Grievance Redressal - MANCER Consulting...Phase-IV District PMU Lead Grievance Redressal 6 17101747€ Mukul kumar Sinha After two time telephonic discussion with Mancer representative

Phase-IV

District PMU Lead

Grievance Redressal

S. No Application ID Name Grievance Redressal/reply Change in Status Remarks

1 1710396 Pritam Kumar Mishra

In the {Experience of working with state / central government /bilateral /

multilateralorganizations (e.g.World bank, DFID,UNDP, ADB) onproject monitoring

andcapacity buildingaspects} column, You

awarded me Zero mark while I have submitted my two years work experiences with

multilateral organization (Room to Read India Trust under USAID project). I am able

to get 10 marks for that.

Grievance not considered. Room to Read India Trust cannot be

considered State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral Organization.

Hence no additional marks have been awarded.

No Change [email protected]

2 17101703 Sneha Shriti

My score in "Experience of working. Work Experience

with state / central government / bilateral /

multilateral organisation" is 0.

It should be 10, as in have relevant experience

in one of my job experiences.

As per the details mentioned in application form, Candidate has

worked with two organization Dr. Ram Manohar Lohia Vichar

Shodh Sansthan & MATA MANAKKA DEVI SEVA SANSTHAN and

which cannot be considered as

State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral Organization.



3 17106139 MD RAGHIB ANWER

I MD RAGHIB ANWER would like to submit grievances for the position

of District PMU Lead with Application ID 17106139. Although the date for the same

has passed but my grievance is based on the provisional list published on 22nd Feb

for the position of Department PMU Lead with Application ID17106157 where I am

at 3rd position in the merit list (General Category) .I would like to bring your

attention regarding my experience under the parameter of working with state /

central government /bilateral / multilateral organizations on project monitoring and

capacity building aspects. Under this criteria I have not been awarded any number in

the provisional list published for the position of District PMU Lead with Application

ID17106157 but for the same criteria I have been award 10 point for the position

of Department PMU Lead with Application ID17106157.

As per the Preferred marking Criteria of District PMU Lead, Scores

can be awarded based on experience with

State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral organization and where as

preferred marking criteria of Department PMU Lead is different

which includes private organization for marking in this category.

Hence marks have been awarded in Department PMU Lead and

no marks have been awarded in District PMU Lead.


4 17103795 AMIT KUMAR certificate proving association with govt sector not considered.Experience of working

with central government


worked with Multinational/Private organization which cannot be

considered as State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral Organization.



5 1710248 Khagendra Kumar

I did PG Diploma(2 years full time) from Indian Institute Of Forest Management and

My specialization is development Management and I have 3.9 experience with BRLPS

as Young Professional, Now I am posted at Nalanda as a District YP-Themetic

Manager. But My application ID 1710248 is not shortlisted for District PMU lead

Position because

My name is in Provisional List of Candidates Not Fit for Further Evaluation Process

and the reason which you have mentioned is “Candidate does not have PG Diploma

(2 years full time) or Master’s degree or higher (full time) in Business

Administration/Finance / Economics / Public Policy / Social Work / Development

Studies / Rural Development”

Grievance Considereded

Candidate have been moved to Fit for further evaluation.

Score based on post qualification experience-0

Score based on Project monitoring & Data/Business analysis-15

Score based on working with

State/Central/bilateral/multilateral/private-10

Institute/University ranked in NIRF-20

Total Revalidated Score-45

Moved to Fit for further

evaluation [email protected]

mailto:[email protected]

Phase-IV

District PMU Lead

Grievance Redressal

6 17101747 Mukul kumar Sinha

After two time telephonic discussion with Mancer representative I have told

them I have done full time PGDRM course from IRM, Jodhpur. But in remarks

section you mention that I have not done full time PGDRM course. Earlier I

was the part of BRLPS & JSLPS. I am not satisfied with the shortlisting

process done by Mancer .Kindly reject my candidature for this post.

For this I am always

We are extremely sorry for the inconvenience. We have

considered your candidature for further evaluation process.

Revalidated Score awarded is as follows:

Marks awarded based on Post qualification experience-20

Marks awarded based on Experience in project monitoring and

data / MIS / business analysis-25

NIRF Marking-0

Marks awarded on the basis of Experience of working with state /

central government / bilateral / multilateral organizations (e.g.

World bank, DFID, UNDP, ADB) on project monitoring and

capacity building aspect-10

Total Revalidated Score-20+25+10-65 Marks.



7 1710453 rohit maskara

I am having total around 9 years of experience of which around 7 years is post MBA.

This means total 35 marks must be awarded into this.


less than 7 Years of post qualification experience and has been

already awarded maximum possible marks as per the preferred

marking criteria.



8 17103650 karmbir singh

I have done MIT& MBA (INTERNATIONAL) from

Deakin University Melbourne Australia .I

completed this course on the regular basis

(not distance basis) in Bur wood Melbourne

campus. As per ranking of this university, this

university is an Australian public leading

University and having rank world wise especially

in the field of management.

So, here I would like to mention that points

related to qualification should be in the

application review for given applicant. Here ,after addition the total score Total

Score (Interview +Revalidated) should be

57 instead of 47 as per list of current

review status. So please review about the

total score.

Grievance Considereded. Additional 10 marks will be awarded

based on QS world ranking of Deakin University.10 Marks awarded [email protected]

Phase-IV

District PMU Lead

Grievance Redressal

9 17101394 Ranjeet Kumar Sharma

I have been applied for the position of District PMU Lead My application ID

17101394.

1. As I have been maintain in my application that, I have been completed my Post

graduation from Patna University Bihar with the Subject of Rural Study &

Management which is as well as equal to (MBA) professional coarse. There is unfair

marking has been mention in my score card which is Zero (0) marking. in this case I

am eligible to get 20 marks in my score because the patna University is an reputed

and best university in Bihar.

Please re validate the score and give me reward score 20 marks.

2. As I have been maintain in my application that, I have been completed my 7

(seven) years of job as a Block Community Mobilizer (ASHA) Under NRHM/NHM in

Samastipur district at Block Laval Position. So I am eligible to get 20 mark for the

experience but in this case i have found only 10 marks in that score. sir, I have been

working from 5th Jan 2011 to till Now (19th Feb 2018). related salary Sleep is

included in this male and my job starting date is mansion in my Experience

certificate. sir if you want my current experience certificate than I will sand you on

your demand from my new posting place.

Please re validate the score and give me reward score 20 marks as experience.

Please Consider all above grievance and Re-validate my score...

1. Patna University is not ranked in NRIF 2017 list, hence no

additional marks have been awarded

2. Grievance Considereded:

5 additional marks has been awarded for post qualification

experience

5 additional Marks has

been awarded for post

qualification experience

[email protected]

10 17103620Vandana Kumari

1) I have 4.5 years of experience in Project monitoring & data anlysis with Bihar

Rural Livelihood Project(BRLPS ,JEEVIKA ),MoRD,Bihar. Marks awarded in Expreience

in project monitoring & Data Analysis is zero(0) . I should be awrded at least 20

marks against it. As per norms 5 marks for each year of experience. 2) I have 4.5

years of experience of working with State govt. Organization Bihar Rural Livelihood

project (BRLPS,JEEVIKA),MoRD,Bihar on project monitoring & capacity building

aspects but I have been awarded Zero marks against it. My marks should be 10 in

this field


Experience in project monitoring and data / MIS / business

analysis - 20

Experience of working with state / central government / bilateral

/ multilateral organizations (e.g. World bank, DFID, UNDP, ADB)

on project monitoring and capacity building aspects - 10

Additional 30 marks have been awarded

35 additional Marks has

been [email protected]

11 17102621Avinash kumar

Kindly let me know reason my candidature not fit for further even I have been share

all required document by mail.

Grievance Considereded. Candidate has been considered for

further Evaluation Process.

Revalidated Score

Post qualifcation score-25marks

score on project monitoring and data/business analysis-0 marks

score based on state/central/bilateral/multilateral experience-0

marks

score based on NIRF ranking-0 Marks

Total Revalidated Score

25



12 17104682Subodh Kumar

My total Experience is now 7.5+ Years.But the marks given is 10, it should be 20

I think I have 3 years of such experience (project Monitoring and Business Analysis)

(1.10 Years working with Export Promotion Council for Handicrafts and 1.2 Years of

working with Go Dairy Pvt. Ltd), request you to please see the matter as per your

parameters.

Grievance Considereded. Additional 10 Marks have been awarded

on the basis of Post qualification experience.

