Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Keeping Interactivity at the Center of Rapid Development
Facilitator:
Bryan ChapmanChief Learning Strategist
Chapman [email protected]
Name the most common reason someone might not
use interactivity during rapid development.
How long…?
How long does it take to create 1 hour of Classroom Instruction?
How long does it take to create 1 hour of PowerPoint-based, online learning?
How long…? Low Range = 12:1High Range = 60:1
How long does it take to create 1 hour of E-Learning?
How long…?
How long does it take to create 1 hour of Simulation-Based e-learning?
How long…?
1300 hours1300 hours
De
ve
lop
me
nt
Co
sts
Reoccurring costs, over time
Instructor-Led
Online, Self-Paced
Break even point(10 Months)
Break even point(10 Months)
221:1(hours of development per finished hour of instruction)
221:1(hours of development per finished hour of instruction)
34:1(hours of development per finished hour of instruction)
34:1(hours of development per finished hour of instruction)
Example Only
De
ve
lop
me
nt
Co
sts
Reoccurring costs, over time
Instructor-Led
Online, Self-Paced
Break even point(10 Months)
Break even point(10 Months)
221:1(hours of development per finished hour of instruction)
221:1(hours of development per finished hour of instruction)
34:1(hours of development per finished hour of instruction)
34:1(hours of development per finished hour of instruction)
Return on Investment
Example Only
De
ve
lop
me
nt
Co
sts
Reoccurring costs, over time
Instructor-Led
Online, Self-Paced
221:1(hours of development per finished hour of instruction)
221:1(hours of development per finished hour of instruction)
34:1(hours of development per finished hour of instruction)
34:1(hours of development per finished hour of instruction)
75:1
Break even point(10 Months)
Break even point(10 Months)
Example Only
(3.5 Months)
Return on Investment
PCWeek Shoot Out
• Several teams invited to compete
• Convert a 54-hour instructor-led course to online learning
• 2 days of development
• 1 person at the computer at any time
• Storyboard…. actually a lesson plan
• Present course to 20 judges and 150 members of media gallery
• Watched the other teams in action
• Wide variety of approaches
Continuum of Interaction
Cost per finished hour…
Levels of Interactivity Outsource Developed(per finished hour)
Internally Developed(per finished hour)
Level 1:• Page turning• Test Questions
Average: $15,067Low: $10,009High: $20,088
Ratio: 30-50:1Cost: $1,200 - $2,000
(assumed rate of $40 pay per hour)
Level 2:• Level 1, plus…• 25% interactive exercises,
games and mini-simulations
Average: $24,672Low: $17,627High: $33,711
Ratio: 221:1Cost: $8,840
(assumed rate of $40 pay per hour)
Level 3:• High level of gaming and/
or simulation
Average: $41,138Low: $29,639High: $70,279
Ratio: 750:1Cost: $30,000
(assumed rate of $40 pay per hour)
Source: Brandon Hall Research, Custom Content Development Knowledgebase
How?
IBM Learning Model
White Papers
Product Knowledge
PowerPoint
Word
Student Guide
Scenario-Based Simulations
GamesExercises
Instructor-Led“culminating experience”
Instructor-Led“culminating experience”
Practice
Blended Learning as a development model
White Papers
Product Knowledge
PowerPoint
Word
Student GuideGames
Exercises
Practice
Scenario-Based Simulations
Classroom uses the same development model
Rapid Simulation Development – Best Tool for the Job
Rapid Authoring Tools
Blended Learning as a development model
White Papers
Product Knowledge
PowerPoint
Word
Student GuideGames
Exercises
Practice
Scenario-Based Simulations
Classroom uses the same development model
Rapid Simulation Development – Best Tool for the Job
Rapid Authoring ToolsDemonstration
Demonstration
Bloom’s Taxonomy
• Knowledge Action verbs: list, define, tell, describe, identify, show, label, collect, examine, tabulate,
quote, name, who, when, where, etc.
• Comprehension Action verbs: summarize, describe, interpret, contrast, predict, associate, distinguish,
estimate, differentiate, discuss, extend, etc.
