Upload
muhammad-boota-sarwar
View
235
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/12/2019 Manifesto of Emancipation (Urdu Translation)
1/22
(Manifesto of Emancipation)
(Paresh Chattopadhyay) (University of Quebec, Canada)
" "(Marxian Concept of Capital & theSoviet Experience)
2000""University of Massachusetts2010 )http://marxmyths.org/paresh-chattopadhyay/index.php(
" " "" " " :
1 ((Labour and Division of Labour2 ((Significance of Wage3 ((Distribution of Production in Socialist Society 4(Manifesto of Emancipation)
(basicconcepts)
"" (wage or salary system)""(associated)" "
(opposite position)
(Marxian science) (1,2,3) ((quotations((bold letters
8/12/2019 Manifesto of Emancipation (Urdu Translation)
2/22
1875""1 ((marginal notes)
''" "2 ( "3" " " )1()( )2(
)( (theoretical breakthroughs) 4 5 ")) " 6 /( ( )7 8(" "
"9"
1: (Karl Marx: 1818 1883)
(Friedrich Engels: 1820 1895) '' 2
Critique of the Gotha Program)1875 General German WorkersAssociationSocial Democratic Workers Party(merger) (draft program) "" " )')'
18913
(Communist Manifesto 1848)1847 (2) Communist Correspondence Committee (1) League of JustBrussels(merger) ''(Communist League) (Manifesto)
(Communist Manifesto) 4 First International):1864 (International Workingmen Association)
First International 5(Paris Commune): commune 1871
'' 1871 6 (mode of production): ) )) )
(apply) (process)(labour process) (product of labour) ))2 (factors))( (Factors
( ( (social mode(production) )( 7 (nature))( (means)) ( (production) ((Means of production '
(individually) ' ' ' ' ''
"1849 " (totality)'' (dialectically)
} ((serf {
8/12/2019 Manifesto of Emancipation (Urdu Translation)
3/22
) ( " 10) (" (wage
labour)''11 12 (allocation and distribution) )/(
"" 13 14 (followers)
() ((medium of wage ' '
85 8 (capitalism): (money) ) ( ) ( (means of labour) 1847((social relation (consist)
' 1849(wage labour and capital)'9Das Capital)" :" (three volumes) (critical
analysis) 10
Labour): ( (means of subsistence ] [ (means of production)] means of subsistence
[ )(toil (social expression) ) ( ) ( ) (
11(Ferdinand Johann Gottlieb Lassalle : 1825 - 1864):
(socialist ideology) 12
(society s total products): ((production needs (producer needs)
13
value): '' (natural & social expression) (two aspect)''qualitative aspect 'quantative aspect' (medicine) use value
' (socially necessary labour time-SNLT)SNLT] 26 ['' ' (consume) ' )( ' '
(form of value) (exchange value ) (price) 14
state) (Marxian concept of state) (social institute) ( (
(autonomous relations)
" (abolished) "(Engels, Anti Durhing- 1894)
8/12/2019 Manifesto of Emancipation (Urdu Translation)
4/22
Labour & Division of Labour) 15
16 ""17 18 1844
1861"19 " " 0
( "21 "" ) 22 "
15 (May 1875) http://history.hanover.edu/courses/excerpts/111gotha.html
16 17)(A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy:
1859 18 (Inorganic life): " (Estranged Labour)
(Labour process) (organ)inorganic inorganic life
19 :(Enconomic and Philosophical Manuscrpt 1844) )(Estranged Labour
20 Use value): )Use value: ( )natural property( )discover( ' ' )plough(
'' "To discover the various uses of things is the work of history"
)historical&social development( )uses( )dicover( basic use value(( derived )labour process( )use value( )create(
21 : Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy- 1859) 30
22commodity): (goods & services) ) )barter commodity (production)
(servant) (""(commodity ""
"" "" "" (direct social) (commodity form) ))1 )2(
8/12/2019 Manifesto of Emancipation (Urdu Translation)
5/22
"23")" "" " " " "
( "" " (
"24 25
26 "
7"28 29
A(production)xy A (individual needs)XY ) ) B 10000 (Labour hours) )( ( (
indirect relation (money) ' '
(direct) money 23 :as capital ))-((volume 1)1867 -24
:(Das capital 1894)(volume 3)4825: (aggregate of production relations)
((senses :((Material wealth 26
(wants )satisfy ( ) wantsatisfy
27 social labour):
) (
28 : (Wage, Price & Profit) ) (3429
(socially necessary labour): ""socialiy necessary labour time SNLT (isolation)
8/12/2019 Manifesto of Emancipation (Urdu Translation)
6/22
( (social labour
)1( )2(
)3( ( ) (social contact)
" "30 ) ( " )(
"31 "" ""32 (
33 )/( ( )
"" 4 " " ''
(standard)software SNLT)(10 software engineer)( (innovation)
