21
1 Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and Karstification Analysis to the Definition of Quarry Faces Evolution and Restoration Policy Tahar ALOUI 1 and Fredj CHAABANI Laboratory of Mineral Resources and Environment. Department of Geology. Faculty of Mathematical, Physical and Natural Sciences. University Campus, 1060 - Tunis, Tunisia. Abstract The physical properties of the bedrock influence widely the spatiotemporal evolution of the quarry faces, the exploitation, the productivity of the quarry as well as the type of the ultimate rehabilitation. In this study, we propose a new method based on the statistical study of the fracture - karstification couple of the bedrock, to initiate a harmonious exploitation which simultaneously gathers the investor, the natural environment and the local community. It does not only avoid the zones affected by fracture and karstification phenomena, but also adapts a long-term planning policy in order to benefit from the natural bedrock state, minimize the cost of extraction and the risk of eventual loss of high-quality materials. Furthermore, the environmental works should be managed at the rate of the exploitation in order to reduce the consecutive harmful effects of the excavation and to better integrate the site in its local socio-economic context. Keywords: fracture; karstification; quarry restoration; landfill 1 e-mail : [email protected]

Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and ...alonet.yolasite.com/resources/master/SMG_aloui_paper.pdf · Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and Karstification Analysis to

  • Upload
    lymien

  • View
    213

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and ...alonet.yolasite.com/resources/master/SMG_aloui_paper.pdf · Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and Karstification Analysis to

1

Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and Karstification Analysis to the Definition of

Quarry Faces Evolution and Restoration Policy

Tahar ALOUI 1 and Fredj CHAABANI

Laboratory of Mineral Resources and Environment.

Department of Geology. Faculty of Mathematical, Physical and Natural Sciences. University

Campus, 1060 - Tunis, Tunisia.

Abstract

The physical properties of the bedrock influence widely the spatiotemporal evolution of

the quarry faces, the exploitation, the productivity of the quarry as well as the type of the

ultimate rehabilitation. In this study, we propose a new method based on the statistical study

of the fracture - karstification couple of the bedrock, to initiate a harmonious exploitation

which simultaneously gathers the investor, the natural environment and the local community.

It does not only avoid the zones affected by fracture and karstification phenomena, but also

adapts a long-term planning policy in order to benefit from the natural bedrock state,

minimize the cost of extraction and the risk of eventual loss of high-quality materials.

Furthermore, the environmental works should be managed at the rate of the exploitation in

order to reduce the consecutive harmful effects of the excavation and to better integrate the

site in its local socio-economic context.

Keywords: fracture; karstification; quarry restoration; landfill

1 e-mail : [email protected]

Page 2: Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and ...alonet.yolasite.com/resources/master/SMG_aloui_paper.pdf · Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and Karstification Analysis to

2

1. Introduction

Since 1986, the beginning of the first industrial quarry, several specialized factories in

mineral industry have been established along Jebel Feriana (Fig.1). They have exploited

extra-white limestones of late cretaceous age for varied ends: dimension stone, white cement,

glass manufacturing, painting materials and pharmaceutical products. Both surface and deep

observations affirm that limestones are far from the homogeneity foreseen by anterior

geological exploration (Burollet et al., 1954; Trabelssi, 1989). During his study of the

irregularity of a clinker based on the limestones of Jebel Feriana, Sadran G. (1988) had the

merit of evoking, for the first time, the heterogeneity of the raw material itself. Indeed, the

envisaged limestones do exist, but they are often karstified and contain various impurities

limiting their use. The exploiter attenuates these difficulties by discarding more materials

which may be of good quality and by reorienting the phases that were foreseen by the initial

exploitation plan.

Although this approach satisfies national and international requirements in terms of

quantity, the hazard to the environment is still significant and the quality of the quarrying

operations remains to be improved. Throughout the present paper, we propose a model based

on the statistical study of the fracturation - karstification couple of the rock to initiate a

harmonious exploitation which gathers, at the same time, the stakeholders (investors, local

community...) and the natural environment requirements.

