Upload
melanielco
View
222
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
1/33
Sandra R. Robinson, VSB #31885Robinson Law & Consulting Firm, P.C.P.O. Box 503Richmond, Virginia 23218(804) 928-5458(804) 303-3499 [fax]Counsel for Debtor
UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURTEASTERN DISTRICT OF VIRGINIA
Richmond Division
In re: Chapter 11United States National Slavery Museum Case No. 11-36013-DOTaka U.S. National Slavery Museum
REORGANIZATION PLAN
SUMMARY OF PLAN
The Plan provides for the Debtor to reinstate its fundraising efforts to provide for the
public display of its artifacts and other historical items and documents in its own building on its
own land. After paying all the pre-petition debts and the administrative expenses, including such
things as judgments, and after reserving for additional expenditures, the Debtor commits its net
operating income to the payment of all filed Claims. The Claims will be paid as follows:
Secured Claim of Pei Partnership shall be paid to the extent of its judgment at the time of
entry, in full within four years after receiving its first payment, while receiving interest
payments.
Secured Claim of City of Fredericksburg shall be paid in full within four years after
receiving its first payment. This claim is impaired.
General Unsecured Claims held by any Person other than an Insider shall be paid in the full
amount of the Allowed Claims, receiving four yearly distributions on the first day of each
quarter, beginning October 1, 2012.
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 1 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
2/33
2
Unsecured Claims held by Insiders shall be paid after all other Allowed Claims have been
paid in full.
Other alternatives available to the Debtor or which might be imposed upon the Debtor by
certain of their secured creditors would not provide for an orderly reorganization of the Debtor in
a manner that would maximize its value for the benefit of all creditors. The liquidation
alternatives analyzed by the Debtor demonstrate that a complete return to all creditors is possible
only if (1) the Debtor is able to generate revenue consistent with the minimum annual level of
donations it received prepetition and are utilized in connection with the further development of
the Property, (2) the Debtor restructure its indebtedness and (3) the Debtor utilize its net
operating income to repay their indebtedness.
The Debtors board of directors is committed to the success of the Debtor. As evidence of their
commitment to the Plan and the success of the Debtors reorganization, the Insiders have agreed
that they will accept no payment, on account of any Unsecured Claim, until all other Allowed
Claims have been paid in full.
The Debtor asks that you carefully consider this Plan and cast a ballot in favor of the Plan.
ARTICLE I
Defined Terms
Any term in the Disclosure Statement or Plan that is defined in 101, 102 or 1101 of
the Bankruptcy Code shall have the meaning assigned therein. The following terms, where they
are used in the Disclosure Statement and in the Plan, shall have the meanings hereinafter
assigned.
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 2 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
3/33
3
1. Administrative Bar Date: The date by which all Persons asserting
Administrative Expense Claims arising before the Effective Date must have filed such claim, as
may be fixed by Order of the Bankruptcy Court.
2. Administrative Expense Claim(s): Any right to payment for the costs and
expenses of this Case, including: (a) the actual, necessary costs and expenses of preserving the
Debtors estate and operating the businesses of the Debtor, (b) all allowances of compensation
and reimbursement of costs and expenses under 330 or 502 of the Bankruptcy Code, or (c) or
may be otherwise authorized by an Order of the Court. Except for the filing fee required to
commence this Case, administrative expense claim(s) shall be limited to debts and expenses that
have been incurred post-petition.
3. Allowed: Concerning a claim against or an equity security interest in any of the
Debtor, such a claim or interest to the extent that (a) a proof of claim or interest was timely filed
and to which no objection has been filed, or (b) a proof of claim was deemed filed pursuant to
1111 (a) of the Bankruptcy Code, and such claim was not listed by any of the Debtor as disputed,
contingent or unliquidated in its list of creditors filed with the Court pursuant to Bankruptcy
Code 521 (a)(1), or (c) a proof of claim, to which an objection has been filed, or other claim or
equity security interest, which is allowed by an Order of the Court.
4. Bankruptcy Code and/or Code: Title 11, United States Code, as in effect on the
Filing Date, and all amendments thereto which apply to this Case.
5. Bankruptcy Claim(s): Any and all actions, claims, rights, defenses, third-party
claims, cross-claims, counterclaims, suits, causes of action, chooses in action, controversies,
agreements, promises, rights to legal remedies, rights to equitable remedies, and rights to
payment, whether known, unknown, which the Trustee, a debtor-in-possession, the bankruptcy
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 3 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
4/33
4
estate or other appropriate party in interest may assert under 502, 510, 522(f), 522(h), 542,
543, 544, 545, 547, 548, 549, 550, 551, 553 and 724(a) of the Bankruptcy Code or otherwise
including, without limitation, the bankruptcy estates rights of setoff, recoupment, contribution,
reimbursement, subrogation or indemnity (as those terms are defined by the non-bankruptcy law
of any relevant jurisdiction) and any other indirect claim of any kind whatsoever, whenever and
wherever arising or asserted.
6. Business Day: Any day other than a Saturday, Sunday, or another day on which
the banking institutions in Richmond, Virginia are required or authorized to close by law or
executive order.
7. Case: The case for the reorganization of U.S. National Slavery Museum
commenced by the filing of a voluntary petition under Chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code, and
is now pending in the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Eastern District of Virginia,
Richmond Division, and captioned as above.
8. Chapter 7: Sections 701, et seq., Title 11, United States Code, as in effect on the
Filing Date, and those amendments thereto which apply to this Case.
9. Chapter 11: Sections 1101, et seq., Title 11, United States Code, as in effect on
the Filling Date, and those amendments thereto which apply to this Case.
