^^ fxF

rY^/

^ r,> {

. •, /•' J ai ,,

f ^` i f2 ^H . .. /O'.f/ . •- iJ .c%^°^/ • ...-. .. . :.

.... ....... ... .. "^ : ^1/! . ff^' 1 ^j/+-^ ... ........ .. .. ..... . . . .. . ..... . . .. .. . ....... .......... .. .

....... .. ....... ... . ....... .... ^^.... . ..^.^.. .. ... . ... ........ .. . . . . . ................. ... ... .. . ..... .... . . ... .. . . ..... ....... ....... .. . . . . ........... .. .. . . . ..

. .. .. ............... .. .. .. .

^Z" ^%z'

; .... .. ...... ...... ..... .. . . ..... ........ .. . .. .. . ...^ ...... ............. .. .. . . . ., Jr%%//%/%Nf Javfrff. /!//f ///I! if/^!////!//f/1fI/%l ....... ...1ft . Y /1,f.

^ 5. y,A• .:'^'o"..

$ £. ...... ... ^

_ _ _ . - _ ^r• .r. 3 1 -^, ^

014d 7 ,^ ^ss' s 3r ^'

^r #ifr f3s _ r .... _.^< r^ s^ i^^1t ^,

.^-. . . .... . . ^Y!^.^'^^:^.^r' .^` •^^^„y'--r'^/.. } . ... /

. . . # r r ^ ,/o f r r /,f j >; r 1 y r ^ / _^ .

...

_..___. .. ___. _._ ... . . . . _.._._. .__ _-_ __. ._. . ..... ._ . ........ . ..._.......__ _ . . `. _... ...-_...-.._.. _.. ,. . . .

_ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ .. _ _ _ ^C^.^^i:,^r ii GIC--(^p^ff 3 C./c^' i^,:^%L-^ c,-L<'a/^"^i -.7 _ _ _ _ _ .U .. . . _. ... ...__ .. .. . ..... :i

.___.. -_. '^ ' • .

E.

d2? 12,1, 2^^^^- :_4AN 0 3 ZO 14

CLERK AF CAURT V1 ,/SURREME UpURT OF QWtO

AFFIDAVIT

State of Ohio )

ss;County of&k^^.,) ''K. e;^ a&z^

swear that the following is true:

2. ,.^ L( ^/^/^^. ^t.'Q

jj

3.

^ ^ ,^ ar•''^NA1ViL ANI] NU. ER

DEFENDANT-APPL;LLANT, PRO SE

Sworn to and subscribed in my presence this ^ day of

20

Ozi LA-

NTA Y PUBLIC JfiruNtFER M. p7YOIn and for the State Of O^® ^hhlic

MY CQmmissaon Expdras MaY 21,201,3

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF 01-1I0

STATE OF OHIO,

Plaintiff Appellee,

vs.

^^91'

Defendant-Appel laiit.

: Case No.

AFFIDAVIT OF 1NDIGENCY

do hereby state that I am without the necessary

funds to pay the costs of this action for the following reasons:

I am currently incarcerat d at the and I have been^

incarcerated since,&/S. I work at the prison but receive only &;(f^ dollars per month.

Pursuant to Rule 15.3 of the Rules of Practice of the Supreme Court of Ohio, I am

requesting that the filing fee and security deposit, if applicable, be waived.

AFFIAIvT

Sworn to, or affirmed, and subscribed in my presence this day of ^^A&

20 /^^

_,^„KNotary ublMy Co unission Expires: +f c;; ^ ^C) I

tNote: This affidavit niust be executed not nioi•e than six months prioconiply with fi.Ct. Prac. R. 15.3. Affidavits not in compliance with that

IRAN. 0 3 Z014:

JENNIFER M. OTTO, Notary PublicIn and for the State of OhioMy Commission Expires May 21, 2018

Court in order toby the Clerh,l

CLERK OF COURTSUPREME COURT OF OHIO

_ c'i;^',!1r^'^^i<^i,.^ ^" ,•^?^G ^,-.^^ <^^ ^? _ ^''iY^^^-,E^.^'l^^,G=

_---

Gx

-^'-c.. L^^;^,^'G^ fi.^ <„- 3".rC-^ ,^-.^ -

__^^-

f!L

ieLI%L

^

, .^, .

.^z^'^'3U

61;al 4? ^ 3 ,^ ^^ `r . ^!^?^^^G? 3 ^

•'^-^ ..^/.-',s^C'Jl r .!% ;

^^^1G^ G^ ^.^^y^^^!G^`, ^^i^^l^3'^t^G^^`^^^^ G^^Pi!^?c7C'_

..._._.. . _... ._ .. . _ .. . __ . _. ..(Y/ .___. _. _ .

' ^^^ ^^C.!^'^^L^ ^Z-G'^__^^ -^r^ ^-^ ^` _ 3^:".^%,L^^`cC^.^°^Q.^:^. _ _ _, ,. . F

,^ .^W.f ^

ey

ae^

1-^i^ C.z, lsll

_ _ _ {^^-^'C. ^[".-^C^' _v^^^^^ ,r^L^ '^ e^a.^-^^^k^'l^ C.S^-^.^3^--^;"G^ < _ _ _ . _ _ _

^l

^ 3.^. `^^

41-. . ,, ,

CP'"c.a4^,, .

6^^/'` .,

. ^^ JL^loi

;

. && 9,% q t,, ^ I -C^" e,- - ^

. . . . . .. .V 4.""^V . ^ ^ J ^... C3G'^-^ "^ .. ^^^^I '" /`6b. .:..K.^"^^ ^^^ ^^ C..*^/^/CwG-^d.LK-:^.. .. . . ...

. .... . . . . y^.^C^ + . . .. . .. . . .. .. . .. .. ....... . . . . . .. . . . . .. . ^':4 .. . .. .. .. .. . .. .

^ ! ^ ^^i^^^ ^G^! ^^"^^'3GL^':^^ e:;^(^^^ !^^ , . . ... . . .

^:^ _^.^^^^^%^^` ^:^^^ C,•^ ^ ^^l ^^ ^^^

zez ^`v^`^'^ 3 ^^,Z^^

^

e

3^^-^^-a-,^^-^^ ^^^^^^Y o

-el'^&Ile, . .^.

,. ^

6-^__

_

. . , :^

6z''.^^-^^

izel

^

- ^ _k2r^-^

.^e117^^'^ _

^^^^^^^_ ^,^^^ ^^^°^^3 ^ _ ^ ^^^^^.^

L1 64^^=, tl" ^^

eq

1 oleg-lu

v5

^112^

,- .

. , ._^_ .

^ _. .

zz_w'^^^^^^-.^^`^

: ._Fk

I^y

^^^ ^^^Z^^^^ ^^' _ ^Ge^^i'"•^`"c,;^ ^?^%^

&64^C^^^^^...^^^ . ,

^^^1^

,tk:?^^^^_

^- --- -'-^

4

.^^

.

62

. , ^ .

M ^.

. ^^

6y

.... . .._... .. . ... . . ^'^^^^ i^`^aN" ..YC.,<^^^^23`^4 ^"l^r° ._^^ .S\.s^ ..^ //'"'. "',"".: 9P"4L:R^3^ S`Y K.. . _ .

., .^ . . _ _. . _.. ..._ _.. _ _..._ ... . _.. _. .. .._ _. .. ... . .... . __ _...

.^ ^`^ .. .. . ~ . . . .... . . . .

^^^^^^ ^^^^^3 ^ ^^ ^'^^^^ ^.^ ^'^^_^^'{.e

dcl ^ ^22^61-- , -

2d'

. _ .. . . . . . . . . . . . . ^.`.^d^^ Z.F. GSc^^^^ILJ^ ^^(^4i ' 3

, M.

d/ -

d1ace4a, L2klt^C^^:^r;^`^?

A':, .- .. .. ,

,^r7^^^^^^..

C'^e 116&

au,

^°1 ^^: _ . f $^^^ ^.2 n^ ^^^ ^^ ^^

3

G^^'/C-Z3'3't?^^

- ^ ,. .;. _

dY

_ _ _ ; ^^^^^ .^i^^^I^,^_ c%1L-'L^^ 3 '^' ^^ J^1^ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ .

. ^ _

,

^- : ..

zy a

r1 y^ . .

^^4 yow-^, //,^z 4^v d^,... ."oooa

Cl^ 3 m^

. . .... . . . ^, . . . . . .. . ........ . . . ^b . . . . . . .. . . . . ., . . . . . .. . ..... ...... . . . .

w , .

...

c ^^i ^- ^ %L/G^^_ G..%^L . ^^^! _L^^^. ^w^?r^^''" ^^%3. _.

°^ ^•^.%^r"^^^?^^^,^^ ^.^^1^^ _C^Ee^` /.^' c^c^^

^^G^c^^i^c._

I ZI^'-^

,.^L-tr^l^ G.-'^G'•C^^ ^.^"r^ /i,^ y ^^^^^'..^'c^e^^.:^GC^ ,:,^'^'C-L ^^^^^^^1.""^ _ _

1^1^

^/^^6

zG^.^^'G^L.^ ,.. .,^ ^ ^ ^ '^ '-^^^.^'^^!..^'3',Z!^ ^ .`^^'^^

...Z^

rz

.. ... . . . ... . ^^'^C...^''^^^""`""-.'.-^,G ^^o%'F.".^/^i'"-,-C._1t^•C,^.% G^^ C-rC".-^^^.i^/."% L.^i,sL'^^C^--.c,.',G!. . . .

. G, . ... .. . . . . . .

. ^y . " / • 4 . .. .... . ., ' : . .... . .

,. ^., y.

^^-L^^^^^<

Cz

/ _.

«.G G.^t;- C ?^LL! ^Cf^% c-•. G^C: 3^^G.G.ts1 s

... ._ .._.. _. ._.__._ . . _ . ._ . . .

f l..v -.^i^

-^'!'!^

- ----- -------- ----------- ----- - -------......-- - ---....-- ---- ----- ------ - -- ---...---- ---..----------- --------- ---------- _----....----------.......---- -- --- --- --- ----------- ----...------

,.

" - ^

.^e^rC2

^ . .^71. 6zs gg,5:

a° .',1 i 7r f^ t^~ . .. . . . .. .. . . .

^^3'^^^li!.I^ ^ ^^'^^ ^c ^'^^^ ^^Jr ^^ ^ a J;

^

_^.

• G/ _

.^

_ _ ^. ^^^^• ^^,/'^^^"^,^^^^^ ^^^'^'" ^^^^^ __, ._.

.. . . . . ..y^ ^ ._ _ ^,^ ^G'^^^e.• ^1 _ ^ ^^^` !^^^=^^;^=`^^^. ^'.,^

_ C2z eo

` . <

I ^ / ( e^^^^^/^ e!j^a^^^^C^ ^ 3 !

