The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    1/322

    T Y

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    2/322

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    3/322

    D MONOGRA HS

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    4/322

    Is i lv e r V r- O P h . l us , ^ N y ^ » D e 9 t , * \ £ ^ * f

    My ra

    i no r ?

    r i o d I I si l ve r ^ ^ 5 v oo W 0< v * * £ ~ £ ?

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    5/322

    A B L S x i

    D 1

    S O F L YC I A IN G N E R . . . . 17

    7b.c.

    O FT H C IT I S 2 5

    4-81b.c.

    yanda,Candyba?,Cyaneae,

    (trueLeagueandpseudo-

    ls ( t r ueLeagueand pseudo -

    r a, R hod iapo l is ,S i dyma ,T l os ,Tr e -

    (pseudo-League ,P haselis

    Olympus(pseudo-

    - L ea gue

    E S O F T H C I TI S 9 9

    mid30sb.c.

    ycanda,Cadyanda,Cyaneae,

    , P h e l l u s ,P ina r a ,T l os , Tre -

    R O F TH D I S T R IC T S Il l

    uarterdrachms,mid40s-after

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    6/322

    ytus,butalsoCyaneae,Myra,

    ssus-Cragus?,Tlos-Cragus

    S O F T H D I S T R IC TS 1 8 5

    dalsosestertiianddupondii,

    ytus,butalsoCyaneae,Myra-

    os,Tlos-Cragus,Xanthus-

    LAC SOFTH LYCIANL AGU

    Y MI N T 23 5

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    7/322

    dualsfor theirhelpinthis study,

    LycianLeaguecoinsintheir carebut

    andrecordingcoinsofthe fourhoards

    dispersedforever.Thefriendlyco-

    sofreelyofferedinthe numismatic

    tions.

    ingcuratorsandstaff:Athens,Mando

    lin,Hans-DietrichSchult ;Berne,Balas

    fe;Boston,MaryB.Comstock;Brussels,

    est,KatalinBiro-Sey;Cambridge,Fit -

    lard;Copenhagen,OttoMerkholm;

    chke;Dresden,P .Arnold;Glasgow,

    .A.vanderVi n;Hannover,Margildis

    dGropengiesser;JohnsHopkins,Carl

    er-HugoMartin;Klagenfurt,Ingeborg

    ukov;London,G.KennethJenkinsand

    mannoArslan;Munich,HaraldKuthmann;

    s l o , J anNordbe;O fo rd ,Ca the ri n e E . K in g

    a r i s ,Geo rgesLeRi de r, M on i u e M a in-

    ockholm,UllaWestermark;Strasbourg,

    isabethNau;Turin,AnnaSerenaFava;

    Vienna,HelmutJungwirthand Wolf-

    c he s Museum ,P . C o l e st i n Ra p f (A b t e i z u

    b( I n s t i tu t fu rAn t ikeNu mis ma tik ; Wi n t er-

    d Ya l e , JohnP .Bu rn ha m. To the l i s t o f t h e se

    beadded HansvonAulockwho,before

    edcastsofand furtherinformation

    smagnificentcollection.FredS.

    ybutformerlyresidentinA thens,

    arecordofthe Athensmaterial.

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    8/322

    avein manycasesnotonlysent

    talsovolunteered,sometimesrepeatedly,

    on,forwhichIammostgrateful.Michael

    wardRobinsonhavealsokindlyprovided

    in uiries.RichardAshtonhassupplied

    1977Hoard.Inparticular,I shouldlike

    , O fo rd ,Pa r i s , a nd Ber l i n f or t he i rk ind

    kcasts attheircabinets.Andto my

    r.,whopatientlyassistedmethrough

    ndcastingduringthesevisits,my

    nland,France,Germany,Greece,

    ntryhavesharedwithme recordsoftheir

    nsiderationsofsecurity haveledmany

    shmustberespected,butit mustalsobe

    se privatecollectionstothisstudy

    haveprovideduni ueandsignificant

    eague'scoinage:inP eriodI,thefinest

    of i s sue1 ( l a ; i nP e r i o d I I, t he d r a c hm of

    hP inaraandthedrachmof Cyaneae(55.1

    riodIII,theonly knowndoubleunitof

    V,thebest-preservedhemidrachmwithMA

    furtherdie linkedwiththefollowingissue;

    u p on d iu s184aand th e uni u eh a l f uni t

    alityofmaterialcontributedbyprivate

    nremarkablyhigh,andIamgrateful

    e centraltotheunderstandingofthe

    he Lycia1977Hoard,theyarethe

    70 Hoard,andtheMarmaris1976

    avebeenpublished.Forknowledge

    I amindebtedtoq uiteafew

    rs.Itis solelythroughtheirhelp,given

    onandfromcompletelydisinterested

    cordof theseimportanthoardshas

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    9/322

    hJenkinsoftheBritishMuseum

    blisheddataontheRhodianplintho-

    gesteddatingofthe silverofP eriodII.

    rican NumismaticSocietyhassuffered

    aiveq uestionsaboutmattersRoman.

    cellentresultsIthankthe Society's

    e.Finally,thestudyinits presentform

    eful readinggiventhemanuscript's

    ofCopenhagen,andtheentire manu-

    argaretThompson,NancyM.Wag-

    ededitorMarieH.Martin.Thesefive

    uablecontributionsandsuggestions,

    seriousblunders.Anyerrorsoffact or

    wever,Iclaimasmyown.

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    10/322

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    11/322

    hinon.

    bul.

    Museum.

    Blackburn,England.

    e de Be lg i ue .

    u eum.

    ge(ifpublishedinSNGLewis or

    bi s h ed inMcClean o r S N GFi t ) .

    desbank,FrankfurtamMain.

    ewing,nowondepositatthe

    iversity,Cambridge,

    .

    nt e n ,Penn ingenenG e s ne-

    versitatHeidelberg.

    Heller,Bristol,E ngland

    M . J . P r i c e .

    Bloomington,Indiana.

    pkinsUniversity,

    smatiche,CastelloSfor-

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    12/322

    cSociety.

    Toronto.

    a l e.

    vatecollections,in theUnitedStates,

    ece,orSwit erland.

    tet.

    onaleetUniversitaire.

    ndesmuseum.

    aticana.

    um;orBenedictinerAbtei

    u b l ished inScho l t en .

    hischesAkademiederWissenschaften.

    AntikeNumismatikundVorislamische

    rsitatWien.

    wHaven,Connecticut.

    edin thecataloguearelistedbelow.

    here ifcitedmorethantwice.In general,

    ebeditions.P tolemy'sGeographyiscited

    d C .T.F is che r, vo l . 1 , p t. 2 ( a r i s , 190 1 .

    gy.

    MuseumNotes.

    raay,CatatogueofCoins

    hmoleanMuseum,pt.1,

    ieMineureau point

    i s , 1853 .Thesec ti o non Ly c ia ,

    853, pp.85-98.

    Uni ue.

    , B e it r dgezu rd l t e r e nMi in -

    CoinsfromtheCollection

    n,Indiana:University

    olumeisG.F.Hill,

    ycia,P amphylia,and

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    13/322

    of t h eRomanE m pi r e i n th e B r i t ish

    .

    theRomanRepubticin the

    1910 .

    RomanAsiaMinor, inAnE conomic

    d.T. Frank(Baltimore,

    i demonna i e s g r ec ues ( a r i s

    Chronotogiemittet-hettenistischer

    A M UGS5(Ber l i n, 19 72 .

    heCistophoriofAugustus(London,

    o g y.

    Society,CoinHoards,1-4(London,

    R o b inson , Co in s f rom Lyci aand P a mp hy l i a,

    anRepubticanCoinage(Cambridge,

    uedetaCreteancienne

    E .Levy, Tre so rhel l e n is t i u e t r ouve

    96 5 , pp .503 -66.

    umentsdeI'AsieMineuremiridionate

    de n u misma t i ue g r e c u e ( a r i s , 1 95 1 .

    ofD iscoveriesinLycia(London,

    mtoAuctoritas(Cambridge,1946 .

    c i or u mCommuni ( a r i s , 1898 .

    de r a t S t at e s (O f o r d , 196 8 .

    M i i n p rdgungd e s Go rdi a n I I Iun d

    u b i ngen ,1974 .

    ca.Recueitd'ipigraphie,denu-

    g re c u e s ( a r is , 1 94 6 - .

    i s to r i aNumorum,1s t ed . (O fo rd ,18 87 ,

    .

    eofGreekCoinsintheHunterian

    1 .

    lmandC.M.Kraay,eds.,An

    NewYork,1973 .

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    14/322

    Romanaspertinentes,vol.3,

    e pr i n t ed .,Ch i cago , 19 75 .

    r, Zur griechischenundr6mischen

    r o v inc i a lmun en , S NR1 3

    d Ge neva (1908 , pp .21 -26 .

    nt.

    R Suppt.13(Munich,1973 ,

    R.Jameson:Monnaiesgrec ues

    93 .

    dGetdgeschichte.

    eE asternRomanP rovinces,

    . O fo rd ,1937 .

    KteinasiatischeMiin en,vol.2(Vien-

    E rwerbungenan t i k er M i i n en in d e nJahren

    HamburgerKunstsamm-

    0 .

    Moneta ionediAugustoV. Z ecche

    1916,pp.283-98.

