Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Publishing in ISI journals
for Social Sciences
T. RamayahSchool of Management, Universiti Sains Malaysia
[email protected], http://www.ramayah.com
Kami Memimpin We Lead 2
http://www.ramayah.com
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Publish or Perish
3
Kami Memimpin We Lead 4
Publishing a Paper
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Against all odds
5
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Kami Memimpin We Lead
What issues do you face in your efforts
to publish your research work in ISI
Impact Factor journals?
Question
7
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Publishing
• Publishing research results is an integral part of a researcher’s professional life.
• Without Publication, Science is
Dead.Gerald PielCo-founder of the modern incarnation of Scientific American magazine
8
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Publishing
• Dissemination of research result is just as important as the research activity itself.
• This will ensure the use of research results is maximized.
Ming Tham9
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Publications
The number and quality of the publications is an important, possibly the most important factor deciding the career of a scientist, practically a matter of life and death.
10
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Why Do We Publish?
• The fun of discovery• Advancing theory and practice in our field• Creating worldwide professional (and
personal) networks• Enhancing personal reputation• Enhancing institutional reputation and
funding• Enhancing the field’s reputation
11
Kami Memimpin We Lead 12
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Kami Memimpin We Lead
• Knowledge sharing• Building personal relationships and
professional teams in co-authorships• Obligation of professionals in higher
education• Promotion, tenure, and pay increments
(where merit pay or bonuses are offered)• Pride in accomplishments
Why Do We Publish?
14
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Kami Memimpin We Lead
• Opportunity to travel• Opportunity to fund conference
attendance• Enhance personal development• Enhance opportunity to author a book• Enhance opportunities to edit or become
an editorial board member of a journal and impact the field
Why Do We Publish?
16
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Kami Memimpin We Lead
• Enhance personal development
• Enhance opportunity to author a book
• Enhance opportunities to edit or
become an editorial board member of a
journal and impact the field
Why Do We Publish?
18
Kami Memimpin We Lead 19
How to measure Impact?
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Academic Research Impact
• Total number of papers• Total number of citations• Average number of citations per paper• Average number of papers per author• Average number of citations per year• h-index• g-Index• Number of authors per paper
20
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Number of Authors vs Citations
Kami Memimpin We Lead
• New developments focus on alternative value measurements- h-Index
- g-Index
- Matthew Value
Measures Journals
Authors
Research groups
Subjects
Institutions, etc
Assessing Impact / Research Performance Measurement
22
Kami Memimpin We Lead
h-index
Developed in 2005 by Jorge Hirsch, a condensed-matter physicist (University of California in San Diego) and peace activist.
23
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Definition of h-Index
A scientist has index h if h of his papers have at least hcitations each and the other papers have no more than hcitations each.
“The h-index is the highest number of papers a scientist has that have at least that number of citations.”
Nature (2005)
Eg.: Prof. Ahmad has index 15 if 15 of his papers have at least 15 citations each and the other papers have nomore than 15 citations each.
24
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Google Scholar
25
Kami Memimpin We Lead
SCOPUS
26
Kami Memimpin We Lead
PUBLONS
27
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Types of Research Measures
• Existing metrics focus on short term citation value
▪ Impact factor = 2 years
▪ Immediacy Index = 1 year
▪ Cited Half Life = stops at 10 years
Measures Journals
only
28
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Journals
• Indexed• EconLit, Cabell, Academic Research, Business
Index, Business Source, ABI Inform
• Applied Mechanics Reviews, Current Contents/Engineering, Computing & Technology, El Compendex Plus, Engineering Index, Environmental Abstracts, FLUIDEX
• Non-Indexed• Trade Journals example: MMR
29
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Citation Indexed• SCOPUS
• ISI (Institute for Scientific Information)• Impact Factors • ESCI
• Clarivate Analytics• Islamic World Citation• Indian Citation Index• Taiwan Citation Index• MyCite (Malaysia)
30
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Impact Factor Journals
• How do we Identify them?