Fig. 1. Geographical situation of the study area

0 250 500 m

Tunis

Sfax

ALG

ERIA

L I BYA 35°

36°

34°

10°9°

FERIANA

0 100 km

124000124500125000

124000124500125000

115500116000

116500TUNISIA

Page 3: Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and ...alonet.yolasite.com/resources/master/SMG_aloui_paper.pdf · Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and Karstification Analysis to

3

2. Methodology

The study site was subdivided into elementary stations or measuring sites with square

mesh (Si). Each station is defined by the Universal Transverse Mercator (UTM) of one of its

diagonals. The identification of various families of fractures and the determination of their

geometric and spacial characteristics are based on the data acquisition by the Systematic

Linear Mapping Method (SLMM) along the measuring site (Si). This technique, which was

recommended throughout this work, enables us to get quantitative and qualitative information

that will be evaluated statistically. The visualization of the data on stereograms seems to be a

rather delicate process. If we suppose that the measuring surface is planar and the fractures

are vertical to subvertical, the recourse to rose diagram allows a satisfactory visual

appreciation of the directional data. A diagram briefly summarizes the main steps of the

procedure appears as Figure 2.

Fig. 2. Descriptive diagram showing main stages of the model

2.1. Statistical analysis of fractures

Statistical analysis of fracturation aims to identify quantitatively and qualitatively the

zones of great intensity of fractures. The observations carried out on the terrain and supported

by a mining method enabled us to highlight the particular importance of certain descriptors in

the dynamics of the faces as: direction, overlap, connectivity, openness, depth, slope and

length of fractures (Fig. 3).

Si Identification of the elementary measuring stations

Identification of directional classes

Checking of the model

D1, D2 … Dn’ n’≤n

Useful descriptors

Mapping

Identification of useful descriptors

n=0 or n’→n

- Morphology - Slop - Surface - Access conditions - Lithology - …

Study area

- Aerial photography - Visits on the terrain - Geological radar - Vertical walls - …

Systematic descriptors

D1, D2 … Dn

Model

Reconstituted phenomenon

Yes No

Optimization of the exploitation

Page 4: Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and ...alonet.yolasite.com/resources/master/SMG_aloui_paper.pdf · Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and Karstification Analysis to

4

Fig. 3. Conceptual model of fractured limestone showing studied descriptors

The quantitative study was achieved by representing in angular coordinates the frequency

(ƒ) of each directional class in the measuring site (Si). In contrast, the qualitative study tends

to classify fractures according to their impact on the exploitation. In addition to lithology,

only openness (o) and spacing (e) descriptors have a critical influence on quarrying

operations, that’s why they are considered in the model. Other parameters as (α) and (l), are

ignored because they are relatively constant on the scale of the measuring site (Si). The

compilation of these statistical indicators must define the dominant directional classes of the

fractures to be able to influence exploitation and safety.

2.2. Statistical analysis of karstification

Statistical analysis of karstification consists in the follow-up of the three-dimensional

behavior of the karstification generated by each fracture. This study is based on the results of

the statistical analysis of fracturing, vertical quarry walls and direct observations. Its final

goal is not only the identification of the fractures with high potential of karstification but also

the proposal of a karstification model of the site.

3. Description of the study area

The technique announced above was applied in the establishment of the exploitation plan

of Maastrichtian limestones of Abiod Formation (Burollet, 1956; M’Rabet et al., 1986; Saadi,

1991; Negra, 1994; M’ Rabet, 1996; El Euchi H. 1993) located at Jebel Feriana (Fig. 3).

Typically, those limestones are 150 m thick, sealed by the El Haria shales of the Upper

Maastrichtian and Palaeocene and their equivalents. They are organised in two bars separated

by grey-to-blue marls with intercalations of decimetric limestone beds member which is

missing only in Jebel Feriana (Negra, 1994; Aloui, 1999). Because of their high whiteness

p

l

e

o

r

α

e : spacing r : overlap l : length p : depth α : inclination o : openness

Page 5: Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and ...alonet.yolasite.com/resources/master/SMG_aloui_paper.pdf · Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and Karstification Analysis to

5

(Trabelssi, 1989; Kchouk, 1995; Aloui, 1999), this resource has widespread uses including

paper, painting as well as white cement manufacturing and tiling.

The measurement taken on the field and supported by aerial photographs show that Jebel

Feriana is a dissymmetrical conical fold with an axial plan E-W, a steep north flank and a

gently sloping south flank. Its total length is approximately 4 km and its openness is about 3°.

The weakest inclinations were observed in the deep fold at the level of Choubet Ettarf and

Choubet Si Ali (5 to 8°). The highest inclination is observed in the periphery. Indeed, it is of

20 to 25° on the northern flank and of 10 to 15° on the southern flank (Aloui, 1999).

