Upload
marlene-parrish
View
214
Download
1
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
April 24, 2003
Today’s Agenda
• SMF Performance vs. S&P 500
• Investment Philosophy
• Portfolio Strategy
• Lessons Learned
• Market Outlook
• Questions
April 24, 2003
MBA Portfolio Managers
• Ventzislav Adamov • Amitabh Basak• Eliza Biedziak• Lily Ding • Radu Popescu• Xin Shi • Monica Simsek • Vasim Vasgare• Wiebke Wanner-Borchardt
April 24, 2003
SMF vs. S&P 500
S&P 500 SMF
Sep. 30, 2002 $815.28 $199,675.86
Apr. 11, 2003 $868.30 $214,194.48
Return 6.50% 7.27%
SMF has outperformed S&P 500
•SMF Fund’s overall return is 7.27%
April 24, 2003
Investment Philosophy
• InitiallyUncertain outlook led to conservative approachStrong confidence in Health Care and Consumer
StaplesLow confidence with IT and Financials
• Now Remain confident in Consumer Staples Guarded optimism for economic turnaround
April 24, 2003
Stock Selection Criteria
We look for: – Solid financials– Strong management – Consistent earnings growth – Attractive valuation relative to the index– Higher Return/Risk relative to market
Buy Criteria
• Steady growth rates• Intrinsic value >market value • Above average yield• Upside-downside ratio of at least 2
Sell Criteria
• Stock reaches its price objective• Industry-sector weighting exceeds predetermined limits• Risk/reward profile deteriorates• Earnings figures lower than estimates
In total, we have analyzed 53 stocks.
April 24, 2003
Stocks Presented
Armor Holdings International Flavors & Fragrances Pfizer First Data Corporation
Cognizant Exxon New York Times Johnson Outdoors Wrigley Washington Mutual
General Dynamics Group 1 Automotive WellPoint Health Diebold, Inc. American Express Bally Total Fitness
Petro-Canada Spartan Motors Inc. Abbott Laboratories Sysco Corporation Metlife British Petroleum
Alliant Techsystems TJX Companies PepsiCo MacDermid
purchased sold not purchased
April 24, 2003
Stock Selection Process
Search for stocks in respective sectors that match our investment philosophy and selection criteria
Do you think this will outperform the market
in the long run ?
Prepare Stock Valuation Report and submit it to the group for VOTING
Does the group think that this stock will outperform
the market ?
Recommend this stock for a BUY
Yes
No
Yes
No
April 24, 2003
Methodology
Financial Analysis:
• News and recommendations: Yahoo! Finance, MSN Money Central, Quicken, Value Line, Reuters, Multex Investor, Wall Street Journal
• Value Line: Safety Rank and Beta• Models: DDM,FCFE, Zero Growth, SSG • Relative Valuations: P/E• Benchmarking• Stop-loss: 15% depreciation from buy price• Upside review price between: 15% and 30% appreciation
April 24, 2003
Equity, 28.22%
Vanguard 500 Index Fund,
64.41%
Cash, 7.37%
SMF Holdings (as of 04/11/03)
April 24, 2003
SMF Holdings
• Why ~65% invested in S&P 500 Index Fund?
Inability to find individual stocks satisfying our strict buying criteria due to high volatility and continuously changing market, economic, and political situation
Adopted a conservative approach at the beginning
Could not utilize the funds in the short term after converting them to S&P Fund from Bonds
April 24, 2003
Best Performers
Current Price ($)
As of 04/11/03 Stock S&P500
Abbott Laboratories 02/25/03 34.16 39.12 14.52 3.55 10.97
Wrigley WM Jr Co. 10/22/03 53.16 57.16 7.52 (2.46) 9.98
TJX Companies 04/01/03 17.20 18.91 9.94 1.14 8.80
Exxon Mobil 11/20/02 34.93 34.33 (1.72) (5.02) 3.30
Metlife Inc. 03/04/03 25.58 27.62 7.97 5.63 2.34
WellPoint Health 11/13/02 76.65 76.80 0.20 (1.61) 1.81
Overperform (% points)
StockDate
boughtPurchase price ($)
Holding Period Return (%)
April 24, 2003
Worst Performers
Stock S&P500
Armor Holdings 1 10/22/02 16.36 12.96 (20.78) (0.32) (20.46)
General Dynamics 1 11/13/02 79.71 63.70 (20.09) 0.55 (20.64)
Group 1 Automotive Inc. 2 01/28/03 24.85 21.20 (14.69) (4.26) (10.43)
Spartan Motors Inc. 02/19/03 10.41 8.20 (21.23) 2.74 (23.97)
Cognizant Technology 3 03/10/03 22.67 4 19.30 (14.87) 7.94 (22.81)
1 Sold on 01/23/2002.2 Sold on 03/04/2003.3 Sold on 04/10/2003.4 On 04/02/03 Cognizant Technology had a 3 to 1 stock split.
Underperform (% points)
StockDate
boughtPurchase price ($)
Holding Period Return (%)Current
Price ($)
April 24, 2003
Analyst Report: Abbott Labs
• Business Model Analysis• Financial Data Benchmark• Valuation Models:
Is this a good company? Is the stock a good value? Is the stock a buy?
• Risk Factors• Recent News• SWOT Analysis
(Strengths – Weaknesses – Opportunities – Threats)
April 24, 2003
Analyst Report: Abbott Labs
• Report
• Value Line Investment Survey
• SSG
Abbott Report
April 24, 2003
Managerial Performance- % of Pretax Profit Sales
- % Earned on Invested Capital
Risk vs. Reward Analysis:Is the stock in a buy zone?
Total Return:5-year potential
April 24, 2003
Lessons Learned
• Stock selection processHolistic approach with emphasis on company’s
business risks
• Identify right stock that matches our value growth investing strategyFocus on fundamental analysis and on stocks with
growth potential and low volatility
• Upside review and Sell disciplineAct in timely manner
April 24, 2003
Lessons Learned
• Analyze impact of geopolitical issues on market behavior
• Look at macroeconomic trends
• Understand investor’s reactions to economic indicators
• Look for management shenanigans
• Analyze 10k reports and pay particular attention to footnotes
April 24, 2003
Going Forward
Opportunities:
• Military victory in Iraq raises prospects for economic turnaround
Administration’s fiscal stimulus program promoting growth – Possible elimination of double taxation on dividends
Improved GDP growth
April 24, 2003
Going Forward (cont.)
Risks and Threats:
• Geopolitical concerns still prey on the minds of business executives
• Issues concerning Post-war Iraq and negative economic data making businesses cautious on spending
• Ballooning Federal budget deficit raises concerns
April 24, 2003
Suggestions:
• Maintain Risk Control as volatility is high because investors are looking at weekly economic indicators
• Invest in Consumer Staples
Going Forward (cont.)
April 24, 2003
Thank you to:
• University of Connecticut Alumni Foundation• Investment Advisory Board• Dr. Chinmoy Ghosh• Mr. Pat Terrion• Karthik Krishnan