8/2/2019 LLF v DNPUSA - 2012-03-01 - DNC et al 12(b)(1) & 12(b)(6) Memo in Support of Motion to Dismiss

1/19

:8;:99 9

FD XBM ]DFXMH _XIXM_ HF_XZFOX OA]ZX

LAZ XBM [M_XMZD HF_XZFOX AL XMDDM__MM

CFJMZXV CMKIC LA]DHIXFAD#

GABD H]@@MXX# CMADIZH

\ACAHIZ_EV# OZMK @IZADMV#

^cifdxflls#

|s$

DIXFADIC HM@AOZIXFO ^IZXV AL

XBM ]_I# FDO$# HM@AOZIXFODIXFADIC OA@@FXXMM# XMDDM__MM

HM@AOZIXFO ^IZXV# HMJJFM[I__MZ@ID _OB]CXW# idh OBF^

LAZZM_XMZ#

Hmlmdhidxs$

&

&&

&

&&

&

&

&&

&

&

&&

&&

&

Oism Da$ :79:-o|->:98?-oko

Zm`a|ic al Oism Da$ OB-99-9;=;-? Lza`Obidomzv Oa}zx laz xbm _xixm al Xmddmssmm

fd _bmcjv Oa}dxv

@M@AZIDH]@ FD _]^^AZX AL @AXFAD XA HF_@F__

^]Z_]IDX XA Z]CM 9:"j&"9& IDH Z]CM 9:"j&"9: kmdmzic mcmoxfad "xbm Mcmoxfad& jv ~zm|mdxfdk xbm Hm`aozixfo ^izxv lza`

s}j`fxxfdk ^zmsfhmdx Aji`is di`m is xbm Hm`aozixfo ^izxvs oidhfhixm xa xbm Xmddmssmm

9^cifdxflls icsa di`m xbm Dixfadic Hm`aozixfo ^izxv al xbm ]_I# Fdo$ is i hmlmdhidx# j}x xbfs azkidfwixfad fs

i~~izmdxcv i sbi` azkidfwixfad# `asx cfemcv illfcfixmh {fxb xbm _bmcjv Oa}dxv Zm~}jcfoid ^izxv# idh xbmzmlazm# is

mr~cifdmh fd kzmixmz hmxifc bmzmfd# fs dax i ~za~mz ~izxv xa xbfs ci{s}fx$ Iooazhfdkcv# xbmv {fcc dax jm xzmixmh is i

~za~mz hmlmdhidx$

Oism :79:-o|->:98?-_XI-oko Hao}`mdx = Lfcmh >?!>9!9: ^ikm 9 al 96 ^ikmFH ;:

8/2/2019 LLF v DNPUSA - 2012-03-01 - DNC et al 12(b)(1) & 12(b)(6) Memo in Support of Motion to Dismiss

2/19

:8;:99 :

_mozmxizv al _xixm Hf|fsfad al Mcmoxfads "XD _mozmxizv al _xixm&$ Xa ajxifd xbfs mdh# ^cifdxflls

Cfjmzxv Cmkic La}dhixfad "CCL Gabd H}``mxx# Cmadizh \acizhizsev# idh Ozmk @izadmv

"oaccmoxf|mcv xbm ^cifdxflls& issmzx xbm ijs}zh idh {mcc-hmj}demh iccmkixfads xbix ^zmsfhmdx

Aji`i fs dax i dix}zic jazd ofxfwmd al xbm ]dfxmh _xixms idh xbmzmlazm hams dax `mmx xbm

oadsxfx}xfadic zmy}fzm`mdxs xa bach xbm Allfom al xbm ^zmsfhmdx al xbm ]dfxmh _xixms$ _m|mzic

oa}zxs ix jaxb xbm lmhmzic idh sxixm cm|mc bi|m }dlazx}dixmcv bih xa ihhzmss xbmsm zfhfo}ca}s

iccmkixfads$ Is sba}ch jm ij}dhidxcv aj|fa}s jv xbm liox xbix ^zmsfhmdx Aji`i bis bmch xbm

allfom al xbm ^zmsfhmdx al xbm ]dfxmh _xixms laz a|mz xbzmm vmizs da{# icc al xbm ~zm|fa}scv lfcmh

s}fxs ~za|mh jismcmss# idh xbfs adm mrbfjfxs xbm si`m oa`~cmxm cioe al `mzfx$

M|md fl xbm ^cifdxflls ocif`s hfh dax s}llmz lza` i ocmiz idh lixic hmlmox al cioe al

sxidhfdk# ^cifdxflls ocif`s izm s}jsxidxf|mcv hmlfofmdx idh lifc xa sxixm i ocif`$ Xbm Mcmoxazic

Oaccmkm fs xbm jahv zms~adsfjcm laz omzxflvfdk ~zmsfhmdxfic oidhfhixms idh fs zms~adsfjcm fd xbm

lfzsx fdsxidom xa hmxmz`fdm {bmxbmz i oidhfhixm fs y}icflfmh xa bach xbm allfom al ^zmsfhmdx al xbm

]dfxmh _xixms$ Xbfs ci{s}fx smmes xa sbazx-ofzo}fx xbix ~zaomss fd ocmiz |facixfad al lmhmzic ci{$

L}zxbmz`azm# xbm Hm`aozixfo ^izxv# idh s~moflfoiccv xbm XDH^ is xbm ~izxv zms~adsfjcm laz

s}j`fxxfdk fxs da`fdmm laz ^zmsfhmdx laz xbm Mcmoxfad# bis id ijsac}xm Lfzsx I`mdh`mdx zfkbx xa

da`fdixm idvadm fx {idxs laz ^zmsfhmdx al xbm ]dfxmh _xixms$ Lfdiccv# jmoi}sm xbm I`mdhmh

Oa`~cifdx jzfdks oi}sms al ioxfad laz dmkcfkmdx idh fdxmdxfadic `fszm~zmsmdxixfad# idh ^cifdxflls

lifc xa ~za~mzcv iccmkm xbm mcm`mdx al hmxzf`mdxic zmcfidom# xbm ^cifdxflls bi|m lifcmh xa sxixm i

ocif` }~ad {bfob zmcfml oid jm kzidxmh# idh iooazhfdkcv xbfs oism sba}ch jm hfs`fssmh laz xbfs

zmisad is {mcc$

Lfdiccv# icc Hmlmdhidxs j}x xbm XDH^ sba}ch jm hfs`fssmh jmoi}sm xbm XDH^ fs sacmcv

zms~adsfjcm laz s}j`fxxfdk xbm di`m al xbm Hm`aozixfo ^izxv da`fdmm xa xbm XD _mozmxizv al

_xixm$

Oism :79:-o|->:98?-_XI-oko Hao}`mdx = Lfcmh >?!>9!9: ^ikm : al 96 ^ikmFH ;?

