27
University of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014 GEORGE CERWINSKI, LEAD MANAGER PORNPONG LUEANG-A-PAPONG, PORTFOLIO MANAGER ROBERT SHEDRAWY, TREASURER/SECRETARY XIN WANG, TECHNOLOGY MANAGER JONATHAN COOMBES MURALI KUCHIPUDI YAN ZHU

University of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

University of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014. George Cerwinski, Lead Manager Pornpong Lueang-A-Papong, Portfolio Manager Robert Shedrawy, Treasurer/Secretary Xin Wang, Technology Manager Jonathan Coombes Murali Kuchipudi Yan Zhu. Agenda. Executive Summary - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Citation preview

Page 1: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

University of ConnecticutMBA SMF Presentation

March 6, 2014

G E O R G E C E R W I N S K I , L E A D M A N A G E RP O R N P O N G L U E A N G - A - PA P O N G , P O R T F O L I O M A N A G E R

R O B E R T S H E D R AW Y, T R E A S U R E R / S E C R E TA R YX I N WA N G , T E C H N O L O G Y M A N A G E R

J O N AT H A N C O O M B E SM U R A L I K U C H I P U D I

YA N Z H U

Page 2: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

Executive Summary

Investment Process: Philosophy & Strategy

Our Portfolio Performance

Interesting Stocks

Conclusion

Looking ahead

Agenda

Page 3: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

Executive Summary

Management period: Sep. 13. 2013 — Feb. 28 . 2014

S&P 500 Benchmark

Shift in focus from top down in first semester to bottom up in second semester

Market Themes:

Domestic economy: Three years of uninterrupted economic growth & falling unemployment

Political circumstances: Government shutdown, Affordable Care Act, crisis in Ukraine

Total Return of $158,322

9.93% (Our Portfolio) VS. 11.19% (SP 500)

Page 4: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

Investment Process

Page 5: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

3 – 5 years Investment Time Horizon

10 Sectors Diversified

100% Equity

Philosophy and Strategy

Fall: Hybrid Selection

Spring: Bottom-Up Selection

10 yr. Treasury Rates 2013-2014

Investment Process

Source: U.S. Department of The Treasury

Page 6: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

Strong & sustainable business model

Outstanding amongst peers

Intrinsic value > market value

Corporate social responsibility

- Human Rights- Business Ethics Policy- ESG Disclosure- Equal Opportunity- Emission Reduction- Environmental Disclosure Score

- ROA and ROE- P/E and PEG ratios- Operating margins- Leverage ratios

•Well-balanced/diversified business units•Strong and predictable earnings

Page 7: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

26 StocksSector No.

Technology 4Financials 4

Health Care 5Energy 3

Consumer Discretionary 2Consumer Staples 3

Industrial 2Material 1Utilities 1Telecom 1

Investment Process

Page 8: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

Portfolio Performance

Page 9: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

$158,322 gain

9.93% return

126 bps behind S&P

-4.00%

-2.00%

0.00%

2.00%

4.00%

6.00%

8.00%

10.00%

12.00%

9.93%

11.19%Total Return (Sep 13, 13 - Feb 28, 14)

MBA SMF SPDR

9/16/2013

9/20/2013

9/26/2013

10/2/2013

10/8/2013

10/14/2013

10/18/2013

10/24/2013

10/30/2013

11/5/2013

11/11/2013

11/15/2013

11/21/2013

11/27/2013

12/3/2013

12/9/2013

12/13/2013

12/19/2013

12/25/2013

12/31/2013

1/6/2014

1/10/2014

1/16/2014

1/22/2014

1/28/2014

2/3/2014

2/7/2014

2/13/2014

2/19/2014

2/25/2014

-3.00%

-2.50%

-2.00%

-1.50%

-1.00%

-0.50%

0.00%

0.50%

-1.26%

Performance Difference

Period Performance Review

Page 10: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

Period Analysis Winning Losing Coherent Incoherent

Number 11 13 20 4

Percentage 45.83% 54.17% 83.33% 16.67%

Avg. Difference 0.20% -0.26% -0.07% 0.03%

9/17/2

013

9/20/2

013

9/27/2

013

10/4/2

013

10/11/2

013

10/18/2

013

10/25/2

013

11/1/2

013

11/8/2

013

11/15/2

013

11/22/2

013

11/29/2

013

12/6/2

013

12/13/2

013

12/20/2

013

12/27/2

013

1/3/2

014

1/10/2

014

1/17/2

014

1/24/2

014

1/31/2

014

2/7/2

014

2/14/2

014

2/21/2

014

2/28/2

014-3.00%

-2.00%

-1.00%

0.00%

1.00%

2.00%

3.00%

Relative Weekly Return %

Total Return (P) Total Return (B)

