Remarks on Observation - MANCER Consulting

Phase -IV

Department PMU LeadRemarks on Observation

S.N

o.Unique ID Candidate

Category

Applied

Category

Recommend

ed

Score

before

Observation

BVM Observation Remarks by Mancer Change in Score/ Status

Score Post

Observation

in Merit list

BVM Re-ObservationRemarks by Mancer on Re-

Observation

Change in Score/

StatusScore Post Reobservation

Period of work experience is not clear.

Joining letter under Jeevika,BRLPS and work

experience certificate must be attached with

application form. Agency has given marks under this

category.

Experience letter has not been shared as Candidate is still working in BRLPS & Supporting

document(Salary Slips) to establish duration of experience has been uploaded on FTP. No change

Creamy layer certificate is not attched.Candidate has been asked to share Non creamy layer certificate and same has been uploaded

on FTP No change

again working experience under 'Young

Professionals' is fit to experience under project

monitoring and Data/MIS/business anlalysis or not

must be reviewed.

Candidate has been designated as 'Young Professionals' in BRLPS,Jeevika and had been involved

in project monitoring and Business analysis.

Supporting document for the candidate's role as a "Young Professional" under project

monitoring and Data/MIS/business analysis in BRLPS has been uploaded on FTP.

No change

2 17104468 Suman Prity BC BC FEMALE 52 Ok ok No change 52Marking summary needs to

change since Date of birth and

Application ID is wrong.

Changes have been incorporated in

marking summary and same has

been uploaded on FTP.

No Change

The attached work experience Certificates doesn’t

establish the role of the candidate in her

firms.whereas score for the same has been given.

the agency should verify it.

Experience in project monitoring etc and

subsequent marks given under it should not be

given .

Candidate's role in Ram Manohar Lohia Vichar Shodh Sansthan has not been established under

project monitoring and data/business analysis. Hence, 5 marks has been reduced from the role

criteria and updated marking summary has been uploaded on the FTP.

Candidate has been designated as "Project officer" in Mata Manakka Devi Seva Sansthan and

had been involved in project monitoring work in this organisation. asked to share the supporting

document for Mata Manakka Devi Seva Sansthan regarding her work experience as a "Project

Officer" which can establish her role in project monitoring and the same will be uploaded on

FTP.

5 marks has been reduced for

role criteria.

The caste cum creamy layer certificate is of year

2008. the economic status of a person may vary year

to year.so current creamy layer certificate is

required.

Candidate has been asked to share Non creamy caste certificate and same has been upload on

FTP No change

The agency should also certify that both the firms

where the candidate was posted actually run on

ground.

Credential of the organisation has been uploaded on FTP and same will be verified during the

background verification.No change

Candidate work experience seems inappropriate for

this post. The marks alotted under this categories

must be reviewed.all these NGOs credential must be

checked.Working experience under State/central

govt. or bilateral agency is absent.No point should

be given here.

Candidate has been asked to share the required document which can establish the existence of

both the NGOs she had worked with and the same has been uploaded on FTP.No change

Attached MBA certificate copy is not visible clearCandidate has been asked for the clear copy of MBA passing certificate and same has been

uploaded on FTP. No Change

Non Creamy Layer Certificate is not Attached. Candidate has been asked for the NCL certificate and same has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

The role of the candidate in his past work

experience is not clear.

Candidate has worked as accountant/data manager

in NGO.the credential of NGO must be

checked.Secondly,the post is for Department PMU

Lead.Marks alotted in project monitoring and

Data/MIS/Business analysis column and marks

alotted in work experience under State/central govt.

or Bilateral/Multilateral agencies should not be

given.It must be reviewed properly and fresh marks

should be assigned.

NGO "NJSSMVSSS LTD" is registered under Section- 5 of Bihar Swawlambi Sahakari Samiti

Adhiniyam 1996 and its registration no is BR-06-03-01-OTH-05-2008. Supporting document

regrding NGO Credential has been uploaded on FTP.

Candidate work experience with NGO has not been considered under role in Project monitoring

and data/MIS/business analysis. Hence, 25 marks has been reduced in role criteria and 10 marks

has been reduced in bilateral/multilateral criteria. Updated marking summary has been

uploaded on FTP.

Marks before observation was 68 and post observation is 33.

25 marks has been reduced

in role criteria and 10 marks

has been reduced in

bilateral/multilateral criteria.

Non Creamy Layer Certificate is not Attached.Candidate has requested not to consider him under reserved category and supporting mail

confirmation has been attached on FTPNo Change

Appointment letter required of E-serviceCandidate's certificate for completing probation period in E-Service has been already uploaded

on FTP where DOJ is mentioned as 1-Sep-2003.No Change

The reliving date for employment duration for Bihar

Medical Service & Infra corporation limited is not

avilable.

Candidate is still working in BMSICL so releiving letter can not be produced. Salary slip of

Nov,2017 has been uploaded on FTP to establish duration of experience. Role in Project

Monitoring & Data/Business Analysis could not be established. Hence 25 Marks for role in

Project Monitoring & Data/Business Analysis has been reduced and 10 marks for experience of

working with State /Central/Bilateral/Multilateral/Multinational / Private Organization has been

reduced.

35 Marks Reduced

Candidate DOB is 15-04-1975 Even if he is

considered as preferred according to DOB

category,his position should be below the all

candidates who are 40 yr of age on 01-01-2018 .

This criteria should be applied to all candidate.

We have been following the same procedure while ranking the candidates in the merit list. No Change

Candidate has done PGDM from Deccan Education

society's Institute of Management development and

Research Pune,India. Whether this institute is

recognized or not. Must be ascertained .(affiliated

to any university or Deemed university.)

The Institute of Management Development and Research, Recognised institute in Pune was

established as a constituent unit of the Deccan Education Society in May, 1974 and affiliated to

AICTE and DTE (Maharashtra)

No Change

Creamy layer certificate must be Up to Date because

income vary every year.It is of 2010 .It should be of

current year.

Candidate has been asked to share NCL and same has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

whether the experience as 'Young Professional' in

BRLPS comes under Experience in project

monitoring and Data /MIS/Business analysis. It

should be reviewed.

Candidate has been designated as Young Proffessional in BRLPS and had been involved in

project monitoring and data/business analysis.

Supporting document regarding role has been uploaded on FTP>

No Change

whether the certifiacte of candidate as PGD in Rural

Management will be considered or not for this

post.this must be reviewed.

Candidate has done Post Graduate Diploma in Rural Management which has been considered

under essential qualification criteria for this post.No Change

NCL certificate is not readable

which is uploaded on FTP.

Organisational Credential

document not found on FTP

OK

E-Service organization date of

relieving is not clear with

attached document

OK

1 17102086 Rajani Singh BC FEMALE

3 17105451 Sneha Shriti BC FEMALE

BC

4 17106069

5 17102952

BC

BC open

Bipin kumar Mahto BC OPEN

Manish Sinha BC OPEN

6 1710410 Mohammed Mainaz BC OPEN

52

52

68

79

BC

BC

72

52

47

33

44

72

NCL Certificate is not required as

candidate has not been considered

for Fit for further evaluation

Process.

Candidate has shared an experience

certificate

which establishes duration of

experience and

supporting document to establish

credential of

NGO has been uploaded on FTP.

Candidate gets salary in cash and

hence cannot

produce Bank Statement and

doesn't have salary

slips. and Hence experience of

working with Mata Manakka Devi

sansthan has not been

considered as Valid and Hence

candidate has not

been considered for further

evaluation Process

Moved to Not Fit for

further evaluation

Process

Not Fit

Supporting document(Income Tax

Return slip issued by company) to

establish duration of experience till

Mar 2005 has been uploaded on

FTP

Phase -IV


Current Non Creamy Layer Certificate is not Attached. Candidate has been asked to share NCL and same has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

The attched documents doesn’t establish the work

experience and moreover the role of the

candidate.the agency should review and make

avialable the missing/cooroborating

documents.Again the score given by the agency cant

be justified.

No evidence of work experience of Shyama Surgical

& Chemical attached with application.the above

facts suggest that candidate does not have the

required 3 years of post qualification experience.

Hence,his application should be rejected at once.

Agency should be asked on which ground they are

forwarding such type of application for interview.

As per Experience letter shared, Candidate work experience in DNDI is from 1-3-13 to 21-12-

2017 and in Budha Buddha Jan Swasthya Evam Sarvagin Vikas Kendra is from 25-6-11 to 30-7-12.

Supporting document regarding duration of work has been uploaded on FTP. Experience letter

of Shyam Surgical & Chemical has been asked to share from the candidate and the same has


Candidate does not have role in Project monitoring and data/MIS/business analysis. Hence, 25

marks has been reduced from role criteria and 10 marks has been reduced from

bilateral/multilateral criteria. Updated marking summary has been uploaded on FTP.

As per the Job description experience in specific domain is not mandatory, Hence candidate has

been considered for further evaluation Process


in role criteria and 10 marks

has been reduced in

bilateral/multilateral criteria.

The agreement letter of DNDI is from 1.03.2016 to

28.02.2017.while experience marks has been

alotted from 1.03.2013 to 9.10.2017.this is totally

unacceptable and fraud.

As per agreement letter shared, Candidate initial date of joining is 1-3-2013 and he has been

employed till 28-2-2017.

Candidate employment has been extended from Feb,2017 to dec,2017 so experience for

marking has been calculated from 1-3-2013 to 31-12-2017.

Supporting document regarding duration of work in DNDI (Extension letter) has been uploaded

on FTP.

No Change

Work experience in NGO Buddha Jan Swasthya

Evam Sarvagin Vikas Kendra is from 25.06.2011 to

25.07.2012 only.the credential of NGO must be

checked.

Work experience in NGO Buddha Jan Swasthya Evam Sarvagin Vikas Kendra is from 25.06.2011

to 30.07.2012 as per the experience letter and the same has been already uploaded on FTP.

Credential of organisation will be checked during the background verifitaion.

No Change

Again,there must be a clarity on the point 'private

organisation' which kind of private organisation can

be taken for giving score under work experience.

As per the preferred marking criteria in the job description, no specifications has been given on

the type of private organisations for the consideration. So, all type of private companies has

been considered.

No Change

Candidate age is above 40 years.Candidate has applied under BC category and age is below 43 on 01-01-2018 and Hence

considered for further evaluation Process.No Change

Essential educational certificate is not readable.

The essential PGD /Masters degree has not been

attached.it should be reviewed carefully.

Readable Master Degree certificate has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

Current Non Creamy Layer Certificate is not Attached. Candidate has been asked to share NCL and same has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

The experience Certificate is upto 10-3-15.But the

time period calculation has been done upto 18-10-

17. How?so this should be reviewed & overall marks

should be reviewed.

Supporting document (Payslip of Nov,2017) to establish duration of work has been uploaded on

FTP. Hence, marking has been done from 10-3-15 to 18-10-17.No Change

Whether experience in PHC west champaran as

project monitoring comes under the Experience in

project monitoring and Data /MIS/Business analysis.

If not, then it should be reviewed.

Candidate has been designated as Block health Manager in PHC and has been involved into

project monitoring and Data /MIS/Business analysis. Supporting document regarding role has


No Change

An old Creamy layer certificate of year 2008 has

been attached with this application.whereas the

economic state of a person varies every year.so a

current creamy layer certificate should be attached.

Candidate has requested to move him into unreserved category and the mail confirmation by

the candidate has been uploaded on the FTP.Moved to UR Category

Work experience under NGO should be reviewed

properly.candidate is not working State/Central govt

or bilateral/multilateral agencies.so marks should

not be allotted under this column.

Experience of working with CASA is an NGO and Hence this experience has not been considered

as State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral/Private/Multinational Organization and Hence 10 Marks

has been reduced.

No Change

documents related to MRHFL emlpoyment is not

avialable. Only pay slip of month oct 2017 is

enclosed.Date of joining is not mention in pay

slip.Hence marks allotted for preferred marking on

total experience should be reviewed.

