Upload
john-hatley-pe
View
1.028
Download
2
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
02.05.2023 [Presentation name / Author]1 © Wärtsilä INTERNAL
OPPORTUNITIES FOR SHIPPING LNG TO THE CARIBBEAN, VESSEL LNG BUSINESS CASE ECONOMICS
John Hatley PE LNG Initiatives ( MBA, MSE)
Americas VP Ship PowerWartsila North America, Inc.
Cell +1 281 221 [email protected]
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Keys
Global Energy Policies, market gamesmanship ?
Future Ahead, structural shifts?
As a vessel owner, all I want to knowis the tipping point…
What fuel strategy do I choose to to boost my bottom line?
2 © Wärtsilä
A “Commodity Play” on fuel energy costs seeking competitive advantage for market share.
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Agenda
3 © Wärtsilä
What ? Fuel Price vs. CostEnergy
Why & How ? No. Am ECA & EmissionsOwner ChoicesAbatement: SCR, Scrubber, LNG
Business Case Cargo, Investor, Banker Views20K m3 LNG CarrierInvestment Returns
Oil Price Shock ! Business Case: Robust or Fragile?Stress Test
Conclusions Business Case Appendix
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Agenda
4 © Wärtsilä
What ? Fuel Price vs. CostEnergy
Why & How ? No. Am ECA & EmissionsOwner ChoicesAbatement: SCR, Scrubber, LNG
Business Case Cargo, Investor, Banker Views20K m3 LNG CarrierInvestment Returns
Oil Price Shock ! Business Case: Robust or Fragile?Stress Test
Conclusions Business Case Appendix
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Quiz…. Fuel Price ?
a) HFO 290.83 $ / ton ….
b) MDO 314.68 $ / ton .…
c) LNG 363.01 $ / ton ….
5 © Wärtsilä
Which is the lowest price ?
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
The Price Paid for what it Cost
6 © Wärtsilä
: the amount of money that you pay for something
: the price of something : the amount of money that is needed to pay for or buy something
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Quiz… Fuel Answer Key
a) HFO 290.83 $ / ton ….
b) MDO 314.68 $ / ton .…
c) LNG 363.01 $ / ton ….
7 © Wärtsilä
Which is the lowest price ?
Key concept… purchase energy, not tons or gallons, which is the lowest cost per unit of energy?
7.77 $ / million BTU
7.77 $ / million BTU
7.77 $ / million BTU
Reference Common Values that will vary…HFO 37,430 BTU/kg MDO 40,500 BTU/kg LNG 46,720 BTU/kg density 980 kg/ m3 850 kg/ m3 430 kg/ m3
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Agenda
8 © Wärtsilä
What ? Fuel Price vs. CostEnergy
Why & How ? No. Am ECA & EmissionsOwner ChoicesAbatement: SCR, Scrubber, LNG
Business Case Cargo, Investor, Banker Views20K m3 LNG CarrierInvestment Returns
Oil Price Shock ! Business Case: Robust or Fragile?Stress Test
Conclusions Business Case Appendix
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Emission Control Areas
9 © Wärtsilä
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
2015 ECA 0.1% Sulfur
10 © Wärtsilä
Works with high S HFO Low total lifecycle cost Use everywhere
Scrubber targets SOx, Selective Catalytic Reducer targets NOx, LNG targets CO2, NOx, PM, SOx.
Source: 2015 Exhaust Gas Cleaning Scrubbers Dec 2015 011415.pptx
How clean is Natural Gas compared to Diesel ?
DF Natural Gas Engine
DieselEngine
0
20
40
60
80
100
Emissionvalues [%]
CO2
NOx
SOx
Particulates
-25%
-85%
-99%
-99%
Gas = ULTRA CLEAN
LNG provides significant emission reductions compared to traditional diesel engines
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
No. Am. ECA Fuel Sulfur Limit
12 Wärtsilä
Source:http://www.dnvusa.com/industry/maritime/publicationsanddownloads/publications/newsletters/technical_regulatory/2012/north_american_emission_control_area.asp
Fuel Sulfur 0.10 % limit commences 1 January 2015
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
North America ECA SOx & NOx
13 © Wärtsilä
Fuel Sulfur2012… 1% Limit2015… 0.1% Limit
IMO Category 3 2016… NOx Tier III
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Decision Tree… New Build Vessel
14 © Wärtsilä
New Build
Diesel
HFO
LNG
Scrubber … Fuel Sulfur Compliance
LNG Compliance
ECA January 2016 multiple emission requirements; both fuel sulfur limits (2015) and engine emissions IMO Tier 3 requirements in effect.
