Citizen Journalism 1

Impact of Citizen Journalism on Traditional Media

Name

Instructor

Date

Institution

Citizen Journalism 2

Abstract

The increase of citizen journalism and the widespread trend of content generated by

individuals is creating challenges and opportunities for the traditional media. Traditional media

such as newspapers are trying to incorporate the new wave of user-generated content into their

professional news coverage. This study aims at identifying how citizen journalism has influenced

professional or traditional journalism. It explains how citizen journalism has impacted on the

traditional media. Qualitative and quantitative data from various journalism databases has been

analyzed, and the conclusions reveal that citizen journalism has had both positive and negative

impacts on traditional journalism. Citizen journalism has challenged traditional journalism

resulting into new profound ways of transmitting information to the audience. Consequently,

traditional journalists have been on their toes trying to remain relevant in the journalism field.

They have changed the way in which information is delivered to the audience.

Keywords: citizen journalism, traditional journalism, transmitting information, audience,

internet, technology

Citizen Journalism 3

Introduction

Due to the recent advancements in technology, traditional journalism has undergone

various innovative changes. With the introduction of citizen journalism, ordinary citizens have

had the opportunity of participating in the global media community by providing instantaneous

new through a variety of media platforms (Alejandro, 2010). The media industry players have

noted this shift in journalism. The audience has moved from using newspapers and

radio/television as their only source of information, and retorted to use quicker outlets. There

have been numerous views from individuals in the presence of citizen journalism sphere. A

journalist is an individual who collects information and portrays it to the public. Chung & Nah

(2013) narrates how in the 21st century, defining a professional journalists is getting more

difficult says. Currently, journalism is termed as a trade rather than a profession. Not every

individual who owns a computer and is connected to the internet is likely to be a reporter. A

reporter is that individual who has some information and intends to inform others (Newman,

2009). In the developed countries, almost every household has a computer and internet

connection. Sharing information involving oneself has become less complex due to this. With

such, one would own a press and make the news. With the increase in citizen journalism, many

individuals are getting their news from these individuals rather than from professional

journalists.

What impact does citizen journalism have on the traditional journalism? Of all sectors of

professional media, the newspapers have had the longest history of delivering news. Despite the

Citizen Journalism 4

discovery of television and radio stations, whose coverage was more vivid and attractive, the

newspapers survived and adapted to keeping up with times. However, due to the explosion of the

internet, the newspapers have had a difficult time. They have retorted to using online platforms

to deliver their news so that viewers can get free content online (Rhinesmith, Wolske, & Kehoe,

2011). Others like the New York Times have put up a subscription wall for some select content

where one has to pay to access the content. This move has, however, been criticized by others

while others applaud it and implement the same. But, how should the newspapers harness the

influence of the internet?

This is not the only issue that the newspapers are facing today. The growth of citizen

journalism, whether informal or formal, is changing how the society receives information.

Shapiro (2010) claims that there has been an increase in the number of bloggers over the past

years. Currently, individuals consume content created by citizens. But does citizen journalism

affects how people receive and report news as it has been hyped?

This has been crucial concern for most professional journalists and newspapers because,

in the near future, newspapers may lose their obligation. It is thus obvious that journalists are

concerned. Also, the use of the word citizen in journalism has raised some concern among

citizens themselves. It carries implications of involvement in a democratic society (Shapiro,

2010). Is citizen journalism recognized in the democratic society, and what are the implications

for the society?

Citizen journalism is, therefore, an activity of journalism where ordinary citizens take the

role of independent agents and produce news through the help of various participatory and

interactive tools (Chung and Nah, 2013). Advancements in technology have facilitated creation

Citizen Journalism 5

of content and audiences get a chance to comment online thus making this kind of journalism

different from the traditional media (Hass, 2005 in Chung and Nah, 2013). This study aims at

identifying how citizen journalism has influenced professional or traditional journalism. It

explains how citizen journalism has impacted on the traditional media.

Literature Review

In order to understand the impact of citizen journalism on traditional media, it is

necessary to highlight some background information on certain prime areas. For instance, it is

vital to understand the role played by journalism, the various forms of citizen journalism, and the

on-going debate on issues pertaining citizen journalism.

