Upload
kinnari-pandya
View
223
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/13/2019 Morbi Case for Class Discussion
1/15
1
Customers value expectations (CVE) and suppliers value propositions(SVP) in
developing new services and relationships: Case study from natural gas industry
Copyright: Pramod Paliwal & Ramendra Singh
Analyse and discuss the case in the context of market development f or natural gas/natural gas
based appli cations. You may also bring in the reference of simi lar instances in natural
gas/energy industry for a broader perspective.
1. Introduction
While deciding about products and services, customers always value certain specific criteria in
them. Features, service quality and reliability and service guarantees are examples of attributes
that represent value to customers. Customers incur real costs (and opportunity costs) when
acquiring offerings and hence these are important elements of customer value. Customer value
expectations thus have a very important role to play in developing offerings by marketers.
Value proposition is an offer that describes the quantifiable benefits that individuals or
organizations making an offer promise to deliver. Its development is based on a review and
analysis of the benefits, costs and value that an organization can deliver to its customers,
prospective customers, and other constituent groups within and outside the organization. It is
also a positioning of value, where value is a function of benefits and associated costs.
The significance of the case study stems from the unique context of the case study, i.e., the
natural gas distribution business. Distance between the supplier and consumers and creation of
natural gas transmission and distribution infrastructure form major contours of this business.
Moreover natural gas once explored and produced from the wellhead, cannot be stored easily.
Further the creation of storage infrastructure entails significant capital expenditure and given the
8/13/2019 Morbi Case for Class Discussion
2/15
2
physical & chemical properties of natural gas, considerable space is taken up in storing the gas.
Therefore, ideally end-to-end supply tie-ups have to be in place between suppliers and
customers, before the first cubic meter of gas is sold to the customer. In the absence of such tie-
ups, the entire business model becomes unviable as return on investment in creating pipeline
network for transportation and distribution until last mile becomes inadequate. It is a challenge
for any business marketer to operate under such a business model, unless it finds a match
between CVE and SVP for the target market.
This case study illustrates how the environmental variables such as competitive intensity that
affects profit margins necessitates an industry (in the case study, ceramic industry at Morbi-
henceforth, CERACO), to review internal cost-structure and manufacturing processes, and
design elements of CVE. GASCO finds a latent opportunity for matching CVE while planning a
market entry using piped natural gas (PNG) as total fuel solution, replacing LPG as a previous
solution.
2. The GASCO-CERACO Case Study
2.1.1. Data Collection
To enable data collection for the case study, representatives from supplier, GASCO and the
buyers in CERACO were interviewed to understand the sequence of steps that preceded the
entire market development. Twenty key ceramic manufacturers (customers) were visited that
represent CERACO. We conducted semi-structured interviews with few key representatives of
ceramic manufacturers, equipment supplier representatives, and GASCO representatives. Two
vendors of GASCO and a representative of the gas pipeline (infrastructure) company close to
GASCO were also interviewed. Themes were identified in the analysis of the semi-structured
8/13/2019 Morbi Case for Class Discussion
3/15
3
interview transcripts, focused group discussions and the documented information. The research
thus involved the examination of supplier-customer interaction activities, and the benefits of
making it an integral part of new service relationship strategy.
From both theoretical as well as the practitioners perspective, it would be important to gain
insights into the phenomenon of market development for GASCO by co-creating value by
managing the CVE- SVP (Supplier Value Proposition) interaction process. If value co-creation
as a market entry strategy can be successfully demonstrated in a relatively complex environment
such as the natural gas market in terms of logistics, infrastructure, and technology-, then it
should be useful for business marketers in terms of contextualizing the case findings in various
other (and maybe less complex) business marketing situations.
2.2 The Ceramic Industry at Morbi (CERACO)
2.2.1. Background
Morbi, 210 km from Ahmedabad, the commercial capital of western Indian state of Gujarat, has
a unique distinction for being host to around 400 ceramic units of various capacities. Almost
two-thirds of these units manufacture floor and wall tiles and remaining are vitrified tile and
sanitaryware manufacturers. The typical production levels for ceramic manufacturing plants in
Morbi range from 70 to 1800 metric tonnes/month for sanitaryware and 180 to 4500 metric
tonnes /month for ceramic tiles. The ceramic tile and sanitary wares manufacturing consists of
basic raw clay minerals mixed with other additive minerals that are used for the firing/fusion
process. In the firing /fusion process, the raw materials are transformed in a glassy phase
(vitrification) at temperatures between 1,000C and 1,400C. The vitrification process causes the
ceramic products to have certain chemical and physical properties, including resistance to heat
and fire, high strength, and chemical inertness. The major manufacturing processes include raw
8/13/2019 Morbi Case for Class Discussion
4/15
4
material storage, preparation of raw materials, shaping, drying, surface treatment (glazing or
enamelling), firing, treatment (polishing), sorting, and packaging (Source: UNIDO- DIPP).
