Global Group 4 – Conventional Facilities and Siting 10.26.05V. Kuchler1 of 17 Fermilab R&D Meeting Fermilab R&D Meeting Vic Kuchler Conventional Facilities

Global Group 4 – Conventional Facilities and Global Group 4 – Conventional Facilities and SitingSiting

10.26.05 V. Kuchler 1 of 17

Fermilab R&D MeetingFermilab R&D MeetingVic KuchlerVic Kuchler

Conventional Facilities Conventional Facilities UpdateUpdate

October 26, 2005October 26, 2005

Milestone One: Snowmass 2005 ConferenceMilestone One: Snowmass 2005 Conference

Successfully Initiate the Global Conventional Facilities Successfully Initiate the Global Conventional Facilities and Siting Effort and Complete the Comparative and Siting Effort and Complete the Comparative Site Assessment Matrix FormatSite Assessment Matrix Format

Milestone Two: December, 2005Milestone Two: December, 2005

Identify Regional Sample Sites for Inclusion into the Identify Regional Sample Sites for Inclusion into the Baseline Configuration DocumentBaseline Configuration Document

Milestone Three: December, 2006Milestone Three: December, 2006

Complete Conventional Facilities and Siting Portion of Complete Conventional Facilities and Siting Portion of the Reference Design Documentthe Reference Design Document

10.26.05 V. Kuchler 2 of 17


Organizational OverviewOrganizational Overview

• With the Establishment of the Global Design Effort (GDE), With the Establishment of the Global Design Effort (GDE), Work on the ILC has been Organized into Seven Working Work on the ILC has been Organized into Seven Working Groups and Six Global GroupsGroups and Six Global Groups

• Each Individual Group has a Designated Representative Each Individual Group has a Designated Representative from Each of the Three Regions, Asian Region, European from Each of the Three Regions, Asian Region, European Region and the Americas RegionRegion and the Americas Region

• Global Group 4 is the Conventional Facilities and Siting Global Group 4 is the Conventional Facilities and Siting Group Represented by:Group Represented by:

Atsushi Enomoto – Asian RegionAtsushi Enomoto – Asian Region

Jean-Luc Baldy – European RegionJean-Luc Baldy – European Region

Vic Kuchler – Americas RegionVic Kuchler – Americas Region10.26.05 V. Kuchler 3 of 17


Global Group 4 Goals Developed at SnowmassGlobal Group 4 Goals Developed at Snowmass• Review, Discuss and Amend the Site Assessment Matrix into a Review, Discuss and Amend the Site Assessment Matrix into a Final Working DocumentFinal Working Document

• Agree Upon and Regular Means of Communication for the Agree Upon and Regular Means of Communication for the Conventional Facilities and Siting WorkConventional Facilities and Siting Work

• Identify Points of Contact with Each Working and Global Group as Identify Points of Contact with Each Working and Global Group as NeededNeeded

• Determine a Working Schedule for Completion of Baseline Determine a Working Schedule for Completion of Baseline Configuration Document (BCD - Dec 2005) and Reference Design Configuration Document (BCD - Dec 2005) and Reference Design Document (RDR – Dec 2006)Document (RDR – Dec 2006)

• Discuss Website and Document Management System for the Discuss Website and Document Management System for the Control of CFS InformationControl of CFS Information

• Determine Format for CFS Portion of the BCDDetermine Format for CFS Portion of the BCD

10.26.05 V. Kuchler 4 of 17


Progress To DateProgress To Date

• The Site Assessment Matrix has been Established and is The Site Assessment Matrix has been Established and is Currently Being Used by all Regions to Identify a Regional Currently Being Used by all Regions to Identify a Regional Sample Site for the Baseline Configuration DocumentSample Site for the Baseline Configuration Document

• A Regular Video Conference has been Established Between A Regular Video Conference has been Established Between All Three Regions to Coordinate the Conventional All Three Regions to Coordinate the Conventional

Facilities and Siting WorkFacilities and Siting Work

• Points of Contact have been Identified with Each of the Points of Contact have been Identified with Each of the Working/Global GroupsWorking/Global Groups

• The Schedule and Format for the Baseline Configuration The Schedule and Format for the Baseline Configuration Document as well as the Website Conventions have Document as well as the Website Conventions have been/will been/will be Established by the GDE for all Working and be Established by the GDE for all Working and Global Global GroupsGroups

10.26.05 V. Kuchler 5 of 17


Working Group Points of ContactWorking Group Points of ContactWG 1 – Low Emittance Transport Beam DynamicsWG 1 – Low Emittance Transport Beam Dynamics