The Different Forms of Journalism

Alejandro (2010) describes journalism as a necessary element that plays the role of a

watchdog for a strong democracy. This responsibility bestowed on journalists is vital. Michael

Schudson defines journalism as: “the business of a set of institutions that publicizes periodically

(usually daily) information and commentary on contemporary affairs, normally presented as true

and sincere, to a dispersed and anonymous audience so as to publicly include the audience in a

discourse taken to be publicly important” as cited in (Goh, 2007).

Adam (1993) defines journalism as a form of expression that is used to report in the

public media on events happening. Different people have various ways of defining journalism.

What stands out is the fact that journalism is a means or a system in which individuals transmit

information to the public with an intention of informing people of events occurring around them.

Citizen Journalism 6

This, therefore, shows that journalism can take several forms; professional journalism and citizen

journalism.

Citizen journalism can be defined as “playing an active role in the process of collecting,

reporting, analysing and (distributing) news and information” (Bowman and Willis, 2003, pp.9

as cited in Jack, no date). Jack (no date) Points out the difference between participatory

journalism and citizen journalism. He asserts that participatory journalism includes interactions

between the audience and the journalists. The audience comment on existing stories and engage

in an interactive discussion with the journalist. On the other hand, citizen journalism involves

production of journalistic material that mirrors journalism in the fact that, the citizens creating

these materials have the intention of them being used by the public just like mainstream media.

Thomas (2013) however uses a generalized definition of citizen journalism and implies

that: “journalists now need to think about a global audience that not only reads whet they write

and report but can comment, provide perspective, and offer new insight into the complexities of

an increasingly global society” (Thomas, 2013). Phil Primack asserts that: “journalism is a

science that requires some training and qualifications, certain ethical standards, and credibility”

cited in (Thomas, 2013). This, therefore, shows that not everyone could practice journalism.

However, over the past years, journalism has taken a new turn affecting how news is reported.

Evaluating Citizen Journalism

At the ground level, one might tend to think that citizen journalism intends to overthrow

mainstream media. This is, however, not the case. The rise of citizen journalism is not

necessarily an act of overthrowing the traditional media; rather it complements and supplements

Citizen Journalism 7

it. Both kinds of journalism cannot survive independently (Thomas, 2013). They rely on each

other in various sectors.

These two forms of journalism have several similarities and differences. While

mainstream media is highly centralized, and requires ample investment of resources and may

substantially be influenced by government bodies, citizen journalism is the direct opposite.

Citizen journalism is de-centralized, requires little investment, and is difficult to control. Due to

this, citizen journalism has surprisingly gained immense popularity and acceptance in the society

(Salman et al., 2011).

The rise of citizen journalism is not necessarily an act of overthrowing the traditional

media; rather it complements and supplements it (Thomas, 2013). Nonetheless, the conventional

media owners may not concur. With the emergence of citizen journalism, conventional

journalists worry about losing their influence on news coverage, and consequently their

profitability. Their fear was not only based on the colourful and fast nature of reporting, but also

on the psychology it created on people (Daud, 2008 Cited in Salman et al., 2011).

In Malaysia, despite the fact that the internet has become the foremost source of news,

newspapers remain the chief source of information. People tend to rely more on this source of

information because its content is reliable. Citizen journalism has had issues of privacy,

unreliability, and content accuracy (Salman et al., 2011). (Chung and Nah, 2013) States: “while

media credibility is but a small portion of the extensive discussion on media ethics, it is closely

tied to the ideas of objectivity and the pursuit of truth…” different individuals view the aspect of

credibility and reliability differently. Chung and Nah (2013) points out that while the traditional

Citizen Journalism 8

journalism may be perceived to be more credible; citizen journalism appears to be more credible

especially on issues pertaining to politics.

Positive Impacts of Citizen Journalism

A look at the Iranian protests in 2009, this is an excellent example of how technology has

impacted on news coverage. The government was fighting to restrict information from getting

out. However, the citizens and other media stations were more than determined to let out the

story. Citizens armed with their phones and digital cameras recorded the protests on the streets.