8 10 SNLT (competition) (time ) cost
30
: (Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy- 1859)(Part: Commodity)31 : (Theories of Surplus Value)32 :(Das Capital) Fetishism of Commodities33
Elimination of Capital):
" "(medium) ' '
34
: ) )
8/12/2019 Manifesto of Emancipation (Urdu Translation)
7/22
35 "
" "36 "enslavingsubordination)"
1844
" ) "38 37( ("39") " "40 " "41 ) (
" "42 )( ")( )(
"43 )" ( 44"
narrow horizon of bourgeois right): 35 (producers) (dealer)
certificate )( ' '(bourgeois right) / ( (higher phase36 :37
Class): (concept of class) ) ( ) ( / appropriate)(
(exploitation) Haves and Have-nots (rulers and being ruled) (powerful & powerless) (social position)
-- - 38 :Comments of James Mills Elements of Political Economy(James Mill: 1773 1836)
Elements of Political Economy 1821 1844 (comments) 39 40 41 42
43
8/12/2019 Manifesto of Emancipation (Urdu Translation)
8/22
) ( "45) ( " "46 "
"47 " "((simple & abstract )("( "48
" "49 (social aspect) "50 "
51 " "2 " "
"" )( "53" " (
44 : (Friedrich List: 1789 1846) "(National System of Political Economy)1845 http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1845/03/list.htm
45 : (Friedrich List: 1789 1846) 46
: (Friedrich List: 1789 1846) 47 : (Friedrich List: 1789 1846) 48
: (Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy- 1859 : ((appendix I: Production49 : (Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy- 1859 : ((appendix I: Production50 :Das Capital )(volume I)(7thChapter)51
class society) (producers) (slave society) (lord)
((private capitalism ) ( ((bureaucrats (state capitalism) ( )
('(class society' 52 personal dependence) (production relation) ) )
( ( ((Spartacus72 ' ' '
(material dependence)' (( ''
'' 53
: Theories of Surplus Value)(volume III)256
8/12/2019 Manifesto of Emancipation (Urdu Translation)
9/22
"54 ) ( / " "55 6 "
" " 58 57" ( )
"" "" ""
") ("
') ( 59 " " " ""
"60
54 : : ((Communism and Private Property
55 : : (Big Industry and Contradiction) /
''Adam Smith: 1723 1790): 56 (science)
Wealth of Nations 57 Grundrisse-1953):Adam Smiths Labour as Sacrifice (political economy)
Grundrisse 1953 " "58 :' 'Grundrisse-1953):Adam Smiths Labour as Sacrifice59
" higher phase of association):""(das capital) "(association of free individual)
(two phases) applicable60
:
8/12/2019 Manifesto of Emancipation (Urdu Translation)
10/22
(Significance of Wage Labour) 61 (concept of wage)
" "2
)( )(1840 "63" " "64
" ( )("65 66 ( ) 451844
") ( ' " ""67
61(Ferdinand Johann Gottlieb Lassalle : 1825 - 1864):
(socialist ideology) 62 :((Iron Law of Wage or salary 1863 (Lepzig)
''
63(Pierre-Joseph Proudhon: 1809 -1865): Anarchist
64 (David Ricardo: 1772 1823): 65 : (Principle of Political Economy and Taxation 1817):(Chapter 5- Wage)166 :1847 " "(Philosophy of Poverty)
''' ' " (Poverty of Philosophy)" 1847 1955
67''(Das Capital) (iron law of wage)
8/12/2019 Manifesto of Emancipation (Urdu Translation)
11/22
Moral " "68 ( " "" (
) ( ) :( ) (
)( " Lange9 70
)(wage based on minimum subsistence level ""1
" ) "72 (
68 : 5 (69Friedrich Albert Lange1828 70
Malthusian Theory of Population): 2 4816 2468 71 ) ( (absolute impoverishment) (separation)
( ( ) state capitalism ( socialized( (mode of production or labour ) ) separate socialized
)( ( ( ((slavery socialized separate socialized
72
: Grundrisse-1953)2
8/12/2019 Manifesto of Emancipation (Urdu Translation)
12/22
8/12/2019 Manifesto of Emancipation (Urdu Translation)
13/22
76 ocietyCommunistDistribution in the Socialist )) )
( ( 77 ) 78
] ) ( [ ""
) ( " -Vulgar Socialism
79
")( ( ) (socialism)
/
76 (two phases)
(society of free and associated producers ) 77 Production Relations: ((slavery )( ( (master or slave-owner )( (apply) ) ()(
) ( ) ( 78
79
(equal distribution of wealth) vulgar socialist vulgar socialism
8/12/2019 Manifesto of Emancipation (Urdu Translation)
14/22
1857-58)( ) (")(80 () 81
82 ( )
) ( 83
)/( 4 "85""
") " /( ) ( ""
)( "" ( ) ) " "" " ( (volume 1) "
" "" )
( ) )
80 : 1: ((Grundrisse, Notebook 1, Chapteron Money81 (available labour time) 1000 (abilitiy to produce)
(10 x 1000)10,000 82 ((labour time required for production 83 (production & its distribution)
Grundrisse(Das Capital) (first volume) ''
