Upload
nocompromisewtruth
View
217
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
1/57
Jozk M{ldktz7 ??,;1925 omh ??,;1?18
&J`mz`cehoxkh Akdt{otu :# 49?4%
[MEXKH ZXOXKZ J@[TX @A OYYKOCZ
A@T XFK MEMXF JETJ[EX
PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPCEZO CEDKTE# kx oc#
Ycoemxeaaz/Oyykcckkz#
z-
@TCU XOEXW# HKAKMH @[T
ATKKH@LZ A@[MHOXE@MZ# EMJ-# kx oc#
Hkakmhomxz/Oyykccomxz-
777777777777
7777
@m Oyykoc at`l xfk [mexkh Zxoxkz Hezxtejx J`{tx#
Jkmxtoc Hezxtejx `a Jocea`tmeo# Z`{xfktm Heeze`m
Jozk M`- 67??,j,9986;
F`m`todck Omhtkr B{eca`th
OYYKCCKKZ L@XE@M X@ ZXTENK OYYKCCOMX HKAKMH @[TATKKH@LZ A@[MHOXE@MZ# EMJ- TKYCU DTEKA OMH KVFEDEXZ ?#
4 omh :> A@T ZOMJXE@MZ> OMH OXX@TMKU AKKZ
Yfecey G- Dktb# Kzq{etk &YO Dot M`- 95612%
COR @AAEJKZ @A YFECEY G- DKTB
;;; Omh`tto Bckm J`{tx# Z{exk ?4
Coaoukxxk Fecc# YO ?5888,4;:?Yf7 &1?9% 64;,:?:8
Aov7 &1?9% 6:8,21;5Kloec7 yfecgdktbIbloec-j`l
Oxx`tmku a`t Oyykcckkz# Cezo Cedkte# Cezo
@zxkcco# B` Kvjkc Bc`doc# Yfecey G- Dktb#Kzq{etk omh xfk Cor @aaejkz `a Yfecey G-
Dktb
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 ? `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
2/57
e
XODCK @A J@MXKMXZ
Yobkz
XODCK @A J@MXKMXZ-------e
XODCK @A O[XF@TEXEKZ---------ee,q
ZXOXKLKMX @A AOJXZ-?,;
OTB[LKMX---1,?;
E- OTB[LKMXZ omh KQEHKMJK YTKZKMXKH
a`t xfk AETZX XELK em o TKYCU DTEKA otk
ROEQKH omh L[ZX DK ZXTEJNKM -1,?9
EE- OTB[LKMXZ omh KQEHKMJK EMXT@H[JKH
a`t xfk AETZX XELK em om OYYKOC recc M@X
DK J@MZEHKTKH -----------------------------------?9,??
EEE- ZOMJXE@MZ OBOEMZX @TCU XOEXW# KZ_-
OTK ROTTOMXKH--?4,?;
EQ- J@MJC[ZE@M---?;
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 4 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
3/57
ee
XODCK @A O[XF@TEXEKZ
Jozkz Yobk&z%
Oc`k Qkto `a Olktejo# Emj- q- [mexkh Zxoxkz#:21 A-:h 519 &5xf Jet- 4998%---?8
D-N-D- q- Lo{e Y`cejk Hkyx-#
421 A-:h ?95?# ??92,96 &5xf Jet- 4994%---------?8# ?;
Dotmkxx# kx oc q-@dolo# kx oc#[-Z-H-J-# Jkmxtoc Hezxtejx `a JO# Z`{xfktm Heq-#
Jozk M`- 95,jq,99964 H@J--8
D`cnkt q- J`llezze mkt# 219 A-4h ?9:5# ?984 &5xf Jet-?56;%--5
Jotlkm q- Zom Atomjezj` [meaekh Zjf- Hezx-#4:2 A-:h ?941# ?9:9 &5xf Jet- 499?%---??
Jkhom`,Qekto q- Ozfjt`ax#
:48 A-:h ?914# ?911 m-; &5xf Jet- 499:%---6
ja- Jottebom q- Joc- Zxoxk Ckbezcox{tk#
41: A-4h ;19# ;18 &5xf Jet- ?5;5%-------?4
Jfoldktz q- Mozj`# Emj-# ;9? [-Z- :4# 8;,;9 &?55?% ---?:# ?8
Jxt- a`t De`,Kxfejoc Tka`tl# Emj- q- Jexu ! J`{mxu `a F`m`c{c{#4991 [-Z- Oyy- CKVEZ ?16:2> 8;; A-:h 5?9 &5xf Jet- G{cu 1# 4991%--??
Kdktck q- Jexu `a Omofkel# 59? A-4h 6?8# 6?6 &5xf Jet-?559%---5
Kzxoxk `a Dcoz# 254 A-4h 6;6# 619 &5xf Jet- ?561%---?8
Aemn q- B`lkw# 4:5 A-:h 565# 55:,58 &5xf Jet- 499?%-?8
Btoqkz q- Otyoe`# 14: A-:h ?98:# ?986 &5xf Jet- 49?9%5
Em tk De`Cozk Xkjf- Zkj- Cexeb-#
M`- 98,582 H@J &J-H- Joc- Gom- 42# 499:%---??
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 : `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
4/57
eee
XODCK @A O[XF@TEXEKZ , J`mxem{kh
Jozkz Yobk&z%
Em tk Ckfxemkm# ;18 A-:h ?9;4# ?91? m-8 &5xf Jet- 4995%-- ---?8
Gomkz q- Roc,Lotx Zx`tkz# Emj-# 425 A-:h 66:# 662 &5xf
Jet- 4994%-----?9
Netzfmkt q- [mehkm J`ty- `a Ol-#
684 A-4h ?928# ?922 &5xf Jet- ?566%-??# ?4
N`ktmkt q- Bteboz# :46 A-:h ?9:5# ?986 &5xf Jet- 499:%- 6
Ckmxeme q- Joc- Jxt- a`t xfk Otxz#:29 A-:h 6:2# 68: m-1 &5xf Jet- 4998%---6
Cedkte# kx oc q- Hkakmh {t Atkkh`lz A`{mhoxe`mz# Emj-#
[-Z- J`{tx `a Oyykocz a t xfk Memxf Jetj{ex# Jozk M`- ??,;1925?
Cedkte# kx oc q- @tcu Xoexw# kx oc#[-Z- J`{tx `a Oyykocz a`t xfk Memxf Jetj{ex# Jozk M`- ??,;1?18-?
LojH`moch q- Btojk Jf{tjf Zkoxxck#8;2 A-:h ?925# ?961 &5xf Jet- 4991%---?9
Mkr Ocozno Hkq- J`ty- q- B{kxzjf`r#
615 A-4h ?456# ?:91 &5xf Jet- ?565%---?8
Yohbkxx q- Rtebfx# ;62 A-:h 56:# 56; m-4 &5xf
Jet- 4995%?9
Ykxktz`m q- Febfcomh L{zej# Emj-#?89 A-:h- ?:?:# ?:4? &5xf Jet- ?556%--??
Tf`hkz q- LojH`moch#
129 A- Z{yy- 4h ?:1: &L-H- Bo 4995%--8
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 8 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
5/57
eq
XODCK @A O[XF@TEXEKZ , J`mxem{kh
Jozkz Yobk&z%
Tf`hkz q- LojH`moch#49?9 [-Z- Oyy- CKVEZ ;:89 &??xf Jet- Lot- ?;# 49?9%8
Teqktmehkt q- [-Z- Domn# [-Z-H-J-# Z`{xfktm Hezxtejx a Ac`teho#
Jozk M`- 5795,jq,6?4;;,RYH--8
Zlexf q- Lotzf# ?58 A-:8h ?98;# ?9;4 &5xf
Jet- ?555%?9
Xoexw q- Lejfokc Ozxt{k#[-Z-H-J-# Hezxtejx a J`c{ldeo# Jozk M`- ??,8948
[mexkh Zxoxkz q- Kceoz# 54? A-4h 629# 628 &5xf
Jet- ?559%--?9# ??
[mexkh Zxoxkz q- Tkothkm#
:85 A-:h 196# 1?8 m-4 &5xf Jet- 499:%-----------6
[MEXKH ZXOXKZ J@HK
Yobk&z%
46 [-Z-J- ?542?:# ?8
AKHKTOC T[CKZ @A OYYKCCOXK YT@JKH[TK
Yobk&z%
Akh- T- Oyy- Y- 81&j%-?:
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 ; `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
6/57
q
XODCK @A O[XF@TEXEKZ , J`mxem{kh
MEMXF JETJ[EX C@JOC T[CKZ
Yobk&z%
C`joc T{ck :9,?---?4
C`joc T{ck :9,4-?4# ?:
C`joc T{ck 81,4---?4
MEMXF JETJ[EX OHQEZ@TU J@LLEXXKK M@XKZ X@ T[CK 81,4
Yobk&z%
M`xk :?:
M`xk 8?:
M`xk 2?:
M`xk 6?:
M`xk 5-?:
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 1 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
7/57
?
OYYKCCKKZ L@XE@M X@ ZXTENK OYYKCCOMX# HKAKMH @[T
ATKKH@LZ A@[MHOXE@MZ# EMJ- TKYCU DTEKA OMH OCC KVFEDEXZ
Oyykcckkz Cezo Cedkte ^Cedkte\# Cezo @zxkcco ^@zxkcco\# B` Kvjkc Bc`doc
^BKB\# Yfecey G- Dktb# Kzq{etk ^Dktb\# omh xfk Cor @aaejkz `a Yfecey G- Dktb
`dgkjx x` Oyykccomx# Hkakmh `{t Atkkh`lz A`{mhoxe`mz# Emj- ^H@AA\# `t
^Oyykccomx\# Tkycu Dteka omh Kvfedexz em xfket kmxetkxu- Oyykcckkz otk ocz` oznemb
xfez J`{tx x` Zomjxe`m Oxx`tmku a`t H@AA# @tcu Xoexw# Kzq{etk# omh oroth
Oyykcckkz Oxx`tmku Akkz omh j`zxz-
ZXOXKLKMX @A AOJXZ
Oyykccomxz Oyykoc ez at`l xfk Hezxtejx J`{txz Hkmeoc `a xfket Omxe,ZCOYY
L`xe`m- Xfez Oyykoc foz dkkm hkcoukh m{lkt`{z xelkz du xfk Oyykccomxz# rfejf
ez m`x xfk aetzx xelk xfku fok {zkh om Oyykccoxk J`{tx a`t z{jf xojxejz-
Oyykccomxz aeckh xfket @ykmemb Dteka `m Hkjkldkt ?5# 49??> @m Akdt{otu :#
49?4# Oyykccoxk J`llezze`mkt Ykxkt C- Zfor j`mz`cehoxkh Oyykccoxk JozkzCedkte#
kx oc q- Hkakmh `{t Atkkh`lz A`{mhoxe`mz# Emj-# Jozk M`- ??,;1925 aeckh du @tcu
Xoexw `m dkfoca `a H@AA> omh Cedkte# kx oc q- @tcu Xoexw# kx oc# Jozk M`- ??,;1?18
aeckh du Gkaatku J{mmembfol# Kzq- `m dkfoca `a @tcu Xoexw# zkk o xt{k omh j`ttkjx
j`yu `a J`llezze`mkt Zforz @thkt oxxojfkh fktkx` oz KVFEDEX O-
Oyykcckkz &Ycoemxeaaz% aeckh xfket J`mz`cehoxkh Omzrktemb Dteka `m Lotjf ?5#
49?4-
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 2 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
8/57
4
Oytec ?5# 49?4# Gkaatku J{mmembfol# Kzq- `m dkfoca `a @tcu Xoexw aeckh rfox
fk jocckh o J`mz`cehoxkh Tkycu Dteka oc`mb rexf o Z{yycklkmxoc Kvjktyx `a
Tkj`th em Jozk M`- ??,;1925# H`jnkx M`-z ^HMz\ 89,? omh 89,4> o akr f`{tz
coxkt# @tcu Xoexw# Kzq- ^Xoexw\ `m dkfoca `a H@AA ocz` aeckh o J`mz cehoxkh
Tkycu Dteka omh xftkk ^:\ Kvfedexz em Jozk M`- ??,;1?18# HMz :;,?# :;,4# :;,:#
omh :;,8# hkzyexk xfk J`{txz @thkt j`mz`cehoxemb xfk Oyykocz-
@tcu Xoexw foz Od{zkh xfk J`{txz Yt`jkzz# aecemb o zkj`mhotu J`mz`cehoxkh
Tkycu Dteka# o xfetxu,xr` ^:4\ dteka# rexf otb{lkmxz m`x toezkh em H@AAz
@ykmemb Oyykccoxk Dteka omh otb{lkmxz xfox fok odz`c{xkcu m`xfemb x` h` rexf
Xoexwz omh H@AAz Oyykoc- @tcu Xoexw `m dkfoca `a H@AA ocz` aeckh xftkk ^:\
Kvfedexz rexf xfket Tkycu Dteka xfox fok m` tkcoxe`m x` H@AA omh Xoexwz Oyykoc
omh `mk `a xfk Kvfedexz# HM :;,8# @tcu Xoexw `dxoemkh du ato{h{ckmx omh hkjkyxek
lkomz-
@m `t od`{x Akdt{otu 48# 49??# @tcu Xoexw oz om Oxx`tmku omh om @aaejkt `a
xfk J`{tx j`mxojxkh xfk J`ll`mrkocxf `a Ykmmzucomeo Z{ytklk J`{tx omh zy`nk
rexf Lotjkk Zc`om# Fkotemb J``themox t a`t xfk Hezjeycemotu D`oth `a xfk
Ykmmzucomeo Z{ytklk J`{tx- Xoexw aoczkcu x`ch Lz- Zc om xfox zfk roz
tkytkzkmxemb xfk [mexkh Zxoxkz Hezxtejx J`{tx# Jkmxtoc Hezxtejx `a Jocea`tmeo omh
G{hbk B{eca`th oznkh fkt x` `dxoem xfk h`j{lkmxz em xfk hezjeycemotu yt`jkkhemb#
occ `a rfejf roz j`lyckxkcu aoczk- @tcu Xoexwz Kvfedex :# HM :;,8# EH 6?82946
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 6 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
9/57
:
oxxojfkh x H@AAz Tkycu Dteka# HM :;,? otk h`j{lkmxz xfox otk m`x y{dcej omh
j`mxoem Oxx`tmku/Jcekmx yteeckbk oz rkcc oz yteoxk ehkmxeauemb ema`tloxe`m oz x`
Yfecey G- Dktb# Kzq{etkz jcekmx- Zkk xfk Hkjcotoxe`m `a Yfecey G- Dktb# Kzq{etk
^Dktb Hkjc-\ aeckh j`mj{ttkmxcu fktkrexf ox yobk y- t yy-\ ?,4# 4# :# ;- @m
Oytec 49# 49?4# @tcu Xoexw y`zxkh xfk h`j{lkmxz zfk aeckh rexf xfez J`{tx Oytec ?5#
49?4# emjc{hemb fkt Tkycu Dteka omh Kvfedexz ? xft`{bf :# occ `kt xfk Emxktmkx#
zkmx ex `{x em xf`{zomhz `a TZZ akkhz> xrkkxkh xfk ema tloxe m> y`zxkh xfk
ema`tloxe`m `m fkt Z`jeoc mkxr`tn zexkz> foh `xfkt rkdzexkz y`zx ex# kxj- Emxktmkx
ohhtkzzkz Xoexw y`zxkh xfkzk h`j{lkmxz emjc{hk# d{x otk m`x celexkh x`7
fxxy7//rrr-`tcuxoexwkzq-j`l>fxxy7//rrr-`tcuxoexwkzq-j`l/0y
fxxy7//rrr-`tcuxoexwkzq-j`l/0oxxojflkmxPehfxxy7//rrr-`tcuxoexwkzq-j`l/0oxxojflkmxPehfxxy7//rrr-`tcuxoexwkzq-j`l/0oxxojflkmxPehfxxy7//rrr-`tcuxoexwkzq-j`l/0oxxojflkmxPehfxxy7//rrr-`tcuxoexwkzq-j`l/0oxxojflkmxPeh
fxxy7//rrr-`tcuxoexwkzq-j`l/ry,j`mxkmx/{yc`ohz/49?4/98/Cedkte,,H`aa,5xf,jetj{ex,aeckh,aemoc,tkycu,98-?:-49?4-yha>
fxxy7//rrr-`tcuxoexwkzq-j`l/ry,j`mxkmx/{yc`ohz/49?4/98/Cedkte,,H@AA,aeckh,tkycu,du,@tcu,Xoexw-yha>
fxxy7//rrr-`tcuxoexwkzq-j`l/ry,j`mxkmx/{yc`ohz/49?4/98/Dktb,Tky`tx,94-?9-49?4,Hezjeycemotu,xteoc-yha>
fxxy7//rrr-`tcuxoexwkzq-j`l/ry,j`mxkmx/{yc`ohz/49?4/98/Dktb,j`lycoemx,du,xfk,hezjeycemotu,d`oth-yha>
fxxy7//rrr-`tcuxoexwkzq-j`l/ry,j`mxkmx/{yc`ohz/49?4/98/Dktb,omzrkt,x`,xfk,hezjeycemotu,d`oth?-yha>
fxxy7//mkxr`tnkhdc`bz-j`l/rA1ZO>fxxy7//rrr-aojkd``n-j`l/`tcuxoexw>
fxxy7//rrr-aojkd``n-j`l/`tcuxoexw/y`zxz/?9?;9298:??6;952;>fxxy7//mkxr`tnkhdc`bz-j`l/rAOwm0o
fxxy7//rrr-aojkd``n-j`l/ht-`tcu-xoexw/oyyP55;:42??::>
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 5 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
10/57
8
fxxy7//dka`tkexzmkrz-j`l/zx tu/49;?/11?/AeckhPukzxkthou-fxlc>fxxy7//dka`tkexzmkrz-j`l/zx`tekz/du/99999999999484::>
fxxy7//rrr-`tcuxoexwkzq-j`l/0yfxxy7//rrr-`tcuxoexwkzq-j`l/0oxxojflkmxPeh
fxxy7//dka`tkexzmkrz-j`l/zx`tu/?52;/;28> omh/Ato{hPEzP[mtokcemb-PYfeceyPDktb#PRf`PFozPDkkmPFotozzembPLkPA`t
