Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment et al. (10-9647) -- Letter to P. Kevin Castel to Modify March 3, 2014 Order Part 1 of 2 [March 5, 2014]

7/22/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment et al. (10-9647) -- Letter to P. Kevin Castel to Modify March

1/23

Abrgm3, 8>24

A r.^.Fcvi. GbstcjWkutmcr`Distrigt k e@cwYkrf3>> ^cbrjWtrcct@cwYkrf,@cwYkrf 2>>>?Xc Giv 954?) (^FG)(LGr)

Dcbr Gbstcj24, I prk s jitiob`t Abrgus Isbibm _bsmaotk`, suhaittcd b jcttcr tk yku pursub`t tk tmcI`dividubj^rbgtigcske ..Fcvi Gbstcj 8(B)(2)b`d 8(G), tk ièkra yku tmbt hy Abrgm 2?, 8>24,2wkujdhc eijaob` Cacroc`gy Aktik tk Disqubjiey ^.Fcvi Gbstcj b d Lbacs G.Erb`gisûrsub`t tk 8= S W G 244b`d 433, Kr I tmc Bjtcr`btivc, Cacroc`gy Aktik tk Disqubjiey Aigmbcj ^. \wcio,Gmristib Gbrhk`c b dJkch& Jkch J J ^Duc tk ErbudSpk tmc Gkurt.Xcqucst ekr Disgipji`bry b`d Ak`ctbry Wb`gtik`s. KrbjMcbriòDcab`dcd. ccCxmihit B.Bs yku brc bwbrc, I hcjicvc tmbt wmc` yku io`krcd hktm tmc Ludigibj Gkdck eGk`dugt b`d tmc puhjigpkjigyokbjs ke tmc Givij Xiomts Bgt ke 2954 tkissucykurmiomjy crrk`ckusLujy 8>,8>22 Wtby Krdcr gkapcjjiò tmis jb`dabrf muab` riomts b`d capjkyac`t disgriaabtik`gbscatk brhitrbtik`, ykui`tc`tik`bjjydcprivcd ac ke ay riomts u dcr tmc gkjkr ke jbwavikjbtik ke 2= S.W.G. 848 b`d ykuebijcd tkupmkjdykur ctmigbj dutics bs b` iapbrtibj, ecdcrbj ludoc. Yku wcrcbjskabdcbwbrctmbt I bjjcocd tmbt _ij j ibaAkasC`dcbvkr C`tcrtbiàc`t (ekracrjy f`kw` bs tmc_ij j ibaAkas Boc`gy), Jkch & JkchJJ^ ,Aigmbcj ^.\wciob`dktmcrswcrc còboiò i` b u`gk`sgik bhjc jcvcj ke erbud b`d tmbt2wkujdhc sccfiò disgipji`bry b`dak`ctbry sb`gtik`sbobast_ i j ji ba Akas, Jkch & Jkch JJ^ b d ktmcrs ekr c oboao a b pbttcr` kemiomjyu`ctmigbj b`dgriai`bjgk`dugt - i` b siìstcrceekrttk abatba ojkhbj wmitc/ 'Lcwism suprcabgy b`d tmcaytmkewmitc/ Lcwism supcrikrity, kr a tmc bjtcr`btivc, gk spirc tk i`tcrecrc witmtmc muab` riomts keBerigb Bacrigb`s,i`vikjbtik ke tmc FuFjux Fjb`Bgt ke2=?2,`kw gkdieicd bs 48 S.W.G. 29=3.I` tmis jcttcr,2abdctwkrcqucsts62bsfcdtk hc oivc` pcraissik` tk suhait b` bdditik`bj 7>pbocs(3>pbocsi`tktbj) tk ay Cacroc`gy Akt ik tk Disqubjiey b`d Ibsfcd ekr yku tk stby tmc brhitrbtik`, pc dao dic Gkurt'srcskjutik`ke tmis abttcr. K` Abrgm 7, 8>24, yku issucd b` Krdcr, orb`tiò ayrcqucsttk suhait tmc prkpkscdAkt ik`k` Abrgm 2?, 8>24, mkwcvcr, yku `cvcr bgf`kwjcdocd kr orb`tcd ay twkrcqucsts. ccCxmihitH.BetcrI wbs crrk`ckusjy hciò gkapcjjcd i`tk brhitrbtik` b d wbs tkjdhy tmc Wcgk`dGirguittmbt tmcy did `ktmbvclurisdigtik` tk dcgidc b`y ke tmc ekurbppcbjs tmbt wcrc suhaittcd, tmc kòabj brhitrbtkrbssio`cdtk tmisgbsc,DbvidJ. Orcokry, issucdtmrccI`tcà Dcgisik`s, b`d tmc` b ^brtibj Ei`bjBwbrdk Dcgcahcr 2?, 8>27, eadaotmbt _ij j iba Akas C`dcbvkr C`tcrtbiàc`t JJG disgriaabtcdbobastVacQ i vikjbtik ke pcrti`c`t ecdcrbj,stbtcb`d jkgbj jbw prkmihitao disgriai`btik` i` capjkyac`t k` tmchbsiskerbgc b`d bwbrdcd ac ak`ctbrydbabocs i`gjudiò hbgf-pby, erk`t-pby, gkapc`sbtkry & puìtivcdbabocs,eccs b d gksts, bs b prk sc `k`-bttkr cy prcvbijao pbrty k` stbtutkry gjbias i` bgbscke gk`sidcrbhjc prkgcdurbj b`d suhstb`tivc gkapjcxity. ccCxmihit G Ekr bjj i`tc`ts b`dpurpkscs,Orcokry's dcgisik` wbs eabj, cvc` tmkuom2 eijcdb` Bppcbj k Lbùbry8,8>24 tkmbvctmc bwbrd akdieicd b`dbddrcsstmcissuckedbabocs.K Lbùbr0' 5, 8>24, tmc Dcec`db ts eijcdbscgk`d Aktik tk Disqubjiey Orcokry b ddcspitctmc XcvicwWtb`dbrdske tmc B B B ' s BXG, tmc B B B orb`tcdJkch & Jkch JJ^'srcqucstwitmkut prkvidao b spcgieigrcbsk bs tk wmy Orcokry wbs rcakvcd. @kw, Jkch &Jkch JJ^ b`d tmc `cw, erbudujc`tjy bppki`tcd brhitrbtkr - Tiaktmy F. Jcwis ~ brc sccfiò tk vbgbtcbjj keOrcokry's dcgisik s bjtmkuom tmc BB Bstbtcd Orcokry's dcgisik`s wkujd `kt hc vbgbtcd prikr tk Jcwis'bppki`tac t b`d 2> ke tmc EBBabfcs it gjcbr tmbt k`jy tmc ecdcrbj gkurt gb vbgbtcb Bwbrd b`d betcr b`Bwbrdmbshcc issucd, k`jy tmc ecdcrbj gkurt gb` disqubjiey b` brhitrbtkr.KÀbrgm 4, 8>27, Jcwis issucd mis tmirdprkgcdurbj Krdcr i` ebvkr ke tmc Dcec db ts i jcsstmb` twk wccfs kehciò i`vkjvcdwitm tmcgbsc,rceusiò ayrcqucsttkstbytmc brhitrbtik`, pc`diò tmc [email protected].'s dcgisik` k` ayupgkaiò Akt ik` . ccCxmihit D.Bttbgmcd is b` c-abij gkrrcspk`dc`gchctwcc tmc B B B , Jkch & Jkch JJ^b`d ayscje kvcr tmc jbst twk dbys. Tmis c-abij smkws tmbt I gk`tbgtcdDbvid J.Orcokry b`dbsfcdmia tkissucb


2/23

Ar.^.Fcvi GbstcjAbrgm3, 8>24boc8

stbtcac t disgussao wmctmcr kr `kt mc acb t ekr mis Dcgcahcr 2?, 8>27 ^brtibjEi`bj Bwbrdtk hc ei`bj witmrcspcgt tk tmcissucsbdludigbtcd i tmc bwbrd, b`d i e`kt, tkpjcbsccxpjbi` mis Kgtkhcr 25, 8>27 Krdcr, i wmigmmc bhruptjy suspc`dcd disgkvcry b`d prcvc tcd b` krbj mcbrao erka tbfao pjbgc - b vikjbtik ke aygk`stitutik`bj riomts - hcekrc issui o mis ka ihuseabj dcgisik`, bjskf`kw bs tmc Dcgcahcr 2?, 8>27 brtibjEi`bjBwbrd. ccCxmihit C Jkch & JkchJJ^khlcgtcd.Tmc c-abij bjsk smkws tmbt betcr I ekrwbrdcd ykur Krdcr tk tmc B B B b`d bsfcd bobi` ekr tmc brhitrbtik` tk hcstbycd, Jkch & Jkch JJ bttkr cyAigmbcj Hbactt rcspk`dcd hy abfao atc tik`bj rcprcsc tbtik`s (c.o. miscabij hcjkw is tmc jbtcst a bscricske ebjsc stbtcac tsdbtiò tk tmc kutsct ke tmis abttcr ) b`d sbyiò, I e b`dwmc`Gjbiab teijcsmisaktik hcekrcLudocGbstcj, Xcspk`dc t _A C wi j j ,bakò ktmcr tmi os,rcqucst b stbyke eurtmcr jitiobtik iÈcdcrbj Gkurti vicw ke tmc kòki o prkgccdi os i tmisbrhitrbtik`. Hbscd k Jkch& Jkch JJ^'spbstpjcbdi os b`dkvcrbjju`ctmigbj hcmbvikr, tmisrcspk scstrkòjy adigbtcs tmbt tmcy brc oki o tkbttcapt tk gk`tiùc vikjbtiò Ecd. X. Giv. . 22, ùacrkus rujcs u`dcr tmc @cw Ykrf Xujcs ke ^rkecssik`bjGk`dugt, @cwYkrfLudigibry Jbw 4=? b`d ktmcrgriai`bjstbtutcs. Hbscd k tmc ebgts b`d tmc prcvbijao jbw,b`y ecdcrbj ludoc wmk wkujd gk`sidcr rujiò i` ebvkr ke tmc Dcec db ts k` tmis pc`diò Aktik wkujd hcdcak`strbti olustmkw gkrrupt b`d rbgist tmis Gkurt is.AigmbcjHbactt - b Bsskgibtc bt Jkch & JkchJJ^- eirstbppcbrcd i tmisgbsck Wcptcahcr 27, 8>27 - `cbrjytmrcc ycbrs betcr tmis jitiobtik hcob . Tk ay f`kwjcdoc, Hbactt mbs `cvcr suhaittcd b Aktik k _ijj ibaAkrris'hcmbje K Abrgm7, 8>24, Hbactt eijcdb @ktigc keAktik wi tmtmc [email protected]èbaijibrity witm \wciob`d Gbrhk`c's u`ctmigbj b`d gruàbj bgtik`s wmijcbppcbri o i tmc WkutmcaDistrigtb`d Wcgk`dGirguit,I bsf tmbt misAktik hc dc icd kr tmbtk`jy \wciokr Gbrhk c - ^brt crs bt Jkch &JkchJJ^ wmk mbvc akrc tmb` 8= ycbrs' cxpcric`gc prbgtigiò jbw gkahi`cd - hc bjjkwcd tk rcspk d tk aypc`daoAktik`.