New tier 3 IMO engine + after-treatment SCR
0.1% Sulfur… Fuel Compliance
New tier 3 IMO engine + after-treatment SCR + Scrubber
New tier 3 IMO engine + LNG cryogenics
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
New Build Attributes
15 © Wärtsilä Source: Wartsila Moss White Paper: Exhaust Gas Cleaning: How to Choose the Correct Scrubber, Jennifer Ahlback, 2014.
Excess baggage as systems require host support; chemicals, tanks, waste stream sludge, piping/pumps, controls/automation, soot blowers…
Diesel + SCR
LNG
HFO + SCR + Scrubber
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Wartsila NOx Reducer System
16 © Wärtsilä
Soot Blower
Air
Pump
Mixing Duct
Dosing Unit
NOR Reactor
Controls
Urea Tank
CompressedAir
Urea Mixing & Injection
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
LNGPac System
17 © Wärtsilä
Source: http://www.wartsila.com/media/news/26-08-2014-wartsila-launches-new-technical-solution-for-fuel-gas-handling
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL18 © Wärtsilä
Exhaust Gas Fan
Alkali Feed Module
Bleed-Off Treatment
Process Tank
Alkali Storage Tank
CW Pump
Heat Exchgr
Scrubbing Water Pump
Exhaust Gas Analyzer
Sludge Tank
Water Measurement
Water Measurement
De- Plume Unit
Holding Tank
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
2015 ECA + 2016 NOx Refit Existing Vessel Choices
1. Consume compliant Low Sulfur Distillate… champagne fuel + Selective Catalytic Reduction for NOx
2. Switch to LNG fuel: safe, clean, abundant, affordable, & available natural gas LNGReduction: CO2, NOx, SOx, PM
3. HFO Alternative Compliance… install scrubber for Sox + Selective Catalytic Reduction for NOx
4. Abort the Port
2 May 2023
ECA & EPA force timely choices existing retrofit vessels
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Agenda
20 © Wärtsilä
What ? Fuel Price vs. CostEnergy
Why & How ? No. Am ECA & EmissionsOwner ChoicesAbatement: SCR, Scrubber, LNG
Business Case Cargo, Investor, Banker Views20K m3 LNG CarrierInvestment Returns
Oil Price Shock ! Business Case: Robust or Fragile?Stress Test
Conclusions Business Case Appendix
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Cautionary Remarks
• Each investment case requires careful analysis, inclusion, and weighing a broad variety of issues stemming from technical, financial, operational, regulatory, and other areas.
• The purpose of this exercise is to illustrate a Business Case example and how a few of many key considerations may be transcribed into financial modeling as an aide to decision making.
• Readers are advised that neither the Author nor Wartsila nor it’s subsidiaries are responsible for any errors, omissions, or updates to this information contained herein or assumptions or derivations whatsoever.
21 © Wärtsilä
This presentation is no substitute for your good and responsible decision making. Please utilize prudence and caution when making investment decisions along with securing the advice and guidance of professionals.
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
4 Viewpoints
22 © Wärtsilä
SHIP OWNER
BANKER
PUBLIC
Transport safely at
optimal cost reliably
At fair return capturing
risks
Are risks understood
& I’m repaid !
Ultimate Environment
Safety
CARGO OWNER
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
4 Key Metrics
23 © Wärtsilä
SHIP OWNER
BANKER
PUBLIC
All In Charter
Freight rate $ / ton
Return on Investment:
ROIC, EBITDA, cash flows
EBIT, Times Burden Cover,
cash flows
Ultimate Environment
Safety
CARGO OWNER
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
LNG Demand
2 May 202324 © Wärtsilä
Mostly small markets… total generating capacity exceeds 10 Giga Watts… = LNG ~17.2 mtpa… ~40 mm m3
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Where’s the LNG fuel need?
Source: U.S. Energy Information Administration; ‘Net electricity consumption 2010’
Concentrated electrical power demand… top 3 countries consume more than half the region’s 10 Giga Watts.
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
The Route: Corpus Christi - Jamaica
26 © Wärtsilä
15% “ECA” Bound route, 2634 nm round trip, 0.5 days load/unload per port, 341 operating days per year
Source: http://www.sea-distances.org/
549 mW Utility Power: Demand 710K tons LNG @ 100%
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Business Case Vessel
27 © Wärtsilä
2 vessels on route transport 600K tons LNG per year, satisfy 549 mW Utility Power @ 92% load ( maxima 100% demand 710k tons LNG /yr. )
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Business Case Vessel
US Corporation, Foreign Flag
20,000 m3 LNG Carrier
New build
Design Speed 15.0 knots with margin
Installed power 7,980 HP ( 5,950 kW )
Major Class Society
28 © Wärtsilä
Speed provides 38 annual round trips, … competitive vessel size transport
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Recall ?