P:PUkotzPRexfPOPD`b{zPCorPZ{ex#PTkjkmxcuPOhlexxkhPX`PHkato{hembPXfkPHezjeycemotuPD`oth-PADEPObkmxPXkzxeaekhPXfoxPH`j{lkmxzPZ{dle
xxkhPDuPYfeceyPDktbPomhPCezoPCedktePRktkPA`tbktekz-fxlc-
{zkh xfk J`{tx oz o y{dcezfemb bt`{mh a`t fkt Ytkzz Tkckozk x` y{dcezf yteoxk
j`maehkmxeoc h`j{lkmxz zfk ato{h{ckmxcu# {mhkt aoczk ytkxkmzkz# `dxoemkh at`l o
J`{tx?-
Xoexw ato{h{ckmx# jocj{coxkh# ecckboc omh holobemb ojxe`mz ez rfu Oyykcckkz
otk z{emb Xoexw- Xoexw j`mxem{kz {zemb xfk J`{txz# Od{zemb xfk Yt`jkzz# oz o Ytkzz
? Xoexw# j`{mzkc a`t H@AA# foz o fezx`tu `a `dxoememb h`j{lkmxz du ato{h{ckmx lkomz omh aecemblom{aojx{tkh# ocxktkh omh a`tbkh h`j{lkmxz oz bkm{emk# em `{t Akhktoc J`{txz# zkk Tf`hkz q-LojH`moch# 129 A- Z{yy- 4h ?:1: &L-H- Bo- 4995% &ely`zemb (49#999 zomjxe`mz `m j`{mzkc@tcu Xoexw a`t {zk `a xfk ckboc yt`jkzz a`t om elyt`ykt y{ty`zk%# oaah Tf`hkz q- LojH`moch#49?9 [-Z- Oyy- CKVEZ ;:89 &??xf Jet- Lot- ?;# 49?9%> Cedkte# kx oc q- Xoexw# kx oc# [-Z-H-J-#Jkmxtoc Hezxtejx `a Jocea`tmeo# Z`{xfktm Heeze`m# Jozk M`- 67??,j,9986; OGB &(4;9-99Zomjxe`mz a`t aoecemb x` odehk du xfk J`{txz G{mk ?8# 49?? @thkt# HM 442%> Dotmkxx# kx oc q-@dolo# kx oc# [-Z-H-J-# Jkmxtoc Hezxtejx `a JO# Z`{xfktm He-# Jozk M`- 95,j,99964 H@J&Lom{aojx{tkh/a`tbkh Nkmuo Detxf Jktxeaejoxk# H`jnkx M`- ;;,: aeckh Zkyx- 8# 4995 omh Jktxeaekhj`yu `a Nkmuo Tkbezxtoxe`m `a Detxf# H`jnkx M`- :8,4 aeckh O{b{zx ?# 4995 dkotemb YtkzehkmxDotojn @doloz molk%> Teqktmehkt q- [-Z- Domn# [-Z-H-J-# Z`{xfktm Hezxtejx `a Ac`teho# JozkM`- 5795,j,6?4;;,RYH# zkk H`jnkx M`- ;;,? aeckh Gom{otu 41# 49?9 &Lom{aojx{tkh# ocxktkhomh a`tbkh rkdzexk yobkz> z{dy`kmoz omh kloecz aeckh oz bkm{emk du Xoexw%> omh Xoexw q- LejfokcOzxt{k# [-Z-H-J-# Hezxtejx `a J`c{ldeo# Jozk M`- ??,894# H`jnkx M`- :5# @jx`dkt ?2# 49??#@yeme`m `a G{hbk Coldktxf# yobk :# am 4 omh H`jnkx M`- :: aeckh O{b{zx :9# 49?? @yeme`m `aG{hbk Coldktxf# yobkz 2,6# am 8 &ato{h{ckmxcu `dxoemkh Zkckjxek Zktejk Tkj`th `a Ytkzehkmx@dolo omh o kteaejoxe`m `a Ytkzehkmx @doloz Z`jeoc Zkj{texu m{ldkt `dxoemkh em e`coxe`m `a`{t Akhktoc Corz# xft`{bf xfk Z`jeoc Zkj{texu K,Qkteau%- Dktb Hkjc-# yy- 1,2# ?9-
Zkk Dktbz Hkjc- ox yy- :,8# 6# 5# Kvdz- ? xft`{bf ;# yy- 5,?29- Xoexw
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 ?9 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
11/57
;
jkmxkt x` y{dcezf fkt aoczk zx`tekz# ato{h{ckmxcu `dxoemkh h`j{lkmxz# a`tbkh omh
ocxktkh h`j{lkmxz# omh x` jottu `{x fkt xftkoxz omh kmhkxxoz oboemzx xf`zk rf` h`
m`x obtkk rexf fkt# Oyykcckkz fktkem- Xoexw ojxe`mz omh dkfoe`tz recc m`x zx`y
{mxec xfk J`{tx xonkz ojxe`m oboemzx fkt- Xoexw foz dkkm om Oxx`tmku# cejkmzkh em xfk
Zxoxk `a Jocea`tmeo zemjk 4994# zfk nm`rz rfox zfk ez h`emb# omh foz dkkm occ`rkh
du `{t J`{txz# x` j`mxem{k fkt ecckboc omh holobemb dkfoe`tz omh ojxe`mz oz zfk ez
heaaej{cx x` hkoc rexf omh xfk J`{txz nm`r zfk recc y{dcezf xfk G{hbkz yteoxk
hoxo# oxxojn xfk G{hbkz Jcktnz# ojj{zk xfk G{hbkz `a jtelkz# kxj-4
Oyykcckkz fok
cekh xfkzk xojxejz# omh {mxec o J`{tx xonkz ojxe m x` zx`y ex# cenk G{hbk Comh em
Bk`tbeo heh# Xoexw recc j`mxem{k {zemb xfez J`{tx omh xfk J`{txz em xfez zxoxk oz o
h{lyemb bt`{mh omh Oyykcckkz recc j`mxem{k dkemb a{txfkt holobkh-
A`t xfkzk tkoz`mz# Oyykcckkz tkq{kzx H@AAz Tkycu Dteka omh occ Kvfedexz
aeckh xfktkrexf# oyykotemb oz HMz :;,?> :;,4> :;,:> omh :;,8 dk zxtejnkm> Xoexw
Zomjxe`mkh> omh Oyykcckkz orothkh Oxx`tmku Akkz omh j`zxz-
4 Xfkzk otk xfk ojxe`mz Xoexw x``n oboemzx Oyykcckkz fktkem> Xoexw `dxoemkh occ `a xfk Oyykcckkzyteoxk hoxo# aemomjeoc tkj`thz# jtkhex tky`txz# kxj-> y{dcezfkh xfk yteoxk hoxo omh aoczk zx`tekz#aoczk occkboxe`mz# aeckh cor kma`tjklkmx tky`txz oboemzx Oyykcckkz dozkh `m aoczk occkboxe`mz>oxxklyxkh x` fok xfk Oyykcckkz ottkzxkh dozkh `m fkt aoczk occkboxe`mz> Xoexw foz omh fohh`j{lkmxz a`tbkh em Oyykcckkz molkz omh Kloec Ohhtkzzkz> omh lomu `xfkt holobemb ojxz-Oyykcckkz fok tky`txkh xfk jtelkz x` xfket c`joc cor kma`tjklkmx obkmjekz# d{x dkjo{zk xfkjtelkz jt`zz z` lomu zxoxk cemkz &Mkr Lkvej`> Mkr Gktzku> Ykmmzucomeo> omh Jocea`tmeo# ex ezheaaej{cx a`t xfk Zxoxk Obkmjekz x` yt`zkj{xk- Kojf cor kma`tjklkmx obkmju Oyykcckkz fok aeckhtky`txz# nm`remb Oyykcckkz otk z{emb Xoexw# j`mxem{k oznemb rfox `{t J`{txz otk h`emb x` fkcyyt`xkjx xfk Oyykcckkz omh rfu xfk J`{txz fok m`x ezz{kh o Tkzxtoememb @thkt `t Emg{mjxe`m-
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 ?? `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
12/57
1
OTB[LKMX
E- OTB[LKMXZ OMH KQEHKMJK YTKZKMXKH A@T XFK
AETZX XELK EM O TKYCU DTEKA OTK ROEQKH OMH L[ZX
DK ZXTEJNKM
Xfez J`{tx j`mz`cehoxkh xfk xr` &4% Oyykocz omh `thktkh Oyykcckkz x` aeck o
J`mz`cehoxkh Omzrktemb Dteka omh Oyykccomxz x` aeck o j`mz`cehoxkh Tkycu Dteka-
Emzxkoh `a j`lycuemb# Xoexw omh H@AA x``n ex {y`m xfklzkckz x` aeck xr` &4%
zkyotoxk dtekaz# x`xocemb jc`zk x` a`{txkkm xf`{zomh r`thz omh zevxu,a`{t yobkz-
Oyykcckkz rktk m`x oaa`thkh xfk `yy`tx{mexu x` ohhtkzz xfk mkr kvxkmhkh
otb{lkmxz toezkh a`t xfk aetzx xelk em xfkzk xr` &4% Tkycu Dtekaz &Jozk M`- ??,
;1925# HM 89,?> omh Jozk M`- ??,;1?18# HM :;,?%- Oyykcckkz fok ocz` aeckh o
L`xe`m x` zxtenk mkr otb{lkmxz em @tcu Xoexw dteka# HM 89,? aeckh em Jozk ??,
;1925 omh xfket Z{yycklkmxoc Kvjktyx `a Tkj`th# HM 89,4# otb{lkmxz omh
h`j{lkmxz m`x ohhtkzzkh em xfket Oyykccomxz @ykmemb Dteka omh m`x ytkzkmxkh x`
xfk Hezxtejx j`{tx rexf xfket Omxe,ZCOYY L`xe`m- A`t xfez tkoz`m oc`mk# H@AAz
Tkycu omh occ xftkk &:% kvfedexz oxxojfkh xfktkrexf l{zx dk zxtejnkm-
H@AA em xfket Tkycu Dteka toezkh xfk a`cc`remb otb{lkmxz# a`t xfk aetzx xelk7
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 ?4 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
13/57
2
@m yobkz xr` xft`{bf xftkk :-8
E- Oyykccomx# Hkakmh @{t Atkkh`lz A`{mhoxe`mz# Emj-#
Emj`ty`toxkz Du Tkaktkmjk Jktxoem Y`txe`mz `a xfk Tkcoxkh
Tkycu Dteka `a Oyykccomx# @tcu Xoexw# em Xfkzk J`mz`cehoxkh
Oyykocz
@m yobkz a`{t xft`{bf xfetxkkm
o- Ycoemxeaaz , du xfket zeckmjk em xfket dteka , ohlex xfox xfket
J`{mx @mk# a`t Qe coxe m `a xfk Aetzx omh A`{txkkmxf
Olkmhlkmx ^zej\ `a xfk [mexkh Zxoxkz J`mzxex{e`m ^zej\# ez
ckboccu emz{aaejekmx
d- Ycoemxeaaz J`{mx Xr`# a`t Hkaoloxe`m Ykt Zk# Zcomhktomh Cedkc# ez ckboccu emz{aaejekmx
j- Ycoemxeaaz J`{mx Xftkk# a`t Aoczk,Cebfx Emqoze`m `a
Yteqoju# ez ckboccu emz{aaejekmx
h- Ycoemxeaaz J`{mx A`{t# a`t Fotozzlkmx# ez ckboccu
emz{aaejekmx oz rkcc oz m`x dkemb o ckboccu,j`bmewodck jcoel
k- Ycoemxeaaz J`{mx Aeqk# a`t Aoczk Hkzebmoxe`mz omh
Hkzjteyxe`mz `a Aojxz# ez ckboccu emz{aaejekmx
a- Ycoemxeaaz J`{mx Zev# a`t Emg{mjxeqk Tkceka # ez ckboccu
emz{aaejekmx omh ez m`x o zkyotoxk jcoel a`t tkceka
: Oyykcckkz/Ycoemxeaaz em xfez L`xe`m otk jexemb x` xfk xexck yotobtoyf a`t kojf mkr otb{lkmx omhxfk yobk m{ldktz rfktk xfk otb{lkmx kvezxz em H@AAz Tkycu- Oyykcckkz otk m`x occ`xxkhkm`{bf yobkz x` q{`xk kktu zkmxkmjk em xfk mkr otb{lkmxz- Oxxojfkh fktkx` oz KVFEDEX Oez o j`yu `a H@AAz Tkycu Dteka rexf kojf mkr otb{lkmx febfcebfxkh em ukcc`r# rfejf l{zx dkzxtejnkm-
8 Oyykcckkz otk {zemb xfk KJA h`jnkxemb Zuzxklz yobk m{ldktemb ox xfk x`y `a kojf h`j{lkmxoz Xoexw foz m`xyt`yktcu yobk m{ldktkh H@AAz Tkycu# k-b- Xoexw yobk m{ldktz b` at`l yobk?9 x` yobk 4-
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 ?: `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
14/57
6
Yobkz xrkmxu,a`{t xft`{bf xfetxu,`mk7
OYYKCCKKZ J@LLEXXKH KBTKBE@[Z ATO[H @M XFK
J@[TX# RFKM XFKU XTEKH X@ J@QKT [Y COJN @A
Z[DGKJX LOXXKT G[TEZHEJXE@M OMH COJN @A
HEQKTZEXU OX XFK XELK XFK J@LYCOEMX ROZ AECKH
ATO[H @M XFK J@[TX DU XFK OYYKCCKKZ EZ O YOTX
OMH YOTJKC @A XFK ZOLK L@H[Z @YKTOMHE
EQ- J`mjc{ze`mCOJN @A HEQKTZEXU OX XFK XELK XFK
J@LYCOEMX ROZ AECKH HKLOMHZ HEZLEZZOC @A XFK
JOZK REXF@[X CKOQK X@ OLKMH- H{k x` xfk aojx xfox xfk
Ycoemxeaaz/Oyykcckkz dochcu hkato{hkh xfk j`{tx jcoelemb xfox xfku
yt`qehkh Cedkte"z ehkmxeaejoxe`m yoyktz omh zykjeaejoccu fkt hteqktz"
cejkmzk em `ykm j`{tx h{temb O{b{zx 2# 4995 j`{tx fkotemb# rfkm emaojx xfku rktk `thktkh du G{hbk T`dktkm` `m O{b{zx 2# 4995 x` aeck
Cedkte"z ehkmxeaejoxe`m yoyktz a`t xfk y{ty`zk `a kzxodcezfemb
tkzehkmju omh heqktzexu omh xfku mkqkt heh ex # omh xfku otk em
j`mxklyx `a xfk j`{tx `thkt a`t mkotcu xftkk ukotz m`r# xfk Oyykoc
m`x `mcu mkkhz x` dk btomxkh omh xfk rf`ck ckboc ojxe`m mkkhz x` dk
hezlezzkh# d{x xfk Oyykccckkz mkkh x` dk zomjxe`mkh a`t kbtkbe`{z
j`mxklyx `a j`{tx omh a`t kbtkbe`{z ato{h `m xfk j`{tx-
Ex ez xfk c`mb f`chemb `a xfez J`{tx xfox otb{lkmxz toezkh a`t xfk aetzx xelk em
o Tkycu Dteka recc m`xdk j`mzehktkh- Zkk N`ktmkt q- Bteboz# :46 A-:h ?9:5# ?986
&5xf Jet- 499:%- Ohhexe`moccu# ezz{kz toezkh a`t xfk aetzx xelk em om Oyykccomxz
Tkycu Dteka otk j`mzehktkh roekh- Xfk J`{tx t`{xemkcu tka{zkz x` j`mzehkt xfkl-
Zkk# k-b-# Ckmxeme q- Joc- Jxt- a`t xfk Otxz# :29 A-:h 6:2# 68: m-1 &5xf Jet- 4998%
&hkjcememb x` j`mzehkt ezz{k toezkh em tkycu dteka%> [mexkh Zxoxkz q- Tkothkm# :85
A-:h 196# 1?8 m-4 &5xf Jet- 499:% &Rk hkjcemk x` j`mzehkt Tkothkmz otb{lkmx - - -
dkjo{zk ex ez toezkh a`t xfk aetzx xelk em tkycu-%> Jkhom`,Qekto q- Ozfjt`ax# :48
A-:h ?914# ?911 m-; &5xf Jet- 499:% &^R\k hkjcemk x` j`mzehkt mkr ezz{kz toezkh
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 ?8 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
15/57
5
a`t xfk aetzx xelk em o tkycu dteka-%7 Btoqkz q- Otyoe`# 14: A-:h ?98:# ?986 &5xf
Jet- 49?9% &ykt j{teol% &otb{lkmxz toezkh a`t xfk aetzx xelk em o tkycu dteka otk
roekh-%>Kdktck q- Jexu `a Omofkel# 59? A-4h 6?8# 6?6 &5xf Jet-?559% &$Ex ez rkcc
kzxodcezfkh em xfez jetj{ex xfox xfk bkmktoc t{ck ez xfox oyykccomxz jomm`x toezk o mkr
ezz{k a`t xfk aetzx xelk em xfket tkycu dtekaz-$% &q{`xoxe`mz omh jexoxe`mz `lexxkh%>
q{`xemb D`cnkt q- J`llezze`mkt# 219 A-4h ?9:5# ?984 &5xf Jet-?56;% &$Oz o
bkmktoc t{ck# rk recc m`x j`mzehkt om ezz{k toezkh a`t xfk aetzx xelk `m oyykoc-$%-
Xfk tkoz`m a`t xfez ez aoetmkzz- Rfkm om ezz{k ez toezkh a`t xfk aetzx xelk em o Tkycu
Dteka# ex lkomz xfox xfk Oyykcckkz fok m`x foh om `yy`tx{mexu x` tkzy`mh x` xfox
ezz{k- Zkk Ckmxeme# :29 A-:h ox 68: m-1-
Xfk od`k `{xcemkh zxoxklkmxz omh xfk zxoxklkmxz febfcebfxkh em KVFEDEX
D aeckh em H@AAz Tkycu# HM :;,? omh H@AAz Kvfedex ? xft`{bf :# HMz
:;,4# :;,:# omh :;,8# l{zx dk zxtejnkm omh m`x j`mzehktkh- H@AAz Kvfedex ?
