Upload
jun-magdaraog
View
222
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/3/2019 Can Fiction Be History
1/21
%0!5530,943,89907,9:70/:7390207.,3!074/
%09:,,943,82
%0!5530,943,89907,9:70/:7390207.,3!074/
708908,/,7,4
3974/:.943
30 ,8 574-,- 30;07 0,7/ 41 907,7 8947 47 , 8947 9,9 8 -,80/ 43
907,9:70%42,907,090:8041.:9:70,8,8947.,84:7.02,0:8041907,7
47841 90 0,73,943,8979078 ,3/54098/:7390207.,35074/%0 9,8 8 94
9,0,25804170,94190.4:397174290507850.9;041905348:54390,/;039
41.443,943 - 90 207.,38 :73 90 3.5039 5,8041 90 207.,3 7:0 3 90
.4:39790207.,380708:..0881:94,;0,.6:70/,30.443390,7,899,98
90!55308%05,80415,.1.,943,8.,7,.9070/94-0,974.4:83905,794190
5348%09209007013,8:-/:0/90207.,331:03.0,3/.:9:70:8070/3
9484.,0330073033,8907290534894207.,3933,3/2,0
,3/ ,70 9070,8 ,3 390394394/0153090 5348 /:7390207.,3 .443,
5074/3,,850.989070,8,/0,77,41207.,331:03.0090549.,9:90,0
41 90 207.,38 94 90 5348 90 570803.0 41 90 207.,3 0.4342. 44/8 ,3/
.42207.0390.4:397,3/9084.4.:9:7,24/1.,9439480/4:9903,943,8241
0;07534
%05,507800894,3807,90709070,.9438419053480570880/974:
9073,943,89907,7478:3/0790.443,5074//5343,943,82,841,94
8:7;;0/:0 94 90 0,;280/:.,943 4190207.,38742 90 1.994:80020398 ,3/
8/3/2019 Can Fiction Be History
2/21
%0!5530,943,89907,9:70/:7390207.,3!074/
.,7,.9078 41 90 907,7 478 98 5,507 89:/ 0 .,3 /07;0 ,9 .079,3 8947.,
3434190534870,.94394,7/90207.,34..:5,9435,79.:,7/70.90/94
908:-0.941.443,82,3/2507,82907,9:703/00/.,3-0,90994-47747
,847/41.43909:,38947
3985,50790/8.:884341903,943,89907,74783,3,990259947010.990
5343,943,82:3/07207.,32507,82/0290/90907,7147289454028,3/
/, 47;309908 3 38 ,70 .:3 41 90 54028 ,3//, .,20 1742 %,,4
5074/.,8/:7390207.,307,0:3!,8,3,3/904907800.90/54028,70
17421,24:83,943,8980:704%403934,3/:,347,43008:837010703.094
90:8041 90800.90/907,747890708, 300/ 147,.340/3902,907,81742
. ,;0 ,9070/ 9080 50793039 572,7 2,907,8 90 0/90/ -44 41 #4,3/4
%403934,3/789490903,03990/3,3%,,4..439,3890%,,4
/, 097,.90/ 1742 %,,4 5074/.,8 1742 5074/8 .4;073 ,3/ 90
:3/077,/:,90 90888,3 5,,,7, 8, 2, 9:,3 32-, 3 :3 !,8,3-
89477,/:,9081742$&73#4,8,3/,33,$,3.04,5503/0/390747
90.450841%,,4540283907473,9095:-80/-90:3!,8,3.
070,9,03174290,943,-7,74190!55308
39070,;3:9:70907,9:70,3/8947
0307, 9070 8 , 70,9 8,70/ ,1139 -09003 8947 ,3/.:9:70 30 .,3349
1::3/0789,3/90894741,3,94394:99,3394,..4:3990.:9:70907,41
10-0018,3/97,/94384198504509897:09,9504508.:9:702774789075,893
98548924/0739209089:/41.:9:70,850720,90/90793418947&543/43
8/3/2019 Can Fiction Be History
3/21
%0!5530,943,89907,9:70/:7390207.,3!074/
8490793418947944,/11070391472,890507850.9;0/0;4;0//70.9949070,
050703.0841504502,38947/3,2.,3/;-7,39
%0 /4.:20398 . 070 90 2,3 84:7.08 41 8947., 31472,943 ,;0 -003
70,7/0/,85,88F3890,/41.,39,84:7.0,3/9400539,.9990/0,8415489
24/073827,0854:80/9047/90994,557457,90,-0,3939,902-4/08
8947.,831.,943,982470998,:2,3,.9;908,7070,7/0/,89098%0
,/;0394198-74,/033418947.,31472,9438947,38.,317005:90;0793,8,
8947.,909385,09907,43.0,,389,90/380.9:709,92:8.8,;079,-0
90947908,-4:9908947.941,;035074/%4:2:8./408349;070,9078.450
418947.,:3/0789,3/30,//0/9,92:8..,389;0,8947.,;,:0189:/0/3
90 949, .4390941 908947., 5074/%07014701:8390 909 2:8.,3/ 90 .43909
8947.,3;0,70,907:3/0789,3/341905,89
03/3907,9:70,3/894790701470411078,349078947.,/09 1470,733
02:8.417,907,9:70.,3574;/00;0324701472/,-0:3/0789,3/34150450
,9,;035074/472489504504:98/04190/0,41308947.82907,9:7088003,8
, -574/:.9 41 90 .70,9;0 2,3,94341:2,38 907,9:70 8 43 ;03 .70/9 147 98
,08909. ;,:0 %04/474 43.4 70;0790/ 98 289,03 34943 ,-4:9 907,9:70 ,3/
