I

2

?"4

5

6

?

8g

l0

l1

12

l3

l4

l5

l6

l7

18

t9

20

2r

72

23

24

25

26

z7

28

08/07/2001 18 50 FAX 213 821 7552 LASC EXECUTIVE OFFICE

ROCI(ARD J. DELGADILLO. City Atlomev (SBN 125 465tELLEN A. SARMIENTO, Supcrvising Assisaht City ArtoniqDAN F.IEFFRIES, Assisraat City anbruey, (SBN l'10?67)DAVID A. BOZAIIICH, Deputy City Attoiney (SBN 212458)MenrcDolitan Courrbouse1945 South llill Stect, Suirc 501Los Aanolce, CsJifornie 90007(213)97E-2400 (o)(2r3) 485.8243 (D

Anorncis for PlaintiffTIiEFEoPi,E oT NN ST^TE Or CALIFORMA I

Pleintiff,

vs,

PARIS WHITI{EY HILTON,

t r'BN 10243t)

"*"#,{#P**JUN0 7 2007

Caso I l;r.:6MPO9I60

EX R ,I; 1T APPLICATON FOR ORDERSHOI I'II\IING TIME, ORDER TO ST{OWCAU| ,i RE: CoNTEN4PT AI{D ORDER ToTRAI II;:PORT PAT{IS WHITNEY TIILTON TNCUS: :: DY TO COIJRTI I\4EMORAT.IDUMOF PI; I;.ITS A]'ID ATJTITORITIES INSUPI ',II.ITTHEREOF;E)(H::f lfs

IN TTIE SUPERIOR COURT OF TI{E ST I : B OF CALTFORNI,A

COUNTY OF LOS A}.I(:::LES

THS PEOPLE OF TltE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

Defcndant

TO THE ITONORABLE MICHAEL T. SAUER, ;'IIDGE O}T T}IE ST'PERIOR COUR'T O

THD STATE OF CALIFORMA, COTNTY OF LOS AN I:,LPS, DEPAR-II\4ENT 60, AND TO

LOS ANGELES SHERIFF,S DEPARTN,fENT AND LOS ,I.NGELES S}TERIFF LgF, BACA AND

DEFDNDANT PARIS WHITNEY HILTON AI-ID HER (.':UNSEI.: Piaase take uotics tbat on June 7

2007 at4:30 p.m., or at soon thcroaficr os the matler may I ; .leard in Deparurrcnt 60 of the Meuopoli

Courrhouse at 1945 Sourh }lill Street, Los Angelcs, C, , fornia 9000?, the People of tbe Srate

California will apply to this corut for tbree orders: (l) an ( ':rle-r Shortcning Tirne. (2) an Order to the

juds,DcpaDntcTirnt:

Hon. Micbael T. Saucr' r r rcnu 60

June 7,20074:30 p.m.

@0ol/010

Thc pcople's Ex Parrc Applicotion for Orrier Shorrening I ae, Ordct ro.Show Crnse Re: Contempq-

rnd otdct to Trnnspon Puis Whiucy I I l.oo in Custody to Court

- l

I

2

3

.45

6

7

6

9

l0

l l

12

t3l

14

r5r5

:17

IE

r920

2t

22

23

24

25

26

z728

oB/07/2001 18 50 FAX 213 821 7952 LASC EXECUIIVE OFFICE B oo2l0 1 0

I

nsgcle6 sheriffs Department to show causE Re: contc rr1:,! aod (3) an order to ore los

Sberifs peparrrnent o Transport Paris Whitncy tlilton i:' riustody to Coutt for Thir Heering.

application is based upon this r:oticc and thc attached Mern< r.udr:m of Points aud Authqities in

Thcrco{ Extribi6 and such additional evidence and argume r.: as may be ptcsefied at the heedng of

applicarion

DATE: June 7,2007

Rcspectfully sr' : : :oir!cd,ROCKARD J. I rd,LGAI)ILLO' City AttomcyELLEN A. SA :.),/fiENTO,

Supew : lrtg Assisant City AttoracyDAN F. JEFFI l.lS, Assistaot City AttorncyDAVID A. BC;:,$.TICH' Deputy CltyAttorney

"rQ' :DA).IF, JEFFI.l:,iSAssisunt Crty,,' torDsY

Deputy CrtyA:'(rmey

Artomeys for . ',i,inti-ffTHE PEOPLE ::F THH STATE OF CALIFORNIA

rD',,'il) il.DAVID-A. B C . : ;,\},II CH

T5e Pcoplc's Ex Panc Applioarion for Order Shortcning J i ' ':, Ordcr ro Show Ceus€ Re: Contempt,and Ordcr to Transport Parir Wbincy H I t n in Cusrody to Corur

