Upload
dave-buehler
View
282
Download
1
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Basic principles from traditional Just War Theory, posing the question "Is Just War Theory obsolete"?
Citation preview
Just & Unjust Wars
Philosophy 314 D. Bühler
October 1, 2013
Just & Unjust Wars 2
•
The phrase “Just War” is bandied about by politicians, the media, historians, and church officials in discussions of the Iraq war. However, we do not often hear the actual criteria of just war theory — or a critical evaluation of how it is applied. We ought to understand the criteria that have guided both secular and religious debate about war, keeping in mind that war has meant the death of hundreds to millions of specific human lives like our own. Here are criteria for just war, as well as
a view of this concept from a general ethical perspective, plus activities to apply the criteria to a current situation, and to challenge our perspectives.
Just & Unjust Wars 3
JUST WAR CRITERIAJUST WAR CRITERIA
BEFORE A WAR:BEFORE A WAR:
1. The war must be a LAST RESORT. Every effort at negotiation and arbitration must have been tried.
2. The war must have a JUST CAUSE — to protect the innocent and to defend us against unjust demands and/or imminent threats of force.
•
Just & Unjust Wars 4
JUST WAR CRITERIAJUST WAR CRITERIA
3. The war must be waged by a . . .
LEGITIMATE AUTHORITY
4. It must be . . . FORMALLY DECLARED.
Just & Unjust Wars 5
JUST WAR CRITERIAJUST WAR CRITERIA
5. It must be fought with PEACEFUL INTENTIONS. It cannot be waged by a crusade mentality, self interest, or pride, but must be for the well-being of all people.
6. There must be a reasonable HOPE OF SUCCESS. The goals must be achievable without squandering the life and property of the people.
Just & Unjust Wars 6
JUST WAR CRITERIAJUST WAR CRITERIA
7. The means used must be
P R O P O R T I O N A T E
to the ends sought. War must NEVER cause unnecessary destruction or “collateral” damage that outweighs the final good the war seeks to achieve.
Just & Unjust Wars 7
During the war:During the war:
• NONCOMBATANTS must be given immunity. No harm is to be done to those who can do no harm (civilians).
• PRISONERS must be treated humanely.
• INTERNATIONAL TREATIES and/or Conventions must be honored.
Just & Unjust Wars 8
Just & Unjust Wars 9
If we made full use of the principles of Just War, the quality of our moral deliberation about conflict would improve. This can help us think ethically about the tendency of any society to justify its own violence, assist us to confront all the various effects of violence, and encourage us to creatively seek alternatives.
Just & Unjust Wars 10
Christians (also) critically
examine these criteria in light of the Ethic of Love, Forgiveness, and the Sanctity of each human life. Jesus lived a life of love and taught his followers to use nonviolence in their struggle for justice. This message can even transcend mere “just war “ thinking to engage alternatives ideas like “Just Peace” thinking or Christian Nonviolence.
Just & Unjust Wars 11
In the past our justifications for
war have sometimes been faulty, e.g.:
• Following the Spanish-
American war, the Philippines were handed over from Spanish to US control. When Philippine citizens resisted, the U.S went to war against them from 1899-1902.
Just & Unjust Wars 12
The rhetoric at the time was that they were an “uncivilized” people who would benefit from the hand of the US government and Christianity--and it would also open up new economic options. To growing protest at home, the US army wiped out dozens of towns. An estimated one-third of the population was killed. What was once considered a justifiable war is now seen by most historians as a bloody war of self interest. One looks in vain for a war that wasn’t considered ‘Just’ by the leading public figures of the day.
Just & Unjust Wars 13
VALUES versus VALUES versus THEORYTHEORY
Whether or not a war meets Just War Criteria, violence has drastic consequences for us as humans, and for society, our earth, and our future. Use these quotations as discussion starters for erxploring the call in the Sermon on the Mount to become peacemakers. (Use in small group or all together.
Just & Unjust Wars 14
VALUES versus THEORYVALUES versus THEORY
“If we are honest, we find the temptation to vengeance in our own hearts. Yet we know that the first real victim of violence is the perpetrator. What Gandhi said is true: ‘An eye for an eye results only in two blind persons.’”
Mary Evelyn Jegen (see also Matthew 7:1-5)
Just & Unjust Wars 15
VALUES versus THEORYVALUES versus THEORY
“All discussions of “just war” start with the assumption that war can be justifiable. This is a reprehensible assumption. What if we had discussions of “just slavery” or “just sexism”?