.70,9;0 89,90/ 9,9 907,9:70 94:9 8947 8 :393,-0 147 907,9:70 -03 10
.,3349089,5,79 174290 9208,3/.7.:289,3.08 3. 9,8 .43.0;0/#0,/3
907,7478;0824709,3:898,98139070,/07850,8:70-:9247025479,39,3
36:7,7808,34;05,540247 84798947.,20394 -03,9.7.:289,3.08
3943/4,/0003390790:,:843,0.9:7007307/9,:7.8947,3/:9:70,3:,0,3/907,9:70$00.90/88,841%04/47443.4
,3,&3;078941$,394%42,8!:-834:80
8/3/2019 Can Fiction Be History
4/21
%0!5530,943,89907,9:70/:7390207.,3!074/
2,/090,:94794;07-,03941.9438;04170,9%:8,350.041907,9:702:89
-0,3,0/9409079988947.,20:
0307,907,9:70 8,;,/8947.,84:7.0198.4390398 14:3/94-030,790
70,9 9 8 8:0890/ 43 90 4907 ,3/ 147 8947,38 94 -0 .79., 3 ,..0593 9080
907,7478302:8989-0.,701:,894,990097,.9174290801.943,4788
8947.,574;03479.43147289490,.9:,.43/94347,9248507041,5,79.:,75,.0
,3/ 920 %8 8 94 8, 9,9 907,9:70 .,3349 840 70.43897:.9 , 97:0 8947 8 8,/
907,9:70 .,3 43 -0 , 909 0 47 , /08.7-0/ 2:8. ,3/ -03 , 909 9,9
574;/088947., 831.,3.0,.43909 5,79.:,75079,3394 8947.,.439092:89
8:11.0908947.,70.43897:.943,981:79078:0890/-%04/47443.489,9
8947,3884:/349700.:8;0:543/4.:2039,70;/03.08-:94424701474907
.:9:7,84:7.04131472,9430907,9:70370.70,9390,9248507041,5,79.:,70;039
,9,5,79.:,7920%04/47443.48008901407341907,9:70,889470-00;08
9,98947,3884:/-70,908947349907,0:2098479920,389,989472:89
-0.43902547,304:843.41:7907,//0/
%01:3.94341908947,3834920709470.90900;03983907.74344.,
47 4., 47/07 -:9 942,0 90 5,89 ,;0,3/ ;-7,39 ,3/ 1 5488-0 ,8 .4471:,8 90473,0;0398907,9:7089:8,3,41908947,3370.70,93905,89990,/
41907,9:70908947,3.,370;0905,89398/11.:9:3/079,398349034:9,990 8947,3 :808 907,7 478 ,8 2,907,8 3 90 793 41 8947 0 2:89 ,;0 90
907,7,-9942,0905,89;0,,31479070,/078%8,850.98,349072,9907,3/.4208:3/0790.,9047418947,8907,9:70
-/
-/
8/3/2019 Can Fiction Be History
5/21
%0!5530,943,89907,9:70/:7390207.,3!074/
907,9:70 ,8 8947 %0 !5530 #0,9 1742 90 ,943,89 907,7 478
/:7390207.,3!074/
9 90 9:73 41 90 9 .039:7 ,720/ .436:089 ,/ 03,-0/ 90 &390/ $9,908 94
089,-8, .; 00243. 90:80/549.,,3/.:9:7,20,38 147,..42583
985:75480%0089,-8203941905:-.8.4488902938,89020/:241
3897:.943,3/90411.,,3:,09000.94341,!55308802-,3/9097,33
415348070,3/,-74,/14790.443,-:70,:.7,.3/.,90/9,997:254190.:9:7,
,882,943 574.088 41&$00243 3 90.4:3974943 3 90 10/841.:9:70,3/
549.,0/:.,943,9908,20920;,74:897,/0,70020398:,7,3900/4.,2,7098147
&$ 574/:.98 ,3/ 90 8:55 41 7, 2,907,8 147 &$ 1,.94708 !5530 ,7.:9:7,
0.4342,/-00390/:59904557088;0:2-.,.47/4190207.,30.4342
9 98 8:-:,943 :3/07,30 .443, 31:03.0 41 ,34907 7:07 ,1907,70.039
430 907,9:70 4:/ 43.0 ,,3 02070 ,8 , -07,93 944 ,,389 14703 897,304/
2077/430 ;79:, /0130/ 98 9703/ 3 907,9:70 ,8 0207039 907,9:70. 8
907,9:703907930/990504508 897:0147 3,943,-07,943 9890 907,9:7041
902,73,0/,3/45570880/9890907,9:709,984:994.4:39079000243.7:0
4190.44307085909070039088:841207.,3,94341!5530.:9:7,10
903,943,89.438.4:830888:7;;0/-:9//349840.789,031472841,72897:0
147.0 ,3/ 80/ 41 -44/ -:9 ,84 - 90 2,3,9;0 88 41 90 3,943,89 79078
5,798,3/54098974:907907,750.08
#03,944389,3934%0!55308!,89#0;890/":0439%,,!:-83$07;.082077/430207039907,9:70":0439&3;07894190!55308!70885
8/3/2019 Can Fiction Be History
6/21
%0!5530,943,89907,9:70/:7390207.,3!074/
:.41903,943,89907,9:70,885,30/-9079078,3/540984190%,,4
0/947,8 %0 2,/0 8947 9 907 83 907,7 478 ,,389 90 207.,3
2507,82,3/.443,82%00570884341902507,,389 90.443,2,890794490
147241,9 .,909:, 3,943,8207033,943,898 3 907,9:70 4508 942,0
8947-793907897:0147-07,9433907907,750.0843.470;0,0/9,9
,703:2-078418947.,89:/08,-4:953470,.94394900,7207.,37020700/
247043,990207.,3894:9,890534708543809,3-00;3247039080
534907,7478.0570880/2470025,9.,9070,7085438041905348
