Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 1
REPORT ON INDUSTRY CASE PRESENTATIONS
19 and 20 September, 2018, IIT Bombay, Mumbai
01 March, 2019, Prof Shyam R Asolekar
This report serves as a summary of the industry case presentations Deliverable 5.3
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 2
Table of Contents
1) Introduction
2) The Design and Contents of the Programme
3) Practitioners' Group Discussion
4) The Field Visit to the Pilot-Scale Constructed Wetland
5) Poster Session
6) Industry Visit
7) Evaluation of Speakers in the Capacity Building Workshop and Industry
Case Presentations
8) Summary
9) Selected Photographs
10) Appendix 1 – Schedule of the Programme
11) Appendix 2 – List of the Participants
12) Appendix 3 – Proforma of the Evaluation of Speakers (Day 1)
13) Appendix 4 – Proforma of the Evaluation of Speakers (Day 2)
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 3
INTRODUCTION
Indian Institute of Technology Bombay (IITB), a partner institution in the on-going
collaborative project entitled “Capacity Building in Sustainability and Environmental
Management” (CapSEM) - which is funded by Erasmus+ Programme of the European
Union; organized a two-day capacity building workshop and industry case presentations
programme entitled: “Urban & Rural Ecological Upgradation of Blue - Green Spaces
Through Water Reuse & Community Engagement: A Circular Economy Approach to
Building Smart Habitats”. The following institutions have contributed and participated in
this programme:
1) Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, Norway,
2) Makerere University, Uganda,
3) Makerere University Business School, Uganda,
4) Mbarara University of Science and Technology, Uganda,
5) Tata Institute of Social Sciences, Mumbai,
6) Tribhuvan University, Kathmandu
7) Rajiv Gandhi Science & Technology Commission, Mumbai, India
8) Earthwatch Institute India Trust, Gurgaon, India
9) Mann Deshi Foundation, Mhaswad, India
The IITB team engaged in CapSEM Project has made categorical efforts by
encouraging the students from the under-graduate, post-graduate and doctoral
programmes to participate in the capacity building workshop and industry case
presentations in order to encourage the lateral learning. The specific efforts have also
been made for encouraging the students in IITB to interact with the partner institutions
from CapSEM Project participating in the capacity building workshops and the industry
case presentations as well as the participants from the industry and regulatory
agencies.
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 4
This capacity building workshop and industry case presentations were attended by:
1. the faculty members from Centre from Environmental Science and Engineering
(CESE), Centre for Urban Science and Engineering (CUSE), Centre for Technology
and Rural Alternatives (CTARA),
2. under-graduate, post-graduate and doctoral students from CESE
3. doctoral students from other departments in IITB and other institutions
4. participants from municipality, regulatory agency, industry and consultancy firms.
THE DESIGN AND CONTENTS OF THE PROGRAMME
The two-day capacity building workshop and industry case presentations programme
was inaugurated at the Victor Menezes Convention Centre in Powai, a Suburb of the
City of the Mumbai, at the hands of Prof Suparna Mukherji (Head of Centre for
Environmental Science and Engineering, IITB).
The detailed schedule of the two-day capacity building workshop and industry case
presentations programme has been appended in „Appendix 1‟.
Total 17 technical presentations were made by the subject experts in six sessions of
technical deliberations. Through the group discussions, panel debates and plenary
presentations (of the break-away groups) were conducted in order to invoke the
participation of the delegates. In addition, participants were taken for the field visit at
the site of pilot-scale horizontal sub-surface flow constructed wetland on IIT Bombay
Campus. The design and contents of the two-day capacity building workshop and
industry case presentations programme was to provide knowledge eco-system for the
concepts in circular economy, preventive environmental management, capacity building
and stakeholder participation.
11 delegates from Uganda and two delegates from Nepal (program country-partners)
were the resource persons for the two-day capacity building workshop and industry
case presentations programme. Also, in all 20 persons (graduate students, researchers
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 5
and faculty members) participated from Centre for Environmental Science and
Engineering, IITB. In addition, 5 researchers from other departments in IITB and other
institutions participated in the programme. Furthermore, 16 participants were present
from industry and consultancy firms along with 3 Participants from Municipal
Corporation of Greater Mumbai and 3 Participants from regulatory agency (Maharashtra
Pollution Control Board).
