48
Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social- Communicative Competencies of Students with Autism Mike Miklos Pennsylvania Training and Technical Support Network April 2014

Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network

Systematic School-Based Instruction

of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-

Communicative Competencies of

Students with Autism

Mike Miklos

Pennsylvania Training and

Technical Support Network

April 2014

Page 2: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Overview of PaTTAN’s Autism Initiative

efforts…

A collaborative effort to expand and provide effective science/evidenced based practices for students with autism in the PA public education/special education system.

Participants:

– Local school agencies and Intermediate Units as direct service providers

– Intermediate Units and Technical Assistance Consultants as partners in delivery of technical and training support

– PaTTAN Autism Initiative

– Parents as partners

• All sites volunteer to participate

• All examples are derived from a Behavioral Practice model (this is not a research presentation.)

• ABAI ED Conference Prezi

Page 3: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Students Eligible for Special Education under

Definition of Autism

4981,317 1,593 1,881 2,281

2,7983,296

4,0394,821

5,889

7,178

8,616

10,315

12,323

14,401

16,705

18,879

21,083

23,405

25,177

0

5000

10000

15000

20000

25000

30000

Growth in Autism by Year as Reported on the PDE December 1 Annual Child Count Ages 3-21

Page 4: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Some Meta-Analyses Supporting the Role

of Behavior Analysis

• National Autism Center Standards Report

• Missouri: ASD Guide to Evidence-based Interventions

• Maine: Interventions for Autism Spectrum Disorders: State of

the Evidence

• North Carolina: Evidence-Based Practices for Children, Youth

and Young Adults with ASD

• New York: Report of the Recommendations - Autism /

Pervasive Developmental Disorders; Assessment and

Intervention for Young Children (Age 0-3 Years)

• National Research Council: Educating Children with Autism

Page 5: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Autism and Effective Interventions

• Educational interventions should be chosen

from sound empirical evidence.

• The meta-analysis reviewing autism

interventions suggest the power of a

behavioral conceptual model in driving

effective interventions.

• This pattern of findings suggests that

treatments from the behavioral literature have

the strongest research support at this time

Page 6: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

An Analysis of Verbal Behavior

• Behavioral Interventions are the most

effective conceptual basis for addressing needs

of individuals with ASD

• Key area of deficit in ASD Populations: social

communicative functioning

• A behavioral model for addressing social

communicative needs is likely necessary

Page 7: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Autism Interventions, ABA and Education

• Need for quality services and highly skilled

teachers

• Need for services that address core deficits of

autism (including social-communicative

competencies)

• Need for evidence-based treatment

• Need for services to address a range of

student needs across both general education

and more restricted settings

Page 8: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Data Systems

Assessments VB-MAPP

Program/ Target

Selection

Teaching Procedures

Staff Training/ Treatment Fidelity

Materials Organization

Program Components Fit Together

Page 9: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Verbal Behavior and Instruction

• The primary verbal operants as a starting

point (mand, tact, echoic, intraverbal and

related skills of listener responding, imitation,

match to sample)

• Primary verbal operants taught through

processes including: – Mand training

– Discrete trial instruction

– Natural Environment Training

Page 10: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Characteristics of training primary verbal

operants in IT sessions

• Program and target selection (assessment: VB-MAPP)

• Materials organization

• Intersperse target and maintenance trials

• Teach target through errorless procedures

• Clear error correction procedures

• Pace of instruction

• Attend to instructional control (MO, Schedule of

Reinforcement)

• Video Natalie and Candice

• Scheduling instruction

• Classroom organization video

Page 11: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Mand Training

• Addresses many of the core deficits of autism

– Social initiation

– Communication guided by motivation

– With discrimination training leads to flexible

responding

– Video of mand training

• Mand sequences

– Items, activities, missing items, information, mands

in academic instruction, conversational manding

Page 12: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Instruction in the primary verbal

operants is insufficient to establish

complex verbal repertoires

Page 13: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

A note about something commonly

misunderstood about behavior analysis

1. Complex behaviors emitted by competent

humans are rarely shaped bit by bit

2. Most human behavior is not directly shaped

3. Complex behaviors, however, arise from

other response classes that have been shaped

bit by bit

4. Palmer calls the building blocks of complex

behavior “atomic repertoires”

