Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (10-9647) (PKC) (JCF) -- Draft of Appeal to Second Circuit re: Fraudulently Procured Orders of P. Kevin Castel [Handwritten

8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (10-9647) (PKC) (JCF) -- Draft of Appeal to Second Circuit re: Fraudulently Procured Orders o

1/55

Q M H \ A L ^ \ @ \ A ^ L H ^ \ Z H N \ N K Q Z \ ^ K Q \ F A Z M L H ^ \ Z H N \

KO

M A R X K Z D

[ . . - [ - [ - . . . . V 3

G@ZNQ^ H ^ @ H @ F

R@^FHMB\KM,

3

Ye`hmt h oo

3

-`b`hmst-

R H E E H @ G

GKZZH^

AMLA@_KZ

AM\AZ\@HMGAM\,

E E N ,

okrgarey dmkwm`s tfa

R H E E E ] _ e

GKZZH^ @BAMNX,HMN.,

CAOO

G A @ L A

`ml ^ @ Z @ F R H M H @ Z ^ D H ,

N h v h e @nt hkmM k.

09

N hv .

8?


2/55

H

HM\ZKLQN\HKM

H prk sa Ye`hmthoo, G`rnus Hs`h`f R`sfhmbtkm, sujght tfhsG k t h k m ' hmraspkmsatk tfa ^aptagjar 1, :90?9 fkurs (69 fkurs waad),

wkrdhmb

km tfhs

Gkthkm

`ml H mkw ra ehza

tf`t ht'southea okr ga tk ga tk nkmthmua. \fa rbugamts r hsal hm gyG`rnf 02, :90< Or ul Qpkm lha Nkurt

Gkthkm

lagkmstr ta tf t Rheeh`g

Gkrrhs

f samb balhm 00? ya r p ttag `ml nkmthmuhmb pr nthna kor`nh elhsnrhghm`thkm

`b hmst

@orhn`m

@garhn`ms hm agpekygamt `ml lhsnrhghm tal `b hmst ga

jan usa

ko

gy

r`na, nkekr `ml/kr m thkm e

krhbhm

hm

vhke`thkm

k o

tfa

Nhvhe

Zhbfts

@nt

ko

08?


3/55

tf`t3 (0.) Y.

Dav hm

N`stae f`s

hmtamthkmèey

nkmsphral tk laprhva ga

k ogy

nkmsthtuthkmè `ml st`tutkry rhbfts

umlN\ tfa nkekr ko e`w,janùsako gy

r`na,

nkekr, m`thkmè kr hb hm

`ml/krprk sast`tus

hm

vhke`thkm

ko 06

Q.^.N. :


4/55

kmeyjankga avam gkra nkgpQn`ta< nkmoushmb `ml wgpeax, e`rbaey lua tk tfa hmtK\thkm e

r`tarsk o

Zapujehn`m ]pkhm tal oalar e culba Y.

Davhm

N`stae.

T@rjhtr`tkr

Brabkry Y`rthè

Ohmè @w`rl,

0.W

r`.

E A B @ E

^ \ @ M L @ Z L

O K Z Z A _ H A R 3 O A L . Z. N H _ .

Y. ?9.

Yursu`mt tk Oal. Z.

Nhv.

Y. ?9(j)(>), kma

k o

tfa brkumls w`rr`mthmb

rae hao

orkg

`

ohmè

culbgamt, krlar, kr

prknaalhmb hs orùl (wfatfar pravhkusey nèeal hmtrhmshn kr axtrhmshn), ghsraprasamt thkm, kr ghsnkmlunt

jy

`m kppkshmb p`rty, kr pursu`mt tk ?9(j)(?), `my ktfar

ra`skm

tf`t custhohas raQao \fa st`ml rl okr

br`mthmbsunf ` gkthkm hs strhnt, `ml rankmshlar`thkm

w h e e

bamarèey ja lamhal

umeass

tfa gkvhmb p`rt n`m

pkhmt tk

nkmtrkeehmb

lanhshkms kr l`t` tf t tfa nkurt kvarekkdal - g tars, hm ktfar wkrls, tf`t ghbft

ra`skm`jey ja axpantal tk ètar tfa nkmneushkm ra nfal jy tfa nkurt. ^fr`lar

v .

N^V \r`msp.. Hmn.. 29 O.>l

:11,:12 (:l

Nhr.

0881). \fa n`tnfèeprkvhshkmokr `my ktfar

ra`skm

tf`tcusthohasr a e h a o raqgras ` sfkwhmb

k o

axtr`krlhm`ry nhrnugst mnas. Bkmzèaz

v.

Nrksjy. 162 O.>l ?68 (08?6)4

sa a èsk \fa Yakpea ko lha^t`takoHe e hmkhsv. Oral A. ^tarehmb. >12 g. >1>?

000.

>0?4 0?6

M . A .

:18 (08:8)

( \fa g`xhg tf t orùl vhth`tas avary tr`ms`nthkm hmtk

wfhnf

htamtars . . . ) 4Hm ra

_hee`ba

koRheekwjrkkd.

`w rlal tkNe hg`mt.Z tfar tf mneuttar tfhs Y`rthè

Ohm e @w`rl

w h tf`

eht my

koehjae,H lhrant

Zaspkmlamt's

e wyars

tk

prkvhla ehst

k o

n sanht thkms nkrrkjkr thmb Ne hg`mt's umprktantalspaanf`s ehjaekus/lao g tkry tk tfa

@ @ @

tk

okrw rltk Ne hg`mt ml nkphal tk ga.

T@rjhtr tkr

BrabkryY`rth eOhm e

@w rl,

00-0:.W

-> -


5/55

>2 H e e .@pp.:l>8> (08?:)( H ths `xhkg`thn tf`t orùl vhth`tas

avarytfhmb. ),

(agpf`shs `llal) \fhsn`sae`w

f`s jaam nhtal shmna H

`nnusal

Ekaj & EkajE E Y ,Ghnfàe Y.

Swahb

`ml

R h e e h ` gGkrrhs

k o amb`bhmb hm `

p`ttag ko orùl upkm tfa Nkurt hm gytfhrl/okurtf`ppaè tk tfa ânkmlNhrnuht.

H _ . @ Z B Q G A M \ ^ ^ Q Y Y K Z \ H M B \ F @ \Y.D A _ H M N @ ^ \ A E F @ ^

H M \ A M \ H K M @ E E X L A Y Z H _ A L G A K O

G X

N K M ^ \ H \ Q \ H K M @ E

@ML

^ \ @ \ Q \ K Z X

Z H B F \ ^

Q M L A Z

\ F A

N K E K Z K O E @ R L Q A \ K G X Z @ N A N K E K Z

@ML/KZ

M @ \ H K M @ E K Z H B H M

@ML

H ^ A M B @ B H M B

HM

@

E @ Z B A Z

N K M ^ Y H Z @ N X \ K

H M \ O A Z A R H \ F

\ F A F Q G @ M

Z H B F \ ^ K O

Y A K Y E A

K O @ O Z H N @ M L A ^ N A M \ .

h q ] W

^hmna H

oheal

` nkgpe`hmt

w h t f

tfa ^kutfarm

Lhstrhnt k o

Maw X k rdkm Lanagjar

:0 ,

:909,0

f`va mavar f`l tfa kppkrtumhty tkspa`dumlar k`t h h`t `m krè fa`rhmb. H f`va mavar gat Y.

D a v hm

N`stae,

mkr f`va H avar stappal okkt hm fhs nkurtrkkg. H `g g`dhmbskgapratty sarhkus èeab`thkms `b`hmst `

suppksaley fkmkr`jea oalarè culba, tfaraokra, kma ko tfa

kmey

w`ys tk lagkmstr`ta tfa

`ppa`r`mna

`ml/kr `ntuè r`nhè jh`s, praculhna, hgprkprhaty `ml

p`rthèhty w h t f

tfa culbas `sshbmal tk tfhs

n`sa,

hs

tfrkubf tfah ] E a , axtragaey hgpkrt`mt lanhshkms lh`t fa f s

g`la

hm tfhsn`sa.

@ .

Dtfhnè

()jeh `thkm.s (to

@rthnd-

H HH Hnltrhhe.Hmlhas `ml tfa H matfhnè .Unthkms keY. D a U h h h (

`sQ'e|

h*vo|(nC-

\frkubfkut tfa fhstkry ko tfa Qmhtal

^t`tas

k o@garhn`,g`ckrhty k o tfa oalarè culbas wfk f`va jaam

tk tfa jamnf f`va jaam wfhta gèas. Km G`rnf 1, :99>, N`stae w`s mkghm`tal jy Yrashlamt

Uh

Bakrba R .Jusf tk sa tkm lha

Lhstrhnt

Nkurt okr tfa ^kutfarm

Lhstrhnt

k oMawX k r dv`n`tal jy E`wramna

G . GnDamm`. N`stae w s nkmohrgal jy tfaQmhtal

^t`tas âm`ta

km âptagjar 02, :99>, `ml ranahval fhs

.nkgghsshkm km âptagjar ::, :99>. Hm fhs K`tf ko KoPna, l`tal âptagjar ::, :99>, fa st`tal3

w h e e

suppkrt `ml laoaml tfa Nkmsthgthkm ko tfa

Qmhtal

t tas

`b`hmst èe amaghas, okrahbm `ml

lkgasthn4 thh`t

0w h e eja`r

trua

o`htf

`ml èeabh`mna tk tfa

s`ga4

lh`t H t`da thus kjehb`thkm oraaey,

whtfkut

`my gamtè rasarv`thkm kr purpksa

k o

av`shkm4 `ml tf`t H

w h e e w a e e

`mlo`h tfohley lhsnf`rba tfa luthas ko

tfa

koohna

km

wfhnf

H `g `jkut tk

amtar.

^k faep ga Bkl.

