31
Subsea HPUs Subsea HPUs Contribution to reduced cost for injection X-mas trees Svein Lilleland, FMC Technologies Per Ragnar Dahl StatoilHydro Per Ragnar Dahl, StatoilHydro

Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs

Contribution to reduced cost for injection X-mas trees

Svein Lilleland, FMC TechnologiesPer Ragnar Dahl StatoilHydroPer Ragnar Dahl, StatoilHydro

Page 2: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

Presentation overwiewPresentation overwiew

• A historic review of subsea HPUs• A historic review of subsea HPUs

• Development of a subsea HPU to power injection XTsDevelopment of a subsea HPU to power injection XTs

2

Page 3: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

A historic review of subsea HPUs:A historic review of subsea HPUs:

• Hydraulicontrol; Subpack - 1972y ; p• NTNF-K; ”Snurre” RCV (ROV) – 1973 - 1978• Myrens Verksted Controlled Lifting Hook• Kvaerner underwater excavator• Mølleroddens Verksted; ”Check Mate” - 1977• SAAB Scania; SAAB Sub – 1978• Myrens Verksted; ”Snurre-III” ROV -1982

D V C1A j t• DnV C1A project• KOS / Technomare XT with subsea HPU - 1987• KOS Subsea HPU – 1993 - 1994• KOS Subsea HPU – 1993 - 1994

Those highlighted will be presented in more detail..

3

Page 4: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

Hydraulicontrol; SubpackHydraulicontrol; Subpack

Subsea HPU, designed to power diver operated underwater hydraulic tools.

Was in use by a number of divingWas in use by a number of diving operators.

Vickers PVB pressure controlled pump with externally controlled stroke.stroke.Commercial squirrel cage 3-Φmotor, modified for subsea use.

4

Page 5: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

IKU ”Snurre”IKU Snurre

Developed by NTNF-K (IKU)Brain child of Dr.Ing. Bo BrännströmProject mgr.: Arnfinn Lindstadj gElectronics: SI in OsloHydraulics: HydraulicontrolAssembly and test: Hydraulicontrol

5

Page 6: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

IKU ”Snurre”IKU Snurre

Ringerikes Blad 1975:

6

Blad, 1975:

Page 7: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

A side glance; Snurre development, the helmet controlled ROV

7

Page 8: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

NUI Check MateNUI Check Mate

D l d b M ll dd V k dDeveloped by Mølleroddens VerkstedProject mgr.: Tor LindheimOperated by: NUI (NUTEC)Pil t Vid F d ikPilot: Vidar FondevikHydraulics: Hydraulicontrol

8

Page 9: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

NUI Check MateNUI Check Mate

9

Page 10: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

SAAB SubSAAB Sub

Developed by: SAAB Scania (Aerospace) in Linköping(Aerospace) in Linköping.Project mgr.: Göran AlsebyHydraulics: Hydraulicontrol

10

Page 11: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

Myrens Verksted: Snurre and Snurre 2 1Myrens Verksted: Snurre and Snurre 2.1

• Developed by Myrens Verksted in Oslo• Developed by Myrens Verksted in Oslo

• Project mgr. Snurre: Kjell Nilsson

P j t S 2 1 P Ol f T• Project mgr. Snurre 2.1: Per Olaf Tangen

• Hydraulics: Hydraulicontrol

• Known customer for Snurre 2.1: Intersub Services SA (Marseilles)

11

Page 12: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

KOS / Technomare XTKOS / Technomare XT

•Developed by KOS and Technomare

Subsea XT with subsea HPU

•KOS project mgr.: Bjørn Quistgaard•Technomare project mgr.: Gianfranco Gobbo•Installed in July / August 1987•Commissioned in January 1988•”6 years of reliable operation” in 1994• 6 years of reliable operation in 1994•Current status unknown

12

Page 13: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

KOS HPU

Developed by Statoil and KOS

KOS project mgr.: Kjell StensrudKOS project mgr.: Kjell Stensrud

13

Page 14: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

Development of a subsea HPU to power injection XTs; the FMC eSHPUinjection XTs; the FMC eSHPU

StatoilHydro project mgr.: Per Ragnar DahlFMC project mgr : Peter Bergsland

14

FMC project mgr.: Peter Bergsland

Page 15: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

Development of a subsea HPU to power injection XTsXTs

The CAPEX motivation:The CAPEX motivation:

1. Five-well field using conventional electrohydraulic umbilical

2 Same field using only electric cable and subsea HPUs2. Same field using only electric cable and subsea HPUs

Hardware + Engineering

Umbilical + installation costg g

Case 1 MNOK 515 MNOK 191Case 1 MNOK 515 MNOK 191

Case 2 MNOK 438 MNOK 18Case 2 MNOK 438 MNOK 18

C fi FMC i t l ti t

15

Capex figures are FMC internal estimates.

Page 16: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

Development of a subsea HPU to power injection XTsXTs

• Hydraulic circuit diagram

• Main components

• Drive options

• LP-pumps

• HP GenerationHP Generation

• The rotary shaft seal challenge

• Replenishment of control fluid• Replenishment of control fluid

• Reservoir sizing

S ifi ti• Specifications

• Energy balance

16

Page 17: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

Development of a subsea HPU to power injection XTsXTs

Hydraulic circuit diagram

17

Page 18: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

Main components of the eSHPUMain components of the eSHPU

• Electronic cans with batteries, charger circuit, motor control d CAN band CAN-bus

• Motor and pump compartment

• HP Intensifier

• Pressurized reservoir* (Active Receiver)( )

• Hydraulic filter

Jumper*• Jumper*

• Water separator *

• Mounting base

* Not inside SCM-sized outer can

18

Not inside SCM sized outer can

Page 19: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

Drive options:Drive options:

• “Unter Oel” squirrel cage motor and DC/AC converter and• Unter Oel squirrel cage motor and DC/AC converter and batteries (Ziehl-Abegg, IKM)

• Submersible motor (Franklin), with DC/AC converter andSubmersible motor (Franklin), with DC/AC converter and batteries

• FMC eTech drive train with syncron motor and batteriesFMC eTech drive train with syncron motor and batteries

FMC eTech driveFMC eTech drive train selected. Field proven, and at an advanced stage of development

19

development.