/? /' 9 •zl / ^ '^ 9 ^

^^ ^`"

. ..^^^^ ^ ^'3 2 ; /,^ ,^^ fj/^ 7 ^,., / ^,^ ^/

cf-°15,. _

^ ,.

An) 0-^ ,Y

^: ^ ^ ^^^-^^ ^^3 ^,^ ^.^^ _ _

__

x .z zc.> j/Lzat-

^

. . . . . . . . . . . . ... . _ . . •L3L.,.C..'^.: - ^ i i

.., .

Z'/Z .,. ^_ ^-^ ". 2P _ ^^zw&_^ 6AO

,

.. ,

O^^^^oL4 0 itI^^^ 07wtrerP(Ca^c^,^

Pic^. .-D-ecki, ^5^^ ^1 :^i.ea -4)

.^^^^ ^eaL ^^) ^6,t^^^^ rnci-^^^^'r_^ ^mat. Ft ^ ^b^:.^e - Cttier

-

^-{Ret^^ bcut- I i Jf L) -eA.A -T-r (e

fftl)c A-^ 13.) ^^^ 3^ccr ^::s

.Pie ^^.- D^ Q-:^. i ^ ) 1j^Asd^ ^ vloncq

.,"^) ^l^Cc.>^ 8 ic- . 6ne_s

&iU

PLe& .,t^eaL

arllfiC4 ^ orle^& Oa^lyloh;n

^^1 ^og_? .5 " ^- 1 7^.

^7,qy y7

3,5q v-rS'^^^q,;P-q

YN A^Y`^^^n^(, (, (, e^^33 q-',^^^17-e5q Cf5

k.k£eo's

Ou^iahccla

; /nrn4br^ ery.

ctz:c,laY}c^q&

r^CdumbEdra^^^^^^ lawavc-^.

CL^^ ^^^^if, *Ash(^xyj^

^^^^^^ ^cIrmc.:itn

ko^

^^' ` l'^ ^ _ t^°1^^^^^ ^ ^ ►^ _

rank(i1^

_

PlP& zeA^.. Sag.rw1^^ y(0b';7- q

ftecEo 739_ VU5Lvac,^ las

,^ 911) pj-Q b ^p

r.(Ouri

pleC^ ^br-aL ll-raai (ub(pcf^

^c;i `7D^'c:e,.t.., a3.d) ^C C^tri -^ ►4-

d'n Cv rrn^,^{-

pfe^ ^ 6LL 35,) ^^ ^ a- C

nwae^^ F°2t qv ^

^^ -bmi. ambe-° ^-c-uit nve-e kf-

L ^3 :?. C^d ^fo2^1'tVYt%^^

o^S Z_^^? zq

^ -1)412.)

-^Ri 4N9) CU-iqe-L . Spat-tdGi Vl9. ^ A ^z

.-c^x.^: c^.:l...qS•) .^,z f ",e-q 36So'l -3

7°"^3 3

IZ,^'r^. ^UCzr7^C^

PlP_ ^ 7^6-L 48) kAji,Shd. R&3 6

9ew DeaL=.. :5-0) At'^^e^k 61MYS

16L, X)Jaz/ ¢^•^ ^i ^C%fc'^ `^ ^^G^^ S`2^^^^?

^^^^ ^^c-^.t 77^^ ^1,^1d7. .

C-77ongewi-n5

. ..l^'l ^.^..^^'.C.^ ^ ^6;^ ^^C^e-.^1 ^ , -s L1 6_ 0/')r C;/-)

^ 57) ^"lea-D^'GZE^ 11dX10 7-1,P%a 7 ^.^at

Pi -^ ^^eat De- b^roj1 6rubb 3-7616pt^^CCLi &boke

,^)6Ct(^ Y°75- 0

.^^^P1^^ beW -5:t2-^^

Pf^-.^. Zy°-^bg

^^eCx ^ .^ ^^^^ ^^^:_ _^^^s__ _ ^7r^ ►Plea ct^

e o _ teo.L aq. ^ me-e: ^ 1)C-4t^\.._._.^. o ...---^ ^ ^

aealycaL.771n ^ W((4(nO., ( --rrdC°. ht one- 9U4 4`7

m L;b letr:X,j

^Ueas

ei Ac.ic

^^cto Q i 03P

pfe^ 7q= ) ^ 1 ^. ^c^ rYt ^c^ t^ f h7 f

f g 6;Z o^ec- -cx^c^^^i.-.L 17s}► . _.

,--

^^.i74 n k.lin

..:_... .^^._.^.^L .. ._.:._ .__... .

Ptec`beaL `r,-) rY1ani 10001 Y 0 oc^g ket(fs

Rea`bcca z e ) fiskle.c^ vlvl-^ejcx^

Rea-Meft`Deo-L, P-) Cvww^in yr) o"e1erA -

5.) kQra^ L, & 6brG^ e 's

q(^

^3

6-,3^

(4C^Ct. 35) {^-- ^ [C.e... dO i(l S{_`76r-) -ran k.,f f^\

^ck^

PJea . --t^eaL gB^J ^ ck.' t`r ro,^,oOA riS^^^ ^^v^j h+__

de.^^^ ^^ ^

^^ea -06at,, 90) ^.!^hQdq J:h f4den fi7ahoY ^P^ect

.bea.(- aL....

a ^ack.5 mahot-,M^oeCe... -Deo- (, 047 ^rirlvi_

9^73&^qq) l^ ^'^'j^^nc, 7 0^ ^rrr^rr^ k L ^ Y^

Plep- -bfca , 91) k &+rc^ na, lDleslq3

.,^---- ,t Ir 4 GZ ^ F,5 L4 3 C'iuqca2.ln (^ ^

. .. .q^^ ? g 3 Y3 C!utah0qcz ^^:

^ ^ ) -De i C_Ar_ d.i( Wi T7 5-

^^L^^Cc^^ ^1211) ^c^+C)Ct^^^rC;t^^

^^,^Z..^t3 £..^ ^^'L".t^ ^,^^ ^ ^ ` ^• ^;^C^c.F i ^ ^^L4 ^^ v ^ `^ ^ ^ ^C^r'l ^ i67

1r:^f

$

. _ - ..^-_-... __ . . ^ T ., ;.. . . . . _. . __... _ ... ..._ . . . ^. . . .. . .^ki^^^t^ti"<%^'b'..1_ . . , . _ . .

F p^ /

L' S'57&5

H

U

.,: .^14

ell,^ ^,.^.., .^C`^165x2C "^ ^r'Sc_d^E^ ^^VI

y

.. . . (^r : ^^,'^ithrb^^ ^S.V^'•`r^^.^o3. . . . ... . . '^J'X! ^. . . .... . . . ..^ . ...... ^. ^4../ f C` ^'r^y L

! ^^ ^^ t^^^^•,^ r. ^'^'^-^., ^ +^ f ^C^ ^^ 7^ ^' ^^^,^^,^ ys`Y^^t ^ ^

c(Vk

Vj C.,_rC6002-1'

. . .. .. . ^ r ^• . . , . . . . .. . , .... . . . . . .. . / `'- . . . . . ...,: , .^.. ^ . ..i

^ ^^. .. ^ - • .'NbLV^ ^

^° Le -t , r)

ld

1-1^

9 °! ^f

NL"r--

.697a

^^s f feti IO

^^^Df re &H:Dr

. . r' r ^l .,^-C.il . ^ ^3' f^'4./ ^, . .

^0 C. .

ot ovt1cl (cr ci

^►^• _^^,^^^. ^^,^ ^

^^ gW UnT

C^v^► "^°c^ J c^W

^ ^^ 4, ^.

O4O A

0J ^

^ ^

^60 60Y6 b (a &

(821 5!^1^q338'70^ 7

iaot^544^^

B . ^

►^^. ^`',

A -16^^ tr, a^^34 7

1333U

<2a.^^

L,j+G, r 6`e.r\

onq hon-d)

LAcas

k^^^^6

" ^^ 6

i

Opv

^P

^ ^^ ^ ^ -t-

t°' , A) t ^,

.. ^

7^^^^COs

All.s ^7.^

^ W&.t Gs r^^ ^'^. r ^s ... .. A VY)_ ` . .

.^6 ": .^-N i... . ^ . ..:^..a ^^,^1 ^.^. . . .. .. ._ . __ . . ^

^,..._.....,............ ^ - .__^./^1'^3" :.. .r,.^[.A^/1 .__._. ....__-..E^.^.._.___ __.^^L/^^^is.SS.^.^J.l.^ ..._.... ^..^ ^

-7f hu

J 1 ^ ^- ^ .. . ........... .... .. .

707.r ^^^^c^^,^^^^^^^^^^^►_ ^' ^^.^^^ ^'^ ^^^^^^^ ^^j^ _ °^. .

73 b._p^.^,^^`7^

., ;

_ . _., ,-.--^- -^ ^^-- ^

: AJtfo ..... ..... ..- Cet ^-^ ^ ^^^ ^^,. .

^ ^. - . . . ., .or,. ^. {

4 ' . ( ^ . . . . .zc., ^ .`79. r^.^t^ Scic(cL

._....

.__^q(o^s^^ v.Ve_^5

t4cm^ - .... .., ^ _. ..: . ^ ^^ . . . . . ^ ^^^.^

^^---- - - ----:::.^66 ,

&Igs

"D Li

...9^3 GZ . - . . f .^ ^^

6 ^', IV lq_ ^^ ^^^7 7^. . ,,, ^ . . _ _ .. . _. . : _. : _.^ .:... .^ . _ .^-^ , ,^. .., . . _ - {

., cv,_jk4clu,c 675-3.._ . ^ ___._ ..k \ . ...._. ...- ... . ..... . . ......

_. ^^^. , :... . . ^^ ^ _ . .... , , .

Onk.li n_.^ ^ .

. . . _ ^l ^^. `3^^ ^^'^2^ ^ ^ ^^°r^^ (^ _ ^'.^ ^C^^' , 1 ^ _ _ x

ca►r^,t; n

Posalqo -ba-ui,^s .. . . Jt c w._

Atic )^-,^,^^^..^^o,_^^^^ 4^, ^TT^ _.

t t ^t

lCd.