Candidate has shared salary slip of Nov,2015 & Oct,2017 to establish duration of work

experience in MRHFL.

Hence marking for total experience has been calculated from 2-11-2015 to 14-10-2017

No Change

Marks allotted for experience in project monitoring

and Data /MIS/Business analysis is wrong. Marks

should be allotted 15 instead of 25

Total marks should be reviewed.

Total experience into project monitoring and Data /MIS/Business analysis is 3Years, 4Months,

26Days. Hence 15 marks has been alloted under role criteria.

Updated marking summary has been uploaded on FTP.


from role criteria

Creamy Layer Certificate is not Attached. Candidate has been asked to share NCL and same has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

Also the certificate of the candidate as Post

graduation diploma in Forestry management with

major specialisation in development

management.This shows that the candidate has

done the development management regarding

Forestry. The basic degree is pGD in Forestry

management .so this should be reviewed carefully.

whether forestry management will be considered or

not for this post.

Candidate has been asked to share the supporting document which can justify PGDFM is

equivalent to MBA and the same has been uploaded on FTP.No Change

Whether the experience as 'Young Professional' in

BRLPS comes under the Experience in project

monitoring and Data /MIS/Business analysis. If not,

then it should be reviewed.

Candidate has been designated as Young Proffessional in BRLPS and had been involved in

project monitoring and data/business analysis.

Supporting document regarding role has been uploaded on FTP.

No Change

M/s Shyama Surgical & Chemical

organization duration of

experience is from 1st August,

2012 to 28th Februray, 2013 as

per attached document.

OK

CASA is non-governement

organization and as per JD

private organization experience

is considered. Hence this NGO

experience may be considered as

private organization.

OK

Shailendra Kumar Singh BC OPEN

7 17101202

Shambhu Kumar BC OPEN

BC

BC

BC

BC

Ranvijay Kumar Singh BC OPEN

9 1710347

10 17105641 Shashi Kumar Yadav BC OPEN

8 17106242 74

78

72

78 43

74

68

62




Candidate has worked CASA which

has been considered under

State/Central/Bilateral/Multiateral/

Private/Multinational organization

in Project monitoring &

Data/Business Analysis as per the

marking criteria of Department

PMU Lead. Updated marking

summary has been uploaded on

FTP

78

No Change

CASA has been

considered in

State/central/bilater

al/private

organisation. Thus,

10 marks has been

awarded and the

updated marking

summary has been

uploaded on FTP.

Phase -IV


Actual date of joining in SDJ INFRATECH Pvt. Ltd.

And Date of relieving is also not clear.

Work experience certificate of SDJ Infratech,ERA

Infratech engineering Ltd. Is not clear while

experience certificate describes diff. dates of

certificate describes issuing ,work experience

coumns give different dates. It must be reviewed.

Similarly Date of relieving from ERA is also not

clear.

Candidate has been asked to share the supporting documents for SDJ infratech and Era infra

engineering which can justify the joining date and relieving date in these companies and the

same has been uploaded on FTP.

No Change

candidate has done Post graduation Programme in

management of Business Finance(MBF). whether

this degree is in Confirmity with Job description of

Department PMU Lead must be reviewed and

ascertained minuetly.

As per the Essential qualification criteria Master’s degree (full time) in Management / Business

Administration / Finance / Economics / Public Policy / Social Work / Development Studies /

Rural Development. Hence candidate's Post graduation Programme in management of Business

Finance(MBF) has been considered.

No Change

Degree certificate of MBA is not available. Only

marksheet of MBA Fourth semester has been

attached.

Candidate has applied for MBA degree Certificate till then he had provided Degree Verification

Certificate and if selected candidate will produce certificate at the time of Joining.No Change

Non Creamy Layer Certificate is not Attached.it is must.Candidate has been asked to share Non Creamy Layer Certificate and same has been uploaded

on FTPNo Change

Experience as in Reliance as per attached document

[10/8/07-08/05/10] Discrict Health Society Nalanda

[17/08/10-21/06/17] which is under 10 years.so

overall exp. Marking should be 30 not 35 .It should

be reviewed.

As per attached documents, Candidate total duration of work experience is 10Years and 28Days

as he had been employed in Reliance is from [10/8/07-08/05/10] and in District Health Society

is from [17/08/10-21/06/17]. Hence, 35 marks has been correctly awarded based on post

qualification experience.

No Change

Whether exp. As District Planning Coordinator

comes under Experience in project monitoring and

Data /MIS/Business analysis. It should be reviewed.

Candidate has been designated as "District Planning Coordinator" in District Health Society and

had been involved into project monitoring and data/business analysis and supporting document

regarding role has been uploaded on FTP.

No Change

Candidate age is more than 40 years.Candidate is 43

yrs 11 months 13 days

Age of candidate is more than 43 year which is more than Preferred Age criteria as Job

description and Hence candidate has been moved to Bottom of Merit ListNo Change

Pass certificate of degree of master of social work is

not avialable.Marksheet of social work part 2 is

attached.

Candidate has been asked to share Master degree Certificate and same has been uploaded on

FTP.No Change

Experience certificate of State health society,patna

is not avaliable. Only offer letter is attached.

Candidate has been asked to share state health society last month salary slip and same has been

upload on FTP.No Change

Marks awarded for experience in project monitoring

and Data/MIS/Business analysis is not clear.

Candidate has been designated as Social worker, Field Cordinator, and Community Mentor

which does not comes under project monitoring/data/business analysis and hence no marks has

been awarded under Experience in project monitoring and Data /MIS/Business analysis

35 Marks Reduced


on FTP.No Change

Candidate exp. In state Society for ultra poor &

social welfare, Patna (02-05-13 to 10-03-17) and

State health Society (08-03-14) hows it possible? It is

overlapping. It should be reviewed.

As per Review, candidate had been employed in State society for ultra poor & social welfare

from (2nd May 2013 to 10th Mar 2017) and in State health Society from (16th Mar 2017 to 14th

Oct 2017). Hence duration of work experience is not overlapping and supporting documents has


No Change

Whether exp. As Field Cordinator in Aathik

Anushandhan Kendra Allahabad comes under

Experience in project monitoring and Data

/MIS/Business analysis. It should be reviewed.

Candidate has worked as Field Cordinator in Arthik Anushandhan Kendra Allahabad which does

not come under Experience in project monitoring and Data /MIS/Business analysis. Hence, 25

Marks has been reduced from project monitoring role and 10 Marks has been reduced from

State/Central/Private sector.Hence updated marking summarry has been uploaded on FTP

25 marks reduced from role

10 marks reduced from

private

organization/Govt./Multilatra

l

creamy layer certificate must for reservation benefit.Candidate has been asked to share Non Creamy Layer Certificate and same will be uploaded on

FTP.No Change

Matriculation CertificateCandidate DOB has been already mentioned on 10th marksheet which is a valid document &has

been uploaded on FTP. Hence matriculation document not required.No Change

Candidate is working as office executive in

BUIDCO.Office Executive Post work must be

analyzed as whether they are fit for Department

PMU Lead.

Candidate had been designated as Office Executive in BUIDCO which does not comes under

project monitoring and data/business analysis. Hence, role could not be established and 10

marks has been reduced from state/central/multilateral/private organisation.

10 marks additional has been awarded for NIRF Ranking.

Marks before observation was 35 and post observation is 35

10 Marks reduced from

govt./private organization

10 Marks awarded for NIRF

Revalidated Score =35

Non Creamy Layer Certificate is must but it is not Attached. Candidate has been asked to share Non Creamy Layer Certificate and same has been uploaded

on FTP.No Change

Whether exp. As State project manager (PI)comes

under the regd. Experience in project monitoring

and Data /MIS/Business analysis. If not then marks

should be reviewed.

Candidate has worked as state project manager which comes under Project Monitoring and

Data/MIS/Business Analytics. Candidate has been asked to share role supporting document and

same has been upload on FTP

No Change

Masters degree certificate shows at one place

"University of Pune", examination held by university

of pune in the month of April,07. But, the degree is

Master in Marketing (Revised 2005-06). Also,at

other place, the degree has been attached is Post

Graduation diploma in business Administration

(June,07) Sinhgad Institute of Business

Administration and Research .whether both degrees

are same?

Sinhgad Institute is affliated to Pune University(Currently known as Savitribai Phule Pune

University).

Sinhgad university offeres 1years(PGDBA) programme along with MMM(2years full time course)

these two courses are simultaneously & supporting document has been uploded on FTP

No Change

Also any college attached to the Pune University

(Sinhgad Institute of Business Administration and

Research) can get (NIRF) 20 marks Like Pune

University itself. It should be reviewed.All colleges

attached are not equal in quality of education.

Any college which comes under pune university can be provided marks based on NIRF ranking No Change

NCL Certificate not uploaded on FTP.

OK

SDJ & Infratech duration of

experience is still not clear with

attached document.

Experience duration of Reliance

needs to be reviewed as wrongly

considered.

Moved to bottom of Merit List

among the candidate of same

marks.

BC

12 17102376 Abhishek Azad MBC OPEN

13 17103825 Ajay Kumar Saxena MBC OPEN

11 17101984 Sushil Kumar BC OPEN

14 17106333 Bibha Kumari MBC Female

15 17101045 Gyan Prakash MBC OPEN

MBC

MBC

MBC

MBC

79

78

79

78

43

35

78

35

76 76

Candidate has shared salary slips of

March which establishes duration of

experience till 31st March 2010 and

same has been uploaded on FTP.

Candidate doesn't have experience

of

No Change

Experience of working with Reliance

has been considered from 10-09-

2007 to 11-08-2010 and supporting

document(Accepted copy of

resignation has been uploaded on

FTP). Marking summary with

correct duration of experience has


No Change

Changes have been incoporated in

Merit List.

Candidate has not shared NCL

certificate even after several

reminders and Hence has been

considered under Unreserved

Category

Moved to

Unreserved

Category

79

78

Phase -IV


Period of experience In BRPLS -Jeevika is not clear.Candidate is still working in BRLPS-Jeevika so experience / relieving letter can not be produces.

To establish work experience, Candidate has been asked to share BRLPS-Jeevika last month

salary slip to establish duration has been uploaded on FTP.

No Change

creamy layer certificate must for reservation benefit.Candidate has been asked to share Non Creamy Layer Certificate and same has been uploaded

on FTP.No Change

Candidate's experience certificate of working in

Indian Institute of Health Management, Jaipur has

been signed by state cordinator, State office Patna

while candidate has worked in Jaipur.This exp.

Certificate must be verified for Jaipur Branch first

then only marks can be alotted.

Candidate was on deputation with patna. Hence experience certificate can be issued by local

authorities and same will be verified at the time of background verification process.

IIHM Jaipur experience has been not considered for role in Project Monitoring & Data/Business

Analysis. Experience with DHS, BRLPS and SRKPS has been considered under role in Project

Monitoring & Data/Business Analysis. 5 Marks has been reduced under role criteria.

5 Marks reduced

Candidate has attached only the contract letter of

appointement which has been issued on 30-09-2013

and it says that contract for appointment to block

project manager is valid upto 30 Sept. 2013.but

marks has been alotted taking into consideration.

Candidate has been asked to share BRLS-Jeevika last month salary slip and candidate is working

from 6th Dec 2013 to till now.Hence last month salary slip has been uploded on FTPNo Change

Creamy layer certificate has not been attached

because creamy layer depends on income and

income vary every year.so current certificate is

necessary.

Candidate has been asked to share Non Creamy Layer Certificate and same has been uploaded

on FTP.No Change

Candidate was Gramin Awas Sahayak (IAY) in Block

office,Mohania. The exp. Certificate is upto

15/03/16.but the marking summary sheet shows

that last date upto 08/06/17.How? IT should be

reviewed. Document to establish last date in DC

office Ramgarh and DRDA Kaimur

As per exp-erience letter shared, Candidate has been designated as Gramin Awas Shayak(IAY) in

Block Office from (26th feb 2014 to 8th jun 2017).