xft`{bf :# otk fkotzou h`j{lkmxz# j`lyckxkcu ettkckomx x` xfez Oyykoc omh rktk
m`x yt`h{jkh x` xfk Hezxtejx J`{tx tkbothemb H@AAz Omxe,ZCOYY L`xe`m omh
rktk m`x yt`h{jkh em H@AAz Oyykccomx @ykmemb Dteka omh xfktka`tk otk roekh
omh l{zx dk zxtejnkm omh m`x j`mzehktkh- Xoexw `m dkfoca `a H@AA otk zelycu
xtuemb x` ytkg{hejk xfez J`{tx oboemzx xfk Oyykcckkz oz om {maoet xojxejoc ohomxobk-
Oyykcckkz fok m`x foh om `yy`tx{mexu x` tkzy`mh x` xfkzk mkrcu toezkh
otb{lkmxz `t Kvfedexz# rfejf ez kvxtklkcu ytkg{hejeoc omh l{zx m`x dk occ`rkh-
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 ?; `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
16/57
?9
H@AAz Tkycu omh Kvfedexz oxxojfkh xfktkx` l{zx dk zxtejnkm> omh xfez J`{tx l{zx
Zomjxe`m Oxx`tmku @tcu Xoexw> omh Oroth Oyykcckkz Oxx`tmku akkz omh j`zxz-
EE- OTB[LKMXZ omh KQEHKMJK EMXT@H[JKH A@T XFK
AETZX XELK EM OM OYYKOC RECC M@X DK J@MZEHKTKH7
Oz xfez J`{tx ez orotk# om Oyykoc ez o yt`jkkhemb em rfejf o febfkt J`{tx
tkekrz xfk ojxe`mz xonkm du o Xteoc J`{tx# `t em xfez jozk# xfk Hezxtejx J`{tx-
Oyykocz otk bkmktoccu celexkh x` o tkekr `a xfk tkj`th at`l xfk c`rkt J`{tx-
Yotxekz jomm`x emxt`h{jk mkr kehkmjk omh otk celexkh x` rfox roz zoeh omh
emxt`h{jkh ox xfk `tebemoc yt`jkkhemb- Ezz{kz# hkakmzkz omh otb{lkmxz m`x toezkh ox
xfk Hezxtejx J`{tx jomm`xdk toezkh em xfk Oyykoc- Xfez J`{tx tkekrz xfk c`rkt
J`{tx"z oyycejoxe`m `a xfk cor x` xfk aojxz oz ytkzkmxkh-Gomkz q- Roc,Lotx Zx`tkz#
Emj-# 425 A-:h 66:# 662 &5xf Jet- 4994% &Rk bkmktoccu h` m`x j`mzehkt ezz{kz toezkh
a`t xfk aetzx xelk `m Oyykoc%>LojH`moch q- Btojk Jf{tjf Zkoxxck# 8;2 A-:h ?925#
?961 &5xf Jet- 4991% &Rk hkjcemk x` j`mzehkt otb{lkmxz toezkh a`t xfk aetzx xelk `m
oyykoc-%> Zlexf q- Lotzf# ?58 A-:8h ?98;# ?9;4 &5xf Jet- ?555% &Rk h` m`x
j`mzehkt j`mxkmxe`mz# aojxz `t otb{lkmxz toezkh a`t xfk aetzx xelk `m oyykoc%>
Yohbkxx q- Rtebfx# ;62 A-:h 56:# 56; m-4 &5xf Jet- 4995% &ykt j{teol% &Rk h` m`x
j`mzehkt otb{lkmxz omh occkboxe`mz toezkh a`t xfk aetzx xelk `m oyykoc-%> [mexkh
Zxoxkz q- Kceoz# 54? A-4h 629# 628 &5xf Jet- ?559% &Rk hkjcemk x` j`mzehkt kehkmjk
`t otb{lkmxz ytkzkmxkh a`t xfk aetzx xelk `m oyykoc-%-
?1
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 ?1 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
17/57
??
Oyykccomxz mkr otb{lkmxz oyykotemb em xfket Tkycu Dteka `{xcemkh od`k omh
febfcebfxkh em KVFEDEX D# otk a{txfkt roekh du H@AA dkjo{zk H@AA heh m`x
ytkzkmx xfkl x` xfk Hezxtejx J`{tx tkbothemb xfket Omxe,ZCOYY L`xe`m omh
xfktka`tk l{zx dk zxtejnkm- Zkk Ykxktz`m q- Febfcomh L{zej# Emj-# ?89 A-:h- ?:?:#
?:4? &5xf Jet- ?556% omh Jotlkm q- Zom Atomjezj` [meaekh Zjf- Hezx-# 4:2 A-:h
?941# ?9:9 &5xf Jet- 499?%- Zkk ocz` Em tk De`Cozk Xkjf- Zkj- Cexeb-# M`- 98,582
H@J &J-H- Joc- Gom- 42# 499:% m?>Akh- T- Oyy- Y- ?9&o%> omhNetzfmkt q- [mehkm
J`ty- `a Ol-# 684 A-4h ?928# ?922 &5xf Jet- ?566%-
Oz zxoxkh du G{hbk LjNk`rm em Jxt- a`t De`,Kxfejoc Tka`tl# Emj- q- Jexu !
J`{mxu `a F`m`c{c{# 4991 [-Z- Oyy- CKVEZ ?16:2> 8;; A-:h 5?9 &5xf Jet- G{cu 1#
4991% em fkt Olkmhkh @yeme`m ox am- :# $Xfktk ez b``h tkoz`m rfu rk bkmktoccu
h` m`x j`mzehkt ezz{kz a`t xfk aetzx xelk `m oyykoc,,xfk tkj`th foz m`x dkkm
hkkc`ykh# xfk hezxtejx j`{tx foz m`x foh om `yy`tx{mexu x` j`mzehkt xfk ezz{k# omh
xfk yotxekz" otb{lkmxz otk m`x hkkc`ykh oboemzx xfk hezxtejx j`{tx hkjeze`m-
Ojj`thembcu# xfez J`{tx zf`{ch Zxtenk H@AAz Tkycu Dteka em exz kmxetkxu a`t
aoecemb x` ohfktk x` xfk J`{txz Akdt{otu :# 49?4# omh a`t xfk tkoz`mz `{xcemkh
od`k omh em KVFEDEX D omh Kvfedexz ? xft`{bf : oxxojfkh xfktkx aeckh
rexf xfez J`{tx `m Oytec ?5# 49?4 xfox ^rktk\ m`xytkzkmxkh x` xfk hezxtejx j`{tx
Netzjfmkt# z{yto# 684 A-4h ox ?926-
?2
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 ?2 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
18/57
?4
EEE- ZOMJXE@MZ OBOEMZX @TCU XOEXW# KZ_- OTK
ROTTOMXKH
Xfktk otk zkktoc T{ckz em xfez Jetj{ex xfox occ`r xfez J`{tx x` Zomjxe`m om
oxx`tmku omh oroth oxx`tmku akkz omh j`zxz x` xfket `yy`mkmx# a`t Aoec{tk x`
J`lycu rexf Jetj{ex T{ck :9,?# ea ettkckqomx loxkteocz otk emjc{hkh em xfk Kvjktyxz
`a Tkj`thz `t Kvfedexz aeckh rexf o Dteka# zkk xfez J`{txz Jetj{ex T{ck :9,4;- Xfk
Memxf Jetj{ex C`joc T{ck :9,4 occ`rz a`t Zomjxe`mz# J`zxz omh Oxx`tmku akkz
oboemzx om Oxx`tmku rf` qkvoxe`{zcu omh {mtkoz`modcu emjtkozkz xfk j`zx `a
cexeboxe`m du emjc{ze`m `a {mmkjkzzotu loxkteoc em xfk kvjktyxz `a tkj`th- Oz @tcu
Xoexw# Kzq{etk# Oxx`tmku a`t H@AA foz h`mk x` xfk Oyykcckkz fktkem-
Xfk Memxf Jetj{ex T{ck 81,4 &o% `{xcemkz zomjxe`modck j`mh{jx omh j`mh{jx
z{dgkjx x` Hezjeycemk# Xfez J`{tx lou ely`zk hezjeycemk `m omu oxx`tmku
ytojxejemb dka`tk xfez J`{txrf` kmbobkz em j`mh{jx qe`coxemb oyycejodck t{ckz `a
yt`akzze`moc j`mh{jx# `t rf` aoecz x` j`lycu rexf t{ckz `t `thktz `a xfez J`{tx-
Xfk hezjeycemk lou j`mzezx `a hezdotlkmx# z{zykmze`m# tkytelomh# j`{mzkcemb#
kh{joxe`m# o l`mkxotu ykmocxu# tkzxex{xe`m# `t omu `xfkt ojxe`m xfox xfk J`{tx
hkklz oyyt`yteoxk omh g{zx- ^klyfozez ohhkh\-
Oz `{xcemkh em xfk Jetj{ex ohez`tu J`llexxkk M`xk x` T{ck 81,4# xfez J`{tx
lou zomjxe`m om oxx`tmku rf` z` l{cxeycekz xfk yt`jkkhembz em omu jozk
; Xfk Memxf Jetj{ex J`{tx foz xfk emfktkmx y`rkt x` zxtenk ettkckomx loxkteoc- Jetj{ex T{ck :9,?>Zkk ocz` ja- Jottebom q- Joc- Zxoxk Ckbezcox{tk# 41: A-4h ;19# ;18 &5xf Jet- ?5;5% &hezj{zzemb omoyykccoxk j`{txz emfktkmx y`rkt x` zxtenk dtekaz omh yckohembz oz kexfkt zjomhoc`{z# elyktxemkmx#zj{ttec`{z# omh/`t rexf`{x tkckomju%
?6
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 ?6 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
19/57
?:
{mtkoz`modcu `t qkvoxe`{zcu# 46 [-Z-J- ?542# Jetj{ex Ohez`tu J`llexxkk M`xk
&:%> y{tz{omx x` Jetj{ex T{ck :9,4 xfez J`{tx lou Zomjxe`m om Oxx`tmku rf`
qkvoxe`{zcu omh {mtkoz`modcu emjtkozkz xfk j`zx `a cexeboxe`m du emjc{ze`m `a
{mmkjkzzotu loxkteoc em xfk kvjktyxz `a tkj`th-> [mhkt Jetj{ex T{ck :9,4# oboemzx
j`{mzkc rf` qkvoxe`{zcu omh {mtkoz`modcu emjtkozkz xfk j`zx `a cexeboxe`m du
emjc{ze`m `a {mmkjkzzotu loxkteoc em xfk kvjktyxz `a tkj`th-# zkk Jetj{ex Ohez`tu
J`llexxkk M`xk &8%> Oboemzx j`{mzkc a`t j`mh{jx xfox qe`coxkz xfk `thktz `t `xfkt
emzxt{jxe`mz `a xfk J`{tx# `t a`t aoec{tk x` j`lycu rexf xfk Akhktoc T{ckz `a
Oyykccoxk Yt`jkh{tk `t omu Jetj{ex T{ck-# zkk Jetj{ex Ohez`tu J`llexxkk M`xk
&2%> omh [mhkt xfk emfktkmx y`rktz `a xfk J`{tx- Zkk# k-b-# Jfoldktz q- Mozj`#
Emj-# ;9? [-Z- :4# 8;,;9 &?55?%# zkk ocz` Jetj{ex Ohez`tu J`llexxkk M`xk &6%>
omh Oz o a`tl `a hezjeycemk {mhkt ATOY 81&j% omh Jetj{ex T{ck 81,4# rexf m`xejk
`a z{jf zomjxe`mz yt`qehkh x` xfk oyyt`yteoxk j`{txz omh zxoxk hezjeycemotu
obkmjekz rfkm xfk J`{tx hkklz z{jf m`xejk x` dk g{zxeaekh-# zkk Jetj{ex Ohez`tu
J`llexxkk M`xk &5%-
46 [-Z-J- ?542 occ`rz xfez Jetj{ex x` zomjxe`m om oxx`tmku rf` z`
l{cxeycekz xfk yt`jkkhembz em omu jozk {mtkoz`modcu omh qkvoxe`{zcu a`t xf`zk
kvjkzz j`zxz# kvykmzkz# omh oxx`tmkuz akkz tkoz`modcu emj{ttkh oz o tkz{cx `a
oxx`tmkuz j`mh{jx- Tkjnckzzmkzz z{aaejkz {mhkt ?542# d{x xfk J`{tx l{zx aemh
xfktk roz doh aoexf-D-N-D- q- Lo{e Y`cejk Hkyx-# 421 A-:h ?95?# ??92,96 &5xf Jet-
?5
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 ?5 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
20/57
?8
4994%- Xfktk ez m` q{kzxe`m xfox @tcu Xoexw# rf` ez o zkoz`mkh Oxx`tmku cejkmzkh x`
ytojxejk cor em xfk Zxoxk `a Jocea`tmeo# ojxe`mz rktk em doh aoexf omh ex ez z{yy`txkh
du fkt aecemb `m Oytec ?5# 49?4# rfejf ez jckot omh j`mqemjemb kqehkmjk- Em tk
Ckfxemkm# ;18 A-:h ?9;4# ?91? m-8 &5xf Jet- 4995-%> Mkr Ocozno Hkq- J`ty- q-
B{kxzjf`r# 615 A-4h ?456# ?:91 &5xf Jet- ?565% &$Doh aoexf ez ytkzkmx rfkm om
oxx`tmku nm`rembcu `t tkjnckzzcu toezkz o ateq`c`{z otb{lkmx `t otb{kz o
lktex`te`{z jcoel a`t xfk y{ty`zk `a fotozzemb om `yy`mkmx-$ %Eh- &q{`xembKzxoxk
`a Dcoz# 254 A-4h 6;6# 619 &5xf Jet- ?561%> D-N-D- q- Lo{e Y`cejk Hkyx# 421 A-:h
?95?# ??92,96 &5xf Jet- 4994% &oxx`tmkuz nm`remb omh tkjnckzz emxt`h{jxe`m `a
emohlezzedck kqehkmjk roz xomxol`{mx x` doh aoexf omh rottomxkh zomjxe`mz {mhkt
?542 omh xfk j`{txz emfktkmx y`rkt%> Aemn q- B`lkw# 4:5 A-:h 565# 55:,58
&5xf Jet- 499?% &oxx`tmkuz tkjnckzz lezzxoxklkmxz `a aojx# j`ldemkh rexf om
elyt`ykt y{ty`zk# otk zomjxe`modck {mhkt xfk j`{txz emfktkmx y`rkt%> Jfoldktz
q- MOZJ@# ;9? [-Z- :4 &?55?% &f`chemb xfox xfk kvjkzzeqk zomjxe`memb a`t
oxx`tmkuz akkz omh j`zxz a`t doh,aoexf j`mh{jx roz oyyt`yteoxk%-
@tcu Xoexw# Kzq- e`coxkh xfk J`{txz Akdt{otu :# 49?4 J`mz`cehoxe`m @thkt#
du aecemb o zkj`mhotu Tkycu Dteka `m dkfoca `a H@AA# rfejf oc`mk rottomxz
zomjxe`mz omh om oroth `a Oxx`tmku akkz omh j`zxz x` Oyykcckkz# Oc`k Qkto `a
Olktejo# Emj- q- [mexkh Zxoxkz# :21 A-:h 519 &5xf Jet- 4998% &Zomjxe`mz otk
oyyt`yteoxk rfkm o yotxu y{ty`zkcu e`coxkz o J`{tx @thkt%Eh- ox 511-
49
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 49 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
21/57
?;
@tcu Xoexw# Kzq- ocz` e coxkh xfez J`{txz Jetj{ex T{ckz du aecemb Oyykccomxz
Tkycu dteka rexf mkr otb{lkmxz omh Kvfedexz xfox fok m` tkcoxe`m x` xfket Oyykocz