%,,454028,3/847989470841985074/3/00/.4;079010038,3/94:984190
534870,7/390207.,33907;03943390!55308
489419054028147/.70/900,7334190534894-07,9090280;08
174290207.,37:0%05402,3!0-7074-!,9,7,34/08.7-08901941
90 5348 ,,389 90 2507,82 41 90207.,38 39738., 90 990 .43./08 90
8,20/,90419089,794190!5530207.,3,7,3/94/,8,1907430-7,:790
920 4:9-70, 41 489908 :70/ 90 207.,38 94 7,91 90 %70,9 41 !,78 %0
2507,898 34 ,/ 1: .43974 3 90 .4:397 %0 5402 45038 9 90 5348
930883907.,3041.443,2,8907,190790/0.8;03,,38990$5,3,7/8
3,,33,3,38,5,,24
8,-,3830438,,3,:2:545
2:33,8,,39,8,,,83/,4
32,2097,,95:34383,-433,3,9:438,/2,,33,9,548
07307/9,:7.8947,3/:9:70,3:,0,3/907,9:70$00.90/88,841%04/47443.4
,3,&3;078941$,394%42,8!:-834:80,3!0-7074:3!,8,30-7:,7
8/3/2019 Can Fiction Be History
7/21
%0!5530,943,89907,9:70/:7390207.,3!074/
%039,1703/70,943-09003905348,3/207.,38,3/907.,;,07
19,,389$5,3,7/8 30;9,- 0/ 94 90207.,38.4433 905348%05402
.4393:08,2039390-44/,7419053489902:.89743,720/207.,38
938,3,-3,3,3943,7,
,3,7,3:3,35,,,,7,5,38,32,,,82,,92,,2,3938,32:3938,8,3/,9,:,3
93,8,,39,5,8,/2,,33,/,,3
98,,,5,,3:5,9,,-4
32,,2,3/:42,9:3:2,48,/,3-,,33,/,3-:3/49,,3,,9,33,,-5,3544
,3/3,59,8,/:439,,4
9 ,8470.4:398.4:3908841/0,9843905348/0 3 907897:094705090
2507,898090207.,380703901472/,-0/0.84341.4250905,.1390
40 .4:397 0;03 - 097020 20,8:708 9 2:89 -0 70202-070/ 9,9 90 &390/ $9,908
5,880/;,74:8,393,943,89.,8503,3/0,9474357843803903.080899070-0
5348 708893 94 90 207.,3 00243 3 907 ,3/%080 ,8070 90 $0/943
,907,3/,0,.990#0.43.0397,943.9,3/90,,8009030989,3,
3/,2,3-4,33,3,8,,39,3/,2,3-4,33,5,3,3,,3/,2,3-4,32,9,3/,9-,9,
,3,:,3/,8,3,8,,,3839,3,,2,9,32,,,
%05402 .4808 9097,.8.030- 90207.,38 97:25,39 8:-/:3 830
.44390!55308489147,3490710/0.,/0841.443,82
,,932,3,78,2,55,3
/,8,,,833,3,,,
3/3,3,73943,,8,,8,3,3,493,9,2439,:25,
!,,9,33,,5,,3,35,3,-,3
#03,944389,3934%0!55308!,89#0;890/":0439%,,!:-83$07;.085
8/3/2019 Can Fiction Be History
8/21
%0!5530,943,89907,9:70/:7390207.,3!074/
943,3,3,7,3,,2,2,,43-,3/,32,9,943-9:3
2:33,945,93,5,,2
$,44-35:8432,:3
$,,3,3,9,,9,/9:2,9,
25,88574;/0/
%0703/341903,943,898039203941905345045002070/,843041
90 14., 90208 3 90 54028 41 90:3 !,8,3%0 534 4:98 070 -03
8:22430/390540203990/%:2:39433,3/,8-170/407707,%0,:947
70;0/ 3854029,9 9,8,70,/ ,50710.9920 147905348 94 89,3/ 94090794
1914790724907.4:3978009089,3,8
3,9,39,,433,45,3,433,3 32,2,9,2:,9
$,5,,,2-3,9/245,5:3,
$,2,93/37,532433, $39,3!53,8 98,/,9,98,,98,,,
,8,4,3,3,3:-483,5,,8,3 $,,,82433,9
,3,3,95:743,,/,
,4,-3,9,:,,32,9,4 $,5,3,4394
!,,92,5,3,3-,3/28,,49
!,8,3-:2,8,,,:348:348 3,5,,7,324 ,,2,5:,,92,982,5,4/
:2,3,53,3/,89-,,3,344-
$,5,7,,3949 ,39:3,32433,8,432,,,-49
%0540203990/,8,::,3
-$,3.,34,8,84411070/9490534
4:989,90570880/9,990920830,7314790294-0:390/%089,3,841905402
.43;0 9,9 9070 ,8 3493 2:.4780 9,3 94 -0 8,;0/ 3 907 43 .4:397 %0
%:2:39433,3/,8:3!,8,3,8,:,3:3!,8,3
8/3/2019 Can Fiction Be History
9/21
%0!5530,943,89907,9:70/:7390207.,3!074/
534807045570880/-, 147037:07 3 90743 84,3/4398/022,9,9 90
5402,398905045094543/074370,/90308
$,2:3/4,,3,32,8,,58,-:, ,,3,32,,5/99,3/8,7,5,3 :3/,3:2,3
%:,/8,,53,,33,,3
,,3438,,3,8,,7,9,,3
,43:2,,8,5-,439:292 443,,,,35,2,3,8,,9332,3,:9,8
,8,5,839,98,-,,5, :39,,,,3,,2-,3,2
:-48,35,,8,33/3,,,8,5 2,/,35,,45,3,43,
,9-,93-:9:3,3,3,3,9,,9
,,-,39:3,8,2,5,8,37,5
35,,-:8,-483,8,/,35,9 ,43,43,433,/:8,32,-,38
943!53,8 3,:3:33,,,!,398
9,,32:8,2,/,35,3,3-
%05402,8494:.0/9054399,9905348070574280/-902507,8994
,73088987084:7.0814790.4:3978435:754808,3/0549,943-:97,907904554890
,55030/0905348070/057;0/390743,3/90147030780700343