Candidate is still working in DC Office Ramgarh so relieving letter can not be produced as last

month salary slip has been uploladed on FTP to establish the duration.

No Change

Whether exp. As Gramin Awas Sahayak & E- Block

Manager comes under the Experience in project

monitoring and Data /MIS/Business analysis. If not

then marks should be reviewed.

Candidate worked asGramin Awas Sahayak & E- Block Manager which does not comes under

Project Monitoring and Data/MIS/Business analysis role in Project Monitoring & Data/Business

Analysis. Hence, 15 marks has been reduced from role marking criteria and 10 marks has been

reduced for role in Project Monitoring & Data/Business Analysis with

private/state/central/multilateral organisation.

Marks before observation was72 and post observation is 47.

Updated marking summary has been uploaded on FTP.Overall Marks should be Reviewed. Overall marks has been reviewed and updated marking summary has been uploaded

Date of birth in matric certificate is illegible. Candidate has been asked to share 10th Certificate and same has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

Only statement of marks M.A Social work 2nd year

has been attached.No master degree certificate has

been attached.

Candidate has been asked to share Master Degree Certificate and same has been uploaded on

FTP.No Change

No Caste certificate(with Non creamy layer)has been

attached.without Caste certificate(with Non creamy

layer).How can this application has been considered

so far?Its very surprising.

Candidate has been asked to share Non Creamy Layer Certificate and same will be uploaded on

FTP.No Change

Joining Letter in Jeevika has not been attached.only

offer letter is there .only pay slip of jan,18 has been

attached in which no joining date is there.

Candidate has shared NOC with Date of Joining mentioned in certificate and same has been

uploaded on FTPNo Change

whether exp. In district health society as district

planning coordinator and management health &

Nutrition in jeevika comes under the Experience in

project monitoring and Data /MIS/Business analysis.

If not then marks should be reviewed.Also overall

marks should be reviewed.

Candidate has worked as "District Planning Coordinator" in district health society And "Manager

Health & Nutrition" in Jeevika which has been considered under the experience in Project

Monitoring and Data/MIS/Business Analysis, supporting document has been uploaded on FTP.

Post qualification marks have been reviewed again 5 marks has been reduced based on post

qulification experience of the candidate.

5 Marks reduced from post

qualification experience

Revalidated Score:74

19 17101012 Md. Rashid Khalil MBC MBC OPEN 73creamy layer certificate must for reservation

benefit,which is not attached in application form.


on FTP.No Change 73 OK


on FTP.No Change

Experience certificate of the firm District Rural

development agency, Lakhisarai is not signed or

countersigned.so,it cant be accepted as an

experience certificate.

Candidate has been asked to share experience letter of District Rural development agency,

Lakhisarai which should be duly signed by concerned authority and same has been uploaded on

FTP.

No Change

Martric CertificateDOB is already mentioned on marksheet of 10th Class which is a valid document & is already

uploaded in application form & FTP. Hence matriculation document is not required.No Change

Master Degree in social work in rural development

from Tata Institute of Social science

Candidate has been asked to share Master Degree Certificate and same has been uploaded on

FTP.No Change

Non Creamy Layer Certificate is not Attached.which

is necessary for the claim of reservation.


on FTP.No Change

Candidate worked as 'Young Professional' under

BRLPS.whether this experience is suited for Job To

be decided.

Candidate worked as Young Professional under BRLPS and Experience as young professional has

been considered under Project monitoring/data/business analysis.Hence supporting document

has been uploaded on FTP

No Change

Non Creamy Layer Certificate is not Attached.which

is necessary for the claim of reservation.


on FTP.No Change

Whether exp. As BPM in Jeevika and Program

Manger in Vikas Sahyog Kendra comes under the


/MIS/Business analysis. If not then marks should be

reviewed.

Candidate has worked as BPM in Jeevika comes under project monitoring and Data

/MIS/Business analysis and Candidate has worked as Program Manger in Vikas Sahyog Kendra

which has been considered as in project monitoring and Data /MIS/Business analysis.

No Change

Ok

OK

NCL Certificate is not uploaded

on FTP.

OK

OK

OK

16 17104864 Karuna Shankar MBC OPEN

17 17105545 Md. Moquarrab Danish MBC OPEN

21 17107149 Priyanka Sharma UR Female

22 17103183 Ramanek Kumar MBC OPEN

18 17101102 Md. Nurul Hoda MBC OPEN

20 17106631 Mrinal Satyarthi MBC OPEN

MBC

MBC

MBC

MBC

MBC Female

MBC

79

72

79

73

62

78

62

78

74

47

74

73

15 Marks reduced from mis

role


Private organization

Total Revalidated score-47

Candidate has been asked to share

Non Creamy layer certificate and He

has applied for the same and same

will be uploaded within this week

on FTP.

No Change

Phase -IV


Application Form is not attached.Candidate had applied for District PMU Lead and we have collected all the documents from

there so we considered this candidate as offline No Change

C.V is not attached. C.V has been already uploaded on FTP.Hence no need to ask again No Change

Date of birth is wrong on evaluation sheet.Candidate DOB has been checked again and updated marking summary has been uploaded on

FTPNo Change

Provide any document like Salary slip/TDS slip of

experience Certificate Candidate has shared experience certificate & Same has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

There is overlap of working experience certificate

issue from CDPO Office Makhdumpur and Primary

health Cantre, Hulasganj.Secondly The applicant is

lady supervisor of CDPO office and her experience

certifiacate can be issue only by parent office and

not by any other any other office.these errors must

be corrected .whether this type of candidate is fit to

became Department PMU Lead of Job description .It

must be analyzed properly.

Candidate has worked as part time with Primary Health Center Hulasganj.Hence 10 marks has

been reduced from post qualification experience and Candidate is working as Lady Supervisor in

CDPO so experience is not in project monitoring lead/Head And/OR project monitoring &

Capacity building in state/central govt./bilateral/multilateral/private organization/multinational

corporation.Hence 5 marks has been reduced from govt./private sector and 5 marks has been

reduced from the role critereia. Hence Updated marking summary has been uploaded on FTP

10 Marks reduced from post

qualification experience


Central/Bilateral criteria


from the role critereia.

Revalidated Score-20

Non Creamy Layer Certificate is not Attached.Candidate has been asked to share Non Creamy Layer Certificate and same has been uploaded

on FTP.No Change

The candidate has attached the certificate of M.A

(Rural studies) whereas the required qualification is

master in rural Development.Both are two different

certificate.it should be reviewed.

Master of Arts in Rural studies comprises of Rural Management & Development, Hence this

course has been considered for further evaluation Process.supporting document has been

uploaded on FTP

No Change

No marking summary sheet is attached.first attach

marking summary of the candidate.After then it wil

be checked.

Marking summary has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

Non Creamy Layer Certificate is not Attached.Candidate has been asked to share Non Creamy Layer Certificate and same has been uploaded

on FTP.No Change

Martriculation Certificate

DOB is already mentioned on marksheet of 10th Class which is a valid document & is already

uploaded in application form & FTP. Hence matriculation document not required. Post

qualification experience has been reviewed additional 10 marks has been awarded. Updated

Marking summary

10 Marks Awarded

Only Marksheet of PGD (BM) has been

attached.degree certificate has not been attached.Candidate has shared Passing Certificate and same has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

Candidate PGD(BM) session is 2004-2006 and

candidate experience (Attached) in Real Anchors (19

Nov 2005 - 07 june 2016) How can it be possible?It

is only possible that the PGD(BM) degree is part

time ,not full time. It should be reviewed very

carefully.

Candidate has completed MBA in year 2008. His

working experience of Real Anchors Developers Pvt.

Ltd.'s Tenure is 19 Nov 2005 to 07 June 2016.it is

pre qualification experience Rest experience of

Bihar Vikas Mission is less than 3 years. The

candidate does not possess minimum qualification.

Candidate got the placement during his final semester and started working on 19 Nov 2005.

Experience has been calculated from May 2006 based on Marksheet. Updated Marking

summary has been uploaded on FTP.

Candidate had completed MBA in 24 th May 2006 as per the Marksheet and Hence experience

post qualification has been considered from 24th May.

No Change

Whether exp. As Senior Manger in Corporate

Investment& Finance comes under the regd.


/MIS/Business analysis. If not then marks should be

reviewed.

Candidate has worked as Senior Manager in Corporate Investment & Finance which not been

considered under role in Project Monitoring and Data /Business analysis . Where as experience

AM Schemes with BVM has been considered as Role Project monitoring & Data/Business

analysis. Hence 20 marks has been reduced for role in Project Monitoring & Data/Business

Analysis and 5 Marks has been reduced for experience with State/Central/Bilateral and

Multilateral experience.

20 Marks reduced from role

5 marks reduced from private

organization/Govt./Multilatra

l

Whether Real Anchors Developers comes under

multilateral/Bilateral govt. Organistion. It should be

reviewed and marking too.

Candidate doesn't have Project Monitoring & Data/MIS with Real Anchors Developers and

Hence this experience has not been considered for marking under State/Central/Bilateral and

Multilateral experience.

No Change

28 17103314 Anita UR UR Female 68Candidate has applied as a named Anita however in

her document Clearly mentioned Anita Pratima

Minz .Name has to be rectified

Correct name of applicant as per the document is Anita Pratima Minz.If selected, candidate will

produce an affidafit at the time of JoiningNo change 68

As per the application form

employment history, , the

applicant had mentioned UNICEF

experience duration as 01-06-

2010 to 31-12-2010. Provisional

offer of employment as District

Coordinator in BCC Program for

UNICEF under MaFoi has been

provided. The above mentioned

experience has not

beennincluded in the marking

summary and may be revised

accordingly.

Candidate doesn't have salary slip/

any other supporting document to

establish duration of experience

with Unicef(On the Payroll of

Mafoi), Hence this experience has

not been considered for marking

calculation.

No Change 68

Pass certificate of M.A. (Rural Development) is not

available. Only statement of marks has been

attached

Candidate has been asked to share passing Certificate of Degree and same will be uploaded on

FTP. No change

Supporting document is required to establish the

role of Project monitoring and data /MIS / business

analysis from the organisation Jan Jagran Samiti

Patna. Primary health center sabalpur Patna

experience as a community mobilizer may be

included in the marking summary.

Experience of working with JanJagran Samiti Patna has not been considered into role of Project

Monitoring & Data/Business Analysis. Experience of working with PHC as Block Community

Mobilizer has been considered as role in Project Monitoring & Data/Business Analysis and same

experience has been considered under State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral

experience.Supporting document has been uploaded on FTP. Additional 10 marks has been

awarded for role in Project Monitoring & Data/Business Analysis.

Additional 10 Marks awarded

PGDM Passing Certificate is not attached. Candidate has been asked to share PGDM Degree and same has been uploaded on FTP. No change

NCL Cetificate is not attached Candidate has been asked to share NCL and same has been uploaded on FTP. No change

Application form not attached Candidate has applied as an offline candidate and hence Application form has not been attached No change

31 1710260Minakhshi Kumari

ChoudharyUR UR Female 78 O.K. O.K No change 78 OK Ok No Change 78

OK

OK

OK

OK

OK

Senior Manager role to be

reviewed again.