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

t

9

10

l l

t2

l3

r4

l5

l6

l1

IE

r920

2l

22

23

24

2s

26'11

28

08/07/2007 16 50 FAX 21s 821 7952 LASC EXECUIIVE OFFICE@ 003/ o1o

MDMORAIIDUM OF POINTS AIIII iT.IITHORITIDS

I

Introduction

This coun sbould. issue an order to the Los Angeles :l:rerifls popartmcnt to renua

Paris Whitucy }liltou ("Hiltoa') in cunody to the Centrry I r ijonal Dctention Centcr in order to

hcr sentcncc in conpliancc with California law aad tbis co r;r's order. Additionelly, bccause the

Aogeles Sheriffs f)eparto.e.nt has actcd in violation of such :.w ald order by allowigg Hiltos to

thg Qmtury Regional Detentios Ccntcr on cloctronio moni: ':ing, this court sbor:ld issue an ordcr

show cause to rha Los Angelcs Shuiff s Dcpartmeut regardi: r;; why it should not bc held in contempr

violating this corut's conrmitmont ordel made pursuaot to itt inding Hilton i.o violation of the tenns

conditioas of her probarion on May 4,2007'

On May 4,2007, this court rcvokcd Hilton's probal ,,rl and reinsteted ir on the satnc tenDs

conditions with tbe followiug modifications: Scrvc 45 days i i.,rail. The court fixther ordercd, botl:

on the rccord and in its'wihcn sentenci:og otder, 'No Worl f,rrlough; No Work Release; No Fl

Monitoring; No Wcekends; No City Jail." @xhibit I - S', ,;f,ior Coutt of California - County of

Angelcs - Ptobation violation Prooeedings (Misdemean" Docket) - Paris Hilton - casc

6MP09160), To efilectrrate tbat order, t}e clerk of this r ilrn exccuted a Conrmitnent Ordcr,

states in relevant part "TO TIIE SHERIFF OF LOS A'l:iE1Bt COIJI'ITY: Thc defendaat

having been oouvicted beibre a judge ir thc above-namr ,I coutrt sf the offense(s) and in thc case(s

describcd below, and rhe judgment having been duly entet: ; in tlrc pieutc otdc of said cotxt, I

certi$, flre forcgoing lo bc a u'ue copy of th.et ponioo o; e; i;l judgmant ordering the defendant

15. DEFEI{DAI.{T COMMITTED TO: COUNTY JA]L 5. FOR TIIE I.ERM OF: 45 DAYS; 29

OTIIER: No Work Release No Early Release No Electr< r i;: Monitoring No Weeksnds." (Exhibit 2

comrnitnrent - cJ - Hilton, Paris \l/!ritncy, case Nurnber : ''1P09160.)

On or about June 7,200?. the Los Aneeles Sbe:i:'''s Departmeat violafed thal court ordcr

permining Hilton 1o lcava the Cennrry Regional Dctentic , rlcntcr subject !o alccri'onic moniroring. B

The People's E< Pune Rpplication for chder Shonenr'ng 'r1e, ordcr ro sbow cause Roi Contcnpl'-

sod C)rdcr to Transport Pori. Yl*O'

:on in Custody to Court

_rD t l r ! , , .A ' ,aEt

I,,

I

4

5

6

7

E

9

r0l l

t2

l3

l4

15

l6

17

r8

t9

20

2l

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

08/07/2001 16 50 FAX 213 62I ?952 LASC EXEDUIIVE OFFICE a 004/010

violatiog thar courl order, thc Loe Sgclcs Shcrifs f r lrarEdcDt should bc hold b

Addirioualln this cogrr should order thar the Los Angelel jiheriffs Departuent tansport Hilton

c'stody to this corul fo{ the haanng on this appfication snd t' . i: coult should order that the Los A

Shcrilfs Dcpartmeat s'anqporr tlilton in custody to rhc Ccr:.try Regional Detentiou Ccnter in ordcc

sewe the remsindor of hcr sentcncc in cornpliaace with C'. ilbrnia law and tbis cotlt's May 4,

ordcr. Srlch relief ie just" propcr and ncccssary to snr rrt'! compliance wi$ thif court'g

Additiotally, such relicf rightfrlly will rcstorc any loss o i 'Lublic confidcnco in and rcsPect for

integrity of the govenrmeut of this ciry, county and sratc.

