MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    1/115

    DOE/PC/88651-T1DE90006270)

    MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH

    A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTORProject Final Report

    R E P R O D O C E O FA V O P Y

    April 20,1989

    Work Performed Under Contract No. AC22-88PC88651

    ForU. S. Department of EnergyPittsburgh Energy Technology CenterPittsburgh, Pennsylvania

    ByANSALDOS.p.A.Genova, Italy

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    2/115

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    3/115

    DISCLAIMER

    Portions of this document may be illegible inelectronic image products. Images are producedfrom the best available original document.

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    4/115

    Progettoproiect

    NUCLEAR MHO CONVERTERIdentificativoflocuTient no

    RD-12-01-FNPR

    Rev Paginarev page

    1

    DOE/PC/88651-T1(DE90006270)

    Distribution Category UC-112

    6 . Tu n i n e t t i ^

    E. Botta, C. Criscuolo. P. Riscossa^^

    F. Giammanco* , M. R o s a - C l o t " *

    D 0 E / P C / 8 8 6 5 1 ~ T

    DE90 006270

    Research Division, A N B A L D O SDA

    Nuclear Division, AN5Ai_D0 SpA

    'Deoartment o-f Pnvsics, University o-f Pisa

    Department o-f Pnvsics. University o-f Florence

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    5/115

    PAGE BLANK

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    6/115

    Pro ge tto lOentidcativo Rev Paginaproieci aocument no rev oaae

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR l 3

    CONTENTS

    EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 5

    1 INTRODUCTION 6

    1.1 Project UDjectives S

    1.2 Reoort Organization . . . . . . . . . 9

    TaDies ana Figures 10

    2 PROJECT DESCRIPTION 11

    3 REFLECTOR MODELING 13

    3.1 Symoois. Terms ana Abbreviations 13

    3.Z Re-ference Core De scription 15

    3.3 Analysis Coaes 19

    3.4 Fea tur es o-f Fer-formed Cal cul ati ons 21

    3.5 Nuclear Cross Section Calculation s 23

    3.6 Reactor Calculations 26

    3.7 Reactivity Reauirements 27

    3.S Re-ferences 30

    Tables ana Figures 3Z

    4 1

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    7/115

    Progetto lOentificativo Rev Pagmaproiect aocument no rev oaae

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER RD-12-G:-FNPR i 4

    5.2 Channel Characteristics and Conauctivity 73

    5.3 Fission and Gamma Density in the Channel 77

    5.4 Conductivity Calculations 81

    5.5 Re-ferences 91

    Tables and Figures 93

    6 SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS 106

    7 REPORT DISTRIBUTION LIST HO

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    8/115

    Progetto Identifica tivo Rev PaginapfOfeci , - , _ . _ ^ . _ _ ^ _ aocum ent no

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER aocument no p D _ i2 - 0 1 - F N P R '*' 1 " ^ '

    EXELL'~IVE SUMMARY

    CONTRACT TITLE AND NUMBER:

    M M D Como ressor - Exoanaer Conversion System Integratea with a GCR

    Insiae a D eployao ie Re-flector,

    DE-AC22-68PC8S651

    CONTRACTOR NAME AND ADDRESS:

    A N S A L D O S.D.A.

    Corso P.M. Perrone, 2516161 Geneva - Italy

    START DATE: 4-21-1988

    COnnFLETION DATE: 4-20-1989

    Tnis work origin ates -from the prooosal M H D ComoressorE;

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    9/115

    Pro getto Identificativo Rev Pagmaproiect document no rev page

    N UC L EA R MHD C O NV E RT ER R D - 1 2 - 0 1 - F N P R 1 6

    be either uranium heAa-f luoriae or a m ixtu re o-f uranium

    hexa-fluoride and helium, aaded to enna nce the heat trans-fer

    pro pert ies. The original Stat ement o-f Wor , which concernea the

    wnole conversion system, was suD seauently reairected and

    focused on the basic mecn anis ms o-f neu tro nic s, react ivit y

    cont rol, ionization ana electrical conauctivity in the PCu.

    Furtherm ore, tne study was reauirea to oe inherently generic

    sucn that the analysis and results can be aooliea to various

    nuclear reactor ana/or MnD cnannei Designs .

    Soeci-fic goa ls o-f the proj ect were:

    - To eva lua te the oer-formance o-f tne e,;ternal re-flector.

    - To dete rmine the in-fluence o-f a dai tio nal . -fission-inducea

    mech anism s on the ionization levels o-f the working -fluid.

    - To estimate the electrical conduct ivity levels that can be

    attained in the M HD channe l, t a^lng into accoun t the e-f-fects o-f

    F- or other negative ions.

    Two major conc lusio ns can be drawn -from the accom oiisn ment o-f

    this project:

    - A reactor con-figuration has been o o t am ed whicn avoias to

    deco uple the neut ron ics o-f the cavity and its internal

    re-flector from the external shell, thus enabling t ne latter to

    be used -for reactivity control.

    In particular the results show that the movable re-flector is able

    to make the reactor subcritical by 1000 pcm t least, and to

    control th e reactor -from CZP to HFP condit ion , accoun ting -for a

    reactivity change up to 3300 pcm associated to depletion.

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    10/115

    P r o g e t t o I d e n t i f i c a t i v o R e v P a g m a

    ' ^ NUCLEAR M HD CONVERTER ~= ' ' ' RD -12- 01-FN PR ' l '' '

    - Tne conditions expected in the M HD channel show that tne

    ionizatio n and con duct ivit y levels can be ampli-fied thr oug

    'secondary' proces ses induced by the 'primary' hot electron s

    which are directly generated by the -fission reactio ns.

    The numerical calculation s suggest that conauctivit y levels in

    the range 10-100 (ftm) * are consistent with the characteristics

    o-f short no zzl e, high power dens ity gen erat ors . In -fact, tne

    nozz le lengtn turns out to be o-f critical impo rtance becau se of

    the sharp decrease of resiaual fission ana gamma aensities as a

    function of tne aistance from tne reactor outlet.

    Tnis conclusion remains true even if the effect of aissociation

    ana attachment are mcluaea in the numerical moael.

    Furtne rmore, a preliminary evaluation of the influence of wall

    material and thickne ss snows the potential for tne fission ana

    gamma densit ies in the duct to be increased of one order of

    magnitude, m comparison with the values used in tne

    conductivit y calculat ions, if a material with favourable

    nuclear properties is adopted.

    7

    g

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    11/115

    Progetto Identificativo Rev Pagma

    ' ^ " ^ ' NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER ' ' "" " "" '" RD -12 -01 -FN PR ' 1 ' " ' " i

    1 INTRODUCTION

    l.i Project Objectiv es

    This work concernea an innovati ve concept of nuclea r,

    closed-cycle M HD converter for power generation on space-based

    systems in the multi-megawatt range. A schematic diagram of the

    concept IS shown in Fig. 1.1. The basic element of this converter

    is the Power Conversion Unit (PCU) consisting of a gas core

    reactor D irectly couoleo to an MHD expansion channel. The working

    fluid could D e eitner uranium hexaf luoride or a mi xture of

    uranium h exafiuo rioe ana helium, aaoea to enhance the heat

    transfer orooerties.

    Two major items, both concerning tne PCU, were adaressed in tne

    project:

    1. Because of the high levels of temoe rature expected m the

    reactor cavity, reactivity control is not achievea by neutron

    absorbers (control rods) located in the cavity, but by

    moving part of the reflector, located outside the pressure

    vessel, in order to change the amount of neutrons escaping

    from the core.

    2. The mere levels of temoerature, however, cannot sustain

    levels of ionization and, hence, of conductivity, capable of

    providing efficient power generation in the MHD chann el.

    Fission products may represent a possible additional source

    of ionization.

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    12/115

    Pi-ogetto Identificativo Re v Pagma

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER oocument no J , D _ ^ 2 - 0 1 - F N P R '^ ' l ' * y

    Tnis reoort aocu ments tne result s of worh aone to investigate

    tnese aspects of tne co oo se a conceot. H I O H L - D J aGces seD ootn

    Iter i. ana Z. : tne istter reauirea tne Bcienti-ric suDDQ' t a- f tne

    unive rsiti es o-r ioren ce ana Fisa. D eoartmenr n-f Fnvsic s.

    -I Reoort Organization

    Section 3.. Re-riector iloaeiing, illustrat es tne reactor

    configur ation, as aefined tnrougnout contract wor^ . cescrioes tne

    cooes ana D''oceaure= aaootea in tne anai vsi s. ana oresen ts tne

    resu lt s conce rn ing tnp oer-formance of t^e e terna i (T'o 'aDle

    ret i ector.

    Eection -, . ^or^lnq ^ laio Cna ract eris ticE . i-vestigates tne

    f 1 ssion-incucea ionization mecnanisms acting i tne w c M n g gas.

    and oroviaes a svstem of simoiifieo rate eauations for numerical

    solution.

    Section 5., Electrical Conauctivity Effe cts, adaresses tne stuav

    of tne electrical conauc tivity levels in tne Mt-iD cha nne l, ana

    presents the results of numerical estimates oerformea with

    different gas ano ouct parameters.

    References, Taoles ana Figures are located at tne ena of each

    section.

    n*

    i

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    13/115

    00123

    RE6. HX PCU

    * ' R A D

    I I 1 I I 1 II I I I I I I

    R = REACTOR

    HH D = HMD CHANNELREG.HX = REGhNER ATlVE HEAT EXCHANGEDHX = HEAT EXCHANGER

    f

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    14/115

    Progetto Identificativo Rev Pagina

    ^^' NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER " ' ' " '" * " '" RD -12 -01- FN PR '*" 1 '11

    2 PROJECT DESCRIPTION

    This section is based on the contents of paragraph 4.2 in the

    Statement of Work.

    The work is divided into four tasks.

    Task 1. Reflector Moaelino

    Tnis task shall provide the nuclear anaivsis of the conce ot,

    performed on a reference PCu geometry , using develooea ana ooen

    comouter coaes availaole at A N S H L D O .

    The reflector moaeling shall aadress the following items:

    - Reflector reactivity worth.

    - Power density distribution insioe the PCU, at constant core

    power level.

    Task 2. Working Fluid Characteristics

    This task shall provide an analytical model enaoling the

    prediction of the temoerature distribution and ionization levels

    of the working fluid in tne PCU.

