41
Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitam Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg Saito, Masako (Saitam with Plan Introduction Two-Flavor Oscillation Parametric Resonance in Neutrino Oscillation More on Parametric Resonance Summary

Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Parametric Resonance

by the Matter EffectSATO, Joe (Saitama)

Koike, Masafumi (Saitama)Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg)

Saito, Masako (Saitama)

with

PlanIntroduction

Two-Flavor Oscillation

Parametric Resonance in Neutrino Oscillation

More on Parametric Resonance

Summary

Page 2: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Introduction

Page 3: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Interior of the Earth

http://www.math.montana.edu/~nmp/materials/ess/geosphere/expert/activities/planet_earth/

Page 4: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

cru

st

man

tle

ou

ter

core

Interior of the Earth

http://www.math.montana.edu/~nmp/materials/ess/geosphere/expert/activities/planet_earth/

inner

core

Preliminary Reference Earth Model

Depth

Page 5: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Matter Density Profile

Page 6: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Matter Density Profile

Page 7: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Constant-Density Approximation

Page 8: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Matter Density Profile

Page 9: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Matter Density Profile

Page 10: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Inhomogeneous Matter Koike,Sato

1999Ota,Sato 2001

Page 11: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Parametric Resonance in Neutrino Oscillation

• Ermilova et al. (1986)• Akhmedov, Akhmedov et al. (1988 — Present)• others

“Castle-wall” matter profile (Akhmedov, 1998)

Fourier decomposition (Present approach)

Mode 1

Mode 2

Mode 3

Page 12: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Two-Flavor Oscillation

Page 13: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Two-Flavor Oscillation

• Second-order equation in dimensionless variables

• Dimensionless variables

• Initial conditions ,

• Matter effect

• Evolution equation of the two-flavor neutrino

Page 14: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

• MSW-resonance peak.

• Peaks and dips of the oscillation spectrum• Simple solution when

:

• Appearance probability at the endpoint of the baseline

• (n+1)-th oscillation peak.

• n-th oscillation dip.

Constant-Density Oscillation

Page 15: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

id numbers of the oscillation peaks

Constant-Density Oscillation

Neutrino Energy / [GeV]

Ap

peara

nce P

rob

Page 16: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Parametric Resonancein Neutrino Oscillation

Page 17: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Matter Density Profile

Page 18: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Matter Density Profile

Page 19: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Matter Density Profile

Page 20: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Matter Density Profile

Page 21: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Matter Density Profile

Page 22: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Matter Density Profile

Page 23: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Evolution Equation

• Inhomogeneity

• Fourier expansion

• Effect of the n-th Fourier mode on the oscillation

Mathieu Equation

Page 24: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Pow!

Pow!

Parametric Resonance

Periodic Motion

Oscillation of Oscillation Parameter

in classical

mechanicsin classical

mechanics

We kick a swing twice in a period of motion.

Mathieu Equation

Page 25: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Pow!

Pow!

Parametric Resonance

Periodic Motion

Oscillation of Oscillation Parameter

Para

metr

ic

Reso

nance

in classical

mechanicsin classical

mechanics

We kick a swing twice in a period of motion.

Parametric Resonance Condition

Page 26: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Parametric Resonance

Neutrino Oscillation

Fourier modes of

matter effect

in neutrino

oscillationin neutrino

oscillation

Page 27: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Parametric Resonance

Neutrino Oscillation

Fourier modes of

matter effect

Para

metr

ic

Reso

nance

in neutrino

oscillationin neutrino

oscillation

Parametric Resonance Condition n-th oscillation

dip

Page 28: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Effect of the Mode 1

Neutrino Energy / [GeV]

Ap

peara

nce P

rob

Sizable effect at1st peak (n=0) and 2nd

peak (n=1) 0 g/cm3 0

0.1 g/cm3

0.231

0.2 g/cm3

0.462

0.3 g/cm3

0.693

0.4 g/cm3

0.925

0.5 g/cm3

1.16

Page 29: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Mode 1: Possible Large EffectEarth models suggest for a through-Earth

pathEarth models suggest for a through-Earth path

0 g/cm3 0

1 g/cm3 2.31

2 g/cm3 4.62

3 g/cm3 6.93

4 g/cm3 9.25

5 g/cm3 11.6

Page 30: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Mode 1: Possible Large EffectEarth models suggest for a through-Earth

pathEarth models suggest for a through-Earth path

0 g/cm3 0

1 g/cm3 2.31

2 g/cm3 4.62

3 g/cm3 6.93

4 g/cm3 9.25

5 g/cm3 11.6

Page 31: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Effect of the Mode 2

Neutrino Energy / [GeV]

Ap

peara

nce P

rob

Sizable at2nd (n=1) and 3rd (n=2)

peaks 0 g/cm3 0

0.1 g/cm3

0.231

0.2 g/cm3

0.462

0.3 g/cm3

0.693

0.4 g/cm3

0.925

0.5 g/cm3

1.16

Page 32: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Effect of the Mode 3

Neutrino Energy / [GeV]

Ap

peara

nce P

rob

Sizable at3rd (n=2) and 4th (n=3)

peaks 0 g/cm3 0

0.1 g/cm3

0.231

0.2 g/cm3

0.462

0.3 g/cm3

0.693

0.4 g/cm3

0.925

0.5 g/cm3

1.16

Page 33: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

More on the Parametric Resonance

Page 34: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Resonant Enhancement

Page 35: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Resonant Enhancement

Page 36: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Resonant Enhancement

Page 37: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Resonant Enhancement

Page 38: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Resonant Enhancement

Page 39: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Resonant EnhancementResonant enhancement of apparance probability, even for a small Fourier coefficientResonant enhancement of apparance probability, even for a small Fourier coefficient

n = 1

n = 2

n = 3Fictious repetition of the matter profile

Matter profile (Arbitrary vertical scale)

Oscillation “dip” at

0 g/cm3 0

0.3 g/cm3

0.693

1 g/cm3 2.31

Page 40: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Large-Scale Oscillation

Page 41: Parametric Resonance by the Matter Effect SATO, Joe (Saitama) Koike, Masafumi (Saitama) Ota, Toshihiko (Würzburg) Saito, Masako (Saitama) with Plan Introduction

Summary

• Neutrino oscillation across the Earth• Deviation from the constant density

• Fourier analysis

• Parametric resonance• Frequency matching of the matter distribution

and the neutrino energy

• Mathieu-like equation provides an analytic description

Matter distribution n-th Fourier mode

Appearance probability

n-th dip and neighbor