The list of participants attending the two-day capacity building workshop and industry
case presentations programme has been appended in „Appendix 2‟.
Composition of the Participants in the Training Programme:
5 Faculty members and 15 Graduate students and researchers from CESE, IITB
5 Researchers from other departments in IITB and other institutions
2 Faculty members from Nepal
11 Faculty members and students from Uganda
3 Participants from Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai (MCGM)
3 Participants from regulatory agency (Maharashtra Pollution Control Board)
19 Participants from industry and consultancy firms
The Pie-chart depicting the composition of participants
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 6
The copies of bound volume of the “Lecture Notes” entitled: Urban & Rural Ecological
Upgradation of Blue - Green Spaces Through Water Reuse & Community Engagement:
A Circular Economy Approach to Building Smart Habitats, were distributed to all the
participants in the programme. The bound volume included the presentations of the
speakers in the programme as well as the literature reviews on the salient topics
including preventive environmental management, the theory and practice of circular
economy, natural treatment systems, wastewater management, solid waste
management, energy management as well as organizational improvements and
business strategies from the circular economy perspective.
PRACTITIONERS' GROUP DISCUSSION
The stakeholder perspective was articulated by conducting group discussion on “drivers
and obstacles in promoting eco-friendly technologies and waste minimization in the
industry”. The each group (a, b and c) was of nearly 15 participants. One elected
representative from each group has made presentations on conclusions of each group
at the plenary for the benefit of the entire audience. The summary of group‟s opinion at
the end of one-hour group discussion in the respective break-away groups is as follows:
below.
Summary of Practitioners' Group Discussion
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 7
Drivers Obstacles
Availability of eco-friendly technologies.
The availability of environmentally-sound
but cost effective technology is the most
important drivers of promoting the use of
sustainable technologies.
Lack of incentives is one of the biggest
obstacles in adopting the so-called
sustainable technologies. The cost of
sustainable technology affects the overall
cost of the final products. Additionally,
adapting to new technology would require
trained manpower, new setup, land etc.
End user – The behavior of the
consumers also motivates the industries
to opt for sustainable technologies.
Lack of commitment thinking. There is an
urgent need to adopt evidence-based
technology especially in the industries.
The technology alternatives can be
compared for their effectiveness and eco-
friendliness on the basis of life cycle
analysis and life cycle costing.
Government policies and compliance
requirement contributes significantly as
the driver of adopting the sustainable
technologies. The Regulatory compliance
demands for low emission technology to
be adopted by the industries.
Cost- It becomes unaffordable to provide
low cost products while abiding with the
stringent environmental standards which
require costly treatment technologies.
Man power is required for operation and
maintenance of installed facility. Also,
cost increases with treatment process.
The detailed cost analysis data is not
available.
Recycle and reuse - the new concept of
industrial symbiosis coming up with
potential use of waste from one industry
as a resource in other industry can also
act as a driver for adopting the sustainable
technologies.
Lack of political will, no motivation among
the industries and vendor-driven policies
are few other obstacles. Implementation
of laws is not strict and the penalties are
affordable as compared to other countries
where the owner of the company is
penalized and not the operator in case of
a breach. There is a communication gap
between industry and regulator.
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 8
THE FIELD VISIT TO THE PILOT-SCALE CONSTRUCTED WETLAND
On first day of the programme i.e. 19th September, 2018, the participants visited the
pilot-scale constructed wetland (CW) research station at IIT Bombay and actively
discussed its potential for treating and reusing the municipal wastewater and
significance for such an intervention in given community towards implementation of
concepts of circular economy. The CWs have been seen as the panacea for escalating
flows of sewages and industrial effluents emitted by communities and industries. The
eco-centric wastewater treatment technology entitled “CW4Reuse” for management of
domestic effluents employing horizontal subsurface-flow CW beds has been developed
at IIT Bombay and is being demonstrated in three locations in India, namely, a) the
Town of Mhaswad (District of Satara), State of Maharashtra, India (sewage flow rate
250 m3/d), b) Charotar University of Science & Technology, District of Anand, State of
Gujarat (sewage flow rate 100 m3/d) and c) “Sant Gulab Baba Aashram”, At Post. Katel,
District of Buldhana, State of Maharashtra (sewage flow rate 25 m3/d).