10. Claim(s): Any right to payment from any of the Debtor, whether or not such right
is reduced judgment, liquidated, unliquidated, fixed, contingent, matured, unmatured, disputed,
undisputed, legal, equitable, secured or unsecured, known or unknown; or any right to an
equitable remedy for breach of performance if such breach gives rise to a right of payment from
any of the Debtor, whether or not such right to an equitable remedy is reduced to judgment,
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 4 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
5/33
5
fixed, contingent, matured, unmatured, disputed, undisputed, secured or unsecured, known or
unknown.
11. Commencement Date: September 21, 2011.
12. Collateral: Real and/or personal property (a) securing a Claim against the Debtor
and/or (b) encumbered by a valid lien.
13. Confirmation or Confirmation of the Plan: The date on which an Order
confirming the Plan becomes Final.
14. Confirmation Date: The date the Confirmation Order becomes Final.
15. Confirmation Order: The Final Order entered by the Court confirming the Plan.
16. Consummation of the Plan: The accomplishment of all things contained or
provided for in this Plan, and the entry of an order dismissing the case.
16. Court and/or Bankruptcy Court: The United States Bankruptcy Court of the
Eastern District of Virginia, Richmond Division, presiding in this Case.
17. Debtor: The Debtor in possession in this Case, namely U.S. National Slavery
Museum.
18. Disclosure Statement: The Disclosure Statement that relates to the Plan, as such
Disclosure Statement may be amended, modified, or supplemented (including all exhibits and
schedules annexed thereto or referenced herein).
19. Effective Date: The effective date of this Plan, as effective date is used in
Chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code, shall be the first (lst) Business Day on or after the
Confirmation Date on which (i) no stay of the Confirmation Order is in effect and (ii) all
conditions to the effectiveness of the Plan have been satisfied or waived.
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 5 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
6/33
6
20. Estate Property: All property and interests in property belonging to the Debtor
as of the Filing Date pursuant to Bankruptcy Code 541 (a); all Bankruptcy Claims, and, the
proceeds of such rights and actions. This term excludes property excluded from the Estate
pursuant to Bankruptcy Code 541(a) (6) and (c) (2).
21. Estates: The estates created in this Case in accordance with 541 of the
Bankruptcy Code.
22. Executory Contract(s): All contracts, subject to the provisions of Bankruptcy
Code 365 for which there is on-going performance due, prepetition, by all parties.
23. Event of Default: Failure of Plan payments as defined in Article V.
24. Fee Claim: A claim for compensation, indemnification or reimbursement of
expenses pursuant to 327, 328, 330, 331 or 503(b) of the Bankruptcy Code in connection with
this Case.
25. Filed: In reference to a document or pleading which must be filed with the
Court.
26. Filing Date: September 21, 2011, the date on which this Case was filed with the
Court.
27. Final: In reference to an order, shall mean an order of a court that has not been
reversed, modified, amended or stayed, and the time for appeal or to seek review or certiorari or
rehearing thereof, has expired and as to which no appeal, review or rehearing is pending, and has
become conclusive of all matters adjudicated thereby and is in full force and effect.
28. Hearing: The date on which an actual hearing before the Court is first conducted.
29. Holder: The owner of any Claim or interest.
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 6 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
7/33
7
30. Impaired: Treatment under the Plan that impairs a classified claim or interest, or
a class of claims or interest, in accordance with 1124 of the Bankruptcy Code.
31. Insiders: Insiders of any of the Debtor as such term is defined in 101(31) of the
Bankruptcy Code. Insiders include current and/or former officers, directors, and persons in
control of the Debtor.
32. IRS: The Internal Revenue Service.
33. Loan Documents: All of the documents evidencing, securing, guarantying or
otherwise relating to the obligations of any of the Debtor.
34. Notice Cure Period: Thirty days from delivery of written notice from a creditor
or the United States Trustee to the Debtor of the failure of payment under the Plan.
35. Order: An Order entered by the Bankruptcy Court.
36. Person(s): Any individual, corporation, partnership, association, limited liability
company, organization, joint stock company, joint venture, governmental unit or any political
subdivision thereof, interest holders, or any other entity.
37. Petition Date: September 21, 2011, the date this Case was filed with the Court.
38. Plan or Plan of Reorganization: The Debtor Plan of Reorganization dated
February 17, 2012 as the same may be amended or modified from time to time in accordance
with the provisions of the Bankruptcy Code and the terms hereof.
39. Priority or Priority Claim(s): The portion of an Allowed claim that is not a
Secured claim, and that is entitled to priority under Bankruptcy Code 507(a).
40. Proof of Claim(s): Claims filed in accordance with 501 of the Bankruptcy
Code.
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 7 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
8/33
8
41. Quarterly Distribution Date: The first Business Day of the month in each
calendar quarter after the Effective Date; provided however, that if the Effective Date is within
forty-five (45) days of the end of a calendar quarter, the First Quarterly Distribution Date will be
the first Business Day of the month following the end of the first calendar quarter after the
calendar quarter in which the Effective Date falls.
42. Debtor: U.S. National Slavery Museum as it exists on or after the Effective Date
(or any other of the Debtor listed on Exhibit A as might be filed prior the Effective Date).
43. Secured or Secured Claim(s): An Allowed claim secured by a lien, security
interest or other charge against or interest in Property in which any Debtor has an interest, which
interest was perfected as required by applicable non-bankruptcy law, or which is subject to setoff
under 553 of the Bankruptcy Code. A claim is an Allowed Secured Claim to the extent of, but
not exceeding, the value (determined pursuant to 506 of the Bankruptcy Code) of the interest of
the holder of such claim in the debtors interest in such Property, or the extent of the amount
subject to setoff. An Allowed Secured Claim includes interest, fees, costs and charges only to the
extent they may be allowed by 506(b) of the Bankruptcy Code.