The footage was uploaded to social media sites and also to other mainstream media such as CNN

and BBC. The speed at which citizens uploaded and distributed these footages helped in bringing

out this story into the open (Newman, 2009).

Through citizen journalism, such stories that occur abruptly may pass by since it is not

always that professional journalists get to be at the right place at the right time. This kind of

journalism gives voice to the “marginalized” people allowing them to tell their side of the story.

This rarely occurs in the mainstream media as the government has a way of silencing the media

from airing content that may be deemed “not appropriate.” During the Westgate attack in Kenya,

there were claims of looting by the Kenyans soldiers (see appendix 1). CCTV footage that

recorded this ordeal were not aired, however, there were pictures that circulated in social media

that revealed that safes, cash drawers, and shelves were broken into (Okari, 2014). The

government may want to conceal such footages from going live, but owing to citizen journalism,

the facts got out.

In 2010 and 2011, there were ample of videos and pictures covering conflicts in North

Africa and the Middle East. These videos were uploaded by ordinary citizens who were

Citizen Journalism 9

devastated and experienced the conflicts first-hand. Another example of citizen journalism in the

process was the “Hudson River plane crash” (see appendix 2) individuals used their mobile

devices and recorded the incident which made headlines news. The online social platform was

booming with numerous pictures from eye witnesses. These images were later used by the

professional journalists and saw their way into newsrooms and newspapers. People got

information minutes after the crash, and it would have taken mainstream media hours to air the

crash. Citizen journalism does help in capturing real events occurring in real times.

Although citizen journalism has been applauded for providing timely and true updates, to

others, it has caused pain. For instance, are situations where the police have been taken on

camera treating citizens brutally (see appendix 5). This ultimately led to their dismissal. To most

citizens, this is a positive action that sheds light on the brutality of the police. However, to the

government it portrays a fractured judicial system. For instance, in America, George Holiday

recorded a video showing the beating of Rodney King by the police. The video went viral, and

George Holliday was termed as “the man who pioneered citizen journalism” (see appendix 3).

Citizen journalism is however not always applauded. Some of the footages that

individuals upload online cost people their careers and reputation. Mobile phones and digital

cameras, if used inappropriately, can obliterate an individual’s honour. Some high profile people

have had their reputation refuted when videos were uploaded online. In other cases, Narces

Benoit (Arsenault, 2011) was jailed when policemen caught him trying to videotape a shooting

(see appendix 4). This is just one of the many attempts at citizen journalism gone wrong.

Citizen journalism has taken the step of filling gaps left by mainstream media by

providing information that the mainstream media has intentionally or unintentionally avoided.

Citizen Journalism 10

Though citizen journalism has been hyped, Thomas (2013) points out that there have been

concerns about the credibility and accuracy of the information produced by citizens. Regrettably,

some information conveyed by citizen journalists may be untrue thus misinforming.

Methodology

So as to achieve the objective of this study, data was taken from various journalism

articles and initial researches involving the impact of citizen journalism on traditional media. An

online survey was done on various journalism databases. Data was gathered from diverse sources

so as to get diverse opinions on the issue. The key aspect of this methodology was ensuring that

every source material was relevant to the question in hand and that the sources were legit. The

researcher compared past data with present data to track down the changes that have taken place

since the onset of online platforms.

So as to verify the credibility of information provided, the researcher visited several

blogs, twitter pages, wiki reports and CNN coverage which showed aspects of citizen journalism

in action. In addition, online journalism databases, journal articles, and related excerpts from

web pages and books, assisted in building up the literature review. Combining data from both

primary and secondary journals gave the researcher quantitative and qualitative data, which was

used to list the findings of the research.

Analysis and Findings

Analysis of the various articles reviewed showed that citizen journalism is on the rise.

There is a large population of citizen journalism across the borders. This trend of citizen

journalism is mostly prominent in developed countries where individuals have access to free

internet and personal computers. However, even in the less developed countries, use of social

Citizen Journalism 11

media platform is prominent. Individuals have mobile gadgets that are capable of recording

videos and taking photos and ultimately ability to upload them on an online platform.