900,94190.4:397
-,3,35,/5,/3,432,,,8 $,5,35,3394,3,3-,38,
$,,9,3:,3 53,3,439,49:9:,/ $,839,3,5,9/,97,33,,3,
9,32,8,,3,3,93,,2,3
25:3,3,95,8,8,3,,3 :393,4-,9
%,4,35::-9,4,3/,:5, 99,4,3/,9,8,2,/,3,2,2
839,43,33,9,38,2,/, $,/:3438,5,,,8,,3, ,9,,-,
,38:28282,93,5,5,58,8,
8/3/2019 Can Fiction Be History
10/21
%0!5530,943,89907,9:70/:7390207.,3!074/
$,2,39,,3,,3,5,9/:89,
$,5,,,539,4,93:-48 -,3943,,33,43,::545
$,,9,,4,3
,9,5,9:3-,95,,732:94
3,8,8,3-,,34374
3 90 /, $,2,,,3,3,,53 - 47,390,/70.9 5,7,082
,8:80/-90,:94794-0,8/8,554392039,-4:990:804170,843,3/8:50747941
90 2507,898 0 90 &390/ $9,908 3 .4433 9480 4 90 507.0;0/ 94 -0
:3.;0/70,/900.075930
35,3,43,8:2:8:43,9,32,-,,32,5,,/:3,394,32,8,8,-,93,::3,,38,2,9,43,9,:943,7,5,9,3,9,/,,,3948,3/,5,95,,98,39,,,39,/,3,8,,9,:,3
,,35,2,2,,,/32,-,,3-,394,92,9,9,34,3,-,-,9,8,,97,32,432,:,939,,8,33,,32,-,38,3:2,-498,9:,94,5,,3/,,3,:33,95,2,,,,35,,9,3,9494,3,3,2,2,,33,,,-,9/3,,3
9,43,-:-:,:5,32,34/8,,97,3
33,2,2,,832,7,2:33/2,33,,9,9,,3,7:3:3,33,3
-,,3,3,,298,,9:89:8,3,9:8:,3-,2,3,8,,5,,9,,338,3
4825,88574;/0/
3 :89 13 90 05,384382 41 90 207.,38 430 353 70,843 ,8 90
207.,3.43.059412,31089/089398,33047,-09,814790207.,3894-73907
8:50747.:9:709490!55304290-00;0/,.0/907041%8-0.4770,90/
- 90 .43.059 41 $4., ,7382 05,33 9,9 90 05,384382 ,8 , 3,9:7,
503420343 0703 90 8:57020 .:9:70 4;077:0 90 :3.;0/ 3 90 030;4039
882,943 !74.,2,943 - !708/039 .30 05,384382 ,8 -,.0/ :5 -
:2,39,7,370,843894059053488,39,9-6:493!708/039.309070
,83493019147:894/4-:9949,0902,,3/940/:.,90905348,3/:519,3/
$,2,-,,32,3,,53:3!,8,3$05902-07
8/3/2019 Can Fiction Be History
11/21
%0!5530,943,89907,9:70/:7390207.,3!074/
.;0 902 ,8 4:7 104203 147 4 789 ,84 /0/ %0 7907 41 90 /,3
570.80/70.90/870;,3.094980934.0397.249;,94341907:07944..:59084
.,0/40750450
%0/,03/0/90909- -:--3:59088:041 3/0503/03.01 914770,8438
9,9 :891 90207.,3 8://0324;08 41 2507,82 90 8,20,8 -00;0/94 ,55 94
90770.4394341903/0503/03.0414907.4:39708%0207.,3807034394-090
02,3.5,947847-07,9478412,33/98,9984300//08.759439,9905348.4:/
349/0.50790.4/30884190207.,3894,7/9071700/42800490/,03/8
$3,- 4 ,3 ,394 8,3 8, :3 9:3, 3, ,3 2, -,,3 ,3 , 9,,,3
2,9,34 3, , ,-8 3, 2,,, 3, ,3 ,3,3 ,,,,3 ,9 :3 ,394 3, ,2,,,,3,,,,3 3,2,33-,,,3,,,,3,2,33,,33,,,:3,43,3/8,9,45,,9,39:3,3,9,4,,43:2,,,3,9:2-8,,,,,3
3,,9
9,.425090/0;,9439490.302,9.,/,59,9433/7,2,41,,543:,8,9
,439,989470/904..:5,943841/1107039.4:39708390!55308905402
;0784341908,20990-:704%403934799033,/,/70.97010703.09490,5
990&390/$9,908 %02,9.,.425480/ 3 90 5402#,,,-,3,,3,8
050/-,73$,2:0,,389,70884785499394.436:07907,3/03,80/,9
5,2039.4:/.425038,90907/0-9942$,2:0:2-708543/0/9,990,/,84:9
41;79:0,3/7085438-9,//39,90,390/06:,9,24350450947:09047/
40;07 903-7408574280,3/.436:070/90 ,3/3#,,,-,3,,3
,3/2578433810,,,,3
#03,944389,3934%0!55308!,89#0;890/":0439%,,!:-83$07;.082077/430,943,89907,9:70":0439&3;07894190!55308!70885
8/3/2019 Can Fiction Be History
12/21
%0!5530,943,89907,9:70/:7390207.,3!074/
%05402,842039430/90:2,39,7,3288434190207.,38 3/0./394
,33090 .4:397$004%4039342,/0,04708949090,38:7/03,3/90
030;4039882,943
39:3,433,8,9:7:,3 5,2,2,,,3943343-,,3 $,,5,,9,5488,34-, 35,8,8,732,,,3-:,
3-:43,,84,5,::-:83
&503/32,5,,,,3343:5,3
,,93343,2,3,5,88-:3 &5,3,3-:,3342,:3333
9,907,3/48057434:3.020398174290.44307,,,,380081700/4241
07 ,3/ %4: 3 , 1472 41 706:089 9 8 .0,7 9,9 90 5402 ,//70880/ 90 88:0 41
805,7,943 174290 .43974 4190207.,380,74 90 6:003 ;4.08 4:9078 147
02,3.5,943
333943,3-,, 435,,,3 !,3-,,,3,43:2,,3,23
,,:9:8,38:,9,,3,33
;078,97.,,412,3,04708 94,2,89078,;070,94385-0900390
207.,38,3/905348,810,9:70/390/,03990/,5,,9:3,4.