    Robinson,CatatogueofAncientGreekCoins

    mpson(London,1923 .

    detacottectionde Luynes,vol.3

    l e s e tmonnai e sd e Ly c ie , H e t t en i ca1 0

    i n As i aMino r ( r i ncet o n , 19 50 .

    No/ i i a /i a r i i E vXXo yr Ar / i r x q lov I I .

    o u r na t i n t e rna t i ona t d ' ar c h io to g i e nu-

    1 7 7- 268 .

    oftheMcCteanCottectionof

    1929 .

    eekCoins,MuseumofFine

    n th e O fo rdC ol l ec t ion s , NC1 940,

    to n demida i t t es an t i ue s , g r ec u e s e t

    Miscellanea, NC1903,pp.400-402.

    nnaiesgrec ues(Amsterdamand

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    15/322

    eleghegreche,P roblemiericerche

    .

    heClassificationofLycianCoinsbefore

    G 1 964,pp .65 -76 .

    holmandJ.Z ahle, TheCoinageofKuprlli,

    ,pp.57-113.

    u e s in d i t e s s ur d e s t t r a -

    aNumismatica,ed.G.F.

    d Toronto,1906 ,

    d el l emedag l i e an ti c heg rech e de l

    ence,1828 .

    electae,ed.W.D itten-

    Ancient World(Liverpool

    alencyctopddiederclassischen

    rt,1894-1963 .

    ailles,voi.2( aris,1763 .

    c he M un kunde . IV.Lyci a ,

    eetd'histoireancien-

    o n nai e she l l n i s t i ue s . I . U ne mon nai ed e

    R N1977,pp .7 -3 4.

    icaescien eaffini.

    d'istru ioneclassica.

    anImperialCoinsintheHunter

    , 19 6 2 .

    n sammlungd e s S ti f l e sScho l t en in Wi e n ,

    1 9 20 .

    a p h i cumGraecum.

    MainAcsCoinagesofAugustus

    korfor SNGCopforcoins

    Graecorum.TheBurtonY.Berry

    62 .

    raecorum.TheRoyalCollectionof

    ionalMuseum.Lycia-

    5 .

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    16/322

    mGraecorum.TheNeivnhamDavis

    ClassicalandE astern

    g e, A be rdeen (Lon do n , 19 36 .

    mGraecorum.Fit williamMuseum.

    t.7,Lycia-Cappadocia

    mGraecorum.TheLewisCollectionin

    dge,pt.1,TheGreekand

    .

    mGraecorum.TheLockettCollection,

    n,1949 .

    umGraecorumDeutschland.Sammlung

    n,1964 .Thefewcoins

    chtrage4(Berlin,1968 .

    matischeRundschau(RevueSuissede

    nageoftheRomanRepublic

    herland, TheSymbolismoftheE arlyAes

    N1965,pp.94-109.

    ed.E .Kalinka(Vienna:

    920—44 .

    nnaiesgrec uesetromaines

    erLykier(Stuttgart,1887 .

    hernShore(London,NewYork,

    M i n eu re ,2nded . ( a r i s , 196 2 .

    nlairedelacollectionWaddington( aris,

    alcherdeMolthein,Catatoguedelacollection

    . Wa lche rdeMo l the i n ( a r i s

    ayonGreekFederalCoinage(Lon-

    ollection:GreekCoins,vol.3,pt. 2

    ma t i k .

    n cl u deF L(F i ed P r i ceL i s t .

    r t s , Minneapo l i s,M in neso t a .

    ,St.P etersburg,Florida.

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    17/322

    Basel.

    Munich.

    mMain.

    o i ns andAn t i u i t i es , L td . ( s ucce s sor s t o D . J .

    na .

    omischeundby antinische

    London.

    kfurtamMain.

    Numismatists,Ltd.,NewYork.

    ich.

    delphia,P ennsylvania.

    mMain.

    rf.

    k ab ine t t ,Cologn e.

    tuttgart.

    Salem,N.Y.

    c h er Nach f .,Mun i ch.

    M i i n enundMed a i l l enA . G . , Base l .

    herlandsCoinCo.andB.A.Seaby,New

    ismaticFineArts,BeverlyHills,California.

    m M ai n .

    o.,Halle.

    urtamMain.

    dam.

    n.

    nCo.,BeverlyHills,California.

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    18/322

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    19/322

    T A BL S

    D rachmsandP linthophoric

    o f Lyc ianP e r io d I I (Si l ve r o f t he

    er o f t heC i t i es Se r i es 1 - 3 . . . . 34

    er o f t heC i t i es S e r i es1 -3b yRegi on 35

    o p ho r i cDrachmGr oup E an do f

    heC i t i es Se r i es 285

    er o f theC i t i es S e r i es 3and o f P e r io d

    es1-696

    rachmsby Series118

    s t r i ctS i l ve rDen omina t i ons . . . . 119

    drachmSeries6and Augustus-Head

    iioftheSecondHalf oftheFirst

    HemidrachmSeries1-6...122

    s 3 2

    criptionalE videnceforCities

    ,P eriodsII-V39

    a nd f o rRhodianP l in th op hor i c D rach m

    iodIII106

    es 1 64

    84

    r o n es187

    2 2 4

    ypesandObverseLinks.. .249

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    20/322

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    21/322

    D

    atdealofscholarlyattentionhasbeen

    e,andthroughit theinternalhistory,

    e ander.1Thiswasinevitable.P re-

    plesofAsia, theLyciansseemalways

    f nationalunity,whichkeptthemfree

    lativelyfreefromforeigndomination

    calperiods.E venundertheP ersian

    ouldnotresist,the Lyciansretainedsome

    astscoinedin theirownnamesthrough-

    rthcenturies.D uringthistime,al-

    heGreekandAchaemenidworlds,a

    urishedinLycia, whosearchitecture,

    mirationtoday.

    rthefall ofthelastdynast,ca.

    vestruckvirtuallynocoins.2Butin the

    cesspeakof aformalLycianLeagueof

    yHelleni ed,andwhichstrucka large

    verand inbron e.Mostofthiscoinage

    tire two-centuryspanfrom167b.c,

    sbeenanaly ingwithconsiderablesuccessthe

    sical times.SeeMorkholmandMerkholm-Zahle,

    olm, TheCoinHoardfromP odalia, JVC1971,

    Z ahle, TheCoinagesoftheLycianD ynasts

    , Ac t aArchaeo tog i c a 47 (19 76 , pp .4 7 - 90 .

    od wasminimal.D r.Merkholmtellsmehesuspectsthat

    mporarywiththe dynasts'mayhavecontinuedfor

    w;A.D .H.Bivarhassuggestedthatcertain small

    tionswerestruckin LyciaunderP ersianruleinthe later

    f C y rus theYounge r, N C 19 6 1, pp . 12 4 -27 ; an dso me

    eaguecitiesmay possiblyantedatetheLeaguecoinage

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    22/322

    iandominion,toa.d.43,whenshe

    absorbedinto theRomanE mpire.

    e uentlycitedasevidenceforthe mem-

    League,theyhavereceivedremarkably

    nlittle studied,presumablybecause

    ek,and theirgovernmentwasnot

    Greekpoliticaldevelopment.3Yetthe

    eni edbythetime theLeaguesprang

    weunderstandthemseemthoroughly

    catedfederation,atthe endofthe

    ies controlledthreevoteseachinthe

    ordingtosi e,controlledtwoorone.

    gue'sinstitutionsisnot, andcannotbe,

    coinagecan,however,tellussomethingof

    hipatdifferentperiods,andattimes

    withherneighbors— andamongthese

    ed Rome.

    onhasbeenpaidtothe LycianLea-

    arlyinthis centurye aminedcertain

    Claudius,5but thelastworktosurvey

    sa wholeappearedoverhalfacentury

    htheLycianLeagueand itshistoryareTreuberand

    dchieflywithLycianhistory,with whichitdeals

    ncentratesontheLeagueand itsinstitutions.E .A.

    uebrieflyinhis HistoryofFederalGovernmentin

    nand NewYork,1893 .Renewedattentionhasbeen

    odecadesbyMoretti,by J.A.O.Larson,GFS and

    amesoninarevisedarticle onLyciainR Suppl.13.

    onvenientsummaryofLycian geographyandhis-

    fsources(ancient andmodernliterary,inscriptions,

    citieswhichstruckunderGordian.Andof course

    scussedinMagieandin Jones.

    i s a lone in r ecog n i i n g t hat t h e l a rg es t Lyc i anL e a gue

    d,aresestertii.Claudius'sLycianstrikingsare nottrue

    rAY; theyweremostprobablystruckimmediately

    s e e Appendi 3 .