Fullerton (no date) implies that about a third of individuals using the internet have at one

point uploaded content that is intended to be viewed on the world wide web. The affordability

and the availability of the necessary gadgets to report news to the world on a personalized level

have had both positive and negative impact on the traditional journalism.

There have been several instances where citizen journalism has complemented the

mainstream media in providing first-hand footage of particular occurrences. A right photo or

video footage at the right time could make a story and change how the world views a certain

incident. A wrong one could adversely affect the world’s view and create a false impression. The

“Hudson River plane crash” and the Westgate attack in Kenya are examples of citizen journalism

footages that complemented mainstream media coverage by proving first-hand information on

the happenings of both incidences.

Citizen journalism could also have a negative impact on mainstream media. Getler (2001)

says that the media always gets the blame for any fictitious stories that are posted. Most

individuals do not consider that there are different forms of journalism, and in most instances,

the mainstream journalism is always the scapegoat and receives the scolding.

Citizen journalism has enforced mainstream media to retort to other ways of delivering

news so that they can remain relevant in the current technology. One can now read the

newspaper online. This is because citizen journalism is freely available to all at any time. Most

newspapers have also included some bloggers as part of their team. This type of collaboration

could turn out to be powerful and accommodating. They can reach a particular audience through

Citizen Journalism 12

the social media websites. Also, most media houses have also included segments in the coverage

that allow submissions of videos by citizens. Furthermore, the media houses have also opened

Facebook pages and twitter accounts, which they use for transferring information to their

audience.

The increase in online content provided by citizen journalists has also raised some doubts

concerning the future of newsrooms. Smaller media firms struggle with the reduced profitability

because individuals lack interest in buying print editions. Despite the negative impact citizen

journalism has caused on traditional media, their existence and development has changed how

information is delivered to the audience.

Conclusion

To sum up, with the advancements in technology and widespread internet, it was

inevitable for citizen journalism to grow. According to Yapp (2008) cited in (Salman et al., 2011,

pp. 9) “some observers think that conventional media practitioners should do some serious soul-

searching and accurately feel the pulse of the nation in order to stay relevant.” Traditional

journalism has now begun to implement some new tactics so as to remain in the game.

With the current generation, the journalism world is in a transition from the old tactics of

mainstream reporting and coverage of new tactics. The new trend has its difficulties as

traditional journalism will still withstand time. It, however, faces some challenges while trying to

compete with the citizen journalism. As Thomas (2013) asserts, the rise of citizen journalism is

Citizen Journalism 13

not necessarily an act of overthrowing the traditional media; rather it complements and

supplements it. This type of collaboration could turn out to be powerful and accommodating.

.

References

Adam, G. S. (1993) “Notes towards a definition of journalism: Understanding an old craft as an

art form.” St. Petersburg, Florida: Poynter Institute for Media Studies. Reprinted in:

Adam, G. S.,& Clark, R. P. (2006). Journalism: The democratic craft. New York: Oxford

University Press

Alejandro, J. (2010). Journalism in the Age of Social Media. Available from

https://reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac.uk/sites/default/files/Journalism%20in%20the

%20Age%20of%20Social%20Media.pdf [Accessed: 21st March, 2015]

Citizen Journalism 14

Arsenault, C. (2011) US police smash camera for recording killing [internet]. Available from

http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/features/2011/06/201162114131825860.html

[Accessed: 21st March, 2015]

Beaumont, C. (2009) New York Plane crash: Twitter Breaks The News Again. Available from

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/twitter/4269765/New-York-plane-crash-Twitter-

breaks-the-news-again.html [Accessed: 21st March, 2015]

Bowman, S., & Willis, C. (2003) We Media: How Audiences Are Shaping The Future Of News

And Information. Reston, VA: American Press Institute.

