33
| | CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Conference on Combustion in Switzerland 07.09.2017 – ETH Zurich Nicolas Noiray, Oliver Schulz CAPS Lab – D-MAVT – ETH 07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 1 New sequential combustion technologies for heavy-duty gas turbines

New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.

Conference on Combustion in Switzerland 07.09.2017 – ETH Zurich Nicolas Noiray, Oliver Schulz CAPS Lab – D-MAVT – ETH

07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 1

New sequential combustion technologies for heavy-duty gas turbines

Page 2: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.

Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines

07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 2

Ansaldo (formerly Alstom)

Sequential Combustion in H-Class gas turbines. More than 700 MW in combined cycle with approx. 62% plant efficiency

Increased operational flexibility Increased fuel flexibility

Lower emissions Higher CC efficiency

General Electrics

Adapted from US20100170216 A1 See also ASME paper GT2017-63998

See ASME paper GT2017-64790

Page 3: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.

Associated scientific challenges Technological characteristics §  Increased complexity of the combustors architecture and

of the operating concept §  Auto-ignition plays a key role §  1st and 2nd stage flames influence each others Corresponding scientific needs §  Adequate combustion models for accurate simulations §  Validation from experimental data §  Deep understanding of ignition, anchoring, blow-off

physics §  Modeling and control of combustor dynamics

07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 3

Page 4: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.

Related research at CAPS

07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 4

Experiments:

Generic sequential burner

Page 5: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.

Related research at CAPS

07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 5

Experiments:

1st stage 2nd stage

Page 6: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.

Related research at CAPS

07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 6

Compressible Reactive Large Eddy Simulations with autoignition chemistry

Page 7: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 7

Are these really autoignition fronts? Paper submitted to C&F:

Combustion regimes in sequential combustors: autoignition and flame

propagation at elevated temperature and pressure.

O. Schulz, N. Noiray

Page 8: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 8

Different types of 1D flames Autoignition front

Very lean condition: most reactive mixture fraction (shortest

autoignition delay)

Hot reactants propagating flame at stoichiometric

condition

Page 9: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 10

From flame propagation to autoignition: residence time

Conclusions from idealized 1D perfectly premixed situations can be very informative for the practical configurations (3D partially premixed and turbulent)

Critical paramters: •  Mixture fraction, •  Inlet velocity, •  Mixture residence time

upfront of the flame

Page 10: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 11

Sequential Combustor Configuration

Operating pressure 1 and 10 bar Inlet temperature 1350 and 1450 K

4

Page 11: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 6

Numercial Methods

•  LES with AVBP

•  12 millions mesh cells

•  Dynamic Thickened Flame (DTF) model

•  Analytically Reduced Chemistry

(ARC) scheme

•  Wall heat loss

(Gicquel et al. Comptes Rendus – Mec., 2011)

(Colin et al. Phys. Fluids, 2000)

5

(Schulz et al. Proc. Combust. Inst. 2016) (Jaravel et al. Proc. Combust. Inst. 2016) (Pepiot and Pitsch Combust. Flame, 2008)

Page 12: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 13

Autoignition versus propagation at 10 Bar

10 Bar “hot” inlet à Autoignition dominates

10 Bar “cold” inlet à Propagation dominates

Page 13: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 14

Ignition of sequential combustor

Conditions •  Operating pressure 10bar •  Simulated time 43ms •  1st stage power 300kW •  2nd stage power 300kW •  2nd stage global phi 0.76 •  2nd stage inlet T 1350K

Page 14: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 15

Ignition of sequential combustor

Conditions •  Operating pressure 1bar •  Simulated time 90ms •  1st stage power 30kW •  2nd stage power 30kW •  2nd stage global phi 0.76 •  2nd stage inlet T 1450K

Autoignition driven transient evolving to propagating flame

Page 15: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 16

Flame stabilisation mechanism of a reactive jet in crossflow Paper submitted to C&F:

Large eddy simulation of a reactive jet in hot vitiated crossflow: flame stabilisation

mechanism. O. Schulz, E. Piccoli, A. Felden,

G. Staffelbach, N. Noiray

Page 16: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 17

Premixed jet flame behavior in a hot vitiated crossflow of lean combustion products Wagner, Renfro, Cetegen, Combustion and Flame 176 (2017),

Conclusions/Outlook -  Windward flame anchoring closer to the

crossflow suggests that auto-ignition was most likely the dominant mechanism

-  Further characterization of out-of- plane

motion may be necessary to interpret principal strain rate behavior along the windward flame edge.

Page 17: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 18

Detailed experimental data available

PIV

PLIF

Velocity magnitude Vorticity

LIF CH2O LIF OH Heat release location deduced

from LIF

Page 18: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 19

3-d large eddy simulation

Page 19: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 20

Comparison with experiments

Page 20: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 21

Comparison with experiments

Page 21: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 22

Instantaneous snapshot from LES

Page 22: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 23

Windward flame stabilisation due to autoignition 1. Autoignition at most reactive

mixture fraction Z_mr

2. Heat transfer to higher Z

Page 23: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 24

3-D flame dynamics

Page 24: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 25

3-d flame vortex interaction

Page 25: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 26

Nonlinear response of auto-ignition flames to entropy waves

Combustion & Flame paper under revision: O. Schulz, N. Noiray

Page 26: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.

The sound of flames

07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 27

Gas turbine combustors

Boilers, Industrial furnaces

Power generation

Liquid Rocket Propellant

Solid Rocket Propellant

Aerospace

Afterburners

Aeronautics

Aero-engine combustors

Resonant feedback loop

Chamber acoustics

Reactive flow dynamics

p′u′

Q̇′

Pulsations-induced damages

Frequency

Time

Dynamic pressure

Frequency

Time

Structural vibrations

Page 27: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 28

Flame Response to Temperature Fluctuations

1350 K 1450 K

Gain 1.7 Gain 3.4

Page 28: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 29

Flame Response to Temperature Fluctuations

Page 29: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 30

Decrease of inlet temperature

1450 K

1350 K

Page 30: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 31

0-D Autoignition Delays (CANTERA)

1450 K

1350 K

Page 31: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 32

Non-linear flame response to T fluctuations

Page 32: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.

§  Significant progress over the last years in terms of simulations and modeling capabilities

§  Research effort to be pursued in topics like

§  Auto-ignition in turbulent environment at relevant conditions, §  Analytically Reduced Chemistry, §  Combustion modelling for partially premixed flames, §  Combustor dynamics associated with entropy waves §  Passive and active control of combustor dynamics

§  Strong need for experimental data to develop and validate these combustion models

07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 33

Conclusions and Outlook

Page 33: New sequential combustion technologies for heavy …...CAPS Combus+on and Acous+cs for Power Systems Lab. Sequential combustors in modern gas turbines Nicolas Noiray 07/09/17 2 Ansaldo

| |

CAPSCombus+onandAcous+csforPowerSystemsLab.07/09/17 Nicolas Noiray 34

Acknowledgement