Page 14: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Verbal Atomic Repertoires

• Most of the things we say, we have never said

before

• Most spoken language is the result of having

acquired atomic verbal skills

• Verbal atomic allow repertoires so that

children learn to speak flexibly and

appropriately

Page 15: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Example One

Activity

Page 16: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Example two

• Activity

Page 17: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Some Atomic repertoires

• Imitation (doing what someone else does)

• Echoic (repeating words said to you)

• Tacts (saying the name of things)

• Textual behavior (reading words)

• Transcriptive behavior (copying a text)

Page 18: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

How to teach to build complexity

• Teach concepts

– What is a concept? An extended tact

– Multiple exemplars and critical features

• Teach recombination and novel responding

– How you arrange and populate skill tracking sheets is

critical (tacts of actions examples)

– Natural environment teaching

• Directly teach complex skills

– Use of joint control procedures

Page 19: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Target

Date

introduced

Date

Mastered

1

Rolling (Pencil)

2

Rolling (Ball)

3

Rolling (Marker)

4

Rolling (Bottle)

5

Rolling (Glue)

6

Tapping (Pencil)

7

Tapping (Ball)

8

Tapping (Marker)

9

Tapping (Bottle)

10

Tapping (Glue)

11

Spinning (Pencil)

12

Spinning (Ball)

13

Spinning (Marker)

14

Spinning (Bottle)

15

Spinning (Glue)

16

Coloring (Ball)

17

Coloring (Tree)

18

Coloring (Flower)

19

Coloring (Circle)

20

Coloring (Car)

Skill Tracking Sheet

Student Name: _________________ Skill: Tact of Ongoing

Actions

Page 20: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Target

Date

introduced

Date Mastered

1 Rolling Pencil

2 Rolling Ball

3 Rolling Marker

4 Rolling Bottle

5 Rolling Glue

6 Tapping Pencil

7 Tapping Ball

8 Tapping Marker

9 Tapping Bottle

10 Tapping Glue

11 Spinning Pencil

12 Spinning Ball

13 Spinning Marker

14 Spinning Bottle

15 Spinning Glue

16 Coloring Ball

17 Coloring Tree

18 Coloring Flower

19 Coloring Circle

20 Coloring Car

Skill Tracking Sheet Student Name: _________________ Skill: Tact of Verb-Noun Combinations

Page 21: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Target

Date

Introduced

Date

Mastered

1 Pencil: Eraser 2 Point 3 Car: Wheels 4 Wipers 5 Headlights 6 Door 7 Seatbelt 8 Seat 9 Window

10 Trunk 11 Steering wheel 12 Bus: Yellow 13 Wheels 14 Door 15 Windows 16 Stop sign 17 Headlights 18 Wipers 19 Seat 20 Steps 21 Steering wheel 22 Shirt: Sleeves 23 Collar 24 Buttons 25 Tag 26 Pants: Legs 27 Zipper 28 Snap 29 Button 30 Pockets 31 Tag

Page 22: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Target

Date introduced Date Mastered

1 Tell me an animal: Cat

2 Dog

3 Horse

4 Pig

5 Cow

6 Elephant

7 Lion

8 Zebra

9 Sheep

10 Monkey

11 Tell me a food: Pizza

12 Hamburger

13 Hotdog

14 Sandwich

15 Spaghetti

16 Soup

17 Rice

18 Chicken

19 French Fries

20 Eggs

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

29

30

31

32

33

34

35

36

37

38

39

40

Target

Date introduced Date Mastered

1 A cat is a type of: Animal

2 A dog is a type of: Animal

3 A horse is a type of: Animal

4 A pig is a type of: Animal

5 A cow is a type of: Animal

6 A elephant is a type of: Animal

7 A lion is a type of: Animal

8 A zebra is a type of: Animal

9 A sheep is a type of: Animal

10 A monkey is a type of: Animal

11 A pizza is a type of: Food

12 A hamburger is a type of: Food

13 A hot dog is a type of: Food

14 A sandwich is a type of: Food

15 Spaghetti is a type of: Food

16 Soup is a type of: Food

17 Rice is a type of: Food

18 Chicken is a type of: Food

19 French fries are a type of: Food

20 Eggs are a type of: Food

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

29

30

31

32

33

34

35

36

37

38

39

40

Skills Tracking Sheet:

Student Name:_____________ Skill: Tact of Class/Tact of Item by Class

Page 23: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Joint Control

• Joint Control is when several verbal operants

control a response

• Joint control can involve:

– “Talking to oneself” (emitting a “self-echoic” or “tacting”

to oneself)

– Responding that is not unmediated, rather the result of a

conditional discrimination based on an intervening verbal

response

Page 24: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Joint Control

• Usually works by:

– First echoing something that was said, then using

the echoic while tacting/or emitting an intraverbal

as part of a selection response; as the selection is

made an “aha” comment or prosody change is

usually emitted (autoclitic or verbal behavior

about verbal behavior)

Page 25: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Joint Control

• “It is thus a perfectly behavioral instantiation of the

relation between thought and language” (Lowenkron,

1998)

• Video Example of Yes/No tacts or Multiple LR Discrimination

Page 26: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Teacher Says:

Is this a pencil?

Rehearsal: “pencil,

pencil, pencil…”

(covert self-echoic)

(presence

of joint

control)

Teacher Says:

Is this a drum?

Rehearsal: “drum,

drum, drum…”

(covert self-echoic)

“pencil”

(tact)

“YES”

“NO”

CONCEPTUAL ANALYSIS YES/NO TACTS

“pencil”

(covert echoic)

“drum”

(covert echoic)

(descriptive

autoclitic)

(descriptive

autoclitic)

(absence

of joint

control)

Page 27: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

To establish effective instruction of

verbal behavior and other skills:

Training, Consultation and Feedback are

necessary

Page 28: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

• Competency based

• Modeling; role-playing; and performance

feedback demo

• High rates of responding (Choral responses;

guided notes) demo

• Tied directly to practice requirements

Pre-Implementation Training within PATTAN Autism

Initiative ABA Supports

Page 29: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

PaTTAN Autism Initiative

ABA Intensive Training Individual Participant Competency Checklist

Task Criteria Score

1. Tacts verbal Operants

20/minute in a 1-minute timing

Pass No Pass

Check Criteria

Record Correct/ Incorrect below 1 2 3

4 5 6

7 8 9

2. States Errorless protocol Less than 3 second latency/No errors Pass No Pass

3. Demonstrates Errorless protocol Less than 4 second latency/No errors

across all 4 steps Pass No Pass

4. States Error Correction protocol Less than 3 second latency/No errors

Pass No Pass

5. Demonstrates Error correction

protocol

Less than 4 second latency/No errors

across all 5 steps Pass No Pass

Conceptual Competency Scores

Written

Pretest ______ % correct

Posttest

______ % correct

Filled in textual responses sheet

Y N

Oral (posttest only)

Posttest

______ % correct

Responded consistently with

choral/individual responses

Y N

Check all that apply:

Classroom Teacher

Internal Coach

Itinerate Teacher

Speech and Language Pathologist Occupational

Therapist

Behavior Analyst

Administrator

Guidance Counselor

Para-Educator (includes SEA, PCA, etc.

Other (specify):_____________________

Participant Name: ____________________________

Training Dates: ______________________________

Job Title: ___________________________________

School/Site Location: _________________________

Employer: __________________________________

Page 30: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

6. Program/data:

Completes skill tracking

sheet based on sample of

cold probe data

Within 5 minutes with 3-4 items listed on

skill tracking sheet Pass No

Pass

7. Program Data: takes

cold probe data and

scores, records and

graphs appropriately

across three hypothetical

days data

Accurately scores 5 cold probe examples

demonstrated by confederates, enters data

correctly on data sheet, notes mastery where

appropriate, graphs accordingly and

completes new probe sheet

Pass No

Pass

8. Demonstrates Mand

transfer trials

States within trial transfer Pass No

Pass Demonstrates within trial transfer

States Second trial transfer

Demonstrates second trial transfer

9. Demonstrates error

correction procedures

and scroll for mand

States Error correction Pass No

Pass

Demonstrates error correction

10. Sets up and Labels a

card sort piles

organization and correct

ratio of presentation

Sets up and labels 4 piles

Pass No

Pass

States ratio presentation for

targets vs. easies

States teaching procedures for

each

States data system where each is

found

11. Demonstrates 4 run-

throughs of intensive

teaching

Minimum of 20 trials with one errorless

trial/ maintain 80/20 mix/ pace of at least 10

trials per minute

Pass No

Pass

Oral Competency Check Out (Score + or - )