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    23/322

    ndHistoria Numorum,whichareinevitably

    ccurateaswellase tremelyimprecise

    nominationsinuse,nouseful treat-

    agee ists.

    orconsistschieflyoftwolargemoun-

    ciaTracheia,separatedby theP am-

    hichis Lycia.NortheastofLycialies

    ned,shiftingseveraltimesduringanti-

    d i a andP hrygi a ; t o th e wes t , againac r o ssa

    outhwest,somefiftymiles away,the

    t el y 8 0mi l esea s t t o we st , an d4 0 nor t h to

    0s uaremiles.Amountainousland,

    t u n derand j u s t ov er1 0 , 000 fe e t— a nd th is

    Thereare fewplains:oneinthe north

    epartin Lycianaffairseitherinclassi-

    eague;one aroundTelmessusinthe

    eXanthusRiver,theheartlandofLycia;

    utherncoast.

    workofroadsunderthe RomanE mpire,

    r e me lyd i f fi cu l t:A l e a nde r a vo i d e d t he

    marchingacrossthelevelcountryin

    mes,onlyveryrecentlyhasaroad

    hecoast.Internalcommunications

    y b yseao rby the r i ver swh ich f lo w to th e

    mportant,westto east,werethe

    dus,andtheLimyrus.

    oftheLycianLeagueli ewithineasy

    serivers.Telmessus,a ma orcity,is

    rncoast.P atara,Lycia'schiefport,

    oins(London,1907 ,pp.151-68,precededonlyby

    e r, Be l t ragez u rMQn k un de Lyc i en s, pp .9 3 -1 22 ,

    n de r, Be it rOgezu ra l t e r e nMOn k un de (Be r l in , 18 51 .

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    24/322

    esoutherncoast,nearthemouthof the

    at riverisXanthus,Lycia'slargest

    heriver'stributariestothe northlie

    yanda.Withinanareanomorethan 10

    southerncoastareCandyba,P hellus,

    Trebendae,andMyra.Slightlytotheeast

    gae,aroundasmallcoastalplain; up

    sthroughthisplain,is Arycanda.And

    ehighSolymaMountainsfromthe rest

    aselis.

    populationinancienttimesas

    high.3Twohundredthousandwould

    anthecurrent population,butthisis

    otesthatin manyinstancesAsianareas

    dancientpopulationsgreaterthantheir

    ,however,whateveritsabsolutesi e,

    munities.P linystatesthatwhileLycia

    eitcontainedbut 36.9Strabo,speaking

    sharedthe voteinthefederalassem-

    sareknownfrominscriptions,andthese

    te.Andwhat,in anycase,isthedefi-

    me orvillage?Itis clearthatspec-

    cities isidle.Wecanbe sureonly

    atteredin manysmallcommunities

    havebeentheLycians'chiefsources

    yimportantproduct,but ancient

    fish,sponges,cattle,andgoats— butno

    a l t hatwou lde p l a i n t he r a th er s u r p r i si ng

    altimes,orinthe periodoftheLycian

    hisstudyhasbeen thatthesurviving

    mpleindeedoftheoriginal output.

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    25/322

    p l o r er s i nLyc i a i nc lu ded th e E ng l i sh men

    amLeake,SirCharlesFellows,Sir

    aterinthecentury threeAustrian

    wrotevaluableaccountsofthetopo-

    ions:0.BenndorfandG.Niemann,

    c h an , andR .Hebe rde yand E .Ka l in ka .u

    wn.Archaeologicale cavations

    ldWar,12and thearearemainsoneof

    ninAsiaMinor.E speciallynowthat

    rchaeologicalandnumismaticinterest

    ears.

    esettledbyGreeksin heroicand

    emainfreeof Greekcoloni ation.13

    eeknamesdoes notcontradictthis

    knownthatthesewerenot thecities'

    ample,wascalledArnainthe Lycian

    meoftheL ycianswasadoptedonly

    o wi n gAle ander ' s co n ue s t , as i n t he i ro w n

    rmilai.P haselisontheeasterncoast

    Reisenimsi1diue.ittichenKleinasien1: Reisenin

    8 4 ;E .P e t e r son a ndF.v on Lu s c han , Re i sen im s i 1 d -

    nLykien,Mityas,undKibyratis(Vienna,1889 ;

    erichtUberz weiReisenimsUdivesttichenKleinasien,

    en45(Vienna,1896 .Fortheseandothertravelers'

    ntheworkscited inn.3.Recentworksdealing

    atsonlyLycia'seasterncoast;andBean'sposthu-

    donandNewYork,1978 ,asplendidsurveywhich

    onofthepresent study.

    inXanthus,J.Borchhardtin MyraandLimyra,C.

    S.BulucinP atara.M.Mellink'se cavationsinthe

    timesand arebeyondtheareaofthe Lycian

    orydowntothearrivalof AntiochusIIIcontains

    nerallyaccepted.Fullertreatmentandspecific

    can befoundinTreuber,Magic,andJones.

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    26/322

    n,butinearlytimes thiscoast,separated

    maMountains,wasnotLycianbutP am-

    mesflourishedintheXanthusValley

    limits,asshownbythec haracteristic

    owertombsandby inscriptionsinthe

    thewesterncoast oftheGulfof Tel-

    north,andRhodiapolistotheeast,

    ortheastofArycandaandRhodiapolis,

    ocaldynasts,whomthecoinsshowto

    fcities,governedLyciaat thistime.

    certaintimes asleadersofthewhole

    ngP ericles,whointhefirst halfofthe

    yciae cepttheeastcoast.But the

    eeofautonomy,sincein thefourth

    thenamesofseveralofthe larger

    norstayedfreeofCroesus'sdominion

    desperatebut unsuccessfulresistanceof

    Ly c i apas sed in to th e P e r s i anE m pi re , bu t

    ortheLycianprincescoined intheir

    oinherwesternneighborsinthe Ionian

    shewasatleastbrieflya memberof

    b u t e l is t s fo r446b .c . a s s es s th eAv i o i

    te n t al e nt s .

    dabove,j oinedintheRevoltofthe

    62 b.c.,Lyciawasplacedunderthe

    osehousecontinuedto controlLycia

    dynastswouldseemtohavedisappeared

    citieswithwhich Ale anderdealt,and

    him.

    afelltoAntigonus.The P tolemies,

    ervariousvicissitudes,theareacame

    the 270sandremainedE gyptian

    tury.P apyrishowthattheLycian

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    27/322

    a r i e t yof spec i fi c t a e s , an d a wel l -

    usgivesavividpictureof P tolemaic

    ntof240b.c.recordsseveralactsof one

    p e r hapsanephewo fP t o l e my I I I u po n

    mtheE gyptianking.P tolemysonof

    ufferingfromthewars —i.e. theSyrian

    ertaincropsandpasturage,andregu-

    d u e onava ri e tyo fg ra i n s , i n o rd e r t o

    t h e t a f a rmer s . Th e Eg yp t i an s no n e the l es s

    onomically;andthelargenumberofL y-

    tolemaicarmiesalsoatteststheim-

    heperiodof E gyptiancontrol.

    entury undertheineffective

    7b.c.AntiochusIII ofSyriatookpossession

    ythathetookLimyra,Andriace

    thus,andprobablyTelmessus,butthesources

    ofthewholecountry.18

    tof Agatharchidesmaybelong,

    theArycandians,neighborsofthe

    lvedindebtbecauseoftheirprofligacy

    useofidlenessandfondnessforpleasure

    turned theirhopestoMithradates,

    dedbythe abolitionoftheirdebts. 17

    desiscorrect,thefragmentcannotrefer

    ofP ontus,forAgatharchideswrotein

    thereferencetothecancellationof

    datesdid enactj ustsuchapolicy.

    oundlikewhatweknowotherwiseof

    es.

    dividualcities,but Antiochus'spossessionofP atarais

    where.Specificcities aregiveninJerome,Comm.

    s f r ag .46 inF. J a cob y,D ieF r a g men ted e rg r ie c h i sc hen

    1 9 29 ,p .1224 ; t h i s a ndJ ero meo nDan ie l 11 .1 7 - 19

    Livy,implythatAntiochuswoncontrolover allLycia.

    KalinkainTAM,pp. 288-89,andMagie,pp.1384-85,

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    28/322

    ntreferstothetime ofAntiochusIII.

    southerncoastofAsia Minor,winning

    romSyriato Sardesundertwogenerals.

    hradates,itistohim thatthefragment

    btsin thiscasemightwellrefer to

    a p p ear sa f e inany cas e to d i s r ega r d t he

    travagance ,althoughitis perhapsdoubt-

    tedate wereabletocollecttheir revenues

    thatAntiochus'sarmypassedvery near

    otbe suretowhichruler,Antiochus III

    efers,for itwouldbevaluabletoknow

    ratedintoLycia,andwhatthelocal

    weasilyAntiochusoccupiedLycia.

    racesiumresistedhimandthatthe

    helibertyof severalCariancities.Hethen

    h itishardlyworthwhile torecordin

    eworld. 18Aninscriptionrecords

    ustoLeto,Apollo,and Artemis.19This

    Xanthuswasabletoarrangesomesort

    ng,butit mayhavebeenakindof

    icationthatLycia's relationshipto

    han sub ection.

    emstoshowthatthe Lycianswere

    nin 190ami edRomanandRhodian

    P atarawithitsimportantharbor,

    ng t h e t roopso f th ek ing wh o mthey h a dasag a rr i so n,

    he battlewenton, largernumbers

    ... thewholepopulationwaspouring

    d L ivysays t h e Ly c ia ns , no t t heSyr i an

    ivenbackintothe city;theRomans,how-

    ledoff.ALycian contingentoflight-

    chus'sarmy atMagnesia.21

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    29/322

    isalsoimpliedbythe reportthat

    ia atApamea,didnotpleadduress,as

    ctedweresuchapleapossible.Theymerely

    ofthekinshipbetweenIlium andLycia,

    e v a .22P o lyb iu s r e por t s t h a t t he I l i a n sw ere

    eonlypunishmentRomeinflictedon

    s,whohadtakenthewinningsidein the

    awardedCariasouth oftheMaeander

    e s su s ,wh ichwas g i ven to E um e ne s .2 8

    ling, andRhodesapparentlyhadto

    y.TheLyciansrevoltedrepeatedly,and

    threewars theyhadtowagethere.