The Dr Sanjay Mukerjee, Additional Municipal Commissioner of Municipal Corporation
of Greater Mumbai (MCGM), announced in his presentation on 20th September, 2018
that the technology of constructed wetland developed by Prof Asolekar‟s group at IIT
Bombay would be implemented at larger scale by MCGM for treatment and reuse of
municipal wastewater. This was prompted by the capacity building of his officers on the
prior day during the visit to the pilot-scale research station and the presentation on
circular economy during the capacity building programme.
The participants at the site of pilot-scale horizontal sub-surface flow constructed wetland
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 9
POSTER SESSION
About 20 posters (size: 600 mm x 900 mm) were displayed on poster-display boards in
the foyer at the venue (Victor Menezes Convention Centre on IITB Campus) of the two-
day international capacity building and industry case presentations programme by some
of masters and PhD students participating from the Centre for Environmental Science
and Engineering in the programme.
There was great response from the participants and every one appreciated the efforts of
students. The topics related to circular economy and sustainable development were
presented in the posters installed at the display. The findings from the on-going
research and development activities at Centre for Environmental Science and
Engineering, IIT Bombay in the Research Group of Prof Asolekar were displayed on the
poster-display boards.
The participants and guest speakers viewing the posters during the session breaks
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 10
INDUSTRY VISIT
On 20th September, 2018, the participants in the capacity building workshop and
industry case presentations visited the wastewater treatment and reuse plant
functioning in the most prestigious twin 5-star hotel in Mumbai (The Trident Hotel and
Oberoi Shereton Hotel). The twin 5-star hotel services nearly 1000 rooms and by the
virtue of the sophisticated wastewater treatment and reuse facility constructed and
operated in the basement of Hotel, it is considered as the most spectacular example of
reusing facility for treated wastewater achieving the so-called near-zero liquid discharge
from the Hotel. The designer and operator of the facility (Mr Ajit Khandeshe) presented
the concept and technical details in industry case presentation at IITB on 19th
September, 2018 and all the participants were taken to the south Bombay to see facility
at twin 5-star hotel on the following day.
Participants at wastewater treatment and recycling plant of the Trident Hotel and Oberoi
Shereton Hotel
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 11
EVALUATION OF SPEAKERS IN THE CAPACITY BUILDING WORKSHOP AND
INDUSTRY CASE PRESENTATIONS
All the participants have evaluated all the presentations of the capacity building
workshop and industry case presentations conducted during 19th and 20th September,
2018. It is the usual practice at IIT Bombay that the organizer of a given programme
makes categorical efforts to improve upon the relevance, depth and effectives of the
capacity building programme based on the feedback received from the participants.
The participants were given the prescribed tabular format for recording their ratings of
each presentation in every technical session of the two-day programme. Accordingly,
the anonymous evaluation forms were collected at the end of the programme and
reviewed.
The evaluation of speakers in the prescribed formats at the two-day capacity building
workshop and industry case presentations programme have been appended in
„Appendixes 3 and 4‟.
Additionally, the survey was conducted for the participants. The most important
environmental priorities - which were listed by participants during the survey are as
follows:
1) Water treatment, recycling and reuse
2) Cleaner production processes
3) Environmental Management
4) Solid waste management
5) E-waste collection and disposal
6) Sustainable development
7) Low energy use and carbon footprint
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 12
8) Green marketing
9) Community engagement
10) Zero liquid discharge
11) Lake rejuvenation
12) Resource utilization and conservation
13) Rainwater harvesting
SUMMARY
The very fact that the two-day capacity building workshop and industry case
presentations programme was extremely successful as evidenced by the participants
from various stakeholders. In this programme, the Additional Municipal Commissioner
of Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai and Member Secretary of Maharashtra
Pollution Control Board presented their action programmes towards improvement of
sustainability in the jurisdiction of the Corporation of Greater Mumbai (25 million
population) and the State of Maharashtra (120 million population), respectively.