\faQmhtal

^t`tas

Nkmsthgthkmprkvhlas 1* `ml 0


6/55

km

'bkkl o` hl h ' lanhshkm-g`dhmb. Ht w`s mavar hmtamlal tk hmneula 'j`l-o`htf' lanhshkm-g`dhmb, wfara `

culba

dmkwhmbey

`ml laehjar`taey lhsrab`rls tfa o`nts `ml e`w ko n`sa.\fhs hs prkparey tfa sujcant ko

lhsnhpehm`ry

ravhaw, hrraspanthva

k o

wfatfar

ht

hs nkrrant`jea km `ppaè. @ml abrabhkus arrkr èsk nkmsthgtas

ghsnkmlunt, shmna hts m`tura `ml/kr g`bmhtula

prasuppksa

tf`t ` culba `ntal

w h e e o h l e y ,

kr tf`t fa hs

hmnkgpatamt.' *

Kvar tfa

nkursa

ko ma`rey okur ya`rs, N`stae f`s hssual okg lanapthvaey

wrhttam

`ml kma-shlal

Krlars hm tfhs

n`sa3

(0.) Cuey :9, :900 Krlar

wfhnf

st`yal tfa

n`sa

hm tfa oalarè nkurt `ml nkgpaeeal tfa

n`sa

tk ja `rjhtr`tal jaokra tfa @garhn`m

@rjhtr`thkm

@ssknh`thkm ( ^t`y

Krlar ),

(:.) G`rnf 2, :90< Krlar

gklhoyhmb

fhs G`rnf >, :90< Krlar lhranthmb ga

mkt

tk sujght gy Orùl Qpkm tfa Nkurt

Gk t h k m w h t f hm

89

l`ys

otar @rjh tr`tk]rabkry hssual fhs Lanagjar 02, :90> Y`rthè

Ohmè@w`rl,

(>.) G`rnf :2, :90 (@ubust

:991).

pb. >2 (0828){qukthmb009 Nkmb. Zan. ?1


9/55

lhsnrhghm`tkry pr`nthnas `ml lavhnas wfhnf f`va okstaral r`nh`eey str`thohal ckj amvhrkmgamts tk tfa

lhs`lv`mt`ba ko ghmkrhty nhthzam. )4@ejarg`reaY`parNk. v. Gkkly.


10/55

ehjarènkmstrunthkm ko T@garhn`'sW ragalhè

n h v h e

rhbftsst`tutagust ja `ppehal tkamsuratf`t

\ h t h a

_ H H

nkmthmuas tk ja `

sarhkusraspkmsa

tk ` nkgpeax sknhè

prkjeag.''''*

A`nf r`nhè

lhsnrhrmhm`thkmn`sa

hs umhqua

`ml gust ja lanhlal km `

n`sa-jy-n`sa

j`shs.Lua tk tfa o`nt tf`tefhs w`s `m umlashr`jea n`sa

wfhnf

laèt

w h t f

` nkgpeax, yat axtragaey hgpkrt`mt sknhèhssua`ml 0, s `m @or hn`m @garhn`mprk saehthb`mt,

w`s nfèeambhmb tfa

hmsthgthkmèey

r`nhst `ml `mthnkgpaththva agpekygamt &

jushmass

pr`nthnas, pkehnhas

`mlprknaluraskoR h e e h `g

Gkrrhs

`mlFkeeywkkl`s ` wfkea, ht w`s avam gkra hgpar`thva tf`t tfa oalarè

culba`sshbmaltk tfan`saw s `jea tk rag`hmhgp`rthè`ml hmlapamlamt avam wfam lanhlhmb tfa tfrasfkel

hssuak owf`tokrugtfan`sasfkuel jaehthb`tal.\fara hs bamarèey `m ùtkg`thn prastumpthkm tf`t tfa culba

hs kjcanthva `ml jahmbhgp`rthè,jut tf`t prasugpthkm n`hgkt ja bhvam tk Y. D a v h mN`stae lua tk tfa o`nt

thh`tfa f`s hmtamthkmèeyvhke`talthhaQ. . Nkmsthtuthkmc -o Qh** ,]]rt]] ] c(=ht]']

Rheeh`g

Gkrrhs' Fhstkry ko ehhtamthkhhèev Dvneulhhh @orhn`m ._hhharhn`ms Yhh'-L`thmm

H L

Knnurrhmb

Lurhmk Gr. U s Agpekygamt._mlYkehny ko _rehhtr`thm=Uee e`hmhs. | H m0686,

tfa

R hQh`g

Gkrrhs

@bamny w`s okhglal jy ` Barg`m Cawhsf hgghbr`mt m`gal Sadm`m Gksas, e`tar

]

dmkwm`s R h e e h ` gGkrrhs,hm Maw Xkrd Nh ty .Okr gkra tf`m 001ya`rs,tfhs tèamt `ml Qtar`ry`bamnyf s hmhm]h

s t `t tfa aphnamtar koFkQywkkl`mlraprasamtalskgako tfa jhbbastm`gashm amtart`hmgamt. Yursu`mttk

tfa \èamt @bamnhas @nt( \ @ @ ) ,Nè. E`jkr Nkla 0299at saq. kma gust ja ehnamsal `s `m @bamt hm

krlar tk prknura

amb`bagamts

okr tèamt.'] ] ]] ]]]

`ppQal tk tfa nkgp`my's @bamt \r`hmaa prkbr`g kmCuma?, :90< `ml wamt tfrkubf Rfam Hjab`m']]]

t h p v

agpekygamt `t tfa nkgp`my's Maw

X k r d

koohnakm

aptagjar

:, :996,0, èkmb

w h t f

twk

ktfars

wfk st`rtal {sr

tfa @bamt \r`hmaa prkbr`g, shbmal ` mugjar ko agpekygamt nkmtr`nts, hmneulhmb ` g`ml`tkry, pra-lhsputa -p5

`rjhth`thkm`braagamt

wfhnf

st`tal

tf`t tfa p`rthas `braaTlW, tk `rjhtr`ta `my `ml èe

lhsputas

wfhnfg`y

`rhsa

jatwaam tfag rab`rlhmb `my

`spant

ko tfahr agpekygamt rae`thkmsfhp, hmneulhmb

lhsputas

rab`rlhmb

nkgpams`thkm, jamaohts, luthas krtarghm`thkm,jaokra ` shmbea, mauthè `rjhtr`tkr`nnapt`jeatkjk t h hp`rthas.

nkmthmua tk hmlhn ta lr`sthn eey pkkrar kutnkgas okr Je nd tf`m Rfhta @garhn`ms. Raprkpksatf`t Rfhtas'

jaehao

`jkut tfa hmnra`shmb prav eamna ko `mth-Rfhtajh sraoeants vhaw ko r`nhsg `s zark-sug b`ga...wfhnf n`m ja

suggal up s

'eass

`b hmst ykuga msgkra `b hmst ga.' )

Garrhnd.Agpekygamt

Lhsnrhghm`thkm

E w`ml

Ehthb`thkm.

AAKN Nkgpeh mna G`mu e ânthkm 013Z na`ml NkekrLhsnrhghm`thkm.( Janùsalhsnrhghm`thkm hs kotam sujtea

ml tfarar`raeyhs 'sgkdhmb bum,' latarghmhmb wfatfar r nape yal rkea hm tfa lanhshkm g`dhmb raquhras

ax`ghm thkmk o è etfa surrkumlhmb o`nts `ml nhrnugst mnas )

Hmtfa

ghnusnurhàjrhaooheal

km Lanagjar 2, :992 hm suppkrt kotfa

Zaspkmlamt

hm

@rmkelG .

Yrastkm

v.@eax

A.

Oarrar,

Rheeh`gGkrrhs'

ttkrmays L`vhlC. Jalarg`m `ml Culhtf J. Yrkwl`

st tal3

\fa

Rhe e h`g

Gkrrhs@bamny

amlkrsal tfa am`ntgamt ko rueas okr tfa trhn e `ml gkthkm phntura`bamts( s waee s rthsts'

g`m`bars)

tfrkubf

Nèhokrmh`'s

Agpekygamt @bamnhas @nt hm 08>2, `ml suppkrtal tfa \@ @wfam ht w`s `lkptal hm htsprasamtokrgjy

tfa N ehokrmh eabhse`tura hm 0826. R G @ nkmthmuas tk suppkrt tfa

\@@'s

kpar thkm `s tfrkubf tfa ehnamsura,

kvarshbft, `ml `lculhn thva lanhshkms ko N ehokrmh 's E`jkr Nkgghsshkmar tk tfhs vary l`y. \fa Maw Xkrd

aquhv eamt tk tfa \@ @hs okuml hm@rthnea 00 ko tfa Bamar eJushmassE`w ml @rthnea>2 ko tfa @rts `ml Nuetur e

@oo`hrsE`w,hmwfhnfumehnamsal

jkkdhmb

hs nkmshlaral nrhghm ekooamsa.\fasae wsnra`tatfa

heeushkm

tk kutshlars,

tf`t

tfara

ra umhquasdheeskr dmkwealba tf t kma gust `nquhra jaokra jahmb fhral `ml/kr prkgktal tk @bamt.

-8-


11/55

T R G @ :996

@rjhtr`thkm

@braagamtW Yhu-sm`mt tk

R h e e h ` g Gk r r h s '

nkmtr`nt, `my `ml èe lhsputas,

hmneulal lhsputas

hmvk evhmbst`ta

`ml oalarèlhsnrhghm`thkm`ml

f`r`ssgamt

ne`hgs, ne`hgs okr

wrkmbohl

targhm`thkm, ktfar st`tutkry ne`hgs, `ml tkrt `ml nkmtr`nt ne`hgs, hmneulhmb whtfkut

e hgh t` t hkm,

ne`hgs

jrkubft umlar

\h t ha

_ H H k otfa

N h v h e

Zhbfts

@nt ,

tfa @baLhsnrhghm`thkmhm Agpekygamt

@n t . . .

`ml `my ktfar

`mèkbkus

st`ta

kr oalarè

st`tkta

kr `my ktfar agpekygamt-rae`tal

ne`hg

k o

`my

d hml .

Hl.

@ ttfa thga k o

shbhumb

tfa `braagamt, H f l `jskeutaey mkra`skmtk kjcant tk thus e`mbu`ba. Lua tk

tfa o`nt tf`t H dmaw tf`t tfa nkgp my raprasamtal mhumarkus

@ o h h n ` m

@garhn`mamtartùhars kvar tfa

lan`las

`ml gy praehghm`ry

rasa`rnf

km tfa nkgp`my yhaelal mktfhmb `jkut tfa nkgp`my's fhstkry ko r`nhsg, H

`ssugal

tf`t @o h hn`m @garhn`ms wara `laqu`taey raprasamths] hm

ga`hthmbohl

pkshtkms tfrkubfkut tfahr

wkrdokrna.H f`l uu hE`skm tk ajcknt tfhn e`mbu`ba,

janùsa

H

Hgkw

lha nkgp`thyeapha&auealg`my

@o h hnlm

@gnrhkPJ

amtkrt`hmkrs'`ml mkma uo

hnsnc h h]f lhè 0e huGeh&eal uth Etetonkgphethy

pr hu h eu gy agpeuygamt,

hmlhn`tal

tf`t tfa nkgp`my f`l fhBtkr=rkohmtamthkmèeyaxneulhmb@ o h h n ` m@garhkkm`

oh-kg

fhral `ml/kr

prkgktJl

tk @bamt, Nuuhlhuèu. u. @oanut

\h` huEE .