rcspcgteujjy bsf tmbt ykuakdiey ykur Krdcr, bddrcssi o hktm ay kjd b`d `cwrcqucsts,sk tmbt tmcgbschcekrctmc Bacrigb`Brhitrbtik Bsskgibtik gb hc stbycd. 2 bjsk bsf tmbt yku krdcr Dbvid J. Orcokry tk issucbstbtcac t rcobrdi o mis atc tik`s i issui o tmc ^brtibjEi`bjBwbrdhyAbrgm 24, 8>24 b`d a tmc i tcrcsts ketatm b`d lustigc, 2 bsf tmbt 2 kw hc bjjkwcd tk suhait b Aktik tmbt's `k akrc tmb ?3pbocs,duc tmc `cwdcvcjkpac ts b`dgkapjcxitykeissucstmisAktik sccfstk mbvc rcskjvcd.I e`kt,I bsf tmbt si`gc I'vc `cvcr mbd b krbjmcbriò tmis abttcr, tmbt b` cxpcditcdkrbjmcbrao tbfc pjbgc bt tmcWkutmca Distrigtke@cw Ykrf,3>> cbrj Wtrcct, @cwYkrf,@cwYkrf 2>>>? k kr hcekrc Eridby, Abrgm 24,8>24._ijj ibaAkas ekuomt tk mbvc ac tk ok tk brhitrbtik` b d `kw I mbvc beabj dcgisik erkatmc brhitrbtkr,wmigmgb k jyhc gkèiracd,akdieicd b`d/kr vbgbtcd hy tmc ecdcrbj gkurt pursub t tk 9-22 ke tmc EBB .TmcBBB did `kt mbvc lurisdigtik tk rcakvc Orcokry. 2 gb `k jkòcr gk ti uc pjbyiò tmcscobacs bobi st 5bttkr cys b`d 7 pbrbjcobjs. 2mbvc hcc u`capjkycd ekr tmrccycbrsb`d ba gurrc`tjy jiviò kee ke $4>>/ak`tm,wmijctmcscprcdkai btcjybjj-wmitc/ Lcwism gkapb ics brc abfaoaijjik`ske dkjjbrs erka tryiòtk abi`tbi`rbgisa i`Bacrigbb`d tmrkuomkut tmcwkrjd.Ay gkaputcr is k its jbst jcos b`d2gb 't cvc beekrd af. Tmisgbscmbs hcc`mbraeujjy dcjbycd ekr ebr tkkjkòb`d it's tiac ekr ac tk hc bhjc tk akvc k witm ay jiec. _i j j i baAkrrisisouijey, kr tmcy brc `kt. Citmcr wby,Aigmbcj .\wciob`d Gmristib` Gbrhk`c brc `kt eit tk prbgtigc jbwb`d aust hc dishbrrcd iaacdibtcjy b`d Jkch & Jkch JJ b`d_ ijj iba AkrrisC`dcbvkr C tcrtbi ac t aust hcmcbvijysb`gtik`cd ekr tmcirmiomjyu`ctmigbj b`dgriai`bjbgtik`s YkurLujy 8>, 8>22 aust hc vbgbtcd b`d dcebujtludoac`tk bjj gjbias broucd hcekrcDbvidJ.Orcokry smkujd hc c tcrcd a ay ebvkr.Hcst,

Abrgus I ._bsmi otk`

C`gjksurc8 8= 24 ^boc 2 ke 4

Echabry8=,8>24

Ar. .Fcvi GbstcjWkutmcaDistrigtke @cwYkrf3>> cbrjWtrcct@cwYkrf,@cwYkrf2>>>?Xc, 8>22Wtby Krdcrgkapcjji o tmis jb dabrf muab riomts b d capjkyac t disgriai btik gbsc i tkbrhitrbtik , ykui tc tik`bjjy dcprivcd ac ke ay riomts u`dcr tmc gkjkr ke jbw i vikjbtik ke 2=S.W.G. 848 b`d yku ebijcd tkupmkjd ykur ctmigbj dutics bsb iapbrtibj,ecdcrbjludoc.Iba`kwwriti otk i ekra ykub dtmc Wkutmca Distrigtke @cwYkrftmbtIwijjhc eiji o b Cacroc gyAktik` tk Disqubjiey ^.Fcvi Gbstcjb`d LbacsG .Erb`gisûrsub ttk 8=S.W.G 244 b`d 433, Kr I` tmc Bjtcr`btivc, Cacroc`gy Aktik` tk Disqubjiey Aigmbcj ^.\wcio,Gmristib Gbrhk`cb`d Jkch & JkchJ J Duc tkErbudSpk tmcGkurt.Xcqucst ekrDisgipji`bryb dAk`ctbry Wb`gtik`s.KrbjMcbri oDcab`dcd `k jbtcr tmbAbrgm2?, 8>24.S dcrvcry jiaitcd orku`ds,bpbrty mbs 9> dbys tk sccf tk akdiey b d/kr vbgbtcb brhitrbtkr'sBwbrdpursub t tk9 S.W.G. 2> ke tmc Ecdcrbj Brhitrbtik Bgt. K Dcgcahcr 2?, 8>27, brhitrbtkr Dbvid J. Orcokry' ke tmcBacrigb Brhitrbtik`Bsskgibtik ( BBB )issucd mis brtibjEi`bjBwbrd,eadi o tmbt_SjibaAkrrisC`dcbvkrC tcrtbi ac t disgriai btcd bobast VacQ i vikjbtik ke pcrti c t ecdcrbj, stbtc,b`d jkgbj jbw prkmihiti odisgriai btik i capjkyac t k tmc hbsis kerbgc b d bwbrdcd ac suhstb tibj ak ctbry dbabocs, i gjudiòhbgf-pby,ei-k`t-pby,gkapc sbtkry & pu itivcdbabocsb d rcbsk bhjceccsb dgkstsbs b prk sc `k -bttkr cyprcvbiji opbrey k stbtutkry gjbias i bgbsc ke gk`sidcrbhjcprkgcdurbjb dsuhstb tivc gkapjcxity.Bjtmkuom Orcokry's dcgisik bppcbrs ebvkrbhjc, itdkcs 'tgmb oc tmc ebgt tmbt mc i tc tik`bjjy cxgccdVcdQmispkwcrs hy crrk ckusjy dcgidi o tmc issuc kebrhitrbhijity,bs wcjj bs pbrtibjjy dctcrai i o tmc acrits ke rbygjbias, witmkut bjjkwi o disgkvcry krb krbjmcb`ò tk tbfc pjbgc - b hjbtb t vikjbtik keducprkgcss b`d cqubjprktcgtik u`dcr tmc jbw. K Lb ubry8,8>24,2eijcd b bppcbjpursub ttkB B BXujc4> ibmkpcske mbvi o tmcBwbrd akdieicd, bs wcjj bs tk sccf tk mbvc Orcokry gkapcj _KjibaAkrristk prkdugc vbrikus ei b`gibjdkguac ts sk tmbt I gkujd gbjgujbtc ay ak ctbry dbabocs. Bjtmkuom tmc Xcvicw Wtb dbrds ke tmc BBB'sBrhitrbtik`XcvicwGku`gij( BX G )gjcbrjystbtcstmbt b ypbrtyaby abfcbkhlcgtik tk b brhitrbtcs bt b`ytiac i tmc brhitrbtik , up tk tmc issub`gc ke tmc Bwbrd kr ktmcr tcrai bti o krdcr, tmc Dcec`db ts eijcd bscgk`d Aktik tk DisqubjieyOrcokrygk tbi ao ùacrkus aisrcprcsc tbtik s k Lb ubry5, 8>24b dk Lb ubry8?, 8>24, tmc B BBorb tcd tmcir aktik witmkut prkvidi o b`y spcgieig rcbsk`s bs tk wmyOrcokrywbs bgtubjjydisqubjieicd, (capmbsis bddcd).Dcspitc ay rcp0cbtcd khlcgtik s tmbtOrcokry'srcakvbj wbs prkgcdurbjjy iaprkpci b dtmbtpiusub`t tk 2> ketmcEBB,k jy tmc ecdcrbj gkurt gkujd disqubjiey tmcbrhitrbtkrbetcrbBwbrdwbsissucd, mc wbs rcpjbgcd b`ywby

Brhitrbtkr Dbvid J Orcokrymbs72ycbrs'cxpcric gc bs hktmb brhitrbtkrekr tmcBacrigb Brhitrbtik`Bsskgibtik b d jbhkr&capjkyac t jbw prkecsskr btWt,Lkm 's S ivcrsity - tmcbjababtcr ke .Fcvi Gbstcjb dwiec.


5/23

G b s c 8 < 2 g v 9 5 4 ? ^ F G L G E kguac`t 77 Eijcd >8 8= 24 ^boc8 ke 4Ar. .Fcvi Gbstcj