The highpoints of the capacity building workshop and industry case presentations
conducted in IITB during 2018 have been the presence and participation of
environmental consultants and innovative project implementing companies. More
importantly, the most significant bureaucrats as well as regulators participated by
presenting their case studies suggests that the stakeholder from academia, government
and industries perceived value in the programme year after year.
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 13
SELECTED PHOTOGRAPHS (1/2)
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 14
SELECTED PHOTOGRAPHS (2/2)
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 15
APPENDIX 1 – SCHEDULE OF THE PROGRAMME
Co-funded by the Rajiv Gandhi Science and Technology Commission
Co-funded by the Earthwatch Institute India Trust
Co-funded by the Indian Institute of Technology Bombay
TWO-DAY INTERNATIONAL CAPACITY BUILDING WORKSHOP
19TH
& 20TH
SEPTEMBER, 2018
URBAN & RURAL ECOLOGICAL UPGRADATION OF BLUE - GREEN
SPACES THROUGH WATER REUSE & COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT: A CIRCULAR ECONOMY APPROACH TO BUILDING SMART HABITATS
ORGANISED BY: INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY BOMBAY
CENTRE FOR ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & ENGINEERING
IN ASSOCIATION WITH:
RAJIV GANDHI SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY COMMISSION, MUMBAI, INDIA
EARTHWATCH INSTITUTE INDIA TRUST, GURGAON, INDIA
MANN DESHI FOUNDATION, MHASWAD, INDIA
NORWEGIAN UNIVERSITY OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY,
TRONDHEIM, NORWAY
UNIVERSITY OF LISBON, LISBON, PORTUGAL
TATA INSTITUTE OF SOCIAL SCIENCES, MUMBAI
TRIBHUVAN UNIVERSITY, KATHMANDU, NEPAL
KATHMANDU UNIVERSITY, KATHMANDU, NEPAL
MAKERERE UNIVERSITY, KAMPALA, UGANDA
MAKERERE UNIVERSITY BUSINESS SCHOOL, KAMPALA, UGANDA
MBARARA UNIVERSITY OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY, MBARARA, UGANDA
DELFT UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY, NETHERLANDS
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 16
Venue: Victor Menezes Convention Centre
Hall No. 23 (Second Floor) (Opposite CESE & IDC) IIT Bombay Campus,
Powai, Mumbai 400076
Dates: 19th & 20th September, 2018
(Wednesday & Thursday)
Wednesday, 19th September, 2018 DAY ONE
08:30 – 09:00 Registration and Tea/Coffee
09:00 – 09:15 Welcome and Introduction to the Workshop
Prof. Shyam R. Asolekar (about 5 min) Coordinator of the two-Day Programme Centre for Environmental Science & Engineering (CESE) Indian Institute of Technology Bombay
Round of Introduction (about 10 min)
Participants
09:15 – 09:30 What are the priority areas in “Environmental Management” in your sector?