1) ;3 s

l d^^

^^^•

ZZ-6

Gideon Alert: Ohio Public Defender Commission to force change in Hamilton County (Ci... Page I of 2

NLADAJustice Standards, Evaluation & Research Initiative

JSERB Home

About JSERI

JSERI Publications & Reports

Contact Us

Gideon Alert: Ohio Public Defender Commission toforce change in Hamilton County (Cincinnati)

BY David Carroll on Monday, June 28, 2010 at 11:33 AM

Cincinnati

Hamilton County

JSERI

NDLI

Defender

Ohio

Funding

Public Defense Reform

Standards

State Public Defender

On June 27th, 2010 the Cincinnati Enquirer reported about how the Ohio Public Defender Commission

(OPDC) is forcing change to public defense services in Hamilton County, by withholding state

reimbursements and potentially suing the county over failure to provide an adequate right to counsel.

As_ backround, Ohio was the first state to adopt what has come to be known as "the Indiana Model" for

providing public defense. In 1976, the Ohio Legislature created a centralized state oversight system,

designed primarily for the purpose of administering state assistance grants to local jurisdictions to improve

standards of representation. Though funding remained predominantly a county function, the state was to

reimburse counties up to 50% of their cost. The statute established the OPDC - a nine-member board

empowered to set the standards of performance for existing county public defender offices and to set

statewide criteria for determining indigency, reasonable caseloads, and attorney qualifications. OPDC

oversees and appoints the Director of the Ohio Public Defender Office (OPDO) - a centralized public

defender office that serves as the administrative and reimbursement funding agency for the counties, and

provides: limited direct tria}-IeVel client representation to those counties that cede local control; death penalty

appellate and habeas representation; appellate representation in non-capital cases; juvenile appellate

representation; and mitigation and investigation services.

Unti12009, OPDC had never established any meaningful standards for attornQy_Qr-system performance, and__- _therefore there was no measure by which thecentra( office could judge the effectiveness of the counties'

delivery systems. And, during this same time period, the state had consistently retreated from their financial

commitment - in 2008 counties were reimbursed for only 23% of their public defense costs. The impact was

such that county governments had little incentive to consider^^^ej^iinqrbudget concerns.

On July 10, 2008, NLADA published a report on indigent defense in Hamilton County (Cincinnati), to the

Hamilton County Commission. NLADA found that, while services were constitutionally inadequate, many of

the problems identified are beyond the ability of the County and the Public Defender Office to solve on its

own. Solutions require statutory authority from the state legislature, funding beyond what the county can

http://www. n1 ada: net/j serifblog/gi deon-alert-ohi o-publi c-defender-coxnmi ssi on-force-cha... 11 f 14/2013

Gideon Alert: Ohio Public Defender Commission to force change in Hamilton County (Ci... Page 2 of 2

provide, and the cooperation of the courts, the prosecutors, law enforcement, and the private bar. On the

heels of the report, local advocates pushed for changes, resulting in a stunning victory whereby the governor

added $35 million to the State Public Defender budget to bring the state funding closer to the promised 50%

level,

Unfortunately, that new funding did not come with enough restrictions or instructions for how it must be

used. Hamilton County's portion of the new funds amounted to $1.2 million. Rather than give that money

entirely to the public defender system in Cincinnati, the county last year reduced the public defender county

budget by $700K and increased the sheriffs budget by $700K. Effectively this meant that the $1.2 million of

new money resulted in oniy $500K go^ to pubiic defense and the other $700K going to law enforcement.

Such blatant disregard for the intent of the new funding has encouraged the OPDC to put Hamilton County

on notice. Hamilton County has until July 23, 2010 to submit a reform plan or face defunding. The plan

must include a new office with appropriate space for confidential attorney-client discussions, appropriate

technology (Cincinnati is yet another example of a major urban jurisdiction that expects public defenders to

share computers!), and 42 additional staff.

ShareThis

O National Legal Aid & Defender Association. All rights reserved.

http://www. nl ada. net/i seri/i3l og/gideon-al ert-ohi o-public-defender-commi ssi on-force-cha... 1 l/ 14/2013

Legal Advocates Want Overhaul Of Public Defender System / ideastream - Northeast Ohi... Page 1 of 3

Legal Advocates Want Overhaul Of Public Defender

System

Posted: October 2, 2013

C Share ihtfps:/lwww facebook com/sharertsharer php?u=http:/Iwww ideastream org/ne ws/npr/2285724181 4

Tweet (https://twitter.com/share'urt=htfp•//www ideastream org/news/npr/228572418&text=Leqal Advocates Want

Overhaul Of Public Defender Systeml Email (mailto:?subject=Check out this paqe from ideastream owl

&body=Check out this page from ideastream.org - Legal Advocates Want Overhaul Of Public Defender System:

h ttp://www, ideastrea m. orq/newsln n r/228572418 )

Former Vice President Walter Mondale and a former Alabama Supreme Court justice are among those

pressing for a bipartisan commission to improve legal services to the poor.

(http://med i a, n pr, org/assets/im.q/2013/10/02/181739036-

031 b9d9323c58d275f41 eaol f8444426cfd6ce84. i pa )

Former Vioe President Walter Mondale

speaks at a Georgetown University Law

Genter discussion last week. He is one of

several prominent individuals calling for

better legal representation for the poor,

Win tvl^Narrmee

Prominent members of the legal community are pressuring the Obama administration to do more to ensure that

poor criminal defendants have access to a lawyer, a situation that Attorney General Eric Holder has already

likened to a national crisis.

Calls to create a bipartisan White House commission began earlier this year

Lhttp:/lwww.npr.ora/2013/03/15/174331300/50-^years-after-key-case-problems-defending-the-poor-persistj, with the

50th anniversary of the landmark Supreme Court case Gideon v. Wainwright that first insured a public defender

for persons accused of non-capital offenses. This week, advocates traveled to Washington to meet with

Associate Attorney General Tony West to push the idea of the commission beyond the talking stage, NPR has

learned.

Former Alabama Supreme Court Justice Sue Bell Cobb, former Vice President Walter Mondale, New York

indigent legal services director William Leahy, and Equal Justice Initiative Director Bryan Stevenson wrote a

letter to the Justice Department earlier this year expressing concern that many defendants charged with minor

http://tvwvv. ideastream. org/news/npr/228572418 11 /14/2013

Legal Advocates Want Overhaul Of Public Defender System / ideastream - Northeast Ohi... Page 2 of 3

offenses were not getting legal counsel and that others were not being properly served by overworked and

underpaid public defenders.

"The right to counsel is a precious right that goes to the core of who we are as a people," the letter said.

They said work needs to be done in the areas of reducing the use of cash bail, which can be unaffordable for

the poor, appointing a lawyer earlier in the criminal process, ensuring defenders are truly independent from

judges who appoint them, getting rid of some low level and non-violent cases through treatment and other

programs, counseling defendants on the impact of waiving their rights and studying the fiscal and psychological

costs of over-incarceration.(They want the Obama administration to establish a National Commission on the

Fair Administration of Justice for the Indigent Aecused)

David Carroll, executive director of the Sixth Amendment Foundation, describes the scope of the problem this

way. "The most prevalent form of right to counsel services in America is for an attorney to handle an unlimitqd

number of cases for a single flat fee under contract to a judge or county manager. This model produces a

financial conflict of interest in.which the less amount of resources or effort the attorney puts into the case, the

more he puts in his own pocket. And, judges often appoint only those attorneys who contribute to their political

reelection campaigns. Over 64% of counties (1,900 of 3,033) in the U.S. operate under this model:"

Attomey General Eric Holder has given a series of speeches on reorienting the Justice Department away

from non-violent drup offenders htt ://www.nfrr orq/2013/08/07/209253516/with-holder-in-the-lead-sentencina-

reform-qains-momentum), making use of compassionate release programs for sick and elderiy inmates, and

other steps to reduce the nation's overcrowded prisons. But advocates say one issue that cuts across all those

problems is the )ack of defense attorneys for people facing criminal charges..

States already have been moving to try to address that concern. Texas overhauled its system for defending the

poor more than 10 years ago. Earlier this summer, Michigan's Republican Gov. Rick Snyder signed bipartisan

legislation in that state to create an indigent defense commission

(http://www.nor.org120121061141'954849477/michiqan-finally-eyeing-chancles-to-lawyers-for-poort, an idea pushed

by Tea Party state lawmakers and the Texas branch of the American Civil Liberties Union.

And public defenders in 47 out of 50 states have been writing Holder all summer to urge the Justice

Department to take a broader role. For instarice, Carlos Martinez, a public defender in Miami, wrote "for

hundreds of thousands of Florida residents, the right to counsel is a hollow right."

Martinez said many misdemeanor defendants get no legal assistance at alt, and in other cases, defendants run

through an "assembly line" guilty plea mill with little of the "adversarial testing of the evidence" that undergirds^ .- -^-_

Ahe American justice system.

It's a familiar as far away as South Dakota.

"The fact that we do not have a statewide public defender system leaves us with no support when it comes to

advocating for equal funding," wrote Traci Smith, the chief public defender in Minnehaha County, South

Dakota. "Due to excessive caseloads and staffing shortages, it has become incredibly difficult to keep qualified

attorneys on staff. ... Urifortunately whenever there is a shortfall, the Public Defender education and training is

always the first line item that gets cut."

http-//www.ideastream.org/news/npr/228572418 11 / I 4/2013

Legal Advocates Want Overhaul Of Public Defender System / ideastream - Northeast Ohi... Page 3 of 3

In Missouri, whose indigent defense system has long.been cited for its triage-level workloads, Cat Kelly'of the

state public defender's office and Chief Justice Richard Teitelman of the Missouri Supreme Court wrote this

plea: "As a nation, we daily pledge our allegiance to 'liberty and justice for all' whiie collectively closing our eyes

to the horrific gap between that ideal and the reality of our jusficesystem."

Earlier this year, in what officials at the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers called a milestone,

the Justice Departmentweiaheci irt to affirm a federal interest in the smooth and fair operations of pub1defQnder functions ( http°/lwww npr ora/2013/OS/03/216809388/justice-dept-tackles-Aualitv of defense for the-

oor in two towns near Seattle.

The issue is drawing attention on Capitol Hill; too. Florida Democratic Rep. Ted'Deutch is preparing to

introduce legislation that would create a permanent, national center for the right to counsel, a nonprofit group

that would provide financial support and training for public defense systems. The idea is modeled on the LegalServices Corporation, which helps provide legal aid in civil cases, according to a draft summary of the billobtained by NPR.

Update at 10 a.m. on Oct. 3: 'Time To Stop Studying These Problems'

Not everyone who works on public defense for the poor thinks spending time and money to study the problem

is a good idea. A group of lawyers and activists told the Justice Department earlier this week there's virtually no

debate on the key point: that more money and training need to be provided to public defenders nationwide.

"We believe it is time to stop studying these problems and to do something about them," wrote a group that

-irrcludes Stephen Bright of the Southern Center for Human Rights, David Bruck of the Washington and Lee

University School of Law, Sherrilyn lfill of the NAACP Legal Defense & Educational Fund and Virginia Sloan of

the Constitution Project.