Echrubry8=, 8>24^boc 8

k Echrubry2=, 8>24 witm ekracrXcpuhjigb bppki tcd ecdcrbj b`d bppcjjbtc ludoc TiaktmyF .Jcwis.B wccfi tkJcwis'bppki tac t, mc mbs bjrcbdy prkvc miascje tk hc u eit tkiapbrtibjjydcgidc tmis gbsc duc tk mis hibs ièbvkr ke b prcdkai btcjy bS-_mitc/ Lcwism Mkjjywkkd i stitutik tmbt mbshcc eku`d ouijty kecòboi oi`rbgibjdisgriai btik . Mc mbs rceuscd tk rcbd b y ke tmc pbst pjcbdi os eijcd hy tmc pbrticshcekrcb`d betcr kurEchrubry83, 8>24 gk ecrc`gcgbjjb d bjtmkuom tmcB BBstbtcd tmbt Orcokry'sBwbrdswkujd kt hc vbgbtcd, mcc tcrtbi cdAigmbcj .\wcio's rcqucst tk vbgbtcOrcokry'sdcgisik`s bjtmkuom mcdkcs 'tmbvc tmc butmkrity tk dksk. Bjsk, betcr hci o bssio cd tk tmc gbsc, mc i ekracd hktm pbrtics ke mis pjb`s tk smietskacke mis rcspk sihijitics(c.o. rcscbrgm )k tkskack cwmk is `kt capjkycd hy tmcBBBb`d smkujd mbvc bhskjutcjy `k i vkjvcac`t itmis gbsc. Bjtmkuom2khlcgtcd, ay khlcgtik wbs iaacdibtcjy kvcrriddc .Tmisis eiirtmcr cvidc`gc ke tmc ycrbjjerbud tmbt mbs kggurrcd si gc tmc i gcptik ke tmis gbsc b`detbrtmcrdcak strbtcs wmybrhitrbtik wbs `cvcr b`bpprkpribtcekruatk bgmicvc tmcpuhjigpkjigyokbjsketmis`btik 'sb tidisgriai btik b`d b titruststbtutcs.I`krdcr tk ei bjjy gkrrcgt tmis ab iecst i lustigc,bjjketmcscissucswijjhc hrkuomt tk tmc bttritik ke tmc WkuteicaDistrigtke@cwYkrfi ay upgkai o aktik .Oivc tmc gkapjcxity ketmcùacrkus gkapjcx issucs tmbtwijjhcbddrcsscd, cbgm kewmigmwbrrb tsbdctbijcd cxpjb`btik , I suhaittmbtb bdditik bj tmirtypbocs(tktbji o kakrctmb i typbocs)brc `cgcssbryb dwijjbssist tmisGkurti abfi oiapbrtibjb dctmigbj dcgisik`s witm rcobrds tktmc rcabi dcr ketmisjitiobtik .Hciò b vigtia ke_ijjibaAkrris' disgriai btkry capjkyac t prbgtigcs wbstkuomc`kuom, hut abfi o tmcdcgisik tk gmbjjcòc i stitutik`bjizcdrbgisatmrkuomkut Mkjjywkkd witmkut gku`scj mbs prbgtigbjjy rui cd ayjiec. Tmc irrcpbrbhjcmbratmbt I'vc sueecrcd bs b rcsujt ke tmis erbud mbs lckpbrdizcd ay bhijity tk gk`ti ucjitiobti o tmis gbsc bobi st 5 bttkr cys b`d 7 pbrbjcobjserkaJkch & JkchJ J ^ MbdGbstcjdctcrai cd tmbt tmcab dbtkry, prc-disputcbrhitrbtik borccac ts tmbt I sio`cd bs b gk`ditik ke capjkyac t wcrc u`gk`sgik`bhjc bsbabttcr kejbw b`d puhjigpkjigy, b iapbrtibjluryrcejcgti o tmcrigmdivcrsity ke @cwYkrfGitywkujd mbvc bjskrcbgmcd b vcrdigt hy `kw. Tmcy wkujd mbvc `kt k jy borccd witmBrhitrbtkrOrcokry's gk`gjusik` etbt I wbsdisgriai btcd bobast hcgbusc ke ayrbgc,huttmcywkujd mbvc bjsk dctcrai cdtmbt_ijjiba Akrrismbsc obocd,i`b 225ycbrpbttcr b dgk ti ui oprbgtigckedisgriaabtik bobi stBerigb Bacrigb sb dwmctmcrcapjkyccsi`b prcdkai btcjy _mitc/ Lcwism wkrf c`virkàc t brc hjbtb tjy rbgist kr kt,tmcydkmbrhkriapjigitrbgibjhibscs b`d tmc gkapb`y's capjkyac t prbgtigcs, pkjigics b`d prkgcdurcs grcbtc b dispbrbtc iapbgt bobi stqubjieicd Berigb Bac`gb`s erka hci o mircd b`d/kr prkaktcd tk Boc t, kr mircdi tktmcir Boc`t Trbi ccprkorba.Ietmcsc stbtcac tswcrc `kt truc, wkujd `kt mbvchcc tmc k jyBerigb Bacrigb capjkycd bt b yjcvcj ke tmc @cw Ykrfkeeigc'sBoc t Trbi cc prkorba (tmc i cxkrbhjc zcrk ) wmc I hcob capjkyac t iWcptcahcr8>>=- tmc sbac ycbrBacrigbabdc mistkry hy cjcgti o b aixcd-rbgc ^rcsidc ti tkkeeigc. Betcrjcbr i obhkut Cxmihit72 b`d tmc gk`spirbgy tk gk`gcbjtmcscu`dcrjyi o c-abijs i Xkwc.tmcywkujd mbvcbjsk rujcd i ay ebvkr k hktm ke aygivijgk spirbgy gjbias - gk`spirbgy tk abi tbi b rbgc-hbscdak`kpkjytmrkuomkut dcgisik -abfi opksitik si Mkjjywkkd b`d tmc abrfct pjbgc keidcbsb`d gk`spirbgy tk i tcrecrc witmtmc muab riomtskeBerigb Bacrigb s,b vikjbtik keF u FjuxFjb`Bgtke 2=?2.Bsbrcsujtkec oboi oi griai bjbgtivityk hcmbje ke_ijjibaAkrris,Jkch & JkchJ J ^b dbttkr cysAigmbcj\wcio,Gmristib Gbrhd cb d ktmcrs mbvc vikjbtcd @cwYkrfLudigibryJ bw 4=? b`d uacrkus rujcs u`dcr tmc@cwYkrfXujcske ^rkecssik`bjGk`dugt.Tmisaktik wijjsccfdisgipji brysb`gtik`s bobi stAigmbcj^. \wciob dGmristib Gbrhk c(c.o. dishbrac t) b`dwijjbjsk sccf ak`ctbry sb`gtik`sP bobi st_ijjibaAkrris,Jkch &

Bs b rcsujt ke Aigmbcj . \wcio,Gmristib Gbrhk`c, Jkch & Jkch J J ^ b d_ijjiba Akrris'i tc`tik`bjaisrcprcsc`tbtik s, gk tuabgikus hcmbvikr, khstrugtik ke lustigc b`d ktmcr disgkvcry bhuscs, I eijcd b`Cacroc`gyAktik tk Gkapcj b`d Xcqucst ekr Ak ctbry Wb`gtik`s k Wcptcahcr 7>, 8>27,Orcokryrceuscd tkabfc b dcgisik k tmc aktik , tmc bhruptjy suspc`dVcdQ disgkvcry b`d gb`gcjjcd tmckrbjmcbri o. Mc did,mkwcvcr,bwbrdacdbabocstkgkapc sbtcac ekr emcir bhusivc jitiobtik tbgtigs, witmkut cvcr sbyi o tmc wkrd


6/23

G b s c 8 < 2 g v 9 5 4 ? ^ F G L G E kguac`t 77 Eijcd >8 8= 24 ^boc 7 ke 4Ar. .Fcvi Gbstcj

Echrubry8=, 8>24^boc 7JkchJ J ^ Aigmbcj .\wcio,Gmristib Gbrhk`c b`dktmcrsi b baku t kjcsstmb $83>aijjik pursub t tk tmcGkurt'si mcrc t pkwcr.Ductk tmcBBB'sjbgfkelurisdigtik tk dctcrai c gjbias kebttkr cyaisgk`dugtb dvikjbtik`s kegriai bjjbw, Ibsftmbtb krdcrhc issucd iaacdibtcjy stbyi o b`yeurtmcr brhitrbtik u tijtmcscabttcrsbrceujjy rcskjvcdhytmcWkutmcaDistrigtke @cwYkrf.B dsi`gc it's tmc jbst dby keHjbgfMistkry Ak tm, I bjsk bsf tmbt yku rcecr tmis gbsc tk tmc bttc`tik ke S.W.Bttkr cyOc`crbjCrigMkjdcr b`d rcsidc tke tmcS itcdWtbtcsHbrbgfKhbab.

sb`gtik s. VOrcokry,^brtibj Ei`bjBwbrd,28.Q ( .. rcobrdi o Xcspk`dc t's hurcbugrbtig cjkòbtik kercbdijybsgcrtbi bhjc miri o dbtb, ekr cxbapjc, I ba pbrtigujbrjy bac`bhjc tk bpprkpribtc rcgkapc sc bwbrdcd ekrbvkidbhjc dcjbys. ) Wi gcOrcokrywbsprcabturcjyrcakvcd erka tmc gbsc, tmcrcwijjhc k wby ekrmiatk gjbrieybahioukus b`d vbouc stbtcac ts jifc tmis kr dctcrai c b baku t tmbt ceecgtivcjy pu ismcs b`d dctcrs tmcDcec`db ts b`d tmcir gku`scj ei-ka cvcr còboi o i tmis typc ke hbd ebitm gk`dugt bobi . Citmcrwby, tmcDcec`db ts b`d tmcir gku`scj `ccd tk hc krdcrcd tk pby tmis pkrtik ke ay dbabocs ( kjcsstmb $3> ùjSk )`kw, rcobrdjcss ketmc kutgkacke tmckvcrbjjgbsc.

Hcst,

AbrgusI ._bsmi otk

C`gjksurc954? ^FG LGE Dkguac`t 77 Eijcd >8/8=/24 ^boc 4 ke 4

S@IT CD WTBTCW DIWTX IGT GKSXTWKSTMCX@ DIWTXIGT KE @C _YKX FAbrgus Isbibm _bsmiòtk`

Jist tmc`bac s) ketmc pjbi`tile s)/pcMtik`cr s).) 2> Gi v. 954? ( ^FG ) ( LGE )

bobi st- BEEIXABTIK@ K E W C X U I G C_ijjiba AkrrisC`dcbvkrC tcrtbiàc`t JJG (ekracrjy f`kw bstmc_ijjiba Akrris Boc`gy), LceeAcbdc b`d Wbrbm _iìbrsfI

Jist tmc`bac s) ketmcdcec`db`t s)/rcspk`dc`t s).)

I pri`tykur`bac) Abrgus Isbibm _bsmiòtk Pdcgjbrc u`dcrpc bjtyke pcrlurytmbtIscrvcdbgkpyke tmc bttbgmcd jist tmc`bacs ketmcdkguac`tsyku scrvcd)24b`d rcqucst tk cxtc`d pbocjiaitbtik`spursub`t tk8 (B)(2)b`d 8( G) ke .Fcvi Gbstcj's I`dividubj ^rbgtigcs.upk bjjktmcrpbrticsi tmis gbschy stbtcmkw yku scrvcd tmcdkguac`ts,ekr cxbapjc, mb`ddcjivcry,abij, kvcrìomtcxprcss) abij b`d c-abij tk tmcekjjkwi o pcrsk`s jist tmc`bacsb`d bddrcsscs ketmcpckpjcyku scrvcd)> ^brfBvcùc,@cwYkrf,@Y 2>234.

k dbtcyku scrvcd tmcdkguac`tes)) Echrubry8=.8>24

Echrubry8 =,8>24Dbtcd 34Hkcrua Wt., Bpt. 5A

BddrcssHrkkfjy`, @cwYkrfGity Wtbtc

228>5\ip545-3>4-549?Tcjcpmk`c@uahcrmuab`riomts.brcbaustNoabij .gkaC-AbijBddrcss

Xcv. >2/8>27


8/23

xmi it


9/23

G b s c 8 < 2 > g v > 9 5 4 ? ^ F G L G E D k g u a c ` t74 E i jcd >7 / >7 / 24 ^bo c ke

S @ I T C D W T B T C W D I W T X I G T G K S X TW K S T M C X @ D I W T X I G T K E @ C _ Y K X F

]A B X G S W I W B I B M _ B W M I @ O T K @ ,

^jbi`tiee, 2> G i v .954? ^ F G ) L G E )-bobi`st-

K X D C X_ I J J I B A A K X X I W C @ D C B U K XC @ T C X T B I @ A C @ T , J J G , L C E E A C B D C ,b`dW B X B M _ I @ I B X W F I ,

Dcec`db`ts.]

G B W T C J ,DistrigtLudoc24. Dcec db`ts smbjj rcspk`d witmi` 24 dbys ke eiji`o ketmc aktik` b`d pjbi`tieea by eijc b rcpjy witmi` ? dbys ke tmc rcgcipt ke tmc dcec db`t srcspk`sivc pbpcrs.

W K K X D C X C D .

