View
586
Download
1
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Citation preview
Confidential Presentation
Project REBIRTH YGHCC Team #13 Cynthia Chan Bernice Qi Tammie Kwong Sisi Wang Joshua Lyons November 10, 2012
Introduction Final Presentation
Introduction
Our goals:
Provide the South African government with a set of innovative, effective, and feasible recommendations for reforming and developing the mining industry
Understand the demands of competing stakeholders, including:
– Government
– Private sector
– Mine employees
– Non-governmental organizations
Client goals:
Appropriately respond to recent crisis in the mining sector
Implement reforms designed to promote long-term business growth
Strive to improve the health, freedom, and economic security of South Africa’s citizens
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Executive Summary Final Presentation
Key Problem Areas
Inadequate protection of human rights
High rates of Disease
Insufficient economic incentives
Weak support for education and research
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Executive Summary Final Presentation
Key Recommendations: REBIRTH
Revitalizing Education & Business, Improving Rights, Targeting Health
1. Research & Development – Bernice Qi
2. Business Policies – Joshua Lyons
3. Human Rights – Cynthia Chan
4. Health Education – Sisi Wang & Tammie Kwong
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Revitalizing Education Business Improving
Rights Targeting
Health
Research & Development Final Presentation
Current Challenges
Low productivity due to:
Lack of innovative techniques for efficient mining
Lack of skilled workers and researchers
Health and safety hazards
Competition with other countries
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Research and Development Final Presentation
Benefits from Improved Research Capacity
Increased productivity
Better technology: discovery of new mines
More skilled practitioners
Expansion of manufacturing sector
Improved strategies to ensure safety and health for mine workers
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Research & Development Final Presentation
Proposed Solution
Increase funding for research and
education in mining
Expand education programs
Undergraduate Postgraduate: research grants
Attract more researchers
Increase research funds and contracts
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Research & Development Final Presentation
Beneficiaries
Research institutions and programs
The Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) Natural Resource and Environment
– CoalTech, PlatMine
Mine Health and Safety Council
The Mining Industry Growth Development and Employment Task Team (MIGDETT)
Educational institutes
University of the Witwatersrand
University of Pretoria
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Revitalizing Education Business Improving
Rights Targeting
Health
Business Policy Final Presentation
Key Areas
Wage growth
Employment growth
Investment growth
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Business Policy Final Presentation
Wage Growth
Policy recommendation:
For each $1 year-on-year increase in average miner wage above the increase in South Africa’s CPI, offer a $0.18 tax credit against mineral royalties per worker employed (restricted to citizens of South Africa)
Effects:
Stimulate wage growth beyond rate of inflation
Flexible and non-disruptive policy to improve wages (alternative to minimum wage)
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Business Policy Final Presentation
Employment Growth
Policy recommendations:
Offer an employee retention credit: $500 for miners each year that have been retained as employees for at least one year (restricted to citizens of South Africa)
Develop the rare earth mineral sector:
– Offer a 5-year waver of royalties on rare earth mineral investment projects that commit to minimum cleanup and human rights standards
– Offer a new hire credit: $500 for new miners hired and retained for at least 3 months
– Offer an employee retention credit: $500 for miners each year that have been retained as employees for at least one year
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Business Policy Final Presentation
Employment Growth
1 Calculated based on a similar hiring credit employed in the U.S. (approximately same value/per capita GDP, yielded 2% employment growth) 2 Extrapolating from the Steenkampskraal project, estimated to create 100 jobs, to additional possible investment projects, and job growth due to processing/export business 3 Based on the turnover rate at AngloGold Ashanti in 2011 4,5 Calculated by multiplying credit value by projected job creation
Effects:
Induce new miner hiring within existing industries (estimated 10,000)1
Create approximately 1,000 to 2,000 new jobs in the rare earth mineral sector2
Promote fair treatment and continued employment of miners by incentivizing longer-term work arrangements (at least one year)
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Business Policy Final Presentation
Investment Growth
Policy recommendations:
Adjust royalty policy to bias towards extraction of locally-refined minerals
– Refined mineral rate: 0.5 + [EBIT / (gross sales of mineral resource x 12.5)] x 100
– Unrefined mineral rate: 0.5 + [EBIT / (gross sales of mineral resource x 9)] x 100
– We suggest changing the divisor multiples from 12.5 and 9 to 13.5 and 7
Adjust royalty collection formula to use EBT as a measure of profitability instead of EBIT