    Since the equilibrium thermal ionization is not expected to

    maintain sufficient electrical conductivity for efficient power

    generati on, this task shall investigate additional ionization

    mechanisms that can be present in a fissioning plasma.

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    15/115

    Progetto Idertid cativo Rev Pagmaprotect document no rev page

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER R D -1 2- 01 -F N P R 112

    Task 3. Electrical Cond uctivity Effect s

    This tas^ shall proviae aporooriate relations enabling tne

    preaiction of the electrical con ductivity of the working g as. For

    this purpo se, this task shall primarily address the evaluation

    of the electron mobility in the gas. The possible contribution

    (beneficial and/or detri ment al) to electric conduct ivity of the

    other chargeo particles m the gas, such as F- ions, snail be

    taken into account.

    Tasi< 4. Reporting

    This task concerns tne execution of the reporting reauirements

    incorporatec in tne contract.

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    16/115

    Pro get to Identificativo Rev Pagmaproiect aocument no rev page

    NUCLEAR M H D CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR 1 .

    7 REFLECTOR M O D E L I N G

    7 . . Svmoois , Terms ana Hooreviations

    a Absorotion

    a/o Atom pe r cent

    B O L Feginning of life

    BU Fuel burn-uD

    CZF Cola zer o pow er

    f FlSElOn

    riFF not -full po we r

    HZF ho t zei'o power

    a Energy grouD

    pcm Percent mille ^a reactivity change of 1 pcm

    ecuais a reactivit y chan ge of lOe-5 A ^ )

    Power aensity T n e thermal power proauc ed pe r unit volume of

    the core (w/cm~)

    Reactivity

    Change in reactivity, definea a s

    A ^ = l n k 2 / k l ) , where kl and k 2 are t h e

    9

    A y

    eigenva lues obtained from t w o calculations

    that differ only in t h e values assigned t o

    the indepenaent variables

    Removal

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    17/115

    Prog etto Identificativo Rev Pagmaprotect document no rev page

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR 1 14

    shutoown margin Tne amount of negative reactivity ( o ^ by

    which a reactor is ma in ta me a m

    subcritical state at CZP conditio ns after a

    control trip

    Teff Resonance effective temoerature of the fuel

    tr Transport

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    18/115

    Pro getto Identificativo Rev Pagma^**= ' N i i r TF AD u u n rohnr iTDT trD document no ^ , ^ , rev _ pageNUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER > . RC-12-01-FNPR 1

    Reference Core Description

    General

    15

    The results presented m this section are referred to

    tne reactor reference configuration shown in Figures 3.1-3.2.

    This configuration is a simolifiea arrangement suoject to

    tne limitations of the coaes aoootea in the analysi s: in

    partic ular, a coarse aiscre tization of both composition ana

    geometry has oeen maae at the core inlet ana outlet conical

    segments.

    A simoie ax ia l- ml et flow pattern has oeen aaootea in tne

    analysis; however , the cooling reauirements of tne wail maae it

    necessary to add an internal diffuser that diviaes tne inlet

    flow into two par ts, the larger flowing m the annulus between

    the internal diffuser and the external one.

    In this reactor the same fluid acts as working medium and fuel;

    it flows across the reactor cavity and consists of highly

    enriched gaseous UF6 (region 1 of Fig. 3. 1) ; 90'/. a/o enrichea

    in U235 with the reactor at BOL.

    The core supplies a thermal power of 277 Mw at full power.

    The following parameters have been fixea for the power

    density distribution calculations m s i d e the core and for

    the reactivity integral worth evaluation of the movable

    reflector:

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    19/115

    Progetto Identificativo Rev Pagma

    ^ ' " ' ' N UCLEA R MHD CO NVERTER ' ' " " " ' " R D - 1 2 - 0 1 - F N P R " ' ' l ' ' ' '16

    - Reactor at full power ( H F F ; ,

    - B O L ,

    - no Aenon, no 5m,

    - inlet pressure 15 MFa,

    - UFto flow ra te 1000 tg/ s.

    - inlet temoerature 17Z0 t .

    Tne rationale for tne selection OT rnese system parameters is

    oroviaea m section 5.2.

    Besiaes, in oraer to estimate tne reactivity reauirements auring

    reactor operations , two aocitionai core conoitions nave oeen

    aefineo:

    e> conoition I:

    - Core at cola zero power ^ L Z F J .

    - B O L ,

    - uFc) inlet ore ssure 52 oar.

    - UFc> inlet temoeratu-'e 573 r .

    - UPto flow rate iOOu fg / s ,

    p; conoition II:

    - Core at not zero oower ( M Z F ) ,

    - BOL,

    - UF6 inlet oressure 15 M Pa,

    - UF6 inlet temperat ure 1720 K,

    - UF6 flow rate 1000 Kg/s,

    The above conditions are possible if the reactor control

    system can assure that:

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    20/115

    Pro ge tto Identificativo Rev Pagma

    17p ro te ct d o c u m e n t no rev p a g e

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR 1

    A) condition I is reached without using nuclear heating to

    attain the gaseous phase of tne fuel;

    B) the fuel density at the core inlet is kept constant (0.36

    g/cm~) by controlling the inlet parameters during reactor

    operations.

    Components

    The dimensio ns of the reactor components (shown in Figures

    3.1-3.2) have been fixed after some preliminary conside rations .

    basea on the thermal and mecnanical feasioility of tne system

    and on the basic neutronic reauireme nts enabling the core

    reactivity to oe controlled by a movao ie reflect or, slicing

    a x 1 ally on the external side of tne p ressure vess el.

    As already pointed out in CI ] , the main proolem is the

    selection of a pressure vessel material highly transoarent to

    neutrons.

    It can be shown that the adoption of the most common

    metallic materials , such as nickel alloys or stainle ss-stee l.

    introduces a strong reactivity penalty and decouples the inner

    shells from the external movable reflector to such a degree

    that reflector worth becomes negligible.

    For the above reasons a Zr/Nb alloy (UN5=R60901) has been finally

    selected as pressure vessel material.

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    21/115

    Prog etto Identificativo Rev Pagma

    U^^' NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER ' ' ' RD-1 2-01-FNPR ' 1 '^^

    The cylinorical shell thickness (10 cm) has been evaluated

    preliminarily in conformity with the ASME III Code C2] for a

    permanent static load condition at 15 MPa. In order to

    minimize creep Phenomena the pressure vessel maximum

    temoerature has been supoosea to be lower than 620 K.

    To keep tne pressure vessel temperature at such a low value

    an active neat removal svstem has to be provided.

    Since tne maximum temperature in the reactor cavity is expected

    to reacn aoout 2800 K close to the wall, highly refractory

    materials have been used: in partic ular, a graphite shell (10 cm

    thick; ana a BeO shell (10 cm thick) have been interposed between

    the fuel ana the pressure vessel.

    These shells have to be cooled by helium gas flowing across a

    number of coolant channels obtained m the shells themselve s.

    Tne purpose of tne coolant system is twofold;

    1) to remove the gamma and neutron heating from the inner shells:

    2) to create a strong temperature gradient between fuel and

    pressure vessel. Tab. 3.1 shows the radial temperature profile

    assumed for the core reference configuration.

    Further more, m order to avoid the corrosion reaction s between

    UF6 and graph ite, a thin Mo-alloy liner (0.6 mm thick) has been

    placed to insulate the fuel from the graphite surface.

    An adequate liner material is TZM (UNS=P/M,R03640) that has a

    high melting point (3300 K) and a liquidus temperature at

    2895 K.

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    22/115

    Prog etto Identificativo Rev Pagmap ro te ct M t i o T P i i n iMun /^ni in iPD TET i document no rev page

    NUCLEAR M HD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR 1 19

    Typical fields of application of this material ar e heat engines,

    extrusion dies and nuclear reactors, as it retains good

    mechanical performances at high temperature.

    It should be pointed out that only M o-alloys can oe prohaaly

    used for structural parts in the reactor cavity (e.g. tne

    diffuser); however, since these alloys act as strong absorbers

    in the proposed conceot of gas reacto r, their use shouio be

    limited.

    In this preliminary feasibility analysis, however, tne internals

    ( diffuser and gas coolant tubes) have been ignored; tne

    reactivity penalty due to the internal materials can be

    balanced by increasing fuel enrichment.

    Finally, beryllium has been selectea as the material of the

    movable reflector.

    M ass and volume of the reactor components are summarizea in Tao.

    Analysis Codes

    The principal computer codes adopted in the analys is ar e GGC-4

    C3] (zero-dimens ional), ANISN C43 (one-dimens ional), SQUID-3faO

    [5] (two-dimensional ), WAPITI-GAS C6] (two-dimensiona l),

    M ERCURE-IV C7] (thre e-dimensional). A brief presentation of these

    codes IS provided below: additional information can be found in

    the references.

    So

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    23/115

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    24/115

    Progetto Identificativo Rev Pagmaprotect document no rev paoe

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR 1 21

    MERCURE-IV Code:

    The Monte Carlo code MERCURE-IV comoutes in a three-dimensional

    heterogeneou s geometry heating and gamma dose rat es, and by

    the point-wise kernel attenuation in a straight line, the fast

    fluxes.

    Tabulated accumulation factors give the contribution of

    the scattered gamma rays. The program calculates the

    accumulation factors for mixtu res; for multi-layer media the

    Kitazume formulation is used.

    Additional suooort codes have been usea for soecial ca lculations

    sucn as the correlation factors ana the cross section uodate

    durina the iteration process between BOuID ana WAPITI.

    3.'' Features of Performea Calculations

    Fuel and structural material cross sections

    In accordance with the scheme reported in Fig. 3.3 the cross

    sections have been calculated by using:

    a) GGC-4 for the fuel cross sections with:

    - fast energy range from 14.9 MeV to 2.38 eV and Bl

    approximation (GAM);

    - thermal energy range from 2.38 eV to zero and BO

    approx i mat i on (GATHER):

    So

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    25/115

    Pro getto Identificativo Rev Pagmaprotect document no rev page

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR 1 22

    - 50 grouD microscopic cross section generation i i fast

    groups ana 9 thermal grouos ) to be input to ANISN coae in

    oraer to generate fuel ana structural cross sections.