S`itcd Wtbtcs Distrigt Ludoc

Dbtcd24

S W D W W K @ YD K G S A C @ TC J C G T X K @ I G B J J Y E I J C DD K G PD B T C E I J C D


10/23

xmi it


11/23

A CXIG @ XHI TX TIK@ WWKGI TIK@

G WC 27 25>> 2 4 8 5 2 8

A brg us i . _ bsm i ò t k` , p rk sc Gj b i ab` tU

_i j j i b a A k r r i s C`dcbvkr C` t c r t b i à c` t JJG,

e k r a c r j y f ` k w ` bs t m c _ i j j i b a A k r r i s Boc`gy , c t . b j . . Xcspk`dc` t

WSA A BXYU|:vj tW P Ip i@D _i j j i b a A k r r i s C`dcbvkr C` t c r t b i ` a c ` t JJG m c r c i ` b e t c r

EI@D t m b t Gj b i a b ` t m bs s u e e c r c d a k ` c y dbabocs.EI@D, p u r s u b ` t t k t m c Br h i t r b t i k ` Bo r c c a c ` t , t m b t G j b i ab` t i s c ` t i t j c d

t k r cbsk`b h j c e ccs b`d gks ts , bs b p rk sc `k` -b t t k r `cy p rcvb i j i ò pb r t y k`s t b t u t k ry g j b i as i ` b gbsc k e gk`s i dc rbh j c p rkgcdu r b j b`d suhs t b` t i vc

^ XTI JEI@ J _ XD


12/23

I_dcP ' P P A * P P't PP PP

^XKGCDSXBJKUCXUIC_, EI@DI@OW KE EB b , B@D GK@GJSWIK@WKE JB_ P - P _P y k v

g u),* ,eSB l Gjb i ab `t wbs mi rc d hy Xcspk` dc` t bs b` Boc` t Trb i` cc i` ai d-Bu ou st , w*v~ S8 > > = . Mc hcob` wkrf k` Wcp tcahcr 8 ,8 > > = . Ek j j k w i ` o j u ` g m k ` B p r i j = , 8 > 2 > i ` iP @c w Ykrf G i t y w i t m A s. Gbrkjc Fbtz, t mc Jks Bòcj cs hbscd mcbd ke P M'P

Xcspk`dc` t ' s Muab ` Xcsku rgcs . , G jb iab ` t gcbscd wkr f hu t r ca b i `cd k` t mc BP .PPP ' ' P P i ' pbyrk j j u ` t i j a i d - B u o u s t 8 > 2 > . P P gPPuBe

I ` c b r j y 8 > 2 2 , G jb ia b` t u`suggcss eu j j y sucd Xcspk`dc` ts I ` t mc S` i t cdWtb tcs D i s t r i g t G k u r t e k r t m c Wk u t m c r ` D i s t r i g t k e @cw Ykrf, b`d u`sug gcsseu j jybpp cb j cd tk tm c Wcgk`d Gi rg u i t . Mc mbs yc t t k ac ct w i t m b`y suggcss wmbtskcvcr ePQgcs Z-Z-i ` t m c e c d c r b j g k u r t s 6 t m c y m b vc u ` c q u i v k g b j j y r c p u d i b t c d b j j k e Gj b i a b ` t ' s P ' Ii ` i t i b t i v c s t k b v k i d b r h i t r b t i k ` b ` d i ` s t c b d k h t b i ` b l u r y t r i b j i ` e cd cr bj gk ur t . rxvPb

Xcspk`dc` ts a k v c d t k g k a p c j b r h i t r b t i k ` i ` cbr j y Echrubr y 8 > 2 2 . I ` a i d - :P:,ikP{~Lu`c, 8 > 28 , t mc Gjcrf k e t mc Gkur t issucd b @k`-Lur i sd i g t ik ` Jct t c r . pg-t tuvi/ Pg

b g g c p t c d t m c BBB b d a i ` i s t r b t i v c b p p k i ` t a c ` t i ` j b t c Lujy, 8 > 2 8 t k scrvcbs t m c B r h i t r b t k r i ` t m i s a b t t c r . W m k r t j y t m c r c b e t c r , i ` b ` B u o u s t 8 4 , 8 > 2 8 g k ` e c r c ` g c gb j j , t m c p b r t i c s u ` c q u i v k g b j j y s t b t c d t m b t t mcy wcrc bac` bh j c t k -M* < - P ' i va c d c g i d i ` o t m i s a b t t c r s k j c j y k ` A k t i k ` s b ` d w i t m k u t t m c ` c c d e k r b ` k ` - s i t c m c b r i ` o . Tmc BBB ru jcs b j j kw ek r dcg i s ik` k e ca p j kyac ` t d i spu t cs w i t mk u t b LPPPgm c b r i ` o b` d hbscd sk jc jy k` t mc pbr t ics ' suhai ss ik`s . Uib t m c i r cxt c ` si v c A k t i k ` kkPemS`Pp b p c r s, t m c p b r t i c s s cc f s u a a b r y l u d o a c ` t , di s a i s sb j k e t m c k p p k s i t i k ` ' s g j b i as -P P l P P , P P

e . c ` t i r c t y , s i o ` i e i gb ` t a k ` c y dbabocs (c .o . , " IV Gj b i a b `t Q smku j d rcgc i vc UwP P L

b g k ` e c r c ` g c gb j j k`Lujy 7 > , 8 > 2 7 ,m k w c v c r . Gjb iab`t bthruRt jPy gmbòcd bBdiPPsWgk(v()g~ l 0e(lsa i ` d b ` d sb i d m c w b ` t c d b m c b r i ` o . Mc t m c r c b e t c r p r k a p t j y" d c r ` b ` d c d t k Z'PZBkZgL vsP

dcpksc Xcspk`dc`t ' s Gm ic e Cxcgut i vc Ke e ig cr Br i Cabù c j b`d Xcspk`dc`t ' s P e ' P P d lp r i ` g i p b j b t t k r ` c y s , i ` g j u d i ` o A r . A i gm bc j \wcio , Csq. b`d m is gk j jcbou cs b t t mcJkch j b w e i r a . I d c ` i c d t m k s c r c q u c s t v ~ Gk ` g u r r c` t j y , d i s g kv cr y c e e k r w s P t k t m coc`cs is b` d m is t k ry k e " Cxm ih i t B" bfb " Cxm ih i t 7 2 wcr c `k t p rk dug t i vc . Tc j b h k r b t c gk` d i t i k` b j d i sgkvc ry gb jc`dbr ) I mbd sc t e k r t m i ` I ` t c r i a Dcg is ik` 7 km - " j P ' P ' -e

a k r c t m b ` $ 2 8 3 a i j j i k` . .. " ) b ` d b d d i t i k ` b j r c a c d i c s b ` d b t t k r ` c ys ' e c c s b ` d ( P c Pgks ts PgSbdt

W c p t c a h c r 8 3 , 8 > 2 7 ( I i s su c d t w k p r i k A ` t c r j a D cg i s i k `s , d b t c d Bp r i j 2 = b ` dLujy 28 , 8 > 27 rcspcg t i vc j y , i ` gk r pk r b t cd mc rc i` hy rc ec rc`gc , b`d scvcrb j QP P lcP . l Q \5Z


13/23

p r k g c d u r b j k r d c r s . ) w b s c g j i p s c d h y t m c r c b j i t y t m b t ` k t m i ` o ` k t b j r c b d yP ' P M P . u j P ' P P xm bu st i vc j y b d dr c s s cd i ` t m c p b r t i c s ' t m k u s b ` d s k e p b oc s ke A k t i k ` s w b s

( r c a k t c j y j i f c j y t k s u r e b g c cvc` i e t m c b r h i t r b t i k ` m c b r i ` o w b s t k g k ` t i ` u c cBP P i ` d c e i ` i t c j y b ` d t k t m u s t b f c k ` t m c a u j t i - d c g b d c d i a c ` s i k ` s ke Gm b r j c s Di g f c ` s '

lc > P Lb r`dygc v. Lbr`dygc.j pPPtPriP Tm c r c e k r c , w i t m c v c r yt m i ` o h c e k r c a c t m b t I ` c c d c d t k d c g i d c t m i s a b t t c r ,

I sc t b dcbd j i `c e k r e i ` b j s u h a i s s i k ` s . I g k a p j c t c d r c g c i p t k e s b a c b ` d g j k s c d t m c r c g k r d k ` D c g c a h c r , 9 , 8 > 2 7 .P c P P - P P j ' bitdlfd AP-88,9>2-;. PsP WPP P PP P

cv g -ewJ i t m i r t y ycb rs bs b ` B r h i t r b t k r k e t b h k r b ` d Ca p j k y a c ` t D i s p u t c s , - e P g t - l P e j P t m i s g b sc p r c s c ` t s t m c a k s t c xt c ` s i v c A k t i k ` p r b g t i g c t m b t I m b v c c ` g k u ` t c r c d . g L P e L *

Z c ZP t .Z c mbvc g b r c e u j j y r c b d t m c p b r t i c s ' p b p c r s b ` d t m c b v b i j b h j c r c j c v b ` t b u t m k r i t i c s iSv* o'vev*P g i t c d t mc r c i ` . V Br ' j (B4c-6-v I P G P I G P P G k ` v c ` t i k ` b j W u a a b r y Lu d o a c ` t i s b p p r k p r i b t c w m c ` ` k a b t c r i b j e b g t s

jb I t P t d i s p u t c b ` d t m c g k ` s t r u g t i k ` is g k ` d u g t c d i ` b j i o m t a k s t e b v k r b h j c t k t m cwc i k p p k s i ` o p b r t y . Tmbt d y` b a i g s i o ` i e i g b ` t j ys m i e t s , bs b p r b g t i g b j a b t t c r , w m c `

e i tPbLl-PPPP i s b g r k ss A k t i k ` e k r W u a a b r y Lu d o a c ` t b ` d g k u ` t c r g j b i a s . I ` t m i s :P0iP6gi(Arhitrbtik`, u ` d c r t m c r u h r i g k e Wu a a b r y Lu d o a c ` t , t m c p b r t i c s a k u ` t c d b e u j j

- e P * s g bj c b r h i t r b t i k ` hy b`y ac bsu rc . i ` g c p t i k ` k e c a p j k y a c ` t , b ` d s u h s c q u c ` t j y k ` Lujy 2 , 8 > > 9 ,

' P ' i k j j k w i ` o t m c _i j j i b a A k r r i s B o c ` g y b ` d C`dcbvkr g k a h i ` i ` o t m c i r hus i`csscs.G j b i a b ` t s i o `c d t m c A u t u b j B r h i t r b t i k ` Bo r c c a c ` t , b o r c c i ` o t k b r h i t r b t c , i ` t c rb j i b , g j b i a s k e u ` j b w e u j r b g c d i s g r i a i ` b t i k ` . Tmc bo r cca c` t s s w c c p h rkbd j y . I `8 > > 9 i ` 24 ^c`` ^jbzb v. ^vct t . 28 9 W,.Gt.4 3 5 ( 8 > > 9 ) , t mc S` i t cd Wt b t cs W up r cac

i d: rcP 4 P 0 G ku r t u p m c j d b ` b r h i t r b t i k ` b o r c c a c ` t h r k b d j y b ` b j k o k u s t k t m k s c i ` t m i sb r h i t r b t i k ` . Wcc, Dbv id J. Orcokry , A b ` d b t k r y Jb h kr Br h i t r b t i k ` k e Wt b t u t k r y