omh rktk m`x toezkh em xfk Hezxtejx J`{tx tkbothemb xfket Omxe,ZCOYY L`xe`m `t em
xfket Oyykccomxz @ykmemb Dteka# occ xfk xelk nm`remb Oyykcckkz &Ycoemxeaaz% r`{ch
m`x dk odck x` tkzy`mh x` xfkzk mkr otb{lkmxz omh Kvfedexz- Xfez j`mh{jx ocz`
rottomxz Zomjxe`mz omh xfk oroth `a Oxx`tmku akkz omh j`zxz x` Oyykcckkz# D-N-D-
q- Lo{e Y`cejk Hkyx# 421 A-:h ?95?# ??92,96 &5xf Jet- 4994%-
EQ- J@MJC[ZE@MZ7
A`t xfk tkoz`mz `{xcemkh fktkem# Oyykccomx Hkakmh `{t Atkkh`lz
A`{mhoxe`mz# Emj-z h{ycejoxek J`mz`cehoxkh Tkycu Dteka aeckh em Jozk M`- ??,
;1?18# HM :;,? omh Kvfedexz ? xft`{bf :# HMz :;,4# :;,: omh :;,8 oxxojfkh
xfktkx l{zx dk zxtejnkm em xfket kmxetkxu- @tcu Xoexw# Kzq{etk l{zx dk zomjxe`mkh
omh Oyykcckkz orothkh Oxx`tmku akkz omh j`zxz-
Tkzykjxa{ccu z{dlexxkh#
Hoxkh7 Oytec 48# 49?4 /z/ Yfecey G- DktbYfecey G- Dktb# Kzq{etk
Oxx`tmku em yt` zk omh a`t Oyykcckkz#Cezo Cedkte# Cezo @zxkcco# B` Kvjkc
Bc`doc omh xfk Cor @aaejkz `a Yfecey
G- Dktb
4?
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 4? `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
22/57
KVFEDEX O
44
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 44 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
23/57
olx/Yt` L ` j`llezf :9Gom 49?4
[MEXKH ZXOXKZ J@[TX @A OYYKOCZ
A@T XFK MEMXF JETJ[EX
CEZO CEDKTE> kx oc-#
Ycoemxeaaz , Oyykcckkz#
q-
HKAKMH @[T ATKKH@LZ
A@[MHOXE@MZ# EMJ-#
Hkakmhomx , Oyykccomx-
M`- ??,;1925
H-J- M`- 67??,jq,9986;,OB,OGR
Jkmxtoc Hezxtejx `a Jocea`tmeo#
Zomxo Omo
@THKT
CEZO CEDKTE> kx oc-#
Ycoemxeaaz , Oyykcckkz#
q-
@TCU XOEXW# ONO Ht- @tcu Xoexw#
Hkakmhomx , Oyykccomx-
M`- ??,;1?18
H-J- M`- 67??,jq,9986;,OB,OGR
Jkmxtoc Hezxtejx `a Jocea`tmeo#
Zomxo Omo
@THKT
Dka`tk7 Ykxkt C- Zfor# Oyykccoxk J`llezze`mkt
J`{tx tkj`thz tkackjx xfox hkakmhomx Hkakmh @{t Atkkh`lz A`{mhoxe`m aeckh
o m`xejk `a oyykoc omh yoeh aecemb akkz `m G{mk 42# 49?? a`t oyykoc m`- ??,;1925-
Hkakmhomx @tcu Xoexw aeckh o m`xejk `a oyykoc omh yoeh aecemb akkz `m G{cu ?:# 49??
a`t oyykoc m`- ??,;1?18- Xfk J`{tx z{o zy`mxk j`mz`cehoxkz oyykoc m`z- ??,;1925
omh ??,;1?18-
AECKH
AKD 9: 49?4
L@CCU J- HRUKT# JCKTN[-Z- J@[TX @A OYYKOCZ
Jozk7 ??,;1925 94/9:/49?4 EH7 69;1244 HnxKmxtu7 41 Yobk7 ? `a 4
4:
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 4: `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
24/57
olx/Yt` L ` j`llezf :9Gom 49?4
Oyykcckkz `yy`zkh g`emx l`xe`m x` zxtenk xfk `ykmemb dteka ez hkmekh-
Oyykcckkz `yy`zkh g`emx l`xe`m x` hezlezz xfk oyykoc ez hkmekh- Oyykcckkz
l`xe`m x` zxtenk mkr otb{lkmxz ez hkmekh rexf`{x ytkg{hejk x` tkmkremb xfk
otb{lkmx em xfk omzrktemb dteka- Xfk jt`zz,oyycejoxe`mz `a xfk yotxekz a`t oxx`tmku
akkz otk hkmekh rexf`{x ytkg{hejk x` tkmkrkh oyycejoxe`mz# ea rottomxkh# oaxkt xfk
J`{txz tkz`c{xe`m `a xfkzk oyykocz- Zkk 5xf Jet- T- :5,?-1-
Oyykccomxz l`xe`m x` zxtenk aecembz omh a`t zomjxe`mz ez hkmekh- J`{tx
tkj`thz tkackjx xfox oyykcckkz j`{mzkc# Yfecey G- Dktb# Kzq-# foz dkkm ohlexxkh x`
xfk [mexkh Zxoxkz J`{tx `a Oyykocz Memxf Jetj{ex dot kaakjxek Gom{otu 49# 49?4-
Oyykccomxz l`xe`m x` btomx om oyykoc du hkao{cx ez hkmekh-Zkk
5xf Jet- T-
42,?9- Oyykccomxz yy`zkh l`xe`m a`t om kvxkmze`m `a xelk x` aeck om `yy`zexe`m
x` xfk l`xe`m x` hezlezz ez btomxkh-
Xfk Jcktn zfocc zxtenk oyykccomx @tcu Xoexwz &Xoexw% tkq{kzx a`t g{hejeoc
m`xejk aeckh `m Hkjkldkt 49# 49?? em M`- ??,;1?18 dkjo{zk xfk h`j{lkmx aeckh du
Oyykccomx Xoexw j`mxoemz z`jeoc zkj{texu ema`tloxe`m- Zkk Akh- T- Oyy- Y- 4;&o%&;%>
Akh- T- Je- Y- ;-4&o%- Oyykccomx Xoexw lou aeck o tkhojxkh h`j{lkmx oc`mb rexf
om`xfkt tkq{kzx a`t g{hejeoc m`xejk- Omu a{txfkt l`xe`mz a`t g{hejeoc m`xejk recc dk
tkakttkh x` xfk lktexz yomkc a`t tkz`c{xe`m- Zkk 5xf Jet- T- 42,?# Jetj{ex Ohez`tu
J`llexxkk M`xk &2%-
Xfk olkmhkh dtekaemb zjfkh{ck ez oz a`cc`rz7 xfk j`mz`cehoxkh omzrktemb
dteka ez h{k Lotjf 2# 49?4> xfk j`mz`cehoxkh `yxe`moc tkycu dteka ez h{k rexfem ?8
houz oaxkt zktejk `a xfk j`mz`cehoxkh omzrktemb dteka-
Oyykcckkz otk tklemhkh xfox ea xfku j`mxkmh oyykccomxz kvjktyxz `lex
tkckomx y`txe`mz `a xfk tkj`th xfku lou aeck z{yycklkmxoc kvjktyxz `a tkj`th
y{tz{omx x` Memxf Jetj{ex T{ck :9,?-2 oc`mb rexf xfk j`mz`cehoxkh omzrktemb dteka-
Jozk7 ??,;1925 94/9:/49?4 EH7 69;1244 HnxKmxtu7 41 Yobk7 4 `a 4
48
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 48 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
25/57
KVFEDEX D
4;
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 4; `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
26/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 ?
Jozk M`z- ??,;1925 omh ??,;1?18
&J`mz`cehoxkh `m Akdt{otu :# 49?4%
EM XFK [MEXKH ZXOXKZ J@[TX @A OYYKOCZ
A@T XFK MEMXF JETJ[EX
Cezo Cedkte# kx oc-#
Ycoemxeaaz/Oyykcckkz#
-
@tcu Xoexw# Hkakmh @{t Atkkh`lz
A`{mhoxe`mz# Emj-# kx oc-#
Hkakmhomxz/Oyykccomxz-
TKYCU DTEKA DU OYYKCCOMX#
HKAKMH @[T ATKKH@LZ A@[MHOXE@MZ# EMJ-
&Z{dlexxkh rexf Oyykccomxz Z{yycklkmxoc Kvjktyxz `a Tkj`th omh Tkycu Dteka du
Oyykccomx# @tcu Xoexw# em J`mz`cehoxkh Oyykocz# Xodck `a j`mxkmxz omh xodck `a
o{xf`texekz ez em xfk oyykccomx @tcu Xoexw dteka%
Ht- @tcu Xoexw# Kzq-# JZDM 44:8::
COR @AAEJKZ @A HT- @TCU XOEXW# KZ_-
456:5 Zomxo Lotbotexo Ynru
Zxk- ?99Tomjf` Zomxo Lotbotexo# JO 54166
&585% 16:,;8?? , xkckyf`mk
&585% 211,219: , aov
J`{mzkc a`t Hkakmhomx/Oyykccomx#
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 ? `a :4
41
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 41 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
27/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 4
Hkakmh @{t Atkkh`lz A`{mhoxe`mz# Emj-
E-
Oyykccomx# Hkakmh @{t Atkkh`lz A`{mhoxe`mz# Emj-# Emj`ty`toxkz Du
Tkaktkmjk Jktxoem Y`txe`mz `a xfk Tkcoxkh Tkycu Dteka `a Oyykccomx# @tcu
Xoexw# em Xfkzk J`mz`cehoxkh Oyykocz
Xfk oyykocz du Hkakmhomx omh Oyykccomx# HKAKMH @[T ATKKH@LZ
A@[MHOXE@MZ# EMJ- &H@AA%# omh Hkakmhomx omh Oyykccomx# @TCU XOEXW
&Xoexw% &j`cckjxeqkcu Hkakmhomxz%# foqk dkkm j`mz`cehoxkh-
Ojj`thembcu# a`t xfk zonk `a kaaejekmju omh j`mqkmekmjk `a xfk J`{tx `a
Oyykocz# H@AA emj`ty`toxkz du tkaktkmjk oz xf`{bf a{ccu zkx a`txf fktkem xfk
a`cc`remb zkjxe`mz `a Xoexwz tkycu dteka7
E- Z{llotu `a Otb{lkmx>
EE- Oyykoc Lou Dk Xonkm at`l xfk @thkt Hkmuemb Hkakmhomxz Omxe,ZCOYY
L`xe`m>
EEE- Oz Hkxktlemkh em xfk Hezxtejx J`{txz @thkt# xfk Btomxemb `a Ycoemxeaaz
L`xe`m a`t Ckoqk x` Aeck Xfket Aetzx Olkmhkh J`lycoemx ez Emhkykmhkmx At`l omh
Ettkckqomx x` exz Hkmeoc `a Hkakmhomxz Omxe,ZCOYY L`xe`m> omh
EQ- Xfk Hezxtejx J`{tx# oz o Loxxkt `a Cor# Kttkh em J`mjc{hemb xfox
Hkakmhomxz Heh M`x Lkkx Xfket D{thkm [mhkt Zkjxe`m 84;-?1&d% x` Zf`r xfox
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 4 `a :4
42
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 42 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
28/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 4
Ycoemxeaaz J`lycoemx Otezkz @{x `a Hkakmhomxz Ojxz em A{txfktomjk `a Xfket
Tebfxz `a Ykxexe`m `t Atkk Zykkjf em J`mmkjxe`m rexf o Y{dcej Ezz{k-
EE-
Xfk Hezxtejx J`{tx# oz o Loxxkt `a Cor# Kttkh em J`mjc{hemb xfox Ycoemxeaaz
Lkx Xfket D{thkm [mhkt Jocea`tmeo J`hk `a Jeqec Yt`jkh{tk Zkjxe`m
84;-?1&d%&?% x` Hkl`mzxtoxk o Yt`dodecexu a Ytkqoecemb oz Oboemzx Oyykccomxz
O- Oz o loxxkt `a cor# Ycoemxeaaz heh m`x lkkx xfket d{thkm {mhkt
zkjxe`m 84;-?1&d%&?% x` hkl`mzxtoxk xfk ckboc z{aaejekmju a xfket
J`lycoemx rfktk xfku lohk o g{hejeoc ohlezze`m xfox xfk
J`lycoemx roz ckboccu emz{aaejekmx
?- Ycoemxeaaz ohlexxkh xfox xfket J`lycoemx roz
ckboccu emz{aaejekmx omh# xf{z# oz o loxxkt `a cor#
heh m`x lkkx xfket d{thkm {mhkt zkjxe`m
84;-?1&d%
Zkjxe`m 84;-?1&d% &?% tkq{etkz o Ycoemxeaa x` kzxodcezf xfox xfktk ez o
yt`dodecexu xfox xfk ycoemxeaa recc ytkoec `m xfk jcoel- O ycoemxeaaz d{thkm {mhkt
xfk zkj`mh yt`mb `a zkjxe`m 84;-?1&d% ez xr`,a`ch7 $^X\fk ycoemxeaa "l{zx
hkl`mzxtoxk xfox xfk j`lycoemx ez d`xfckboccu z{aaejekmxomh z{yy`txkh du oz{aaejekmx ytelo aojek zf`remb `a aojxz x` z{zxoem o ao`todck g{hblkmx ea xfk
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 : `a :4
46
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 46 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
29/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 4
kehkmjk z{dlexxkh du xfk ycoemxeaa ez jtkhexkh-"$Loxz`m q- Hq`ton# 89 Joc-Oyy-8xf
;:5# ;86 &?55;%> klyfozez ohhkh- T`zkmo{t q- Zjfktkt# 66 Joc-Oyy-8xf 419# 428
&499?%-
Oz o loxxkt `a cor# ex ez emz{aaejekmx a`t o ycoemxeaa x` lktkcu otb{k xfox ex foz
lohk om kehkmxeotu zf`remb `a lktex em `yy`zexe`m x` om omxe,ZCOYY l`xe`m-
^X\fk ycoemxeaa l{zx hkl`mzxtoxk xfox xfk j`lycoemx ez d`xf ckboccu z{aaejekmx omh
z{yy`txkh du o z{aaejekmx ytelo aojek zf`remb `a aojxz x` z{zxoem o ao`todck
g{hblkmx ea xfk kehkmjk z{dlexxkh du xfk ycoemxeaa ez jtkhexkh- Xo{z q- C`ax{z# 89
Joc-8xf 16:# 2?:,2?8 &4992%-
$Xf{z# ^xfk m`m,l`emb yotxu"z\ d{thkm oz x` xfk zkj`mh yt`mb `a xfk omxe,
ZCOYY xkzx ez onem x` xfox `a o yotxu `yy`zemb o l`xe`m a`t z{llotu g{hblkmx-$
Moqkccekt q- Zckxxkm# ?91 Joc-Oyy-8xf 21:# 216 &499:%-
Ycoemxeaaz ohlexxkh xfox xfku heh m`x zoxezau xfez aetzx tkq{etklkmx `a xfket
d{thkm7