– EBIT artificially raises the measure of profitability and raises the royalty rate for those companies which invest in new production (by ignoring interest payments)
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Business Policy Final Presentation
Investment Growth
Effects:
Increase prevalence of mineral extraction that favors creation of refinement and processing jobs
Improve fairness of royalty collection by eliminating the investment penalty
Encourage investment by including interest payments in profitability calculation
1 South African mineral industry, analyst research 2 Based on proxy measurement for firms in the mining sector, calculated by finding average interest expense, determining impact on average royalty rate
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Revitalizing Education Business Improving
Rights Targeting
Health
Human Rights Policy Final Presentation
Right to Life and Compensation - Current Challenges Introduction R & D Business
Policy Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
1. Right to Life Unsafe working
conditions lower health and productivity, increase in death and injury rate (e.g., 277 mining deaths 2008-2009)
2. Right to Compensation The two main existing
statutes complicate the application process unrreliable
(these challenges frustrated workers violence and strikes)
Human Rights Policy Final Presentation
1. Right to Life
Background Existing Millionaire's Award awards one million fatality-free shifts Exchange rate: 1 USD = 8.7 South African Rand
Goal Increase incentive for longer term workplace safety
Method: Millionaire’s Club (MC) Increasing rewards for consecutive achievements Publicize the members list Award immediate towns $50k for public projects Use saved funds for new team, development, and publicity
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Human Rights Policy Final Presentation
2. Right to Compensation
Background
ODMWA under DOH; COIDA under DOL
Goals
Maximize efficiency and funds
Minimize waste, overhead, overlap
Method: Consolidate
Equalize compensation ranges
Increase employer contribution for funding
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Revitalizing Education Business Improving
Rights Targeting
Health
Health Education Final Presentation
Current Challenges
HIV
• Rates of HIV infection among miners range from 22 to 30%
• Low status of women
• Low levels of condom use
• Low levels of male circumcision
• Multiple sexual relationships
• High mobility and worker migration
• People living with HIV are 20-30 times more likely to develop TB
TB
• Crowded living conditions
• Exposure to silica dust
• Put families at risk
• Lack of access to basic health and social services
• Lack of surveillance and post-employment follow-up
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Health Education Final Presentation
Peer Education Program
Who?
• Motivated sex workers and miners
How many?
• A ratio of 1:20
What approaches?
• ICE Approach: Information, Counselling and Education
What are the impacts?
• Reduce mortality, morbidity and health costs
• Set example for future HIV/TB programs
• Generate research hypothesis and values
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Health Education Final Presentation
3 Pillar Strategy
Peer Information Peer Education Peer Counselling
Target Population Disease-free High-risk Diseased
Objectives Awareness, information, and attitude to change
Self-esteem, behavior-change communication, and prevention skills
Coping skills, psycho-social support, problem-solving, and referral to clinicians for treatment
Confidentiality None Important Essential
Example of activities Material distribution (i.e. Condom)
Repeated structured workshops
Clinic-based counselling
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Health Education Final Presentation
Group Assignment Introduction R & D Business
Policy Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Budget Final Presentation
Budget Introduction R & D Business
Policy Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
2012-2014 2014-2016 2016-2018 2018-2020 2020-2022
Research and Development Research
$1.4 billion
$1.4 billion
$1,4 billion
$1.4 billion
$1.4 billion
Business Policy Employment Policy Investment Policy
$230 million $40 million
$230 million $40 million
$230 million $40 million
$230 million $40 million
$230 million $40 million
Human Rights Millionaire’s Club Mining Project Fund
-
-
-
-
-
Health Education Training & Supplies Screening Incentives & other
$140 million $350 million $3 million
$120 million $275 million $3 million
$90 million $275 million $3 million
$90 million $225 million $3 million
$80 million $200 million $3 million
Total Costs: $2.163 billion $2.068 billion
$2.038 billion
$1.9678 billion
$1.953 billion $10.19 Billion
Limitations Final Presentation
Limitations
Lack of cross-border referral system for foreign mine workers
Financial and time constraints:
Limited capability to address treatment-related issues
Impact of expanded education system not immediately observable
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Conclusion Final Presentation
Conclusion Introduction R & D Business
Policy Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Through Revitalizing Education and Business, Improving Rights, and Targeting Health,
REBIRTH will be able to promote safety, increase accountability, spread healthy practices, promote
economic growth and improve the general condition and caliber of mining.