44. Tax Claim: Claim under 507(a) 8 of the Code.
45. Unexpired Lease: A lease between the Debtor and a third party, for either real or
personal property, which is unexpired and was not terminated prior to the Filing Date.
46. Unsecured or Unsecured Claim(s): An Allowed claim which is not an
Administrative Expense, nor a Priority Claim, nor a Secured Claim.
ARTICLE II
General Provisions
The following general provisions apply to this Plan:
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 8 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
9/33
9
1. Claims: Various types of claims are defined in this Plan. The Plan is
intended to deal with all claims against the debtor of whatever character, whether or not
contingent or liquidated and whether or not allowed by the Code pursuant to 11 502(a).
However, only those claims allowed pursuant to 502(a) will receive treatment afforded by the
Plan in Article III.
2. Preserved liens: to the extent required under 1124(2) to preserve the rights of a
secured creditor, the lien or encumbrance of that creditor shall, to the extent valid, be preserved
or with otherwise be satisfied by cash payment to the amount of the secured debt existing on the
Petition date.
3. Time for filing claims: all creditors whose claims are scheduled as disputed,
unliquidated or subject to setoff in the Debtors schedules must file such claims by the bar date
established by the Court in order to be treated under the Plan.
4. Modification of the Plan: the Plan may be modified upon application by the
Debtor or corrected prior to Confirmation without notice and hearing and without additional
disclosure pursuant to 1125 of the Code, provided that notice is given to any creditor committee
that may be established during this case, the committee does not object to the modification or
correction and the Court finds that such modification or correction does not materially or
adversely affect any creditor or class of creditors. After confirmation of the Plan, the Debtor
may, with the approval of the Court and as long as it does not materially and adversely affect the
interest of a class of creditors, remedy any defect or omission, or reconcile any inconsistencies in
the Plan or in the Confirmation Order, as may be necessary to carry out the purpose and effect of
the Plan.
ARTICLE III
Division and Treatment of Claims and Interests
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 9 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
10/33
10
The Debtor expects to be fully operational by October 1, 2012. For purposes of this
organization, fully operational includes, but is not limited to, having the statutory authority to
engage in fundraising, to successfully solicit and collect donations, and engage in day-to-day
administration and implementation of its design and construction plans to display its historical
documents and artifacts for view to the public, and in a facility upon land it owns.
Based on its last full year of active operations, the Debtor conservatively projects that in
the first 12 months of this Plan, it will raise approximately $900,000.00 in revenue. Debtor
anticipates that there will be a period of lag time after the Debtor regains its authority to engage
fundraising and the first donations it will receive. Debtor conservatively estimates a lag time of
90 days between authorization and the actual receipt of a donation. To accommodate the
anticipated lag time in receipt of donations, the Debtors plan does not call for payment to any
creditor prior to October 1, 2012, at which time the Debtor will begin to make quarterly
distribution payments thirty (30) calendar days after such date and on the Business day of each
quarter thereafter.
Class 1: Secured Claims by Statute
Class 1 consists of the delinquent real estate taxes owed to the City of Fredericksburg,
Virginia for real estate taxes, penalty and interests as provided by law. Said debt is secured by
state and local law by the Debtors real property.
On the first day of each quarter, beginning October 1, 2012, Debtor shall pay the City of
Fredericksburg $15,000.00 toward the payment of the full payment of its claim, as determined at
the date of filing or as modified by express agreement of the parties.
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 10 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
11/33
11
During the effective period of this reorganization plan, Debtor shall take all reasonable
steps to remain current in the payment of its real estate taxes including, if necessary, entering
into an installment payment arrangement with the City of Fredericksburg to avoid default.
Class 2: Secured Claims by Judgments
Class 2 consists of the Debtors judgment creditors. Except as otherwise provided in the
Plan, all holders of claims in this class shall retain their principle claim, but shall not be entitled
to receive any interest, whether pre-judgment or post-judgment. Class 2 consists of default
judgment owed to Pei Partnership Architects LLP (Pei Partnership). On the first day of each
quarter, beginning October 1, 2012, Debtor shall pay Pei Partnership the first of equal
installments toward the payment of the full payment of its claim within four years, or as
subsequently modified by express agreement of the parties.
Class 2 is impaired.
Class 3: Unsecured Claims
Class 3 consists of the all Allowed Unsecured Claims not otherwise treated in another
class.
Class 3 claims shall be satisfied as follows: on or before four years from the Effective
Date, Debtor shall pay the full balance of all Allowed Unsecured Claims in Class 3.
Objections to Classification
Any holder of a Claim or interest in Classes 1 through 3 that fails to object in writing to
the classification provided for in this Plan and to file such objection with the Court and to serve
the same upon counsel for the Debtor at least five (5) business days prior to the date first set by
the Court for the Confirmation Hearing shall be deemed to have accepted the classification and
to be bound by it.
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 11 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
12/33
12
ARTICLE IV
Description of the Plan of Reorganization
A. TREATMENT OF CLAIMS
The principal provisions of the Plan are summarized below. The Plan provides for three
(3) classes of claims and/or interests as follows:
1. Class One Secured Claim(s) created by statute (City of Fredericksburg)
Class One consists of the outstanding balance, as of Confirmation, of the City of
Fredericksburgs Claim arising from the non-payment of real estate taxes, as provided by statute.