1. Reinforcement

Score /8

2. Positive Reinforcement

3. Negative Reinforcement

4. Punishment

5. Discriminative Stimulus Percentage Score for Oral Competency (8

questions)

7 = 88% 6 = 75% 5 = 63% 4 = 50% 3 = 38%

2= 25% 1= 13 %

6. Motivative Operation

7. Extinction

8. VR

IT Transcription:

Page 31: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

PaTTAN Autism Initiative

Intermediate and Advanced Verbal Programs for Students with Autism

Individual Participant Competency Checklist

Participant Name: ____________________________

Training Dates: ______________________________

Job Title: ___________________________________

School/Site Location: _________________________

Employer: __________________________________

Conceptual Competency Scores

Written

Pretest ______ % correct Posttest ______ % correct

Filled in textual responses sheet Y N

Oral (posttest only) Posttest ______ % correct Responded consistently with choral/individual

responses Y N

Task Criteria Score

1 Errorless Teaching of Tacting

Actions

States steps in errorless teaching of tacting actions

Demonstrates an errorless teaching of action

while keeping tact of item strong.

2 Error Correction of Tacting

Actions

States steps for correcting tacts of action that do

not involve discrimination

Demonstrates error correction without

discrimination

States steps for correcting tacts of action that

involve discrimination

Demonstrates error correction with discrimination

Page 32: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

3 Errorless teaching 2 component

(noun/verb) tacts

States steps in teaching noun-verb tacts Pass No Pass

Demonstrates an errorless teaching trial

sequence for two component tact of

object/action.

Pass No Pass

4 Error correction: Noun-Verb Tact States steps in correcting noun-verb tacts Pass No Pass

Demonstrates an error correction trial of

object/action.

Pass No Pass

5 Errorless teaching of tact of

parts/features

States steps in teaching tacts of parts and

features

Pass No Pass

Demonstrates an errorless teaching of parts and

features while keeping tact of item strong.

Pass No Pass

6 Error correction with contrast for

tact of item/tact of feature

States contrast Error correction procedure for

tact of part/feature

Pass No Pass

Demonstrates contrast Error correction

procedure for tact of part/feature

Pass No Pass

7 Errorless teaching tact of

adjectives

States steps in teaching tacts of adjectives Pass No Pass

Demonstrates an errorless teaching of adjectives

while keeping tact of item strong.

Pass No Pass

8 Errorless teaching tact of

prepositions

States steps in teaching tacts of prepositions Pass No Pass

Demonstrates an errorless teaching of

prepositions while keeping tact of item strong.

Pass No Pass

Oral Competency Check Out (Score + or - )

1. Tact

Score /5

2. Multiple Control

3. Verbal Conditional Discrimination

4. Joint control

5. Concept

Page 33: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Teachers of Students with Autism Benefit from

Effective Consultation

• Consultation provides ongoing support and allows

transparency

• Provides systematic feedback

• Consultation guided by Site Review

• Effective consultation focuses on:

– instructional behavior

– teacher responsiveness to data systems

– analysis of the many variables that can affect student

outcomes

– Motivating teachers and staff

• It helps teachers be aware of when to make changes

Page 34: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Treatment Fidelity

• Instruction, reinforcement systems, and positive

behavior supports programs require staff training

and consistent implementation

• Treatment integrity is critical to successful autism

support programs

• Examples of treatment integrity methods:

– Checklists

– Inter-observer agreement regarding instructional delivery

– Transcription of instructional sessions

– Event recording

Page 35: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Staff Training and Support

• Teaching defined in set procedures (“manualized”)

• Competency based: Results in staff knowing what to do and

demonstrating how to do it.