An Urgeut lfearing and Retief Are Neeessrry Becluse I l'r,ton lr Earnlng Cuctody Credits EVery

Day Shc Is op Electronic Monltorlng, Despite tbe Fact T rrrrl Tbc Los Augcler Shcrif s

.. Acled ln Controvention And in Conteu: I of This Courttr Order.

Despite rhc thct that Hilton serving ber sentenco or r; edtroDrc monitodng is in contrevcntion

California law and this coun's order, Ililton will carn cred t ;r,gaiust her fony-five (45) day sentenoe

each'say speot oD elccuonic monitoriag. Cal. Pco. Code :900.5(a) provides thar "[ifn all felony

misdemeaoor convictions, cithcr by plca or by verdict, ';,'hen tbc dcfcndant has becn in cuslody

includiug, but not limited to, eny timc spent in a jail, c,. r,p, work furlough facility, halfilay

rehabilitation facility, hospital, prison, juvenilc dercntiou : ;;ility, s1 sinital tesidendal institution,

days of custody of thc defendanr includiag days served as , 'ondition of probetion in corupliancc wjft

court otdar, and inclrtding days credited to theperiod of s',rlinementpu$uant ro Secdon 4019, shall

c.redited upon his or her tena of impriso'.-ent[-1" ln Peol i,t t. Lapaille (1g93) l5 Cal.App.46 I 159,

corut concluded t}at a defcndant would be er:titled to c.:':ody ctedits pursuant to Cal. psrr. Code2900.5(a) lbr timc spcnt on c]ecronic raoniroring pursrut: r;y e4l. pcn. Codo ! 1203.016. AdditionallyCal. Pcn- Code $ 2900.1 provides that "tw]hcce a dcfenda r; has serycd any portion of his sentencea commitrnent based uPor, I judgmenr whicb judEnenr i subsequently cleclarcd invalid or which

modifled tluing the rerm of irnprisonnrenq such time slra I 're credired upon any zubsequcnl Bentence

The Poople's Ex Psne Application for Order Shot-rcning ' jne, Orclcr to Show Cause Re; Conrcmp!snd Ordcr ro l}rnsport paris Wbioey I 'ron in Cusrody to coun

t

tr

4

5

6

7

8

9

l0

l l

12

l3

l4

1s

l6

17

18

l9

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

?8

06/01/2001 l6 50 FAX 213 821 7952 LASC E)(ECUIIVE OFFICE

rDay reccivc upon a new comtnitoeat for the same crirni' , I ac't or acls," Finally, Cal. Pen. Code

2900.5(a) requircs that "[i]f $c total numbcr of days in cut t,rdy occeeds the number of days of the

of imprisonmcnt to be imposed, the entire term of imprison trr:ut shall be deemcd to have been served."

Hilton is coming co-gtody credits while on eler.:r:'nic monitorirrg; nrch crcdits cFnEot

wiihdravvn once the Los Angclcs Shcriffs Dcparment hes i:re! found to h.ave acted il violation ofI

oorut's order and once this coun ordqs tb$ Hiltoa ri;: r:fully should be returngd to cormty

Ibcro,forc, cvery day tliat Hilton remaios on the electonic rrrrnitoring program is credited to hcr

of rhe forty-five (45) day county jail tcrm otdcred by this c r.rft, If this coufi docs not sborten time,

Hilton oay bc dccmcd to have sewed bcr entirc tcrrs of i rprisonment despite serving a maximum

fivc actr:al dap in couDty jail. ln other words, cvot] rl:.r' 11'ttoo ssryes her sentence illcgally

alectroaic uroniroring oannot be recovcred by the People v lnn tle SherifPs ections are deemod il

Conseqlently, tinc is of tbc "ssence.

Therefore, tlre Peopl,, t::ove this court for arr order shonening

tiurc required by 1aw for isnunce of an order to show cl :,;e why tle Los Angeler County Sbcciff

Depar@ent should not be held in coDtempt for violatin t this court's order, nD cx parte order i

necessary to preserve the People of thc State of Califonia" irterest in cnforcing a va[d co\:rt order

in preventiug the Los A.ugeles Shedffls l)epartuent ftom a ::irrg iu contravemtion of such ordor snd

law to tbe People's dctriment

'Hpursunnt to Cntifonle Penal Code $ 1203.016(e), ADd ('rrlileyslg Judicial luterpretation'I'hereof,

thc Lcgistnrure Eltl Vested Statutory Power in Tbte r .': url to Deny Electronlc Monttoring to

Hiltou. Tbi.r Court Exercised Such Powr r in lts Moy 4, 2007 Order.

