~SSW&~IMI 524PAG(674

BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD

IN RE:

SUPPLEMENTAL ORDER REGARDING DOCKET NUMBER VGO$ 4141164&64

ELECIIONS: UNIT D-16(bccem "Subject Drilhtt& Un')

REPORT OF BOARD

FINDINOS AND ORDER

Ms Sepphmnual Order is cakcnd by the Ba¹d cua cpacccc in tbe Sxm cuborhcd by Ibc Baanl at hearings

bchloa Pelrfay15, 1994aad June 16, 1992; ssd Ibis Supplemnnd Order is beiag recanhd Sx0» purpaee ofnyp'==--'—-SceOnhr~ h Scc~ments on M¹oh 2, 2001 width wac iecanhd ¹Deed Book520, Page 343 ia 0» Ogh» ofthe Clark sf0» Chcoh Cour( ofBucbanaa Couaty, Virginia, on Msnh 7, 2001,(bcceh "Bomd Ordain) aad~d» mcacd ~shathm.

Ocdsr to sg Rcspamlecus whose ~ifsay,l"were

Bourg Onhx nquhad each Rscpnsdnn whaee ~ifmehP aa ahagcn w&ia Sdcty(30) dcps ager S»d¹so&

hf sh¹hns Shd batch ¹d aaan¹d henso as Sddbh

pooled by cahl Ba¹d Order,

aay, wwu paotnl by S» tenne ofsail Boardmagmg ar hwviahlhca ~ ¹I sPPScsbh, ofcwd Ocdal;

A ¹¹an (i) wb¹bw c»ch Reepamhcn bsc

the Bond's1bs

Odar«ths nghhchmnh or «mahe admslyeh¹ha; (h) dcs n¹me ofNrshcthn(s) mnhr, ¹xl(ig) wbegux, hymen«sf

alum�«ar«thnslyehct

ac» m uxxe R~~ uch) deemed, i«der 6» tern» ofg» Bo¹d'c Onhr, tohave leased Scchrlghs, this, bnnwm, c¹acc eel dahn |n Subjns Dr&gag Unh to Suh~

'lhatgw afchcgam¹mmsdhne«ted»8¹dhh mhmnad ~xhntcgm the Recpcndnn(c)bbhb ~hmhbbhh 6 b "hh'~~ ~l bh b6666~6——'=- iaths¹s md chhns which nquhe escrow; idenggdc tbo lasne¹s ¹d daimc, ifany, nxtuhhg escrow~bbhlhblbh ~653.3633133.:~~lb3 'm~~h ~65ieanm of~leased ar ememd iata s vohatacyagn»ment whb 0» Appgcaat

11»aghbddt ofeh»Sons hdhatm that Ibs snxow ofSaCk is nxpdnd whh cetpud to Unit D-16;

Qtitg ~Qnhr. 0» Bond acdns tbe Dsdsastd Opccath» Io «ader, cosst¹cm whh and h cxocdacu»whb the~set Satb at pccsgngk 2. above ¹d 0» ass»ad etgdsvh sfSleadmn whh Bxhgdn Ibcnnc, enySmds ecbeCN mmw mdh¹nxmdw Sscww Agent, First Wiaa Negaasl ~Corpora«Trust PA1320,123Breed Sneeg Pbthxhlphia, PA 19109-1199,Tehpbona: (215) 90$-3405 ar (000) 664-9359, Atnr. DaaBdgngle@ dr ssy n»cmear us«cd by the Board to e¹abgcb imccest bearieg a»sow eccou¹(s), JRS Texc=-'=="--5lgumbcr $4-1629506, h accccdanm whb 6» h4nuele cet Sade h 0» atgdevh ofelacthm wide

Bxhgchs thuota, to mcstve Scads ncd accoum ccg» Boanl Sxcegxe.