4. Results and discussion

On the surface, the limestones are relatively karstic. The paleokarstic forms are in various

stages of lapiezation. These forms result from a progressive dissolution of the carbonate beds

during wet seasons. Some karstic forms have undergone a filling formed mainly of reddish

residual clay. The closed depressions of low altitude are sometimes filled by terra rossa soil

type.

In depth, the observations of the quarry faces highlight a significant network of

subvertical and parallel veins with inter-bed plans. The parallel ones are frequent in hard and

soft limestone alternations of the summit part of the Abiod Formation (Fig. 4).

At this stage, the variation of permeability involves a preferential infiltration of water in

depth. Indeed, in rainy weather, water follows the surface of the hard carbonated levels, its

speed of percolation decreases, the time of contact with the rock increases and the dissolution

of subjacent soft limestones becomes clearly marked (Aloui, 1999). The karstic vacuums are

approximately 20 cm in diameter, filled with rust clay and sometimes it is easy to observe a

thin film of calcite deposits in cavities and small faults.

Special care should be taken when drilling, blasting and detonating explosives for

breaking rock. Infact, during the loading of mines, the explosive accumulates in the karstic

pockets, which generates a bad distribution of the demolition energy; a raised blocometry

accompanied with a significant noise or even mine failures.

At the lower part of the Abiod Formation (Campanian pp.), the cavities are very often

localized and vertically lengthened with a more important diameter than that on the upper

part. The apogee of the karstification phenomenon is located approximately at 25 m depth.

The scarcity of silicification and dolomitization process indicates that the karstic vacuum

was not filled with stagnant and reduced water, but corresponds probably to percolation

zones. Under the electron microscope, these limestones are made up mainly of geared and

subhedral grains of micrite with a size varying between 5 and 10 µm. Inspite of the partial

Page 6: Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and ...alonet.yolasite.com/resources/master/SMG_aloui_paper.pdf · Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and Karstification Analysis to

6

cementation by sparite, the resulting porosity is that of an open channel-type (Negra, 1994),

which is very favorable for the installation of the karstification process (Aloui, 1999).

Fig. 4. Synthetic lithostratigraphic column of Jebel Feriana

In addition to the inclination of the layers, morphology and lithology of the rock, the

fractures exert a mere control over the definition of the karstic style in the area. The majority

of the mapped fractures presents free extemities (weak connectivity) and generally crosses the

totality of the Abiod Formation. The stratification is often blurred and when it is well

individualized, particularly in the upper part of the Formation, the plans of stratification are

increasingly tightened and the fractures are well highlighted. With the exception of the

measurements carried out in the vicinity of the deep northern side where the inclinations are

close to 30° S and rarely 60° S, the inclinations are subvertical to vertical. In general, the

fracture network is well developed in the vicinity of the hinge of the anticline. The vertical

observation of the quarry faces does not show any significant variation in the density of

fracturing with the depth.

Littostratigraphic log Formations Age

AB

IOD

A

LEG

Cam

panian to Maastrichtian

Santonian C

oniacian

Decimetric alternations of crystalline limestone and rather hard yellowish limestone with flint at the top

Saccharoid chalky white limestone with blurred stratification intercalating some metric siliceous limestone passages at the top

Soft limestones with nodulous appearance

Beige to white massive limestone

Alternations of beige to yellows deposits of bioclastic limestone and grey marls

0

50 m

25 Marno-limestone alternations

Page 7: Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and ...alonet.yolasite.com/resources/master/SMG_aloui_paper.pdf · Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and Karstification Analysis to

7

4.1. Contribution of the statistical analysis of the fractures

The experiment shows that the harmful effect which the spacing (e) can carry to the

exploitation grows with 1/e ratio, and that the critical value of spacing between two fractures

belonging to the same directional class of the station (Si) is often lower than the length of the

bench (Aloui, 1999). This critical value can generate hazardous effects for the exploitation

only under the effect of reducing the spacing. The observation of the evolution of some quarry

faces located on the left bank of the Wadi Errachih proves that the critical value - for which

openness can generate harmful effects to the exploitation only when (o) increases - is about

0.5 cm.

From surface and underground mapping in mines and quarry faces in Jebel Feriana, the

quantitative study (Fig. 5) of the fractures identified various styles and structural elements in

the area.