"Whatever resources the federal government is willing to commit to the right to counsel for poor people

accused of crimes should be immediately spent funding people and programs working in states and

communities where there is the greatest need to make Gideon a reality," they added.

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http:Jtwww.npr.org/.

Tags

The Two-Way

Leave a Comment

Please follow our community discussion rules /home/rutes) when composing your comments.

{iavascript:;) {iavascript:•)

http://www,ideastream.org/.news/npr/228572418 11 / 14/2013

County Indigent Defense Systems Page 1 of 6

(r F''''Search

'YL'^rs C^the^^^to CoZiJisd

°2d{?t?f?`, ^^^^IT14^7T1 z^- tr :9¢3v 101-^i

Home (About Us ( Divisions jReimburseament I OPD Resources ( xnternet Links County PD's I

County Indigent Defense Systems

Ohio's indigent defense system consists of County Public Defenders, which includes County offices and alsoagreements with Non-Profit Corporations, Court-Appointed Counsel, and the Office of the Ohio PublicDefender. The defense system used by each county is determined by the local Board of CountyCommissioners.

Together, Ohio county public defenders handled over 258,827 cases in fiscal year 2012.

Court Appointed Counsel County Contract w! Non-Profit Corporation

County Public Defender Contract with the State Public Def7

,,

der -"

® ke n.ra L-u 1Fulton u:sr ,s S a ^ j

St iiiia,ns

GeaugaCuya4eoga

^efiance' lienry ^1'ocd Sandusky Erie ---^ . ^ TrurnbuflLorain

ldin1 1Hurort PortagePaug $eneca Mledina r.>if

Puinam Hancock ^ J Mahoning

ff Ash° _r7_--`r3? ^-rt Wyandot Crawford Rieh-

P.1len land EandJVayne

Stark

H^?rr{in

Mercer Aaralaixe piEarion Carroii; IYiorrow -' Holmes

Tuscar- Jeffer-

Logaro Knox Ir ^ a:nas (r- y son

Sheli;y^ ^Jnian r}e.l:,ware Coshocton Har.rison

-^-ChampaignMliarrti Licking )"`'^, ^ htuskin Guernsey Belrnont

gumCfark Nladi- Franklin^ ! L ^

son ^^---

P11r3r t 1 ` ^ { ^^Irebl -gom r• ^_ rairfiel perry ^^ NU6[e 11 f+4onroe

reenePirkaedey.

L. _f + ^ ^ Hockiuy Ji ii i,toI3c ler Warren Ciinton

- !_. ^ ^ f{css ( Ahc.n> S jVinton

Hamilton^ ^^ Highland

Cier- P evj s( P^EN

mont ^-- ---L ----- f. .

\ ^rE t n -^^ Ad rr}s Scioto ^ r li;aL- ^

Law

rence

http:,I/www.opd.ohio.gov/countypd/countypd,htm 11 / 14t 2013

Lucas County Democratic Headquarters Page 1 of 4

"7'he Lucas County Dem-cacratzG. Party - Elected +:)fficiaIsPage

Lucas County Democratic Elected Officials

Name Office

John Adler Washington Local School Board

Michael Ashford

Donald Atkinson

Mike Friedman

Jenny Barlos

James Bates

Julia Bates

,.,Vallie Bowman-English

John Boeliner

Edna Brown

Tyronne Riley

Gary Byers

Ann Cherry

CaroE Contrada

Gary Cook

Stacy Cook

Shaun Enrigft,..,..... ._. .. __.

Michael Coyle

Michael Craig

Maridee Curry

Denise Navarre Cubbon-------------

Dean Mandros

Myron Duhart

Keith Earley

Don Eisel

Frank Erme

Ohio House District 48

Anthony Wayne Board of Education

Democratic State Central Committee

Maumee City Council

Judge, Lucas County Common Pleas Court

Lucas County Prosecutor

Toledo Municipal Clerk of Courts

Maumee City Council n,t

Ohio Legislature House District 48

Toledo City Council District 1

Judge, Maumee Municipal Court

Waterville Council

Lucas County Commissioner

Judge, Lucas County Common Pleas Court

Judge, Lucas County Common Pleas Court

Toledo C ►ty Councii- At Large_ . u,^.... . ,Maumee Council

Toledo City Council District 3

Whitehouse Council fJ!

Judge, Lucas County Common Pleas Court.

Judge, Lucas County Common Pleas Court

Judge, Lucas County Common Pleas Court_.: ,.Lucas County Engineer

Richfield Twp Trustee

Washington Locaf School Board

http:liwww. l ucasdems.com/elected_off'ici al s. php 12/4/20 1 ;

Home Candidates Events Calendar Clubs Volunteer Links Cont;act Us

Lucas County Democratic Headquarters

Teresa Fedor

Tyrone Riley

Adam Martinez

Cecelia Adams

Ruth Ann Franks

Richard Gable

Pete Gerken

George Gernot

Jeffrey Gibbs

Kevin Gilmore

Francis Gorman

Rodney Graffis

Michael Dansack Jr

Eric Heintschel

Rebecca Henderly

David Hunter

Linda Johnston

Wade Kapszukiewicz

Marcy Kaptur

Diane Karoly

Jeff Keller

Steve Kendall

Norma King

Carol Contrada

Karen Krause

Joan Kuchcinski

Gary Kuns

Curtis Lancaster

Anita Lopez

Mark Luetke

Jeff Marty

C. Allen McConnell

Fred McDonald

Joe McNamara

Arthur Nevers

Jim Nusbaum

Thomas Osowik

Rosemary Ott

Page 2 of 4

Ohio Legislature, House District 47

Toledo City Council - District 1

Toledo City Council At Large

Toledo Board of Education

Judge, Lucas County Cornmon Pleas Court

Oregon School Board

Lucas County Commissioner

President, Sylvania Board of Education

Ottawa Hills Council

Mayor of Ottawa Hills

Judge, Toledo Municipal Court

Waterville Councii

Jerusaiem Twp Trustee

Lucas County Board of Education

Oregon School Board

Harding Twp Trustee

Washington Local Board of Education

Richfield Twp Fiscal Officer

Lucas County Treasurer

U.S. House of Representatives, Ninth District

Oregon School Board

Judge, Oregon Municipal Court

Providence Twp Trustee

Ottawa Hills Council

Lucas County Commissioner

Lucas County Edu Services Gov Board

Lucas County Edu Services Gov Board

Monclova Twp Trustee

Spencer Twp Trustee

Lucas County Auditor

Sylvania City Council

Waterville Council

Toledo Municipal Court

Judge, Lucas County Common Pleas Court

Toledo City Council, At Large - President

Richfield Twp Trustee

Sylvania School Board

Judge Sixth District Court of Appeals

Berkey Council ,

http://wNvw.lucasdems.com/clected- officials.php 12/4/2013

Lucas County Democratic Headquarters

James Patrick

Gail Perry

Phil Copeland

Steven Perry

Paula Hicks-Hudson

Diana Piasecki

Stephanie Piechowiak

Mark Pietrykowski

Jack Puffenberger

Bernie Quilter

Heather Rade

Terry Reeves

Robert Righi

Joseph Rutherford

Jim Seaman

Barbara Shaheen

Michael Sheehy

David Simko

Arlene Singer_.......... .... ....Michelle Wagner

Steve Steel

Lisa Sobecki

Carl Stanoyevic

Steve Steel

Brenda Hill

Matt Szollosi

Robert Taylor

James Telb

Dennis Tippie

Jim Valtin

Julie Van Nest

Robert Vasquez

Timothy Wagener

Sylvia Washburn

Lindsay Webb

Stan Wielinski

Janet Wolff

Tina Skeldon-Wozniak

Page 3 of 4

Lucas County Coroner

Providence Twp Fiscal Officer

Lucas County Recorder

Providence Twp Trustee

Toledo City Council District 4

Springfield Board of Education

Maumee Board of Education

Judge, Sixth District Court of Appeals. . .....,... . ...... .. .. ....

Judge, Lucas County Probate Court

Lucas County Clerk of Courts

Evergreen School Board

Oregon City Councti

Maumee School Board

Lucas County Board of Education

Oregon City Council

Washington Twp Trustee

Oregon City Council

Sylvania Twp Fiscal Officer

Judge, Sixth District Court of Appeals

Judge of Common Pleas

Toledo City Council - At Large

Toledo Board of Education

Mayor of Harbor View

Toledo City Council 1) c,,na tF>

Toledo Board of EducationCurrently our donation system is

Ohio Legislature House District 49 down. If you would likle to make a

Spencer Twp Trustee donation to the Lucas CountyDemocratic Party, please contact

Lucas County Sheriff us eit (419) 24 6-930 ?. Thar;ics foryour patience as we transition to

Swanton Twp Trustee the now website.

State Board of Education

Waterville Councilt^.;tion

Jerusalem Twp Fiscal Officer

Toledo Board of Education< . :

Mayor of the City of Maumee^^ i^-,C,^,t,4es' <^ , . < .. . „ ` < <

. .<.<..<.... .....Maumee Board of Education ^ C'<<^n r,c C:1^^t^a3 t^rficitcGs

++ < a 4 q.w w Y. 4 4M s s Y a a<• i' o s s Y

Toledo City Council District 6Katto Al.ban1' > d• . R• w c< M Y P. 1• < e ♦ Y.•Mayor of Whitehouse

N`otirtg tt1foi"[2lyilfifl#tMaumee Board of Education

Lucas County Commissioner

http ://wvtiTw. l ucasdems , c om/el ected_offi ci al s. p hp 12/4/2013

''L,ucas County Democratic Headquarters Page 4 of 4

Connie Zemmelman Judge, Lucas County Juvenile Court

Norman Zemmelman Judge, Lucas County Domestic Relations

Angela Wallington-Zimmann Lucas County Edu Services Gov Board

Jeffrey Ziviski Oregon School Board

Steve Zuber Washington Local Board of Education..., ,., ... ,, _

AuthorPZed.nt? paid toi by tuc. vucJ 'i Maal 3vr; Ftvenuo, snizc4 , vmo ^^.4. xL wntet^^ .,

. .. ,. . , . ^ ^ ././r..,.; r• ' ^ . . . ., . , i . . . . ^ . ., _

- , .. - .-., .._ . _ . . • ... .. „ t. .. ^ .

- ' . . . ., ^t. , .. ^ .. .s .. . . .. i . . .._ ._ . , .. . . ,

, ^, , ^. r . f ^I , ^ • 'r y,, . , . . . ., r. .. .

%^/ ^, r .. - . . .^ . _ .. . ... ..- . - ^ ^ . .

