364 Roberts, Cynthia G. Robins Kaplan Miller & Ciresi 14dp20339
365 Shackleton, Richard E. Robins Kaplan Miller & Ciresi 13dp20701
Case: 1:10-md-02197-JJH Doc #: 1086 Filed: 10/11/16 18 of 24. PageID #: 11696
Appendix A
DEPUY ASRTM HIP SYSTEM CASES MDL No. 2197
19
No. Plaintiff Name Plaintiff's Firm MDL Case No.
366 Van Sweden, Ronald Romano Law Group 14dp20262
367 Nelson, J.C. Saunders & Walker 11dp20754
368 Wilson, David Schlemmer & Maniatis 12dp22084
369 Eldridge, Pamela Schlesinger Law Offices 11dp21027
370 Adamich, Thomas Schwebel Goetz & Sieben 15dp20133
371 Allen, Renee Gayle Schwebel Goetz & Sieben 12dp23665
372 Berg, Janice Arlene Schwebel Goetz & Sieben 12dp23186
373 Dorholt, Karen Schwebel Goetz & Sieben 12dp23674
374 Faust, Janice Schwebel Goetz & Sieben 12dp23558
375 Fuller, Veronica Schwebel Goetz & Sieben 12dp23536
376 Haglund, Thomas Allen Schwebel Goetz & Sieben 12dp23549
377 Hicks, Sammy Schwebel Goetz & Sieben 14dp20032
378 Jaeck, Karen Louise Schwebel Goetz & Sieben 14dp20009
379 Johnson, Trever Thomas Schwebel Goetz & Sieben 12dp23593
380 Knochenmus, Lary Dean Schwebel Goetz & Sieben 14dp20010
381 Melville, Judith Lynn Schwebel Goetz & Sieben 12dp23390
382 Miller, Patricia Schwebel Goetz & Sieben 12dp23455
383 Monson, Sandra Joan Schwebel Goetz & Sieben 14dp20008
384 Navin, John Thomas Schwebel Goetz & Sieben 12dp23551
385 Nerby, Terry Jean Schwebel Goetz & Sieben 12dp23133
386 Stanek, Stephanie Andrea Schwebel Goetz & Sieben 12dp23582
387 Taylor, Karen Lydia Schwebel Goetz & Sieben 12dp23545
Case: 1:10-md-02197-JJH Doc #: 1086 Filed: 10/11/16 19 of 24. PageID #: 11697
Appendix A
DEPUY ASRTM HIP SYSTEM CASES MDL No. 2197
20
No. Plaintiff Name Plaintiff's Firm MDL Case No.
388 Wolff, Joan Marie Schwebel Goetz & Sieben 14dp20037
389 Blauweiss, Heather Searcy Denney Scarola 14dp20314
390 Focose, Jerome Searcy Denney Scarola 14dp20441
391 Parker, Mark Searcy Denney Scarola 15dp20114
392 Johnson, Ellis Daniel Seeger Weiss 11dp20206
393 Newman, Brenda M. Shields & Shields 11dp22277
394 Kirkham, Daned B. Showard Law Firm 14dp20574
395 Dougherty, John M. Sieben Grose Von Holtum 13dp20809
396 Kujat, Karen Simmons Browder Gianaris 11dp21699
397 Nicolini, John Simmons Browder Gianaris 14dp20616
398 Pangle, Paula Simmons Browder Gianaris 14dp20614
399 Visker, Tamara Simmons Browder Gianaris 14dp20615
400 Watson, Leola Simmons Browder Gianaris 12dp21410
401 Mellis, Mary Simon Law Firm 13dp20385
402 Davis, Michelle Skikos, Crawford, Skikos 14dp20260
403 McNerlin, Velma Skikos, Crawford, Skikos 11dp22901
404 Morrison, Hartwell Dick for Morrison, George Ann (dec'd)
Slack & Davis 12dp23114
405 Wilson, Grace Smith & Alspaugh, P.C. 12dp23870
406 Cappelli, Katherine Ann Sommers Schwartz 14dp20065
407 Simmerly, Carol E. Spangenberg, Shibley & Liber 12dp23743
408 Vick, Diane Spillman & Partners 13dp21485
Case: 1:10-md-02197-JJH Doc #: 1086 Filed: 10/11/16 20 of 24. PageID #: 11698
Appendix A
DEPUY ASRTM HIP SYSTEM CASES MDL No. 2197
21
No. Plaintiff Name Plaintiff's Firm MDL Case No.