Survey based on the individual‟s perspective (mode: questionnaire filling by the participants) Facilitators: PhD Scholars, IITB
09:30 – 10:15 How do We Fulfil our Commitments to SDGs?: Opportunities for Environmental Management in India’s Industries & Municipalities
Prof. Shyam R. Asolekar CESE, IIT Bombay
10:15 – 10:30
Inauguration Ceremony
Prof. Suparna Mukherji, Head, Centre for Environmental Science & Engineering (CESE) Indian Institute of Technology Bombay
Prof. B V S Viswanadham Dean (IPS), IIT Bombay
10:30 – 11:00 Tea/Coffee
11:00 – 11:30 Urban ecological upgradation through natural treatment systems: Case study on Powai Lake and Banganga Lake
Lekshmi B. and Prof. Shyam R. Asolekar, CESE, IIT Bombay
11:30 – 12:00 Industry Case Presentation: Implementation of WWTP technologies aiming at Circular economy: Some success stories
Mr Nitin Umbralkar Vice-President, Ion Exchange (India) Limited, Mumbai
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 17
12:00 – 12:30 Industry Case Presentation : The State-of-Art Facility for Reuse of Treated process water in Industry
Mr Ajit Khandeshe, Managing Director, Kwan Environmental Solutions India Private Limited, Ambernath (East) 421 506 State of Maharashtra, India
12:30 – 13:00 Industry Case Presentation : Country Presentation for Nepal
Prof Arun Timalsina & Prof Gokarna B Motra Tribhuvan University, Nepal
13:00 – 13:40 Lunch
13:40 – 14:00 Realization of the Benefits of Circular Economy through Reuse of Source Separated Wastewaters using Constructed Wetlands: A Model
Lekshmi B. and Prof. Shyam R. Asolekar, CESE, IIT Bombay
14:00 -14:20 Industry Case Presentation: Country Presentation for Uganda
Makerere University, Uganda
14:20 -14:40 Industry Case Presentation: Country Presentation for Uganda
Makerere University Business School, Uganda
14:40 – 15:00 Way towards sustainable development: Experiences at industries in the Uganda
Mbarara University of Science and Technology, Uganda
15:00 – 15:30 Water Recycling Efforts by MCGM
Dr. Sanjay Mukherjee, IAS Additional Municipal Commissioner (Projects), Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai (MCGM), Mumbai
15:30 – 16:00 Tea/Coffee
16:00 – 16:30 Significance of “CW4Reuse Technology” for Enhancing Reuse of Treated Wastewaters: Case Studies
Rahul Sutar and Dr D R Ranade and Prof. Shyam R. Asolekar CESE, IIT Bombay and Chetna Gala-Sinha Mann Deshi Foundation, Mhaswad
16:30 – 17:00 Panel Discussion: “Drivers and obstacles on the path of selection of sustainable technologies”
Moderators: Mr D P Misra, Environmental Consultant, Mumbai and Prof. Shyam R. Asolekar
17:00 -17:30 Address by the Guest of Honour: “Regulatory Priorities and Tasks for MPCB”
Dr. P. Anbalagan IAS Member Secretary Maharashtra Pollution Control Board, Mumbai
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 18
17:30 – 17:45 Tea/Coffee
17:45 – 18:30 Visit to the Constructed Wetland on IITB Campus
18:30 – 19:00 Fellowship, Networking & Relaxing Free time for lake-side walk
19:00 – 19:45 Dinner 2nd Floor Foyer VMCC, IIT Bombay
Thursday, 20th September, 2018 DAY TWO
09:00 – 09:45
Management of Legacy Wastes for Resource and Material Recovery
Richa Singh, Prof Bakul Rao and Prof. Shyam R. Asolekar CESE, IIT Bombay
09:45 – 10:30
The Framework and Solutions for Facilitating the Implementation of Ban on Plastics and Thermocol in Maharashtra
Prof. Shyam R. Asolekar CESE, IIT Bombay
10:30 – 11:00
Tea/Coffee
11:00 – 12:00
Plenary Session
Prof. Suparna Mukherji, Head, CESE, IIT Bombay Dr. Anil Kakodkar Chairman, Rajiv Gandhi Science & Technology Commission, Mumbai Prof. Dr.Ing. Annik Magerholm Fet Department of Industrial Economics and Technology Management (IØT) Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU) N-7491 Trondheim, Norway Title: Way towards sustainable development