    The assumed energy cuts are shown in Tao. 3.3.

    b) GbL-4 as in item a) but for the structural cross sections

    witn :

    - Bl aooroximation in GATHER.

    c; H(-.I5iv co ae using c vi inar ic ai geom et rv a no P0-5'+

    aooro'imation in oraer to:

    - investigate tne fuel 5 group cross section oeoenaence on tne

    temoerature ana Density of tne fuel;

    - generate tne structural material macroscooic cross sections

    ana a 5 group cross section data set to calcul ate tne fuei

    macroscopic cross sections to be input to SOUID coae as

    a function of temperatu re and density at each iteration step.

    The assumed energy cuts m the range 14.9 MeV - 0.0 eV are

    14.9 MeV, 0.821 MeV, 150 KeV, 5.53 Ke V, 0.625 eV, 0.0 eV.

    Reactor Calculations

    In accordance with the scheme reported m Fig. 3.4 , total

    reflector worth and the distri bution s of thermal pow er,

    fuel te mper ature , ana fuel density ha ve been calculatea av using:

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    26/115

    Pro ge tto Identificativo Rev Pagmaprotect document no rev page

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR 1 23

    a) SDUID-360 code with;

    - simplified R-Z geometry and material comoositions,

    - k-eff calculation,

    - spatial fluxes calculations in order to evaluate the thermal

    power aensity aistribution to be input to WAPITI code.

    b) W A P I T I - G H 5 coae for the thermal-fluid analysis witn:

    - R-Z geometry,

    - turbulent flow,

    - density ana temperature distributions of tne fuel to be input

    to S Q L I D - 3 6 0 Coae.

    3.5 Nuclear Cross Section Calculations

    The macroscooic cross sections reauired as input data for the

    full core R-Z SOUID calculat ions have been generatea by

    using the proceaure outlinea in Fig. 3.3. The cross sections

    are referred to :

    -fuel,

    -structural material.

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    27/115

    Pro getto Identificativo Rev Pagma

    2 4P'otect document no rev oaae

    NUCLEAR MHD CO^fVERTER R D -1 2 -0 1 -F N P R ^ ^ p ge

    Fuel cross sections

    It has been assumed that in side the re-ference core con-figuration

    (see par. 3.1) -fuel temperatu re and density may chang e in the

    range 1600-3000 K and 0.15-0.45 g/cm , respectively, as shown in

    Fig. 3 .5.

    A sensitivity analysi s has been per-formea by applying the

    proc edur e of Fig. 3.3 to each o-f the poin ts 1-9 o-f Fig. 3. 5.

    The results are summarizeo below:

    a) tne fuel microscooic cross sections cnange only:

    - with fuel density in the 4th energetic group (eoithermal

    range),

    - with fuel temperatu re in the 5tn energetic group (tnermal

    group);

    b) the 5 group structural material cross section s are not

    significantly affected by the fuel conditions unoer the

    assumption that the radial tempera ture profile in the

    structural material doesn't change.

    Conseque ntly, in order to update the fuel macroscopic

    cross sections during the iterative SDUID calculations of

    reactor power distribution with thermal-fluid feedb ack, the

    following correlations can be used:

    g g n g= lf ~ si t j=tr ,a,f

    I (T,n) = I ( To , n o ) or

    J j no g=l?4 and j=r

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    28/115

    Prog etto Identil icativo Rev PagmaPfoiect document no rev oaoe

    NUCLEAR MH D CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR 1 25

    4 4 n 4

    Z u . n ; = I (To ,no) +L Z (n) j=tr,a,f

    J J no J

    5 5 n 5

    I 'T,n; = Z ( To , n o ) +AI (T> j=tr,a,f

    : J no J

    4

    AZ in) = n^ajn' - ojn + cj ; j=tr,a,f

    J

    5

    AI (T; = n(AjT= + BjT + Cj ;

    J

    where:

    Cnj=g/ cm- LTj=f , no=0.3 g/cm- To=2l00 t -

    The correlation coefficients a j , b j , c j , A j , Bj , Cj have oeen

    estimated by using the previous ANISN calculations.

    The results a re reported m Tab. 3 . 4 .

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    29/115

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    30/115

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    31/115

    (Proget toprotect

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER

    Identihca^vodocument re

    RD-12-01-FNPR

    Rev Pagmarev page

    1 28

    b) reactivity changes due to changes in reactor power over tne

    power range of operations;

    c) reactivity changes due to fuel depletion;

    d) reactivity associated to the minimum shutdown margin.

    The reactivity cha nge associatea to each item is reported in Tab.

    3.8.

    The integral worth of the movab le reflector has oeen evaluated

    by means of the reactor calculations: an uncertainty of about 107.

    has been associated to the results.

    The reactivity change between CZF and hZF does not appear

    to be significant oecause in this reactor the Doooier effect has

    been consiaered only for UZTS , as in the GAM library there

    isn't any information about the Doooier effect in UZT5.

    Finally, since it is not in the scope of this preliminary

    analysis to mai e accurate assumptio ns about the system operatin g

    modes. it has been supposed that the reactor is operated

    at full power level contmuosly.

    It has been estimated that, with a 3300 pern of reactivity change

    available for deplet ion, reactor life is limited to a few

    hours because of the strong Xenon poisoning that affects this

    type of c ore. This time is a function of the UFo overall

    plant/core mass ratio as shown m Fig. 3.9.

    The full power level can be restored after an interval of time

    whose length depends on the operational strategy; the process can

    be repeated until fuel depletion allows it.

    o

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    32/115

    Proget toproiect

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER

    Identificativodocument no

    RD-12-01-FNPR

    Rev Paginarev page

    1 29

    Fig 3.10 snows tne evolution of reactivity after a snutoown

    pertormea at the eno of the first lifetime at full power , wnose

    length is about 5 nours . In tnis cas e, whicn is referrea to a

    UFfc mass ratio of 5, tne time reauireo for reactivity to pecome

    positive again is approximately 30 hours from snutaown: tnis

    waiting time is reducea by increasing the mass ratio.

    The minimum value of reactivity that occur s 9 nours after

    Shutdown in Fig. 3. 10, corresponding to a maximum of the Xe

    concentration, is explained by tne presence of a source of Xel35,

    tne raoioacti ve oecay of 1135, in competition witn its

    aisaopearance aue to aecay to Csl35.

    So

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    33/115

    Progetto Identificativo Rev Pagmaproiect Ml,/^T IT A n n u n r

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    34/115

    Pro getto Identificativo Rev Pagmaproiect document no rev oaoe

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR i ^ 31

    C8] Joanou G.D .D . and Dude> J. 5. , GAM-II-A B3 Code for the

    Calculation of Fast Neutron Spectrum and Associated

    Muitigroup Constants , GA - 4265 Seotemoer 1963.

    C93 G.D. Jo anou et al . , GATriER-II, An IBM 7090 Fortran- II

    Program for the ComDutation of Thermal-Neutron Spectra and

    Associated Multigrouo Cross Sections , GA-4i32 1963.

    [IOJ Orer 0. ana Garber D. , ENDF/B Summary D ocumentation,

    ENDF-20r'. BNL 17451, Brool

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    35/115

    Proget toproject

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER

    Identificativodocument no

    RD-12-01-FNPR

    R e v P a g m arev page

    1 32

    Tab. 3.1 Radial temperature profile in the core

    reference configuration.

    Radi al Rang e (*)

    (cm )

    Material Average Temperature

    (K)

    50.0-53.5

    53.5-56.5

    56.5-60.0

    60.0-63.5

    63.5-66.0

    66.0-70.0

    70.0-80.0

    80.0-110.0

    Graphite

    BeO

    Zr-Nb

    Be

    2200

    1500

    1200

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    36/115

    ProgettoprO)Cl

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER

    IdentificativodOCuTieil nc

    RD-12-01-FNPR

    Tab . 3.2 Mass and volume summary for thecore reference configuration.

    Rv Fac: 'arev pao*

    1 ' 33

    Reactor Material Average

    Density

    (kr3/dm3)

    Volume

    (dm3)

    Masr,

    (kg)'

    o f

    Tota l Mass

    UF6 0.20 1723 500 1.9

    T 2 M

    Cr.-pl->ito

    UcO

    10.IG

    1.71

    3.02

    : .G3

    1320

    1317

    20

    2 2 5 7

    3 9 7 7

    0.1

    8.51^.9

    ,r-Nb alloy

    Dc

    6.5

    1.B5

    1634

    5012

    10G21

    9 2 7 2

    39 .8

    3-1. e

    Tota l Reac to r Mass 2G65G 100.0

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    37/115

    i

    5

    T

    r

    5

    r

    X r

    ^

    ~

    fN

    r

    .T

    T

    XO

    c

    *

    -

    T

    xr.CCC

    J

    ^T

    .^

    x;

    ~

    7 r

    ^

    z

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    38/115

    Progettoproiect

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER

    Identificativodocument no

    RD-12-01-FNPR

    Re v Pagmarev page

    1 35

    Tao . 3.4 C c r r e l a t i o n c c e f f :c ler.t 3

    c r 3 5 5 s e c t i o n u p d a t e .

    -.r.e ma cr cs cc oi c

    f o r

    1k

    t r

    k

    r

    33

    . 5 7 0 5 5 - 3 3

    . 1 1 1 5 5 - 3 7

    . 5 5 7 4 5 - 3 3

    ^ '

    - . 1 3 4 9 3 - 0 4

    - . 2 5 4 9 5 - C 4

    - . 1 3 3 8 5 - 0 4

    C3

    . 1 3 9 7 6 - 0 1

    . 2 7 7 1 7 - 0 1

    . 1 3 3 9 1 - 0 1

    f o r

    Ft r

    k'f

    O-a

    A J

    . 7 5 1 5 3 - 0 1

    . 8 9 4 3 3 - 3 1

    . 5 8 1 3 9 - 0 1

    3 J

    - . 7 9 9 3 0 - 0 1

    - . 9 3 4 1 4 - 0 1

    - . 6 0 5 2 3 - 0 1

    C J

    . 1 7 5 3 9 - 0 1

    . 2 0 4 0 1 - 0 1

    . 1 3 1 9 9 - 0 1

    so5

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    39/115

    t h M P E R A n i H H S

    1 4 b I E1 4 S i FI Of , 1 F1 4 h / F1 1 / O t1 4 H . LI O -J ^ LI ' . n O F

    1 s 1 ; F' s a n tI b 4 b tI ' . ( ) J F' ' .H 1 I11,11 ; 'e11> (. ' (H > 4 / II / H i t1 / *j r t

    (14 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 u o DO (10 n o (14 U4 t j o II .1 1)0 00 0 0 DO U J

    ooootoooot0 0 0 0 1 :i b j o eI ' j b O h' ' i 3 H F) > 7 4 F

    ' / 0 2 tt / 7 O t

    1 H 4 7 E1 'J n o K? r i 3 ? F? 1 9 4 E/ J S . M :2 3 9 ' Li i o o o eU i l O O L

    0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 0 4 0 4 0 4 0 4

    0 4 0 4 0 4 0 4 0 4 0 4 0 0 0 0

    1 4 5 1I 0 ',.I Oh II 4 h /1 4 7 41 O b JI 4

    1 ' . 9 111 l> 1 .)