Fig. 5. Frequency distribution of the directional classes

The network of fractures comprising five classes of dominant direction was highlighted:

- the class NS is frequent in the vicinity of the Wadi Errachih, Choubet Ettarf and Choubet Si

Ali. They are fractures of weak openness (Fig. 6) and spacing (Fig. 7);

124000124500125000

124000124500125000

115500116000

116500

115500116000

116500

10

20

30 0

90

180

270

10

20

30 0

90

180

270

10

20

30

90

180

270 10

20

30

180

10

20

30 0

90

180

270 10

20

30 0

90

180

18

20

30 0

180

0 250 500 m

10

20

30 0

10

20

30 0

90

Page 8: Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and ...alonet.yolasite.com/resources/master/SMG_aloui_paper.pdf · Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and Karstification Analysis to

8

- the class N45 constitutes a secondary network of fracturing with weak frequency and which

appears in the axial zone of the anticline between the Wadi Errachih and Choubet Ettarf.

Those accidents are very isolated with slightly developed openness;

- the class N60 is frequent in the zone where concavity of the anticline axis changes. It is

characterized by weak spacing and openness;

- the class N90 is frequent in the axial zone. Those accidents have weak spacing and variable

openness often important southward;

- the class N130 constitutes a network of fractures very frequent in the massifs of the region

and the tertiary deposits of Maamoura synclinal. It is probably the relatively recent network

fractures. Its genesis seems to be irrelated to the local conditions of Jebel Feriana (Aloui,

1999).

Fig. 6. Aperture distribution according to the directional classes

124000124500125000

124000124500125000

115500116000

116500

115500116000

116500

10

20

30 0

90

180

270

10

20

300

10

20

300

90

180

10

20

30 0

90

180

270

10

20

30

90

180

10

20

300

90

10

20

30 0

180

0 250 500 m

10

20

30

90

180

10

20

30 0

180

Page 9: Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and ...alonet.yolasite.com/resources/master/SMG_aloui_paper.pdf · Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and Karstification Analysis to

9

Fig. 7. Reverse of the spacing distribution according to the directional classes

4.2. Contribution of the statistical analysis of the karstification

Karsts result from water circulation and its aggressive chemical and physical action in

cracks, joints and fractures along the layers of limestone over time. In few situations where it

is not possible or appropriate to recover the variation of the volume of dissolved limestones,

non-destructive cores were used. They show that the karstification phenomenon is

approximately 25 m in depth (Fig. 8).

The appreciation of the karstification state of the bedrock was deduced from the definition

of the karstification index (IK). For a single fracture network, IK is proportional to openness

and fracturing intensity that could be estimated as follows:

Ik=o.If (1)

in which (o) represents the average openness and (If) a term describing the characteristic

fracturing of the site. Here, we suppose - for simplicity - that the constant of proportionality is

equal to 1. In the particular case of a site with a surface (s), made of (nC) beds and including

(n) fractures which are spaced by (e) meters and have the same direction, this term can be

defined by the following relation:

124000124500125000

124000124500125000

115500 116000

116500

115500 116000

116500

0 250 500 m

0.01

0.02

0.03

90

180

0.01

0.02

0.03

90

180

0.01

0.02

0.03 0

90

180

0.01

0.02

0.03 0

90

180

0.01

0.02

0.030

90

180

0.01

0.02

0.03 0

90

180

270

0.01

0.02

0.030

90 0.01

0.02

0.030

0.01

0.02

0.03

90

180

270

Page 10: Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and ...alonet.yolasite.com/resources/master/SMG_aloui_paper.pdf · Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and Karstification Analysis to

10

If s.en.n C= (2)

After replacing the term (If) in the initial equation we get:

IKs.e

n.n. Co= (3)

The case of a simple site, in which fractures are mono-directional, seems to be rare. In

fact, the network of fractures is often extremely complex. The fractures are often poly-

directional. Each directional class is characterized by its relative frequency in the network, its

openness and its average spacing. In the same way, one or more networks interfere with each

other and contribute to increased fracture intensity. On the scale of the study area, the

observations of surface, as well as those of undersurface, affirm that karstification seems to be

a localized phenomenon and the intensity of fracturing is mainly generated by the cumulative

effect of each directional class in the measuring site. This simple procedure allows us to

estimate roughly the karstification intensity at Jebel Feriana by the following model:

i

j

1=i i

ic o e

s

n= ∑

fkI (4)