Maximum possible marks have been already awarded for role

Project Monitoring & MIS/data/business Analysis.Additional 10 Marks

[email protected]

Phase-IV

District PMU Lead

Grievance Redressal

13 1710423Manish Singh

My Institute of PG comes under 1-50 as per Insititue NIRF ranked is in 1-50 MCM –

Pune University.Total field experience- Worked as dpmu district coordinator in DFID

in Ranchi Jharkhand .Overall- over 5 Years of Experience

As per the detail mentioned in application form MBA from

Singdad University has been considered as qualifying criteria and

Secondly MCM cannot be considered equivalent to MBA. Hence

no additional marks have been awarded.

As per the document shared in application form total experience

is less than 5 years(till date of application).

Hence 5 marks will be reduced based on post qualification and 5

marks will be reduced in project monitoring role.additional 20

marks have been awarded for university ranked in NIRF 2017 List.

10 Marks reduced

20 Marks awarded for

NIRF

[email protected]

14 17106792 Rananjay Kumar Rai

Score of Institutes not Added/ Included in Total Online Score which should be 10

Marks additional in Re validated Score (70+10=80) Total Marks including Marks of

Interview should be 87 (80+7) Rank of Institute/ University - 95

Grievance Considereded.candidate have been awarded

addiditional 10 marks ,as institute is ranked in 2017 list.

Additional 10 Marks

[email protected]

15 17105335Sanjay Suman

1) I have 6 year experience and should be given 15 marks as per marking criteria. 2) I

have been working since 05.03.2014 in Rural Development Department which is

state govt. organization. Before this I have worked in

Rashtriya Manav Vikas Samitti which is bilateral organization. Hence 10 mark should

be given.

We had not received one document in application form and We

had provided an opportunity to all candidates to update

application form between given time period of 14th -18th

November. Hence we would not be able award additional marks

for Post qualification experience and Experience of working Rural

Development Department cannot be considered in project

monitoring and data /MIS/business anaylsis. Hence no additional

marks have been awarded.


16 17105878 Dhiraj Singh

1) I am losing 5 marks because I could not upload experience certificate of my

present company due to lack of information. I m working as a Project Manager in

IEISL sine 09/01/2018. I have attached the relevant document. 2) I did not get any

marks in this section. I have been working as Project Manager in different

organizations working with different State Governments on PPP mode for specific

projects since April 2011. The detail has been mentioned in my CV uploaded at the

time of application.

As per details mentioned in application form and perferred

marking criteria published on website already maximum possible

marks have been awarded .Hence no additional marks have been

awarded.


17 17103458 Anil kumar Relieaving /experience attaiched. last last month salary slip RGAVP attached and sent

you today and 29th January 2018



Revalidated Score




marks


60



18 1710238 RAHUL RANJAN

I reviewed my application(1710238), my name is not shortlisted for furthur

processing.

I would like to inform you that I have completed Masters in Marketing Management

which is equivalent to MBA and recognised by University of Pune.

Requesting you to consider my application for furthur process.



Revalidated Score




marks



Phase-IV

District PMU Lead

Grievance Redressal

19 17104284 Parimal Saurabh

after seeing the final list on your portal, I came to know that my application for

"District PMU Lead" was not considered for further evaluation as I don't have

minimum three years of experience, but I request you to please look my application

again as I have more then six years of experience after my PGDBM course and

currently I am associated with Jeevika ( Bihar Rural Livelihoods Promotion Society).

My date of joining of this organization was 6th of December 2013 and prior to it I

was associated with Prism Cement Limited.

As per the details mentioned in application form .We had not

received one document in application form related to

experience and We had provided an opportunity to all candidates

to update application form between given time period of 14th -

18th November. Hence we would not able to consider this

certificate.


20 17103883 Manish Kumar

My total Experience is more than 7 years. But out of 35 marks I have been allotted

only 5 marks. In this regards already I have sent an email on 5-Feb-2018 with all the

attachments with joining dates and relieving dates mentioned in the attached letter

of various organisations.


on the basis of Post qualification experience.



10



21 17103208 Manish Sinha

I have 6.5 years work experience at Bihar Medical Services & Infra Corpn. Ltd.

(BMSICL) (A Govt of Bihar undertaking), however I have been allotted zero marks

under "Experience of working with state"- My total work experience is 15 years, out

of which 6.5 years as DGM (Adm) at BMSICL from July 2011 to current; 5.9 years as

AVP Credit Insurance at ICICI Lombard General Insurance Co. Ltd. Oct 2005 to June

2011; 1.5 years as Agency Manager at e-Serve International Sep'03 to March'05.



Revalidated Score


marks


10

Additional 10 Marks

[email protected]

22 17103477sanjay kumar

please find my experience certificate.Thank you for sharing document again .Document sharing can

not be considered as grievance.No Change [email protected]

23 17104591 salman khurshid

1- Preferred marking for total post qualification experience of project monitoring

and data max 35 marks, 5 marks for each additional complete year.

I have given 5 marks only by authority, My total working experience is 5.3 year,

So kindly request consider grievance . please find attached experience letter here

2-Experience of working with state /bilateral organisationI have given 0 (zero

)marks by authority.so kindly request consider grievance

As per details mention in application form 4.3 years of post

qualification experience could be established.MAYA NARAYAN

SANSTHAN experience cannot be consider as

State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral.



24 1710401 Anil PrasadAs I belong to EBC Caste (Koeri, Kushwaha), Kindly look into provision of shifting

from BC to EBC if such possibilities exist from your end.

As per the claims made in application form category is BC not

EBC. Will consider your candidature for EBC category at the time

of interview candidate is required to produce an affidavit to

establish clame made.

Considered for EBC [email protected]

25 1710383Amit Mishra

My total experience is more then 8 yrs as submitted.

As per details mention in application form 7.9 years could be

establish,which already awarded Hence no additional marks have

been awarded.


26 17103519 Raghu Kumar

I have already completed Master of Social Work in 2015-2017 through

correspondence mode and current taking care a district (Samastipur) of Bihar.Hope

above application can be consider.

Candidate has not done PG Diploma (2 years full time) or Master’s

degree (full time) in Management / Business Administration /

Finance / Economics / Public Policy / Social Work / Development

Studies / Rural Development. Candidate has done MSW-Distance

Education which cannot be considered as full time course Hence

we would not be able to take the candidature ahead.



Phase-IV

District PMU Lead

Grievance Redressal

27 17101739 Vijay kumar Srivastav

I have applied the for the post of District PMU Lead . I have seen my score, published

on 15.02.2018 but i get astonished & shocked to see my poor marks. Sir I have

Worked as Managerial position for more then 3 years. I have worked in different

Department of Government Sector i.e Bihar State Housing Board, BRLPS (jeevika),

Bihar Industrial Area Development Authority etc. I have total more then 5 years

experience in working period . Sir i have worked more then 4 years for project .i am

presently working with Industry Department of Bihar . it also surprised to see the

marks of interview because no one has called me for interview. Sir i have done my

Post graduation in Rural management & development from Patna University ,

Besides its I have also done journalism & Mass communication from the same .

Patna university is one of the prestigious University in the Bihar. It is very

heartbreaking that this university got Zero marks. its unjust ice for Bihar Student .sir i

am very fond to work with this prestigious organisation . i have fill up the form with

hopefully. its a rare chance for me.

So, Kindly reevaluate & examine my whole documents again. i will be ever

great full .

Candidate has been awarded maximum possible marks as per the

preferred marking criteria .

As per the details mention in application form institute or college

is not in NIRF list.



28 1710490 manoj kumar

As per my application, I have done full time master degree in Labour and social

welfare (LSW) and also done PG diploma in rural development. So I request to

revalidate my candidature and make it fit for further evaluation process.




Studies / Rural Development.And secondly , Candidate has done

MA-LSW & PG-Diploma Distance Education which cannot be

considered as desired specialization as per preferred marking

criteria. Hence we would not be able to take the candidature

ahead.


29 17103280ADITYA PRAKASH

I had submitted by complete application form. But my name is coming in the list of

Not Fit for Further Evaluation Process". I am submitting my documents again for

consideration. Documents required.

1. OCT/SEP 2017 Salary slips of PwC India

2. Offer Letter of IMRB International (now Kantar Public), issued in 2011.



Revalidated Score




Total Revalidated Score-50 Marks



30 17102967Kumar abhishek

1-MY Management Degree not matching with the criteria thus my candidature has

been rejected.

2-Score of Preferred marking on Post-qualification Experience.

3-Score for Role- PMO role marking.

4-Score for Experience of working with Bilateral organizations.



Revalidated Score

score on project monitoring and data/business analysis-25marks




31 17104506 Md Shabbir Alam

I have worked in a project funded by PACS - A DFID a program for 1 year between

March, 2015 to February, 2016 for which I have not given marks. Kindly consider my

experience and give mark for it.


on the basis of state/central/bilateral/multilateral.

