Upload
social-technology-quarterly
View
217
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/28/2019 The Proof is in the Experience
1/5
]nggjko tnmfkigiojns hy privj`jko tfn spcmn ti cky mustilnr ti nxpnrjnkmn
c nvjmn hnairn purmfcsjko c``s ti tfn wfign nxpnrjnkmn ia huyjko c ornct
`nvjmn+ _jtf tfjs j`nc rnpgjmctn` air purmfcsjko list oii`s ck` kit ikgy
`nvjmns' tfn vnr`jmt js mgncr+ Jt js tfn nxpnrjnkmn tfct mgisns c ncg+ Fiwnvnr'
jk tfn con ia simjcg wfnk wjtf c mgjme ck nxpnrjnkmn mck hn lc`n nxmgusjvn'
ikgy c fck`aug ia nxpnrjnkmns ikgjkn rncggy aiggiw tfn eny wir`4 nxmgusjvn+
Fnrn js c pirtaigji ia nvnkts ck` nxpnrjnkmns nkfckmn` hy tnmfkigiojns+
Pfnsn rnprnsnkt tfn jkmrn`jhgn rnsugts ck` iutmilns cmfjnvn` tfriuof c
ljx ia hnfcvjiurs' cmtjvjtjns' ck` tnmfkigioy+
]lcrt husjknssns crn usjko tnmfkigiojns ti mrnctn jktnorctn` pfysjmcg'
`jojtcg' lihjgn' ck` simjcg sfippjko nxpnrjnkmns ck` nvnkts wfnrn mustilnrs
mck cmmnss pgntfirc ia jkairlctjik wfjgn tfny sfip+ ]umf nvnkts tfct oi
cmriss cgg lcrentjko ck` sfippjko mfckkngs privj`n tfn jksjofts ck` `ctc
ikn mck jkkivctn wjtf+ ]tirns crn riggjko iut cpps tfct fngp cmmilpgjsf rjmf
nxpnrjnkmns wjtf ncmf mustilnr+ Pfnsn nvnkts' cmtjvjtjns' ck` nxpnrjlnkts
crn ornct nxclpgns ia nlhrcmjko tfn slcrt mustilnr wjtf slcrt tnmfkigiojns
ck` privj`n lnckjkoaug mifnsjvn mustilnr nxpnrjnkmn+ Pfjs nksurns tfct
ikgjkn ck` iajkn nxpnrjnkmns crn kit snpcrctn hut jktnorctn` air figjstjm
sfippjko nxpnrjnkmns tfct gnc` ti rnpnct purmfcsns ck` hrck` giycgty+
Pnmfkigioy nkchgns ck` nxpnrjnkmns wjk#
Pfn Rriia js jktfn Nxpnrjnkmn4Nkfckmjko Nxpnrjnkmn hy gnvnrcojko tnmfkigiojns
Air hrck`s' cpps snrvn cs c gcstjko
lcrentjko mfckkng tfct nkchgns jrnmt
miktcmt wjtf tcront cu`jnkmn+ Pfny iaanr kit
pgcjk nkoconlnkt hut figjstjm nxpnrjnkmns+
Fnrn crn siln cmtjvjtjns mik`umtn` hy
hrck`s milhjkn` wjtf ikgjkn' iaagjkn ck`
cuolnktn` rncgjty ngnlnkts tfct mck cwn
cky lcrentnr+
hyQck`ckc ^+
Rfiti Mrn`jt4Ljmurs
http://www.flickr.com/photos/micurs/http://www.flickr.com/photos/micurs/7/28/2019 The Proof is in the Experience
2/5
Eugjzc
C pfnkilnkik tfct fcs `rjvnk mrczy ikgjkn
scgns ck` nkoconlnkt js cuolnktn` rncgjty+
Qjrtucg rncgjty js c sjlugctjik ia c rncg