H

' ] e ] - * ]

' ' ] e ] ] - R t

] t . ' D + _

U/v. (n-uR

r u o ] ] n

@otargaathmb èek ogynk-wkrdars, H raèhzal tf`t H w`s tfakmey@ or hn`m @garhn`m agpekyal `t 5, ]k -

`my

eavae k o

tfa @bamt \r`hmaa prkbr`g.

@etfkubf

tfara wara 19 @bamts agpekyal g tfa Maw

Xkrd

koe&na,

zark wara

@ o h h n` m

@garhn`mkr

Fhsp`mhn. aa xfhjhtL

\fhs w`s mkt `prkjeagokr ga

janùsa

H'va

spamt

gyamthra foa axnaeQmb hm pralkghm`mthy

èe-wfhta

amvhrkmgamts, fkwavar,

0

lhl f`va ` buthmsthmnt lh`t

skgatfhmb w`s mkt

rhbft

`jkut ga jahmb tfa

kmey

@ o h h n` m@garhn`m@bamt \r`hmaa. \fa nkgp my w`s `w`ra

tf`t H f`l cust nkgpeatal gy G`stars hm Gushn Jushmass

orkg

lha Qmhvarshty ko

G h ` g h ,

` ekt ko gy

prhkr

wkrd

axparhamna èekwal ga tk

wkrd wh tf

g`my ko tfa `rthsts hm urj`m nkmtagpkr`ry gushn tf`t tfay

raprasamtal, `ml tf`t tfa `rthst H

spamt

twk

ya`rs

nk-g`m`bhmb w`s sh bmal] kma ko tfa jhbbast @bamts `t

tfa `bamny - tfa ^_Y

k o

Qrj`mNkmtagpkr`ry

Gxhshn,

N. Eawhs( NYE ) /NEZhs` wfhta/ Cawhsf oagèa.

R h t f h m tfa ohrst waad k o gy agpekygamt, NYE kooaral ga `m kppkrtumhty tkwkrd `s far

tfhrl

`sshst`mt.Yrhkr `ml lurhmb gy agpekygamt, tfa nkgp`my w`s `w`ra k o NYE's raput`thkm ko jahmb vary

lho o hnhlt tkwkrdokr, tf`t sfa lhlm't gamtkr `ml tf`t hm gkra tf`m 01 ya`rs, sfa f`l mavar prkgktal `my ko

far @sshst`mts tk @bamt. \frkubfkut farn`raarsfa f`s raprasamtal gkra tf`m >1 k ojhbbast

m`gas

hm r & j

`ml fhp-fkp gushn, sunf `s C`y-S, Eùrym

F l e ,

Aghmag, Zhf`mm`, D`mya Rast, 19 Namt, Cahghoar Fulskm,

Yf`rraee

Rhef`gs,

G`ry

C. Jfba,

Ma-Xk,

Eul`nrhs `ml g`my ktfars. Nkhmnhlamtèey,hm kr `rkuml tfa thga

sujghttal gy rasuga, tfa nkgp`my tt`msoarral kma

k o

hts@bamt \r`hmaas - ` wfhta gèa - tk

wkrd

umlar

NYE`ml èekwal fhg tk jkkd tèamt umlar far, `s

w a e e

`s

raprasamt

fhs kwm

`nts,

ètfkubf fa f`l mkt yat

jaam prkgktal tk @bamt, `ml tfus, w`s mkt ehnamsal - `

vhke`thkm k o

tfa

\ @ @ - O kr

tfraa gkmtfs, H wkrdal

Yrhkr

tk `ppeyhmb tk tfa nkgp`my's @bamt \r`hmaa prkbr`g, H nk-g m`bal ` rankrlhmb `rthst `ml tkkd tfa

hmhthè

gaathmb

whtf

tfa nkgp`my's ^_Y ko Qrj`m Nkmtagpkr`ry Gushn okr raprasamt`thkm. \f t @bamt e`tar shbmal tfa

rankrlhmb `rthst, `ml lurhmb gy agpekygamt `s `m @bamt \r`hmaa, tfa rankrlhmb `rthst's n raarjeksskgal. TYH.

.L.M.X.Nkgpe`hmt ooe .W

-09-


12/55

hmwf`t

tanfmhnèey,

wkuelja nkmshlaral fkstlawkrdamvhrkmgamt.

0

w s mavar `laqu`taey tr`hmal `ml

w`s je`gal okr g`my tfhmbs tf`t H lhl mkt lk, H

trhal

gy

f`rlast

tk `jhla jy far rueas, jut sfa

`nnusal

ga

k o

tryhmbtk rum gy kwm sfhp. @etfkubf0f`l ` bkkl rae`thkmsfhpw h t fEawhs,wa jkg raèhzal tf`t jahmb

far`sshst`mtw`sm't bkhmb tkwkrd.^fa st`tal jahmb `m @bamt w`sjkrhmb,`ml amnkur`bal ga hmsta`l tk

ja `m `rthst

g`m`bar

`ml/kr

@ & Zjanùsa

rankbmhzal tf`t0f`l ` bkkl a r okr gushn. \frkubfkut tfarast

k o

gyagpekygamt, H g hmt`hmal ` bkkl rae`thkmsfhpw h t fNYE `ml far`sshst`mts.0b`vafar oaalj`nd km `

ek tko maw `rthsts, prkpksal tkur hla`s, nra`tal g`rdathmb prasamt thkms `ml `ttamlal g`my sfkws

w h t f

far

`ml far`sshst`mts.

@otar ea`vhmb NYE's

lasd,

H tt`msoarral j`nd tk tfa

G`hdkkg

`ml w`s mavar `jea tk e`ml `m

@sshst`mt pkshthkm okr tfa rag`hmlar k o tfa thga tf t H w s agpekyal `t tfa nkgp`my. TYH . ^.L.M.X. o [ . W

Kvar tfasp`mko08gkmtfs,

0

ra`fzal tf`t H w`s nkmshlar`jey gkraquèhohallh`m Qk ogy wfhta/ Cawhsf

nkumtarp rts fhral hmtk tfa @bamt \r hmaas prkbr`g, gkst wfk wara ranamt nkeeaba

br`lu`tas

`ml f`l mk

,

raeav`mt

wkrd

axparhamna hm tfa amtart`hmgamt hmlustry.

aa Axfhjht

A. H w`s bhvam fhbforaquamny ko

la`l-aml

`sshbmgamts`ml ^hsypfa`m t`sds, wfheajahmb v`buaey tk eljy Fug`mZaskurnastf`t @bamts

lhlm'tw`mt tk

wkrd

w h t f ga - ètfkubf tfa avèu`thkms tf`t H bkt `

nf`mna

tk saa lhl mkt raoeant tfahr

4

st`tagamts.TYH. ^.L.M.X.

Mkg`ttar fkw f`rl

trhal

tk

sunnaal, ht

w`s mavar bkkl amkubf. Kvarthga,htjan`ganea`r tk ga

tf`t H

wkuel

mavarf`vatfa kppkrtumhty tk rhsa `jkva tfa nkgp`my's

be`ssnahehmb.

H jab`m tk lavaekp `

sarhasko b`sttkhmtasthmè `ml urhm`ry faètf

hssuas

rae`tal tk tfa hggamsastrasstf`t H w`s umlar. H dmaw

tf`t ht

wkuel

ja hgpksshjea okr ga tk rhsa `jkva tfa nkgp`my's

be`ssnahehmb

`ml ja prkgktal tk gushn

@bamt.

^hmna H wkrdal tfrkubfkut tfa amtora nkgp`my `s ` oek`tar, H axparhamnal ` mugjar ko hmnhlamts

tf`t

g`la

ga jabhm tk jathava0w s

wkrdhmb

hm ` r`nhèey lhsnrhghm`tkry

wkrd

amvhrkmgamt.0lhsnkvaral

tf`t kma agpekyaa je`t`mthye halkm ga hm twk a-g`hes tk Fug`mZaskurnas`ml H ranahval `m axttagaey

mab`thva ravhaw

orkg

taeavhshkm @bamt

C`skm

Fklas, ètfkubf H wkrdal t fhslasdokr

eass

tf`m `m fkur `ml

tfa kmey lhhmb H f`l tk lk w`s nkmmant fhs nehamt tk ` nkmoaramna nèelh`t sfa w`s um`w`ra w`s t`dhmb

pe`na.

TYH .

^.L.M.X.

%

[ [ . W@otarjahmb um`jea tk

`lv`mna

tk @sshst`mt `ml/kr ja gamtkral,] H fael `

sarhas

k ogaathmbs

w h t f

uppar g`m bagamt `jkut gy nkmnags tf`t0w`s jahmb sat up tk o ` h e . TYH .^.L.M.X. %

D . W

Rfam 0 gat wh tf tfa okrgar NKK ko tfa Maw Xk rd

koohna

- N`r` ^tahm - `ml hmokrgal far thh`t H

jaehaval

tf`t H s w a e e`s ktfar

@or hn`m

@garhn`ms, wara jahmb lhsnrhghm`tal `b hmst

janùsa

ko kur r`na,

\frkubfkut

tfaehthb`thkm,tfhs f`s assamth eeyjaamtfa

laoamsak o

tfaLaoaml`mts.

\k gy dmkwealba, Fklas' sshst mt- G .G`ndamzha - wfk lhl mkthmokrgfhs nehamt ko tfa nkmoaramna

nèe,

f s

shmna

jaam

prkgktal tk @bamt.

Jaokra tfa nkgp`my garbal

whtf

Amla`vkr \ eamt @bamnyhm @ prheko:998,

R G @

fhral mktfar@orhn`m@garhn`m

@bamt

\r hmaa otar ga. \frkubfkut fhs agpekygamt t tfa nkgp`my'sMawXkrdkoohna,fa esk w s um`jea tk e ml `

lasd s m @sshst mt.

- 0 0 -


13/55

far

raspkmsa

w`s tf`t tfa nkgp`my wkuel

mavar

lhsnrhghm`ta

`b hmst@oh hn`m

@garhn`ms. TYH. ^.L.M.X.