    77procuredanattemptedcompromise:

    tshehad neverintendedtheLycians

    s,butallies. Thispleasedneitherside.At

    keofattemptingto mediateinthe

    heensuing negotiations,andin167

    odesofhermainlandterritoriesand

    diusformallyincorporatedthem

    yciansretainedtheirfreedom,which,

    ominalastimewenton.Tothisperiod

    coinageoftheLycianLeaguehas

    owerlimitmuststill hold,butthe

    mewhat,aswillbeseen.

    ciousnessandunityisevidentthrough-

    ofsomesortis oftenassumedinclassi-

    e Av io ix a l c fv v r e X el ^ ] e n t ry in the

    y37.56and 38.39.

    5,and30.31;Livy41.6,41.25,42.14,and44.15.Livy

    that itisnot worthrelating''theLycians'struggles

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    30/322

    eof thecommonreversetype,the

    sts'coins.25Mutualcooperationamong

    tentthiswasvoluntaryratherthan

    ot known.Inanycase,anyearlyLeague

    ot ofcities;andit wouldhavecome

    henthecountrywasmadesub ectto

    ,especiallyinnumismaticcircles,

    wasbasednotonlyon theobviousfact

    utalsoonthe BMC'sdatingofthe

    CdatedtheLeague'ssilvercoinsto

    liticalconsiderations,butalsobecause

    arlyimitatedtheRhodianplinthophoric

    MCwaswritten,theRhodianplintho-

    after167.2 ButHillalso,unfortunately,

    ue commencedonlyuponthewith-

    eadinHistoria Numorumhasfollowed

    bothof thecoinageandoftheL eague

    uehaslongbeensuspectedby its

    r,q uitepossiblyinthelate third

    ofanearlierdatefor theRhodianplintho-

    ting.TheRhodiancoinswillbe dis-

    he evidenceforalatethird-century

    uggestedthattheLeague'sorigin

    probablyin itsclosingyearswhen

    12-13.

    e168,orat times166,insteadof167,but 167b.c.

    ate.ThattheLyciansilvercoins imitatedthe

    isstatednotin BMCLyciabutinBMCCaria,p.cvi;

    r t i s t he r eda t ed to ca . 16 7 ( pp. c i an d2 52 .P e rhaps

    pecificallyinBMCLycia,Larsenseemsunawareofthis

    ciandrachms,regardingtheacceptedterminuspost

    rary( RepresentationandD emocracyinHellenistic

    4 5, p p .72 f . .

    s te a d o f167b . c , b u t s ee ab ov e,n .2 6 .

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    31/322

    ning, 9butJ.A. O.Larsenfirstpresented

    istencebefore167b.c.Henotedin

    bedatedbetween188and181, isa

    l cov, and tha t i n t he1 80s b . c . t he r ew e re

    hleticvictorsidentifiedbya formof

    s t a te s :Av iogdn o r dy mv,Av i os i b i d

    dgwv.Larsenalsobelievedthatthe

    oinstoafter 167wasarbitrary.30

    earlierLeague,organi edandeffective,

    48G.E .Beanpublishedalong

    northernend oftheXanthusBiver.31The

    agorasof Ara a,whohadalong and

    oagetes,tyrantof Bubon,j ustnorthof

    a'sterritory.Orthagorasfirstcommanded

    heBubonians,andwentasAra a's

    Cibyra,towhichBubonwasevidently

    whichiswhatinterestsus here,wentto

    orderto seekitsaid.In thishewas

    ntlyregardingthedisputeasa mere

    id appointOrthagorasasitsown

    homsomesettlementwaseventually

    rantssei edXanthus,killedmanyof

    v es u pasdespot s . Th i s t im e , i t sm a or c i t y

    dmilitarily,withOrthagorascommand-

    etyrantswere,aftersomedifficulties,

    wasinvolvedina war,whoseoutcomeis

    ndTermessus,mostprobablyTermessus

    dAra aina territorialdisputewithan

    tsweremadetothefederalgovernment,

    ort,andweresettledpeaceablybythat

    dmissiontotheLeagueof asmall

    g er e s , pp.15 f .

    e e a bove ,n .26 .

    omLycla, JHS1948,pp.46-56.

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    32/322

    ervedasenvoyto thefirsttwoofthe

    d b y theLyci ans i nh on o r o f ' d / M t 6 e a

    thedateofthis highlyinteresting

    nspointtoca. 180b.c.,whichnowseems

    nforthedatingis theuseofpraenomina

    ates:thisusage,characteristicoftheearly

    Another reasonistheestablishment

    e a i n t

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    33/322

    hc he t ends thewo rk on th is su b ec t by

    partofMoretti'slucidworkon theGreek

    hnics. ThesimpleAv iog,used

    romthemid-fourthto themid-third

    i ogand, e . g . I J ardg w , i s f ou nd f ir s t

    t ur y ( s eebelow , wh i l e mo s t e am p l es

    condcentury.Thesimplemunicipal

    earsinthefirst halfofthesecondcentu-

    deralethnicbythetimethe predominant

    he easthadmademembershipinthe

    ss.Morettiobservesthatitisnot without

    ampleofthefederalethnicbelongsto

    these ethnicsforthestartof the

    este ampleofthefederalethnicfound

    us,datedto spring206-spring205:

    toanumberof foreigners,amongthem

    o vo g Av ioga ndSdvdo v. *

    preceding167b.c.that thefollowing

    ned.TheysurelyantedatetheL eague's

    everthee actdateofthe silver's

    mablyearlierthanthe Rhodianplintho-

    mitated.As willbeseenbelow,the

    havecommencedsomeyearsbefore

    dhereasa convenientandhistorically

    m f o r theLyc ianL e a gu e ' s b r on e s o f

    0 ; t he Mi l e tusdec ree i s Mi l e t I I I ,D as D e l phi n i on (Be r l i n, 1 915 ,

    t ti , p . 215 ,n .36 .P e r hapsb e c au se o f th e h i gh i nt e r es t

    sclear evidenceofMoretti'sfortheLeague'-e is-

    enignoredbyJones andLarsenintheirsubse uent

    restillincontrolin 206-205b.cisshownbyTAM 263,

    anruleinLycia:the inscriptionrecordsthededication

    ofP tolemyV,whoaccededlatein 205(orperhaps

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    34/322

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    35/322

    le anderLycianLeagueandits

    c a . 200b . c . -a . d . 43. App ro i ma tel y1 ,825

    ndare catalogued.Coinsareconsidered

    g s i nc ludee i t he r1 AY KI QN, o r AY,

    o rMA, theabb r e vi a t i on so f t h e L eagu e ' s

    firstcentury,CragusandMasicytus;

    seudo-LeaguestrikingsofOlympusand

    O AZHAIrep l ac ingAYKIQN , a rea l s o i n-

    nortwentyLycian citiesstruckLeague

    utonomousissuesduringthesecondand

    mousissuesarenot treatedhere.

    mint isusedinthe senseofthe

    ythelocationatwhich acoinwas

    e r i od ha sbe en used to deno t e the f ive

    scoinage,alternatelybron eandsilver.

    ablechronologicaloverlapbetween

    V, a n d IVandV.

    tbetweenthebron eandsilverissues.

    oinages,haveseriesdenotedbyArabic

    d i n t he s i l ve r i ssue so fA p pe nd i 3 , ob ver se

    reindicatedby lowercaseRoman

    othe rightindicatereversedieidentities.

    ed.

    n eco inages ,h a vese r i e sde no t ed by

    C .The reand i n t heb ro n e i s s ue s

    umbered,andGreekminuscules(a,p,y

    dfor illustration.

    becausevirtuallyallareff,withthe

    onlye ceptionstothisrule areissues

    4,in whichasignificantnumberof

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    36/322

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    37/322

    G N R

    eriodI,diesare notnumbered.The

    reepairsof dies,andthediesof issues3

    certainty.Relativediea esofthefew

    kethoseofallLycian Leagueissues,

    /orf \.InissueH, however,com-

    hichasignificantnumberofa esare

    Greekminuscules(a, p,y merely

    coinsontheplatesand tofacilitate

    N e i t he r t he se l et t e r s nor t h e s e u en c e of

    ulardies,andonlya representative

    trated.

    ellerophon,facing.

    n e e rgue,N (p r e se rv edo n l y on l a .

    .,bowandq uiver.

    oosstandingfacing,holdingbranch

    rved inoutstretchedr.

    d.

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    38/322

    ing;to r.,cithara.

    sfacing;to l.,bowandq uiver.

    bv.dies,av.wt.3.53

    s 2 . 86= Rh odes , p . 31 , f i g. 4= BMC

    Re cent e sac u i s i t io nsd uCab in e tdes

    , 2 2; O fo rd3 . 62 , pu rc ha s e da tK es t ep

    o i ns Lyc i a , pp .37 a nd 4 1-4 2 , 3 4.

    K e s t ep= Co in s Lyc i a , p p . 3 7

    38 , 4 ;p \Pa r i s1 .4 1= Wad din g t on

    g;to r.,cithara(presentonmany

    er.