. . .. , . ,_ .. ... . , - .. .. . .. ^ .. ^ . . :^^'i

.. . .. ., .. ,., , .. . ^ ^ i,

.. .. . .. , , . , . . ^ ., . ^ ... ., . .. r .. . . .. > . ., . .

, ..

. . .. . ^ . . f . . . - .. .., .,. .., ^ ' . 't:L .. .. r... ,>.

^.,.d A.

, , ,• '; _ , . .. . ., .. .. ^ - .. . ' _ . . . f i^. . r f. .. r •. .

y .,

, _ _. {: .:. .. . . : . . . . .. . . .

. r . :. ;.. _.. . . ^u,.,: . ^, t. , . ., . .. .. ,.. % „ . r < . .... r _ .

„f .. .... .. ... . ^ .,

F a^

.. i. , ,. „

.. / ! ^^-.,... , c . .. .. . . .. _ .. . . . . _ . r

-. . .,., .. . ,r .. . ,, . . '. .. '. . . .. :. . . > ./_^ . . . , . . . . . . . . .. . . -^ .. ,,.^^.,. .^1 ^ . ... .

. . . . . , .. .., : ^ .. . . . . . . _ ^.:. :^ ^ ,.,/'.,:;, • . ' . . . : . , .

. % ,•':' i , .I :_ ^. .. .^ ' ...; - s' ,. :_ ' ^ .

^ ^ ` - - . . . . _ . . . . ^

^ . . . . .. .. . . ^r, .^^ .. .. ,_. .

^ ,^/ ^,. . _ .. , . / ^ ^.',. /,

http: /fwww.l ucasdems. comlelected_offici al s, php 12/4/2013

Unions back Enfight to succeed Copeland on Toledo City Council - Toledo Blade

THE BLADEnnxnfAn^nNre^wi.tr+riti.no.^ir:yrr+

Page 1 of 3

Unions back Enright to succeed Copeland on Toledo City CouncilDY'I'OMTROY AND IGNAZIO MESSINABLADE PQLITICS WRITER

As one union representativc departs Tofedo City Council for an elected job 'Aqth

Lucas County, Toied'o-area canstruction unions are sttpporting another union

11 ^:4<

W

Coaetruction dnions are supporting 5haun Enright,

left, to succeecl Phil Copelaiitt on Toledo City

Counoil.

representativeto take his place - a man with a history of legal trouble.

Shaun Enright, an unsuccessfu12011 council candidate, was convicted in 1999 of

illegally carrving a concealed handgun. In 2004 he declared personal bankruptcy.

Mr. Enright and his supporters say he has niatured and that he would bring a needed

labor voice to city council,

"It happened over 14 years ago, and since then I put tnyself througli college, put

niyself through an apprenticeship, started a family, and I would hope thatwouldn'tbe

held against me;" Mr. Enright said.8niarge ;

Phil Copeland, business maiiager for the Laborers Local 500, will soon resign his at-

large seat on council to become Lucas County recorder, a job he Aon in the,Nov. 6 election.

The Lucas County Deinocratic Party is expected tc> endorse a candidate for the council vacancy Dec. 3.

In September; 1999, Mr. Enrightwas charged }uith carrying a concealed wea on and was sentenced to six months in jail, but the--- . ..

entire sentenee was suspended. He was placed on inactive probation for one year:

According to a complaint filed in Toledo Municipal Court in Ju1y, 1999, Mr. Enright "had concealed afid ready at hand the loaded

Lorcin 2-5-cal. automatic pistol found underneath the driver's seat" of a car he was driving. The court record indicates he was

pulled over for failure to display a license, not wearing a seat belt, and slow speed.

In November, 1998, he was charged with having an open container in a stopped vehicle, menacing, resisting arrest, and disorderly

conduct-t ntoxFcatton.

All the charges wer-e dismissed. The feiony menacing charge stemmed from an exchange at ftis booking during wltieh Mr. E,nf-ight__ _ ....:...:

told a sheriffs dc.putv "that he would remember his face and take care oE'him when he got out of jail," records .show.

Mr. Enright, 33, an organizer with International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Local 8, said all ofhis criminal charges were

the result of youthful indiscretion --- "just being dutnb and making mistakes."

Mr. Enright has lrad lnorerecent financial troubles. The Ohio Department of Taxation filed a personal incorne tax lien in Lucas

County Common Pleas Court against him and his wife in August for $3,447. He said he has paid that debt and the licn is in the

removal process. `I'he couple filed for Chapter 7 batrkruptey in November, 2004, listing credit-card debt of nearly$13,700.

T'he criminal history became an issue during Mr. Enright's campaign last year againstDemocratic Councilman ivlike Craig, who

won re-election to Council District 3, which includes East Toledo and part of South "l"oledo.

"Mike Craig put out a mailer about [the charges]," Mr. Enright said. "I don't know if that affected the campaign,"

tinions contributed more thati $18,0U0 to Ivlr. Enriglit's campaign, of which construction-related unions donated $14,050,

according to campaign tinanee reports for 2011 on file with the Lucas County Board of Elections. He also had a fund-raiser that

generated $2,800 in contributions. None of the contributions was from Mr. Etvight hitnself.

To ward off Mr. L;nright's challenge, Mr. Craig raised $20,090 for Itis cantpaign, including a $2,000 loan from his wife, Karen

Craig. He received contributions of $500 each from political action committees representing dock workers, the utilities industry,

and general contractors. ^.':.1^.^' sl _{:'s. .^... € c.. . . . . . ..... .4is..1

f U..

^ r^s .i u; I .i.: ^ s ^, f . .., r,...i, ^ ^g , ^, >'s/ ., .,. . . - 4.^ '^' , .! , ./3 / , i . G , Z^`^., f .. ^:^; F/.; ..,/ . . ^

(

http://www.toledoblade.com/Politi cs/2012/11/24/Uni ons-back-Enright-to-succeed-Copel a... l 11 /26i2013

^'•...

Unions back Ertright to succeed Copeland on T'oledo City Couticil - Toledo Blade Page 2 of 3

Mr. Craig reported to police that two fan»ly cars werevandali2cd on May 31, 20l1, just hours after he voted to sell a 69-acre

portion of the Marina District in East Toledo to Chinese investment firm Dashing Pacific Group Ltd. for $3.8 rnillion. Five tires

were slashed on his and his wife's vehicles in front of their Consaul Street hotne. No arrests were made.

The Nortllwest Ohio Building and Construction Trades C:ouncil objected to that transaction because the buyers would not cornmit

in writing to hiring union labor for the project, although the group said a verbal commitment given by the cotnpany's construction

manager before council's vote allayed some of the concerns.

Nine days after the incident, Mr. Craig received an anonynious letter suggesting Mr. Enright as the culprit based on a"history,"

but without offering any evidence,

Mr. Enright on Friday denied any role in vandalizing Mr. Craig's cars. "I don't condone that behavior and we don't do that

behavior," Mr. Enright said. "I'm not the type that wishes harm on anybody."

Mr. Craig did not discount as a reason for the vandalism bis support the previous year of an "exigent circumstances" declaration to

force concessions trom most city labor unions, which also aroused union opposition.

Mr: Craig said the party's endorsement "doesn't cany a thing for me, because thev didn't endorse me last tinie," and he liad no

intention of voting to appoint Mr. Enright.

"I don't believe he is qualified," Mr. Craig said. "I know all there is to know about his criminal history. ... There are tons of people

out there who are qualifred and who don't have criminal records. This is the best they could come up with?"

The Northwest Ohio }3uildingand Construction Trades Council is trying to line up support for hi m within the party and on couneil.

"I'bc council of 16unions, representing as many as 12,000 workers, contends that council needsa labor representative to replace

Mr. Copeland.

"We'd support him for that seat. We would like to see Shaun appointed," said John Sehlagheck, executive secretary of the

organization that represents area unions, including electricians, ironworkers, pipefitters, laborers, painters, tnasous, and carpenters.

Mr. Selilagheck said Mr. Enright has experience as a conimunity activist.

"We're just trying to get a guy wlro thinks like us on council. He shows interest in being in council because he ran for the district

from East Toledo. IIe was unsuecessful, but he didn't have a bad run," Mr. Schlagheck said.

Lucas County Democratic Chairman Ron Rothenbuhler, a former director of the Northwest Ohio Council of Carpenters, said he

supports Mr. Enright for the vacancy.

"I believe in giving people a chance to recover and beconie what theyreally want to be. He really wants to do that and I'm willing

to give him a chance and I support that," Mr. Rothenbuhler said. "I do believe that he would be a good replacement for Phil

Copeland, because we feel that the labor eommttnity needs a representative to watch out for issues that are near and dear to their

heart."

Councilman Lindsay Webb said the party's endorsement would cany significant weight, tmd she would "most assuredly" vote for

the person receiving the endorsement.

"There is a process that the Democrats use to 97elp determine who is the best person to serve, campaign, and retain theseat after the

appointment as with Paula Hicks-Hudson and Steven Steel," Ms. Webb said.

Ms. I-Iicks-Hudson, w'ho like Mr. Steel was appointed to council after getting the party's endorsentent and later won election, said

Mr. Enright's past does uot disqttalify him.

"I know there is a lot of interest in whoever is in that seat has an interest in labor," Ms. Hicks-Hudson said.

Councilman Tom Waniewski, one of the three Republicans on council, said he would not support Mr. Enright or fortner mayor

Jack Ford, who has also expressed interest.

"I can't seehow someone could adequately perform public servicc when they violate it so oftei) based on a criminairecord," he

sa'rd.

Mr. Waniewski ran a rtewspaper ad seeking people intet-ested in the endorsernent,

http a!www.toledoblade, comIPoliti cs12012/ 1l /24IUni ons-back-Enright-to-succeed-Gopela. ,: 11/26/2013

, Unions back Enright to succeed Copeland on Toledo City Council - Toledo Blade Page 3 of 3

"I had a retired CEO inqiiire about the position," he said. "If you look at what we have, it seems to be a political career ladder and

the public is cheated when we get that."

Council President Joe MeNaniara, a Democrat who supported Mr. Craig's re-election in 2011, wants the party to endorse someone

all the Democrats will support.

"I think the party should be working with all Democrats to find a candidate we can all support and who the voters will elect," he

said. "At the end of the day, as a Democrat, I want to see Democrats elected, and part of that goal is to find a candidate who will

vti<in and be supported by the voters."

Former Mayor Carty );%inkbeiner, who defeated Mr. Ford in 2005, said Mr. Ford's inte(lect and knowledge of city issues, inciuding

finances and developme3rt, are too valuable to pass up.

"Almost annually there is an opportunity for an appointment to be made. It should go to the person who can contribute

immediately to dealingwith budget issues, public safety issues, and job creation issues,"Mr. Finkbeiner said.