(via recorded video)
12:00 – 12:30
Industry Case Presentation: Experiences of Zero Liquid Discharge (ZLD) Systems for
Mr Ravishankar Vaidya Director, Ecotex Pte. Ltd. Singapore and Ecotex
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 19
Textile Industry: Success stories and future opportunities
Environmental Technologies blr Pvt. Ltd., Bengaluru, India
12:30 – 13:15
Practitioners' Group Discussion: Drivers and obstacles in promoting eco-friendly technologies and waste minimization in the industry
Leaders: Mr Yogen Parekh, Environmental Consultant, Mumbai and Prof. Shyam R. Asolekar
13:15 – 14:00
Lunch
14:00 – 14:30
Role of Environmental Science & Technology as the Tool while Transitioning to Sustainable Futures
Prof. Shyam R. Asolekar CESE, IIT Bombay
Valedictory Session
14:30 – 15:00
Role of Environmental Policy & Law as the Tool while Transitioning to Sustainable Futures
Dr. Ajay Deshpande, Consultant, Asian Development Bank
Q&A Session
15:00 – 15:15
Concluding remarks & Distribution of Certificates
15:15 – 15:30
Tea/Coffee
15:30 – 18:00
Industry Visit : Wastewater treatment and recycling plant (Optional)
Hotel Trident (Oberoi Sheraton Hotel), Nariman Point, Mumbai
18:00 onward
Free time for Site Seeing in South Mumbai
CONTACT PERSONS
Prof. (Dr.) Shyam R. Asolekar
Indian Institute of Technology Bombay Centre for Environmental Science & Engineering Powai, Mumbai 400 076 (Phone) +91-22-2576 7867 (E-mail) [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]
Logistics and Directions
Rahul S. Sutar: +91 95959 39389
Richa Singh +91 99206 58638
Lekshmi B. +91 82915 30667 Shruti Sharma +91 96434 65741
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 23
APPENDIX 2 – LIST OF THE PARTICIPANTS
Sr. No. Name Affiliation Country
1 Vinod Mane Reliance foundation India
2 Arshad Moolji A.M. Ozonics Pvt. Ltd India
3 R M. Nivedha Ramanathan
Ecotex Environmental Technologies Pvt. Ltd.
India
4 Sanjay Sheth Shree Sai Siddhi Pvt. Ltd. India
5 Rashmi Mishra HSE Manager, L&T Hydrocarbon Engineering
India
6 Dasika Sampat Kumar Sr. DGM, L&T Hydrocarbon Engineering
India
7 Bhalchandra Pedgaonkar
Managing Director, ARTS Watermatics Pvt Ltd.
India
8 Ravindra Janardhan Parab
Supriya Lifescience Pvt. Ltd. India
9 Simranjit Singh Research Scholar, NIT Jalandhar India
10 Chandani Parekh Paani Foundation India
11 S. Yogeswari Scientist C (Environmental Planner), National Centre for Sustainable Coastal Management, Chennai
India
12 Debasis Tudu Scientist C (Environmental Planner), National Centre for Sustainable Coastal Management, Chennai
India
13 Rekha Desai Rizvi College of Architecture, Mumbai
India
14 A. Gurunathan Director, The Dhan Academy, Madurai
India
15 S Elamuhil The Dhan Academy, Madurai India
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 24
Sr. No. Name Affiliation Country
16 Faizaan Ali Contractor MAC Traders, Mumbai India
17 Prasad V. Parab Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai
India
18 Sushil L. Ubale Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai
India
19 Uday S Patil Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai
India
20 Ajay Deshpande Consultant, Asian Development Bank
India
21 Dilip R Ranade Consultant (Research), National Centre for Microbial Resource, Pune
India
22 Yogen Parikh Environmental Consultant, Mumbai India
23 Arun Sapre Member Secretary, Rajiv Gandhi Science & Technology Commission, Mumbai, Govt of Maharashtra
India
24 D P Misra Environmental Consultant, Mumbai India
25 Yeswant B. Sontakke Joint Director (Water), Maharashtra Pollution Control Board
India
26 N. N. Gurav Sub-Regional Officer - Co-Ordination, Maharashtra Pollution Control Board