    I ( .0 ;1 (>BHI / H ' >1 H 9 ' .1 'J u :>

    E ' O Or 0 0r. 0 0E ^ O Ofc 0 4I U 0r 0 0

    1 0

    O O O O FO O O O Lo o o o t1 f a 4 J t1 t j J 4 t1 b 7 7 eu> ;> 0 F1 7 a 7 EI 7 9 I F1 7 / t

    l 9 i O L^ 0 0 () F? 1 4 ? r

    2 4 i y EO O O O Fo o o o to o o o t

    0 0 00 0 0 0 4 0 4 0 4 0 4 0 4 0 4 0 4

    0 4 0 4 0 0 0 4 00 0 0 1101 00

    1 4 5 1 t1 0 S ( , FI 0 6 2 F1 0 b 9 i

    . 1 0 H 11 L1 0 -J / I

    . I ' . U I M

    . t S < .' 11 -, r, H F1 "l H b FI t.1 1 2 F

    1 t) J> ) l1 t . l i / 11 / l i s t1 / 7 U1 'H I 1 '2 0 ^ . .

    . 2 U .1 J 1.

    0 0 n o 0 0 0 4. 0 4. 0 0< 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 0 0

    0 0. I ) . l. 0-1t o o

    . 114 0 0. O'l

    O O O O FO O O O Eo o o o to o o o t180 7 t1 6 0 0 F1 (>')HF1 7 9 F > Fi a 9 0 t1 9 H ' . F

    2 0 ( > H t2 I'D 1 C2 2 .1 ll 17 U i O l2 0 / 7 1 ;o o o o tO O O t OO O O O L

    0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 0 4 0 4 0 0 0 4 0 4

    0 4 0 0. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

    . 1 O-b If .1 0 S ' i tI S O ( > t

    . 1 b 1 ' i t

    . I b b / l

    . l b ' , H I

    . l ' > l , l . l

    . 1 S H H I

    . 1 6 1 3 1

    . I b J H F

    . I b b O F

    . 1 b ' ) 2 (1 / 2 0 1

    . 1 / 7 ' , (

    . I H 7 0 1

    . 2 l ) 2 H t

    . 2 1 2 2 12 1 )

    0 4 0 0 0 4 0 0 0 0 O-^. 0 0 0 01 0 0 0 41 0 41 0 . 1I n o1 n o n o 0 0 0 0. o o

    1 2

    O O O O FO O O O Fo o o o tO O O O L18 J 2 t1 b H 3 F1 7 t > . l l1 8 / H II 9 H 2 I2 0 7 2 L

    2 I b O l2 2 2 b t2 3 0 2 r2 4 1 S I2 b J 0 Lo o o o tO i i O O lO O O O L

    o n 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 0 4 0 4 0 0 0 0 0 4

    0 4 1)4 0 0 0 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 o o

    I O S I [

    1 ' l ' , ' > l

    1 o ( , n iI O b . F1 ( i ' j 2 t1 > I 111 II o 0 ' . . L1 l . / b l1 t . ' i O FI b / '1 FI 7 n 2 (

    1 7 3 .111 7 / 1 1' H ) / I1 I . l l

    2 1 2 0 12 1 7 (IO O O O L

    1 i

    0 0 no no 0 0 0 0 oo (10 0 0 0 0 04 0 0

    . 0 0I 0 0111 0. D O no no un

    O O O O FO O O O Fo o o o to o o o to o o o t1 7 7 1 F1 H 2 2 11 ^ 2 7 t. ' i 2 M t2 1 1 ) t

    2 1 H 7 I2 2 ' , H 12 \?ni2 0 2 01o n o n io n o n io i m n iO O O O L

    0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 n o n o 0 4 0 4 0 0

    0 0> 0 0 o o 0 0 0 0< 0 0t o o 0 0

    o o o o t1 O ' . ' l f1 0 < > 0 l

    . 1 O b ' l l

    . 1 O O O l

    . 1 0 ' i 0 1

    . 1 0 2 2 11 ( , 3 H F1 b b f l F

    . 1 7 0 I F

    . 1 7 3 b F

    . 1 7 / 2 t

    . 1 M 1 111

    . 1 ' 1 0 0 12 l l O ' ) l2 I ' l H I

    . 2 2 0 ' ) lO O O O L

    0 0, n o n o 0 4 0 0< n o 0 0 0 4 0 0 0 4 0 0

    114 0-1. 0 0

    . n o o o 0 01 o n

    O O O O FO O O O F0 0 0 0 10 0 0 0 10 0 0 0 12 0 3 ' ) l1 ') 7 212 0 3 3 F2 10 112 1 0 / 1

    ^ / ) 0 I2 2 ' l ) l2 1 ' , / I2 0 ' , H I( I I I O O I0 1 1 0 0 1o o o o tO O O O L

    > O I I 0 0 0 0 0 0

    0 0 o o n o 0 0 0 0 0 4

    0 0. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o o. o o

    , 0 0 0 0 1o o o o t1 t^iri'ji

    . 1 4 H ' ) 1

    . 1 4 'J'.) 1

    . 1 ' , 11 0 1

    . 1 S 3 t . l1 '> '>0 I

    . 1 b O H t

    . M i M M t

    . 1 7 0 9 t

    . l H n 2 LI H l . ' l tI ' l H O I. I ' . ' l l2 2 1 . 7 1o i i n o i

    . O O O O L

    0 0 n o. n o 0 0> 0 4 0 4 0 0 0 4 0 4 0 4 0 4

    OO. 0 0. OO1 n o 11 1

    n o 0 0

    15

    O O O O FO o o o to o o o to o o o to o o o to o o o t2 1 4 . 12 I H I F2 2 0 H F2 2 4 ' j L

    2 2 9 O 12 1 0 / L2 ) ) 7 12 0 ' l 2 tO O O O FO O O O FO O O O LO O O O L

    0 0 0 0 0 0 OO o o o o. 0 0 o o 0 4 OO

    OO 0 01 0 0 0 0< 0 0' 0 0. 0 0

    > o u

    Tab. 3.5 Temperature distribution in the reactor cavity.External reflector 10 0% in anti 65 % of the fuelthrough the annular diffuser.

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    40/115

    I L M P F H A 1 UHti>

    Z-

    I B1 7IC1 ')1 01 i1 Z

    1 1lO

    9n/t 0 0 ' . l ' , / 3 t . 0 0 ' 1 0 1 , 5 1 ' O Ol ^ / H t ' . l O ' I O H ' , 1 I M I ' . I ' . / b l . 0 0 ' 11 , / 1 , 1 . 11 01 4 H H I m o 1 0 0 ( 1 1 n o ' I ' . i . / i . n o i b i ' , i . n oI ' . O O F t O O ' 1 5 1 1 , 1 . 11 .1 ' 1 5 / 7 1 n o l b , ' 7 l t n o1 . 1 7h 0 0 ' . 1 ' . 0 11 . 0 0 ' . 1 bO I I 0 4 ' . 1 1,0.11 . 0 01 5 3 / 1 ' 0 0 ' 1 ' . / 11 . 1 ) 0 . i b 3 . ' i ' O O ' M j i . ' j t . n oI ' . b O l . n o ' 11 ,11 0 1 .11.1 . 1 b b 1 1 0 0 ' 1 1 , 1 / 1 . n o1 5 H b l > 0 0 ' . 1 1 , l l . l . l l - l ' . 1 0 9 1 1 OO . 1 / . / 1 . n o

    1 b 1 o t n o 11 . b i l l . n o 1 7 2 3 F 0 0 ' . 1 7 b 1 1 . 0 0I b 4 2 t + O 0 ' . l / O l l . l l O ' I 7 b 0 1 0 0 ' . I H O O I ' O O1 b 7 9 + 114 ' 1 74 / I n o ' . 1 H 1 01 0 4 ' . 1 H b ' . l < 0 41 7 .131 no 1 u 1 /1 no ' . 1 90111 > no . i I O M I . no

    I H . i . l . 1 10 ' l ' ) . ) i . 1 1 0 ' . ' 1 1 . " . i . 1 ) 0 . i m o i . n oI ' l i i i i " O O . . '1 1 . ' n i . ( i . i ' . ' D ' j M . n o ' . ' 1 1 1 1 . n o1 9 3 11 0 0 ' .2 n i i n . n o ' . 2 i n .' i . n 0 ' n n 11 n i < n n