Where s : measuring surface or station expressed in km2 ƒ : frequency of the directional class in the measuring station

nc number of beds in the directional classes ei : average spacing of the directional ith class expressed in meter oi : average openness of the directional ith class expressed in meter i : positive integer between 1 and j [ 1, j ] j : positive integer indicating the number of directional classes

4.3. Generalization of the model

Not only can a mathematical model as i

j

1=i i

ic o e

s

n= ∑

fkI

be adjusted with the statistical

data of fractures in the vicinity of Jebel Feriana, but it is also probable that a model based on

the same observations could be applied to other localities. In this concern, we are led to adjust

the data with a simple model in which the following considerations were taken:

- the sampling must be representative and likely to give a non-deformed or reduced image of

the site from which it was carried out;

- the descriptors of IK present the same probability of being raised and implied in the

development of the karstification phenomenon.

Page 11: Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and ...alonet.yolasite.com/resources/master/SMG_aloui_paper.pdf · Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and Karstification Analysis to

11

Actually, no natural site corresponds to the plain scheme considered previously.

According to his experience, the exploiter should adjust this model to adapt it conveniently

with his case of study.

Basing on the karstification index IK, it is possible to appreciate the karstification degree

according to table 1.

The fractures of direction N60 and N90 would probably be the major cause of the

karstification in Jebel Feriana whereas the fractures of direction N130 seem to have a local

effect. The karstified zones are slightly at the South flank and at the change of concavity of

the anticline axis.

Fig. 8. Block diagram outlining the fractures and karstification characteristics of Jebel Feriana

Table 1. Degree of karstification according to Ik

Ik [0 , 250] ]250 , 750] ]750 , 1500] ]1500 , 3000] ]3000 , +∞[ State Not karstified Slightly karstified Fairly karstified Enough karstified Very karstified

These results enabled us to envisage a selective exploitation in three working floors with

a 12-m high bench. The evolution of the faces should follow the direction of the dominant

fractures (Fig. 9) and the zones of weak karstification (Fig. 10).

Har

d lim

esto

nes

with

low

por

osity

S

oft l

imes

tone

s w

ith

high

por

osity

Karstic pocket

25 m

Depth (m)

Importance of karstification

Page 12: Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and ...alonet.yolasite.com/resources/master/SMG_aloui_paper.pdf · Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and Karstification Analysis to

12

Fig. 9. Distribution of the fracture network

Fig. 10. Distribution chart of karstification

0 250 500 m

Fracture network

N130

N90

N60

N45

NS

123850 124100124350124600124850125100 125350

123600 123850 124100124350124600124850125100 125350

115400115650

115900116400

116150116650

Slightly karstified

Bedrock state

Very karstified

Fairly karstified

Not karstified

Enough karstified

0 250 500 m

123850 124100124350124600124850125100 125350

123600 123850 124100124350124600124850125100 125350

115400115650

115900116400

116150116650

Page 13: Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and ...alonet.yolasite.com/resources/master/SMG_aloui_paper.pdf · Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and Karstification Analysis to

13

In this concern, it is preferable to carry out the extraction in three phases of a total

duration of about 45 years. A grid surface in 3D was computed to illustrate the dynamics of

the faces during the three production phases (Fig. 11).

4.4. Rehabilitation of places

Feriana town, located at 1 km of the studied site, was marked during these two last

decades by a fast development of urbanization under the triple effect of the economic growth,

the demographic increase and the change in consumption modes. This is accompanied by a

domestic and industrial solid waste with unceasingly varied growth (Table. 2).

Table 2. Evolution of the quantity of solid waste in tons (Municipality of Feriana)

Year 1986 1988 1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 Quantity (tons) 4329 4612 4957 5323 5723 6123 6623 7210 7708 8237

bi-annual 6.14 6.96 6.88 6.99 6.53 7.55 8.14 6.46 6.42 Increase (%) annual 3.07 3.48 3.44 3.49 3.27 3.77 4.07 3.23 3.21 3.33

Page 14: Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and ...alonet.yolasite.com/resources/master/SMG_aloui_paper.pdf · Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and Karstification Analysis to

14

Phase 1

Current state of the quarry after 9 years after 12 years after 15 years Phase 2

after 23 years after 26 years after 29 years after 33 years

Phase 3

Insertion of the site in its new socio-economic context

after 38 years after 41 years after 45 years

Fig. 11. Evolution of the faces based on the statistical analyses of fractures and karstification

Page 15: Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and ...alonet.yolasite.com/resources/master/SMG_aloui_paper.pdf · Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and Karstification Analysis to

15

Their collection and treatment constitute a major concern for the local community.