Total Revalidated Score-10marks

Additional 10Marks

[email protected]


Phase-IV

District PMU Lead

Grievance Redressal

32 17104531 Abinash

1) Consider my work Experience (ADITHI-Plan International-India)under bilateral /

multilateral organizations and award me full 10 marks.2)Reservation for Grandson of

Freedom Fighter

As per the details mentioned in application form, Additional

experience of 1 year has been mentioned for duration between

01-11-2017 to 31-10-2018(Which is beyond date of application.

and which cannot be considered and hence 5 marks based on

post qualification experience have been reduced.

Candidate has worked with Athithi and Cyber Infodev which

cannot be considered as experience of working as

State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral.

Reservation benefits will be provided as per the Reservation

guideline of Bihar Government.


10 Marks reduced [email protected]

33 17104326 SREE SHIVAM1) My total score by mancer is 14. Out of which 4 is given as interview marks.

But I have not given any interview to your agency.

Please clarify regarding the methodology adopted.

Additional 20 Marks will be awarded for 4 completed years of

experience in Project Monitoring & Business Analysis. Updated

Interview Score will be -8

Changes will be incorporated in Final Merit List.

Additional 20 Marks

[email protected]

34 17102604 Ravi Shankar Kumar

1)MBA full time.2)Having 7 year of experience with State Govt. 3)5 year of

experience over 3 years experiece as on dated 01/01/2018 at District level postion

so far consider for 25 marks as :- 5 year x 5 marks= 25 marks must be added in my

score. 4)Expereice of working with state org. Must add 10 marks.

We had not received any document in application form and We



November. Hence we would not be able to take the candidature

forward.


35 17106778 DIVYA VIKAS SHARMA

1) Marks of total experiences has been not considered as I have total 4 & half years

of experiences, only 3 years has been considered, experience of 1 years in DHFL

Pramerieca LIC need to be counted, also doc(Exp Certificate) had been submitted

earlier & 5 marks should be alloated instead of 0 mark. Again, I am attaching &

sending the experience cum relieving letter of that 1 year experience along with this

mail.Kindly consider it. Apart from that I have 8 months of experince, where I am

currently working, for which I had attached the offer letter & NOC(No Objection

Certificate) along with application and again I am sending you along with the

mail.2)Marks of working with state/central government has been not counted

although I have 3 years of experiences in state govt. Organization i.e Jeevika so

requested to give 10 marks on the basis of this experience. Other candidates with

similar organization got 10 marks.3) Marking of Interview is not known , how is it

alloated as I got 5 marks only. As i didnt get any telephonic call or interview call so

kindly look into the issue.


on the basis of Post qualifcation experience.

score based on state/central/bilateral/multilateral-10marks


Additional 15Marks

awarded [email protected]

36 17101152 GOUTAM KUMAR VIKHYAT

MA in Globalization and labour is one of the programmes offered by School of

Management and Labour studies from Tata Institute of Social Science, Mumbai. It is

a super specialized programme, this program specifically designed to strengthen the

informal labour market, trade union and cooperatives. This program is run by TISS,

Mumbai and TISS is part of the Global Labour University network in partnership with

the International Labour Organization.The course content is very similar to Master of

Social Work and some part is similar to human resource management. So kindly

consider this to be as a Master of Social Work.

As per the details mentioned in application form candidate has

not done PG diploma(2 years full time) or master's degree(full

time) in Management/Business

Administration/Finance/Economics/Public Policy/Social

Work/Development Studies/Rural Development as candidate has

done Master of arts in Globalisation and Labour.


37 17105434 Kaushal Ray Marks for Experience not added. I have 4 years of experience

As per details mention in application form 3.7 years experience

could be establish,which already awarded Hence no additional



Phase-IV

District PMU Lead

Grievance Redressal

38 17102424 satyendra kumar

1) i have four years experience but i have got only 5 MARKS .2)I am working in DAY-

NULM project (state and central govt) but i got 0(zero) marks. 3).i want to know

,what is interview marks.

As per details mention in application form 4.6 years experience


marks have been awarded.Additional 10 Marks have been

awarded on the basis of State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral

Experience.


Additional 10 Marks


39 17101466 ANUP ANAND

I want to say that I have more than 7.9 year of experience but from your side it is

considered only 4 year.Therefor I requesting to you kindly considered on

my grievance.


on the basis of Post qualifcation experience.

score based on state/central/bilateral/multilateral-5marks


Additional 20 Marks


40 17104033 Ajay Kumar

AS per requirement of this post I have all essential qualification as well as

experience.So,please consider my candidature for this post.All relevant experience is

attached here.


on the basis of state/central/bilateral/multilateral.

score based on Post qualification experience-30 marks

experience with State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral Experience-

10 Marks




41 17101737 BINOD Paswan

i am sending supporting document take necessary action . i am working Health

Dept govt of health (NHM) since 30-05-2010 to Till date . Mention related Field

of Application Form

candidate does not have minimum 3 year of post qualification exp



Revalidated Score

score on Post qualifcation score-20marks


Additional 10 Marks have been awarded on the basis of

state/central/bilateral/multilateral.




42 17107294 Manav Saurav

Working as Project Manager MIS from 3rd November 2014 till date at BRLPS, JEEViKA.

This experience only contributes more than three years when calculated as on

01/JAN/2018. This is the date for calculation of DOB which also qualifies it to be

considered for experience. And this is post qualification of Master’s degree. Prior to

Masters I have 6 and half years of experience.




November. Hence we would not be able to take the candidature

forward.


43 17106185 Manish Pandey

1)Candidate has worked with USAID/ A2Z project approx 30 months and this

organization also a multilateral organization. Candidate has downloaded the

experience cetificate with online application form.Candidate has worked with Fhi

360 approx 12 months and this organization also a multilateral organization.

Candidate has downloaded the experience cetificate with online application form.

2) Candidate could not attach experience certificate worked with Manav Sewa

Sansthan but mentioned in Curriculum –Vitae and attaching it .

Candidate could not attach any documents related to present company but

mentioned in Curriculum –Vitae and attaching appointment letter copy

candidate have been working with A2Z which cannot be consider

as state/central/bilateral/multilateral experience as candidate has

not been directly associate with such organisation.Hence no

additional marks would be awarded.

In the case of non availability of supporting document of Manav

Sewa Sansthan we would not be able to consider such experience.

in case of current employee we need salary slip or some others

supporting document to establish the case.

No Changemanishomnamahshivay1982@gmai

l.com


Phase-IV

District PMU Lead

Grievance Redressal

44 17106434 Sumit PrakashMy Name or Application id is not in any of the list. ( Not fit or fit). Can you please

look onto it ASAP.

Application ID is 17106434 and Candidate can check their

application status by visiting www.mancerbvm.com in Provisional

Merit List in Not Fit for Further Evaluation Process because after

post qualification experience is 1.7 years.


45 17106433 SATISH KUMAR SUMANtotal experience in Project Monitoring & data analyst -25 marks . NIRF Ranking-10

marks


on the basis of experience with project monitoring and

data/MIS/business analysis

additional 10 marks have been awarded for university ranked in

NIRF 2017 List.

Total Revalidated Score-15 marks

Additional 15Marks


46 17106149 Sumit Kumar

1) Less Experience has been

Counted with BRLPS( Jeevika) 2)Experience of Medecins Sans

Frontiers (MSF) has not been

Counted as it’s a bilateral

Organization.3)Working with Gramin Evam Nagar Vikas Parishad and Bal Mahila

Kalyan under Link worker Scheme was Funded by UNDP and GFATM and monitored

by NACO/BASACS which are Government Wing

.So its Experience also be counted.

As per details mention in application form 8 years experience




47 17103019 Ravi Kumar

1)Consideration of Two years Master of Social Work completed through Directorate

of Distance Education. 2)Having more than 7 years of post-qualification Working

experience in the Government organisation at state level.3)Appreciation letter

received for “Mukhyamantri 7 Nishchya Yojana”

(copy attached)





MSW-VMU Distance Education which cannot be considered as

desired specialization as per preferred marking criteria. Hence

we would not be able to take the candidature ahead.


48 17104265 OMKAR SHUKLA Not received reservation under freedom fighter grand Son

Reservation benefits will be provided as per the Reservation

guideline of Bihar Government and changes will be incorporated

in Final Merit List.


49 17105673 piyush kumar

10 marks has been deducted in experience of working with state . Currently I am

working with “ Bihar Rajya Madhayan Bhojan Yojna Samiti” which is a State Govt.

entity under Education Department of Bihar. I have worked for more than 2 years

now and so please look into this matter.