Xfk zkj`mh yt`mb ez rfkxfkt xfk Ycoemxeaaz fok
hkl`mzxtoxkh o yt`dodecexu `a ytkoecemb `m xfk jcoel-
Ycoemxeaaz obtkk xfku l{zx olkmh xfket J`lycoemx x`
dtemb ex em j`lyceomjk rexf xfk Jocea`tmeo Corz- ^? KT#
?4;7 ;,6> klyfozez ohhkh-\
Ycoemxeaaz em xfket OD &y- 8?% ojnm`rckhbk xfku ohlexxkh xfku mkkhkh x`
olkmh xfket j`lycoemx---- Xfku fok# xf{z# ohlexxkh xfox xfku heh m`x lkkx xfket
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 8 `a :4
45
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 45 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
30/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 :
d{thkm {mhkt 84;-?1&d%&?% x` hkl`mzxtoxk xfk ckboc z{aaejekmju `a xfket
J`lycoemx- Xfez g{hejeoc ohlezze`m tkq{etkh# oz o loxxkt `a cor# xfox xfk omxe,
ZCOYY l`xe`m dk btomxkh-Loxz`m# z{yto# 89 Joc-Oyy-8xf ox ;86- T`zkmo{t#
z{yto# 66 Joc-Oyy-8xf ox 428- Xo{z# z{yto# 89 Joc-8xf ox 2?:,2?8-
Ycoemxeaaz otb{k xfox rfktk xfku rktk btomxkh ckok x` aeck xfket AOJ# xfku
rktk tkcekkh `a foemb x` lkkx xfket d{thkm {mhkt zkjxe`m 84;-?1&d%- &OD# 8?,84-%
Kzzkmxeoccu# ykt Ycoemxeaaz# rfkxfkt xfku lkx xfez d{thkm oz x` xfket J`lycoemx ez
ettkckomx rfktk xfk J`{tx occ`rkh xfk AOJ x` dk aeckh-
Ycoemxeaaz otb{lkmx lebfx fok z`lk ocehexu eaxfk J`{tx y{tz{omx x`
Qktew`m omh Qkzz foh hkklkh xfk omxe,ZCOYY l`xe`m l``x- F`rkkt# xfox ez m`x
rfox `jj{ttkh- Ocxf`{bf xfk J`{tx em exz xkmxoxek t{cemb roz ytkyotkh x` hkkl
Hkakmhomxz l`xe`m l``x# em cebfx `a Ycoemxeaaz l`xe`m# exz aemoc t{cemb yt`ehkz xfk
`yy`zexk> xfk J`{tx kvycejexcu oyycekh d`xf yt`mbz `a xfk omxe,ZCOYY zxox{xk x` xfk
J`lycoemx x` {cxeloxkcu hkmu zoeh l`xe`m- ^? KT# 8,5 omh 4;,45-\
Xfk J`{tx em exz aemoc `thkt ^? KT# 8,5\ zykjeaejoccu t{ckh `m xfk lktexz `a xfk
omxe,ZCOYY l`xe`m# rexf`{x tkboth x` Ycoemxeaaz l`xe`m a`t ckok x` aeck xfket
AOJ- Xf{z# xfk J`{tx kvycejexcu heh m`x aemh xfk omxe,ZCOYY l`xe`m x` dk
ytklox{tk `t l``x em omu tkzykjx# emjc{hemb {mhkt Qktew`m `t Qkzz-
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 ; `a :4
:9
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 :9 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
31/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 8
Xf{z# a`t xfkzk tkoz`mz# Ycoemxeaaz otb{lkmx ez emj`ttkjx- Rfktk xfk J`{tx
zykjeaejoccu ohhtkzzkh omh t{ckh `m Ycoemxeaaz d{thkm {mhkt zkjxe`m 84;-?1&d%# xfku
rktk tkq{etkh x` zoxezau xfox d{thkm- Oz zf`rm em Hkakmhomxz dteka fktkem# omh em
xfk J`{tx dkc`r# Ycoemxeaaz heh m`x lkkx xfket d{thkm-
L`tk`kt# oz o loxxkt `a cor &omh c`bej%# Ycoemxeaaz j`{ch m`x omh heh m`x
zoxezau xfket d{thkm rfktk xfku ohlexxkh xfox xfket J`lycoemx roz ckboccu
emz{aaejekmx- Xf{z# ex roz o ckboc omh c`bejoc ely`zzedecexu a`t Ycoemxeaaz x` fok
z{aaejekmxcu lohk o ytelo aojek zf`remb `a aojxz xfox r`{ch# ea yt`kh# z{yy`tx o
g{hblkmx em xfket ao`t ^? KT# 6\ rfktk xfket `yktoxek yckohemb &xfk J`lycoemx%
roz ckboccu emz{aaejekmx-
4- Ycoemxeaaz aoeckh x` lkkx xfket d{thkm x`
hkl`mzxtoxk xfox xfket J`lycoemx omh kojf `a
exz jcoelz rktk ckboccu z{aaejekmx {mhkt zkjxe`m
84;-?1&d%o- Ycoemxeaaz , du xfket zeckmjk em xfket
dteka , ohlex xfox xfket J`{mx
@mk# a`t Qe`coxe`m `a xfk Aetzx
omh A`{txkkmxf Olkmhlkmx zej\ a
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 1 `a :4
:?
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 :? `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
32/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 ;
xfk [mexkh Zxoxkz J`mzxex{e`m zej\#
ez ckboccu emz{aaejekmxYcoemxeaaz" aetzx jcoel a`t tkceka foz m` ckboc dozez- ^4 KT# :??,:?1-\ Xfk
A`{txkkmxf Olkmhlkmx jomm`x oyycu x` yteoxk j`mh{jx- Zfkccku q- Ntoklkt# ::8
[-Z- ?# ?: &?586%- Xfk Aetzx Olkmhlkmx h`kz m`x oyycu x` yteoxk j`mh{jx kexfkt-
Tkmhkcc,Donkt q- N`fm# 8;2 [-Z- 6:9# 6:2 &?564%- Rfktk Ycoemxeaaz occkbk `mcu
yteoxk j`mh{jx# omh m`x tkq{etkh b`ktmlkmxoc emoze`m `a yteoju# xfket aetzx
jcoel oz o loxxkt `a cor l{zx aoec-
Ycoemxeaaz aetzx jcoel ez ocz` dozkh `m o lezf,lozf `a ote`{z Jocea`tmeo#
Ykmmzucomeo omh akhktoc zxox{xkz- ^4 KT# :?8,:?;-\ Oz hkl`mzxtoxkh em
Hkakmhomxz @D# m`mk `a xfkzk corz z{yy`tx Ycoemxeaaz jcoel- A`t kvolyck#
Jocea`tmeo Jeqec J`hk zkjxe`m ?256 kx zkq- &Jocea`tmeo"z Ema`tloxe m Ytojxejkz Ojx
`a ?522% tkq{etkz b`qktmlkmx obkmjekz x` yt`xkjx xfk yteoju `a yktz`moc
ema`tloxe`m loemxoemkh du zxoxk obkmjekz-
Xfktk ez m` hezj{zze`m `t jexoxe`m x` ckboc o{xf`texu em Ycoemxeaaz OD
tkbothemb xfket aetzx jcoel a`t tkceka- Xf{z# xfku fok ohlexxkh du xfket zeckmjk xfox
xfku heh m`x lkkx xfket d{thkm {mhkt 84;-?1&d% `m xfez jcoel-
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 2 `a :4
:4
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 :4 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
33/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 1
d- Ycoemxeaaz J`{mx Xr`# a`t
Hkaoloxe`mYkt Zk# Zcomhkt omh
Cedkc# ez ckboccu emz{aaejekmx
Ycoemxeaaz j`ll`m cor jcoelz otk dozkh `m Jocea`tmeo cor# beqkm xfox xfk
jozk ez ykmhemb em Jocea`tmeo omh Hkakmhomxz otk occkbkh x` dk# omh otk# tkzehkmxz
omh jexewkmz `a Jocea`tmeo-Ktek Toect`oh J`- q- X`lynemz# :98 [-Z- 18# 26 &?5:6%-
Xf{z# Ycoemxeaaz j`ll`m cor jcoelz a`t hkaoloxe`m ykt zk# zcomhkt omh cedkc otk
dozkh `m Jocea`tmeo cor- ^4 KT# :?2,:49-\ Oboem# Ycoemxeaaz obtkk xfku l{zx
olkmh xfket J`lycoemx x` dtemb ex em j`lyceomjk rexf xfk Jocea`tmeo Corz- ^? KT#
?4;7 ;,6-\ Xf{z# ykt Ycoemxeaaz# xfket zkj`mh jcoel aoecz x` zxoxk o z{aaejekmx jcoel
{mhkt Jocea`tmeo cor-
Xfktk ez m` z{dzxomxeqk hezj{zze`m em Ycoemxeaaz OD `a xfk kcklkmxz `a o
hkaoloxe`mykt zk jcoel# m`t `a omu kqehkmjk z{dlexxkh du Ycoemxeaaz x` z{yy`tx xfk
zkj`mh yt`mb `a xfket d{thkm x` ytkzkmx z{aaejekmx ytelo aojek zf`remb `a aojxz x`
z{zxoem o aoq`todck g{hblkmx ea xfk kqehkmjk z{dlexxkh du xfk ycoemxeaa ez jtkhexkh-"$
Loxz`m#z{yto# 89 Joc-Oyy-8xf ox ;86-
j- Ycoemxeaaz J`{mx Xftkk# a`t
Aoczk,Cebfx Emqoze`m a Yteqoju#
ez ckboccu emz{aaejekmx
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 6 `a :4
::
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 :: `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
34/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 2
Ycoemxeaaz xfeth jcoel ez dozkh `m Jocea`tmeo cor- ^4 KT# :49,:4:-\Ktek
Toect`oh J`-# z{yto# :98 [-Z- ox 26- Rfktk Ycoemxeaaz obtkk xfku l{zx olkmh xfket
J`lycoemx x` dtemb ex em j`lyceomjk rexf xfk Jocea`tmeo Corz# xfket xfeth jcoel
aoecz x` zxoxk o z{aaejekmx jcoel {mhkt Jocea`tmeo cor-
Xfk emz{aaejekmju `a Ycoemxeaaz xfeth jcoel ez hkl`mzxtoxkh em hkxoec em
Oyykccomxz omxe,ZCOYY l`xe`m omh z{yy`txemb yoyktz- F`rkqkt# Ycoemxeaaz
g{hejeoc ohlezze`m xfox z{jf jcoel ez emz{aaejekmx ez demhemb- Olktejom Xexck Emz-
J`-# z{yto# 61? A-4h ox 441- Ycoemxeaaz g{hejeoc ohlezze`m ez hezy`zexeqk em
kzxodcezfemb xfket aoec{tk x` zoxezau xfket d{thkm {mhkt zkjxe`m 84;-?1&d% x`
hkl`mzxtoxk xfk ckboc z{aaejekmju `a xfket xfeth jcoel-Loxz`m# z{yto# 89
Joc-Oyy-8xf ox ;86- T`zkmo{t# z{yto# 66 Joc-Oyy-8xf ox 428-
h- Ycoemxeaaz J`{mx A`{t# a`t
Fotozzlkmx# ez ckboccu emz{aaejekmx
oz rkcc oz m`x dkemb o ckboccu,
j`bmewodck jcoel
Ycoemxeaaz a`{txf jcoel ez a`t fotozzlkmx- ^4 KT# :4:,:41-\ Xfktk ez m`
ckboccu,j`bmewodck jcoel a`t tkceka a`t holobkz kmxexckh fotozzlkmx- Ea omh x` xfk
kvxkmx xfktk ez z{jf o ckboccu,j`bmewodck jcoel &celexkh x` emg{mjxeqk tkceka%# ex
r`{ch dk dozkh `m Jocea`tmeo cor- Jocea`tmeo J`hk `a Jeqec Yt`jkh{tk zkjxe`m
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 5 `a :4
:8
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 :8 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
35/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 6
;42-1-Ktek Toect`oh J`-# z{yto# :98 [-Z- ox 26- Ycoemxeaaz zkkn holobkz `m xfez
jcoel- ^4 KT# :48-\ Rfktk Ycoemxeaaz obtkk xfku l{zx olkmh xfket J`lycoemx x`
dtemb ex em j`lyceomjk rexf xfk Jocea`tmeo Corz# xfket a`{txf jcoel aoecz x` zxoxk o
z{aaejekmx jcoel {mhkt Jocea`tmeo cor-
Xfk emz{aaejekmju `a Ycoemxeaaz a`{txf jcoel ez hkl`mzxtoxkh em hkxoec em
Hkakmhomxz omxe,ZCOYY l`xe`m omh z{yy`txemb yoyktz- F`rkqkt# Ycoemxeaaz
g{hejeoc ohlezze`m xfox z{jf jcoel ez emz{aaejekmx ez demhemb- Olktejom Xexck Emz-
J`-# z{yto# 61? A-4h ox 441- Ycoemxeaaz g{hejeoc ohlezze`m ez hezy`zexeqk em
kzxodcezfemb xfket aoec{tk x` zoxezau xfket d{thkm {mhkt 84;-?1&d% x` hkl`mzxtoxk
xfk ckboc z{aaejekmju `a xfket a`{txf jcoel-Loxz`m# z{yto# 89 Joc-Oyy-8xf ox ;86-
T`zkmo{t# z{yto# 66 Joc-Oyy-8xf ox 428-
k- Ycoemxeaaz J`{mx Aeqk# a`t Aoczk
Hkzebmoxe`mz omh Hkzjteyxe`mz `a
Aojxz# ez ckboccu emz{aaejekmx
Ycoemxeaaz aeaxf jcoel ez a`t aoczk hkzebmoxe`mz omh hkzjteyxe`mz `a aojxz- ^4
KT# :41,:45-\ Ycoemxeaaz jexk x` ?; [-Z-J- ??4; oz z{yy`txemb xfez jcoel- ^4 KT#
:42-\ Xfez zkjxe`m ez yotx `a xfk [mexkh Zxoxkz Xtohklotn Ojx- Zkjxe`m ??4;&o%&?%
tkaktz x`7
Omu yktz`m rf`# `m `t em j`mmkjxe`m rexf omu b``hz `t
zktqejkz# `t omu j`mxoemkt a`t b``hz# {zkz em j`llktjk
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 ?9 `a :4
:;
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 :; `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