409 McDaniel, Michael Steele Sturm 11dp20572
410 Velez, Maria Steven C. Rauchberg, P.C. 13dp21194
411 Purcell, Jean Emily Steven L. Beard 11dp22616
412 Pickard, Marvin Calhoun Stewart & Stewart 11dp20925
413 Casale, Marie A. Sugarman & Sugarman 14dp20067
414 Pross, Juliana Sullivan Papain Block 12dp21492
415 Aquino, Xavier Swartz & Swartz 13dp21338
416 Pulusila, Manuele Jr. Teal, Montgomery & Henderson 14dp20238
417 Bastable, Charles M. The Nations Law Firm 12dp22148
418 Gates, Patricia Ann The Nations Law Firm 12dp22593
419 Mutch, Alice Jane Neily The Nations Law Firm 13dp20386
420 Wagner, Louise E. The Nations Law Firm 12dp23014
421 Wilson, Donald Gordon The Nations Law Firm 12dp22138
422 Bruce C. Anderson as Representative of the Estate of Anderson, Howard C.
Tichenor & Dziuba 12dp20610
423 Bernal, Mario Tom Rhodes Law Firm 12dp20696
424 Dacey, George R. Tom Rhodes Law Firm 11dp22313
425 Palao, Abel D. Tom Rhodes Law Firm 12dp20093
426 Settles, Shelly Renee Tom Rhodes Law Firm 12dp21017
427 Steverson, Gerald Tom Rhodes Law Firm 12dp21044
428 Fitzgerald, Joseph George Tracey Law Firm 12dp21013
429 Smith, Ann Blythe Ury & Moskow 12dp20192
Case: 1:10-md-02197-JJH Doc #: 1086 Filed: 10/11/16 21 of 24. PageID #: 11699
Appendix A
DEPUY ASRTM HIP SYSTEM CASES MDL No. 2197
22
No. Plaintiff Name Plaintiff's Firm MDL Case No.
430 Torrans, Allen Dale Verhine & Verhine 11dp22294
431 Johnson, Regina Wagstaff & Cartmell 11dp21315
432 Zicarelli, Anthony Wagstaff & Cartmell 14dp20304
433 Lipson, Hyla Watkinson, Laird, Rubenstein, Baldwin & Burgress 14dp20044
434 Mares, Sally Watts Guerra 14dp20414
435 Martinez, Carolyn Watts Guerra 14dp20413
436 Burns, Stephanie Lynn Watts Guerra Craft 11dp22167
437 Henry, Larry Webster Law Firm 13dp20047
438 Carroll, Noreen Weisman Kennedy & Berris 14dp20189
439 DiFranco, Livia Weisman Kennedy & Berris 12dp21659
440 Neill, Andrew for Courtney, Suzanne (dec'd)
Weisman Kennedy & Berris 11dp20506
441 Shelly, Shirley Mae Weisman Kennedy & Berris 14dp20389
442 Alexander, Gordon Weitz & Luxenberg 14dp20283
443 Amesquita, Lorenzo R. Jr. Weitz & Luxenberg 14dp20259
444 Ball, Helen Weitz & Luxenberg 14dp20284
445 Buckner, Sarah Steelman for Steelman, Thomas Clay (dec'd)
Weitz & Luxenberg 11dp22247
446 Camp, William G. Weitz & Luxenberg 14dp20251
447 Cavaleri, Michelle Weitz & Luxenberg 13dp21011
448 Cotie, William B. Weitz & Luxenberg 14dp20563
449 Danley, Marilyn Weitz & Luxenberg 12dp23113
450 Diaz, Francisco Jr. Weitz & Luxenberg 15dp20068
Case: 1:10-md-02197-JJH Doc #: 1086 Filed: 10/11/16 22 of 24. PageID #: 11700
Appendix A
DEPUY ASRTM HIP SYSTEM CASES MDL No. 2197
23
No. Plaintiff Name Plaintiff's Firm MDL Case No.