23 160014 Rashmi Kumari MBC Female

24 160013 Sarita Rani MBC OPENMBC Female

26 17106719 Sunil Kumar Sharma MBC OPEN

27 17101144 Sunil Kumar MBC OPEN

MBC

MBC

Non Creamy Layer Certificate is not Attached.it is must. Candidate has shared NCL and same has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

MBC Female

75

67

78

40

53

20

75

77

69 79

75 75

29 17106712 INAKSHI KUMARI SC UR Female

30 160013 Sarita Rani MBC UR Female

Duration of experiece in the

capacity of Senior Manager could

not be established and secondly

role in Project Monitoring could not

be established from role supporting

documents and Hence no additional

Marks has been awarded

No Change

Ok No Change 79

Phase -IV


NCL Cetificate is not attached Candidate has been asked to share NCL and same has been uploaded on FTP. No change

Matriculation certificateDOB is already mentioned on marksheet of 10th Class which is a valid document & has been

already uploaded o FTP. Hence matriculation document not required.No change

Degree of M.A. in Social work in Rural Management

from Tata Institute of social scienceCandidate has been asked to share M.A Degree and same has been uploaded on FTP. No change

33 17107006 Ragini Kumari UR UR Female 62 O.K. O.K No change 62 OK

Document considered for DOB is not readable.

Matric Certificate is not available on FTP.Document

attached to establish the date of birth is not

readable.

Candidate has been asked to share Readable Matric documents and same has been uploaded on

FTP.No change

RMSA' readable document requiredCandidate has been asked to share Readable "RMSA" documents and same has been uploaded

on FTP.No change

Document considered for DOB are not available. Candidate has been asked to share Matric documents and same has been uploaded on FTP. No change

It is not clear from the documents provided by the

candidate that when did she left the organisation

Bihar Mahila Samakhya society

As per the experience certificate issued from Bihar Mahila Samakhya Society experience till 15-

09-2012 could be established and only this experience has been considered for marking

calculation and Hence 10 marks Reduced based on Post qualification Experience.

10 Marks Reduced

Documents of S.K. Medical College Hospital

Muzaffarpur provided by the candidate instead of

population service International Bihar. She worked

as a Counsellor in this organisation. The role of

experience in project monitoring and

data/MIS/Business analysis is not clear.

Candidate has worked in S.K. Medical College &

Hospital as a Counsellor. It is not clear with her

experience to establish the role of

data/MIS/business and in project monitoring.

Candidate worked experience has to be reviewed.

Candidate had working on Payroll of Population Service International Bihar but was deputed in

S.K Medical college and Hence experience certificate had been issued from SKMCH

Muzaffarpur. Disclaimer email sent by candidate has been uploaded on FTP. Candidate had

worked as Councellor and Hence this experiece has not been considered as role in Project

Monitoring & Data/Business Analysis. Hence 15 marks has been reduced and 10 marks has been

reduced for experience of working with

State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral/Private/Multinational Organization in Project Monitoring &

Data/Business Analysis. Updated marking summary has been uploaded on FTP.

35 Marks Reduced

Score awarded should be reviewed. Score reviewed at 35 marks has been reduced

Duration of experience is not clear with the

attached experience Certificate of 'Bihar Samakhya

Society'

Experience certificate has Issue date and Date of Joining is mentioned in the certificate which

establishes duration of experience.

Role of the candidate in her past job is not clear in

the provided work experience certificates.

Role in Project Monitoring & Data/Business Analysis could not be established from supporting

documents. Hence 25 marks has been reduced and 10 marks has been reduced for experience

of working with State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral/Private/Multinational Organization in

Project Monitoring & Data/Business Analysis. Updated marking summary has been uploaded on

FTP.

35 Marks Reduced

Applicant age is more than 40 years as per required JDAge of candidate is more than 45 year which is more than Preferred Age criteria as Job

description and Hence candidate has been moved to Bottom of Merit List

Moved to Bottom of Merit as

per list Preferred Age Criteria

As per attached documents , the date of joining in

JEEVIKA is not clear. It should be clear by taking a

work experience certificate from the candidate.

Candidate has shared appointment letter of Jeevika in which date of joining is mentioned and

salary slip to duration of experience has been uploaded on FTP.No change

PGDM degree Certificate is not attached. Candidate has been asked to share PGDM Degree and same has been uploaded on FTP. No change

38 17101842 Jaya Sharma UR UR Female 73 O.K. O.K No change 73 OK

39 17106407 Nazish Bano UR UR Female 73

Experience certificate of Women Development

Corporation Bihar states that she left the

organisation on 15th oct. 2009 and her another

certificate of Bihar Mahadalit Vikas mission states

that she joined the organisation on 15th sept. 2009 .

This needs to be rectified.

Experience certificate of WDC & Bihar Mahadalit

Vikas Mission date is overlapping. Experience

certificate has to be verified.

Candidate has worked with WDC from 20-09-2004 to 14-10-2009 as there had been typing error

in certificate. Disclaimer email from candidate has uploaded on FTP. Candidate will share

updated experience certificate of WDC and same has been uploaded on FTP.

No Change 73 OK

40 1710807 Pummi Tiwari UR UR Female 64

Candidate has provided HAFELE India Pvt. Ltd.

Appointment letter & Payslip. In appointment letter

Designation is mentioned as a Executive Training

and at the same time in Payslip designation is

mentioned Assistant Manager -Cross Media.

Experience certificate has to be rechecked to

establish the role of Project Monitoring and

Data/MIS/business analysis.

Candidate has been asked for the supporting document for justifying her role into Project

amangement and data/MIS/business analysis and same has been uploaded on FTP.No change 64 OK

41 17103676 Vandana Kumari UR UR Female 61Instead of matric certificate , mark statement has

been provided

DOB is mentioned on marksheet of 10th Class which is a valid document & is already uploaded

on FTP. Hence matriculation document not required.No change 61 OK

42 17105529 Preeti Sharma UR UR Female 78

Pass certificate of M.A. (Social Science) is not

available. Only statement of marks part. II has been

attached.M.A. ( Social Work ) Degree Certificate

required.

Candidate has been asked to share MA Degree and same will uploaded on FTP. No change 78 Degree Certificate Required.

Candidate has applied in University

for Degree Certificate and if

selected may produce at the time of

Joining.

No Change 78

Documents considered for DOB is not available.Candidate has shaerd 10th Certificate in which Date of birth mentioned and same has been

uploaded on FTP.No change

Pass certificate for MBA is not available . Only

statement of marks is attached. Year of passing

Essential qualification could not be established due

to printed document's low visibility.

Candidate has applied for Passing Certificate and if selected will produce document at the time

of Joining and readable document of Marksheet has been uploaded on FTP.No Change

Documents confirming the employment tenure at

Tractors & farm equipment Ltd. Patna & Bilt graphic

paper product ltd, balarshah are not available . Only

offer letter has been attached.

Supporting to establish duration experience TAFE, Patna and BILT Graphic Paper Ltd has been

uploaded on FTP.No Change

44 17101538 Kamal Kishore SC SC Open 76

Document supporting Employement tenure at

BRLPS is not available . Only offer letter has been

attached.

BRLPS work experience from 14 october 2008 to 11

June 2012 document required.

Candidate has been asked to share Experience certificate/Relieving letter to establish duration

of experience and same will be uploaded on FTP.No Change 76

OK

Updated marking summary

required with PSI experience

detail and its duration.



marks.

OK

OK

57

78 43

68 68

62

73

62

73

22

32 17107149 Priyanka Sharma MBC UR Female

34 17103607 Priya Kumari UR UR Female

35 17104876 Sarita Kumari UR UR Female

36 17107393 Tarannum Naseem UR UR Female

43 17101321 Aditya Kumar Das SC SC Open

UR Female37 17106331 Ruby Kumari SC

7878



been uploaded on FTP. 5 Marks has

been reduced based on Post

qualification Experience.

17


Merit ListNo Change

Phase -IV


Bihar Mahila Samakhya Society is a registered

autonomous body under Societies Registration Act

1860. It's not a govt. or bilateral/multilateral org. So

marks should be reviewed.

Experience of working with Bihar Mahila Samakhaya Society (Ministry of HRD, GoI) has been

considered as experience of working with State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral organization and

Hence 10 marks has been awarded correctly

No Change

Also the role of the candidate in her last job is not

clear . Marks in this regard should also be reviewed.

Candidate had been designated as District Program Co-ordinator in Bihar Samakhya Sociey and

had been involved in Project Monitoring & Data/Business Analysis. Supporting document has


No Change

Data Analyst Preferred marking summary is attached

. Needs to be changed.Updated marking summary has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

Pass certificate of M.A.(Rural Development) is not

available . Only marks statement has been

attached.

Passing certificate of M.A(Rural Development) has been uploaded on FTP

Essential Post qualification experience is less than 3

yrs. So this application is liable to be rejected.

Candidate has in total 7 Years and 4 Months experience and Hence candidate has been

considered for further evaluation Process.

Candidate Work experience in Primary Health

Centre agency has mentioned the date from

30.05.2010 to 31.08.2015 whereas in attached

document duration of experience is from

01.09.2015 to 15.10.2017. So based on attached

Work experience marks needs to be reduced.

Candidate has shared document to establish experience of working with PHC Bandra and PHC

Sahebganj and is still working with PHC. Supporting document has been uploaded on FTP.

Data Analysts preferred marking summary is

attached . Needs to be changed.Updated marking summary has been uploaded on FTP.

The final exam of MBA or equivalent held in March

,2005. However, the candidate was appointed as

Project Monitoring Officer on 21.12.2004. So, this

experience can't be reckoned as post qualification

work experience . So, the post qualification

experience should be count from the further fresh

appointment which would be based on MBA or

equivalent.

Candidate got the placement during his final semester and result was published 09th Sep 2005

and Hence experience has been calculated from 10th Sep 2005 of WDC post qualification.No Change

Again, his work experience of BRLPS as a District

Project Manager should be count the date of joining

has been given on his pay slip.

Candidate had not shared any document in application form, Hence this experience has not

been considered for marking calculation.No Change

Experience certificate of BRLPS is not available .

Only offer letter and Pay slip of month Dec 2017 has

been attached.

Candidate is still working in BRLPS-Jeevika so experience/relieving letter can not be produces.

Supporting document to establish duration has been uploaded on FTP.

25 marks should be added in experience in Project

Monitoring and data/MIS/Business analysis.

Candidate had been designated as Manager HR & Admin and had been responsible HR Project

Monitoring & Data/MIS and Hence this experience has been considered under role in Project

Monitoring & Data/MIS/Business Analysis. Additional 15 Marks awarded.

15 Marks awarded

10 marks should be added in experience as Project

Monitoring lead/head and/or Project Monitoring &

Capacity Building Aspects in State/Central Govt.

Organisation.

10 Marks has been awarded under State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral experiece 10 Marks awarded

BRLPS work experience needs to be counted for

Project Monitoring and data/MIS/business analysis

and at the same time BRLPS experience can be

counted for state/government. Marking summary

needs to be revised. Additional marks will be given

for those two columns. Data Analyst preffered

marking summary is attached. Needs to be changed.

Updated marking summary has been uploaded on FTP.

49 17106110 BIRENDRA RAM SC SC 62

BRLPS, Patna (23 Feb 2015 to 17 Oct, 2017)

Candidate has provided Pay Slip of August from

which it is not clear last date of working in BRLPS.

Experience certificate or Salary Slip is required to

establish duration of experience.

Duration of experience with BRLPS, Patna has been considered till 16-09-2017(Salary certificate

issue date) has been considered for marking calculation. Updated marking summary has been

uploaded on FTP.

No Change 62

50 17104181 Manoj Kumar SC SC 74

The agency has mentioned the working experience

till 15.10.2017 whereas the attached work

experience certificate certifies the period till

10.07.2015. So, the agency should attach the

relating documents to validate the given score ,

otherwise marking should be done on the given

/provided experience certificate.

Recent salary slip has been uploaded on FTP to establish duration of experience. No Change 74

DAVV,Indore comes under NIRF ranking . Marks has

to be awarded for this university . Data Analyst

preferred marking summaryis attached. Needs to be

changed.

Marks for NIRF ranking has been updated in Marking Sumaryand same has been uploaded on

FTP in correct format. Additional 10 marks has been awarded.10 Marks awarded

Matriculation certificateMarksheet of 10th in which has been already uploaded on FTP in which Date of birth is

mention. Hence 10 th Ceritificate is not required.