Currently, their evacuation is made towards two great wild landfills established on the flood

plains of Wadi Saboun and Wadi Bou Haya (Fig. 12).

Fig. 12. Air sight showing the situation of the wild landfills and the industrial quarries

Deposited in the natural environment without precondition treatment, these solid wastes

may cause serious potential problems (like soil contamination, groundwater and surface

water) that may occur as leachate produced by water or liquid wastes. For this reason, we

believe it is interesting to re-use the consecutive space to the excavation as a controlled

landfill (Qasim et al., 1994).

Several audits of the waste characteristics arriving in the domestic and commercial

collection vehicles at Feriana town have been undertaken since 1997. The daily production of

waste per inhabitant is about 0.47 kg/capita/day. It is 0.5 kg in large Tunis, 0.75 kg in Sousse,

1 kg in Sfax and can reach 2.5 kg/capita/day in other communes as Sidi Bou Said (Souissi,

2000).

Out of dustbin and without being compressed, the specific mass (ρ) of wastes is about 32

kg/m3. From the composition perspective (Fig. 13), the wastes of Feriana town, like in most

Tunisian towns, are very often wet (the water content varies from 60 to 70%) and most of the

wet weight (65 to 70%) consists of organic matter (70%); paper accounts for 11% and plastic

approximately 7%.

1

2

3

Industrial quarries

Wild landfills

Feriana town

Bou Haya Wadi

Saboun Wadi

1

2

3

Page 16: Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and ...alonet.yolasite.com/resources/master/SMG_aloui_paper.pdf · Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and Karstification Analysis to

16

72.15

11.27

7.072.445.1 1.98

Organic matter paper Plastic matter

Alloys Glass Others

Fig. 13. Average composition of a representative dustbin of Feriana town during 2002

(Municipality of Feriana, 2002)

4.5. Lifespan of the landfill

The estimated quantity of waste poured by the commune of Feriana was deduced, based

on its high linear correlation (R2 = 0.989) with the time (t) expressed in years (Fig. 14).

qt = 219.42t - 431661 (5)

Fig. 14. Linear correlation between the quantity of solid waste and time

We assume that the projected growth rate per annum (Γ) between two years (i-1) and (i) in

the quantity of waste is given by the equation below:

100.q

q-qΓ

i

1-ii= (6)

4000

5000

6000

7000

8000

9000

1985 1990 1995 2000 2005

Time (year)

Qua

ntity

of w

aste

Qn

(tons

)

Page 17: Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and ...alonet.yolasite.com/resources/master/SMG_aloui_paper.pdf · Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and Karstification Analysis to

17

Where (Qi-1) and (Qi) are, respectively, the quantities of waste generated during the year (i-1)

and (i). Multiplying the equation (6) by (Γ

iq) and grouping (qi ) term, we get:

1-ii q.100

100qΓ−

= (7)

Note that each term after the first is found by multiplying the previous term by a fixed

number. Consequently, the quantity of solid waste describes a geometric sequence of common

ratio 1100

100r >Γ−

= and starting value Q0. By successive substitution applied to equation (7),

we easily get:

( ) 0i

0i

i q1.033=q.)100

100(=q

Γ- (8)

If we suppose that the excavation starts from the point of coordinates (124600, 116650)

and that the landfill is in use from year (n) and finishes at the end of year (n+d), n and d are

two natural numbers. The equation (8) can be written as follows: ndn

n q)033.1(q ++ =d , where

Qn (first term of the sequence) corresponds to the quantity of waste during the year in which

the landfill is in use and Qn+d (last term of the sequence) represents the quantity of solid waste

collected during year (n+d).