8/2/2019 LLF v DNPUSA - 2012-03-01 - DNC et al 12(b)(1) & 12(b)(6) Memo in Support of Motion to Dismiss

3/19

:8;:99 ?

JIOEKZA]DH

Ad Aoxajmz :99# xbm ^cifdxflls lfcmh i ociss ioxfad oa`~cifdx laz hmocizixazv idh

fdg}doxf|m zmcfml fd _bmcjv Oa}dxv Obidomzv Oa}zx# Oism Da$ OB-99-9;=;-?# idh fdfxficcv di`mh

is ~izxfms xbm Dixfadic Hm`aozixfo ^izxv al xbm ]_I# Fdo$ "DH^ ]_I [issmz`id _ob}cxw

"Obifz~mzsad al xbm HDO idh Obf~ Lazzmsxmz "Obifz~mzsad al xbm XDH^&$ "_mm Azfkfdic

Oa`~cifdx$& Ix xbfs xf`m# ^cifdxflls adcv smz|mh xbm DH^ ]_I idh hfh dax smz|m mfxbmz

Obifz~mzsads [issmz`id _ob}cxw az Lazzmsxmz$

Ad Gid}izv :># :>9:# ~zfaz xa idv ~izxv lfcfdk id ids{mz# ^cifdxflls lfcmh i Lfzsx I`mdhmh

Oa`~cifdx# {bfob fs xbm a~mzixf|m oa`~cifdx fd xbfs oism# idh ihhmh xbm HDO idh XDH^ is

~izxfms$ Ad Gid}izv :9:# ^cifdxflls lfdiccv smz|mh Lazzmsxmz j}x xbm s}``ads bm zmomf|mh

ocmizcv i~~cfmh adcv xa bf`# idh xa hixm# xbm XDH^ bis dax jmmd smz|mh$ Ad Lmjz}izv 6# :>9:# xbm

HDO lfdiccv zmomf|mh smz|fom# idh xa hixm [issmz`id _ob}cxw bis dax jmmd smz|mh$

Xbm I`mdhmh Oa`~cifdxs sacm ~}z~asm fs xa ~zm|mdx ^zmsfhmdx Aji`is di`m lza`

i~~mizfdk ad xbm jiccax fd xbm _xixm al Xmddmssmm$ "I`mdhmh Oa`~cifdx 9# 8$& Xbm I`mdhmh

Oa`~cifdx iccmkms xbix ^zmsfhmdx Aji`i: fs dax i dix}zic jazd ofxfwmd idh fs xbmzmlazm dax

oadsxfx}xfadiccv y}icflfmh xa bach xbm allfom al ^zmsfhmdx al xbm ]dfxmh _xixms al I`mzfoi idh

xbmzmlazm bfs di`m sba}ch dax i~~miz ad xbm jiccax fd Xmddmssmm$ "I`mdhmh Oa`~cifdx 9$& Xa

iobfm|m xbm }d~zmomhmdxmh zmcfml sa}kbx# xbm I`mdhmh Oa`~cifdx hams dax smme xa mdgafd xbm

ioxfads al sxixm az lmhmzic mcmoxfad allfofics# j}x zixbmz smmes xa mdgafd xbm Hmlmdhidxs lza` lfcfdk

zmcm|idx hao}`mdxs {fxb xbm XD _mozmxizv al _xixm fhmdxflvfdk ^zmsfhmdx Aji`i is xbm hm`aozixfo

oidhfhixm laz xbm Allfom al xbm ^zmsfhmdov fd xbm }~oa`fdk Mcmoxfad$ "I`mdhmh Oa`~cifdx 8#

;-2$&

:_ba{fdk xbmfz xz}m oacazs# ^cifdxflls oadxfd}a}scv zmlmz xa ^zmsfhmdx Aji`i is @z$ Aji`i xbza}kba}x xbmfz

I`mdhmh Oa`~cifdx# id aj|fa}s ixxm`~x xa hm`mid xbm ^zmsfhmdx idh xbm allfom$ Hmlmdhidxs {fcc aj|fa}scv

xbza}kba}x xbfs oism zmlmz xa ^zmsfhmdx Aji`i is ^zmsfhmdx Aji`i# kf|fdk ~za~mz zms~mox xa xbm `id bf`smcl idh

xbm allfom bm aoo}~fms$

Oism :79:-o|->:98?-_XI-oko Hao}`mdx = Lfcmh >?!>9!9: ^ikm ? al 96 ^ikmFH ;8

8/2/2019 LLF v DNPUSA - 2012-03-01 - DNC et al 12(b)(1) & 12(b)(6) Memo in Support of Motion to Dismiss

4/19

:8;:99 8

Xbm I`mdhmh Oa`~cifdx xbmd kams ad xa hmxifc xbm iccmkmh m|fhmdom s}~~azxfdk xbm ocif`

xbix ^zmsfhmdx Aji`i fs dax i dix}zic jazd ofxfwmd y}icflfmh xa bach xbm allfom al xbm ^zmsfhmdx al

xbm ]dfxmh _xixms$ "I`mdhmh Oa`~cifdx 6-9:$& Xbm I`mdhmh Oa`~cifdx icsa iccmkms xbix

^zmsfhmdx Aji`i jmoi`m i h}ic ofxfwmd al jaxb xbm ]dfxmh _xixms idh Fdhadmsfi idh m|mdx}iccv

zmcfdy}fsbmh bfs ]dfxmh _xixms ofxfwmdsbf~ idh jmoi`m sacmcv i ofxfwmd al Fdhadmsfi$ "I`mdhmh

Oa`~cifdx 9?-96&$

Xbm I`mdhmh Oa`~cifdx icsa iccmkms xbix ^zmsfhmdx Aji`is saofic smo}zfxv d}`jmz

"__D& fs lzi}h}cmdx idh xbix xbm lmhmzic M-|mzflv svsxm` lciks ^zmsfhmdx Aji`is __D is

lzi}h}cmdx$ "I`mdhmh Oa`~cifdx 96-:?$&

?