/ jjlX(P4P' 9P G jb ias b`d t m c Eu tu rc k e Eb i r Cap j kyac `t . 29 Gkr`c j j Lkur `b j k e Jbw b` d ^uh j i g

GA G |b0u

B g 0 P P U^ k j i g y 4 8 9 4 3 = ( 8 > 2 > ) ( w i t m C. A g @ b a b r b ) . SPP,P sZ jZcP Pg P] PP P dBsPgPPgP* i P P v, VgP ,P I e i ` d h k t m k e t m c B r h i t r b t i k ` Bo r c c a c ` t s i ` t m i s b r h i t r b t i k ` t k hc

ZiZPrP yP g k ` v c ` t i k ` b j , o b r d c ` v b r i c t y , b ` d ` k ` p r k h j c a b t i o T@ m c r c i s k g r c d i h j c c v i d c ` g c / p>-| P(yt8B I e ' " - t m b t t m c y b r c u ` g k ` s g i k ` b h j c i ` w m k j c k r i ` p b r t . ) gj r*] P-

i e rtg4) AwBvkiktP/ v


14/23

TMC " @" _KXD A C A K C]MIHIT B@ D TMC GJ I A @TrtP iz P G jb iab ` t bssc r t s t m b t t m c rc wc rc mu `d r cds k e dcsp igbh j c , sgu r r i j kus uscs

U k e t m c k d i k u s " @ -w k r d " b ` d k t m c r rbg i s t pc lk rb t i vcs hy dcg i s ikàbfc r boc` ts k eP P P P ' P ( X c s p k ` d c ` t s . Gj b i a b` t b g f ` k w j c d oc d t m b t mc wbs `cvc r gb j j cd b " @" t k m i s e bgc

hy b ` y k ` c b t Xcspk`dc`t .Tmc rku om jy t wc ` t y pbocs rc e c r r cd t k bs Cxm ih i t 7 2 , b`d / kr bs Cxm i h i t B,

P P P P 5PP * k7W Cxm ih i t B mc r c i` b e t c r e k r gk`si s tc`gy' s sbfc , i sVP Ppa ^ PP dt k hc b jkò j i s t k e ` b a c d p c r sk ` s g k r r c j b t c d t k t m c ` u a h c r k e t i a c s

t m c ` b a c d p c r s k ` m b d b ` y i ` v k j v c a c ` t b s c i t m c r b t b r o c t k r g k a a u ` i g b t k r k eb ( t * " P P P P sugm v i jc jbòub oc.

sZ) . ekPl G j b i a b ` t m b s b s sc r t c d e r k a t m c i ` g c p t i k ` t m b t , e k r a k r c t m b ` b d c g b d c , A b e 0 P P:;_PP I kd i kus " @-wkrd " mbs hcc` uscd hy supcr ik r boc`t s k e Xcspk`dc`t j P P , P P

/ r cob r d i ò c ap j kyccs k e gk jk r . Hy pu r c e k r t u i t k u s g i r g u a s t b ` g c ( w m i g m G j b i a b ` t P P Z P zTj i M i P t c r a s " a i r b g u j k u s " ) a k r c t m b ` b d c g b d c b o k, t m c " @ - wk r d " j is t wb s B

l / PJ-_ ke i ` bdvc r t c` t j y scc` k` t m c dcsf k e W@X V Wk``c`sgmc i` , @b t m , b`d Xksc` tm b j Q P V77cP S:l P b t t k r ` c y X b y ak ` d Mcsj i ` . Ar , Jck`b rd Xkwc, h y B e e i d b v i t , b e e i r a s


15/23

kMvP P G j b i a b` t s i t ub t cs m i s I` d i v i dub j cxpc r i c`gc b t Xcspk`dc` t bob i `s t t mc h r k b d c r h b g f d r k p k e Cxm i h i t B b ` d t m c a b g r k h b g f d r k p k e m i s i ` t c r d i s g i p j i ` b r y g r i t i q u c k e d c c p j y c a h c d d c d r b g i s a . g0(P*l.,LP S -e_. ?,ZPPShrZ,P Pk t -PP eSgc) / PK Wkac k e Gj b i a b ` t ' s c x t c ` s i v c A k t i k ` p b p cr s r c e j c g t s k p m i s t i g b t c d

'{v s k g i k j k o i g b j l u r i s p r u d c ` g c o r k u ` d c d i `s k a c k e t mc j cbd i ò sgmk j b r sm i p k e t mc4 ' / g r i t i gb j rbgc t mck r i s t s . Gs* P GA P -evP -e. A lk '4 l cP-ei`,kPPt-rsgiP : 0 0 P g P j t P - + i 5 ( v i s P

Z r p b r t s k e G jb i a b `t ' s A k t i k ` p b p c rs br c g k u ` t c r p r k d u g t i v c b ` t i - ' P P l oPTWHai t ig r b` t . Bs Xcspk`dc` t gk r rcg t j y pk i ` t s ku t , s k a c k e t m c d c e b a b t i k ` wb s (Z/Z lgPrrPku P

c p b r t i g u j b r j y a c b ` s p i r i t c d , d c j i h c r b t c j y d i s t r i h u t c d t k a c a h c r s k e t m c Hb r b ` d v0Y-et * T0pg bggus i ò Xcspk`dc` t ' s j b w y c r s k e p b r t i g i p b t i ` o i ` b ' g k `s p i rb g y t k a b i ` t b i ` x P c P w m i t c s u p r c a b g y t m r k u o m k u t Ba c r i g b . ' ( X cs p k` d c `t ' s Ei ` b j ^ ks i t i k ` dPP'8-kZ-8~

' -P Wt b t c a c ` t , @ k v c a h c r 8 > , 8 > 2 7 b t 2 4 . ) Wu g m p k i ` t j c s s v i t u p c r b t i k ` o r ks s j y P P L P PksjiP d c h i j i t b t c s t m c c e e i g b g y k e Gj b i a b ` t ' s s u h s t b ` t i v c b r o u a c ` t s . B - M

P w i - m Gj b i a b ` t g i t c s, i ` t c r b j i b , t m c i ` e j u c ` t i b j j cob j sgmk j b rsm i p k e Mb rvb rd Jbw P P ' P P P P P Wgmkk j ^rke csskr Xb`dbj j F c ` ` c d y ( scc Gj b i ab` t ' s Lbùb ry 7 2 , 8 > 2 7 A k t i k ` , '/~]gk

^P Wc = = , e k k t ` k t c s 8 4 7 - 8 4 5 , u j t i a b t c j y g u j a i ` b t i ` o i ` ^r k e cs sk r Fc``cdy' s ' bPstP_,dc e i ` i t i vc hkk f @ioocr < Tmc Wt rbòc Gbrccr k e bTr k u h j c s k a c _ k r d ( ^ b ` t m c k ` , S

8 > > 8 ) . PtePgPgPuv,:.4vB BLP ' p P ' 6 > > , b e i j a b g g c ` t u b t i ` o t m c i ` c x k r b h i j i t y

stcrcktypc w i t m t m c c a p m b s i s k ` t m c t b r o c t s k e r b g i s a mypcr-cxboocrbt iòewi P ' PWtcrcktypcs i ` k rdc r t k gku ` t c r b`d e r cczc t mc ac tbs t bs i zcd rbg i sa bs t c p i d 6 Dr.

iL M c ` r y Jkuis (Wfip) Obtcs, Tmc Wio` i e y iò A k` f cy< B T m c k ry k e B e r i gb` J i t c rb ryP Gr i t i g i sa ( 29 == Ei rs t Cd i t i k` b`d pkst ) .

P P P P G j b i a b ` t m b s s i t u b t c d m i a s c j e i ` b p b r b d k x i g b j p r c d i g b a c ` t . Mc b s sc r t s P P P P Le c e e - 'P P l P t m b t mc is us i ò t mc j cob j p rkgcss bs b` i ` s t ru ac ` t ek r skg i b j l u s t i g c . Tmc ak dc r` P P P 'P'P

gtA ' -e g i v i j r i o m t s a k v c a c ` t i s r c p j c t c w i t m ` k h j c c x b a p j c s k e g k u r b o c k u s j c b d c r s w m k t e l PePu skuom t , b`d u j t i a b t c j y bgm i cvcd , skg i b j gmbòc t m r ku om j cob j p rkgcss . Wcc, e k r i [ 6

cxba pj c , t mc Xcv. Dr . A b r t i ` Ju tmcr F iò ,Lr. b`d m i s c j kqu c` t Jc t tc r e r ka b v Pf ( LK@


16/23

>P4-3 H i r a i ` o m b a Lb i j . " J i f c w i s c, s cc t m c a b o ` i e i g c ` t w k r f k e T m u r o k k d A b r s m b j j b ` d P e ' P U/ P id* e" * vreljsa c ` t k r b t t m c M k w b r d J b w Wg m k k j , Uigc D cb ` G m br j c s M b a i j t k ` M k u s t k ` . t m d

Pk d clZ c cbgm ke t mcsc oc`t j cac` pursucd boorcssivc auj t i e bgc t cd i t ib t i vcs,I ba ue QZ bZlc.PP2P` k t b w b r c k e b s i ` oj c i ` s t b ` g c w m c r c i ` t m c y d c j i h c r b t c j y c ` o b o c d i ` j i h c j pcr sc. kSt{t

PPrP A k s t r c g c ` t j y , t m c j i e c k e A r . @ c j s k` A b ` d c j b , b j b w y c r , c j k q u c ` t j y c x c a p j i e i c sv (xui-);) r c vk j u t i k ` b r y m u a b ` r i o m t sbgtivisalB itmkut g k u ` t c r p r k d ug t i vc b d m k a i ` c a P P P P ' cvkj ut i k` br y m u a b ` r i o m t s b g t i v i s a P i t m k u t g k u ` t c r p r k d u g t i vc b d m k a i ` c a

I . l - ` j I ` t m i s gbsc hc ekrc ac b t t m i s B r h i t r b t i k ` , t m c p b r t i c s ' b s sc ss ac ` t s k e S g c e ev.RiP P ' P P ' ' ' ' P P d rb a b t i g b j j yvbry . W k a c k e a y k r i o i ` b j qucs t i k` s bh ku t Cxm ih i t B

( g * P - i I(AjP | P ' 7 i` k p c ` . _ m k b u t m k r c d i t ; . _ m b t w b s t m c g k ` t c x t ; ' P W P ' P P e " P P P 4 P P P P P ' b s f c d t m c p b r t i c s t k c ` d c b vk r t k p r k v i d c t m c e u j j ` b a c , t i t j c , b ` d d b t c s l P P P l P

g P p lP -j ' f ' F' P e c a p j k y a c ` t e k r cb g m b ` d cvc ry pc rsk` ` ba cd i ` wm k j c k r i ` p b r t i ` Cxm ih i t iPlP`-k Q r B . I b s f c d t m c p b r t i c s t k e u r t m c r i d c ` t i e y b j j ` b a c d p c r s k ` s w i t m i ` Cxmi hi t B w m k u,Uk u Li