Lucas County Republican Chairman Jon Stainbrook said that in light of the Democratic Party's eouncil majority, there isn't

anything the Repiiblican Party can do to derail the appointment.

"Obviously this guy has turned his life around and it happened over a decade ago. If the Democratic Party is picking Mr. Enright,

then Mr. Enright is going to get the nod. It's jirst the way it is; "Mr. Stainbrook said,

Whoever isappointed to the vacancy v.'ould be expected to run for election in tiie Septemberprunary and in the general election

tlext November with other at-large counc'rl candidates.

Contact Toni `Troy at: tomtroy(c^.theblade.com or 419724-6058.

Copyright 2013 The t•;lade. Al! rights reserved. This material may not be copied or distributed without permission,

http:l/cvww.toledoblade:com/Politicsl2012I11/24r'Unions-back-Enright-to-succ>ved-Copela;,, 11/26/2013

Real Estate Transfers: 10-25 - Toledo Blade

._ . . . : . : ... DE

Real Estate Transfers: 14-25LUCASCOUNTY

October 14 througb October 18, 2013

43522

Residential

Ritsenia Robert Miehael to Gharpie Charles F Iv, 13325 Ivlohler Rd; GrandRxapids, $210,000, (10116)

43528

Pagelof18

Residential

Arnold Stephen L & Nicki A to Okorowski Lauren, 421 Danesmoor Rd, Holland, $77,325, (10/16)

Bayview Loan Servicing LLC to Greater Metropolitan Title LLC As Trustee, 709 SHi11Pack Dr, Holland, $35,000, (10i17)

Bmo Harris13ttnk Na to Honnough iVlichael J, 6579 Pilliod Rd, Ho(land, S72,000, (1I)/15)

I-Iyler David K to I'nc Bank Na, 925 Albon Rd, I-Iollartcl, $76.667, (10/17)

43537

Residential

Fauble Debra I, SucTrnstee to Martin Miu•ray M & Jean, 1059 Leith St, Martmee; $92,500, (10/15)

Louisville Title Agency For Nw Ohio Inc Trnstee to Giesige Jeffrey J& Amy M, 7704Lonetree Ct, Maumee, $229,900; (10/16)

Lumh LTD to Cavazos Matthew R, 1109 Holgate Ave, Manmee, $101,000, (10/17)

Oswald Gary & Janice to Hawk Robert & Jill, 500 Thackeray Rd, Maumee, $140,815, (10/18)

Prebeg Victor to Meek Samuel & Linda, 736 N High St, IvTaumee, S12$,650, (10/17)

Slabe Edward C to Snow Lyle E Trustee Etal, 4733 PortI>r,1Vlaamee, $175,000, (10118)

Warren Sherman Flats L.p. flrt Ohio Limited Partnership to Srtsquehannah Home Finance LLC, 117 EBancroft St. Toledo, S0,

(10%16)

43542

Agriculture

Crounts Jeanne M & James W to Reed Family Farms LLC, 0 Kccner Rd, Monclova, $425,000, (10/18)

Resident7al

Stitt DevelopmentParttzers LLC An Ohi Limited Liab Co to Vance Winston G, 5809 Watermill Ct, Monelova, $89,900, (10/16)

43560

Industrial

http;//www.toledoblade,com/Real-Estate/2013/10/25/Real-Estate-Transfers-10-25.htm] 11/26/2013

,,Real Estate Transfers: 10-25 - Toledo Blade Page 2 of 18

Miller Bros Paviug Inc to Loek-it-up LLC An Ohio Limited Liability Coznpany, 7950 SylvaniaAve, Sylvania. $300,000, (10/18)

Residential

Carpenter Cynthia J Suc Trustee to Rich Linda K, 5013 Maryhill Rd, Sylvania, $110,000, (10/17)

Dodge N..p. Jr (trustee) to F-Ilr Properties LTD An Ohio Lirnited Liability Conipany, 5305 Westcroft Dr Rear, Sylvania, $0, (10115)

Dodge Np. Jr (trustee) to Hlr Properties LTD An Qhio Limited Liability Company, 5305 Westcroft Dr, Sylvania, $175,000,

(1O115)

Huhn David S Sue Tr to Feeback Roger A & Rosemary, 5 Callaway Gt-een, Sylvania, $190,000, (10/16)

Johnson Jereriiy & Emily A to I-Iobbs Ryan & Erica, 9072 Stonybrook Blvd, Sylvania, $227;000, (10/16)

Klever Christopher J & Jennifer I to Dodge N.p. Jt• (trustee), 5305 Westeroftllr Rear, Sylvania, $0, (10/15)

Klever Christopher J & Jennifer I to Dodge N.p. Jr (t:-ustee), 5305 WestcroftDr, Syivania, S175,000, (10/15)

Kralovic Richard P & Ainy F to Pnc Bank N.a., 5701 Westview Dr, Sylvania, $60,000, (10/17)

Lyons L.c. Jr to I'hlipot John, 5122 Inland Dr, Sylvania, $0, (10J18)

LyonsL.c. Jr to Phlipot John, 51261nland Dr, Sylvania, $36,000, (10/18)^ -

Lyons L.c. Jr to Phlipot John, 5130Inland Dr, Sylvania, $0, (10/18)! f .J /, f : .; 4!r .: .'^., .. r' ^ .l •._:.. v

Lyons L.c. Jr to Phlipot John, 5134 Inland Dr. Sylvahia; $0, (10/18)

Neinian Philip M & Patricia K to Giordano Philip G & Arinmaric, 8745 Slate Ridge Ct, Sylvania, $280,000, (10/16)

NickensFred C & Laura K to Nasser Ajaj & I-3absa, 6736 Sweet Bush Ct, Sylvania, $185;000, (10/18)

Parker Philip R Jr to Kopaniasz Ashley L & Michael P, 5139 Olde Ridge Rd, Sylvania, $214,000; (10/16)

Ricli Angela to Dj('ProperticsLT1)An Ohio Limited Liability Company, 5618 Balfour Rd, Sylvania, $60,000, ( 10;16)

Saba Custom Homes LLC to Shuster Jerad R & Jennifer J, 5515 Waterbrook Ct, Sylvania, $299,850, (10/16)

Spencer H Evan & Rebecca J to Sundermeier Christopher W, 7561 Bonniebrook Rd, Sylvania, $179,000, (10/18)

Warren Sherman Flats L.p. An Ohio Limited Partnership to Susquehannah HomeFinanceLLC, 207 E Bancroft St Rear, Maumee,

$0, (10i 16)

Zaner Lois to I-Iafner Dewayne D, 6063 Peppermill Dr;Sylvania, $182,000, (10J16)

43566

Re•sident'sal

Anderson Michael J Jr & Sarah L Trustees to Louisville Title Agency For Nw Ohio Inc Trustees, 7743 Wellsbury I9r, Waterville,

$240,000, (10/15)

13ucher Kirt W & Cindy E to 5ample Jaines Keitit & Mary M Ralph, 1411 E;astritlge Dr, Waterville, $251,000, (10/16)

Kruse Jeffrev L to White Water Worship Center An Ohiir Nonprofit Corp, 1113 I3ending 13rook Ln,Waterville, $230,000, (10/16)

Mohr Faith M to Vershum Linda K, 843 Maple Ln, Vdaterville, $146,750, (10l16)

Raridall Rebecca I. Iital to Densel David S, 8505 Neapolis Waterville Rd, Waterville, S64;000, (10±17)

43571

Residential

Deutsche Bank National Trust Company (as IndeXrture Trustee) to Figy Weston J, 7205 Jeffers Rd, Whitehouse, S150,500, (10/16)

IZttp: //www. to1 edobl ade. corrm/Real -Estatef2013/ 10/25/Real-Estate-Transfers-10-25 , html 11/26/2013

,.Real Estate Transfers: 10-25 - Toledo Blade Page 3 of 18

Hallmark Development Co,lle to Gil bertson Kevin W & Meredith J, 9650 Preakness Ln, Whitehouse, ti41,500, (10/16)

Louisville Title Agency For Nw Ohio Inc "I'rustee to Wilczynski Richard G & Cynthia L, 10373 Blue Ridge Dr South,

Whitehouse, $25,000, (10/16)

Snow Lyle E & Marlene J, Trustees to Bucher Kirt & Cindy, 5956 Lynwood Ct, Whitehouse, $330,000, (10/16)

43605

Residential

Coker Timothv B to F'ifth Third Mortgage Company, 2020 Nevada St, Toledo, $26,000, (10/18)

Elamon Michael I3 to Travis T'ina L, 2619 Norwalk St, Toledo, S15,000, (10115)

Elamon Michael E to Travis Tina L, 2621 Norwalk St, "I'olcdo, S0, (10/15)

Forbes Jaequeline to Boykins Sylvia V. 1958 Burr St, Toledo, $11;000, (10/18)

Grady Kathy Ann Et AI to Pinson Suzanne M, 2032 Greenwood Ave, Toledo, $31,000, (101"] 8)

Hicks Ruby D to Hsbc I3ank Usa National Association (as Trustee), 105 Navarre Ave. Toledo, $6,667, (10/17)

Kp Premier Properties L"I'D to Betts Tiffany R. 361 Valleywood Dr, Toledo, $20,000, (10/18)

Todd James E& Virginia l, to Espino Thomas, 1306 Nevada St, '1'oledo, $4,000. (10i15)

436tKi

Residential

Dismukes Joan-anne Tr to Toledo'I'ransformation LLC,3970 W BaneroftSt; Toledo, S154,000, (10/l6)

Federal National Mortgage Association to Harbour Portfolio Viii Lp, 1641 Ottawa Dr, Toledo, $6,287, (10/16)

Gillespie Kimberly N to Jpmorgan Chase Bank lv'ationaI Association, 1422 F'oster Ave, 'I'oledo, $10,000, (10l18)

Hunter KevinEtal to Willard Marcy J. 3420 West Lincolnshire F31vd, Toledo, $77,250, (10/16)

InvestmentPropertiesC}f Ohio LTD An Ohio LLC to Alvarado Celeste E Etal, 2833 Densmorc Dr, Toledo, $"153,000, (10/16)

Nationslar Mortgage LLC Dba Champion Mortgage Of Ohio to Kendrie.k Jessica & Matthew, 3013 Siierbrooke Rd, Toledo,

$63,200, ( l 0i 1$)

43607

Residential

Breckler Matt to Conklin MatthewWitliam, 125113uckinghamSt, Toledo, S13,00(3, (10/17)

1) & G Sunshine Properties LLC An Ohio LLC to Asad Moneer Eta], 4059 Herinosa Ave,'I'oledo, $22,000, (10/16)

I-Iague Kenneth Jr to Harris 3ohn S Iii, 1410 Pinewood Ave, Tolcdo, 52,000, (10/15)

Nance "l'errell to Jpmorgan Chase Bank National Association, 616 Broer Ave, Toledo, $20,000, (10/16)

Williams Michael E to Williams Christopher A, 1662 Woodland Ave, Toledo, $2,223, (10I18)

43608

Commercial

Moubarak I-loussein to Worlds Courtney L, 3201 Elm St, Toledo, $100, (10/16)

http: //www. toledobl ade, com/Real-Estate/2013/ 1 U/25/Real-.Fstate-Transfers-10-25. html 11/26/2013

i

-OHiOSTATEF'IRE MARSHAL -` EtRE: ariif;EXPLOSlL?N INVESTIGATifJR! BUREAUINCIDC=NT REPORT.