29 © Wärtsilä
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Then… 5 August 2014
30 Wärtsilä
LS180 1% 636 $/mt… LSMGO 0.1% 971 $/mt… LNG 500 $/mt
Source: http://www.bunkerworld.com/prices/port/us/hou/
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Cargo Owner Transport safely at optimal cost reliably
31 © Wärtsilä
Cargo owner with LNG captures significant emissions reductions supporting green goals.
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Ship Owner A fair return capturing risks
32 © Wärtsilä
Compelling fuel payback for vessels running on LNG fuel; an initial screening tool … not a good investment metric.
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
ROCE Investment Criteria
33 © Wärtsilä
ROCE: reflects the company fundamental earning power.
Source: Robert Higgens, Analysis for Financial Management, 10 th Edition, pg 53-55.
• Return on Capital Employed (Return on Invested Capital, ROIC ) reflects the company fundamental earning power as it removes the distorting effects of leverage inherent with Return on Equity (ROE).
Shipping companies often target 12% ROCE
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Ship Owner A fair return capturing risks
34 © Wärtsilä
Investor finds LNG Competitive Advantage for return on capital… LNG hurdle rate is highest & yet preserves cargo owner savings in emission reduction.
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL 35 © Wärtsilä
Warren Buffett… World Famous InvestorEBITDA as equivalent to earnings for a company is tantamount to the Egyptian Pyramids: forever state of the art…with never a need to be replaced, improved or refurbished…
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
The Pyramids
• Earnings Before Interest Taxes Depreciation Amortization
EBITDA may overstate available cash flow… when used carefully and fully understood it may indicate what is available to pay bank debt and shareholders.
Often viewed as one of many economic indicators of company performance by financiers/investors/bankers.
Is often utilized when company has significant fixed assets.
36 © Wärtsilä
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL 37 © Wärtsilä
LNG fuel has strongest EBITDA… + $1.7 Million over HFO+ Scrubber and + $1.9 Million atop MDO.
Years
EBITDA
MDO Fuel
HFO + Scrubber
LNG Fuel
Ship Owner A fair return capturing risks
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Banker Are risks understood & I’m repaid !
38 © Wärtsilä
Banker finds debt cover is weakest on MDO fuel, favorably stronger on alternatives, LNG is strongest.
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
The Pyramids
• Earnings Before Interest Taxes
EBIT = Revenue minus expenses, excluding tax & interest
EBIT may conservatively understate available cash flow… when used carefully and fully understood it may indicate what is available to pay bank debt and shareholders.
Often viewed as one of many economic indicators of company performance by financiers/investors/bankers.
EBIT nulls the effects of different capital structures and tax rates. EBIT was the precursor to EBITDA.
39 © Wärtsilä
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL 40 © Wärtsilä
Years
EBIT
Banker Are risks understood & I’m repaid !
LNG has strongest EBIT… Depreciation 10 Year MACRS ½ Year Convention… Dry docking years 5,10,15,20
LNG Fuel
HFO + Scrubber
MDO Fuel
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Agenda
41 © Wärtsilä
What ? Fuel Price vs. CostEnergy
Why & How ? No. Am ECA & EmissionsOwner ChoicesAbatement: SCR, Scrubber, LNG
Business Case Cargo, Investor, Banker Views20K m3 LNG CarrierInvestment Returns
Oil Price Shock ! Business Case: Robust or Fragile?Stress Test
Conclusions Business Case Appendix
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
US #1 Shale Resources
42 © Wärtsilä
1,161 tcf gas & 120 billion barrels oil
Development rapid with technology advances in horizontal drilling, fracking, and computer seismic abilities.
In 5 years US became world’s largest producer of gas
Strong infrastructure & know how
Source:http://www.eia.gov/conference/2013/pdf/presentations/kuuskraa.pdf
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Shale Gas
43 © Wärtsilä
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Shale Oil
44 © Wärtsilä
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
28 November 2014
45 © Wärtsilä
Source: http://www.reuters.com/article/us-opec-meeting-idUSKCN0JA0O320141128
Key OPEC Vienna meeting sets stage for market share battle. Brent begins steep fall.
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
5 January 2015
46 © Wärtsilä
Source: http://www.forbes.com/sites/nathanvardi/2015/01/05/saudi-arabias-750-billion-bet-drives-brent-oil-below-54/
Exert Discipline in the Marketplace amongst OPEC and Non OPEC countries... Key focus on market share… oil prices plunging.
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Discipline Target US or Russia ?