[ [ . W

@oear

gaathmb wh tf tfa fa`lko Fug`m

Zaskurnas

- N`rkea D`tz - H lhsnkvaral tf`t Fug`m

Zaskurnasmavar

hmokrgal far tf`t H w`mtal tklhsnusstfhs

hssua

w h tffar `ml òtartaeehmbfar0nkuel

g`da

tfhs ` gunf jhbbar poajeag, sfa kooaral gaohvagkmtfs' sè`ry tk ekkd okr`mktfarckj. TYE .L.M.X.

t-]h^W . ' U

Kmgy e`st l`y,

@pr h e

8, :909,0

samt

` bkkljya a-g`he tk tfa amthra nkgp my tf`t wamt pujehn.]'

\fhsnra`tal ekt

k olaj`ta

jkut tfa lhsnrhghm`tkry agpekygamt

pr`nthnask o

tfa tèamt

`bamnhas

ml r`nhsg

hmFkeeywkkl

`s ` wfkea. Km Thmsart l`taW, H oheal` nkgpe`hmt w h tftfa AAKN wfhnf oknusal amthraey km

gy

hmlhvhluè

axparhamnas,

s w a e e s

hohokrg`thkm

`jkut tfa nkgp`my pkst-agpekygamt. @otar jahmb

U=Ch]dw]/_U*/yC

hmokrgal k ogy

nkgpe`hmt, Maw

Xkrd

koohna fhral 1

@oh hn`m

@garhn`ms hm kma gkmtf.]

Km

Lanagjar

:0, :909,]] H oheal ` lat`heal `ml thhkrkubf, 69p`baNkgpe`hmt wh tf tfa ^kutfarm

Lhstrhntko MawXkrd`b hmstgy okrgar agpekyar `ml tfa kelast tèamt `bamnyhmFkeeywkkl3 Rh e e h ` g

GkrrhsAmla vkr Amtart`hhghamt (okrgarey dmkwm s tfa Rh e e h ` gGkrrhs @bamny). \ ] , nkcmpe] t ` ekm] ]] ].

ast`jehsfal `prhg o`nha n`sako p`ttag `ml pr`nthna ( systaghn lhsp`r`ta tha`tgamt ),lhsp`r`tahmt`nt, @ v ] _

pra `ml pkst-fhrhmb lhsnrhmum`thkm, o`lga tk prkgkta, ratèh`thkm `ml `hlhmb & `jatthmb hmvhke`thkm ko ' y]C]

ânthkm 0860 ko lha

N h v h e

Zhbfts @nt ko 06??,


14/55

prkva tf`t `s ` g`ttar ko e`w3 Jktf ko tfa g`ml tkry, pra-lhsputa `rjhtr`thkm

`braagamts

H shbmal `s `

nkmlhthkm k oagpekygamt, wara prknalurèey `ml sujst`mthvaey hgnkmsnhkm`jea.

\fa nkgpaeehmb avhlamna lagkmstr`tal tf`t

RhQh`g

Gkrrhs w sfhbfey nkmsnhkus kor`nawfam

g`dhmbhts agpekygamt lanhshkms - hmneulhmb tfa lanhshkm tkf`vaagpekyaas shbm `rjhtr`thkm

braagamts

`s ` nkmlhthkm ko agpekygamt. @etfkubf

0

w`s

kjehvhkus

tk tfhs ra`fty

wfhea

agpekyal `t tfa nkgp`my,

lhas`gan`mmkt ja s`hl okrRQeh`g Gkrrhs.@s rasuet, 0`rbual tf`tuethg`taey, Rh e e h `gGkrrhs`rjhtr`thkm

`braagamts

wara mktfhmb gkra tf`m ` s`vvy, eabè ekkpfkea tf`t `Qkwal Rh e e h `g Gkrrhstfa `jhe h tytk

g`hmt`hm hts r`nhèey lhsnrhghm`tkry agpekygamt pr`nthnas, pkehnhas `ml prknaluras whtfkut `my

`nnkumt`jQhtyohrkgtfa oalarè nkurt,j`sal km tfa nkgp`my's abrabhkus p`ttag `mlnkmthmuhmb]''pr`nthna

k o hmtamthkmèeylhsnrhghm`thmb b`hmst @orhn`m @garhn`ms hm agpekygamt sp`mmhmb wf`t w`s tfam 009

ya`rs.\fa fhstkrhnè `ml st`thsthnè avhlamna suppkrtal tf`t gy hm`jlhty tk ja fhral `ml/kr prkgktal tk

@bamt

w`s mkt `nnhlamtè kr lua tk

nf`mna.

@s m@orhn`m@garhn`m,ht w s umnkmsnhkm`jea]']hgp`my

w h t fsunf `m abrabhkus fhstkry ko agpekygamt lhsnrhghm`thkm, f`l tfa pkwar tk

suparsala

\ht ea

_ \H

`geC

f`va

n`saslanhlal hm prhv`thzal,qu`sh-culhnhè

okrug.

KmCuey :9, :900, Y. DavhmN`stae hssual fhs Krlar, hmwfhnffa hbmkral gy `rbugamts, kghttal

parthmamt o nts `ml ghs]pQal tfa e`w hm krlar tk larhva t ` lanhshkm

wfhnf

st`yal tfa

n`sa

hm tfa oalarè

nkurt `ml nkgpaeeal tfan`sa

hmtk

`rjhtr`thkm. H mfhs sugg`ry k ogy69p`baNkgpe`gt, fa

g`la

mk gamthkm

tk tfafhstkrhnè`ml st`thsthnè avhlamna pral`thmb gy agpekygamt, kr `my gamthkm tf`t gy ne`hgs hmneulal

systaghnlhsp`r`tatra`tgamt krlhsp`r`tahgp`nt.

@etfkubf

`m umnkmsnhkm`jhQty `rbugamt f`l

jaam

r`hsal,

fa `mèyzal tfa

`braagamts

j`salkm tfa ftarè

e`mbu`ba

nkmt`hmal hm tfa

`braagamts

`ml nkmneulal tf`t

pursu`mt tk tfa Laea];|thkm

Yrkvhshkm

nkmt`hmal

hm

tfa sankml

`rjhtr`thkm

`braagamt

H shbmal `s `

nkmlhthkm

90

agpekchm`ptok e ekwhmbtfa garbar jatwaam tfa Rh e e h `g

Gkrrhs

@bamny `ml Amla`vkr \èr`ht @bamny hm

@ p r h eko:998, tf`t lha `rjhtr`tkr f`l tk lanhla tfahssuak o

`rjhor`jhehty,

ètfkubf thus w`s `mhssuatyphn`Qy

lanhlal lha nkurt. TYDN ^t y Krlar,

[ . W k o

`

^hmna

N`stae's

Krlar w`s mkt o hm` e , tfa

`ppaQ ta

nkurt ne`hgal tfay lhl mkt

f`va

tfa

curhslhnthkm

tk ravhaw fhs

arrkmakus

Krlar `ml gy

raquast

okr fhs N`stae `ml Or`mnhs' lhsquèhohn`thkm. Km

Cuma

01, '

:90:,0 oheal` Lag`ml okr @rjht h` t hkm w h tftfa @garhn`m

@rjhtr`thkm

@ssknh`thkm, wfara 0nkmthmual tk

`rbua

tf`t `s g`ttar k o e`w `ml pujQn pkfny, tfa g`ml`tkry, pra-lhsputa `rjhtt`thkm

`braagamts

H shbmal

sfkuel mkt ja amokrnal

j`sal

km tfa ne`hgs tf`t wara r`hsal g tfhs p`rthnue`r

n`sa

`ml `s ` g`ttar

k opujehn

Rfam\htha

_ H Hw sam`ntal,

ht

nra tal rhbftokrehthb`mtstk `lculhn ta ne hgsk olhsnrhghm thkm

hm

tfa oalar e nkurt.

\fhs w s suppkrtal jy tfa o nt tf ttfarawara zark

@orhn`m

@garhn`m @bamts, Nkkrlhm tkrs kr @bamt'\rh hmaas

agpekyal hm tfa MawXkrdkoohnawfam Hjab`m]agpekygamt hm aptagjarko :996, `ml tf t kvar tfankursakogy

agpekygamt,0wkuelra ehza tf t H w`s axtragaey gkra qu ehohal tf`m g ckrhty, h mkt èe,kogyshghe reyshtu tal

wfhta/

Cawhsf nkumtarp rts wfk wara esk@bamt \r hmaas.


15/55

pkehny,

`rjhtr`thkm w s `m hm]prkprh`ta okrug tk

`nfhava

tfa pujehn pkehny

bk`es

ko tfa

N h v h e

Zhbfts @nt ko

08?


16/55


17/55

HmgyChQy

0:,

:9

0,tfap`rthassujghttaltfahrraspanthvaGkthkmsokrûgg`ryCulbgamt`ml (]k

"](.]]]kss-Gkthkms tk Lhsghss. Jatwaam @p r h e 01, :90> `ml

âptagjar

:1, :90>,

@rjhor`tkr

Brabkry hssual

] * ' * 1 ] a a f h t a r h g Lanhshkms. t/]

a= v@KKG.

5]C Lhsnuss

@rjhtr`tkr L`vhl

E . Brabkry's Y`rthè Ohmè

@w`rl.

âa

Axfhjht

F . Km tfa ourstp`ba k o tfa

@w`rl,

fa sugg`rhzal fhs oglhmbs, nkmneulhmb tf`t

"Rleh`g Gkrrhs

Amla`vkr Amtart`hmgamt EENd;wY

lhsnrhgg`tal `b hmst TgaW hm

vhke`thkm

k o parthmamt oalarè, st`ta,`ml eknè e`w

prkfhjhthmb

lhsnrhgg`thkm . ]

h m agpekygamt km tfaj`shs k o

r`na,"

tf`t H suooaral gkmay

l`g`bas

`ml thh`tH w`s "amththal tk

ra`skm`jea

00@

. .

oaas

`ml

nksts,

`s ` prk sa mkm- ttkgay prav`hehmb p`rty km st`tutkry ne`hgs hm n`sa ko nkmshlar`jea

'

prknalurè `ml sujst`mthva

nkgpeaxhty."

Tpb. 0.W Fa `ndmkwealbal

kmna

`b`hk@tf`t hm fhs tfhr ty

ya`rs

`s

/Utavrb

(>C

-v

]c

]t`.

kohth/ThnG9]

.