{:P m 8 3 b rc p r csc` t j y ca p j kycd hy Xcspk`dc` t s . I bsfcd t mc pb r t i cs t k i dc` t i e y b`y sugm p' i sw ' i jiPP pc rsk`s `b a c d i ` wmk j c k r i ` p b r t i ` Cxm ih i t B wm k wc rc i ` vk j v cd i ` t m c K P - M : P L

Z e PksP r c g r u i t a c ` t ,m i r i ` o , k r i c ` t b t i k ` , t r b i ` i ` o , s u p c r vi s i k ` , d i s g i p j i ` c , s c vc r b ` g c . PP P b ` d / k r g c s sb t i k ` k e t m c c a p j k y a c ` t k e G j b i a b ` t . t e j P i l _ P e L

G j b i a b ` t , ` k t X c sp k ` d c ` t , d i d a k s t k e t m i s t c d i k u s w k r f i ` b o k k d e b i t m P . l c * P Pc e e k r t t k b ` s w c r a y q u c s t i k ` s . B j t m k u o m X c s p k ` d c ` t i s t m c p r c s u a p t i v c et0v,t

d P_klg u s t k d i b ` k e t m c c a b i j b ` d k t m c r g k a a u ` i g b t i k ` b r g m i vb j r cg k r d s . X cs p k ` dc ` t ' s :lGiB l- hi*/:. c e e k r t s i ` t m b t r c o b r d w c r c r c j b t i v c j y d c s u j t k r y , g k a p b r c d w i t m t m c r c s k j u t c i0PgA0

t c ` b g i t y k e Gj b i a b ` t . L - P , Ppgke j c gZtuPcd B j t m k u o m t m c " @" _ k r d A c a k Cxm i h i t B w b s b d a i t t c d i ` t k cvidc `g c, i t i s P ' P ' P s k a c t m i ` o j cs s t m b ` b s a k f i ` o o u ` h u t i t i s k t ` c g c ss b r i j y ` k t m i ` o . M P i P P vL. v /_

' 7 2 - - D - g j - * P P 4 g P e - P - P W kv-j i j P P / T g ib-kdJgZl smPd jbP-l Tm c k r i o i ` b j b u t m k r s m i p , b ` d , t m u s , t m c s i o ` i e i g b ` g c k e Cx m i h i t B r c ` i b i ` s j P P P k P p

Z% ZlgP u ` g c r t b i ` , s t b ` d i ` o b j k`cP 1 j V l l t , e b s t e k r w b r d i ` o t m c h c t t c rp b r t k e t w k dcgbdcs g j u ' a lB e P j ( e | \ P t 2 e r k a t m c t i a c A r . X k w c e i r s t sPByCxmihjt B t k t m c p r cs c` t , P j c s b j i c ` t e b g t is sjv / i/ 0t De kl i' k c s p c g i b j j y g k a p c j j i ` o b h k u t Xc s p k` d c ` t ' s w k r f p j b g c - B e ri g b `P P ]a cr i g b` s o c t u-c-tP_i/ v

m i r c d b t t m c h k k t g b a p t r b i ` c c c ` t r y r c vc j , i ` g j u d i ` o G j b i a b ` t , h u t a b v b j s k o c t K e p ' 4 P P 7 Y w i t m k u t c xg c p t i k ` b` d Irt s m k rt k r dc r . Gj b i a b` t ' s s t b t c a P t m b t LjPPePkPs' g P P P P P P P w crc a k r c B e r i g b ` B a c r i g b ` B o L ` t s c a p j k y c d b t _ i j j i b a A k r r i s i r P 9 5 7 VrPPP

l P P e 6 ( P ( k ` c ) t m b ` t m c r c w c r c w m c ` I h c o b ` P a p j k y a c ` t i ` W cp t c a h c r 8 > > = ) " i s `k tk e ePigiPx r c h u t t c d .


17/23

pA-Tgv_PI . i P e j i P \DKK l ec tBePZu eP

G_ccP jby-.Capjkycrs, i ` g j u d i ` oXcspk`dc` t , b r c c ` t i t j c d t k m i r c , r ct b / ` , b ` d ZP d buZZJ

p r k a k t c w m k a t m c y w i s m p r k v i d c d t m b t t m c y d k sk j b w e u j j y . P p j k y c r s i ` t m c g P P - e i l i ` d u s t r y b ppb r c` t j y rcj y k` t m c m i o m b t t r i t i k ` r b t c b a k` o ` cw c a p j k y c c s bs b

JP ' P P skr t k e hkkt gbap r i t c ke pbssboc. Eb i r c`kuom. Akst cap jkyccs gkac b h kb rd ' P?]P2+v8P w i t m t m c i r cycs w i d c kpc` , f ` kw i ` o t m b t upwbr ds k e ` i `ct y pcrgc` t k e t mc `cw

rcg ru i t s w k` ' t a b f c i t , h u t cbgm k` c rcskjvcd t k h c b a k` o tm c surv ivkrs. Bo b i ` , kZ PPg t g P S e b i r c` ku o m . ByPZ'* 0iPeP e i ioP ' Y l m c rcvkjv iò dkkr , kr, pcrmbps a k r c b g g u r b t c j y , t m c i ` s u r a k u ` t b h j c \PP BBK

s

o jbss gc i j i ò c`gku ` t crcd hy G jb iab` t c e e cg t i vc jy , b` d u` j bwe u j j y , kpcrb t cs bs b` -Pwb i' PP ePPcxgjusivc o b tc f ccpcr . G j b i a b ` t gk` t c` d s t m b t t m c rc b rc v i r t u b j j y ` k B e r i gb ` - (" UB\Bacr igb`s surv iv iò Xcspk`dc` t ' s `cw m i rc hkkt gbap, " . . . . tmcrc gk` t i` ucs t k |hc zcrk B e r i gb ` -Ba cr i gb ` Bo c` ts k r Gkkrd i ` b t k rs c a p j k y c d I` t mc @cw Ykrf P ,ke e igc . . . " (G j b i ab ` t ' s Wcpt ca h cr 7 > , 8 > 2 7 Cacroc` gy A k t i k ` b t pboc 9 , ) Pdt. mk pM* -

g J - t b P e k k t ` k t c 9 6 c ap m b si s i ` k r i o i ` b j ) B P P + TvP / PP Z < ,> > P Xcspk`dc` t d isborccs, hut dkcs `k t prkvidc b spcgi e i g j is t hy `bac, t i t j c ,

P d b t c k e m i rc k r cq u i vb j c` t pb r t i gu j b rs . I ` s tcb d , Xcspk`dc` t g i t cs Gjb iab `t bs sby iò " t mb t b pprkx i a b t c j y 8 > B e r i gb ` Ba cr i gb ` s w c r c m i r c d b ` d / k r p r k a k t c d - P 2 A P b

P b o c` t . " Xcspk`dc`t Ei`b j ^ks i t ik r vWtb t cac`t b t pboc 9 ) . Gj b i a b ` t dkcs ` k t kd2;F suc hcgbu sc 8 > aby mbvc h cc` m i r c d i ' Tb t j i i P m c sucs hcgbusc mc wbs e i rc d b` d

e t m b t `k B e r i gb` Bacr igb` surv ivcd t k h c g k a c b ` B o c t P I e i ` d Xcspk`dc` t ' s p rcsc` tb t i k` k e sugm d b t b i ` su e e i g i c` t t k rch u t . Xcspk`dc` t i s t mc gustkd i b` k e

P P P t mc rcgkrd , i ` hus i`css e kr a k r c t m b ` b gc` tu ry . I t scc` P b s i a p j c a b t t c r e k r KL0P P8 : P I jikP rtP Xcspk`dc`t t k j is t hy ` b a c b ` d pb r t i gu j b rs cbgm pcrspT` m i rcd b t tm c c` t ry jcvcj , PPZr0

i ` g ju d i ò G jb i ab`t s i`gc, sby, 8 > > ? . Tmc ù ahcr k e P crs k`s k e gk jkr m i rcd , BU|: G Z *B P P k t c d , b `d e i P d wk u j d t mi / s hc e kr t m r i om t L: P r csc` t cd . I e i ` d Gj b i ab `t d id P P P P

a c t i g u j k u s v* k rfkr i 4mTs sgkrc t mb ` d i d Xcspk`dc` t . G j b i a b ` tw c` t e u r t m c r , b ` d rcb d b ` d I`getrpWebtcd i ` t k m i s p r c sc ` t b t i k ` t m c M b r v b r d Jb w :P 0.kBXcvicw b r t i g j c k` k e " zcrk" i ` t m c w kr f p j b g c . I e i ` d i t i ` t c r ` b j j y Pd i s g k r d b ` t j M b t j P s p k` d c ` t gb` Z y j is t a k r c t m b ` t w c` t y i ` s tb ` gcs k e

_b`t 's vbr iku s dcj i` quc` gics, cspcgib j j y t mksc gk`si dcr cd issucs ke (`k` ) L PPPgiPj i rvwic

t rb i `c cs. isi i * (Lvl , P k , .Gbsc. G jb i ab`t sb t i s e ics S lc pr i ab eb g ic t cst , w i '

(' g.' P ( S ` i vc r si t y k e A i b a i P g P j c r b t c d o r b d u b t i k ` b ` d b ab st c r' s P c o e c i l y P o c 8 7 )v P ' sk a c i ` i t i b j P g c s s c s i ` t m c i ` d u s t r y h c ek rc w krf i ` o ek r X c s p k ` d c ` t Mc

p u ` g t u b j i t y , hu t sccai` o jy gb `` kt j is t t mc ù ah cr b` d rbgc ke pcrsk`s m i rcd ,p r k a k t c d , e i r c d 8 > > ? - pr c sc ` t(dr, b t j cb s t e k r t m c 8 > > = -8 > 2 > t i a c pcr i kd ) b st r b i ` c c s . P PP s:PiP:PPPPyPLP P-YPPP-PMTe, PPP -P

i a prcss i vc q u b j i e i gb t i k` s

T2IL gPcgPi P


18/23

b g f ` k w j c d o c s m c w b s ` k t t m c p c r e c g t c a p j k y c c , w i t m b e c w j b t c ` c ss I ` g i d c ` t s I ` Kf


19/23

s i o ` i e i g b ` g c , skac supcrv iskrs g k ap j b i ` c d b h k u t G j b ia b ` t w i t m i ` j css t m b ` k ` cmkur k e m i s hc i ò k` t mc l k h . & : e P c P t *

Hc e k rc m i s Bpr i j = , 8> 2> j u`g m w i t m As . Fbtz, Gj b ia b ` t ' s dbys p rkh bh j yw c r c b j r c b d y ` u a h c r c d m c l u s t d i d ` ' t f ` k w t m b t y c t . { Pd I e vP P L j S l w i e

I t i s b g j ksc qucs t ik` , hu t I e i `d Xcs p k`d c` t d i d ` k t s u e e i g i c ` t j y r c h u t PP P P lP TP. ' e vP j * , Gj b iab` t ' s p r i ab e bg i c gbsc w i t m j c o i t i ab t c `k`d is g r ia i `b t k ry rcbsk`s , `cu t rb j j y vP g P e l g ,

`t4t0Q b ` d i a p b r t i b j j y b p p j i c d , e k r t c r a i ` b t i ` o Gj b i ab ` t ' s c a p j k ya c ` t .P P ' / x0 iP kA ' G j b ia b ` t d i d ` k t vk j u` t b r i j y q u i t . I e mc mbd d k ` c sk, i t wku j d

' mbvc h c c ` r c j b t i v c j y cbsy e k r Xcs p k`d c` t t k mbvc i a ac d i b t c j y c ` d c b v k r c d t k r c t u r ` Gj b i a b ` t t k w k r f . I ` s t c b d , Xcs p k`d c` t s w c c t c ` c d G j b iab ` t ' s d c pb r t u r cL wm i j c bd bab ` t j y p rcg j ud i` o b`y pkss ih j c r c t u r` hy G j b iab` t .

e i ` d t m b t G j b ia b ` t p rkvcs h y b p rcpk`d crb` gc k e t mc c v i d c`g c t m b t mcwbs u` j bw e u j j y d i s g r ia i `b t cd bob i `s t hcgbusc k e m i s r bgc .