^cifdxflls issmzx x{a oi}sms al ioxfad7

9$ Dmkcfkmdx @fszm~zmsmdxixfad7 Iccmkfdk xbix Hmlmdhidxs {fcc lifc xa mrmzofsm zmisadijcmoizm# hfcfkmdom# az mr~mzxfsm fd s}j`fxxfdk ^zmsfhmdx Aji`is di`m is xbm Hm`aozixfo

^izxv da`fdmm laz xbm ~asfxfad al ^zmsfhmdx al xbm ]dfxmh _xixms xa xbm XD _mozmxizv

al _xixms Hf|fsfad al Mcmoxfads$ "I`mdhmh Oa`~cifdx -;>$&

:$ Lzi}h!Fdxmdxfadic @fszm~zmsmdxixfad7 Iccmkfdk xbix jmoi}sm Hmlmdhidxs bi|meda{cmhkm al ^zmsfhmdx Aji`is cioe al y}icflfoixfads xa bach xbm allfom al ^zmsfhmdx

jv |fzx}m al jmfdk smz|mh {fxb xbfs ci{s}fx# xbix xbm Hmlmdhidxs {fcc mdkikm fdfdxmdxfadic `fszm~zmsmdxixfad jv s}j`fxxfdk ^zmsfhmdx Aji`is di`m is xbm

Hm`aozixfo ^izxv da`fdmm laz xbm ~asfxfad al ^zmsfhmdx al xbm ]dfxmh _xixms xa xbm XD

_mozmxizv al _xixm$ "I`mdhmh Oa`~cifdx ;9-;?$&

^cifdxflls smme i hmocizixfad xbix idv zm~zmsmdxixfad jv xbm Hmlmdhidxs xbix @z$ Aji`i fs

y}icflfmh xa bach xbm allfom al xbm ^zmsfhmdx al xbm ]dfxmh _xixms {a}ch oadsxfx}xm dmkcfkmdom az

lzi}h idh ^cifdxflls smme id fdg}doxfad ~zm|mdxfdk xbm Hmlmdhidxs lza` fss}fdk idv cmxxmzs#

omzxflfoixms# az axbmz hao}`mdxs xa xbm XD _mozmxizv al _xixm fdhfoixfdk xbix ^zmsfhmdx Aji`i fs

xbm Hm`aozixfo ^izxvs da`fdmm laz xbm Mcmoxfad$ "I`mdhmh Oa`~cifdx ix ^zivmz laz Zmcfml

9-:$&

?Xbm lazmkafdk iccmkixfads izm xbm adcv izk}`mdxs cahkmh fd s}~~azx al ^cifdxflls ocif`s xbix ^zmsfhmdx Aji`i fs

dax i dix}zic jazd ofxfwmd$ _mm kmdmziccv I`mdhmh Oa`~cifdx$

Oism :79:-o|->:98?-_XI-oko Hao}`mdx = Lfcmh >?!>9!9: ^ikm 8 al 96 ^ikmFH ;=

8/2/2019 LLF v DNPUSA - 2012-03-01 - DNC et al 12(b)(1) & 12(b)(6) Memo in Support of Motion to Dismiss

5/19

:8;:99 =

Fd sbazx# ^cifdxflls smme xa mds}zm xbix ^zmsfhmdx Aji`is di`m hams dax i~~miz ad xbm

jiccax fd xbm sxixm al Xmddmssmm jv ~zm|mdxfdk xbm Hmlmdhidxs lza` s}j`fxxfdk bfs di`m is xbmfz

oidhfhixm laz xbm allfom al ^zmsfhmdx al xbm ]dfxmh _xixms fd xbm Mcmoxfad$

_XIDHIZH AL ZM\FM[

Hmlmdhidxs `a|m xbfs Oa}zx xa hfs`fss xbfs oism }dhmz jaxb Z}cm 9:"j&"9& "cioe al s}jgmox

`ixxmz g}zfshfoxfad& idh Z}cm 9:"j&"9=6;=# ix ': "@$H$ Xmdd$ Da|$ 96#

:>>6& "ofxfdk Jmcc Ixc$ Oaz~$ |$X{a`jcv# ==> ]$_$ =88# =;> ":>>;&&$ Xbfs sxidhizh *zmy}fzms

`azm xbid cijmcs idh oadoc}sfads# idh i laz`}cifo zmofxixfad ad xbm mcm`mdxs al i oi}sm al ioxfad

{fcc dax ha$* X{a`jcv# ==> ]$_$ ix ===$ Xbm X{a`jcv sxidhizh i~~cfms xa icc of|fc oisms# idh i

~cifdxfll `}sx iccmkm mda}kb lioxs xa icca{ xbm liox lfdhmz xa hzi{ i *zmisadijcm fdlmzmdom xbix xbm

hmlmdhidx fs cfijcm laz xbm `fsoadh}ox iccmkmh$* Isbozalx |$Fyjic# 9:6 _$ Ox$ 96?;# 9686 ":>>6&

"m`~bisfs ihhmh&$ Xb}s# i oa`~cifdx `}sx ~zallmz s}llfofmdx liox}ic s}~~azx xa jzfdk xbm

~cifdxflls ocif` *ija|m xbm s~mo}cixf|m cm|mc$* X{a`jcv# ==> ]$_$ ix ===$

Oism :79:-o|->:98?-_XI-oko Hao}`mdx = Lfcmh >?!>9!9: ^ikm = al 96 ^ikmFH ;

8/2/2019 LLF v DNPUSA - 2012-03-01 - DNC et al 12(b)(1) & 12(b)(6) Memo in Support of Motion to Dismiss

6/19

:8;:99 ?!>9!9: ^ikm < al 96 ^ikmFH ;;

8/2/2019 LLF v DNPUSA - 2012-03-01 - DNC et al 12(b)(1) & 12(b)(6) Memo in Support of Motion to Dismiss

7/19

:8;:99 ;