As provided in 1129 of the Bankruptcy Code, the City of Fredericksburg shall retain its
statutory lien securing its Claim whether the property subject to such liens is retained by the
Debtor or transferred to another entity, to the extent of the allowed amount of such claim, as of
the Effective Date of the Plan, of at least the value of the City of Fredericksburgs interest in the
estate's interest in such property. As long as the Debtor is not in default on obligations to the
City of Fredericksburg under the Plan, the City of Fredericksburg shall provide reasonable
cooperation that would customarily be expected of a secured creditor in connection with a
project like the Museum. Beginning on the Effective Date, interest will accrue on the City of
Fredericksburgs Claim at the rate required by law.
1. Class TwoSecured Claim created by judgment (Pei Partnership)
Class Two consists of the outstanding balance, as of Confirmation, of Pei Partnerships
secured Claim arising from the entry of default judgment against the Debtor in Pei Partnerships
favor, excluding all pre and post-petition interest as asserted by Pei Partnership. Payment of the
Pei Partnership secured Claim will be secured as provided by law unless otherwise specifically
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 12 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
13/33
13
modified in the Plan. As long as the Debtor is not in default on obligations to Pei Partnership
under the Plan, Pei Partnership shall provide reasonable cooperation that would customarily be
expected of a secured creditor in connection with a project like the Museum.
2. Class ThreeGeneral Unsecured Claims (If Applicable)
Class Three consists of the all Allowed Unsecured Claims not otherwise treated in
another class. No interest will accrue on these claims, and only should they be deemed allowable
by Order of this Court will these claims be satisfied as follows: Debtor shall pay 100% of all
allowed unsecured claim in equal installments on each Quarterly Distribution Date starting in the
fourth year of distribution under the Plan.
ARTICLE V
Plan Implementation and Financial Information
The funding of the Plan is premised on the reinstatement of Debtors authority to re-
engage its fundraising activities, as well as receiving charitable donations to generate the cash
flow needed to sufficiently perform under the Plan. The Debtor is committed to making its best
effort to broaden its donor base and to utilize lower-cost options to effectuate fundraising. The
Debtor is optimistic that its fundraising efforts will be sufficient to perform under the Plan as
Debtor has been approached by several volunteers and potential contributors since the Petition
Date. Debtor has conservatively planned on a six-month lag in receipt of donations from the
date on which it is reauthorized to engage fundraising. The Debtor conservatively estimates
that its first full year of fundraising will generate approximately $900,000.00, and that
subsequent years revenue will increase by fifty (50) percent.
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 13 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
14/33
14
ARTICLE VI
Effects of Confirmation
In addition to the effects prescribed by 11 U.S.C. 1141, the confirmation of this Plan
shall bind the Debtor and all holders of claims and interest, without regard as to whether they
filed a proof of claim, whether they accept this Plan, and without regard as to whether their
respective claim or interest is impaired or allowed under this Plan.
Confirmation of this Plan shall also cure all defaults under any agreement between the
Debtor and a third party, which may include third-party guarantees. Further, only upon the
Event of Default by the Debtor shall any creditor whose claim(s) are provided herein be
authorized to pursue third parties or non-Debtor collateral, if such is the case.
Confirmation of this Plan shall also discharge Debtor of all claims, liens or encumbrances
against the Debtor, the Debtors assets and properties, and Estate Property with respect to debts,
claims, liens and interests, whether known or known, direct or indirect, which any creditor or
interest holder of the Debtor ever had, now or hereafter can, shall or may have, or succeed to,
arising from, relating to, or in connection with, whether directly or indirectly, the Case and the
provisions of this Plan, which arose at any time prior to the Effective Date. On the Effective
Date, as to every discharged claim and interest, any holder of such claim or interest shall be
precluded from asserting against the Debtor, either before or after reorganization, or against its
assets, properties, or Estate Property, any other or further claim or interest based upon any
document, instrument, act, omission, transaction or other activity of any kind or nature that
occurred before the Effective Date.
In accordance with the Bankruptcy Code, the discharge provided by 524 and 1141,
inter alia, acts as an injunction against the commencement or continuation of any action,
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 14 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
15/33
15
employment of process or act to collect, offset, enforce or recover the claims discharged hereby,
or continue any action or proceeding to foreclosure or otherwise enforce any lien, claim,
encumbrance, mortgage, security agreement, deed of trust, assignment or other instrument, the
obligation or claim for which, has been discharged and provided for in the Plan and the
Confirmation Order, whether against the Debtor or a non-Debtor third party. Specifically, any
defaults as of the Filing Date, including liability of third parties for obligations of the Debtor
whether or not reduced to judgment, are cured as of Confirmation and rights of creditors are
subject to the terms of this Plan. Creditors shall retain all rights, remedies and collateral,
including rights against guarantors except as cured by the provisions herein, which shall be
enforceable any third party only if the Debtor defaults on its obligations under this Plan.
Except as otherwise specifically provided in or contemplated by the Plan or in any
contract or other document created in connection with the Plan, each holder of any claim
(secured or unsecured), judgment, personal property or ad valorem tax, mechanics or similar
lien , regardless of whether such claim is Allowed shall, on or immediately before the Effective
Date and regardless of whether such Claim has been scheduled or proof of such Claim has been
filed, be deemed released and all right, title and interest in such underlying property shall revert
or be transferred to the Debtor free and clear of all Claims and interest, including but not limited
to, liens, pledges, encumbrances and/or security interests of any kind.
ARTICLE VII
Treatment of Property
Upon Confirmation, the Debtor will retain all Estate Property in accordance with
Bankruptcy Code 1123(a)(5)(A), subject to all liens of record as of the Filing Date (the
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 15 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
16/33
16
validity, extent and priority of which are subject to determination by the Court), which shall
secure to holder of such liens only payments due under this Plan.