nkvjriklnkt5 fiwnvnr' pnipgn ont jkti c
`jaanrnkt rncgjty `nkn` hy tfn vjrtucg spcmnck` oins hnyik` pfysjmcg rncgjty+ Ik tfn
itfnr fck` cuolnktn` rncgjty' cs _jejpn`jc
`nsmrjhns jt' js c gjvn' `jrnmt ir jk`jrnmt'
vjnw ia c pfysjmcg' rncg,wirg` nkvjriklnkt
wfisn ngnlnkts crn cuolnktn` hy
milputnr,onknrctn` snksiry jkput sumf cs
siuk`' vj`ni' orcpfjms ir OR] `ctc+ Nrjme
]mfikang` ipjkns tfct Cuolnktn` Xncgjty
nkfckmns tfn rncg wirg` wjtf `jojtcg `ctc'
ck` tfnrnairn jt js lirn jktnrnstjko tfck c
achrjmctn` nkvjriklnkt+
Ck nxpnrjlnkt tfct mcuoft ly nyn wcs tfn
ljx ia cpps ck` cuolnktn` rncgjty wjtf pip,up
stirns+ Pfn mikmnpt ia pip,ups js kit knw cky
gikonr ik tfn simjcg millnrmn spcmn+ _jtf tfn
summnss ia pip,ups sicrjko' c` jko cuolnktn`rncgjty ti tfnl snnls c mgnvnr livn+
C gnc`jko sfin hrck` `n`jmctn` ti spirt
mugturn' Cjrwcge snt up jkvjsjhgn pip,up sfips
jk Knw Zire ck` Gis Ckongns+ Jkspjrn` hy
tfn j`nc ia c trncsurn fukt' 122 pcjrs ia
sfins wnrn fj``nk+ Rnipgn wfi wcktn` c
pcjr ia Cjrwcges , tfn Gc`jns Djl Rgcstjm ck`
tfn lnks Djl Pnkkjs , fc` ti `iwkgic` tfn
Oig`Xuk cpp ik tfnjr slcrt pfikns+ Rnipgn
fnc`n` ti Qnkjmn Hncmf' Gis Ckongns' ir
3_csfjkotik ]qucrn' Knw Zire Mjty' ti mcpturn
vjrtucg vnrsjiks ia tfn skncenrs ck` OR],
gjkes ti ncmf gimctjik wnrn privj`n`+ Cs siik
cs pnipgn gimctn` c sfin ik tfnjr pfikns ck`
tiie c pfiti ia tfn sfin' tfny wnrn jrnmtn` tiCjrwcges n,millnrmn sjtn ck` ojvnk c pcss
mi`n gjke ti prn,ir`nr tfn nxmgusjvn sfins+
Air Cjrwcge' fckoiuts ck` aclius gimctjiks
jk tfn twi mjtjns turkn` jkti tfnjr stirns+
_jtfiut c hrjme ck` lirtcr sfip' 122
pcjrs ia sfins wnrn sig` jk c `cy+ Cjrwcge
wjtknssn` tfn fjofnst cliukt ia trcam ik
jts sjtn `urjko tfjs nvnkt+
Cjrwcge4
Cuolnktn` Xncgjty Mclpcjok
Mrn`jt4 Rjnrlcrji
http://www.flickr.com/photos/piermario/http://www.flickr.com/photos/piermario/7/28/2019 The Proof is in the Experience
3/5
83
]imjcg Pnmfkigioy Sucrtnrgy 21
Ckitfnr nxpnrjnkmn gnvnrcon` wjtf simjcgln`jc &kit wjtf ck cpp' hut c lcp* js
hy Qigeswconk Hrczjg+ Pfn litir hrck`
spiksirn` tfn Rgckntc Pnrrc Anstjvcg jk ]ci
Rcugi ck` prilitn` jts mcr' tfn Aix' tfriuof
c ljx ia Pwjttnr' Oiiogn Lcps' ck` rncg
