65
Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Page 2: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Part 1

Representing Complex Geology

© DHI

Page 3: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

© DHI

Complex

Page 4: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

© DHI

Page 5: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

© DHI

3D Groundwater Model

Page 6: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

3D Groundwater Model

© DHI

Multi-Faulted Regional Groundwater Model, Switzerland

Page 7: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

3D Groundwater Model

© DHI

• Continuous Layers

• Vertical Walls

Page 8: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Unstructured Meshes

© DHI

Page 9: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Example of teaserFollow the guide from the Branding SharePoint page to learn how to change the pictures

© DHI

Page 10: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

© DHI

Page 11: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

All Problems solved?

Page 12: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Traditional Layered Meshes

Creating Computation Meshes

© DHI

Page 13: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Mathematical Approach

© DHI

• Finite Differences Method • Finite Element Method

Page 14: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

© DHI

Page 15: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

2.5 D Mesh (Layered Mesh)

© DHI

2 Triangles →

1 Quadrangle

Page 16: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Element Deactivation

© DHI

• Create Caveats in Mesh, e.g.

for pit mines or tunnels

• Permanent or temporary

Page 17: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Element Deactivation

© DHI

• Remove unwanted layers

(Top / bottom only)

Page 18: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Steep Interfaces

© DHI

• moderate inclination:

Layer Elevation

• steep inclination:

step layout

Page 19: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Layered Meshes with local remeshing

Creating Computation Meshes

© DHI

Page 20: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Pinching

© DHI

Topography

Page 21: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Pinching

© DHI

Page 22: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Local Re-Meshing

© DHI

Page 23: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Non-Layered (Fully Unstructured) Meshes

Creating Computation Meshes

© DHI

Page 24: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

© DHI

Page 25: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

© DHI

Page 26: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Non-Layered Meshed

© DHI

• Geological contacts (volumes)

• Insets such as well locations

Page 27: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Non-Layered Meshed

© DHI

Legacy Approach

Structural Geologic Model

Computation mesh for numerical

model

Page 28: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Interfaces of geologic units

Non-Layered Mesh

© DHI

Page 29: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Interfaces and geologic units

Non-Layered Mesh

© DHI

Page 30: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Tetrahedral-meshed geologic units

Non-Layered Mesh

© DHI

Page 31: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Clipped tetrahedrons

Non-Layered Mesh

© DHI

Page 32: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Non-Layered Mesh

© DHI

Full tetrahedral mesh

Page 33: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Challenges

© DHI

Page 34: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Piecewise Linear Complexes (PLC)

© DHI

http://wias-berlin.de/software/tetgen/plc.html

Page 35: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

The Problem of Self-intersecting Surfaces

© DHI

Page 36: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Closed and Consistent Volumes

© DHI

Piecewise Linear Complexes (PLCs)

Page 37: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

DHI In-House Solution with TetGen

Example Case

© DHI

Page 38: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Consideration of Fault Offsets

Page 39: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Consideration of Fault Offsets

© DHI

Page 40: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Consideration of Fault Offsets

© DHI

• Case 1: Offset at isolated fault

• Solution: Record and sort all elevation data at faults

+ applicable for isolated faults

- Not applicable for isolated faults

Page 41: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Consideration of Fault Offsets

© DHI

• Case 2: Intersecting Faults

Grouping of elements to sectors

+ can represent more generell complex settings

Page 42: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Consideration of Pinchouts

© DHI

• Pinchouts and outer model hull

Page 43: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Closing of Remaining Gaps

© DHI

• Ensure closed volumes

Page 44: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Regional Markers

© DHI

• Bookkeeping for later numerical model

Page 45: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Entwicklung der Methodik

© DHI

• Result: Set of 3D face objects consistently enclosing all separable

geologic volumes

• ~ 700.000 points

• ~ 500.000 faces

Page 46: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Geologic Units

© DHI

VIDEO

Page 47: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Geologic Units

© DHI

VIDEO

Page 48: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Face Objects

© DHI

• red: Outer Border

• Light green: Faults

• blue: pinch-outs

• Other colors: geologic contacts

Page 49: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Resulting Mesh

© DHI

Page 50: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Carbonate Layer at Depth

© DHI

Page 51: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

CGAL Meshing GeneratorComputational Geometry Algorithms Library CGAL

© DHI

Page 52: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

CGAL Library

© DHI

• Computational Geometry Algorithms Library CGAL

• Open Source (www.cgal.org)

• Integrated in Geomodeller (Intrepid Geophysics)

Page 53: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Pilot Model of Lusitian Over-Thrust

27 May, 2019© DHI #53

• Geological model created in

3D Geomodeller

• Incl. Major geologic units

• Incl. vertical faults and

Lusatian overthrust

Page 54: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Unstructured mesh generated

Tetrahedron mesh created using CGAL

27 May, 2019© DHI #54

Page 55: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

27 May, 2019© DHI #55

Faults require a finite thickness

• Conduit

• Barrier

Handling of Faults

Local refinement

Page 56: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Handling of Faults

27 May, 2019© DHI #56

Nodal connections

Test24.fem

Page 57: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Mesh Refinement

Accuracy vs. Computational Speed

27 May, 2019© DHI #57

more refinement more refinement

Elements: 669.910

Nodes: 114.274Elements: 723.628

Nodes: 124.077

Elements: 1’201.954

Nodes: 201.930

Page 58: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Optimum for Geometric Representation

27 May, 2019© DHI #58

Page 59: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Optimum for Computation

27 May, 2019© DHI #59

Page 60: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Finally: What are the Benefits?

© DHI

Page 61: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Flexibility

© DHI

Page 62: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

© DHI

Page 63: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

© DHI

Page 64: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

Thank [email protected]

Page 65: Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments · Modelling Groundwater Flow in Hard Rock Environments Alexander Renz, DHI, Munich, Germany

DHI are the first people you should call when you have a tough

challenge to solve in a water environment.

In the world of water, our knowledge is second-to-none, and we strive

to make it globally accessible to clients and partners.

So whether you need to save water, share it fairly, improve its quality,

quantify its impact or manage its flow, we can help. Our knowledge,

combined with our team’s expertise and the power of our technology,

hold the key to unlocking the right solution.

© DHI

About DHI