Upload
others
View
5
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Blood Gas Reference Intervals
The Struggle Continues
Roger Ashton
Pathlab Whakatane
Walking on eggshells
Riding on the shoulders of those who have tried before
Lynne Clarke – Waikato
Tony Mace - Pathlab
And many others including :
RCPA
ARQAG
AACB
Blood Gas Reference
Intervals
Lyn Clarke
Dip MLT, BBS
June2016
Analysers in New Zealand
Radiometer – majority of large volume sites
41 ABL800
11 ABL80
25 ABL90
iSTAT – Large numbers in low volume sites
Siemens – A few sites APPROX 9
GEM At least 2
? Others e.g. Epoch, Roche, Novastat
12 New Zealand Locations
Reality
Few Laboratories have references in their methods. • Some use vendor ranges.
There is a lot of data on cord bloods
Plenty of data on animals
Very little data on adults
Text books often have no references or reference each other e.g Tietz, Sigaard-Andersen, Wallach, New England Medical Journal
Still cannot get agreement on UNITS
Klaestrup et al 2011
182 patients
Medical Students and health professionals
118 medical students practising on each other
76% <40 yrs (138)
Age range 20-76 yrs
Radiometer analyser
Conclusions 2015
CLSI now allows for Consensus Ranges
Logically the ranges should be the same throughout the
country.
Get buy in from Pathologists
Set up a meeting of the participants
iSTAT
Comparison of Reference Intervals REFERENCE RANGES LITERATURE
Test Age Range
Tietz 4th ed
2006
ABBOTT
ISTAT Radiometer
Klaestrup et
al (2011)
Widdop
(2002)
Cousineau et al
( 2006) Helwig (1996) Yeomans (1985) Victory (2004) Shirley (1996)
Number in study ? ? ? 182 126 16060 146 20456 53 pH Arterial 1 Day 7.29-7.45 7.35 - 7.45 7.35-7.45
Male 7.376 -7.455
Female 7.35-7.45 7.384-7.468
Female/Male 7.35 - 7.45 7.382 - 7.462
pH Venous Adult 7.32-7.43 7.31 - 7.41
60-90 7.31-7.42
pH - Capillary 36-60 hours 7.312-7.473
pH Cord Blood- Arterial 7.28±0.05 7.10-7.38 7.15-7.43 7.17-7.31
pH Cord Blood - Venous 7.35±0.05 7.20-7.46 7.24-7.49 7.27-7.45
pO2 Arterial 1 Day
54-95 mmHg
7.18-12.64 kPa
>1 Day
83-108 mmHg
11.04-14.36 kPa
83-108 mmHg
11.07-14.4 kPa 11.1-15.5 kPa
pO2 Venous
pO2 Capillary 36-60 hours 32.8- 61.2 mmHg
pO2 Cord Blood- Arterial
80 -105 mmHg
6.7 -14 kPa 6-30 mmHg 3.8-33.8 mmHg
pO2 Cord Blood - Venous 16-43 mmHg 15.4-48.2 mmHg
pCO2 Arterial Newborn
27-40 mmHg
3.59-5.32 kPa
Adult Male
35-48 mmHg
4.66-6.38 kPa
35-45 mmHg
4.67 - 6.0 kPa
35-48
mmHG(M/F)
4.67-6.40 kPa 4.5-6.0 kPa
Adult Female
32-45 mmHg
4.26 - 5.99 kPa
35-45 mmHg
4.67 - 6.0 kPa 4.1 - 5.6 kPa
Female/Male 4.3-6.0 kPa
pCO2 Venous
0.8-0.83 kPa
Higher than
arterial
41-51 mmHg
5.47 - 6.8 kPa
Where we are currently
pH
Tietz (2006) 7.35 – 7.45
Wallach (1996) 7.36 – 7.44
Radiometer, Siemens iSTAT 7.35 – 7.45
Klaestrup et al (2011) 7.382 – 7.462
pH
Propose 7.35 - 7.45
pO2
Adult
Semantics and conversion factors
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
0 5 10 15 20 25
mmHg
KPA mmHg
1 7.5
2 15
4 30
6 45
8 60
10 75
12 90
14 105
16 120
18 135
20 150
KPA mmHg
1 7.5
2 15
3.5 26.25
4 30
6 45
6.7 50.25
7 52.5
7.6 57
8 60
9.34 70.05
9.5 71.25
10 75
10.65 79.875
10.66 79.95
10.67 80.025
11.34 85.05
11.4 85.5
12 90
13.3 99.75
14 105
16 120
18 135
20 150 • Do we want our Reference Range to be exact?
• To how many decimals?
• Or Memorable?
• Or close enough?
