Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Real world delivery of cancer precision medicine: The UCSF experience
E. Alejandro Sweet-Cordero, MD Benioff UCSF Professor of Children’s Health Head, UCSF Molecular Oncology Initiative
PMWC 2019 Mountain View, CA
e Precision Cancer Medicine
Advanced Cancers
Comprehensive Profiling
Molecular Tumor Board
Decision Support Systems
Tumor
Blood
Treatment Guidance
Individualized treatment, umbrella/basket trials
Resistance?
Better Predictions Improved Outcomes Less Toxicity
e UCSF500: Paired normal/tumor DNA next-generation sequencing assay
• CLIA-approved – available to patients seen across UCSF sites
e UCSF500 Technical specifications
• UCSF pediatric AND adult oncology community consulted for
inclusion of genes relevant to their diseases of interest
• Tumor DNA extracted from FFPE + normal DNA
• Exon tiling across 479 genes
• Selected intron tiling across 47 genes.
• Selected probes across genome to report copy number
• Average read depth 500X
• Variant pipeline in DNAnexus
• Report generated using Genome Oncology platform
e UCSF500 Panel Assay
• Current volume ~100 sequenced cases/month
• First case signed-out April of 2015
• >2000 cases reported to date
• 80% Adult, 20% Pediatric
• Data imported and visualized using a local cbioportal
instance
• Manuscript reporting results on initial 2000+ cases in preparation
• Held every two weeks
• Cases discussed by physician request (4-8 cases/session)
• Both UCSF and outside referrals (Kaiser, UC Davis, Valley Children’s Hospital, many others)
• Cases discussed prepared/discussed by referring clinician, molecular pathologist and oncologist with molecular expertise (Moasser, Collisson, Stieglitz, Klein, Sweet-Cordero)
• Sessions attended by core group of pediatric/adult clinicians with wide disease-specific expertise as well as geneticists, pharmacists and others.
• Written report provided to clinicians
• IRB approved Registry Trial
e UCSF Molecular Tumor Board
Molecular Tumor Board
Change in Diagnosis
Biomarker-guided treatment options
Risk Stratification
Cancer Genetics (germline findings)
• Biweekly meetings • A team molecular
pathologists, genetic counselors and clinicians with genomics expertise research variants/genes in report
• Clinical hx of patient,
UCSF500 results, and recommendations discussed at meeting
• Recommendation report
provided
UCSF500 Report
Utility of Test
CLINICAL OUTCOME TRACKING
e UCSFMolecular Tumor Board
Clinical Utility of UCSF500 Testing Uncover cancer risk traits Detection of therapeutic targets Firmly establish diagnosis
e The UCSF500 Report
e UCSF500 – Molecular Tumor Board - Patient Flow
1276 cases analyzed
174/438 (40%) with MTB treatment
recommendations
793 (62%) cases not discussed
62/174 (36%) therapeutic action taken (e.g. Rx)
95/174 (55%) no therapeutic action
17/174 (10%) lost to follow-up
300 (24%) No therapeutic recommendation 483 (38%) discussed at MTB
Updated to April, 2018
e MTB Case Study: Change in Diagnosis
1/15: 20 year old man presented with left-sided hip pain and intermittent fevers. Clinical Diagnosis: Ewing sarcoma.
3/15: chemotherapy initiated.
5/15: no response to treatment, ongoing daily fevers, weight loss 50 lbs, bed ridden. 6/15: UCSF500: EWSR1-ATF1 fusion, indicative of histiocytoma, not Ewing sarcoma.
6/15: Specific treatment (anti-IL-6 ) initiated. Fevers resolved.
12/15: Tumor resected
7% of all UCSF500 analyses result in changes of the diagnosis
• 4-year-old girl diagnosed as anaplastic medulloblastoma by referring provider
• Synaptophysin/neurofilament neg. and patchy OLIG2 staining not seen in medulloblastoma
• Internal tandem duplication within exon 15 of BCOR
• Amended diagnosis of CNS high-grade neuroepithelial tumor with BCOR alteration
• Because newly described, challenging to ascertain prognosis or identify best therapy; however, indicative of importance of correct identificationpreviously would have been inaccurately identified as MB and therefore would never have known to look for reasons why didn’t respond or why outcome different without knowing actual diagnosis was wrong->how do we know what we don’t know?
e Case Study #2: CNS tumors change in diagnosis leading to management change
Medulloblastoma to CNS high-grade neuroepithelial tumor with BCOR alteration
Highly cellular tumor with rosettes, scattered pseudorosettes, and areas of necrosis
MTB Case Study: Change in diagnosis
Courtesy of Dr. Cassie Kline
Medulloblastoma to CNS high-grade neuroepithelial tumor with BCOR alteration
MTB Case Study: Change in diagnosis
Courtesy of Dr. Cassie Kline
MTB Case Study: Targeted Therapy
A 12 y/o boy with metastatic chordoma
February 2016 April 2017
EZH2 Inhibition Tazemetostat
Rutkowski et al., JNS Ped., 19:531–537, 2017
• 18 yo F with metastatic osteosarcoma
• Treated with standard of care chemotherapy (cisplatin/doxorubicin/methotrexate)
• 99% necrosis at resection (consistent with a very good response)
• Developed metastatic disease in the lungs. Metastatectomy performed as clinically indicated. Viable tumor sent for sequencing.