ARTICLE VIII
Alternatives to the Plan
A. BEST INTEREST OF DEBTORS CREDITORS
The Debtor has proposed a Plan which provides for payment over time to its creditors.
The Debtor believes that its Plan provides for the greatest possible recovery to its creditors and
while preserving the estate and the Debtors mission.
B. CHAPTER 7 LIQUIDATION ANALYSIS (Hypothetical)
Section 1129(a)(7)(A)(ii) of the Bankruptcy Code requires that holders of claims that are
impaired under the Plan who do not vote for the Plan must receive property under the Plan
worth, as of the effective date, at least as much as the amount they would receive if the Debtor
liquidated in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy. Because the payment schedule elected by the Debtor in
this Chapter 11 Plan provides a full payout (exclusive of some interest charges) to creditors, the
Debtor believe that the distribution under their Plan is preferable to what creditors would receive
if the Debtor estates were liquidated under Chapter 7 because of the substantial discounting that
is foreseeable in the event of a fire sale of Debtors property.
In a hypothetical Chapter 7, if the property has equity, the Chapter 7 Trustee would first
reduce the property of the estate to money (the Proceeds). The first question a Trustee would
ask is whether there is sufficient equity in the property to justify his or her administration of the
property. In making a decision not to abandon the property and instead to administer it, the
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 16 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
17/33
17
Trustee would have to be confident that he or she could obtain more than the value of the
Secured Claims after paying the operating costs and costs of sale.
A Chapter 7 Trustee is charged under Bankruptcy Code 704(1) to perform his or her
duties expeditiously. If the Trustee concludes that he or she should liquidate rather than abandon
the property, a Trustee would be under a duty to liquidate the property expeditiously. Once the
estate property is liquidated, the Trustee would then be required to pay the Proceeds in the order
outlined below. If the Proceeds were insufficient to satisfy each category of claims, the Proceeds
would be shared pro rata by the claimants in that category:
1. The costs of preserving and liquidating the assets;
2. Allowed claims secured by the property that was sold, including principal and
accrued interest when the value of the collateral exceeds the amount of the Secured Claim. To
the extent that a Secured Creditor is not paid in full from the sale of its collateral, the balance of
the claim would be an Unsecured Claim;
3. The costs and expenses of the Chapter 7 proceeding. These costs and expenses
may include: a. paying professionals to file contested matters with the Court, to obtain required
approval, to prepare and file income tax returns, to make reports to governmental agencies and
to perform other acts for which their employment has been approved;
b. paying tax liabilities incurred by the estates; and
c. paying the expenses and fees of the Chapter 7 trustee;
4. Unpaid expenses incurred by the Debtor during the Chapter 11 cases, including:
a. paying professionals to file contested matters with the Court, to obtain required
approvals, to prepare and file income tax returns, to make reports to governmental agencies and
to perform other acts for which their employment has been approved;
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 17 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
18/33
18
b. paying tax liabilities incurred by the estates, and
c. compensation for the Court-approved fees of attorneys and other professionals;
5. Priority Claims; and
6. Unsecured Claims, including the Unsecured Claims arising from the rejection of the
Debtors executory contracts and unexpired leases of business personal property.
The Debtor believes that liquidation in a Chapter 7 would result in merely a percentage
payout of Secured Claims and no distribution to unsecured creditors. The Debtor also believe
that this Plan provides a return to creditors far in excess of that which such creditor would
receive were the Debtor liquidated under Chapter 7 of the Bankruptcy Code.
ARTICLE IX
Material Post-petition Events
The Debtor has acquired professionals who have committed a substantial amount of time
and effort in analyzing restructuring alternatives for the Debtor. These efforts have included
discussions and negotiations with certain secured creditors of the Debtor, and foretell Debtors
success in reorganizing with slight modifications to the many engineering and architectural
drawings that Debtor has already paid, collectively, millions of dollars to obtain. Debtor has
also initiated the process by which it will regain its fundraising authority.
ARTICLE X
Notices
When notice is required under this Plan, it shall be in writing and shall be deemed to have
been given by the sending party and received by the receiving party when such notice or request
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 18 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
19/33
19
shall have been hand delivered to the person designated below for the receiving party, one (1)
business day after transmission by facsimile evidenced by electronic receipt and after
transmission by electronic mail (email) evidenced by electronic receipt, or three (3) calendar
days after such notice shall have been posted in the certified mail of the United States, postage
pre-paid, return receipt requested and addressed to the party designated below for such receiving
party.
Any notice required by the Plan, or given by any creditor or party in interest concerning
the Plan, shall be to all of the following:
U.S. National Slavery Museumc/o Lawrence Douglas Wilder, ChairmanPost Office Box 1354Richmond, Virginia 23218Telephone: (804) 828-8520
Sandra R. Robinson, EsquireRobinson Law & Consulting Firm, P.C.Post Office Box 503Richmond, VA 23218Telephone: (804) 928-5458Facsimile: (804) 303-3499
Robert B. Van Arsdale, EsquireOffice of the United States Trustee701 East Broad Street, Suite 4304Richmond, VA 23219Telephone: (804) 771-2310Facsimile: (804) 771-2330
A change of address or person designated to receive notice may be affective only by written
notice provided to all persons designated above at least five (5) business days prior to the
effective date of the change.
Covenants
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 19 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
20/33
20
Until such time as all of the payments contemplated to be made by the Plan have been
made, the Debtor covenants as follows:
1. That it will preserve and maintain its corporate existence.
2. That it will preserve and maintain its real and personal property assets.
3. That it will maintain and cause to be maintained a system of accounting
established and administered in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles then in
effect.