.,201742,3:3343,:947%0990.,374:20,3,889:5/0.,20/-,
50,8,39,19073,70,,9439,90.,3898:7;;0-280194:982,8907%0/,
45038 9 43 94 .,7,.9078 3,-93 ,3 8,3/ ,2/89 , /0 4.0,3 430 2,34
,88:2089089,9:841,2,8907,3/,50,8,394/408,9047147907;3$0090
309308
/3,,5,39,,3,5,:704%403934800.90/7938":0439&3;07894190!55308
-7,7,5,,9:3,4,,9,857
8/3/2019 Can Fiction Be History
13/21
%0!5530,943,89907,9:70/:7390207.,3!074/
4,3-:2:-:,8,4,3,33448,2,-:-:/
32,-:-:/3,2,33,9494433,5,,385,98,3:2,,,2:,8,
:2,,,3,3,-3,48,,3,,-,3,3,8,8,,95,8,5,,3:5,32,:,3,,932,8,8,7,58,,3,35,33443,8:2,8,49/99438,493,2,5,,,
5,3:9,35:,,38,2-,4,92,5,5,/35,8
$, 3, 54 ,3, !,33443 4 34 ,3 2,3,,7 8, ,3 5,2:2:,
:33/8,34
%0 309 0584/0 840/ 90 /0,9 41 8 2,8907 0 90 50,8,39 8:75783
/8.4;070/ 9,9 0 .,3 89 08994:9-43 9482,8907,3/0,9144/0 - 843
,3/8,7;0890/070,8-0147004:/,3/917899482,8907%0309308070
909707330419050,8,393,5,,9:3,,43,070,.0/9089,904123/
9,9 0 ,/ 1440/ 2801 - -00;3 0 ,8 3 30,7 093.943 94:9 , 8:50747
.425,343 %8 8 90 831.,39 055,3 3 90 8947 %0 ,34324:8 7907 2,08
5,7,082 41 90 94 .,7,.9078 94 90 89:,943 050703.0/ - 90 !55308 ,3/ 90
&390/$9,908,34-;4:8,99025994822074:990/0,418014;073,3.0
%0 /, 03990/ 480 #, - 2/4 #,248 .439,38 1: 41 70947.
/0;.080,:8438,3/82-482890394480#,9,9,90,//70,2914790
.4:397,80994-0,.0;0/8009089,3,
#,8, 435,,2,7,3 8,2,,2 3,-43,3 ,2,3,7 ,2,33,
8:2,3/,,32,-,343,92,,832495,2,8/,3,3,,-,,-,3,,48343
-,,3,9 2,2,2,,8 243 2, :8, 5, 3/ 5, 3,,, ,3 /2 3/ 5,3,,,29,3,3433,5,:3535,#,
%0 309 308 .70/ 4:9 , 2470 850.1. 701 94 #, 90 3/0503/03.0 147 90
.4:3971907905,9749./0,941#,90.4:397,8891,71742,.0;3903,943
9,981700174209073,2,35:,9438%05348,;034909947089017:9434190
97:254;07905,89.44307-:99097,38943,8349,.44394,33/0503/0393,943
480#,3#05:-,0.02-07
8/3/2019 Can Fiction Be History
14/21
%0!5530,943,89907,9:70/:7390207.,3!074/
-:9 7,907 , .443 94 89 , .443 :3/07 , 30 2507,89 %0 /, 4-;4:8 :808
82-48289,92,/07010703.094,32507,899,941.4:780890&$.0.90308
,33,3 3,43 ,, 5, ,23 ,, ,548 5, 3 3,,,,3 9,3, ,3
,23 2, 5,, ,9 ,2, !,9 3 ,23 ,9,,9 , 3/ 2,,,,, 3 2,,, ,98:2,,532,-338243,2,33,3,8,83:8:-:,35,7,932,-9:3,,3,,3-,3/,3435,9
3,2,,8 24 73 #, 3, ,3 2, ,, 24 :, 8, ,,,,3 3:39 ,8,,5!:2,5,,8,,-:33,,3,932933,,9,,3,353,5,:7,3
,99:43,3,8,3,32,7,232,8,35,,/3,3,-:,8,93,3/2
%0 57,8082,-:333 ,, ,3/2,-9:3 ,,3 ,,3 -,3/, 4-;4:8
2,/0,5,7,082945079,39490&390/$9,908%02,-9:3,,3,,3-,3/,47
3389,920,38, 7057088;01, 1:4189,784-;4:8/08.7-0/90207.,3 1,
%0 1789 57,80 9,8 ,-4:9 90 207.,3 0,0 . ,/ -003 , 82-4 147 90
3/0503/03.041 90&390/$9,908 /05.93 901700/42,3//024.7,.9,9070,,8
/03910/ 9 90 207.,38 40;07 90 5348 070 3 /01,39 94 98 1,,.4:8
209,547,8901094-038,.0/:3/0790385,34190207.,370204790
5348 02,3.5,943 ,8 , 34 .,:80 147 90 207.,38 %0 /, 03/8 ,8 9 :808 90
507843,41#, 94.43;0 982088,0 9,9 90!55308:3/07, 7:07,8 -003,34907
/,7,014790.4:397948,900,898004913808
#, 4 3,::349 2,9,28 5, ,3 ,4 2,2, ,9 2,3,,3 /,3 8, -,,3
5,,5,,8,8:2,,533/2,,,3,338,:39,33,,393943!53,8,5,,/24#,%,2,3,,,,,95,,5,,5,,8,,23#,,5,,/24$,5,,9/24
3,-495,,3,,-,,-,3,,,,,33,238,2,8,3/,394
30.4342.3,943,82,890/203843413/0503/03.014:3/390/, ,