_ i t m i ` b e c w dbys ke r cgc i p t ke ay I` t c r i a Dcg is ik` 2 , G j b iab` t cxp rcss jy ,s t b t c s i ` mi s c a b i j w r i t i ` o t k A r . A i g m b c j \wc io , Csq. t m b t " I V Gj b i a b ` t Q r c e us c t k PcPPg k a au ` i g b t c b ` y e u r t m c r w i t m m i a V A r . Gm r i s t i b ` B. Gbrhk`c , Csq., b j bwy c r P P P P P Pgk j j cb ouc k e A r . \wc io b t Jkch & Jkch, t m c j b w e i r a r c p r c s c ` t i ` o Xcs p k`d c` t s Q" . .. ." Hbscd k` Gm r i st i b ` ' s b r r k o b ` t b ` d d c e i b ` t r cspk`sc t k ay rcqucs t t k ' acc t vBb7b ` d g k` e c r ,' g k u pj c d w i t m t m c e b g t t m b t mc wbs `kt I ` v k j v cd i ` Xkwc b ` d g j c b r j y P P' LLf ` k w s ` k t m i ` o b h k u t w m b t b g t ub j j y k g g u r r c d i ` c j c g t r k ` i g d isgkvcry . " (Xcspk`dc` ts ' Xcpjy t k I ` t c r i a Dcg is ik` 2 , Cxm ih i t 8 )

2 iP Tv. l e P t - m P g tP I / t k k f Br h i t r b j ` kt i g c k e t m c s t u ` ` i ` o bd v b`g cs i ` c -d i s gkvcry r c t r i c v b j V P PkP t_ ic r e gj l F S P P k r c ` s i P b ` d I b ` t i g i p b t c d g k r r c sp k ` d i ` o j y d r b a b t i g g ks t r c d u g t i k ` s . Xc j i b h jc ePlPkg_ Z d w c r c ` k t e k r t m g k a i ` o , w i t m t m c p b r t i c s h j b a i ` o k` c b ` k t m c r e k r kB Pe PbJ t e | : g m ' P j kg f j ` o_e e c g t i vc d isgkvcry . Xcs p k`d c` t wb s g k ` e r k ` t c d w i t m 7 8 9 P P P j i IJ,

i ` t c r r k o b tk r i c s . T m c e i r s t oc` c rb t ik` k e IT spcg ib j i s t s g i r gb 299 = w c r c ` k j k ` o c r * e P lcap j kycd , s j kw i ò t mc p rkgcss . Gk`s cq u c` t j y , t m c r c w b s ` k t m i ` o a k r c t k v Z

P 4 * j i f c j y g kac e k r w b r d e r k a m u` d r c d s k e t m k us b ` d s k e c a b i j s h c y k ` d b o rkss jy Zd i s p r k p k r t i k ` b t c muoc h i j j . (Xcspk`dc` t Kg t kh c r 2 2 , 8 > 2 7 j c t t c r ) . B j t m k u o m l

G jb iab` t suoocs tcd t m b t m i s cxpc r t aby gmb roc k` j y b e r b g t ik` j ke t mc p rcvb i j i ò e ; US3 P Zr b t c s , t mc j ko i s t i g s k e cbgm pb r ty' s IT cab i j cxpc r t s iau j t b` ckus j y hc i ò i ` t mc .rSP| v|s bac r kka , t k sby `k t m i ò k e G j b iab` t b `d Xcs p k`d c` t ' s b t t k r ` c y s h c i ` o i ` " "" P ' ' P Pt m b t sbac r kka, wbs tm c rcg ipc e k r b v i r t ub j oub r b` t cc k e b qu i g f o r id j kgf cde i b sgk .


20/23

- ( t v P P evPKK L FL - (/ K-B ' ecBP`s j-J-e L- Tmc pkss i h j c t cs t i ak` y k e A r . Xbyak`d Mcsj i` , Csq. s c c a c d cssc` t ib j i `

^GALP P ' P ' ' P ' H t mc gmb i ` k e gus t kdy b`d gk` t rk j r cob rd i ` o Cxm i h i t B . G jb ia b` t ,m k w c v c r , dcg i dcd mc wku j d rb t mc r dcpksc Xcsp k`dc `t ' s GCK b` d j bwycrs. Tmbt ,

wbs b gj bssig`k`-Wtbrtcr, dcs i o`cd t k fccp t m i s a b t t c r o k i ` o ` k w m c r c 'M'P-W jP i PP P ' i W ' " d ce i ` i t c j y . Gj bi a b` t ' s d c p ks i t i k ` " st r bt c oy" i s b `b j ko ku s t k A b r h u r v v . TP j P P l z* 'r.

A bdi sk `. 2 Grb`gm (3 S.W. 27 ?. 8 J.Cd. 5 > ( 2 = > 7 ) . I t `cgcssb r i j y acc t s w i t m b I Pjt]l_g IW- s ia i j b r rcsu j t . I t i s b sc`sb t i k` b j i s t i g i ` t c r rk rc a t b g t i g dcs io`cd t k i` dugc gmbks (SLlP P P .

. b a k ` o t m c k p p k s i ` o s i dc . Lust bs A brh u r y wbs gkap c j j c d t k p rkg ccd Z P0P:i i ` g r c ac ` t b j j y b ` d t m u s gk u j d ` k t s i ap j y w bj f i ` t k t m c Wup r cac Gkurt b`d hc g j P Z P ( P / P P' PPP i ` s t b`gc , dcpk s i `o Xcspk`dc`t ' s GCK i` t mc e i r s t i ` s t b ` g c ej ics PwPP -PUP

WPA P t B ' i ` t m c e b gc k e c s t b h j i s m c d p r k gc d u r c . I o r b ` t c d i ` p b r t Xc sp k ` d c ` t s ' Bu o u s t 8 > , t P l I evPPkk 8 > 2 7 J c t t c r A k t i k ` i ` Xcspk`sc t k Gjb iab` t ' s Buous t ? , 8> 27 Wuhai ss i k` . P t *

P t P s B t t k r` cys \wc io , Gb rhk`c , b`d Obvbr is, b`d _A C Gk-GCKBr i Cab`uc j smbj j ` k t T "hc dcpkscd b`d smb j j `k t hc gbj j cd t k t cs t i e y hy Gjb i ab` t . Tmc rc brc bdd i t i k ` b j - P P PZZc/PPRrP g k ` s i d c r b t i k ` s a i j i t b t i ` o b o bi ` s t su gm p k t c ` t i b j d c p k s i t i k ` s . Tm r k u o m k u t t m i s bPP-PP

Z WPP c ' j t i r c ab t t c r . G jb iab` t mbs vkg i e c rkus j y b`d rcp cb t cd j y bgguscd cbgm k e t mcsc g / P ' 0t* *P p/ P P pc rsk`s k e g r ia i` b j gk` dug t . Tk rcq u i rc b`y k e t mcsc Jkch bt t k r ` c ys k r A r . P P P P Pv0 P P k P 0 g P a b ` uc j t k p r k v i d c t c s t i a k ` y i ` t m i s g i v i j b r h i t r b t i k ` w k u j d p k t c ` t i b j j y v i k j b t c

G k ` st i t u t i k ` b j WP B a c ` d a c ` t r i o m t b ob i `s t s c j e - i ` g r i a i ` b t i k ` i ` t m c P P P P 2 P P P t m b t G j b i ab ` t e k j j k w s t m r k u o m k ` mi s p c r s i s t c ` t t m r c b t k e s c c f i ` o g r i a i ` b j kPyP:GZ

L-lPkvcB-U- p r k s cg u t i k ` . Lj i e P M P - j B J . / r" P e P P Le P wry @Z - p_Bvl r:{ k B PkP8 APKL Crok, u p k ` gk a p j c t i ` o ay r c gc i p t k e t m c p b r t i c s ' e i ` b j pbpcrs k` PPTPPP

D c g c a h c r 9 , 8 > 2 7 , 2 dcg jb r cd t mc rcgk r d g j kscd . kTPl 2P b d d i t i k ` t k a y EI@DI@OW sc t e k r t m i ` s u a a b r y k` pboc k`c bhkvc ,:luPbZ7P ' P P' PD t m b t b` y " j i c` " p rbg t i gc i ` vk j v i ` o c i t mc r pb r t y k r t mc i r boc` t s is

I g LP d g k ` t r b r y t k t m c o k k d e b i t m b ` d g k ` e i d c ` t i b j i t y c xp c g t b t i k ` s k e t m i s br h i t r b t i k ` . tvvgbBiL _t | _- b g m p b r t y i s h k u ` d h y t m c i r w r i t t c ` p r k a i sc " t k fc c p t m c b w br d gk ` e i d c ` t i b j PUPP

P - e j t r Tt y i P C " P ... c xc g u t c b j j d k g u a c` t s `cgcssb ry t k a b i ` t b i ` s ug m g k ` e i d c ` t i b j i t y . " I ` m i s P 2 P Pg i x0 c P P P P ' k r t m g k a i ` o A k t i k ` e k r r c bs k `b h j c e cc s b `d g k st s bs t m c p r cvb i j i ` o p b r t y,

F g P i b P s P e Gjb i ab` t smb j j sct e k r t m b`d t mk r ku om j y cxp jb i ` m i s i ` vk j vca c` t , i e b`y, i ` b`y M s { : * f x ii`/ v` t iPcP " j i c` " p r b g t i g c b ` d sm b j j e u r t m c r s m k w gbusc bs t k wm y b`y b`d bj j a k ` c y 2 P 4 P P ar P g4 P / P gg i P dbabocs, eccs , b`d gks ts bwbrd cd G jb i ab`t smku j d `k t hc csgr kwcd hy PPTeiP

W P g P Xc sp k `d c` t ' s b t t k r ` c ys u ` t i j t m c r c is s u e e i g i c ` t b e e i r a b t i v c p r k k e Gj b i a b` t wb s P P / P P ,` k t b`d is `kt i ` v k j v cd i ` j i c` p rbg t i gc rcob rd i ` o b`y pc rsk` w m b t s k c v c r , k rh u s i ` css , g k r p k r b t i k ` , j b w e i r a , k r t mc BBB, i` vk j vcd , i d c ` t i e i c d , kr ` b a c d i ` 'PPPP-csgPP Z T


21/23

b`y eb sm i k` wmb t skcvc r i ` t m i s b r h i t r b t i k ` . O k i ` o e k r w b r d e r k a t m c d b t c k e tm i s^ b r t i b j E i`b j Bwbrd , k e e c`s i vc j i c p r b g t i g chyc i t m c r p b r t ykrb` yket m c i r boc`ts ,i d c ` t i e y i ` o , i ` v k j v i ` o ,kr` b a i ` o b`yp c r s k ` , h u s i ` c ss , g k r p k r b t i k ` , j b w e i r a ,krt m cBBBw m b t s k c vc r , isp c r a b ` c ` t j y c ` l k i ` c d .