• Application Action verbs: apply, demonstrate, calculate, complete, illustrate, show, solve, examine,
modify, relate, change, classify, experiment, discover, etc.
• Analysis Action verbs: analyze, separate, order, explain, connect, classify, arrange, divide,
compare, select, explain, infer, etc.
• Synthesis Action verbs: combine, integrate, modify, rearrange, substitute, plan, create, design,
invent, what if?, compose, formulate, prepare, generalize, rewrite, etc.
• Evaluation Action verbs: assess, decide, rank, grade, test, measure, recommend, convince, select,
judge, explain, discriminate, support, conclude, compare, summarize, etc.
“Remember” – “Do”
Course Designer
Don’t wait too late to apply interactivity
Analyze
Develop
Implement
Evaluate
DesignDocumentDesign
Document
StoryboardStoryboard
Design
Prototype
Authoring and Production
Course Designer
Interactivity to meet instructional goals
Interactivity Menu… Discovery Exercise Progressive Disclosure Branching Scenario (troubleshooting) Software Application Simulation Labeling Exercise Role-play simulation Discrimination Exercise (classification) Game show (i.e. Jeopardy, Millionaire) Simple Games (Tic-Tac-Toe) Crossword puzzle (reinforce terminology) Sequencing Exercise Interactive Glossary Flash Cards (recall) Branching Quesitons Matching Video Interaction Animated Diagram
Interactivity Menu… Discovery Exercise Progressive Disclosure Branching Scenario (troubleshooting) Software Application Simulation Labeling Exercise Role-play simulation Discrimination Exercise (classification) Game show (i.e. Jeopardy, Millionaire) Simple Games (Tic-Tac-Toe) Crossword puzzle (reinforce terminology) Sequencing Exercise Interactive Glossary Flash Cards (recall) Branching Quesitons Matching Video Interaction Animated Diagram
Demonstration
Course Designer
Raptivity – Interactivity Samplerwww.raptivity.com
Half-Baked Softwarewww.halfbakedsoftware.com
Course Designer
Class Tool – Free Gameswww.classtools.net
Course Designer
• 247,000 employees
• Factory Training
• Supply Chain Model
• 50 SME’s created 200 learning modules in very short timeframe
SME-Developed
SME-Developed
Publishedby Center
Publishedby Center
LearningChampions(local units)
LearningChampions(local units)
Support Staff• ISD
• Graphic Artists
Support Staff• ISD
• Graphic Artists
Strategy?Strategy?
LearnersLearners
Tips and Suggestion – Using Interactivity for Rapid Development
• Create an interactivity “sampler” to show to internal customers, SME’s, etc. Review before design activities.
• Don’t create navigation controls at the page level. It’s a waste of time.
• Page turning isn’t bad if used in moderation. Add a healthy mix of interactivity.
• When prototyping, create a prototype for each interaction, not just a single lesson or module.
• Consider using multiple tools to meet the need.
• One caution: make sure interactivity choices don’t overshadow the instruction. It is possible to use too much of a good thing.
Tools used in Class:
• Raptivity (200+ templated interactions) – See www.raptivity.com
• Instructional Spice (much fewer templates, but web based) – See www.instructionalspice.com
• Quandary (used for the desert island maze) See www.halfbakedsoftware.com
• Hot Potatoes (used to create the crossword puzzle) – See www.halfbakedsoftware.com
• Classtools.net (shooting game) – See www.classtools.net
• Unison (demonstration of integrating interactivity samples) – See www.rapidintake.com
• OnPoint Digital (LCMS demonstration of integrating samples) – See www.onpointlearning.com
Cost
Too much time
Steep Learning Curve
Hard to Integrate
Why should I?