47 © Wärtsilä
Russia suffering double whammy:
Oil rich Ukraine and Black Sea burdened by politics under imposed sanctions as oil takes severe price slide…Ruble plunges down against USD
Source: http://online.wsj.com/articles/ruble-hits-new-low-as-oil-prices-drop-1417441184
Source: http://www.usnews.com/news/articles/2014/11/10/an-oil-price-cold-war-with-saudi-arabia-not-so-fast-experts-say
Source: http://www.businessinsider.com/ruble-plunging-again-2014-12p://online.wsj.com/articles/ruble-hits-new-low-as-oil-prices-drop-1417441184
1 December 2014
December 31, 2014
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL Source: http://www.businessinsider.com/citi-saudi-arabia-wont-win-this-oil-standoff-2014-11 48 © Wärtsilä
Profits negative… Severe Pain
Profits squeezed…Manageable Pain
45 $/BBL
Key Oil Production Cost
40$/BBL
Total Liquids Production
Brent Breakeven Price
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
2014 Production
49 © Wärtsilä
US vaults to 1st in production oil and other liquids
OPEC
OPEC
OPEC
OPEC
OPEC
OPEC
OPEC
OPEC
Source: ttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_oil_production
http://www.eia.gov/beta/international/rankings/#?prodact=53-1&cy=2014
Saudi Arabia11.6 m BBL/day
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Government Breakeven Budgets
50 © Wärtsilä
Severe shortfalls @ prices under 100$/BBL, present oil glut & soft prices challenge sustainability beyond short run
Source: https://alfinnextlevel.files.wordpress.com/2014/04/oil_breakeven_deutsche_bank_oct_14.png40 $/BBL
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Brent Crude Oil Prices
51 © Wärtsilä
Source: http://www.nasdaq.com/markets/crude-oil-brent.aspx?timeframe=1y
THEN
NOW
Oil severe price 70% price drop past 18 months as abundant supplies face weak demand from China and stagnant EU.
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
What’s the impact of the steep fall in oil prices !
Is competitive advantage of LNG robust or fragile ?
52 © Wärtsilä
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Recent … 28 January 2016
53 © Wärtsilä
Port Houston Delivered Price
LS380 1% Sulfur 139 $ / ton
LSMGO 0.1% Sulfur 333 $ / ton
Source: http://www.kpibridgeoil.com/
LS180 1% 139 $/mt… LSMGO 0.1% 333 $/mt…
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
LNG Price 08 February 2016
Fixed Liquefaction Charge 4.60 CAD $/ GJVariable Sumas Gas Basis + 3.00 CAD $/ GJTotal FOB LNG Price 7.60 CAD $/ GJ
conversion to million BTU x 1.05435 LNG FOB price 8.02 CAD $/ mm BTU
exchange rate x 0.72 USD $ / CAD $ Price LNG FOB 5.77 US $ / mm BTU
54 © Wärtsilä
Allow 2.00 US $/mmBTU transport = 7.77 or LNG 363 $/mt
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Owner A fair return capturing risks of oil fall 28 Jan 2016
55 © Wärtsilä
LNG emissions savings remains for shipper but returns on LNG moderate climb for investor amidst oil glut steep price dive.
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Fuel Stress Test: 15% ECA
THEN 5 August 2014
14.17% @ LNG 500 $/mt 12.80% @ MDO 971 $/mt 12.44% @ HFO 636 $/mt
56 © Wärtsilä
Deviation
ROCE
NOW 28 January 2016
15.22% @ LNG 363 $/mt 17.87% @ MDO 333 $/mt17.23% @ HFO 139 $/mt
LNG robust despite steep crude drop; today choose MDO for best ROCE, but sustainable? Volatility returns MDO & HFO similar, least LNG but also provides shipper lowest emissions. Small % voyage ECA; MDO inside ECA & HFO outside superior.
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Agenda
57 © Wärtsilä
What ? Fuel Price vs. CostEnergy
Why & How ? No. Am ECA & EmissionsOwner ChoicesSCR, Scrubber, LNG Abatement
Business Case Cargo, Investor, Banker Views20K m3 LNG CarrierInvestment Returns
Oil Price Shock ! Business Case: Robust or Fragile?Stress Test
Conclusions Business Case Appendix
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
Keys
Global Energy Policies, market gamesmanship ?
Future Ahead, structural shifts?
As a vessel owner, all I want to knowis the tipping point…
What fuel strategy do I choose to to boost my bottom line?
58 © Wärtsilä
A “Commodity Play” on fuel energy costs seeking competitive advantage for market share.
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
BUSINESS CASE DETAILSAPPENDIX
59 Wärtsilä
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Financials
60 Wärtsilä
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Key Values
61 Wärtsilä
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Key Values
62 Wärtsilä
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
Fuel Attributes
63 © Wärtsilä
Utilize fuels specific for regional case... As fuels widely vary, the historic dollars per ton or gallon is challenging to use as differing fuels host widely varying energy content, density, value... These values shown are generally representative.
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
EBITDA
64 © Wärtsilä
© Wärtsilä INTERNAL
EBIT
65 © Wärtsilä