• Clarivate Analytics
• What is the Impact Factor?• Journal website• Clarivate Analytics
31
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Web of Science
32
Kami Memimpin We Lead
SSCI, SCI, AHCI and ESCI
33
Kami Memimpin We Lead 34
InCites Journal Citations Reports
Kami Memimpin We Lead 35
Impact Factor
Kami Memimpin We Lead 36
Impact Factor
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Journal Impact Factor
37
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Journal Quartile
38
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Journal Website
39
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Elsevier
40
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Wiley
41
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Springer
42
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Emerald
43
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Taylor & Francis
44
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Problematic Impact Factors
45
Kami Memimpin We Lead
ISI also but ……….
46
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Criteria of Evaluation
47
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Criteria of Evaluation
48
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Global Impact Factor (GIF)
49
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Universal Impact Factor (GIF)
50
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Fake Journals
51
Kami Memimpin We Lead
https://beallslist.net/hijacked-journals/
52
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Hijacked Journal
53
Kami Memimpin We Lead
JCR – Clarivate Analytics
54
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Hijacked Journal
55
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Original Journal
56
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Writing the Paper
57
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Habit of Writing• Talking about writing isn’t writing. Thinking
about writing isn’t writing. Dreaming or fantasizing isn’t writing. Neither are outlining, researching, or making notes. All these may be a part of the whole milieu of the writing life and necessary to getting a project completed, but only writing is writing.
• “You can’t sit around thinking,” said fiction writer David Long. “You must sit around writing.”
58
WORK ETHICS
“Never mistake motion for action”
Ernest Hemingway
59
Kami Memimpin We Lead
My Old Work Station
60
Kami Memimpin We Lead
My New Work Station
61
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Kami Memimpin We Lead 63
Writing the Paper
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Idea for Writing
• Literature
• Google Scholar Alerts• Big names in your area of research
• Colleagues• Intra
• Inter
• Competitors
• Reviewing Papers
64
Kami Memimpin We Lead
How to get research done?
• Individually
• Postgraduate or
Undergraduate students
• Colleagues
• Collaborate
▪ Local
▪ International
65
Kami Memimpin We Lead 66
66
Reputation
Availability&
MotivationPersonality
Co-author A
Co-author B
BUILDING STRATEGIC NETWORKSCOMPLEMENTARY COMPETENCES ARE IMPORTANT, BUT…
No hard feelings when buying into a coop! Everything is normally distributed (almost) ... ha ha ha
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Targeting the Journal
67
Kami Memimpin We Lead 68
1. What is the journal`s general scope? Conceptual, methodological, theory-driven, data-driven,...
2. What is the journal‘s current scope (editorial policies) in terms of topics, data, and methods?
3. Does my paper tie in with previous papers from that journal?
4. Can I cite prior research from that journal?
5. Who is on the journal‘s editorial board (AEs and reviewers)?
6. When is a good time to submit?
Targeting: Questions
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Do your homework• Pick journals like you pick stocks
• Should have a pool of journals
• Submit paper to a journal with a rising impact factor and higher acceptance rates. avoid declining journals with low acceptance and diminishing impact factor.
• Could cause the journal to be removed from the SSCI and SCI ranking.
• Betting your research where you have the highest probability for publication
• Target your submission, not all to top journals
69
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Dream List
70
Rank Full Journal Title Impact Factor
1 International Journal of Information Management 5.063
2 Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication 4.896
3 Journal Of Knowledge Management 4.604
4 MIS Quarterly 4.373
5 Government Information Quarterly 4.311
6 Journal of The American Medical Informatics Association 4.292
7 Information & Management 4.120
8 Journal of Strategic Information Systems 4.000
9 Information Processing & Management 3.892
10 Telematics and Informatics 3.714
11 Information Systems Journal 3.286
12 Journal of Information Technology 3.225
13 Journal of The Association for Information Systems 3.103
14 Journal of Management Information Systems 3.013
15 Social Science Computer Review 2.922
Kami Memimpin We Lead 71
NO ALL-IN
GAIN EXPERIENCE IN LOWER-TIER JOURNALS & CONFERENCES
BALANCE TIME AND JOURNAL QUALITY
Submission Strategy
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Journal Finders
72
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Elsevier
73
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Key in the details
74
Kami Memimpin We Lead
List will be shown
75
Kami Memimpin We Lead 76
List will be shown
Kami Memimpin We Lead 77
Interesting …………
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Web of Science
78
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Key in Paper Details
79
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Results
80
Kami Memimpin We Lead
WILEY
81
Kami Memimpin We Lead
SPRINGER
82
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Google Scholar
83
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Related Researchers
84
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Submitting the Paper
85
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Submitting the Paper
• Before submission preparation1. Cover Letter2. Authors Page3. Main Manuscript4. Tables5. Figures
86
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Submission LogNo. Paper Title Authors Journal Date Submitted Indexed