ARTICLE XI
U.S. Trustee Fees
Pursuant to Bankruptcy Code 1129(a)(12), quarterly fees due to the U.S. Trustee will be
paid on each quarter as set forth by statute and continue to be paid pursuant to this schedule until
this case is closed.
ARTICLE XII
Event of Default for Non-Taxing Authority Creditors and Default Remedies
As to any creditor and party in interest, an Event of Default under the Plan shall occur
upon the failure of the Debtor to make any payment or distribution required under the Plan, and
which remains uncorrected after the period of time in which to cure the failure has fully expired.
The cure period shall be the 30 day period from which the U.S. Trustee receives written notice
from a creditor of the Debtors failure to pay as required by the Plan.
ARTICLE XIII
Event of Default for Taxing Authorities
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 20 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
21/33
21
As to any taxing authority, an Event of Default under the Plan shall occur upon the
Debtor to pay any currently accruing tax liability or file any required tax return, unless the
Debtor has expressly made alternative arrangements for paying and/or filing and is in
compliance with the alternative arrangements made, and which remains uncorrected after the
period of time in which to cure the failure has fully expired. The cure period shall be the 30 day
period from which the Debtor receives written notice from the taxing authority of a Debtors
failure to pay or file as required.
ARTICLE XIV
Cure of Defaults
The Debtor expressly reserves the right to cure an Event of Default by the Debtors
tender of any missed payment or distribution complained of within the Notice Cure Period or by
an agreement reached with the party providing written notice of a default. Unless otherwise
agreed, such cure must be made within the term of the Notice Cure Period.
ARTICLE XV
Corporate Structure
The officers and directors of the Reorganized Debtor shall remain the same as they were
on Filing Date.
ARTICLE XVI
Confirmation Process
A. CONFIRMATION HEARING
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 21 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
22/33
22
The Bankruptcy Code requires the Court, after notice, to hold a hearing to determine
whether a Plan of reorganization should be confirmed. A hearing on Confirmation of the Plan
will be scheduled and notice thereof will be circulated in accordance with the Bankruptcy Code
and Bankruptcy Rules. The hearing may be adjourned from time to time by the Court without
further notice except for an announcement made at the hearing.
B. OBJECTIONS TO CONFIRMATION
All objections to confirmation of the Plan will be heard at the Confirmation hearing.
Bankruptcy Rule 9014 governs objections to confirmation of the Plan. Any objection to
confirmation of the Plan must be made in writing, filed with the Court and served upon the
following parties within seven (7) business days before the hearing on Confirmation:
Sandra R. Robinson, EsquireRobinson Law & Consulting Firm, P.C.Post Office Box 503Richmond, Virginia 23218Counsel for the Debtor
Robert B. Van Arsdale, EsquireOffice of the United States Trustee701 East Broad Street, Suite 4304Richmond, Virginia 23219Assistant United States Trustee
An objection to confirmation must be timely filed and served or it will not be considered by
the Court.
C. REQUIREMENTS FOR CONFIRMATION
At the confirmation hearing, the Court must determine whether the Plan meets the
requirements for confirmation set forth in 1129(a) of the Bankruptcy Code. The Debtor
believes that the Plan satisfies all the statutory requirements of Chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy
Code, with exception to 8(b) as set forth below. The requirements of 1129(a) are as follows:
(l) The Plan complies with the applicable provisions of the Bankruptcy Code.
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 22 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
23/33
23
(2) The proponent of the Plan complies with the applicable provisions of the
Bankruptcy Code.
(3) The Plan has been proposed in good faith and not by any means forbidden by law.
(4) Any payment made or to be made by the proponent, the Debtor, or a person
issuing securities or acquiring property under the Plan, for services or costs and expenses in or in
connection with the case, or in connection with the Plan and incident to the case, has been
approved by or is subject to the approval of the Court as reasonable.
(5) (A) (i) the proponent of the Plan has disclosed the identity and affiliation of any
individual proposed to serve after confirmation of the Plan, as a director, officer, or voting
trustee of the Debtor, an affiliate of the Debtor participating in a joint Plan with the Debtor or a
successor to the Debtor under the Plan; and (ii) the appointment to, or continuance in, such office
of such individual is consistent with the interests of creditors and equity security holders and
with public policy, and
(B) The proponent of the Plan has disclosed the identity of any Insider that will be
employed or retained by the reorganized Debtor, and the nature of any compensation for such
insider.
(6) Any governmental regulatory commission with jurisdiction, after confirmation of
the Plan, over the rates of the Debtor has approved any rate change provided for in the Plan, or
such rate changes expressly conditioned on such approval.
(7) With respect to each impaired class of claims or interest:
(A) each holder of a claim or interest of such class
i. has accepted the Plan; or
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 23 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
24/33
24
ii. will receive or retain under the Plan on account of such claim or interest
property of a value, as of the effective date of the Plan, that is not less than the amount that such
holder would so receive or retain if the debtor were liquidated under Chapter 7 of this Title on
such date; or
(B) If Section 1111(b)(2) of the Bankruptcy Code applies to the claims of such
class, each holder of a claim of the class will receive or retain under the Plan on account of such
claim property of a value, as of the effective date of the Plan, that it is not less than the value of
such holders
interest in the property that secures such claims.
(8) With respect to each class of claims or interest
(A) the Class has accepted the Plan; or
(B) the Class is not impaired under the Plan.