Weekly Return Analysis

Page 11: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

Less risky portfolio than benchmark

Sharpe ratio and Treynor ratio slightly below benchmark

MBA SMF S&P 500

Total Return 9.93% 11.19%

Mean Weekly Return 0.40% 0.45%

Geometric Weekly Return 0.40% 0.44%

Standard Deviation 1.11% 1.22%

Sharpe Ratio 0.36 0.37

Beta 0.92 1.00

Treynor Ratio 0.00436 0.00450

Jenson’s Alpha -0.0168%

Source: Bloomberg, Team calculation

Risk Adjusted Ratios

Page 12: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

Health care Energy Consumer Staples

Financials Utilities Telecom IT Materials Consumer Discretionary

Industrials Cash0.00%

5.00%

10.00%

15.00%

20.00%

25.00%

20.57%

11.85%

10.97%

16.91%

3.14%

2.22%

17.28%

1.29%

10.22%

5.44%

0.11%

13.66%

10.01%9.42%

15.81%

2.96% 2.52%

18.79%

3.51%

12.46%

10.68%

0.00%

MBA SMF S&P 500

Benchmark & Portfolio Asset Allocation

As of Feb 28th, 2014

Page 13: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

Source: Bloomberg

Portfolio Attribution Analysis

Cash

Industrials

Consumer Discretionary

Information Technology

Health Care

Stocks

Funds

Telecommunication Services

Utilities

Materials

Financials

Consumer Staples

Energy

MBA SMF 2014

-2.00% -1.50% -1.00% -0.50% 0.00% 0.50% 1.00%

-1.55%

Allocation Selection

-1.88% +0.62%

Page 14: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

Top 5 Holdings % WeightDICK'S SPORTING GOODS 5.05

PRICELINE.COM INC 5.05

COVIDIEN PLC 4.91

BLACKROCK INC 4.88 KLA-TENCOR CORPORATION 4.84

Bottom 5 Holdings % Weight

CASH 0.11

ALCOA INC 1.29

VERIZON COMMUNICATIONS 2.22

UNITED PARCEL SERVICE 2.27

PEPSICO INC 3.11

Top 5 gain % gain

Alcoa Inc. 29.65

UnitedHealth Group Inc. 13.58

Halliburton Company 12.08

Altera Corporation 11.64

CVS Caremark Corporation 11.48

Top 5 loss % gain

Ford Motor Company -15.03

Verizon Communications Inc. -5.52

United Parcel Service, Inc. -4.84

General Electric Company -4.16

PepsiCo, Inc. -3.96

% Holding

% Gain / loss

Top and Bottom 5 as of 2/28

Page 15: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

Most Interesting Holdings

Page 16: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

Investment ThesisOnly U.S automaker to weather financial crisis intactOne Ford Plan: fix balance sheet, improve vehicle

portfolioHighest ROE 28.5% in the industryStrong sales and profits support our high intrinsic value

Possible Factors Affecting Price DeclineSpeculation and concern over CEO’s possible departure Disappointing January Sales (Weather Related)Stop Loss executed at $15.30 due to risk management

and stronger security alternatives

Sector: Consumer DiscIndustry: Auto MakersMarket Cap: $60.91B

Price @2/28/2014: $15.39Purchase Price: $18.0052 Week Range: $12.11 - $18.02

Intrinsic Value: $26.89Market Cap at Intrinsic Value: $102.6BRealized Loss: (15.03%)

Source: Yahoo Finance

Ford Motor Co. (F)

Page 17: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

Investment ThesisPoised to be lowest cost fully integrated Aluminum

ProducerStrengths in downstream business insulates business from

volatile Aluminum pricesImproving economic climate indexes in Asia, EU, and NA

bode well for metals demandFactors Affecting Price Growth

Upgrade from JP Morgan, among others, to overweight/over-perform citing predicted upswing in Aluminum prices

Cost cutting initiatives and closing of burdensome smelting facilities

Worldwide economic improvement is leading to increasing demand for Aluminum

Domestically Auto and Airline manufacturers Sector: MaterialsIndustry: Mining/AluminumMarket Cap: $12.61B

Price @2/28/2014: $11.74Purchase Price: $9.0552 Week Range: $7.63 - $12.32

Intrinsic Value: $16.27Market Cap at Intrinsic Value: $17.43BUnrealized Gain: 29.65%

Source: Yahoo Finance

Alcoa (AA)

Page 18: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

Investment ThesisSeizing international market share by successful

acquisitionsBooking.com’s success in Europe and fast growth in

other newer markets; Agoda.com strengthens its position in the Asia-Pacific market

Offline marketing campaigns in Booking.com in U.S., Canada, Australia, U.K. and other markets as well as other brands

Investments in Mobile Execution and Innovation areas, such as “Name Your Own Price” and “Express Deal”

Factors Affecting Price GrowthQ4 and full year 2013 Earning Announcement on Feb 20,

2014

Sector: Consumer DiscretionaryIndustry: Internet RetailMarket Cap: $65.83B

Price @2/28/2014: $1,348.84Purchase Price: $1,286.9452 Week Range:$677.72-$1375.41

Intrinsic Value: $1,659.05Market Cap at Intrinsic Value: $82.95BUnrealized Gain: 4.80%

  2012 2013  Booking.com's Mobile Bookings $ 3 billion $ 8 billion 160%

Net Income $ 1.42 billion $ 1.89 billion 33%EPS $28.48 $37.13 30%

Priceline (PCLN)