• Second line chemotherapy (ifosfamide and etoposide),
discontinued due to poor quality of life.
e Case Study #4: recurrent metastatic osteosarcoma with multiple potential therapeutic targets
UCSF500 on diagnostic biopsy
e Case Study #4: recurrent metastatic osteosarcoma with multiple potential therapeutic targets
Multiple genes identified, consistent with recent work indicating these are comon Copy number gained drivers in osteosarcoma (Sayles and Breese, Cancer Discovery 2019) Patient currently on treatment with CDK4 inhibitor
BRCA1/2, BRCAness PARPi, Platinum
MYC Dinaciclib*
PI3K BYL719*
HER2 Trastuzumab/Pertuzumab
IDH1,2 AG-120*, AG-188* FGFR2 BGJ398*
PDGFRA
SOS
BRAF
H3F3A
Everolimus, Temsirolimus
Dasatinib
Vemurafenib
Trametinib, Cobimetinib
Sorafenib
Peptide Vaccine* NF1
High TMB Pembrolizumab, Nivolumab SMARCB1 Tazemetostat*
Panobinostat
Cetuximab, Panitumumab
KRAS, RASA1
EGFR
TSC1/2, STK11
FLT3
ROS, ALK Crizotinib, Alectinib
Breast
Prostate
Endometrial/Ovarian
CNS
Lung
Gastro-esophageal
Colorectal
Pancreatic
Hepato-biliary
Neuroendocrine (GI)
RCC
Melanoma
JMML *Experimental Agent
e Matching Disease-Gene-Drug
527, 78%
81, 12%
69, 10%
1, 0%
Pediatric Cases (n=678)
Somatic Only Somatic and Germline No Pathogenic Variants Detected Germline Only
1186, 84%
151, 11%
65, 5%
Adult Cases (n=1402)
Detected Variants in UCSF500 Cases e UCSF50: informative vs non-informative cases
90-95% of samples had an informative assay (likely pathogenic or pathogenic alteration somatic alteration AND/OR a germline alteration found).
APeX Clarity Caboodle RDB
Info Common
s (IC)
• Relational database • ~13,000
tables!
• Clinical Data Warehouse
• ~170 tables
Identified De-Identified
PHI
• Research Data Browser
• Flat file ‘datadump’
• Pt has10 digit surrogate identifier 1:1 with MRN
• Query-able database
• Structured eHR data
• 15 tables
”eLockBox”
(2) Pt MRN 10-digit RDB/IC ID
Mappings
MOI Database
• MRNs not stored!!
• Use RDB/IC ID for pulling patient-level data from IC
eLockBox: T. Goldstein
(1) 10-digit random RDB ID (de-ID) (2) Genetic alterations + test metadata
e Annotating genomic data using the EHR
Clinical Adoption Interpretation of
genomic results &
Clinical Care Recommendations
Capturing clinical outcomes
Knowledge sharing
Engage Insurance Providers
Clinical Trials
New Drug Development
Easily accessible, affordable & clinically-
impactful genetic testing
More actionable biomarkers
Engage Pharma
• Multi-institutional platform (e.g. GENIE)
• Peer reviewed publications
New Drug Approvals
e Precision Oncology Flywheel
e Does precision medicine lead to improved outcomes?
Days
P=0.007663
Kaplan-Meier Survival
Recommended treatment received?
Courtesy Jennifer Grabowski
Overview
International pancancer registry built through data sharing
Driven by openness, transparency, and inclusion
GOAL: improve clinical decision making • Linking clinical genotype to clinical outcomes
8 19
Eight founding participants, now 19 • North America & Europe • Plans for future expansion
Sponsored research Collaborative projects
e Project GENIE
e Key challenges
• Building a knowledge base base on: • external data • analysis of internal data and prior experience
• Linking to clinical trials
• Clinical annotation of genomic results by data
extraction from EMR.
• Determing clinical utility and better definition of real-world barriers to utility
e
11/9/15 37
Molecular Oncology Unit
Summary
• The UCSF500 assay can detect a wide range of clinically relevant alterations that can modify therapy, refine diagnosis and identify inherited cancer predispositions.
• UCSF500 is unique in its coverage of both adult and pediatric alterations and paired germline/somatic analysis.
• Emerging opportunities for research in defining best practices to maximize utility of genomic testing.
• Data sharing through GENIE will increase opportunities for real world analysis of cancer precision medicine.