    10 11 ' 12 ' 13

    O o o o t 0 0 ' . n o o o t ^ o o . o o o o t . n o . o o ( i o t o oO O OO l + 0 O ' . 0 0 (1 1 0 ' O O ' . o o o o L ' i H ) ' . o n o n t . o OO O O O ) > O o . i i O M i i i . 0 0 ' o n o n i . o n ' . n n o n i . o n1 1 . 2 5 1 . 0 0 . n n o n i . o n o o n n i > i i n . i i n n i K . n nt b l 5 F t ( ) 0 1 / 0 / ( M I O ' . i H d . i . n o ' ( n i n n l ' n i i1 ' i i 3 n o . u . 1 ' J l . no ' . 1 1 , 5 , - i no i / ^ i i no1 ' . 9 71 0 4 . 1 b ' i b L o o . 1 7 1 . ' 1 . 0 0 . 1 / ' , ) l 0 01 1,1.4 1- 0 4 . 1 / . I ' l l < 0 0 ' . 1 I I O H I 0 0 . 1 11.) 1 t . 0 01 / 3 b 1 I JO ' . 1 H / , L m o . 1 H ' l b l 0 0 > 1 ' ) 1 0 t 0 0I B O ' H O O I O O O ' ^ J O O ' l ' ) / ' , l O O ' l O ' K l t . 1 1 0I H 8 4 F 0 0 ' . 1 ' I H l F t O O ' . 2 0 0 ' I F . I I O ' 2 0 ( , I . F < n O1 9 t , 5 0 4 ' . 2 0 ' . ' J I 0 0 ' . 2 1 2 .11 0 0 ' . 2 1 l o t 0 02 n b O t < 0 0 . 2 1 0 1 1 O O . 2 1 9 3 1 O O 2 2 O . ' t < l l 02 1 9 5 t ^ 0 4 ' . 2 2 5 3 L + 0 0 ' . 2 2 H 3 1 ' O O . 2 2 H ' , . l ' 0 0. '3 1 10 1 D O ' . 2 . l 5 0 t ^ ( 1 0 . 2 3 9 , 1 1 . 0 0 ' . 0 I 1 0 0 L ( I 0O O o n l 11 1) ' . 0 0 1 1 0 1 . 0 0 . o o o o t . 1 1 0 ' . 1 1 0 1 ) 01 . o n n no o o o t l O O ' n o o n i o o ' . O o O O i ' < o O o n o o i . 0 0

    b

    O O O O F ^1 4 5 H t1 0 b < 11 0 11 / 11 0 / M l1 O ' l O l1 b < ) ) l ll b ' . 2 l -1 b l l l U1 7 10 11 / ' . 111

    1 / H i l l1 H .1 i t1 '1 1 1 1. ' ) i n i.' 1 O ' . l.- 1 ' . ( , 1o o o n i

    1 4

    o n o o tO O O O ln o i i i i in 0 n 111o o n n i1 1 . I l l1 H i . n i1 9 1 1 11') / . '12 0 3 ' i l

    2 I ) ' 1 H I2 1 b 1 12 2 .' .' 12 3 l ) ' ) lo n o n in n n n to o n n i1 n l

    o n . 1 )4 '

    no 'n o 1n o >n o '0 0 0 0 'n o 1n o 0 0 >

    no 'n o b f t t I o n < j*m* I (1 t 1

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    46/115

    WD 00123

    C o r r e l a t i o n

    C o e f f i c i e n t s

    F i r s t 9 u e s s p o w e r D e n s i t y d i s t r i but 1 on I

    d e n s i t y O i s t r i t i o t i o n

    t e i T . p e r a t o r e o i s t r i i m t i o '

    F u e i c r o s s s e c t i o n

    o p d a t e

    p o w e r d e n s i t y d i s t r i pi. t i o.

    1- - e f f c t 1 ve

    c o n v e t y e n c t-

    c n p c I-

    I y

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    47/115

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    48/115

    Progettoproiect

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER

    Identificativodocument no

    RD-12-01-FNPR

    Rev Pagmarev page

    1 45

    ^ R A D l U S - ^ 7 . 9 6 C MO R A D I U S - 4 3 . 6 0 C MX R A D I U S - 3 8 . 7 3+ R A D I U S = 3 3 . 1 7 C MA . R A D I U S = 2 6 . 4 5 C M

    O R A D I U S = 2 2 . 3 6 C MCD R A D I U S = 8 C M

    I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 e ee 4t .Be te .e a i?.ee lee .ee 2*e.ee z^O'et ?i.ae 32e.e

    Z A X I S ( C M )

    F i p 3. 6 P o w e r d e n s i t y v s . a x i a l c o o r d , f r o m c o r e i n l e t ) a t d i f f e r e n t r a d i a lc o o r d i n a t e s .

    E x t e r n a l r e f l e c t o r 1 0 0 % i n and 6 5 % o f t h e f u e l t h r o u g h t h e a n n u l a rd i f f u s e r .

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    49/115

    Proget toprotect

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER

    Identificativodocument no

    RD-12-01-FNPR

    Revrev

    Pagmapage

    4 6

    X

    --

    o

    RADlUS-47.96 CMRADIUS43.60 CMRADlUS-38.73RADIUS=33.I7 CMRADIUS=26.45 CMRADIUS=22.36 CMRADlUS=e CM

    Z AXIS (CM)

    Fig. 3.7 Power density vs . axial coord, (from core inlet) at different radialcoordinates .External reflector out and 65% of the fuel through the annular diffuser.

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    50/115

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    51/115

    M O 0 0 1 2 3

    1 0

    8 -

    t (H)

    5 -

    T

    2T -8

    T -

    10

    t : t imem: UF6 Overall Plant/Core Mass ratio

    Fig. 3.9 Reactor life vs. UF6 Overall Plant/Core Mass ratio.

    Reactor operated at full power level continuously.

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    52/115

    Proget topcoieci

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER

    Identificativooocument no

    RD-12-0 : -FNPP

    Rev Paginarev page

    1 49

    "If";" -

    ~ - n ^ -

    1 t '- -1 -

    _-

    , - - ^- -

    - - -n r-

    - - - V -

    t

    \

    \\

    11

    1k 1

    11

    |

    '11

    V

    ~-^

    1

    11

    11

    11 ,1

    1

    '

    1

    ' i1 11 ^

    '

    >I

    ,

    1

    11

    1. _,--< '

    11

    1, 1

    'J-

    j

    ^-'

    1

    1i

    1

    Mr

    45

    Fig. 3.10 Reactivity vs . time (UF6 mass ratio = 5) .

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    53/115

    Pro getto Identificativo Rev Paginaproject document no rev .paoe

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR 1 50

    WORK'INB FLUID CHARACTERISTICS

    4.1 Symb ols, Terms and Abbreviations

    n

    ni

    rei

    NumDer o-f particles pe r unit volume

    0 Collision c o r s section

    V Particl e velocity

    (\jn Nurioer ot neutral molecules pe r unit volume

    0 heiombination coe++ici ent

    T Temperature

    ne Number o+ electrons pe r unit volume

    Number of ions oer unit volume

    NumDer o-f primarv electrons D sr unit volume

    Tnermalization time between electrons ana

    ion =

    Quantity in tne e. pres sion fo'' thermal izat ion

    time

    t Eoltzmann s constant

    m Electron mass

    A Ion mass in amu

    M Ion mass

    e EiBctron charge

    r Quantity in the e'ioression -for coulomb

    collisions

    eo Energy ot primary electrons

    Tp TemDerature oi primary electrons

    So

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    54/115

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    55/115

    Progetto Identificativo Rev. Pagmaproject . , _ , _ . _ . _ . _ . _ document no rev page

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR 1 52

    4.2 Phase I

    This phase provided a qualitative assessment of the types of

    primary reaction s considered as the most import ant, and the

    evaluation of the relevant cross-section s, using current

    literature data and theoretical models.

    The Production of Primary Electrons

    Wnenever 235U unaergoe s a fission reaction a number of ionizing

    agents sre generated. Fission fragments are the most imoortant as

    they aosorb arouna 80/. of the energy rele asee. Tne energy balance

    of a fission reaction is illustrated in TABLE 1 (oata Are

    essentially similar for thermal or fast fission reactions ana for

    th e two uranium isotooes)CI].

    TABLE 1

    1. Fission Fragment s 165 MeV

    2. Prompt gamma rays (bremmstrahlung) 7 MeV

    3. Delayed gamma rays (discrete spect rum) 6 MeV

    4. fi+ and (i- rays 7 MeV

    5. Neutrons 5 MeV

    6. Neutrino s 10 MeV

    TOTAL 200 MeV

    8o

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    56/115

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    57/115

    ^'of," 'aentificativo R ^^ PagmaNUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER document no R D - 1 2 - 0 1 - F N P R '* ' l '^^^*

    These pr imary io ni za t io ns sre mo stly maae up oy "s t ri p p in g " an

    ele ct r on wi th out moaifym g the molecular or a tomic s t ru ct ur e of

    t h e t a rg e t .

    4.3 Phase I I

    Tnis Phase aaaressea tne study of the rate eauations in tne

    reactor core, provioing an ap or oM ma te analytical solution, and

    Identifying tne critical p arameters.

    Tne Froouction of Seconaary Electrons

    The orimary electrons give rise to processes sucn as elastic and

    inelastic scattering (excitation of bo nding electro ns in the

    molecule), secondary ionization, and recombination.

    Elastic scattering is low at energie s greater than 10

    eV and can be almost neglected in most case s. The

    inelastic scatte ring, on the other hand, is a very important

    reaction channel since it absorbs around 2/3 of the primary

    electron energy. This value is difficult to be computed or

    measured. It depends on the energy and on the struct ure of the

    molecules: data available in literature give a ratio between

    ionization and inelastic collision cross sections of 0.2 - 0.5

    C3]. These reactions are part of the gas thermalization and

    heating proc ess.

    So

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    58/115

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    59/115

    Pro ge tto Identificativo Rev Paginaproiecl document no rev page

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR 1 55

    Recombination

    The neutralization prooability of the ionized system is

    related to the product of the electronic density , the

    ionic density, ana the density of a third element essential

    for energy ana momentum conservation C4 ]. This third element may

    be either a neutral atom or an ion, or even an electro n. Tne

    higher mobility of the electrons maKes tne following the

    preferred recompination process in our case :

    ne t ne + ni ne ni

    Tnis parameter is extremely' sensitive to the density ana

    temperature of the system.

    The rate of recombination can be expressed by the following

    relation:

    dn/dt = - 'xn

    whe re a = lOe-ZSn/T''-= , n is the electron (or ion) dens ity per

    cm- and T is the temperature expressed in eV.

    Note the depend ence upon n- (the coefficien t is linearly

    related to n ) , which reminds that recombination is a three-body

    process [5j.

    sQ

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    60/115

    Pro ge tto Identificativo Rev Pagmaproject document no rev oaae

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR i 57

    The dependence on T is very strong because the electron velocity

    IS the other hey parameter to the problem , both when calculating

    the cross-section and when successively calculating the

    average on the velocity distribution, necessary to determine the

    probability per second of the proce ss.