    26 = Wadd ing t on3 009 ;y.O fo rd

    inara,1.04;Copenhagen1.23=

    d o n 1 .69= BMCp .3 8,1 ;New Yor k

    Waddington3008,0.61;Vienna1.11,

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    39/322

    eagueissuesinbearingonly thesimple

    furthercityor districtidentification.

    s s ue 1canno t, pe rh aps f o r t una t e ly,b e e ua -

    tspositionand thefactthatit isamono-

    ouldindicate areferencetoanin-

    hateverthatindividual'srelationship

    alsoalone amongLeagueissuesinbearing

    ntcoinageofthearea,theRhodian,down

    o b in son longago i n1 914 re c og ni e d t h a t

    andthat theywereamongtheearliest

    mesi eandweight(averageweights

    ppeartobenot contemporarybutsucces-

    ethelater,withits inanimatereverse

    s i mp le r i ne ecu t io n t h a n t he f a c in gh ead

    crossedbowand q uiveroflatersmall

    ownspecimensofissue 1is3.53;

    5.Theseagreetolerablywell witha

    ctively,oftheweightof thesmallest

    ues3and4;and issues1and2 maythen

    anotherofthesesmallerissues.Issue3

    1and2,bears twoanimatetypes,and

    pleheadratherthanabust, anda

    arsonissue4. Accordingly,issues1-3

    theLycianLeague'sfirstperiod ofcoin-

    gSeriesB.

    nnectionswiththe XanthusValley,

    mablyof theLeague,andthisis

    coinage,possiblymintedin oneor

    n c i t ie so fXan thus a nd Pa t a r a . And, o l -

    -2 .

    o d I I I and theha lfu n i t so fSer i e s AofP e r i odV.

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    40/322

    bablythe areaofLyciamosttravelled

    uringthe lasttwocenturiesandthus

    morecoinprovenancesthanother areas,it

    nprovenancesofP eriodIcoinsare in

    se ofcertainsmallbron esofP ata-

    ier orlaterthanthe Leaguecoinsisnot

    e2is poorlypreserved,itsreverse

    elythatfound onLyciancoinsthrough-

    l ater:Apollo(sometimesradiate ,

    ,cladina longgown,holdingabranch

    h i s e t ended r i gh thand a ndab ow(an dso me-

    weredlefthand.This mostprobablyisthe

    esofvariouscitiesin themid-first

    doubtthatshownonthelate first-

    c t s o fCragusandMas i c ytu s , 8 o nb o t h t he

    from,probably,a.d.43,40andon theIm-

    fromthemid-thirdcenturya.d.41Thebase

    coins showthatastatuewasportrayed,

    ns,sometimesshowninhistemple,is

    Butin anycasetheconsistenticono-

    nfourcenturies,demandsaspe-

    erenownedApolloP atroosatP atara,

    G o r di anwh ichma ke e t en s ive a nd v i rt ua l ly

    A p o l lo' s cu l t ando rac l e a tPa t a r a wer e wid e ly

    nditis strangethattheApolloonGor-

    r o n eco in so fPe r io d I I I ( 63aand 71 a .

    eco ino lSe ri e sFo fP e r i o dV (2 22 8 . S e r i es E a l so s ho w s

    c h mfromAppend i 3 ' so bve r s e d i eC2 .4 ; and E ,ab ro n e

    .

    B M CMyra14 -17 a nd1 9 ( th e l a t te r a h om on o iaco in

    P a t e r a ; and Gordi an 193 -22 1 , 230 - 31 , an d 25 3 ( a l l

    a t a r a , and29 7 -98 (R hod i apo l i s , t he o n l yo the r two c o in s i n

    hisreversetype .

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    41/322

    y,beenidentifiedasthe actualApollo

    rlier coins,underClaudiusandunderthe

    mage.

    nLeague'srecords werekeptat

    erehasbeen suggestedastheactual

    mtoconfirmthis. Thecoins'Apollois

    eepithetunderwhichhe wasknowntothe

    merousinscriptionsof theLeaguerefer

    stwasaLeagueofficial,andwhosecult

    P atara.43

    onofthechimera,bodytense,head

    shedfromCorinth,arrivedat Lycia

    hefirsttaskassignedhimbythe king

    mythicalcreature,partlion,partgoat,

    forthterriblefire.44 Inlatertimesthe

    d i d en t i f i edwi thab u r ni ng j e to fna t ur a l ga s

    ympusonthe easterncoast;thisweak

    eidentificationofthemonsterwiththe

    eenmadeinthethird centuryb.c.,4

    alonewerenamedChimera,onesuspects

    e earthalsoinotherplaces inthis

    a k es .

    thicalcreatureandnota gasflame,

    that themythisconnected.Strabo

    A p ol loP a t roos , s eeR I I , c o l . 6 3 ( We rn i ck e .G .F. H i l l

    fClaudius'scoins withthefiguresshownonthe Masi-

    lsof Gordian,butmadenosuggestionasto thepro-

    C 1 903,p .402 .E ven von A u l ock in h is r e cen tG or d i a n

    oins'Apollo.

    'srecordsatP atara,seethecommentaryonthatcity

    n1 0 6 .OnApol lo P a t ro dsan dh i s c u l t, s eeTAM 4 20=

    R 7 39 , IIB ,XI I IC , an dXVI I .

    C h i ma i r a2 (Ruge .S t r abo speakso f t he l oca li t yc a l led

    P linymentionsoneonthesoutherncoast (NH5.131

    ,andsaysthatthe latterisoneof twonearbyplaces

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    42/322

    hatthesceneofthe mythwasthe

    8

    o d I were s truck ,Lyc i ahad beco meq u i t e

    echimeraofthe coinsmaywellbeunder-

    theGreekBellerophon,grandfatherof

    cusandSarpedon.Furthermore,the

    emayrepresentBellerophonhimself.

    wasHelios, typerhodienetcarien. 47

    ledge,shownbearded.HillintheBMC

    RobinsoncalledtheheadHeracles,

    imitatedcertaincoins ofSelgewhich

    thestyleofthe LycianandSelgean

    eofSelgeshowingthehair andbeardin

    paratelocks,whiletheLycian heads'

    and longandflowing.AndHeracles,

    Lyciancoins oftheclassicalperiod,

    either Lyciaorthechimera,while

    ruckmore thanacenturyanda half

    coinageofthedynastP ericleswasthe

    LyciabeforetheLeague's.Inthesecircum-

    yhavecirculatedforsomeconsiderabletime,

    furnishedsomeofthemodelsforthe

    denominationsrepresentedbyissue2

    doubleunitsand units,respectively are

    i m a tewe ight so f t he tw osma l lb ro n e deno mi -

    f n o t t heon lyLyc i a nb ro n ep r i o r t o the

    atersshowinghisfacinglaureatehead,with

    9: BMCSelge35.ThiscoinshowsHeracles'sheadto r.;

    eemcloserparallels.

    nd163-64.Thesi esarethoseofthe Leagueissues

    average2.03(14specimenslocated comparedtoissue

    18(12specimenslocated comparedtoissue

    d i s sue4 ' t 1 . 07 (15 spec i me n s .SeeTabl e 8 .O th e re t r e mely

    struckin LyciabeforetheLeaguecoinagearementioned

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    43/322

    aypossiblyhaveservedas theartistic

    .

    Bellerophon,however,thechoiceof

    besignificant.Whilethechimerais

    atefifthcenturyonward,thereis but

    nclassicalcoinage,althoughother

    ted.51Itsappearanceonissue1 would

    Lycians'tieswith Greeceandwiththe

    emostprobabletimeforthe commence-

    theLycians' alliancewithAntiochusand

    me.Itis worthnotingthatTelmessus,

    s notaformalmemberoftheLycian

    alsoissuedbron esunderAntiochus's

    i eofissue1, withfacingHelios

    don theomphalosonthereverse,ason

    ethe LycianadoptionoftheRhodian

    rseheadinprofileandreversetype in

    atof mostoftheLeaguecoinage,especial-

    n thesilverdrachmsofthefollowing

    dateofthis style'sintroduction,firstat

    efoundinthe commentaryonP eriodII.

    kholm-Zahle,p. 92.

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    44/322

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    45/322

    S

    hichhavein thepastbeenerroneous-

    ftheseis aseriesofpseudo-Rhodian

    obverseshowsafacingheadofHelios

    ek,andwhosereverseshowstheusual

    fferingcombinationsofletters and

    enturyascribedtovariouscitiesof

    berofthereversecombinations(e.g.

    t o Lyc iaandseeme dan a lo g ous t o t h e t rue

    K HANorK TA. 56 Th e e r r o r o f

    haspersistedasrecentlyas1950,for

    ethatXanthuswasbrieflya memberof

    Caunus, plausiblepoliticallyalthough

    nfortunatelybeenrevivedinthemost

    oftheseries, byW.Sheridanin1972.68

    pedthe argumentsofA.Akarca,who

    ecoins toMylasa.Akarca'sreasons

    veeverbeenreportedfrom Caunus(or

    w h i l e the s i kn own pr ov enances a r ea l l

    that anidenticalheadofHelioswith

    onsilvercoins,probablyofthe Augustan

    01.

    e D rachms , A NSMN 18 (1 97 2 ,p p . 5 - 15, e s pe ci a l l y

    lishesahoard,nowIGCH1335.