Prusuanr ro Calfomja Penal Code $ 1203.016(e), " i,l'l the Ume of scntencing or Et eoy time

thc court cleems it necessary, the court may rasllict or d r.t'r the defcndant's participation in a

detenrion prograna." (Enrphasis added.) The Calilbrnia Co . '. ol'Appeal relied on that text to Pro

thot.,[t]he sentencing judge has only the right to rcstrict or rlt:nv a defendant'.s 1:articipation in the

cf ctcotion 1y6yan. (Ciration-)t' Pcople v. Superior Courr 1t;ubbard) ( 1991) 230 Cal.App .3d 28J ,

The people's 61t Psne Applicarion for Order Shonening T I 1,', QJdsl to,$!rsw Causa Rc: Contr:rnp4'

arrd Order to Transpoh Faris firjmcy Hj t:r r in Custody to courl.5

I

2

3

@ oo5/0 1 0

I

2

t

4

,56

7

E

9

10

ut2

t3

t4

l5

l6

l7

t t

l9

20

2t

22

23

24

2s26

27

2E

0B/07 /2007 16 50 FAX 2 13 82 1 7952 LASC IXECUIIVE ( ]FFICE @ 008/0 1 0

(relyfu oB o previous, but relevarrtly uochanged, vffsion of ,.;rl, Pcn, Code $ tZOl,Otg. Thc

court referrod to rhe legislative history of scction 1203,016 l,;plairring that "[aJs iuitially drafred,

honre dctention legislatiou conrained no provisiort for judi;.r,1 intervendon. 'Judges ocpresscd

reservations regarding the autbority of thc correctioul r;hninistrator 1s imFosa or rcvokc

deteutioD, sc,nlcncing decisiono Dotrnally withiD thc puni :.,' of the court, Howancc, they find

.*.*r'acceptable as long as rhc discrction of the adurinis : :-or is linrited by the absohn€ hgnt of

court to rostrict or deoy participation in thc program.' (! :;r. Mem-, Hg, Of Aug. 2, 1988, p. 4.

Hubbard,230 Cal.App.3d at 298. "Thcreafter, subdivision tt', wae added giving judggr veto powsr

a defendant's cligibility to participale in the prograrn." lJvfi,' t'4230 Cal.App,3d 8t 298-

Any hotdin g iD Hubhud mu-st be read in the contex . rrf thc facu of that case, wberein the

ordered the conectiopal administralor 1o placc the probatir trrfi ia the home moniroring FogrsrD,

facts in that case src not the same as the feste ia this case, lrr tlis oase, thc court gxerciscd its

veto pgwsr rc deny l-Iilton elecuonio mouitoring. ln Hubbc, 'r; , thc court exceeded its Etstrrtory

by ordcring electronic rionitorilg.

IV

Eccitrse No Motiou War Filed by thc Loe Angelos Sber I'l'e Dcpartment or rlilton to Modi$ Thtr

Courl's SeDtcnclnt nnd Connitment Ordon, And The. .rrr Angeles Sbcriff p Departmcnt Pfnced

Hilton oo Elccttonic Monitoring, tbe Los Angeler iilrrcrfffs Departmenf Ir tD Coutenpl

Additionally, tbc Los Angeles Sbcriffs Dcpartrnent Ac .;:J Withoui Any Prior Notlflcatiun to thc

Los Augcles City Attorney's Office, 'Wbo Rapreeen J I be People of tbe State of California-

NoithEr the Los Angeles Sheriffs Department nor , irton filed any motioo to modify t}is court'

senterrciog ordet or comrtitment order. -I}e courl's ;rlris1 spccificolly denied llilton

monitoring. Ln violation of this courl's order arrd Californ t, ,aw prusuant to Ca.I. Peu. Codc 1203.016(c

and People v- I{ubbtttd (1991) 230 Cal.App-3d 287, the I.::i Arl.geles Shcrif s Deparurreut violared

corut order and permincd flilton io be on electroruc monit' . irrg.

Tbr Pcople's Ex Pene Application for Order Shonening , irqe, order to Show Cause Re: Contcmpt,and Ordcr ro Trnnspwt Paris Whiurey l.t'>tr in Cunody to Court

1

2

J

4

5

6

7

I

9

l0

1l

72

t3,

t4

l5

l6

r7l8

l9

2Q

2l

22

2t

24

25

26

2?