@'-o-G'-F] = * @ ] C (e/w;]


19/55

'] `m@rjhtr`tkr k o E`jkr `ml Agpekygamt Lhsputas, tfhs

n sa

prasamtoalW tfa gkst axtamshva G ]]

@t*

CHm lhajabhhghmbko

G ^@w`rl,

famkw st`talthh`ttfa @@@mlas`Qkw okr

V = <

]ss] c ]] c

lanhshkm k o agpekygamt lhsputas

whtfkut

` fa`rhmb `mlj`salskeaey km tfa p rthas' sujghsshkm `ml

]

st`tal tf`tlurhmbkur Cuey >9, :90> nkmoaramna

nèe,

H `jgpthy nf`mbal

T g y W ghml

`ml s`hl

T H W

w`mtal

]

c

]0

fa`rhmb `ml tfaraòtar prkgply lag`mlal tklapksaTRGA'sW

Nfhao

Axanuthva

Koohnar @ r h

Ag`muae

Y'38n=

* ' ] ' ] ] ] ] ' ' ] ` ] -

] Gtv]

`rjhtr`thkmtk ja nkmvamthkmè, b`rlamv`rhaty,`ml mkmprkjeag`thn. \fara hs mk nralhjea avhlamna tf`t tfay

>Q.

. =. , E `ra umnkmsnhkm`jea g wfkea kr hm p`rt Tpb. >, 00.W Brabkry st tal tf`t H shtu`taTalW TgyW

hmlhvhluè

hy*]

'*tka*5] axparhamna t

T R h ee h `g

GkrrhsW `b`hmst tfa j`ndlrkp ko

Axfhjht

T>0W `ml tfa g nrk j`ndlrkp k o T g y W U / U

@]5=n* hmtarlhsnhpehm`ry nrhthqua k olaapey agjallal r`nhsg,

wfhnf

w`s mktamthraey

trà

janùsaH ea`rmal `jkut

Axfhjht

> 0 "

gkra tf`m ` ya`r òtar H ohealgy nkgpe`hmtw h t h rtfa

^.L C ] H .

X .

Tpb. 1.W Fa tfam st`tal tf`t gy ]

- ' oKcRo axtamshvaGkthkmp]arsraoeant skpfhsthn`tal curhspglamnabrkhglhmskgako tfa ea`lhmb snfke`rsfhp ko `.

tC]

N?5h

oo]

nrhthnèr`natfakrhsts, èlhkubf gkst k o tfa curhspglamna tf`t H hmnkrpkr`talhmtkgy gkthkms wara mkt

wmttam jy hmlhvhluès wfk

wkhll

ja ne`sshohal jy tfa `n laghn `ml eabè nkggugty s

nrhthnè r`na ]vQw

tfakrhsts (a.b. e`w prkoasskr

\rhsthm D .

Braam), Tpb. 1W

@b`hm,

fa

ehdamal

gy aookrts tk

nkur`bakus ea`lars NC] k`

wfk

uethg`taey

`nfhaval, sknhè

nf`mba

tfrkubf tfa eabè

prknass ehda

Zav. Lr.

G`rthm

Eutfar

D h m b,

Cr.,

\fgrbkklG`rsfèe ml Maeskm G`mlae`,

wfhea

shguet`makusey st`thmb tf`t

p`rts

ko

T g y W Gkthkmp]ars ] h C h ] _

_ . . TwaraW nkumtarprklunthva `mth-âghthn r`mt avam tfkubf

R h e eh ` g Gkrrhs

`ml tfahr nkhgsae mavar

raohhtal . t

'tfa

fhstkrhnè

`mlst`thsthn eavhlamna lagkmstr`thmb tfa nkgp`my'snamthuy-peusya`r p`ttarm ml

nkmthmuhmb

n

n@rCk pr`nthna

k or`na-j`sal

agpekygamt lhsnmgg`ttkm. Tpb. 1.W

]]xhlh]e@U

,]y]E o] ]-] ]

]oh]*]

c ' Zab`rlhmb

Axfhjht > 0 , "

fa `ndmkwealba

thh`t " T Y e ` h m t h o o W ,

mkt TLaoaml`mtW,

lh l

gkst

k o

lus talhkus

:] 0 "

hmtktfa avhlamna

k o

rankrl km

aptagjar

:1, :90> ml mk lhsnkvary avar tkkd pe`na

**]WC o h

. .

g tfa

n sa

jaokra fa `jgply lanhlal tk

suspaml

lhsnkvarywhtfkut

lanhlhmb

gy

A g .

GkthkmtkNkgpae,

fa mkw st`tal tf`t tfhs lknugamt w`s skgatfhmb

eass

tf m ` sgkdhmb bum - jut ht hs mkt manass`rhey

mktfhmb. Tpb. ?.W Fahmnkrranteyst`tal tf`t Eakm`rl Zkwa lhsnkvaral

Axfhjht

> 0 " twklan`las `bk, .

=n](rt

ètfkubf Zkwa lhsnkvaral tfa lknugamt km lha

lasd

koFasehmhm Kntkjar :99:.

- s=o]hU] ]sujghttal `m @ppaè tk@rjhtt`tkrBrabkry's Y`rthèOhmè

@w`rl,

tfa Laoaml`mts

`ml tfahr nkumsae oheal sankml Gkthkm tk Lhsquèhoy @rjhtt`tkr Brabkry. H hggalh`taey kjcantal `ml

]]]]`rbual tf`t pursu`mt tk tfa Zavhaw^t`ml`rlsk o tfa@ @ @ ' s@lghmhstt`thkmZavhaw Nkumnl

( @ZN ),

t h h hs

e / ] .n]aC.* ~ . s h k l ] .

t - o Q


20/55

o]- h

"prknalurèey hgprkpar"

janùsa*

st`tatcoeh`t `m kjcanthkm tk `m `rjhtr`tkr g`y ja

g`la

'`t `my thga

] ' ] ] `rjhtr`thkm, up tk ota

hssu`mna

ko tfa @w`rl kr ktfar targhm`thmb krlar." (agpf`shs

`llal)

\fa o`nt

tfa @ @ @ lhl mkt hggalh`taey strhda tfa Laoaml`mts'

Gkthkm,

shbmèal tk ga tf`tlasphtatfa e`w `ml

Ch]*] ]

. tfahr kwm buhlaehmas part`hmhmb tk lhsquèhohn`thkm, tfay wara bkhmb tk bat @rjhtr`tkr Brabkry kut kotfara

(@ * okrruehmbhm gy o`vkr. Km

C`mu`ry

:2, :90


21/55

Ohvagkmtfs `otar r`hshmbtfasa hssuas, N`stae st`ta`hm fhs^aptagjar1, :90


22/55

H , *

Gkrr hs

`ml/kr Hx)aj & H]aj EEY $0,999 okr lnohgr`thkJr]etfku]

st`thsthnè avhlamna 0

prasamtal

k o RhQh`g Gkrr hs ' 00? ya`r p ttag `ml pr`nthna k o lhsnrhghm`thmb `b`hmst

@garhn`ms hm agpekygamt, gy ne hgs k o orùl

f`va

mkt

jaam

lanhlal shmna N`stae ]

ht hm fhsâptagjar1, :90< Ohmè Krlar, `ml mktfhmb tf`t H'va s`hl `jkut tfa Laoaml`mts `ml tfaor nkhgsae

f s

jaam*

prkvam oèsa. Kvar tfa

nkursa

k o o h v a

gkmtfs, Ekaj & Ekaj

E E Y

mavar nkgpehal

w h t f

@rjhtr`tkr

]*]] 'N1 Brabkry's Krlars part`hmhmb tk lhsnkvary, `ml mavar nkgpfal w h l h`my kogy lhsnkvaryraquasts.@o tar H

oheal `m Agarbamny G k t h k mtk Nkgpae,@rjhtr`tkrBrabkry `jgply"suspamlal"lhsnkvary `ml n`mnaeeal

. . lha krè fa`rhmb. Fa hmstgntal us tk hmsta`l sujght Ohmè Ykshthkm^t`tagamts`ml st`tal tf`t fawku eltfr` ==

Q

/=v@fnhramlar fhs "kgmhjus

ohmè

lanhshkm."]] ]].]h ]h4] , n h]+G ] - ] ] r " ] ] ] ' ] t E ] ,

H otfa

" @ w ` r l "

@rjhtr`tkr Brabkry w`s "o hmè , okr thhas`dak o culhn h` eravhaw," lham @ZN lhl mkt K ] C ]

D n*

taa] eh`va

cghslhnthkm

ragkva Brabkry jaokra fa nkuel latarghma tfa `ngè gkmat`ry l`g`bastf`t H

wku el

C]@

+` ranahva hm tfhsjhohoon`tal prknaalhmb.

Qethg`taey,

h t

lkasm't

g`ttarjanùsaGhnfàe Y. Swahb ml Ekaj & ] ' \

'NEo]on.

Ekaj EEY `ra amb`bhmb hm ` "p ttag

]c

]nro]'orùl u]km lha Nkurt" tf`t N`stae

raousas

tk

`llrass

hm

]]s]]]]

âptagjar

1, :90< Ohmè Krlar.@esk ,Zuea e / ] a n h o h n ` e e ylaèsw h t f

oheehmb

` v`n`mny wfam tfa `rjhtr`thkm ]

h]]

`braagamt

eekws okr p`maek o`rjhtt`tkrs. \fa g`ml`tkry, pralhsputa `rjhtt`thkm`braagamtsprkvhlal tf`t ao-a

kmey

shhhbea

`rjhtr`tkr

wkuel

latarhmhma tfan`sa`ml tf`t tfa lanhshkm

wku el

ja "o hmè`mljhmlhmb." @esk,

| H]a

HoX] è t h hku]f

h t hs nea r lh`t pursu`mt tk 09 ko lha

O @ @ ,

kmey

thha

oalarè nkurt n`m

v`n`ta

lha

p ] D

'

] t ] @ w ` r l "

k o`m `rjhor`tkr. . ' . .

" o o / hav e

] ] * h s 5 ] ] s h ] ]

H tl]

s ^ t n g ] H nhtakma*ko tda gkst hm-laptf ml nkgprafamshva e`w `rthneas

wr h t tam

n]

km tfa tkp ko lha ohm`fty kohmtarhglanhshkms `ml p`rthè

ohmè

` w ` r l - r @ a O a o h ; a r ` / / e r h / r r ` ] / k . < n / . - ] / ] h

{]]th]] ]

Hmnkmbruhthas Zae`thmb tk tfa Hssu`mna k o Hmtarhg `ml

Y`rthè

@w`rls hm Lkgasthn `ml Hmtarm`thkmè p ,

@ N h]]

@rjhtr`thkms, vmhtta`fy

Ca`masG.