Daniel Schulte (CERN) - Daniel Schulte (CERN) - Jean-Luc Baldy (CERN)Jean-Luc Baldy (CERN)WG 2 – Linac DesignWG 2 – Linac Design

Hitoshi Hayano (KEK) - Hitoshi Hayano (KEK) - Atsushi Enomoto (KEK)Atsushi Enomoto (KEK)WG 3A – SourcesWG 3A – Sources

John Shepard (SLAC) - John Shepard (SLAC) - Vic Kuchler (FNAL)Vic Kuchler (FNAL)WG 3B – Damping RingsWG 3B – Damping Rings

Andy Wolski (LBNL) - Andy Wolski (LBNL) - Tom Lackowski (FNAL)Tom Lackowski (FNAL)WG 4 – Beam Delivery SystemWG 4 – Beam Delivery System

Andrei Seryi (SLAC) - Andrei Seryi (SLAC) - Fred Asiri (SLAC)Fred Asiri (SLAC)WG 5 – Superconducting Cavities and CouplersWG 5 – Superconducting Cavities and Couplers

No Point of Contact at this TimeNo Point of Contact at this TimeWG 6 – CommunicationsWG 6 – Communications

Judy Jackson (FNAL) - Judy Jackson (FNAL) - Vic Kuchler (FNAL)Vic Kuchler (FNAL)

10.26.05 V. Kuchler 6 of 17


Global Group Points of ContactGlobal Group Points of Contact

GG 1 – ParametersGG 1 – ParametersKaoru Yokoya (KEK) - Kaoru Yokoya (KEK) - Atsushi Enomoto (KEK)Atsushi Enomoto (KEK)Nick Walker (DESY) - Nick Walker (DESY) - Jean-Luc Baldy (CERN)Jean-Luc Baldy (CERN)Tor Raubenheimer (SLAC) - Tor Raubenheimer (SLAC) - Fred Asiri (SLAC)Fred Asiri (SLAC)

GG 2 – Instrumentation and ControlsGG 2 – Instrumentation and ControlsNo Point of Contact at this TimeNo Point of Contact at this Time

GG 3 – Operations and AvailabilityGG 3 – Operations and AvailabilityTom Himel (SLAC) - Tom Himel (SLAC) - Emil Huedem (FNAL)Emil Huedem (FNAL)

GG 5 – Cost and EngineeringGG 5 – Cost and EngineeringTetsuo Shidara (KEK) - Tetsuo Shidara (KEK) - Atsushi Enomoto (KEK)Atsushi Enomoto (KEK)Wilhelm Bialowons (DESY) - Wilhelm Bialowons (DESY) - Jean-Luc Baldy (CERN)Jean-Luc Baldy (CERN)Peter Garbincius (FNAL) - Peter Garbincius (FNAL) - Tom Lackowski (FNAL)Tom Lackowski (FNAL)

GG 6 – Physics OptionsGG 6 – Physics OptionsNo Point of Contact at this TimeNo Point of Contact at this Time

10.26.05 V. Kuchler 7 of 17


Moving Toward the Sample SitesMoving Toward the Sample Sites

• Each Region is Reviewing Various Candidate Sites Using the Each Region is Reviewing Various Candidate Sites Using the Site Assessment Matrix as a Tool to Eventually Identify Site Assessment Matrix as a Tool to Eventually Identify

Each Each Regional Sample Site for Inclusion into the BCDRegional Sample Site for Inclusion into the BCD

• The Matrix is Divided into 9 Major Headings with 99 Individual The Matrix is Divided into 9 Major Headings with 99 Individual Items of AssessmentItems of Assessment

• Sample Site Selection Will Necessarily Include a Degree of Sample Site Selection Will Necessarily Include a Degree of Judgment and Subjectivity as part of the AnalysisJudgment and Subjectivity as part of the Analysis

• The Asian Region is Currently Reviewing 4-5 Candidate SitesThe Asian Region is Currently Reviewing 4-5 Candidate Sites

• The European Region is Currently Reviewing 2 Candidate SitesThe European Region is Currently Reviewing 2 Candidate Sites

• The Americas Region is Currently Reviewing 5 Candidate SitesThe Americas Region is Currently Reviewing 5 Candidate Sites