1hs BccsdOwhr dhe¹ad Caacol Sangy hc. (hain "S¹gtutd Opaasap) to meg ocpioc ofthe Band Onhxto ag Rcepcddccm whose iatcxe¹c, ifany, ewe pooled by Sck said Baenl Onhr,

Tbc D—'Opannar Shul hc aghhvh ofehcdaas disktoeiag Ihat Shad maged a true aal conect aapy of

000I 524fgg(675

tvhtgns sfOabr sml Filius ofA%davit. Tbe~Opera«e uadcr tbe captious Order or shall gh aeaSde4 wllh tbs Secre«ay oftbe Bomd whbia tcn (10)days ager tbe deer ofmceipt ofdus Order sashg that aaue aad cmtectecpycfthh Oahr am asdhd m each Respomhsn whose buerech or chime mu subject m escrowsad whose mhhmn is hnown wbhin cevsa seven (7)days gem thc dcse ofreordpt ofthis Order.r~.aad ff IS SO ORDERED.

IBgrcthe Da«c Ibis Order shall be sghcthe oa the dern ofbs ececu«on.

DONE AND EXECUTED dus fP day of ~s ~,2001, by a majority ofthe

Virginia Gm and Oil BawL 0

STATE OF VIRGINIACOUNTY OF WISE

Achrtoedalgcdmt this~dayof ~ ,2001,~before ms a mmuy

pubgc h eel ketbe Comamawalth ofVirghia, pph rtpid Benny R. Wmnpler, hsing duly swum did depose aadssythct be hOsdmsm oftbe Vhgbia Gac and Oil Board, that bs esecutad ths scam sad was authcrhsd to do so.

~gums G. GarronNo«uy

Myo ~esphm: 7S/-~

DONE AND PERFORMED THIS Zt day of ~ache, 2001,byOrdcr oftbe BoenL

A>re&rhea

Director of the Divhhn ofGes 4 Oil Boardead Priaeipd Esacutive to thc Board

STATE OF VIRGINIACOUNTY OF WASI BNGFON

Ardmosdedged on this rQl day of %~,2001,pnmnsgy before me ammsypubgc in aad kr tbe Caaunmiwealth ofVirginia, ~B.R. Wgscn, behg drdy sworn did dspomaad ssy that be is Acthg Principe Exccudve m tbe S«df, Vbghria Gss aed Og BocsvL thn be erecucd thesmrm and wae amhorhcd to do so.

Mycomadmhu esp r I l 3 II AaP~ 8,HAh~(~CQ> tlat LHblbraol(

B00K 524 PAGE 676

VIRGINIA:Exhibit A

BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD

IN RE:

Applicatica of BUCHANAN PRODUCIION CO. Cn F«esd Pcoliag of lnt«eats in CBM Unit D-16VGOB014116-0064 ia Ibe North Grundy dt Sash Gru«ly Dinrhrs ofBuchanan County, Vhginia

AFFIDAVfl'F Consol Energy lac. (h«ein "Desigmntd ~REGARDING E1ECflONS, ESCROWAND SUPPURCENTAL ORDER

Losge K Arrtngtcn, beiag Erst duly swam ca otrh, deposes and says:

That your ngh»t is~by Consol Euergy lnc„as sGas Eagb»sr and is duly smhortsM to make Ibisatgdsvh on Melf ofC» dssigmnsd cpa«acr,

2bst 6» Cbdsr s«tsmd oa Mmch 2, 2001,byd» Virginia Gas aad Oil Board~"Bo«tF)regards 6» cspdcnsd CBM Unit nquired tbs Applicsat to mail a true «ul cert«s copy ofsaid (bdtr to sechpsrsoa poolsd bytbe Order,