• Should be efficient (take little time to deliver to produce clear

outcomes that change in staff behavior for the better)

• Effective staff training involves:

– Promoting conceptual understanding

– Clear procedural descriptions/instructions

– Modeling

– Hands-on practice

– Feedback (immediate as well as ongoing…role of treatment fidelity checklists)

• Next slide shows example of competency based training outcomes: PATTAN AI

ABA Supports Intensive Skill Trainings Competency Based Training.

Page 36: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Sample Fidelity Checklist

Intensive Teaching Treatment Fidelity Checklist:

Date: ________ Staff:______________________ Observer:_________________________

YES NO N/A 1. Was instructional area neat and sanitized? 2. Did instructor have all materials needed for instruction organized and ready? 3. Did instructor have a variety of valuable reinforcers available? 4. Did session begin with delivery of reinforcement or an opportunity to mand? 5. Did instructor gradually fade in the demands/tasks presented? 6. Did instructor use fast-paced instruction (no more than 2 seconds between student’s

response and your next instruction)?

7. Did instructor mix and vary instructional demands (no more than 3 of the same

operant/task in a row)?

8. Were easy and difficult tasks interspersed at the appropriate ratio?

9. Easy/hard ratio: ________

10. Did instructor use a natural tone of voice? 11. Did instructor reinforce at set VR schedule?

12. VR:______

13. Did instructor use 0 second delay prompts for teaching targets? 14. Did instructor re-present the instruction followed by a 0 second delay prompt when

errors occurred?

15. Did instructor prompt student if no response occurred within 2 seconds for a previously

mastered item?

16. Were prompted trials followed by a transfer trial, easy trial(s), and a check trial? 17. Did instructor differentially reinforce (better reinforcement) target responses? 18. Did instructor differentially reinforce (better reinforcement) quicker and more

independent responding?

19. If problem behavior occurred, did instructor not remove the demand and follow

through by keeping the demand on?

20. Did instructor deliver less reinforcement following run through’s that required

extinction (keeping demand on)?

_____20=

_____%

Page 37: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

trial Transcription of demands/

Responses

Number of

demands

Timing of

trial Feedback

1. (T-p Ttt) I R T√ SR+ 4 12” Remember to repeat your SD

following the error and before

you prompt.

Great job remembering your

transfer trial and check trial!

2. E R T R SR+ 4 8” Nice run through of easy and

quick responses. Also great

example of mixing of the

different operants

3. (Rp Rtt) I R R√ SR+ 4 15” Perfect example of errorless

teaching! Nice job Jeanne

4. T I I (T-p Ttt) R R (T-p Ttt) R T√

SR+

9 22” Need to repeat SD before

prompting. Watch the number

of demands. This run through

would have been better sprit up

by reinforcing Andrew a little

on the first transfer trial and

completing the check on the

next run through. You may

have been able to prevent the

second error due to motivation

to respond remaining higher

with denser reinforcement. His

VR is a 3.

Example of Written Feedback from Transcription

Page 38: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

Boot Camp No Boot Camp

50.9

28.4

Mean Initial Site Review Score

2011-2012 (N=56 Classes)

Page 39: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

Boot Camp No Boot Camp

81.8

61.5

Mean Post Site Review Scores

2011-2012

Page 40: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

Schedule Mand Training Intensive Teaching

59.5

54.8 54.6

16.7

5.5

17.5

Boot Camp

No Boot Camp

Mean Initial Site Review Score in 3

Content Areas Covered 2011-2012

Page 41: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Summary Slide

• Harrisburg Case Study Video

• Thank you!

Page 42: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Resources

• PATTAN Autism Initiative Resource File

– http://webapps.pattan.net/files/PaTTANAutismResour

ces.zip

• PATTAN Website: Video resources

– http://www.pattan.net/Videos/Browse/?topic=3

Or go to Pattan.net; click on videos; then click under

“by topics” in the column on the left the title “Autism”

Page 43: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Selected References

• Adams, G. L., Tallon, R. J., & Rimmel, P. (1980). A comparison of lecture versus role-playing in the training of the use of positive reinforcement. Journal of Organizational Behavior Management, 2, 205-212.