B`hths `ml pujehsfal jy lha

@garhn`m

Zavhawko

Hmtarm`thkmè

@rjhor`t hkm

' ] hm :991. T Y H .Orùl Qpkm lha NkurtG k t hkm ,>0->:.W @s raoeantal hm thtthaB`hths' {mugjwk op`basWe`w

C e ] e l \ ] e ]

`rthnea, avam Hm tarhgLanhshkms n`m ja

"o hmè ,

okr lha

s`da

ko

culhn h` e

ravhaw." Ht 's tfa "nkmtamt k o lanhshnGh

0;/]

oottCh

~e k t hts mkgamne`tura - Ttf`tW latarghmas

ohmèhty."

N`sas e hdaO=ujfnhs Nkggumhn`thkm v. \ga Mkrtf ]

c ys en*Qd.Nkggumhn`thkms, f hn . :9? O.>l 2:1, 2:6-2:8 (2t h hNhr. :999) "sfkw tf`t ètfkubf lha T O @ @ W

usas

lhaw k r l '

] ] w ` r l hm nkmcumnthkm

w h t f ohmèhty,

nkurts bk jaykml ` lknugamt's fa`lhmb `ml laevahmtkhtssujst`mna ml

hgp`nt tk latarghma wfatfar tfa lanhshkm hs ohmè." (agpf`shshm

krhbhmè) .

âaa.b. , @mlra` Lkraam.E t l . v.

JullhmbG`tarhè Eknè

Qmhkm

:6:. :19 O. ûpp. :l 092, 00: (A . L . M. X.:99>) ("lhan`sae`wlkasmkt

>10`g nkmohlamt tf`tHf`vasuoohnhamt avhlamna tkwrhtatfa kgmhjus

ohmè

lanhshkm. Ne hg`mt's Kntkjar 01, :90> h]h]

TZapeytkAg. Gkthkmtk Nkgpae ml

Zaquast

okr `mnthkmsWwheemkt ja okrw`rlal tk ga." T@rjhtr`tkrBrabkry ' r N ]

Kntkjare?,:90> 9rla b. .

@ - o - t D R a o ] ] l o t y ,

hu]akf

H ] _ Q e u w t } v B * ] ] t n ] h R ] t M ' v Q e`d]nh h]ò ' -

o] ]

@ w * ] Q oao]\h\ t

- k ] ] ] e ] ] ] ] n G w u

] , s ] ] ] ] ] p h ^

] Q ] G ] " " ] ] h k ]


23/55

hmlhn`ta tf`t nkmohrg`thkm n`mkmeyja lkma wfam tfa 'p`rthas axprassey lane`ra `m `w`rl km f`jlhty hm `

jhohoon`tal prknaalhmb

w l e

ja laagal

ohmè. ') {nhthmb

GnBrabkr _`m La Gkara. Hmn. v. Y`vnfax. Hmn.. 8:2

O.

ûpp. ?0?, ?06 ( R . L . M . X . 088?)). 4 '

p`bas

>< tfrkubf ?:, H

lhsnuss

tfa "^fkrtnkghmbs ko

@rjhtr`tkr L ` v h l

E. Brabkry `ml \fa

] Q

''=aoeOantu`ta tfa pujfn pkfny bkès ko tfhs m`thkm's fug`m rhbfts `ml `mthtgst e`ws krfkel R h e e h ` g

G k r rh s ,Ekaj & Ekaj EEY, Ghnfàe Y.

S w a h b ,

Nfrhsth`m N`rjkma `ml ktfars T`nnkumt`jeaW okr tfahr

BkwYo. fhbfeyumatfhnè kr

nrhghmè

nkmlunt.

rUo

N`stae sfkuel f`va raskeval tfa

hssua

ko wfatfar kr mkt@rjhtr`tkrBrabkry sfkuel f`va jaam lhsqu`fohal, rtv*h

]]]"]

]

lanhlal wfatfar tk nkmohrg,

gklhoy

`ml/kr

v`n`ta @rjhth`tkr

Brabkry's "Y`rthèOhmè

@ w ` r l . ]C]

Hmsta`l, N stae s`hl mktfhmb `jkut tfa

@ @ @

lhsquèhoyhmb

@rjhth`tkr

Brabkry òtar hssuhmb fhs @ w ` rl`ml n]RhoZ

]']] oe kwa@''tfaorùlueamthyppkhmtal rape`nagamt "`rjhor`tkr" - \hgktfy D.Eawhs- tk f va lanhshkm-g`dhmb 5

ùtfkrhty kvar

R h e f ` r m G k r rh s

`ml Ekaj & EkajE E Y ' sG k th kmtk _`n`ta

@rjhor`tkr

Brabkry' s Y`rthèOhmèe]aa] 4

@ w ` r l- ` nea`r vhk e`t hkmko lua

prknass.

5 ] ? ] e

Nea`rey,H

lhs`braaw h lh

tfa

st`tagamtsk o

tfa@garhn`m

@rjhor`thkm@ssknh`thkm,\hgktfy D. Eawhs,

Ekaj & Ekaj

E E Y

`ml Y. DavhmN`stae rab`rlhmb tfa ohmè h ty

ko @rjhor`tkr

Brabkry's Y`rthèOhmè

@ w ` r l.

\f`t hs `m

hssua

lh`t w h e ef`va tk ja raskeval jy tfa ânkml

Nhrnuht.

cO.. N`stae's

âptagjar 1, :909,0888W.ZapujQn`m Yrashlamt Bakrba

F . R .

Jusf ppkgtal 4

Eawhstk jktf pkshthkms. * .

@rjhtr`tkrs,

e hdaculbas, gust èsk jhla jy Nkla

k o

Atfhns.1aaAxfhjhtN N .Jaokra

Eawhs

hssual

fhs

"Ohmè

@w`rl,"

H skubft fhs

lhsquèhohn`thkm

km G`y >9, :90


36/55

e ] ' h l t

-{]otC

n k k h t o o Cuey

>k]SkU^

@ohhn`m

@garhn`ms

`ml

nkmsphrhmb

tk

axneula tfag orkg ga`mhmbohhe pkshthkms ko agpekygamt, sunf

s

@bamt.H'va jaam amb`bhmb hm axtraga "j`l

o`htf,"

tf`tHw`s "`jusThmbW tfa

prknass

ko tfa Nktmts tk

f`r`ss

`ml `mmky ktfar

w h tf

garhlass, ohhvkekus, vax`thkus kr rapaththva pea`lhmbs," atn, tfus èsk w`rr`mthmb tfa

hgpkshthkm

ko `

ohehmb

hmctgnthkm

`b`hmst ga,

s

waee

s

praculhnhmb

gy `ppaè jy st`thmb tf`t

h o

H `ppaèal

*

nra`ta

shmna H'va axpksal tfa nkgp`my's 00? ya`r fhstkry

k o

f`rjkrhmb r`nhè`mhgus `b`hmst

fhs lanhshkm, ht

wkell

mkt jag`lahm "bkklo`htf." T Y D N OhmèKrlar, 08-:?.W

]

( ] ] 0 H C G H | R c e | Q G C o e C | ]

bh h ;k5] T \ R 6 e F r k h e o o m o { J R 0 ] ] \fahssuako

t ]Q. wfk f`s

cghslhnthkm

tk lanhla tfa garhts ko tfa ne`hgs r`hsal hm tfhs e`mlg`rd agpekygamtlhsnrhghm`thkm,

`mthtgst

`ml fug`m rhbftsn`sahs `m axtragaey hgpkrt`mt tfrasfkel hssua.

Kmp`bas?: tfrkubf

20 k o gy

G`rnf02,:90< Orùl Qpkm tfa Nkurt

Gkthkm,

Haxpe`hmal tk N`stae

ok r

tfa

ohrst

thga,wfyHjaehaval fhs Cuey :9,

: 90

e]t`y Krlar w`s arrkmakus s g`ttar

ko e]w

`ml pujfn

pkehny.

1aa

Axfhjht

A A . Hm

N`stae's

G`rnf:2, :90< Krlar, fa raohhsal tk lhsqu`Qoymhh hsaeo orkgtfa n`sh

kt(]]U

Q])=

`ml stkkl jy fhs Cuey :9, :900 ^t`y Krlar, s yhmb lh`tht"spTkdaW okrhtsaeo -

èthhkubf

h mthh`tKrlar,fa ]F]

,

g`la

`jskeutaey mk gamthkm lh`t gy ne`hgs

hmvkeval

systaghn lhsp`r`ta ora`tgamt `ml lhsp`r`ta hgp`nt,

U t @o ]

5 Q /]n

" ] m k r l hl falhsnusstfapyr`ghl k o fhstkrhnè`ml st`thsthnè avhlamna lagkmstt`tuhb tf`t Rlf`g

Gkrrhs

w s

]

vhke`thmb

tfa N h v h eZhbfts @ntko08?< jaokra `ml lurhmb gy agpekygamt. Hmraspkmsatk gy ne`hgs tf`t ] ] ]b

N`stae'sCuey :9, :900 ^t`y Krlar w`s arrkmakus s g ttar koe` w `ml pujQn pkfny,fast`tal3 ]]]-oh]

, Km Oajg`ry :1,

:900,

tfa laoaml`mts gkval tk lhsghss kr st y tfa `nthkm jy ra`skm ko `m `rjhtt`thkm

@smktal,hm m

H^ch`ba-Gkgkr]tt]hg

mlKrlar

oheal

Cuey:9,:900,tfaumlarshbmal

u

br`mtal tf`t

gkthkm

h msko`r(]]]yhmb tfa pamlh mb] `w`rl hm rjhtt thkm.Gr. R`sfhmbtkm

lhs`braas

wh tf

tfa nkmtamt `ml nkmneushkm1-hm tfa

Gkgkrkmlgm

`ml Krlar.