(9) Except to the extent that the holder of a particular claim has agreed to a different
treatment of such claim, the Plan provides that:
(A) with respect to a claim of a kind specified in 507(a)(2) or 507(a)(3) of the
Bankruptcy Code, on the effective date of the Plan, the holder of such claim will receive on
account of such claim cash equal to the allowed amount of such claim;
(B) with respect to a class of claims of a kind specified in 507(a)(1), 507(a)(4),
507(a)(5), 507(a)(6) or 507(a)(7) of the Bankruptcy Code, each holder of a claim of such class
will receive:
i. If such class has accepted the Plan, deferred cash payments of a value, as of the
effective date of the Plan, equal to the allowed amount of such claim; or
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 24 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
25/33
25
ii. If such class has not accepted the Plan, cash on the effective date of the Plan
equal to the allowed amount of such claim; and
(C) and (D) with respect to a class of a claim of a kind specified in 507(a)(8) of
the Bankruptcy Code, the holder of such claim will receive a specified amount.
10. If a class of claims is Impaired under the Plan, at least one class of claims that
is Impaired under the Plan has accepted the Plan, determined without including any acceptance
of the Plan by any insider.
(11) Confirmation of the Plan is not likely to be followed by the liquidation, or the
need for further reorganization of the Debtor or any successor to the Debtor under the Plan,
unless such liquidation or reorganization is proposed in the Plan.
(12) All fees payable under 28 U.S. C. 1930 as determined by the Court at the
hearing on confirmation of the Plan, have been paid or the Plan provides for the payment of all
such fees on the effective date of the Plan.
(13) The Plan provides for the continuation after its effective date of payment of all
retiree benefits as that term is defined in Section 1114 of this Title at the level established
pursuant to Subsection (e)(1)(B) or (g) of Section 1114 of this Title, at any time prior to
confirmation of the Plan, for the duration of the period the Debtor has obligated itself to provide
such benefits.
D. ACCEPTANCE OF THE PLAN
The Bankruptcy Code defines acceptance of a Plan by a class of claims as acceptance by
holders of at least two-thirds in dollar amount and a majority in number of claims in that class
which actually cast ballots for acceptance or rejection of the Plan. Only the classes of claims
which are Impaired under a Plan are entitled to accept or reject the Plan. A class is Impaired
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 25 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
26/33
26
if legal, equitable or contractual rights attaching to the claims or interest in that class are
modified. Acceptance by a class of equity interest holders is defined as acceptance by
holders of interests with at least two-thirds in dollar amount, counting only those holders of
interests whose holders cast ballots.
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 26 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
27/33
27
E. NON-ACCEPTANCE AND CRAM DOWN
Even if a class of Impaired claims or interests does not accept the Plan, the Debtor has the
right to request that the Plan be confirmed pursuant to 1129(b) of the Bankruptcy Code, the
Cram Down provision.
As long as one Impaired class votes in favor of the Plan, the Court may confirm the Plan
if the Court determines that the Plan does not discriminate unfairly and is fair and equitable
with respect to each rejecting class. A Plan does not discriminate unfairly within the meaning
of the Bankruptcy Code if no class receives more than it is legally entitled to receive for its
claims and interests. Fair and equitable has different meanings with respect to the treatment of
Secured and Unsecured claims as well as the treatment of Equity. In general, 1129(b)
establishes that the treatment of classes of claims and interests is fair and equitable as along as all
junior classes are treated in accordance with the absolute priority rule which requires that each
dissenting class be paid in full before a junior class receive anything under the Plan.
F. CONFIRMATION THROUGH VOTING
The Bankruptcy Court will confirm the Plan only if all of the requirements of 1129 of
the Bankruptcy Code are met. The requirements for confirmation are that the Plan (i) is
accepted by all impaired classes of Claims entitled to vote or, if rejected by an impaired Class,
that the Plan does not discriminate unfairly and is fair and equitable as to such Class and as
to the impaired Classes of Claims and Equity Interests that are deemed to reject the Plan, (ii) is
feasible and (iii) is in the best interests of the holders of Claims and Equity Interests impaired
under the Plan.
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 27 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
28/33
28
G. BALLOTS
Creditors entitled to vote will receive Ballots on which to record their acceptances or
rejections of the Plan. You must complete your Ballot and return it to counsel for the Debtor who
will tally the votes and report the results to the Court at the Hearing on Confirmation of the Plan.
Please complete the Ballot sent to you with this Disclosure Statement, sign the original,
and return it to counsel for the Debtor. If no members of a class tender a vote, that class will be
deemed to accept their treatment.
H. ENTITLEMENT TO VOTE
A holder of a claim against the Debtor is entitled to vote to accept or reject the Plan only
if:
(1) The Court has not previously disallowed the claim;
(2) The claim is Impaired under the Plan; and
(3) The claim is not of a class that is deemed to have rejected the Plan
pursuant to 1126(g) of the Bankruptcy Code; and either:
a. The Debtor has not scheduled the claim as being disputed, contingent or
unliquidated; or
b. The holder of the claim has filed a proof of claim or interest on or
before the last date set by the Court for such filing.
Any claim to which an objection has been filed is not entitled to vote, unless the Court
temporarily allows such claim in an amount that it deems proper for the purpose of voting on the
Plan. In addition, a vote may be disregarded if the Court determines that such vote was not
solicited or procured in good faith or in accordance with the provisions of the Bankruptcy Code.
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 28 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
29/33
29
I. EFFECT OF FAILURE TO VOTE
If a creditor or holder of an interest does not return a fully completed Ballot within the
specified time to the Debtors attorneys, neither the creditor nor the amount of its claim or the
amount of the interest holder is counted to determine acceptance or rejection of the Plan. If you
are entitled to vote and do not, the Ballots will be tallied as though you do not exist. If no
members of a class tender a vote, that class will be deemed to accept their treatment.
