DISCHARGE SUPERVISION REPORT

MT "PETRO CARA" Voy No. 202 at MACO, COMPOSTELA VALLEY

5th Floor Filipino Building, 135 De La

Rosa St., Legaspi Village, Makati City

Tel No. 468-4819 Fax No. 856-5015

At the request of MESSRS. PILIPINAS SHELL PETROLEUM CORP., we duly attended on board the MT "PETRO

CARA" whilst she lay afloat and secured at MACO, COMPOSTELA VALLEY in order to carry out the

survey/inspection requirements prior to and after discharge of the vessel's cargo. A summary of our findings

are as follows:

Date/Time FinishedDate/Time Commenced

- Discharge operation Jan 18, 2011 / 0730H Jan 19, 2011 / 1000H

*Also see Statement of Facts field document included with this final report for complete details.

SUMMARY OF QUANTITIES

CRFO Metric TonsG.S.V. @ 15

Deg.C

G.O.V. @ Air

(Cu.M)Cargo:

MT "PETRO CARA" before discharge 2881.492 2947.818 2999.408

MT "PETRO CARA" after discharge 0.000 0.000 0.000

Quantity Discharged 2999.408 2947.818 2881.492

SHIP TANK'S SOUNDING REPORT

MT "PETRO CARA"BEFORE DISCHARGE

CRFO

Metric TonsG.S.V @ 15

Deg.C

W.C.F.

(T-52)

V.C.F.

(T-54B) Density

Nominated tank figures are as follows:

Tank

Nos.

Corr'd

Dips (M)

T.O.V. @ Air

(Cu.M)

Free

Water

G.O.V. @ Air

(Cu.M)

Temp.

(Deg. C)

1P 2.290 249.320 249.320 -

1S 2.253 250.190 250.190 -

2P 2.088 349.836 349.836 -

2S 2.057 349.633 349.633 -

3P 2.128 348.910 348.910 -

3S 2.101 349.289 349.289 -

4P 2.088 350.822 350.822 -

4S 2.057 350.779 350.779 -

5P 4.183 199.224 199.224 -

5S 4.149 201.405 201.405 -

Total: 0.9775 2947.818 2881.492 2999.408 0.9786 0.9828 39.8

Draft (M): AFT: TRIM: LIST: Water Condition: 4.43 5.45 1.02 0.00 SLIGHTFWD:

MT "PETRO CARA"AFTER DISCHARGE

CRFO

Metric TonsG.S.V @ 15

Deg.C

W.C.F.

(T-52)

V.C.F.

(T-54B) Density

Nominated tank figures are as follows:

Tank

Nos.

Corr'd

Dips (M)

T.O.V. @ Air

(Cu.M)

Free

Water

G.O.V. @ Air

(Cu.M)

Temp.

(Deg. C)

ALL - 0.000 0.000 -

Total: - 0.000 0.000 0.000 - - -

SHORE TANK MEASUREMENT

The measurements for the receiving tanks could not be obtained due to its simultaneous usage while receiving

cargo. No comparative analysis could also be done for those tanks due to the same reason.

SAMPLING

The inspectors of ELITE have also witnessed the drawing and distribution of the following samples:

TypeDistributed ToDescriptionNumber and Qty.

SpotBEFORE DISCHARGE (CRFO) Therma Marine2 BOTTLES x 100 ML

Representing the aforementioned cargo which had been transferred.

_______________________MARINE & CARGO SURVEYORS * INSURANCE CLAIMS ADJUSTERS_______________________

Page 1 of 2Ref. No.: BP-0114-PS-034-DIS-11

Attachments

Attached hereto forming an integral part of this report are as follows:

1. Statement of Facts

2. Vessel Sounding Report (Before Discharge)

3. Cargo Tank Inspection Report / Dryness Certificate

4. Non-cargo Tank Inspection Report

5. Bunker Report

6. Certificate of Quantity

7. Notice of Apparent Discrepancy

8. Sampling Report

9. Sample Aknowledgement Receipt

10. Field Reports Aknowledgement Receipt (Checklist)

11. Certificate of Quality (PSPC Document)

12. Certificate of Quantity Delivered (PSPC Document)

13. Withdrawal Certificate (B.I.R. Document)

The present report reflects our findings determined at the time and place of our investigation only and does

not refer to any other matters.

All attendances made, discussions held, and reports/opinions were issued totally without prejudice.

ELITE ADJUSTERS AND SURVEYORS INC.

Bulk Petroleum Products Department

KEENAN U. ANSELMO

Operations Support Specialist

Attending Surveyors: A. C. RODRIGUEZ

Page 2 of 2Ref. No.: BP-0114-PS-034-DIS-11