India
27 Amar R. Supate Principal Scientific Officer, Maharashtra Pollution Control Board
India
28 Ayush Singh CESE, IIT Bombay India
29 Prasenjit Ghosh CESE, IIT Bombay India
30 Prashant Sinha CESE, IIT Bombay India
31 Vipin Singh CESE, IIT Bombay India
32 Richa Singh CESE, IIT Bombay India
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 25
Sr. No. Name Affiliation Country
33 Rahul S. Sutar CESE, IIT Bombay India
34 Lekshmi B. Nair CESE, IIT Bombay India
35 Shruti Sharma CESE, IIT Bombay India
36 Deepanjan Saha CESE, IIT Bombay India
37 Ketan Kamble CESE, IIT Bombay India
38 Ansaf V Karim CESE, IIT Bombay India
39 Subhojit Bhowmick CESE, IIT Bombay India
40 Vinay Yadav CESE, IIT Bombay India
41 Vinay Kumar CESE, IIT Bombay India
42 Chetan Prakash Sharma
CESE, IIT Bombay India
43 Gautamdev Chakravarty CESE, IIT Bombay India
44 Darpan Das CESE, IIT Bombay India
45 Ariz Tauqir CESE, IIT Bombay India
46 Rajhans Negi CESE, IIT Bombay India
47 Amruta Garud CTARA, IIT Bombay India
48 Rakesh Kumar Civil Engineering, IIT Bombay India
49 P Pallavi Climate Studies, IIT Bombay India
50 Charles Tushabomwe-Kazooba
Mbarara University of Science and Technology, Mbarara
Uganda
51 Moses Ntaro Mbarara University of Science and Technology, Mbarara
Uganda
52 Provia Kesande Mbarara University of Science and Technology, Mbarara
Uganda
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 26
Sr. No. Name Affiliation Country
53 Bosco Amerit Makerere University Business School, Kampala
Uganda
54 Dennis Nuwagaba Makerere University Business School, Kampala
Uganda
55 Jimmy Moses Otim Makerere University Business School, Kampala
Uganda
56 Pearl Ankunda Byabashaija
Makerere University Business School, Kampala
Uganda
57 Maya Balunywa Makerere University Business School, Kampala
Uganda
58 Mukiibi Ssewannyaga Ivan
Makerere University, Kampala Uganda
59 John Mary Kiberu Makerere University, Kampala Uganda
60 Josephine Mary Rose Ariao
Field Operations Manager, Kalangala Oil Palm Growers Trust Ltd, Kalangala
Uganda
61 Arun Timalsina Tribhuvan University, Kathmandu Nepal
62 Gokarna B. Motra Tribhuvan University, Kathmandu Nepal
63 Shyam R. Asolekar CESE, IIT Bombay India
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 23
APPENDIX 3 – PROFORMA OF THE EVALUATION OF SPEAKERS (DAY 1)
Po
or
Be
low
Ave
rage
Ave
rage
Go
od
Exce
llen
t
1 2 3 4 5
Speaker: Prof. Shyam R. Asolekar
How do We Fulfil our Commitments to SDGs?: Opportunities for
Environmental Management in India’s Industries & Municipalities
Relevance and Contents 8 15
Effectiveness of Presentation
9 12
Question & Answer Interaction
2 9 9
Speaker: Lekshmi B. and Prof. Shyam R. Asolekar
Urban ecological upgradation through natural treatment systems:
Case study on Powai Lake and Banganga Lake
Relevance and Contents 1 13 8
Effectiveness of Presentation
3 9 8
Question & Answer Interaction
4 8 8
Speaker: Mr Nitin Umbralkar
Industry Case Presentation:
Implementation of WWTP technologies aiming at Circular
economy: Some success stories
Relevance and Contents 2 8 10
Effectiveness of Presentation
1 15 8
Question & Answer Interaction
3 8 11
EVALUATION OF PRESENTATIONS
Day 1: Wednesday, 19th September, 2018
Two-day international capacity building workshop entitled: “Urban & Rural Ecological Upgradation
of Blue - Green Spaces Through Water Reuse & Community Engagement: A Circular Economy
Approach to Building Smart Habitats” Organized by CESE, IIT Bombay
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 24
Speakers: Mr Ajit Khandeshe
Industry Case Presentation :
The State-of-Art Facility for Reuse of Treated process water in
Industry
Relevance and Contents 1 13 5
Effectiveness of Presentation
1 10 11
Question & Answer Interaction