In order to optimize the stability of the slope, we suppose that the landfill will be

exhausted after a lifespan (d) which corresponds to the filling of T% of the excavated volume

v(m3). Here, the lifespan (d) indicates the number of years necessary so that the cumulated

quantity of solid waste between the (n) and (n+d) years takes the value (v.T). If we ignore the

contribution of the materials intended for the covering and the compaction effect, (d) must

check the subsequent relation:

∑=

+

d

1iinq=v.t (9)

or:

v.t = n

1+d

qr-1

r-1. (10)

from which we can conclude:

nn

1+d

.rqr).v.t-(1-1=r (11)

After the application of the log function to the two terms of the equation (11), we find:

Page 18: Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and ...alonet.yolasite.com/resources/master/SMG_aloui_paper.pdf · Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and Karstification Analysis to

18

).rq).v.tr -(1-log(1=1).log(r)(d n

n

+ (12)

The lifespan of the landfill expressed in terms of year could be estimated by equation (13):

1-)r log(

).rq

)r -(1v.t-log(1=d

nn

.

(13)

At an annual tonnage of excavated limestones of 200000 tons/year, we estimate that the

first phase will be spread out over a period of 15 years. It is highly recommended that the

excavation be planned with the intention of conserving and enhancing the quality of the area

for an ultimate use of the site. Besides, the operators should integrate environmental works

into all daily operations at the rhythm of the quarry faces in order to facilitate the

rehabilitation into a landfill.

Similarly, it would be beneficial to all partners (local authorities, elected officials,

operators, environmentalists …) to begin the handing over of the controlled landfill from the

end of the first phase of exploitation (Aloui, 1999). Ultimately, if we suppose that the density

of the rock is 2.1 tons/m3 and on the basis of the particular case:

v = 171 8646 m3 r = 1.033 T = 0.66 n = 2020 Γ= 3.43 Qn = 219.42n - 43 1661

The lifespan of the landfill will be about 15 years.

4.6. Alternative treatments and special considerations

The ceaseless progress of the transformation techniques and conditioning of materials

does not consider waste as garbage to be systematically eliminated, but as secondary raw

materials in order to be highly-valued to release surplus (Scholtz et al., 1994; Merchant et al.,

1995; Stessel, 1996; Nyamwange, 1996; Aloui 1999). Authorities can, also, encourage new

techniques and try to adapt them to their local context like waste reduction such as source,

resource recovery or differentiated collection (paper and cardboard, glass, plastic, aluminum,

durable goods and electronic devices, car batteries…). These alternative solutions should be

considered in priority (Alexander, 1996; Stessel, 1996; Calaminus et al., 1998).

Page 19: Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and ...alonet.yolasite.com/resources/master/SMG_aloui_paper.pdf · Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and Karstification Analysis to

19

The quantity of the buried waste must be controlled, road traffic ought to be harmonized

and access roads must be adequately maintained. However, special considerations should be

evoked:

- in order to combat the throwing of papers and plastic materials, a permanent and a mobile

barrier whose height ranges from 3 to 5 m should be placed perpendicular to the dominant

direction of the wind;

- traffic lanes should be filled by inert or recuperated materials in rainy weather. These

materials will be handy to the rolling facilities;

- the future landfill will be located at less than 1 km of the agglomeration, watering will

represent an adequate solution to control the emanation of dust in dry time;

- certain dangerous waste can be neutralized by lime or a coating in butine or plastic films

(Fig. 15).

- the final cover system must maximize surface water run-off and prevent its pending.

Fig. 15. Block diagram showing briefly the adjustment of the landfill and the treatment under

consideration for each type of solid waste

Front mask

Hazardous wastes neutralized by butine

Hazardous wastes neutralized by lime

Hazardous wastes in plastic sachets adapted

Impermeable cover

Impermeable clays and marls of the Aleg Formation

Karstic fill materials or marls of the Aleg Formation

Inert harmful wastes

Limestone of the Abiod Formation

Final cover

leachate collection system

Page 20: Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and ...alonet.yolasite.com/resources/master/SMG_aloui_paper.pdf · Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and Karstification Analysis to

20

5. Conclusions

The statistical analysis supported by observations on surface as well as in depth of the

fracturing-karstification couple, has enabled us to identify the networks of discontinuity and

to propose a model of karstification in Jebel Feriana. In the light of the compilation of these

results, a model of the quarry faces evolution is defined. This formalism is too simplistic to

allow the development of models other than those necessary to guide the exploitation of

limestones in the studied area and those similar to it. Nevertheless, this study has the merit to

show the role of the main parameters widely controlling the exploitation.

Considering the potential risk that the waste poured in non-made-up places can generate,

we propose to re-use the consecutive vacuum to excavation as controlled landfill. Such

restoration should constitute a capital priority in matters of local authorities, elected officials,

developers, and conservationists.