-John Stoner (see also Matthew 5: 38-45)
Just & Unjust Wars 16
VALUES versus THEORYVALUES versus THEORY
“Violence can never stop violence because its very success leads others to imitate it. Ironically, violence is most dangerous when it succeeds.”
- Walter Wink (see also Matthew 26:52)
Just & Unjust Wars 17
VALUES versus THEORYVALUES versus THEORY
The followers of Christ have been called to peace…. And they must not only have peace but make it. To that end they renounce all violence and tumult. In the cause of Christ nothing is to be gained by such methods.”
- Dietrich Bonhoeffer (see also 1Peter 3:11)
Just & Unjust Wars 18
VALUES versus THEORYVALUES versus THEORY
“You can no more win a war than you can win an earthquake.”
- Jeanette Rankin (see also Micah 4:2-4)
Just & Unjust Wars 19
VALUES versus THEORYVALUES versus THEORY
“It all really boils down to this:
that all life is interrelated. We are all caught in an inescapable network of mutuality, tied into a single garment of destiny. Whatever affects one directly, affects all indirectly.”
- Martin Luther King, Jr.
Just & Unjust Wars 20
Applying the CriteriaApplying the Criteria
War with Iraq: “Was” or is it a Just War?
Compare & Contrast: WW II Vietnam Wars Persian Fulf War “War on Terror” “Coming Wars” (S. Hersh)
Just & Unjust Wars 21
Applying the CriteriaApplying the CriteriaSmall Group Discussions: Each group has the task of applying their criteria to war
with Iraq, and deciding whether the war does or did not meet that standard.
Share the questions below, and ask the group questions of your own. After 10-15 minutes, have report your conclusions. Invite the rest of the group to raise questions to encourage critical thinking. Conclude with a group reflection on the main question:
Was or is the Iraq War Just?Was or is the Iraq War Just?
Just & Unjust Wars 22
Applying the CriteriaApplying the CriteriaSmall Group Discussions:
1.War must be a Last Resort: Did we try negotiation and nonviolent intervention before using violence? Are there any alternatives we missed?
2. War must have a Just Cause: What is a just cause? Who has authority to decide? What if both sides think their cause is just?
Just & Unjust Wars 23
Applying the CriteriaApplying the CriteriaSmall Group Discussions:
3. War must be waged by a Legitimate Authority: What role did or should the UN play? How do citizens give their government authority?
4. War must be Formally Declared: Did the US Congress declare war? What should the process be? What are the pros and cons of the US process? Could it ever be “too” democratic?
Just & Unjust Wars 24
Applying the CriteriaApplying the CriteriaSmall Group Discussions: 5. It must be fought with Peaceful Intentions: How could war affect
the long-term well-being of people in Iraq, the US, the world? What might be our true motivation?
6. There must be reasonable Prospect of Success: What is the goal? What could be the costs and for whom? Who decides what success is?
Who pays for it all? In money? In lives?
Just & Unjust Wars 25
Applying the CriteriaApplying the CriteriaSmall Group Discussions: 5. It must be fought with Peaceful Intentions: How could war affect
the long-term well-being of people in Iraq, the US, the world? What might be our true motivation?
6. There must be reasonable Prospect of Success: What is the goal? What could be the costs and for whom? Who decides what success is?
Who pays for it all? In money? In lives?
Just & Unjust Wars 26
Applying the CriteriaApplying the CriteriaSmall Group Discussions:
7. Means must be Proportionate to Ends: What does Proportionality mean? Will the goal outweigh the destruction?
8. Noncombatants must be given Immunity: Are the lives of civilians protected? How is this be done?
Just & Unjust Wars 27
Applying the CriteriaApplying the CriteriaSmall Group Discussions: 9. Prisoners must be treated
humanely: What does this mean? What are their rights?
10. International Treaties must be honored: Are we breaking any international agreements? How could we be sure? Why honor Agreements?
Just & Unjust Wars 28
Applying the CriteriaApplying the CriteriaSmall Group Discussions: 11. The defeated are to be shown
Mercy: Are we confident the US public supports the cost of rebuilding Iraq?
12. Was there a “revenge” motive at work in this war? If so, it was not “just.”
Just & Unjust Wars 29
Web Sites:Web Sites:
http://www.paxchristiusa.org/
http://www.usccb.org/
http://members.tripod.com/~lutheran_peace/
Just & Unjust Wars 30
Further Reading:Further Reading:
M. Walzer, Arguing about War (2004).