2 9 11
Speaker: Prof Arun Timalsina & Prof Gokarna B Motra
Industry Case Presentation: Country Presentation for Nepal Relevance and Contents
2 8 10
Effectiveness of Presentation
2 10 8
Question & Answer Interaction
2 9 9
Speakers: Lekshmi B. and Shyam R. Asolekar
Realization of the Benefits of Circular Economy through Reuse of
Source Separated Wastewaters using Constructed Wetlands: A
Model
Relevance and Contents 1 9 10
Effectiveness of Presentation
2 13 7
Question & Answer Interaction
1 10 11
Speaker: Participants from Makerere University, Uganda
Industry Case Presentation: Country Presentation for Uganda Relevance and Contents
2 9 9
Effectiveness of Presentation
3 9 7
Question & Answer Interaction
1 10 12
Speaker: Participants from Makerere University Business School,
Uganda
Industry Case Presentation: Country Presentation for Uganda
Relevance and Contents 1 10 11
Effectiveness of Presentation
1 11 10
Question & Answer Interaction
2 10 8
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 25
Speaker: Participants from Mbarara University of Science and
Technology, Uganda
Industry Case Presentation: Way towards sustainable
development: Experiences at industries in the Uganda
Relevance and Contents 2 8 8
Effectiveness of Presentation
2 10 7
Question & Answer Interaction
2 9 7
Speakers: Rahul S. Sutar and Shyam R. Asolekar
Significance of “CW4Reuse Technology” for Enhancing Reuse of
Treated Wastewaters: Case Studies
Relevance and Contents 1 5 11
Effectiveness of Presentation
2 6 9
Question & Answer Interaction
2 5 9
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 26
APPENDIX 4 – PROFORMA OF THE EVALUATION OF SPEAKERS (DAY 2)
Po
or
Be
low
Ave
rage
Ave
rage
Go
od
Exce
llen
t
1 2 3 4 5
Speaker:
Richa Singh, Prof Bakul Rao and Prof. Shyam R. Asolekar
Management of Legacy Wastes for Resource and Material
Recovery
Relevance and Contents 14 14
Effectiveness of Presentation
15 10
Question & Answer Interaction
2 11 12
Speaker: Aravindhan Nagarajan and Prof T Jayaraman
A Case Study of the Plastic Ban in Maharashtra Relevance and Contents
5 8
Effectiveness of Presentation
4 7
Question & Answer Interaction
2 1
Speaker: Prof. Shyam R. Asolekar
The Framework and Solutions for Facilitating the Implementation of
Ban on Plastics and Thermocol in Maharashtra
Relevance and Contents 2 8 20
Effectiveness of Presentation
3 10 17
Question & Answer Interaction
4 14 12
EVALUATION OF PRESENTATIONS
Day 2: Thursday, 20th September, 2018
Two-day international capacity building workshop entitled: “Urban & Rural Ecological
Upgradation of Blue - Green Spaces Through Water Reuse & Community Engagement: A
Circular Economy Approach to Building Smart Habitats” Organized by CESE, IIT Bombay
01 MARCH, 2019, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 27
Speakers: Mr Ravishankar Vaidya
Industry Case Presentation: Experiences of Zero Liquid Discharge
(ZLD) Systems for Textile Industry: Success stories and future
opportunities
Relevance and Contents 1 14 16
Effectiveness of Presentation
15 14
Question & Answer Interaction
14 14
Speaker: Dr. M. V. S. S. Giridhar
Role of Citizen Scientists in Facilitating Blue-Green Balance in
Urban Habitats
Relevance and Contents 5 4
Effectiveness of Presentation
5 4
Question & Answer Interaction
3 5
Speakers: Shyam R. Asolekar
Role of Environmental Science & Technology as the Tool while
Transitioning to Sustainable Futures
Relevance and Contents 2 13 15
Effectiveness of Presentation
1 16 14
Question & Answer Interaction
2 14 12
Speaker: Dr. Ajay Deshpande
Role of Environmental Policy & Law as the Tool while Transitioning
to Sustainable Futures
Relevance and Contents 1 14 18
Effectiveness of Presentation
11 18
Question & Answer Interaction
13 13