Degree certificate of DAVV,Indore specialisation

"finance"Passing certificate of MBA has been uploaded on FTP.

52 1710806 RUCHI KUMARI SC SC 42Data Analyst Preferred marking summary is attached

. Needs to be changed.Updated marking summary has been uploaded on FTP. No Change 42

Pass certificate of M.B.A is not available . Only

Marks statement of semester IV has been attached.Passing certificate of MBA has been uploaded on FTP.

Experience of Budha Institute of Pollution Control &

Social Welfare Development is pre qualification

experience.

Candidate had passed examination in Sep 2006 and experience has been calculated from Oct

2006 for marking calculation based on experience of working with Budha Institute of Pollution

Control & Social Welfare Development.

Score awarded should be reviewed. Score has been reviewed. 15 marks based on Post qualification experience has been reduced.

5715 Marks Reduced.

45 17103682 SUPARNA SC SC

46 17107217 BINOD PASWAN SC SC

47 17106211 SANJAY PRASAD PASWAN SC SC

48 17101585 Munmun Kumari SC UR Female

51 17101588 JAYSHREE CHORMA SC UR Female

53 17101516 YASHWANT KUMAR SC SC

42

No Change 62

42

62

77

35

52

72

62

72

60

Phase -IV


The candidate has passed both the examinations of

M.B.A and M.A.(LSW) in the same year 1996 with

the same registration no. 3171/91 of Patna

university . In no case , two curriculum may be

completed simultaneously. The agency should

clarify it.

Candidate has done course in different sessions and passing year had been same. Hence both

regular Degree courses are valid. Supporting document has been uploaded on FTP

As per attached work experience certificates, the

candidate has experience of marketing field.

Experience of project monitoring and

data/MIS/business analysis is not clear . The agency

should give a clear certificate about it.

Candidate has worked in managerial capacity and had been involved in Project Monitoring &

Data/MIS analysis of Marketing initiative Project.

Also both the firms mentioned above are private Ltd

who make curtain pipes, curtain poles etc. and are

not govt./bilateral or multilateral organisations.

Score regarding this area should be reviewed.

As per the Job description marks can be awarded under this criteria if candidate has experience

of working in Project Monitoring & MIS role with

State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral/Private/Multinational Organization. Hence 10 marks has

been awarded under this criteria.

55 17103987 MEENAKSHI KUMARI SC SC 4Data Analyst Preferred marking summary is attached

. Needs to be changed.

Candidate has experience in Project Monitoring & Data/Business Analysis and Hence 15 marks

for role in Project Monitoring & Data/Business Analysis has been awarded and 10 marks has

been awarded for role in Project Monitoring & Data/Business analysis for experience of working

with State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral/Private/Multinational Organization. Updated marking


Additional 25 Marks awarded 29

Candidate Matric Certificate there is error in Name.Candidate has mentioned mistakenly Kumar Anupama Nath whereas her correct name Kumari

Anupama Nath and if selected will produce affidavit at the time of Joining.No Change

Data Analyst Preferred marking summary is attached

. Needs to be changed.Updated marking summary has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

The candidate has provided Marks Statement of

MBA Part-II Exam 2007 ( Revaluation). So, the

certificate is required to establish.

MBA certificate is required as candidate had

technically not passed in 2 subjects i.e., in Financial

Management got only 24 marks in theory out of

minimum of 25 marks. In Economic Environment of

Business candidate have achieved less than the

passing marks. Grace marks been given in both

subjects.

Role and responsibiliityis not clear with the Kirby

experience Certificate.

Candidate has worked as Assistant Manager S&W in Kirby and doesn't have experience in

Project Monitoring & Data/Business Analysis. Hence 25 marks for role has been reduced and 10

marks has been reduced for experience as Project Monitoring Lead/Head And/Or Project

Monitoring and Capacity building aspects in State / Central / Bilateral / Multilateral / Private /

Multinational organization.

35 Marks Reduced

Date of relieving ON Track is not clear.Resignation letter to establish duration of experience has been uploaded on FTP. Candidate

doesn't have experience certificate of Ontrack

Period of experience in Saksham is not clear.Resignation acceptance letter to establish duration of experience has been uploaded on on

FTP..

Matriculation certificate Date of Birth has been mentioned in 10th Marksheet and is valid document and 10th certificate

is not required

Creamy layer certificate Candidate has been asked to share NCL and same will been uploaded on FTP.

Work experience in Husk Power organisation date of

relieving is not clear.

Candidate is still working with Husk Power Organization. Supporting document(Salary Slip to

establish duration of experience has been uploaded on FTP.No Change

Supporting paper of work experience in Bihar Urban

Infrastructure Development corporation Limited is

not attached.

Supporting document to establish duration of experience has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

Work experience in Reliance Communication Ltd.

Should be 14.01.2008 to 05.06.2009 it should be

rectified.

Candidate had Probation Period of Six Months Hence D.O.J is 14-07-2008 and Date of Leaving is

05-06-2009 and Updated marking summary has been uploaded on FTP.No Change

Marticulation certificate Date of Birth has been mentioned in 10th Marksheet and is valid document and 10th certificate

is not requiredNo Change

Photocopy of Degree Certificate Degree certificate has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

Candidate Work Experience in Reliance

Communication Ltd, Bihar urban Infrastructure

Development Corporation Ltd.,& husk Power

System Pvt Ltd. duration of experience is not clear

with attached document. Agency needs to clarify.

Supporting document to establish duration of experience with Reliance Communication Ltd,

Husk Power System Pvt Ltd has been uploaded on FTP. Role supporting document BUIDCL and

Tata Telservices Ltd has been uploaded on FTP

No Change

61 17102960 DR. KUMAR ABHISHEK General UR OPEN 82 O.K. O.K No Change 82 OK Ok No Change 82

Pass certificate of M.A.(Social Work) is not available

. Only Marks sheet of IV Semester has been

attached.

Passing Certificate of M.A(Social Work) has been uploaded on FTP No Change

Candidate has passed M.A. (Social Work) in Aug

2006. But employment tenure of Navjyoti India

Foundation is 05.06.2006 to 25.06.2007 . It seems

pre qualification experience.

Navjyoti experience considered from 01-Sep 2006(Passing Date) and Updated marking

summary has been uploaded on FTP.No Change

Employment tenure of Sutra Consulting is not clear.

Only Contract Letter has been attached.Supporting document to establish duration of experience has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

63 17105065 SIDDHARTH KESHARI General UR Open 84Pass certificate of M.B.A is not available . Only Final

Grade report has been enclosed.


FTP. No Change 84

64 17103837 SUBASH CHANDRA PANDEY General UR OPEN 88The provided document doesn't support the length

of job in JEEVIKA . A Work experience certificate is

needed.

Supporting to establish duration of experience with Jeevika has been uploaded on FTP. No Change 88Marking summary should be on

the pattern of District PMU Lead

Updated marking summary as per

the marking criteria of District PMU

Lead has been uploaded on FTP.10

Marks has been reduced for role in

Project Monitoring and

Data/Business analysis as candidate

does not have experience in Project

Monitoring and Data/Business

analysis with Basix & Atma

10 Marks Reduced 78

OK

NCL still not uploaded in FTP.

Bihar Urban Infrastructure

Development corporation

Limited duration could not be

established with the supporting

paper. If not established then

marking summary may be

revised accordingly.

79 No Change 79

94 94

99 9962 17106157 MD RAGHIB ANWER General UR Open

59 17106284 Ajit Krishna BC UR Open

60 17102093 Rohit Prakash General UR OPEN

58 1710511 Vikas Kumar singh General UR OPEN

Candidate has not applied for passing certificate but has claimed that cleared all papers.

Supporting document and clarification email will be uploaded on FTP.No Change

4782

No Change 76

The provided caste certificate is not readable .

Agency has to provide readable document because Readable Cast certificate has been uploaded on FTP. No Change 78

Pass certificate of M.B.A is not available . Only

Marks sheet of semester IV is attached.Passing certificate of MBA has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

42

56 17106462 MANOJ KUMAR SC SC

57 17105482 Kumari Anupama Nath SC SC

76

78

42

54 17106581MANOJ KUMAR

CHAUDHARYSC SC

OK Ok No Change

Candidate has not shared NCL

certificate even after several

reminders and Hence has been

considered under Unreserved

Category

Moved to

Unreserved

Category

Candidate has been asked to share

valid supporting document to

establish duration of experience of

BUIDCL and same has been

uploaded on FTP.

No Change

Ok Ok No Change

78

94

84

Phase -IV


Experience in JEEVIKA , Bihar the pay slip of oct.

2013 to Nov. 2017 is not available i.e., The period of

experience in Jeevika , Bihar Organisation is not

verified. So it should be verified.

Supporting document to establish duration experience with Jeevika has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

Only Jeevika Appointment letter required to be

attached.Appointment letter of Jeevika has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

66 17105934 Raju Kumar Lal SC UR Open 83

Experience tenure is not clear in Employement

JEEVIKA , Bihar . Only Employment letter and Pay

Slip has been attached. Provided document doesn't

established the tenure of Jeevika Bihar.

Supporting document to establish duration of experience has been uploaded on FTP. No Change 83 OK Ok No Change 83

67 17106257 Md Masoom Iqbal General UR Open 98 O.K. O.k No Change 98

68 17101527 Jitendra Kumar Chaurasiya MBC UR Open 84 Creamy layer certificate is not available.N.C.L Due Non creamy layer certificate has been uploaded on FTP No Change 84 OK OK No Change 84

69 17102478 Ashish Kumar General UR Open 99Pass certificate of M.A.(Social Work) is not available

. Only Marks sheet of M.A. Part II has been

attached.


FTP by 10th Jul 2018 No Change 99 OK

Candidate's age is more than 40 years. Age of candidate is on Higher side, Hence Candidate has been moved to bottom of Merit ListMoved to Bottom of Merit as


Rest O.K. Ok No Change

Date of relieving of Uttar Pradesh Skill Development

Mission is not clear.

Rest O.K.

In Axis bank experience certificate , start date of job

is not visible.

Experience certificate of Axis bank which establishes duration of experience has been uploaded

on FTP.

Candidate has worked as Manager with Axis bank which has not been considered as role in

Project Monitoring & Data/Business Analysis. Hence 25 marks has been reduced in role marking

and 10 marks has been reduced based on experience of working with

State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral experience.

35 Marks Reduced

Candidate's age is more than 40 years, which is

more than preferred age.Age of candidate is on Higher side, Hence Candidate has been moved to bottom of Merit List

Moved to Bottom of Merit as


Preferred marking on period of experience in

Jeevika Organisation should be rectified. Because in

supporting paper period of experience is 06.09.2010

to 05.11.2011. but preferred marking on period of

06.09.2010 to 01.08.2014.

Supporting document to establish duration of experience has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

DRDA,Munger last day of working is not clear .

Document is required to be establish the duration of

experience .

Duration of experience could not be established and has not been mentioned in application

form and hence this experience has not been conisdered for marking calculation.No Change

Date Of Birth on certificate is not very clear to read. Readable 10th Certificate(Proof of Date of Birth) has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

MBA certificate copy is not in proper size to read. Candidate has been asked to share readable MBA certificate and same will be uploaded on FTP. No Change

Work experience certificate of TESCO is not

provided. So date of joining is not clear. Supporting document to establish duration of experience has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

The joining date in the firm SHOPPERS STOP LTD is

given 29.01.2016 on its payslip whereas the agency

mentioned the joining date as 29.09.2011 on its

marking summary as mentioned on the offer letter .

So the date of joining should be clear.

Candidate had worked with Shopper stop in two stints, supporting douments to establish

duration of experience has been uploaded on FTP. Updated marking summary has been

uploaded on FTP.