Thank you! Final Presentation
Thank you! Introduction R & D Business
Policy Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Questions?
Appendix: Table of Contents Final Presentation
Supporting data
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
A: South African Mineral Resource B: Lifetime of Selected Minerals C. Fatality Data on South African Mines D: R & D Expenditures E: Number of Students in Mining F: Facts on Research and Development G: Safety in Mines (1-2) H: Main Contributors of Fatalities I: Mine Health and Safety Council Award ‘00 J: Mine Health and Safety Council Award ‘09 K: Mine Health and Safety Council Award ‘10 L: Mine Safety Achievements M: Compensation N: Demographics of Miners O: TB Financial Burden
P: HIV Financial Burden Q: Condom Use R: Timeline- Pillar 1 Peer Information S: Timeline- Pillar 2 Peer Education T: Timeline- Pillar 3 Peer Counseling U: Impact of HIV V: TB Education Curriculum W: HIV Education Curriculum X: TB-HIB Co-Infection Y: Recruitment Process Z: Incentives AA: Status of Women in South Africa BB: Male Circumcision CC: Silicosis DD: Projected Health Education Program Costs EE: Economic Data FF: Human Rights Policy Timeline GG: References (1-3)
Appendix A: South African Mineral Resource Final Presentation
Supporting data
Major South African mineral resources and production as a percentage of global resources and production. The commodities are ranked by share of global known mineral resource (Chamber of Mines, 2009).
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix B: Lifetime of Selected Minerals Final Presentation
Supporting data
The lifetime of selected South African mineral resources based on 2008 production figures and resource estimates (data from Chamber of Mines, 2009).
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix C: Fatality Data Final Presentation
Supporting data
The recent fatality record on South African mines compared to the 2003 summit target rate. (Vogt el al., 2011)
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix D: R & D Expenditures Final Presentation
Supporting data
Source: World Bank
Parameters South Africa Australia Canada Brazil
Population (million) 48.2 20.5 32.6 19.7 GDP (US$ billion) 255 780 1426 1366 GDP/capita (US$) 10401 31794 33375 10200 R&D spend (US$ billion) 4 11.4 28.1 14 Expenditure on R&D as % of GDP 0.9 1.8 2 1.1 Full-time equivalent (FTE) R&D personnel per million inhabitants 377 4053 3922 696
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix E: Number of Students in Mining Final Presentation
Supporting data
*50-60% can graduate with a degree and out of the graduates, 15% remain in the employ of mining companies as long-term career.
University of the Witwatersrand
University of Pretoria
Undergraduate 360* 210* Coursework Postgraduate
290 17
Research Postgraduate
38 6
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix F: Facts on Research & Development Final Presentation
Supporting data
• Funding from Mine Health and Safety Council: $8 million in 1996 vs $2 million in 2010 • 500 mining engineers currently with an estimated shortage of 15% • Number of students need to be trained = 1.5 X number of engineers required • It requires 15 years to train a student from undergraduate level to reach substantive managerial capacity • Mining researchers: 800 in 1980s versus < 80 now
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix G: Safety in Mines (1) Final Presentation
Supporting data
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix G: Safety in Mines (2) Final Presentation
Supporting data
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix H: Main Contributors of Fatalities Final Presentation
Supporting data
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix I: Mine Health and Safety Council Award ‘00 Final Presentation
Supporting data
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix J: Mine Health and Safety Council Award ‘09 Final Presentation
Supporting data
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix K: Mine Health and Safety Council Award ‘10 Final Presentation
Supporting data
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix L: Mine Safety Achievements Final Presentation
Supporting data
8 Million Fatality Free Shifts: Modikwa Platinum Mine 4 Million Fatality Free Shifts: Impala Platinum 1 Shaft and 7A Shaft 2 Million Fatality Free Shifts: Impala Platinum 12# Mine, Marula Platinum Mine, Karee Platinum Mine, Western Platinum Mine, Grootegeluk Colliery 12 Million FOG Fatality Free Shifts: Rowland Mine 1 Million Fatality Free Shifts: Cullinan Diamond Mine, Assmang Manganese Mine, Doornkop Gold Mine, Barberton Gold Mines, Tao Tona Gold Mine, Blyvooruitzicht Gold Mine, Impale Platinum 7, 16, 17, 20 Shafts, Bafokeng Rasimone Platinum Mine, Bokoni Platinum Mine 12 Thousand Fatality Free Shifts: Tselentis Colliery, Forzando Colliery North 9 Thousand Fatality Free Shifts: Graspan Colliery 8 Thousand Fatality Free Shifts: Sedibeng Diamonds