Rfhea

tfa Gagkr`mlug `ml Krlar

"f]spa`ds okr

htsaeo

ht, `gkmb ktfar tfhmbs, sugg`rhzaltfankgpe`hmt, `mèyzaltfa:998 @rjhtt`thkm

] - t t @ - G @braagamt, ax`ghmal tfaumnkmsnhkm`jhfty `rbugamt, nkmshlaral ht tfam`tura ko lha `rbugamts

_

|]o C * , E C

rab`rlhmb wfatfartfalhsputa s tk`rjhtt`jhQty wara okr tfa Nkurtkrtfa `rjhtt`tkrtklanhla `ml,

]

`ppeyhmb ast`jehsfal pranalamt, nkmneulal tf`t tfay wara okr lha

`rhhhor`tkr

tklanhla. \fa nkurt èsk

ax`ghmal wfatfar tfara w`s`nkmbrasshkmè hmtamt tk okraneksa `rjhtt`thkm ko ne`hgs`ssartalumlar HX]N

e ]D \h t h a _ H H

kr


37/55

Nhr. :9()6)Mk g`ttar wfk tfa `rjhtr`tkr w`s, h o tfay ] amokrnal tfa g`ml`tkry, pra-lhsputa `rjhtr`thkm

`braagamtH shbmal

whtfkut

hssuhmb ` wmttam

kphmhkm

tf t lhsnussal y `rbugamts `ml nhtal]']yn`sae`w .

tkaxpe`hm

tfahr ra`skmhmb, H w s bkhmbt k 5 ] t

tk

f`vatfa@w`rlv`n ta

y

`rbugamts `ml nhtal]']yn`sae`w

taljanùsatfa rjhtr`tkr s lanhshkm h t h

w s

g`la

hm g`mhoast lhsrab`rl ko tfa e`w, `ml s ` rasuet, tfa `rjhtr`tkr axnaalaltfahr pkwars jy

N ^

t

=ro_kwt-

lanhlhmb

tfa garhts

k o

gy

ne`hgs.

]

_o *R=ek|5e]

Hm `rjhtr`thkm, H r`hsal tfa

s`ga

`rbugamts tf`t wara

g`la

jaokra tfa ^kutfagLhstrhnt ko Maw

`ml tfa ânkmlNhrnuhttk sfkw tf`t tfa g`ml`tkry, pra-lhsputa `rjhtr`thkm braagamtstf`t H shbmal

C

C

s `

nkmlhthkm

k o

agpekygamt

wara umnkmsnhkm`jea, t`hmtal

wh tf

heeabèhty,gèug hm sa`ml tf`t

`rjhtr`thkm

fmn

c

]]o-] w s `m hm`pprkprh`taokrugokr tfhs p`rthnue`r

n`sa,

janùsatfa okrug htsaeopravamtal tfa pujfn pkfny

bkèsk otfa

N h v h e

Zhbfts@ntko 08?1.W3

( =* ] e n y n] GU ) * U ( ] ] ] ] ] ] N`stae, nkmshlarhmb R`sfhmbtkm's ne`hgs tf`t tfa Laeab`thkm Yrkvhshkm ko tfa @braagamt

wds

umnkmsnhkm`jea, fael tf`t 'tfa :998

@rjhtr`thkm

@braagamt w`s mkt shbmal umlar prknalurèey

(]c

o e`hnkhhsnhkm`jea nkmlhthkms.'

Culba

N`stae ohhrtfarfael tf`t R`sfhmbtkm o`lal tk 'sat okrtf skuml

j`shs]]]]

ck oR/_thpkmwfhnftfhs Nkurt

nkuel

nkmneula tf`t Laeab`thkm

Yrkvhshkm

hs sujst`mthvaey umnkmsnhkm`jea sunf tf`t ]

tfhs èkma nkuel ja j`shstk ohml tfa prkvhshkm umamokrna jea.' @s amokrna`jhehty ko tfa Laeab`thkm y h]h

Yrkvhshkmf`sòra`ly

jaam

lanhlal, ht n`mmkt ja raQthb`tal fara. r

t

=vDhh /= Jktf @rjhth`tkr L`vhl E. Brabkry `ml \umktfy D. Eawhs lanhlal tk amokrna tfa `rjhtt`thkm 5 5

0k|-

`braagamts

H shbmal `s `

nkmlhthkm

k o

agpekygamtwhtfkut

`my lhsnusshkmk o

gy

`rbugamts kr `my

nht`thkm

k o

tfae`wtksuppkrt tfaor nkmneushkms,ètfkubf tfhstfrasfkelhssuaw`s rbual

h m

gy

Gkthkm

okr ûgg`ry

0 5]']]5]Culbgamt.

Bhvam

tf`t Hf`vaspamtma`rey

okurya`rs

r`hshmbtfhs `rbugamt hmkppkshthkmtk tfa amokrna`jhQty

rjhtt`thkm`braagamts

0shbmal `mlRleh`g

Gkrrhs

`ml Ekaj & EkajEEYr`hsal nkumtarne`hgs tf`t

U*r`s H jra`nfal tfa`rjhor`thkm `braagamttf`t H rbual w`s umnkmsnhkm`jea, tfa ohmlar ko o`nt f`l tk axpe`hm

ra`skmhmb, shmnaRh e e h `gGkrrhstkkd `w`y tfa nkurt's ùtfkrhty tk lanhla tf`thssua.

p]hQk]nhaob]nFRhtfkutavar lhsnusshmb tfa mkw

umraohhtal

pyr`ghl ko avhlamna H'va prasamtal ast`jehsfhmb,

u/D?rp

vhke`thkms

ko tfa oalarè,st tas,eknè`mthlhsnrhgg`thkmpra-l`thmb gy agpekygamt, N`stae nkmneulal tf`t ]tpW

tfa lanhshkms tk amokrna tfa`rjhor`thkm`braagamtwara mkt hm g`mhoast lhsrab`rl ko tfa e`w `ml tf`t tfa 9]{c

`rjhor`tkrw`s umlar mk kjfb`thkm tk prkvhla tfa ra`skmhmb okr fhs `w`rl `ml nkurts w h e e bamarèey mkt

`ttagpt tk `mèyza tfa ra`skmhmb

prknass

ko m rjhth`tkr. TYDN

Ohmè

Krlar, 0?.W

@etfkubf

N`stae nhtal

F`Qhb`mv.Yhpar

Cò&`v.

orhn. 0l 082, :9< (:lNor. 0886),wfhnfst tasthh`t wfara`ravhawhmbnkurt

hs

hmnehmaltk ohmltf`t `rjhor`tkrs g`mhoastey lhsrab rlal tfa e`w kr tfa avhlamna `ml tf`t `m axpe`m`thkm,ho

bhvam, wkuel f`va str`hmal

nraluehtX.

tfa `jsamna ko axpe`m`thkm g`y rahmokrna tfa ravhawhmb nkuros

nkmohlamna tf`t tfa`rjhtr`tkrsamb`balhm g`mhoastlhsrab`rl, faokuml`jskeutaeymktfhmbwrkmbwh tf

tfa o`nt tf`t tfa `rjhor`tkrs oekutal tfa e`w `ml raohhsal tk `ndmkwealbaR h e e h`gGkrrhs'fhstkryko r`nh e

lhsnrhghm`thkm,

kr `ppey

`mthlhsnrhghm`thkm

e`w

w h tf h m

tfa or`gawkrd ko tfa Oalarè @rjhtr`thkm@nt, tk

latarghma tfa `rbugamts tf`t wara r`hsal jy

jkth h

p`rthas. / h . .


38/55

hrCF ehR f Q m h R e

]nG5tko-

@9-|-rkh5 0 ]? ohhh p`r`br`pf ko tfhs twk-p`ba santhkm,N`stae'sra`skmhmb t das` turm okr tfa-wkrs\wfam

TYDN

\fara hs ` 'j`raey nkekr`jeacusthohn`thkm' okr@rjhtr`tkrEawhs's latarghm`thkm tf`t tfa

`braagamt

w`s

mkt umnkmsnhkm jea. Hm hts prhkr kphmhkm, tfa Nkurt fael tf`t tfa 'Laeab`thkm Yrkvhshkm'

htsaeo

w`s mkt

umnkmsnhkm`jea `ml`llrassal`rbugamts shmthe`r tktfksaR`sfhmbtkm r`hsal wh t f @rjhtr`tkr Eawhs.

ûmhe`r ra`skmhmb nkhll nkmnahv`jey

cust h oy

`

ohmlhmb

tf`t tfa

`braagamt

`s ` wfkea w`s

èsk

mkt

g`huoast

] ] ] ] ]

N`stae f`s mavar `ndmkwealbal

Rhef`g

Gkrrhs'fhstkryk or`nhè lhsnrhghm`thkm,thharaokra fhs eabè

nkmneushkms rab`rlhmb `my

`]ant

ko gyn`sa,n`mmkt `ml sfkuel mkt ja tfa

s ga

`sskgakmawfk

lkas

nkmshlar tfhs avhlamna. H o N`stae f`l mk hmtamthkms ko

upfkelhmb

tfa

N h v l

Zhbfts @nt ko 08?< kr wahbfhmb

tfa pyr`ghl ko avhlamna ast`jfsfhmb systaghn lhsp`r`tatra`tgamt `ml lhsp`r`ta hgp nt pra-l thmb `ml.

knnurrhmblurhmb gy agpekygamt, wf`t w`s tfapurpksako st`yhmb tfan`sa;\fa khly `ssugpthkm 0n`m

g`da, w`s tk pravamt tfa ânkml

Nhrnuht

orkgf`vhmb tfa

curhslhnthkm

tk ravhaw fhs eabèeyarrkmakus

`ml praculhna gy `rbhghamts nfèeambhmb tfa amokrn]`jlhty ko tfa g`ml`tkry, pra-lhsputa `rjhtr`thkm

]`braagamts H shbmal `s ` nkmlhthkm ko agpekygamt. Assamthèey, wa cust wamt hm kma jhb nornea, wh t f mk

lar ko o`nt hssuhmb `m kjcanthva, wrhttam lanhshkm rab`rlgb tfa hssua ko `rjhtr`jhehty,'`gh lhsnus>] ]

` h

RhQh`g

Gkrrhs'fhstkryk ohmtamthkmèr`na-j`sallhsnrhgg`thkmhmagpekygamtwfhnfknkurrkl jaokra `ml

ofhrhmn gy

og]U ]'g]*

Rhe e h`g Gmrr hm , kr `t ea`st axpe`hm wfy avhlamna ko

Rh eQ`g

Gkrrhs'.fhstkry . ,

C axneulhmb quèhohal@ o h hn ` m @garhn`ms

orkg

jahmb foral `ml/kr prkgktal tk @bamt hs mkt

maaass`ry

wfam

latarghmhmb wfatfar tfhs p`rthnue`r nkgp`my' s pkfny ko

f`vhmb

hts agpekyaas shbm `rjhth`thkm`braagamts,

h

nC]']kC] mktfhmb gkra tf`m ` s`vvy eabè ekkpfkea tk bhva tfhs cox)gp`my tfa pkwar tk gkva ne`hgs ko r`nhè

Um hmtk ` prhv`thzal, q u`sh-culhnhèokrug tf`t m um`jea tk `laqu`taey aooang`ta tfa e`rbar .