ARTICLE XVII
Miscellaneous
Neither the filing of this Plan, nor any statement or provision herein, nor the taking of any
action by a creditor shall be deemed (a) an admission against interest; (b) a waiver of any right
which the creditor may have against the Debtor or any of its property or any other creditor. In
the event that the effective date does not occur, neither the Plan nor any statement or provision
herein may be used or relied upon any suit, action, proceeding or controversy involving the
Debtor, whether in or outside of the reorganization case.
ARTICLE XVIII
Modification of Plan
The Debtor reserves the right, in accordance with the Bankruptcy Code and Bankruptcy
Rules, to amend or modify this Plan at any time prior to the entry of the Confirmation Order.
After the entry of the Confirmation Order, the Debtor may amend or modify this Plan, in
accordance with Bankruptcy Code 1127, or remedy any defect or omission or reconcile any
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 29 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
30/33
30
inconsistency in this Plan in such manner as may be necessary to carry out the purpose and intent
of this Plan.
ARTICLE XIX
Withdrawal or Revocation
The Debtor may withdraw or revoke this Plan at any time prior to the Confirmation. If
the Debtor revokes or withdraws this Plan prior to the Confirmation Date, or if the Confirmation
Date does not occur, this Plan shall be deemed null and void.
In such event, nothing contained herein shall be deemed to constitute a waiver or release
of any Claim by or against the Debtor or any other person in any further proceedings involving
the Debtor.
ARTICLE XX
Jurisdiction
The Court shall retain jurisdiction of this case until the Plan has been consummated, as
set forth herein:
(a) Classification of the claim of any creditor and re-examination of claims which has
been allowed for purposes of voting, and the determination of such objections as may be filed to
such claims. The failure by the Debtor to object to, or to examine any claim for the purposes of
voting, shall not be deemed to be a waiver of the Debtor right to object to, or re-examine the
claim in whole or in part.
(b) Determine any and all applications for compensation and reimbursement of expenses
pursuant to Bankruptcy Code 330.
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 30 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
31/33
31
(c) Modify the Plan or correct any defect, cure any omission, or reconcile any
inconsistency in the Plan or the Order of Confirmation as may be necessary to carry out the
purposes and intent of the Plan to the extent authorized by the Bankruptcy Code and Rules.
(d) Determine any and all applications, adversary proceedings, and contested or litigated
matters pending on the Confirmation Date or arising in or related to the Debtors reorganization
proceedings.
(e) Determine matters concerning state, local and federal taxes pursuant to Bankruptcy
Code 106, 505, 1141 and 1146.
(f) Determine the validity, priority, enforceability and extent of all liens, encumbrances,
mortgages, security agreements, deeds of trust, assignments and other charges and levies which
are, or become liens or encumbrances on assets or Estate Property prior to Confirmation.
(g) Resolve controversies and disputes regarding the interpretation of the Plan.
(h) Implement the provisions of the Plan and enter any orders in aid of Confirmation and
consummation of the Plan including, without limitation, orders to protect the Debtor, the
Reorganized Debtor and assets and Estate Property from actions by creditors and/or interest
holders of Debtor.
(i) Enforce the rights of the Debtor under the Plan.
(j) To take such action to enjoin interference with implementation of the Plan.
(k) For such other matters as may be set forth in the Order of Confirmation.
Courts of Competent Jurisdiction
If the Court abstains from exercising, or declines to exercise jurisdiction or is otherwise
without jurisdiction over any matter arising out of this Plan, such abstention, refusal or failure of
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 31 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
32/33
32
jurisdiction shall have no effect upon and shall not control, prohibit or limit the exercise of
jurisdiction by any other court having competent jurisdiction with respect to such matter.
ARTICLE XXI
Severability
In the event that the Court determines, prior to the Confirmation Date, that any provision
of this Plan is invalid, void or unenforceable, the Court shall, with the consent of the Debtor,
have the power to alter and interpret such term or provisions to make it valid or enforceable to
the maximum extent practicable, consistent with the original purpose of the term or provision
held to be invalid, void, or unenforceable, and term or provision shall then be applicable as
altered or interpreted. The remaining terms and provisions of this Plan shall remain in full force
and effect and shall in no way be affected, impaired or invalidated by such holding, alteration or
interpretation.
ARTICLE XXII
Governing Law
Except to the extent the Bankruptcy Code or Bankruptcy Rules are applicable, the rights
and obligations under this Plan shall be governed by, and construed and enforced in accordance
with, the laws of the State of Virginia, without giving effect to the principles of conflicts of law
thereof.
ARTICLE XXIII
Headings
Headings are used in this Plan for convenience and reference only, and shall not
constitute a part of this Plan for any other purpose.
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 32 of 33
8/3/2019 Museum Plan
33/33
ARTICLE XXIV
Conclusion
The Plan is proposed in good faith, is not prohibited by law, and is in the best interests of
all creditors, holders of interest, and the Debtor as reorganized in accordance herewith.
Respectfully Submitted,
U.S. National Slavery MuseumBy Counsel
/s/ Sandra R. Robinson
Sandra R. Robinson (VSB #31885)
Robinson Law & Consulting Firm, P.C.Post Office Box 503Richmond, Virginia 23218(804) 928-5458(804) 303-3499 [fax]Counsel for the Debtor
Certificate of Service
I hereby certify that on February 17, 2012, a true copy of the Debtors ReorganizationPlan was served, electronically, through ECF, to the United States Trustee and all creditors andinterested parties requesting service of pleadings in this case.
___/s_ Sandra R. RobinsonSandra R. RobinsonRobinson Law & Consulting Firm, P.C.Post Office Box 503Richmond, Virginia 23218(804) 928-5458(804) 303-3499 [fax]
Case 11-36013-DOT Doc 46 Filed 02/17/12 Entered 02/17/12 23:29:00 Desc MainDocument Page 33 of 33