%,343353,39,3$,493,,94,84.,201742,3:3/03910/,:947
,9,3433,53,39,3,,93,4;02-07
8/3/2019 Can Fiction Be History
15/21
%0!5530,943,89907,9:70/:7390207.,3!074/
%0/,,/;4.,908908:5547914790534-:83088%02,3570/.,2039070890
0.4342. 039,302039 41 90 !55308 94 90 &390/ $9,908 9,9 708:90/ 94 90
-,.,7/3088 41 90 14720780.4342. 749 -:83088,.9;908070 .439740/ -
,038 47 14703078 ,3/2:. 41 90 0549,943 41 90 .4:3978 7084:7.08070 ,70
0340/ -9080 ,038 $004 98 14703897,304/4190 !55300.4342,8
7,80/390/,
%3:9:43,23,33,3,,73 5,,-:,32, 93/,,3/,:,3,9 3
5,,2,9, 3,2,/,,8393/,,3!534-,9 34435,3:3,:3,-3,,3,,35,3,,73,393/,,38,7,/3,/,,3,3,2,332,2,22:5,38,3,,9
, 9:2,2-,/ ,9 ,48 2,,,,3 8, 8,3 93/,,3 3 /,:,3 9:,/ 3 389,2-,,-,98,5,,,,3,3,39,/3,73,3,2,,9,53,,,,338,3
93/,,3!5348,,7,538,393/,,3/,:,39482,,3,,99,8,,23,,432,3,232,2-,-,8,8,33,,9,9,48,93,,/,/,2,2,7,9/3
3,2,3,8,,23,,4,33,,,,32,8,3353,-:-:,9,332,:3943,
,9494,3,39:2,9,488,,-:9,7,33,232,5:84
%0 /, ,;0 6:089438 ,9 90 ,9907 5,79 ,8 94 5348 ,70 1,7 1742
0.4342.,1700174290570803.0419014703-:8308808390.4:397,3/03/0/9
,702,79,9450894897905343,943,82944;0,9890743
,9 ,,3,-:-:,,3 ,,,3 /,:,3/94 8,,93,93,2,2,9,3, ,7,3,3 ,3
8,73,93
34,32,,3,3,8,33,394
$,2,9,3433,,3,-3-,33,235,3:3:8,5,3,,933,,,,38,3
:5,3:3942,,75,3:3,8,3,2,,,3,,3,332,5,3,43
,,73 2,,5,,,/ 3 ,,9 3 3,,,,3 5,3,-,3,3 3 -,3 2,2-,-,8, ,92,,9:948,5,9,3,/,2/,2332,7,233,,2498,9:3:35,2,2,,8,8,7
3490770,9,392507,89907,9:709,96:089438900.4342./423,9434190
.443078 8 90 /, 03990/897,30798- 34 #0,,/4 .,8 3 , 1472
/,4:08 - 94 5348 49 43 // 90 /, 70;0, 90 70,908 41 503097,943 41
.443,574/:.98390.4:397.,8,.43806:03.04190170097,/041.443,829
897,307985,3,,-,.94-07
8/3/2019 Can Fiction Be History
16/21
%0!5530,943,89907,9:70/:7390207.,3!074/
,84/08.7-0/9017,.9:70/.443,2039,941905348,9.490.43;078,9438
419094.,7,.90787:3
4,..48,3,,3 $,4900974540 ,5,,5,3,3,,3,5,,,8,,33,2,3,3439:343,3
$,,83485,34,
9/443,5,,3,--,7,,7,2,:8,3,,3,,397,0248,,3-,-3,3,$,!,78,3,
98,32453,9,$,904:80
!,7,339 ,38,5,94824$,,3-,,3$,207.,3$408
,3842-707424,:,3$0-49
%0.43;078,943841909403/-90,894380/5347/.:38.4430/
1703/9,908344307,534,32470-:9,30897,30709847,897,3073843
,3/93088901383308
,,3,::74438,34 $,,35,,4::,/-,99,,79473,48,,3,3,2:,24
8,3,5,,,3,703,-,:,33,,39334,9,,,8,438548,2,83,-424,9,3,53,9,,:745,,3,49,,207,/,8,,,9,,93433,,293,,3-3-384,9 3,,24,9 9,,3,83,3/9,, 794 :3/9,, 7443 8,
348,897,3074 $3,8,-,0243,,9,,40
3/3,2,33,,,303,,885,7948,,93-,,3,3,-,3,3/,2,5,3,-,3,3,-:95,/443,3,9:27,8,897,3074
,3/ ,70 90 /, 9,9 894708 90 .443,2039,941 90 5348,398 94
/05.945348,70.443,.:9:70/9900,;280/:.,9434190207.,38
90 5348 070 84., 0330070/ 94 -0 ,3 207.,30/ 534 50450 ,3/ 9:8
/01530/945:993,34907,%0/,8848,97.,3703/073982088,0-:99
.:98974:03997,38.03/890574-0241.443,2039,94190534849438
9 .:9:7, 700;,39 -:9 ,84 94 8420 09039 58.44., 9,8 ,-4:9 90 534
2039,9,8907933,870,32,90/94-0.43/:.;094207.,344/8:7390
8/3/2019 Can Fiction Be History
17/21
%0!5530,943,89907,9:70/:7390207.,3!074/
207.,3 5074/ 90 !5530 2,709 ,8 ,2489 90/ 9 90 207.,3 4557088;0
0.4342%0534807031:,..0884190207.,344/89,90703,708:75:8