, 02

Lujehn LkQnvakès

ko tfa N h v h eZhafts @nt ko 08?1>

(^.L.M.X.Oaj. 2,:990) (pe`hmthoo'slhsnrhghm`thkmne`hgs sujcant tk

`rjhtr`thkm

hmneulhmbne`hgs

k o`rjhtr`thkm

`braagamt'sumnkmsnhkm`jhQty). Tpb. 1W

H oRh eQ`g

Gkrrhsw`s hm o`ntvhke`thmbthus m`thkm's

`mthlhsnrhghm`thkme`ws jaokra `mllurhmbgy agpekygamt, tfam nea`rey tfa uhuqua o`nts ko gyn`sa`Qkwal

ga tkr`hsatfhs umhqua `rbugamt hm kppkshthkm tk tfa amokrna`jhQty kolha `rjhtr`thkm`braagamtsH shbmal


39/55

s ` nkmlhthkm ko agpekygamt. \fa

s`ga

avhlamna tf`t suppkrtal gy ne`hgs ko

hmtamthkm e

systaghn ]eh

lhsp`r ta tha`tgamt, lhsp`r ta ump`nt `ml

vhke`thkms

k ooalarè`ml

st`ta

mthtgste `w, w`s tfa

s`ga

avhlamna (]Ce

usal tk suppkrt gy ne`hgs tf`t tfa

`rjhtt`thkm

`braagamt H shbmal wara umamokrna`jea `s ` g ttar k o e`w

`ml pujfn pkfny. H o l ha

ohmlar

ko o`nt hbmkral lus avhlamna wfamlatarghmhmbtfa tfrasfkelhssua k o w f k o]]

f`l tfa prkpar

curhslhnthkm

tk lanhla tfa garhts ko

tfhs

n`sa,

tfay

wkuel

gkra

e h d a e y

tf m mk t hbmkra tfhs b,

avhlamna hm tfahr Ohmè @w`rl. Zab`rleass, Hwkuelf`va nea`rey `rbual tk tfa ^kutfagLhstrhnt

k o M a w

Rk]t]

Xkrd`ml/kr `ppaee`ta

nkhut

tf`t tfa rjhtt`tkr ml/kr culba's lanhshkm km tfa

hssuak o`rjhtt`jhfty

w`s

lk ^K '

] H ']]] 'v ] ] wfhnfsuppkrtal N`stae sfkuelb b f`vacurhslhnthkmtkwahbftfhs r

]Y5C]

n ] ]n a k oRhQh`g

Gkrrhs'

fhstkry kor`nhè lhsnrhghm`thkm, aspanh`Qy shmna H w s kjQvhkus * ] ' ] * ] ] ]

o R ' 8- hmokrg`thkm kr tf`t tfara wara zark@ohhn`m @garhn`m @bamts, Nkkrlhm`tkrs kr @bamt \r`hmaas agpekyal ]]

o-UU hm tfa MawXkrd koohna wfam 0jab`m agpekygamt. âa a.b.,K'Za`b`m v.@rjhor`thkmOkrugs. Hmn..:


40/55

- oN h@ h] e pne/nv] o a=*Ck't5dc5

, ^hmna H w`s kmey bhvam kma kppkrtumhty tk

kppksa

amokrnhmb

R h e e h ` g

Gkrrhs'jhmlhmb `rjhtr`thkm

`braagamts,

H axpkhglal upkm gy

`rbugamts

jy sfkwhmb tf`t ht w`s strkmbey hm tfa

pujfn's hmtarasts

tk

H H . Fha @nthkms ko

R h e e h ` g

Gkrrhs, e.kaet & Ekaj EEY, Ghnfàe Y. / . w n h b . ( e h r h s t h ` m ( `rjkmn. Y.

hp-o]w'

f`vatfan`sarag`hm hm tfa oalarè nkurt `ml ja lanhlal jy `m

hgp`rthècury.

.MUnrrt, ]v.*],'*]]']

]o]*]]*'']]* ]

ûpragaNkurtst`tal hm @eax`mlar v.

B`gar-

t`y]-**]'Lamvar Nk.. ?,


41/55

Orùl Qpkm lha Nkurt

Gkt hkm ,

H axpe`hm hm lat`he wfy H jaQaval tfa `ppa`r`mna `ml/kr `ntuè r`nhè jh`s, * '

praculhna, hgprkprhaty `ml p`rthèhty axhsts

wh t f

tfa twk oalarè culbas tf`t `ra nurramtey

`sshbmal

tk gy *.

n`sa `ml wfy lhay sfkuel f`va lhsquèhohaltfagsaevas pursu`mt tk 3 .._

^fkwhmb

tfa hmtarsanthkm jatwaam r`nhsg, pkfthns `ml tfa e`w. Bam`kmho thvnculhnhè`bgl .]' Ucro/UGc

U`JaghPL.hkmP^ s:PP:`hUhnUP

rhthnè

Z`na

\fakry3 Maw

^tr`tabhas okr

hvhea

Gheeamhug; pujQsfal jy tfa F`rv`rl Je`ndeattar E`w Ckurmè,

Ckmas

axpe`hms tfa rkea p r a s h l a m t

pkfthns f`l km sf`phmb tfa hlakekbhnè g`da-up k otfaculhnh`ry

eass

tf`m twklan`laspranalhmb tfanh@le ] c b ] e

rhbftsgkvagamt`mlp`ss`bakotfaNhvlZhbfts @ n t k o 08?. (nkmneushkms waraj salkm `m ax`ghm thkm ko

gkra tf`m


42/55

f`va sfkwm tf`t culbas `ppkhmtal jy Zapujfn`m prashlamts shmna Za b`m f`va rueal okr nkmsarv`thva

]]bo\*

rcutnkgas gkra kotam tf`m f`va tfahrpaars.

\fay f`va jaam gkra ehdaey tf`m toàhr nkQa`buas tk o`vkr

nkrpkr`thkms kvar rabue`tkrs `ml

pakpea

`Qabhmb lhsnrhghm`thkm, `ml tk o`vkr bkvarmgamt kvar

]=ht< h]akpeawfk ne`hg rhbfts vhke`thkms. \fay f va èsk jaam gkra ehdaey tk tfrkw kut n`sas km tanfmhnè

brkumls, ehda ra`nthmb pe`hmthoos' st`mlhmb tk sua. ''(agpf`shs `llal) \fa lanhshkms

k o

Y.

Davhm

N`stae

' h m

tfhsn`saraoeant tf`t tfa bkvarmgamt's bkè

k o

sfhotThmbWtfa nkurts hm gkra nkmsarv thvalhranthkm f`s

' h h s nea r lh`t N stae hs fksthea tk nhvl rhbfts kr ` stmnt nkmstgnthkmhst janùsa

< 5 at]u]] phU'tah a]]o^hNoC

'. - agpekygamt lhsnrhghm`thkm ml

n h v h e

rhbfts

a sa

nfèeambhmb

hmsthgthkmèey

r`nhst pr`nthnas koRheQ`g

Gkrrhs

(`ml

FkQywkkl),

fa mavar lhsnhessas tfa NhvQ Zhbfts]@ntko 08?


43/55

:90< kr 1> ya`rsW. Lasphta raprasamthmb g`my@Gn`m@garhn`mamtart`gars ml g ` ]

k o o

ko tfag kvar tfa

lan`las,

ht n`mmkt ja lhsputal tf`t ht tkkd tfa nkgp`my ?>

ya`rs

prkgkta hts ohrst

@orhn`m

@garhn`m tk gushn @bamt `ml 090

ya`rs

tk prkgkta hts

ohrst @ohhn`m

@garhn`m tk tfa pkshthkm ko

oheg

@bamt.

Y E

^ . L . M . X . Nkgpe hmt,

D.W

' R' n`mmkt ja lhsputal tf`t jatwaam :999 `ml :909, zark@ohhn`m @garhn`m @bamt \r`hmaas wara

prkgktal

tk @bamt hm tfa Maw

Xkrdkoohna,

`ml

khly

kma

@ohhn`m @garhn`m

w`s fhral lhranly `s `m @bamt

koohna

hm ohrst

lan`la

ko tfa

:0**

namtury. Ht èsk n`hgkt ja lhsputal tf`t wfam H jab m

agpekygamt hm tfa MawXkrd

koohna,

tfara wara zark@ohhn`m@garhn`m kr Fhsp`mhn @bamts, Nkkrlhm`tkrs

/Rv]a< |t*=atC

kr

@bamt \r hmaas agpekyal tfrkubfkut tfa @bamt \r`hmaa prkbr`g.

aa

Axfhjht L.

^hmna H w`s mkt `

e`wyarkr dmkwealba`jea g

`mthlhsnrhghm`thkm

e`w `t `my thga lurhmb gy agpekygamt, H lhlm't dmkw tf`t

tfhs èkma n`mnra`ta`m hmoaramna ko

lhsnrhghm`thkm. aa

J`gar v.

Nhty

ko F`rvay. Mk. 81 N >>0?, 0886

R E

??< O. ûpp. :l

698(A.L.M.X.

0888) (ra`l \a`gstars `s

fkelhmb

tf`t m hmaxkr`jea zark

st`mlhmb èkma

nkuel

suppkrt ` lhsp`r`ta hgp`nt

ne`hg

ko sax

lhsnrhghm`thkm

hm prkgkthkms, `ssarthmb tf`t

TtWfa

ûpraga

Nkurt

f s rapa`tal nkumtam`mnal tfa usa

k ost`thsthnè

avhlamna, `ml avhlamna

k o

tfa

`jsamna

k o

` shmbea

ghmkrhty

agpekyaa jahmb fhral, e`jaeal tfa'hmaxkr`jea zark,'wkuel hm `ml ko

htsaeo

suppkrt `m

hmoaramna

k olhsnrhmum thkm. ]3Awhmbv.

Nkn` Nke`

JkttQmb

Nk..

Mk.

99

NO_.

29:9(NG),

:990

R E

2?2929

(^.L.M.X.

Cuma

:1, :990) (lha nkurtokuml`

ne`hg

mkthmb tf`t tfa hmaxkr`jea zark w`ssuoohnhamt tk laoa`t

`

gkthkm

tk lhsghss

janùsa

` ma`r-zark

prkgkthkm

r`ta

k oghmkrhthas

hmtk

fhbfar-sdheeal

ckjs raoeantal la

o`ntk sabrab`thkm, `ml tfaraokra suppkrtal `m goaramna ko

hmtamthkmè lhsnrhghm`thkm.)4

Ekvl v.

Yfheehp

.

Jrks.. :1 O.>l 106, 1:< m.

Documents

Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (10-9647) (PKC) (JCF) -- Draft of Appeal to Second Circuit re: Fraudulently Procured Orders of P. Kevin Castel [Handwritten