The products mainly consist of a mixture of clay minerals complemented with other minerals
such as additives, fillers and fluxing agents, and glaze components. When received from the
extraction- sites, raw materials are prepared through several processes (primary and secondary
crushing, grinding, screening, dry or wet milling, dry screening and spray drying), mixed and
pressed, and extruded or slip cast into shape using shaping/forming. Glaze -preparation is
conducted using silica (as major glaze component), fluxing agents (alkalis, alkaline earths,
boron, lead, etc.), pacifiers (zirconium, titanium, and so on), and colouring agents (iron,
chromium, cobalt, manganese, etc.). Water is used frequently for a thorough mixing and shaping,
followed by aeration stage. Surface treatment and decoration of the clay products may follow
later. The products are then placed in kilns for firing/ vitrification. (UNIDO- DIPP)
The firing process allows the vitrification of the shaped and dried clay products. The continuous
kilns include tunnel kilns for sanitary ware, and roller hearth kilns for tiles. Firing is produced by
burners located at the sides of the kiln. The manufacture of ceramic products is complicated due
to the sensitive nature of the numerous chemical reactions that occur during the manufacturing
process. Therefore, manufacturing is a complex operation that involves massive supply of heat.
Usage of cheaper fuels may lead to technical problems, which may result in poor quality of the
end products. The use of a clean fuel such as natural gas enhances the product quality by
reducing technical problems in the manufacturing process. Ceramic products depending upon
their finished quality of the final products are generally categorized as follows:
1. Category A: These command a premium price2. Category B: These are sold at a discount of 20-25% as compared to category A
8/13/2019 Morbi Case for Class Discussion
5/15
5
3. Category C: These fetch a price that ranges between 10-50% of the discounted priceof A.
4. The average daily production from Morbi ceramic cluster reflects a clear pattern, asshown in Table 2:
End-Product Quality
Fuel Used
Coal Gas/CBFS LPG Natural Gas
Category A 50% 52-55% 52-55%
Category B 40% 42-45% 42-45%
Category C 10% 0-6% 0-6%
Total 100% 100% 100%
Table 2:Product quality wise distribution based on type of fuel used in Morbi Cluster
Fuel cost
per unit of
production
Supply
security
Kiln/Equipment
maintenanceFinal
product
quality
Health, safety
&
environmentissues
Coal Gas 2 3 2 3 4
CBFS 1 4 3 2 3
LPG 3 2 1 1 2
Natural Gas 4 1 1 1 1
Note: Ranking: 1-4 (Highest to lowest)
Table 3: Comparative analysis (ranking) of fuels used for kiln firing at Morbi
Thus, natural gas has the potential to increase the production of category- A and B products,
which commanded significantly higher premiums in the market. Incidentally, using LPG also
8/13/2019 Morbi Case for Class Discussion
6/15
6
brings down the rejections of end product, but since LPG, compared to natural gas, scored less
on other major underlying parameters (Table 3); natural gas became the preferred heating fuel in
the Morbi ceramic industry. As shall be also seen in the subsequent sections, the intensive
interactive engagement of GASCO with CERACO players was extremely useful in
understanding this phenomenon, and eventually the adoption of natural gas as a preferred fuel,
was beneficial for the end customers.
Both the major stakeholders in the process i.e. customers, and the business marketer reported that
they had intensive interactions with each other during the entire process i.e. from the beginning
of the business discontinuance till the adoption process for natural gas as the new fuel for kiln
firing was complete.
2.2.2.The Fuel Crisis: Business discontinuity and a latent opportunity for CVE-SVP interaction
process between GASCO and CERACO
Ceramic manufacturing is highly energy intensive, where energy costs account for 15% to 40%
of the total production cost. The existing fuels being used are fuel oil, producer gas, natural gas
and liquefied petroleum gas, which mainly used for firing the burners. A key aspect of the
process involves drying, which is followed by firing at temperatures between 800 centigrade
and 1,250 centigrade. Surplus heat is often recovered from ceramic dryers, using hot air
recovered from the cooling zones of tunnel kilns, supplemented with hot air from the burners.