Grievance Considereded. Additional 10Marks have been awarded

on the basis of experience with

State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral Experience.

Additional Marks awarded-10 marks

Additional 10 Marks


50 17107500 OM BABU1.My experience is not counted.I have attached my experience certificate. 2.Remarks

column is not clear,if anything I have to provide.

As per details mentioned in application form and preferred



awarded.


51 17103626DR MAHESHWARI SINGH

MAHESHDone Full time M.Sc and P.hd





MBA-VMU Distance Education & MSC-Botany & PGDE which

cannot be considered as desired specialization as per preferred

marking criteria. Hence we would not be able to take the

candidature ahead.


Phase-IV

District PMU Lead

Grievance Redressal

52 17101373 ARBIND KUMAR SINHA

With reference to trail mail and above cited subject, I would request to please look

into the marking allotted under head "Experience in Project Monitoring & Data

Analysis" . Please find the attached documents in this regard. If anything more

required then please let me know. Looking forward to your kind support.

As per the details mentioned in the application, in Experience in

project monitoring and data/ MIS / business

analysis criteria candidate is having only 4 years of experience in

NAV BHARAT JAGRITI KENDRA. Hence, maximum possible marks

has been already awarded to the canddate.


53 17102263 RAHUL RANJAN

Ranking show that kalinga Institute of Industrial technology (KIIT University) shows

the rank 22 but in revalidate score I had received only 10 marks which should be

according to University rank will be 0f 20 marks.

Grievance Considereded.

Revalidated Score:

Additional 10 marks in NIRF ranking has been awarded to the

candidate

Changed [email protected]

54 17102648 Manish Kumar

1.Higher Education qualification - MBA from Xavier Institute of Social Service ,

Ranchi session - 2009 - 11 , Marks obtained 56.36 % .2. Experience - BIHAR RURAL

LIVELIHOOD PROMOTION SOCIETY (JEEVIKA )Worked from 24.10.2013 till

15.02.2018 till Today , Experience - 4 years and 2 Month. 3. Experience - NEED

PATNA - Worked 20-06-2011 to 22-08-2013 Experience 2.2 years. 4. NIRF Ranking -

Xavier Institute of Social Service , NIRF ranking is 75


Revalidated Score awarded have been as follows:

Post qualification experience-15 marks

Project monitoring and data /MIS/Business analysis-15 marks


10 marks

NIRF-10marks

Interview Score-

Total Revalidated Score-



55 17104164 MD FAIYAZ ANSARI

I have 3.9 years’ experience after post-graduation as an Executive HR/Admin /CSR

in REC Ltd,where I had experience in project monitoring on CSR activities and

doing MIS report monthly and sending to our Corporate Office but I didn’t get any

marks on that.


Revalidated Score awarded have been as follows:

Project monitoring and data /MIS/Business analysis-15 marks


10 marks

Additional 25 Marks

[email protected]

56 17105278 Krishn Kumar Gupta

I am hereby sending you my grievances

experience letter, Marksheet of Social Work, resume.




November. Hence we would not able to consider this certificate

and Hence we would not be able to take the candidature

forward.


57 17105144 Shashi Shankar Khan

1)As I have worked with private limited organisation which is comes under

multilateral/bilateral organisation hence this marks should also be added.2)Since, I

have started my career from 2007 hence total marks should be calculated on 10+

years experience and it should be 35 instead of 30.

Additional 5 Marks have been awarded on the basis of post-

qualification

Score based on experience state/central/bilateral/multilateral-

10 marks

as per the details mention in application from institute or college

is not in NIRF list. Hence no additional marks have been

awarded.


Additional 15Marks

awarded

& 10 Marks reduced from

NIRF

[email protected]

58 17105935 Bandana kumari

I Bandana kumari applied for the District PMU Lead which Aplication no-

17105935,and another post Department PMU Lead which application no-

17105930.Until i didn't receive any information regarding Department PMU lead

post. I got marks for District PMU lead,but there is no information about interview

or selection or rejection process,Plz clearify about its process.

It's humble request:

we request candidate to visit www.mancerbvm.com to

understand the further process. No Change [email protected]


Phase-IV

District PMU Lead

Grievance Redressal

59 17105871 Md Afroz Alam As required by mail and Telecon , I have mail the Document attached with mail



Revalidated Score

Score on Post qualifcation score-10marks


score based on state/central/bilateral/multilateral experience-

10 marks



45



60 17105399 Manish Kumar Unable to find my application ID in any of the list

Application ID is 17105399 and Candidate can check their

application status by visiting www.mancerbvm.com in

Provisional Merit List in BC Open List.


61 17103938 DEWAKI NANDAN TIWARI

In project monitoring and data / MIS / business analysis, I have received 15 mark.

This appears to be based on 3 years of work experience in project monitoring

however i have 4 years of work experience on dated 31 October 2017.

BRLPS (JEEViKA) (SRLM) (NRLM) BIHAR- 22nd Oct 2013 to 28th March 2016 ( 2

Years & 5 months) (Experience Letter Attached)

National Urban Livelihood Mission (NULM)- 1st April 2016 to till date( 31 october-

2017) ( 1 years & 7 months) (Offer letter Attached, head no. 2- Financial Inclusion &

Micro Enterprises, point No.-6)

Thus till 31 October 2017 I have total work experience 4 years.

5 more marks should be considered in this regards.




awarded.


62 17101143 VIKASH KUMAR

I have 7 years 7 months experience after my full time MBA 27-7-2009 from MU,

Bodh Gaya but

According to Mancer:- Candidate does have 6 year of post qualification experience

from document.


Additional 5 Marks has been awarded for post qualification

experience

Additional 5 Marks

[email protected]

63 17101583 JAYSHREE CHORMA

I have 5 years 9 months experience after my full time MBA (Finance) 2010 from

DAVV, Indore but

According to Mancer:- Candidate does have 4 year of post qualification experience

from document.Kind your better information my PGDHHM course is

correspondence from vinayaka mission university, Tamilnadu in 2012 during my

service period of Caritas India.

Therefore, I requested to you please count my experience total 5 years 9 months

after my full time MBA in 2010 according to employment history.


post qualification experience-5 Marks

Project Monitoring and data/MIS/business analysis-5 Marks

Additional 10 Marks

[email protected]

64 17107413 SAJAL SALIL Please inform for further action as my name is listed for further evaluation process.We request candidate to visit www.mancerbvm.com to

understand further processNo Change [email protected]


Phase-IV

District PMU Lead

Grievance Redressal

65 17102207 Sharvan kumar jha

Masters of management science From IIPS ,DAVV Indore period from 2003-0

equivalent to MBA degree .

Related field of application form Candidate has not done PG Diploma(2 years full

time) or Master’s degree( full time) in Management / Business Administration /

Finance / Economics / Public Policy / Social Work / Development Studies / Rural

Development.


further evaluation process

Score based on post qualification experience-5

Score based on Project monitoring & MIS/Business &

data/business analysis-10 marks

Score based on experience of working with

State/Central/Bilateral/multilateral organization-10 marks.

Score based on NIRF ranking of Institute/University-0

Total revalidated Score-25



66 17103458 ANIL KUMAR1)Relieaving /experience attaiched .2)last last month salary slip RGAVP attached

and sent you today and 29th January 2018

Post qualification score-25 Marks

score on project monitoring and data/business analysis-25 Marks

score based on state/central/bilateral/multilateral experience-

10 Marksplease check



67 17105267Ravindra Kumar

I have 8 year experience after Post qualification

We have not received any document in application form and We



November. Hence we would not able to consider this certificate

and Hence we would not be able to take the candidature

forward.


68 17102941 GAUTAM BHARTI DOC ALREADY SENT ON THE MENTIONED MAIL ID

As per the documents shared its not possible to establish end

date of DISHNET WIRELESS LIMITED and TELENOR

COMMUNICATION. We request you to share relevent document

either last month salary slip or experience letter else we would

not take your candidatue ahead.


Phase-IV

District PMU Lead

Grievance Redressal

69 17106157 MD RAGHIB ANWER

I MD RAGHIB ANWER would like to submit grievances for the position of District

PMU Lead with Application ID 17106139.

I would like to bring to your kind notice regarding my experience in project

monitoring and data/MIS/business analysis. Under this criteria I have not been

awarded any number but I would like to mention the following supporting

statement in this regard.

Currently I am working as Manager Inspection and SOP Assurance (Sutra

Consultancy) with Bihar Rural Livelihood Promotion Society under DDUGKY

(Ministry of Rural Development Project- Government of India and Government of

Bihar). (evidence attached)

Here I coordinate, collate, prepare and track progress report of all partners.