2bm vdgdh seven (7)dtps ofreceipt ofan «««nsd copy Sf0» Ordrr Iegrrvd to at pragrsph 2. above, youraShmt cswed a true aad correct ocpy ofsshl Onhr to be tpsgsd via tbe Unhrd gaum Real Service to each

almtsd ia C»~Appgcsgcn, wb«» addrsm wm hnown, aad to all p«seas, ifany, wbo wme

sddsdmgmjrnuhsus at tbe bearing beld in 0» cspdcrud msher; C»t pmof ofsuch msgtag bas Furiously bernsmdsred to Ibs Diviiaa ofGas aad OS, Ibe Ogh» ofC» Gas «ul OS bnpecnn, st Abiagdcn, Virghth;

2bstd» Onhr ofthe Bo«d ia Ibe capdcnsd n»csr r«pdteS ag pars«» poohd Ib«eby to nsuhr Ibeb wrhnm

elscticas Io Iho Unh ops«acr »leds tbhty(30) days ofc» db» Ibe order war recorded in thc couaty ide»csedabove; Ibat said Ordsr wus rccmdsd on Mech 7, 2001;

1bst the- top«sns Consol Entvgy inc. has~pocesdmve to revtew ag mail mceived sad sgwrtnm dccsatnm mcived cdur Canbymagm ss«smh vdusbtr pmtiss whose its«us have bosn pooled havemades wrbtmchcgaa, hta dungy%shiva,mt«pdndbyd» Ordsr tbstsiid ptocsdurm wrre MewedIo bhnc(elbe ~ifany mace whh tesnd to c» suhiect Unit; cun 6» fosowiag p«sow deliver by mailor~wrhten etecdoas tbe Unh Op«assr, wbbbt C» Ibhty day ehsshms per«L

None

YbaR 'hlhhhtlL3~~h&ghhda ~m hNw ~a h

C»ir ccatbtd meduu» rtgtus, interes«sad chime to Apphcant, sg as Provided m tbe Bo«d's Otdrr ofMarch 2,2001;

800K 584 PAGE 677'Ibat «» rigbls, htsrests aad chime of tbe hlhwing psa»ns me subject to escrow under tbe Board's Order

pooling «» cspthnrd Unit, Bcmd Betpdafrons snd «» Code cfVirginia:

None

'Il»t agar «» poogag bearing bald m tbe csptbmed neater, the ««towing persot» bove leased or entered hsoe vohntary rm~ wl«l tbe~Operetta:

Ncoe

the to «» eatvat mry ofsaid pvvsoos gmsd m Bsbgdt B-2 bare rtgbts, hterests aad claims which me ma subjectro easow, «try sboubl be~street»ndcvns; tbe Operator rvquaas «»t tbs Mowhg parsons be 6'smiseed

as Respondtnts:

Nm»

None

Tbatpumesst totbe ptovishrn ofVAC 23-160-70%.10.snd C aad VAC 2S-16040 ibe~ssvv' ~order svm gtrtb tbc bneres» snd chime Sat teqube escrow ofgmds pursuers to Virghia Code secticas 4S.1-361213Ksad 4S.1-36122%3.sad 4.

Dahd at Tazeweg, Virgima, ibis N day of MvsPA/d 2001

Tebea,~and swmn to befcre me by Laslie K Awingam eg Gas~ofConsol Envrgy b»„onbehdfof«» impar ~Stlgnslsd OPerstor, tbhd day of QDL8 , 2001.

Ncmry

Mycomadssha aspires: 0 I gel o t

I

/

QA

CBM-D16-88

II

I

I

/

(lill

I

I,'

l,

p>-~ ~

8J ACTI INIT p tN 368,884.76 I /

kcDQHsowcstv I. %Howe wEOE TH<EH rsRM ss'5

9006 +$5+.@78Peowoco ev IIossoc Inc. Ne wEOE HOI sucvEYEo.

i/ H 3ecyec.-eJ, I(( E 9 ~ 5,310.07

I

N 361,863.86IE 873,447.57

// .. )i I,> 8 I V/- ji -+~-

((

~4B ICBM-016A-1021I

I I

I

E 873,377.57

II

I

I

\

EXHIBIT A

OAKWOOD FIELD UNIT D-16FORCE POOLING

VGOB-DI WI 16WB64

Caspany CDNSDLI Enercv I nc. eel li Nasei and NumberDNITiD16'uadr

is'Dpuodw- - -----Tract No. : Elevatian'ounty ~ District North Grundv/scsIeh crundv scoiec 1' %00'ate / ii~i