36/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex
98-?5-49?4 5
omu r`th# xktl# molk# zuld`c# `t hkejk# `t omu
j`ldemoxe`m xfktk`a# `t omu aoczk hkzebmoxe`m `a `tebem#
aoczk `t lezckohemb hkzjteyxe`m `a aojx# `t aoczk `t
lezckohemb tkytkzkmxoxe`m a aojx----
Ycoemxeaaz aoec x` occkbk omu aojxz em xfez jcoel xfox Hkakmhomxz {zkh em
j`llktjk omu r`th---- oz tkq{etkh du ??4;&o%&?%- L`tk`kt# x` j`lk rexfem
8:&o% `a xfk Comfol Ojx &?; [-Z-J- ??4;&o%%# j`ktkh ojxeexekz l{zx tkcoxk x`
b``hz `t zktejkz rfejf fok z`lk kaakjx `m emxktzxoxk `t a`tkebm j`llktjk
rexfem j`mxt`c `a J`mbtkzz- Yotnrou Donemb J`- q Atkef`akt Donemb J`-# 4;; A-4h
18? &:th
Jetj- ?5;6%- Jozflktk ! Jolkc Foet Latz- Emzx- q Zonz Aeaxf Oqk-# 468
A-:h :94 &?zx
Jetj- 4994%- Ycoemxeaaz em xfket aeaxf jcoel aoec x` occkbk xfez kzzkmxeoc
kcklkmx `a yt`eze`m `a b``hz `t zktejkz em emxktzxoxk j`llktjk# `t omu kaakjx `m
emxktzxoxk j`llktjk-
J`mbtkzz" y{ty`zk em kmojxemb 8:&o% `a xfk Comfol Ojx roz x` jtkoxk o
zykjeoc omh celexkh {maoet j`lykxexe`m tklkhu kvjc{zekcu x` yt`xkjx xfk emxktkzxz
`a o y{tkcu j`llktjeoc jcozz oboemzx {mzjt{y{c`{z j`llktjeoc j`mh{jx- J`ccebom q
Ojxeqexekz Jc{d `a Mkr U`tn# Cxh-# 884 A-4h 161 &4mh
Jetj- ?52?%- Ycoemxeaaz aoec x`
occkbk omu aojxz kzxodcezfemb xfk kzzkmxeoc kcklkmx `a {maoet j`lykxexe`m oz dkxrkkm
xfkl omh Hkakmhomxz# m`t xfox Hkakmhomxz kmbobkh em omu {mzjt{y{c`{z
j`llktjeoc j`mh{jx-
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 ?? `a :4
:1
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 :1 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
37/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 ?9
Xf{z# Ycoemxeaaz aoeckh x` zoxezau xfket d{thkm {mhkt 84;-?1&d% x`
hkl`mzxtoxk xfk ckboc z{aaejekmju `a xfket aeaxf jcoel-Loxz`m# z{yto# 89
Joc-Oyy-8xf ox ;86- T`zkmo{t# z{yto# 66 Joc-Oyy-8xf ox 428-
a- Ycoemxeaaz J`{mx Zev# a`t
Emg{mjxeqk Tkceka # ez ckboccu
emz{aaejekmx omh ez m`x o zkyotoxk
jcoel a`t tkceka
Ycoemxeaaz zevxf jcoel ez a`t emg{mjxeqk tkceka- ^4 KT# :45,::4-\ Xfez ez m`x
o zkyotoxk jcoel a`t tkceka> ex ez lktkcu o xuyk `a tklkhu hkykmhkmx {y`m xfk
kvezxkmjk `a o zkyotoxk# z{yy`txemb jcoel a`t tkceka- Jexu `a Z`{xf Yozohkmo q-
Hkyotxlkmx `a Xtomzy`txoxe`m# 45 Joc-Oyy-8xf ?469# ?45: &?558%- Oz hezj{zzkh
fktkem# omh hkl`mzxtoxkh em Hkakmhomxz omxe,ZCOYY l`xe`m omh z{yy`txemb
yoyktz# Ycoemxeaaz aoeckh x` zxoxk omu z{aaejekmx jcoel {y`m rfejf xfket zevxf jcoel
j`{ch dk dozkh-
A{txfkt# ex oyykotz xfox Ycoemxeaaz zevxf jcoel ez
dozkh `m Jocea`tmeo cor- Ktek Toect`oh J`-# z{yto# :98 [-Z- ox 26-
Rfktk Ycoemxeaaz obtkk xfku l{zx olkmh xfket J`lycoemx x` dtemb ex em j`lyceomjk
rexf xfk Jocea`tmeo Corz# xfket zevxf jcoel aoecz x` zxoxk o z{aaejekmx jcoel {mhkt
Jocea`tmeo cor-
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 ?4 `a :4
:2
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 :2 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
38/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 4
Xfk emz{aaejekmju `a Ycoemxeaaz zevxf jcoel ez hkl`mzxtoxkh em hkxoec em
Hkakmhomxz omxe,ZCOYY l`xe`m omh z{yy`txemb yoyktz- F`rkqkt# Ycoemxeaaz
g{hejeoc ohlezze`m xfox z{jf jcoel ez emz{aaejekmx ez demhemb- Olktejom Xexck Emz-
J`-# z{yto# 61? A-4h ox 441- Ycoemxeaaz g{hejeoc ohlezze`m ez hezy`zexeqk em
kzxodcezfemb xfket aoec{tk x` zoxezau xfket d{thkm {mhkt 84;-?1&d% x` hkl`mzxtoxk
xfk ckboc z{aaejekmju `a xfket zevxf jcoel-Loxz`m# z{yto# 89 Joc-Oyy-8xf ox ;86-
T`zkmo{t# z{yto# 66 Joc-Oyy-8xf ox 428-
D- Oz o loxxkt a cor# Ycoemxeaaz heh m`x lkkx xfket d{thkm
{mhkt zkjxe`m 84;-?1&d%&?% x` hkl`mzxtoxk xfk ckboc
z{aaejekmju a xfket J`lycoemx , dozkh m occkbkh hektzexu
g{tezhejxe`m , rfktk xfku aoeckh x` yckoh aojxz kzxodcezfemb
hektzexu omh x` aeck yt``a `a xfket zxoxk jexewkmzfey oz
tkq{etkh du xfk Hezxtejx J`{tx
Ycoemxeaaz occkbkh xfox heqktzexu g{tezhejxe`m {mhkt 46 [-Z-J- ?::4&o%
kvezxkh rfktk Ycoemxeaaz rktk jexewkmz `a Ykmmzucqomeo# Mkr Gktzku omh @ncof`lo#
omh kojf Hkakmhomx roz o jexewkm `a `xfkt zxoxkz# emjc{hemb Jocea`tmeo &a`t Xoexw
omh H@AA%- ^? KT# 4;;-\ Ycoemxeaaz occkbkh xfox Cedkte ez om oh{cx emheqeh{oc rexf o
d{zemkzz ohhtkzz `a ;;; Omh`tto Bckm J`{tx# Z{exk ?4# Coaoukxxk# YO---- ^?KT#
4;;-\
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 ?: `a :4
:6
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 :6 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
39/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 :
Ycoemxeaaz aoeckh x` occkbk xfox Cedkte roz o jexewkm `a Ykmmzucqomeo &`t omu
`xfkt zxoxk%# du qetx{k `a tkzehemb em Ykmmzucqomeo# d{x lktkcu xfox zfk foh o
d{zemkzz ohhtkzz em Ykmmzucqomeo &e-k-# xfk ohhtkzz `a Ycoemxeaaz j`{mzkc%-
[mhkt xfk xktlz `a Cedktez yt`doxe`m# zfk roz occ`rkh x` tkzehk em `mcu xr`
zxoxkz , Jocea`tmeo omh Mkr Lkvej`- ^? KT# ?5;,498-\ Xf{z# ex r`{ch foqk dkkm o
qe`coxe`m `a fkt yt`doxe`m a`t Cedkte x` foqk tkzehkh em Ykmmzucqomeo-
Hkakmhomxz xf{z jfocckmbkh Ycoemxeaaz emz{aaejekmx heqktzexu g{tezhejxe`m
occkboxe`mz ox xfk `{xzkx `a xfez jozk# emjc{hemb dka`tk F`m`todck Hezxtejx J`{tx
G{hbk Kh{oth` J- T`dtkm`- Em O{b{zx 4995# G{hbk T`dtkm` j`mh{jxkh om
kqehkmxeotu fkotemb ox rfejf fk `thktkh# omh Ycoemxeaaz obtkkh# xfox xfku l{zx aeck
yt``a `a xfket zxoxk jexewkmzfey em `thkt x` kzxodcezf heqktzexu g{tezhejxe`m- ^? ZKT#
TX ?1,?5$-\ Cedkte xkzxeaekh {mhkt `oxf xfox zfk r`{ch aeck fkt ehkmxeauemb
ema`tloxe`m- ^? ZKT# TX 82$-\
CEDKTE FOZ QE@COXKH G[HBK T@DTKM@Z @THKT RFKTK
ZFK FOZ AOECKH X@ AECK FKT EHKMXEAUEMB EMA@TLOXE@M
MKJKZZOTU X@ KZXODCEZF HEQKTZEXU G[TEZHEJXE@M FKTKEM- ^?
KT# ?12# ?15,?29-\
Ojj`thembcu# em xfket omxe,ZCOYY l`xe`m# Hkakmhomxz jfocckmbkh Ycoemxeaaz
occkboxe`mz `a heqktzexu g{tezhejxe`m y{tz{omx x` Akh- T- Jeq- Y- ?4&d%&?%#
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 ?8 `a :4
:5
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 :5 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
40/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 8
yotxej{cotcu rfktk Cedkte j`{ch m`x ckboccu tkzehk em omu zxoxk `xfkt xfom Jocea`tmeo
`t Mkr Lkvej`- ^? KT# ?11,?29-\ Xfez emjc{hkz Ykmmzucqomeo rfktk Cedkte
occkbkhcu loemxoemkh o d{zemkzz ohhtkzz- ^?KT# 4;;-\ Xfk Hezxtejx J`{tx hkmekh
xfk omxe,ZCOYY l`xe`m# emjc{hemb `m cojn `a heqktzexu g{tezhejxe`m bt`{mhz- ^? KT#
8,5-\
Ycoemxeaaz m`r ozzktx xfox Cedkte ez h`lejeckh em Mkr Lkvej`# omh xfox zfk
yt`qehkh G{hbk T`dtkm` rexf fkt Mkr Lkvej` Hteqktz Cejkmzk# Z`jeoc Zkj{texu
jothz# omh detxf jktxeaejoxk- Xfku j`mxkmh xfox G{hbk T`dtkm` a`{mh# g{zx cenk xfk
Hezxtejx J`{tx em xfez Oyykoc# xfox g{tezhejxe`m roz heqktzeaekh- &OD# ?8-%
Ycoemxeaaz lezz xfk y`emx- Heqktzexu ez hkxktlemkh ox xfk xelk xfk ojxe`m ez
aeckh- Xf{z# o jfombk `a o yotxuz jexewkmzfey oaxkt j`llkmjklkmx `a xfk ojxe`m
h`kz m`x oaakjx ezz{kz tkbothemb heqktzexu g{tezhejxe`m-Ckrez q- Ckrez# :;6 A-4h
85;# ;94 &5xf
Jet- ?511%- O jfombk em jexewkmzfey oaxkt om ojxe`m ez j`llkmjkh h`kz
m`x j{tk o hkakjx em j`lyckxk heqktzexu kvezxemb rfkm xfk ojxe`m ez aeckh- Zoohkf q-
Aot`{ne# ?92 A-:h ;4# ;1,;2 &HJ Jet- ?552%-
$Xfk kzzkmxeoc kcklkmxz `a heqktzexu g{tezhejxe`m# emjc{hemb xfk heqktzk
tkzehkmjk `a occ yotxekz# l{zx dk oaaetloxeqkcu occkbkh em xfk yckohembz-$Em tk
Lkvej` Jexu Oetjtozf# 296 A-4h 899# 898 m-8 &5xf Jet- ?56:%- Ex ez xf{z o Ycoemxeaaz
d{thkm x` oaaetloxeqkcu yckoh heqktzexu g{tezhejxe`m-Edeh-
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 ?; `a :4
89
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 89 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
41/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 ;
Ycoemxeaaz aoeckh x` occkbk z{aaejekmx aojxz em xfket J`lycoemx oaaetloxekcu
kzxodcezfemb hektzexu g{tezhejxe`m ox xfk xelk ex roz aeckh &Lou 4995%# emjc{hemb
rexf tkboth x` Cedktez jexewkmzfey- Ycoemxeaaz heh m`x yckoh xfox Cedkte roz o
tkzehkmx `a Mkr Lkvej` `t omu `xfkt zxoxk- Oz o loxxkt `a cor# occkboxe`mz xfox
Cedkte loemxoemkh o d{zemkzz ohhtkzz em Ykmmzucomeo &ox Ycoemxeaaz j`{mzkcz
`aaejkz% roz emz{aaejekmx- ^?KT# 4;;-\ Xfk J`lycoemx ez zeckmx oz x` xfk jt{jeoc aojx
`a Cedktez tkzehkmjk em Lou 4995# mkjkzzotu x` kzxodcezf hektzexu g{tezhejxe`m- Em
tk Lkvej` Jexu Oetjtozf# z{yto# 296 A-4h ox 898 m-8-
Ycoemxeaaz oxxklyx x` lonk o hezxemjxe`m dkxrkkm o yktz`mz tkzehkmjk omh fez
`t fkt h`lejeck- Nomxkt q- Rotmkt,Coldktx J`-# 41; A-:h 6;:# 6;2 &5xf
Jet- 499?%-
Xfez hezxemjxe`m ez ettkckomx fktkem rfktk xfku aoeckh x` occkbk omu Ycoemxeaaz
h`lejeck em xfk J`lycoemx- Rexf tkboth x` Cedkte# xfktk ez lktkcu om elyt`ykt
occkboxe`m# aoecemb x` kzxodcezf hektzexu g{tezhejxe`m dozkh `m h`lejeck `t omu
`xfkt dozez# od`{x fkt d{zemkzz ohhtkzz em Ykmmzucomeo- ^? KT# 4;;-\
Tkcoxkhcu# Ycoemxeaaz otb{lkmx xfox Cedkte ytkzkmxcu tkzehkz em Mkr Lkvej`
ez ettkckomx- Ycoemxeaaz rktk tkq{etkh x` oaaetloxekcu kzxodcezf hektzexu
g{tezhejxe`m em xfket J`lycoemx- Xfk J`lycoemx ez zeckmx oz x` Cedktez zxoxk a
tkzehkmjk- Xfox hektzexu g{tezhejxe`m lebfx m`r kvezx h`kz m`x lkom xfox ex kvezxkh
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 ?1 `a :4
8?