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    46/322

    ON.59Inanycase,thispseudo-Rhodian

    publishedasilver drachmofanother

    hadac uiredinLycia.Thecoin was

    ndhesuggestedthatit hadbeenstruck

    ngtheperiod ofRhodiansupremacy.80

    ritishMuseum,whosecountermarkhad

    n,81anda thirde amplehassince

    mnos.82Thebeastofthe countermarkis

    thatofissue1, withthelionhead

    and Robinsonisundoubtedlyright,

    sappliedin Lycia.Itisless certain,

    struckin Lycia.

    nown,seemtohave beencounter-

    esduringthe periodoftheLeague.

    thophoricseriesbears astampwitha

    Y, j ustasonthe Leaguesilverof

    msofSidebearcountermarksofa

    d,evidentlyappliedbyAntiphellus.63

    LeaguesilverinP eriodII(Cyaneae

    e s g re c uesdeMy la sa ( a r i s , 1959 , pp .9 7 - 98 ( p r oven a nces

    hethnic .L.Robertagreeswithher attributionin

    s mo n nai e s , He l l en i ca11 -1 2 ( 19 60 ,p .5 3 ,n .1 , a nd ha s

    ilityofSheridan'sattribution,in Rhodes, p.32,

    argumentforMylasa,whichwill notstand:that

    ations(AM/AY,p.58,12 canbereadas MYAA.

    placementofthelettersandfrom theimprobability

    ationsbeingsignificant,theargumentisdestroyedby

    nAkarca's12(not inSheridan'scompilation and

    M and152 (wi th TI / A M . Neve rt he l es s , t hecoin s

    Lyc i a , pp .37a nd 4 1- 42 ,33 (no t i l l u st r a t ed ; com me n t a ry

    aR h odes203 .

    i t is h MuseumAc u i s i ti on s fo r t he Ye a r s 1 93 3 - 193 4 , NC

    i s he dano the r e amp le i n Rh o de s , p . 30 .

    ds , p . 17 , f i g. 1 , a nd p . 3 3 , fi g . 5 = B M C Ca r i a ,Rho des

    ibedinMionnet,Suppl.7,p.10, 36.AN:P late1,J.

    ar.

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    47/322

    hellusfrom butone andmayhave

    theLeaguewiththis counterstamped

    ver,however,thatstruck bythe

    seformatechoesthatof theplintho-

    hodianobversesshowaradiatehead

    nonesalaureateheadof Apollofacing

    theRhodianrosein ashallowincuse

    te'snamewrittenoutin full,and,to

    t h e s ua re , t he two le t te r s P O. Th e

    ithacithara,alsoin ashallowincuse

    alethnicAYKIQ N,and,inthesamel oca-

    hefirst twolettersoftheparticular

    ncoinswith thisformatwereknownin

    vdo

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    48/322

    r a chmsandP l i n t hop ho r icD rac hm

    P e r i od I I (S i l ver o f t h e C i t ie s Se r i es1s

    deonlythefull-weightplinthophoroiofJenkins'sGroups

    aredrawnfromthe ANScollectionandBMCCaria,

    GLockett.

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    49/322

    ns.88GroupsA-D ,showninFigure2,are

    ricgroups.

    strucktoastandardnoticeably

    rachms.67Theweightofthe Lycian

    betweenthesetwo,butmustbeunder-

    eryslightlyr educedfromthatofthe

    ionwasgenerallythecaseamongthe

    age:theweightsoftheplinthophoric

    fromthe Mugla1965Hoard,forin-

    m e r angeas thoseof P e r i o d I sSe r i e s l .8 8

    tohaveconsistedofsome200 Lycian

    nLycia.8 Oneaccountgavethefind

    southerncoast;another,fromprob-

    t asnearmodernKemeronthe eastern

    notherKemerinwesternLycia .The

    nofthehoard (133coins,ofwhichwell

    citiesofOlympusand P haselis confirms

    ghtlyoverahundredof theRhodian-

    ckbythecities wereknownbeforethe

    asappro imatelydoubledthenumber

    eLeague.

    nplinthophoricdrachmgroups,seebelow,pp.81-84.

    ntedout(privatecommunication thattheoldstyle

    ight,weighingconsiderablylessthantheappropriate

    styledidrachmsand tetradrachms;andthateven

    ewhatheavierthantheold styledrachms,theystill

    rdintermsofthosedidrachmsand tetradrachms.

    lberpragungdeskarischenStratonikeia, JNG1967,pp.7-9

    ordian,pp.34,37,47,and 52;itis no.96inCoin

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    50/322

    ofthecities, withAYKIQ Nandcity

    caseofmostof thecoinsofOlympusand

    OAIHAIreplacingAYKIQ N.Fourteen

    havestruckLeaguesilver wererepresented,

    ehoardcontained,however,noneofthe

    ruckbythedistricts ofCragusand

    velyrarecity issueswiththedistrict

    e p la c ingAYKIQN on reve r se .

    furthermore,wereofRhodianweight,

    2, above .Indeed,withveryfew

    lyknowne amplesofLeaguecoinsissued

    Q Nonreverseareof Rhodianweight.

    ,onthe otherhand,mostofwhich

    civicpieceswiththe sameformatare

    kingat1.80grams.

    ebetweenthetwogroupsof kithare-

    tharephoroiwithAYKIQ Nonreverse:

    sP eriodII.Theothergroup isthe

    ndMasicytus,withwhichare tobe

    oroiwithAYonobverse;theseform

    rdsandthe usualplacementoftheethnic

    tbeen understoodascomprisingtwo

    eentherulein mostformertreatments

    e BMC'scataloguecallsthedistricts'—

    kitharephoroidrachms,butdoesnot

    hermints'coins. E lsewhereinthe

    drachmsandhemidrachms(ofdegra-

    In thed rachmsh e incl ud e s a ll t h ek i t ha r e -

    idrachmshemeansthesmalldistrict

    and q uiverastypes.71Instill another

    hesesmallercoinsashalf drachmsor

    ies2and3, incontrasttoSeries 1ofRhodianweight.

    headpiecesareindeedthe halfdenominationsofthedistrict

    ntothe heaviercivicdrachms.

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    51/322

    themin thecatalogueasq uarterdrachms,

    doncewithout.72HeadinHistoriaNumo-

    rcifullyinshorter form,73andthesetwo

    yfollowed.Thefirstworkwhichhas

    woclassesofkitharephoroiis0. Merk-

    ock,wheretheheaviercoinsareconsist-

    er oneshemidrachms.74

    roughthekindnessofmanyin-

    E uropeithasbeenpossibleto collecta

    pro imately200coins.Thecoins

    peinseparatelots,twoof about50coins

    ndtheremainderapparentlyafewat a

    eriodIIdrachms,thenumberof their

    seknownfromtheKemerHoardare

    stedgeographicallyfromwesttoeast,

    sion;thisisthe orderemployedinthe

    individualmints.Table1alsogives

    nforeach mintineachof thethree

    i o d I I, bo thbe fo reand a ft e r t h e a pp e a ran c e

    av e t he samefo rmat , w i thAYK IQN a n d

    OAYMTTHorOAZ HAI,however,

    ns ofOlympusandP haselis.Suchcoins

    ederalethnic,maybeconsideredandare

    ns.Theonlytrue-LeaguecoinsofOlym-

    eries1; theircoinsofSeries2 and3areall

    C r ag us15 ,Mas i cy tu s 24 .

    sinSNGvAutockis nearlyperfect;herecogni esthat

    8and4365 aretobeclassedwith thedistrictissues,

    eavycoin,withonlyMfor mintidentification

    n ofMyra.Still,Morkholmseemstobethe first

    atthekitharephoroifallintotwo distinctgroups.

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    52/322

    a

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    53/322

    ies

    1

    bversedie Identities;dottedbracketstotheright

    nitialsof onecityhavebeencutover thoseof

    thus. Pseudo-League coinsarethosewithout

    ndefinitenumbersofnewdiesresult fromspecific

    castorphotographicrecordcouldbe obtained,

    tknown.D ietotalsareof coursereducedby

    mberofcoinsintrade since1970areq uite

    hoardbutarenot hereorinthe cataloguecalled

    ecificevidence.

    areofRhodianweight,ornearlyso:

    weightoftheRhodianplinthophoric

    ducedfrom Series1;andSeries3 is

    3 .

    acharea(west,south,andeast within

    nSeries2and 3.TheKemerHoardhas

    nsknownof Series1,andaddeda few

    nownofSeries2.Itcontainedno coinsof

    eakdownswithineachseriesagree

    dityof thedivisionofP eriodIIinto

    n weightsisanewphenomenonfor

    timeshadbeenstrucktodiffering

    thecitiesanddynastsofthewest using

    hesouthcentralregion.75

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    54/322

    o f t heC i t i e s Se r i es1 -3

    erHoardcoins.