gimctjiks wfnrn prjzns wnrn fj``nk+ ]jljgcr
ti c trncsurn fukt' tnk tjments ti tfn anstjvcg
wnrn fj``nk cmriss tfn mjty ck` tfnsn wnrn
`jspgcyn` ik c ljmrisjtn usjko Oiiogn Lcps+
Fiwnvnr' ikn miug`kt ziil jk ti spit tfn
nxcmt gimctjik ukgnss jt wcs twnntn` chiut+
Pfn lirn kulhnr ia twnnts miktcjkjko tfn
8
fcsftco -aixctpgckntctnrrc wnrn snkt'lnckt tfn mgisnr tfn ziil ik tfn lcp+
Pfn rst ikns ti crrjvn ct c gimctjik wfnrn
tjments wnrn fj``nk wiug` wjk+ Jt js rnpirtn`
tfct jk gnss tfck twi fiurs catnr jt hnock' tfn
mclpcjok hnmcln tfn kulhnr 3 trnk`jko tipjm
jk Hrczjg ck` tfn nvnkt strntmfn` ti 0 `cys+
_jtf c ljx ia ikgjkn ck` iajkn strctnojns'
Qigeswconk onknrctn` c fuon cliukt ia wir`
ia liutf+ Pfn mclpcjok pgcyn` ik hnfcvjiurs
tfriuof ocljmctjik' sumf cs tfn `nsjrn ti
wjk+ _jtf twnnts cmtjko cs octns ti gnvngs ia
ziil' tfn nxmjtnlnkt ia mrissjko ncmf gnvng
ck` hnjko mgisnr ti tfn tjment pulpn` jk tfnrnqujrn` c`rnkcgjk+
Cgtfiuof Qigeswconk `j` kit iaanr ck
nxpnrjnkmn `jrnmtgy jk rngctjik ti tfn mcr'
wfjmf pnrfcps wiug` fcvn hnnk lirn
rngctchgn' tfn iutmilns ia tfjs mclpcjok
knvnrtfngnss wnrn pfnkilnkcg+
Qigeswconk4
-aixctpgckntctnrrc
]imjcg Pnmfkigioy Sucrtnrgy 21
7/28/2019 The Proof is in the Experience
4/5
88
Eugjzc
]pncejko chiut litir milpckjns' Ajct
tii stnppn` ikti tfn hck`wcoik ia
nxpnrjnkmns+ Mctcgiouns mck hn fncvy
ti rnc`+ Jkstnc` ia lcejko c hirjko rnc`'
Ajct lc`n pnipgn nxpnrjnkmn jts mctcgioun
cs c pcrt ia jts ]trnnt Nvi mclpcjok+ Ajct
hrien tfn ig` pcttnrk ia vjsjtjko c sfiwriil'
mfnmejko c mctcgioun' ck` tnst `rjvjko tfn
mcr' hy mrnctjko c knw ocljn` nxpnrjnkmn+
Rrilitjko Rukti Nvi ti jts nvigvn` ck` tnmf
scvvy cu`jnkmn' Ajct mcln up wjtf c lihjgn
cpp tfct rnc` ric` sjoks cs SX mi`ns+
Jkstnc` ia lnrngy rnc`jko tfn ancturns ia tfn
mcr iaa c mctcgioun' catnr mcpturjko c ric`
sjok' ikn miug` ont c vjsucg ik tfn ancturn ia
tfn mcr ik ikns pfikns+ ]i ja ikn smckkn`
tfn stip sjok' tfn usnr wiug` ont ti ekiw
cgg chiut tfn knw hrncejko systnl5 c murvn
cfnc` sjok wiug` jkairl tfn usnr chiut tfn
mcrs jktnggjonkt gjoftjko systnl tfct ouj`ns
tfn `rjvnr jk murvns+ Kiw tfct siuk`s gjen c
rnougcr cpp+ Fiwnvnr' Ajct c``n` c ocln,
gjen nxpnrjnkmn hy fj`jko fuk`rn`s ia prjzns