Physical site inspection of each PIAs is one of my KPA through online MIS system,

visiting of the skill training centers and hostels across the state of Bihar, compliance

verification, scientific representation of skill training centers for grading and

ranking. (evidence attached)

I am also actively involvement in monitoring the progress through monthly

conference calls/using MIS based reports/financial tracking/field inspection.

(evidence attached)

Monthly and quarterly progress review of PIAs- I am part of the team for all kinds

of review of all the project implementing agencies.(evidence attached)

Apart from the current organization in the previous organisations also I have

experience in project monitoring and data/ MIS. (evidence attached)

In District PMU lead criteria is Experience of working with state

/ central government / bilateral / multilateral organizations (e.g.

World bank, DFID, UNDP, ADB) /private organization /

multinational corporation on project monitoring and capacity

building aspects where as in district PMU lead criteria of marking

is Experience of working with state / central government /

bilateral / multilateral organizations (e.g. World bank, DFID,

UNDP, ADB) on project monitoring and capacity building

As Private organisation is inclded in department PMU lead hence

10 marks has awarded where as private organisation is not

included in district PMU lead hence no additional marks has

been awarded in District PMU Lead.


70 17104087 GAURAV SINGH

The remark for my application is mentioned that "Candidate does not have

Minimum 3 years of post-qualification experience" i would like to consider you that

I HAVE COMPLETED POST QUALIFICATION IN 2014. AND CURRENTLY I AM

WORKING AS CITY MISSION MANAGER IN ARARIA, BIHAR UNDER DAY-NULM. I

HAVE 3 YEARS OF EXPERIENCE AFTER POST QUALIFICATION.This I had mentioned in

telephonic interview.Kindly take serious look into my ATTACHED DOCUMENT and

revalidate if Possible.For your convenience I would like to say I applied for

DEPARTMENT PMU LEAD and my application is Fit for Further Evaluation

Process.2.EXPERIENCE :- I HAVE COMPLETED POST

QUALIFICATION IN 2014. AND CURRENTLY I AM WORKING AS CITY MISSION

MANAGER IN DAY-NULM. I HAVE 3 YEARS OF EXPERIENCE AFTER POST

QUALIFICATION

As per the documents mentioned in application form only 2.11

years of post qualification experience that’s why candidate has

not meet perfered criteria. Hence we could not take candidature

ahead.


71 17101283Sagar Ojha

Ref to the email dated 14.02.2018, application status of 17101283 is unable to track

by visiting www.mancerbvm.com for the post applied for District PMU Lead.

It has not shown any update (My Details) in Provisional List or not shown in

Provisional Merit list of candidate fit for further evaluation process also.

As per desired documents i have sent you my all related documents as an

attachments on [email protected] dated January 29th, 2018..

Submitted for kind consideration from your side. I will be highly obliged for that.

Candidate is requested to visit www.mancerbvm.com and check

Provisional Merit list of candidates fit for further evaluation

process


Phase-IV

District PMU Lead

Grievance Redressal

72 17105579Mr Omprakash Mishra

In my experience specially with ATDC, SWAJAN and KPMG

(1) I worked twice (for 4 Year and 3 Months and 1 Year) with SAWJAN- Which is an

implementing agency of various government project. As my both role I was engaged

on project management role in various aspects of project, In my first experience I

was looking after risk management, Project monitoring, MIS, MPR and

implementation aspects of project management in my second engagement I was

responsible or whole project from conception and initiation planning, project

monitoring, MIS, execution/implementation, risk management and closing aspects of

project management.

New letter of SAWJAN defining role and responsibility is attached here with for your

kind reference.

(2) With ATDC (2 year and 8 Months) – In this experience

I work for conception and initiation, planning, execution, risk management and

closing aspects of Project Management and project monitoring over there. I

requested ATDC for document which can describe my role. Still document is awaited

and will be submitted as soon as it will received.

(3)With KPMG (6 Months)- KPMG is well known project management organization

and here also I am involve in all aspects of PMO. Agreement which indicate PMO role

in this role is also attached here with.

At least my this 8 year 4 month experience in project management aspects make me

eligible for additional 25 Marks for PMO role.


Additional 25 marks will be awarded for experience in project

monitoring and data/ MIS / business analysis

25 Marks awarded [email protected]

73 17107103 Manish Kumar Singh

I have total 8 years of working experience in development sector. As per the post

qualification experience criteria, i should have considered for addition marks.

I am currently associated with Azim Premji foundation and cordinating teachers

training program at district level.

I have 2 year's of working experience with state goverment program (MpoWeR-

Mitigating poverty of western Rajasthan, Project of Rajasthan Govt.), in my previous

organization SRIJAN

Please also consider it in the marking criteria.

As per details mentioned in application form,candidate has

experince of less than 8 years(till the date of application)hence no

additional marks have been based on post qualification

experience.

As per details mentioned in application form,candidate has work

with Azim Premji Foundation and Srijan which can not be consider

experience of working with State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral

Organization.


74 17103420 RAHUL KISHOR Find attachment regarding grievances for revalidated score for the post

of District PMU Lead and kindly do needful.

Grievance Considereded. Additional 10 marks will be awarded for

experience of working with State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral

Organization.

Additional 25 marks will be awarded Candidate has 7 years of

experience as Project Monitoring and MIS.

Additional35 Marks

[email protected]

75 17101509 SHIPRA SINHA

Alloted 0 marks in Preferred marking on Total Experience: Max 35 marks 5 marks for

each additional completed year (over 3 years minimum experience).Kindly clarify on

this and check it again.




awarded.


Phase-IV

District PMU Lead

Grievance Redressal

76 1710620 Rehan Nabi

I would like to draw your attention that along with District PMU Lead I have

applied for the Management Assistant II also, and i got call from Mancer

representative ( Mr. Amit) and he has told that after review my application and cv

he found that i have knowledge of Data Analysis, MIS and Business Analysis but

Mancer criteria required PMO role, So he did not award me additional marks,

But since now i have all relevant experience like Data Analysis / MIS / business

analysis so i am well eligible for the criteria of ( Experience in project monitoring and

data / MIS / business analysis - Max 25 marks 5 marks for each completed year of

such experience ) I have enclosed my grievance redressal detail in excel sheet with

this mail, Please consider it seriously and provide my right this time i am not going to

loose these marks.

As per details mentioned in the application form Candidate does

not having Experience in

project monitoring and data / MIS/ business analysis/data /

MIS / business analysis.


77 17102141Md. Zakaullah

1)The required/requested documents for the establishment of eligibility &

experience validation has been duly submitted with the application as well as

through e-mail within provided time frame. Kindly request to re-evaluate the

application, qualification (submitted docs), as per the criteria I fulfill all the pre-

requisites for the post.2)Provisional list of candidate Not Fit for Further Evaluation

Process Comment: Claims made from application form could not be

established as per attached documents ("Claims", mentioned in the comment is not

clear, kindly specify the word Claims).

Greivence considered

Candidate have been moved to fit for further evaluation process



Revalidated Score

Post qualifcation score-5 marks



marks



55



78 7104792Laljee Dipak

I have master degree while mentioned in the remarks is Candidate does not have PG

Diploma (2 years full time) or Master’s degree or higher (full time)





Work/Development Studies/Rural Development. Candidate has

done MSW part time.

Note: If you have any queries , Please write back to us by 16th

march 2018(6PM)


79 17106709 Md. Moquarrab Danish

Revalidated score 55+7=62 1. I have total 7 year experience in Government

Project. 3 years onward 4 years experience my score should be 4x5=20. in first

colum

2. maximum 25 marks in govt. project but I got only 15 in second colum. as per govt

exp. my score should be 25.

3. My total online score is 75 and my revalidate score should be 75+7=82

Additional 10 marks have been awarded for post qualification

experience , no additional marks provided for experience in

project monitoring&MIS/ Business Analysis as role with othr

organisation as field officer.Hence no additional have been

awarded this catogery


80 1710964Janeshwar Renu

please find the attachment of work experience of hind dalit utthan samiti 01-01-

2010 to 10-11-2013,offer letter of jeevika and last month salary slip.


been already Awarded maxmimum possible marks.We had not

received one document in application form related to

experience and We had provided an opportunity to all candidates

to update application form between given time period of 14th -

18th November. Hence we would not able to consider this

certificate.


Phase-IV

District PMU Lead

Grievance Redressal

81 17107285 Rajiv Ranjan pls find working detail of peasant organization.




awarded.