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    55/322

    o f t heC i t i e s Se r i es1 -3 ,b yReg io n■

    erHoardcoins

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    56/322

    efirst silvercoinsknownofAnti-

    dedthe secondknowndrachmof

    obtainedofthis pieceandithas un-

    hethirddrachmof P hellus;andthe

    houghoneof thesemayinsteadbeof

    guecoinsare known .Theonlyother

    alsoherepublishedforthe firsttime.

    rueLeaguecoins ofOlympusand

    e g en dsAYKIQ N OAan d AY KI Q NOA,

    rkingsofOAYMTTHandOAZ HAI.

    selishasbeenforsomeyearsin aprivate

    oneofOlympusin theCopenhagen

    pin1955, butinvain,forthe coinhas

    ince.78

    tsalsoappearedin thehoard,and

    hetwoeasterncitiesof Olympusand

    heunderstandingofthesecities' emissions.

    l LeagueP eriodIIcoinageis pitifully

    a po l i s , i nPe r io d I Id o t h e c o in s e cee d

    ahandfulofothercities dotheyeven

    dII,leavingasidethe fivehoardcoins

    reknown311 coinsfrom201dies,a

    .Clearlythe knownmaterialrepresents

    aloutput,andanyconclusionsdrawn

    beregardedas tentative.

    h e m a orLyc i an s a nc t ua r i e s, t heL e too n

    mmerof1975a depositunderthecella

    s.Thehoardisthefirst containing

    eenfoundunder controlledconditions,

    ppl.7,p. 17,69.Overlooked,fore ample,byJones:

    Olympus,thoughof federaltype,neverbearthename

    0 2 , andbyvon Aulock ,wh o i s a t l e a st aw are o f the M i o nne t

    ngtonandWarren,however,appeartohaveseentrue

    Mineure,p. 113;Warren,p.42 .

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    57/322

    er coinagetogetherwiththeLeague's.

    tedareaunderthecella floor,ormore

    re thefloorhadbeen,forthe blockshad

    y.Thefollowingbriefsummaryisbased

    hoard,writtenbeforeallthecoinshad

    fied.

    n esandabout50silver coins.

    tharephoroiofthe Leaguewithreverse

    blycitycoinsof P eriodII;eightRhodian

    hophoroi;41Rhodiantriobols(the only

    ;andatleast onepseudo-Rhodian

    rroneouslycalleda hemidrachm .

    edarethree smallonesofXanthusas

    .7 8

    coins areincludedinthe present

    etospeculateonthehoard'sdateor

    ledge.Itismentionedhereonlyfor

    nLeague,P eriodsII-V.

    LycianLeagueisStrabo.I nthemidst

    country,hesaysoftheLeague:

    chsharethevote.The

    rvariouscities totheircongress

    v e r c i ty theyhavese l e c ted .E a c h o f

    votes,themedium-si edtwo,

    ashiontheypaytheircon-

    gies.Artemidorussaidthat

    AuLe tdondeXan tho s : l e s deu t em ple sd e L t o ,

    bliged toM.MellinkandH.Met gerforhavingput

    owasdirectlyresponsibleforthe e cavationofthe

    d.I ammuchindebtedtoM.Le Royforhislong

    o n t he sub ec to f t heh oa r d , w hic hh e e p e c t sw il l b e

    . 7 7 ,p .324 ,n . 1 .

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    58/322

    a nt h u s ,Pa t a r a ,P in a r a ,O lym p us,

    ssfirsttheychoosethe

    theLeague,andappoint

    a r l i er t heyused tod e c id e abo u t

    nowtheydonot,ofcourse,

    esettledbythe Romans

    ratesareelectedfromthecities in

    ntofLycia,Strabosays ofP haselis:

    .. butithasno partinthecommon

    a t i on to i ts e l f . 80 T he f tor u i t o fS t ra bo ' s

    us,wasinthe169thOlympiad,104-100b.c.,

    formationthatattheveryend ofthe

    ostimportantcitieswereXanthus,P inara,

    Myrainthesouth,andOlympusin the

    otthenaLeaguemember.

    recapitali edinTable2, whichgivesa

    sof evidenceforthenineteenLycian

    gue,andforatwentieth,Candyba,which

    ties mintedthesilverdrachmsof

    s us a ndArycanda , i ta l i c i e d a r ekn ow n

    ecities strikingthecivicbron esof

    o t ye tknown ins i l v er.D r a c hmsof

    chmsofseveralother citiesareknown

    yfew.

    Leaguecoinagesofthetwenty

    ms ofP eriodIIandcolumn2 thecivic

    um n s3and4g iv e si l ve r and b r on es t r uc k

    enamesofthe cities,althoughthebulk

    riodswas,ofcourse,in thenamesof

    lissues bearingcityinitials.Many

    autonomouscoinages,someq uitepossibly

    s;thesearenotincludedin thisstudy.

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    59/322

    ptionalE vidence

    eCoinage,

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    60/322

    softhe mintingcitiesinthe three

    Lycia:Strabo,81whowroteinAugustan

    edon theearlierworkofArtemidorus;

    ury a.d.;andP tolemy,83fromthemiddle

    tolemyorperhapsabitearlier wasan

    e n namedOpra mo a s : a l ong in sc r ip t i o n f rom

    s thecitieswhichbenefitedfromhis

    lementedbyafewothersinTAM,

    ownincolumn8 forallthecities

    ba.Thesetwo,however,occurinacon-

    citieshonoringthe LyciarchJasonof

    dunder Claudiusina.d.43(see

    o mi ti an ,Nerva , andTr a a n i n t h e b r ie f

    ngsbearno indicationofmint.Lycia's

    tedand rathersurprisingoutburstof

    nderthe youngGordianIIIandhis wife

    uckthiscoinage;thefourteenthat cor-

    shownincolumn9.

    useful,andcertainlyismorecom-

    n,citybycity,with allthesebitsof evi-

    ilationandstudyof thecoinageof

    udesforeachof theirmintingcitiesan

    raphical,inscriptional,andnumismatic

    guecities,theinscriptions havebeen

    whichincludestheinscriptions fromthe

    odiapolisamongthesouthernmints,

    haveerroneouslybeenascribedLeague

    n di 1 .

    d I GR704( Ja son .

    onalcitiesstruckunder Gordian:Arneae,P odalia,

    ndTrebenna.

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    61/322

    neachissue.Individualdies are

    ediscussionby issuenumberfollowed

    thethirdobversedieof issue8.

    asterisks.Whenmorethan one

    strated,theillustrationsfollowtheorder

    sedieisillustrated.Unknownobverse

    uebyanx .

    bversedie areshownbylower-case

    obversedienumber;theselower-case

    the plates.Bracketstotheright

    r e n ot g iven, a s theg reat ma o r i t y a re f f ,

    f\.

    nis fromtheKemer1970Hoard.

    esttoeast,and commentaryoneach

    alcommentaryfollowsSeries3.

    ehind shoulder,usually,bow

    nitials toeithersideof cithara;all

    inscriptionsvaryonthe pseudo-

    5and47-49 .

    rev.dies

    1 0a .

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    62/322

    2 1 ( Nov.16 ,1908 3 66 8

    1

    4 272 ,2 .80= Su p er io r ( O c t. 14 ,

    G Fi t 5051= G lend i n i ng (Fe b .

    k e t t 3012= Nav il l e 5 ( J un e

    3 ( May15 ,1905 4 24 4

    1 9 67 131 ,2 .75= Weber7 308

    G 4 476

    = Kuns ts am m.2 0

    G 4 475

    t c l ea rwhichc i t y 's c o i n swer e s t ruck

    e'sslight deterioration(spreading

    theCadyandacoin showsthatXan-

    vertheXanthusRiver,someeight

    ofLycia.Xanthus'sremainsarethe

    einLycia;fromit cometheNereidmonu-

    turedtombsnowinthe BritishMuseum.

    c.,says thatXanthuswas,besidesone

    hreevoteseachinthefederalassembly,

    8

    ngthatbut 15ofthe316 coinsof

    asthese15arestruck from15reverseand

    yles,itis clearthatthesurvivingma-

    nal si eofXanthus'sLeaguecoinage.

    dIIpresumablyweremelteddownfor

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    63/322

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    64/322

    d,one travelinggroupofdies,is not

    likelybythefactthatthe Sidymareverse

    oupof dieswouldpresumablyhave

    inara,andfinallytoCadyanda,thefar-

    sunlikelythatthe mintworkmen

    oruseatSidymawhilesavingused

    ngatP inaraandCadyanda—especially

    eredE somuchmoreeasilythanwould

    llthe coinsofthefourcities were

    reaksandrecuttingsallshowXanthus

    teonlythatthe homecity'sre uired

    afterallwhatonewoulde pect.

    oughP ataraandTlosinthe west

    esefourdie linkedcitiesofXanthus,

    adid.(TheonlyotherP eriodIImint

    he insignificantTrebendae. What-

    eenthefourcitiesherediscussed,it

    rev.dies

    e u donne , Mon n a i e sg rec u e s r ecem ment

    M e da i l l es , RN 19 0 2, p .8 1 , 71

    o t c l ea rwhichc i t y 's c o i n sw ere s t ru ck

    otrecut.Althougha Z could

    andtheI istiltedsomewhat,thereisno

    runder theI,and,withthe cithara

    space wouldhardlyhavebeenlarge

    eliablyreportedtohavebeenin the

    wasmadeofit,andits diesare

    lopeofMt. Cragus,westofthe

    ninemiles northwestofXanthus.

    antimesarenote tensive.