This requires careful consideration of plant layout, because low-temperature excess heat can be
managed usefully, provided that the distance between excess heat generation and use (and
therefore piping length) is limited. Over the last few years, the Morbi ceramic cluster (CERACO)
had been experimenting with Carbon Based Feedstock (CBFS), Liquefied Petroleum Gas (LPG)
8/13/2019 Morbi Case for Class Discussion
7/15
7
and Coal Gas for firing the kilns that also shifted from conventional tunnel kilns to roller kilns
over the years. Between 1992 and 2002, CERACO units were largely roller kilns based, using
LPG as a fuel, which was a cleaner and less polluting fuel that also addressed the issue of
consistency of temperature required in the kilns. However, in 2002, the price of commercial
LPG increased to the extent of 130%, and suddenly the ceramic units found the LPG
economically unviable as it resulted in a substantial increase in their cost structure.This led to a
fuel crisis.
2.2.3. CustomersValue Expectations: Looking inwards for solutions
CERACO manufacturers taking a cue from their Chinese counterparts, explored the technology
available in China and looked at the option of adopting the coal gas based gassfier mechanism,
for kiln firing. The CERACO units had a unique distinction for adaptability, and true to this
spirit, within few years of the fuel crisis; a majority of units converted their kiln firing process
into coal gas based gassifiers, and also developed indigenous technology for manufacturing these
gassifiers. However, the coal gas fuel failed to bring about a consistent kiln temperature, which
resulted in variation in the quality of their product range i.e. vitrified, floor and wall tiles. This
inconsistency in product quality led to higher rejections, and dropping revenues from the
customers, most of whom purchased in bulk. The customers of CERACO further used their
bargaining power to drive down the contracted price with the CERACO units, who were left with
little or no option to wriggle out this situation. Moreover, coal gas production involved multiple
mechanical steps, which made the process complicated. Between 2002 and 2007, while the
installed capacity went up by almost 40%, the CERACO units were still struggling with finding
an appropriate fuel solution to fire their kilns. The fuel crisis was blowing out of proportion, and
8/13/2019 Morbi Case for Class Discussion
8/15
8
the solution seemed out of sight. This was a latent opportunity for GASCO to engage in CVE-
SVP interaction process.
2.2.4 GASCO
GASCO is a subsidiary of a large public sector petroleum company (2009-10) sales, USD 1.6
billion) promoted by the state government of Gujarat, India. The role of the natural gas
marketing company is complementary to another group company that operates one of the largest
gas transmission pipeline networks in India. At every location where the transmission network
ends, GASCOs retail network starts. This has resulted in a strong synergy in network
management besides ensuring that gas is adequately available to all retail segments in Gujarat
that comprise industrial, commercial, transportation and residential customers. GASCO provides
last mile linkage to small consumers by way of networks. The company is supplying Piped
Natural Gas (PNG) to nearly 30000 domestic households, 125 commercial establishments and
about 400 industrial customers. It handles sales volume in tune of 2 MMSCMD (Million Metric
Standard Cubic Meters per Day). Understanding the complexities of Natural Gas business, the
promoter company, apart from collaborating with Canada based Niko Resources, has forged
strategic business alliances with international partners like Heramec Limited, UK, GeoGlobal
Resources (Barbados) Inc, Canada, Hallworty Shipping Limited SA, Panama, Oilex, Australia,
Petrogas E & P LLC, Oman and Silverwave Energy Pte Limited, Singapore.
2.2.4.1 The New Service
Natural Gas is a safe, efficient, and economical fuel to use in different forms by different set of
users, either as Piped Natural Gas (PNG) or as Compressed Natural Gas (CNG). Unlike LPG,
CBFS and Coal Gas, the PNG Fuel Service needs an extensive infrastructure for reliable service,
which means substantial upfront investments. Natural Gas is supplied to the customers at the
8/13/2019 Morbi Case for Class Discussion
9/15
9
usage point through linear gas pipelines, as this cannot be stored in cylinders like LPG. Gas
flows to customers premises going through various stages of pressure reduction. These pipelines
take their supplies from cross-country trunk pipelines. Apart from these trunk lines, the PNG
infrastructure include heavy-duty compressing units at various points, a deodorization plant, and
a city gate station from where the trunk line is connected to pipelines for intermediate and last
mile connectivity. The pipelines network, and the city gate station requires a continuous
monitoring with state-of the -art hardware and software. Though PNG was seemingly a logical
fuel for CERACO units because they have already traversed on the Liquid (CBFS) to Gas
(LPG/Coal Gas) curve, and with minimal need for retrofitting, the SVP was still not free from
challenges.