451 Doman, Shirley M. Weitz & Luxenberg 14dp20232
452 Gonzalez, William A. Weitz & Luxenberg 13dp20961
453 Gould, Lars A. Weitz & Luxenberg 14dp20526
454 Hixson, Frederick P. Weitz & Luxenberg 14dp20135
455 Kilmer, James P. Weitz & Luxenberg 14dp20504
456 Kloepfer, George J. Weitz & Luxenberg 15dp20067
457 Matthews, Donald L. Weitz & Luxenberg 14dp20239
458 Murray, Geneva George Weitz & Luxenberg 12dp22927
459 Nichols, Lori Jean Weitz & Luxenberg 13dp20397
460 O’Connor, Marianne Weitz & Luxenberg 12dp21425
461 Peet, Charles Russell Weitz & Luxenberg 13dp21303
462 Peet, Michael A. Weitz & Luxenberg 15dp20064
463 Shirley, Drew E. Weitz & Luxenberg 13dp20954
464 Sims, Otis J. Jr. Weitz & Luxenberg 12dp21467
465 Skaug, DeAnn J. Weitz & Luxenberg 11dp22651
466 Takeshita, Yoshiko Weitz & Luxenberg 14dp20478
467 Thomas, Susan H. Weitz & Luxenberg 11dp22856
468 Tomaselli, Thomas J. Weitz & Luxenberg 13dp21016
469 Vincent, Eugene Weitz & Luxenberg 11dp21457
470 Wildermuth, David L. Sr. Weitz & Luxenberg 12dp23329
471 Williams, Carol Weitz & Luxenberg 12dp23330
472 Williams, Christopher E. Weitz & Luxenberg 13dp21065
Case: 1:10-md-02197-JJH Doc #: 1086 Filed: 10/11/16 23 of 24. PageID #: 11701
Appendix A
DEPUY ASRTM HIP SYSTEM CASES MDL No. 2197
24
No. Plaintiff Name Plaintiff's Firm MDL Case No.
473 Williams, James E. Jr. Weitz & Luxenberg 12dp22902
474 Winsor, George E. Jr. Weitz & Luxenberg 14dp20480
475 Gentile, Michelle A. Wetherall Group Ltd 13dp21143
476 Fudge, Andrew M. William J. Faubion 12dp23796
477 Ehrmantraut, Edward A. Williams Cuker Berezofsky 15dp20003
478 Fragnito, Diane M. Williams Cuker Berezofsky 11dp21213
479 Searfoss, Victor L. Williams Cuker Berezofsky 15dp20115
480 Gerez, Constance Wright & Schulte 13dp21286
481 Hinkebein, Donald Wright & Schulte 14dp20573
482 Thibodaux, Michael Sr. Young, Richaud & Myers 13dp20278
483 Colbert, John H. Zimmerman Reed 12dp21259
484 Marsden, Mary Zimmerman Reed 13dp21197
485 Anderson, Philip Zoll, Kranz & Borgess 14dp20539
486 Holloway, Robert W. Zoll, Kranz & Borgess 13dp20693
487 Kalenderian, Rosemary Zoll, Kranz & Borgess 13dp21325
488 Musbach, James Zoll, Kranz & Borgess 13dp20983
Case: 1:10-md-02197-JJH Doc #: 1086 Filed: 10/11/16 24 of 24. PageID #: 11702