996 C$ Mh$ :h ?=9 "966:&$ _xidhfdk fs id *fzzmh}ofjcm oadsxfx}xfadic `fdf`}`* xbix bis xbzmm

mcm`mdxs$ Fh$ ix =$ Lfzsx# i ~izxv `}sx bi|m mr~mzfmdomh id fdg}zv-fd-liox7 *id fd|isfad al i

cmkiccv ~zaxmoxmh fdxmzmsx {bfob fs7 "i& oadozmxm idh ~izxfo}cizfwmh5 idh "j& iox}ic az f``fdmdx#

dax oadgmox}zic az bv~axbmxfoic$* Fh$ "ofxixfads idh y}axixfad `izes a`fxxmh&$ _moadh# xbmzm `}sx

jm i oi}sic oaddmoxfad jmx{mmd xbm fdg}zv-fd-liox idh xbm hmlmdhidx+s oadh}ox xbix fs *lifzcv $ $ $

xziomUijcmP xa xbm obiccmdkmh ioxfad al xbm hmlmdhidx# idh dax $ $ $ xbm zms}cx UalP xbm fdhm~mdhmdx

ioxfad al sa`m xbfzh ~izxv dax jmlazm xbm oa}zx$* Fh$ ix =-8 ]$_$ ix =>2& "*UAPdom xbm Hfsxzfox Oa}zx hmxmz`fdmh xbix

U~cifdxfllsP hfh dax bi|m sxidhfdk# fx dmomssizfcv hmxmz`fdmh xbix fx hfh dax bi|m g}zfshfoxfad idh

xb}s fx oa}ch dax hmofhm xbm `mzfxs al xbm oism$*&$

I {micxb al ~zmomhmdx zmcixmh xa sf`fciz oisms lfcmh xbza}kba}x xbm oa}dxzv sxzadkcv

s}~~azxs xbm oadxmdxfad xbix ^cifdxflls cioe sxidhfdk$ Da cmss xbid sfr lmhmzic oisms idh ix cmisx

adm sxixm oism bi|m jmmd hfs`fssmh ix xbm lmhmzic cm|mc {bmzm ^cifdxflls sa}kbx xa obiccmdkm

^zmsfhmdx Aji`is y}icflfoixfads xa bach xbm allfom al ^zmsfhmdx al xbm ]dfxmh _xixms jv |fzx}m al

bfs iccmkmh# idh da{ l}ccv hmj}demh# lifc}zm xa `mmx Izxfocm FF# _moxfad Fs dix}zic jazd ofxfwmd

zmy}fzm`mdx$ Hziem |$ Aji`i# :98?-_XI-oko Hao}`mdx = Lfcmh >?!>9!9: ^ikm ; al 96 ^ikmFH ;2

8/2/2019 LLF v DNPUSA - 2012-03-01 - DNC et al 12(b)(1) & 12(b)(6) Memo in Support of Motion to Dismiss

8/19

:8;:99 2

hfs`fssfdk i hmocizixazv g}hk`mdx ioxfad iccmkfdk ^zmsfhmdx Aji`i {is fdmcfkfjcm }dhmz ]$_$

Oadsx$ izx$ FF# 9# oc$ =# {is illfz`mh&5 Jmzk |$ Aji`i# =2< L$?h :?8 "?h Ofz$ :>>6& "Id azhmz

hfs`fssfdk id ioxfad smmefdk i hmocizixazv g}hk`mdx xbix hmlmdhidx xbmd-^zmsfhmdxfic oidhfhixm

{is fdmcfkfjcm }dhmz ]$_$ Oadsx$ izx$ FF# 9# oc$ =# idh id fdg}doxfad jizzfdk bf` lza` z}ddfdk laz

^zmsfhmdx {is illfz`mh jmoi}sm xbm ~cifdxfll cioemh sxidhfdk jmoi}sm bm bih s}llmzmh da fdg}zv

~izxfo}cizfwmh xa bf`&5 Xifxw |$ Aji`i# ;>; L$ _}~~$ :h 9# "H$H$O$ :>9>& "^cifdxfll cioemh

sxidhfdk jmoi}sm sbm hfh dax iccmkm s}llfofmdx fdg}zv-fd-liox xa obiccmdkm {bmxbmz ^zmsfhmdx

Aji`i fs i dix}zic jazd ofxfwmd is zmy}fzmh jv xbm Oadsxfx}xfad&5 Jizdmxx |$ Aji`i# Oism Da$

>6->>2:# :>>6 ]$_$ Hfsx$ CMRF_ 9>9:>< "O$H$ Oic$ :>>6& "Ocif`s iccmkfdk xbix xbm ]dfxmh

_xixms ^zmsfhmdx hfh dax `mmx xbm y}icflfoixfads s~moflfmh jv ]$_$ Oadsx$ izx$ FF# 9# oc$ =# {mzm

hfs`fssmh laz cioe al sxidhfdk {bmzm icxba}kb xbm xbfzh ~izxv ~zmsfhmdxfic oidhfhixms bih i

~axmdxfic fdg}zv-fd-liox# xbm oa}zx oa}ch zmhzmss xbm ocif`s is zm`a|ic al i sfxxfdk ~zmsfhmdx {is

oa``fxxmh xa Oadkzmss&5 Oabmd |$ Aji`i# :>>2 ]$_$ Hfsx$ CMRF_ 9>>99 "hfs`fssfdk ocif`s

iccmkfdk ^zmsfhmdx Aji`i fs id fccmkic icfmd jmoi}sm U~Pcifdxflls sxiem fs da kzmixmz idh bfs

sxix}s da `azm hfllmzmdxfixmh xbid xbix al `fccfads al axbmz |axmzsU#P $ $ $ bfs biz` fs xaa |ik}m idh

fxs mllmoxs xaa ixxmd}ixmh xa oadlmz sxidhfdk ad idv idh icc |axmzs$*&5 smm icsa [zaxda{sef |$

Jvsfm{fow# :26 Oadd$ =:: ":>>2& "hfs`fssfdk laz cioe al sxidhfdk ocif`s issmzxfdk xbix ^zmsfhmdx