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 8? `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
42/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 1
rfkm xfk J`lycoemx roz aeckh em Lou 4995- Xfk J`{tx heh m`x tkxt`ojxekcu
ojq{etk hektzexu g{tezhejxe`m du etx{k `a Cedkte coxkt tkzehemb em Mkr Lkvej`-
Ckrez# z{yto# :;6 A-4h ox ;94- Zoohkf# z{yto# ?92 A-:h ox ;1,;2-
L`tk`kt# Ycoemxeaaz aoeckh x` z{dlex omu yt``a xfox Cedkte yt`ehkh G{hbk
T`dtkm` rexf omu h`j{lkmxz kzxodcezfemb tkzehkmjk em Mkr Lkvej`- Em xfez tkboth#
Hkakmhomxz otk yt`ehemb xfk tky`txktz xtomzjteyx `a xfk O{b{zx 4995 fkotemb
dka`tk G{hbk T`dtkm`- ^? ZKT# :,?9:-\ Xfktk ez m` emhejoxe`m xfox Ycoemxeaaz
yt`ehkh omu yt``a `a Cedktez tkzehkmjk- Ocz`# xfktk ez m` t{cemb `t kkm
j`llkmxz du G{hbk T`dtkm` oz x` hektzexu g{tezhejxe`m dkemb kzxodcezfkh-
Oz hkl`mzxtoxkh# Ycoemxeaaz aoeckh x` lkkx xfket d{thkm xfox hektzexu
g{tezhejxe`m kvezxkh# yotxej{cotcu oz x` Cedkte- Ycoemxeaaz xf{z aoeckh x` lkkx xfket
d{thkm {mhkt zkjxe`m 84;-?1&k% x` hkl`mzxtoxk xfox xfk j`lycoemx ez d`xf ckboccu
z{aaejekmx omh z{yy`txkh du o z{aaejekmx ytelo aojek zf`remb `a aojxz x` z{zxoem o
ao`todck g{hblkmx ea xfk kehkmjk z{dlexxkh du xfk ycoemxeaa ez jtkhexkh- Xo{z#
z{yto# 89 Joc-8xf ox 2?:,2?8-
J- Ycoemxeaaz heh m`x lkkx xfket d{thkm {mhkt zkjxe`m 84;-?1&d% x`
ytkzkmx j`lykxkmx omh ohlezzedck kqehkmjk z{aaejekmx x` z{zxoem o
g{hblkmx em xfket aoq`t `m xfk J`lycoemx
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 ?2 `a :4
84
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 84 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
43/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 2
O ycoemxeaaz d{thkm {mhkt zkjxe`m 84;-?1&d% emjc{hkz x` lonk o ytelo aojek
zf`remb qeo j`lykxkmx omh ohlezzedck kqehkmjk `a aojxz z{aaejekmx x` z{zxoem o
aoq`todck g{hblkmx-Loxz`m# z{yto# 89 Joc-Oyy-8xf ox ;86- T`zkmo{t# z{yto# 66
Joc-Oyy-8xf ox 428-
Oz hkl`mzxtoxkh em Hkakmhomxz dteka# Ycoemxeaaz heh m`x zoxezau xfox d{thkm
rfktk xfku aoeckh x` z{dlex j`lykxkmx `t ohlezzedck kqehkmjk z{yy`txemb xfket
`yy`zexe`m- Xfktk ez m` hezj{zze`m em Ycoemxeaaz OD oz x` xfk z{aaejekmju `a xfk
kqehkmjk &Cedktez omh Dktbz hkjcotoxe`mz% em `yy`zexe`m x` Hkakmhomxz l`xe`m-
Xf{z# Ycoemxeaaz du xfket zeckmjk xojexcu ohlex xfox xfket kqehkmjk roz emz{aaejekmx x`
lkkx xfket d{thkm {mhkt zkjxe`m 84;-?1&d%-Lkkfom# z{yto# 6;1 A-4h ox ?91 m-?-
J`ccemz# z{yto# 68? A-4h ox ::5-
EEE-
J`mxtotu x` Ycoemxeaaz [mz{yy`txkh J`mxkmxe`mz# Hkakmhomxz @ykmemb Dtekaz
Otk M`x Dozkh `m Mkr Otb{lkmxz# Mkr Zxoxklkmxz# omh Mkr Hkakmzkz#
M`t H` xfk @ykmemb Dtekaz J`mxoem Elyt`ykt Jexoxe`mz x` xfk Tkj`th
Ycoemxeaaz hkq`xk memk yobkz `a xfket OD &ybz- 4?,45% x` xfk zykje`{z
otb{lkmx xfox Hkakmhomxz `ykmemb dtekaz otk dozkh `m mkr hkakmzkz omh
otb{lkmxz oz rkcc oz xfox Hkakmhomxz jexoxe`mz x` xfk tkj`th `m oyykoc otk
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 ?6 `a :4
8:
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 8: `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
44/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 6
elyt`ykt jexoxe`mz--- ^xfox\ h` m`x zxoxk `t tkackjx xfk zxoxklkmxz jcoelkh du Xoexw
omh H@AA- &OD# 4? omh 41-%
Ycoemxeaaz lohk xfez zolk otb{lkmx em xfket {mz{jjkzza{c l`xe`m x` zxtenk
Hkakmhomxz `ykmemb dtekaz omh hezlezz xfk oyykocz- Ycoemxeaaz otb{lkmx zf`{ch
&oboem% dk tkgkjxkh-
Ycoemxeaaz aoec x` ehkmxeau omu y{ty`txkh mkr hkakmzkz omh otb{lkmxz-
Xf{z# ex ez heaaej{cx &omh z`lkxelkz ely`zzedck% a`t Xoexw x` ohhtkzz Ycoemxeaaz
j`mxkmxe`mz rfktk xfku aoec x` ehkmxeau xfk y{ty`txkh mkr otb{lkmxz-
H@AA recc oxxklyx x` ohhtkzz Ycoemxeaaz j`mxkmxe`mz em xfk `thkt xfku oyykot
x` dk toezkh em xfk OD- Ycoemxeaaz aetzx occkbkh mkr hkakmzkz omh otb{lkmx
emq`cqkz7
Em Xoexw omh H@AAz L`xe`m dka`tk xfk Hezxtejx J`{tx
rfejf ez xfk z{dgkjx `a xfez Oyykoc# H@AA jcoelkh
Ycoemxeaaz/Oyykcckkz &zej% corz{ex roz aeckh x` celex
y{dcej yotxejeyoxe`m omh zykjeaejoccu x` zeckmjk xfk
hkakmhomxz# rf` otk rfezxck dc`rktz--- F`rkqkt# H@AA
mkqkt zxoxkh rfox xfk y{dcej yotxejeyoxe`m roz `t rfox ex
roz jcoelemb xfk y{dcej yotxejeyoxe`m roz `t rfox xfku
rktk dc`remb xfk z{yy`zkh rfezxck `m- &OD# 4?-%
X` xfk j`mxtotu# Hkakmhomxz omxe,ZCOYY L`xe`m jckotcu ehkmxeaekh xfket ojxz
em a{txfktomjk `a xfk yktz`m"z tebfx `a ykxexe`m `t atkk zykkjf {mhkt xfk [mexkh
Zxoxkz J`mzxex{xe`m `t xfk Jocea`tmeo J`mzxex{xe`m em j`mmkjxe`m rexf o y{dcej
ezz{k---- &Zkjxe`m 84;-?1&d%&?%-%
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 ?5 `a :4
88
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 88 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
45/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 5
Oz kvycoemkh em Hkakmhomxz l`xe`m omh tkycu yoyktz# Xoexw `jj{yekz o
ckohktzfey y`zexe`m em xfk omxe,b`qktmlkmx y`cexejoc l`qklkmx emjc{hemb o
j`ly`mkmx `a ex nm`rm oz xfk Detxfkt L`qklkmx- H@AA ez Xoexwz a`{mhoxe`m
xft`{bf rfejf h`moxe`mz otk `dxoemkh x` a{mh xfket y`cexejoc ojxeqexekz# a`j{zemb `m
cexeboxe`m moxe`mrehk emjc{hemb x` jfocckmbk xfk kcebedecexu a Ytkzehkmx @dolo-
Dktb ez ocz` yt`lemkmx aeb{tk em xfez y`cexejoc l`qklkmx-
A`t kvolyck# Hkakmhomxz em xfk J`{tx dkc`r otb{kh xfox Ycoemxeaaz jozk roz
aeckh x` celex y{dcej yotxejeyoxe`m omh zykjeaejoccu zeckmjk xfk hkakmhomxz# rf` otk
rfezxck dc`rktz# od`{x xfk aojx xfox Ykmmzucqomeo oxx`tmku Yfecey G- Dktb ez
klyc`uemb oz fez ckboc ozzezxomx o j`mqejxkh h`j{lkmx a`tbkt omh xfeka Cezo
Cedkte- ^? KT# ?;57 ?6,44-\
Hkakmhomxz y`emxkh `{x xfox Ycoemxeaaz jcoelkh xfox Ycoemxeaa @zxkcco roz
hkaolkh# rfkm Xoexw y{dcezfkh `m fkt rkdzexk# xfox fkt a`tlkt rkd lozxkt @zxkcco
c`jnkh Xoexw `{x `a xfk `ch rkd zexk a`t fkt a`{mhoxe`m# Hkakmh @{t Atkkh`lz
A`{mhoxe`m omh tkycojkh Xoexwz you,yoc ojj`{mx rexf fkt `rm- ^? KT# ?197 5,
?4-\ Ycoemxeaaz zjfklk# x` zeckmjk Hkakmhomxz rfezxck,dc`remb ojxeqexekz omh
tkcoxkh zykkjf# jo{zkh omu h`moxe`m beqkm x` @zxkcco `t qeo you,yoc `m xfk `ch rkd
zexk--- r`{ch m`x b` x` xfk A`{mhoxe`m# d{x r`{ch b` x` @zxkcco- ^? KT# ?1?7 2,?9-\
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 49 `a :4
8;
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 8; `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
46/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 ?9
Tkcoxkhcu# @zxkcco {zkh Hkakmh @{t Atkkh`lz A`{mhoxe`m rkd zexk x`
hkaolk Xoexw omh yt`l`xk om`xfkt oxx`tmku# Yfecey G- Dktb- Dktb ez kmbobkh em
moxe`mrehk a{mhtoezemb--- Oz lkldktz `a xfk y{dcej rktk h`moxemb x` Dktb# xfku
foh x` dk rotmkh xfox o yktz`m rexf xfkax j`mqejxe`mz ez r`tnemb oz om ozzezxomx a`t
xfox oxx`tmku- ^? KT# ?147 48,42# omh ?1:7 2,?9-\ Xfez emq`cqkh om ely`txomx
ezz{k `a y{dcej emxktkzx# omh om kaa`tx# du Xoexw# rf` ez xfk ytkzehkmx ^`a H@AA\ omh
om `aaejkt `a xfk j`{tx x` yt`xkjx xfk h`m`tz oboemzx y`zzedck xfkax- ^? KT# ?1:7 ?:,
?1-\
Hkakmhomxz kvycoemkh f`r Ycoemxeaaz oxxklyxz x` {z{ty Xoexwz ckohktzfey
y`zexe`m em xfez y`cexejoc l`qklkmx , ytemjeyoccu du zeyf`memb,`aa h`moxe`mz x` a{mh
y`cexejoc ojxeqexekz , elycejoxkh ely`txomx y{dcej ezz{kz emjc{hemb d{x m`x celexkh x`
ckohktzfey omh j`mxt`c `a xfk Detxfkt L`qklkmx- ^? KT# 5:7 4:,46 omh 587 ?,??#
rfejf emjc{hkz o hezj{zze`m `a Dktbz Detxfkt rkdzexk
rrr-`dolojtelkz-j`l-\
Xf{z# j`mxtotu x` Ycoemxeaaz {mz{yy`txkh omh aoczk otb{lkmx# Hkakmhomxz em
xfk J`{tx dkc`r kvycejexcu zxoxkh rfox xfk y{dcej yotxejeyoxe`m roz--- ^omh\ rfox
xfku rktk dc`remb xfk z{yy`zkh rfezxck `m-
Ycoemxeaaz zkj`mh occkbkh mkr hkakmzkz# zx`tekz omh otb{lkmx j`mjktmz
Hkakmhomxz otb{lkmx xfox Xfez jozk otezkz `{x `a om `mb`emb hezy{xk emq`cqemb
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 4? `a :4
81
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 81 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
47/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 ??
xfk y`cexejoc hezzehkmx l`klkmx--- nm`rm oz xfk Detxfkt L`klkmx du xf`zk
jfocckmbemb xfk q{oceaejoxe`mz `a Dotojn @dolo x` f`ch xfk `aaejk `a xfk
Ytkzehkmx---- &OD# 4?,4:-% Rexf`{x q{kzxe`m# Hkakmhomxz toezkh xfkzk ezz{kz em xfk
J`{tx dkc`r- @mk kvolyck ez em xfket tkycu lkl`tomh{l zxoxemb7
Xoexw emheeh{occu omh xft`{bf fkt a`{mhoxe`m ^H@AA\ ez
o y`cexejoc jt{zohkt- @a yotxej{cot tkckomjk x` xfk emzxomx
ojxe`m roz Xoexwz jt{zohk x` {mj`kt xfk xt{xf tkbothemb
xfk detxfycojk `a Ytkzehkmx Dotojn @dolo- &Hkjcotoxe`m
`a @tcu Xoexw em z{yy`tx `a fkt Tkycu x` @yy`zexe`m x`
L`xe`m x` Hezlezz--- 4-% Xoexw omh Dktb jt{zohk a`t xfk
zolk jo{zk- &Xoexw Hkjc- :-% Ox `mk y`emx xfkuzel{cxomk`{zcu loemxoemkh xr` zelecot rkdzexkz
hkhejoxkh x` xfket jo{zk- Xoexw loemxoemkh fkt dc`b `m
rrr-hkakmh`{tatkkh`lz-{z omh Dktb loemxoemkh o
rkdzexk ox xfk rkd ohhtkzz fxxy7//`dolojtelkz-j`l-
&Xoexw Hkjc- :-% D`xf Xoexw omh Dktb z`cejexkh h`moxe`mz
x` xfket tkzykjxek jo{zkz xft`{bf xfket dc`b omh rkd zexk#
tkzykjxekcu- &Xoexw Hkjc- 8> Kvfedex :-% D`xf Xoexw
omh Dktb rktk ojj{zemb @dolo `a foemb j`llexxkh
ato{h omh a`tbkh h`j{lkmxz tkbothemb @doloz
detxfycojk- &Xoexw Hkjc- 4,;-% ^? KT# 5;7 ??,4?-\
Xfeth# Ycoemxeaaz otb{k xfox xfktk ez m`xfemb tkcoxemb x`# tkakttemb x`# `t kkm
lkmxe`memb o Detxfkt L`klkmx `t Detxfkt c`joxkh em xfk Tkj`th- &OD# 48-% X`
xfk j`mxtotu# xfk l`xe`m omh tkycu yoyktz otk tkyckxk rexf z{jf tkaktkmjkz
emjc{hemb# d{x m`x celexkh x`# xfk ktu kvycejex tkaktkmjkz x` Xoexwz jt{zohk x`
{mj`kt xfk xt{xf tkbothemb xfk detxfycojk `a Ytkzehkmx Dotojn @dolo omh Xoexwz
omh Dktbz kaa`txz em xfox l`klkmx-
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 44 `a :4
82
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 82 `a ;2
http://www.defendourfreedoms.us/http://www.defendourfreedoms.us/http://obamacrimes.com./http://obamacrimes.com./http://obamacrimes.com./http://www.defendourfreedoms.us/8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
48/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 ?4
Xf{z# Hkakmhomxz em xfk Hezxtejx J`{tx a`tjka{ccu hkl`mzxtoxkh xfox xfez jozk
otezkz `{x `a xfk Detxfkt L`klkmx- Ycoemxeaaz otb{lkmxz tkbothemb mkr
hkakmzkz omh otb{lkmxz otk yoxkmxcu rexf`{x lktex &oz rkcc oz o dcoxomx
leztkytkzkmxoxe`mz a Hkakmhomxz otb{lkmxz em xfk J`{tx dkc`r%-
Ycoemxeaaz xfkm otb{k xfox Hkakmhomxz jexoxe`mz x` xfk tkj`th h` m`x zxoxk
`t tkackjx xfk zxoxklkmxz jcoelkh du Xoexw omh H@AA- &OD# 41-% Ycoemxeaaz toezk
xr` y{ty`txkh emzxomjkz `a emojj{toxk jexoxe`mz x` xfk tkj`th- Aetzx# xfku xonk ezz{k
rexf Hkakmhomxz jexoxe`m x` G{hbk T`dtkm`z {mhezy{xkh j`mjc{ze`m xfox7 Z`lk
`a xfkzk yotxekz fok o c`mb omh j`lycejoxkh cexeboxe`m fezx`tu- Zkk k-b-# Dktb -