No Change

NCL certificate is not attached. Non creamy layer certificate has been uploaded No Change

75 17103870 Ashok Pradeep Minz General UR OPEN 82 O.K O.K No Change 82 OK Ok No Change 82

76 1710409 Sudhir Kumar Singh General UR OPEN 88 O.K O.K No Change 88

Marking summary should be on

the pattern of District PMU Lead

with the consideration of

experience with Private /

Multinational.

Changes has been incorporated in

marking summary and updated

marking summary has been

uploaded on FTP. 20 Marks has

been reduced for role in Project

Monitoring & Data/Business

Analysis and 5 marks has been

reduced for experience under

state/Central/Bilateral/multilateral/

Private/ Multinational experience

25 Marks Reduced 63

1)pass certificate of M.A (social work) is not

available. Only marks sheet of 6th semester has

been attatched.

Passing Certificate of M.A(Social Work) has been uploaded on FTP No Change

2) rest ok O.K No Change

3) only NCL required. NCL has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

78 17105316 Nishant Ranjan BC UR OPEN 99 Only NCL. NCL has been uploaded on FTP. No Change 99

1) Overlapping experience of

IDEA with State Health Society

may be reviewed properly.

2) Sambhavna Trust experience

may be reviewed w.r.t. the

experience of Project Monitoring

and data / MIS / Business

Analysis role.

1. Candidate has worked with

Institute for Development

Education and Action(2010-07-10 to

2013-11-30) as full-time employee,

part-time in State Health Society,

Bihar at same time period.

Supporting document has been

uploaded on FTP.

2. Sambhavna Trust experience of

Community Research worker has

not been considered into role of

Project Monitoring & Data/Business

Analysis. Experience of working

with IDC and District Program

Manager has been considered into

role of Project Monitoring &

Data/Business Analysis

OK

OK

94 94

91 91

77 17103718 MD RAZAULLAH MBC UR OPEN 83

74

OK

10 marks to be reduced for NIRF

ranking of UPTU. Updated

marking summary required.

OK

Shopper stop experience

duartion is not established.

Revised marking summary may

be required revising the date of

Shoppers Stop experience.

89

97

89

Experience certificate has been uploaded on FTP. No Change 97

88 53

87 87

70 17101355 ARBIND KUMAR SINHA General UR Open

71 17107507 NAVEEN KUMAR PANDEY General UR Open

65 17106780 Rananjay Kumar Rai General UR Open

17103026 CHANDAN KUMAR BC UR Open

83

72 17107418 SAJAL SALIL General UR Open

73 17103503 Manoj Kumar SC UR Open



marks.

Candidates has received Degree

certificate from UPTU and UPTU is

not ranked in NIRF 2017 list and

Hence 10 marks has been reduced.

Updated marking summary has


10 Marks Reduced 77


Merit List

No Change

No Change

OK

OK No Change

Candidate has worked in two stints

with Shopper Stop. Supporting

document to establish duration has

been uploaded on FTP. Updated

marking summary has been

uploaded on FTP.

No Change

Ok No Change

89

97

94

91

83

Phase -IV


1) candidate and his father's name is incorrect in the

application form.

2) matric and PG, both certificate are not provided.

3) The role of the candidate in his past jobs is not

clear from the provided documents. Its should be

clear to give score

4) candidates name needs to be corrected.

5)MBA degree certificate is not attached.

OK Ok

2) candidate is more than 40 yrs, which is more than

preferred age.Age of candidate is on Higher side, Hence Candidate has been moved to bottom of Merit List

81 17105567 Mishra Omprakash Tirthraj General UR OPEN 87 1) ok OK Ok 87 OK OK No Change 87

1) BRLPS - Agency has mentioned the date of joining

on 23.10.2013 but in attatched document it is

mentioned 23.11.2013

1.Correct Date of Joining has been mentioned in marking summary. Updated marking summary

has been uploaded on FTP.No Change

2) To establish Mis/project monitoring and data/

Business analysis supporting document is required

for the designation Mgr. IB & CB in BRLPS.

2. Candidate had been designated as Manager IB & CB and had been responsible for monitoring

of various training Program/Project and Hence this experience has been considered under role

in Project Monitoring & Data/MIS

No Change

3) M.A social work degree is required.Master

degree in social work from TATA institute of social

science , mumbai

3. Master Degree certificate TISS has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

4) Matriculation certificate 4. Marksheet of 10 th in which Date of Birth is mentioned is a valid document and Hence 10th

certificate is not requiredNo Change

5) Experience/reliving letter of work experience in

SSK/DAG/Jeevika organisation.

5. Supporting document to establish duration of experience in SSK/DAG/Jeevika has been


Candidate has provided jeevika's pay ship in which

date of joining is 01/07/2017 but in marking

summary date is mentioned 09/01/2015 to

19/10/2017. Agency needs to clarify the date of

joining in jeevika.

Candidate had joined jeevika as District Project Manager in Jeevika based in Samastipur but was

transferred to Gopalganj in July. Supporting documents, clarification email has been uploaded

on FTP.

No Change

updated NCL is required. Candidate has been asked to share NCL and same will be uploaded on FTP. No change

M.A social work certificate is required, certificate of

master degree in social work from jamia millia

islamia , New delh

Candidate has been asked to share passing certificate of MA and same will be uploaded on FTP. No Change

Required Experience/ reliving letter of work

experience in CAPART/ IMACS/ MAMTA

organisation.

Experience certificate/Reliving letter of work experience in CAPART/IMACS/Mamta has been


OK Ok No Change

NCL due. NCL has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

In supporting paper of experience in nav bharti

jagriti kendra certified the period may 2008 to till

date that letter has been issued on 25.8.2014 while

preffered marketing on 2.5.2008 to 18.10.2017 so

that it should be varified.

Candidate is still working with Nav Bharat Jagriti Kendra. Supporting document to establish

duration of experience has been uploaded on FTP.No Change

Duration of experience period is wrongly considered

in the marking for the organization " Nav bharat

jagriti kendra''.

Marking summary with correct duration experience of Nav Bharat Jagriti Kendra has been


3) Experience duration dates to be rectified for

BREAD and holy cross.

Supporting document to establish exact duration of experience has been uploaded on FTP.

Candidate doesn't experience certificate to establish exact duration of experience with Holy

cross. Hence this experience been considered for marking calculation.

No Change

4) Candidate is more that 40 yrs. Age of candidate is on Higher side, Hence Candidate has been moved to bottom of Merit ListMoved to Bottom of Merit as


Duration is not clear of working in women

Development Corporation Bihar.Documents

provided by the candidate is partially. Provided

documents doesn’t established total tenure of

employment women Development

Corporation,Bihar,The total tenure of WDC is not

getting clearly established with the documents

provided by the candidate

Candidate has shared docucment to establish Date of Joining and supporting to establish that

candidate is still working with WDC and same has been uploaded on FTP.No Change

Age is more than preferred age of 40 years Age is below 40 years on 01st -Jan -2018 and Hence candidate has been considered for further

evaluation ProcessNo Change

Date of Joining and relieving is not clear with IDF

experience Letter.

Candidate had received experience certificate from IDF with Month & Year mentioned in

experience certificate. Hence date mentioned in application form mentioned by candidate has

been considered as Date of Joining & Date of leaving IDF and same will be verified during

background verification Process. Appointment Letter has been uploaded on FTP to establish

Date of Joining.

No Change

Employment tenure is not clear in Apne Aap

Women World Wide.Experience certificate provided

by the candidate is without letter no. & signature .

Date of joining in experience letter is 05.03.2011.

Whereas in pay slip it is 21.03.2011.It is also not

clear when did the candidate left this organisation.

Experience certificate of Himmotthon tata trusts is

not available . Only appoinment letter & pay slip of

month July 2017 & January 2018 has been attached .

The Date of joining is 16.09.2013 in acceptance

letter whereas it is mention in Marking Summary is

7 Jan 2013. The agency should clear it.

Score awarded by the agency should be reviewed.

Agreed with all the above comments and marking

summary must be reviewed basis the authencity of

documents .

Haryana labour Net experience to be reviwed for

including in Project Monitoring role.

Moved to not Fit by the Agency

itself.

1) Duration Period from 12th

June'2008 to 11th March'2009,

and 12th March'2010 to 30th

June'2010 in WDC not

established and marking

summary may be revised

accordingly.

2) Discrepency observed in DOJ

of IDF . As previous submitted

document suggests DOJ as

June'2005 whereas supporting

document provided by the

agency to clearly establish the

date specifies DOJ as 8th

OK

OK

BRLPS duration needs to be

rechecked.Updated marking

summary required.

From the pay slip produced the

date of joining is 1-07-2017 as

DPM ,however in marking

summary it is mentioned as 09-

01-2015

General UR OPEN 89

89

JAWAID AHSAN General UR OPENCertificate of PG has been uploaded on FTP. Candidate is not Interested for the role and Hence

Not keen to share any additional document. As candiate is not interested for the role, Hence

candidate has not been considered for further evaluation Process.

Moved to Not Fit for further

evaluation Process

89

Md Wasim Ansari MBC UR OPEN

SUBODH KUMAR MBC UR OPEN

89Anil Kumar

79 1710946

83 17107160

84 17106827

85 17106533 RAJEEV KUMAR SINGH General UR OPEN

82

80 17105721 DEBAJYOTI KUNDU

Candidate has shared 3 documents with 3 different Dates of Joining of Apne Aap Women World

wide and has mentioned different Date in Application form and Hence this experience shown

appears to be fake and hence candidate has not been considered for further evaluation Process


evaluation ProcessNot Fit87 17103622 Manish Kumar General UR OPEN

88Moved to bottom of Merit

List among the candidate of

same marks.



marks.


evaluation Process

93

86 17101923

93

General UR OPEN

82 17106835 Prakash Kumar General UR OPEN

Not Fit

88

99 99

9999

82

Changes have been incoporated in

Merit List.No Change

No Change




No Change

Candidate had joined jeevika as

District Project Manager in Jeevika

based in Samastipur but was

transferred to Gopalganj in July but

has not shared supporting

document to establish duration

starting 09-01-2015. Hence

experience has been considered

from 01-07-2017 till Date of

application.

10 Marks has been reduced based

on post qualification experince and

15 Marks Reduced 84

Ok No Change

Ok No Change

1. Supporting document to

establish duration of experience of

working with WDC has been

uploaded on FTP.

2. Candidate had joined IDF on

08th Jul as per the experience

certificate. Disclaimer email sent by

candidate has been uploaded on

FTP. Marking summary with correct

duration of experience has been

uploaded on FTP.

88

82

89

89

Phase -IV


Marks statement of MBA is provided but certificate

is needed.Passing certificate of MBA has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

The provided documents don't establish the joining

and tenure of the candidate in Uttar pradesh

livelihood Mission . So, the corroborating

documents are needed. Only after establishing

above , the final scoring may be done .

Supporting document to establish duration of experience with Uttar Pradesh Livelihood Mission


Issue date of Mark Sheet is 9th Nov' 2007 and thus

experience of Grameen Development Services to be

counted from the post qualification date.

Duration of experience with Grameen Development Services has been considered post

qualification. 5 Marks has been reduced based on Post qualification experience and additional

10 marks has been awarded for institute/University ranked in NIRF 2017 List. updated marking


5 Marks Reduced based on

Post qualfication experience

and 10 marks awarded for

Institute/University ranked in

NIRF 2017 list.

Agreement letter of UPSLRM requires some clarity:- Readable copy of Agreement letter of UPSLRM has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

Agreement is of 1 year only from 9th Dec' 2013. so

clarity /document required for the further extension

given to the candidate.

Supporting document(Salary certificate) showing duration of experience has been uploaded on

FTP.No Change

Candidate joined as DTE (SM). What is the full form

and role of DTE (SM).

Full form of DTE(SM) os District Thematic Expert(Senior Manager) and role supporting

document has been uploaded on FTP.No Change

Transaction statement of UBI given is reflecting the

name VAP Infosolutions for monthly payment . This

does not give the clarity of working with UPSRLM.