Aji`i {is dax i dix}zic jazd ofxfwmd&$8

^cifdxflls lifc xa o}zm idv al xbm hmlmoxs fhmdxflfmh jv xbmsm hmofsfads$ ^cifdxfll @izadmv fs

sf`~cv id I`mzfoid ofxfwmd idh bfs adcv iccmkmh fdg}zv hmzf|ms lza` bfs sxix}s is i |axmz$ Bm fs#

xbmzmlazm# fd da hfllmzmdx ~asfxfad xbid axbmz ~cifdxflls {ba bi|m jza}kbx sf`fciz oisms$ _mm m$k$#

8D}`mza}s axbmz oisms lfcmh xbza}kba}x xbm oa}dxzv icsa obiccmdkmh ^zmsfhmdx Aji`is y}icflfoixfads# j}x xbmsm

oisms {mzm hfs`fssmh ad axbmz kza}dhs axbmz xbid sxidhfdk$ _mm m$k$# ^}z~}zi |$ _mjmcf}s# :>99 ]$_$ I~~$ CMRF_

9668? "?h Ofz$ :>99&5 Jizdmxx |$ H}dd# :>99 ]$_$ Hfsx$ CMRF_ ?9:96 "M$H$ Oic$ :>99&5 _xz}de |$ ]dfxmh _xixms

Hm~+x al _xixm# 9>&5 Zbahms |$

@ioHadich# L$ _}~~$ :h 9?

8/2/2019 LLF v DNPUSA - 2012-03-01 - DNC et al 12(b)(1) & 12(b)(6) Memo in Support of Motion to Dismiss

9/19

:8;:99 6

Jmzk# =2< L$?h ix :8> "M|md fl {m iss}`m xbix xbm ~ciom`mdx al id fdmcfkfjcm oidhfhixm ad xbm

~zmsfhmdxfic jiccax biz`mh Jmzk# xbix fdg}zv# fdoc}hfdk idv lz}sxzixfad Jmzk lmcx jmoi}sm axbmzs

zml}smh xa iox ad bfs |fm{ al xbm ci{# {is xaa kmdmzic laz xbm ~}z~asms al Izxfocm FFF7 Jmzk sbizmh

jaxb bfs fdxmzmsx fd ~za~mz i~~cfoixfad al xbm Oadsxfx}xfad idh ci{s# ~izf ~iss} {fxb icc |axmzs&5

Oabmd# :>>2 ]$_$ Hfsx$ CMRF_ 9>>>99# ix '9 "hfs`fssfdk ofxfwmd obiccmdkm xa Aji`i+s

mcfkfjfcfxv&$

^cifdxflls \acahizsev idh H}``mxx izm scfkbxcv hfllmzmdx fd xbix xbmv izm iccmkmhcv

~zmsfhmdxfic oidhfhixms# j}x xbmfz ~zmsfhmdxfic ~zas~moxs izm xbmazmxfoic ix jmsx idh idv biz`

iooz}fdk xa xbm` jv |fzx}m al xbmfz oidhfhiov fs s~mo}cixf|m$ Zajfdsad |$ Ja{md# =;&

"hfs`fssfdk ocif`s laz cioe al sxidhfdk {bmzm iccmkmh biz` {is xaa s~mo}cixf|m xa sixfslv

fdg}zv zmy}fzm`mdx al Izx$ FFF sxidhfdk&$

^cifdxfll# CCL# id issaofixfad {basm ~zf`izv kaic fs xbm hmlmdsm al jisfo b}`id zfkbxs#

icsa cioes sxidhfdk$ Issaofixfadic sxidhfdk fs i xbzmm-~izx xmsx7 "9& xbm issaofixfad+s `m`jmzs

Oism :79:-o|->:98?-_XI-oko Hao}`mdx = Lfcmh >?!>9!9: ^ikm 6 al 96 ^ikmFH 2>

8/2/2019 LLF v DNPUSA - 2012-03-01 - DNC et al 12(b)(1) & 12(b)(6) Memo in Support of Motion to Dismiss

10/19

:8;:99 9>

{a}ch fdhm~mdhmdxcv `mmx xbm Izxfocm FFF sxidhfdk zmy}fzm`mdxs5 ":& xbm fdxmzmsxs xbm issaofixfad

smme xa ~zaxmox izm kmz`idm xa xbm ~}z~asm al xbm azkidfwixfad5 idh "?& dmfxbmz xbm ocif` issmzxmh

daz xbm zmcfml zmy}msxmh zmy}fzms ~izxfof~ixfad al fdhf|fh}ic `m`jmzs$ _mm B}dx |$ [isb$ _xixm

I~~cm Ih|mz$ Oa``+d# 8?: ]$_$ ???# ?8?# 6; _$ Ox$ :8?8# =? C$ Mh$ :h ?2? "96;;&$ CCL oiddax

sixfslv xbmsm zmy}fzm`mdxs laz x{a zmisads$ Lfzsx# is iczmihv hfso}ssmh# fxs issaofixm `m`jmzs

cioe sxidhfdk# idh xbmzmlazm id issaofixfad `ihm }~ al `m`jmzs xbix cioe sxidhfdk oiddax fxsmcl

bi|m sxidhfdk mfxbmz$ Fh$ ix ?8?5 smm ILKM |$ Ocfdxad# 92> L$?h ;:; "

8/2/2019 LLF v DNPUSA - 2012-03-01 - DNC et al 12(b)(1) & 12(b)(6) Memo in Support of Motion to Dismiss

11/19

:8;:99 99

FF$ ^cifdxflls Lifc Xa _xixm I Ocif` Idh Xbm Oism @}sx Jm Hfs`fssmh ^}zs}idxXa Z}cm 9:"j&">2&$ Xbm Oa}zx icsa daxmh xbix ^zmsfhmdx Aji`i fs

dax xbm lfzsx ^zmsfhmdx al xbm ]dfxmh _xixms xa jm jazd xa i lixbmz {ba {is dax i ]dfxmh _xixms ofxfwmd$ Obmsxmz I$

Izxb}zs lixbmz {is Fzfsb$ Fh$ ix 9!9: ^ikm 99 al 96 ^ikmFH 2:

8/2/2019 LLF v DNPUSA - 2012-03-01 - DNC et al 12(b)(1) & 12(b)(6) Memo in Support of Motion to Dismiss

12/19

:8;:99 9:

al ^zmsfhmdx Aji`i xa bach xbm allfom al ^zmsfhmdx al xbm ]dfxmh _xixms$ _mm Zajfdsad# =9!9: ^ikm 9: al 96 ^ikmFH 2?