@dolo# ;61 A-:h 4:8 &:h Jet- 4995%--- Xfez cexeboxe`m oyykotz x` dk yotx `a xfez
`ktocc hezy{xk ol`mb xfk yotxekz- ^? KT# 4:6# am- ?-\Ycoemxeaaz h` m`x hezy{xk xfox G{hbk T`dtkm` ez ojj{toxkcu q{`xkh# d{x emzxkoh
j`lycoem xfox Hkakmhomxz heh m`x otb{k em xfk J`{tx dkc`r xfox xfez jozk otezkz `{x
`a xfk Detxfkt L`klkmx- &OD# 42-% Oz hkl`mzxtoxkh od`k# Hkakmhomxz
kvycejexcu hkl`mzxtoxkh em xfk l`xe`m omh tkycu yoyktz xfox xfk jozk# em aojx# h`kz
j`mjktm ckohktzfey `a omh j`mxt`c `kt z{jf l`klkmx- ^? KT# 5:,5;# omh ?;5,
?1:-\
Zkj`mh# Ycoemxeaaz j`lycoem xfox Hkakmhomxz otb{k xfox Dktb em xfk j`{tzk `a
xfk Detxfkt L`klkmx foz aeckh o jozk jfocckmbemb Ytkzehkmx @doloz
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 4: `a :4
86
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 86 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
49/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 ?:
q{oceaejoxe`mz# d{x jexk x` o y`txe`m `a xfk tkj`th xfox zouz m`xfemb od`{x o y`cexejoc
hezzehkmx l`klkmx---- &OD# 42- % Xfk z{dgkjx y`txe`m `a xfk tkj`th ez ? KT# 452-
Xfez y`txe`m `a Ycoemxeaaz J`lycoemx zxoxkz em tkckomx yotx7 @m O{b{zx 4?#
4996 Dktb aeckh xfk aetzx corz{ex oboemzx Dottu Z`kx`t` o/n/o Dotojn F- @dolo---
Dktb roz xfk aetzx oxx`tmku rf` aekch &zej% z{ex oboemzx Dottu Z`kx`t` o/n/o Dotojn
F{zzkem @dolo tkbothemb fez jexewkmzfey ezz{kz-
Xfktka`tk# xfk z{dgkjx y`txe`m `a xfk tkj`th rexf`{x q{kzxe`m j`mjktmz xfk
Detxfkt L`klkmx omh Dktbz jcoel x` jottu xfk lomxck `a z{jf l`klkmx-
Ycoemxeaaz otb{lkmxz x` xfk j`mxtotu otk zelycu leztkytkzkmxoxe`mz `a xfk tkj`th `m
oyykoc-
OYYKCCKKZ J@LLEXXKH KBTKBE@[Z ATO[H @M XFK J@[TX#
RFKM XFKU XTEKH X@ J@QKT [Y COJN @A Z[DGKJX LOXXKT
G[TEZHEJXE@M OMH COJN @A HEQKTZEXU OX XFK XELK XFK
J@LYCOEMX ROZ AECKH
Oyykccomxz fok zf`rm xfox xfk Oyykcckkz jomm`x ytkoec `m xfk lktexz oz o loxxkt
`a cor# oz xfku mkkt zoxezaekh xfk hektzexu a g{tezhejxe`m- Xfku mkkt yt`ehkh
omu j`lykxkmx ohlezzedck kehkmjk `a Cedkte"z zxoxk jexewkmzfey-
Em xfket Oyykcckkz" dteka# Oyykcckkz yt`ehkh `mcu `mk otb{lkmx7 Kbtkbe`{z ato{h-
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 48 `a :4
85
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 85 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
50/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 ?8
Xfku jcoelkh xfox h{temb O{b{zx 2# 4995 fkotemb dka`tk g{hbk T`dtkm` em `ykm
j`{tx xfku yt`qehkh G{hbk T`dtkm` rexf Cedkte"z ehkmxeaejoxe`m yoyktz zf`remb
fkt tkzehkmju7 fkt detxf jktxeaejoxk# fkt Z`jeoc Zkj{texu joth omh fkt Mkr Lkvej`
hteqktz cejkmzk- Xfk tkj`th zf`rz xfez x` dk o d`ch cek- Aetzx# Z`jeoc Zkj{texu joth
omh detxf jktxeaejoxk# kqkm ea z{dlexxkh# h` m`x yt`qehk yt``a `a tkzehkmju ox xfk
xelk xfk jozk ez aeckh- Xf`zk h`j{lkmxz oxxkzx `mcu x` tkzehkmju ox xfk xelk `a detxf
omh ox xfk xelk xfk Z`jeoc Zkj{texu joth roz ezz{kh- Xfk `mcu h`j{lkmx xfox jom
oxxkzx x` zxoxk tkzehkmju ox xfk xelk xfk ckboc ojxe`m roz aeckh# ez xfk Hteqktz
Cejkmzk- Kvjktyx `a tkj`th $Xtomzjteyx `a xfk O{b{zx 2# 4995 fkotemb dka`tk G{hbk
T`dtkm` ? ZKT `a Oyykccomx @tcu Xoexw# :,?9: jckotcu zxoxkz xfox Cedkte heh m`x
yt`qehk omu ehkmxeaejoxe`m yoyktz x` G{hbk T`dtkm`- Dktb m Cedkte"z dkfoca oznkh
G{hbk T`dtkm` x` occ`r Cedkte x` yt qehk fkt hteqktz" cejkmzk {mhkt zkoc ox o coxkt
xelk- G{hbk T`dtkm` obtkkh omh `thktkh Cedkte omh Dktb oz fkt oxx`tmku x` aeck
rexf xfk j`{tx Cedkte"z ehkmxeaejoxe`m yoyktz x` zf`r fkt tkzehkmju- Cedkte omh Dktb
mkqkt heh ex- Xfktk ez m` kqehkmjk omurfktk em xfk tkj`th `a xfkl kqkt aecemb
Cedkte"z hteqktz cejkmzk `t omu `xfkt ehkmxeaejoxe`m tkj`thz- Cedkte omh Dktb rktk em
j`mxklyx `a j`{tx a`t xftkk ukotz m`r omh z` aot akhktoc g{hbkz otk h`emb m`xfemb
od`{x ex omh otk kmj`{tobemb xfez j`mxklyx `a j`{tx du tka{zemb x` xonk ojxe`m omh
occ`remb o jozk rexf m` g{tezhejxe`m x` cembkt em akhktoc j`{tx zuzxkl a`t xftkk
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 4; `a :4
;9
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 ;9 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
51/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 ?;
ukotz- Xoexw ez btkoxcu j`mjktmkh xfox xfez ez h`mk dkjo{zk zfk ez o y`cexejoc
hezzehkmx ckohkt omh a`t o m{ldkt `a ukotz m`r akhktoc j`{tx zuzxkl roz {zkh oz o
x``c `a fotozzlkmx `a y`cexejoc hezzehkmxz rexf d`b{z cor z{exz-
Cojn `a omu ohlezzedck j`lykxkmx kehkmjk `a tkzehkmju `a o yotxu em o hektzexu
cor z{ex hkzxt`uz hektzexu- Xfez hkaejekmju jomm`x dk j{tkh du omu olkmhkh
j`lycoemx- Omu jfombk `a tkzehkmju z{dzkq{kmx x` aecemb `a xfk jozk ez ettkckomx x`
xfk z{dgkjx loxxkt g{tezhejxe`m ox xfk xelk `a aecemb- oz z{jf xfk j`{tx foz m` `xfkt
ocxktmoxek d{x x` btomx xfk Oyykoc omh hezlezz xfez rf`ck ckboc ojxe`m h{k x` cojn
`a z{dgkjx loxxkt g{tezhejxe`m em xfk akhktoc j`{txz zuzxkl-
ATO[H @M XFK J@[TX DU XFK OYYKCCKKZ EZ O YOTX OMH
YOTJKC @A XFK ZOLK L@H[Z @YKTOMHE
Oz yt`ehkh em xfk OmxeZCOYY Cedkte ez o j`mejxkh a`tbkt omh xfeka# rf` roz
jfotbkh rexf 4: akc`mu j`{mxz omh j`mejxkh `a ?9 akc`mu j`{mxz em 4996 em xfk
Z{ykte`t J`{tx `a Jocea`tmeo# Zom Dktmothem` j`{mxu &ARQ,946999- % Ox xfk xelk
`a xfk aecemb `a xfk ckboc ojxe`m ox fomh zfk roz `m yt`doxe`m {mhkt xfk g{tezhejxe`m
`a xfk Z{ykte`t J`{tx `a Jocea tmeo omh xfk Zom Dktmothem` J`{mxu# Jocea`tmeo
yt`doxe`m hkyotxlkmx- Ex ez tkoz`modck x` dkcekk xfox zfk emhkkh {zkh Jocea`tmeo
htektz cejkmzk# romxkh x` fehk xfk aojx xfox zfk cekh od`{x fkt tkzhkmju# omh xfox
lebfx dk xfk tkoz`m# rfu zfk lohk {y `{xtobk`{z hkaolox`tu zxoxklkmxz jcoelemb
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 41 `a :4
;?
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 ;? `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
52/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 ?1
xfox zfk jomm`x zf`r fkt hteqktz" cejkmzk em j`{tx dkjo{zk zfk ez oatoeh a`t fkt ceak
omh ojj{zemb @tcu Xoexw# rf` ez o cejkmzkh h`jx`t omh o cejkmzkh oxx`tmku omh o
ytkzehkmx `a H@AA `a oxxklyxemb x` fetk o fex lom x` necc fkt omh x` nehmoy jfechtkm
`a @zxkcco-
Occ `a xfkzk `{xtobk`{z zcomhkt`{z zxoxklkmxz rktk kmxktkh emx` tkj`th du fkt j`,
ycoemxeaa omh oxx`tmku Dktb# oz fk omh Cedkte aeckh xf`{zomhz `a yobkz `a xfk l`zx
`{xtobk`{z hkaolox`tu ojj{zoxe`mz oboemzx Xoexw# d{x mkqkt aeckh rexf xfk j`{tx `mk
zlocc yobk,o j`yu `a Cedkte"z hteqktz cejkmzk at`l Lou 4# 4995-
Ex oyykotz xfox Dktb omh Cedkte"z hkzetk x` bkx h`moxe`mz omh tkj`bmexe`m em xfk
l`qklkmx du j`cc{hemb rexf rkd lozxkt @zxkcco omh xonemb `qkt xfk H@AA rkd
zexk omh heqktxemb h`moxe`mz at l H@AA lebfx foqk dkkm `mcu yotx `a xfket
l`xeqoxe`m- Oyykccomxz otk yt`qehemb xfk tky`tx du o cejkmzkh emqkzxebox`t `a
Akdt{otu ?9# 49?4 xteoc `a oxx`tmku Yfecey Dktb du xfk Hezjeycemotu D`oth `a xfk
Z{ytklk J`{tx `a Ykmmzucqomeo- &`aaejeoc xtomzjteyx `a xfk fkotemb foz m`x dkkm
tkckozkh du xfk Hezjeycemotu D`oth ukx%-
Em 4995# rfkm Xoexw dckr xfk rfezxck `m Cedkte# Dktb omh `xfkt Oyykcckkz#
Hezjeycemotu D`oth `a xfk Z{ytklk J`{tx `a Ykmmzucqomeo zktqkh Dktb rexf o
a`tloc j`lycoemx# rfktk fk roz jfotbkh rexf hkato{hemb fez jcekmx a`t 4 ukotz#
jcoelemb xfox fkt jozk roz ojxeqk# rfeck em tkocexu xfk jozk roz hezlezzkh-
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 42 `a :4
;4
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 ;4 `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
53/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 ?2
Dktb {zkh j`mqejxkh a`tbkt Cedkte x` ytkyotk o jfoem `a k,loecz z{yy`zkhcu
dkxrkkm fkt omh xfk jcekmx# rfktk Cedkte z{yy`zkhcu ohqezkh xfk jcekmx xfox fkt
jcoel roz hezlezzkh-
D`xf Cedkte omh Dktb z{dlexxkh x` xfk Hezjeycemotu D`oth `a Ykmmzucqomeo zr`tm
oaaehoqexz# rfktk xfku hk aojx` ojj{zkh Dktbz jcekmx `a cuemb# `a ato{h `m xfk j`{tx
&`m hezjeycemotu j`llezze`m% omh a yktg{tu-
Ox xfk tkjkmx Akdt{otu ?9# 49?4 fkotemb Dktb ohlexxkh xfox fk hkato{hkh xfk
Hezjeycemotu D`oth# xfox emhkkh fk hkato{hkh xfk jcekmx omh xfox fk z{yy`zkhcu c`zx
aeckz omh xfk jfoem `a k,loecz dkxrkkm xfk jcekmx omh Cedkte roz m`x om ojx{oc jfoem
`a k,loecz# d{x ex roz tkjtkoxkh- Emqkzxebox`t a`t xfk Hezjeycemotu D`oth# o a`tlkt
ADE obkmx xkzxeaekh xfox xfk $tkjtkoxe`m$ roz o a`tbktu- Xfk hkjeze`m du xfk
Hezjeycemotu d`oth ez kvykjxkh zf`txcu# d{x j`mzehktemb xfk btoqexu `a xfk `aakmzk
du Dktb em xfox fk {zkh o j`mqejxkh a`tbkt `m yt`doxe`m x` tkjtkoxk d`b{z
h`j{lkmxz omh mkotcu zkmx fez jcekmx# om emm`jkmx r`lom x` ytez`m a`t ato{h `m xfk
j`{tx omh yktg{tu# ckohz y{dcej x` dkcekqk xfox xfk hezjeycemotu y{mezflkmx a`t Dktb
recc dk zxeaa7 kexfkt hezdotlkmx `t ckmbxfu z{zykmze`m at`l ytojxejemb cor- &Kvfedex
? Tky`tx `a xfk Akdt{otu ?9# 49?4 xteoc `a oxx`tmku Yfecey G- Dktb du xfk
Hezjeycemotu D`oth `a xfk Z{ytklk J`{tx `a Ykmmzucqomeo# Kvfedex 4, J`lycoemx
kvfedex : Omzrkt du Dktb%-
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/?5/49?4 EH7 6?82946 HnxKmxtu7 :;,? Yobk7 46 `a :4
;:
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98/48/49?4 EH7 6?;?91: HnxKmxtu7 :6,? Yobk7 ;: `a ;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Motion to Strike DOFF's Reply Brief and Exhibits Doc 38-1
54/57
Cedkte q H@AA Tkycu x` Oyykcckkz" dteka 5xf jetj{ex 98-?5-49?4 ?6
H{temb xfez hezjeycemotu jozk Xoexw# o cejkmzkh JO oxx`tmku omh o ytkzehkmx `a o
m`myt`aex `tbomewoxe`m Hkakmh `{t Atkkh`lz dckr xfk rfezxck `m Cedkte omh
Dktb- @mk `a xfk loem tkoz`mz a`t Oyykcckkz x` aeck xfket ZCOYY ojxe`m# roz x` xtu
x` zeckmjk Xoexw omh xtu x` nkky xfk ema`tloxe`m od`{x Cedkte"z a`tbktu j`mqejxe`mz
fehhkm at`l xfk Hezjeycemotu D`oth# z` Dktb jom {zk Cedkte oz fez ocede em fez deh x`
ytkzktqk fez cor cejkmzk- xfomnz x` Xoexw"z hezjc`z{tk x` xfk y{dcej `a xfk aojx xfox
Dktb r`tnz rexf o j`mqejxkh a`tbkt# lohk ex y`zzedck a`t xfk Hezjeycemotu d`oth x`
a`cc`r {y `m xfez ema`tloxe`m- xfez zf`rz f`r ely`txomx rktk hezjc`z{tkz du Xoexw#
ex zf`rz xfox xfk hezjc`z{tkz lohk du Xoexw# rktk emhkkh xfk loxxkt `a y{dcej
emxktkzx# ex zf`rz xfox ex fkcykh om emm`jkmx r`lom# Dktb"z jcekmx m`x x` dk
j`mqejxkh dozkh `m ato{h{ckmx oaaehoqexz du Dktb omh Cedkte- Ex yt`lyxkh ohlezze`m
du Dktb xfox emhkkh fk hkato{hkh xfk hezjeycemotu D`oth- Ea xfktk roz kqkt o jozk#
a`t rfejf OmxZcoyy roz jtkoxkh# xfox ez xfk jozk-
Ex oyykotz x` dk o l`h{z `yktomhe `a o x`xoccu heod`cejoc omxez`jeoc dkfoqe`t `a xfk
Oyykcckkz omh yotxej{cotcu Cedkte x` zelycu lohk {y xfk l`zx `{xtobk`{z cekz omh
occkboxe`mz x` j`qkt {y a`t xfk jtelkz zfk ez j`llexxemb- G{zx oz Cedkte omh Dktb
ojj{zkh Dktb"z jcekmx# om emm`jkmx r`lom `a ato{h rfkm zfk dckr xfk rfezxck `m
Jozk7 ??,;1?18 98