82 17101285Prabhakar Kumar

My Grievance related to Preferred marking on total experience(In the first column

where the chances is for 35 Maximum marks) I have total Eight and Half year of Post

Qualification Experience till the date of application send to work with different

Multilateral organizations like in the different capacity. But I have got only 20 marks

where I have opportunity to get 35 Marks. Revalidate the Marks of Preferred

Marking on Total Experience

As per the details mentioned in application form candidate has 8

years of experience post qualification . Hence as per the preferred

marking criteria 5 additional marks have been awarded based on

post qualification experience


83 17104965anju kumari

I am not satisfied with this score after provisional merit list score (25)




awarded.


84 17101312 Rajiv Ranjan

I have received a SMS regarding viewing the application status online but I am

unable to view my details in the linked file.Please resolve.Note: The soft copy of the

application is attached herewith for your perusal..

Name of applicant name is mentioned in provisional list Not fit for

further evaluation process so candidate is requested to

visit www.mancerbvm.com.


85 17102028Aditya Mishra

As Per list Published for District PMU Lead in Bihar Vikas Mission. totally

disappointed for marks which I have got Initially I have got 55 marks but after re-

validated score it's showing only 5.But Actually NIRF ranking marks I should get 20

marks. Please Let me know how it's calculating.FYI Please find the screen shot

Grievance Considered.

Additional 20 marks awared for University / College /

Management Institution ranked in NIRF2017, as

applicable.Institutes ranked upto 50

For post qualification experience already 5 marks have been

awarded no additional marks have been awarded as per the

preferred marking criteria.

For Project monitoring & Data/business analysis 20 marks have

been awarded.


86 17101283 Sagar Ojha

Ref to the email dated 14.02.2018, application status of 17101283 is unable to track

by visiting www.mancerbvm.com for the post applied for District PMU Lead.

It has not shown any update (My Details) in Provisional List or not shown in

Provisional Merit list of candidate fit for further evaluation process also. As per

desired documents i have sent you my all related documents as an attachments on

[email protected] dated January 29th, 2018..

Submitted for kind consideration from your side. I will be highly obliged for that.


Provisional list of candidates not fit for further evaluation process


87 17101502Deepak Gupta

Applicant first name need to be correct (First Name should be Deepak in place of

Deeapk)

As per the details mentioned in application form Name mention is

Deeapk, that’s why system categorized your name as Deeapk.

We will make required changes but if called for interview

candidate has to submit affidavit to established claim made


88 1710282 Nishant Kumar

I have completed my 2 year full time PG Diploma in Rural Management from NIRF

Institute IRMA with a ranking of 29(Reason-I don't have 2 years full time PG Diploma

In rural management??).I have been deemed unfit for further

evaluation.Surprisingly, one of my juniors with the same degree(app id- 17107355 )is

part of the provisional merit list ???Has there been any strict vigil mechanism or

results have been drawn randomly??

Based on post qualification experience:15 Marks will be

awarded(Experience calculated till(05-10-2017).

Role marking in Project Monitoring & Business Analysis-25 Marks

NIRF Marking-20 Marks

Interview Marks-9 Marks

Total Revalidated Score-15+25+20+8-69 Marks.



Phase-IV

District PMU Lead

Grievance Redressal

89 17101354 mritunjay rai

1) I did not get marks for experience in project business analysis-As mentioned in my

CV , I have experience in financial analyisis of different projects/business.2)I did not

get marks for Experience in data anaysis-As mentioned in my CV I am Proficient in

preparing & presenting various weekly & monthly MIS Reports after analysis

pertaining to several processes




awarded.


90 17102370KUNJAN SINGH

I am not able to check my Application status District PMU LEAD.....

APPLICATION NO - 17102370..

Plz provide current status....

Name of applicant name is mentioned in provisional merit list fit

for further evaluation process so candidate is requested to

visit www.mancerbvm.com.


91 17107354 Reetika Upadhyay

3 Years Post Qualification Experience Available Still showing in Reject List. I have

completed my MBA in May 2014 , still i have received a mail mentioning that i have

completed my MBA in Dec 2014 , so my candidature cannot be considered , how is

this possible , as I have received my Passing out certificate on 31st May 2014 itself . I

also have experience of more than 3 years . Please re validate my certificate.

attached are documents for verification.

Grievance Considereded. Candidate have been moved to fit for

further evaluation process.

Revalidated score awarded is as follows:

Score based on Post Qualification experience - 0



applicable.Institutes ranked upto 50 & 51

& above:

Revalidated Score:10



92 17103406Mukesh Kumar

I bag to say that my name is Mukesh kumar, I had applied for the post of District

PMU Lead,but my grievance is that i had selected in first merit list which had been

issued by in your side and i am already fulfilled the essential and desirable

qualification as per your advertisement.but the recent list is my name is reflecting in

not fit candidate list.so, I request you to please again review my application. i am

attaching here required document for your reference.

Candidate has been considered for further evaluation process

Score based on post qualification experience-20 Marks



93 17106643Reeta yadav

1.I have 2 years experience in project monitoring, on the basis of experience marking

I got only 5 marks in experience category whereas 5 marks each years of experience,

on that basis my score should be 10 in experience category.2. I have 1 years

experience in finance field banking but I didn'tget any marks.

Grievance Considered.

Additional 5 marks awraded for Experience in

project monitoring and data / MIS / business analysis


94 17101587 Munmun Kumari

I have grievance regarding score published against the position of DISTRICT PMU

LEAD.I have working experience with State government ,World Bank but in the

scoring board no any marks added in this reference.Kindly re validate the

documents/data about the core and basic works done in state Government /World

bank by me.Find the attachment and do as needful.Ignore the previous mail.




awarded..


Phase-IV

District PMU Lead

Grievance Redressal

95 1710459 Dr.jaikant singh

This post for essential required Qualification in Master Degree. (Two year full time)

I have Two year Master Degree in Financial Management (Full Time). Please see on

my Degree and Mark sheet clearly mention a Subject of Financial management

(i am Gold Medalist and First Rank in Financial Management of University Level in

2007.)

(Please find enclosed file.)

and other second degree in Master of Social Work and other technical diploma in

computer application. so i have full fill the essential qualification for this post.

2. for this post essential required experience is minimum 3 year of post qualification.

(a) I have 5.5 year experience in Research and Data Analysis in Banaras Hindu

University India.

(b) I have 2.4 year experience work on Project monitoring and capacity building

aspects in international level organization (Help Age India)

(b) I have 1.4 year experience on livelihood,Project Monitoring Lead in ambika

shiksha samaj kalyan samiti at india level.

Total 9 year Experience In different area after post qualification. so i have full fill the

all essential qualification and experience.

But My Application is Rejected

Kindly i request to you please accept my application for the this post.

Candidate have not been PG Diploma (2 years full time) or

Master’s degree (full time) in Management / Business

Administration / Finance / Economics / Public Policy / Social Work

/ Development Studies / Rural Development. As Candidate has

done M.COM. Hence, We would not be able to take the

candidature ahead.


96 1710953Jawaid Ahsan

Marks of Govt project not added in my score -I worked from 1st Sept 2016 to 11th

January,2018 i.e 1.4 years in Rajasthan Skill Development Corporation (RSLDC) A

Rajasthan Govt Enterprize as a Zonal Coordinator.

Here Project Management Unit (PMU) is Accenture Solution Pvt Ltd, and all staffs of

RSLDC were hired by Accenture.

The role of Zonal Coordinator is to Execute and monitor Skill Development Project in

the State. Hence 05 points must be added in my score of experience in Govt related

Project.

Relevant documents in the form of Offer Letter, resignation acceptance &

Appreciation certificate (RSLDC) is also attached herewith for your kind consideration




awarded.


97 1710503 Vikas SinghRegarding Experience in project monitoring and MIS -Marks variation.I have not got

25 marks of Project monitoring and MIS in application form-1710503




awarded..


Phase-IV

District PMU Lead

Grievance Redressal

98 17101324aditya das

I Aditya Kumar Das (Application id-17101324) has applied for the post -District Pmu

Lead. I received an email on 30th Jan 2018 from [email protected]

regarding requirement of documents within 48hrs .Due to some unavoidable

circumstances I could not send the documents within the given time limit. I could

sent the required documents by 2 Feb.2018 while it had to be sent by 1 Feb 2018.

Today,when I checked the application status on Bvm Mancer website I find the

remark - not fit for further evaluation process

1. Claims made in application form could not be established from documents

I request you to kindly consider my request to look back into this matter and sort me

for further process as I do not wish to loose this golden opportunity of my life for a

mistake.I also promise the selection board to keep myself update on all notifications

in future regarding this selection process.

I shall be obliged if I get an opportunity to correct myself and allowed to go further.I

am attaching the supporting documents with this email.