8/2/2019 LLF v DNPUSA - 2012-03-01 - DNC et al 12(b)(1) & 12(b)(6) Memo in Support of Motion to Dismiss

13/19

:8;:99 9?

I`mdh`mdx ~zmsozfjms xbm `iddmz fd {bfob xbm mcmoxazs i~~afdxmh

jv xbm sxixms sbicc fd x}zd mcmox xbm ~zmsfhmdx7

*UxPbm mcmoxazs sbicc `mmx fd xbmfz zms~moxf|m sxixms idh |axm jv

jiccax laz ^zmsfhmdx idh \fom-^zmsfhmdx $ $ $ idh xbmv sbicc $ $ $

xzids`fx Uxbmfz |axmsP smicmh xa xbm smix al xbm ka|mzd`mdx al xbm]dfxmh _xixms# hfzmoxmh xa xbm ^zmsfhmdx al xbm _mdixm5 -- Xbm

^zmsfhmdx al xbm _mdixm sbicc# fd xbm ~zmsmdom al xbm _mdixm idhBa}sm al Zm~zmsmdxixf|ms# a~md icc xbm omzxflfoixms idh xbm |axms

sbicc xbmd jm oa}dxmh$*

Lmhmzic cmkfscixfad l}zxbmz hmxifcs xbm ~zaomss laz oa}dxfdk mcmoxazic

|axms fd Oadkzmss$ ? ]$_$O$ 9=$ _moxfad 9= hfzmoxs xbix Oadkzmss

sbicc jm fd smssfad ad xbm i~~za~zfixm hiv xa oa}dx xbm mcmoxazic

|axms# {fxb xbm ^zmsfhmdx al xbm _mdixm ~zmsfhfdk$ Fx hfzmoxs xbixhmsfkdixmh fdhf|fh}ics sbicc a~md# oa}dx idh zmoazh xbm mcmoxazic

|axms# idh xbmd ~zmsmdx xbm zms}cxs xa xbm ^zmsfhmdx al xbm _mdixm#{ba sbicc xbmd *idda}dom xbm sxixm al xbm |axm$* Fjfh$ Xbm sxix}xm~za|fhms i `mobidfs` laz ajgmoxfads xbmd xa jm zmkfsxmzmh idh

zmsac|mh7

*UmP|mzv ajgmoxfad sbicc jm `ihm fd {zfxfdk# idh sbicc sxixm ocmizcv

idh oadofsmcv# idh {fxba}x izk}`mdx# xbm kza}dh xbmzmal# idh sbicc

jm sfkdmh jv ix cmisx adm _mdixaz idh adm @m`jmz al xbm Ba}sm al

Zm~zmsmdxixf|ms jmlazm xbm si`m sbicc jm zmomf|mh$ [bmd iccajgmoxfads sa `ihm $ $ $ sbicc bi|m jmmd zmomf|mh idh zmih# xbm

_mdixm sbicc xbmzm}~ad {fxbhzi{# idh s}ob ajgmoxfads sbicc jm

s}j`fxxmh xa xbm _mdixm laz fxs hmofsfad5 idh xbm _~miemz al xbmBa}sm al Zm~zmsmdxixf|ms sbicc# fd cfem `iddmz# s}j`fx s}ob

ajgmoxfads xa xbm Ba}sm al Zm~zmsmdxixf|ms laz fxs hmofsfad$*

Fjfh$ Xbm X{mdxfmxb I`mdh`mdx l}zxbmz ~za|fhms7

*fl xbm ^zmsfhmdx mcmox sbicc bi|m lifcmh xa y}icflv# xbmd xbm \fom^zmsfhmdx mcmox sbicc iox is ^zmsfhmdx }dxfc i ^zmsfhmdx sbicc bi|m

y}icflfmh5 idh xbm Oadkzmss `iv jv ci{ ~za|fhm laz xbm oism

{bmzmfd dmfxbmz i ^zmsfhmdx mcmox daz i \fom ^zmsfhmdx mcmox sbicc

bi|m y}icflfmh# hmocizfdk {ba sbicc xbmd iox is ^zmsfhmdx# az xbm`iddmz fd {bfob adm {ba fs xa iox sbicc jm mcmoxmh# idh s}ob

~mzsad sbicc iox iooazhfdkcv }dxfc i ^zmsfhmdx az \fom ^zmsfhmdx

sbicc bi|m y}icflfmh$*

Fx fs ocmiz xbix `mobidfs`s mrfsx }dhmz xbm X{mclxb I`mdh`mdx

idh ? ]$_$O$ 9= laz idv obiccmdkm xa idv oidhfhixm xa jm |mdxfcixmh{bmd mcmoxazic |axms izm oa}dxmh# idh xbix xbm X{mdxfmxb

I`mdh`mdx ~za|fhms k}fhidom zmkizhfdk ba{ xa ~zaommh fl i

~zmsfhmdx mcmox sbicc bi|m lifcmh xa y}icflv$ Fss}ms zmkizhfdk

Oism :79:-o|->:98?-_XI-oko Hao}`mdx = Lfcmh >?!>9!9: ^ikm 9? al 96 ^ikmFH 28

8/2/2019 LLF v DNPUSA - 2012-03-01 - DNC et al 12(b)(1) & 12(b)(6) Memo in Support of Motion to Dismiss

14/19

:8;:99 98

y}icflfoixfads laz ~zmsfhmdx izm y}fdxmssmdxficcv s}fxmh xa xbm

lazmkafdk ~zaomss$ Izk}`mdxs oadomzdfdk y}icflfoixfads az cioexbmzmal oid jm cifh jmlazm xbm |axfdk ~}jcfo jmlazm xbm mcmoxfad idh#

adom xbm mcmoxfad fs a|mz# oid jm zifsmh is ajgmoxfads is xbm

mcmoxazic |axms izm oa}dxmh fd Oadkzmss$ Xbm `m`jmzs al xbm

_mdixm idh xbm Ba}sm al Zm~zmsmdxixf|ms izm {mcc y}icflfmh xaihg}hfoixm idv ajgmoxfads xa jiccaxs laz iccmkmhcv }dy}icflfmh

oidhfhixms$ Xbmzmlazm# xbfs azhmz bachs xbix xbm obiccmdkm ~zmsmdxmhjv ~cifdxfll fs oa``fxxmh }dhmz xbm Oadsxfx}xfad xa xbm mcmoxazs idh

xbm cmkfscixf|m jzidob# ix cmisx fd xbm lfzsx fdsxidom$

Fh$ Xbix oa}zx oadoc}hmh# ~}zs}idx xa xbm Oadsxfx}xfadic idh lmhmzic ci{ `idhixms ija|m# xbix