Page 20: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

LP pumpsLP pumps

• Dynex Rivett “check ball” pump – basic but rugged

• Marshalsea subsea pump (for water-glycol)

• Bieri radial piston pump (for water-glycol) in testBieri radial piston pump (for water glycol) in test

20

Page 21: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

HP generationHP generation

• High pressure intensifier –High pressure intensifier Good record of reliability from Vigdis Extension

• Separate motor driven HP pump – expensive

Split flow pump no track• Split flow pump – no track record with split flow pumps

Marshallsea high pressure intensifier selected basedintensifier selected based

on Vigdis experience

21

Page 22: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

The rotary shaft seal challengeThe rotary shaft seal challenge

• Process industry type rotary seals, used extensively in early Hydraulicontrol projectsy p j

• Contain the pump and motor in a pressure compartment, virtually no differential pressure over the shaft seal

22

Page 23: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

The rotary shaft seal challengeThe rotary shaft seal challenge

23

Page 24: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

Replenishment of control fluidReplenishment of control fluid

• Supply hose from platform based HPU

• Retrievable reservoir ROV transported• Retrievable reservoir – ROV transported

• Pre charged and filled accumulator – ROV transported –connects via single line coupler – see circuit diagramconnects via single line coupler – see circuit diagram

Pre charged and filled accumulator currently selected

24

Page 25: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

Reservoir sizing:Reservoir sizing:

The FMC Active ReceiverThe FMC Active Receiver

• Active Receiver volume: 25 liters

• Pressure ratio: 20 : 1

• RET pressure @ 207 bar(g): ple

only

. at

ion

• RET pressure @ 207 bar(g): 10.3 bar(g)

• Pressurized reservoir: 25 liters how

n as

prin

cip

s fro

m th

e ill

ustra

• Pressurized reservoir: 25 liters

• Pressure ratio: 19 : 1

ve R

ecei

ver i

s s

al d

esig

n di

ffers

• RET pressure @ 207 bar(g) LP: 10.8 bar, and at 345 bar(g); 18 bar(g)

The

Act

ivTh

e ac

tua

25

bar(g)

Page 26: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

Reservoir and reservoir sizingReservoir and reservoir sizing

Sizing considerations:Sizing considerations:

• Accumulator charge and discharge volume

E t l l k t (DHSV)• External leak rate (DHSV)

• Temperature contraction

• Fluid compression

• Air inclusions

• Actuator rod imbalance

External leak rates will be carefully scrutinized

26

te a ea ates be ca e u y sc ut ed

Page 27: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

Reservoir and reservoir sizingReservoir and reservoir sizing

Two Active Receivers provides a reservoir capacity ofTwo Active Receivers provides a reservoir capacity of 50 liters, one on the XMT, the second on the ISS

The Active Receiver (Pressurized reservoir) on the eSHPU is level instrumented.

27

Page 28: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

Specification – 1: HydraulicSpecification – 1: Hydraulic

• eSHPU shall connect to XMT via logic cap on XT• eSHPU shall connect to XMT via logic cap on XT

• Control fluid as standard for Hydro (Brayco SV/B)

LP l 207 b ( )• LP supply: 207 bar(g)

• HP supply: <690 bar(g)

• Return pressure: 10 bar(g) (Nominal)

• Design pressure return: 40 bar(g)g p (g)

• Hydraulic cleanliness: AS4059 class 6B-F, 20% Rh

• Total air inclusion: < 2 normal liters• Total air inclusion: < 2 normal liters

28

Page 29: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

Draft specifications – 2: ElectricDraft specifications – 2: Electric

• Battery capacity: 5 4 * 106 Joules• Battery capacity: 5.4 10 Joules

• Requirement 1: Capacity to open well 6 times in sequence

R i t 2 2 h t h ft 1 ll• Requirement 2: < 2 hours to recharge after 1 well open sequence

C t l F SCM i j d CAN b• Control: From SCM via jumper and CAN-bus

• Charging: 24 VDC nominal

• Charging power: 100 watts

29

Page 30: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

Energy balance:Energy balance:

• Energy to open a well @ 207 bar≈ 300 000 joulesEnergy to open a well @ 207 bar≈ 300 000 joules

• Energy in fully charged battery ≈ 5.4 * 106 joules

A d ffi i ( lifi d ti ) 50 %• Assumed efficiency (qualified assumption): 50 %

• Requirement 1: 9 well open sequences

• Requirement 2: 1.5 hours

• Internal leakage SCM max. (From Vigdis Study): 3 wattg ( g y)– 4.3 cc/min @ 350 bar and 50% efficiency

• The pump will recharge accumulator every 2 6 hours• The pump will recharge accumulator every 2.6 hours– Pin=325(barg), Pout=345(barg), Precharge 200 bar, Vol 20L, net 0.68L

30

Page 31: Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs - Possibility - Event Planner ... - Svein Lilleland_c.pdf · Subsea HPUsSubsea HPUs ... ( lifi d ti ) 50 %Assumed ... Conclusion: The project is feasible and

Conclusion:

The project is feasible and will be implementedThe project is feasible and will be implemented.

31