48
GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159

GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

GENE 3000Fall 2013

slides 127-159

Page 2: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki
Page 3: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

wiki. wiki. wiki.

Page 4: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki
Page 5: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

4 species can be related to each other in only 3 ways

Page 6: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

4 species can be related to each other in only 3 ways

A B

C

Page 7: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

evolution - story of gain and loss

•when and how were complex eyes evolved? in what species are they lost? are the genes required to develop eyes still there? can they be expressed in different ways?

•how frequently are genes gained and lost? how often is there lateral gene transfer between hosts and pathogens, or microbes?

•why are there more A/T bases in parts of the mitochondrion?

Page 8: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

Nature, June 2012

Page 9: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

all starts with this

Page 10: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

terms• phylogeny: visual representation of the

evolutionary history of populations, genes, species

• tips: terminal ends of a phylogeny, representing the populations, genes, species

• branches: lineages evolving through time

• node: where lineages split; the common ancestor to descendants

• clade: a group all descended from one ancestor

Page 11: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

terms• phylogeny: visual representation of the

evolutionary history of populations, genes, species

• tips: terminal ends of a phylogeny, representing the populations, genes, species

• branches: lineages evolving through time

• node: where lineages split; the common ancestor to descendants

• clade: a group all descended from one ancestordiscovermagazine.com

Page 12: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki
Page 13: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki
Page 14: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

organisms are related through descent from

ancestors

progression of generations

Page 15: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki
Page 16: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki
Page 17: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki
Page 18: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki
Page 19: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

more than 2 million identified and classified

species extant

Page 20: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

taxonomy (systematics)

•groups defined on previous slides are clades

•group comprised of one organism and all its descendants (mono-phyly)

•indication of homology

Page 21: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki
Page 22: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

Archosaurs

Page 23: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

how do we know?

•inference, reconstruction

•characters are heritable traits that can be compared (an A in position 117; body hair)

•careful evaluation of homology

•assume that having more things in common indicates more recent common ancestor (longer shared history)

Page 24: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

homology and homoplasy

•similarity without shared descent is homoplasy - convergent evolution (wings) or evolutionary reversal (snakes don’t have legs)

•homology may require full evidence, e.g. development of insect wings very different from development of bird wings

Page 25: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

phylogeny inference

•morphological characters (presence, absence, quality)

•DNA-based characters work the same (idea is there may be more independence, and more of them)

Page 26: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

our data matrix

Text? in NEXUS format

Page 27: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

parsimony analysis

•assume each state evolved only once (not necessarily true)

•principle of parsimony: the simplest explanation is the most likely

•we can identify how often this assumption is violated

Page 28: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

one character

•tentacular forelimbs might be able to split into 2 clades, but cannot fully resolve tree

Page 29: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

parsimony is a CRITERION

•our assumption of parsimony does not find the tree, it is a score given to a tree

•trees are searched algorithmically for all possible topologies (or all possible better than score X)

•a parsimony phylogeny analysis returns the set of most-parsimonious trees

Page 30: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

our tree

Page 31: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

eyeless

Page 32: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

“presence of 2 eyes” - obviouslynegatively correlated with “eyeless”

Page 33: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

tail

Page 34: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

digits

Page 35: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

dark stripeshmmm correlated with digits!?

Page 36: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

wings

Page 37: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

circular tail fin“forked” tail fin

Page 38: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

“protruding body”

Page 39: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

2 digits - an autapomorphy

Page 40: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

our tree

•parsimony tree(s) from class data matrix

•which characters exhibit HOMOPLASY

•remember: homoplasy may be evolutionary convergence/reversal, may also reflect our own uncertainty about the character and how it develops!

•see Box 1 (chapter 4) for another example

Page 41: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

molecular data• we will come to this later how it is analyzed, but

we see the problems of

• highly correlated, non-independent characters

• hard to identify very many characters

• thus not a fully resolved phylogeny (but good!)

• if you sequence a single gene region, might have 100 characters that are unbiased by the person collecting the data

Page 42: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

example of carnivores

define “carnivore” please...define “carnivore” please...

Page 43: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

why study phylogeny of carnivores?

lets ask a simple question: did aquatic pinnipeds evolve only once, or were there multiple transitions to the sea?

Page 44: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

12 characters, 10 carnivores

Page 45: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

synapomorphies

Page 46: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

1313

1313

Page 47: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

20 characters, 3 equallyparsimonious trees

our result is robust to this uncertainty: one origin of pinnipeds (consensus at

left)

Page 48: GENE 3000 Fall 2013 slides 127-159. wiki. wiki. wiki

parsimony•simple assumption, simple model -

may lead to several ‘equally parsimonious’ results

•more data will not always solve the problem

•more complex models evaluate the non-independence of data, the empirical patterns of DNA substitution, and probability theory