94 8:5590!55302,7099 9023/809 0;05348070.443, .:9:70/ 94
507.0;0 9,9 ,393 254790/ .4208 9 -09907 6:,9 ,3/ 70,907 8,981,.943 %,9
.443,2039,9,8:3/03,- 702,30/ ,.7488/0.,/089 90207.,3545.:9:70
.4393:0894-0,331:039,5745,,3/,-90207.,3894.44309053480;03,9
985489.443,920
%0., 147 90-,439,43050450 8 9014., 9020 3 90/,32,
%,43,4
-,3,:3,/4%0504500707010770/94,890534844:/
089,-8,3,94382,794 9,94198.44307 82-40/- ,02 3 90/, 9,9 8
7.1700,3/70,9#0,/90308
$,,32,3-,:,338,3:5,452,-,3,33,882-35,8,,2:,,,3,
2,2, 9,43-,43,53,,-,,33,9:-:8,32,9,432,9,9,43 8,3-,,3,:732,,,3,3,8-,3:-,32,:842,,,,9/,,
%0/,1440/-5742493903,943,8979384190%,,40/947,894
34247041,990.,90-,439,4
:3,43,9:3,,3,32,,3/432,5,3:,98,5,,3,33-,,3 -3,932,,2,3,3,2,335,3:,93,,3
:3 ,43 , 9:3,3 3,93 ,3 2, 59, 3 5,,,,3 2,5,3:8, 8, 2,3,,772,723,/:23-,,3 $2,7949049070/947,890/,,84.43.:/0/9,8974389,902039.,3
147,3,943,89-07,943
:3,43,-:2,,89,4:,2,3,8,2,9,9,23,8,53398,
:43,9 ,,83:4,98,/,4 7443,2,2,9,33,88,:3,8,2,9,9,743,
-:3/4,93,88:8438,2,,,23,-,333,9,,,3-,3/,35,-,-,43-:,
32,9,43-,4:3!,8,3$05902-07
8/3/2019 Can Fiction Be History
18/21
%0!5530,943,89907,9:70/:7390207.,3!074/
%070,8 ,84 , 5,79 4,9390 5348 4 .4,-47,90/ 9 90207.,38
%0070.,0/9045548904190-,439,443890,/41,8573147901700/4241
90.4:397.480948/0990.443078948018:519907;08$0090309308
,,, 3 2, 5,3/:343 5,2,3 3 2, :-,33 5,3,, 3 8,78,73
5,-,-,,9,4 ,,, 3 2, 9,43 3,88, 8, 3,3 3 ,8 3 2, 2,5,,7,7,3/:,32,2,/,,35,3,3,,,,32,3,-/:833-,,332,2,5,2,9,,8,92,5,-:38,8,732,5,38,,-,8,5,8:433-,,3
%0.,14790507509:,9431479070;499,98,9097:25419053484;07
90$5,3,7/8,89090204190/,03990/,5,9:4,,,3-%,
, %0 ,:94741 90 /, ,9902598 94 2,0 , ., 147 :31.,943 - 70;3 90 5,89
474:8;.947419053484;07904557088;0$5,3,7/80,78,40,7:089,919
,8 8:..0881: 147 90294,;0/7;03411,32507,893,9434:/9-0/1107039
34 9,9 90 ,70 1,.0/ 9 ,34907 2507,89 9,9 84:9 94 ;0880 90 8,20 .443,
70,943,8,99,/-003-01470%0/,89,798411-20394339009574;3.089,9
07017899439,9024;08,,38990$5,3,7/870,/90308
:, 8, ,43 ,,,3!5343 :3,:3,3 83,9,3 ,9 53,9933,3 3,432,3333,83,37,3!,-,-,3435:,:2,,3,58,8,3,553:,3,3,,83,
/,2/,233,,,,95,8,8,73,43,,,3 ,433,8,93, 35:4 3:43,3,,,8,2,5,3,,3,3,,;90,9,3,8%,,-,84743,:3,:,.,3,9:0;,
.,,32,,,,39488,353,33/:,3,332,:,,935,2,83,3
!534,-,38,2,5,3383,,5,3,7,33,89,
%0/,.4393:08-20394333,2089,902070/17429080574;3.08,3/,
,/908,20249;,943 , 70;4:943%03,208 03/708431,.4!,7/0,-3
/-0794 ;,3089, :3,/4 ,3/ 470 070 :89 , 10 1742 90 89 41 534
70;4:943,7089,9,20/9480;071742,.443,70,94385%08947.,70;894190
,5,9:4,,,3:3!,8,3::89
8/3/2019 Can Fiction Be History
19/21
%0!5530,943,89907,9:70/:7390207.,3!074/
/,4508947003,.9908,2070;4:94394.4393:0193147,3,9439,98170070,/
490/,03/8
$, 5,::3,2:3,2 8, 2, ,-,,3,3 3 ,93 2, ,-,-,,3 3,3,:4/ 8,5,2,8 8, ,7,,7, , :2,,4 ,9 :2::84 ,3 ,9:9:-43 /,2/,23 8, ,,,,3 ,95,8,8,7 $,3 73 /44 53,,229 3 ,,5,,3 !534 ,3 3,43 /33 -,,33,-,34335,2,8 3 ,8,32,::948 ,9 ,,,/ 3 ,5,,,8, 39,3,3$,2,39,,::934,38,32,7,23,,3,,5,9:4,,,3
0,90/5745,,3/,94,7/8,.443,805,7,943,80570880/390/,03990/
207,,8,2494,:9470/-43/00,7/4%05,7,7,58390/,
-:398970880/,99053485099430/970,7/94907,39413/0503/03.01742