This plat is a rlew plat II : an updated plat

-TI~~~:": SeaRev. 9/91 ', Licensed protessional Engineeri or Lice/(sed Land survey'er„..'~,-.„.,

oIspoa.es ~>sIeaae aescm sw

es StItse57$December 13, 2000

3.

f

4S.

CONSOL K Y INC.UHtT 1B

Tract tds

Yukon Pecatusnlas, st al. Tr. 50- Coal( ON 5 QesCool Lesseelehml Crack CoelCsmporS-Sohw Dratnays Coal LoosedSuokanen FrodudNon Company -CW ILsasodJAN Coal 8 Ceks Company-Surhc e23.07ecsss 2N.NNINN tt

Derrsk Atstn Dsntsls, at ux. - FooCoal Losseshhnd Creek Coal Company-Sataw g~~ Coal Leased3.51acres 4.

ttortk Assms~ ~ Tknbor Corp. Tr. 5 FINCoat Losseshhnd Cntak Coat.Company-Sehw Coal LeasedS ~P~ Company-0.41 acres 0.$1

Sert W. Yahs, etaL tHotreor Loots S.lyoh >- Coat, ON a DosCoal Lesseetshnd Nkeek Coat Company-Sehur .—: '.:-coal LeasedJaeN ~ . 'ast Carp. -Tier sr ~ Atsoue Cool Loosed8 . —,Oaeyasy- IS L Iman4 CM~(10K!lNtL83 acres SLQK 8 %

DaneNAtsh Danhh, ot rsr, -Surhc»theyQoaa Setdah-%8urhsekkskoikeLeaSektnh -%8whee

ttorNr A—-"——.Thdssr Corp. Tr. 5 - Fels

hhnd Craek Caet C——— -Sehw ., Coal Leased~Chas$%%WWRW( ~ f%%%WWI

tk88 asses L

HAI. Ccat, CC IOmCoat Losseshhnd Cheek Coal ~«Sohw ——Coal Leased~S.—.—.---CaSCaa.-Mha 4mls~1.12asses 1.

Pace 1,

I, @~880

IiI. I I I s s

li I I

li

i fI

Ill)5 gg 8%i %$ Pl QS

lsNgd

Ii'l 4I l

WIjl= I

b. I,: f>: ,)„ -.,:, ,)!li il(

lH flI )II i!I I:'I II)

O sCI Ci Ci O O CI

N

O

eo

If

ww lMesr%8

.g 5.'.

.)glg

gg li

f3)) I) SI

8 8

l

o I

O

Cll

f

I I l

8

I

+!I

II

tt

If

~j gl I

rt ." fi."f

e'I I II I II

I I

I ~ '~ I

; i:lI'iu ~4%%hiiFkiii'Mhkii+iw@ ll

™fien '%

'I'I ~rWlN&'~~%%FYPW~ * rrr rr

PgIijzig@4~~"sxusiV/l~l~iQXgi'r . ~

ISii

I

f r..'.:I,'Itt

,r I ':I

< i Il:I I I N~

t

X~~N Li~~~M~'%~,~i//ii~~~~iik@>iM ', )rrrrrrx'A, r:xa"rAwprrrrrr1( i I ! S t II

z/r//g'~w,,~~$ /~;large/gl~ ~ '

gROiIIIIA GAS ALID„OIL BOARD

'ssfIsne of ths C't Court of Buchanan County. 11m foregoing instrumentthe ~Seats of acknovsse ~amused,

Deed Book No. M g ~~No.W~W / 1g~ J~sgg~ins, Jr., Clerk

gr tr rc 0'