• Or Clinically Significant
NUMERICAL CREEP
11 KPa = 82.5 mmHg
“ Let’s call it 83”
83 mmHg = 11.1 KPa
“must be exact”
80 ~ 10.7
85 ~ 11.4
100 ~ 13.3
108 ~ 14.4
PO2 Adult
Low 70 – 85 mmHg = 9.3 – 11.4 KPa
High 100 - 108 mmHg = 13.3 - 14.4 Kpa
9.3 - 14.4 Kpa ?? Too wide, and not referenced ??
ORIGINAL PROPOSAL
Tietz 83 - 108 mmHg = 11.0 to 14.4 KPa
P O 2
ARQAG Proposal
75 - 105 mmHg 10 - 14 KPa
PCO2
Test Age Range ADHB Christchurch Waikato Wellington WDHB Hawkes Bay Whakatane
pCO2 Arterial 4.6-6.0 kPa 24-30.0 mmHg 4.5-6.0 kPa 35-45 mmHg 4.6 -6.0 KPA 35-45 4.67 - 6.00 kPa
pCO2 Venous 5.0-6.4 kPa 25-33.0 mmhg 5.0-6.4 kpa 38-48 mmHg 41-51 5.47 - 6.8 kPa
Wider variation depending on source
Tried looking at Low & High separately
Some sources had different Male and Female
PCO2 Adult Low MALE 32 – 37 mmHg = 4.3 – 4.9 KPa
Low FEMALE 27 – 32 = 3.6 – 4.3 Kpa
LOW limit NZ LABS 24 – 30 = 3.4 – 4.0 Kpa
High MALE 45 – 48 = 6.0 – 6.66
High FEMALE 43 – 45 = 5.6 – 6.0
High limit NZ LABS 30 – 48 = 4.0 – 6.67 Kpa
DO WE NEED GENDER SPECIFIC RANGES ??
PCO2 Adult
Tietz
Male 35 – 48 mmHg = 4.7 – 6.4 KPa
Female 32 – 45 mmHg = 4.3 – 6.0 KPa
ARQAG PROPOSAL
35 - 45 mmHg 4.7 - 6.0 KPa
Consensus Recommendation
NZPOCTQAG / ARQAG
NSW Pathology • source
pH 7.35 - 7.45 Tietz
PO2 75 - 105 mmHg = 10.0 to 14.0 Kpa Tietz / ARQAG
PCO2 35 – 45 mmHg = 4.7 to 6.0 KPa Tietz / ARQAG
HCO3 22 to 28 mmol/L
Base Excess -3 to +3 mmol/L
Lactate less than 2.0 mmol/L
Cord Bloods Agreed 2018
What is next?
HAEMOGLOBIN
HaemQAG RCPA
Haematology nationwide recommendations 2014
Needed “pruning” to give 10 age related for use in POC
Number of significant figures
The reference intervals are rounded regardless of the
number of decimals in the original source.
pH: Rounded to 2 decimal places.
pCO2: Rounded to 0 decimal place for mmHg and 1 decimal place for kPa.
pO2: Rounded to 0 decimal place for mmHg and 1 decimal place for kPa.
ctHb: Rounded to 0 decimal place. (1 decimal for g/dl )
sO2: Rounded to 0 decimal place for % and 2 decimal places for fraction.
Laboratories may choose to report to a higher number of Decimals,
but Ranges should be rounded
Other parameters
(Electrolytes, Metabolites, & Co-oximetry)
Generally follow ARQAG
Do we need separate ranges?
Serum, Plasma, Whole Blood?
Potassium
Venous Ranges
To be discussed in more detail by Rita
Currently before ARQAG
Where to next?
Propose pH , PCO2, PO2 ranges to
NZPOCTQAG
ARQAG
PATHOLOGISTS
Other Quality Groups
Suggest need for haste and assertiveness.
onions
References
B.E. Statland, Clinical Decision Levels for Lab Tests (Oradell, NJ:
Medical Economic Books, 1987).
P.C. Painter, J.Y. Cope, J.L. Smith, “Reference Ranges, Table
41–20” in Tietz Textbook of Clinical Chemistry—Second Edition,
C.A. Burtis and E.R. Ashwood, eds. (Philadelphia: W.B. Saunders
Company, 1994).
CLSI Defining, Establishing and Verifying Reference Intervals in
the Clinical Laboratory – Third Edition v28 n30
Base Excess??
Standard Base Excess ?? SBE
Actual Base Excess ?? ABE
Bicarbonate
HCO3
Plasma
Standardized
K 3.5-5.2 mmol/L
Na 135-145 mmol/L
Cl 95-110 mmol/L
pH 7.30-7.40
PO2 No RR
PCO2 5.0-6.4 Kpa 40-50 mmHg
HCO3 22-28 mmol/L
Lactate < 2.0 mmol/L
Ionized Ca 1.15-1.30 mmol/L