90&$%070,83470947./0;.08:80/94/0903903943,3/90249;0-907907
387939420.,308,392507,894:944:3/07907,/,74190&$%047/8
070/70.99,90;0390990,70,/05.970;0,0/90,392507,89803920394190
907,7 47 %0 /, .8411 98 702,7 - 70;0,3 90 /4:-01,.0/ ,999:/0 41 90
207.,38 .43.0733 90 3/0503/03.0 ,3/ 1700/4241 905348 9 870/5:9 90
207.,38949339,919007070,,3,/07039411700/42,3//024.7,.,3/90
1,.99,990944,/-003,.44343.0.4:/34990:3/0789,3/905348/0870
947:090743.4:39780090308
$, ,8,:,3 ,3 974343 3,:::,3 24 ,3 8,3 ,43 /,, 8,
8,3/,/$,5,,3,324,3,8,8,-:,3,3,432,-,-,343-:,,35,5:7,95,,3,3-,32,-,38,8,344243,33333,3,7,3,,353,2,2,,343,3,,98,/-/-24438,5:54,38,3,8,8,,3-,8,5,,488,/:4
32,-,,3243,3,3,3,2,9,/,8,8,3,9,:,3
$,2,39,,3 3,8, ,3,3 ,3 ,,,,38,3/,3 :2394 ,8,5,/// 3
2,2932,9,4,95,-,,324 3,8,8,,3343,,5433443 ,,,573 5, 73,9 ,9:,/ 3,233,2,2,334435, 8, -,3-,38,,2/,2324,3//,2/,23243443,9:4248,,232,!534-,45,,9,548,9,343248,
438,73-:/:32,9:/,,,33,,,248,,239,343248,8,7243
207,,8,3494,,,::89
8/3/2019 Can Fiction Be History
20/21
%0!5530,943,89907,9:70/:7390207.,3!074/
-:/ :3 8, 5,3 3,23 3 ,8,73,3 , /,5,9 , 5, ,,3 2,,9:- 3
5,--,8,,23
%0/,03/8,89/70.9,881473/0503/03.0
9:3,,3,,2-,,3,233,43:3,39743424,3::,3,232, 3,9,,3 :3 ,2 , 3,8,2,8,2, 8, 5,-:-:4 3 8,3 8, 3, 2,,,8 ,92,,5,3,7,3:38,-:43/,/,3,,9,,93,23,32,5,8,23,3,,,,3
3,8,3,3,3,33,232,293
35,,,3,232,!534,8,35,9,,7,33,23-:,,9,5,,7,33/,299,3,3/2,9,2494,,98,,43,33333343,7,3,,3,-,243,8,,23,3,23,8,73,3
43.:843
%0907,79098,-4;0,70:89, 104190;4:234:8 907,9:7089,90854:8090
/0,41%09:,,943,82980;/0399,9-:8970,/3.439039419080907,9:708
0.,3 8:11.039 2,30 90 8947.,20:070 908054028,3/ /, .,20 1742
907,9:70 -03 ,3 ,5503/,0 41 .:9:7, 31472,943 .,3 9:8 -0 .438/070/ , 8947.,
84:7.0 %0 ,72 ,3/ 025,9. 1003 41 9080 907,7 9098 703/078 , 2470 97:91:
7085438;030889,9 905348389,90/ ,894 90 2507,824190&$3 90 .4:397
3/0503/03.08,.454:89020,2439080907,9:708.90/3/.,939,9905348,8
0,7,8901472,9;05,804190207.,37:0,70,/,/,2,9:70/,857,943147,1700
3,943 %0 3,943,82 41 90 5348 ,8 0;/039 349 ,25070/ - 90 0,;
280/:.,943 41 90207.,38 - .439743 90 50/,4 3 0/:.,943 9,9 ,/ -003 ,
831.,39,55,7,9:84190207.,383907.443,9433847990-:733!5530
3,943,82 // 349 907, 1,3 4:9 ,8 90 207.,38 5742590/ 907 5745,,3/, 41
/01533 90 5348 907,9:70 :3/85:90/ 03.,58:,908 394 47/8 ,3/ 57480 90
3,943,89897:041905348/:73985074/
8/3/2019 Can Fiction Be History
21/21
%0!5530,943,89907,9:70/:7390207.,3!074/
#010703.08
!72,7$4:7.08
:3,/4,332,9,43-,4:3!,8,3$05902-07
34324:8,5,,9:3,4,,9,857
34324:8,9,3433,53,39,3,,93,4;02-07
,,%,5,9:4,,,3:3!,8,3::89
0,7/443/0207,,8,3494,,,::89
47,390$,2,,,3,3,,53:3!,8,3$05902-07
07707,170/4%:2:39433,3/,8:3!,8,30-7:,7
,7,34!,9,3!0-7074:3!,8,30-7:,7
#,2482/4480#,3#05:-,0.02-07
#0,,/434897,307985,3,,-,.94-07
$,3.,34,8,:,3:3!,8,3,3:,7
$0.43/,7$4:7.08
:7. 073,7/9, 8947 ,3/ :9:70 ,3:,0 ,3/ 907,9:70 $00.90/ 88,8 41
%04/47443.4,3,&3;078941$,394%42,8!:-834:80
4389,3934 #03,94 %0 !55308 !,89 #0;890/ ":043 9 %,, !:-83
$07;.08
,39434/0003390790:,:8430.9:70
7/430207207039907,9:70":0439&3;07894190!55308!7088
,5,39,,3,5,/3,:704%403934800.90/7938":0439&3;078941
90!55308-7,7