UgP}hfofic zm|fm{ -- fl idv -- sba}ch aoo}z adcv ilxmz xbm mcmoxazic idh Oadkzmssfadic ~zaomssms

bi|m z}d xbmfz oa}zsm$ Fh$ "m`~bisfs ihhmh&$

^cifdxflls ocif`s bmzm lifc laz xbm mriox si`m zmisads is xbm ~cifdxflls ocif`s lifcmh fd

Zajfdsad$ Xbm I`mdhmh Oa`~cifdx sf`~cv `mids xa sbazx-ofzo}fx xbm mcmoxazic ~zaomss idh

}s}z~ xbm ]dfxmh _xixms Oadkzmss zacm fd omzxflvfdk i ~zmsfhmdxfic mcmoxfad jv ixxm`~xfdk xa }sm

xbfs Oa}zxs ~a{mz xa emm~ ^zmsfhmdx Aji`i all xbm jiccax fd Xmddmssmm$ Idv sxixm ci{ zmy}fzfdk

xbix i hmxmz`fdixfad is xa i oidhfhixms y}icflfoixfad xa bach xbm allfom al xbm ^zmsfhmdx al xbm

]dfxmh _xixms a}xsfhm xbfs ~zaomss fs ocmizcv ~zabfjfxmh jv xbm lmhmzic ci{ zmy}fzfdk xbix xbm

mcmoxazixm idh xbm ]dfxmh _xixms Oadkzmss lfzsx hmxmz`fdm xbix fss}m$ Iooazhfdkcv xbm I`mdhmh

Oa`~cifdx `}sx jm hfs`fssmh laz lifc}zm xa sxixm i ocif` }dhmz Z}cm 9:"j&"?!>9!9: ^ikm 98 al 96 ^ikmFH 2=

8/2/2019 LLF v DNPUSA - 2012-03-01 - DNC et al 12(b)(1) & 12(b)(6) Memo in Support of Motion to Dismiss

15/19

:8;:99 9=

iccmkixfads izm xz}m# idh xbmv bi|m ocmizcv jmmd ~za|md `mzfxcmss idh lizofoic# xbm Hmlmdhidxs

bi|m i Lfzsx I`mdh`mdx zfkbx xa obaasm laz fxsmcl fxs da`fdmm$

Fx fs {mcc smxxcmh xbix `m`jmzs al i zmoakdfwmh ~acfxfoic ~izxv }dy}msxfadijcv bi|m i

oadsxfx}xfadic zfkbx xa smcmox xbmfz da`fdmms laz ~}jcfo allfom$ Oic$ Hm`aozixfo ^izxv |$ Gadms#

=?> ]$_$ = ]$_$ ?=9# ?;9

"966;& "G$ _xm~bmds hfssmdxfdk&$ Xbfs zfkbx mrxmdhs xa xbm sfx}ixfad {bmzm i ~izxv ixxm`~xs xa

da`fdixm i oidhfhixm xbix fs fdmcfkfjcm laz xbm allfom az }d{fccfdk xa smz|m$ Xf``ads# =:>

]$_$ ix ?=6$ Fd Gadms xbm _}~zm`m Oa}zx bmch xbix Uxbm _}~zm`m Oa}zxsP oisms |fkaza}scv

illfz` xbm s~mofic ~ciom xbm Lfzsx I`mdh`mdx zmsmz|ms laz# idh xbm s~mofic ~zaxmoxfad fx iooazhs#

xbm ~zaomss jv {bfob i ~acfxfoic ~izxv smcmoxs i sxidhizh jmizmz {ba jmsx zm~zmsmdxs xbm ~izxv+s

fhmacakfms idh ~zmlmzmdoms$ Fh$ ix =;= "fdxmzdic ofxixfads a`fxxmh&$ F`~azxidxcv# xbmsm

~zaxmoxfads bi|m jmmd mrxmdhmh s~moflfoiccv xa xbm XDH^ fd i zmomdx oism lfcmh fd xbm @fhhcm

Hfsxzfox al Xmddmssmm$ _mm E}zfxi |$ _xixm ^zf`izv Jh$ al xbm Xmdd$ Hm`aozixfo ^izxv$# Oism Da$

>2->682# :>>2 ]$_$ Hfsx$ CMRF_ 2?:;2 "bachfdk xbix xbm Xmddmssmm Hm`aozixfo ^izxv bis i

Lfzsx I`mdh`mdx zfkbx xa obaasm fxs a{d oidhfhixm laz xbm kmdmzic mcmoxfad&$

Fd sbazx# xbm Hmlmdhidxs# idh ~izxfo}cizcv xbm XDH^ {ba fs sacmcv idh mroc}sf|mcv

zms~adsfjcm laz fhmdxflvfdk fxs da`fdmm laz xbm Mcmoxfad# bi|m i oadsxfx}xfadic zfkbx xa obaasm laz

fxsmcl fxs a{d da`fdmm$ Fdsxmih# fl ^cifdxflls {fsbmh xa obiccmdkm xbm XDH^s ~axmdxfic da`fdmm#

fx `}sx {aze {fxbfd xbm ~zaomss smx lazxb jv xbm XDH^ laz hmxmz`fdfdk fxs da`fdmm laz xbm

Mcmoxfad idh sba}ch dax ~mxfxfad xbm oa}zxs xa kmx fd|ac|mh {fxb xbm XDH^s smcmoxfad al fxs

da`fdmm$ _mm E}zfxi |$ _xixm ^zf`izv Jh$ al xbm Xmdd$ Hm`aozixfo ^izxv# Oism Da$ ?7>2->682#