Salary Certiificate issued UPSRLM clearly establishes that candidate had been working with

UPSRLM.No Change

Period of post experience in BHU is not clear i.e.,

total post experience should be reviewed.Supporting document to establish duration of experience has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

Matriculation certificate for age verified.Candidate has shared 10th Marksheet in which Date of Birth is mentioned and hence 10th

Certificate is not required.No Change

Master degree in social work from BHU.Candidate has been asked to share passing certificate of MA(Social Work) and same will be


Marking summary is not attached. Marking summary has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

Whether the experience of research work while

doing PhD from BHU will get counted as work

experience / Project Monitoring to be reviewed.

Candidate is working as Senior Research Fellow hence fellowship program experience in BHU

has been calculated under post qualifivcation experienceNo Change

Latest NCL required. Candidate has been asked to share NCL & same will be uploaded on FTP. No Change

Supporting document of Sanofi Synthelabo India

Ltd. is not enough for employement tenure.

Supporting document to establish duration of experince with Sanofi Sythelabo India Ltd has

been uploaded on FTP.No Change

Experience of Month May 2008 is mention in

MNREGA. Whereas Pay Slip of these month is issued

by Sanofi aventis Pharma Ltd.

Salary slip of Sanofi Aventis Pharma Ltd. is for the

month of May' 2008 and on the other side ,

candidate have specified that DRDA on 5th

May'2008. Requires clarity.

Candidate had worked with Sanofi till 30-04-2008, Hence salary slip of May of Sanofi has been

shared. And Duration of experience will be verified during background verification Process. No Change

Creamy layer certificate is not available. Latest NCL

certificate required.Non creamy layer certificate has been uploaded on FTP No Change

Candidate's age is more than 40 yrs.Age of candidate is less than 43 Year(Age Relaxation Limit for BC Category) and hence candidate

has been considered for further evaluation Process.No Change

D.O.J. DRDA is not clear with the experience letter.Candidate has been asked to share supporting document to establish Date of Joining and same


Sanofi Aventis Pharma Ltd. Experience letter

required to establish properly the D.O.J and D.O.L.

Candidate doesn't have experience certificate of Sanofi Aventis. Supporting document to

establish duration of experience has been uploaded on FTP.Disclaimer email from candidate has


No Change

Degree certificate of M.B.A is not attached . Only

mark sheet has been attached.Degree certificate has been uploaded on FTP.

Rest O.K. Ok

92 17101310 Nishant Kumar General UR Open 78 O.K Ok No Change 78

Candidate's age is more than 40 yrs.Candidate has been moved to below the candidate with same score in Merit list as Age of

candidate is more than Preferred Age mentioned in Job description for General Category

Moved to below the

candidate with same score in

Merit list

79 OK OK No Change 79

Rest O.K. Ok

Degree certificate of M.B.A is not attached . Only

mark sheet has been attached.MBA certificate has been uploaded on FTP.

Rest O.K. OK

Degree certificate of Rural Development is not

attached . Only mark sheet has been attached. Degree certificate has been uploaded on FTP.

Rest O.K. Ok

Caste certificate is not attached. Caste Certificate has been uploaded on FTP

Rest O.K. O.K

SGS issued letter dated March 04, 2015 seems to be

reflecting a typing error in the experience period . It

should be period from March 15, 2015 to December

14, 2015. The error of mentioned year March 15,

2014 is resulting in the overlap of experience with

Alankit Assignments Ltd. Candidate may be asked to

submit the document with required correction.

As per the contract letter issued by SGS, issued on 04th March 2015 duration of experience has

been mentioned as 15th March 2014 to 14th December 2015 and which overlaps with Reliving

Date of Alankit i.e 13th Dec 2014 As there had been overlapping in experience with Alankit.

Hence this experience has not been considered as valid and candidate has shared another

document issued on 04th March 2015 in which contract period is 15 Mar 2015 to 14 Dec 2015.

Hence Experience with SGS has been considered valid from 15 Mar 2015 till Date of application

and same has been considered for marking calculation. 5 Marks has been reduced based on

post qualification experience. . Supporting document to establish duration of experience with

SGS and Alankit has been uploaded on FTP.

Else O.K. OK

The period of work experience in Nidan

organisation is not clear. Relevant work experience

certificate and its awarded marking should be

reviewed.

Relieving Letter of Nidan and Appointment letter of Nidan has been uploaded on FTP to

establish duration of experience with Nidan. Marking summary with correct duration has

uploaded on FTP.

The work experience certificate of Technopack

Advisors is not certified the period of work

experience alloted in the application.

Relieving Letter of Technopak Advisors has been uploaded on FTP to establish duration of

experience with Technopak

Rest O.K. OK

PhD is an educational degree

and may not be treated as

experience and hence marks

awarded for BHU experience

may be reduced accordingly.

Candidate MBA certificate is

issued from UPTU which is not

under NIRF 2017 ranking.

Therefore 10 marks awarded by

the agency may be accordingly

deducted.

DOJ in DRDA may be corrected in

the marking summary as per

supporting document.

UR OPEN

90 17103529 Manish kumar BC UR OPEN

83

99

89 17105689 Manish Kumar MBC

79 84

83

88 17104069 Pankaj Kumar Mishra General UR OPEN

99

Candidates has received Degree

certificate from UPTU and UPTU is

not ranked in NIRF 2017 list and

Hence 10 marks has been reduced.

Updated marking summary has


10 Marks Reduced 74

Candidate had been working as

Senior Research Fellow hence

fellowship program experience in

BHU has been calculated under post

qualification experience. This

experience has not been considered

under Project Monitoring &

Data/Business Analysis. Hence 20

marks has been reduced for role in

Project Monitoring & Data/Business

Analysis and 5 Marks has been

reduced based on experience with

25 Marks Reduced

No Change

58

99

91 17106494 Kumar Abhishek General UR Open 79

93 17102120 Prashant Priyadarshi General UR Open 79

94 17106679 Priti Choudhary SC SC Female 4

95 17103830 Santosh Kumar General UR Open 78

98 1710534 Shrinidhi Kumar General UR Open 78

96 17105164 Shambhu Nath Sudhakar SC SC Open 61

97 17105122 Shashi Shankar khan General UR Open 78

No Change 79 Ok

No Change 4

No Change 78

No Change 61

5 Marks Reduced

No Change 78

73




Ok No Change 79

Phase -IV


Candidate's age is more than 40yrs.Candidate has been moved to below the candidate with same score in Merit list as Age of

candidate is more than Preferred Age mentioned in Job description.

Moved to below the


Merit list

10 marks added in institute ranking . NRIF rank of

rashtrasant tukadoji maharaj nagpur university is

144.10 marks to be rewarded for institute NIRF

ranking 2017.

10 Marks for institute/university ranked in NIRF 2017 list has been awarded in Final Merit List 10 Marks Awarded

name mismatch as per matriculation certificate and

in application form.

There is name mismatch as per the matriculation certificate and if selected candidate will

produce affidavit at the time of Joining.No Change

ok

Candidate has worked as Social Worker, Community Mentor and Field co-ordinator and hence

these experience has not been considered as Project Monitoring & Data/Business Analysis and

Hence 25 marks has been reduced for role in Project Monitoring & Data/Business Analysis and

10 Marks has been reduced for experience in Project Monitoring & Data/Business Analysis role

with State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral/Private/Multinational Organization.

35 Marks Reduced

100 1710562 Anand Kumar Rai General UR Open 78 ok Ok No Change 78

Degree certificate of M.B.A is not attatched. Only

marks sheet has been attached.Candidate has been asked to share the degree certificate of MBA and same will be uploaded on FTP.

Experience certificate of sahara prime city ltd is not

attached. Appointment letter and pay slip has been

attached. Issue date of appointmrnt letter is

03.08.2004. But effective date of experience is

12.12.2003 D.O.J and D.O.R is not clear in

experience sahara prime city ltd.

Supporting document to establish duration of experience in Sahara Prime City Ltd has been

uploaded on FTP.

Role of experience in project monitoring and data/

MIS/business analysis is not clear.

Role of experience as project monitoring lead /head

and/or project monitoring and capacity building

aspects is not clear.

Degree certificate of M.B.A is not attatched. Only

marks sheet has been attached.Candidate has been asked to share MBA Certificate and same has been uploaded on FTP.

Ok Ok

103 17106872 Chandramani Kumar SC SC Open 61 Ok Ok No Change 61

104 17103601 Virat Prince General UR Open 78 Ok Ok No Change 78

Candidate BRLPS appoinment letter is reflecting the

date of joining as 4th oct' 2013 but salary slip is

reflecting 22nd Aug'2013 as a "Block Project

Manager". Agency may revalidate the same.

Candidate had joined BRLPS on 04th Oct 2013, There had been typing errror in salary slip.

Experience certificate to establish exact duration of experience has been uploaded on FTP.No Change

D.O.J. and D.O.L. is not clear in Awadhesh Singh

Vikas Sansthan experience letter.

Experience certificate has been issued in Month-Year format ,Hence experience has been

considered from 30-Jun 2010 till 1-Jul-2011 and updated marking summary has been uploaded

on FTP.

No Change

NCL certificate is not attached. Candidate has been asked to share NCL certificate and same will be uploaded on FTP.

In certificate of experience of GRAMOTHAM BAL

MAHILA KALYAN SANSTHAM MAU & OPERATION

ASHA DELHI D.O.J &D.O.R has not been mentioned

clearly.

Experience certificate of GRAMOTHAN BAL MAHILA KALYAN SANSTHANAM MAU & OPERATION

ASHA DELHI has been issued in Month-Year format. Hence Duration of experience has been

considered as 30-06-2004 to 01-07-2007(GRAMOTHAN BAL MAHILA KALYAN SANSTHANAM

MAU ) and 31-07-2007 to 01-07-2008(OPERATION ASHA DELHI)

No Change

Period of experience of SAFDARJUNG HOSPITAL

DELHI & UP SKILL DEVLOPMENT

MISSION,LUCKNOW overlaps.

Candidate had worked between 25-7-2008 to 16-12-2013 as he got early relieving from Delhi

Aids Control Society and had been issued correct experience certificate with above mentioned

duration. Supporting document has been uploaded on FTP.

No Change

The Period of experience in UP SKILL DEVLOPMENT

MISSION,LUCKNOW should be 17.12.2013 to

20.11.2016. But in the marking summary it has been

written 11.10.2017 instead of 20.11.2016.

Candidate is still working with UPSKILL Development Mission Lucknow. Recent experience

certificate has been uploaded on FTP.No Change

Experience of NAVCHETNA GRAMIN VIKAS has been

mentioned in application form , however it has not

been included in marking summary.Marking

summary may be revised accordingly , however no

change in marks.

Experience of working with NACHETNA GRAMIN VIKAS has been included in marking summary.

No Change in overall scoreNo Change

Updated NCL certificate Required Updated NCL has been uploaded on FTP.

Experience certificate of BRLPS is not attached only

payslip has been attached

Candidate doesn't have experience certificate of BRLPS and Date of Joining is mentioned in

salary slips which establishes duration of experience.Resk Ok Ok

Updated NCL certificate Required Updated NCL has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

Resk Ok Ok Ok

Age is more than preferred age.Candidate has been moved to below the candidate with same score in Merit list as Age of


Moved to below the


Merit list

Certificate of MBA has not been attached marksheet

has been attachedCandidate has been asked to share MBA Certificate and same will be uploaded on FTP.

Period of Experience in MAAN Pharmaceuticals and

PDCSL is not clear. Date of Joining & Date of Leaving

of is not getting established from proper

documents also of FHRM-TA Project. If not

supported with Proper documents then marks may

be revised accodingly.

Candidate has not shared supporting document to establish duration of Experience with FHRM-

TA, PDCSL and MAAN Pharmaceuticals and Hence this experience has not been considered for

marking calculation. Updated marking summary has been uploaded on FTP. . 20 marks has been

reduced based on post qualification experience.

