Krishan Bhattacharya's theory of Conspiracy Theories

  • Upload
    hexag1

  • View
    212

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Krishan Bhattacharya's theory of Conspiracy Theories

Citation preview

I just discovered this sub, and I'm so glad it exists.I've been wanting to share my thoughts about conspiracy theories, but I haven't received much response when I've posted this elsewhere. So here goes:Conspiracy theories can be found everywhere. They are a big problem, especially if they become widespread in a political culture. If people get in power who believe them, the results can be catastrophic. In the case of European fascism, political parties came to power which believed in a vast array of ludicrous conspiracy theories and then passed laws banning publications critical of conspiracy theories. The result were societies besieged by pernicious delusions, trapped in a hall of mirrors reflecting back crazy beliefs with no escape, until war brought them to total ruin.I live in Texas, and we have conspiracy theories here, but they are mostly marginalized politically. But they are there to be found. But when I look across the world, I see societies where conspiratorial thinking reigns supreme. Most especially: Russia and its neo-fascist, Putinist, feudal, racist right wing; India and its crazy theocratic Hindutva movement; and the Muslim world. Conspiratorial thinking grows in the darkness of ignorance and dogma. Why do people believe them?Here's the deal with conspiracy theories.Conspiracy theories become widespread and influential in a political culture because they fill a psychological need. **Conspiracy theories function as a kind of ideological scapegoat: when your own cherished (dogmatic) beliefs lead you astray, and you aren't willing to criticize or alter them, you must find something else to blame your problems on. This something else is an imagined conspiracy.**Say you were a far Left wing type in America. If you held, on 9/11/2001 that America was the Evil Empire, that nothing about it was worth defending, and that no other actor in the world could possibly have intentions as evil as the attacks of that day appeared to require, then you had a problem: How to explain evil committed against the United States when the United States is the source of all evil? The solution? The United States attacked itself. Problem solved.The same logic gave the same result in other parts of the world. If you were an Egyptian Muslim who knew that Islam was a peaceful religion, and that terrorism was only the result of distortion of 'true' religion or legitimate political grievances then you had a problem: how to explain the 9/11 attacks when the religion of peace was invoked to justify them by the perpetrators, and the lead hijacker was from Cairo? The solution? The United States, in conjunction with Israel attacked itself, and then blamed it all on Muslims. Problem solved. No need to rethink your basic assumptions.Once you notice this kind of casuistry, you start seeing it everywhere. The belief among Western conservatives that global warming is a conspiracy by liberal academics and media has the same motivation. Conservatives are committed to free market capitalism as a dogma. The phenomenon of global warming calls into question the benefits of our current global economic regime. Solution? Global warming is a liberal hoax. Problem solved.Once conspiracy theories get up in the air, they can take on a life of their own, creating new ideological realities that can be hugely dangerous. There are always demagogues waiting in the wings to use fear - fear that conspiracy theories both create and are the expression of - to gain political power. In some countries, whole governments function by huffing the fumes of conspiratorial delusions (modern Russia, Pakistan, the Islamic State / ISIS / the Caliphate) etc.Good science, good history, and good journalism are the way to fight them.