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix M: Compensation Final Presentation
Supporting data
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix N: Demographics of Miners Final Presentation
Supporting data Introduction R & D Business
Policy Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
To date, most mine workers are in between the ages of 15-48
To date, the average age of sex workers is 25-30 years old
Appendix O: TB Financial Burden Final Presentation
Supporting data
Annual Financial Burden of TB
-Annual cost of the TB epidemic in the South African mining sector $886 million -Annual cost of implementing best- practice interventions $570 million -Annual savings as a result of implementing best-practice interventions $316 million
-Annual productivity increase from implementing interventions $467 million Total annual benefit: $783million
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix P: HIV Financial Burden Final Presentation
Supporting data
Financial Burden (2010 USD)
Total cost (millions) $282
Total annual cost (millions) $14
Mean annual cost per $11,792 HIV-positive employee
Impact of HIV/AIDS on Mining - 20% of coal miners and 30% of gold miners are HIV+ (these prevalence rates are 16% higher than base
population)
- Total productivity loss of 20% - Attacks 25-45 year olds who subsidize benefits of retirees
- Savings used to treat illness, reducing retirement of benefits
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix Q: Condom use Final Presentation
Supporting data
Condom use and relationship characteristics with most recent partner in past 12 months (in 2001) and individual characteristics (in 1999) by sex, Black South African Transitions sample
Condom Use in 2001 Overall Male Female P-value
% Did not use condom at last sex 40.6% 33.6% 47.1% 0.002
Condom Use Consistency
% Always 42.5% 55.1% 30.9%
% Intermittent 34.9% 26.0% 43.2% <0.001
% Never 22.5% 18.9% 25.9% <0.001
% Somewhat/ Not confident in Knowledge of Condom Use
54.7% 36.9% 71.1% <0.001
% Believe Using condoms Means Not Trusting Partner
32.7% 32.2% 33.2% <0.803
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix R: Timeline - Pillar 1 Peer Information Final Presentation
Supporting data
Priority Reform Area
Goals (Year 1-10)
Monitorable Outcomes
Provide awareness, information, and attitude to change
Risk reduction, including condom distribution Identify current high risk populations Develop peer health support groups for both sex workers and miners Train health workers Incorporate annual screening into workplace Reduce stigma and discrimination of people living with and affeced by HIV and key populations
Increased condom-use Formation of disease-free, but at risk clusters Increase detection rate Heightened acceptance of peer health education programs
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix S: Timeline - Pillar 2 Peer Education Final Presentation
Supporting data
Priority Reform Area
Goals (Year 2-8)
Monitorable Outcomes
Provide information on self- esteem, behavior-change communication and prevention skills
Establish supportive environments and promote sense of community within mining communities and sex workers respectively Further reducing vulnerability and expanding choices regarding health Create and maintain a new pool of health educators to ensure sustainability of peer health education program
Greater sense of wellness and connection within community Continued increase in condom use, along with greater awareness to health options Increased participation of local miners and sex workers
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix T: Timeline - Pillar 3 Peer Counseling Final Presentation
Supporting data Introduction Human
Rights Health
Education Business
Policy R & D Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Priority Reform Area
Goals (Year 1-10)
Monitorable Outcomes
Provide coping skills, psycho-social support, problem-solving and referral to clinicians for treatment
Identify diseased individuals and reduce personal stigma on illness Alleviate anxiety and stress associated with Educate early stages of TB and HIV cases with treatment options Refer all TB and HIV cases to NGO's for treatment
Higher rates of treatment of HIV and awareness of health options Lower rates of MDR-TB with effective primary intervention
Appendix U: Impact of HIV Final Presentation
Supporting data Introduction Human
Rights Health
Education Business
Policy R & D Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix V: TB Education Curriculum Final Presentation