For ensuring the switch to an alternative core activity in the manufacturing process for
CERACO, in this case from the usage of Coal Gas to Natural Gas for kiln firing GASCO crafted
its SVP in the following way:
1) Adequate distribution infrastructure for consistency in supplies: Unlike oil that can bemanaged in batches, gas requires a constant flow and requires complex pipeline networks
right through upstream (exploration & production) and midstream (transmission at high
pressure) to downstream (distribution at last mile) even for minimal usage. GASCO being a
downstream company needs to create the infrastructure to handle the high-pressure natural
gas coming from the cross-country trunk line transportation network of midstream
companies. Thus GASCO takes the rights of natural gas at the city- gate- station (CGS) and
distributes gas to end-consumers at low pressures through an intensive network of low
pressure pipelines.
8/13/2019 Morbi Case for Class Discussion
10/15
10
At a very conservative estimate, CERACO entails an investment of USD 60 Million for
creation of a city gas distribution network. In addition, the creation of such distribution
network also involves tackling a host of regulatory issues and managing Health, Safety &
Environment (HSE) norms.
2) Justify relatively high prices for natural gas: Natural Gas is benchmarked with
international crude oil prices and hence relative to Coal Gas and Carbon Based Feed Stock
(CBFS), is priced higher. The higher price in part also stems from a substantial investment in
infrastructure. Its price may be at par with or slightly higher than LPG. However, a customer
making a decision about choice of fuel only because of price grossly overlooks the other
advantages of natural gas, i.e. high calorific value, clean (less polluting) fuel and above all the
assurance of adequate supplies at all times.
3) Availability of adequate quantities of natural gas for CERACO:/ Consistency ofNatural Gas Supply:
Reliability of gas supply is a paramount issue for a ceramic customer. As also
discussed earlier, it is relatively expensivefor both, the buyer as well as supplier- to
store adequate quantities of natural gas. Therefore, in the event of disruption of
supplies, the customer shall be at a loss-both in terms of downtime in manufacturing
operations, and costs involved in maintaining and (short-term) switchover to alternate
fuels. For reliable and secured gas supply, city gas distribution networks should have
a network system with minimum of two sources from different trunk lines.
GASCOs marketing strategy of diversifying its natural gas supply sources such as spot gas etc.
to hedge against volatility of natural gas prices combined with the professional and forward
looking approach of the top management also helps in contributing to a unique SVP of ensuring
8/13/2019 Morbi Case for Class Discussion
11/15
11
perennial gas supply. GASCO has a lot of support from the government the majority
shareholder- to enable it to take calculated yet bold business risks on gas sourcing and
distribution infrastructure creation.
4) Safety issues: The properties of natural gas at times makes its customers vulnerable topotential mishaps and hence it is imperative that a downstream company (GASCO) adopts good
industry practices in design and construction of facilities, laying of pipelines, infrastructure and
in selection of equipment. These practices are as also per the mandate of Oil Industry Safety
Directorate (OISD) of the government of India. Further, it is also required to implement
engineering and management measures based on the outcome of internationally accepted tools
like Quantitative Risk Assessment (QRA) and Hazard & Operability Studies (HAZOP). Other
measure- which is also mandatory- such as use of odorants is also a safeguard to enable early
detection of leakages of natural gas. Consumer safety measures are required to be implemented
including provision of information on safe practices, emergency response, dos and donts at the
time of connection and in subsequent customer-visits.
To address these concerns, GASCO regularly engages with key CERACO customers in order to
understand the salient features about fuel consumption by the units. GASCO also has a stateof
the -art Supervisory Control & Data Acquisition (SCADA) mechanism in place which aids to
better monitoring of the gas distribution networks.
To address these concerns, GASCO regularly engages with key CERACO customers in order to
understand the salient features about fuel consumption by the units.
The following are the identified aspects from the perspective of customer value expectations
(CVE):
8/13/2019 Morbi Case for Class Discussion
12/15
12
a) The fuel usage patternsb) Details of kiln firing mechanismc) Their cost structure, rejection rate and associated opportunity costs.d) Ceramic manufacturers end -customers expectations in terms of quality & consistency.The CERACO units were well networked among themselves, extremely cost-conscious, and
were always looking to improvise their processes by rising up on the learning curve. These
factors made GASCO to take a deep look into their operational details, since given the distinct
nature of its customers who have high prior knowledge, any new proposed fuel based solution
would need to be sustainable and of higher perceived value. It is imperative or any supplier to
develop a solution that is perceived valuable by its customers, besides being sustainable in the
medium to long-term horizon. This perceived value also needs to be successfully communicated
e.g., the short-term price differentials need to be explained with reference to the overall
customer-benefits. This also presented another challenge for GASCO- in terms of dealing with
customers influenced by their intense prior knowledge and experience. This prior experience of
customers aspect is an important one when dealing with such customers and has implications for
customer judgments (Jiewen and Sternthal, 2010), and value expectations.