    Simplified Rate Equation

    The effects of recomoination and ionization may be combined into

    a rate eouation for the electronic part of the system:

    dn/dt = nO v>Ng - an^

    Supstituting tne numerical values into tne aoove eouation

    yields:

    dn/ dt = n 3.10el3 TJT - lOe-25 n-/T*-=

    Ng was assumed to be 5.10e20 molecules per cm-.

    Let us now suppose to be under steady state conditions

    (hence neglecting dn /d t ) .

    This assumption requires that a unique equilibrium temperature

    exists, at least among the various ionized species, and that the

    time to reach such conditions is much shorter than the time

    during which the gas remains in the reactor core. In fact.

    So

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    61/115

    Prog etto Identificativo Rev PaginaP'OI'Ct unnivno ttun oo nr i7 r.Tr . r. documen t no _ r ev page

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR 1 58

    electrons arouna 500 eV, electron s of a few eVs (secondary), and

    ions at almost the same temperature of the gas coexist curing a

    first phase.

    however, as we snail see better afterwards, tne condition s in tne

    reactor core lead to extremely short thermalization times

    compared with the transit time of the gas, and hence, in spite of

    the simple approac h, this first evaluation may be consiaered

    quite realistic.

    Let us now introduce the energy balance, that is determinea by

    tne distribution of the ionization and thermalization energies:

    ynoSOO = n(T+I) = ncT+10) = vZ.B-lOeZl

    where v-'l is the part of energy involved in ionizatio n p roce sses

    and I IS assumea to oe eaual to 10 eV, a value typical of most

    atoms and molecules.

    The rate eo uation, once inserted into th e balance eouatio n.

    gives:

    T=' '=.(T+10J = 165v => T = 2.8y=-''=

    Similarly, the implicit value of the electronic density

    can be found:

    n = 6-10e5(2.G-10e20y-n)=-'

    o

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    62/115

    Pro getto Identificativo Rev Pagmaproject document no rev oaoe

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR i 59

    which yields approximately

    n = 2.6-10e20y

    It should be noted that the recombinatio n process is

    active, above all, at low t emperatures. However, the

    process temperature is o et er mm eo critically througn

    the parameter y. The con ventional thermal region

    (T 4000 C) IS indicated by values of y less than lOe-2.

    Tneref ore, the critical parameter that must be

    calculated is the actual distribut ion of energ y between the

    ionization and thermalization processes or, if one prefers, the

    electron equilibrium temperature.

    Thermalization Times

    Whet remains to be seen is whether the secondary electrons, which

    still have sufficien tly high energy , of the order of 2-3 eV, can

    thermalize tand hence recombine/ rapidly or not.

    The electron-ion thermalization time decreases with the

    temperature according to the following relationship C53:

    Tei = (tT)-''=

    where 6 is given by [5] as:

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    63/115

    Progetto Identificativo Rev Pagma

    ' ^ " " ' NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER ' " * " ' ^ " ' " RD- 12-0 1-FN PR ' " 1 ' eO

    3 m ^ ' - 1 6 3 2 A

    8 ( 2 T T ) > '= e * l o g r

    where m is the electron mass, e the electron charge, A the ion

    mass in a.m.u., and logP a parameter which varies slightly with

    density and temperat ure (it is related to the smallest collision

    parameter in a Coulomb interaction;. In tne case of U F D . tne

    value of

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    64/115

    Pro ge tto Identificativo Rev PagmaP'dject . , _ , _ . , . , document no re v page

    NUCLEAR M HD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR 1 61

    Complete Rate Eauations

    The complete rate eauations tafe actually into account only a

    few of the numerous possible reactions in the system. On the

    basis of the cross-section experimental data and of the analysis

    reported in the previous paragraphs, we selected the reactions

    which were consiaered as the most significant for the

    purpose of this stuoy.

    reaction s such as the multiple ionization of atoms or molecules

    have been neglected. In otner words, only UFi, UFit (with i=0,6;

    ana F- type systems are considered and possible states such as

    UFi-, UFi+t, etc. ar e neglected.

    Under this assumption, there ar e 16 unknown parameters in tne

    problem:

    ni =UFi/cm' ( 7 variables ) ,

    ni+=UFi-t-/cm~ ( 7 vari ao les ',

    nf = F/cm',

    nf2 = FZ/cm',

    nf- = F-/cm' (3 variables),

    m addition to n that represents, as before, the number of free

    electrons. Therefore IS equations are required to solve the

    system as a function of three basic input paramet ers: Ng (gas

    density in the reactor) , no (number of primary electrons) and the

    average primary radiation energy eo = 500 eV.

    The rate equations provide 17 relations, one for each variable;

    the energy balance yields the missing condition (system

    neutrality is implicit in the rate equations).

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    65/115

    Progetto Identificativo Rev Paginapro ject . , . , _ , _ . _ . _ , ^^^,-r,T^r^^^ document no rev page

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER RD -12-01-FNPR 1 62

    Method of Solution

    Before proceeding, it is necessary to discuss some assumptions

    that should be introduced in a numerical approach to tne

    evaluation of ionization levels and gas composition in the

    cavity.

    1) The system is homogeneous.

    This IS a good appro;; imati on given the parameters of

    the reactor and the properties of the system being examinee.

    In fact, the mass transfer rates are very small m comparison

    with two significant fluid parameters, tne tnermal

    transfer rate and the speed of sound; in addition, the

    thermalization processes tate place on small space

    scales, of the oraer of a few cms. Hence, tnere is no use in

    introaucing the convection terms into the rate eauation s. and

    considering the unknowns as a function of position.

    2) The system is under steady state conditio ns.

    This assumption is undoubtedly true when considering the

    thermalization time scale (lOe-9 s), and allows the rate

    equations to be simplified considerably by neglecting the time

    dependence of the variables.

    3) Cross-section values.

    In our approach, there are 46 cross- sectio ns (which are strongly

    energy dependent) constituting a set of input parameters to the

    problem. They are not variables but physical quantit ies that can

    be experimentally measured. In any case, these parameters are not

    8o

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    66/115

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    67/115

    Proget toproject

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER

    Identificativodocument no

    RD-12-01-FNPR

    Rev Paginarev page

    1 64

    1) gas density is uniform during tne transit time in tne

    channel;

    2) a uniform distribution of fission reactions provides a

    uniform background of primary electron s (500 eV;;

    3) as a first approa ch, the secondary soecies are supposed to

    derive essentially from the ionization of UF6. Therefore, tne

    maximum level of cnarge density cannot overcome gas aensitv.

    Tne conseauences of tnis statement will oe oiscusseo later:

    4; tne loss of electr ons is ascripea to tnree-ooav

    recomoination:

    5; since tne local neutrality conoition is well verifieo

    because of tne very short Deo ve length comoared with plasma

    dimensi ons, it is assumed ne=ni for secondary charge s.

    Even a simplified approach reouires to solve the system giving

    the thermal exchange rates among tne ionized soecies . Since

    charge density is variable, the energy balance must be couoleo to

    the rate eouation for electron production:

    dTp

    no

    dt

    noTp - neTs noTp - neTi

    ree Tpei

    tl;

    dTs

    ne

    dt

    noTp - neTs neTs - neTi

    Tee Tsei

    (2)

    8o

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    68/115

    Pro gett o Identificativo Rev Pagmapro ject . , , , _ , _ . _ . _ ,_ , _ _ . . _ _ _ _ document no rev page

    NUCLEAR M H D CONVERTER RD-1 2-01-FNPR 1 6 5

    Oil noip - neii nets - neii

    ne = ^^^^ * _ ^

    at Toei Tsei

    one a e \ p ( - I / T p ; e x p ( - I / Ts ;

    = Not no

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    69/115

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    70/115

    Pro getto Identificativo Rev Pagmaproject , , _ , _ . _ . _ . _ - , . , - _ _ , _ document no rev page

    NUCLEAR M HD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR 1 67

    dTi m t5Ng R m Tp R

    = - [Tp - - Ts - -( ;--= (Ts-Ti)-] u>

    dt M yTo -= ('j M Ts (1

    oR aNg(l-R) expt-I/Tp; exD (-I/Ts) oNg^R-

    = C (j f R] - (S;

    at I T D ' ~ T51 ~ Ts -

    The assumption of a uniform aensitv oistrio ution. reiatea

    to the rather flat profile of gas density during tne transit

    in tne chan nel, allows one to neglect tne contribution of tne

    terms Vg.gra atT) ana Vg.graatn; in com parison witn tne time

    oerivatives. Tnerefore, an elementary volume of fluia is

    modified in its properties oefore aopreciap le deplacement

    takes place. As a consequence, tne integration in time is

    equivalent to follow the space evolution, with the variaoie

    Change x=Vg.t. It turns out that a non-uniform source of

    primary electro ns can be included m the mod el, unoer tne

    condition that the induced gradient s still verify the inequality

    Vg.grad(T)>NaT/at ana Vg.graa(n;^^dn/dt. For instance, in the

    presence of a step distributio n of the fission sour ce in

    a length xo, it is sufficient to introdu ce, in the solution

    of the system, the condition no=0 for t^xo/Vg. Alternatively,

    the system can oe solved in the space variable by

    introducing dx=Vg. dt. In gene ral, it is not strictly

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    71/115

    Pro getto Identificativo Rev PagmapfOtoct _ document no rev , oaoe^ ^ N UC LE AR MH D C O NV E RT E R o ocu e . o p D - 1 2 - O l - F N P R 1 6 8

    required that gas velocity and density ar e uniform ano

    constant; it is sufficient that significant variations of Vg

    and density occur in a time longer than the time required to

    reach a stationary state for Tp, Ts , Ti , and R.

    8o

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    72/115

    Pro getto Identificativo Rev Pagmaproject document no rev oaoe

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR l 69

    t.^ References

    CI] Gladstone, Nuclear Reactor Tneory , Fergamon Press, 1964.

    C2] Ziegler J.P., Stopping Power and Ranges in Elemental

    Matter , Fergamon Press, 1977 - 1981.

    C3] Golant V.E. , Zilinskij A.P. , Sacharov I.E., Osnovy fiziki

    olasmy ( Fundamentals of Plasma Physics ) , MIR, Moscow, It .

    transl. 1963.

    C4] Zeidovicn ano R aizer, Fhysics of Shoc^ Wave and hign

    Temperature hvoroovnamic Phenome na . Acaoemic Press, New

    York , I'v&fi.

