Upload
luke-shaw
View
214
Download
0
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
TODAY’S CLASS
Announcements Where We Are & What We’re
Doing Skills: Reading Cases
Washington Equip. Mfg. p. 145 Skills: Arguing From Precedent
Burnham, p. 150) Take-Aways & Tomorrow
ANNOUNCEMENTS
Reschedule Mon, Nov 10 Class Th, Nov. 13, 2:30 p.m.
FEEDBACK ON COURSE
Mid-quarter feedback forms Still welcome!
DM Question about questions Power v. process
Mutually exclusive or Overlapping
CLARIFICATIONDue Process
Federal government 5th Amendment
State governments 14th Amendment
Burger King Federal court PJ
FR 4(k)(1)(A) Piggybacks on Florida long-arm statute PJ under FL statute consistent with 14th
Amendment?
CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK Choosing a Trial Court
Choosing aTrial Court
(Federal or State Court)
Subject MatterJurisdiction
Personal Jurisdiction
VenueVenue Transfer
Forum non conveniens+ +
International Shoe “Boxes”
ContactsSystematic Isolated
& continuous
Jurisdiction | ? ||
_____________ |______________|||
? | No jurisdiction||
Claim Related
Unrelated
SKILLS: READING CASES
Wash. Equip. Mfg. v. Concrete Placing Co., p. 148
General jurisdiction Pl’s argument? Why?
SKILLS: READING CASES
Wash. Equip. Mfg. v. Concrete Placing Co., p. 148
General jurisdiction Court’s view? Why?
SKILLS: READING CASESDetails
Wash. Equip. Mfg. v. Concrete Placing Co., p. 148
“dismissal with prejudice” !!!
Power
Personal (Territorial) Jurisdiction
Process
Presence?Consent?Domicile?
Minimum Contacts+
SubstantialJustice
&Fair Play
SKILLS: ARGUING FROM PRECEDENT
Burnham v. Superior Ct., p. 150 Rule choice
What gap or ambiguity is addressed in Burnham?
SKILLS: ARGUING FROM PRECEDENT
Burnham v. Superior Ct., p. 150 Rule choice
What gap or ambiguity is addressed in Burnham?
Does “presence” still establish jurisdiction?
Must all assertions of pj satisfy minimum contacts?
SKILLS: READING CASESRule Choice Options
What rule choice options are suggested by the Justices in Burnham?
SKILLS: READING CASESRule Choice
The S.Ct.’s choice? How do you know?
SKILLS: READING CASESAssessing Precedential Value
Precedential value of Burnham? Reorganize the conceptual
framework?
SKILLS: ARGUING FROM PRECEDENT
Interpreting the constitution Original intent Precedent
Agree with plurality’s approach? Why?
SKILLS: ARGUING FROM PRECEDENT
Hypothetical President of Concrete Placing
liable as individual on guarantee of debt
attends Apple Cup served with process in Pullman
WA court personal jurisdiction?
TAKEAWAYSGeneral Jurisdiction
Conceptual Frameworks Personal Jurisdiction
Where does Burnham leave us?
Skills: Arguing From Precedent Rule Choice Counting Votes & Assessing Precedential Value
TAKEAWAYSGeneral Jurisdiction
General jurisdiction What is it?
Claims not related to def’s contacts w/ state What contacts permit gen’l jurisdiction?
Individuals Presence, domicile, ???
Corporations Incorporation, prinicipal place of business, ???
TOMORROW: IN CLASS
Topic: PJ Based on Consent Before Class
Read Hypothetical on Web Types of Consent clauses Consent on the Internet Hypo
TOMORROW: IN CLASS
Topic: Consent In class
Types of Consent clauses Skills: Arguing From Precedent
Hypothetical: Consent on the Internet