Supporting data
Part 1 - Identifying what TB, symptoms, and treatment plans - Transmission of TB - Prevention of TB Transmission - STIs and TB, specifically relationship between HIV+ and TB - How to assess personal risk and formulate behavior change plans; Part 2 - TB testing facilities and processes - The rights of infected and affected employees (including rights to confidentiality) - How to treat a co-worker with TB - Treatment, care and support for infected employees - Infection control in the workplace Part 3 - TB, as part of broad-based wellness programs - The workplace TB policy and current programs - Non-discrimination and equality (in terms of benefits etc) - Referral sources and services
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix W: HIV Education Curriculum Final Presentation
Supporting data
Part 1 - Transmission of HIV - Prevention of HIV Transmission - STIs and TB - How to assess personal risk and formulate behavior change plans; - Safer sex and condom use Part 2 - HIV testing facilities and processes - The rights of infected and affected employees (including rights to confidentiality) - How to treat a co-worker with HIV/AIDS - Treatment, care and support for infected employees - Infection control in the workplace Part 3 - HIV/AIDS, as part of broad-based wellness programes - The workplace HIV/AIDS policy and current programes - Non-discrimination and equality (in terms of benefits etc) - Referral sources and services
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix X: TB- HIV Co-Infection Final Presentation
Supporting data
Most cases of TB in HIV-Positive patients are not caused by drug-resistant strain of TB (this means that early detection and prompt treatment with 'first line' antibiotics)
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix Y: Recruitment Process Final Presentation
Supporting data
• Identify selection criteria
o Educational background, experience, commitment, communication skill, willingness to learn, leadership qualities
• Pre-selection workshop
o Provide general information about programme, information on training process, roles and responsibilities, and time commitment required
• Written contracts
o With statement on minimum time commitment, roles and responsibilities
o Sign by staff of NGOs, peer educators, and workplace manager
• Establish feedback mechanism
• Determine incentives
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix Z: Incentives Final Presentation
Supporting data
Professional incentives: locally-agreed accreditation system, with opportunities for increasing involvement and responsibility offered
-e.g. peer educators can develop to become peer trainers
Social incentives: friendship and team building -e.g. provision of social and recreational opportunities; linkages
established with other similar organizations for experience exchange (and travel) opportunities.
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix AA: The Status of Women in South Africa Final Presentation
Supporting data
Predicted Probability of not using a condom at last sex by gender confidence in condom use knowledge
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix BB: Male Circumcision Final Presentation
Supporting data
http://www.malecircumcision.org/programs/documents/South_Africa11209.pdf
44.7% of adult males are circumcised, with significant regional variation
Scaling up male circumcision to reach 80% can:
Avert more than 1.2 million adult HIV infections 16 years
Yield total net savings of $6.5 billion in 16 years
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix CC: Silicosis Final Presentation
Supporting data
The prevalence ranges from 31% in Botswana, 24 to 36% in the Transkei, and 24% in laid-off, older, longer-service Basotho men.
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix DD: Projected Program Costs Final Presentation
Supporting data
2012-2014 2014-2016 2016-2018 2018-2020 2020-2022
Training Costs $60 million $40 million $20 million $20 million $20 million
Materials Safe Sex Supplies
$80 million $80 million $70 million $70 million $60 million
Incentives* $1 million $1 million $1 million $1 million $1 million
Screening HIV TB
$150 million $200 million
$125 million $150 million
$125 million $150 million
$100 million $125 million
$100 million $100 million
Misc $2 million $2 million $2 million $2 million $2 million
Total Costs: $493 million $398 million $368 million $318 million $283 million $1.86 Billion
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix EE: Economic Data Final Presentation
Supporting data
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix EE: Economic Data Final Presentation
Supporting data
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix FF: Human Rights Policy Final Presentation