    C5] Spitzer L., Physics of Fully Ionized Gase s , Inters cience,

    New York, 1956.

    8o

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    73/115

    Pro getto Identificativo Rev Pagmapro ject , , _ , . _ . _ , _ ^ . _ . _ _ _ document no rev page

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER RD -12-01-FNPR 1 70

    5 ELECTRICAL COND UCTIVITY EFFECTS

    5.1 Symbols, Terms and Abbreviations

    Electrical conductivity

    Mc Mass of the superconducting coil

    Pg Power generated by the ht-iD channel

    oc Conouctor mean density

    po Permeability of free space

    J Current density

    L Channel length

    D Channel diameter

    u Gas velocity

    B Magnetic field strength

    Ms Mass of the magnet structure

    o Density of the structural material

    st Working stress level of the structural

    material

    TI Gas temperature at the compressor inlet

    0 Neutron flux along the duct

    0o Neutron flux at the entrance of the duct

    d Diameter of the entrance section of the duct

    X Axial coordinate along the ductUe Electron velocity

    Ui Ion velocity

    E Total electric field

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    74/115

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    75/115

    Proget toproject

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER

    Identificativodocument no

    RD-12-01-FNPR

    Rev Pagmarev page

    1 72

    Ti

    a,b

    no

    i

    nf

    t

    T

    I-

    a-

    Temperature of ions

    Coefficients in the rate equations

    Number of primary electrons per unit volume

    Ratio of no to Ng

    Number of primary electrons per fission

    Number of fissions per unit volume

    Time

    Time constant

    Attacnment energy

    Coefficient in the attachment equation

    8o

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    76/115

    Pro getto Identificativo Rev Pagma'^'*' i r , c * = u u n rr^n,T^oT^T, document no , ^ ^ , rev _ pageNUCLEAR M HD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR i 73

    5.Z Channel Charact eristics and Conduct ivity

    To proceed further in the analysis, it is necessary to combine

    conductivit y calculat ions with actual cnannel (ano nozzle;

    characteristics. In fact, the results of the former depeno

    directly on the latter, as channel and nozzle lengths, along with

    the density distributio n of the gas flowing through them, are

    required to solve the rate equatio ns (l)-(4; or (5)-(8) given in

    section 4.4. Furthermore, the same characteristics influence the

    distrib ution s of residual fission neutron s and gamma rays

    available in the duct which, in turn, provid e the source of

    primary electrons to be introduced in the rate eauatio ns. On the

    other hand, the channel operating charact eristics ar e largely

    dependent on the conouctivity levels assumed m tne analysis. For

    this reason, a parametric approach has been aoooted, and the

    generator perfo rmance has been estimated for two levels of

    con duct ivi ty , nam ely (r=10 and (r=100 (iim;~^. The n ozz le ano

    channel configurations arising from this process have been tested

    to verify if they were consistent with the conduct ivity levels

    resulting from the rate equations. Channel performance has been

    evaluated under the following assumptions:

    - Faraday configurat ion of the generator electrodes with a load

    factor of 0.9;

    - Straight channel with a constant aperture angle of 7*;

    - Nozzle inlet temperature and pressure of 2300 K and 15 M Pa,

    respectively;

    8o

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    77/115

    Progetto Identiticat ivo Rev Pagmapfoiecl , - , , , An uiirN /-./^t r-r^^r- flocumentno rev page

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR 1 74

    - Cnannel t'iow rate o-f 1000 Kg/s:

    A 1-D tnermal--fiuia moael ot tne cnannel ana nozzle aucts has

    Deen aoootea in tne analysis. For eacn o-f the two reference

    levels OT conoLCtiVItv, a numoer o-f cnannel con-figurations nave

    been comoareo as a -first aooroach oy using the soeci-fic ma ss

    relation given DV Rosa in Clj tor a cnannel o-f length L and

    oiameter D:

    Mc lo oc L 1 1

    F'Q UO J D F-g TTtrU'B -'*

    where pc is tne conouctor mean Density and J is the current

    densitv. Tnis relation gives tne mass o-f a suoerconauctin g coii

    oer unit o-f oeneratec oower. In tne conaitions o-f the analysis ,

    tne mass ot tne structure reauirea to noid the coil together

    should be comoaraoie witn tne coil mass given by Ea. ^1> A lower

    limit -for tne -former can be estimated witn the -following

    relation:

    M s = - j d v (2)

    S t J ).'0

    o

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    78/115

    Pro gett o Identificativo Rev PagmaP oiect Oocumeni no rev oaoe

    NUCLEAR M HD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPP i 75

    wnere p is the density and st is the wo r H n g stress level o-f the

    structural materi al. Tnis relation too is derived -from [IJ; tne

    stru ctur e unit m ass -for a saadle coil is e;;Dectea to be witnin a

    -factor 2 o-f tne val ue given by Ea. (2;.

    In aaaition to tne two levels o-f conducti vity mentionea above,

    the con-f igurations that have oeen investigatea ar s -featurea oy

    Oi-f-ferent values o-f tne inlet M acn num oer ana ina uct ion t'lela o-f

    the generator duct. The parameters assumeo in tne analysis enaole

    to e-;tract o ower in the 110-15 0 MwJe ran ge, limiting the inauction

    -fiela strengtn at reasona ole values (6 T at m o s t K ooserving the

    constra ints on the length to diameter ratio imoosea oy heat ana

    pressur e losses, ana oD taining a speci-fic mass u ro m Ea. i in

    the ran ge o-f 10e -2- 10e -3 Kg/klve. Tnis range is in the reacn o-f

    both re-ference level s o-f con ouct ivi tv: how eve r, a aecrease o-f cr

    must be o-f-fset oy a co rre spo nai ng var iati on o-f otner terms in Ea.

    ii). In partic ular, tne values ot u ana B are assumea as

    independent parameters , while L/D and Fg ar e aeri ved -from tne

    cal cul ati ons . It is evioent that a higher level o-f conou ctiv ity

    ma^es it possibl e to attain the desired range of power aensity

    with lower val ues o-f B and, esp eci all y, o-f u (and, hence , o-f the

    Mach numoer at the generator inlet). This latter condition

    appears to be o-f special importance, as a lower gas velocity in

    the channel means a shorter nozzl e be-fore the chann el. On the

    other hand, the distanc e between the generator and the reactor

    cav ity ha s a strong in-fluence on the actual level o-f

    conduct ivity. The results show that, i-f one pursues a high oower

    o

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    79/115

    Pro getto Identificativo Rev Pagmaproiect _ document no rev paae

    NUCLEAR M HD CONVERTER RD -12-01-FNPR 1 75

    density condition (that is, essent ially, a high value o-f (ru2) ,

    the system should work at a high conductivity , low velocity

    condition, rather than the opposite.

    It should be pointed out that sucn influen ce is not connected

    with the effect of the field on the reactor core, which is

    negligible, oue to the different order of magnitude of the

    fission ion gyro radius in comoarison with their mean free patn.

    In fact, tne nozzle length turns out to be of critical importance

    because of the snaro decrease of residual fission and gamma

    densities as a function of the distance from the reactor outlet.

    Finally, a few consiaerations aoout the parameters adootea in the

    analysis.

    Tne value of nozzle inlet temper ature (2300 K) has been partly

    assumed on the basis of material requirements, by analogy with

    conventional MHD converters, and partly to maintain an adeauate

    level of cycle efficiency with a high heat rejection temperature

    (Tl=600-900 K, Tl being the compressor inlet temperature), as a

    space-based system is expected to reouire. W i t h m this range of

    Tl and with the other cycle parameters indicated m this section,

    efficiency may vary between 0.12 ano 0.36, It should be stressed

    that cycle efficiency is heavily mf lu en ce a by heat rejection

    temperature and regenerator performance; both characteristics

    should be ultimately selected on the basis of minimum system

    mass, rather than maximum efficiency.

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    80/115

    Prog etto Identificativo Rev Pagmapfoiect flocument no rev cao e

    NUCLEAR M HD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR i 77

    The nozzle inlet pressure (15 MFa^ is eaual to the average

    operating pressure of the reactor , which was derived on the

    basis of an average reactor temperature and density of 20 00 K and

    0.3 g/cm-, respectively, Tne latter is the result of a

    preliminary estimate of criticity. The same calculations gave the

    cavity diameter (1 m) assumed in the neutron analy sis.

    The flow rate of 1000 kg/s results from the power output to be

    generated by the converter, assumed in the range 120-150 MWe

    gross and 20- 30 MWe net. The latter is actually a lower limit

    applicable to the highest rejection temperature assumea in the

    calculat ions: the net output increases to 60-8 0 Mw when Tl is

    lowered to 600 >-.

    Tne temperature of the gas at the reactor inlet U 7 7 0 \ ) has been

    obtained t hrough a preliminary an alysis of the working cycle, and

    it IS typical of regenera tive Brayton cycles operating between

    the temperature levels mentioned above. The same analysis gave

    the referenc e value of 277 MW for the thermal power provided by

    the reactor.

    5.3 Fission and Gamma Density in the Channel

    The fission and gamma power densities m the M HD expansion

    channel must be estimated to solve the rate equations ana

    evaluate the conductivity levels.

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    81/115

    Progetto Identificativo Rev Pagma' " " " ' NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER document no R D - 1 2 - 0 1 - F N P R ' " 1 ' " ' ' 7 5

    Fission rower Density

    Tne fission power aensity calculatio ns nave oeen carriea out D V

    means of tne following approximations:

    1. Preliminary evaluation witn a simpiifiea metnoa ^see he-f. L I J .

    pag. 2 9 0 ) ,

    2, SOuID- 360 L 3 ] Diffusion calculat ions witn a s i mon fi eo

    two-aimensionai t -Z geometry ana walls faoricatea from AlZu 3

    or BeO,

    In oraer to e stimate tne power aensit v, tne auct nas oeen

    oiviaeo into a f inite numoer of re gion s w itn aif-fe^ent u'b

    aensitv (see Fig. 5.1 ana Fig. 5.1' .

    For eacn region , tne fission macroscopic cross sections na^e

    oeen oerivea from tne core cross sections calcuiateo aur-ing

    Tasi- 1. reauceo oy tne appropriate density factors.