1 The Impact of Technological Learning on NPD Outcomes: The Moderating Effect of Project Complexity
Joshua Ignatius, Jasmine Yeapand T. Ramayah
Technovation 1st RevisionSeptember 9, 2019
ELSEVIERSSCI ISI = 5.250
2 An Assessment Of E-Training Effectiveness In Multinational Companies In Malaysia
T. Ramayah, Noor Hazlina Ahmad and Tan Say Hong
Journal of Educational Technology & Society
1st RevisionOctober 11, 2019
SSCI ISI = 2.133
3 Does The Notion Of "Doing Well By Doing Good" Prevail Among Entrepreneurial Ventures In A Developing Nation?
Noor Hazlina Ahmad and T. Ramayah
Journal of Business Ethics
1st RevisionOctober 22, 2019
SSCI ISI = 3.769
4 Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) Benefits Survey Of Indian Manufacturing Firms: An Empirical Analysis Of SAP Versus Oracle Package
Annamalai and T. Ramayah
Benchmarking: An International Journal
1st RevisionOctober 1, 2019
EMERLADSCOPUS
5 Understanding Consumer Intention with Respect to Purchase and Use of Pirated Software
T. Ramayah, Norazah Suki and Lee Sze Ern
Information Management and Computer Security
1st RevisionAugust 31, 2019
EMERALD SCOPUS
87
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Handling Revisions
88
Kami Memimpin We Lead89
“Oh, how lucky I am to receive your (no doubt great) paper for review. It really made my day!”
Kami Memimpin We Lead90
THE TYPICAL REVIEWER
Kami Memimpin We Lead
E-mail from the Editor
91
Kami Memimpin We Lead 92
E-mail from the Editor
Kami Memimpin We Lead 93
THE TWO GOLDEN RULES OF REPLYING TO REVIEWERS
RULE #1: THE REVIEWER IS ALWAYS RIGHT
RULE #2: IF THE REVIEWER IS NOT RIGHT, SEE RULE #1
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Reply to Reviewers
94
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Revisions• Don’t be discouraged. A paper
often requires 3-4 revisions before it is finally accepted. Especially in SSCI, SCI and other quality journals, you will probably be rejected the first time around.
• Pay attention to all the feedback you get and modify accordingly, and revise, resubmit, revise, resubmit, revise, resubmit.
95
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Post Publication Dissemination
96
Kami Memimpin We Lead
KUDOS
97
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Detail Description of Paper
98
Kami Memimpin We Lead
PUBLONS
99
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Review Endorsements
100
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Research Gate
101
Kami Memimpin We Lead
102
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Altmetrics
103
Kami Memimpin We Lead 104
Altmetric it!
Kami Memimpin We Lead 105
Altmetric it!
Kami Memimpin We Lead 106
Altmetric it!
Kami Memimpin We Lead 107
Altmetric it!
Kami Memimpin We Lead 108
Altmetric it!
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Website
109
Kami Memimpin We Lead 110
BUT THE MOST IMPORTANT
THING...
Kami Memimpin We Lead 111
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Some Journal Targets
112
Kami Memimpin We Lead 113
Kami Memimpin We Lead 114
Kami Memimpin We Lead 115
Kami Memimpin We Lead 116
Kami Memimpin We Lead 117
Kami Memimpin We Lead 118
Kami Memimpin We Lead 119
Kami Memimpin We Lead 120120
Proverb – Za’ba
Kekayaan saudagar adalah pada pundipundi emasnya, Kekayaan pendeta adalah
pada keping keping kertasnya.
The wealth of a merchant is in their purses of gold, the wealth of a scholar is in the knowledge they unfold
Kami Memimpin We Lead
GRATITUDE
121
Kami Memimpin We Lead
You’ll learn more
from sharing
than from
holding.
Share Your Resources with Others
122
Kami Memimpin We Lead
Thank you for listening
•Passion
•Perseverance
•A little bit of Luck
123
Kami Memimpin We Lead
THANK YOU
124