Source: Yahoo Finance

Page 19: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

Investment ThesisThe largest player in Managed Care industry with its

high speed growthCompany's growth in EPS (normalized earnings) from

$2.77 in 2008 to an estimated $4.93 for 2013 The growth opportunities due to Affordable Care ActFrom 2012, the company made several acquisitions and

expand to international marketsFactors Affecting Price

Reasonable earnings that didn't please Wall Street on Oct 17, 2013 (losses of 5%)

Afford Care Act brings potential of increased enrollment, expansion and broader coverage to UnitedHealth GroupSector: Health Care

Industry: Managed CareMarket Cap: $76.43B

Price @2/28/2014: $77.27Purchase Price: $68.0352 Week Range: $75.80-77.71

Intrinsic Value: $114.42Market Cap at Intrinsic Value: $117.5BUnrealized Gain: 13.58 %

United Health Group (UNH)

Source: Yahoo Finance

Page 20: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

Investment ThesisChina’s build out of LTE broadband wirelessExclusive partnership with IntelTaking market share from ASICsStrong leadership in Structured ASIC market

Factors Affecting Price Fourth quarter earnings and sales beat estimatesShare buy backPositive news from sell side analysts

Sector: TechnologyIndustry: SemiconductorsMarket Cap: $11.53B

Price @2/28/2014: $36.31Purchase Price: $32.5252 Week Range: $30.62 - $39.18

Intrinsic Value: $51.11Market Cap at Intrinsic Value:

$16.23BUnrealized Gain: 11.64%

Altera (ALTR)

Source: Yahoo Finance

Page 21: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

Conclusion

Page 22: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

Valuation techniques

Advantages of a bottom-up approach

Liquidation and cash management plan

Training tools

What We Learned

Page 23: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

Continue training (Bloomberg tour in April)

Continue to monitor the performance and risks of portfolio

Potential Meeting with First-Year MBA Candidates

Looking Ahead

Page 24: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

Q & A

Page 25: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

Appendix

Page 26: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

Portfolio Snapshot as of 2/27/2014

Port      # % Wgt Mkt Val Pos Px Close Crncy

MBA SMF 2014 27 100.00 1,727,719Cash 1 0.11 1,912

USD 0.11 1,912 1,912.16 1.00 USDConsumer Discretionary 2 10.22 176,618

DICK'S SPORTING GOODS INC 5.11 88,362 1,633.00 54.11 USDPRICELINE.COM INC 5.11 88,256 65.00 1,357.79 USD

Consumer Staples 3 10.97 189,555CVS CAREMARK CORP 3.63 62779 870 72.16 USDESTEE LAUDER COMPANIES-CL A 4.23 73008 1080 67.6 USDPEPSICO INC 3.11 53768 680 79.07 USD

Energy 3 11.85 204767HALLIBURTON CO 3.6 62150 1116 55.69 USDSCHLUMBERGER LTD 3.87 66928 723 92.57 USDTESORO CORP 4.38 75689 1492 50.73 USD

Financials 4 16.91 292188BLACKROCK INC 4.92 85015 278 305.81 USDJPMORGAN CHASE & CO 3.25 56123 990 56.69 USDMSCI INC 4.34 75067 1717 43.72 USDWELLS FARGO & CO 4.4 75983 1650 46.05 USD

Health Care 5 20.57 355312AETNA INC 4.59 79343 1110 71.48 USDAMGEN INC 3.28 56617 460 123.08 USDCOVIDIEN PLC 4.89 84538 1185 71.34 USDJOHNSON & JOHNSON 4.15 71718 785 91.36 USDUNITEDHEALTH GROUP INC 3.65 63097 830 76.02 USD

Industrials 2 5.44 94001GENERAL ELECTRIC CO 3.17 54825 2150 25.5 USDUNITED PARCEL SERVICE-CL B 2.27 39176 410 95.55 USD

Information Technology 4 17.28 298547ALTERA CORP 3.67 63438 1750 36.25 USDEBAY INC 4.46 77125 1322 58.34 USDINTL BUSINESS MACHINES CORP 4.29 74108 400 185.27 USDKLA-TENCOR CORPORATION 4.85 83876 1291 64.97 USD

Materials 1 1.29 22352ALCOA INC 1.29 22352 1858 12.03 USD

Telecommunication Services 1 2.22 38285VERIZON COMMUNICATIONS INC 2.22 38285 806 47.5 USD

Utilities 1 3.14 54182AMERICAN ELECTRIC POWER 3.14 54182 1088 49.8 USD

Page 27: University  of Connecticut MBA SMF Presentation March 6, 2014

PEPAET

VZJNJ

AMGNCVSAEP

UNHUPS

EBAYIBM

ELGE

MSCICOVWFCTSOSLBBLKAA

DKSKLACJPM

ALTRPCLN

HAL

0.40 0.80 1.20 1.60

Beta

Port Beta  

0.92

Stock betas range from 0.63 – 1.52

Portfolio Beta