Not in PowerPoint
Lack of Creativity
Authoring Tools 1. Accordent Capture Station 2. AcroTrain e-Learning System 3. Adobe Authorware 4. Adobe Captivate 5. Adobe Connect (formerly Breeze)6. Adobe Director7. Adobe Dreamweaver8. Adobe Flash9. Apixel Metamorphosis10. Articulate Presenter 11. Articulate Quizmaker 12. Assima Wizard Training Suite13. Atlantic Link14. AuthoLearn 15. Banshee 16. Brainshark Communications Platform 17. Brainvisa18. Camtasia Studio 19. CLI Virtuoso Authoring System 20. Composica Enterprise 21. CONSTRUCT Author 22. CONSTRUCT Roleplaying Engine 23. Content Authoring Software 24. CourseGenie 25. Design-a-Course 26. Designer's Edge 27. EasyAuthor 28. Edufolio 29. Eedo ForceTen 30. Elicitus Content Publisher31. Exam Engine 32. Experience Builder33. Firefly 34. FLEXeLEARN EDITOR 35. FLEXeLEARN POWERSYNC
36. Gen 21 Knowledge Assembler 37. IBT Content Conversion 38. IBT Web Authoring39. Impatica for PowerPoint 40. Impatica OnCue41. Instant Demo 42. Intiva 43. Intuition Publisher 44. iPerform Course Builder 45. Kallidus Authoring System 46. Kaplan STT Trainer47. KBridge 48. Knowledge Builder 49. KnowledgeHub Authoring Services 50. Kookaburra KnowledgePresenter 51. Learn.com CourseMaker Studio 52. LearnPoint Creator 53. Lectora Publisher 54. LECTURNITY 55. LERSUS 56. MaxIT 57. MAXMEDIA 58. Mindflash Training System 59. MOS SOLO (Generator + Styler)60. OnPoint Course Manager 61. OutStart Trainer (formerly Trainersoft)62. PedagogueTesting 63. Performance Analyzer 64. podia 65. PointeCast Publisher Professional 66. Power Book Builder 67. Qarbon ViewletBuilder 68. Qube Learning System 69. Quest70. Question Writer - Quiz Edition
71. Questionmark Perception 72. Rapid Intake73. RapidBuilder 74. RapideL 75. RapidGuide 76. Raptivity 77. ReadyGo Web Course Builder 78. Red inQ79. Respondus 80. SCObuilder 81. SCORMxt 82. ScreenWatch Producer software83. Sculptoris Voices Studio 84. Seminar Author85. Siebel SimBuilder 86. SimCorder 87. SimShop Developer Tool 88. SkillSoft Course Customization Toolkit 89. SmartBuilder 90. SoftChalk91. StudyMate 92. TACTIC! 93. TEDS Learning Composer 94. Testcraft 95. THESIS 96. ToolBook Assistant 97. ToolBook Instructor 98. Toolbox 99. TurboDemo100. VBTrain.Net 101. ViewletAce 102. ViewletCam 103. Vox Proxy 104. Webex Presentation Studio 105. WTDS106. X-Pulse LearnCube
Classifications of Authoring Tools
General Purpose Authoring Tools
PowerPoint to E-learning (Rapid)
Gaming
Simulation
Assessment/Testing
Groupware/Content Management Centric
General Purpose Authoring Tools
Adobe Flash Adobe Authorware Adobe Director Adobe Dreamweaver Lectora Publisher OutStart Trainer (formerly Trainersoft) ToolBook Quest Rapid Intake ReadyGo Web Course Builder Learn.com CourseMaker Studio EasyAuthor Intuition Kallidua Authoring Kookaburra KnowledgePresenter TACTIC! MaxIT Toolbox LearnPoint Creator TEDS Learning Composer
PowerPoint to E-Learning
Articulate Presenter Adobe Connect (formerly Breeze) Atlantic Link PointeCast Publisher Professional Brainshark Impatica for PowerPoint AcroTrain e-Learning System MindFlash FLEXeLEARN Power Book Builder Vox Proxy
Gaming
Raptivity Learningware Unison (Rapid Intake) Hot Potatoes Classtools.net Composica Enterprise Intiva MOS SOLO (Generator + Styler) StudyMate
Simulation Adobe Captivate Kaplan STT Trainer Assima Camtasia Studio Firefly RapidBuilder Siebel SimBuilder Experience Builder TEDS SimCorder SimShop Developer Tool TurboDemo Humentum NexLearn Qarbon ViewletBuilder
Assessment/Testing
Questionmark Perception Testcraft Exam Engine Respondus Articulate Quizmaker Pedagogue Testing Red inQ ViewletAce