Score awarded for Experience in project monitoring and data /

MIS / business analysis- 0

Score awarded for experience of working with

State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral Organization/Private

Organization -0

Revalidated Score: 35



99 17102207 Sharvan kumar jha

I have applied for post of District PMU lead in Bihar vikash mission bearing

application number 17102207 ,but to my utmost surprise I found myself in rejection

list .Reading the remarks I got surprised as I am masters in management science

from DAVV Indore period from 2003-05 Full time course, it is equivalent to MBA

degree as I am a rank holder at MAT having rank 102 all India Level in 2003.My

institute name Is IIPS Indore and university is DAVV further it is 2 nd best in Madhya

Pradesh , India.i am attaching my marksheet for reference .Kindly go through it and

consider my candidature

Candidate has been considered for further evaluation process

Score based on post qualification experience-5 Marks

MIS Monitoring & Data/business analysis-20 Marks



100 1710230Anup Ojha

1) Sir , I have More the 6 years experience as a HR & Admin Office and We know that

MIS/Business Analysis and Project monitering its come under the HR & Admin, it’s

the part of my work. I have got the 0 marks. Currenty I am handling 8 Working site

and handling MIS/Monitering the projects/and Anlysis the business of site. 2)Sir,I

have more the 6 years exp then how may I Got only 15 Makrs, I can provide all the

documents when needed, so please consider this sir. 3)Sir, I have not face any

interview then how may I got 5 marks.


1)Score awarded for Experience in project monitoring and data /


2) 5 marks have been awarded for interview based on discussion

during validation process. Hence no additional marks have been

awarded

Additional 25 Marks

[email protected]

101 17107120Ratnish Verma

Kindly ref to my application no: 17107120 Name Ratnish Verma my candidature has

been held for further processing - reason given that my experience is not established

as per the documents, where as i have more than 15 year of experience in related

work and in Nidan i was for13 years, i have also resend my experience documents

also to establish the same,Pls reconsider the same,









Organization -0

Total Revalidated Score:60



Phase-IV

District PMU Lead

Grievance Redressal

102 17102444Arup Ain

As per your information regarding the application status, which I applied for the

position of District PMU Lead. My application no is 17102444. As you mentioned my

experience is below three years is not correct. I have been working in World Bank

Project currently and my total experience is 14 years. Hoping you will treat my

application properly and definitely give me the opportunity so that I can serve your

esteemed organization accordingly.

As per the details mentioned in application form,duration of all

employment could not be established due to non availibility of

supporting document to establish duration (start date and end

date) with employer.


103 171027 RAHUL MISRA

1) I have 70 mths experience in service + time spent during my executive MBA from

IIM adds to my experience and recognized across globe as experience. Kindly

consider one more year of experience. Certificate attached. 2) I have 5 plus years of

experience in Data Management and MIS Maintenance, which can be verified

through these points. A) Same has been mentioned in my resume. B) Mail sent on

20/11/2017 to bvm. C) Same can be confirmed from HR of both of my employers. D)

Same can be confirmed from my then reporting managers - Numbers attached in

mail. (I have managed All India online franchisee single handedly in Motilal Oswal

Securities Ltd., 75+ franchisee, 4000+ clients, 500+ cr turnover. In Capital First

Securities, I have managed Options trading desk single handedly) .3)I have done Full

Time Residential Executive MBA from IIM Indore. It is recognized as MBA from govt.

of India. It ranked 10 in NIRF2017 ranking. It cannot be ruled out of my credentials.4)

I have not said, wrote or done anything to deserve 4 out of 10 in interview section.

Kindly reconsider and award marks as per my performance and credentials.

1)As per the perfred marking criteria maximum marks have been

already awarded for post qualification experience

2)Additional 25 marks has been awrded for Project Monitoring &

Business Analysis.

3)NIRF Score has not been awarded as institute is not ranked in

NIRF 2017 list

4)Interview marks has been awarded on the basis of discussion

and overall experience.

Hence no additional marks for this criteria

Additional 25 Marks

[email protected]

104 17101044Gyan Prakash

1) NIRF Ranking Marks have not been given.Sir/ma'am, I have also submitted my

Master in Marketing Management from Savitribai Phule Pune University whose NIRF

ranking is 18 so 20 more marks should be given in this section.Even I had sent a mail

regarding this matter on Mon, Nov 20, 2017 at 9:16 PM. So I request you to add the

additional 20 marks. 2) A missed call had come on my mobile and when I called on

the number a girl picked up my call and told me that my collegue might have called

me regarding the post you applied in BVM. He would again call you. But no call I got

then.Sir/ma'am, as no previous intimation regarding interview through email or

messages had been done that any one could prepare for the interview on the

scheduled day and time.

Grivence Considered Additional 20 marks have been awarded for

NIRF Ranking of Institute

Mancer Representative will get in touch today for telephonic

interview and taking prior appoinment for telephonic interview is

not possible that’s why email and sms has not been sent for

Telephonic Interview.

Additional 20 Marks

[email protected]

105 17106107SUMEET SHIVAM

As per Remarks "candidate does have post qualification of minimum six years";

Although I have total 07 years 02months (86Months) work experience post

qualification.

Attached Letter for your reference.

As per the details mentioned in application form Candidate has

less then 7 years of experience (till date of application) .

Hence no additional marks has been awarded


106 17102793 Sudhanshu Shekhar There is not list on given link!!! Candidate is requested to visit www.mancerbvm.com and check

Provisional list of candidates fit for further evaluation process


Phase-IV

District PMU Lead

Grievance Redressal

107 17106127Prashant Kumar Singh

Experience of working with state and world bank

University Ranked in NIRF in NIRF 2017

ON LINE SCORE

Gender

1)As per the details mention in application from Experience in

project monitoring and data / MIS / business analysis Hence no

additional marks have been awarded.

2)Additional 20 marks awarded for NIRF Institute

3)As per the details mentioned in application form, gender

mention is female, that’s why system categorized you female

category .We will make required changes but if called for

interview candidate has to submit affidavit to establish claim

made.

Additional 20 Marks

[email protected]

108 1710355 Sujeet Kumar

1) From July 2010 to Oct 2012, I worked with TRIFED (Ministry of Tribal Affairs, Govt.

of India) and Presently (from 15th May 2017 to till date) working with IWAI, Ministry

of Shipping, Government of India in National Waterways 1 project funded by World

Bank, the same has not been considered while evaluating. Please do so-Experience of

working with State government/Central Government/World Bank . 2) I am having 8

years of Post Qualification experience and the score given is only 25. It should be 35-

It has also not been considered

1) Grivence considered regarding experience of working with

State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral Organization

Additional 10 marks have been awarded.

2)We request the candidate refer prefred marking criteria as for 8

years of experience only 25 marks can be awarded which have

been Already awareded. Hence no additional marks for this

criteria

Additional 10 Marks

[email protected]

109 1710593Ranvijay Singh

As per the given chart for Provisional list of Candidate fit or Not-fit for further

evaluation process, there is my name mentioned in not Fit for further process due to

behind “Claims made from application from could not be established from

documents”

Please i have to requesting my all educational and work experience are correct and

same had been submitted during applying the form as given format, there was a

little change in my last experience at DNDi (till 31st December2017 was working, so

attached my last year contract) but when ever had e-mail me regarding the

documents to establish claims made in application form on 27th January,2018, I had

attached experience certificates of DNDi and Shyama Surgical & Chemicals again,

replied you within 48th hours as requesting, hence attached a snapshoot for the

commutated required documents

So requesting for consideration for short listing in further scrutiny where I will

definitely prove my expertise and competency as per your predefined clause.

Anticipating kind support and providing a chance to prove my expertise.

I will be ever grateful to you





Role marking in Project Monitoring & Business Analysis-5 Marks



applicable.Institutes ranked upto 50 & 51

& above:




110 1710142Avishek Kumar Singh

About Not Shortlisted Application form in the post of District PMU Lead,

App. No.- 1710142

Mention related Field of Application Form:-

I am eligible for the post of District PMU Lead, App. No.- 1710142 in

Bihar Vikash Mission vacancy. Please Re-check my application form &

Candidature.

My Higher Educational Qualification is Master of Arts (Economics) full

time degree from Magadh University Bodh Gaya and my working experience

is 3 year more than in Social Development, Rural Development,

Livelihood, Microfinance and Community Development etc. in

organization BIHAR RURAL LIVELIHOOD PROMOTION SOCIETY (JEEVIKA) at

the post of ‘’Community Co-ordinator’’. Role of Project Monitoring.

So, Please Re-check my application form & Candidature.

Ø Supporting Document attached in this Mail, Please checking…






MIS / business analysis-15 marks



Organization -10 marks




Phase-IV

District PMU Lead

Grievance Redressal

111 17104001Jainandan Kumar

1) field of experience colem in Block Health Manager and Hospital Manager -there

are mentions in my application form "OTHER"but this the project of NATIONAL

HEALTH MISSION govt of india so I requested to plese change position of other to

PROJECT.in all experience collems. 2)experience in goverment sector -i have all

experience related to goverment sector. Excluding MSEVS Jamshedpur. So plese

provide extra weightage.