Timeline
Sho
rt te
rm: Y
1-2 Action Plan
• Amend MA policy, publicize MC [$275k]
Indicators • # of mines and
mining towns expressing interest (90%)
Med
ium
term
: Y3-
5 Indicators • 25 (1), 10 (1+)
Long
term
: Y6-
10
Indicators • 30 (1), 15 (1+)
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix GG– References Final Presentation
References
South African National AIDS Council. (April 2011). South Africa: HIV Epidemic, Response and Policy Synthesis http://www.hst.org.za/sites/default/files/South%20Africa%20national%20synthesis%20report%20rev1%20with%20covers.pdf Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS). (June 2012) A people-centered investment tool towards ending AIDS. Geneva Switzerland. http://www.unaids.org/en/media/unaids/contentassets/documents/unaidspublication/2012/JC2359_investing-for-results_en.pdf Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS). (2012). Meeting the Investments Challenge- Tipping the Dependency Balance. Geneva Switzerland http://www.unaids.org/en/media/unaids/contentassets/documents/epidemiology/2012/20120718_investmentchallengesupplement_en.pdf 18Twenty8. (June 2009). The Status of Women in South Africa. http://www.18twenty8.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=67&Itemid=71 Burgard, S. & Kusunoki Y. (July 2009). Gender and Condom Use among Black South African Young People http://www.psc.isr.umich.edu/pubs/pdf/rr09-683.pdf International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies. (2009) Standards for HIV peer education programmes. Geneva Switzerland http://www.ifrc.org/Global/Publications/Health/hiv_peer_education-en.pdf International Finance Corporation- World Bank Group (2004). HIV/AIDS Guide for the Mining Sector- A resource for developing stakeholder competency and compliance in mining communities in Southern Africa http://www-wds.worldbank.org/external/default/WDSContentServer/WDSP/IB/2005/02/03/000090341_20050203151830/Rendered/PDF/313740hiv0aids0mining0toolkit.pdf Courtwright, A. (2010). Tuberculosis and Stigmatization: Pathways and Interventions. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2882973/ USAID (September 2009). The Potential Cost and Impact of Expanding Male Circumcision in South Africa. http://www.malecircumcision.org/programs/documents/South_Africa11209.pdf The World Bank. (June 2010) AIDS & Mining. http://web.worldbank.org/WBSITE/EXTERNAL/TOPICS/EXTOGMC/0,,contentMDK:20220933~menuPK:509392~pagePK:148956~piPK:216618~theSitePK:336930~isCURL:Y,00.html Myer-Rath, G., J. Pienaar, B. Brink, and A. van Zyi. (July 2012) Company-level ART provision to employees is cost saving: a modelled cost-benefit analysis of the impact of HIV and antiretroviral treatment in a mining workforce in South Africa. United Kingdom http://pag.aids2012.org/abstracts.aspx?aid=16160
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix
Appendix GG– References (Page 2) Final Presentation
Stop TB Partnership. A Challenge to a Key Southern African Economic Sector. http://www.stoptb.org/assets/documents/news/TBMining2.pdf Stop TB Partnership. (2009) South Africa Country Profile http://www.stoptb.org/assets/documents/about/cb/meetings/17/2.09-12%20South%20Africa/2.09-12.2%20South%20Africa%20WHO%20Country%20Profile%202009.pdf Vogt, D., Durrheim, R., McGill, J. (2011) State Intervention in the Mining Industry. CSIR. Kaplan, D. (2011) South African mining equipment and related services: Growth, constraints and policy. University of Cape Town. Stacey, T.R., Hadjigeorgiou, J., Potvin, Y. (2009) Technical skills—a major strategic issue. Journal of the South African Institute of Mining and Metallurgy. The World Bank http://data.worldbank.org The Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) website http://www.csir.co.za Chamber of Mines of South Africa http://www.bullion.org.za/content/?pagename=About&pid=122 Mine Health and Safety Council website http://www.mhsc.org.za South African Regional Poverty Network. (2011) Coventry Poverty Papers http://www.sarpn.org/CountryPovertyPapers/SouthAfrica/taylor/report11.pdf Millionaire’s Award: http://www.dmr.gov.za/mine-health-a-safety/mhsc-award-scheme.html COIDA and ODMWA: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1995466, http://www.anglogold.com/subwebs/informationforinvestors/reporttosociety06/worker-compensation.htm MHSC Summit OHS Action Plan. ( 2011) Mine Health & Safety Council “Zero Harm Through Action” http://option1.mhsc.co.za/images/stories/pledges/OHS-Action-Plan1.pdf Authorities: Mine Health and Safety Act created the Mine Health and Safety Council and the Mine Health and Safety Inspectorate
Introduction R & D Business Policy
Human Rights
Health Education
Timeline & Budget Conclusion Appendix