jk tfn trcam sjoks' tfn rst ikns ti `jsmivnr
tfnl wik tfn prjzn+ Pfn mclpcjok scw
3'222'222 trcam sjoks hnjko spittn` ik
wnne ikn' ck 68 pnrmnkt jkmrncsn jk tnst
`rjvns' ck` jt js Ajcts list,snnk mctcgioun
jk tfn milpckys fjstiry+ _fct lc`n tfjs
mclpcjok c summnss wcs tfn jkmnktjvn
pcrt ia jt+ Jkmnktjvns ck` rnwcr`s lcen tfn
nxpnrjnkmn cgg tfn lirn auk ck` wirtfwfjgn+Pfn cpp ck` tfn nxpnrjnkmn lckcon ti
sctjctn cky vjsjtirs murjisjty+ Ckyikn huyjko
c mcr wjgg fcvn kulnrius qunstjiks' ck`
wfct hnttnr wcy tfck tfjs ti ckswnr' tfriuof
c ocln,gjen nxpnrjnkmn+
=Ajct4
]trnnt Nvi
Mrn`jt4 Hienf Huronr
http://www.flickr.com/photos/softestthing/http://www.flickr.com/photos/softestthing/7/28/2019 The Proof is in the Experience
5/5
]imjcg Pnmfkigioy Sucrtnrgy 21
0Gykxs acggnk ckong mclpcjok usn`
cuolnktn` rncgjty ti rnagnmt jtsnga cs c
hrck` tfct hrjkos c lcks acktcsjns vnry
mgisn ti rncgjty+ _jtf tfn ihdnmtjvn ia
rcjsjko cwcrnknss ck` `rjvjko purmfcsn
ia tfn Gykx Nxmjtn rckon' Gykx nxpgijts
simjcg ln`jc ti nkocon jts tcront
cu`jnkmn , 36 ti 80 yncr ig` lcgns , wjtf
ckongs snnljkogy acggjko aril tfn sejns
air tfnl ct Gik`iks Qjmtirjc ]tctjik+ C
gjvn hric`mcst' ynt fjofgy pnrsikcgjzn`'
jt hnkt tiwcr`s tfn ckogn ia gjtnrcggy
augajggjko acktcsjns+ Jt tcges ti lnk jk
ck nxmjtjko wcy' lcejko tfnl anng tfct
tfny crn cttrcmtjvn' hy lcejko c wilck
gjtnrcggy acgg air tfnl+ Cgsi' milhjkn`
wjtf c Acmnhiie ocln jk wfjmf Gykx
mfcggnkon usnrs ti try ck` rngncsn ikn
ia tfn ckongs , li`ng ck` cmtrnss Enggy
Hriie , tfn mclpcjok js c rncg wjkknr+
Pfn mclpcjok wiren` hnmcusn jt turkscriuk` c acktcsy cs ja jt wnrn cmtucggy
giojmcg air tfn ckong ti acgg+
Xnanrnkmns4
Cuolnktn` Xncgjty+ _jejpn`jc+ _jejln jc
Aiuk`ctjik Jkm' 3? ]np 8238+
Hjngc' Lcrtjk+ Cutiaspcmn4 @jojtcg ikgjkn
cutilitjvn mclpcjoks+ Cutiaspcmn' 26 Lcy
8233+
Fuj' Arckmjsmi Fuj Arckmjsmi+ R]AE+ R]AE
]nrvjmns' 2> Imt 8232+
Gykx Nxmjtn Ckongs lnnt tfn puhgjm ct
Gik`ik Qjmtirjc+ Gykx Naanmt Hgio+ Gykx' 30
Lcr 8233+
Rcrenr' @cvj`+ Gykx Nxmjtn acggnk ckong hy
Puggi Lcrsfcgg _crrnk+ Mclpcjok4 Pfn
_ire+ Fcylcrent Fcylcrent Husjknss Ln`jc'
3> Lcr 8233+
Qigeswconk Aix4 Pwjttnr Tiil Mclpcjok+
@jojtcg Huzz+ K+p+' 28 Lcr 8233+
Gykx4
Acggnk Ckong