    Tne neutron fiu;- level insiae tne fiMD cnannel nas oeen

    calcuiateo as transmission tnrougn a cvlinaricai ouct.

    Freiiminarv evaluation . Tne neutron flu;;es at tne inlet of tne

    nozzle have oeen derivea from the nuclear analysis of Tas^ 1.

    The effect of wall material reflections ana wor^lng fluia

    absorptions have been neglected.

    The uncoil I ded flui-'es along the duc t hav e been cal cui ate o

    with the formula:

    d2

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    82/115

    Pro ge tto Identificativo Rev PagmaPfOiect docume nt no rev oaoe

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR i 79

    where 0o is the flux at the entrance of tne nozzle, d is tne

    diameter of the entrance section of the nozzle, and L is the

    distance between the entrance of the nozzle ana tne point wnere

    the flux IS calculated.

    The results iheV/cm^s; are reportea in Tap. 5.1.

    D iffusion Calculations. In oraer to estimate tne influence of

    wail material ana tnlc^ness on fission power aensit y. a secona

    analysis of tne MriD channel has been carriea out bv tne

    50LIID-360 diffusion code, using the R-Z geometry to model tne

    Power C onversion Unit (gas reactor + nozzl e and MriD channel) , and

    the cross sections derived from Task 1,.

    The configuration extends radially to m cl u a e tne mcvaDle

    reflector and axially from the core midplan e to 1200 cm in the

    cnannel (see Fig. 5, 2) ,

    As to the spatial discre tizat ion, 114 axial ana 37 radial

    meshes have oeen used.

    The ouct nas been divided into 9 regions witn different UF6

    oensi t ies c a m e o out f rom Fig , 5 .3.

    The nozzle ana channel walls have been assumed to be faoricatea

    from A1203 or BeO, For each material, two values of wall

    thickness have been examined: 3 cm and 6 cm. The adoption of a

    two-dimensional model doesn't account for the presence of the

    electrodes. However, it shouldn't be unreasonable to assume an

    electrod e wall consisting of thin electro des mounted on thick

    insulating blocks: furthermore, the electrodes themselves might

    So

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    83/115

    Progetto Identificativo Rev Pagmaprotect . , _ , _ . _ . _ , . _ d ocu me nt no re v p ag e

    NUCLEAR M HD CONVERTER RD -12-01-FNPR 1 80

    be fabricated from zirconia based materials, ana zirconium

    possesses favourable properties being a low capture cross-section

    material, which would allow to exploit the potential of a

    moderating layer.

    As previously mentioned, the calculation s have been carried

    out by using the cross section data from Task 1. collapsed

    to a 5 group structure.

    Tne fission power for each region is snown m Fig. 5.4. Tne

    results of the cases e;>aminea ar e reoortea in Tab. 5.2.

    Gamma Power Density

    Tne gamma fluxes in tne M HD channel have been calcuiateo by

    the MERCURE IV point kernel code C4 ].

    The gamma source, consisting of fission gamma, is located in the

    core.

    Build-up factors have been used in the MERCURE calculation.

    The geometry of the analyzed configuration is shown in

    Fig. 5,1,

    The core has been divided into 3 regions and the duct into 6

    regions with different UF6 density.

    Region-wise UF6 D ensities in the duct have been carried out

    from Fig, 5,3,

    The nozzle ana channel walls are assumed to be fabricated from

    A1203 material, but they have not been taken into account for

    streaming calculations.

    8o

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    84/115

    Progetto Identificativo Rev Pagina' ' ' " ' NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER documem no pD -1 2-O l-F N P R "^ i " ' ' ' g i

    Tne calculatio ns have been performeo by using the BIF GZ

    library cross section data from Ref. [5 ],

    The results are reported in Table 5,3.

    5.-i Condu ctivi ty Calc ulat ions

    A Felation for Conductivity

    Owing to the rang e of gas transit time in the channel ( 10

    ms) and to the very small Deb ye length compared with th e

    dimensions of plasm a, tne motion of both charged species can oe

    described by neglecting the convecti ve De rivatives of the

    velocities and assuming the neutrality conaition ne=ni .

    Therefore, the velocities Ue and Ui are given by C6]

    eE kTe graa(n)

    Ue = - (1)

    mVet mVet n

    eE kTi grad(n)

    Ui = (2)

    MVit MVit n

    8o

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    85/115

    Progetto Identifica tivo Rev PagmaP' + (li

    O T B - =

    where the symbols have been previou sly defin ed. The internal

    field IS obtained by eauating the flu,;e5 of ions ana

    electrons, m accoraance with the neutrality condition. It turns

    out that in the absence of an external field, the current is

    zero. The internal field is given by

    Di-De graa(n)

    pe+pi n

    where Dj=kTj/mjVjt is the diffusion coefficient and pj=e/mjVjt

    is the mobility. T herefore, current density becomes

    e=n

    J = en(Ui-Ue)= e=n(t.ie-t-pi >Eo = Eo (4)

    mVet

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    86/115

    Prog etto Identificativo Rev Pagm aP"*'**' Kt t.Pi rA D u u n ^AKnrcDT^cn document no , ^ ^ , rev _ page

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR i 83

    wnere the mobility of ions nas been neglected, because of the

    very small mass ratio. By using the same notation s, the

    conductivity is given by

    e-RTs- '

    (T = (5;

    mCcTs^(l-R)-^R/t>

    l+3.10e-4Ts=

    Sa

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    87/115

    Pro getto Identificativo Rev Paginaprotect . . . , _ , _ . _ ._ . _ . . _ document no rev page

    NUCLEAR M HD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR 1 84

    IS verified. In case of total ionization (R=l), the

    cond ucti vity is simply equal to 10e2Ts ''= , If Ts~1 0 eV, a degree

    of ionizat ion of 107. is sufficient to gi ve (r=3.10e3 (ftm) .

    Numerical Results and Discussion

    The system of Equatio ns (5)-(B) derived in section 4.4 has been

    solved bv the Runge-Kutta fourth order method. The initial

    conaitions are Tp=500 eV. Ts=l eV, Ti=0.5 eV and R=0. Tnev

    correspond to typical mean values: however, the stationary

    values don t deoend on the initial conditio ns. The a and b

    parameters m Ea.(8) ar e chosen on the basis of data available

    m literature, namely a=10e-6 and b=10e-2 2 (cgs units). Tne

    value of b is probably more realistic than tnat given previously:

    in any case, an overestimation of the recombination rate gives

    the lowest limit of achiev able ionization . The ionization

    potenzial of UF6 is =-15 eV. The thermali zation coefficient

    IS 10e4 (cgs units). The initial rate of primary electro ns /3

    IS relateo to the number of fissions i.e fl=5n f/Ng,

    where represents the number of 500 eV electrons per fission,

    whose value has been estimated at 4.10e5. Figures 5.5-5,7

    show the time evolution of temperatures and degree of

    ionization at different initial gas de nsit ies. It has been

    assumed fi=10 e-2, that corresponds to nf=2.5elO-8Ng,

    8o

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    88/115

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    89/115

    Prog etto Identificativo Rev Pagmaprotect _ _ document no rev naoe

    NUCLEAR M HD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR i 86

    fission react ions , plavs a relevant role. If an initial rate h

    of lOe-3 and an initial density of 3.10el8 molecule s/cm are

    assumed, the stationary values become Tp=21 eV, Ts=Ti=2 .4 eV ana

    R=0.01, I.e. (T =2. 10 e2 (sim) insteaa of 3.10e3, if the initial

    valu e of (5 IS lOe-2,

    The distributio n of fission rate in the cnannel is very

    important in order to maintain suitable condi tions for MriD

    conversion. In fact, if the ionization source stops at a time

    to (eauivalent to a sharp cut in the spatial distribution at

    xo=Vg.to), tne furtner evolution of the ionization rate R is

    given by

    dR bNa'-R-

    dt Ts'' =

    the secondary electrons being too cold to sustain the ionization

    level. This equation can be integrated by assuming as initial

    values those determined, in the stationary state, by the fission

    source. Thus, the time evolution is represented by

    R=Ro/(l+t/T) ''=, where T=Ts''''=/2b (RoNg) .

    By introducing the data of Fig. 5.6, R is reduced by a factor 10

    in 0.05 ps. It results that m the absence of a ionization

    source, the conductivity drops quickly to unsuitable values.

    Tne time benavior of temperature s ana ionization .rate

    greatly simplifies the analysis of the fuel chemical composition,

    8o

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A DEPLOYABLE REFLECTOR

    90/115

    Pro ge tto Identificativo Rev Paginaprotect document no rev oaoe

    NUCLEAR MHD CONVERTER RD-12-01-FNPR l 87

    with special regard to the formation of negative ions and to the

    contribution to ionization of the species arising from UF6

    dissociation . D issociation is important from the point of view

    of the effective neutral densitv. Reminding the results snown

    in Fig, 5.8, an increase of neutral density due to dissociation

    does not aiiect dramatically the relevant parameters. On the

    contrary, if the initial densitv is 5,10el7 molecules/cm~, as

    it could be expected curing the gas expansion in the MriD channel,

    a growth of a factor 7, due to dissociation and subsequent

    ionization, could lead to an improvement of the final degree

    of ionization and tempera tures, whose values should

    approximat e those of Ng=3,5 ,10el8 molecules/cm^ (see Fig, 5.6/.

    However, according to the measurements of Compton C7 ], the

    thresholds for the formation of UFn+ type ions by electron

    impact ionization ar e respect ively 14 eV for UFS-f, 18 eV for

    UF4+, 22 eV for UF3+, 26 eV for UF2+, 32 eV for UF+ and 4 0 eV for

    U+ . Since the stationary temperature of secondary electrons and

    ions IS in the range of 5 eV, relevant contribut ions can be

    only expected from UF6 and UF5.

    The influence of the formation of negative ions on the

    conductivit y can be estimated by simple argumen ts. The affinity

    potential is around 5 eV with a cross section of 3 A= C7D

    (the behavior is similar for UF 6- and F - ) . By averaging over a

    M axwell distribut ion, the contribution of attachment in

    Eq.(8) can be expressed as

    8o

  • 8/12/2019 MHD COMPRESSOR-EXPANDER CONVERSION SYSTEM INTEGRATED WITH A GCR INSIDE A D