-------------------- - - -- -------IncidentT,, CountyNumber ^011 0608 Type 0 1 Incendiary UeR 0,l 5ingle liamily Dwelling & Name 48 Lucas

Location 5128 Inland Drive ^z^ T i Sylvania, Ohio 4356fl FDID €^}8-017

Incident Loss AOccupied Yes Date 2011/07/04 Time 0529^ Day j Monday

IAmt. $150,000.00 A 0 A 0

j 0 P 1 F 0 PAotive 0 rime Concealment Status L^pen dateA: J A I ! ClosedVehicle License Pal e" VlN VehicleMake Pfate State Year

DBA

tjvrner Lyons, L.C., Jr. Fatality DOB 1952/11/24

- --Address 5128 Inland Drive Oityip ST

] Sylvania, Ohio 43560

Home Phone ^ Work Phone Cellular or Pager

SSN I7OB^ ! ---r--

SSN DOB

SSN 008

SSN DOH

First Lien/ Second LienEloider 513.Ban1t ^ Holder

INSURANGE INFaRMAT1ON_ .. . _ :.-.- =-- --------- --- -- - --=-- - -. _;,Property Ins Nationwide Insuraizce Co. Adjuster Iten, Don PhoneGo _ _

Contents Nationwide Tnsurance Co. Adjuster Iten , m- Phone

Private Inv `^Compan ^-T^1fied Investigation Investigator Marihugh, Bob Phone ^- -

1$150 000.04 Donfents ^75 000.00reae a._ $198,700.00 PLa srty 75,000.00 Cort entsCovera"e Loss " ^

RA en^crng )Sylvania Twp. Police And Fire Phone 419-822-7676 Date 2011/07/04' Time 0613

vestigafi' n 2011/07104 0654 RDeport 9011107/08 Evidence YES Phofios YesTime -- ^-----

rimary Assisfing r>at^rank J. ReitzneierIny t` Iriuesti ator '^^et^rrrr^n

Ap roved AIC McCarthy ^te 2011,'07/12Smoke Detector Present - Activated

DOCUMENTARYINFORMAT!®N

Weather ^- - "_----- -- ^ Area - --- -Cbnditians 68 Legees And Clear _ Descri tion Rural Stable

Scene Yes T'ire &Poiice Depart,*nent Auth o rit

y to Criminal Searcht^?^arrantSecured Er

OtherAgencies Police CoronerOn SceneAlamZ

Systems I -i Intrusion q Fire Smoke Company Guaa°dian Alarm Phone 800 782 9f88

Atarnr AlarmActivation Yes Comments

lncident Guardian Alarrn Phone 800-782-9688 t^OtherDiscovered B ^,ontact

Incidentj2rdian Alarm Phone 800-7$2-9688 OtherReported B Gortact

Forced Entry No Doors Secured AIl Locked 1nl:ndovrs Secured All Closed

Electric ---^ in Gas Gas liz^Toledo Edison Yes Columbia Gas Natural YesSeivice Use Su . 3 T e Use

Prima In Seconda n V^Jater 6n'y 1"orced ?rir ^ No

ry 13lech-ic YesHeaf. Use Heat. Use Heater Use

Date Scene ReleasedDe arted-

2011107l05 Time 1500 To ^Police^- --^-- - - ----- ----- -- - - -

Previouslncidents

0R1G1WANALYS1s :^. _ - -- ---- _ _For reference purposes the stru.cture fpces west,

During the exterior examination smoke and heat damage was noted around the master bedroom windows on both the westand north elevations. Damage was noted to the front 7nain entrance and was confirmed to bave been done by the fixe crews.It was also confirmed that the overhead garage door was opened by the fire crews using the door opener frorn the inside.

The unattached shed in the back yard was also searched as was the yard. Nothing was collected from these areas.

The exterior of the structure was eliminated as an area of fre origin.

The interior examination began in the attached garage on the south end of the structure. There was no fire damage in thegarage.

It was noted that two nlastic grocery bags of meat, still partially frozen were sitting on the garage floor i.n front of the chestfreezer. The silver BMW, Ohio tags- HELPWTD, vras towed from the garage to the police station for storage and forensicevidence proces.sing. Other items of evidence collected from the garage will be documented on the evidence log.

The main alarnz panel and furnace were intact in the crawl space. Access to the crawl space was made f om-the garage.

The garage and crawl space were eliminated as areas of fire oriain.

The examination of the interior of the living area of th'e structure began in the south hallway from the garage. The hallwayhad moderate smoke damage. The bathroom/laundry room had liglit snloke damage. The electrical panel was located in thebathroom/ laundry room. It was intact with the main breaker turned to the off position by the fire crews. Only one 20 ampbreaker was in the tripped position. The ledger indicated the breaker was for the master bedroom. It was noted that the twosingle pole light switches in tlle hallway were in the on position. They are believed to be for the hallway and the garage.

The south hallway and bathroom/ laundry room were eliminated as areas of fire origin.

The kitchenlfamily room had sustained moderate smoke damaae. There were two distinct and separate areas of fire originnote . e irs on the island counter top. The second was on the walking belt surface of the treadmill.

The living room/foyer had sustained moderate smoke damage. There was one distinct area of fire or^gin on a chair in thefoyer. It was noted that the smoke detector was on the floor of the foyer. It wasconfzrmed that the fu•e crews had rernouedffie detector to silence it.

The north hallway and bathroona had sustained heav-y smoke daniage. The closets off the hallway had sustained light smokedamage. The electric t^ater^ieaier ivas intact a-d7ocated iri tlie-TiaMcloset.

The southeast and northeast bedrooms had sustained light srn.oke damage. 'I'he doors to both rooms were found closed by firecrews. The door to the southeast room was locked-ani^sacTto be fcirced open. The wholehouse water filtering system waslocated intact in the closet of the southeast bedroom. ^ ------ -- -- -----^w. - ------------- --__._-,The north hallway, north hallway closets, north bathroom, northeast and southeast bedrooms were eliminated as areas of fireorigin.

T'he master bedroom suite consisted of the bedroom, toilet rooni, shower/tub roon1 and walk in closet. The toilet roomsustained heavy smoke damage. The shower/tub room and walk in closet had moderate ssnoke damage.

The toilet room, shower/tub room and walk in closet were eliminated as areas of fire origin.

The bedroom area had heavy snioke, heat and flame darnage, There were two distinct and separate areas of fire origin. Onewas in the southwest c"oi^^o^ttl^^^wTere a p astic tote was sittiiig on top of a cabiriet. The other was on the north halfof the bed.

It was therefore determined that there were five separate and unconnected areas of fire origi

2011-0608 Redacted nIsa-2 Rev. 04/2412003 Page 4 of 5

I. The top of the countertop for the kitchen island.2, The treadmill in the family room.3, The chair in the foyer.4. The plastic tote in the southwest corner of the master bedroom.5. The north half of the bed in the master bedroom.

CAt1SE ®EERMtfVATi®N

This fire was determined to be incendiary.

It was caused by person(s) starting five separate and uncon.raect.ed fires within the i-esidence, The fres were caused asfollows:

1. The top of the countertop for the kitchen island. - Caused by the ignition of papers and a towel with an open flame.2. The treadmill in the family room. - Caused by the ignition of papers with an open flanle.3. The chair in the foyer. - Caused by the ignition of the clothes lying on the chair cushion with ar open flame.4; The plastic tote in the southwest corner of the master bedroom. - Caused by the ignition of papers in the plastic totewith an open flame.5. The north half of the bed in the master bedroom. - Caused by igniting tlie linerl on the bed with an open flame.

During the scene examination an unburned wood stick match with a green tip was located in the fam.ily room attached to theside of a shelf. Another wood stick match with a green tip was located among the debris from the master bedroom. Bothitems were collected as evidence.

Investigator Peterman deployed K-9 Lacey at the scene. The results will be documented in his report.

The following items were collected as fire evidence and will be taken to the SFM. Forensic Laboratory for analysis:Burned debris from the kitchen island countertop.Burned debris from the tread mill.Clotliing from the floor of the floor,Burned clothing from foyer chair.Burned cushion from foyer chair.Burned debris from southwest corner of master bedroom.

... ;CASE STATUS

Open The investigation will continue.

Frasik J. ReitmeierAssistant Fire Marstzal

2011-0608 Redacted MiB-2 Rev. 04/24/2003 Page 5 of 5

• c^¢ t^'r'^^G''^L ^^^ ^ <^ ^'^ C^^^' ^^^' ^-%-^=^-^^;/%%^^>^'^ ^ ^ ^,'2%C'^'^ -,:^;'^^^ 3

OHIO:STATE FIRE'NIARSNAL - i I6?E'a"nci EXPLC3S1{7N lN1fESTIGATit^N Bt1REAll.::INGtgENIREPOFtT`__ ::. ^.- ^ ^. _-- -------- --- - - ---- -- -r-- - _ - -- ----- ---

ncident ^ UG^t 27 Passenaer Car County # 48 LucasI iary Z^' NameNumber 2011-C^27 ypeOl lncendCity ST Toledo, Ohio ^ FDID- 48-017

t.ccation Franklin Street Zip------- ^

Occupied NoIncidentDate 2011/07/07 Time 0248 Day Thursday Arnt. S30;000A0 A 0 A 0

^ 0 ^ Q! F 0 F 0 1 Mot^ ^Grime Concealsnent Status Open C osedJ-

Vehicie License ^ late t}H VIN 1N4,^T 2APMake

3BN442446 Vehicle 2011Nissari Plats EUC 2b^ 5ate Yeat

- - -^DBA__ - - --- - ^

J vner ^L;yoils, L.C., 3r. SSN DOB

City 8T S ivania, Ohio 43560Address 5128 Tnlaud Drive zip Y

Home Phone Work Phone Cellular or Pager

- - E SSN DOB

SSN DOB

SSN DOB

SSN DOB

FirstLien JSecondLienJHobJec UTiknovm Holder

INSURANCE lNFOR.MATION, - --- -Property I Geico Insurance ! v^ Adjuster Phone

CoContents Adjuster Phone

Ins Co _._._r_-Private Inv

,_-------- _.-^ t(vJsigator`• Phone

Property .. Property Contents GontentsLoss f ^30,OOQ.OQ Covera e Loss

r hone 414-$82-1250 Date 2011/07/07 TimeY uP

0930uesti vania`"1 oice De1}tA enc

'on ^-^^18 E Time 0847 Report 2011/07/11 Evidence YES Photos Yes

Date _ DatePrimary ^ ' Assisting

Investi ^^ ato Frank J. Reitmeier lnvesti ator - -- -- _..._, _^.