• Alessi, G. (1987). Generative strategies and teaching for generalization. The Analysis of Verbal Behavior: 5, 15–27.

• *Azrin, N. H., Jamner, J. P., & Besalel, V. A. (1989). Student learning as the basis for reinforcement to the instructor. Behavioral Residential Treatment, 4, 159-170.

• Causin, K., Albert, K., Carbone, V. J., &Sweeney-Kerwin, E. (2012) The Role of Joint Control In Teacing Complex Listener Behavior to Children with Autism. Presentation at 33rd Annual Conference of the Berkshire Association for Behavior Analysis

• Carbone, V. (2003). Workshop Series: Teacher Repertoires Necessary to Teach Language and Basic Learner Skills to Children with Autism; Four Important Lines of Research in Teaching Children with Autism.

• Carbone, V. (2004). Invited Address: Clinical Applications of Verbal Behavior Research with Children with Autism. Presentation at the 30th Annual Convention of the Association of Behavior Analysts: Boston, MA

• Carbone, V.J., Morgenstern, B., Zacchin-Terri, G., & Kolberg, L. (2007). The role of the reflexive conditioned motivating operation (CMO-R) during discrete trial instruction of children with autism. Journal of Early Intensive Behavioral Interventions, 4, 658-679.

• Carbone, V. J. (2015) Selected Topics in Behavior Analysis and Teaching Children with Autism. Training Workshop: Harrisburg, PA.

Page 44: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Selected References

• Codding, R. S., Feinberg, A.B., Dunn, E.K., & Pace, G. M. (2005). Effects of immediate performance

feedback on implementation of behavior support plans. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 38, 205-219.

• Cooper, Heron, and Heward. (2007). Applied Behavior Analysis, 2cd Edition, Prentice Hall: Upper

Saddle River, NJ

• Dipuglia, A and Miklos, M. (2014). Instructing Functional Verbal Behavior in Public Schools: Recent

Outcomes from the PATTAN Autism Initiative. Symposium presented at the 40th Annual Convention

of the Association for Behavior Analysis, Chicago, Il

• Donahoe, J. W., & Palmer, D. C. (2004). Learning and complex behavior. Richmond, MA: Ledgetop

Publishing (Originally published in 1994)

• Durcharme, J. M., & Feldman, M. A. (1992). Comparison of staff training strategies to promote

generalized teaching skills. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 25, 165-179.

• Engleman, S. & Carnine, D.W. (1982) Theory of Instruction: Principles and Applications. New York:

Irvinston

• Fleming, R. K., Oliver, J. R., & Bolton, D. M. (1996). Training supervisors to train staff: A case study in a

human service organization. Journal of Organizational Behavior management, 16, 3-25.

• Ford, J. E. (1984). A comparison of three feedback procedures for improving teaching skills. Journal of

Organizational Behavior Management, 6, 65-77.

• Greenwood, C. R., Delquadri, J. C., & Hall, R. V. (1984). Opportunity to respond and student academic

achievement. In W. L. Heward, T. E. Heron, D. S. Hill, & J. Trap-Porter (Eds.), Focus on behavior

analysis in education (pp. 58-88). Columbus, OH: Merrill.

Page 45: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Selected References

• Jones, F. H., & Eimers, R. C. (1975). Role playing to train elementary teachers to use a

classroom management skill package." Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis,8, 421-433.

• Keller, F. (1968). "Goodbye teacher..." Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 1, 79-89

• Krumhus, K. M., & Malott, R. W. (1980). The effects of modeling and immediate and delayed

feedback in staff training. Journal of Organizational Behavior Management, 2, 279-293.

• Luiselli, J.K., Russo, D.C., Christian, W.P., Wilczynski, S.M. (2008). Effective Practices for

Children with Autism. Oxford University Press, Inc., NY

• Layng, T.V. J. (2012) Analyzing and Teaching Concepts to Higher Functioning Children.

Conference presentation: 2012 National Autism Conference, State College, PA

• Maine Department of Health and Human Services and Maine Department of Education.