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    65/322

    d,firstpublishedin 1902,istheonly

    dLeaguedrachmfromtheKemerHoard

    ight.Sidyma'sdrachmsseemtohave

    entedinP eriodIIaremissing from

    e s o fP e r iod I II .T heab se nc e o f two ,

    ablysignificantandwillbe discussed

    esofSidymaorof Rhodiapolishaveyet

    ce.

    r e v.d i e

    7 3 0 0

    N G 4380 , ca l l edP a t a r a

    n o t c l ea rwh ichc i t y' s c o i n sw er e s t ruck

    ehasclear remainsofanAunder the\.

    eundertheTT,and thiswasprobably

    o n t a l s tr okea rev i s i b lea t t h e b o t tom

    ern slopesofMt.Cragus,perhaps14

    hus.P inara'sruinsfromtheperiodof

    mesareimpressive.Strabo,besides

    ycianLeaguecitieswiththreevotes,singles

    helargestcities inLycia.

    ncitiesmade contributionstothe

    otheir votesintheassemblydoesnot

    oinageat thetimeStrabowasdescrib-

    enturyb.c. ,oratany othertime.

    nthus,Tlos,P atara,andMyra did

    ages,seeminglythroughoutSeries1.

    agewase tremelyscant(oneobverse

    eudo-Leaguecoinage(withoutAYKIQ N

    mustbeunderstoodinconnectionwith

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    66/322

    oinageofP haselis—whichStrabo

    aguememberattheendofthe second

    s k nownofP in a r a, t he s i t h o f S t r abo ' s

    wayto theimportanceofthecity.

    cutXanthianone;oneoftheir two

    anda;andthecoins probablywereeven

    Strabowouldchange P inarato

    wouldagreefarbetter withthee -

    rranted.Alonginscriptionof81 b.c.,

    hereorgani ationofAsia,specifiessi

    dwithCarianStratoniceia,wherethe

    iancitiesare Xanthus,P atara,P inara,

    hthe substitutionofLimyraforOlym-

    thStrabo's.Olympuswouldby81b.c.

    eintopiracy,8 andLimyrahad

    possiblyreplacingOlympusasa

    dimportancemaywellbereflectedin

    dIIcoinage.Butforpresent purposes,

    trabo'saccuracyin includingP inara

    stcities.

    its Leagueobligationsincoinother

    Rhodianplinthophoroi.Hereis a

    ownimportancedoesnotcorrelatewith

    i t s er vea sacau ti on .

    rev.dies

    v e r Xan thus

    sslight deterioration(spreading

    theCadyandacoin showsthatXan-

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    67/322

    d i e b reaka toneo f t he l ower l ea veso f t he

    atesthatthedie wasusedfirstfor

    clearremainsofan z .under

    ycity isperhapsstretchingthings

    idistantfromtheupperXanthusRiver

    acessouthwest.Fromitshighsiteone

    wellas theriverandthesea beyond

    evenoreight milesfromtheriver,no

    Thenorthernmostofthemintingcities

    yabout30milesfromXanthusas the

    eciallyfromtheRomanperiod,are

    um,agora,gymnasium(? ,theater,

    smallbutmagnificenttown. 90Ithad,

    eratureuntilL.Robertresurrected it

    ny.Thefoolish Ascandiandalis,Amelas,

    storedtoitsoriginal Cadyanda,Lissa

    an o s cop ium. 91

    dyandaareherepublishedforthefirst

    withmintinitials KAhavelongbeen

    hethertheirmintwas Calynda,inthe

    messus;Cadyanda;orCandyba,inland

    mesaremaddeninglysimilar—but at

    aryanda,mercifullysituatedinCaria.

    vethesmallbron estoCadyanda;they

    ly,byMagie.93Calyndahasbeenfavored

    otherLycianmintsandfurthermore

    ncyofCaunus,afterwhichdateit placed

    des.94Candybaisfavoredhesitantly

    es,onthe groundsthatCadyandalay

    ngonP liny,NH5.101.

    arlierscholarsfavoringCadyandawereFougeres

    ng t o n3035 , and H e a d (t f N9 , p . 69 5 .

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    68/322

    67b.c.was Attalid;buttheydonot

    gorasinscription showingthat

    an activeLeaguememberintheearly

    sotentativelyassignstheKA bron esto

    ofthe threetostrikeImperialsunder

    responsibleforthe KAcoinsmight

    b r on e ,o r q uad rup l eu n i t, a tA th e ns , 7

    eotherelevencoinsof thisraredenomi-

    wns,asare nineofthetwelveidenti-

    n i t s o fP e r io d I II .

    shedfirmly linktheKAcity, which

    ies oftheXanthusValley.Itmay be

    ewhatcloser,inair miles,toXanthusthan

    munications,overthemountains,be-

    unthinkable:anypracticalroute

    of riversandthesea,past otheractive

    elyhaveusedinpreferenceto themore

    TAM,althoughchieflyfromRoman

    n easyreachofothers.Theinscriptions

    tionofciti ensofnineothercom-

    a,Tarsus,andLaodiceia arenon-

    thesefivearepreciselythefive other

    ,Tlos,Sidyma,P inara,andCadyanda.

    astoccur intheXanthusinscriptions.

    dtheLeaguesilvercataloguedabove;

    s s u e9 , fol l owing ; a nd theKAb ro n eso f

    FortheOrthagorasinscription,seepp.11-12.

    arintheXanthianinscriptionsTAM 307,330,and335.

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    69/322

    remainuncertain.Itsobversestyle

    eaguecoinage.Its fabric,thickand

    is unusuallyplacedtotheright,yet

    allyoncoins ofmintsthroughoutLycia

    olis anddoesnothelpto attributethecoin.

    er,foundelsewhereonlyoncoinsofthe

    uitecorrectasusual,that thereisa

    semanatedfromtwomints,andthatissue

    iscrownsymbolofthe othersouthern

    asdifferentiationenoughbetweenthe

    P reciselythissortofdifferentiation

    heAchaeanL eaguecoinsofMessene

    e.100TheIsiscrown'ssouthernandeastern

    stivebuthardlyconclusive,forthetwo

    thusValleyarealsofoundelsewhere

    Arycandatookcare todistinguish

    n s, u s ingAYorA > in s t ead o f a s im ple AP .1 M

    andyba,ifindeeditstruck issue9,would

    vedistinguisheditselffromCadyanda.

    Candybastruckissue 9,theevidence

    mtowarranttheratherdrastic stepof

    hmsto twoseparatemints.IfCadyanda

    iking wasprobablydoneathome.

    ariancein styleandfabricfromCadyan-

    ndfromtheknowncoinsofXanthus.

    ies

    rebendae,Myra,Olympus,andP haselis.

    Hoard,ANSNNM159(NewYork,1968 ,pp.31-37.

    ,andOlympus;the branchatOlympusandP haselis.

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    70/322

    a ls o i s sue13 .

    L 1971 ,no.5 G 74 7 , 2. 41 (Kemer

    = Kuns ts amm.1 9

    G 4 4 63

    on 1 2 .3a .

    e so n 1580

    ; VonAulock2.83 = S NG4 46 2

    ng ( F eb .21,1961 24 81 , 2. 81 = S N G

    n e 2 3,1924 15 88= Web er7 30 3

    a ls o i s sue11 .

    ratedbecauseofobversestyleand

    dmintinitialsfoundonlyonsome later

    n d 3 .

    aguecities,Tloslay northofXanthus,

    stofthe XanthusRiver.FromTlos'slofty

    tand thecentralLycianmountainsto

    gthe mostimportantLyciancities;

    inscriptionalevidence.108Itisnotable

    as independentofthatofXanthusandthe

    hXanthus.Tlosalsoproducedagreat

    n ag e , i n s i l ve r andb ron e , i nhe r ow n nam e .

    22rev.dies

    a ( s eea lso i s su e 1 9 .

    e, p . 503 ,1

    .

    p . 503 ,2

    G 4 3 81

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    71/322

    g t on 3135

    1 3 6

    ( seea l so i s sue1 4 .

    G 113

    9 1 = ( ? Weber72 88 ,2 .52 , no t i l lu s -

    G 4 3 79

    2 128 ,2 .72

    = CoinsandAn ti u i t i es ( F L

    me r

    ratedbecauseofobversestyle.

    its havingthecurlinghairof issue

    ecauseitshead issmallerthanthose

    sreverseissimilar tothatofthe coin

    rg es t c i t i es ,P a t a ra l aya t t h e mou t ho f t he

    rncoast.P atara'sport,todaysiltedup,

    smentionedrepeatedlyinLivy's account

    Rome.P ataraistheoneLycian city

    besiegedbyMithradatesVI in88b.c,

    o havecapitulatedtoBrutusin42 b.c.

    madeita naturalcenterofLycian

    bothbyseaand bytheimportant

    was,in practicalterms,thegeo-

    deed considersP atarathecapitalof

    m

    M

    C r e a t i v e C o m m o n s A t t r i b u t i o n - N

    o n C o m m e r c i a l - S h a r e A l i k e / h t t p : / / w w w . h

    a t h i t r u s t . o

    r g / a c c e s s

    _ u s e # c c - b

    y - n c - s a - 4 . 0

  • 8/9/2019 The coinage of the Lycian League / by Hyla A. Troxell

    72/322

    doubtfulthattherewasaformalpolitical

    edthatthefederalassemblymetin which-

    sen,however,supportshisstatement

    o f Pa t a r aa s c a p u t ge n t i s ; 1 0 4More t t i

    lyusedinageneralsense,as theLatin

    p o us des igna t i ono f / i t rgdn ohg tov Av -

    ptionsofthe Romanperiodtoseveral