84 exchange value): concept ''concept )
(production value) ( (money) production value
exchange value production value exchange value (price) ' '(Labour Coupon)
production valueexchange value85
: 2: )(Grundrisse, Notebook 2, Chapteron Money
8/12/2019 Manifesto of Emancipation (Urdu Translation)
15/22
()
" " ""
" "86 ) '' ("" ""/
(total production of society) ( (production needs ((producers needs
/
)/( )/(
) ( ) ( ''7) certificate(
)
86 (first point) (products) " ' "" 85 [ ] ""/
87
(Labour Coupon): (producers) (apply) (wage labourer or salaried person) circulation)((money) ((products () (owner) (consumer)
(necessary deductions) '' (supply)
'' (societys total labour time) '' '' (products) ()
((personal use ) ( (private property) circulation''
''concept (first phase)
8/12/2019 Manifesto of Emancipation (Urdu Translation)
16/22
(
(allocation & distribution of products) (form ofvalue)88
0 9 ) ( " 91
"92 ()
" "93 ( 94 "" ((commodity form
(Money) 95 )(
'(standard)
88 " " (form of value)
89(Realized labour OR Objectified labour OR Embodied labour):
(Finished products) (vulgar economists)objects 90
:((Living Labour ) ( apply 91
: (nationalization of means of production) (consumption goods) '' ((private capitalism
(antagonism)
92 :)((Critique of the Gotha Program, Part I)93 : 1: (Grundrisse, Notebook 1, Chapteron Money94 : 1: (Grundrisse, Notebook 1, Chapteron Money95
(First Phase of Communist Society): '' (labourer) (producers)
8/12/2019 Manifesto of Emancipation (Urdu Translation)
17/22
)) ( ) 6
) (- ) ( (principle of commodity production)
)) ) ) ( )
"97 " " " ( ( " " " " ) (
guarantee (Bourgeois Right) guarantee''
(first phase of communist society) (state) ''
(higher phase of communist society) 96
/ '')( (participate)
(equal) supplier of labour unequal
97 bourgeois horizon): (producers)
(dealer) certificate )( ' '(bourgeois horizon)
/ (higher phase)
8/12/2019 Manifesto of Emancipation (Urdu Translation)
18/22
Manifesto of Emancipation)
( ) " "
" "98 ) ( )( ""
"(wage labour)") ) " " " "9
) ( " (pre-history of human)" ""
" "
" " " " " ) "" ( "-
("( 100 " "
"" 98
(Afterwords to German Edition)''-187399
' 'Associated Mode of Production): )( (labour power)
apply (real producer) (wage or salaried employee) ' '
100
: 1: (Grundrisse, Notebook 1, Chapteron Money
8/12/2019 Manifesto of Emancipation (Urdu Translation)
19/22
" "101- ) (
) ( ) (
" ( "102 03
" 104 "
"105 ) ( " "106- 07
" 108 09
101 : 1: (Grundrisse, Notebook 1, Chapteron Money
102 : 1: (Grundrisse, Notebook 1, Chapteron Money
103
state): (country) (mutual antagonism) disciplined
) (administration )(
' ''' '(capitalist state) ' (mode of production)
(Marxian science) ' '' (mode of production) '
(control) )( " )) "Engels, Anti Durhing- 1894)abolished( 104
" 18447 :http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1844/08/07.htm
105 : : (The Poverty of Philosophy, Chapter 2, Part: Strikes and Combinations of Workers)
106 : (The Communist Manifesto, 2ndChapter)
107(Paris Commune): commune 1871
'' 1871 108
: ' '1871(Civil War in France: Part Concerning the Paris Commune)
8/12/2019 Manifesto of Emancipation (Urdu Translation)
20/22
: ( ) ))
/ (social functions)
"110)(
(followers) ""
)) 11 " (state & the revolution)" " "
Raya Dunayevskaya12 )( " )("113" " )(
) ( )( ) ( ) (
" " )( )( " " "
"114 "
109 revolutionary transformation): (transformation)
(period of revolutionary transformation) (proletariat) 110
concept 111:(Vladimir Lenin 1870 - 1924) )1924()
( ((contribution ((Leninism112:Raya Dunayevskaya1910 Humanism '
1987'113Raya Dunayevskaya:' '
114 Working Class State or Proletariat State): 1921)( " "(new economic
policy) "" " (proletariat state) (control)
)(1921
8/12/2019 Manifesto of Emancipation (Urdu Translation)
21/22
8/12/2019 Manifesto of Emancipation (Urdu Translation)
22/22
119 ) " () ( "120-
( ) ) ( ( ( ) (
) ( " )( " " "121
===========================================================================
119 917 :):(1917 )( 1917 1917
1917 15 1917 )) 1917 Bolshovik 1922 Union of Soviet
(USSR)Socialist Republics 120: :)(Lenin: Book State & Revolution, Chapter: What is to Replace the Smashed State Machine?
121 : (Karl Marx: Civil War in France Character of Paris Commune First Draft)