2.2.5. CVE-SVP Interaction process
GASCO engaged with its customers on a continuous basis, tackling the concerns enlisted above,
and looked at the issues from the customers perspective, as well as from customers end-
e.g. At the intermediate Spray Drier stage (that involves drying of raw material and intermediates and which has
no direct bearing on the quality of end product), the ceramic units can continue with the option using Coal Gas due
to its economical availability.
8/13/2019 Morbi Case for Class Discussion
13/15
13
consumers perspective, to arrive at the following salient issues that needed to be addressed to
match the CVE with SVP:
1. Look beyond the short-term profitability of CERACO manufacturing units. ;2. Bring down rejections due to inconsistent quality, and to ensure consistently good quality
and to be able to compete internationally;
3. Ensure that high initial investment are set-off by the benefits such as zero storagerequirements for LPG, or the need to install and operate complicated mechanical
processes required for coal gassifiers;
4.
Ensure that CERACO units need not make any major process related changes for
adopting the new proposed fuel solution based on natural gas for kiln firing.
The interaction process was perceived by one of the key customers as:
The gas company (GASCO) officials have been very proactive in working with us,
understanding our problem-areas and devising solutions that were customized for our
operations.
In addition, another customer mentions:
Sometimes, we do have anxiety over probable increase in natural gas prices and its
consistent availability. But that is certainly less than the one we used to have when we
used LPG and Carbon feedstock for our kiln firing earlier. Moreover, we are confident
that after having made a substantial investment in creating huge gas transportation and
distribution infrastructure, the gas company shall do all the needful to address our
anxieties.
8/13/2019 Morbi Case for Class Discussion
14/15
14
2.2.6. CVE-SVP Interaction results
GASCOs efforts indeed brought some encouraging results. Within a year, almost 80% of the
CERACO units in Morbi signed up for Piped Natural Gas supply by GASCO. 64% of the total
units use PNG for up to three-fourths of their total requirements. The consumption of Natural
Gas increased from zero to 0.9 MMSCMD in about two years time. In the meantime, the gas
transmission company from the GASCO group, which is into pipeline transmission network
business, was working simultaneously to ensure the availability of adequate supply infrastructure
for the CERACO ceramic units. GASCOs endeavour of working closely with the customers
therefore transcended from mere transaction based interactions to long-term win-win customer
partnerships. Thus, besides co-creating a new value (in form of PNG) that had more long-term
benefits, the business marketer also advised the customers to continuing with maintaining LPG
storage facilities (with marginal investment). That was because in the eventuality of disruption
in natural gas supplies, the last-mile pipeline network can carry LPG and rotary kilns can
alternatively be fired by LPG, reducing the possibility of another business discontinuity, as faced
by customers earlier. GASCO realized that any disruption in manufacturing activity due to
disruption in the supply of natural gas could be much more costly for CERACO units than
temporarily switching to a competing fuel (LPG). As GASCO was not supplying LPG,
suggesting LPG as an alternate fuel to avoid business discontinuities meant that the supplier was
de-facto decreasing its customers switching costs. Therefore, accepting competition(from
alternate suppliers or product substitutes), even in the face of creating value for customers is also
an integral aspect of matching CVE with SVP, since customers perspective out sizes that of the
suppliers own perspective.
The CERACO units were a happy lot. Another customer for instance mentioned:
8/13/2019 Morbi Case for Class Discussion
15/15
15
After switching over from coal gas to natural gas, the rejection rate per box of manufactured
tiles has reduced drastically! In addition, our clients are extremely happy with our production
quality, which, now is more accepted in terms of premium grade rather than relatively sub-
standard as was the case earlier.
Morbi Case: Exercise
Note: For the sake of brevity and avoiding repetition, you are expected to NOT mention any kind of
background etc. to the case while answering the following questions.
Exercise:
Having gone through the case in detail, you are required to answer the following questions:
1. What is the key learning from the case?2. Enlist major concerns/issues that you feel that have not been addressed in the case but may be
crucial for the success of such efforts.
3. What according to you are the challenges to be encountered by either of the entities i.e. naturalgas marketer as well as consumer in the process of co-creation of such natural gas based
solutions? What, in your opinion can be done to make this more effective?
4. Enlist a few successful examples of such natural gas/LPG based novel applications that may (ormay not have) involved the processes of co-creation of solutions.