28

0B/01/2007 l6:51 FAX 2ts BZI 7952 LASC EXECUIIVE OFFICE @00?/o1o

Finally, it mw bc noted tb4t the Shcrilf s Departn, , ,' released Hilton.aud pereitted her to

plaoed oa electronic moniroring withour aay notrfication to ln Los Angelas City Attdraey's Office.

fact, thc People ia tbis,cute, represeutcd by thc Los Angele '.:ity Attorncy's Office, bad no lrrrowl

of rhc actions or inEntione of the SherilPs Departnocnt uDr: 'ihis norniug when it tearned of llilton'

reJease through Deu/s rePorts. At thc prass conferencc, the S :urifPs Deparrment asscr6d tbat Hilonallowed to lcave rhe Cr:nrury Regional Daention Centcr for r,r,disal rea-qons and nol overcto;dinB,

vIt [s Appropriate for Thlc Court to Order Hiltou to Be . 'fescDt for the Hearing ou This Mattcr

Pursuant lo Cnl. Pcn. Codc $ 977(n)(3)(B), (C). Thcrr l');rer This Court Shourd Ordcr the Loc

Angcles Sheriffs Depettment t(r Trrnsport Hiltou rr 'Custody to Court for thc Eenr{ng.

^. Under Cal. Pen. Code $ 1203.016, Hiltou is r',: custody of tbc Lor Angeles

Dcpartment. Because Ore Los Angeles Shcriffs Depa ":renl is in coutravention of tbis conrt,

sentenci.ug and commilmcnt ordcrs, this cor:rt sbould ord ,' the Los A.ogeles ShcrifPs Dcpartrnent

b'ansport Hilroq to thjs cotrvt for thc bearing on wby the Shc ii:'f should not be beld in crntqmpr.

this nrancr involvos the sentencing of Hilton for a violat :'r of Califoraia Vehiclc Code g 23103

spccified in Cal. Veh, Code $ 23103.5 afler bcing chargnl wirb violating Califomia Vchiclc Code

23152, this oourl may order Hilton to be present pursuant 1: .:al. Pcrr. Codo $ 977(a)(3)(B), (C1.

Hilton's disregard of thc laws of the State of Californjr ;and for the terrns and conditions of

probation, rhc Sherift's disregard of the laws of the State o ' I'alifonnia aud for this court's ordors, aod

ensure compliancc with aoy pa^sl present and fliture cow ,;.:rlcr, this court sbould order the Sheriff

transporl Hilton to court for thie hearing. Additionally, lrr: Pcople move this court for au order

Hilton should be rcnuned ro county jail at the Century Re1 , . nal Deteution Ccnter to finish her se

in compliancc with this cotttl's ordcr.

The Pcople't Er Paric Application for Ordcr Sborteniug 'm$ Order to Transpon Paris whioey I

, I

rre, Order to Show Causc Rc: Contempqlt)D in c\r6tody ro Coun

I

2

I

4

5

,6

7

I

9

l0

t1

12

t3

l4

r516

17

IE

r9

20

2l

22

J.)

24

25

26

77

28

06/07/2001 16 51 FAX 213 821 7952 LASC E)(ECUIIVE ( ]FFICE o 008/0 1 0

vt

Conclusion

The people of br Sbte of California apply to this cr .;'r for rhrec ordcrs: (f ) on Ordcr

Time; (2) an Order 1o the Los Angeles SherifPs Dcpartmc:r to Show Carxe Re: CoUernpt, end (3)

Orda to rbe Los Angeles Sberiffs Deparhnent to liaaspo llsris Wbitrey Hill,on in C\sfody to

fOr This Hcanru. Time is of the essEnc€ to ansufe comp,'rrrce with this corrrt'9 order.and ro

public confidence in tho faimess and equal teatnent of all I rrticipaots in the justice system.

DATE: Junc 7,2007

RsspecfilY s l:r:ritted, 'ROCI(ARD J. i;':,LGADILLO, City AtrorneyELLEN A. SA i I.{IENTO,

Supow : irg Assistnnt City AttorneyDAI.I F. JF.FFL,liS, Assisunf Ciq/ AttomeyDAVID A BC ii.'\}IICH, pcpur/ Ciry Anomcy

By \*DAN F. JEI'I]Assistant CitY '

uDltWhDAVTTTA. BC :i'\NICHDepuly Cirye:'(,rDeY

Anomeys for '.:,intiff.I}IE PN,OPLE :F THE STATE OF CALMORNIA

'r:, Ordcr ro Shq^t/ Cause Rc: Conrcmpl::r in OusrodY lo CourtT'lre Pcople's Ex Pane Applicatlou for ordcr.Shortening 1

and ordcr to TlaosPqn Pruis \ 4dmW H-8