:>>2 ]$_$ Hfsx$ CMRF_ 22>;9 "@$H$ Xmdd$ :>>2& "daxfdk xbix lmhmzic oa}zxs sba}ch i|afh

fdxmzlmzmdom {fxb xbm Lfzsx I`mdh`mdx issaofixfadic zfkbxs al i ~acfxfoic ~izxv {bmd xbix ~izxv fs

mdkikmh fd xbm ~zaomss al smcmoxfdk fxs da`fdmm laz ~}jcfo allfom&$

Oism :79:-o|->:98?-_XI-oko Hao}`mdx = Lfcmh >?!>9!9: ^ikm 9= al 96 ^ikmFH 2

8/2/2019 LLF v DNPUSA - 2012-03-01 - DNC et al 12(b)(1) & 12(b)(6) Memo in Support of Motion to Dismiss

16/19

:8;:99 9 ]$_$ ix =

8/2/2019 LLF v DNPUSA - 2012-03-01 - DNC et al 12(b)(1) & 12(b)(6) Memo in Support of Motion to Dismiss

17/19

:8;:99 9;

UXPbm hmlmdhidx s}~~cfmh fdlaz`ixfad xa xbm ~cifdxfll5 xbm

fdlaz`ixfad {is licsm5 xbm hmlmdhidx hfh dax mrmzofsm zmisadijcmoizm fd ajxifdfdk az oa``}dfoixfdk xbm fdlaz`ixfad5 idh xbm

~cifdxfll g}sxflfijcv zmcfmh ad xbm fdlaz`ixfad$

Oixa |$ Jixxs# :>99 Xmdd$ I~~$ CMRF_ ;? '9; "Xmdd$ Ox$ I~~$& ofxfdk @mzzf`id |$ _`fxb# =66

_$[$:h =82# ==2->6 "Xmdd$ Ox$ I~~$

:>>=& "Fd azhmz xa s}oommh fd idv ioxfad jismh }~ad lzi}h}cmdx az dmkcfkmdx `fszm~zmsmdxixfad#

xbm ~cifdxfll `}sx ~za|m xbix fx zmcfmh g}sxflfijcv ad xbm hmlmdhidx+s sxixm`mdxs$ Xbm j}zhmd fs dax

Oism :79:-o|->:98?-_XI-oko Hao}`mdx = Lfcmh >?!>9!9: ^ikm 9; al 96 ^ikmFH 22

8/2/2019 LLF v DNPUSA - 2012-03-01 - DNC et al 12(b)(1) & 12(b)(6) Memo in Support of Motion to Dismiss

18/19

:8;:99 92

}~ad xbm hmlmdhidx xa sba{ xbix fx {is dax dmkcfkmdx# j}x zixbmz# xbm j}zhmd fs }~ad xbm ~cifdxfll

xa sba{ xbix fxs zmcfidom }~ad idv sxixm`mdxs hmlmdhidxs `iv bi|m `ihm {is zmisadijcm$&

FFF$ Icxmzdixf|mcv# Icc Axbmz Hmlmdhidxs J}x Xbm XDH^ _ba}ch Jm Hfs`fssmhJmoi}sm Xbmv Izm Dax Zms~adsfjcm Laz _}j`fxxfdk Xbm Hm`aozixfo ^izxvsDa`fdmm Xa Xbm XD _mozmxizv Al _xixm

M|md fl xbfs Oa}zx bis s}jgmox `ixxmz g}zfshfoxfad# idh m|md fl xbm I`mdhmh Oa`~cifdx

sxixmh i ocif`# fx ocmizcv hams dax sxixm i ocif` ikifdsx icc xbm Hmlmdhidxs$ ]dhmz Xmdd$ Oahm

Idd$ :-=-:>9# xbm XDH^ fs sacmcv zms~adsfjcm laz s}j`fxxfdk xbm di`m al xbm Hm`aozixfo ^izxv

da`fdmm xa xbm XD _mozmxizv al _xixm$ _~moflfoiccv# Xmdd$ Oahm Idd$ :-=-:>9 zmy}fzms xbix i

~mzsads di`m jm sba{d ad i jiccax is xbm da`fdmm al i ~acfxfoic ~izxv adcv fl fx fs s}j`fxxmh jv i

sxixm{fhm ~acfxfoic ~izxv$ Fd axbmz {azhs# xbm XDH^# is xbm sxixm ~izxv al xbm Hm`aozixfo ^izxv#

fs sacmcv idh mroc}sf|mcv zms~adsfjcm laz fhmdxflvfdk xbm hm`aozixfo oidhfhixm laz idv sxixm{fhm

ziom$ _mm Xmdd$ Oahm Idd$ :-=-:>9$

Xbfs fs ms~moficcv sa laz xbm DH^ ]_I$ Jismh ad i zm|fm{ al ~}jcfocv i|ifcijcm

hao}`mdxs lfcmh {fxb xbm XD _mozmxizv al _xixm# xbm DH^ ]_I fs i~~izmdxcv i `mzm sbi`

azkidfwixfad ozmixmh fd :>9># ~assfjcv azkidfwmh jv xbm _bmcjv Oa}dxv Zm~}jcfoid ^izxv# fd

azhmz xa }sm# {fxba}x i}xbazfwixfad idh fd jih lifxb# xbm di`m Dixfadic Hm`aozixfo ^izxv laz

dmlizfa}s ~}z~asms cfem xbfs ci{s}fx$ Axbmz ioxf|m di`ms laz xbm DH^ ]_I fdoc}hm xbm _bmcjv

Oa}dxv Zm~}jcfoid ^izxv# Fdo$ Xbm DH^ ]_Is ~zfdof~ic ~ciom al j}sfdmss fs fd @m`~bfs idh

is fs aj|fa}s lza` xbm I`mdhmh Oa`~cifdx# xbm XDH^ fs jismh fd Disb|fccm$ Xiemd xakmxbmz# fx

fs ocmiz xbix xbm DH^ ]_I fs dax i ~za~mz ~izxv xa xbfs ci{s}fx# idh i~~izmdxcv xbfs azkidfwixfad

{is di`mh is i ~izxv hmlmdhidx laz xbm sacm ~}z~asm al ajxifdfdk |md}m fd _bmcjv Oa}dxv$ Icc

Hmlmdhidxs j}x xbm XDH^ sba}ch jm hfs`fssmh f``mhfixmcv$:?>8=&

Jmdgi`fd I$ Kisxmc "J^Z/>:29-9