Approved By A/C .l t^artf^y Date 2011/07i12 ^ Smoke Detector Not a Strticture

flOCIIMENTAR w&RiVlATION_weaft

Weat

d f onsClear And Warrn Q e don urban Declin%^zg

ConScene Yes Vehicle towed to Police Dept. Au^nter to Criminal Search Warrant

SecuredOther Agencies Police

On SceneAlaTn q lntrasion q Fire q Smoke Company --u ^ PhoneS stems ^Afam1 Alarm

Activation Commentstncident Other

Discovered BToledo Police Dept. - =Phone Con#act^-^-^^

lncident OtherRep

orted B Toledo Police Dept. - Pnone Contact

Forced Entr^y No Doors Secured None Locked Windows Secured All Closed

Electric , N/A In Gas NlA Gas InService Use Su I T e Use

Primary In Secondary In Water InHeaf Use Heat_ Use Heater Use

Date Scene2011!07108 7ime 1122

Released DepartmentDe arted r_ :t?s^11ce -

Previous Vehicle is connected to SFMIFEI Case 42011-0508,lncidents

i^ 3` /^ ^, / ,^ i ^ J ^^ f`/ l 1^ ^. 711, r

^^LL3 '

_ORiG11V ANALYSIS

- ---------------The ext: rior of the vehicle had ino visible signs of fire damag^ T_he truck of the vehicle contained a few personal items andno evZd o ^re ca'mage. e eng2ne compartment vvas intact with no evidciice of firedama

T'ne asp senger compartment had moderate smoke damage. There were a few personal items in the back seat area. The only

fire dama vas _on hasse_ ae^ r floor. Tlere was also a liquid stain on the driver's seat.

The front passenQer floor was determined to be the area of fire origin.

CAUSE DETERMINATION.^ ----- -------- -^ ___^. - - -

The cause of fire is incendiary.

The fire was caused by pouring or spraying an ignitable liquid on the front passenger floor of the vehicle and igniting it with

an open flame. The fire became oxvgen deprived and self-extinguished

CASE STATl1

Open This case will remain open pending additional investigation. ti

Frank J. ReitcneierAssistant Fire Marshal

2011-0627 (2) rV11a-2 Rev. 04i2412003 Page 4 of 4

"errone nt " clairri ofl't_3v-

DeBacker ing filed on- f tharequired documcnts: The

Continued from Page B1 magistrate said *rIat in anOct. 19, 2010,nlin;, ?vls,

hointed to the vac<irrcv.hyDeBacner "erroneouslyinr. Jolin Kasich nii Sopt. stated that thc guaidian's.Il anct sworn in as. jud-c, rel^ort zvas filed, whic`^ ! 1tv uda5 s lat er The va- hadn't heen."

her^ The first removal oc-z a3^ W^ as cteuted tliori^i,e 3 'vhinldp :i ;udgr, iurred un f=ebiu ,1F3', 2006.i,licljael Gouldtrrg i^ 4s ap tctio naonttys after sl etivasPoiaited tb a vacancy l, n cited fo7 f 31inig to filc the

.guardi^zzs xeport and cx-hett rvatuatj ori. Tc1Tn motre

^ t_^ l t,t: ^ ^r't,,^',1 ) E Inov^iI^ occurr i i112003.irnm

r, I 5'i ,, ,'&i^^. t^nu ^^;i ^,[r 2U{i7, t vo IrirlUreit320 11.

^i,)t,h, 71! tt;v,1` i,ll t.l_^t- PUf.e]211ergerS<aid

z F E.^ 1!tl+ u) ^ilcn,. i t, 111 tc ;,. attt rxev ?7a!l- -

tai^:^z^z^,^i. { ulri(^ ,i r^t1!i

fi^^,',^?., ^l,ts^ii .,nar^,,,^z I,^ a^n is.^^iu,f^E=eri1

^i._t^?,t'f^ ;i -(,t^itl. ^til',^' ^r1 ,t^ i-;^ .tlt 1iC'•:[ ,^.

t1w

`•liC'^^'iCf tlt.1]3I11 ail:)41,11^ P ltl'f11C.'; Y^i'<. ^il.ll)^ i!'.f'

3,^^ci:^iij^^i^^ c3i^3 ^i^^a iils.,;]^:^^ zd ^^'<?.ttu^.'_II i',^ ^, <n., i.

n, lUb .-{]nC'le,tf ^ 1i^':1£i^ i(i), .111 L,.'J?1, U:f•[i'.F^ 1bJ nPi'• `

^fti. tl7t^I;.li'h^•2 1C( 310 Ilti S•^3"! Li'lt' 1(,^'y; ,1t

':`^'U1^(i (;f f^is[ , i7 :i%-ii .f( ^:rf E'.O;I.ID^ •i;.C ,'^ i '^,'^^

t'„>>rt ti ^ a 1 n s^. ^1^, ^^•. ^i <^<i, .^,r ,t^it^^ ii^^l;ttt it.,, 1.tj ct f)(+ i,:t ll 1: r^t,zn, i1, 14 It z , m

cases rn i,iirnicipal,state, gu rdians,are hired 1 Vand fedcr,u ^ourt, atid con- lu.sing homes to rn il vtirxf^s to tieaplzoicted to medzcal decisions for#hcirreprc-ent indigent de.fe^- clients: He said tllose fees I-^dan.s, indic;iting that ber are paid by the nursing {svorkas sadsfactnry. iiorrie.

"I 3 r,gi et the srtuation, In onE ca.,e froin ivh ch ^nuvirlusly, hut I ihsoliitelp Ms. DeBackc.1 -,vasre-do tiot think it reflects on move.c:, ]ter successor wa5rtv work ethic, on rny paid '$5[)0 a year. ti' the

conianitinent to znv c3ienE5. ward h is an estate; theI've learhedfrorn it. I getlazvyer:can charge a l;er-appoiritcd by everysiztglcccntagf of e:xpe;zditures i^.judge on (;otninonPleas andincome.Cotnt. That doesn't hap- "Yoa.i sign an cath ofpertif you r.isn't sho%,v upguardianship.And that in-and d"o lnrork,Iv1s. cludes-to file atniQ inven.DeB<cker said. tory and timely and accu-

ln' each of M. rata reports, to file titnelyDeli4cker's:=fortner pro- and accurate accounts, lfhate cases;the dockets you can't do that you

ent entries sJiould kvitlydra;n1 fi-oni thee, reporting case and, the personmclingvdth should have a guardianz g, tbat she wiro is^ willing to fulfillDvedand a those respoizsibilities,"i in. In sev- i*e Pufierihi rgec said.

DeBacker t1'e;ssuP a lot of citationstI e orders [for missed fi13rig deadzeinst Ited, >lines]. There are very few

He said the court has,e inVolving 1 , 91 17 gu.rdiauships pend-umpetent' mg.I11e rn tgis- Coii,acY i om ovat:

u1L pa,-,c tostances, ;ti- or419-724-6058:

wo:^ -ACIn Offa e

^^lo. -li^ - ^ p

Allurm`11MI f';1mlBy TOtA TROY

Di fiL rda;::101^ i'ti7tt ^7r'i81 {,U112"t t^^P^

was , reii, ^ r. ad fi^; m 10 gu r^ r^ia ^^f

twek n ^oRS dnd

ri nired to^:,,^^it a per ^`}

Ix ho- :1.ad " I^^ Back_err] ludged, ntpf'Fetz't ioOtit tUt Ylieir^t£tzirs;<,.nd %m

as t:oi

c ;-o rd17^ `: ,} ^it[^ !uc

e ia7 a a,^,,:1

ropoY45 irlateCWtf ^',i

'uftt^i'^ ;<r ^aze tt^r,-fIdsald ' J'i:

che noEipat lisati gmeral etecticm1*.ov. ^ ;agait.sY I^c.pui^lrcan`s ]lsiiua Lanzin-er and KennetiaPhiilips: The seat iti now h"eld bviY1r. Lai:zingct tiviio r^ as >p-

See DEBA C#iER;;Pagp B4

-------------- ---- -------- - ----- - -- - ---------------- GCTC'BEG 2r..2G73.^

43566

43537

_ ...€^. . ..

43607

0/ 17^

. . . . .. ; . . ^^:. .i. ..

Y14s i ^f^v' Y"tt,1 y`

^ ^t^.F °J CR- ^ ^ ^ ^ !1' L.% /;^,..,^^Zlil^l.'3/ ^ //,E^.^^J^^ ,C.^.,'^/-^^4.^ .'^-^'1uc;^^^t^G^ L^, ,^^^^ C^r^^,'F ^ ^^ ^ ^^r^ ^..^.C 3,Li>^,a ,^ e^, ^^'r^^ ^ ^

'z/ /.,, l^ c_ Ez- ^

L;^c-c? €:1.^...

s^- 111^A..iU6 -'C:Gl7/'/^sd^^^.3 lr2,Z a ^..: L^.l.^^i^,.yL.^ CIt:J^A ^3'L.-'/' G.17C'^^_d ^^ ^^C KJ ^-Q.^^---.^G^^

^,^^^Z.^^'L!'^.-' U^Cr.%^^ ^'^"^G^-'2::^'. s" ^ /- ^/.+^^'^^C.G/..;^^ G.':^^^^ ..'^'^/. 3! .G^_- ^ ^4E'_ y; ,, r ` y ^ j

L:GfL't...i:.^'%"l_. E.,^^•^.3''^..K ^LY Le " L^,^/,J"'°^-L,C,^3 l i^/^ (^.^.r. -y ^ ^

r^/ ^ ...^3.?^^^^ ^^'f7t 1^ ta.!-/` ^^^^=^'''Zd s^ ^^^ P'^ G^C ^^ ^^ C^ ^L?^^l ^ ^t^^^j. !^_7>iJ c'^,^a -

7/^

^...°fr...,^^?:^^',

^ . .- -s-sttCTqVllH;^PAGE6--------------- --- -