By taking into account of the quarry face evolution, the volume of the excavation and the

socio-economic development of Feriana town (waste generation rates per annum), a simple

mathematical model was developed to estimate the quantity of waste poured annually. This

model will evolve over time into a dynamic one, being able to estimate the lifespan of the

controlled landfill.

Actually, no natural site corresponds to the simplistic plan previously foreseen. According

to their experiences, the operators and their partners are led to adjust this method so as to

adapt it with its case of study.

Bibliography

Aloui T. (1999) - Les exploitations carbonatées et siliceuses au Jebel Feriana, Tunisie

centrale, 3rd cycle thesis, Fac. Sc. Tunis, 200p.

Burollet P.F., Dumestre A., Keppel D., Salvador A. (1954) - Unités stratigraphiques en

Tunisie centrale. C.R. 19th Inter. Cong. Geol., Alger, Algeria, Fasc. 21, pp. 243-254.

Burollet P.F. (1956) - Contribution à l’étude stratigraphique de la Tunisie centrale, Annales

des mines et de la géologie 18, La rapide, 345p.

Calaminus B., Stahlberg R. (1998) - Thermal Waste Treatment: a Better Approach

Chemtech 1998, October, pp40-46.

El Euchi H. (1993) - La Tunisie du Centre - ouest de l’Apten à l’Actuel : Tectonique

coulissante, dynamique sédimentaire associée et évolution du champ de contraintes moi-plio-

quaternaire, Doctoral thesis of 3rd cycle, Fac. Sc, Tunis, 237p.

Page 21: Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and ...alonet.yolasite.com/resources/master/SMG_aloui_paper.pdf · Contribution of Statistical Fracturation and Karstification Analysis to

21

Kchouk F. (1995) - Le ciment blanc tunisien, Bulletin des matériaux de construction 18-19,

CTMCCV, pp 25-51.

Gaied M.E (1996) - Etude géologique et géotechnique des matériaux utiles éocènes de la

bordure NE du paléorelief de Kasserine, Doctoral thesis of speciality, 200p.

Marchand G., Lavoie J. (1995) - Evaluation of Bioaerosols in a Municipal Solid Waste

Recycling and Composting Plant, L. Journal of the Air and Waste Management Association

1995, Vol. 45, October, pp778-781.

M’Rabet A., Negra H., Purser B.H., Sessi S. et Ben Ayed N. (1986) - Micrite diagenesis in

senonien rudist build-up in central Tunisia, in Purser B.H. & Schroeder J.H., Reef Diagenesis.

Springer, special Vol., pp 210-223.

Negra H. (1994) - Les dépôts de plate-forme à bassin du Crétacé supérieur en Tunisie centro-

septentrionale, Doctoral thesis, Vol. I et II, Fac. Sc. Tunis, 630p.

Nyamwange M. (1996) - Public Perception of Strategies for Increasing Participation in

Recycling Programs, The Journal of Environmental Education, 27(4), pp19-22.

Saadi F. (1996) - Sédimentologie, stratigraphie séquentielle et diagenèse carbonatée des

faciès du Crétacé supérieur de la région de Kasserine-Tamesmida, Doctoral thesis of 3rd

cycle, Fac. Sc. Tunis, 199p.

Scholtz M., Cassaday V., Patenaude L., Pratt, M. (1994) - An Assessment of the Impact of

Various Waste Management Strategies on Methane Emissions from Landfills in the Year

2000, M.Proc., Annu. Meet. - Air Waste Manage. Assoc. 1994, 87th (Vol.12, Solid Waste

Management), 11 pp. Paper 94-WP100.06.

Souissi A. (2000) - Plan bleu, Profil des pays méditerranéens, Tunisie : Enjeux et politiques

d’environnement et de développement durable Plan bleu, Ed. Sophia Antipolis, 70p.

Stessel R.I. (1996) - Conceptual Design of the Automated Collection/Processing Interface,

Journal of Solid Waste Technology and Management, 23(4), pp219-225.

Trabelssi H. (1989) - Les matériaux utiles de la région de Feriana : Cadre géologique et

potentialités, Doctoral thesis of 3rd cycle, University of Nice. 240p.

Qasim S.R., Chiang W. (1994) - Sanitary landfill leachate: generation, control and treatment.

Ed. Lancaster: Technomic Publishing Company Inc. ISBN 1-56676-129-8. 339p.