:;huP I EI@D i ` s u e e i g i c ` t `cxus hc t wcc ` b`y i ` d i v idub j pc rsk` `bacd bsb a k ` oilCAi' iU i( | j7Xcspk`dc`ts, i `g j ud i `o , h u t ` kt `cg cssbr i j y j i a i t c d t k , Lc e e rcy A cb dc b`d Wbrbm

Z p )-tevB Mkvc _ i ` i b r s f I ) , b ` d t m c y b r c d i s a i s sc d e r k a t m i s a b t t c r .P Pf| B.:zBe' IEI@D t m b t t m c b r h i t r b t i k b o r c c a c ` t s b r c ` k t u ` g k ` s g i k ` b h j c . P P_

siBgPiPZrsPP L^ j P P P P P PI P P P P l u r i s di g t i k ` kvcr t m c p k j i t i g b j q u c st i k ` d k g t r i ` c P rc j b t cd Issucs. @c i t mcr dkcs b`y gku r tkrb r h i t r b t k r . ^ kj i t i g b j q u c s t i k ` ske P s cp P b P

a b o ` i t u d c b j j c o cdhyGj b i a b ` t g b `hcr csk jvcd k` j y hyt m c j c o i s j b t i v c b ` d FPPG- G PPe gvy pfljjk, cxcgu t i vc c jcg t cd h rb` gmcskeokvc r` ac` t . Wcc, Ocrb jd Ou` t mc r b`d Fb t m j cc PP P PgP

W u j j i v b ` ,GK@WTITSTIK@BJJB_(27P P C d i t i k ` 2 9 9 ? ) b t 4 3 - 4 5 . . . pk j i t i g b j q u c s t i k ` s b r c i ` b p p r k p r i b t c e k r l u d i g i b j r c s k j u t i k ` b ` d b rc t m c r c e k r c ZPPPZiigti.

i P r P ` k ` j u st i g i b h j c @P :PP/ i Z P :0@d P P _ A P I i * :PPP:z Gdif}bssje-PSugm ke Gj b i a b ` t ' s t m c k r y kem is gbsc i` vkfcs mis dcsi rct kbgm icvc t mc P2P PP*P''

PPP' T P c rb d i g b t i k ` kew m b tmcb j j cocs isb_ m i t c W u p r c a b g i s t Lcwism r c o i a c b ` d t m c guP vPvg k r r c s p k ` d i ` o s t r u g t u r b j r cdcs io`ket m c p k j i t i g b j , cgk`ka ig b`d skg ib j k rdc rke P P P Pt m c S ` i t c d W t b t c s , P .giy' guP ' P - WP i e P P ' LT M P ' A P L P " P

g:yvmkuc Tmcb ` t i t r u st j b w c j c a c ` t skeGjb iab` t ' s gbsc b rc j i f cw isc `k t l u s t i g i b h j ciPbPt iB i` t m i s b r h i t r b t i k ` . Tmcy b rc t kk g jksc jy i ` t c r wkvc` w i t m t m c p k j i t i g b j q u c s t i k ` gJsat0iP d k g t r i ` c b ` d w i t m Gj b i a b` t ' s r c p c b t c d r c i t c r b t i k ` skeXcspk`dc` t ' s b`d

Xc s pk ` d c` t ' s b t t k r ` c y s b j j c o c d g r i a i ` b j g k ` d u g tt k hcbddr csscd i` t m i s P 'P,PU:iPhPF)P P P P P i t r b t i k ` . IKXDCX t m b t G j b i ab ` t ' s p k j i t i g b j q u c s t i k ` b ` d b ` t i t r u s t g j b i a s b r c L

/ d i s a i s s cd e r k a t m i s b r h i t r b t i k ` . BgP0Z-P''PPP 'PPP'{P dig:S ePPP PPP- FtU IEI@D t m b t G j b i a b ` t j i h c j c d X cs p k ` d c ` t b ` d Xc s pk ` d c` t ' s b t t k r ` c y s . P P `gyipvP jg

|8t| P Z P ' 7 ' ' P 7 t s t b t c s t m b t mc rb i scd g j b i as \wcio b`d Gbrhk` c c`obocd KUL_U g r i a i ` b j g k ` d u g t k ` _ i j j i b a A k r r i s ' h c m b j e. . . gk`sp i rbgy, gk j ju s ik` , b`d gubxj P v(:;(

c/ wj,l(.djkl e r b u d v i k j b t i ` o ,i ` t c r b j i b ,XIGK. Ib w b r d t m c $ 2 , > > >g k u ` t c r g j b i ake PPlP Xcspk`dc` t . Tmis $ 2 , > > > s m b j jhcs u h t r b g t c d e r k a t m c a k ` c y dbabocs b wbr dcd e Lt5G j b i a b ` t . Xb t m c r t m b ` g j u t t c r t m i s ^b r t i b j Ei`b j Bwbrd w i t mbj i t b ` ykej i h c j ,I kkP() PP

d i r c g t Xcspk`dc` t ' s j bwyc rs t k p rkv i dc bj i s tkegbsc g i t b t i k ` s g k r r k h k r b t i ` o :P P ' P


22/23

Gj b i a b ` t ' s u ` p r k t c g t c d s p cc g m bs j i h c j k u s / d c e b a b t k r y t k t m cBBBt k e k r w b r dt kG j b i a b ` t b ` d g k p i c d t k a c .

M b v i ` o e k u ` d t m b t p r c v b i j i ` o p b r t y Gj b i a b ` t w b s d i s g r i a i ` b t c d b o b i ` s tk`t m c h b s i ske m i s r b gc , b ` d m b v i` o e k u ` d t m b t Xc sp k ` d c ` t ' s w k r f p jb g c I s ` k tv i b h j c e k r Gj b i a b ` t ' s r c t u r ` t k w k r f 2 > d b t c mc wbs P (\k/ / |Bklz4P r c a k v c d e r k a Xc s p k `d c ` t ' s p b y r k j j b ` d mi s h u y - k u t b t e u j j p b y gc b sc d t m r k u o m Z / UJgi / M

t m c d b t cke t m i s ^BXTIBJ EI@BJB_BXD. Tmis b a k u ` t ke hbgf pby smb j j hc b t j i i s eZ/Zp k r i c i ` k j m i r c r b t cke $ 4 > > p c r w c c f . Z /PjKPZ

B 0 P ( I KXDCX t m r c c yc b r s ke e r k ` t pbyo k i ` o e k r w b r d e r k a t mcd b t c ke t m i s ^BXTIBJ EI@BJ B_BXD. Tmis b a k u ` t ke e r k ` t pby s m b j j hk g b j g u j b t c db`d

2 P PP b w b r d c d bt t m c r b t c ke $ ? 3 , > > >pkr b ` ` u a ( s cc pbocs 2 5 - 2 ? b ` d e k k t ` k t c 8 3 ,. P P l P P P P j P j b i a b ` t ' s A k t i k ` e k r Gj b r i e i g b t i k ` k e Wcgk`d I ` t c r i a D cg i s i k `)

' KXDCX Gj b i a b ` t t k e i j c m i s d c t b i j c d ( h y d b t c , m k u r , b ` d w k r f d c s g r i p t i k ` )s(r`jVkPVL A k t i k ` e kr r c b sk ` b h j c e c c s b ` d gk s t s k` kr h c e k r c L b ` u b r y 7 2 , 8 > 2 4 .I KXDCX

s i e g P A G j b i a b ` t b j s k t k sct e k r t m t mcb a k u ` t b`dt y p c ( c . o . g k a p c ` s b t k r y b ` d / k r/ vi i ,e P i | ' P c vl ^u `i t i vc ) ke d b a b o c s mcg j b i a s h c y k ` d b g t u b j h b g f pbyb ` d e r k ` t p b y, b ` dmis

l r b t i k ` b j c e kr s b a c . Bs s t b t c d b h k v c r c ob r d i ` o Xc sp k ` dc ` t ' s h u r c b u g r b t i g P P P ( ( P c j k ` o b t i k ` ke r c b d i j y b s g c r t b i ` b h j c m i r i ` o d b t b , e kr c x b a p j c , I bap b r t i g u j b r j y L/ UA gT

b a c ` b h j c t k b p p r k p r i b t c r c g k a p c ` s c b w b r d c d e k r b v ki d b h j c d c j b y s b ` d I d i r c g t r f0P j-(t F P ' _e ' : B( | l t j bj ab `t ' s b t t c ` t i k ` c s p cg i b j j y t k b d d r c ss su gm i ` s t b ` gc s i ` mise kr t m g k a i ` o ' P P ' P

U ' P t p k t i k ` . I e G j b i a b ` t ` c c d s a k r c t i a c h c y k ` d Lb ` u b r y 7 2 , 8 > 2 4 , duc t k t mc P P ) PP P P P P m r i s t a b s . @cw Ycbr, b ` d Xcv. Dr. A b r t i ` Ju t m c r F i ` o,Lr. m k j y d b ys / ` b t i k ` b j | i T

* P ' ' P 7 y* ' G j b i a b ` t a b y r c q u c s t s b a c ke ac vib BBB b ` d b`ys ug m r c b sk ` b h j c P k P P Ll Pr c q u c s t s m b j j hc j i h c r b j j y o r b ` t c d . Xc s p k ` d c ` t s m b j j m b vc 7> dbys e k j j k w i ` o r vi P P PXc sp k ` d c` t ' s r c g c i p t e r k a t m cBBB ke Gj b i a b` t ' s A k t i k ` s t k r c s p k ` d t ks b a c , PvZP:rPb ` d G j b i a b ` t s m b j j m b vc 7 >dbys t m c r c b e t c r t k e i j cbe i ` b j r c p j y . PL

BP:UkPi :v (( .P eevc rcj ice {-ekPidUBtP rzkGvP U* :i -ikA

8


23/23

Bj j e i j i ` o s s m b j j hc s u h a i t t c d t k B B B e k r e k r w b r d i ` o t k a c b ` d t k t m ck p p k s i ` o p b r t y .

Wk Krdcrcd

Dbvid J. Orcokry

Dbvid J. Orcokry b e e i r a t m b t k ` t m i s 2 ? t m Db y k e D c g c a h c r 8 > 2 7 Im b v c c x c g u t c d t m i s d k g u a c ` t bs a y ^ b r t i b j Ei ` b j B w b r d i ` t m i s a b t t c r .

Dbvid J. Orcokry

^brt ibje i `b j bwbrd

7

Documents

Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment et al. (10-9647) -- Letter to P. Kevin Castel to Modify March 3, 2014 Order Part 1 of 2 [March 5, 2014]