Chung, D. S., & Nah, S. (2013). Media Credibility and Journalistic Role Conceptions: Views on

Citizen and Professional Journalists among Citizen Contributors, Journal of Mass Media

Ethics:[internet], 28(4), pp. 271-288. Available from doi:10.1080/08900523.2013.826987

Deuze, M. (2005). “What is journalism? Professional identity and ideology of journalists

reconsidered.”. journalism, 6(4), pp. 442-464.

Daud, N. M. 2008. “Trends & Future of the Malaysian Mass Media.” A Series of Lectures on

Fullerton, I. “Everybody’s A Reporter: The City Makes It Easier For Journalists Of All Stripes

To Get To Where The Action Is [internet]. Available from http://

www.chicagoreader.com/chicago/everybodys-a-reporter/Content?oid=2396147

Hass, T. (2005). From “public journalism” to the “public’s journalism”? Rhetoric and reality

in the discourse of weblogs. journalism studies, 6(3), pp. 387–396.

Citizen Journalism 15

Jack, M. (n.d.). The Social Evolution of Citizen Journalism. Canadian journal of media

studies, 6(1), pp. 95-158. Available from The Social Evolution of Citizen JournalismMassarotto, R. first ever viral video. The story by George holliday. Available from

http://www.rodneykingvideo.com.ar/ [Accessed: 21st March, 2015].

Newman, N. (2009). The rise of social media and its impact on mainstream journalism: A

study of how newspapers and broadcasters in the UK and US are responding to a

wave of participatory social media, and a historic shift in control towards individual

consumers. Available from

https://reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac.uk/sites/default/files/The%20rise%20of

%20social%20media%20and%20its%20impact%20on%20mainstream

%20journalism.pdf [Accessed: 21st March, 2015]Okari, D. (2014). What happened about the looting? Available from

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-29282045 [Accessed: 21st March, 2015].

Rhinesmith, C., Wolske, M., & Kehoe, A. (2011). Measuring the Impact of Citizen

Journalism:A Study of Community Newsrooms in North Champaign and East

St.Louis, Illinois. Available from

http://ccnr.infotech.monash.edu/assets/docs/prato2011papers/rhinesmith.pdf

[Accessed: 21st March, 2015]

Salman, A., Ibrahim, F., Ab dullah, M. Y., Mustaffa, N., & Mahbob, M. H. (2011). The

Impact of New Media on Traditional Mainstream Mass Media. The Public Sector

Citizen Journalism 16

innovation journal , 16(3), pp. 1-11. Available from

http://www.innovation.cc/scholarly-style/ali_samman_new+media_impac116v3i7a.p

df [Accessed: 21st March, 2015]

Schudson, M. (2003). The sociology of news. New York: Norton.

Shapiro, I. (2010). Evaluating journalism: Towards an assessment framework for the practice

of journalism. journalism practice, 4(2), pp. 143-162.

Thomas, C. (2013). A study on social media’s impact on a journalist’s role, method and

relationship to the audience (Master's thesis, University of Gothenburg, Department

of Applied Information Technology, sweden). Available from

https://gupea.ub.gu.se/bitstream/2077/33941/1/gupea_2077_33941_1.pdf [Accessed:

21st March, 2015]

Trends & Future of the Malaysian Mass Media, presented at Dewan Tunku Canselor,

University of Malaya KualaLum purGoh, R. (2007). mainstream media meets citizen

journalism: in search of a new model (Master's thesis). Available from

http://www.mediagiraffe.org/tufts-thesis/tufts-thesis.pdf [Accessed: 21st March,

2015]The Rise And Impact Of Citizen Journalism. Available from

http://hightechgalore.blogspot.com/2012/10/the-rise-and-impact-of-citizen.html

[Accessed: 21st March, 2015].

Citizen Journalism 17

Appendices

Appendix 1: looting by the soldiers in the Westgate attack in Kenya

Citizen Journalism 18

Appendix 2: Hudson River plane crash

Citizen Journalism 19

Appendix 3: beating of Rodney King by the police.

The video can be seen here https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=xZDrZDEqeKk

Appendix 4: police shooting as recorded by Narces Benoit can be found http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/features/2011/06/201162114131825860.html

Citizen Journalism 20

Appendix 5: police treating citizens brutally

Citizen Journalism 21