20 Marks Reduced

Experience certificate of Bajaj Allianz life insurance

Co.Ltd is not attached.Only Pay slip of Month

september 2017 has been attached.

Candidate is still working with Bajaj Allianz life insurance, so experience certificate has not been

shared. Date of Joining is mentioned in salary slip and experience till 30-Sep 2018 has been

considered for marking calculation.

No Change

Rest O.K. O.K Ok

43

42

111 17107122 MD SUHAIL AHMAD BC BC Open 63

110 17103015 Ashok Kumar BC BC Open 63

101 17103202 Arvind Kumar Singh General UR Open 79

1710111 Ashish Kumar General UR Open 78102

99 17103825 Ajay Kumar Saxena MBC UR Open 78 53

Candidate has worked as Assistant Manager in Sales function which has not been considered

under role in Project Monitoring & Data/Business Analysis and Hence 25 marks has been

reduced for role in Project Monitoring & Data/Business Analysis and 10 Marks has been reduced

for experience in Project Monitoring & Data/Business Analysis role with

State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral/Private/Multinational Organization. Updated marking

35 Marks Reduced

44

No Change 78

42

73106 17103513 SUMAN KUMAR BC BC Open 73

Exact duration of experience with Jaipur Rugs could not be clearly established from supporting

document and Hence Experience of working with Jaipur Rugs has not been considered for

marking calculation.

No Change 78

The period of work experience in jaipur rugs

foundation is not clear from attached relevent

As per the application form the candidate has

mentioned experience of jaipur rugs foundation

105 17104641 Subodh Kumar General UR Open 78

109 17101216 Amrita Kumari BC BC FEMALE

UR Open 78 78

108 17107246 Amit Kumar BC BC Open 62

No Change 62

63

107 17103901 SANJIV KUMAR BARANWAL General

Phase -IV


HDFC Bank experience may be consider for project

Monitoring/MIS/Business Analysis.

HDFC Bank experience has been considered as role in Project Monitoring & Data/Business

Analysis and additional 15 marks has been awarded under this criteria. Updated marking


Additional 15 marks awarded

Kotak Educational initiative,indusind bank ltd and

kotak mahindra bank experience also may be

consider for Monitoring/MIS/Business Analysis.

Candidate has been designated as an executive in Indusland Bank & Kotak Mahindra Bank & as

Business Development Manager in Kotak Educational Iniative and Hence experience of working

with these organizations has not been considered for marking calculation.

No Change

Experience Certificate of kotak mahindra bank ltd.

Has not been attached.pay slip of Dec 2011 has

been attached on which date of joining is not clearly

visible.

Candidate has been asked to share readable salary slip of Kotak Mahindra Bank and same will

be uploaded on FTPNo Change

Degree certificate of M.A(ECO) is not attached .Only

marks sheet has been attached.Candidate has been asked to share Certificate of Master's Degree and same will be uploaded on FTP No Change

Role of experience in project monitoring and data/

MIS/business analysis is not clear.

Kala- Azar Data operator and data entry operator

cum incharge data manager may not be considered

into experience in project monitoring and

data/MIS/Business analysis role.Marks may be

reduced accordingly.

Candidate had been designated as Data Entry Operator, which had not been considered role in

Project Monitoring & Data/Business Analysis and Hence 25 marks has been reduced under this

criteria and 10 marks has been reduced for role in Project monitoring & Data/Business Analysis

for experience with State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral experience. In total 35 marks has been

reduced. Updated marking summary has been uploaded on FTP.

35 Marks Reduced 18

Certificate of post graduation Diploma has not been

attached. Mark sheets of semester 1 to 4 have been

attached.

Candidate has been asked to shared Certificate of PG Diploma and same will be uploaded on FTP. No Change

Reference no./Memo no has not been mentioned in

the experience certificate of ASA.Moreover date has

not been mentioned in it.

Duration of experience and Issue date is clearly mentioned on experience certificate and

experience certificate is duly signed. Hence this experience certificate has been considered

valid. It has been issued in Month-Year format. Hence duration of experience has been

considered from 28th Feb 2009 till 01 Dec 2010. Updated marking summary has been uploaded

on FTP.

No Change

Reference no./Memo no has not been mentioned in

the experience certificate of Skillpro foundation.

Duration of experience is mentioned in experience certificate and is duly signed and Hence this

experience certificate has been uploaded on FTP.No Change

Period of experience is not clear in IPE Gobal. Duration of experience has been clearly mentioned in IPE Global

115 17106597 Prabhat Kumar Mandal MBC MBC Open 72

Role of Executive Assistant is similar to Data Entry

Operator and IT Assistant Excperience should not be

considered for role in Project Monitoring &

Data/Business Analysis. Hence marks awarded for

role in Project Monitoring & Data/Business may not

be considered.

Candidate had been designated as IT Assistant in BPSM"RTPS" and as Executive Assistant in

Gaya Collectorate has not been considered under role in Project Monitoring & Data/Business

Analysis. Hence 10 marks has been reduced under this criteria

10 Marks Reduced 62

116 17102256 RAHUL RANJAN BC BC Open 62 OK OK No Change 62

Period of experience in cosmic softech limited

should not be considered for marks because it is pre

qualification experience and not post qualification

experience .CBS/Cosmic softech ltd will not be

considered into marking sheet as this experience is

not post qualification (MBA in the year 2014)

experience .Marks to be reduced and marking

summary needs to be revised.

Experience of working with Cosmic Softech Ltd has not been considered for marking calculation

and Hence 15 Marks has been reduced based on post qualification experience. Updated

marking summary has been uploaded on FTP.

15 Marks Reduced

Period of experience in BRLPS is supported by letter

of joining and salary slip.

Candidate is still working BRLPS therefore experience certificate has not been shared. Duration

of experience gets established from Joining letter and Salary Slips.No Change

Else O.K. OK Ok

Reliance Communication date of relieving is not found.

Duration of experience could not be established and hence experience of working with Reliance

Communication has not been considered for marking calculation. 10 Marks based on post

qualification experience has been reduced. Candidate had been working in managerial capacity

since 1 April 2013 till date of application, Hence this experience has been considered under role

in Project Monitoring & Data/Business Analysis. 5 marks has been reduced under this criteria

15 Marks Reduced

NCL certificate is required. NCL has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

Marks needs to be awarded for Pune university 20 Marks for University ranked in NIRF 2017 list has been awarded 20 Marks Awarded

Marking summary needs to be revised. Updated marking summary has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

119 1710610 Srikant Kumar BC BC Open 60 OK OK OK 60

120 1710743 Tarique ur Rahman Ghani BC BC Open 60 OK OK Ok 60

District Health Society last working date may be

considered as 09/09/2016 as per the letter no 795

date 06/09/2016.However there will be no change

in Marks.

Marking Summary with correct duration of experience as per the supporting documents has

been uploaded on FTP. 5 Marks based on Post qualification experience has been reduced.5 Marks reduced

Else O.K. OK OK

122 17106896 DHANANJAY KUMAR SC SC Open 52 OK OK OK 52

123 17105882 Govind Kumar SC SC Open 52 OK OK OK 52

Degree certificate of MBA is not available. Only

marksheet has been attached. Candidate has been asked to share MBA Certificate and same will be uploaded on FTP. No Change

Experience Certificate of BRPLS is not attached.Only

Pay Slip of March 2017 has been attached .In

marking summary Doj mention 11.12.2013 instead

of 10.02.2014 . Date of relieving is not clear in this

experience

Duration of experience has been considered from 10-Feb-2014 till 08-Oct 2017 and updated

marking summary has been uploaded on FTP. Post qualification score has been reviewed

additional 5 marks has been awarded

Additional 5 Marks has been

awarded

Current Non Creamy Layer Certificate is not

Attached.Updated NCL Certificate is required.Candidate has been asked to share NCL certificate and same will be uploaded on FTP. No Change

Period of experience in Jeevika is not clear Neither

Experience certificate nor Salary slips have been

attached.Salary slip required to support the

continuity of job in jeevika till Oct 2017.

Supporting document to establish duration of experience with BRLPS has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

Else O.K. OK No Change

126 17104141 MD AFTAB RAHMANI MBC MBC Open 72 OK OK No Change 72

127 17101486 ANUP ANAND MBC MBC 69

ECOVIC TI PROJECT MOHANIA is pre-qualification

experience. Candidate has completed MBA in

08/10/2009, hence experienced may be considered

from 09/10/2009. 5 marks may be deducted and

accordingly marking summary needs to be revised.

Experience of working with ECOVIC TI Project Mohania has been considered post qualification

and duration of experience has been updated in marking summary Updated marking summary

has been uploaded on FTP. 5 Marks based on post qualification experience has been reduced.

5 Marks Reduced 64

124 1710938 Janeshwar nath renu BC BC Open 68

125 1710245 KHAGENDRA KUMAR SC SC Open 52

118 17106731 RAVINDRA KUMAR BC BC Open 67

121 17101148 VIKASH KUMAR SC SC Open 63

114 17101750 Mukul kumar BC BC Open 62

117 1710484 RAJAN KUMAR PRASAD BC BC Open 65

112 17101345 MISHU MANISHA KUMARI BC UR Female 45

113 17104983 MUKESH RAM SC SC Open 53

60

62

50

72

58

52

73

Phase -IV


NCL certificate is required. Candidate has been asked to share NCL certificate and same will be uploaded on FTP.

CWET, GAYA is pre-qualification experience,since

candidate has completed MBA Degree in

12/12/2006. Hence ,CWET, GAYA work experience

may be considered from 13/12/2006 and 5 marks

may be deducted.

Post qualification marks has been reviewed again and CWET experience has been considered

post qualification and additional 5 marks has been awarded based on Post qualification

experience.


awarded72

Age is more than preferred age.Candidate has been moved to below the candidate with same score in Merit list as Age of


Moved to below the


Merit listElse O.K. OK OK

NCL is not provided.Candidate has been asked to share NCL certificate and same will be uploaded on FTP else

candidate will be considered under unreserved category.Ok

Rest O.K. Ok OK

5 marks to be added for total post qualificatrion

experience. Revised marking summary with addition

of 5 marks will be required.

Post qualification experience has been reviewed again, 5 marks based on post qualification

experience has been awarded.


awarded

Pune University is wrongly mentioned in the

marking summary to be corrected.Updated marking summary has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

Total Marks-63 Marking summary with 63 as Total score has been uploaded on FTP. No Change

Rest O.K. OK

Latest NCL is not attached. Caste certificate is also

not available.

Candidate has been asked to share NCL certificate and same will be uploaded on FTP else

candidate will be considered under unreserved category.No Change

Else O.K. OK No Change

Marketing Executive may not be considered for the

role of Project Monitoring , hence marks awarded

for project Monitoring may be reduced. Candidate is

promoted as a Assistant Manager from 01-04-2012,

hence Project Monitoring role may be considered

from 01-04-2012.

Experience in Project Monitoring & Data/Business Analysis role has been considered from 01-04-

2012. and updated marking summary has been uploaded on FTP.No Change

Videocon Industries Ltd. Starting from 27 March

2006 is pre-qualification experience, since candidate

has finished his PGDBA in 15 April 2006'.Hence

starting date may be consider after post

qualification in Marking summary.

Experience of working with Videocon Industries Ltd has been considered post qualification from

16-04-2016 and same has been uploaded on uploaded on FTP.No Change

68

63

68

72

78

128 17106793 BABU SARVAJEET AKELA MBC MBC Open 67

129 17104934 MD EKHLAQUE ALAM MBC MBC Open 68

130 17103194 MD MAHBOOB ALAM MBC MBC Open 63

131 1710412 MD NAUSHAD HUSSAIN MBC MBC Open 72

132 17104739 MD ABDUL TOUFIQUE MBC MBC Open 63

133 17105576 Pranav Kumar MBC MBC Open 68

134 17105041 Danish Siraj MBC MBC Open 78