As per the details, mentioned in application form and as per the

preffered marking criteria maximum marks have already awarded,



112 17106392 Anand Jha

n Currently, I am working as a Young Professional for the National Career Service

Project, an initiative of the Ministry of Labour & Employment, Government of India

since 5th of October 2015.

n I have already completed two years implementing, coordinating and monitoring a

national level project of the Central government.

n The selection of Young professionals- NCS project was made by the National

Institute of Career Service, Noida or NICS,Noida ( erstwhile CIRTES) ,under

Directorate General of Employment, Ministry of Labour & Employment, Govt.of

India.

n Therefore, I do qualify for getting reasonable marks for my experience of working

with Central government organization for at least two completed years of such an

experience.

n I would like to highlight that my online score was “10”under that category while

the revalidated score is “0”.

It is requested to consider revising my overall scores considering my full time 2 years

experience with a central government organization.







Total Revalidated score : 10 marks



113 17104138 Hasan Reza

My name os not included in the merit list due I am not a master degree holder.

I have completed my my Masters in International Business from Jamia Millia Islamia

New Delhi in 2005 a full time course.

Please find the below comment of yours;

378 HASAN IMAM REZA 17104138 General Male Candidate does not have PG

Diploma (2 years full time) or Master’s degree or higher (full time) in Business

Administration/ Finance / Economics / Public Policy / Social Work / Development

Studies / Rural Development

Please find the certificate attached with this email.

Hoping a positive response for the same.

Candidate has done Master in international Business which

cannot be considered as desired specialisation as per preffered

marking criteria which is PG Diploma (2 years full time) or

Master’s degree or higher (full time) in Business

Administration/ Finance / Economics / Public Policy / Social Work

/ Development Studies / Rural Development


114 17102628

Anand Mishra I ma failed to check my candidature status. Please check and confirm me.

Name of applicant name is mentioned in provisional merit list fit

for further evaluation process so candidate is requested to visit

www.mancerbvm.com.


115 17102427Vikas singh

1) I have experience of project monitoring MIS, Market Research, Business

Strategy.but not mention 25 marks for such experience. 2) I have experience in one

of the institutes its name is NIMS (National Institute Of Management Solutions) This

institute is running under the Govt of Delhi, Its an NGO, We follow all the rule of

Govt of Delhi, so That reason I want marks more.









116 17102934 RAKESH DEEP

I, Dr. Rakesh Deep, application no- 17102934 (cat- gen) had applied for the post of

District PMU Lead. I have been shortlisted in the provisional merit list for further

evaluation process. But I am not satisfied with the prefered making on total

experience. I have shown 6 years experience in the related field so according to

marking criteria i should be given total 35 marks for this field, but i got only 10

marks out of 35.


been already Awarded maximum possible marks. Hence no

additional marks has been awarded.

Candidate has worked around 5.9 years post qualification

experience.No additional score have been awarded.


Phase-IV

District PMU Lead

Grievance Redressal

117 1710236RAJU KUMAR

document awalting....

sir i am submit all document which you required on this mail id-

[email protected]

and submit before 48 hr

Submitting document cannot be considered as Grievance. No Change [email protected]

118 1710571 Abid Hussain

1) I would like to inform you that i have finished 2 yrs full time PGDRM Session-

2008 to 2010 Degree Course with specialization in Retail Management from Imis

Bhubaneswar Odisha

But in Remarks its mentioned that Candidate has not done PG diploma(2 years full

time) or master's degree(full time) in Management/Business Administration . 2)I

herewith attached my 2 yrs full time PGDRM degree Marks Sheet & Certificate for

your reference

As per the essential criteria candidate should have PG Diploma (2

years full time) or Master’s degree (full time) in Management /

Business Administration / Finance / Economics / Public Policy /

Social Work / Development Studies / Rural Development. As

candidate has done Post graduation diploma in retail

management .We would not be able take the candidature

forward.


119 17105281 Anurag Kumar Rai1) I have 10yr. post qualification experience. 2) I have experience in data analysis,

Team Handling,Preparing MOU of suppliers,Broker,Customer, project monitoring.

Grievance Considereded based on post qualification experience

additional 25 marks have been awarded.Experience in project

monitoring could not be established from document shared in

application form. Hence no additional marks can be rewarded.

Additional 25 Marks

[email protected]

120 17106875arun kumar

I had done my MBA in Regular Full Time mode But I am not shortlisted

for further assessment.Sr. Grievances

1 I had Completed My PG in Regular(Full Time) Mode.




Score awarded for Post Qualifiaction experience- 0 marks .



Score awared for University / College / Management Institution

ranked in NIRF2017- 0 marks







121 17101373Arvind Sinha

W.r.t. trail mail, website has been viewed but no such records found posted there. Pl

update

As per the details mentioned in the application form, kindly visit

www.mancerbvm.com and check list of Provisional list of

candidates fit for further evaluation process.

Name of Applicant is mentioned in list of candidates Fit for

further evaluation Process.


march 2018(6PM)


122 17103396Priyadarshi Shrivastava

I am unable to see the status of my application as mentioned above. It would quite

helpful if you could guide me with the process.


Provisional list of candidates not fit for further evaluation process


123 17106315 Vivek Kumar

As per below mail link is not available

on http://www.mancerconsulting.com/biharvikasmission.php.

for District PMU Lead. Please do the needful.Name of applicant name is mentioned in provisional merit list fit

for further evaluation process so candidate is requested to visit

www.mancerbvm.com.


Phase-IV

District PMU Lead

Grievance Redressal

124 17101551manoj sharma

My name is Manoj kumar and Dalit candidates and I received your contact

information through your

company web site. I am interested in applying for a position in your but Scores

invalid so please my score review





Work/Development Studies/Rural Development. Candidate has

done MSW part time.


march 2018(6PM)


125 17101152Goutam Kumar

How come my provisional score post-screening is 0?

After passing out from TATA Institute of social science, a renowned institute in the

domain of development and having more than six years of work experiences in the

different organizational platform, I dishearten by the message that I do not meet

essential qualifications. Kindly revisit my uploaded details.

As per the details mentioned in application form candidate has




Work/Development Studies/Rural Development as candidate has

done Master of arts in Globalisation and Labour.


126 1710398Tripurari Pathak

i am Tripurari Pathak, my name comes in unreserved category and fit for overall

category but both places you did not enter any score in "Experience in working with

or on government projects" (screenshot attached). As i am already submitted details

of my working experience with government agencies such as Eshakti project - RDD

(Bihar), EPDS - DFCP(Bihar), BSBCL (Bihar Excise), DDED & DNHED (Daman & Diu and

Dadra & Nagar Haveli).

As my entire experience is in e-Gov sector so i think i deserve better

marks instead of ZERO.

Candidate has worked with E Connect Solutions Private Limited

and Glodyne Technoserve Ltd which cannot be considered as

State/Central/Bilateral/Multilateral organization as Candidate

have not been directly working with such organization.



127 17105604Prince Kumar

I am Prince Kumar. Yet,I haven't get my application whatever the position i applied. I

am keen interested to know my application status.


Provisional list of candidates not fit for further evaluation process.

As candidate does not have 3 years of post quantification

experience


128 17105530 Subodh Kumar Post qualification experience marks should be 20 instead of 10Grievance Considereded additional 10 marks have been awarded

based on post qualification experience

Additional 10 Marks

[email protected]

129 17103160 Kumari Soumya

I beg to state that I have applied for the post of District PMU Lead. According to

provisional merit list published on your website I have awarded 15 marks for project

monitoring work experience however I have four year's complete experience in

project monitoring work, three year experience in Archonics tetheologies pvt. Ltd.

and one year experience in Bihar Vikas Mission as a Assistant Manager(Scheme) and

the nature of work is also project Monitoring. So kindly provide me 20 marks in this

relevant column.

I have also awarded zero(0) marks for experience of working with

state/central government organization on project monitoring. I have completed one

year experience in Bihar Vikas Mission that is fully Bihar Government

office/Department. So provide me 5 marks in this relevant column.

So I kindly requested you to check my genuineness and awarded correct

marks in final merit list.

As per the preferred marking criteria, Post qualification

experience should be minimum 3 years and candidate has passed

MBA in September 2014 and post qualification experience has

been calculated after from 1 Oct 2014 and hence total post

qualification experience is 2 years 9 months and 14 days.

Hence we would not be able to take candidature forward.

Moved to Not Fit for

further evaluation Process