10.26.05 V. Kuchler 8 of 17


Site Assessment Matrix Major HeadingsSite Assessment Matrix Major Headings

1.1. Site Impacts on Critical Science parametersSite Impacts on Critical Science parameters

2.2. Scientific/Institutional support BaseScientific/Institutional support Base

3.3. Land AcquisitionLand Acquisition

4.4. Environmental impactsEnvironmental impacts

5.5. Construction Cost ImpactsConstruction Cost Impacts

6.6. Operational Cost ImpactsOperational Cost Impacts

7.7. Environment, Safety and Health IssuesEnvironment, Safety and Health Issues

8.8. Regional Support InfrastructureRegional Support Infrastructure

9.9. Risk FactorsRisk Factors10.26.05 V. Kuchler 9 of 17


10.26.05 V. Kuchler 10 of 17


Cut and Cover (Near Surface) Sites – Site ACut and Cover (Near Surface) Sites – Site A

10.26.05 V. Kuchler 11 of 17


Cut and Cover (Near Surface) Sites – Site ECut and Cover (Near Surface) Sites – Site E

10.26.05 V. Kuchler 12 of 17


Cut and Cover Site ConsiderationsCut and Cover Site Considerations• Perceived to be Less Expensive but this has not been Clearly Perceived to be Less Expensive but this has not been Clearly Demonstrated by Work to DateDemonstrated by Work to Date

• Neither Site has Uniform Depth for Excavation Which Precludes Neither Site has Uniform Depth for Excavation Which Precludes Saving from Uniform Construction MethodsSaving from Uniform Construction Methods

• Neither Earth Curved or Laser Straight Alignment Show Any Neither Earth Curved or Laser Straight Alignment Show Any Advantage and Both Could Be ProblematicAdvantage and Both Could Be Problematic

• Surface Disruption and Surface Building Presence is Extensive Surface Disruption and Surface Building Presence is Extensive with Respect to Roadways, Drainage Patterns, Rail Lines, Utility with Respect to Roadways, Drainage Patterns, Rail Lines, Utility Corridors, Current Land Usage, Berms, etc.Corridors, Current Land Usage, Berms, etc.

• Requires Extensive Land AcquisitionRequires Extensive Land Acquisition

• May Not be Environmentally ViableMay Not be Environmentally Viable

• Precludes an Alignment Centered on the Fermilab SitePrecludes an Alignment Centered on the Fermilab Site10.26.05 V. Kuchler 13 of 17


Deep Tunnel Sites - Site ADeep Tunnel Sites - Site A

10.26.05 V. Kuchler 14 of 17


Deep Tunnel Sites - Site BDeep Tunnel Sites - Site B

10.26.05 V. Kuchler 15 of 17


Deep Tunnel Site ConsiderationsDeep Tunnel Site Considerations

• Uniform Construction Methods Can Be Used Throughout Uniform Construction Methods Can Be Used Throughout the Projectthe Project

• Both Earth Curved or Laser Straight Alignments Could Be Both Earth Curved or Laser Straight Alignments Could Be AccommodatedAccommodated

• Surface Disruption and Land Acquisition are Minimized Surface Disruption and Land Acquisition are Minimized Compared to a Cut and Cover SolutionCompared to a Cut and Cover Solution

• A Deep Tunnel Configuration is Less Susceptible to Surface A Deep Tunnel Configuration is Less Susceptible to Surface Background Noise and Ground MotionBackground Noise and Ground Motion

• Relatively Uniform Environmental ImpactRelatively Uniform Environmental Impact

• Could Readily Take Advantage of Existing Fermilab Site Could Readily Take Advantage of Existing Fermilab Site With Respect to Land and InfrastructureWith Respect to Land and Infrastructure

10.26.05 V. Kuchler 16 of 17


Near-Term ScheduleNear-Term Schedule

• 11.4.05 – Draft BCD Documentation Due11.4.05 – Draft BCD Documentation Due

• 12.7/9.05 – GDE Meeting at INFN, Frascati, Italy with 12.7/9.05 – GDE Meeting at INFN, Frascati, Italy with Regional Sample Sites IdentifiedRegional Sample Sites Identified

• BCD Accepted as Baseline and Configuration Management BCD Accepted as Baseline and Configuration Management System is in PlaceSystem is in Place

• 1.06 – Begin Work on Reference Design Report1.06 – Begin Work on Reference Design Report

• 3.06 – GDE Meeting in Bangalore, India3.06 – GDE Meeting in Bangalore, India

• Continue Working to Complete RDRContinue Working to Complete RDR

• 12.06 – Reference Design Document Complete12.06 – Reference Design Document Complete

10.26.05 V. Kuchler 17 of 17


Documents

Global Group 4 – Conventional Facilities and Siting 10.26.05V. Kuchler1 of 17 Fermilab R&D Meeting Fermilab R&D Meeting Vic Kuchler Conventional Facilities