(2009). Interventions for Autism Spectrum Disorders: State of the Evidence. Report of the

Children’s Services Evidence-Based Practice Advisory Committee

• Michael, J. (1988). Establishing operations and the mand. The Analysis of Verbal Behavior, 6, 3-

9.

• Michael, J., Palmer, D. C., & Sundberg, M. L. (2011). The multiple control of verbal behavior.

The Analysis of Verbal Behavior, 27, 3-22.

Page 46: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Selected References

• Miklos, M. & Dipuglia, A. (2009) Mand training within the Pennsylvania Verbal Behavior Project: a training manual. Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network: Harrisburg, PA.

• Miklos, M., Dipuglia, A., & Galbraith, W. A. (2010, May). Changes in student performance: Case studies in verbal behavior within a large-scale public school project. Symposium presented at the 36th Annual Convention of the Association for Behavior Analysis, San Antonio, TX.

• Missouri Autism Guidelines Initiative (2012.) Autism Spectrum Disorders: A guide to evidence based interventions. Missouri Foundation for Health: St. Louis and Springfiled, MO.

• National Autism Center (2009). National Standards Project, Findings, and Conclusions, Addressing the need for evidence-based practice guidelines for autism spectrum disorders. National Autism Center: Randolph, MA

• National Research Council (2001). Educating Children with Autism. National Academy Press: Washington, DC

• Neef, N. A., Walters, J., & Egel, A. L. (1984). Establishing generative yes/no responses in developmentally disabled children. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 17, 453-460.

• O’Hanlon, J. and Mortensen, L. 1980. “Making Teacher Evaluation work.” Journal of Higher Education, 51, 664-72

• Palmer 2012 The role of atomic repertoires in complex behavior. The Behavior Analyst, Spring; 35(1): 59–73

• Partington, J.W. & Sundberg, M.L . (1998). The assessment of basic language and learning skills. Behavior Analysts, Inc., California

• Pennsylvania Department of Education (2012). Annual child count data: 1993-2013. Harrisburg, PA: DOE.

Page 47: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Selected References

• Sautter, R. A. , & LeBlanc, L. A. ( 2006.) Empirical applications of Skinner’s analysis of verbal behavior with humans. The Analysis of Verbal Behavior: 22, 35-48.

• Skinner, B.F. (1957). Verbal Behavior. New York: Appleton-Century.

• Sundberg, M. L. (2005). A behavioral analysis of motivation and its relation to mand training. In L. W. Williams (Ed.). Development disabilities: Etiology, assessment and intervention.

• Sundberg, M. L., & Michael, J. (2001). The Benefits of Skinner’s analysis of verbal behavior for teaching children with autism. Behavior Modification, 25, 698-724.

• Sundberg M.L. (2008)The verbal behavior milestones assessment and placement program: The VB-MAPP. Concord, CA: AVB Press.

• Sundberg, M. L., & Sundberg, C. A. (2011). Intraverbal behavior and verbal conditional discriminations in typically developing children and children with autism. The Analysis of Verbal Behavior: 27, 23–43.

• Tu, J. C. (2006). The role of joint control in the manded selection responses of both vocal and non-vocal children with autism. The Analysis of Verbal Behavior, 22, 191-207.

• Wolery, M., Bailey, D. B., & Sugai, G. M. (1988). Effective teaching: Principles of applied behavior analysis with exceptional students. Boston: Allyn & Bacon

• Wong, C., Odom, S. L., Hume, K., Cox, A. W., Fettig, A., Kucharczyk, S., Brock, M. E., Plavnik, J. B., Fluery, V. P., & Schultz, T. R. (2014). Evidence based Practices for Children, Youth, and Young Adults with Autism Spectrum Disorders. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Frank Porter Graham Child Development Center.

Page 48: Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal …...Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Systematic School-Based Instruction of Verbal Behavior to Increase Social-Communicative

Contact Information www.pattan.net

Mike Miklos

[email protected]

Amiris Dipuglia

[email protected]

Commonwealth of Pennsylvania

TomWolfe , Governor

Pennsylvania Department of Education

Pedro Rivera. Acting Secretary

Patricia Hozella, Director

Bureau of Special Education